Skip to content
PodSubs
ShowsPeopleGuestsJobsNewsEvents
More
BlogPodCred
Menu
ShowsPeopleGuestsJobsNewsEventsBlogPodCredNetworksSign in
Join nowSign in
  • Shows
  • People
  • Jobs
  • News
  • More
    • Guests
    • Events
    • Blog
    • PodCred
    • Networks
    Join nowSign in

Noosfera

Noosfera artwork

Noosfera 199. La periferia de tu galaxia | Felipe Paredes

May 10, 20241 hr 5 minAudio
ShareXLinkedInFacebookWhatsAppEmail

No somos el centro de nuestra galaxia. De hecho, vivimos en su periferia… o tal vez no. Porque cuando le preguntamos a quién sabe, resulta que eso de la periferia no está tan claro y que, para algunas definiciones, estamos prácticamente en el mismo centro de la Vía Láctea. ¿Dónde están los confines de nuestra galaxia, entonces? ¿Qué sucede en esos bordes? Para hablar de ello tenemos con nosotros a Felipe Paredes, licenciado en Física y máster en Astrofísica por la Universidad Complutense de Madrid. Allí se especializó en el estudio de galaxias a través de las simulaciones numéricas. Continuó hacia la radioastronomía en el Observatorio de Yebes, centrándose en la interferometría de muy larga base. Mientras tanto, ha desarrollado una intensa actividad divulgadora desde la Asociación de Astrónomos Aficionados ASAAF y desarrollando experimentos para la televisión nacional en programas como Órbita Laika, Curioseando y Todos Contra 1. Un podcast de Diario La Razón, dirigido y presentado por Ignacio Crespo y producido por https://lafabricadepodcast.com

Audio and video play straight from the show's own hosting. PodSubs stores and serves no media.

Transcript

From the show. Tap a time to play from there.

He doesn' t expect the tinty podcast of reason. I' m about to send a letter to myself to see how long the intergalactic mail takes and what I know to see if I miss it or what happens. Let'

s go there street of laerce number one, Madrid, Madrid, Spain, the Earth, the way, the tea, c fourth b to see where we' re really supposed to be. My name is Ignacio Crespo and this

is nosfea podcast of science of reason. We' re astrophysicists today because we ' re going to talk about the galaxy, specifically, about the periphery of the galaxy. What' s beyond the center. The thing is, it ' s the center, which is the periphery that' s in the middle and where we put the line that' s going to divide it. For this we have with us Felipe Paredes, who graduated in physics and master' s degree in astrophysics from the Complutense University of Madrid. There he specialized in

the study of galaxies through numedic simulations. It continues towards radio astronomy at the Jeves Observatory, focusing on very long base interfeometry. Meanwhile, it has developed an intense outreach activity from the Association of Amateur Astronomy to SAF and developing experiments for national television in programs like Vitallik, curiosating or all against one. Thank you so much for being with us, Felipe Mucha. Thank you so much to you for the invitation and for the opportunity to talk about this distress of

galaxies. But, well, it' s an African girl that almost everyone likes. That seems to me to be one of the important points to start with. Why am I going to ask you like everyone else why you studied this, because you dedicated yourself to this field and not to another. It ' s a multi- part question. I' m gonna try to use it as the most emotional part. Okay, it' s kind of more cliché, so to speak, because when I was a kid I was asking him with a bunch of questions, even too many, I would say I

and my mother always had you as the infinite patience to answer them all, because I could quietly have told me I don' t know go to Wikipedia or what I would have existed at that time to read it, but I was trying to answer it. He was looking for information with me, showing me documentaries and also my parents. That was like a kind of double- edged weapon, because if it' s worth everything we can, that there ' s something specific that can make him cool. And, on the one hand, I turn, in this typical supermarket microscope that breaks to the minimum

and between these tiny little details, they ended up with a horrible telescope. They ended up giving me a terrible gift. I always sell it fell by its own weight. The lens was not well curved, the eyepiece had never just focused. But after fighting me all night trying to observe the moon that ' s like the star, that observes, that it' s like it ' s not hard to lose it. First I saw was the moon in

relief, which is something I had never seen that was like one, which is this moon, especially in the terminator this boundary between light and shadow, I began to see the reliefs of the characters. And it' s like I already knew, the moon was a ball. But there, I kind of saw it for the first time and from there it was a whole connection to say it' s okay why this is so, why there are craters, because there' s a ball around there and I found the next day that there' s the astrophysicist euse. The next day, literally, the next day, I literally said, there is the astrophysicistic trade, not in

the astronomer, not anything astrophysicistic. So I was that kid that from the age of eight when I asked him what I wanted to do, because astrophysicist I did, but I don' t want to do astrophysicist, and then I did everything that is the path of physics and astrophysics to get to that knowledge and then the topic of astrophysics happened to me the same. We have like the sides, between sides, between quotes, between stars and galaxies. Then there are the astroparticuleros we call them and I liked everything. Then I

tried to prove everything just that there was a coincidence that in my TFE, in my TFM, the theme of galaxies came up with a wonderful tuton SANTII Rock, Fábrega and so on, that let' s say that I allowed myself to explore very freely the whole subject of galaxies and the theme of galaxy simulations, which is something that I already had in my heart the whole subject of programming and that I liked very much. So it was such a beautiful

experience and so let' s say that I ended up learning so much with so much freedom that in the end, I decided to tie myself to the side of galaxies and, above all, to the side of galaxy simulations. From that telescope, well, from that microscope that was even before. The change that involves total years. It' s a lot of years, but from that telescopic cla, the microscope, the typical thing about starting to land and anything to see what came out. And you didn' t see anything, but you saw a drop move and you said oh, I' m

