What happens when a man seeks help for pain that has a political cause? Therapy may help him recover, but what changes the institutions that injured him? And how do we help men recognize injustice without leaving them trapped in anger and resentment? In this conversation, Stephen Baskerville and I explore the relationship between personal healing and political change. Stephen approaches these questions through his work on politics, fathers, and the family. I bring my experience working with men as a therapist. Those perspectives give us plenty to discuss, including where therapy helps, where it can go wrong, and what happens when therapeutic language becomes entangled with ideology. Stephen also raises a challenging question for those of us who create and watch content about men’s issues: Are we helping men change their circumstances, or sometimes giving them another place to rehearse their grievances? Recognizing a problem matters. Finding a way to act on that knowledge matters too. Our discussion ranges from family courts and feminism to the role of churches, men’s reluctance to challenge women, and the growing number of men withdrawing from dating and marriage. Stephen offers some provocative arguments about what that withdrawal means and whether it can become a source of leverage for change. There is much here to consider, and plenty to debate. I hope you’ll watch and share your thoughts: What helps men move from recognizing injustice to doing something effective about it?Taken Into Custody https://amzn.to/3nGaMh6 Who Lost America https://amzn.to/4mOH2tDNot Peace But A Sword https://amzn.to/3nENVSQThe New Politics of Sex https://amzn.to/3DIYjifA Gentlemens Guide to Manners, Sex, and Ruling the World https://amzn.to/3nDfD2yStephens Substack: Youtube www.youtube.com/@skbaskervilleyoutube www.youtube.com/@amalespace Thanks for reading MenAreGood Substack! This post is public so feel free to share it. MenAreGood Substack is a reader-supported publication. To receive new posts and support my work, consider becoming a free or paid subscriber. This is a public episode. If you'd like to discuss this with other subscribers or get access to bonus episodes, visit menaregood.substack.com/subscribe
Audio and video play straight from the show's own hosting. PodSubs stores and serves no media.
Transcript
From the show. Tap a time to play from there.
SPEAKER_01Men are good, as are you. Indeed, men are good, as are you. And as is Stephen Baskerville, who's sitting right next to me. Stephen is an amazing sort. I've known Stephen for a long time. I think gone back, what, over 20 years at least. But Stephen has been a hero to me in some ways because he sees things others don't see. He sees things ahead of people, what other people see, and he's not afraid to say what he sees.
SPEAKER_01I mean, that's a really nice combination there. And if you're interested in Stephen, you should look at his books. I mean, Who Lost America? He was talking about America's Lost to Communism. That book was published in 2024, right? That was... Two years ago. And people are just starting to wake up now and go, uh-oh, what's wrong? What have we lost? But the Take It Into Custody book was the one that caught me. And it was just the first book that really chronicled out there what is going on with the family courts and how are we getting screwed in so many different ways.
SPEAKER_01And it's just an incredible read. Even now, I would highly recommend. We'll have links to all of these and Steven Substack in the links below. And what are we going to talk about today? We're going to talk about something a little odd. Do we need therapy, political change, or both? What do you think, Stephen? What do you think?
SPEAKER_00Well, I'm a little biased, as you can imagine. First of all, I really love your show. I love your Substack, your work, your videos, and the interviews that you do. So it's a great honor to be here. So thank you very much.
SPEAKER_01It's an honor to have you.
SPEAKER_00And I've learned how to do my own show, partly from you, as well as a few others.
SPEAKER_01Mansplainers, check it out. We'll leave a link to the Mansplainers, too. That's a good point. Got some fascinating people on there, including Janice, who I think was on a couple of times in the last month or so, right?
SPEAKER_00Yes, we did. We had her on once for her book, and we had her on because so much was going on with Lindsay Clancy and with the Carnell Seven. Yes. All that happened right after her book. So it wasn't included in the book, but we thought it was worth the discussion. Yes. We had Janice on.
SPEAKER_01Oh, she is just incredible. She's in the two, Stephen and Janice together, even better.
SPEAKER_00But as for your question, the question about the, you know, this came up, I, of course, I'm a bias. My field is politics. That's my background. I've tried to look into the background of what's happening to men and fathers today, the political background, the political, what's driving it politically. Right. A lot of it is, you know, a lot of what happens between men and women and the Today is handled under the opposite. Well, legal practitioners have cornered the market
SPEAKER_00and to some extent sociologists and psychotherapists also. And some of them, many of them, for example, present company, have done a great job of it. But I think sometimes I'm concerned that the politics get lost and that's almost always the case. With things. It's always our temptation to retreat into our own world, into our own private lives. Most of us, quite rightly, want to live our private,
SPEAKER_00want to prioritize our private lives, our family lives. We see politics as a distraction. We see politics as something that we have to, you know, kind of force ourselves to do. But it's also a part of us. It's a part of our, well, citizenship. It's part of who we are. It's certainly part of what men are. We talk a lot about male leadership. We talk about male, some people talk about male dominance, male, well, even male supremacy.
