Skip to content
PodSubs
ShowsPeopleGuestsJobsNewsEvents
More
BlogPodCred
Menu
ShowsPeopleGuestsJobsNewsEventsBlogPodCredNetworksSign in
Join nowSign in
  • Shows
  • People
  • Jobs
  • News
  • More
    • Guests
    • Events
    • Blog
    • PodCred
    • Networks
    Join nowSign in

Over This Should

Over This Should artwork

The Default Manager: Why You're Exhausted by a Day You Can't Remember

Aug 20, 202613 minAudio

You get to the end of the day completely wiped out. Somebody asks what you did, and you genuinely cannot answer. You noticed the milk was gone. You moved the three o'clock because it was going to run into the three fifteen. You caught the mistake in the document before it went out the door. You remembered the permission slip. Nothing you can point to, and you are wrecked. There is a name for that, and it is not bad time management. In this episode, Pamela unpacks the default manager: the woman who has quietly become the operating system everyone else runs on. She walks through the sociology of cognitive labor, tells the story of a dentist appointment that took nine invisible steps before anyone got in the car, and lands on a distinction that changes how you see your entire life. Help is not the same as ownership. She also gets into why the default manager shows up at work as much as at home, why indispensable is not the same as influential, and why the resentment you have been talking yourself out of might be information rather than pettiness. In this episode: What cognitive labor actually is, and the four parts researchers break it into Why the deciding gets shared, and the noticing and the remembering do not The default manager at work, and the research on low promotability tasks Help versus ownership, and the six stages of carrying something A three-question audit you can run this week on one responsibility in your life Research referenced: Daminger, A. (2019). The Cognitive Dimension of Household Labor. American Sociological Review, 84(4), 609 to 633. Ciciolla, L., and Luthar, S. S. (2019). Invisible Household Labor and Ramifications for Adjustment: Mothers as Captains of Households. Sex Roles, 81(7 to 8), 467 to 486. Babcock, L., Recalde, M. P., Vesterlund, L., and Weingart, L. (2017). Gender Differences in Accepting and Receiving Requests for Tasks with Low Promotability. American Economic Review, 107(3), 714 to 747. Mentioned in this episode: The Invisible Work Ledger, a whole life agency tool that walks you through one responsibility, all six stages, and shows you exactly where you are stuck being the manager. Send me an email and I'll send you back the PDF: pamela@pamelameadows.com The Should Audit, a quiz that identifies the invisible expectations shaping how you work, care, lead, and decide. Results are immediate.. www.pamelameadows.com Tell me one thing you are always remembering for everybody else. Leave it in a review or send it to me directly. I read them. pamelameadows.com Love this conversation? Follow Over This Should and share the episode with a woman who is ready to get over the expectations keeping her stuck. Learn more about Pamela Meadows, coaching, speaking, and upcoming programs at https://www.pamelameadows.com/.

Audio and video play straight from the show's own hosting. PodSubs stores and serves no media.

Transcript

From the show. Tap a time to play from there.

SPEAKER_00Have you ever had the experience of being completely exhausted by the end of the day? But if somebody asks you what you did, you really can't recall it. You don't remember what you actually did or why you're so tired. You worked, you answered messages, you probably handled something at home. You made a decision. You remembered something. You followed up on something. You fixed a small problem before it became a bigger one. You made sure nobody forgot the thing that they absolutely would have forgotten. And then you sat down at the end of the day and thought, I didn't even do that much.

SPEAKER_00Why am I so tired? I want to offer you a possibility. It's not that you're losing time or that you're bad at time management. Maybe you're the default manager. Yesterday I launched a quiz on my website called The Should Audit. It helps ambitious women identify invisible expectations, shaping how they work, care, lead, and make decisions. And since I announced it less than 24 hours ago, dozens of women have taken it, and the majority have landed in the default manager category, which tells me this is not just a niche little problem happening inside my wildly overactive brain.

