Send us Fan Mail The Art of Credibility with Mike McCartney What does it take to build a reputation as one of the most respected negotiators in professional football? For Mike McCartney, the answer isn't about winning every argument, making the biggest demands, or intimidating the other side of the negotiating table. It's about preparation. Patience. Relationships. Integrity. And above all, credibility. "If they say Mike has credibility, that would be the best word for me." Those words reflect a philosophy that has guided McCartney throughout his remarkable career, from NFL scout and front office executive to one of the league's most accomplished player agents. And that philosophy would help him negotiate one of the most groundbreaking contracts in NFL history. When Washington was unwilling to offer quarterback Kirk Cousins a contract that reflected his market value, McCartney faced a decision that would ultimately change the trajectory of NFL player contract negotiations. Rather than accept a below-market deal, he encouraged Cousins to embrace the risk of playing under consecutive franchise tags. It was a bold strategy requiring extraordinary patience, confidence in his client's abilities, and a willingness to trust the negotiating leverage that could develop over time. The decision paid off. In 2018, Cousins signed a historic three-year, $84 million fully guaranteed contract with the Minnesota Vikings, becoming the first veteran NFL player to secure a fully guaranteed multiyear contract. But McCartney's remarkable career is about much more than one historic negotiation. In Episode #021 of Negotiation Warriors, I sit down with Mike McCartney, Head of Football at VaynerSports and an NFLPA-certified agent since 2002, to explore the experiences, values, and negotiating principles that have shaped his career. The son of legendary Colorado football coach Bill McCartney, Mike grew up immersed in football. He began his professional career in coaching before transitioning into NFL front offices, serving as a pro scout for the Chicago Bears and Director of Pro Personnel for the Philadelphia Eagles. With aspirations of eventually becoming an NFL general manager, Mike appeared destined to lead an NFL franchise. But a difficult personal realization changed everything. Following a playoff loss with the Eagles, Mike began questioning whether the demands of his career were preventing him from being the father and husband he wanted to be. He made the difficult decision to walk away from the NFL front office and pursue a career representing players. That decision would lead to more than two decades as an NFL agent, representing players including Kirk Cousins, Aidan Hutchinson, and Evan Engram, while developing a reputation throughout the league for honesty, integrity, and credibility. Yet despite his extensive football background, Mike quickly discovered that understanding the game and understanding NFL player contracts were two very different things. Determined to master the financial side of the business, he began dissecting first-round rookie contracts, creating spreadsheets, analyzing contract structures, and learning from experienced NFL salary cap executives. His preparation eventually produced one of the most memorable stories of our conversation. After receiving an initial contract offer that he believed reflected a lack of respect for his negotiating knowledge, Mike sent Chargers salary cap executive Ed McGuire an entire bound book of contract research, accompanied by a handwritten message: "Just so you know, I know." The next contract offer was completely different. Throughout our conversation, Mike explains why successful negotiators don't necessarily talk the most, why patience can create leverage, and why credibility with the other side is one of the most valuable assets a negotiator can possess. He also shares how his guiding principles of faith, family, and football have influenced his approach to representing players, mentoring young agents, and defining success beyond professional accomplishments. But this conversation isn't just about football. It's about preparation. It's about patience. It's about knowing when to stand firm and when to listen. It's about building relationships without sacrificing negotiating strength. It's about understanding that being liked and being respected aren't necessarily the same thing. And it's about recognizing that credibility isn't something you can demand. It's something you earn through your actions, your honesty, and your willingness to stand behind your word. Mike's story demonstrates that great negotiators don't have to choose between integrity and results. In fact, the two can reinforce one another. IN THIS EPISODE, YOU'LL LEARN: How growing up as the son of legendary Colorado football coach Bill McCartney shaped Mike's values, work ethic, and understanding of the game. The advice his father gave him about perseverance, commitment, and why you shouldn't evaluate an important decision based on a single difficult day. How Mike transitioned from coaching to scouting with the Chicago Bears and eventually became Director of Pro Personnel for the Philadelphia Eagles. Why Mike walked away from his aspirations of becoming an NFL general manager to prioritize his family and pursue a different career in football. How an unexpected conversation with NFL agent Rick Smith helped open the door to his career in player representation. Why Mike initially underestimated the complexity of NFL player contracts and how he developed the technical knowledge necessary to become an accomplished negotiator. The remarkable story behind the contract research book he sent to Chargers salary cap executive Ed McGuire, accompanied by the message, "Just so you know, I know." Why Mike believes credibility is one of the most valuable assets an agent possesses - and how exaggerating contract terms or misrepresenting information can undermine that credibility. How spending time on both sides of the negotiating table helped Mike develop a negotiating philosophy centered on honesty, relationships, preparation, and patience. Why building relationships with NFL executives is essential, but being liked should never be confused with being weak. How dedicating just 10 minutes a day to intentional networking can create meaningful professional relationships and opportunities over time. Why Mike encouraged Kirk Cousins to play under consecutive franchise tags rather than accept Washington's contract offers - and how that strategy ultimately created extraordinary negotiating leverage. The strategy behind Cousins' historic fully guaranteed contract with the Minnesota Vikings and how Mike's confidence in evaluating football talent influenced his negotiating decisions. Why successful negotiators must resist the temptation to rush a deal, particularly when patience can improve their bargaining position. Why Mike believes negotiators should identify two or three essential talking points, stay disciplined, and avoid talking themselves into unnecessary concessions. How Mike balances his core values of faith, family, and football with the competitive demands of representing NFL players. What being a Negotiation Warrior means to Mike - and why perseverance requires continuing to fight even after setbacks and failures. Why Mike hopes his legacy will be defined more by his family, faith, and integrity than by the contracts he negotiated. The essential traits Mike believes define a great negotiator: preparation, patience, discipline, strength, and credibility. THE NEGOTIATION WARRIOR TAKEAWAY Preparation gives you confidence. Patience gives you leverage. Relationships create opportunities. But credibility is what makes everything else work. As Mike explains, you can be tough without being disrespectful, patient without being passive, and successful without compromising your integrity. And sometimes, the most powerful thing a negotiator can do is say less, listen more, and let the other side come to them. Ultimately, your greatest negotiating asset may not be your knowledge, experience, or leverage. It may be your credibility. 🎧 Listen now: Search Negotiation Warriors wherever you get your podcasts. Follow on Instagram: @frontoffice360 Follow on X: @frontoffice360 Front Office 360 #NegotiationWarriors #MikeMcCartney #VaynerSports #KirkCousins #NFL #NFLAgents #NFLContracts #Negotiation #Credibility #Integrity #Leadership #Preparation #Patience #SportsBusiness
Audio and video play straight from the show's own hosting. PodSubs stores and serves no media.
