Skip to content
PodSubs
ShowsPeopleGuestsJobsNewsEvents
More
BlogPodCred
Menu
ShowsPeopleGuestsJobsNewsEventsBlogPodCredNetworksSign in
Join nowSign in
  • Shows
  • People
  • Jobs
  • News
  • More
    • Guests
    • Events
    • Blog
    • PodCred
    • Networks
    Join nowSign in

Negotiation Warriors

Negotiation Warriors artwork

Episode 016: The CBA Negotiator (Jeff Pash)

Sep 7, 202657 minAudio
ShareXLinkedInFacebookWhatsAppEmail

Send us Fan Mail Negotiation Warriors, Episode #016 - THE CBA NEGOTIATOR with Jeff Pash For more than four decades, Jeff Pash helped shape the business and labor framework of the National Football League. As the NFL’s Executive Vice President and General Counsel, Pash served as one of Commissioner Roger Goodell’s closest advisors and played a leadership role in some of the most consequential negotiations in professional sports - including two landmark collective bargaining agreements governing more than $100 billion in league revenues and player compensation. Those agreements helped establish the foundation for what could ultimately become 20 years of NFL labor peace, during a period of extraordinary growth in league revenues, player salaries and benefits. It is rare to have an interview with Jeff Pash. In this special episode of Negotiation Warriors, he takes us inside the preparation, strategy and decision-making behind negotiations at the highest level of professional sports. In this episode, Jeff discusses: His remarkable 40-year career in professional sports Building consensus among 32 NFL clubs Why the CBA is critical to the NFL’s success Preparing four years in advance for the 2011 CBA The keys to nearly 20 years of NFL labor peace Negotiating the NFL’s rookie compensation system Why great opponents can make you a better negotiator How listening and compromise lead to better outcomes Why the NFL preferred face-to-face negotiations Staying calm and respectful under pressure Lessons from the NFL for college athletics Why great negotiators keep ego out of the deal Throughout the conversation, Pash provides a rare look behind the scenes at negotiations involving billions of dollars, 32 NFL clubs, thousands of players and the future of the game. And when asked what he believes is one of the most important lessons for any negotiator, his answer is remarkably simple: “It’s not about you.” 🎙️ Negotiation Warriors - conversations with the greatest negotiators in professional sports. Hosted by Cliff Stein Former Chicago Bears SVP & General Counsel | NFL Contract Negotiator | Sports Attorney | Negotiation Strategist

Audio and video play straight from the show's own hosting. PodSubs stores and serves no media.

Transcript

From the show. Tap a time to play from there.

SPEAKER_01when you're when you're negotiating when your negotiating partner is someone who is you know really well prepared, understands the issues, smart, creative, it makes you better. When you're dealing with with good negotiators on the other side, I think it helps you to really see where compromise can can strengthen you. It can strengthen the outcome. It also also allows you to avoid, at least to some extent, the unintended consequences.

SPEAKER_01You can learn that quite effectively by listening to your negotiating partner and recognizing that they have a point of view and they have knowledge and understanding that is different from your own.

SPEAKER_00Welcome to Negotiation Warriors. I am Cliff Stein and I am on a never-ending quest to learn what it takes to be a great negotiator. In every episode, I will sit down with some of the greatest negotiators.

SPEAKER_00Go to frontoffice360.com to schedule a demo. Welcome back to Negotiation Warriors, the podcast that features conversations with the greatest negotiators in professional sports. I am your host, Cliff Stein. I'm very excited about our next guest. Jeff Past has shaped the modern National Football League for more than four decades. He is the former executive vice president and general counsel of the NFL where he served as one of the commissioners Roger Goodell's closest advisors and played a leadership role in some of the most important negotiations in the history of professional sports.

SPEAKER_00During his career, Jeff helped negotiate collective bargaining agreements governing over$100 billion in league revenues and player compensation, as well as media rights agreements, stadium deals, ownership transactions, international initiatives, and many of the policies that have shaped the NFL's growth into the most successful sports league in North America. Jeff is a graduate of Harvard College and Harvard Law School.

SPEAKER_00He has earned a reputation as one of the most respected attorneys, strategists and negotiators in professional sports. Today we go into the minds of one of the most influential people in professional sports on negotiations, labor agreements and leadership at the highest level Jeff, welcome to Negotiation Warriors.

SPEAKER_01Well thanks Cliff nice to be with you and and thanks for that introduction. I think maybe we should just stop now because if we keep going people may may wonder if you took leave of your census there a little bit.

SPEAKER_00But it's well deserved and I'm really excited about this for for a few reasons. Number one, you don't you haven't done a lot of this I was told by many people that I would never get you to do it. And and I want to say to all our friends at the NFL all of our friends at the in the front offices of clubs, general counsels, salary cap people, we're here with Jeff Pash. I'm excited about that. And for everyone else for the the lawyers the professors the the law students and everyone else interested in the NFL collective bargain agreement whether you're driving in your car or going for a walk or you just had you know listen to the podcast as opposed to reading a book we hope that you enjoy this.

SPEAKER_00So Jeff really excited to have you here and really where I want to start with you Jeff is just, you know, your longevity is unprecedented. 40 years working for not just the most successful sports league in North America but one of the most successful business enterprises in the world generating more than$20 billion in annual revenue and creating billions of dollars in value for its stakeholders. I do want to read this to you.