looking at the microscopic world. Sometimes what you saw was your own eyelashes that I' m so not telling damage, you say no, they' re not spiders. I had a hard time finding out. I discovered it with the telescope, the truth of the eyelashes. You say yes, yes, because I do what happens to the moon. There are black things moving around by declaring that they are the earth samples. It was likely, but on the moon, no, no, I couldn' t be discovering life on the moon. It would be wonderful, but accurate. But I said no and ended up finding out it was me in the end. That' s great. Okay. We' re going to pause very briefly and we'

re going to start with the listeners' questions now, because I don' t know if it' s been taking a telescope and the next day wondering if they wanted the astrophysicistic trade. But at the very least they are curious we pause very briefly and immediately. We' re back or we' re back. The first question we have, because here let us remember that the questions are asked by listeners on social networks. We ask you what doubts you have for an expert person in this or that field they do to us, we pick it up, and these ask us why galaxies are flattened, since we are going to talk about galaxies on their periphery and so let' s

start if you want. For this reason I will try to reach a comparison that still escapes my generation a little, but still escapes younger generations. And it' s talking about Olivery BNG going from Olivery BENJY' s ball one thing you see in this series is, after giving him a magic ball, crossing a field of eighty zero kilometers, let' s say that the ball

takes a rotation that you see as it starts to be planned. And even though Oliver and Benji are never talking to you about what is the angular moment of their ball, the truth is that it represents in a way that is quite realistically, what would happen to an object that is in rotation and is a little bit of the image that I want to take with it, which is anything in rotation is going to tend to flatten, which is the idea

that is going to be crushed by the poles, but, for example, we have a ball, a sphere is crushed by the poles and let' s say that it stretches towards the equator and this is the vision. Then the question that makes it is why. Because all of a sudden this would happen, because we' ll have this flattening and one way we can imagine it is let' s say. I think the best way to imagine ourselves is first to go to the linear world in plan everything in a straight line,

because here we are talking about rotations and movements, which is a little difficult to understand the first, because the linear world. Imagine if you imagine that in a soil you throw mobolón of marbles in one direction, mogollón of marbles in another direction, but randomly, with random force and with a quantity of random canicas. Well they' re going to start colliding with each other, they' re going to start interacting with each other and let' s

say that each marble is going to face other marbles, for example, and one is going to win. There' s one that there' s morecanics, there' s another where we say the cane goes faster. Or if we have marbles of different size or mass that we would say in the universe, I would also win this fight or this confrontation and let' s say it' s something like a winning side. It' s not like you get all the marbles collide in the center and stay still that can happen, but it' s a very strange thing, but there' s always going

to be some marble series that goes one way or the other. Well, if we imagine it with objects in rotation, the same would happen. There are things that are rotating along the equator of an imaginary sphere, along the poles, along the diagonals, in the sense, in the direction of the clock, in the previous sense, then we have all those confrontations towards the schedule, the anti- clockwise that in the end, when interacting with the rest of the material or the rest of the pieces like that someone is going

to win, then of all the sum that we are going to find ourselves in a nebula, in a galaxy, in any object that is in the universe, that is like forming, if it has loose particles. One of those rotations is going to win, and then the rest of us are going to say they' re going to get lost, and it' s going to end up with just one. And an area means having a single disk. In the perfect case, it would be a perfectly plan disk but in the case of the galaxy, it is a very flat disk with correct astrophysic

terms. It' s very flat and the system ah there will be people saying good, but a sphere I can also imagine rotating everything in the same direction and such, but it wouldn' t be exactly the same. The particles wouldn' t be going perfectly parallel in the same direction. There are problems in places, of course, there are problems. This would be, say, a simplification. Then, if you want to talk about how objects rotate around the galaxy, because we don' t imagine the idea of the

solar system of everything rotating homogeneously in its orbit. And what' s more, the solar system already has its problems. But it is true that this general tendency to move towards a single rotation. We observe it in anything in the universe and in galaxies. It is especially noticeable, because there are many loose particles that have had a lot of time to interact. It' s fantastic, I mean, it' s true that you can' t imagine

it as that cloud where everything goes in random directions. The opposite directions end up colliding like two cars going in the opposite direction and, logically, those cars don' t move anymore or if they move, it won' t be in the previous directions. No, and the good thing about these objects is that they don' t crash, they merge with each other. Sure, then you' re going to have an even bigger particle, which is going to want to dominate more in its rotation. Sure, sure, then there' s a hierarchy that feedbacks. Well, that' s fine and

we' re already clear then the shape of galaxies, that it' s not little notice that in this case we haven' t started by saying it ' s a galaxy, because I presume that that' s already controlled. Besides, you' ve told us, but there are many more basic questions. However, already passing a little bit to that concept of the periphery, because look Manuel Osorio tells us how far the periphery of one galaxy goes, and it is possible that the periphery of one overlaps with that of another. Okay it' s super interesting, because the concept of periphery is a concept

that at least we get into I don' t know which one. In any subject of mathematics or science or so on, we always imagine that there is an X edge up to ten. This is a sphere or this is the coverage of x or what' s something similar. And when we talk about galaxy peripheries, the point is that we have that the best way to see why it' s not an easy concept is to see in its components.

