Skip to content
PodSubs
ShowsPeopleGuestsJobsNewsEvents
More
BlogPodCred
Menu
ShowsPeopleGuestsJobsNewsEventsBlogPodCredNetworksSign in
Join nowSign in
  • Shows
  • People
  • Jobs
  • News
  • More
    • Guests
    • Events
    • Blog
    • PodCred
    • Networks
    Join nowSign in

Off the Record

Off the Record artwork

Episode 9 - The Risk Appetite that Nobody Talks About

Aug 18, 202622 minAudio

In this episode, Lisa and Adam explore the risk appetite that rarely gets discussed: the personal risk tolerance each director brings into the Boardroom. Boards may collectively agree how much and what types of risk an organisation is prepared to accept, but every director brings their own experiences, conditioning, successes and failures to the table. And sometimes, those personal experiences can quietly influence how they respond when a real decision tests the boundaries of the Board’s agreed appetite. Lisa and Adam unpack what happens when an individual director’s comfort with risk begins to influence collective judgement, why being more cautious doesn’t necessarily mean better governance, and how the same dynamic can play out when a director has a much higher tolerance for risk than the organisation itself. They also explore the role of the Chair, the impact these dynamics can have on management, and the importance of directors recognising when their experience is providing valuable insight and when their personal conditioning may be driving their response. Because different perspectives on risk are valuable. The governance challenge is ensuring they inform and strengthen collective judgement rather than quietly replace it.

Audio and video play straight from the show's own hosting. PodSubs stores and serves no media.

Transcript

From the show. Tap a time to play from there.

SPEAKER_02Well, hello everyone, and welcome again to another episode of Off the Record, a podcast full of governance conversations that don't make the minutes. I'm Adam Coonan, and here as always with me is my friend and colleague Lisa Colletta. We are both specialist governance consultants, and between us bring different lenses to governance. I'm sure those that have listened to this have have noticed that much. And in this podcast, we explore what's really driving decisions inside boardrooms in our own unique ways, not just the structures and frameworks, but the dynamics, tensions, and conversations sitting underneath them.

SPEAKER_02The disclaimer, everything we share is drawn from our own experiences working with boards, chairs, and executives, teams. And these, of course, are our perspectives only. They do not constitute legal advice or formal governance guidance. With that out of the way, as always, hello Lisa, and let's get right into today's topic. Today we are talking about risk appetite. Specifically, whose risk appetite is running the board. Most boards, uh Lisa, jump in when you want, but most boards have spent some time agreeing how much and what type of risks the organization is prepared to accept in pursuit of strategy.

SPEAKER_02But every director sitting around the table has, I guess, a risk appetite of their own inherently. And while they theoretically should, sometimes the two don't align. Lisa, uh I guess I'll start with a question for you. What what happens when the board hasn't uh agreed is prepared to take a particular risk, but um what ha or has or hasn't, but let's say has agreed to take a particular risk, but one of the directors personally hasn't or won't or isn't at that point?

SPEAKER_00Yeah, it's a really interesting thing, isn't it? Because the reality is that at the time that the board are approving the board's uh risk framework that includes risk appetite typically within the policy, they're not actually thinking about the operational realities around the boardroom table when they're using it. And um, it can happen. Um, there is a difference between the board's agreed company level risk appetite and one director uh one director personally isn't quite there around their personal risk uh appetite.

SPEAKER_00And this is where the risk appetite conversation stops about being purely about the framework and becomes a behavioral governance one. Um, because what I found is that every director brings their own relationship with risk into the boardroom, regardless of whether they were one of the many collectives signing off on that policy and framework. So their experiences, their successes, and especially, Adam, their failures, uh the crisis that they've lived through, the investment that went badly, or the risks they've taken throughout their career that paid off spectacularly well, those experiences shape how they and how we respond to uncertainty.