Transcript
From the show. Tap a time to play from there.
SPEAKER_01If it's work related, I do want my legacy to be that I did it with integrity and that um, you know, I never lied, I never oversold. Just, you know, I do have passion now. When I believe in a player, I can I can definitely get going. Um, I really I don't, I've I will never lie. Because it's just the moment the first moment I lie, I've lost my credibility. And I just that's the one word I guess if you could pick from a career standpoint. I, you know, I would hope, you know, maybe people like me, maybe people respect me, but they said if they say Mike has credibility, that would be the best word for me.
SPEAKER_02Welcome to Negotiation Warriors. I am Cliff Stein, and I am on a never-ending quest to learn what it takes to be a great negotiator. In every episode, I will sit down with some of the greatest negotiators in professional sports who will share insights, knowledge, and draw upon their real-life negotiation experiences.
SPEAKER_03Negotiation Warriors is sponsored by Front Office 360, premium cap management software. To find out how we are helping college athletic programs, go to frontoffice360.com to schedule a demo. Alright, welcome back to Negotiation Warriors, the podcast that features conversations with the greatest negotiators in professional sports. I am your host, Cliff Stein. Today's guest is a longtime colleague and friend.
SPEAKER_03Mike McCartney is the head of the football division at Vayner Sports and he's been an NFL PA certified contract advisor since 2002. Over the course of more than three decades, Mike has worked across the entire football ecosystem, coach, scout, front office executive, and now one of the most respected agents in the NFL. Before entering the agent business, Mike spent time in NFL front offices, including roles with the Chicago Bears as a pro scout and with the Philadelphia Eagles as director of pro personnel, giving him a rare perspective of both sides of the negotiating table.
SPEAKER_03Today, he represented some of the top talent in the NFL. This includes players like Kirk Cousins, Aiden Hutchinson, Evan Ingram, many more. Today we're going to get inside the mindset of a great negotiator, what it's like to sit on both sides of the negotiating table, and what it takes to be an advocate for players while maintaining strong relationships with NFL teams. Mike, welcome to the Negotiation Warriors podcast.
SPEAKER_01Thanks, Cliff. Uh, this is uh great to revisit with you uh or visit with you. So I'm I've been looking forward to this.
SPEAKER_03Great. I'm so happy to have you because we definitely um go way back and I want to talk about that. But before I do, I'm very interested in you talking about your career path. You know, you grew up in a football family. How did you end up working in sports? What was your first opportunity all the way to becoming an agent?
SPEAKER_01Yeah, as you said, I did grow up in a football family. My dad was a longtime college football coach, coached at Michigan for eight years under the legendary Bo Shenbeckler, which allowed me to grow up with Jim and John Harbaugh, amongst other coaches, kids. And then he, my senior year in high school, summer of my senior year, got the head coaching job at Colorado and uh was there 13 years, uh, won a national championship. Anytime I meet with a recruit that's in his 20s, I say, I know you can't believe Colorado won a Natty, but we did. And uh he's in the College Football Hall of Fame.
SPEAKER_01And so, you know, when you drop grew up with a dad like that, you eat, sleep, and drink football and sports. And sports was always my life. And I knew after playing college football that I was gonna go into football. I started as a graduate assistant coach at Colorado. Actually, I started as an assistant recruiting coordinator, and then I was a GA uh in the 89 season when we played for our first national championship at Colorado. And then I went to North Carolina for two years uh as a graduate assistant. And then in 1992, as you alluded to, I got hired by the Chicago Bears as a pro scout.
SPEAKER_01So I tell people I used to sit in a dark room, no windows, no light, and just study football from sunup to sundown. And uh, did that for six years, and then I went to the Philadelphia Eagles for three, uh, where I was the director of pros. So that's kind of my uh my football background before becoming an agent.
SPEAKER_03Yeah, and you mentioned uh your dad. So Bill McCartney uh is a legend to many, to all. Um, really the only coach that ever win a championship of Colorado, and and the only one in in the history of the school. You know, what was it like growing up as his son? Was there an expectation that you would work in sports?
SPEAKER_01Say expectation. I love being a coach's kid. Now my dad wasn't around very often, But it was intoxicating being I'm I'm in fourth grade, I'm in the Michigan locker room every day, you know, and hanging out with the players. And so I just grew up, you know, in the locker rooms. And um, so it wasn't really an expectation for my my mom or dad. Like I never thought about anything else but being in sports just because it was in my DNA, you know, growing up. So it was never any pressure on my uh from my dad at all. Uh it was interesting when I I started trying to coach and then I went into the personnel side.
SPEAKER_01He was extremely supportive. In fact, I can remember being a graduate assistant in 1989, and I was supposed to be the assistant recruiting coordinator, which was a lot less hours working than a graduate assistant. So I went from 40, 50 hours a week to well over a hundred. And those first few days, uh, you know, every coach thinks that I'm they're my boss and ordering me around. And I was miserable. And I can remember my dad, uh, we were walking to the training table and he said, How are you doing?
