Skip to content
PodSubs
ShowsPeopleGuestsJobsNewsEvents
More
BlogPodCred
Menu
ShowsPeopleGuestsJobsNewsEventsBlogPodCredNetworksSign in
Join nowSign in
  • Shows
  • People
  • Jobs
  • News
  • More
    • Guests
    • Events
    • Blog
    • PodCred
    • Networks
    Join nowSign in

MSL Talk

Inside The Mind Of A Medical Affairs Hiring Manager

Mar 31, 202641 minVideo
ShareXLinkedInFacebookWhatsAppEmail

In this episode, Tom Caravela and Stefanie Cribb explore building successful Medical Science Liaison (MSL) teams. They discuss how candidates can showcase their value in interviews, stressing the importance of conversation skills and aligning career goals with the role. The episode covers the screening and interview process, highlighting key skills, behaviors, and presentation significance. They identify interview deal breakers, traits for promotion, and standout resume features. The discussion also touches on changes in the MSL job market, AI's impact on hiring, and the vital role of networking and referrals in job searches.

Audio and video play straight from the show's own hosting. PodSubs stores and serves no media.

Transcript

From the show.

0:00Hey, guys. Welcome to the podcast. Have an awesome, awesome episode. You guys are gonna love this because you're always interested and looking to see inside the mind of a hiring manager, and that's the title of today's episode. I have Stephanie Cribb with me who is the perfect guest for this episode because she's built a bunch of MSL teams. She knows exactly what it takes to hire good MSLs. So you guys are gonna hear from a pro. Stephanie, welcome to the MSL talk podcast.

0:33Oh, thank you very much, Tom. I'm happy to be here today. Well, this before we get started, why don't, Steph, why don't you do a quick introduction, and then we could talk about I do have an announcement to make. We'll get through that real quick, and then we can get started. So let's tell everybody who you are, where you're from, all that good stuff. Yeah. Sure. So, Stephanie Cribb. I am a PharmD by my education. I currently live in South Carolina, although I was born and raised in Pennsylvania. I have been in pharma now for twenty plus years, but I started my career as a clinical

1:05pharmacist in in critical care. So I bring a lot of different experiences over the years. And in medical affairs specific field medical affairs, I've done a lot of different roles, MSL, MCL, some hybrid roles. I've been the team trainer. I have been a mentor, project lead. And then towards the last ten years or so, I have been the leader of a team. In the last eight years, I've had the opportunity to build some teams of MSL. So I've done multiple, multiple interviews with, MSL candidates and and and found a

1:41process that I think fits and helps build a really strong team. Awesome. I'm excited, guys. You're gonna get so much out of this, so be prepared to take notes. Before we get started, just a reminder that it's time to register for Fierce Pharma Engage, which is in San Diego. It's April 22 to the twenty fourth. This used to be Mass West. If any of you have gone to Mass West or Mass East, this is the new version of that. So it's not just medical affairs.

2:14It's also pharma marketing, PR communications, and business development and licensing. So there's really four subgroups in the event, but there's a very big medical affairs presence. I went last year. It's in San Diego. Again, great it was just a great event. Fierce does an awesome job. So just go to Google, type in Fierce Pharma Engage, and you'll see all the information you need, or go to my LinkedIn because I post on my LinkedIn feed every week.

2:44So, Steph, let's get into it. Let's I wanna talk about you first because I know that you have a lot of experience, and you've built a bunch of MSL teams. Can let's talk about that a little bit. Sure. Sure. So, in my opportunities to build out team, I had a couple of jobs in smaller pharma where we wanted to expand the field medical presence. And and there, I either had current members that I were adding to or I was starting from

3:14scratch and building out a team. So my philosophy of building a team is is really based on finding that cohesiveness that makes them a very strong team. A team that no matter where they are and what they're doing, the rest of the company will look at and say, wow. That's a really strong team. Right? They really do trust and engage with each other as well as with all of our cross collaborative partners for for instance. And I feel like the best way to do that is to bring a lot of different experiences together.

3:45So if you hire eight of the exact same experiences and the exact same learning experience together, you're going to have exactly that, all of the same thing. When you bring in different knowledge bases, different experiences, different degrees even, different, past jobs that they've had, it really allows for the situation where you say, how are gonna solve this problem to let that brainstorming be really creative and and genuine and just flows in a natural processes where everybody contributes.