A galaxy is usually composed, say, of particles and gases. I ' m already seeing it from the point of view of simulations and you have all the concepts of star, all the concepts of stars with planets and all these concepts of particles. Then you could define dark matter also as particles depending on who asks for large particles. Then we' ll talk about what dark matter is if you want And then we have the nebulae, all the gas

and everything else that extends beyond. And normally particles can be contained within a limit, so to speak, very much in quotation marks. But gas is even harder to tell where it is. And I think that somehow we can imagine this is, for example, with a flame. It is easy to

see, for example, that a flame appears from one of an example, from a match and to see the match is worth the core of the match great. Then that brighter part the flame looks and you say okay Here' s a flame all this red part that' s just in contact with the match. Okay I can kind of see it as a limit. But as we move up in this flame, it' s like the flame is becoming more and more blurred, this one that there' s a point where you

haven' t noticed and there' s no flame. You say, I ' m going back, this way it' s called. Then I' ll go ahead. Not here. So it' s a hard concept to understand. So, rather than talking about a strict periphery, we' re talking about a quantitative periphery, which is rather to say to what extent, my galaxy has power over the material, to what extent this gas is from

the galaxy or is from the universe, so to speak. So that simulation is a term that we use a lot. It is the radius of the virial and it is a comparison between the gravitational force of the galaxy, that force of attracting all that material and the very dynamics of the universe, the expanding universe, which is trying to separate everything. So you do a calculation of a little bit equal to so much in a very crude way and you

see how far you get from the galaxy or the one where the universe itself is winning. And that would be our video radio. I mean, it ' s got interaction up here, but then a lot can happen. The universe just outside can be very quiet. So let' s say the galaxy has more interaction or not. Suddenly there may be another galaxy pressing or pushing that here is like entering that second part of the question, where another galaxy with its own periphery. They can either push or try to move or steal

or give material to the periphery of our original galaxy. So that' s how far the galaxy can work with its material, how far they leave it depending on everything around it, of course, how far it has control, where it starts to lose control. Of course and this is a number that we have had to put on mathematician, a number that we have all had to agree on, because, if it is not impossible. It' s the same as if you asked an astrophysicist from the sun, it tells you

where the sun ends. Well it depends on who' s studying whether the chromosphere, the photosphere. It says that the atmosphere of the sun ends up past our common solar system of pluton and so on. Yeah, yeah, so, and you' re convinced of this number you' ve chosen to front our galaxy out of curiosity, or that' s one of these things that sometimes wakes you up because of the nochis. It' s true, I mean, how could you say this? Let' s say it'

s one of these sensations that happens sometimes in astrophysics, where you have something dynamic so big that you can' t say. I have a unique definition that I understand that this can happen especially to biologists, for example, in biology to say that it is a single species. I here doing labor intrucism, or it' s giving me a unique definition of what a dog is, I don' t know, but the same is a term in which

you have to have so many things in mind that someone has to agree, to say, okay let' s cut here. I do not like it in the sense that it is not a tangible limit, so to speak, but we must agree. If not, then all the statistics you make could be dictatorial, you would put it a little closer or a little further. Of course, yes, it' s true that it' s a poquillo.

This is already personal taste, that is to say, in the piers I have been reading they always put it as to put this limit, or this limit usually enters for more internal interactions, as with that inner focus saying that it is happening inside and I am very, very, very fan of studying intergalactic material, merging with this material from the galaxies that you would carry

the border. A little further, a little further, don' t miss something. A couple of blocks further? A couple of apples over there? Yes, or from a question because of course, seeing that this boundary is agreed, as much as there are doubts, comes another question that Gerardo Sacris is asking us are and says we can be considered to be on the periphery of our galaxy, uy or far away. We' re really far away. No, we' re not very close to forgiveness, well, very close to downtown. If you' d confuse me. That' s for

sure, yes, of course, puff from the periphery, far away. We' re a long way from the periphery. It is true that it is something that has always been told to us is that the galaxy is this disk of galaxies. Not just talk about elliptical galaxies,' cause I don ' t like them. Then I' ll talk solar about spirals. I got that gite elliptical galaxies for some reason. We' re usable. Oh, it' s good, but they help you explain what you were saying about how a dish, not how it' s anchored in structures. It

' s seeing him. Another is more complicated. Yeah, it' s true that it' s the most perfect oliveryvenje ball, of course. But the spiral arms, the spiral bars, yes, yes, the zones of star creation. We' re not comparing. No, no, no, it' s not clear and clear. So we' re always given this idea of the galaxy, it' s this disk or, it' s this very dense set of material with a bright core. There are times that

tell us about the arms, There are times that tell us about the bars and the like and you usually show an image of, for example, a simulation of the milk way or an artistic representation and put the earth and put it a little bit half and a little out. Okay and one could say we' re on the outskirts of the galaxy, sort of. I' ve passed that center and then something that' s added beyond the galaxy for,

well, rather, to try to understand a galaxy at all. Once you study it you see that there are interactions that the galaxy has, that are part of its life, part of all the properties that it has, that you are not missing. If you just study that core, so to speak, and if you extend your gaze a little bit further. See with telescopes, see with simulations, you find yourself with a huge cloud. It

is super chaotic, different, difficult to see and difficult to study what is called the galactic circum material, which is all this gas, which is loose beyond, in much lower densities, which continues to interact with the galaxy and which follows and which marks the material that enters, the material that comes out a little bit of the fuel that is available to the stars. How you protect yourself from the universe from this intergalactic matter or how you interact with this

intergalactic material. And of course this is something so loosely dense that it can expand, so much so that we' re talking about a sizeable inference, for example, a spiral galaxy, like the milk way. We' re talking about the order of ten twenty kilopar sex for putting a number, because then, if you want to talk about it being a bread that isn'

t Star Wars' time unit, it was wrong here. No. No. And then the radio, this radius of the virial that we were talking about before, which is the one that contains all this material, and until the one that expands this material, five galactic, galactic circus, we will be talking about 200 kiloparces, for example. Then our galaxy would be just our disk galaxy, it would be just ten percent. So we' re about six percent of the distance from the center to this radius, the viral limit. So we' re very at the core, we' re in

the metropolis. You know, if this limit of the video was like Spain, pretty much, we' d be on the outskirts of Madrid. Yes, yes, we will be right there, through the Sierra de Madrid and normally with the images that are usually shown that do not go this far, How far would we be the typical images where the arms will be very defined and they ask you that this is the end already of the galaxy and that is the limit, How far would we be from the center If it were