SPEAKER_01And I said, Dad, I hate this. I don't want to coach. And he goes, Mike, you you you made a decision. You got to see it through. He goes, but here's my advice. You can't evaluate it every day. If you do, you're gonna be high with the highs and low with the lows, and you're going to be miserable. And so you made your decision, see it through. And at the end of the year, you take a week or two, you know, some time and evaluate. And if you want to continue to coach, coach. And if you want to do something else, do whatever you want. It was great advice because I was miserable those first few weeks and just said, you know what, I got to embrace this and see it through.
SPEAKER_01And now playing for a team that played for a national championship didn't hurt, you know. But um, but I kind of knew deep down that I really didn't want to go into the coaching side. And and when I was coaching it, but I stayed in that. And I when I was coaching at North Carolina, Bill Tobin from the Chicago Bears came through. He was the general manager, and we started having conversation, and and ultimately he hired me on the personnel side. And that was really right up my alley, I thought, at the time.
SPEAKER_03Oh, okay. That's what I was gonna ask you. So you do your opportunity to switch from college to pro came through a relationship with Bill Tobin.
SPEAKER_01Yeah, I made sure my especially my second year at North Carolina that I that I would go and introduce myself to scouts and you know, knew that they, you know, wanted inside information on players. And and so uh Bill Tobin, you know, ultimately brought me in for an interview in July and then told me he wouldn't hire for 30 days. So I had to sweat that out. But he hired me August 15th as a pro scout, which is a really odd time to hire scouts. But that that was when Plan B free agency was kind of introduced to the National Football League uh as opposed to unrestricted free agency.
SPEAKER_01So they were teams were starting to beef up their pro scouting staff. And the pro guy at the time was a guy named Ken Geiger, and he had told Bill that that would be his last season. That's why Bill was looking for uh his replacement.
SPEAKER_03When you uh made that transition, what did what were your goals at that time? Did you want to be a general manager?
SPEAKER_01Absolutely, yeah. I wanted to have a chance to run a team, and I knew that uh eventually, you know, I would have a family and and I wanted that challenge of um you know running a football team and and doing it the right way with integrity, but also being home a little bit, you know, or at least, you know, be present as a father. And and as I continued up the ladder, so to say, it just got harder and harder. You know, I did get married, I started having kids, and I then I got to the Eagles and I can remember my third training camp.
SPEAKER_01I had three little boys at the time, they were four, two, and one. I drove away from South Jersey to Lehigh, about an hour and 15-minute drive, and I cried the whole time. I just, you know, knowing I was going to be away from my kids for six weeks back then, training camp was a little longer. And I just I knew deep down that I was not good at balancing the job and being present when I was home. You know, the hours were crazy, but even when I was home, I was so distracted, you know, just how do we win a Super Bowl?
SPEAKER_01How do we get better today? And and the truth is I grew up that way. My mom had a saying every year on August 1st, football's here, goodbye, dear. And my dad didn't see us for five months, you know. We would talk to him and he just looked right through us. And, you know, so I remember really thinking it through like, are is it right for two generations of McCartney men to kind of miss out on their dad for half a year? And um, so I just made a tough decision, and then the Eagles made it easy when they let me go. So and that's that was kind of I was not gonna come back that next season.
SPEAKER_01Uh, I had a contract in my drawer, never signed it, and I was ready to move on because and it was really more family reasons than anything.
SPEAKER_03Yeah, I'm gonna ask you about the next transition, but before I do, so the first time I met you, mid-late 90s, you were working for the Philadelphia Eagles. I was an agent practicing law in Pennsylvania and New Jersey, didn't have a lot of clients, didn't have a lot of credibility. You were one of the few people that had time for me. If I called about a player, whether you were interested or not, you took the time to listen to me. I'm not sure how many other agents you did that for, but when we talk about, you know, being a great negotiator, being a negotiation warrior, one of the things that I really emphasize in the classroom is building strong relationships.
SPEAKER_03Because you did that, because you treated me that way and showed empathy, I was more inclined to give players that other that multiple bidders wanted to you because of the way you treated me. And I think we've did that several times where we were able to sign players with the Eagles. Is that something that has helped you? Is that based first of all, is that always been kind of your philosophy with dealing with people? And is that something that has helped you um be a better negotiator now that you're on the agent side?
SPEAKER_01Well, first I really appreciate you sharing that. Um, and I and I I do remember those times when we got to know each other. And um, you know, I would say it's a people business, and um, you know, developing relationships is really important. I definitely um, I guess, you know, navigate to the to the relationships of people with integrity and character. We're not in an industry where everyone has character and integrity. So I certainly uh lean on people that I can build relationships where there can ultimately be some you know honesty and trust and all those kind of things.
SPEAKER_01And you know, I I do think you use the word credibility is is such an important piece of um you know being an agent, uh even or even being a negotiator on the other side. If your yes means yes and your no means no, it goes a long way. And you know, having been on the team side, I do know that a lot of agents can't be trusted, you know, and we see it the way they even release contract details on Twitter, you know, you know, uh up to, you know, how many contracts do we see where it's up to you know, the number?
SPEAKER_01And we just you know immediately that that's uh a number that's not accurate. It's just simply to make the agent look good. And there's a little loss of credibility when those things go on. So I just I really believe in honesty and integrity and credibility. And so I will lean on people that are like-minded, uh, and you were that way from from the very start.
SPEAKER_03Yeah, and I know you I know a lot of people know you as Mac, but there's a side of you that I'm sure a lot of people don't know that I really wanted to get from you in terms of your core values, and you just really talked about a lot of it. And I think that's a lot of reason like people can relate to you. There was a lot of honesty in conversations with you, which is kind of rare sometimes with the agent business. So what what else would it be important for you that people should know about you that they wouldn't necessarily be able to read in a bio?
