Skip to content
PodSubs
ShowsPeopleGuestsJobsNewsEvents
More
BlogPodCred
Menu
ShowsPeopleGuestsJobsNewsEventsBlogPodCredNetworksSign in
Join nowSign in
  • Shows
  • People
  • Jobs
  • News
  • More
    • Guests
    • Events
    • Blog
    • PodCred
    • Networks
    Join nowSign in

MSL Talk

How AI Ruined My Job Search

Sep 30, 202526 minVideo
ShareXLinkedInFacebookWhatsAppEmail

In this episode, Tom Caravela explores the role of AI in the job search process and key factors that could lead to critical mistakes. The discussion begins with an overview of how AI can aid in resume optimization and the potential consequences of relying on these tools. Tom addresses the issue of age discrimination in resumes, offering insights into how AI can help mitigate this challenge. The episode also covers AI tools for interview preparation, highlighting common pitfalls to avoid. The conversation extends to AI's influence on compensation and offer negotiation, emphasizing the importance of using these tools responsibly. The episode wraps up with closing remarks and a call to action for listeners.

Audio and video play straight from the show's own hosting. PodSubs stores and serves no media.

Transcript

From the show.

0:01Hey, guys. Welcome to the podcast coming at you with a very special solo episode. We're gonna talk about or I'm gonna talk about artificial intelligence kind of from a different angle. I think you guys are gonna love this because I'm gonna use some really practical real life stories that I think are gonna really help all of you. Before I get into that, couple quick announcements. For those of you who don't know, my name is Tom Caravella. This is the MSL talk podcast. The reason I'm introducing myself, there's a lot of new listeners. It's conference season.

0:32I've been meeting a lot of people, and I'm hearing from new folks that are like, yeah. I just discovered your podcast, but I don't think they really know what this is, what it's about. So I'm an executive recruiter that specializes in medical affairs and MSL recruitment. This podcast has been in existence for over five years. I welcome anyone new. Follow me on LinkedIn for content each day, and, hopefully, you can get a lot of value out of this. So, specifically, when I'm talking about AI and as we get into this conversation and it's funny

1:09because I like to kinda come up with catchy or clickbaity titles. So the title of this episode is how AI ruined my job search. It's not about one specific person, and there's not someone on here telling the story about how it ruined their search. It's just me telling you how people are ruining their their their job search by misusing artificial intelligence. But I'm not saying that you shouldn't use artificial intelligence, chat GPT, Gemini,

1:41perplexity, whatever it is that you use. I just want to give you some explanation as to how people are using it and making mistakes. So the first thing that I'm I see people doing is using AI, let's say ChatGPT specifically, to help with your resume. I recommend this. I think it's a great practice. I think you should absolutely do it. I'm gonna tell you a quick story, though. So one of the job seekers that we've been working with at the Carolyn Group who's

2:15actually excellent decided to go to ChatGPT and use the prompt. Don't quote me, but this is somewhat of what I think the prompt was based upon our conversation. Something along the lines of, act as a resident professional resume writer and help me to rewrite and optimize my resume for a medical science liaison position with x y z company. I am going to attach my current resume and the job description.

2:50Please match the keywords, language, and phrases within the job description so that my resume will be inclusive of that information and help me get through app I can tracking system filters, but please base it on my experience and as it relates to the role. Something along those lines. Guys, that's a really good prompt. You'd be surprised at what comes out of that. And sure enough, boom. Chatty spits out this amazing resume spot on.

3:20Right? Person gets the resume through an applicant tracking system filter and gets an interview. Okay. Great. Right? So what's the problem? Well, the problem is it was too good, and they didn't edit it. And they're on an interview, and the hiring manager says, oh, well, I see here the first bullet on your resume says in your current job, spearheaded a project a b c x y z details

3:50whatever that resulted in one, two, three, four, five, six. Right? Tell me about that. Well, the person froze because they weren't prepared to give details about something. They thought they could just answer it on a surface level perspective. And although they did they were involved in that initiative, they did not spearhead it. They were not in charge of it, and they kinda had a menial role in the project.

4:23So the the person did just didn't give a very detailed answer. They actually said something along the lines of, well, I was involved, and here's to what extent. So the hiring manager said, oh, well, kinda doesn't really say that. It kinda says that you were spearheaded it, and you did x y z a b c. So, like, kinda talk through it, whatever. Okay. Okay. Okay. Well, Well, you know, let's continue and went to the second bullet. Same thing happened.