4:19I also find that that other team members will understand who has what strengths across the team, and they will look to those individual people to say, hey. That's not my strength. Tell me how you do that. And, again, that's just always being very growth minded and just just building a team that, you know, can handle any situation. I'm always there as a mentor, of course, as the director, but I like to see the interaction amongst the team and building that strong that strong base. And so doing that in selection of candidates is really based on what do I already have, what

4:52can add to it, and how can we really bring differences together to create that strength. That's I I I think that's such a great way to start this episode because I think couple things. I'm gonna unpack a little bit of that is I think a lot of people don't realize that when you're building a team, you want you wanna have a diversified group of individuals. Of course. And to as you just said. So I think a lot of people are like, I'm the perfect they say to me all the time. Tom, I'm the perfect fit for that team.

5:25And it's like, well, maybe. I don't know. That's up to the hiring manager because they know what specific needs they have within that team. But what's really important to keep in mind is when you're interviewing, you have to show what makes you most valuable. How do you fit on that team from the standpoint of, are you the go to person when it comes to, like, are you really good with technology? Are you really good with AI? Are you really good with spreadsheets? Like, what is your hidden talent that maybe the manager needs to know? Because there's that go to person that you have on the team.

5:58Maybe it's managed care presentations. But make sure you bring your best self so that you can leave that impression and show how you're valuable. Right? Agree? Yeah. Yeah. No. I I completely agree. And, you know, and and as you told me to introduce myself, I told you a story. Right? Yeah. So in that in that very quick, brief, one minute story, you got an idea that I have done many, many different things within field medical affairs, and I have incorporated all of that into my own experiences.

6:28So when I'm introducing myself to a candidate, they have the confidence to know that I've been there, done that, walked the shoes of an MSL, and I I'm capable of being that coach and mentor. Remember, interviewing is two ways. Right? It's not just me talking to somebody to see what they're about, but they wanna know what I'm about too. So I I try to pull out of the candidate that story. What's your story? I can read a CV. Anybody can do that. I can see what's on here. But what makes you unique? What makes you special that is a gift or a a talent or something that you focused on over

7:05the years in your career? And how is that going to add to the team that I already have or that I'm trying to build for whatever is the quest of the company that that I'm working for and what we wanna do out in the field. So if you're not able to articulate your story and your strengths, then that's gonna be problematic. Right? I love this conversation because Yeah. Obviously, I do this for a living. So it's so great to, to be able to talk shop like this and share this conversation with others who may not have the experience or know the inner workings of what it takes behind the

7:40scenes. You're just applying to the position. And Yeah. You right? So you don't you don't get to see the inside. So let's let's talk about your process, like, what your screening process looks like and your interview process so that we could share that with people that might be interested. Yeah. So I think in any company, you know, HR, the talent acquisition team, you know, they they're doing that initial phone screen. Right? They have a certain set of things, and they're all very well trained at picking out what's

8:13good, what's bad, and bringing candidates to me. So I've had both opportunities. I have had to do the screening for the hundreds, and I do mean hundreds of applications that come in for just one position. And then I've had where the talent acquisition has streamed through those and brought me candidates and allowed me to say yes or no to the next step, which is the interview with me. My interview is a little different. Maybe it's not different anymore, but it certainly was eight years ago when I started.

8:43And I really like to start with a a obviously, you see a candidate. They're poised. They're ready. They've prepared. And I throw them off a little bit in the very beginning by simply saying, I'm not gonna ask you a situational question and how you handle that. I'm just not. I wanna have a conversation with you. And the reason that I picked the word conversation is what you and I have talked about in the past. To be a good MSL, the one trait you need to have is having a conversation. Right. You need to be able to have a conversation.

9:14So if you can hold a forty five minute conversation with me, which is unprepared, is off balance a little bit, I think I get the true you as a candidate, and the true you is what's gonna tell me whether that fit. We all talk about the fit. Right? I'm not sure I understand what fit is even myself as a hiring manager, but I think I depend on my instincts of of what that feels like and what I know what I have, what I need, where we need to go. So holding that conversation is really, really important to me, and that's that's where I go

9:47with my interview. And then I make that decision whether or not you progress to the next to the next step, which can be different either by company policy. My policy is a little different too. I like the presentation to come next. That throws people off a little bit too. I tend to lose candidates in a presentation, so I wanna see it upfront before we move on to everybody else in the in the, department that they're you're gonna interview with. But that conversation is a big deal. That's such great advice. And I think that a lot of people, they sometimes when you say to them, okay.