SPEAKER_01Well, certainly in a bio, you know, from a team side or an agent side, you you're not gonna understand how important my faith is to me. Uh, I grew up in a home, a Christian home, and and uh my relationship with Jesus Christ is the most important relationship that I have. And so my faith means a lot. I try to never hide it, but I also don't ever try and push it on anybody. I, you know, even in recruiting, I'll let players know who I am, but I never it's not my place to to judge or anything like that. But I also don't want to hide who I am, and so and that drives, I guess, my core values, and and that's how I was raised and how I'm raising my you know, children and uh with a new granddaughter uh just in the last couple days, um, you know, whispering in her in her ear right now already.
SPEAKER_01So um, you know, those that that's just really important to me. Faith, family, football. You know, I think there's something behind my uh next to me here. Uh, but that's that's really true. It's faith, family, and football. That's what drives me. I don't really have any hobbies. I don't golf. I have faith, family, and football.
SPEAKER_03I love those values. Uh, congratulations on the granddaughter. Amazing. Thank you. You know, and I I just want to hear you say those values. Like that has to be helpful and impactful when you look, you're serving as a mentor for the clients you have that are as young as your children, I would think, at this time.
SPEAKER_01Younger, yeah.
SPEAKER_03Younger. So, so does that come across in how you guide them that your core values help in the kind of advice and guidance that you give them?
SPEAKER_01You I would hope, uh, but I also believe that um, you know, the players that choose me are choosing me for those reasons. You know, I have a current grading scale for players, for people. A, B, C. And A kid is a kid that does everything right. He learns from his mistakes, he wants to operate in integrity. Go to the C kid. The C kid is looking to cut a corner, he's looking to blame somebody, looking for a handout. Well, A's and C's probably are, you know, on a bell curve are outliers.
SPEAKER_01Most kids are probably B's, most people. And depending on who you put in their life, they can navigate towards that A or C group. I've just been really fortunate and blessed to have repped a lot of A kids. A lot of A kids. And and it and it makes it easier, honestly, because they know who. That's the thing. I I try to put myself out there without being too strong in my faith, but let people know who I am and let players and families know that I care about integrity. I care about doing things the right way, that I'm not going out at night with them, I'm not lying for them, I'm not negotiating uh a certain way.
SPEAKER_01You know, ultimately I think they choose me for some of those reasons.
SPEAKER_03That's great. And I that's I I love the A, B, and C, like we what the takeaways from that. I love that you really simplified it and it also makes a lot of sense that people can understand like you were a scout, you know, you were grading players based on their talent, and now you're able in a better position to evaluate them as people, I assume, when you're recruiting.
SPEAKER_01Well, absolutely. I think you know, we both know, Cliff, that the agent only has so much impact, right? Uh, when when teams are picking players. Certainly, we can have some relationships, you know, we can, you know, drop some nuggets and things like that. But the reality is we have one big advantage over the teams, and that we get in the living room, we get to know the kid differently, we get to know the families, how they were raised, what their core values are. And so over time, going back to credibility, you know, I I don't I can't oversell a player.
SPEAKER_01The moment I do that, I lose my credibility. So I may not focus on those negatives, you know, I'm gonna focus on their positives, but you know, having real conversation with uh NFL general managers, scouts, coaches, cap people, whatever it is, you know, over time, just believing, you know, with all my heart that if I'm honest and I tell this to tell a story that is in you know ingrained in truth, that I can make a difference over time because we do know these kids differently. You know, we have that advantage.
SPEAKER_03Yes, you do. And that's um that's a great perspective that you you saw what you didn't have when you were on the other side. Going back to your last year with the Eagles, you kind of knew it was a strain on your family, kind of knew that that was going to be difficult to manage. You certainly could have continued your career as a front office executive. I knew you that there was no doubt in my mind. Uh the irony of this whole thing is I was an agent early in my career, scraping, crawling, getting to network with people like you to try to build my career up.
SPEAKER_03And then I end up in 2002 on the team side for a team that you worked for, and in 2002 you become you switched size and go become an NFL PA certified contract advisor. I remember when you told me you were gonna make that transition, but I don't remember how, I don't remember why you made that transition.
SPEAKER_01We played the the Giants in the playoffs uh the 2000 season, so it's early 2001, and we got beat two games from a Super Bowl. We had gone my first year in Philly, we were three and thirteen, and we let Ray Rhodes go. We hired Andy Reid, and then two games or two seasons later, we're two games from a Super Bowl. And I remember driving home, and it's it's funny. I I tell players all the time, if you don't hear anything else I say, hear this. I started taking inventory with my life on that drive home.
SPEAKER_01I tell them, don't take inventory after a tough loss. Wait a couple days. I didn't do that, and I really did on that drive home get convicted on this question. In 20 years, I'm gonna ask myself, who raised my kids? Because I literally wasn't home. And even when I was home, I wasn't. And I tried. I would get up at four in the morning, I'd get to the office, I'd have some quiet time, you know, a lot of coffee, uh, and then I'd get home at time to put my kids to bed, and then I look at my wife and just fall asleep.
SPEAKER_01And I was just, again, I was so distracted. It was just really difficult to turn it off. Again, I was really convicted on that drive home and I wrestled with God a little bit, and but I kind of knew deep down that it was time to make a career change. So at that point, I'm like, what am I gonna do with my life? You know, I'm in my mid-30s, I have all this football experience, but that's it. I'm not like, you know, gonna go into pharmaceutical sales and I'm not gonna be a home builder. I have one uh skill at this point in my life, that's it, football. In trying to figure out what was next and thinking through that, you know, what one of the things I really did enjoy as a pro scout was I would go in the locker room and grab players and talk to them.
SPEAKER_01And I remember all the time, hey, what do we need to do to help you be better? You know, how what can we do as an organization to take away any obstacles for you so that our team can win? And then players would come to me and they would want to know, hey, how do I sit, you know, in this and on our team? And the, you know, the NFL is the no-feedback league, right? Like players often really don't understand their role. The starters, the high-paid guys, they get it. But uh so many players in that locker room really are day-to-day and they don't know.
