Skip to content
PodSubs
ShowsPeopleGuestsJobsNewsEvents
More
BlogPodCred
Menu
ShowsPeopleGuestsJobsNewsEventsBlogPodCredNetworksSign in
Join nowSign in
  • Shows
  • People
  • Jobs
  • News
  • More
    • Guests
    • Events
    • Blog
    • PodCred
    • Networks
    Join nowSign in

MSL Talk

The Wrong Voices: How Bad Mentors Can Ruin Your Career

Nov 17, 202628 minVideo
ShareXLinkedInFacebookWhatsAppEmail

What qualifies someone to influence your future? Tom Caravela explains why career guidance should be filtered through relevant experience, current knowledge, credibility, and objectivity. He examines the risks of listening to emotionally invested loved ones or self-proclaimed experts, and why great mentors ask thoughtful questions, challenge assumptions, and know when not to advise. For major decisions, seek multiple perspectives while remembering the final choice and its consequences are yours.

Audio and video play straight from the show's own hosting. PodSubs stores and serves no media.

Transcript

From the show.

0:00Hey, guys. Welcome to the MSL talk podcast. We are going to do a special solo episode. I wanna talk to you about something that's been on my mind for a while, and it's kinda come to a head to a point where I feel like I need to talk to you guys. I need to share something with you. We're gonna talk about mentorship today. And as you know, I've done a lot of episodes in the past about mentors and the importance of having a mentor or a coach. This is gonna be a completely different angle.

0:32This is going to talk about the wrong mentors and how not all mentors are going to advise you properly and help you. They could actually hurt you. I've seen a lot of situations recently where people are just getting bad advice, and they're making mistakes, and they're living in regret because they're listening to the wrong people. So today, we're gonna talk all about how to avoid those situations and prevent that from

1:06happening. And let's just... Guys, let's face it. It seems like right now everyone has a mentor these days. Everyone is a mentor these days. You can't... Like, I... You can't turn around without someone else posting on LinkedIn or coming up with a coaching program or a certification course or a webinar, whatever it might be. And that's all fine. Guys, I fully support all of that. But what happens when the person giving you advice is wrong?

1:40What if they're the wrong person? What if they're not qualified? What if they don't have the experience? What happens when you make a major career decision based upon someone's recommendation, but then months later, you find out you've made a terrible mistake, and it happens. I'm telling you, and it's happening more and more, which is why I wanted to talk to you guys. You guys know that I've been in the recruiting space, the executive recruiting industry, for

2:11twenty five years. I've I've talked to thousands of of professionals. I've had so many hiring leaders on this show, and I've seen how career decisions can dramatically change the trajectory. So sometimes it really... It comes down to these single decisions that lead to big ramifications. And I don't wanna scare anyone. I don't wanna make this, you know, this this big scary thing, but I do want to caution you

2:45guys because getting advice from the wrong person can sometimes be worse than getting no advice at all. So let's let's start with something that I think we all need to recognize is that not everyone who gives you advice is qualified to give it. Okay? So... And and and here's what I mean by that. We just have to... First and foremost, we have to know who we're listening to because, you know, someone who has

3:17or says to have experience doesn't mean that they have the right experience. Someone who cares about you, maybe a family member, that doesn't mean that they're qualified to advise you. And just because someone out there is saying that they're a mentor, that doesn't make them one. It doesn't make them qualified. So the first thing I want you to look out for, and here's here's just different things to look

3:49out for as you're selecting mentors or as you're developing mentors because sometimes these things just develop, is first and foremost, you really want to watch out for the money grab. Some of these so called mentors or career coaches that charge a lot of money, you know, you really have to kind of vet that out and look at their backgrounds, look at their situation, look at who they're... Who they've helped in the past, who they're currently helping, and how qualified are they

4:25to advise you, and is the juice worth the squeeze? Find out. Like, okay. Well, you know, what does this cost, and and how does this relationship work? And ask a lot of questions because sometimes you go down a path and you don't even realize that you're hiring someone that's not fully qualified or they're really not gonna give you the value that you need based upon the amount of money that they're gonna be charging you.