SPEAKER_00And it's really hard to leave all of that at the door. And to be really frank with you, it's actually can be valuable. And the issue begins when our experience stops informing the board's judgment and starts often unconsciously overriding its collective judgment. Um, because I found that there's a really significant difference between my experience tells me there may be something here we haven't considered, and I personally wouldn't take the risk, therefore the organization shouldn't either.

SPEAKER_02Yeah. Yeah, well there's there's certainly a tension there though. Um directors are required to exercise independent judgment. We recently talked about that in our in our AI episode. Uh and if genuinely they believe a decision is wrong, I you know, I I I can't simply um point to the risk appetite state uh statement and and you know exclaim, apparently we're comfortable with this. Um after all, exercising independent judgment is uh not a task you can quietly outsource to a document.

SPEAKER_02And you know, I know you'll be with me there. Um legal obligation does not carry a footnote reading, you know, unless the board PAC has already dealt with it. Um and the risk appetite statement, uh, useful as it is, has never once offered to sit in the witness box on a director's behalf.

SPEAKER_00That's absolutely true. And you know, it's it's not and we can't. It can't. Yes. If something doesn't stack up, directors are actually expected to challenge it. If circumstances have changed, there's an expectation that that will be surfaced. If new information changes the risk profile, interrogate it. Yeah, just ask the questions. That's what the expectation is of every director sitting around that boardroom table.

SPEAKER_00An approved risk appetite isn't a substitute for judgment.

SPEAKER_02Yeah, it can't just be set and forget.

SPEAKER_00Look, it can't be, and neither should an individual director's personal risk tolerance become a substitute for the board's collective judgment.

SPEAKER_01Yeah.

SPEAKER_00Because assuming the process is, you know, is being done or has been done properly, the board has already considered strategy and opportunity and downside and capacity and uncertainty. And they've already collectively agreed, right, that this is the level and type of risk we're prepared to accept, or even this is the level of risk we're not willing to accept, and this is our mitigation strategy, or is it a yes or a no, or a go or a no-go, depending on the dynamic of what's being considered.

SPEAKER_00Um, and the reality is that's when the real decision arrives, or that's where the real framework gets tested. Agreeing with risk appetite when it's in a document that requires approval in the board pack is one thing. Living with what that appetite feels like when there's money, reputation, and genuine uncertainty attached to something else is something really quite different.

SPEAKER_02No, well, yeah, exactly. It it can't, it can't possibly be an answer for everything. I mean, let's take a director who's uh previously lived through a disastrous acquisition, like you were sort of saying at the top, these these experiences, these negative experiences probably that that help us. Ten years later, different organization, different management team, another acquisition comes to the board. Um, and you know, the classic scenario, if it's the strategy, the due diligence is strong and it's within appetite. But um, our director asks uh another question.

SPEAKER_02Um the the the it's probably healthy, but but then another scenario may arise, then another sensitivity analysis, and I guess that's the tension. At some point, um, are we still assessing the acquisition or trying to establish that absolutely nothing could ever go wrong? That's that's where it starts to become dangerous. Some somewhere around the fourth sensitivity analysis, you suspect the deal team has uh quietly stopped modeling the acquisition and and instead started modeling uh the director and their preferences for all things.

SPEAKER_00Yeah, exactly. And uh, you know, every organization battles that peace around progress over perfection. And can there ever not be a risk? And all those kinds of things, and that's where experience can actually become conditioning. You know, experience says, I've seen something like this before, here's what I've learned. Conditioning says, I've seen something like this before, therefore this will just happen the same way again.

SPEAKER_00And conditioning actually really feels like conditioning when it's ours and it's ours personally. It actually feels like judgment, and sometimes it even feels like good governance, and we can kind of hide behind that good governance piece. The board needs to ask whether the additional information is still improving the quality of the decision, or whether we're trying to remove uncertainty because somebody, typically one body, their personal risk appetite or their personal comfortable comfort levels are being affected.