SPEAKER_01And I just developed, I think I developed a reputation where I was gonna be really honest with guys. I was not gonna sugarcoat it, I was gonna tell the truth. And I just believe that players want the truth. They may not like it, but they want the truth, at least really good character guys. So so as I'm driving home and the nit in the ensuing weeks thinking about what's next, engaging with players, I did enjoy. I just I also felt like I had a unique perspective. There was no other agent, as you said earlier, that really understood the game of football like I did, that had been, you know, in those, you know, strategic draft meetings who had been to the combine.
SPEAKER_01I was a group leader twice. Like I just felt like I would have a huge advantage in some cases. So as I started to explore it, then I had to have conversations with my wife. And here's what happened help helped with my wife. It was April, it was around draft time, and I got home, and my oldest was uh three, turning about four about to be five. And I get home and she's not happy. And I said, What's going on? She goes, Nicholas sounds like he's he's from Jersey. He's got a Jersey accent. We're out of here. So she didn't like the Jersey accent for our kids.
SPEAKER_01It was a great move for my family. You know, uh, I ended up that was 25 years ago, and uh, I didn't miss anything with my kids. I went to every event possible. I went to over a hundred baseball games one summer, you know, and I would just sit, get my chair, sit behind home plate, and have my phone and do do work while watching my kids. And I didn't miss a thing. And there's no way that would have happened if I was on the team side.
SPEAKER_03So you went to work for priority sports, a large agency based in Chicago. How'd you get connected with them?
SPEAKER_01At the senior bowl, I was uh getting ready to get a cab uh to go to the airport. And Rick Smith was one of their agents that you know well. He sees me and and Rick says, uh, you know, we're are you headed home? And I said, Yeah, I'm just catching a cab. And he goes, I'll take you to the airport. So we actually had time to stop for lunch and we were talking, and I can remember uh saying the words to Rick. Ultimately, these words changed my life. I was asking a lot of questions about being an agent. And I said these words, you know, Rick, I've often thought about being an agent.
SPEAKER_01And Rick was great. He went into full recruiting mode at that moment. You know, he was like, oh, Mike, you know, you could be really good at this. And um, because of his excitement, and we stayed in touch, of course. I think that was um a big that was big for me, you know, because he kind of validated that I could do it. And you never know, right, until you do something. So we stayed in touch and then ultimately they hired me that summer.
SPEAKER_03So you made the transition, you go and work for a pretty prominent sports agency and you got certified. Were you, because you were coming from the world of scouting and coaching, were you intimidated about whether you would uh be good enough to be a negotiator? Did you have any initial reservations about that aspect of the job?
SPEAKER_01I didn't at the beginning, but I my first year I was able to sign Josh McCown, uh, who had an 18-year career and we're still close to this day. Keith Heinrich was a tight end, and I recruited Dwight Freeney. Dwight Freeney, I didn't get him, but he ended up being, I think, the 11th pick in the draft. And once I started getting into contracts and studying contracts, at that moment I was like, probably a good thing not getting Dwight Freeney because I was ill-prepared to do a first-round contract back then. Today would be different, of course, because the CBA changed how first round or all the rookie deals are.
SPEAKER_01But I didn't know how exposed I would have been until I really started studying contracts. When on the team side, I didn't have a chance to really study contracts. A, it wasn't my job. B, those weren't even readily available. And C, you know, I had to watch tape all day. When I became an agent, I actually had more access to the contracts because of the union. And so I would take every first round contract in August and I created a spreadsheet. I created flow charts. I just, I knew I didn't know. You know, I wasn't maybe gonna admit that to people, but I knew deep deep down I did not know.
SPEAKER_01And so I really worked hard and I had to understand everything. I can remember calling you, you know, I don't remember the exact question, but what's a one-timer and what's this and you know, what's that? And I just I said to myself, I'm gonna make myself vulnerable and ask cap guys questions, you know, and try to get an understanding. And between cap guys and Rick and, you know, some people at the union, it allowed me to get through that month. And so I what I did is I um I literally kind of redid every first-round contract in Excel spreadsheet with the I made sure every number worked.
SPEAKER_01I had the descriptions, I had the flow chart. Then the lights started to go on. I said, Oh, now I see what's happening here, right? Well, the following year, I did it again, and I think it was my fourth year. I got my first first rounder, Luis Castillo. Ed McGuire is the cap guy for the uh San Diego Chargers back then. Castillo was 28th in the draft and mad respect for Ed Maguire. Love the dude, but he sent me an offer that basically told me, I don't have respect for you because you don't know what you're doing, right?
SPEAKER_01And you know what I mean by that, Cliff. And so instead of getting mad at him and just saying this is an absurd offer, I printed out the book from the year before. It was a thick book, like four pages for all 32 first round picks, right? And I got it bound at back then with Kinkos, and I I put it in the mail with a handwritten note, Ed, comma, just so you know, comma, I know, Mike. I sent him the book. The next offer was completely different.
SPEAKER_01And had a conversation with a GM, and uh the GM said, Yeah, uh, somebody was asking about you, Mike, if you know what you're doing. And the GM's like, yeah, Mike, Mike knows what he's doing. And and Ed said to him, Yeah, he sent me this research book. I've never seen anything else, anything like it, you know. And but that's what I had to do. I had to just put it on paper and see it. That's how my brain works. I excel, I love Excel. I can see numbers, but I got to see them. What's interesting is my partner Kyle Dolan, who's a brilliant, brilliant agent, teen eighty on his SAT, finished number one in the law school at University of Chicago law.
SPEAKER_01He's the opposite. He doesn't have to see it. He can, but he can he can read a contract, and his brain works where the language makes sense to him. My brain works where the math works that makes sense to me, seeing it. And so when you bring us together, that can be pretty potent. I had to like just go down to the studs and learn this, you know, at the most basic level. That gave me a it exposed that I wasn't ready for the Dwight Freeney year, but and and I knew that and I had to keep doing it, and then it gave me confidence because I had done so much research and to try to really understand.
