Skip to content
PodSubs
ShowsPeopleGuestsJobsNewsEvents
More
BlogPodCred
Menu
ShowsPeopleGuestsJobsNewsEventsBlogPodCredNetworksSign in
Join nowSign in
  • Shows
  • People
  • Jobs
  • News
  • More
    • Guests
    • Events
    • Blog
    • PodCred
    • Networks
    Join nowSign in

Off the Record

Off the Record artwork

Episode 10 - Boardroom Time Travel: When Decisions Come Back

Sep 8, 202617 minAudio

When should a Board revisit a decision it has already made, and when is it simply re-prosecuting an argument that should have been left in the past? In this episode of Off the Record, Lisa and Adam explore the governance and behavioural dynamics that emerge when decisions find their way back onto the Board agenda. They unpack what should legitimately trigger reconsideration, why unresolved disagreement can keep dragging Boards backwards, and how collective accountability, delegation and the Chair’s role all influence whether a Board can actually move forward once a decision has been made. They also explore why the parameters for reconsideration can sometimes be established at the point of the original decision, what the minutes should capture when a decision is revisited, and the deceptively simple question that can help distinguish good governance from Boardroom time travel: What has changed?

Audio and video play straight from the show's own hosting. PodSubs stores and serves no media.

Transcript

From the show. Tap a time to play from there.

SPEAKER_02Well, hi everyone. Welcome again to Off for the Record, a podcast full of governance conversations that don't make the minutes. I'm Adam Coonan, and here with me as always, my friend Lisa Colletta. We are both governance consultants for our SIMS. And the following represents our perspectives drawn from our work with board and chairs of those boards. They don't, these views constitute legal advice or formal governance guidance. And so with our regular disclaimer done, Lisa, what are we starting with today?

SPEAKER_00Today, Adam, it's a it's a topic really close to my heart. And uh let me just ask you, have you ever sat in a boardroom, board meeting, and had the strange feeling you've had exactly this same conversation playing out before?

SPEAKER_02Ah, yes, yes, yes, I have indeed. Uh sometimes you are thinking, I'm fairly certain we just discussed this. We we made a decision about it, didn't we? Yet somehow it's found its way back onto the agenda. Um, and you know, I guess it's a particular kind of deja vu that only exists for boardrooms and governance people. It's it's the one that arrives with the paper and the words in the heading, you know, for further consideration, you know.

SPEAKER_02So yep, know it well.

SPEAKER_00Yeah, yeah, you know the deal. Same issues, same arguments, quite possibly the same people making them. And so today I thought we would actually talk a little bit about a bit of boardroom time travel. Because um, for me, while I I do believe boards should absolutely revisit decisions because circumstances change, risks move, assumptions can prove wrong. But for me, there's a difference between revisiting a decision because something material has changed and re-prosecuting because somebody didn't like the decision in the first place.

SPEAKER_00And you know, where does that line actually sit?

SPEAKER_02Yeah, yeah. Well, I if you're asking me, I I I think it um turns or it should least turn on whether there's a new basis for the board's judgment. That is a decision is an immutable, so the circumstances underpinning it materially changing, of course the board should reconsider. But I guess maybe it's controversial, maybe not. My my starting position sits higher, and that is that I don't think a board should be revisiting decisions in an unplanned way at all.

SPEAKER_02Um two two honourable exceptions, I guess. Uh one is shutting something down, shutting bad things down sooner is uh something boards often struggle with as well. I I think when you make decisions to do that, if it's a revisiting all good. Um but the other one is I guess the post-implement implementation review type approach where you um deliberately go back to uh learn rather than to relitic relitigate. Um but outside those parameters um or outside those circumstances, going back should uh the rules for going back, or the parameters again, I guess using that word too many times, but the parameters for going back should be settled when the decision is made.

SPEAKER_02If the decision is genuinely contingent, build the trigger into the resolution when you first make the decision. Uh we approve this and we will come back to it at X point, or if Y happens, the reconsideration then becomes part of the decision rather than an assault on it.