SPEAKER_00But, you know, we forget sometimes that one area of that is citizenship, our civic duty. And an awful lot of what happens to men is the result of what is inflicted upon them from the state. And so I'm a little concerned. I've been concerned for some time. And a few recent things have confirmed my concerns that we are attempted to retreat into our private worlds and that sometimes a kind
SPEAKER_00of therapeutic culture has supplanted or displaced us. As our public lives, our citizens, our roles as citizens. And even in the best of times, it takes a lot to get people out of their tunes and into the public sphere. So I realize it's an uphill battle, and it's been an especially uphill battle for men, because we haven't gotten very far with politics. So I don't mean to set up an either-or,
SPEAKER_00I don't mean to set up a hostile relationship between therapy and culture. I think that There's some very good counselors out there and therapists. We just interviewed Hannah Speer for a show that's going to be on soon. And we interviewed Paul Elam a while back. And we'd like to interview you too, Tom, for our show, The Mansplainers. Because I think all of three of them are actually very, all three of you, I should say.
SPEAKER_00I'm sure there are others. Are somewhat critical of your own professions, the therapeutic culture, and rightly so, and managed to keep it in perspective, I think. And so I want to encourage that. I want to point out that you can't retreat. And therefore, it can't be an either or thing. It's got to be. Men are hurting very badly.
SPEAKER_00From what happens to them in the public sphere. And they need to, you know, things like healing and, you know, learning to express themselves better is, I think, extremely important. But they also need to realize that they can't retreat from the political dimension of this as long as what happens to them is not just life's unfairness in general.
SPEAKER_00It's injustice inflicted upon them by the state machinery.
SPEAKER_01Yeah. I don't know. I think that men actually are pretty good at dealing with their emotions. Just people don't know how they're doing it. They don't see it. But I agree with you that the tendency is to kind of pull back here and not step out and say what we need to say. And that's a real problem. Of course, that's been encouraged by the whole toxic masculinity group. The whole feminist thing with the academia saying there's no such thing as logic
SPEAKER_01so that all the things that men did well have become shamed and blamed. The logical, the standing up for what you think is right, all these things are by the wayside now because if you do that, oh, he must be toxic. It's crazy. So men are in a tough spot and I agree. I think that It wouldn't hurt men to get into therapy if it's the right kind of therapy. Today's therapy has just gone mad.
SPEAKER_01It's focused on safety instead of honesty. And if you don't have honesty, if you don't have someone who's looking at, okay, what's my problem? What am I causing here? If you don't have that, you don't have growth. You know, so the therapy is not about growth. It's about safety. It's about keeping people safe and, oh, someone else is the problem and you're fine the way you are, you know, all those things. And so the way it is now, it's just not going to help people. It's not going to help people. It's just like feminism in general is all about blaming others.
SPEAKER_00Exactly. I take that away from your work very much, Tom. Yeah, it's not that men can't express their feelings. They just do it differently. They cannot dwell on their feelings and they connect it to objective reality much more. It's less subjective and more connected with the objective world. This is very much a masculine trait.
SPEAKER_01Yes, and they connect it with meaning making.
SPEAKER_00You know, argue that it is the male, the father in the home that connects the children to, that weans the children from the subjective self-centeredness that comes from in the early years of childhood under the mother's nurturance and connects them with the objective world. Precisely. And forces them to interact and engage with the world as it is.
SPEAKER_01Yes.
SPEAKER_00So, you know, there's nothing wrong with the I'm not expressing that, but it's different. It's more, I think... Absolutely! Just as on your subjective you know, your self -centered, natural love. Your natural, you're a self -center. Yes.
SPEAKER_01And just us feminists have pulled fathers out of the home and shamed anything that their fathers did like setting limits, same thing is happening on a more global scale. You know, we're shaming men so that they're being pulled away from the political sphere and their input is not valued. You know, it's crazy. It's absolutely crazy.
SPEAKER_00Yeah, it's very true. And, you know, this feminization of, well, feminization of everything.
SPEAKER_01I was just going to say that.
SPEAKER_00It's the whole feminization of society, this adoption of a feminine attitude toward Everything. And I think, well, not to get too far astray, but certainly the psychotherapeutic profession has been taken over very much by feminism and by other forms of sexual radicalism. And anyone who's... Well, the psychotherapy, especially perhaps the most toxic form of all is
SPEAKER_00the couple's counseling, which, you know, many people think it should be just avoided like the plague. I think so too. It tends to, you know, put the therapist in the, well, it destroys the man's authority in the home just by that because the therapist becomes the referee. He said, she said, and the therapist decides which one is correct.
SPEAKER_01And we know which way they're going to decide.
SPEAKER_00Yeah. The man has no more authority over his wife or over the home or any of the family. It's a done deal, baby. It's just one plaintiff alongside the wife, and they're pitted in an adversarial role, and the counselor takes sides. And if it's forensic psychotherapy that is connected with the court, It's even more dangerous, downright, because it can be reported to the judge, it can be made of custody decisions, for example, or other decisions,
SPEAKER_00time decisions. And, you know, for example, if a therapist reports that, if the man takes a principled stand and says, I don't like talking about this, this isn't my way of dealing with things, I don't want to talk about my private family life in front of a stranger, And discuss my, you know, what should be a private sphere of life. And, you know, I want to talk about not how I feel. I don't want to talk about the morality of this and the legality. Well, then the psychotherapist could, if they become hostile, say, well,
SPEAKER_00the father is not being cooperative. He's not going along with it. So, you know, he's just an uncooperative, spiteful person. And, you know, you give custody of the children to the mother.
SPEAKER_01That's right.
SPEAKER_00So it's actually quite a dangerous, you know, my first book taken into custody. I draw on a number of studies that were going on back in the 90s and early 2000s showing the corruption of psychology, psychiatry in family courts.