SPEAKER_00On May 2nd, 2024, when your retirement was announced Commissioner Goodell said that Jeff's career has been dynamic and highly successful for four decades. He has loyally and effectively represented the league as external and internal counsel and labor council contributing tremendously to the accomplishments of our organization over those years, including two successful CBAs his leadership and impact across our business are immeasurable.

SPEAKER_00And I wanted to ask you Jeff have you had the opportunity now that you've been nearly a year away from the NFL to reflect on what it has been like to be in that role for such an important brand, an important business?

SPEAKER_01A little bit. I mean I am tremendously lucky to have had the opportunity I had you know for a kid who grew up in Central California. Anybody who knows me would wouldn't never uh mistake me for for an athlete of any any particular ability to have had the opportunities I I've had in in my profession it's uh it's remarkable and I'm I'm deeply grateful to the people who helped make it possible and and helped me along the way.

SPEAKER_01And uh you know working working in the NFL it's uh been the great privilege of my professional life and uh I'll always treasure when you began work in the NFL in the early 90s the league revenue was approximately$2 billion.

SPEAKER_00By the end of this current CBA it's projected to approach$34 billion salary cap grew from$34 million to a projected$400 million.

SPEAKER_01And when you look back that's incredible growth what stands out to you the most in be able to be a part of that type of growth well I think the most important thing uh cliff is that that growth doesn't just happen it it's not it's not preordained uh it wasn't uh directed by an act of Congress nobody you know when when I tell people when Moses received the tablets on Mount Sunday there was nothing in there about the NFL and and its success it happened because a lot of people some who are celebrated and some who are anonymous many of whom are anonymous have worked very very hard for decades and that includes not just people in the league office not just club executives it includes the coaches the players the athletic trainers the other members of the medical staff all the people who work throughout the game to make it what it is to make it so that a hundred million people every Sunday want to either go to a stadium or watch not just a game but multiple games on television across a wide range of channels not just here but increasingly all over the world.

SPEAKER_01So that doesn't just happen.

SPEAKER_00I think it's the quality of the game the genuine excitement the unpredictability the extraordinary play of of so many professional football players every week and the the other elements that surround the game that that make it a spectacle the fashion the music the pageantry all of it makes it exciting special and that's why it's been able to grow as much as it has I'm going to ask you about some of that and I knew I anticipated that you would have an answer like that that showed your humility but even going back before you started working in the NFL I think people would like to know tell us about your career path I know you went from Covington to the NFL but how did you get involved in a career in sports in the first place?

SPEAKER_01I I went to work at uh Covington and Burling a law firm in Washington DC at when I graduated from law school. Covington as it turns out has represented the NFL for many many years going all the way back to the early 60s when Commissioner Rosell hired uh a very noted antitrust partner at that firm who ultimately became a federal judge but uh I really didn't know or I I I may have had like a passing knowledge that the NFL was a client of Covington and Burling.

SPEAKER_01It certainly played no part in my decision to to go to that firm but on my first day I was assigned uh to work for a partner there by the name of Paul Tegliapu Paul who as as everyone knows ultimately became the commissioner he was the lead partner on the NFL account and he uh immediately put me to work on all kinds of different matters and when I say I'd been very fortunate working for Paul for the years that he was at the firm before he became commissioner was a big part of that.

SPEAKER_01I had an opportunity to work on litigation matters, congressional matters you know substance abuse issues, labor, television just pretty much the full gamut of what the full range of legal issues you face in professional sports. And so when when I ultimately left the firm and I went first to the National Hockey League to be the general counsel for uh at that point the new commissioner Gary Bettman and then eventually to the NFL some years later I really was well prepared and and I there there were not too many major issues that I hadn't had some experience with or exposure to.

SPEAKER_00Did you ever think at that time that this would turn into a career this long in one place?

SPEAKER_01Definitely not I had no idea that that this would happen and uh you know as I say working for working for Paul Tagalibu was uh a a daily seminar in in excellence. He was uh I think till the day he left us uh there were very very few places where he wasn't the smartest man in the room thoughtful reflective great judgment a wonderful writer I mean one one once and and a very compulsive editor there was there was one time where he had me write a fairly simple letter to someone and it came back and there was so much red ink on it I thought maybe he'd opened a vein.

SPEAKER_01I I called him and I said hey this letter you had me write uh draft for you I don't think you read it very carefully he says uh why is that I said well in the second paragraph here there are three consecutive words that you didn't change and he paused he said I don't have time for this and hung up the phone and that was that but that was the kind of editor he was he had uh he was focused and it didn't matter whether it was a Supreme Court brief or a a letter to somebody he gave it the same attention and focus and he uh invariably made it better.

SPEAKER_01So I learned so much working for him that uh it it really jumps you know gave me the opportunity to to learn and and and grow and and he never he never tried to shield you know or prevent me from having direct dealings so even as an associate I was able to work directly with Commissioner Rosell with Jay Moir who was then the general counsel at the NFL with other executives with team executives and and it was it was really a a wonderful way to learn about how different people approach things and what your role as counsel is and and how yours how you can help them to accomplish their their goals but you always have to remember they're in charge they're they're the client.