SPEAKER_00Yeah, yeah, I get that. And I guess that the behavioral benefit of that trigger, um, it doesn't really get enough credit, does it? Um, if the board has already agreed when it's going to look at something again, coming back isn't a challenge to anyone. You know, it's just a schedule. It's just it gets added to the Ford plan, or it actually it's a trigger point, right? Um the director who was uncomfortable, um, you know, has somewhere legitimate to put that discomfort. You know what I mean? Because really very often what we're actually after, which gives us a really beautifully simple starting question.

SPEAKER_00And that is, what's changed? So before we fire up the, you know, the TARDIS time machine or whatever it's called from Doctor Who, um, you know, tell me what's different. New information, an assumption no longer holds, a shift in regulation or funding, or someone materially affected um who was never consulted. And I wonder, would you actually include a problem, you know, with the original process itself as part of that condition or part of that trigger point, Adam?

SPEAKER_02I think so. I mean, if if material information wasn't available or a conflict wasn't managed or an important risk wasn't considered, there may be very good reason to reopen it. Um I'm sounding a bit contradictory now, I know, from my firm at the beginning, but a good example in Australia at present is uh almost any public company board who has run a competitive tender in recent years for their uh audit services.

unknownAbsolutely.

SPEAKER_02They're all looking back at that. So um I I have to say, possibly a little cynically, uh, that enthusiasm for discovering a process deficiency does tend to correlate rather rather neatly with how votes go on decisions, but none of that is inherent weakness, I don't think. A board doesn't have to defend a decision just because it made it.

SPEAKER_00Yeah, look, look, I agree. Um it is the we decided on what we knew then. What we know now is materially different type situations. So it's indecision for me. Um, and then there's the other version. Nothing's changed. Someone still doesn't agree. And I've got to say it's my tolerance levels for someone still not agreeing after a collective decision-making environment. Uh, conversation was had and the table was banged and the approval was provided.

SPEAKER_00For me, that's a really behavioral conversation because what's actually being reopened isn't the decision, it's the emotional residue of the decision, Adam. You know, someone felt they weren't holed or heard or they lost an argument, there might be ego, a power dynamic, or someone who can't reconcile their own view with the collective one. And I can, you know, and I can tell you, and everyone listening in family boards, especially the disagreement often has a historical kind of you know, considerably longer kind of history than the actual board itself.

SPEAKER_00So the actual dynamic comes into the boardroom even, you know, before the board even existed, likely. Um, so we're not traveling back to the last meeting. We might be traveling back to the angst or whatever's being carried from like 20 years ago. Um, but look, anyway, let's let's talk about the director who genuinely disagrees but is outvoted. Like what bang.

SPEAKER_02Well, the the the the director, the director, sounds like sort of a maybe the title of a movie. Um they they don't have to pretend they agree, they can they can put their position, they should almost always be challenging thinking. I've said that many times before, and yeah, it's theoretical, but you know, pretty important too in a practical sense. Um and they can have their dissent recorded if they really want to or insist. But back to your point, a board is a collective decision-making body.

SPEAKER_02So once a decision has been properly made, there has to be recognition that the board has decided, even if it isn't the decision every director would have made. Otherwise, the board decision is provisional. And, you know, from our previous discussion, Lisa, we're back to our uh board or business risk appetite versus the director and their own risk appetite. So in my in my opinion, the the way back should be narrow. Uh deal with the new basis, not the whole uh original argument.

SPEAKER_02Uh or to use a uh, dare I say, Lisa behavioral governancism, um, the meeting reverts to the emotional state it was in the first time. So we don't want that. We move beyond that. Yeah.

SPEAKER_00Yeah, look, look, I get that. Governancism.

SPEAKER_02Well yeah, I don't know. Maybe, maybe that's maybe it'll catch on.

SPEAKER_00Yeah, look, look, maybe it will, maybe it will. Um I think though, when I think about it, it's really one of the hardest disciplines around a board table because the question itself changes before the decision, what do I think we should do? After the decision, what has changed?