SPEAKER_01Yep, yep. That's a lot of it. That's a lot I love it. It's a crazy place. And I think you're absolutely right that, you know, the feminists have taken over the therapy industry. And that's why it's all about safety now. But it's unsafe for men. You know, if you look at the graduate schools, I get I get emails maybe once a month or so from guys who are in graduate programs studying to be therapists. And what they say is absolutely stunning in the way they're being treated.
SPEAKER_01And most of them bail out. Most of them leave because they can't stand it. But they're being judged harshly. They're being told to shut up, that their thoughts don't matter. They're a man. They should shut up and let the women talk. That's the basic idea is that they have no voice whatsoever. It's gone. And their grades, of course, suffer because they're men. And they suffer in all kinds of ways because they're men. And it's a crazy place, really. I mean, it's so hate-filled. It's literally hate-filled. They hate men, and they're not ashamed to show it.
SPEAKER_01It's just stunning. I can't figure out how we could let such a thing happen.
SPEAKER_00You know, or how these people- Well, it's happened in so many of the professions all across the board. I mean, just anyone. I mean, just an absurd one. I mean, my field is history. Originally in political science and to some extent literature. And, you know, I saw those when I was in graduate school in the 1980s. I saw those fields being taken over, you know, as long ago as that by by feminism. So, you know, if I saw it in those fields, you can imagine the fields that are,
SPEAKER_00you know, involving family policy, things like not just psychotherapy, but social work is another one.
SPEAKER_01Oh, it's the worst.
SPEAKER_00Marginalized men taken over and politicized by radical women. Anything that has to do with caring for children, especially, the whole welfare machinery, all of these professions and virtually every academic field has been taken over by not just women, but by feminist women. Yes, yes. What do you think is the power they have to do that?
SPEAKER_01There must be a huge power behind it to be able to take over all these different places. What do you think is going on?
SPEAKER_00Yeah, well, I don't know what's going on. How they did it so easily. I mean, men tend to- Exactly. Women, they tend to let the ladies have their way. They tend to back down and avoid confrontations with women. It's a well-known principle, many people have argued, In certain areas, like sports, for example, it used to be a well-known principle. A man simply doesn't compete with a woman. You don't compete with women. It's not an athlete.
SPEAKER_00Especially in sports, a man doesn't, because he can't win. In sports, for example, he either wins, which proves nothing, or he loses, which proves that women are just as good as men at sports.
SPEAKER_01And then he's a wuss. He can't beat a woman. So no women.
SPEAKER_00Right. So if that happens in sports, you know, but so women don't want to compete with men generally in sports. They usually want to keep it separate. Even the feminists push back on that when the transgenderists try to muscle their way into the women's sports. Even the women don't want, they want the sports to be separate so they can win.
SPEAKER_01Right.
SPEAKER_00But every other place, they're perfectly happy to compete with men because they can win there, too, in the workplace, in the academics and journalism a long time ago. Yes. So in those areas where they can rig the game and win, they're very happy to compete with men. In those areas where they can't rig the game, like in sports, they want it separate, separate and equal, which it's not.
SPEAKER_01And they rig the game by claiming victimhood, which stimulates men's urge to take care of them and to protect them. It's a real racket.
SPEAKER_00But to go back to the question of psychotherapy, I think that there are areas in which psychotherapy and politics can and should Compliment one another. I think they can actually help. If you consider that the first, the earliest form of psychotherapy, at least in the Western world, was religion. The things that therapists used to do, sorry, the things that therapists do now are things that used to be done in the churches.
SPEAKER_00Priests and pastors. If there was a troubled marriage, troubled family dispute, who would intervene? The priest or the pastor would intervene, and unlike the therapist sometimes, at least in some instances, he did so with the consent of both parties, both the parents, both the spouses. So this was accepted. The place to sort out family difficulties was in the church.
SPEAKER_00If the congregation needed to become involved, they would become involved, again, with the consent of the family itself. There was no coercion, there was no courts, there was no legal proceedings, there was no Threat of punishment by the state, either in terms of dissolving the marriage or taking away the children or plundering one of the spouses or anything like that, let alone throwing one of them in jail. Completely non-coercive form of therapy.
SPEAKER_00And it wasn't perfect, of course. The other thing that it had, the other thing that religion had, was if a priest or pastor intervened in the family or the congregation intervened in a troubled family, they didn't get special pay for it. They weren't paid extra for doing this. They didn't get a financial stake in perpetuating it. It was something they had to do in addition The priest or pastor had to do this
SPEAKER_00in addition to preaching and all the other pastoral work he had to do. So he had no incentive to prolong the matter. He had no incentive to spit it all out because he didn't get paid for any of it. He had incentive to go into the family, knock their heads together, remind them of the moral issues involved, not talk too long about feelings, not include self-penny. But, you know, to get the problem sorted out, and if he couldn't do it, then call in the congregation, and they would help. Somebody would knock somebody's head together,
SPEAKER_00and if they couldn't knock somebody's heads together, one or both of the spouses or parents, they would threaten them with excommunication. They would ostracize them. They'd throw them out of the church. And you had an incentive to solve the problem. The problem today is that with therapists, in the courts, And in the same sort of lawyers, by the way, they have the opposite incentive. They are incentivized to inflame the situation and make it worse
SPEAKER_00because they're paid by the power. The more trouble there is and the more trouble they themselves cause and encourage, the more they get paid, whether they're lawyers, the legal practice, the judges, the whole lot of the entourage. The welfare workers, the social workers, you know, you name it. So that's, you know, the churches were amateurs in a way.