SPEAKER_00And you also brought up that there's so many people involved and here you are learning the different aspects of the general counsel role and I think it was Tom Delaney said to me you know when he thinks of Jeff Pash, you know, like a traffic cop you know you have owner stakeholders you have the commissioner you have executives at the NFL then you have the players interest the coaches the players association and then all these other media stakeholders or sponsorship stakeholders that you're dealing with so you serve so many.

SPEAKER_00But then you when I think about the pressures you must have been under with the different perspectives and expectations of 32 different owner billionaires what was it like how did you do it and what was it like managing the expectations of 32 NFL owners how did you build consensus internally before you even sat down to do a CBA one of the themes we always talk about is that internal negotiation and when I think about the internal negotiation I think I can only imagine for the type of pressure you were under and you did it so well for so long what was the secret to that I think the the ownership at least their their interests their expectations there's a lot more commonality than people might might think and and there are certain common principles or expectations everybody believes in promoting the quality of the game everybody believes in having a game that is exciting attractive for fans and and at the core of that is the the whole concept of competitive balance and and making sure that at the start of every season and then throughout the season each club can be competitive with every other club.

SPEAKER_01That doesn't mean that there won't be very successful teams and un and teams that are unsuccessful in any any given year but that you have a system playing rules labor agreements free agency draft etc that help to give every team the opportunity to compete. The teams want that the owners want it the fans want it the players want it. So there are some real common principles I think I think most owners recognize that the the success of an individual team is really tied to the success of the overall venture the overall venture that we call the National Football league.

SPEAKER_01And so this goes all the way back to you know Commissioner Rosell's days the the concept of league thinking and and focusing on the collective good for all the teams which in turn is beneficial for fans, players and other people who are involved in the game. What does that mean? It means that you do a lot of listening one of the great things about the NFL I think is that the governance structure which relies so heavily on committees made up of active engaged knowledgeable owners and working with them closely taking your time making sure that things have really been thought through and vetted working with the committees to then share information and concepts and ideas with teams who aren't represented on those committees so you get their feedback, their reactions, answer their questions and and by the time something is brought to the membership for a vote it's really been carefully studied, carefully analyzed everyone's had a chance to weigh in on it.

SPEAKER_00The questions have been addressed and that's why so many proposals so many resolutions that come to a vote are adopted either unanimously or virtually unanimously because of the very careful process that goes into refining and and and preparing before there is a vote taken so the process that's a great point Jeff so you you do a lot of listening and then you have the committees and then there's this careful well thought out process where it feels like you know everyone knows that processing and trusted do you think having that in place really helped you continue to build credibility and trust with the stakeholders well I hope so it's it's not something that that I did alone by any means.

SPEAKER_01I think the people people who are most successful uh in the NFL in the front office at least are people who understand you're not operating in a command and control environment. We are in the league office we're a service organization we're there to to help the membership if if if someone has the if someone has a problem or a concern, you know I I always said hey if it's important to the owner or to the team president or the GDN or the team general counsel if it's important to that person it's important to us too.

SPEAKER_01So let's let's help them to solve whatever problem it is to answer whatever question they have and and as if if we approach it from that perspective rather than hey we're we're sitting uh on top of Mount Olympus here on Park Avenue and we'll tell you what to do it's it's that that just doesn't work. It's it's got to be cooperative it's got to be service oriented. Sometimes obviously as as you know Cliff you have to say hey you cannot do that or you did something that was in violation of a rule and some penalty may be imposed and and and people understand that but they understand that a lot more and they're a lot more accepting of it if they know that you're also there to work with them to help them to to try to work alongside them to solve their problems and advance you know the work of their clubs.

SPEAKER_00That must have been a very very difficult part of that that comes with that position. I mean I was I was a general counsel but the stakeholders were were very different that I'm dealing with and so I imagine as you're sitting and helping guide decisions or helping lead your staff, you know that that comes into play in terms of just making sure there's effective communication and that everyone knows that there's this this careful process. I do I do love that.

SPEAKER_00The the other thing about your career when I think about you is obviously you were part of and led a lot of the media rights negotiations which with networks and and NFL is the highest revenue sports league in the world. You played a lead role in negotiating the one of the most important collective bargaining agreements in professional sports history. And it and at a high level I just want for people that are listening what is a collective bargaining agreement?

SPEAKER_01Well it's it's an agreement that's reached between a a labor union and in our case it's the NFL Players association and either a single employer or in our case a group of employers. So all the NFL clubs are members of what's called a multi-employer bargaining unit which is uh known as the management council and uh that's common and and uh has you know been approved by the National Labor Relations Act and and recognized by the NLRB for for many many decades to have that kind of bargaining.

SPEAKER_01And what in in professional sports what a collective bargaining agreement does is it sets out the rules that will allow for fair and balanced competition. The goal of collective bargaining in in professional sports is to fashion rules that allow for balanced, fair competition and set up a system for allocating the the rewards, the benefits of that competition.

SPEAKER_00When I think about the success of the NFL compared to other sports, what role do you think what role do you think the collective bargaining agreement play plays in that success?

SPEAKER_01I think it's critical I think it's critical because what the collective bargaining agreement does at at in its most fundamental way is ensure or or help to ensure that there is balanced competition, that you don't have a league of haves and have nots, that you don't have a league where at the start of the season or at at a very early stage in the season There are teams that have little or no hope of competing, not just for a championship, but even competing with many of the teams who are going to come in to play them.