4:54Same thing. So, obviously, the interview fell flat. Mean, I I think they probably kept talking, but the decision was already made after the first question, to be honest. But so this this person completely bombed the interview because they didn't look through the entire language that was used in each bullet throughout that resume to make sure that they

5:25could support the claims that they were making. You have to be able to give details, share stories, talk about what you did, how you did it, what the result was. If you're gonna put something on your resume, you have to be able to talk about it. And if you can't talk about it, then you gotta take it off. So had another situation where a resume comes to me from one of my recruiters. We're working on a position. Resume comes to me, and the first thing I read is something along the lines of accomplished

5:59medical affairs professional with fifteen years of blah blah blah blah blah. Right? Okay. So I start reading through I'm like, okay. You know, pretty senior person. So I start reading through the experience. I get to the last page, to the bottom of the last page, and I look and I'm like, wait a second. This person said they had fifteen years of experience, but it just kind of ended at, like,

6:29nine years of experience. Like, it only goes back nine years. So I'm like, okay. Well, am I missing a page? Like, is this it? It looked like that was it. So fast forward, I went back to my recruiter. I said, hey. Look. Here's what I'm seeing. Something's missing. They came back and said, oh, no. That's the full resume. And I'm like, it's not the full resume because it's one of two things. Either this person's lying, and they don't have fifteen years of experience, or they have

7:02fifteen years of experience, but there's information missing. You can't say you have fifteen years of experience and not show the fifteen years because I wanna know what that is. I wanna see what it is and so does everybody else. So now and mind you, the position this person was applying for required it. They were looking for someone very senior. So it would have meant that they're either qualified for it or they're not qualified.

7:32That's the difference between the nine years and the fifteen years. So turns out that this person went to chat GPT and asked it to help revise their resume because they were concerned about age discrimination. So this is an older person that technically actually has over thirty years of experience, but didn't wanna show that because they didn't want to age themselves out of that specific

8:02search, or they were were not age out, but they were worried that they were gonna be evaluated as you know, based upon their age. And, you know, ageism is a thing. I get it, and I'm I I understand. I'm sensitive to that. But the thing is you can't just cut it off at this random point without any real explanation of what else exist. Now one of the things that chat GPT might do or you just might do, a resume writer might do, is

8:36they may to prevent this age discrimination thing from happening, they may take dates out of your education. So instead of saying graduated such and such a date, 1986, whatever, they might take that graduation date out so that it doesn't show their age. They may go back in their career to a certain extent and then not show that they started their career in, you know, 1990 or whatever.

9:07Now look. Is is that misleading? I mean, no. I mean, look. They're not lying. I mean, they're they're showing the portion of their experience that's most relevant. They're showing that they went to school in a certain place. If the hiring manager really wants that information in an interview, they're just gonna say, hey. Look. I noticed that you went to Rutgers University. You I'm know, just curious. When did you graduate? I mean, I think legally, they could probably ask them that.

9:38But even if they don't, even if they know what they're doing, that's fine. Like, I'm not that's not what the concern is here. The concern is that if you're making a claim and saying you have fifteen years of experience, you have to show the fifteen years. Because if you don't show it, then something is missing, and it's going to raise a red flag. So those are two examples of how you really need to make sure that if you're using ChatGPT or any other AI tool to optimize and and edit your resume, you have to make sure of the

10:15accuracy, and you have to be able to to speak about it and support it in such a way where you can justify the claims that you're making. You can talk about the experience, and it's not fluff because there's so much fluff out there. And that's the thing that hiring managers are getting frustrated with is people are over exaggerating their resumes and their backgrounds using these tricks to get through the applicant tracking system filter, but then they can't support any of the claims, and then

10:47it just becomes a big waste of time. So listen. I I want you guys to have the best advantage and the best resumes that you can, but I wanna make sure that you're not overstating, overexaggerating, or getting or gonna get yourself into any kind of trouble. So let's talk about interviewing and how artificial intelligence tools can botch the interview for you. And this is a another real story that happened recently.

11:19And it started out in what I would consider a, like, really brilliant idea of how to use ChatGPT to help prepare you for an interview. So this person went in, and their prompt was don't quote me, but it was something along the lines of, I am preparing for an interview for a medical science liaison position with x y z company. I will share the job description for this position and ask that you act as the hiring

11:58manager for this position and prepare a list of questions that I can use to practice prior to the interview. Now brilliant. I I mean, I I think that's great. Chatty spits out a list of awesome questions for this person to practice. But what do you think it does next? Take one guess. What do you think ChatGPD does next? It says, would you like me to give you answer, I think it said, would you like me to give you,

12:35potential, answers or sample responses to these questions. Something along those lines saying, hey. Do you wanna see what the answers might be to give you some ideas? So the person's like, yeah. Give me the answers to the test, dude. Let me freaking see it. Bring it on. Right? So now this person's practicing with questions, but they're also using answers that are coming

13:07from a machine. Not that that's bad because I think we all sometimes need a little bit of guidance. It's almost like writer's block. You need inspiration. You need guidance. You wanna I mean, that's that's what AI tools are for. It's for getting you through that that barrier and getting you to the next level and helping you to become better at whatever it is that you're doing and you're trying to do. Here's the problem. This person memorized all these answers.