10:23Unfortunately, you're not gonna be moving forward. The feedback was that it doesn't seem like it's a fit. That's really kind of just a way of saying it just it the you know, the manager wasn't vibing with you. It wasn't a good conversation. There was no connection. Like Right. That's what that means. It's a cultural fit. Meaning, if you and I had a conversation let's just say it's not an interview, but we met at a Starbucks and we had a conversation.

10:54And, wow, thirty minutes passed. It would be like, wow. I had this great conversation with somebody that I met and, wow, you know, I've I've I've vibed with that person. Whatever. Like, that's what has to happen on the interview. And I'll say one more thing too. Like, that means that you have good If you go into an interview, even an initial phone screen, and you have really no good questions at all prepared to ask that manager, your

11:25conversation might go flat at some point. So just keep in mind, there's a lot of preparation preparation that has to happen even in the initial interview. Right. And and quite frankly, I I do agree with you have to have questions to ask. Right? I have a tendency to answer those questions before people even ask me the questions. Right? So what I'm looking for is are you listening to the conversation we're having? So that's another thing. Right? You gotta have good conversation skills, but you gotta have good listening skills as an MSL too. And if you're listening to the conversation, something will come up and you go, oh, I wanna

12:00ask about that. So when I have a free moment and I honestly don't mind if people politely interrupt where we're going in the conversation to just say, Stephanie, can I expand upon what you just said? Yes. What is it that you'd like to know? Because they were listening to me. I think we're all guilty of somebody talking, and you're just not listening. Right. Right? And the minute your KOL gets a glimpse of that, you're done. Your rapport is done. So I I also encourage those thoughtful questions to be things that just come out of

12:34nowhere. Yeah. In midst of a conversation because that does what? It progresses the conversation into another direction sometimes. It's a natural way of talking. It's a natural way of them finding out who I am and me finding out who they are. So, yeah, you can have your questions prepared, and I always give time at the end of an interview for those questions. But a lot of times they go, well, you've already answered that. You've already answered that. Why? Because we had a really good conversation about what each of us wants to know

13:06Yeah. About the other person. And when that happens, it's it to me, it's it's a it's a little bit of magic. Yeah. Thirty minutes is not long enough. Forty five minutes sometimes isn't long enough. But when you're not having a good conversation, you can barely make it 20. And that is across the board my experiences with with candidates. So if I'm struggling to get you to open up and talk to me and and I have to pull it out of a candidate, well, that's not gonna be a great vibe is is the use of word that you said.

13:36Right? You have to have that vibe. And, you know, the fit thing is is true. You're you're a good fit or you're not a good fit. And again, I use my instincts for that. And when people ask for feedback, I try to find a little bit more than you just weren't a good fit. Yeah. Right? It's hard to know, but I think if feedback is requested, it's our responsibility as hiring person to provide that. Because your yes or your no is gonna is gonna affect somebody, their life, their career, or

14:10whatever is the situation. That responsibility I take pretty seriously. So I do try to always provide that. It's like, I just didn't feel like you were carrying the conversation. And, again, even that feedback is conversational. So I I keep going back to the same thing and, you know, even doing this with you. This is just us talking. It's just us talking. Conversation. Right. Yeah. And I don't think that that's a skill that a lot of people hold to be easy, and they have to work at it. Well, I yeah. I mean, some people aren't they aren't skilled at it.

14:43It this is this isn't something that comes natural to everybody. But when you're an MSO, you need to be good at it. So, if it requires some extra practice or preparation, then you have to do that. Otherwise, your interview is probably gonna fail. Right. You know? Right. And you you and I I don't mean to interrupt you, but you also have to be prepared for that unknown. Yeah. The situation where you thought you're going to have twenty minutes with said HCP, and they say, I'm busy. I'll give you five minutes. And, you know, you need to develop rapport, find out what they're doing, get a good

15:17insight. You know, you have all of these criteria that MSLs are told, go out and do. You know? So in an interview situation too, if I ask some off the wall question because you said that you like to train dogs at the end of your CV, for example, I'm gonna ask you about that. So tell me about that. And I've seen other people that I've reported to do the same skill, and it always makes me smile because person's then talking about themself. That should be easy. You know you better than anybody else.