SPEAKER_03No, there's no doubt I that someone with your background can do it. And that's why I asked the initial question because some of it is perception and some of it's your own belief in yourself. And when I think about negotiation styles, obviously you know, you have a you have a unique background. You played, you coached, scouted. I always saw this ability of you just a natural thing to stay calm. Chris Voss, who's the FBI negotiator and author of Never Split the Difference, talks about his uh late night radio DJ voice where he would k get people calm when he would be able to slip into this sort of voice that was a little bit like very like just soothing the people.
SPEAKER_03And I feel like you sort of almost naturally have it. Like, I don't see you being someone that really gets too emotional, which is a good trait. How has your experience shaped your negotiation skills and how would you describe your negotiation personality?
SPEAKER_01Again, I do appreciate you saying that about me, and and I do try to I can't tell you I'm perfect, but I try to uh maintain an even keel. And um, you know, I do know it's there's a give and take to every negotiation, right? Um and you know, we can't you can win the battle, lose the war if you're showing people up and all those kind of things. So, but I think one of my strengths is I can definitely be patient in a negotiation. But I think way too many younger agents are just in a hurry to get a contract done and can make mistakes and leave you know some money out there.
SPEAKER_01So being patient is definitely a strong component for me. You know, understanding the game and understanding players, you know, and you know, Kirk Cousins, you know, he had one year starting in Washington, and you know, I'm sure we'll talk more, and it's been documented that I really pushed him to uh play for the franchise tanks. And where I had confidence in doing that is my ability to evaluate the player and you know, and and and knowing the player and what was so important, how football was so important to him, you know, it allowed me to use my football understanding and knowledge to help him, you know, make a much better decision.
SPEAKER_01So, you know, combining football and and and patience, I think. And then again, I had to learn the numbers. I had to get there. I can remember my first several negotiations, though, first several years probably, and every negotiation, I'm on my knees praying, oh God, please help me. And you have to over-prepare when you're really not seasoned. And then you get to a place where you you kind of you never arrive, but you get to a place where you don't have to over-prepare, where you under it it comes a lot more natural. And I still am in prayer mode though, you know, as we head into free agency for me, you know, I just I have to make sure that I stay humble.
SPEAKER_01Like I don't have all the answers. And so I do try to buy design to be be really patient. That's with the actual negotiation, but that's with people too.
SPEAKER_03Yeah, and I think that's that's an incredible takeaway too, just in terms of if I'm on the other side, regardless of how well I know you or not, I really want to be able to trust you, and I really want to be able to tell you more things if I can trust you. And so from what I'm hearing from you is that you are naturally organically doing things to help the other side trust you more because you're just being who you are. And I talked to a lot of front office executives, and certainly when you left the Eagles, you knew a lot of them, right? I mean, you had to know almost all of them.
SPEAKER_03Things have changed, right? It's a different league now from when you left. So when I ask them now, though, about who are some of the best people to deal with, who do you really like, who are some of the best agents? Everyone likes you. I get that a lot. I've told people that myself, but now I see it, now that I'm not out of the out of the NFL front office. Are you aware of that? And what would you say your secret is to building strong relationships with NFL front office executive, especially since it's not the same people when you you left the business?
SPEAKER_01Yeah, look, I think um trying to be intentional about building relationships is really important. I'm trying to counsel you know our young agents, and uh, you know, a lot a lot of times people ask me about getting into sports, and I talk about networking. And networking is really important, and you have to be intentional. What I what I encourage people to do is and I asked the question, can you imagine if you just took 10 minutes a day, every single day, take Sunday off, 10 minutes a day, six days a week, how exponential that'll be if you just simply for 10 minutes network within weeks, you know, and you're gonna get a lot of no's, right?
SPEAKER_01You're gonna get a lot of unreturned calls or whatever it might be. But if you just commit to 10 minutes a day, it truly would is exponential. But you have to be intentional about networking. And too often we let it come to us. And so I think I do think building relationships matters. I think you know, having integrity and honesty matters. And there's a flip side, Cliff, uh, it with all due respect, you know, yeah, I think maybe you know, some people like me, but sometimes I I feel like they could they think they can take advantage of that too. And so, you know, there's a it's a pendulum.
SPEAKER_01You can be nice, but you also have to be strong. And so, how do you be strong, or how I try to stay strong, is know the football player, know the person, have the um understanding of the market or what we're trying to accomplish, and can't be weak. You know, you have to be strong for your player, and and um so there will be conflict at times, and how to handle conflict, you know, is is um it's not always easy. I was in a negotiation recently and we decided to kind of take a break. And I called the the cap guy, you know, a couple days later and I said, Hey, I know we're gonna take a few weeks off here, but what we can't do is not stop talking.
SPEAKER_01Like, because you know, then it gets awkward. Then it's like who's gonna make the first you know move? And so I just tried to find reasons to call. And, you know, uh, we actually uh like the same team in a sport, so we talk about that, you know, just to make sure there was a level of communication. So once we pick that negotiation back up, it wasn't awkward. There is a healthy balance to that though, you know, engaging with people, building relationships, but you don't want to be seen as weak. You know, you have to be strong in a negotiation as well.
SPEAKER_03Being strong is a great mindset learning tool. When I think about the word warrior, we use that word in my teaching and for this podcast. It means a lot to me. I always say it's a powerful word. When you talk about being strong, and we all look, we all have had adversity. Um, some people get stronger of having it, some people don't, some people get stuck and you've had losses, you have had things that have happened to you. What does the word warrior mean to you?
SPEAKER_01Well, you know, um, I guess warrior is just keep going. You know, the the beauty of football is it's an amazing game. It's it's you know, playing with 10 other guys that you have to everybody's got their role, you gotta be together. And the beauty of football is what do you do when you get knocked down? You got to get back up. I guess that's what comes to mind when you say warrior is just continue, just keep fighting. You're gonna lose, you're gonna get beat, uh beat up, you're gonna, you're gonna look bad at times.