4:55So it's really important to make sure that you understand who the person is. If someone lacks relevant experience, they may have experience, but if it's not relevant to you, that's a red flag. So for example, like, there are, you know, maybe someone's out there and they're advising aspiring MSLs, but they've never worked...

5:26Or MSLs or MSL leaders, but they've never worked in medical affairs. They've never... Maybe they come from a different industry, but they're very certainly a leader and they are they are certainly accomplished and qualified, but they've never hired an MSL. They've never been involved in the interview process for MSLs or medical affairs. That person may not be for you.

5:57And I'm not saying that every single person has to have done the exact same job to be a mentor. I mean, look at me. I've never been an MSL, and I'm a mentor to many people. But I've been in the pharmaceutical industry for thirty six years. I spent ten years as a... You know, on the sales side working hand in hand with MSLs. I've been recruiting MSLs for twenty five years. I've been interviewing hundreds of medical affairs leaders on my podcast.

6:31So I think I have the qualifications and the credibility to be able to advise people. So I want you to look at the people that are out there that are trying to provide mentorship, see if they're qualified and how they're qualified. The other thing to look at is there are people out there that have experience, but it might it might not be recent experience.

7:01It might be really super outdated. I know that there are people that are retired, and they're bored, and they wanna offer help. And that's great, and I think you should take it. But I also think you should take it for what it is because if they haven't been in the industry that you're in... I I keep talking about about medical affairs because majority of people that listen to this podcast are in medical affairs or your MSLs. So I'm gonna keep referring to that.

7:31But, you know, if someone hasn't been in the game in fifteen or twenty years, you certainly cannot expect that those people are gonna be qualified to help you. And that would be... That would just be... I think it would be obvious when you start to look at and talk to those folks, but sometimes it becomes clouded because they may be very senior and have done a lot and are very accomplished in their career. The other thing to be careful of, and this is a big one.

8:05This is really, really, really important. And I could actually kind of do a whole show just about this. And if you take anything from this episode, this is the one thing I want you to walk away with. Someone who is emotionally invested in your decision may not be the best mentor. That means it could be a spouse. It could be a parent. It could be a sibling. It could be a very close friend. These people all love you unconditionally unconditionally, and I'm sure that they

8:40genuinely want what's best for you. But I can't tell you how many times that I've seen this go bad. Sometimes you're a little close to the forest to see the trees, and I'm talking about the... Your... The the mentor, the spouse, the husband that wants to do what's right for their significant other or whatever, but they're really giving bad advice. And I'll give you an example. And and this is an old... This is something that happened a while ago, but I can tell you it happens often.

9:15It happened this week. But the one story that really comes to mind is we had a candidate who went through the interview process with the pharmaceutical company. They got the job, and it was exactly what they had asked for. Literally, when we submitted the person's information, the base salary, the comp structure, the long term incentive, everything was exactly what we had expected.

9:48There were no surprises. As matter of fact, it might have even come in a little bit higher. Well... And and this is... And I've told this story before, so I hope I'm not being totally redundant, but... And it's in my book, by the way. But... So what happened was this person's wife was an accountant or in finance of some sort. Well, I didn't realize this, but... So she starts giving him advice.

10:18He now is... He balks at the offer. So the offer was presented by the HR person at the organization, and he balks. And he comes off as really ungrateful and starts negotiating and starts asking for all these these extra things and and asking for more money. And, guys, this situation, everything was already prenegotiated. Like, we we we, meaning my firm and the HR team and the hiring team, we had already hacked it

10:57out. We had everything exactly teed up for this guy to just say yes. We did all of the work, and he got, like, even more than we had anticipated. They rescinded the offer. Like, no questions asked. This guy calls me up, and he's like... And I'll never forget this, and you know what's ironic is that we're having this conversation here, and it... I was... It was a Friday night in November. Okay? Now, it's Friday right now, and I'm doing this podcast, and it's November.