SPEAKER_00I mean, the priest or pastor was paid, of course, but he was paid a certain amount, and this is what he did, among other things. But he didn't have an incentive to inflame and exacerbate the situation. Right, right. Let alone the congregation. They too. If they had to intervene, it was time they took out from their own lives, their work or their families or whatever to help somebody else. They didn't want to drag on needlessly. So that's the big difference between one of the early forms.
SPEAKER_00The other thing that was different about religion, at least the Christian religion in the West, was there were certain attitudes that you had that you tried to encourage, even on a pastoral level. And one of them was, I think, you tried to discourage people from dwelling too much on their own feelings, on their own, you know, too much introspection.
SPEAKER_00One thing that, you know, I know pastors had to deal with a lot was self-pity and resentment. You know, these had to be discouraged. We all have this tendency if we think we're the victims of injustice. And by the way, this is true, I think, on a different level of seriousness and morality. It's true of women and feminists on the one hand, but it's also true to some extent of men in the manosphere. This is one of my biggest criticisms, the manosphere.
SPEAKER_00Emotions like resentment and soft pity and morbid introspection, these are debilitating. They're counterproductive. They don't help anybody, even when they're justified. Even when they're justified. I mean, I think that the resentment of the feminists, and this is a word that I've heard from Janice and Hannah and others, is how much feminism is pervaded by resentment. It's absolutely true, it is. Yes, it's fueled.
SPEAKER_00And that resentment, I think, like most of us these days, that resentment is on the whole not justified, that women have not been across throughout life history.
SPEAKER_01Right.
SPEAKER_00On the other hand, in my bias, I think that a lot of the resentment felt by men is justified. And it is, you know, they are the victims in many ways of injustice. But I also believe that even in men, dwelling on it too much, on that resentment and that self-pity, is also a very debilitating, incapacitating emotion. It doesn't do any good. It doesn't Doesn't help the situation.
SPEAKER_01Right.
SPEAKER_00And, you know, this was once a message. This is a message I've heard And, uh... in which if I wrote a book. My first book was on the Puritans. And the Puritans were very engaged with politics. They invented the first revolution. But they were also very careful to warn their congregations not to. Well, on the one hand, they would encourage resentment. And they would encourage self-pilling to a point, only to a point. And then they would channel it into collective action on behalf of the community
SPEAKER_00and on behalf of other people and on behalf of the cause, as they called it. So they didn't let people wallow in resentment and self-pilling. They just encouraged enough of it to get people hooked. And then they would channel that. That resentment, the self-pity, and the anger, into constructive religion, first of all. And from there, they would channel it from religion, religious faith, into political and civic activity.
SPEAKER_00And so, you know, in that respect, they were very skillful. I was going to say, it sounds civilized.
SPEAKER_01It sounds civilized.
SPEAKER_00And, yeah, and channeling them into Constructive, socially useful. Sometimes they went a little far. They ended up, you know, having a revolution, which, you know, caused problems. But, you know, the point is that this ethic became the basis in many ways of modern citizenship. And so, you know, you can do it to a point, but when you dwell on these things,
SPEAKER_00Then I think it becomes, it becomes counterproductive. Yeah.
SPEAKER_01Yeah. Yeah. The research today has shown that gratitude is the anti-problem. It's like you have gratitude, it erases a lot of that stuff, you know?
SPEAKER_00Absolutely.
SPEAKER_01It's interesting.
SPEAKER_00Gratitude is very important. Yeah, absolutely. You're grateful to God, you're grateful to those closest to you, your parents, first of all, your friends, your local community, the members of your congregation, and then from there to other people.
SPEAKER_01And that's exactly what feminists don't have. They don't have one ounce of gratitude. Zero.
SPEAKER_00Yes, like a lot of modern ideologies.
SPEAKER_01Yes, exactly.
SPEAKER_00I'll point out just one more thing. I can't help but point it out. One of the things that the Puritans used to talk about, one of the ways they discouraged this, this dwelling, was the concept, and this will strike a lot of people, modern liberal secularists, all of us in the modern world. It's strange, but one of the concepts they used was divine vengeance. Divine vengeance. And you think, oh, divine vengeance, it's so silly. You know, Jerry Falwell's ranting on about how the homosexuals are, you know,
SPEAKER_00how God is punishing the homosexuals with AIDS,
SPEAKER_01you know.
SPEAKER_00And there's very crude forms of the concept of divine vengeance. It can be very, it can be applied very crudely.
SPEAKER_01Yes.
SPEAKER_00But it is actually a very sophisticated concept, the way the Puritans used it. It was like this. There were different parts to it. One was, yes, if you're under oppression, if evil people are doing bad things to you, if you are convinced that you are a victim of injustice and oppression, and the wicked, the evil people are harming you, And it's not your fault. But then divine vengeance gives you a certain solace, gives you a certain consolation. God will punish them eventually. He may not punish them in this life. He may punish them in the next life.
SPEAKER_00But sooner or later, they'll get their comeuppance. So don't rant and rave. Don't rail against the evil and wicked and don't get all bitter. And discouraged, and again, self-pitying and resentment and all this, because these emotions are just, you know, so remember, God will deal with it. But where the liberals get it wrong, they say, oh, well, religion just makes people quiet. It makes people suffer in silence. No, no. Because the other half of the divine vengeance principle was God's also going
SPEAKER_00to judge you, right? And if you just sit there and wallow in self-pity, And wallow in your resentment and rant and rave against people who are doing bad things to you. And you don't get off your duff and do something about it. God's going to punish you as well as you.