SPEAKER_00There are a whole lot of women walking around as the unpaid operating system for everyone and everything around them. So today, I want to talk about what being the default manager actually means. Why is it so exhausting? And how to begin changing it without blowing up your job, your family, or even Tuesday night dinner. You know, the problem isn't simply that you do a lot. A lot of people do a lot. The problem is that you may be the person who remains responsible for making sure everything happens.

SPEAKER_00Everybody leans on and everybody comes to. And that's just not sustainable. Let me give you an example. I was talking to my friend the other night and she was praising her husband. He helped take their kid to the dentist so that she could stay at work and stay focused on a meeting that she was prepping for, which is great and helpful. And I love that for her. But as we continued to talk, and I was listening to her talk about how her husband was so helpful with this dentist appointment, she also mentioned that she was the one who noticed that the kid needed an appointment. She found the new provider. She checked the insurance to make sure the provider was covered.

SPEAKER_00She called the dentist office. She scheduled the appointment. She put it on the family calendar. She made sure nobody double booked something so the kid could get to the dentist on time. She filled out the forms. She remembered the follow-up instructions that the dentist sent home with their child and her husband. And she will probably be the person who remembers the next appointment. That isn't one task. And yay, thank you to her husband for taking the child to the dentist. But it wasn't a one-task ordeal. It was an entire operating system that got the kid to the dentist. And I think a lot of women aren't actually exhausted because they're doing the visible thing.

SPEAKER_00They're exhausted because they are the whole operating system behind the scenes. They are the person everyone else's life runs through. And researchers have a name for this. It's called cognitive labor. It's the invisible mental work behind getting things done. One of the clearest research frameworks breaks it into four parts. Part number one, anticipating, noticing that something needs attention. Part two, identifying, figuring out all the options. Part three, deciding, making the call, booking the appointment.

SPEAKER_00Part four, monitoring, making sure it actually happens. And that last one, monitoring, that's where a lot of us live. You can delegate a task and still be the person who has to remember whether or not it got done. You can have a supportive partner like my friend and still be the person who manages the support. You can have a capable team and still be the person everyone turns to when something gets confusing, urgent, political, emotional, or inconvenient. And that's why just ask for help can sometimes feel like one more job.

SPEAKER_00Because then you have to identify the help needed. You have to explain it, assign it, clarify it, check it, probably make a list for it. You're still the manager of it. A recent study of mothers with young children found that the women's share of cognitive labor was even more unequal than their share of physical household tasks. And carrying more of that mental responsibility was associated with higher stress, burnout, worse mental health, and lower relationship quality. Does any of this resonate with you? Listen, that doesn't mean that every woman's stress has one cause, but it does mean we should stop treating this like a personality flaw.

SPEAKER_00You're not necessarily too controlling or a type A personality. You may be the only person who's been assigned or who has gradually assumed the responsibilities, you know, the job of keeping the system from falling apart. And that has a cost. Now, if you're listening and thinking, okay, I don't have children, or that's not how my household functions, let's talk about it from a work perspective because the default manager shows up at work too. She's the one who sees the deadline slipping. She's the one who notices the new person doesn't understand the process.

SPEAKER_00She's the one who remembers the client detail that nobody else captured. She's the one who smooths the tension in a meeting. She's the one who writes the follow-up email that nobody assigned her to write. She's the one who says, I'll just handle it, because frankly, it's faster than explaining it. And then somehow she ends up indispensable, but not necessarily influential. Reliable, but overloaded. Praised, but not always promoted. There's research showing women are more likely to be asked to take on the tasks that help the organization, but do not necessarily help their careers.

SPEAKER_00The office birthday card, the committee, filling in when somebody's gone, the mentoring, the emotional cleanup, the work that makes everybody else look functional, important work, absolutely promotion-worthy work, not always. So the better question is not why don't women set better boundaries? The question might be: what have women been rewarded, expected, and trained to absorb? Now I want to be very careful here before men come into the comments and tell me I'm part of the She Woman Man Haters Club. I'm not saying every woman's caring more than every man.