11:29And it was several years ago, and I was at a charity function that I I support and I go to every year, it just so happens that that charity function is happening tonight. So it's like literally on the anniversary of when this whole thing happened. It was 07:00 at night. He's calling me nonstop on my phone as I'm at this this charity thing. And I finally, like, stepped aside and I and I... The guy is flipping out on the phone.

11:59He's like, they just rescinded the offer. They just took the offer away from me. You have to fix this. What do I need to do? Tell them it was my wife. Tell them that she only wanted what was best for me, that she didn't understand, you know, how this works, and she doesn't understand the industry, and she's coming from a... I mean, guys, that he was going on and on in tears. He's like, I really want this job. I really need this job. Well, that was it, guys. It ended badly.

12:30He... It turned out that they wouldn't reconsider, and they were upset at us because they thought we told him to negotiate. And, I mean, we tried to convince these people. We just... I remember the HR guy being really unreasonable and being like, I find it very hard to believe that you didn't understand what your candidate was doing. And I'm like, I didn't. I had no idea. I'm at this charity thing, blah blah blah. So I know...

13:00I don't wanna make this too long of a story, but I just wanna tell you that if your spouse is giving you advice, but they are not in the industry and they don't know how it works and they've never... Even if they are in the industry, they may not know how it works at this company. Their experience at another company may not correlate and be the same as what's going on at

13:31this company. So they may be able to give you some advice. They may be able to give you some recommendations. But to categorically say, it's this. You need to do this, you have to be careful. And if you're working with a search firm, you're working with a recruiter, you wanna ask that recruiter a lot of questions before you go and say anything in that type of situation, going back to the company. If you're not working with a recruiter but you're interviewing at an organization, you

14:04wanna make sure that you're talking to somebody. Maybe it's in talent acquisition or HR. Ask them a lot of questions and make sure that you understand the situation before you go in there with a sledgehammer and blow the whole thing up. So I I I wanna make... I don't wanna get too far into the weeds with this, but I just wanna make sure that you're careful when you're getting advice from a loved one and get other advice because I just think that you're gonna need to make sure that you're just not listening to one voice.

14:39The other thing, and I'm gonna move on to kind of the next area to be aware of and be careful of, is when you are talking to or you find somebody who is a self proclaimed expert. So there are people that are out there now because of social media that they may have a big following, and they may have an impressive title. They may have a very polished brand, but the thing is, are they qualified? Have they accomplished anything?

15:10Who have they successfully helped? So they may have the visibility, but do they have the credibility? Guys, I can tell you right now the loudest voice in the room isn't necessarily the best voice in the room. And and just as... You know, just to kinda... I wanna get into some other things to look out for, but one of the other things I've learned is that I think the best way for you to evaluate your mentor and consider who's

15:45advising you isn't necessarily by listening to their answers, but it's paying attention to the questions. So great mentors will ask great questions. And I... This is something I feel really, really strongly about. So if if you have a mentor that's giving you advice, but they're not asking you any questions and they don't really know the situation, that's a red flag.

16:15How can somebody possibly give you meaningful career advice without first understanding your circumstances, your goals, your motivations, your challenges, your priorities? Do they know all that? Have they asked the right questions in advance? Are they aware of your situation in in in total? And how often do people immediately jump into telling you what to do without asking you anything first? So let's say you're an MSL and, I don't know, you're frustrated with your current company,

16:51and you're having a conversation with someone and you're telling them that you may wanna leave. And they immediately say, absolutely. You should leave. You deserve better than that. Really? I mean, based on what? Like, have they asked you why you're unhappy? Have they asked you about your manager, your compensation, your career goals, or or what you might be giving up if you left.