SPEAKER_01That's not interesting to fans. It's not interesting to uh people watching games at home. The the the the fundamental goal of a collective bargaining agreement is to establish an orderly system for the allocation and retention of talent within a within a sports league to make sure that there are common rules and principles that everyone's operating under players on the one hand and teams on the other hand, and that that that works in a way that benefits the fans, fairly rewards the players, and and and promotes the growth of the game.

SPEAKER_00Yeah, the collective bargain agreement impacts every player, every club, billions of dollars in revenue. How do you approach a negotiation of that magnitude? You approach it slowly.

SPEAKER_01You spend a lot of time preparing. We started preparing for that, you know, by early 2007. And you have to really start, you know, literally at square one. Okay, what is important to us? And then if you stop there, you'll fail because you also have to ask yourself, what is going to be important to the players' association? What's going to be important to your negotiating partner?

SPEAKER_01Where are we have some common interests? And where do we think it's really going to diverge? How contentious do you think the negotiation could be? How realistic is it that there may be a work stoppage? How do we prepare for that? Will there be litigation? Will it be litigation at the NLRB? Unfair labor practice charges, things like that. Will it be litigation in court? Antitrust claims based on a purported decertification by your union. So there were so many variables to think through that that you you really you start early and you identify all the as many as you can think of ways in which you need to be prepared and and just get to it.

SPEAKER_01And and and then we worked very, very closely, I cannot say enough, about the CEC, which is the Management Council Executive Committee, with a committee of owners who were very, very dedicated. They put in a tremendous amount of time. They were very knowledgeable about the legal issues, the labor issues, the prior work with the NFLPA in in terms of earlier agreements, and they brought tremendous knowledge and history and commitment.

SPEAKER_01And they were critical in helping us to communicate, solicit advice and feedback from owners who were not members of the CEC. But again, part of that process of bringing all 32 clubs into the discussions at an early stage so people felt like they understood what the strategy was, what the risks were, and and how how you know we as a staff and the CEC as the leaders for the ownership uh proposed to address those issues.

SPEAKER_00Yeah, so that's a great point. So when it came to managing your stakeholders, the CEC that represent ownership, and everyone else that had a stake in the outcome, did you see yourself sort of as a quarterback in those negotiations?

SPEAKER_01No, not not not really. I s I think I saw myself a little bit, you know, maybe as a chief of staff or something like that. But you know, we had we had owners and and obviously our commissioner, Commissioner Goodell, who were were uh intimately involved and and and played very, very active roles in the negotiations. You know, as you know, Cliff, from your own experience, the staff at the management council is extraordinary. I had so much help from lawyers like Dennis Kern and Buck Briggs and Larry Farazzani and on economics, people like Peter Ruco, Wyndham Mikowski on benefits, Belinda Lerner, and an encyclopedic knowledge of all the different benefit programs.

SPEAKER_01There is no part of this agreement that I can say was was me alone. I was working with a wonderful team, both internally and then and outside. So it uh the the outside attorneys we worked with were great. The advice they brought and the skill they showed in ultimately having to litigate claims that the union brought in the early stages of the work stoppage was just outstanding and and and really contributed to uh a good outcome for everybody.

SPEAKER_01Trevor Burrus, Jr.

SPEAKER_00You know, you had uh you talked about a work stoppage, and you know, the 2011 CBA produced one of the longest periods of labor peace in professional sports that's still going on, and by the end of this, it could be 20 years of labor peace. What were the biggest issues, though, that led to that work stoppage?

SPEAKER_01Aaron Powell In 2006, as you'll remember, a a new agreement was reached literally, or an extension of the of the existing agreement was reached literally at the last minute. And the the extension that was agreed to in 2006 was quite one-sided. Um I I remember the uh president of the union, Kevin Moway, you know, was was very open and and and accurate in saying that the union had really, really dominated the the negotiation.

SPEAKER_01And the the ownership just felt as though the investments that were required to keep the game growing and to keep things to generate revenue going forward, investments in new stadiums, investments in new media, investments in technology, investments in international opportunities, all of that, all of those and more were going to require the clubs to make very substantial investments. And owners were willing to do that, but there had to be a sufficient revenue base and a sufficient returns on the investments in order to make it worthwhile.

SPEAKER_01And I think the fundamental point was persuading the the players that there had to be a reset on the division of revenues between the clubs on the one hand and the players on the other hand, and that if that division could be reset in a way that was satisfactory, the the clubs were very clear. The owners on the CEC said this over and over again, that those funds we will use that recalibrated economics to grow the game and increase the revenue base, which will support growing salaries, growing benefits, and better working conditions for the players.

SPEAKER_01They will be in newer stadiums, they would have much better facilities to work with. You look at what so many teams in the league have done over the last 15 years as far as rebuilding and and renovating and building all new training facilities, which are really quite spacious and and have every amenity for players and great places to train, high-quality medical and training facilities. So all of that was part of it.

SPEAKER_01And I think the the fundamental reason why there's been labor peace is because the the clubs were able to deliver on that promise. And between 2011 and today, there has been very substantial growth in the NFL. The players have gotten a guaranteed share of that growth. It has you identified the growth in the salary cap. There's been steady growth in player benefits, there's been improvements in working conditions.