15:50So just talk about yourself. Yeah. What are what are some of the other, like, top differentiators that you look for in candidates that impress you that you wanna move them forward in the process? Yeah. So, you know, yes, I want you to be prepared. Right? So I do want that good conversation. I do want the strong listening skills. But on top of that, I want you to show me that you care and are interested in the position for which you're interviewing.

16:22Now that seems common sense. Right? But in reality, I have a lot of candidates that say, oh, this is a great position, but what are the what are the opportunities to advance? Well, I'm glad that you're showing me that you have a career goal. But when I'm hiring you right now, I have a one year, two year goal to fulfill the company that I'm in and I'm working for as a director of the MSL. So I wanna know that you're gonna do this job a 150% for the short term.

16:53And in that, I like to make the commitment to a candidate that I'm here to also help you develop your that career path and to to move forward. I'd like to say that such and such a company has this opportunity for growth and expansion, but we all know any promise in pharma is likely to change because change is inevitable in pharma. Right? So if you're coming into this industry, I think that that's important for you to know too. So, yes, career goals are great to understand. That's who you are.

17:24But I wanna see the commitment to this position that I'm interviewing you for. I've been in that situation myself. Can I do beyond the position that I'm interviewing for? Sure. But what I'm interviewing for is what I'm gonna give a 100% to right now. And what about skills? Are you looking for specific skills in an individual? And what do you like so what would impress you as you're interviewing? What behaviors and skills, are most impressive on an interview? Sure.

17:54I think the the basic knowledge has to be there, you know, that they're they're smart and they can learn, and a lot of that is based on the degree for which they come to the interview with. If you've got that degree, you have the ability to learn. I think that, again, that's common sense. But having the the conversation, the listening, the presentation and I've just said earlier that I put that up front in the interview because I've lost so many people in a presentation. So I've interviewed HR's interviewed. I've interviewed four other people in the company or in the department have interviewed

18:25this person. And then we get everybody together on a on now since COVID, a Zoom call. Gone are the days that you go into the company and do a presentation a lot. You do it you do it virtually, and person just bops. Just doesn't have that skill. Right? So why waste the time of my my departmental colleagues on a candidate who can't do some of the basic things? So being able to deliver a presentation. Now I'm not saying that that's not something that can be learned, but how you go about it

18:56and how you listen as well as you present and and how you hear the questions and honor those questions. And, you know, that can be on any topic you want. I'm not one of those people that says, I want you to present on our data. I want you to present on this topic. Pick something. I just wanna see that you have the skill to get through and teach me something if necessary while you're doing it. Because if you've taught me something, I'm I'm a growth person. I don't know everything. I wanna learn new stuff too. And if that happens, then that's a that's a really good skill.

19:28Being positive is an interesting skill that most people overlook. Right? What you should never do is negative. Don't tell me about your negative experiences. Tell me that you had some and you learned from it. You you turned the negative into a positive. Right? This wasn't the best fit for me. Here we go with fit again. Right? But in that, I learned x y z, and I've applied that to my growth in as a professional and as a MSL. Something like that is impressive to me. Right? They've they've they've always remained very open minded, very growth minded people, and

20:03they're willing to take their negatives and put it into a positive attribute to present to me as as potentially one of their strengths. I'll tell you, there's so much to unpack there, but just a couple of things really quick that I wanna point out is I so you do the presentation first? After my interview. So after eight at night Yeah. Then I then I put the panel on a presentation. So they meet the candidate the first time, my colleagues Right. At a presentation. And then they can expand upon that when they do their individual one on ones.