17:22So here's here's what good looks like. Someone that instead stops and says, alright, Tom. Well, what's really driving your dissatisfaction? Is it a temporary problem, or is it something that's ongoing that you don't see getting better? Have you discussed your concerns with your manager? What would you need to change for you to wanna stay?

17:53And is it possible for that to change? Or what are you hoping to find somewhere else? What do you think exists in another company? What are you running to? Or how does this decision fit into your long term career goals? So you see the difference? One person, if they're reacting to a situation, that may not be good. The other person that's trying to understand it first is better suited to be able to help you.

18:31So, guys, bad advice doesn't always look bad in the moment. Sometimes it sounds like it's it's the right advice, but six months, a year, maybe even longer, you discover the price that you're gonna pay for listening to the wrong person. So let's talk about how do you protect yourself. I want you to think about a few things before you take someone's advice.

19:03So first off, you always need to evaluate someone's experience. Do they actually understand the situation that you're facing? Have they been in that situation in the past? What types of jobs did that person have in the past? Like, is their experience relevant to you and your career goals, and is it current and

19:35relevant for today's environment? Like, that's the first thing is look at someone's experience. How relevant is it, and is it suitable for for you and for what you may need? The next thing is you need to consider that person's objectivity. Are they giving you unbiased guidance? Are they just sharing from their own experiences that it may not necessarily align with your situation or experience?

20:07How much emotion is there involved in that person's advice? Again, getting back to the family member. And what... Like, do their interest... How are their interests influencing their recommendations? Is it because they're getting paid? Is it because... I don't know. There... There's a lot of motivations that sometimes a mentor may have that might not align with what

20:43your motivations are and what your your your best interest is. The other thing is, I think, and I said this before, I'm gonna mention it again, it's important to pay attention to their questions or lack thereof. Are they asking good questions? Are they trying to understand your circumstances? You know, what are the quality of those questions and... You know? Or are they just jumping straight into the advice portion and telling you what to do

21:17without even really having all of the information. And then the other thing too, and I just think that this is really sound advice, is to seek multiple perspectives. You don't need one mentor for everything. I think that sometimes it's not a bad idea to have a posse, to have, you know, several, you know, advisers and voices. The only thing I will caution you is if you talk to too many people, you may wind up

21:49getting... There might be too many cooks in the kitchen and you may wind up just getting confused. So I would take advice not with a grain of salt, but I would take advice, and and I would rank it based upon how qualified that person is. And let them convince you that their experience, that their, you know, kind of their qualifications meet what you need most in order to use that as, you know, something valuable

22:27that you're actually gonna take action on. The other thing too is, you know, sometimes we also... We migrate to what we wanna hear. I think it's also important to find people who are willing to challenge you. And sometimes the most dangerous advice is advice that tells you exactly what you wanna hear. A great mentor should be willing to tell you something you need to hear, not just something

22:57that you wanna hear. But... And before I wrap this up, I wanna kinda turn this conversation around a minute, And I wanna talk to people that might be listening that are mentors, that are in a position where you're giving advice to others, or if you do so... Have an opportunity to do so in the future, I think it's important to make sure that you're

23:29qualified to give the advice. I wanna challenge mentors out there. If you're positioning yourself as an adviser or an expert, are you the right person to give major life and career advice to that person? I think that we we need to ask ourselves before you offer advice. Am I truly the right person for this? Or should I advise them to talk to someone else?

24:02If you know that you're not qualified or if you are qualified, but maybe there is some nuance to your... The advice that you might give or to the situation, you need to be honest about that. You need to say, hey. Look. You know what? What I can tell you is this. I have twenty five years of experience, and I know this. I may not be an expert in your space, but if you're asking my advice, this is what I would do. So, you know, I always... When when people come to me, I always like to ask, do I understand their situation?