SPEAKER_00In other words, they're uncomfortable with it. Because sometimes what looks like organizational risk management is actually personal risk management playing out through the governance process, and we can enable and allow that to occur at these tables in this.

SPEAKER_02And I assume to delve into your sweet spot, Lisa, I assume I assume it works the other way too. The the the entrepreneur who's never met a risk they didn't fancy, perhaps, and you know, governance has come second, if that makes sense. The sort of who reads the risk appetite statement as um an opening bid rather than a boundary.

SPEAKER_00Absolutely. And and the director who's been repeatedly rewarded for taking big risks can be equally conditioned. So it can happen in the negative and it can happen in the positive. And of course, what happens is that management brings something forward that sits outside the agreed appetite, and they say, Well, we're overthinking this, we need to move. Um, that same dynamic plays out in the opposite direction.

SPEAKER_01Yes.

SPEAKER_00Um, this isn't cautious directors versus entrepreneurial directors, though, Adam. It's really for me a personal calibration versus a collective calibration. Okay, making decisions as collective, these are collective decision-making environments, not personal make Lisa or make the individual director feel comfortable and safe. Does that kind of make sense?

SPEAKER_02Yeah, yeah. And and you, you know, you would say that's that's the shift there, right?

SPEAKER_00Absolutely. That is the shift. We don't want to neutralize directors' personal experiences. We want to create space for people to speak up. We want those perspectives around those tables. The directors who experienced a failure acquisition or a failed acquisition may see something nobody else sees. You want to hear from them around that. The entrepreneur may identify an opportunity everyone else is too cautious to recognize. You want to hear them around that. The behavioral discipline is recognizing the difference between my experience is giving this board information it needs, and my experience is making me uncomfortable with the risk the board has already agreed, the organization is prepared to take.

SPEAKER_00And those perspectives should enrich collective judgment. They shouldn't actually replace it. And that's where the challenge is, Adam.

SPEAKER_02And if the board genuinely thinks its agreed appetite is wrong, then change it.

SPEAKER_00I mean, fundamentally change it. Risk appetite isn't carved in stone. Yes, it's in an approved policy, it's part of an existing framework. However, the board are the approvers of that. And if circumstances have changed or the board's thinking has evolved, they have every right to revisit it collectively. But that's very different from allowing it to drift decision by decision because an individual director can't operate comfortably within it.

SPEAKER_02And I I'd just say, as a subset of that, um also don't discount uh not the necessary health of disagreement, but this comes probably back to a topic for another day. But but this scenario of requiring or needing a consensus decision in order for it to be uh official or or or or good, or or what's good is is looked on as consensus. And that's not always the case. And I think sometimes we get around that too. So it may not be that uh the risk appetite does need to change, it just means that we need to talk it out and hear different perspectives.

SPEAKER_02We may end up with consensus, but equally uh it may be that the risk appetite um doesn't need to change and and people need to uh to to look at things in a different way. But but look, um let's talk about um you know the help here, I guess. How does a board know this is happening? I I doubt I doubt the risk appetite statement has a section headed um things David experienced in his previous company that uh you know may unexpectedly denominate today's deliberations. Um although although I guess if you get uh a lot of baggage in a in a new nominee in particular, perhaps it should.

SPEAKER_02Um certainly a bio should come around on that person's background. But the less comfortable version of that heading um tends to service the latter. When when someone at a regulator builds the same meeting from the board papers and asks quite reasonably why the appetite on the page never seemed to match the conduct in the room, um, by then the gap has usually stopped being a governance nuance and and and become closer to, you know, and it's scary words, but it but an exhibit uh for a for a for a court um uh and and or at least uh for some type of proceedings, uh inquiry or otherwise.

SPEAKER_02Um and that gap, uh, in all seriousness between the appetite a board wrote down and the one that actually it lived is is very often the exact thing. Uh, you know, we you or I might get called in to help a client explain and and where we can to r repair it before it develops an audience with uh, shall we say, uh a less understanding stakeholder beyond the boardroom.

