What if museums measured their success not by visitor numbers, but by the resilience of the communities they help build? In this episode, I ask Bob Janes to explore why today's crises demand museums move beyond passive hope to courageous action, redefining their role as trusted civic institutions which confront climate change, social fragmentation, and uncertainty with purpose, honesty, and imagination. I'm Carol Scott (https://www.linkedin.com/in/carol-ann-scott-33a6061a/) and thank you for listening to this episode of Museums, The Big Issues. Join me next Wednesday as we continue to explore the big issues and the big ideas with the people helping to shape the future of museums.
Audio and video play straight from the show's own hosting. PodSubs stores and serves no media.
Transcript
From the show. Tap a time to play from there.
SPEAKER_00What does the future hold for museums as they face some of the biggest challenges and the most exciting opportunities in their history? I'm Carol Scott, and this podcast series is Museums, the Big Issues. Join me as we bring the big issues and the big ideas together with some of the very best thinkers and practitioners in the field. Together, we'll look at how we build a sustainable future for museums in these uncertain times.
SPEAKER_00This week, my guest is Robert James, author, scholar, and activist. Robert, you're no stranger to the museum field. You were the president and CEO of the Glenbow Museum in Calgary. You're a visiting fellow at the School of Museum Studies at the University of Leicester in the UK. You're a fellow of the Canadian Museum Association, and editor-in-chief emeritus of the Journal Museum Management and Curatorship. You've long championed museums as important social institutions, which can make a difference in the lives of individuals and their communities.
SPEAKER_00And today you'll be sharing your view on the role of museums as lifeboats in a troubled world. Bob, welcome to Museums, The Big Issues.
SPEAKER_01Well thank you, Carol. It's a pleasure to be here and thank you for that nice introduction.
SPEAKER_00Bob, you you refer to the multiple crises. In fact, you speak of them as the poly crises currently impacting our world. So we're talking about climate change, geopolitical conflicts, untethered technology, increasing social polarization. And you argue that museums must address this situation through deliberate intervention and action. You, if I understand you correctly, want museums to become culturally active. So what does an active cultural institution look like in practice?
SPEAKER_01Well, to begin, Carol, I think an active museum begins by revisiting its vision and mission. And this must start with some difficult questions, such as why are you doing what you're doing? What changes are you trying to affect? What solutions will you generate? And what are your non-negotiable values? This means paying attention to the broader world in which we both live and work, including the needs and aspirations of one's community. It also means rethinking the museum's ethical foundations, confronting uncomfortable truths, fostering personal and organizational agency.
SPEAKER_01And by that I mean the willingness and ability to take action in the world and hopefully to make it a better place. I've always tried to encourage museums to engage with a fundamental question. What does it mean to be a human being? And today, at a time when living systems are in decline and when that decline is accelerating, this question is immeasurably more urgent. Our civilization needs a new narrative that challenges the belief that continuous economic growth is essential to our well-being.
SPEAKER_01So an active and responsible museum can assist in creating and delivering this narrative, which must be grounded in respect for planet Earth. Museums of all kinds can offer historical perspectives, connect scientific evidence with lived experience, provide spaces for communities to reflect on adaptation and resilience, and assist in learning how to live well with less consumption. And things aren't all bad because I can give you some examples of museums in action, just briefly.
SPEAKER_01The first would be the Ober-Salzberg Museum in Germany, which documents the impact of Nazi rule on Germany, including stories of people from all over Europe showing the consequences of Nazi policies. And this work is essential now as authoritarian governments gain ever-increasing popularity globally. And I should also mention a second example, which is the Museum of the Earth, a natural history museum in the United States. It's been engaged in climate action for years, using school programs, curricular design, professional development for teachers, and exhibitions to empower visitors, teachers, and community to take action.
SPEAKER_01There are many more examples, and there's really nothing mysterious or impossible about addressing critical societal issues with museum practice.
SPEAKER_00So to this point, you you call for institutions to tell the truth about climate change and political failure and ecological collapse. Bob, what challenges might museums face when addressing these topics publicly, especially with funders, boards, political stakeholders?
SPEAKER_01Well, just a bit about this idea of truth. Current scientific trajectories suggest that we're likely to exceed 1.5 degrees Celsius of global warming above pre-industrial levels in the coming decades, with the real risk of approaching two degrees of global warming if emissions are not sharply reduced. We're also immersed in accelerating deforestation, soil degradation, ocean acidification, and major biodiversity loss.
SPEAKER_01And large parts of the global south are increasingly just being treated as extraction frontiers for the valuable minerals and rare earths that we need, not to mention that hunger persists in many regions throughout the world. So we need the courage and humility to accept that the poly crisis that you mentioned earlier, which is basically a series of these interlocked stressors, is now part of the human condition. And how we live through this and how we envision the future really are the essential questions. And museums must start asking these questions.