24:36Am I being objective? Am I willing to acknowledge when someone falls outside my expertise? I don't wanna waste that person's time, and I certainly don't wanna waste mine. And there's nothing wrong with saying, you know what? I don't think I'm the best resource for you. That's outside my area of expertise. You should probably speak to someone who has more direct experience in your area. That, to me, guys, is the sign of a great mentor because knowing when not to give advice

25:08is just as important as knowing when to give advice. So I'm gonna close with... Guys, you know how important I think your career investments are. You know that I have made a career of trying to help people in establishing themselves, whether it's as an MSL, as an MSL leader.

25:39Because the decisions that you make and the advice that you take from people, it's going to affect your professional trajectory. It's gonna affect your financial future, your family, and and your happiness. And I don't take that lightly, and there shouldn't be any mentor that takes that lightly. So I wanna just urge you to be careful about who you allow to influence your decisions. And I'm not telling you to stop seeking advice. I'm not telling you to stop listening to your mentors or stop listening to your family

26:13members. What I am telling you is you need to be a judge. You need to find the right mentors, build the right relationships, surround yourself with the right people, people that want you to succeed, that are... Have your best interest at heart and are most qualified. So you just need to be selective. You need to ask questions. You need to challenge assumptions. And, again, seek multiple perspectives without confusing yourself.

26:47You can respect someone's opinion without allowing it to dictate your decisions. So I say that because a lot of times people may hear differing opinions. It's your... It's up to you to what you do with that information. At the end of the day, it's your career. It's your future. You're the one who has to live with the consequences. So I'll leave you with this. Not everyone who has an opinion has earned the right to influence your future.

27:18So choose your voices wisely. Make really good decisions, and go with your heart. Go with your gut. And as always, thank you guys for your support. Thank you for believing in me as a mentor. I mean, the reason you're here and the reason you're listening to this is I think because you value the advice that you get on this show. And I take it very, very seriously, and you guys know that I want 100% what's best for you. So I hope this has helped you. If it has, please share it with others.

27:49Don't forget to check this out or check out the podcast on YouTube and subscribe to our YouTube channel because... I don't know. I like it. It's out there, and I started to you know, kinda put a little more effort into YouTube. So, hopefully, you guys check that out one day. But I'll see you next time. And as always, love you all and wish you all the best.

Open the transcript file

Hosts and Guests

Nobody is credited on this episode yet.

Credit the people on this episode

Be the first to rate this episode

More episodes

All episodes
  1. Hidden Secret to Career Happiness and Longevity

    Nov 3, 202635 minVideo

    What turns an industry contact into a long-term ally? In this episode, Tom Caravela and Ed Doherty look beyond transactional networking to the genuine friendships that can shape a career in medical affairs. They discuss...

    Listen to the audio

    Credit the people on this episode

  2. How to AI-Proof Your Career: The 4 Pillars of Career Success

    Oct 20, 202623 minVideo

    Becoming undeniable is Tom Caravela’s answer to building career security in the age of AI. He breaks down four pillars you can control: skills, experience, relationships, and brand. Tom explains how continuous learning...

    Listen to the audio

    Credit the people on this episode

  3. How Medical Affairs Influences Decisions that Matter

    Oct 13, 202638 minVideo

    What happens after an MSL submits an insight? In this episode, Tom Caravela and Cameron Tew examine how field observations create value only when organizations decide what to do next. They discuss shared definitions,...

    Listen to the audio

    Credit the people on this episode

  4. Stop Being Your Own Worst Enemy

    Sep 29, 202619 minVideo

    In this episode, Tom Caravela discusses common mindset traps that can hold Medical Science Liaisons and aspiring MSLs back. He covers how to move past worst-case thinking, overanalysis, concern about others’ opinions,...

    Listen to the audio

    Credit the people on this episode

  5. What Medical Affairs Conferences Should You Go To?

    Sep 22, 202623 minVideo

    In this episode, Tom Caravela explores the decision-making process for attending conferences, crucial for Medical Science Liaisons and Medical Affairs professionals. He discusses the importance of networking and...

    Listen to the audio

    Credit the people on this episode