SPEAKER_01And they said this.
SPEAKER_00They said this all the time. So divine vengeance is actually a very great motivator.
SPEAKER_01Yeah, I was going to say.
SPEAKER_00It would give you consolation. It gave you solace in the midst of your suffering. But it also encouraged you to get off your behind. And relieve the suffering of not just yourself, but other people who are suffering with you.
SPEAKER_01Yes.
SPEAKER_00You know, religion is, I think, it gets a bad rap. Yes. Because sometimes these concepts can be very... Creative.
SPEAKER_01Very creative.
SPEAKER_00And it's a way of feeling that those same emotions, those same emotions of... Of resentment, again, resentments of the victimhood, victim status. Yeah, there are victims. There are real victims who suffer in this world. Victims of injustice, especially injustice by the state. But if you're just wallowing your victimhood and don't do something about it and join with other victims and relieve them and relieve other people,
SPEAKER_00then they're Yeah, then it's only half the story. You're only paying attention to the part you want to hear.
SPEAKER_01Yes. So what message does that send to men today? Right.
SPEAKER_00Well, that's a very good question because, yeah, this is the complaint I have to some extent in the manosphere. The manosphere also is heavily criticized by feminists and liberals and so forth. I think for, well, for the wrong reasons. Everyone's lumped together with Andrew Tate, and he's the scapegoat for all of our sins, and we're all Andrew Tate's if we listen to the Manosphere.
SPEAKER_00The Manosphere is also criticized, I think, more constructively by other people, one of whom, what does Paul Eberman now call his new show, he calls it Repairing the Manosphere. And I think he talks about, I think his main target is some of the hedonism and self-centeredness and so forth of the, you know, and gynocentrism that lingers in the manuscript. And I think he's right to be critical of that. Mine is more the, you know, dwelling on the evils, dwelling on the suffering,
SPEAKER_00the oppression of men, injustices against men, without, you Doing without doing, you know, encouraging men to do anything about it. I mean, it's so easy with social media and the internet. It's so easy to listen to videos that tell you what you already believe. You know, they confirm you in your existing opinions. You click like. You know, and you make a comment about how, you know, and it's, yeah, right.
SPEAKER_00And it creates the illusion that you're doing something constructive, but in fact, you're just, you know, you're just, you're not. I mean, it doesn't lead anywhere. And to some extent that's necessary, perhaps, to some extent, to get men, to enlist men, to get them going, to get them out of their own private worlds. But I think it requires more. I think you have to, you know, It's not a substitute. Listening to videos, even good videos, even very good videos that I agree with,
SPEAKER_00but when they start telling me what I already know over and over again, then I want something more. I want them to start telling you what I can do about it. We've tried to do that on the Mansplainers, and I've tried to do that in my books. It's not just to elucidate the injustices, but to go a step further and try to give men pointers as to how
SPEAKER_00the injustices can constructively and realistically So what can men do? It's not just wish lists, it's not just wish lists, not just you know this is my prescription for if I had a magic wand but For, you know, for her. Practical steps for
SPEAKER_01taking
SPEAKER_00up arms so to speak. So what can men do? Good question. What can men do? Well, Yeah, that's the big one. First of all, I'm the first to admit, since we started on the subject of politics, I'm the first to admit that the traditional political methods don't work for men.
SPEAKER_01And they've never worked for men.
SPEAKER_00And they've never worked for men. I think they could work for men, but men just don't do it for some reason. They do it on other topics, but they don't do it on this.
SPEAKER_01Like what topics have men been successful? What topics have men been successful in changing government?
SPEAKER_00Well, I mean, men have been the leaders in most efforts to change the state, change government policy for over the centuries. For other people. Well, for other people or for problems they Perceive as sharing with other people. I mean, you know, men, for better or worse, haven't always done it. You know, I mean, men are leaders in most revolutions since the 16th and 17th centuries. Although it's enough, I won't go into this right now,
SPEAKER_00women have also been in the shadows of just about every modern revolution as well. That's something we need to maybe devote a show to some of the time, is how that happens. In the margins and in the shadows of all radical political ideologies, it's only in our lifetime that they have emerged with their own day in the sun.
SPEAKER_01Yeah, I just think that the - Well they're calling the shots.
SPEAKER_00And not fighting alongside men, they are fighting against men. That's the difference now.
SPEAKER_01I think it's important to understand that the number of times men have stood up for their own benefit and won something is very, very small in this country. We stand up for other people. Or the gays stood up for the gays, the women stood up for the women, the blacks stood up for the blacks.
SPEAKER_00But the men can't stand up for the men.
SPEAKER_01And there's reasons for that. There's reasons for that. But that's more than we're going to talk about today, I think. But I think it's important just to realize that that's the case, that men have never really in this country stood up for their own benefit, you know, together.
SPEAKER_00It's very difficult. They'll stand up for their country. They'll stand up for their social class. They'll stand up for their race. Right. They'll stand up for things which they share with other people, including women, but they won't stand up. And I see this over and over again, brave men, men whose physical courage is beyond doubt, men who have worked in dangerous professions, men who have served their country in uniform, men who have fought in foreign wars,
SPEAKER_00whose physical courage is beyond any doubt. And yet, When it comes to standing up to a woman, they will. For good reasons or bad or a combination of the two. Again, men can't compete with women and in some ways they can't They can't oppose women either. And maybe it's connected to a child.