Spain, we would be more or less in those typical images. Not the sun, no, not us, well, yeah, I don' t care about the sun from us. Yeah, sure, that' s complicated. Not clear, I mean, you mean where the sun is standing in the head taking into account the radius of the virial. No, no, no, no, no, no, no, no, no, no, no, no, no, no, no, no, no, no, no, no, no, no, no, no, no, no, no. The virile over there left behind at the time of Forgetfulness. By the way. Well, it' s not alone in the outskirts of Madrid, if it were, considering that the border is where the album ends, or it' s usually shown in images, where we would

be if the album were Spain. Yes, I say that to see we would arrive, we would not reach Portugal, but some part of extreme would be. Okay, okay, okay. That would be my precise calculation. It' s a change. It' s a change, especially if we measure it in hours instead of miles. If it gets there it' s complicated and it' s okay to tell me then how it looks like in the air. What a parts sec valo, a part seck, a patch, is a unit of distance that we usually use in astronomy, which is

a little more comfortable than the light year or any other distance. So, starting from why don' t we use meters? Why don' t we use miles? That' s because it' s all too big now. Everything is too big to be talking about such a small unit. For example, imagine saying that in your galaxy database, I want to see where Andromeda is, and Andromeda is thousands of trillions, billions of meters away. To

put such a random scale would be impractical. Then you usually look for larger units, beyond the kilometer. And a unit that is often spoken a lot is that of the Light year, which is that distance that goes through the light in a year that for us, for human scale, is a lot, because, for example, the distance from here to our own star, the Sun, which is a lot for us, is only eight minutes in

eight minutes light journey of light eight minutes, because we are talking about the light year unit to make it bigger, and the light year on a universal scale is small. In a small unit it allows us to speak in a matter of millions of light years, when we are talking about distances in galaxies. Okay, the problem is that normally in astronomy distance is good. In other words, I think so, that I could say this without anyone throwing

themselves at my neck. I' d say distance is the most difficult and important measure of getting Vale because we can' t travel there. Of course, then you have to imagine it and as such, we only have a direct way to get distance, which is parallax. All that is beyond parallax are others, are others, methods of calculating distances and parallax is the best

way I like to explain it is interesting The idea is to close an eye to what you have to do is to close an eye. You have to stretch your arm and put your thumb and look at some background on something that you have far back, a lamppost, a mountain, a tree and then change your eye, change from one to the other, close one, close the other. Then it will be seen that this thumb is jumping like one

place to another. A little later, if we approach the thumb and repeat, we see that it jumps more instead of jumping from one lamppost to another, jumps from one mountain to another, for example, our thumb. Well, then here we are seeing a relationship between distance and angle. What we say is separation in our field of vision, which moves more to the left, to the right, which is what angular distances and parallax are, being the first good, our only direct measure of distance, took on much importance

in astronomy. It was what allowed us to study the nearest stars or even planets, or distances from objects in our neighborhood. And it was decided to put a measure that is to see how to explain it. Yes, a measure that is the maximum place we can have from the earth, without leaving

the earth, which is the problem we have in astronomy, without making futuristic interstellar trips, and is the distance between a position of the earth in a season of the year and the opposition that there are six months later on the other side of its orbit of the sun. Of course, those two positions of the sun, that is, of the earth, with respect to the sun would be like each of the eyes of our face, which are separated by a fair distance and is the maximum distance. And we' re looking for this maximum distance that we can measure, because the greater the separation of

these eyes, as you say, the more precise either it' s our measurement or better said our angle is more sensitive to greater distances, so we can see distance further away. So the idea is okay. We have this maximum distance and then we put a minimal or smaller unit, as a reference in the universe of angles, because we can also imagine that we already see

a whole separation with our thumb jumping from one mountain to another imagine the separation that we would see jumping from one side of the orbit to the earth to the other side of the Earth' s orbit. Sure, then you say it' s okay I' m going to get a very tiny unit, which is the second arcs and a quick definition to see how small it is. We have our sphere, with our circle, with our three hundred and sixty degrees. Only one degree is chosen, we divide a circle into three

hundred and sixty parts and we have one degree that is already small. It ' s worth this degree, we split it into sixty and the minute arc appears. And now it' s a super little thing. And this super - quitty thing we split back into three sixty, and it comes out of arc two. So we' re talking about a super little thing in the sky? What those super little things in the sky? Measured in angles, with this maximum distance equals something like equal to just over three light years away.