20:35Right? They can say, hey. That was really interesting in your presentation. And what have they done? Now they're having another conversation. So they're learning, you know, if this person has the ability to expand upon their knowledge in some way. So it's really interesting the feedback that you get from your colleagues when they've been been introduced to this candidate through a presentation first. Yeah. Brilliant. I think that makes so much sense. And, guys, I mean, I'll be this goes without saying, but I can tell you, in my experience,

21:05the presentation is a go, no go kinda thing. Like, you do the presentation. If if it if it doesn't land, you're not you don't pass go, you don't collect $200, you're done. The interview's over. So I think it's brilliant, and I think that, Steph, you're saving so much time for the organization by doing it that way. And yeah. I I just I think that that's something to really take away is the importance of nailing

21:39that. Some companies don't do it until later in the interview process, but either way, it is it's absolutely a deal breaker. And I wanted to ask you what else you know, we talk about what to do. Let's talk about what not to do. Like, what other deal breakers have you seen that you've come across that you wanna warn people about? Yeah. They they've I think they've been interesting. Right? And and it's evolved over the time of my interviewing and me developing as an

22:09interviewer. Sure. Right. Because I I didn't know the first few times that I interviewed somebody, you know, what was I looking for? So one is that negativity. We've already talked about that. But another one is the buzzwords. Right? Everybody has the pharma industry buzzwords. It's it's a packet of things to say, and I think they have their place. So I'm not I'm not knocking the buzzwords. They do have their place. They describe a business. They describe a need. They describe what we're doing in some way.

22:40But when they're overused, it's not genuine. It's not I know you don't talk to your friends that way because your friends would look at you like you're crazy. Right? So why would you why would you use all these big fancy words that we use in business and in pharma? That's the industry that I know. You know, talk to me like a person. You know? And another and part of that is the being over prepared. And, again, that speaks to why I don't ask the standard questions.

23:10We have AI now. Right, Tom? AI can answer those questions for you Yeah. With your specifics. They say say something about this, say something about that, then put it into here, and they use terminology, and that's not genuine either, frankly. You know, you have to talk about you and your strengths the way you speak. Now everybody has executive presence skills. Some are more advanced than others, and, of course, you're gonna use some of that when you speak to different levels. So if you're interviewing with a CEO, you you'll be different than if you're interviewing

23:44with your direct manager, for example. And, seeing that evolution in a in a person is really exciting, but just don't overuse the buzzwords. Don't be negative. You know, be prepared, but be genuine. And I think in all, those are the more positive interviews that I've had over time that are just easy. Yeah. And the forty five minutes goes by like this, and you're like, do you have more time to talk to me? Because I really like what I'm hearing. Right? So sometimes you do. But in a busy busy director, it I don't always have that time

24:18Yeah. To be able to extend it. And it it's so funny we keep coming back to it. Like, that that that impression, that conversation, being genuine, being real, I think it's just it goes such a long way. It goes back to the whole fit thing. We keep talking about that. That's how you show that you could be a fit because you connect with the manager. What happens though when, let's just say, you hire that person? So now you get the job. What are you looking for, and what stands out to you when it comes time for promotion?

24:53When it comes time guys, full transparency, Steph and I, before we got on this call, we're talking about she referred one of her MSLs to me and, like, and and, like, for ten minutes, told me how great this person was. So, like, tell me about what does a person need to do when they get on your team to make an impression. Yeah. Number one is you're always developing. I've been in this business twenty plus years, and I can't say that there's ever a week or a

25:26month or a year that goes by where I haven't learned so much. Right? So being growth minded. So I don't care if you've been an MSL for twenty plus years or you've been an MSL for two years. There's something that you're going to learn from every situation as you go forward. And what you take from that and what how you add that to your own skill set makes you that growth minded person. It's pretty easy to pick them out on a team who who are those people and who aren't those people. And I'm not saying that you're looking for promotion.

25:57That's not necessarily your own development. Maybe you're great with being an MSL, and I know plenty of folks that are. It's a great job. I did it myself for twelve years. Right? And so that if that's what you want, great. But how are you gonna grow in that? And that's where my own mentoring and coaching comes in with finding how to develop and provide that growth to a very experienced MSL. I mean, it's easy with a new MSL. Right? You're teaching them how to be an MSL. You're teaching them all the tricks and the and the tools and the things that you need.

26:29A more advanced or more experienced MSL might be difficult to find that growth, but I still wanna see it because then you're invested in what you're doing, as an MSL. So a lot of that coaching. The other thing that I like to see in a skill of somebody that that works on my team, don't come to me with just problems. Come to me with problems or concerns and have a solution. Because now again, you're training yourself to grow in that situation.