SPEAKER_01Because they and their staff have arrived at a critical watershed, and they have no choice really but to rethink and discard their accustomed roles as mirrors of society. Because the majority of museums clearly reflect the bewilderment of mainstream society, with both museums and the global north unsure of what to do next. And I think it's fair to say that many museums have lost their purpose and their direction. The status quo is now actually a threat, but there's no consensus on how to proceed as challenges and complications intensify.
SPEAKER_01Burdened by corporate values and the straitjacket of neoliberal ideology, the majority of museums continue to uncritically reflect the aims and values of the modern technological industrial society. And this worldview is clearly unraveling and it must be challenged. The truth is that the growth paradigm is over, whether we want to admit it or not. And museums as civil society organizations have the responsibility to challenge this status quo, irrespective of what funders or boards might think.
SPEAKER_01The denial of governing authorities cannot be allowed to threaten the future of museums. In fact, there are foundations and funders out there now that are actually seeking to support this sort of civic leadership that I'm talking about. Museum leaders must ask for forgiveness, not permission, and start to demonstrate some courage and risk taking because we're also disabled by a blind spot, which is obscuring the truth of our predicament. This is the belief that renewable energy technologies such as wind and solar are solutions to global warming.
SPEAKER_01They will remain only a partial solution, however, to our continually expanding need for energy of all kinds. And this belief has been described as a fake green fairy tale, grounded in the claim that humanity can maintain current levels of consumption by being powered by renewables. And this is simply not true. Fossil fuels still account for roughly 80%, 87% actually, of the global energy mix, not to mention the thousands of products that are made from petroleum.
SPEAKER_01This reliance is so deeply entrenched in our society that transitioning will require more than just swapping out of fuel. It actually means completely transforming our consumptive way of life in the global north.
SPEAKER_00To get at this from another angle, Bob, if a museum is going to tell the truth and be intentionally active about social and environmental issues, then I would suggest that they need measures of success beyond attendance and institutional growth. So what alternative metrics could museums or cultural organizations adopt to measure their social value and community impact in these areas?
SPEAKER_01Well, the quantitative measures that you just mentioned, Carol, based on attendance and institutional growth, they're obsolete and they have to be replaced because they're diverting museums from their purpose and value. This emphasis on business has mistakenly replaced values in the museum community. Business literacy is, of course, essential. I mean, every staff person should know how to read a balance sheet and they should know what their budget is. So they're competent.
SPEAKER_01Business literacy is competent, sorry, is essential to a competent museum. But business literacy is not about values. It's about methods, techniques, and processes. The growth paradigm is over, as mentioned earlier. As is increased consumption, so why bother measuring them? The planet can no longer endure our excessive consumption, extraction, and waste. We're already using the resources of 1.75 planets, and we are destroying all of our natural capital.
SPEAKER_01What we need now are qualitative measures that can only be forged through community collaboration and authentic partnerships. And here are some possibilities, such as care metrics over growth metrics, reporting on community benefit and the number and quality of co-created programs that enhance community well-being. Or what about developing an advocacy policy with one's community and monitoring progress in addressing key civic and moral issues that have been identified in collaboration with community?
SPEAKER_01Or hosting constructive dialogues on community preparedness for collapse, mitigation, and adaptation. Really, the possibilities are only limited by one's imagination and the needs and aspirations of one's community.
SPEAKER_00Well, you know, this is a very transformative agenda, Bob. And I mean, you are challenging the very idea that sustainable development can coexist with endless institutional growth. So do you feel that some cultural practices or models should be intentionally phased out? And if so, which ones?
SPEAKER_01Indeed, I do, Carol. Change is going to be essential, and I believe that there are many museum assumptions and practices that need to be phased out, deleted, or reformed. The list is a long one, but I'll provide some examples. Creating new organizational design. Although it really discussed how you work directly affects what you do. There's an urgent need to abandon hierarchy and rigid corporate structures in museums and replace them with new organizational designs such as self-organization and collective leadership.
SPEAKER_01Rethinking collections. Museum collections are the seed banks of the world's material diversity, successes, and failures, and they're akin to biological seed banks. One immediate challenge now is to assess museum collections to determine what is essential to save in advance of a low-energy future and the cessation of unlimited economic growth. A third example scrap the edifice complex. Stop building new museums and galleries.
SPEAKER_01There are now more than 95,000 in the world, and their carbon footprint is enormous. Not to mention that a new building will not create meaning and relevance necessarily. In most cases, they become a distraction and they cause budget deficits. We need to reform governance to commit to reflect community diversity because one's cultural background and life experience are just as important as one's title or formal position or how much money you have.