So, if we speak in Sex par units, which are this a little over three light years, we are including within the definition both the term distance, which we are both interested in, and the angular term, which is also interested in. To observe, then we have that direct relationship of par Sex. Even so it is a small unit, because I have already commented that, for example, our galaxies are in the order of ten twenty

kilopar Sexaro we are talking about ten zero twenty zero kiloparces, which is that thirty thousand sixty thousand light years and no one proposes a unit that is even larger so as not to have to reach the thousands. Larger distances are proposed for more specific, more individual studies. In cosmologists they also have their units when they are already talking about what the entire universe is, but at least

in galaxies. It' s true that we like the sex pair because we usually keep the millions when we' re talking about galaxies, which isn' t such a big number. But it' s also important to know that it' s not a number let' s say too big to hide, to hide objects. In the sense we were going to work with a galaxy. We say it' s worth this galaxy I measure that I know I

' m going to call it a bottle. I wouldn' t have missed this word. Sorry it' s okay. I' m looking at things by the bottle and I say a power and I say a bottle, a bottle, a cosmic bottle. And in our head he has measured a cosmic bottle. And we start talking about distances. Inside the galaxy. We' d always get distances from, like, zero three cosmic bottles, zero five. And it' s very uncomfortable and you end up losing those fine details that then, for example, for computing you need them very big or very

small. So, of course, of course, then you have to be the sourly small judge to be able to have that precision when studying distances and big enough not to have to use trillions and trillions and trillions of numbers and the parsec is fine in galaxies. I don' t know why something came up. I was looking here and I could have chosen in the cosmic cup. The cosmic doza would have been more elegant. The truth is, it ' s more elegant. I' m thinking about it next time. But, well, the bottle already remains as a unit of measurement. Look who

' s open jopet Well, I' m not gonna go through with the joke. But when we then refer to those units of cosmologists, to the case of cosmologists, they are out of curiosity what we are talking about, that is, what is bigger than a passec. More like there, it would be a lot of meddling in doing job intrucism in part of cosmologists. I have seen, for example, sometimes use a radius or diameter of the

milk line, for example, a gaxia theatre. I' ve seen it used as a unit to say between this space that you have a hundred diameters of the milk track and so you can imagine a little that you fit a hundred galaxies lined up a little bit the idea. Then I' ve seen it more. And if a cosmologist is fine and corrects me perfectly, because here is labor entrucism, he comes more to have those scale comparisons. Saying, okay, I got this one way I can do it, I can

simplify it for me to have a unit, a measuring rod. In the sarzo we' re going to pause and come right back, because there are many questions that have to do with modelling and that' s one of the things that we don' t like in the sphere, so let' s give free rein. All your doubts. We' re not back. And as many questions about modeling said, the first one by José Fernando, who says directly I want to know what it is to model what seems interesting to me, because I think we have always assumed it here in the sphere or

we have explained very above, but listen we are going to give it its cool space, because modeling is a super extensive word and I love it because usually you always talk about the results. We' ve modeled this and then someone at the bottom of the audience, but what have you done, because that' s like the question I like right, the problem we have in astrophysics. Unlike other sciences, and here I' m going to talk one more polli of astrophysics is that we don' t have a lab as such.

Not what is the method of experimenting, classical scientific method. We don ' t have the part of experimenting. It is true that then there are, for example, astrochemicals that try to obtain spectral lines from simula, from small creations, from systems that look like nebulae, but at scales, for example, galactic. We can' t hope, we can' t take a galaxy, rebuild it, start putting more stars in it, fewer stars,

it' s getting old a little bit. We don' t have that experimental process. Then we pull the models, the numerical simulations. So here we try to be as faithful as possible, as faithful as possible to what our real universe is. And we' re trying to create that lab, that sandbox where we can try to build our own systems to explore them and experiment with them. Then, it is true that there are other branches

of modeling that study easy universes and if dark matter is double and if there is no dark matter, that is also studied. But the basic concept of modelling is to try to take as many standards of physics as you do, even if you learn, that we are discovering, that if gravity the whole electromagnetic field, everything, try within the possible and then, when we have

created a system in which we have all these standards of the universe, to launch things here I have matter, here I have star, here I have dark matter, here I have dark energy? Throw stuff out. Each one launches it in different ways that we can then specify more in how to model it, but it is to create as our own universe and see what happens. Because we' re talking about dynamic systems so, so big that we

can' t predict everything that' s happened to me. Then it' s more we' re going to leave, which is more to let a computer do the super fast calculations and see what happens. That we still have limitations because we don' t have a can' t when it comes to modeling, working on infinitely small scales, or even on our smallest scale in the universe. This distance from Planck, because our computers don' t have the technology. We can' t be calculating tom atom white distance, distance

from Planck, which would be the ideal thing to say, because on our computers they would come out burning. Then model. It' s also a little bit that negotiation between how much physics I want, how off the list I want to do in our physics and how realistic. I can afford it without the computer, but because it' s too expensive. Basically or at least do the simulation in human time that since I do the simulation, I want to see it clear. It doesn' t make sense to be seen

by your great grandchildren, not the same, yes, but I want to see my work clear. But this isn' t so weird. Not all of a sudden come from above pose a modality and say it is not that this is not computable in human time. It' s not, it' s not weird. There are many experiments that are really trying to get as far as possible to see how much we can. We can explore later depending on the simulations. There are simulations that take 18 months, which take more

than two or three years. I' ve seen some then. It' s that game of how much you want how that works of a simulation that takes two years. I' ll give you something ton and start the two - year load bar. Either it goes in parts or as you see, it' s a load bar. It' s got a perva recharge that you' ve seen in your life, of course, but that' s what I' m saying It looks like a load bar. Of course To tell this, I think one thing that I think could be very cool to

tell is the origin of modelling and simulations, which is that the first simulations of not even galactics. Those gravitations were done not with computers or with such rare mechanical systems. Light bulbs were made light lamps, because the intensity of the light falls, with it falling at the same rate that gravity falls, which is recoiled, which falls faster and faster. So, the first simulations

were, so, I put eight or ten bulbs, for example, randomly placed on a table and I put photo detector sensors to see what my intensity is from what is the intensity of light you are receiving. Then you put them all in a light bulb, you see how much light it has and you say I move it according to this light and I make a pass. If, for example, I' m talking about a minute of time and I say it' s worth how much speed in a minute I was doing