SPEAKER_01And men have always had a hard time with that. Except I remember, Stephen, when I was young, I was 10, 11, 12 years old. I'd go around the neighborhood to my friends' houses. I'd be playing with them, doing something. And I'd hear the fathers and mothers talking about things. And I'm telling you, the fathers were really good at saying no. No, honey, we're not going to do that now because we don't have the money. We can save. We can save for that. I heard that over and over again. And the mother would say, okay, okay.
SPEAKER_01But he knew how to say no in a calm way, in a way that could be heard. That, I think, is one of the things we can help men start practicing, is if we want to make change, start learning to say no in a calm and pleasant way. The kryptonite for feminists is calmness and logic. If we can learn to be calm and logical, they go crazy with that. And they're trying to get you to get upset too.
SPEAKER_01Don't take the bait. Don't take the bait. Stick with your strength, which is logic and calmness, which has been men's strength for centuries. But we've been shamed out of it. We've got to reignite that in men. That capacity, that interest in being calm and loving and forcefully saying no. Oh, that's power.
SPEAKER_00Very true. You're right. You're right. There has been, not that long ago, men were able to say no to women. Look at some of the movies from the 40s and 50s. Right, right. Actors like Humphrey Bogart and John Wayne and Chris Wood.
SPEAKER_01Franklin, my dear, I don't give a damn.
SPEAKER_00Yeah, there we go. Clark Gable, yeah. Absolutely. So it's not like it's a universal thing. I think they're intimidated by, I guess, I think feminism has feminized all of us in many ways. It's the impact of feminism. Well, I'll just talk about that for a minute because it's worth it. The point I've developed in my book I'm working on now is the way it is It is, it is, feminization has emasculated men.
SPEAKER_00And it started with the poor, poor low income men, because they're the most vulnerable. It's worked its way up. The first institutional emasculation of them was the welfare state. And there you had, again, low-income men, minority men mostly. And they were emasculated by the welfare state, taking over their function of protector and provider. And this, by the way, is an old theme in African-American literature.
SPEAKER_00Writers like Richard Wright and Ralph Ellison and James Baldwin were writing about emasculation. And they attributed it, I don't think they got it quite right, they attributed it to racism. With some justice for it. But I think a lot of it came not from racism, but from things like welfare and from paternalism. Anyway, from there, emasculation spread from the welfare system to the divorce system. It went from the low-income men to the middle-class men through the divorce system.
SPEAKER_00Along the way, it emasculated the churches, the pastors and the priests, who were well-known with their diffidence, their pusillanimity, their spinelessness. David Edgington's new book, What's it called? Scolding wives, reviling wives and white knights or something. He's very good on that, but others have pointed this out as well. And the emasculation.
SPEAKER_00And I think the most recent emasculation is the emasculation of the conservatives. They talk about manhood, write books about manhood.
SPEAKER_01Oh, God. So true.
SPEAKER_00And I think those are the latest casualties, because in their way, they, you know, Paul Rehman's very good on this kind of centrism, Peter Wright, about how they engage in this false, phony chivalry. Which actually, unlike real chivalry, it doesn't require any courage. It's actually in some ways a manifestation of cowardice, the inability to offend women, offend feminists, and even to ally themselves to collaborate with feminists.
SPEAKER_00So it's, you know, feminism is very effective at neutering its own opposition and emasculating men from the lowest socially speaking status wise to the highest. And, you know, all the way up, look at the men who were accused of, you know, the men who were emasculated by false accusations of various gender crimes, you know, Bill Cosby, Brett Kavanaugh, Supreme Court nominee, Donald Trump,
SPEAKER_00President of the United States, the Prince of York. You name it. Men at the very highest level are wilted under this pressure. So it is very effective and I think we need to be conscious of it. But I didn't really answer your question about what can men do. And I think one of the things they are doing Well, one of the things they are doing,
SPEAKER_00which I see as a good thing and a bad thing, actually, and that is they are withdrawing. They are withdrawing from the world of women, dating, courtship, marriage, families, children, you name it. They're just withdrawing from that whole world to varying degrees, of course, different than varying degrees, but they're just pulling out.
SPEAKER_00On the one hand, I understand why some people criticize this severely. I think on the one hand, if this is done out of fear, purely out of fear, out of apathy, Out of, you know, well out of what's the word. Demoralization. Then it is indeed sad. It's bad for our society, but it's also sad for the men. They're depriving themselves of one of life's great joys.
SPEAKER_00Marriage, family, children. I mean, this really is a joy if it works well. It's a great thing, and it's necessary to our civilization, and it's necessary to our species. So on the one hand, purely withdrawing from the world of families, marriage, women, if it's done for purely selfish reasons and out of not only fear but impotence
SPEAKER_00and the feeling of powerlessness.
SPEAKER_01Right, right.
SPEAKER_00And it's bad. On the other hand, if it's done for the right reasons, I think it could be actually very constructive. I think men in some ways have no choice. And that is, you know, if you look at something like, I mean, Helen Smith and her book on this topic called The Marriage Strike or The Marriage Boycott. And like any boycott or strike, it should be a means to an end. It should be a way of regaining leverage Yes.