SPEAKER_01It's just but that's life, right? Isn't that life for anything, what anything we do? And you know, we just happen to be in football, but I do love the lessons of, you know, you said it. I played, I coached, I scouted, I've represented players, and and I have failed in all four of those areas, probably uh the as a player the most. But that's being a warrior, it's just keep going. Just you you gotta keep fighting, you gotta keep scratching and clawing. You can't, you just can't give up, you can't stop, you can never quit.
SPEAKER_03I love that. And that's there sounds a lot like you can even pull from your advice from your father, and as a coach, but also when he he told you, look, don't don't judge it in in the moment, you know, like you gotta take time and keep going, give it a chance. And that's I think you took his advice, and now you're giving that same advice, which I love. Talking about all the things you've done now, 25 years as an agent. Can't believe it. Amazing. I know, but you've done so many things. And what would you say?
SPEAKER_03What contract or what moment as an agent are you most proud of?
SPEAKER_01Well, um, it's hard not to uh go to the Kirk Cousins set of contracts. Um, you know, especially that first time when uh Wash, you know, Kirk had played one year. It started one year. He had that you like it, like that year. You know, they made the playoffs that year, encouraging him. And Washington started low. So they, you know, they they helped set the course with all due respect. But um, you know, I can remember there were nine quarterbacks between 16 million and and 19 and a quarter back then.
SPEAKER_01And there were another nine over 20 million. So the 20 million is called tier A, the 16 to 19 and a quarter tier B. That's 18 starting quarterbacks making more than 16 million. And Washington started way below that. And so I said to Kirk, listen, at the end of the day, I'm not really big into the high low game. As you know, Cliff, a lot of teams will start really low and that forces the agent to go really high and it gets absurd. Like I'd much rather build the relationship. Like, let's just get to it, right? You know, of course, you can't give me your best offer, but you don't have to give me your worst offer to start it, you know.
SPEAKER_01Let's find some ability to get to negotiate. Well, Washington gave me their worst offer, and I just said, Kirk, listen, I can play the high-low game, and then we're gonna read about our offer in the Washington Post, and it's just gonna get messy. And at the end of the day, they're not letting you go. And the franchise tag was just about 20 million. And and we did try to negotiate. And I said to the Redskins back then many times, hey, if you get me between tier A and tier B, we can find a contract here. Ultimately, they they chose not to, and and um, they got, I think their best offer was 16 million a year.
SPEAKER_01And so they they finally, you know, before they put the franchise tag, they said, they told me they were gonna put the franchise tag. They said, but we really need another offer from you. I called them and said, here's what I'll do. I've told you all along, I'll I'm willing to go between tier A and tier B. So I want a three-year deal at 19.5 per year. That's 58.5, but I want it fully guaranteed. Before you respond, here's you got to look at it this way. You already gave me the franchise tag at 20.
SPEAKER_01I have a young ascending player who's only gonna get better. You're gonna tag me again. So with a 20% built-in raise, I've got 44 million essentially in my pocket. I'm offering you 58.5. I'm a I'm effectively offering you a one-year extension beyond those two franchise tags for 14.5 million. And they got mad. They got really mad. So, but it gave me confidence that you know I could sell this three-year concept. So we, you know, Kirk plays out the franchise tag two years in a row and and becomes an unrestricted free agent.
SPEAKER_01I had been thinking about it for two years. And so, you know, we uh ultimately had four teams that were very interested, and and all four were willing to do, you know, a three-year fully guaranteed deal. And we, as you know, we chose the Vikings. And um, and then, you know, this is he just finished his tenth year where the previous season ended, and he knew the following year was fully guaranteed. So he's had 10 years of fully guaranteed money, and which is pretty incredible.
SPEAKER_03That's gotta be some kind of record, but also was he the first one to receive a fully guaranteed contract?
SPEAKER_01Yeah, yeah. First veteran, yeah. Yes. There's only been two.
SPEAKER_03So amazing. And you're and you're here you are coming from a other side of the business, and then you work yourself your way up in your career to get the first fully guaranteed contract, and now a player who's has 10 years of fully guaranteed money, that's amazing.
SPEAKER_01Yeah, and he's got another 10 million guaranteed this year, so it could be 11, you know, um, depending on what we do. But yeah, it's been a it's pretty incredible. I think I of course I look at these numbers every now and then. I think 99.3% of every dollar he's earned was fully guaranteed. So essentially only his rookie contract was not, and those were four years of base salaries, minimums.
SPEAKER_03Yeah, well, that's a great, um, that's a great proud moment to be to use that as the example. You know, as I think about you two and uh, you know, your your father, children grown up, married, now a grandfather, maybe your granddaughter stumbles on this podcast 10 years from now or or 15 years from now. I don't know if hopefully you and I are doing well and we're existing, but your in terms of your legacy, what would you like to say to her? What would you like to say to her? What's your message um about your legacy?
SPEAKER_01You know, I love football and I love the game. I don't know if I want my legacy to necessarily be football, though. I'd rather have my legacy be about my faith and my family. Um, that um, you know, I'm not a perfect dad in any way, shape, or form, but I love my children, love my wife. My wife and I are about to celebrate our 32nd anniversary. Uh, we all know marriage isn't always easy. Again, talk about being a warrior, we had to we had to fight scratch and claw at times, like everyone. We don't always talk about those things publicly, but that's the reality of marriage, right?
SPEAKER_01And for most. And just uh just being a a family man that that loves God and loves, you know, his family. That's really what I want. My legacy. If it's work-related, I do want my legacy to be that I did it with integrity and that um you know I never lied, I never oversold. Just you know, I do have passion now. When I believe in a player, I can de I can definitely get going. Um, I really I I don't I I will never lie. Because it's just the mo the first moment I lie, I've lost my credibility.
SPEAKER_01And I just that's the one word I guess if you could pick from a career standpoint. Uh, you know, I would hope, you know, maybe people like me, maybe people respect me, but they said if they say Mike has credibility, that would be the best word for me.