it takes and I move it. And I' m going to the next one and I' m moving it. And I' m going to the next one and I' m moving it and I' m doing little and I' ve moved them all depending on the light they were getting, depending on the gravity they were having. And there what you do is you take a picture or let' s say you see, like it' s both the particles. You take out all his data and repeat I' m going to a light bulb. I see that light has the voevo movement a bulb, I see in which direction it has more light and I move it. I do everything and I take a picture, because in this idea it was

then taken to modeling of I go step by step. Then I have all my particles, I have all the expense, lamentary, dark, everything we want to put in a simulation and I go stage stage, step by step, doing these direct calculations as photos or photo and then it is to leave it as much as you want. Usually you talk about a beginning of the

universe so far to understand the universe now or but you can leave it more time to see what happens. Then, you can leave it less time to see what the first galaxies were like, for example, that' s what you' re interested in. And then it' s depending on how big you want this jump step to be, I want my load bar to go every second in the universe. There are many seconds to the universe. I want it to go every thousand years or every million years. Yeah, it

' s really gonna take me less, but a million years. I' m missing a lot of information. I' m guessing a bunch of things. It' s like having really fat pixels in a picture. You don ' t get to see the details completely. I' ve been playing a little bit with simulations, moving these temporary jumps a little bit and you can go from having a solar system that took you days to calculate, but you get an orbit like this perfect to something that took you minutes and suddenly, on earth. Now it is five light years from the sun, simply because

continuously you no longer continuously and suddenly, five light years away realizes that you want to return to the sun and come back. It' s how I understand. I understand well, because when I hear about the two years of loading, I imagine that terrible thing to download a file before, when the Internet was bad, that you were waiting six hours or seven without waiting to exaggerate, and when I was in ninety- eight percent, you said there was no mistake. You' re starting again. This can happen. You can come in. That' s why the importance of what I was commenting

on the photos, this is a psots you' ve called them. Of course, if suddenly your computer explodes at the end, because you' ve already passed and at least it has a picture of everything that' s going on and these pictures keep you in positions and physical properties. Yeah, you can leave from there, not one of them solves. Sure you can from there because in the background, how you take a picture of everything then depends on how the snapshots are made these photos. Because remember that you can take the photos with summary information, instead of knowing what' s happening to everything.

Let' s say to get a lighter snuption, because it' s that we' re talking about teras and teras and information some of a snupshot as more pixelated with less resolution. Then maybe you can' t continue it. There are others that do depend on how the systems you choose. I understand we have a lot of mobilization questions. We said it and I want to know what it' s like to matilize how a galaxy can be read. All that is more or less clear, because there are several questions that some of us have left inkwell, but there is one that says how not

to model a galaxy. Felix González does it to us. What happens when you don' t model? Of course, it' s a question that gives rise to many interpretations. I like it a lot. I saw you marked it. Also, what invites me is to say major mistakes that one can make or or historically things that you have overcome. Sure, I was thinking about how we can mess it up, too. First of all is not choosing the right resolution, which is a term that speaks a lot of

simulations, which is how I define what is the finesse you want in your measurements. We usually talk about the thinness of time, we usually talk about the thinness in space or after the thinness of forces, for example, in time. We' ve seen it. If we have scales, these very big time jumps, physics starts doing weird things. Objects start doing weird things, then space. Yes, suddenly we have a grid on which we can move, for example, our galaxies or not our stars. If it'

s a slightly thin grid with a very fat pixel, it' s going to make a lot of leap in our simulation, because it has to have precise positions. So you don' t have that smooth move you' re looking for, either. And then one that' s the funniest. I think it' s like the most chaotic way to wreck a simulation. It ' s just that if we see the force, gravity depends on it. The square that' s falling. It is increasingly a weaker etched force.

When we step away, when we approach, it becomes stronger and if we approach infinitely. I mean, we' re exactly the same position that real life can' t happen because we crashed, we blogged, but in a simulation, if you haven' t put it in the limits or not you ' ve put any kind of barrier, it doesn' t matter to the particle the particle says I want to go here and you can chance, they ' re in the same and in the same position. We are talking about a zero distance and we are in a divine between zero that, of course,

our computer does not explode, but it is no longer putting infinite velocity something because that does translate infinite energy. And that, for example, you can say tea. It can happen that suddenly you' re with a galaxy simulating calmly, that there' s a calmly and really a particle decides to have infinite energy, transmits it to everything else and even has a hyperradiating universe that makes it completely ruined. So you also talk about, for example, effective radios, which is from a certain radio, for example, you merge

with this particle or if you don' t want to go that way, which requires a lot of computational charge, it' s very difficult for a computer to say I have two things and now I have only one. Eliminating it is a little difficult. You can say that in a distance around a particle, gravity doesn' t go in function of realsquare, it goes in function of r or an error. I have retouched a minimum or constant herr so to speak as to modify it a little bit, because if they are

near no longer explodes clearly it would not be a direct option to put that they could not collapse with each other, that they could not be in the same place. Of course, the issue is with if we follow this method of photos again things like that and so on, many times what you usually do is worth it. I have the velocity of a particle and I say okay and now I have the position and in that next step of the next position. There, I say ah it' s worth where I am I ' m going to calculate the speed is how you calculate it a posteriori.

Of course, you can' t foresee when it' s going to happen. Then, of course, you have to be prepared to see when it happens. Sure, sure, well understood and look. There is a question here, since the subject of gravity has come up. It seems to me that it comes very well. It makes us jetur and you say it uses Newtonian gravity they either insist on it to make galaxies. How different the results are using one or the other. That' s super interesting. It' s one of the things that impressed me when I entered the world of galaxy

simulations, because I was expecting myself. We want to have our most accurate laboratory, our most modern laboratory, with the most enthusiastic theories of physics. And it' s not that, since we' re working with these technological limitations, we' re always looking to be as vague as possible. Let ' s say our calculations are the simplest possible to allow us major simulations on a larger scale or in a shorter time, a less deadly load beard.