27:00It's not uncommon to be thrown off your comfort zone in in this job. It happens every single day, but that's what makes you a strong person. That's what makes you a strong MSL is what are you doing? So how are you gonna fix it? I mean, I can tell you how to do it, but is that really learning it? You probably ask my children. I raised them the same way. I don't know. What do you wanna do about it? I you know, here here's the problem. What how are we gonna fix it? Let's do that together or at least come to me with solutions. So that's pretty obvious to you, the folks that just wanna settle in their own skill and say,

27:32hey. This is the problem. I need you to fix it. Versus those are like, how can I fix it? What can I do differently? How you know, here's what I see as a possible solution. Do you think that that's possible or viable in in how I'm handling it? And that's what I like to see. So those things when you're on a team that I happen to be the director for, that's what I'm looking for that that tells me that you remain very growth minded. Now I wanna shift gears a little bit and get your opinion on resumes. And and I'm asking this for selfish reasons because I'm presenting next week at MAPS about

28:06the ultimate resume guide for medical affairs. So I'm curious. When you're reviewing resumes, what are you looking for? What stands out to you positively, or what what happens when you look at a resume and you're like, nope. Pass. Talk to me about that. Okay. That's a that's a little harder. I do still feel like it's a feel for me. Okay. And that genuineness of your your resume. If your resume says everything that you've done and you've actually done it Yeah.

28:36It shows in the interview. Right? So if we get an interview but if I'm just paging through the hundreds and hundreds of resumes, sometimes it's a it's a interesting activity in so as an example, this might be a stretch and this might be over exaggerated. But let's say in your brand that's up at the top of the resume, right, are all of the words or statements that define who you are as a professional. You say proven success.

29:08Proven MSL success. And when I look, you have six months to a year experience as an MSL. That's not congruent. Yeah. Okay. I know because I've walked the shoes and been in the job that you're not really comfortable in your skin as an MSL for a more extended period of time than six months to a year. So you you haven't proven success in six months to a year experience as an MSL. Now if you tell me proven success and you have many, many years and in those years, you have

29:39different experiences and different talents that you're showing in a resume. I had somebody help me with mine just recently. I had the old timey resumes from many years ago. We're not gonna talk about that how many years ago, but many years ago. Right? It's different now, and it shouldn't read like a job description. Right? And that was like a huge light bulb to me when this person told me that how to do it or what would be suggested. But you don't have to ask what were some of my best projects or what were some of my best

30:12experiences and and growth and learning through the years. They're all listed there. I've never had to look at my resume and go back and say, what did I what did she do? Okay. Great. She was an MSL. Okay. Great. She was a trainer. But what did she do? Like, it's it's listed there, the success of that role and what I did there. So, I do look for that. And if I have to read four or five pages, I'm probably not getting past the first half. And if you ask HR folks or talent acquisition, they're probably gonna tell you the same thing.

30:44But that Q and I is important. So make sure that you're not overexaggerating what is who you are. Again, genuine. Just being genuine. Being genuine. That's a theme. It's definitely a common theme. It keeps coming back in this conversation. So as we look at the job market right now, how do you feel it's changed, like, let's say over the course of the past, like, five years? How about the course of the last three years? Can we shorten that? That that would look Yeah. A A bit up numbers.

31:15Yeah. The numbers Yeah. Of of candidates that are out there. Self proclaimed or otherwise. I think we can we can say that there's a lot of folks that put in their their resume and apply to a position, and they're not even in the ballpark of qualifications, which, by the way, is very easy to root through when you're the human eye looking at it. You can look through and go, no. No. Okay. That's that's not gonna be a qualified individual, and that's unfortunate. But there are numbers of qualified people looking for positions.

31:48Yeah. Currently, three years ago. I mean, I don't I think it's changed a little bit, the it's full supply and demand. And by no means am I a business major, but I do understand the the concept, you know, that there's a lot of folks looking for one position. Yeah. So things like that positivity, that's the certain skills, that fit fit. I don't think we can necessarily control. As a candidate, you can't control that. You're not in the mind, but why we're talking about this, of the person hiring you.