SPEAKER_02Yeah. And and I hasten to add, underneath all of this sits delegation, which is the same question, albeit one level down. If if delegations are clear and management is operating inside them, there's nothing to revisit because the board never took the decision. Uh, a surprising uh share of what I see reopened should have been settled, you know, a few floors below the boardroom. And to use a perhaps bad joke, has somehow made the lift back up to the to the top.

SPEAKER_02Um, it's um it's it's revisionism at a couple of different levels, I guess.

SPEAKER_00Yeah, look, I think that's right. And um delegation does something to the room that people really underestimate. When a board reaches down and takes back a decision that sits with management, management reads it as a statement about trust. And they respond by bringing more up rather than less, which is exactly the opposite of what the board wanted or ordinarily wants post-decision as well. So if the same matter appeared again next meeting, you know, what would you ask?

SPEAKER_02Well, again, what what has changed?

SPEAKER_00What's changed? Yeah, what has changed?

SPEAKER_02Um if there's no answer to that, um, I'd be asking why we're using the board's time on it.

SPEAKER_01Yeah.

SPEAKER_02Uh hopefully you've worked out that um the chair has some say in things. I guess you know, you do the agenda setting exercise and uh it might not get to it. But either way, asking those questions is not shutting down challenge. It's it's protecting the integrity of the original decision. Uh and it reminds me, you know, the the old rule behind all of this, and it applies to first decisions as much as second. Um if something doesn't need to be decided, don't decide it.

SPEAKER_02Uh we've got a delegation for that, or we've decided that, like whatever the way it w it might go. But um my my late father uh put that to me in terms I've never improved on, uh, and that is uh whether to order the pink or purple polka dot coffee mugs for the staff cafeteria is not a decision that time should be invested in, because either answer is fine. And no shareholder or stakeholder has ever been enriched or benefited by the outcome.

SPEAKER_02Uh, although my rather uh aesthetic, uh is that the right word they use these days, the um the kids uh aesthetic daughter might might might quibble with that one, um, and maybe yours too, Lisa. But bit a bit you fast um uh board, it will happily eat 20 minutes up, I reckon, because it's it's a comfortable liberation. It's safe and and everybody has has the view about the aesthetics of mugs. Um but in all seriousness, those 20 minutes come out of an item that actually carries consequence, of course.

SPEAKER_02And uh it might mean a decision gets deferred because the meeting ran long. Uh, and next month it's back, and half the room has decided the delay itself is a reason to reconsider it.

SPEAKER_00Yeah, look, I get that. And I think that that's a behavioral pattern before it's a time management one, because that inconsequential decision making, it they're real those decisions are really psychologically safe, aren't they? Everyone can hold a view, no one can be wrong, and it feels like proper participation because everyone gets to speak up and have a say. Um, those consequential decisions, though, Adam, carry the risk of being the person who backed the wrong thing. And that's where I think it's really, really interesting. And of course, meanwhile, the real decisions end up being technically made, but psychologically provisional, dare I say?

SPEAKER_00And management doesn't know whether to implement an old argument's kind of eat future agendas. So you know, so so something practical, you know, those those three questions I'd be asking before reopening a decision is what has changed? Is that change material to the basis on which the board decided? And are we acting in the interests of the organization or continuing an unresolved disagreement around that boardroom table?

SPEAKER_02Yeah, and that that last one takes the most honesty because sometimes what needs addressing isn't the decision. Um you're really getting to me here, Lise, with your uh with your behavioral governance because uh it's the dynamic that keeps um dragging the board back into it. Um I guess I'd add a fourth question, um, the one that nobody enjoys asking. Did we agree when we made the decision that we would look at it again? I I think that that has to be a yardstick.

SPEAKER_02Um, if the answer is no and nothing's moved, then uh what's in front of the board isn't a decision. It's ultimately to use the sort of tennis analogy a rematch.

SPEAKER_00Well, look, I think that's right too. And there's a lot to say around the chair's role when it comes to this because you know, the chair, the CEO, or the managing director and the COSEC sit around that table designing great decision-making environments and great agendas to deliver on outcomes. Or not. Um and you know, well, they do, they do, right?

SPEAKER_02No, I'm being silly. I'm being silly.