SPEAKER_00Well, regaining self-respect, first of all. Regaining self-reliance. A way for men to start living themselves on their own terms without necessarily seeking, as Erom says and others say, the approval of a woman. So that's good. But also to gain leverage over the sphere of life. They say the sphere of life, in my opinion, you know. The central problem, the central leverage that feminism has given to feminists,
SPEAKER_00women, men, is the control of sex and reproduction. These are the two big things that they get that men have lost. They've lost any role in setting the terms of sex, sexual relationships, and setting the terms of reproduction. And they need to get that back. And the only way they can get that back, in my opinion, is to withdraw from them for the time being.
SPEAKER_00The only one I see in the way. And this doesn't mean you don't try to change the laws. You do try to change the law. But you try to get the leverage back. In order to change the laws, you need to get leverage. And the way to get that leverage is to withdraw from that world for a while and hope, and I think it's a realistic hope, that there are enough good women uh out there that they value men in their lives uh that they want to get married that they want to have children with a man
SPEAKER_00in a legitimate marriage and they want to have a family um and they want to do it uh you know and and they will do help and they will ally themselves with men um to do this but also hopefully to change the laws because we do need to change things. There's no point in politics. We have to do it.
SPEAKER_01Yes.
SPEAKER_00But we have to get the leverage. You're just writing letters to your congressman or lobbying the statehouse or even
SPEAKER_01media institutions.
SPEAKER_00You know, it doesn't work. It hasn't worked. We failed at that. We need to get leverage to make the efforts, the legislative and litigation efforts work. Otherwise, they won't work. Yes.
SPEAKER_01One of the biggest things I think MGTOW, men going their own way, does is it wakes people up. You know, people, what? They're staying away from it. What? It's like, why? And then they start understanding what's going on underneath things. And so that's my hat is off to these guys for doing that, for being able to start people to wake up a little bit. Because people are really asleep. People are tremendously asleep. They're completely ignorant of what's going on for men.
SPEAKER_01And that's one of the best ways I've seen of helping people to wake up a little bit. So...
SPEAKER_00Yeah, no, they face the problem, the hurdle they face is that, you know, this is being spun all kinds of negative ways by the feminists and by the tradcons and by the liberals. Right. By the entire political class. Right. This fun is male plurality. Men can't grow up. They can't accept responsibility. They're incels. They can't, you know, women don't like them. They're rejected by women, so they're incels.
SPEAKER_01He's going to take his ball and go home. Yeah, right. Or balls and
SPEAKER_00go home. It's very interesting. Roger Devlin points this out. Men are either sexual predators. Or sexual losers. They can't be anything else. They're either successful with women, in which case they're predators like Russell Brandt, or they're unsuccessful with women, in which case they are insane and pathetic and potential terrorists. They can't just be bachelors.
SPEAKER_00Or they haven't gotten married yet because they haven't found the right woman because there aren't too many Really appealing women out there. Oh boy. But, you know, so they, you know, the propaganda just, I mean, the MGTOW supplies the raw material for this. Well, we need to get control of the narrative too. We need to get the spin. Yes, yes. Rest the spin away from the tradcoms and the liberals and the feminists.
SPEAKER_01How did feminists gain the narrative? And one of the ways they did it was through therapy. The kind of therapy they'd give to these women was not just, you know, what can you do today? It was you're being hurt by this system. The system's hurting you. They moved millions of women with those kinds of arguments. And I'm not suggesting we do that with men because men wouldn't buy that crap. But I think it tells us a little bit about the feminist therapy that we've seen. It's geared towards ideology, not towards personal growth.
SPEAKER_01Absolutely.
SPEAKER_00No, very true. And, you know, we see that. I mean, we see that. I think it's important now to point out these days. We've seen the logical conclusion of that. We've seen this thing about, you know, what is it called? This psychosis invoked in the case of Lindsay Clancy. And justifying the murder of her children. And that is not just psychotherapy, it's ideology.
SPEAKER_01Yes, yes.
SPEAKER_00It's the blending of therapy with ideology.
SPEAKER_01Yes, exactly right.
SPEAKER_00And that's what's really dangerous.
SPEAKER_01Yep. And if you say anything negative about this ideology, you're abandoned. You're the bad guy.
SPEAKER_00In fact, I would argue these days, it's a long run that we've raised that topic. I would say one place that psychotherapy could be, psychological psychology generally could be very profitably directed these days would be to... I'm not a clinician by any means, but I think the behavior of the women who support and even admire Lindsay Clancy, Could be described as a form of psychosis.
SPEAKER_00I think the word psychosis is misplaced in that case. It's not Lindsay Clancy, well, she is as well, but these women who have this mass insanity, this mass psychosis, this is something that needs to be examined very carefully. Well, you know, this happened during COVID. Many people were trying to explain why so many people swallowed the COVID.
SPEAKER_00Why so many people went along with this and became just hysterical about COVID. And there was a prominent psychologist named Desmet who came up with a book called The Psychology of Totalitarianism or something like that. And he invented this term mass What was it? Not just mass psychosis, mass formation psychosis. Right, right. And to explain this mass hysteria.
SPEAKER_00In fact, I don't know why people made a fuss of it. I read this in the book, and it strikes me very much as stuff we used to hear from the 50s and 60s and 70s in the aftermath of totalitarianism. You know, Hannah Arendt and... And some of the others, some of the other writers, who was that one, I don't remember the name offhand, but, you know, the lonely crowd who wrote the book, Reisman, the lonely crowd.