SPEAKER_00I'm not saying your partner's lazy or your team is incompetent or your willingness to help someone's a character defect. Not that at all. I would like us to acknowledge there are often real differences in schedules, income, health, caregiving demands, job power, capacity, and different life stages we're in. And sometimes you are the better person for a particular task. Sometimes you like planning the vacation. Sometimes you care more about the pediatrician. Sometimes you are genuinely the most qualified person to make the call.

SPEAKER_00The issue is not whether you carry something. The issue is whether you have a choice. Can you put it down? Can somebody else own it from the beginning to the end? Can you be unavailable without the whole thing becoming your emergency again? That is the difference between generosity and permanent default responsibility. Here's the reframe I want you to take away. Help is not the same as ownership. Help says, tell me what to do. Ownership says, I will notice, plan, act, and follow through without requiring you to remain the manager.

SPEAKER_00That is a very different experience. And it's why women can be surrounded by people who love them, work well with them, and even contribute significantly and still feel completely alone in the responsibility. Because she is the one who has to do the remembering, because she is the one who is carrying the monitoring. So then she's the one who's left with the invisible question. What happens if this doesn't get done? What happens if the ball is dropped? And often she ends up with the I'll just do it myself mentality.

SPEAKER_00So I want to give you a tiny audit. No dramatic life overhaul required. No burning your planner in the backyard. We're not doing that today. I just want you to pick one recurring responsibility in your life. It could be school logistics, meals, caregiving, team coordination, project management, family travel, your parents' medical appointments, whatever it is. And S. Who notices that this needs attention? Who figures out the options? Who makes the decision?

SPEAKER_00Who does the visible task? Who follows up and makes sure it's actually done? Who gets stressed or blamed if it falls through? If the answer to most of those questions is you, you may not have a task problem. You may have an ownership problem. And the first step is not necessarily to quit your job, start a fight with your partner, or hire three new virtual assistants. The first step is to see the work clearly. Because you can't renegotiate what's never been named.

SPEAKER_00I know this pattern because I can find it in almost every part of my own life. At home, I'm basically a human reminder app with legs. It sounds a lot like this in the house. You have a dentist appointment coming up. Did you brush your teeth? Has anyone fed the dogs? And then the kids will ask things like, what are we doing this weekend? What's for dinner? What's in the pantry? What do we need from the grocery store? And then I'm wondering, does anybody have a sporting event this weekend? Do we have cleats, chairs, water bottles, and a hundred other things that nobody will think about until we're backing out of the driveway and maybe even halfway to the sporting event.

SPEAKER_00And somehow every road leads back to mom. I regularly remind my children that mom doesn't mean built-in made. But so far, that particular leadership message has not achieved full organizational adoption. And there's a blessing in being needed. I genuinely love being the person who helps hold my family together. I genuinely enjoy being a person who my children turn to. But it's also exhausting to realize that everybody else gets to participate in the plan while you are the person who is responsible for remembering, organizing, and monitoring the entire plan.

SPEAKER_00And then I go to work and I do a more professionally dressed version of this exact same thing. I'm often the person who thinks somebody should be capturing these decisions from the meeting. Somebody should document the action items and somebody should follow up and make sure those action items actually happen. And because I value organization accountability and solid audit evidence, I am a quality nerd by trade, that somebody is frequently me. It's valuable work. It keeps the company organized. It creates clarity. It gives external auditors exactly what they need. But at some point I have to ask, why am I carrying the invisible coordination of work for a room full of grown adults?

SPEAKER_00Why am I the only one thinking about how the company will hold itself accountable after everybody else leaves a meeting? And here's where this becomes more than an annoyance. Being the person who always takes the notes, catches the loose ends, answers late-night calls, and makes sure that nothing gets dropped can make you indispensable. And indispensable can feel good, but indispensable is not the same as influential. It is not the same as promotable. It can simply make you the catch all. The organization knows it can give you more to carry.