SPEAKER_01I think that's why it's worked, and that's why there has been labor peace.

SPEAKER_00Yeah, so you got the revenue split and reclassification of revenue, you got that done. There was uh uh a rookie wage scale of some sort implemented, mandatory four-year rookie contracts and fifth-year options for first round, minimum cash spending requirements. These are just a few of the things. Like looking back, which of these changes do you think had the greatest long-term impact on the league?

SPEAKER_01You know, it's it's it's it's hard to it's hard to identify a single one because as you know, one thing about a collective bargaining agreement is it is a whole series of of trade-offs. There, there's not any one single issue. But your point about rookie salaries is is is interesting, and it's an important one to highlight because where we ended up in 2011 and continue to be today on that issue is not where we started in the negotiations.

SPEAKER_01We wanted exactly what you're saying: a rookie wage scale. Round one, pick one, here's where you are. Round one, pick two, here's where you are. Period, end of discussion. And the union was very clear that they could not accept a system that deprived players of any right to individual negotiation. So they they said, is your they they they correctly identified the issue. They identified it more precisely than we had, which was avoiding leakage in the system, avoiding circumvention of the old rookie pool that had been put in place back in the 90s and solving that problem.

SPEAKER_01And so they were clear that they would agree to a system that, as I think one of their lead negotiators put it, was really bulletproof. If we would agree that rookies would have a right to individual negotiation, we modified our position in a way that moved towards them and and what they were talking about. They maintained kept their word on having a very clear, tight, bulletproof rookie system.

SPEAKER_01And I think uh I think that's an example of successful collective bargaining. You listened to your negotiating partner, you modified your position as appropriate to incorporate their interests and their concerns, but still accomplish what you want to accomplish. And and and the rookie system that exists uh today um is a good example of that.

SPEAKER_00You also mentioned that um when you said that the teams have delivered on what was in the CBA, which has led to labor peace, one of the most important things that you also put in there, you mentioned is benefits. You know, when fans often focus on the salaries, that's what we hear about. But the benefits negotiating in the CBA are extraordinary. Can you help quantify the value of those and explain their importance to the players?

SPEAKER_01I I think probably about a quarter of the player cost, you know, somewhere north of$80 to$85 million a club uh goes to benefits every year. And uh, you know, it's a very wide-ranging, comprehensive suite of benefits. It includes things like tuition reimbursement, it includes multi, multiple levels of the retirement benefits, there's a 401k where the clubs match on a two-for-one basis, and then there's a a pension, a defined benefit of pension.

SPEAKER_01There are medical benefits, post-career medical benefits. So if you if you're a vested veteran, you get five years of continuing medical care for you and your family. There's a health reimbursement account, and then there are you know other you know, specialized benefits, things like the 88 plan for for players with dementia or or Parkinson's, the neurocognitive benefit, the long-term care benefit, the supplement to help players who are older and are on Medicare to buy a met to help them with the cost of a Medicare supplement, new new expanded mental health benefits.

SPEAKER_01Someone who uh has let's just say has not always been charitable in his view of the of the NFL. A fellow I know wrote that it's probably the finest benefit package that exists for any private employer today. And that and that's that's that's another result of collective bargaining where you know you listen to what's important to your negotiating partner and you know make make appropriate adjustments in your position to accommodate that.

SPEAKER_00Yeah, I'm so glad you brought that up because it really just goes in the whole picture of it didn't just happen that we got all the slaver piece. There were things behind there that made the other side happy and want to advocate to to its constituents of why this is such a good deal, and now it's panning out to be one. And when I think about the other side of it, which is the player compensation in terms of salaries, you know, we're seeing players now multiple positions getting in excess of$30 million per year, wide receivers, defensive linemen, offensive tackles, quarterbacks, obviously, and even we got a center that's making over$25 million a year this year.

SPEAKER_00But do you feel like that was consistent with what the system was designed to produce? And does that positional inflation and how teams are able to spend a lot, cash over cap create any challenges for the next round of CVA negotiations?

SPEAKER_01You know, I think the the first thing that you have to remember is that if the revenues weren't there, the salaries wouldn't be there because the the salary pool, the player compensation pool, is directly tied to the revenue base. The the growth in the revenue is what has led to the growth in the salaries. Uh cash over cap, I think, could be an issue, but again, the the way the system is set up, every dollar will ultimately count. And there are many teams who you know would probably tell you with a rueful expression that they learned this the hard way.

SPEAKER_01You can't assume that you can avoid paying the piper uh forever. And you know, maybe you can defer the the payment for a year or two, but eventually all of that money will be recaptured. It will all go into the cap, and teams will have to make sure that they've managed uh their cap in a way that allows them to continue to sign planners, or they will lose people, or they won't be able to participate in free agency or something like that.

SPEAKER_01So while I I recognize the concern that people have about cash over cap, it still all is encompassed in the same revenue base and the same player compensation pool. So I think you you I think people shouldn't view it as a way of avoiding the cap. It all comes it all counts.

SPEAKER_00Yeah, I think Kai Hartley said it really well too. I know he worked with you at the at the NFL, and he said that the salary cap is the ultimate equalizer, that it ultimately catches up to you. So I thought that was another good way to put it as the way you said it. You know, was negotiators, whether it's it's someone like myself that has to deal with an agent or just any business leader dealing with transactions or or politicians, we're always going to go up against someone that's better, tougher, has the leverage.