SPEAKER_03I definitely uh yeah, I mean, and again, when you say um integrity and never lying, like it sounds I'm taking from that that you need to be able to live with yourself and how you treat and talk to others, and that's important to you.
SPEAKER_01Absolutely. You know, I had a I was at the combine many years ago and and um was meeting with a cap guy for lunch and we're negotiating a player, and and I said to him, you know, I can go get your current offer from 10 teams or something like that. And it this was probably the ultimate compliment to me. He said, Mike, any other agent that says that it goes in more one ear and out the other, but when you say it, I believe you. And and that just that meant the world to me, you know. Um now the other good compliment I got is I signed a punter once, a veteran punter, and I called the team, the cap guy, and I said, Hey man, just letting you know I signed your punter.
SPEAKER_01Oh, that's great news, Mike. Oh no, that's terrible. Now I gotta deal with you in the negotiations. So I took that as a compliment too.
SPEAKER_03Well, I could say what you just said, that Cap guy said to you. Um, I could say from my perspective that all I agree, first of all, I agree with him or her. And that that always made things much easier to deal with, much faster, which is a key. And whether I knew you in your prior life or not, it was getting to know a whole different person when you became an agent. And that person was was the same person, which I loved. And the last question, I ask everyone this question. Some of it will be to sum up for you, because you've touched on some of this, but what are the key traits of being a great negotiator?
SPEAKER_01Yeah, I think you need to be prepared. You know, if you're an agent in particular, you know that the club has uh a lot more people at their disposal. Uh, they have, you know, computer programs, databases, they have a lot more data available. They just do. And so being really prepared matters greatly. I think that being patient is really important. I would also say be smart with how much you talk. Uh, you can talk yourself into giving up, you know, some areas in a negotiation.
SPEAKER_01One of the things I try to do is I try to find my two or three talking points, bullet points, however you want to describe it. And I don't deviate. I just I stay on point and I try not to talk too much in a negotiation, which is really interesting, Cliff, because as a when you're recruiting, it's all it's a lot of talking. You have to go through everything, you know, over and over. Then you you turn to negotiate and are actually representing, and you kind of got to put a different hat on because it's a different skill set altogether.
SPEAKER_01And I would say I watching young people negotiate, that's that's been one of the points of feedback is hey, don't be so quick to give every thought you have, you know, let it come to let the team come to you a little bit more. You know, I think again, being patient, maybe not talking so much, being really prepared. And then, and then again, I truly believe in my heart, if if you have credibility and you're strong and you're prepared and you're patient and all those things, I truly believe we'll do better deals for our players.
SPEAKER_01We may not bet a uh 100%, but we're gonna do overall better deals over the long haul.
SPEAKER_03Yeah, well, look, you just described a lot of the pillars of being a negotiation warrior. That's where the phrase came from. A lot of great takeaways here today, Mike. I really appreciate it. Faith, family, football, amazing core values. They're right behind you. 10 minutes a day to network. I love that. That building relationships matters. It's okay to be nice, but you got to be strong. Don't let people take advantage of you. Warrior, continue fighting, keep fighting, don't stop. Um, love the story about the Kirk Cousins deal.
SPEAKER_03And really, you know, you as a as on the agent side, you're part of history now. Like that will you'll be forever green as part of history. And I'm sure that's something you share with Kirk Cousins and you always will, but it's not something you run around and just talk to about all the time. You're just you're something you're sharing with your client with I love. You have great integrity, you never lie. I know this, and you have tremendous credibility, which again, being prepared, being patient, listening more than you talk, and staying on point, and then having credibility.
SPEAKER_03So these are great takeaways. And I thank you for all of this. And I appreciate your time. I know I don't know when this will exactly everybody know. Right now, it's a very busy time for Mike McCartney. So I really appreciate him taking the time to do this podcast and helping out.
SPEAKER_01Well, this has been great, Cliff. It's been great, you know, being with you and and gone kind of going through a history lesson in some respects, and uh, you know, we have a rich history together. So this has been a blast for me and just really enjoy. And then you've been so complimentary. So I might have to have you send it to me just to make sure my wife feels good too.
SPEAKER_03Well, I'm a huge fan, and you treated me well when I was a young nothing, and you still continue to treat me well while you're doing great deals for players. So appreciate you, appreciate your relationship, keep going, keep doing great things, keep being a great grandfather and father and husband, and um and the transition to really putting your family first is is an amazing story. Thank you. All right, Mike.
SPEAKER_02Thank you for listening to Negotiation Warriors. I hope you enjoyed this episode. If you like what you heard, please subscribe on the Negotiation Warriors YouTube channel and follow us at Fun Office360 on Instagram and X. And to find out our helping college athletic programs, go to FunOffice360.com
Send us Fan Mail "You Don't Look Like an Agent" - Adopting a Persistent Mindset with Kim Miale At her first NFL Combine, a scout looked at Kim Miale and told her: "You don't look like an agent." Her response was simple:...
Send us Fan Mail Negotiation Warriors - Episode #019: THE HUMBLE NEGOTIATOR with Mike Greenberg Mike Greenberg has spent 16 years with the Tampa Bay Buccaneers, quietly becoming one of the NFL’s most respected...
Send us Fan Mail Episode #018 - From Apprentice to Mentor with Andrew Kessler What does it take to become one of the most respected agents and negotiators in professional football? For Andrew Kessler, the education...
Send us Fan Mail Negotiation Warriors, Episode #017 - LIFE ON THE NFL BUBBLE with Maema Njongmeta What is it really like to live on the NFL bubble? Every year, hundreds of NFL players fight to earn a spot on the 53-man...
Send us Fan Mail Negotiation Warriors, Episode #016 - THE CBA NEGOTIATOR with Jeff Pash For more than four decades, Jeff Pash helped shape the business and labor framework of the National Football League. As the NFL’s...