SPEAKER_00Look, I think that's that's absolutely right. And and this sort of dichotomy around everyone being around the boardroom table needs to be happy with every decision we make, uh, is a really interesting one as well. Um, but when it comes down to it, Adam, I'm finding for me and the world I operate in, the environments I'm stepping into, I look for patterns. Look for patterns. Is the same director repeatedly seeking levels of assurance beyond what the agreed appetite requires?

SPEAKER_00Are decisions being revisited without materially new information? Does every answer generate another request? Are they ever satisfied? Is one category of risk receiving disproportionate attention? And let's face it, we always see that, especially around reputational risk as an example. Or is the opposite happening? Or is it in the opposite direction? Is somebody continually pushing the organization beyond the agreed boundaries because they're personally comfortable in doing so?

SPEAKER_00So the risk appetite is uh in a different place to the organizations in uh you know sort of a higher or more appetite sense. And of course, as part of watching the patterns, we also want to watch management because management learns the board's real behavioral risk appetite. So what ends up happening, and I'm sure you've seen it, Adam, is that they learn to it.

SPEAKER_02Oh, Lisa's never going to go for that.

SPEAKER_00They're not gonna go for that. Let's not put it in the back.

SPEAKER_02What's that got to do with the risk appetite? No one will probably then respond to the thing.

SPEAKER_00Because you know, Adam will say yes to this because I know that Adam, you know, you'll you'll have a go. And it's one of those things, right, where management learn which opportunities aren't worth putting forward, which issues require another 10 pages, where the actual decision-making boundaries sit, even you know, and even or eventually they start designing recommendations around the appetite actually demonstrated in the room rather than the appetite written on the framework. And that's where this becomes strategically significant, Adam.

SPEAKER_01Yeah, I agree.

SPEAKER_00And there's another with this, there's another pattern worth naming. Watch what happens to the board's language when it senses it's being observed, whether by a regulator, by an investor, investor group, or the media, the conversation may well shift from what's the right decision here to how will this look if somebody reviews it later? That's a subtlety, a really subtle important tell, because a board managing how it's being judged uh will read to an outsider in a really, really different way.

SPEAKER_00So, in other words, because a board managing how it's being judged at the time, it isn't really demonstrating that it's exercising its own appetite anymore, or after that point, it's actually borrowing someone else's based on their perception of what's actually going to be looked for and how they're actually going to be judged.

SPEAKER_02Yeah. Yeah, well, look, I'd hope at one level those those things uh whilst they're important references, you know, that that you you make them or they can align, they're they're the they're the best decision-making environments, but but when it's not, I totally understand the point you're making. And and you know, I guess that also uh puts the chair right in the middle of it, um, refereeing a contest that uh uh officially nobody at the table will will admit is is actually taking place.

SPEAKER_00Look, it does. It does. And what it means too is that a good chair shouldn't shut down challenge, but they should recognize when challenges stop generating new insight. And that's the challenge there, because sometimes the most useful question is are we concerned that this sits outside our agreed risk appetite, or are some of us personally less comfortable with this risk? And there's a really big difference there. Because for me, the individual directors can actually ask themselves exactly the same thing. Am I challenging this because it sits outside the organization's risk appetite, or because it's uh it sits outside of mine personally?

SPEAKER_00And and that question doesn't actually silence experience. What I think it does, and I've seen this a few times now, over and over, in fact, is that it helps us understand what's actually driving it and what's actually driving us. You know what I mean? And of course, there's a there's a version of this that only shows up under pressure. So when the heat's on and when the stakes rise and the room feels watched, even a well-calibrated director can start confusing caution with rigor.

SPEAKER_00So more questions feel like more diligence, but past a certain point, that extra caution isn't actually reducing the risk in any way. Um, it's not reducing the risk of a bad decision. What it's actually doing is it's that it's reducing the discomfort of making one. And those aren't the same thing. And a board under scrutiny has to be honest with itself about which one it's actually buying at that point in time.