SPEAKER_00And whether you were negotiating the CBA, you were involved in antitrust, litigation, other league matters, you sat across the table from some of the most respected negotiators in all professional sports, and with them. Gene Upshaw, Jeffrey Kessler, D. Smith, on your side, I can think of people like you know, Peter Ruco and Greg Levy. What was that experience like? You know, when you are negotiating against an elite negotiator or someone that it's not going to be easy, how does that change your preparation, your strategy and tactics?

SPEAKER_00You did it for so long. What what can we learn from that?

SPEAKER_01I think it's something to be happy about because when you're when you're negotiating, when your negotiating partner is someone who is really well prepared, understands the issues, smart, creative, it makes you better. And and the the rookie system discussion that I related to you a few minutes ago, a perfect example of that. You know, we had done all our analysis, we had worked through it, we had talked to the CEC, we talked to the competition committee, we talked to other clubs, and we thought our wage scale idea, that was, hey, that was it.

SPEAKER_01Couldn't get better than that. And then in sitting down with the union, with Dee, Tom De Passo, Jeff Castler, and others, they made their point of view very clear about the absolute prerequisite, their commitment to preserving individual negotiations, but but also recognizing that there was mirrored to our concern about having a system that was so full of holes that it really didn't accomplish anything. And so out of that came at least an equally good system and one that allowed the union to accomplish what it wanted and and stay true to its goals and allowed us to accomplish what we wanted.

SPEAKER_01So when you're when you're dealing with with good negotiators on the other side, I think it helps you to really see where compromise uh can can strengthen you and can strengthen the outcome. It also also allows you to avoid, at least to some extent, the unintended consequences. It's it's not it's not physics, but Isaac Newton's law applies here too. For every action, there's an equal and opposite reaction.

SPEAKER_01And so when you propose something, or the union proposes something, one of the things that both of us should be thinking about is okay, if this were to take effect, what would happen? How would people respond? What would people do to try to avoid this principle if it didn't serve their interests? And so you can you you can learn that quite effectively by listening to your negotiating partner and recognizing that they have a point of view and they have knowledge and understanding that is different from your own.

SPEAKER_01I I think it's a positive.

SPEAKER_00I love I love that you've said many times about listening and making sure the other side is being heard, that their ideas are important and that they're incorporated into the deal, especially since when you're dealing with such high-powered people, you're dealing with a certain amount of of ego. And that's not to say in a negative way, just to say that's that's where they've you know achieved so much of their professional careers. I also noticed that it seemed to me, maybe because it was just televised this way, but that you did do a lot of in-person meetings.

SPEAKER_00Was that accurate? And is that was that by design? How did you decide when to have an in-person meeting versus a conference call?

SPEAKER_01Um, I think we had a very strong preference for in-person meetings because, first of all, when you're when you're there in person, you're not sitting in your office doing 10 other things. You're there, you're there for a reason, you've committed a certain amount of time, and presumably there's been preparation in advance of that meeting, and you know, people fly in from all over the country, and it just gives it an air of seriousness and purpose that it's harder to get on a conference call. Conference call is fine if you've got a discrete issue or two.

SPEAKER_01Okay, we've got this particular problem, how should we solve it? You know, that's one thing. But so we really had a strong preference for in-person meetings. Now, the one time when we really couldn't do that was during the COVID, um, when we were negotiating in the spring and early summer of 2020 to uh develop the financial and the medical protocols that would apply for the what we call the COVID season. That was all done by Zoom conference calls, etc. And and you know, everyone adjusted because that was that was the the single most important thing that most people had to focus on from a football perspective at that time.

SPEAKER_00I love that you said that, and I love that that's that was your strategy because there's a ton of studies that we review that shows the the level of success increases in in-person meetings. And so I was great to hear your perspective why you you were doing that. The the other thing I noticed, so you you you had to deal with some very complicated issues. Everything that you've talked about, everything in the CBA. These aren't simple legal issues. And the add on top of that, tremendous amount of pressure, deadlines, everyone's watching.

SPEAKER_00The world sees everything you're doing. It's a super popular sport, but the but You've always appeared to be so calm. Were you that calm? Did you always have that? Did that evolve over time? How important is that in taking the emotion out of it?

SPEAKER_01Personally, I think it's important not to personalize things. I mean, just because someone is on the other side does not make him your enemy. Just because someone, you know, w when I and i when I'm out of the collective bargaining context and I'm in, you know, my no was in my normal job at the NFL, just because someone violated a rule didn't make him a bad person. And so you you you you have to you have to treat people and uh I and I'm sure if you had someone from the union on, they'd be able to give you any number of examples where maybe I fell short of this, but you you you have to treat people with respect and and common decency.

SPEAKER_01Otherwise, why should they listen to you? When when the 2011 negotiation was all done, a club president called me one day and he said, I just have to say that there was not a single day for the past few years when the owner and I didn't understand the strategy, didn't understand what the goals were, didn't understand what people were doing. You know, the communication was so great. I I look at people who I've worked with and seen how they've and and not just people in the NFL, people outside the NFL were people who were, quote, on the other side.

