Can museums strengthen international relationships not by avoiding disagreement, but by making space for it? In this episode of Museums: The Big Issues, I talk to Sascha Priewe as he explores the emerging concept of agonistic cultural diplomacy - a bold reimagining of the museum's role as a trusted forum where contested histories, diverse perspectives, and democratic dialogue become the foundations of cultural understanding. I'm Carol Scott (https://www.linkedin.com/in/carol-ann-scott-33a6061a/) and thank you for listening to this episode of Museums, The Big Issues. Join me next Wednesday as we continue to explore the big issues and the big ideas with the people helping to shape the future of museums.
Audio and video play straight from the show's own hosting. PodSubs stores and serves no media.
Transcript
From the show. Tap a time to play from there.
SPEAKER_00What does the future hold for museums as they face some of the biggest challenges and the most exciting opportunities in their history? I'm Carol Scott, and this podcast series is Museums, the Big Issues. Join me as we bring the big issues and the big ideas together with some of the very best thinkers and practitioners in the field. Together, we'll look at how we build a sustainable future for museums in these uncertain times.
SPEAKER_00This week, the question is how museums can create connections across borders and political differences. And what happens when diplomacy isn't about avoiding disagreement, but about creating space for it. My guest today is Dr. Sasha Prieux, Director of Collections and Public Programs at the Aga Khan Museum in Toronto. Sasha, you're also chair of ICOM Canada, and you're an associate professor at both the University of Toronto and Queen's University, and a senior fellow at Massey College.
SPEAKER_00You've written and spoken extensively about museums and cultural diplomacy, and today you're going to discuss a new model. One that recognizes disagreement, makes conflict visible, and asks whether museums can play a more active role in navigating the complex world we share. Sasha, welcome to Museums The Big Issues.
SPEAKER_01Thank you very much for having me on the podcast, Carol. It's a pleasure to join you.
SPEAKER_00Sasha, to start off, let's go back to basics. Can you describe the features of what we would call traditional cultural diplomacy and the role that museums have played in that?
SPEAKER_01Traditional cultural diplomacy is generally understood as an effort to continue to achieve foreign policy aims by way of culture. This makes it essentially, in the classical understanding, the domain of the states. So the states pursue cultural activities as part of a broader foreign policy toolkit. And museums have always been part of this. I think we're all familiar with the treasures exhibition that have been sent around the world and that were intended to impress foreign audiences. So cultural diplomacy in this scene, like in this way, has always been essentially a vehicle of national promotion.
SPEAKER_00Now you argue that this traditional model of cultural diplomacy has reached its limits. Why do you think that?
SPEAKER_01The advancing of an alternative way of thinking about cultural diplomacy has been really at the heart of the work of NACDI, the North American Cultural Diplomacy Initiative, which is a cross-disciplinary research network that had the privilege of co-founding now some nine years ago. We have advocated and advanced research in this context for an understanding of cultural diplomacy that cleaves less to methodological nationalism, which is about granting the nation state the main role and seeing the nation-state role, nation state in effect as the main unit of analysis.
SPEAKER_01And ideas for new diplomacy have actually been, or new understanding of diplomacy, have actually been around for a good 20 years now. The idea was prompted by an increasingly network world, primarily through globalization and the internet, of course, the hyperspeed of globalization over 20 years ago. And that means that diplomacy, when broken down to its essence, is about the conduct of relationships. And this can be done, in fact, by many actors, among them states, but not only the states. So this is the work that we have been leaning into within NACD and in this research that you indicated.
SPEAKER_01And in this way, as articulated by Cooper and others, foremost in this Oxford Handbook of Modern Diplomacy from over 10 years ago now, they see us as moving not necessarily away from the club of nation states in the contact of diplomacy, but to that club of nation states being complemented by a network of other actors, in effect, network diplomacy. And for culture, this means that we now have if you have to add to the nation states as actors the cities, the artists, cultural institutions, including museums and so on.
SPEAKER_01They all have a role in this one network understanding of cultural diplomacy.
SPEAKER_00One of the things you claim is that culture is rarely neutral, and you argue that museums are areas where conflicts over representation and contested narratives occur. Based on this view of museums, you propose a new model of cultural diplomacy, which you call agonistic cultural diplomacy. Now, the word agonistic suggests a rather combative approach. So can you explain a bit about this model and how it differs from the traditional model of cultural diplomacy?