So, the problem with that of physics, Einstein' s gravity is that it' s very complex As far as calculations are concerned, it' s very complex to insert it into a computer or the way our computers work, it' s kind of hard to calculate. On the other hand, Newtonian can be treated on the basis of readers or matrices, which is the specialization of computers. Computers love numbers boxes. So it' s very easy to

put boxes of numbers together, to make more boxes of numbers than to do that study of relativity. But of course one says it' s worth it on such big scales. Einstein' s gravity has to be affecting. It ' s not East Niana. It' s not like a small scale that I throw an apple and fall to the ground and I can calculate it with the suns. Newton' s coming. The Newton arrives perfectly with all the precision you want but if it already starts to fail at distances of mercury, which mercury no longer follows Newtonian physics, how we wood it we will make

the whole universe work only with Newtonian physics. And the bad way to look at it is to try to see the interactions and the time scale you' re using, because it' s true that you do notice these relativity effects, but when you' re working with such big time scales on such a big simulation or spatial scales, let' s just say you lose that effect

again, so to speak. And you still have in a very crude way, little balls with little balls, falling with vectors and newton and and all nice in quotes, because it is true that you have to make corrections and similar themes. And then one thing you can do is leave space alone, which is something that takes away all these relativistic effects. And that' s a little difficult, because we have an expansion of the universe, but we use what are called the comobile coordinates, which is to say to have a

scale one that grows with the universe itself. So I' m not measuring in part SEX. Let' s say real I' m measuring in a part SEC based on or at what point in the expansion of the universe I find my pair dry before it wasn' t the same as part SEC after it' s expanded. So it' s using those comobile units that you introduce expansion into your own units of measurement. Let' s just say you

' re going overboard and you' re already working with a static system. That static and perfect universe Einstein wanted, but it' s something we could work with. And that' s where Newtonian physics, or more than Newtonian physics just for gravity. Then we could use other thermodynamic systems, but this simpler physics is something you can start applying. One you' ve made all these little corrections and you can apply it on a large scale, which is what impresses me, of course that' s what I' m most interested

in in these cases. Of course you get a lot more of a calculation of a lot simpler. We have one last question. It gives us a lot more time, but Daniel Torregrosa makes it, and I think it' s pretty, because she says she would ask you how you carry the cosmic vertigo? What' s this? The cosmic vertigo? Oh, okay, we have to start there, of course, cosmic vertigo is what we' re talking about. I think it is this concept of scale that is in the cosmos, that concept of dimensions, because we, being on earth,

the human scales and the scales of the earth, seem to us that the earth is very large, that the journeys are very long and to the edge of our galaxy in extreme, is difficult in terms of time or human scale. But then, when we start to study astronomy and we see the galactic scales, that there are, the universal scales, that there are in that on earth, it is nothing in terms of distances, even in simulations.

We don' t even simulate a particle in which our smallest particle is the earth or even the sun. We' re talking about sets of thousands of suns and that' s our smallest scale to start half- understanding galaxies. So, when you' re working on those scales, it' s true that you can get into this fear of jopets. We' re nothing or we' re nothing. Suddenly something can happen and to God earth or we are super unprotected. And it' s kind of lame to try at first,

when you start getting into astronomy, it' s a hard feeling to deal with. So it' s true that it puts a lot of pressure on the fact that there' s nothing, but the way I started treating her this cosmic vertigo that I don' t know if other astro colleagues from the same disciplines have this fear as well. It was like turning him around,

we' re very little and this allows us to explore a lot. We' re not running out of exploration in a second. We have universes to bore, explore to bore, I mean, we can be researching, researching, bringing out new technologies, everything we were, which is very hard to say, that' s it. I have completed the encyclopedia of the Universe. I don' t need you anymore. That will not come, will not come, and above all because the universe is expanding or is constantly

changing. So it' s that point of view where we have a lot to play with, a lot of information, which is to get out, because, for example, good and better said this, even leads us to think that we are at the best time to observe this. I don' t know if I remember Lucia Carla sagan saying it, it' s possible, he left a lot, a lot of things. The one we' re in the best time to explore if we' re born much earlier.

We have a radiant, bright, chaotic universe in which everything is collapsing and all smashing. If we were too late, we would have come to a dark universe, all far away, cold void that we are as in that moment of hearing I can see everything I can or can see much of the universe. You can see what' s happening. And that' s what cured me of that vertigo. He' s partially cured me. Suddenly I get what happened. But it' s the way I have to wear that

vertigo. Well, it' s a very good way. I' m going to keep it as a recommendation and I think it' s a fantastic way to also close what the listeners' questions were. Why are there still three questions that I, as always, make one last pause and come right back. We' re back. The questions are the usual ones. The first program one hundred and ninety- nine. That means that maybe two hundred changes something, but for now we' re going to ask the questions we ' ve been asking almost two hundred programs. The first book you want to recommend. It' s a complex question. Let' s say the first

one that came to mind is the journey to the moon of July. Seeing me not so much for that striking scientific aspect and that it is true that it explores very well in what is the trip to the moon? Explore very well how to explain what they would be traveling to the Moon? And then he tells you a story like this cool and funny, but because he has

a way of Julio vern had a way of acquiring the current knowledge that I haven' t seen in another not only seeing elsewhere I explain myself. Let ' s say he had this science, fiction in which he acquired all this information from the present on technology, on science and so forth, and then