13:40So they get on the interview, and and it's funny. So here's the conversation I have with the hiring manager. Hiring manager calls me up, and he says, yeah. It's a no. Now I don't know any of this before this conversation with the hiring manager. I found out after the fact. So hiring manager calls me up and says, yeah. It's it's a no. And I'm like, well, what happened? They said, well, you know what, Tom? This person I I didn't not like them, but as I'm asking them questions, it just felt like

14:15the answers weren't coming from that person. They seemed overly rehearsed. They didn't seem natural, and I could tell that they went to chat GPT and and and got this these artificial answers. I could just tell. Now, again, the the truth came out after the fact, but this person was so robotic and rehearsed and unnatural in their answers that the hiring manager picked up on it and could

14:50tell. So this is another example of it's definitely encouraged and it's okay to use AI tools to help you to prepare and get to the next level, but you have to make it your own. You you can't be the robot because the people are gonna call you out on it. You it has to it can't it's like plagiarizing or or, you know, speak you know, kinda like

15:21reading off a script. That's not gonna get you the job. It's not gonna win you the job. What's gonna win you the job is when you answer questions with authenticity, with your own character, with stories, solving problems, using examples, digging going deep, not surface and being like, question, answer. Question, answer. And I think that this person's heart was in the right place. I really do. I think they had the right intention, but I think they really overdid the preparation in

15:58trying too hard to make sure that they had the answers that they thought were the right answers without realizing that you totally took your personality out of the situation. So that's a really good example of how to be careful in using AI tools for interviews where it can be a really good like, what this person did could have been a really good thing, but

16:31they needed to use that information in a different way to educate them but make it their own. Same thing with the resume. You gotta make it your own. You gotta own it. It's gotta be real. It's gotta be authentic. It's gotta be, you know, accurate. All those things. Right? I don't even know if the answers were really accurate to that person. I don't know. I'm just guessing that it might have just been two pie in the sky. But, you know, really good example on a pitfall that you can all fall into very easily if

17:06you're not careful. So I'm gonna talk about one more example. I don't wanna make this too extensive. I'm just gonna give three examples. So resume, interview, and now I'm gonna talk about compensation and and offer negotiation. So we have this just happened recently. We had an MSO candidate interview for a position, and they got the job.

17:37So yay. Celebrate. High fives all around. Everybody's excited. Right? So I'm not gonna give you exact details. I wanna keep this as confidential and anonymous as possible. But let's just say for argument's sake, this person told us that they would be comfortable with a base salary of, I'm just gonna say, a $180,000. Okay? Which isn't the number, but let's just say that's what it is.

18:07So turns out that we negotiate the offer for this person, and it comes in at $1.85. So it's $5,000 more than they said they would be comfortable with. So they turn around and they say, yeah. You know what? I was really looking for $1.90. It's like, no. You weren't. You said $1.80. We got you $1.85. So what do you mean $1.90?

18:38Where where's like, where did that come from? And a lot of times what happens, what we're seeing on my side as an executive recruiter, sometimes when you get to this part in the process, people go out and they try everybody's going out and trying to get advice from someone, whether it's a coach, a colleague, a friend, anyone. It's just commonplace. Hey. What do you think I should do? They offered me this. What do you think? And I want I've talked about this before. I did a whole episode specifically on the job offer negotiation and pitfalls of being careful

19:15not to listen to the wrong people. Well, this wasn't a person. This was ChatGPT. Now, what the person did was went to ChatGPT to see if they can find out. They were very specific to say, I'm interviewing for the for a medical science liaison position at this company, and I would like to get some compensation ranges for similar companies based upon information that you might find in job postings or whatever

19:49else. Now right now, we're in a time which very different. We we are in a time that is starting to see what's called pay transparency, which is relatively new. And as you guys might see it, when you look at job postings, a lot of times it includes the compensation range for the position. And sometimes that range is super broad. It's like $1.67 to $2.49. Well, it's not probably not gonna be $1.67, and it's definitely not gonna be $2.49.

20:23That's an exaggeration, but I'm just saying usually there's some type of range. Well, this person actually, chat GPT found a posting somewhere for this exact position. And what she noticed was a range that was that went higher than what she was offered, but it started lower. And to to be totally honest, she fell right in where she should have been.

20:59Like, the offer was exactly what it should have been. But in her mind, because she saw higher numbers, she's like, well, the the range says this. And it's like, but your experience doesn't justify what you're asking for. You were comfortable at $1.80. They gave you $1.85. It's $5,000 more than you were comfortable with, and it's at the higher part of the range for your experience.