SPEAKER_01And I've always admired the people, you know, Gene Upshaw was a perfect example of this, people who could remain calm and remain focused. And I just I've just never thought that you accomplish very much by losing your temper or yelling and screaming, or it just makes everybody uncomfortable, especially in those contexts. It seldom accomplishes a great deal. So as I say, I'm sure if you asked Jeffrey Kessler or or D. Smith or Tom DePasso, they could say, Oh, well, maybe remind him of these ten times when he uh acted like a schmuck, but uh but I I I certainly tried not to.

SPEAKER_00Well, we all learned that from you, and it was interesting to hear you you learned that from Gene Upshaw, where I always felt like every negotiation was an opportunity to learn something from someone else, too. And um, it seems like you took that away as well. Paul Tagley Boo, very, very calm.

SPEAKER_01Pete Rosell, very, very calm. I mean, you know, and and well, I mean, Jerry Richardson, who was, you know, one of the two chairmen of the C's, he always preached that. He said, now just we're just gonna be calm, we're gonna listen, we're gonna be respectful. That was his approach to everything. I never heard him raise his voice in in a uh in a negotiating session.

SPEAKER_00I'm sure there's so many examples you have of that. And not to stray off course too much, but and I don't even know if this is anything you follow, but obviously you got everything that's going on with college student athletes, without there's no collective bargaining, and then and then you have Major League Baseball looking at maybe a CAP that look some type of cap system. Anything takeaways from your experience at the NFL that you think would apply over into those worlds without getting too detailed in an in an area that's outside of your expertise?

SPEAKER_01I mean, I I'm not involved in in either baseball or college football to a degree that would give me any particular insight. And I've read articles saying, well, the obvious solution is for college football or college sports generally to adopt a collective bargaining system the way the professional leads have. You know, use that to reach agreement on rules that will govern how college players transfer, what their NIL payments are, how their contracts are enforced, things like that.

SPEAKER_01In theory, yes, there are a number of schools, obviously, where the student athletes would not be permitted by statute to unionize, if if I understand those rules correctly. And I also am not sure, I s I suppose it it might be viewed as a multi-employer bargaining unit, but but be of of a character that I've never seen in any other context where, you know, could could the SEC, the Big Ten, the ACC, the Pac-12, the MIAC, could all those conferences somehow bargain collectively?

SPEAKER_01And what union would it be that would be representing all of these players? And how would those rules apply in all of the different sports? Would you have, you know, multiple labor agreements, football, men's basketball, women's basketball, swimming, field hockey, etc. How how how would all that work? I'm not saying it couldn't work, but but it it takes it takes a lot of it it's gonna take a lot of thought and probably there will be some fits and starts.

SPEAKER_01Uh baseball, you know, again, I don't I don't know enough about what they're proposing or how they would address uh all the issues that come with creating a salary cap. I know that they're very well represented and that they've got very smart people working on it. And it's it's you know, it's not always easy. It took the NFL a long time and a years of litigation and things like that to finally get to the point where where the union would agree to a salary cap. And so, you know, sometimes these things are and and and and it can take multiple agreements to refine it.

SPEAKER_01Uh it'd be interesting to see what what happens there.

SPEAKER_00Aaron Ross Powell There seems to be so much learnings from the the example that the NFL has set that it's always my hope that others sports look at that and even talking to the unions, talking to each other, they can they can learn that from each other.

SPEAKER_01The NFL does have certain uh benefits just by the nature of the sport and the you know very, very extensive revenue sharing that exists in the NFL. That allows all the clubs to be on a relatively common, not not equal, not uniform, but relatively common economic level. And that makes negotiating for a common uniform salary cap makes that makes that more tenable. It's hard when you have very major revenue disparities.

SPEAKER_01Which certainly that would be the case in college.

SPEAKER_00And could and wouldn't you say that the schools or the conferences that are concerned about that issue, that there's an opportunity when you're sharing it to make more revenue. And that way the teams that are all or the schools that are already or conferences already making the most are still going to make a lot because collectively they're stronger and there will be more revenue to go around.

SPEAKER_01Well, that's certainly the theory, and and that that has been true in the NFL because by promoting competitive balance and and making sure that all the teams have a reasonable opportunity to be attractive and be competitive, it has definitely lifted the boat and and and offered a more high-quality product for fans throughout the the country. So it has definitely been true in the NFL. There are so many schools with college athletic programs. Yeah, I think harmonizing all of those interests could be a bigger challenge than maybe some have some have thought.

SPEAKER_01I could be wrong about that, as I say. I'm not involved at all. Not really involved, I'm not involved at all.

SPEAKER_00So no, it's an interesting uh case study to look at from afar, especially with the legislation that they're they're looking at to address some of this as well.

SPEAKER_01Yeah, very true, very true.

SPEAKER_00The name of the podcast is Negotiation Warriors, because we talk about just all the different elements that make up a great negotiator by talking to people like like yourself, and you know, you've brought up listening, you brought up empathy, uh being prepared, having in-person meetings as well, looking at that, being respectful, calm, being a strong communicator. I'm gonna um without being redundant, I always ask this as the final question. What are some of the key traits of being a great negotiator from your perspective?