SPEAKER_01Museums need deep civic roots to thrive, and strong, diverse local relationships are essential to this strength. We need to experiment with new leadership models. Museums and galleries are dominated by an outdated corporate model, the loan CEO or museum director who has far too much power and far too many responsibilities in a complex world. Other models have to be considered, such as the Roman model, Primus Interparis, or first among equals, which is really about collective leadership, not the lone hero.
SPEAKER_01Museums need to identify, acknowledge, nurture, and support personal agency among museum staff. And again, I mentioned this earlier, but I mean the capacity of staff to take action in the world, irrespective of their positions. They don't have to be leaders in a formal sense, because the relationship between workplace and personhood remains largely unrecognized and unexplored in museums. I would also suggest that museums stop pretending that museums and galleries are neutral voices of authority.
SPEAKER_01They are not neutral and they've never been. Because to do nothing is to support the status quo, and the status quo is actually destroying our civilization. And it's rapidly becoming obsolete. So that's a list to get started. In short, I could sum it up by saying we're really in dire need of new kinds of organizations, not only new museums, but new organizations throughout society.
SPEAKER_00Bob, I'm going to pick up on um one of the last points you made, which was about this issue of neutrality. Certainly there's you know a lot of research saying that museums are one of the few remaining institutions which still hold public trust more than is invested in media or or government. Um and the perception is that some of this trust is associated with neutrality, which is valued in a polarized world. Now, do you think that assuming a socially active stance such as you are outlining risks undermining that trust?
SPEAKER_01Yeah, I think I do. I fear that claiming neutrality because museums are trusted has actually become an excuse for inaction and for museums to sit on the sidelines. This may have been intolerable in the past, but the past is no longer a guide to the future because we're now in this stream of discontinuous change. Risk taking, courage, assuming leadership, and assuming responsibility will not undermine trust, even though they may be contrary to neutrality.
SPEAKER_01The critical issues confronting us now are not only political, they're evidence-based, they're scientific, they're moral, they're social, ranging from ecological overshoot to social injustice. And a deep underlying cause of all these things is our separation and estrangement from the more than human world, the natural world. And museums have been complicit in this separation. I believe for decades that the world's museums could help repair this separation from the natural world because they are such trusted institutions.
SPEAKER_00Now, one of your key ideas is bridging nature and culture through collaborations between artists, scientists, and community knowledge holders. How do you see this interdisciplinary program strengthening public understanding and engagement with climate and social issues?
SPEAKER_01There are so many possibilities. Museums have many of the soft skills, those non-technical skills concerned with how one interacts with others, and these include critical thinking, researching, and problem solving in order to assess and make decisions. Facilitation, helping people think, achieve consensus, and resolve conflict. Helping people cope, being candid about the risks that are accumulating, excessive heat, fire uh wildfire smoke, flood, flooding, power outages.
SPEAKER_01Helping people cope by hosting public conversations around these topics that are grounded in truth. There's also mentoring, which is using knowledge and experience to assist individuals, families, and communities in solving problems and advocating on key civic and moral issues. Hosting community conversations to identify and discuss the important issues and imperatives that will be essential as the future becomes more uncertain every week. In summary, these activities mean contributing to a healthy community, sharing responsibility, building on what works, and making both the museum and the community more collaborative and cooperative.
SPEAKER_01Beyond these soft skills, there's so many opportunities for museums to add value in other ways. And my colleague, Rainey Tisdale, has a couple of really good suggestions. She says, What about museums circulating objects throughout the community like a lending library? Or what about museums functioning like a reference library or a hardware store that help answer your questions and solve your problems? There's nothing lacking to do any of these things.
SPEAKER_01Nothing more is needed. The scarcity myth in museums is a myth. No remarkable or undiscovered technologies are needed. No heroic leadership is needed. Just the courage and commitment to abandon outdated practices and assist in this creating in creating a new narrative that I mentioned earlier and a new future for museums and communities. I want to mention one more idea on how museums can help communities prepare for an unknown future.
SPEAKER_01Because museums need to consider what they preserve and why, and what collections will help us navigate uncertainly. What knowledge do they hold that could serve in a low-energy, less predictable future? I suggested earlier that museums consider something akin to the Svalbard Global Seed Ball, which is a global collection safeguarding the seeds that are essential for the food that we produce. Museums could do the same by cooperating to preserve a sample of humankind's material legacy as an invaluable resource for an unknown future.
SPEAKER_00Bob, I'd like to drill into this whole idea of bridging nature and culture. Can you sort of uh just expand a bit on how this could operate in museums?
SPEAKER_01Well, to begin with, there are numerous reasons for this nature-culture rupture. And one of the most damaging being the museum and academic professionalism based on disciplinary boundaries, you know, how we are trained. The argument in defense of this compartmentalization goes like this science museums are responsible for the environment, and art and history museums are not. But this fuzzy thinking is exacerbating, uh is exacerbated by the lack of multidisciplinary museums, too, throughout the world.