SPEAKER_01So this um the development of this idea of an agonistic museum diplomacy and agonistic cultural diplomacy came out of a German-Canadian research project that included Joachim Ball, Friedrich Alanda Donelli, and Sarah Smith. And in this group, we tried to develop a concept that is fit for the world that we're currently in. And that we've initially applied to museum, but I think has some merit to being applied to cultural diplomacy writ large. So I urge your listeners to check out the open access article that we wrote on this topic.
SPEAKER_01The work starts from the premise that conflict is everywhere. In fact, it is constitutive to democratic life. We see conflicts playing out in the sphere of culture all the time, whether this is about access to funding, access to spaces, and museums, of course, have not been spared from these conflicts. Contestations of museums actually seem to be in condition that museums seem to be constantly immerse in. We see this in debates around decolonization and so on, for example. And we also see this in the still new ICO museum definition, where they still just trying to open up museums in a certain way, partially addressing the um the conflictual um uh um understandings that have been lopped at museums over the years.
SPEAKER_01So conflict rather than something to be avoided is to be understood and worked through. But this should not prevent us from embarking on conversation. And the concept of agonism actually deals with exactly that. We are building on work done by Chantal Mouffe, who says that instead of facing each other antagonistically, agonistic, facing each other agonistically does not brush the differences under the carpet, but it helps us at the same time to open space for common-gether and for sharing spaces.
SPEAKER_00So, Sasha, if I understand you correctly, traditional cultural diplomacy was uh the or has been the parview of nation states and is seeking kind of common meeting points across cultures through promoting national culture. But agonistic cultural diplomacy holds that disagreement is fundamental to democracy. Now, if this is the case, what is the role of museums in implementing agonistic cultural diplomacy? Are you arguing, for example, that museums have a responsibility to make conflict visible rather than to avoid it?
SPEAKER_01Let me begin answer to Azada's question by adding that um embracing agonism as a way of rethinking cultural diplomacy does not mean that conflicts will be resolved per se. It actually permits us to find a space that we can share in dialogue. I previously tried to get at this through the notion of the museum as a diplomatic site. And here I'm not speaking above the museum as a place for dinners of the heads of states of the G7 or something like that. And certain museums have been used for that, or regular use for that over the years.
SPEAKER_01But I rather look at museums as spaces that facilitate contact between groups. And that this can actually work to implement this, where people with different backgrounds, with different even backgrounds that sit in conflict, come together and actually share space has been shown to work. I lean quite heavily into the idea of contact theory as developed in social psychology. And contact theory has now been around for, I think, nearly 70 years.
SPEAKER_01Um and it continues to be validated by lots of research in social psychology. And that at hearts, it speaks to the ways in which contact between different groups of people can lead to a decrease in prejudice. And it has also other effects. For example, there have been strong effects around empathy, cultural learning, and so on. But the key is that you bring groups together on a level playing field and groups that very often potentially be are more prone to antagonistic opposition.
SPEAKER_01In this case, we can bring people together and create a place where prejudice can be actually decreased by the way of contact and carefully curated contact. And I believe that museums can those places in which we could make this really work.
SPEAKER_00Can you provide us with some examples of how this model of cultural diplomacy would work for museums?
SPEAKER_01Okay, this is going to be a little bit experimental because we are presenting somewhat of a new way of thinking in this model. So I let me just uh try to see what examples we can adduce here. So agonistic museum diplomacy is essentially a proposal for how museums retain legitimacy and agency without pretending to stand outside a geopolitical conflicts now running directly through their galleries. What could that mean? That could mean we may find ways to address competing narratives and lone exhibitions rather than outright accepting content uncritically.
SPEAKER_01It could also mean adding independent additional displays to the type of treasure shows that then show in what ways these shows are part of a broader softpower cultural diplomacy push. That would alone create more transparency. So just some initial ideas how we could potentially make this work by being a bit more transparent about the underlying assumption and ideas that underpin the work rather than providing a somewhat uncritical glossing over, as can also happen in museum work.
SPEAKER_00Sasha, if we adopt the view that disagreement is essential to democracy, how does making conflict visible align with what I must say is still a widely held view that museums are neutral spaces?