SPEAKER_00That doesn't necessarily mean it's learned to give you more authority. And throughout my personal life and my professional career, I started to connect the dots and I really began to realize I didn't need to become less capable or more capable. I needed to become more discerning about where my capability was going. Because confidence can create dependence instead of authority. And if this is starting to make your feathers feel a little ruffled or bring up some resentment for you, I want to say something that may be unpopular in the world of just be grateful.

SPEAKER_00Resentment isn't always pettiness. Sometimes resentment is data. It may be telling you this responsibility was never actually agreed to. I'm carrying more than I consented to. I don't have enough support. I'm making everybody else comfortable at my own expense. I need a conversation. I need a system. I need a boundary. I need to stop volunteering for permanent discomfort in my own life. Resentment is not always an instruction. You don't have to act on every feeling immediately.

SPEAKER_00You can let it be information. And for the women like me who have been taught to be easy, helpful, grateful, and low maintenance, we're often very skilled at ignoring information that doesn't make other people comfortable. But hopefully we're all getting to a stage where our discomfort matters as much as everybody else's comfort. If you're resonating with this and feel like the default manager, I don't want you to hear this and think, oh great, one more job I failed to do correctly. We're not doing that here. You are likely excellent at what you've been asked to do. You may have even become incredibly capable because people and systems genuinely rely on you.

SPEAKER_00But capability deserves boundaries and reliability deserves reciprocity, and care deserves support. And a life that works for everyone else should not require you to disappear inside of it. So this week, notice one thing you're carrying that would become obvious only if you stopped carrying it. And I'm not saying drop it tomorrow. But I am saying when you start seeing it clearly, that's where agency over your own life begins. And if you want help doing that, I created the Invisible Work Ledger. It's a simple tool that'll track what you do, what you remember, what you plan, what you follow up on, and what may and what may no longer need to live inside your brain.

SPEAKER_00I'll link it to the show notes. And if you're wondering what shoulds may be running your own life, take the should audit at PamelaMeadows.com. You're going to get your results immediately, along with a clearer picture of the pattern you may be carrying. Tell me in the comments, what is one thing that you are always remembering for everyone else? Because I have a feeling when you start addressing what you're remembering for everybody else, you're going to realize all of the mental load and labor that you are carrying.

Open the transcript file

Hosts and Guests

Nobody is credited on this episode yet.

Credit the people on this episode

Be the first to rate this episode

More episodes

All episodes
  1. Gold Star Girl The Shower That Changed Everything

    Oct 16, 202621 minAudio

    That moment when you say “Of course, count me in” and your stomach drops later isn’t a personality quirk. It’s a pattern and it can burn you out so slowly you stop noticing the heat. We start with a raw story from...

    Credit the people on this episode

  2. Direct, Not Difficult: How to Say What You Mean Without Shrinking

    Oct 7, 202612 minAudio

    You know that email. “Hey, just checking in!” followed by three paragraphs of cushioning around the thing you actually mean: “This was due Tuesday.” Ma’am. That’s a hostage negotiation. In this episode of Over This...

    Credit the people on this episode

  3. Stop Procrastinating By Feeling Safe with Guest Heather Lillico

    Sep 10, 202656 minAudio

    You can be smart, capable, and deeply committed to your goals and still find yourself avoiding the exact actions that would move your life forward. When that happens, we tend to call it laziness, inconsistency, or...

    Credit the people on this episode

  4. How To Delegate Without Hovering Or Taking It Back

    Sep 8, 202612 minAudio

    You finally delegate dinner and then catch yourself checking the fridge, watching the clock, and thawing the chicken anyway. That awkward moment is the real story, not the handoff itself. When we let go of a...

    Credit the people on this episode

  5. The Glass Audit: How to Stop Carrying the Mental Load in Your Head

    Aug 28, 202611 minAudio

    Ever find yourself brushing your teeth thinking, “Don’t forget that email,” sitting in a meeting mentally rehearsing tomorrow’s conversation, or trying to fall asleep when your brain suddenly screams, “DOG FOOD”?...

    Credit the people on this episode