21:30So to go $5,000 higher because you see that there's the potential in the salary range and the pay transparency of whatever they're stating on the job description or job posting, that doesn't mean that you're entitled to it. As a matter of fact, you're not entitled to it. The reason that range is there is because, let's just say, the position didn't go to you. It went to somebody else that had two or three or four more years of experience than you.

22:04And they're making more than you. And the internal equity of the people that have that experience in the organization are making that level. That's why they have the range the way it is. Just because the range is provided doesn't mean that anybody can go in and just get whatever number you want. And I'm not necessarily saying that that's what I think she was under the impression but she was trying to stretch it.

22:34Now here's what happens when you're not careful and you look at things like that and you try to stretch it. You could upset the company. Like, I guys, I am not making this up. I said it on the last episode. Go check it out. I have seen more offers rescinded because of untactful and poorly negotiated offers that I care to mention. I've seen some very, very upset people that are like, well, what do you what do you mean they

23:08rescinded the offer? What do you mean they took the offer off the table? I don't understand. They offered me the job. Well, they offered you the job, but you talked yourself out of the job. They have the ability to pull it. So I don't wanna scare anyone, and I don't wanna say that you shouldn't negotiate. That's look. I want everyone out there to get the most money you could possibly get. Believe me. The reason I do this podcast is to help people, to help you guys, to make sure that you don't make mistakes. So by no means am I suggesting that you should settle for anything more than what you're worth

23:44and what you deserve, but you have to be very careful on how far you push it. It was not a bad idea to use artificial intelligence, chat GPT, whatever, to get this information. You wanna be well researched. But by the same token, you wanna use that information properly and make the right decisions. So the moral of the story here and I'm gonna share something with you. Last was it this past January, I was at an AI and medical affairs conference.

24:21And someone got up there and they said, be very careful when you use artificial intelligence tools because you still need to keep your hand on the wheel. And what they meant was, like, right now, there's there we have, like, self driving vehicles. There's self driving cars out there. But just because they exist doesn't mean I'm taking my hand off the wheel. I still need there's gotta be a human element added to artificial intelligence right now,

24:53especially when it comes to the job search because companies wanna hire people. They're not hiring robots. You're not a robot. They wanna hire a person and know that person who they are and why they're the right fit for the position, what value they bring, and why they're gonna be a great employee, fit within the culture, the environment, and be successful, and all that good stuff. And the only way you can show that is to be your authentic natural self.

25:26Yes. I think it's a mistake if you don't use artificial intelligence tools to help prepare to be to help you in your job search. I will say that. All of these examples started off in a in a really good way. I think people are doing the right thing, but they're misusing the information in all those situations. So it's it's not we can't really blame the AI tool. We have to blame the individual in how they're using that information.

25:59So, guys, I hope this was helpful. I love to share real life examples with you because I think it's the best way to get a message across and help you so that you don't make these mistakes. I wish you all the best. I love you all, guys. If you got value from this episode, please share it with others. Always appreciate your support, and I'll see you on the next one.

Open the transcript file

Hosts and Guests

Nobody is credited on this episode yet.

Credit the people on this episode

Be the first to rate this episode

More episodes

All episodes
  1. The Wrong Voices: How Bad Mentors Can Ruin Your Career

    Nov 17, 202628 minVideo

    What qualifies someone to influence your future? Tom Caravela explains why career guidance should be filtered through relevant experience, current knowledge, credibility, and objectivity. He examines the risks of...

    Listen to the audio

    Credit the people on this episode

  2. Hidden Secret to Career Happiness and Longevity

    Nov 3, 202635 minVideo

    What turns an industry contact into a long-term ally? In this episode, Tom Caravela and Ed Doherty look beyond transactional networking to the genuine friendships that can shape a career in medical affairs. They discuss...

    Listen to the audio

    Credit the people on this episode

  3. How to AI-Proof Your Career: The 4 Pillars of Career Success

    Oct 20, 202623 minVideo

    Becoming undeniable is Tom Caravela’s answer to building career security in the age of AI. He breaks down four pillars you can control: skills, experience, relationships, and brand. Tom explains how continuous learning...

    Listen to the audio

    Credit the people on this episode

  4. How Medical Affairs Influences Decisions that Matter

    Oct 13, 202638 minVideo

    What happens after an MSL submits an insight? In this episode, Tom Caravela and Cameron Tew examine how field observations create value only when organizations decide what to do next. They discuss shared definitions,...

    Listen to the audio

    Credit the people on this episode

  5. Stop Being Your Own Worst Enemy

    Sep 29, 202619 minVideo

    In this episode, Tom Caravela discusses common mindset traps that can hold Medical Science Liaisons and aspiring MSLs back. He covers how to move past worst-case thinking, overanalysis, concern about others’ opinions,...

    Listen to the audio

    Credit the people on this episode