32:23But that shouldn't ever be a negative if you're not the right fit. And I I think that's an important concept here too. You're gonna hear that a lot in the current market. You're not the right fit. You said it yourself. You say that a lot. But rather than saying what does that mean, just say to yourself, if that person doesn't think you're the right fit, you're not gonna enjoy working there. Right. That goes both ways. Yes. You're just not. That you have to have that vibe between the two two of you.

32:53I feel like I'm using my daughter's words now. That's my daughter does that too. And, like, I literally she uses that word so much that, like, it just Exactly. I can't Now it's there. Yeah. And it works. It fits for this situation. That's right. Yeah. No. And and, guys, just really quick getting back to it. Like, that doesn't mean you're damaged goods if someone's saying that you're not a fit. It just it means that they're looking for something else in some way, shape, or form. That doesn't mean you're not fully qualified.

33:24You might just not be what they want for that specific job. Sure. One of the challenges is, I think, that really good candidates are getting lost. They're not even getting a place, a seat at the table. They're not even getting added to the pile that's moving forward. So let's talk about that. Artificial intelligence, AI tools, ChatGPT. Do you think AI is a good thing, bad thing? What's been your experience?

33:56There's two sides to it as there is to every story, and I don't wanna lose any street cred by saying I hate AI. Right? I'm not I'm not going there with it. I've engaged in several projects, as a director in medical affairs and small companies where we use AI, and it was hugely impactful. Hugely impactful. With the market and with finding candidates, I think we are maybe going in an off direction with AI. Think the human eye is much better at picking up the subtleties on a CV or an application or

34:34whatever you wanna say that it's looking at. That candidate that I spoke of before we shut off this podcast is a perfect example of that. It's a nontraditional degree. It doesn't fit the algorithm for the job description, so they just get thrown out. When when I have been searching for a job and I have twenty years of experience, thirteen as a boots on the ground MSL, you know, twelve, thirteen, and then, you know, taking on the leadership roles and doing so many different projects and training and everything, I get the

35:06the bounce back emails that are just computer generated that says we went in a direction of candidates whose qualifications better fit the job description. And and I can say that sentence because I've read that sentence numerous times. Right? Yeah. Which which means, did a human actually look at my CV? Or, you know, are we doing somebody an injustice by not reading it with the eye? Artificial intelligence is it learns as it goes, but it's also what the algorithm says

35:36it's supposed to be making a decision. And how do you set that up to not lose those very qualified candidates. Now oppositionally to that, there's so many candidates. Right. No one has the the staff or the manpower to weed through hundreds, and there are hundreds. Because I worked for a small company. We didn't have that. We had to go through them ourselves. I did some of that. It took hours. Now do I have hours every day to dedicate to weeding through hundreds of of CVs, especially

36:09when I'm hiring multiple positions on a team? No. I I don't have that time. So I think I think we need to find a way to to work it. And maybe, again, it's because of the number of candidates that AI is coming to the forefront, and you're seeing some of that that lost opportunity. And I I don't have any good advice necessarily of how to get past it. I know there's lots of ways that we've talked about changing your words. But, honestly, words like, top performing and strong KOL engager are the same words.

36:45They say the same thing. But because they're not the exact word, the score changes on how your your particular CV is being scored. I think that's what I think that's what disappoints. Yeah. Yeah. And it it's almost like, really, like, is it this is why I'm being discounted because my resume says the exact same thing, only not in the exact same words. So, yeah, there is the skill matching exercises or the word matching exercise that you can do,

37:17and you can do that with or without the use of AI. You could do it manually. You could do it with AI. But the other workaround is just referrals. You know, try to get your resume into the hands of a live individual on the hiring team. Isn't always easy, And even then, you don't know how many other applicants there are. So but, you know, finding an an an internal source or an internal referral, I think, is always good advice. What other I mean, do you have any other advice for for job seekers right now?

37:49Yeah. So I think networking is is really key. Although, I think sometimes internal referrals are not necessarily working. Like, it used to be bold. Right? But, again, that's because companies were struggling to find candidates. They have a plethora of candidates coming to them now. They're not struggling to find candidates. They're in there. How they go about finding them is is the previous discussion. Yep. But I think just constantly networking and and making sure your network stays up to date even

38:21when you're not searching for a job. Right? It's important to to continue to engage with, you know, LinkedIn if that's what you do and podcasts like this and stay on top of who's talking and who's doing what in in the field itself. That's probably the best foot forward at at this point. And I know that a lot of folks say, I'm not in the industry. How do I get into the industry? Right? Like, what is it that that breaks it in? And, again, that's really gonna be depending on the situation. For me, in my last position, I had a lot of very senior MSLs that I first hired.