SPEAKER_00How society was atomized, society is fractured, people are lonely, they swallow, they look for a leader, they look for a demagogue, they follow a mass ideology, and so forth. And this was taken to explain the COVID hopes. And this is the kind of thing that was evoked in the 50s and 60s and 70s to explain, to tell, you know, Legitimately, explain Nazism,
SPEAKER_00fascism, Polonism, Communism, various forms of extremist ideology. Well, I'd like to see some, I don't know why, as far as I know, Desmond has not applied that theory to feminism, but it seems to me that could be very easily applied.
SPEAKER_01Directly applied.
SPEAKER_00These young women. Yes. And easily feminism is young, Either uneducated or overeducated women, depending on how you look at it, who buy into this to the point where they will excuse, not just excuse, celebrate, admire women like Jane Doe, who obviously facticated these rape allegations at Cornell University, or Lindsay Plassie, who's asked for by any
SPEAKER_00Falling down drunk. Where's the therapy profession when it comes to this?
SPEAKER_01Really? Really? They're encouraging it. That's what they're doing. But these people are falling down drunk on ideology. I mean, these women who are, you know, pro-Clancy, you know, it's like they're just completely drunk on ideology. They have no moral compass at all. It's gone, except for their ideology. And that's dangerous.
SPEAKER_00That's really dangerous. Absolutely. We know that ideologies can justify, rationalize, dead, you know, mass killing. I mean, we have the Kool -Aid. Of much Revolution onward. You know, Stalinism and fascism, I mean, you know, radical ideologies have justified mass killing on a scale that, you know, traditional governments also have killed people in large numbers,
SPEAKER_00but not so many in such a short period of time. You know, this is what the killing that results from mass ideologies is, you know, horrible bloodbaths in a relatively short period of time.
SPEAKER_01Right.
SPEAKER_00And that's, you know, much more akin to it. So it shouldn't surprise anybody that an ideology like this is used to rationalize and justify women who abuse, well, it's been good for years, who abuse their children. And now it's being used openly to women who kill their children. Where's the check on out of this?
SPEAKER_01There's only one good thing that's coming from that. The good thing that's coming from that is I think some people are waking up. Some people are saying, this is too much for me. I can't buy this anymore. And with the Clancy thing, with the Jane Doe thing, it's like people are starting to wake up a little bit. They're starting to say, wait a minute. They think what? So it's like feminism is starting to crumble a little bit. We're seeing some of the crumbling and we need lots more crumbling.
SPEAKER_00You're right. You're right. We did see this with Brunswick-Ponsky. People were pushing back. Even the people in the mainstream media said this was too much. Men were starting to sever their relationships with Women, including their fiancées, engaged men. Yes. Women condoned or celebrated Lindsay Clancy. And so, yeah, you're right. You're right.
SPEAKER_00We did start to see this. So it's maybe her children didn't die in vain.
SPEAKER_01Indeed. Indeed. Maybe it's part of the wake-up goal.
SPEAKER_00That's the only thing we can hope for.
SPEAKER_01Yeah, that's true. That is correct. Are we about there? Yeah. What have we left out, Stephen? Anything?
SPEAKER_00Well, I'm sure we've left out a lot. It'll occur to me the rest of the evening. That's it.
SPEAKER_01That's it. We'll figure it out later. It's been a good discussion, though. It's been interesting.
SPEAKER_00But, yeah, I think it's... I'm glad to see people in the profession. Like you and Hannah and Paul and others, you know, calling this stuff out. And that was another effect of the Clancy case I found. I found a lot of psychology. Well, on the one hand, I was chagrined because the Clancy case was the overwhelming majority of the videos I saw on it did debate it
SPEAKER_00in psychotherapeutic terms. Not in terms of ideology. Janice Diomengo is one. I tried to emphasize the role of feminism. A lot of people did leave out feminism as a reluctant to blame feminism, and they wanted to shift the discussion onto psychotherapy, you know, into psychotherapy in terms. On the other hand, I did see a number of psychotherapists on me making videos that said, this is bogus.
SPEAKER_00This is not what it's about and what it should be. Correct. We should not be excusing this kind of thing. Correct. That made me a bit hopeful.
SPEAKER_01Yeah. On a hopeful note, that's a good thing. And I'm glad both our internets worked for the whole time. Something to be grateful for. So thank you very much, Stephen. It's been good.
SPEAKER_00Thank you, Tom. I've enjoyed it.
SPEAKER_01Me too. Me too. We'll have to do it again. You all take care. Men are good, as are you. [music]
Men’s Issues: Past, Present, and Future - with Warren Farrell & David Maywald I was grateful to sit down with two men I greatly admire: Warren Farrell, whose fifty years of work have helped shape the modern conversation...
How does an accusation against a handful of men become an indictment of men everywhere? That question is at the heart of this conversation with Hannah Spier, Janice Fiamengo, James Nuzzo, and me. Starting with the...
We are getting a head start on International Falsely Accused day on Sept 9th!How many false allegations of sexual abuse are there? We are often told they are extremely rare - perhaps only one to three percent. But those...
What if one of the most common claims in health policy simply isn’t true? We’ve all heard the refrain: women are underfunded, under-researched, and left behind by the medical establishment. It’s repeated so often that...
This video explores the enormous challenges men face when they are falsely accused. It also examines our culture’s tendency to overlook or dismiss men’s emotional pain, particularly in situations involving false...