SPEAKER_02I hear you. I hear you. And perhaps that's the real test of risk appetite. Um not whether the board can agree the words in the document, but whether the people around the table can govern with those boundaries when a real decision makes them uncomfortable. Um because a a risk appetite that only works while risky is a hypothetical, I'll say, as much as I love documents, as you know, Lisa, you know, it isn't much of a risk appetite.

SPEAKER_02It's a it's a mood. Risk mood. Um and and if um every difficult decision causes the poor to retreat to the comfort level of, I guess in that case, its most cautious director or or otherwise to stretch to the appetite of the most adventurous one, then the framework um isn't much of a foundation um for the organization. It isn't, it isn't, certainly isn't governing the organization, the personalities are.

SPEAKER_00Look, absolutely, exactly it. So, you know, we know that every director brings experience into the boardroom, and they should. Every director has its own relationship with risk and their past experiences as part of that, and they always will. The governance challenge is having enough self-awareness to actually recognize when your experience is helping the board seeing something it genuinely needs to see, and when your conditioning is actually influencing what you're personally prepared to accept.

SPEAKER_00And our different risk tolerances should inform collective judgment. They shouldn't actually quietly replace it, and this happens, unfortunately. So perhaps for me, Adam, the question is to ask whether you find yourself particularly finding yourself feeling really particularly strongly about a decision and asking yourself, is this outside the organization's risk appetite or is it actually outside of mine? Because sometimes the most important risk dynamic around the boardroom table isn't captured in the risk register at all.

SPEAKER_00It's actually sitting in us, it's sitting within us. And those are exactly the kinds of governance conversations that really make the minutes, Adam.

SPEAKER_02Oh well, um, as always, bringing it uh background to uh to the top, uh Lisa. Uh good point to pause, I think, and uh we'll uh pick it up, no doubt, uh again in another episode soon. So thanks everyone for joining us once again on Off the Record.

SPEAKER_00A podcast full of governance conversations that don't make the minutes. Thanks so much.

Open the transcript file

Hosts and Guests

Nobody is credited on this episode yet.

Credit the people on this episode

Be the first to rate this episode

More episodes

All episodes
  1. Episode 12 - What happens when the Board itself becomes the risk?

    Oct 28, 202621 minAudio

    AI, cyber security, regulatory change and emerging risks are placing increasing demands on Boards. But what happens when the real challenge isn't the complexity of these issues, but the capability of the Board itself?...

    Credit the people on this episode

  2. Episode 11 - Six Degrees of Boardroom Separation

    Sep 29, 202624 minAudio

    How connected are Australia’s Boardrooms, really? In this episode of Off the Record, Lisa and Adam explore the invisible networks that exist between ASX-listed company Boardrooms and what those connections might mean...

    Credit the people on this episode

  3. Episode 10 - Boardroom Time Travel: When Decisions Come Back

    Sep 8, 202617 minAudio

    When should a Board revisit a decision it has already made, and when is it simply re-prosecuting an argument that should have been left in the past? In this episode of Off the Record, Lisa and Adam explore the...

    Credit the people on this episode

  4. Episode 8 - Governance Doesn’t Make You Money... Or Does It?

    Jul 28, 202615 minAudio

    Governance is often viewed as an overhead: something that costs money, adds process and doesn’t directly contribute to the bottom line. So why should business owners invest in it? In this episode, Lisa and Adam explore...

    Credit the people on this episode

  5. Episode 7 - AI Doesn't Change Governance. It Reveals It.

    Jul 13, 202621 minAudio

    In this episode, Lisa and Adam explore why AI isn't changing governance. It's revealing it. They discuss why legal accountability remains firmly with people, how AI is exposing and magnifying the behavioural dynamics...

    Credit the people on this episode