SPEAKER_01And multidisciplinary museums house collections, social history, natural history, ethnology, an art gallery, an archive, a library, all under one roof and one administration. Strict disciplinary boundaries and academic territoriality are not helpful in understanding the complexity of life on earth, especially now as we confront multiple social and environmental stressors that defy reductionism and linear thinking.
SPEAKER_01Museums need other ways of knowing, the arts, the sciences, traditional knowledge, and local knowledge to address climate and all these other issues. What many people, including governments and political leaders, don't realize is that climate trauma is only a symptom of a deeper issue, which is ecological overshoot, which stems from the mistaken belief that humans are separate from nature. And most museums, as I mentioned earlier, continue to reinforce this separation.
SPEAKER_01We need a new kind of museum built on a different foundation, which starts from an acknowledgement of the deep interconnectedness of life, and that that's not a romantic aspiration, but it's a fact. It's confirmed by science and affirmed by wisdom traditions of cultures that have never lost that understanding.
SPEAKER_00Bob, you're really arguing for a much more interdisciplinary approach to our collections and our public education programs and our relationships with communities. Now, this is a for many, this will be a very transformative agenda. And museum leaders are currently grappling with declining funding, rising energy costs, uh digital transformation, which is outstripping preparedness, assaults on social inclusion, decolonization, and the list goes on. So what what do you think would make them want to take on this transformative agenda?
SPEAKER_00What do you see they would gain from it?
SPEAKER_01Well, that that's a very important question, Carol, for sure. And all the concerns you've just mentioned are about how the museum Conducts its work. And I submit that most museums will not survive if they continue this preoccupation with their own well-being. These internal concerns of museums will become increasingly irrelevant as societal pressures intensify. So museums must begin to look beyond their own well-being and use their resources as civic organizations in collaboration with their communities.
SPEAKER_01So this is not about business as usual. It's about recognizing that this dazzling era of unlimited consumption based on fossil fuels is over. And museums are going to have to navigate this new reality, whether you call it societal collapse, the great reckoning, the long descent, or the long repair. No one and no institutions are going to be exempt. The party is over, as I mentioned earlier. And this is not about what museum leaders can gain, it's about assuming responsibility for caring for the earth, the future, and our descendants.
SPEAKER_01And I was reading a book recently by Dugold Hein, a book called At Work in the Ruins, and he suggests that there are two paths now. You could also call these choices that we're free to make. The big and popular path perpetuates the modern technological industrial society, or MTI, our consumption culture that is now threatening our civilization. It's based on the belief that we can manage our way out of our predicament using the same values and methods that created our predicament in the first place.
SPEAKER_01Continuous economic and technological growth. In my view, this belief borders on insanity. Now, the other path, the second path, is largely unexplored, with the boundaries and trails to be determined by those who elect to walk them. This other path, admittedly, has yet to be determined, and it's going to necessitate abandoning familiar conversations and letting go of commitments whose meanings have changed. It's also going to mean curtailing our sense of personal freedom in order to ensure future possibilities for our descendants.
SPEAKER_01For example, if you're still flying to museum conferences in 2026, Heinz book will either engender dissonance, denial, or ridicule for all three. It's time for museums to become societal leaders in their own right and embrace our collective well-being as a priority. And this is what museum leaders will gain.
SPEAKER_00Bob, you've challenged us. Thank you for doing that, and for sharing your view of the role which museums can have not only in communities, but in terms of healing the nature-human divide. For our listeners, links to Bob's publications and other interviews can be found in the show notes accompanying this podcast. And next week, we continue the theme of social impact when our conversation will be with Cristimara Letelier from Brazil. Cristimara will be talking about the next stage of sustainability: museums as regenerative agents in their communities.
SPEAKER_00I'm Carol Scott, and thank you for listening to this episode of Museums the Big Issues. Join me next Wednesday as we continue to explore the big issues and the big ideas with the people helping to shape the future of museums.
What if sustainability is no longer enough? In this episode, I ask Lucimara Letelier to explain the emerging concept of the regenerative museum - an institution that seeks not simply to minimise harm, but to restore...
Can museums strengthen international relationships not by avoiding disagreement, but by making space for it? In this episode of Museums: The Big Issues, I talk to Sascha Priewe as he explores the emerging concept of...
Can museum objects spark meaningful conversations between people on opposite sides of the world? In this episode, Heather Gaunt explains how the Intercultural Heritage Global Classroom is using digital technologies,...
Digital transformation is reshaping every aspect of museum practice - but are museums ready for what comes next? In this episode, I talk to Seb Chan and ask how digitalisation is laying the foundation for artificial...
A museum's greatest financial asset may be what it stands for. In this episode, I ask Cecile Anger to explain why brand licensing is emerging as a powerful strategy for generating income, expanding audiences, and...