SPEAKER_00Yeah, but look, ideally they do that. And so I kind of sit back and go between the three of them, how are they actually justifying this rematch that you're you know you're referring to here? And so, um, and of course, you know, the minutes matter here, including how much of the original rationale needs to be actually captured, right? So, what do you think on that?

SPEAKER_02Yeah, no, I agree. Enough for for a proper governance record, not a transcript. Uh, you know, what was decided, the material considerations, the significant risks, any conditions. Um, where appropriate, like I said before, dissent, someone might really be keen and you record in the minute, you know. Um, but if the board uh does go back, the minutes should be a tool to connect the two decisions. Uh I guess the trail earns its keep in the setting that nobody wants to be in.

SPEAKER_02Um the the the regulator working back through a sequence of decisions reads a board that recorded why it went back as a board exercising judgment. Um I guess. And and and to just throw a point out, you know, three three approvals with nothing to explain any of them reads rather differently uh than that something that has that connection. Um that second version uh is the one we get um called about usually after Asaca's formed a view.

SPEAKER_00Yeah, look, I get that too, which you know, which matters because memory is wonderfully unreliable, isn't it? You know, we remember risks differently once we know what happened. The record tells future us what the board actually knew rather than what we now remember knowing. It's quite an interesting thing that plays out because you know it's it's that it's that one point of the truth, right? And so changing a decision because circumstances have materially changed can be, you know, excellent governance. Refusing to reconsider when they have um can be terrible governance.

SPEAKER_00So reopening a settled matter because someone can't accept the collective decision as something else entirely. So um, you know, next time that time machine warms up, you know, I encourage everyone to ask that one question, you know, what has changed? If the answer is essentially I still don't agree, the governance issue may no longer be the decision. Um, what may be happening is actually between the people around the table, Adam.

SPEAKER_02Yes, and as you usually say in our conversations, uh, that's the bit that doesn't make the minutes.

SPEAKER_00Exactly. And if you take nothing else from this episode today, folks, um, spare a thought for the mugs. Buy whichever is cheaper and hand the board back its 20 minutes.

SPEAKER_02That's a that's a good that's a good summary and and maybe a good point to end on. So uh thanks for listening, everybody. Thanks as always, Lisa. Uh, and we'll see you all next time. See you then.

Open the transcript file

Hosts and Guests

Nobody is credited on this episode yet.

Credit the people on this episode

Be the first to rate this episode

More episodes

All episodes
  1. Episode 12 - What happens when the Board itself becomes the risk?

    Oct 28, 202621 minAudio

    AI, cyber security, regulatory change and emerging risks are placing increasing demands on Boards. But what happens when the real challenge isn't the complexity of these issues, but the capability of the Board itself?...

    Credit the people on this episode

  2. Episode 11 - Six Degrees of Boardroom Separation

    Sep 29, 202624 minAudio

    How connected are Australia’s Boardrooms, really? In this episode of Off the Record, Lisa and Adam explore the invisible networks that exist between ASX-listed company Boardrooms and what those connections might mean...

    Credit the people on this episode

  3. Episode 9 - The Risk Appetite that Nobody Talks About

    Aug 18, 202622 minAudio

    In this episode, Lisa and Adam explore the risk appetite that rarely gets discussed: the personal risk tolerance each director brings into the Boardroom. Boards may collectively agree how much and what types of risk an...

    Credit the people on this episode

  4. Episode 8 - Governance Doesn’t Make You Money... Or Does It?

    Jul 28, 202615 minAudio

    Governance is often viewed as an overhead: something that costs money, adds process and doesn’t directly contribute to the bottom line. So why should business owners invest in it? In this episode, Lisa and Adam explore...

    Credit the people on this episode

  5. Episode 7 - AI Doesn't Change Governance. It Reveals It.

    Jul 13, 202621 minAudio

    In this episode, Lisa and Adam explore why AI isn't changing governance. It's revealing it. They discuss why legal accountability remains firmly with people, how AI is exposing and magnifying the behavioural dynamics...

    Credit the people on this episode