SPEAKER_01It's not about you. The success or failure of a negotiation is not defined by what people say about the people that are involved in the negotiation. You can't make it about yourself, you can't let your ego be dominant. And I think that's particularly true in in sports because we're selling and and and we're selling a form of entertainment. We have got to provide something that people all over the country that the fans think is really special. And I want to drive to the stadium and stand in line and sit in those seats rain, snow, shine, cold, hot, whatever it is, because what's going on on the field is so special, so exciting.

SPEAKER_01I want to be there. I want to stay home no matter what. I want to stay home. I want to commit hours and hours and hours on Sunday, Monday, Thursday to watching the National Football League because I might see something absolutely extraordinary. That's who it's about. And it's about it's about the fans, it's about the players who work unbelievably hard, who take a lot of risks, and making sure that they have good pay, good benefits, good working conditions, good rules to, you know, protect them from unnecessary risks and help promote safe and healthy play, and making sure that the the ownership who have invested tremendous amounts of capital and in many cases decades, decades and decades of their lives to the to the game and to the team, making sure that they're getting a fair return on that investment.

SPEAKER_01So I think that's in in in many ways the most important thing, and just you know, being prepared. You know, we had to be prepared in 2011 for litigation, we had to be prepared for work stoppage, and we had to be prepared for for a negotiation. That involved financial preparation, that involved legal preparation, and it involved bargaining preparation, and and all of that had to be done simultaneously, and it had to be done in a thorough way that that gave the ownership confidence that the CEC and the staff could go out and do this work for them.

SPEAKER_00So it's not about you. Stakeholder satisfaction, obviously super important, being prepared. So many great takeaways, Jeff. And I know uh your decision to go on a podcast didn't come lightly, so it's greatly appreciated when Commissioner Goodell said that your leadership and impact across our business is immeasurable. Uh I am someone that can, you know, a product of that, like I am someone that benefited from your leadership, as well as all the club council, the league, the fans, the players.

SPEAKER_00You paid a huge role in helping grow this game, helping it be something that we can really enjoy. We never talk about labor issues and the players' salaries. The salary cap has gone up exponentially in a way that everybody is winning. New stadiums are going up, the game just keeps growing, and it's fun to watch, it's fun to be a fan, but it's also great to meet people like you that were humble behind the scenes for so long, and then to come on here and talk about it is greatly appreciated.

SPEAKER_00So I really appreciate you doing that. Thank you. Um, it was great, and um it's always great to see you.

SPEAKER_01Well, thank you, Cliff. It was my pleasure. And um, I'll I'll just say that whatever you think you you got from me, um I got a lot and probably a lot more from the opportunity to work with so many talented people at the clubs for so long. I learned a great deal, they made me better, and they uh helped us to get to better outcomes. So uh it was it was very much a mutual, a mutual kind of thing.

SPEAKER_00That's great. Uh look forward to everything you're gonna do next. I know you're retired, but I know you're never really retired, the way your your mind works. So uh excited to see everything you do, and uh and thank you again for everything and look forward to staying in touch. Okay, my pleasure. Thank you. Thank you, Jeff. Thank you for listening to Negotiation Warriors. I hope you enjoyed this episode. If you like what you heard, please subscribe on the Negotiation Warriors YouTube channel.

SPEAKER_00Follow us on Office 36 on Instagram.

Open the transcript file

Hosts and Guests

Nobody is credited on this episode yet.

Credit the people on this episode

Be the first to rate this episode

More episodes

All episodes
  1. Episode #021: The Art of Credibility (Mike McCartney)

    Nov 16, 202647 minAudio

    Send us Fan Mail The Art of Credibility with Mike McCartney What does it take to build a reputation as one of the most respected negotiators in professional football? For Mike McCartney, the answer isn't about winning...

    Credit the people on this episode

  2. Episode 020: "You Don't Look Like an Agent" - Adopting a Persistent Mindset (Kim Miale)

    Oct 26, 202636 minAudio

    Send us Fan Mail "You Don't Look Like an Agent" - Adopting a Persistent Mindset with Kim Miale At her first NFL Combine, a scout looked at Kim Miale and told her: "You don't look like an agent." Her response was simple:...

    Credit the people on this episode

  3. Episode #019: The Humble Negotiator with Mike Greenberg (Tampa Bay Buccaneers)

    Oct 5, 202644 minAudio

    Send us Fan Mail Negotiation Warriors - Episode #019: THE HUMBLE NEGOTIATOR with Mike Greenberg Mike Greenberg has spent 16 years with the Tampa Bay Buccaneers, quietly becoming one of the NFL’s most respected...

    Credit the people on this episode

  4. Episode #018: From Apprentice to Mentor (Andrew Kessler)

    Sep 21, 202655 minAudio

    Send us Fan Mail Episode #018 - From Apprentice to Mentor with Andrew Kessler What does it take to become one of the most respected agents and negotiators in professional football? For Andrew Kessler, the education...

    Credit the people on this episode

  5. Episode #017: Life on the NFL Bubble (Maema Njongmeta)

    Sep 14, 202655 minAudio

    Send us Fan Mail Negotiation Warriors, Episode #017 - LIFE ON THE NFL BUBBLE with Maema Njongmeta What is it really like to live on the NFL bubble? Every year, hundreds of NFL players fight to earn a spot on the 53-man...

    Credit the people on this episode