38:55And I said, I can't keep hiring the same folks. That's all I have is very senior MSLs. So I did actually hire two MSLs out of their fellowship, and I I brought them in as first time MSLs. I felt confident enough in my skills as an MSL and a mentor and a coach to be able to teach them. And I had the experience on the team from several others with multiple years of experience that were also there to be their colleagues and coaches too.

39:26So they had the opportunity to come out of their fellowship into a great team, and they they flourished. You know? They're they're doing fantastic work. So, again, I think it is just the situation of hiring. Don't give up. Just don't give up. It's out there. And, you know, you you know more than I do, and you feel free to jump in that it's just a weird situation. All of a sudden, somebody has a job. And it it came out of somebody you talked to last month, and they said, oh, yeah.

39:56Stephanie. And and all of a sudden, there's an opportunity, and you're hired because you're the right fit. 100%. Back to yeah. Yeah. It keeps coming back to that. But you're right. You have to put the work in. You have to you really have to plant the seeds. If you're not planting the seeds, nothing's gonna grow. And if you're planting seeds and you're doing the networking and you're applying to positions and you're branding on LinkedIn, all the things, referrals, informational interviews, whatever it takes, you're doing all that.

40:27Eventually, it's gonna pay off. It's just don't it it will. It's just a matter of timing. And it's funny. I just had this situation last week where somebody was really, really frustrated and really struggling, and I felt so bad for this person. And she called me up last week, and she's like, you're not gonna believe it. I got two offers. And, like, they came out of nowhere, and it's just the it's feast or famine. That's a lot of times what happens. You know? So so I agree with you, Steph. You can't give up. Just keep putting in the work. Keep putting in the effort.

40:57But thank you. This was such an amazing conference. I I knew this was gonna be great, and I knew the time was gonna fly. This is a perfect example what happens when you get into a good conversation. That's right. That's right. It's a great example of that. Yep. So, Steph, thank you for being here. Appreciate you coming onto the show. Yep. Alright. Well, thank you for having me. Guys, if you got value out of this, as always, please share it with others. Love you guys. Appreciate your support of this show, and we'll see you next time. Alright.

Open the transcript file

Hosts and Guests

Nobody is credited on this episode yet.

Credit the people on this episode

Be the first to rate this episode

More episodes

All episodes
  1. The Wrong Voices: How Bad Mentors Can Ruin Your Career

    Nov 17, 202628 minVideo

    What qualifies someone to influence your future? Tom Caravela explains why career guidance should be filtered through relevant experience, current knowledge, credibility, and objectivity. He examines the risks of...

    Listen to the audio

    Credit the people on this episode

  2. Hidden Secret to Career Happiness and Longevity

    Nov 3, 202635 minVideo

    What turns an industry contact into a long-term ally? In this episode, Tom Caravela and Ed Doherty look beyond transactional networking to the genuine friendships that can shape a career in medical affairs. They discuss...

    Listen to the audio

    Credit the people on this episode

  3. How to AI-Proof Your Career: The 4 Pillars of Career Success

    Oct 20, 202623 minVideo

    Becoming undeniable is Tom Caravela’s answer to building career security in the age of AI. He breaks down four pillars you can control: skills, experience, relationships, and brand. Tom explains how continuous learning...

    Listen to the audio

    Credit the people on this episode

  4. How Medical Affairs Influences Decisions that Matter

    Oct 13, 202638 minVideo

    What happens after an MSL submits an insight? In this episode, Tom Caravela and Cameron Tew examine how field observations create value only when organizations decide what to do next. They discuss shared definitions,...

    Listen to the audio

    Credit the people on this episode

  5. Stop Being Your Own Worst Enemy

    Sep 29, 202619 minVideo

    In this episode, Tom Caravela discusses common mindset traps that can hold Medical Science Liaisons and aspiring MSLs back. He covers how to move past worst-case thinking, overanalysis, concern about others’ opinions,...

    Listen to the audio

    Credit the people on this episode