SPEAKER_01Oh, you're absolutely right. I mean, this is an incredibly widely held view, and probably one of the widest held views about what museums are supposed to be full stop, right? Um and actually that should be an interesting question for your next guest as well. Um, Robert Jaynes very helpfully critiqued what he called authoritative neutrality. And for him, this is a position held by museums in which neutrality helps museums to stay out of things.
SPEAKER_01He was mostly relating to the climate crisis and the museum's failure to address it. As for him, neutrality with regards to the climate crisis basically creates a right for museums to not get involved. And he sees this as extremely damaging. Um I find it's a very cogent position. And he also says that embracing neutrality for museums is a vote for the status quo. And of course, that's where it's what gets very dangerous in an ever-changing world.
SPEAKER_01So I say that actually museums are far from neutral spaces. There's no such thing as a neutral space. Every space was created and built for a certain purpose. And this comes with a potential political and other kind of viewpoint. And museums specifically have politics around what and who is included, what and who is excluded, and that is inherently political. And this has, of course, been wildly critiqued over the years as well. And but embracing the idea of the museum as a neutral space means that we just don't have to deal with these things.
SPEAKER_01And and that is where the museum itself holds the conflictual positions, and we should be very clear about this. And of course, we have heard a lot about the years, just and um justly so that museums I'm proponents of very asymmetrical power relationships that actually favor museums vis-a-vis, let's say, so-called source communities. And that's a clear example of where neutrality just doesn't work. Agonism and ideas such as contact theory actually help us think through how we could work through and be clear about museums' own biased positioning.
SPEAKER_00Well, I'm going to pursue this a little bit, Sasha. So museums are are also uh, and in some cases, the most trusted of public institutions. Now, do you think that museums can foster engagement with contentious issues in the name of democratic debate and still maintain that trust?
SPEAKER_01So that notion of trust in museums is very interesting. And you will probably have seen all those studies that over the years have shown and borne out the high degree of trust. Um indeed, as you say, museums have been some of the most trusted institutions, certainly more than um social media, regular media. They're just right after members of the family and close friends. And what is so interesting about this notion of trust in museums is that it often carries um across party lines.
SPEAKER_01I don't know whether you've seen this recent survey coming out of Germany that shows that a vote um that adherents across all the entire party spectrum all maintain very high trust in museums. I found this quite astonishing. No, I haven't seen that. That's amazing. But then, so that's a study um done by um the state museums in Berlin, and it's a very interesting study that confirms some of the things we know from elsewhere. But of course, trust diminishes for certain groups. Work in Canada has shown that Indigenous people systematically trust museums less.
SPEAKER_01Work by the Alliance of American Museums has shown over years that there's a huge gap in trust in museums in the US between white and African Americans. And so for me, there's a danger of relying on trust and the notion of trust a little bit too much as it can result of not feeling the need to change one's practices. It is in a way can have a similar function to the notion of neutrality where it serves as a vehicle to maintain the status quo rather than looking at the change that needs to happen.
SPEAKER_01And the idea of agonism helps us to be more transparent about these things and making fault lines assumptions um a bit more visible, or at least to think them through in our work much more clearly.
SPEAKER_00You know, when uh I was preparing for this podcast and I, you know, was doing a little bit of research on the word agonistic and and and um the word disagreement, you know, which is kind of associated with it. We when we look for synonyms in English for the word disagreement, we get words like dispute and quarrel and argument and discord and clash and falling out, etc. It's really quite combative language. How can you know, how can museums foster democratic disagreement without deepening social divisions in an increasingly polarized world?
SPEAKER_01Indeed, I think that kind of goes to the heart of what we um might think of the political in the in this conversation. And I should note that one thing I do not subscribe to is for museums to engage in partisan efforts, in partisanship. That is really not our role. And museums do not need to take stand on every issue that arises, but they can help you assure that debate is possible. And this pertains particularly in museums, at least those in liberal and electoral democracies. And these, I would argue, have a stake in democracy actually functioning well.
SPEAKER_01And that logically means that there will be disagreements, there will be struggles, there will be protests. And these are all part of what um characterize a healthy democracy in which viewpoints and policies are contested in a peaceful manner. No, and I just want to briefly say that um what has happened in our world though is that through a various social media-driven filter bubbles, people are just more exposed to information viewpoints that they already share rather than those that they might oppose in some fashion, and actually would have to think through and grapple with. So living in echo chamber is actually not conducive to democracy.