he imagined or projected into the future how it could be and that ability to take what I have now, the knowledge that I have now and project predict is something very interesting and that I think it is worth not only for disciplines like science, but it is worth everything, for everything else, is that I have right now what I gather and what I can do with it or

what can happen, because it took technologies of the moment that were like guns and cannons, but there was already a pretty precise Newtonian physics, quite well studied for what was the time. Then I added those concepts of this what we have, because you could never have imagined a rocket again, for example, but then you project it with that physics that we know, with those precise orbits around the moon and what a journey would be like is especially similar

to the actual moon trips that have been made. So it' s curious what concept you have with that processing of the current information. Then I' d say that one travels the moon of Julio Verme is one of my favorite recommendations, because I' m going to leave the moon. We took that and film what movie? Movie. The subject I have with interest, because

I believe that of a physicist everyone is expected interstellar. It' s the most common thing. Yeah, yeah. The thing I have an interesting one is that it' s how very wonderful it is, but you don' t see it as more documentary, although here it' s like more insulting to many people and it' s okay. So, eye- catching movie. Well, directly, I' m a big fan of gibliy movies aha

and some particular one is thinking, they' re trying to decide, but Chihiro' s trip, as it' s experience, is something that appeals to me a lot, a lot of attention and is that I don' t know all the texture that the film gives you? Is all the excitement that the movie gives you? I think it' s a movie that I would highly recommend watching at least once, at least once, because it' s like an experience so ah doesn' t exa the definition of eyes and

eyes. You know clearly well you' re left speechless. We can say yes, yes, yes, yes, it comes out of the ordinary, it gets out of the ordinary and you explore a series of quite, quite curious concepts. I don' t want to do much spoiler, although it ' s a very famous movie, but we' re adding up telmes books. We have the movie and what a hobby you want to recommend. I like this a lot. Allegos full Vale, full tim Legos, how many

legos do you have? How many legos have you bought? Yes, the answer is yes, yes, the answer. So, yes, money, ah well, it was more the idea of varied legos, not so much to buy a set and already to buy boxes of legos. I mean, I' m gonna do anything random and what' s the weirdest thing you ' ve ever done. Legos. I usually like to say I' m a big fan of space issues. It' s not going to be then

let' s say as a whole international station structure small ships, all like inventing me one and two ss, for example, how cool so to put it is not very rare as such, but it' s like the most curious thing to see what I would do when it comes to riding one and two there with all the pride of space engineer that I' m not good at, but they' re very good recommendations. Of course the lego thing. I think he had recommended it to no one yet. So great.

With this, we do have to close. So, Philip, thank you so much for coming and reminding us that lay people exist. Thank you very much. Yes, yes, well, play with the legos with a lot and we stayed making a brief conclusion of everything that has been said and I ' m going to stay concrete with that moment when Philip told us about that cosmic vertigo and told us how to avoid it, at least him. I find the truth very interesting. It' s true that if we had been long before, then we wouldn' t have seen anything. And many later, we wouldn' t have seen anything. But something else happened, too. Neither would we have been most likely. So we' re where we

have to be, not because it' s the best possible place, but because it' s autological, it' s where we are and that' s worth it. But this and unfortunately and luckily goes for many more things in our life ends up being almost like an attraction to accept things as they come. Thank you so much for listening and until next year

Open the transcript file

Hosts and Guests

Nobody is credited on this episode yet.

Credit the people on this episode

Be the first to rate this episode

More episodes

All episodes
  1. Noosfera 306 - Un cuento chino | Raúl Ramírez Ruiz

    Nov 20, 20261 hr 18 minAudio

    Cada vez hablamos más sobre China… pero ¿qué sabemos de ella? Mayormente clichés y, aunque Noosfera sea un podcast de ciencia, bien entendida, la historia también tiene cabida en él para arrojar algo de luz sobre el...

    Credit the people on this episode

  2. Noosfera 305 - Cómo observar un fantasma (neutrinos) | Juan Antonio Aguilar Sánchez

    Oct 30, 20261 hr 9 minAudio

    "Alguna vez hemos hablado sobre neutrinos, pero nunca hemos aprovechado una percha de actualidad para hacerlos. Hoy nos centramos en un telescopio congelado, hundido en la Antártida, capaz de detectar las partículas más...

    Credit the people on this episode

  3. Noosfera 304 - Controlar cerebros con luz | Rosario Moratalla

    Oct 23, 20261 hr 17 minAudio

    "La optogenética ha sido galardonada con el Nobel y eso ha despertado entre el público el interés por una tecnología que ya había encandilado a los expertos: una forma de activar e inactivar neuronas a voluntad...

    Credit the people on this episode

  4. Noosfera 303 - La IA y... ¿el fin de la matemática? | Anabel Forte, Roberto Giménez y Miguel Camarasa

    Oct 16, 20261 hr 44 minAudio

    "Algunos lo llaman “mathapocalypse”, pero… ¿Lo es? Open AI dice que su IA ha logrado demostrar uno de los problemas del milenio y otros casi 400 problemas abiertos. Todo ha ocurrido en poco más de un mes y la comunidad...

    Credit the people on this episode

  5. Noosfera 302 - La tierra que pisas | Carmen Castañeda

    Oct 9, 20261 hr 3 minAudio

    "El suelo es más que “tierra”... bueno, es que la tierra también es más que tierra. ¿Cómo se forma a partir de minerales erosionados? ¿Cómo cambia? ¿Cuánto cambia? Es hora de hablar sobre la ciencia de los suelos: la...

    Credit the people on this episode