SPEAKER_01That's where actually agonism and a way of encounter across groups might help us open up democratic spaces. And so I think that museums can be spaces to engage with certain topics across potential divides, where people meet other people, real encounters, maybe mediated by objects, which is something we're supposed to be really good at, at least it's been shown over the years. And this actually takes us back to this idea of contact theory. Now, decreasing prejudice could then be our goal through those encounters, even if they don't bring everybody on the same page, which we must also accept as okay.
SPEAKER_00You know, it's it's um it's interesting, you know, just going back to a point that I made before, that the English language has a rather negative interpretation of kind of disagreement in this kind of democratic debate that you're talking about. What do you think museums and diplomacy um can learn from cultures which approach conflict very differently?
SPEAKER_01Yes, um, that's a very that's an excellent question. Um and of course, throughout this conversation, we have been moving in the realm of um a more Western or democra and of democracies as sort of the baseline for some of this. And the question about how museums and cultural diplomacy have been addressed from a different angle is quite pertinent. And while we have privileged and actually acknowledged in the piece that we've written on I'm going to see museum diplomacy, that our angle is that, um, from a sort of Western liberal democratic lens.
SPEAKER_01This is, of course, not the only way of looking at the world. Um, and the conditions that we have been articulating have no claims to universality in this way. They're not universally shared by everybody. Um that by default opens up the field for so many other ideas about conflict, about relations, um, that will have to be part of these discussions, especially considering the change that we're going through in the world, we need to be open to so many ideas. So, in essence, what we provide here in this in this piece on agonistic museum to place is an opening statement, an opening offer, as it were, to think about the world differently.
SPEAKER_01Um, because there's lots to learn still, and at least also lots to unlearn, especially. And so a useful next step would actually be then to exactly look at how other cultures and other traditions look at the notion of conflict and what that then means in a museum setting.
SPEAKER_00So finally, Sasha, if museums adopt this new model of um agonistic cultural diplomacy, what impact do you think um they can have on international relations?
SPEAKER_01I think it will in many ways help us face the world with much more open eyes. As we say in the piece, we, and that is us in the global north, have become used and been the beneficiaries of a global order, one secured by the United States, that hasn't really been equally beneficial to everyone around the world. We're now waking up to the fact that the principal hegemon of the time since the Cold War is no longer all too interested in maintaining the liberal or rules-based international order that it has built and secured.
SPEAKER_01So, in turn, if this all of this is currently changing in front of our eyes, this also means that museums have to change the ways they have been accustomed to. We have been living in a world, at least museums in um the global north or global west, have been accustomed to working in a certain way in the world. Um, but trust and supported by the liberal international order. If that is not changing, we need to rethink. We need to challenge our assumptions and we need to unlearn.
SPEAKER_01And that's why we developed this notion of agonistic museum diplomacy because it can help us face this new reality and provide us with the start of a methodology with which to do so.
SPEAKER_00Sasha, you make the point that the world is changing very rapidly and we have to adapt in order to make a positive world going forward. So thank you for opening up a new way of thinking about cultural diplomacy and museums' roles within it. For our listeners, you can find links to Sasha's publications in the show notes accompanying this podcast. Now, next week, we continue the theme of social impact when we talk to Robert Jaynes, author, practitioner, and activist, who will be discussing a new role for museums in a conflicted world.
SPEAKER_00I'm Carol Scott, and thank you for listening to this episode of Museums the Big Issues. Join me next Wednesday as we continue to explore the big issues and the big ideas with the people helping to shape the future of museums.
What if sustainability is no longer enough? In this episode, I ask Lucimara Letelier to explain the emerging concept of the regenerative museum - an institution that seeks not simply to minimise harm, but to restore...
What if museums measured their success not by visitor numbers, but by the resilience of the communities they help build? In this episode, I ask Bob Janes to explore why today's crises demand museums move beyond passive...
Can museum objects spark meaningful conversations between people on opposite sides of the world? In this episode, Heather Gaunt explains how the Intercultural Heritage Global Classroom is using digital technologies,...
Digital transformation is reshaping every aspect of museum practice - but are museums ready for what comes next? In this episode, I talk to Seb Chan and ask how digitalisation is laying the foundation for artificial...
A museum's greatest financial asset may be what it stands for. In this episode, I ask Cecile Anger to explain why brand licensing is emerging as a powerful strategy for generating income, expanding audiences, and...