Skip to content
PodSubs
ShowsPeopleGuestsJobsNewsEvents
More
BlogPodCred
Menu
ShowsPeopleGuestsJobsNewsEventsBlogPodCredNetworksSign in
Join nowSign in
  • Shows
  • People
  • Jobs
  • News
  • More
    • Guests
    • Events
    • Blog
    • PodCred
    • Networks
    Join nowSign in

MenAreGood Substack Podcast

MenAreGood Substack Podcast artwork

Seven Men Accused. All Men on Trial.

Oct 22, 202651 minAudio
ShareXLinkedInFacebookWhatsAppEmail

How does an accusation against a handful of men become an indictment of men everywhere? That question is at the heart of this conversation with Hannah Spier, Janice Fiamengo, James Nuzzo, and me. Starting with the public reaction to the Cornell Seven case, we examine how quickly allegations become accepted as facts - and how easily the discussion shifts from what particular individuals may have done to what is supposedly wrong with men. Janice explores the ideas behind that shift: the longstanding portrayal of male sexuality as predatory, the readiness to assign collective guilt, and the striking tolerance for public threats against accused men. I discuss survey findings featured in my recent “Blame Men” post and the psychological costs of locating responsibility for our difficulties in someone else. James examines research on false allegations, explaining what commonly cited statistics measure - and what they leave unresolved. We also consider the University of Maryland case, where a finding of “not responsible” did not end a male student’s public vilification, and ask what universities owe the people whose lives their decisions can profoundly change. For me, a thread running through this conversation is the invisibility of male suffering. The damage an accusation can do to a man’s relationships, livelihood, and future deserves serious attention. So does his right to a fair hearing. Taking sexual assault seriously requires careful attention to evidence. Taking men’s humanity seriously requires the same. Jim’s Substack Janices SubstackHannah’s Substack Thanks for reading MenAreGood Substack! This post is public so feel free to share it. MenAreGood Substack is a reader-supported publication. To receive new posts and support my work, consider becoming a free or paid subscriber. This is a public episode. If you'd like to discuss this with other subscribers or get access to bonus episodes, visit menaregood.substack.com/subscribe

Audio and video play straight from the show's own hosting. PodSubs stores and serves no media.

Transcript

From the show. Tap a time to play from there.

SPEAKER_01Hannah from Psychobabble has provided me with the raw footage from a recent interview. Hope you enjoy it. Men are good.

SPEAKER_00Hi, everyone. Welcome back to Psychobabble. In the last two episodes, we talked about the Cornell 7 case in detail, so we're not going to go over that again. Now I want to focus on the more important question, which is what happened after the reaction Because before anything was even resolved, politicians, celebrities, activists, they all came out and it went to become sweeping claims, generalizations about men. And that is very dangerous.

SPEAKER_00It's dangerous for our sons, for our brothers, our husbands, our fathers. As we saw, one of the accused reportedly lost his job before any of the criminal charges had even been brought against him. And Cornell is not an isolated case. This goes far beyond that. Newly at the University of Maryland, a male student was accused of sexual assault and found not responsible, but it didn't end.

SPEAKER_00He continued to be publicly branded a rapist, and a federal jury has now found the university liable for how it handled the harassments that followed. So today we're going to go beyond the Cornell 7. Janice Fiamengo She has an amazing piece over on her Substack, The Fiamengo File. She's been looking at the reactions to the case, what people ended up saying about these seven men, how quickly the accusation became a much broader story about men and rape culture.

SPEAKER_00That brings us to the question, how did we get to this knee-jerk reaction where accusations so quickly become a thing of certainty? How did we get here? And that's where we'll go to Tom Golden. He is the host and the author of Men Are Good. His Substack, he has uncovered some amazing survey data that we'll go through that highlights what women, that women Already see men's behavior as responsible for their problems.

SPEAKER_00And then why does this matter? What is the actual reality of false accusations? That's where we have Jim Newso with us. He is the author of the Newso letter over on Substack. And he'll take us through the statistics behind false accusations. What is the reality? And what are the statistics really telling us? So welcome, everyone.

SPEAKER_01Thank you. Good to be here.

SPEAKER_00Let's go first to you, Janice. Why do you think it so quickly became a story about men?

SPEAKER_02It is interesting isn't it? We go from seven individuals to all men in a split second and it's worth saying I think that not only have there been no criminal charges yet and no investigation of criminal charges but there already was an investigation two years ago I think 1100 pages of documents in the Cornell University's own survivor centered investigation and that found, well,

SPEAKER_02did make some punishments against these students, but did not find that Jane Doe had been assaulted. The sworn affidavit that she filled out and that was sent over to the district attorney did not result in criminal charges because the district attorney determined that everything had been consensual. All of this, of course, is completely forgotten in the rush to judgment. Why does it become all men? Well, because women like making those kinds of sweeping statements and they're able

SPEAKER_02to get away with making them with no blowback and no kind of punishment. Whatsoever, that is the era we live in. Some unfounded, so far, allegations against individual men become yet another occasion for a discussion of rape culture, patriarchy, sexual violence, objectification of women, and so on.

SPEAKER_00And you also highlighted some of the specific reactions Could you tell us about them?

SPEAKER_02Yeah, and I did want to say one more thing about the climate that we live in that makes this possible. I think it starts with a general Cultural climate that tends to feel much more deeply the harms that women experience that we sometimes refer to this as gamma bias. That's a theory that was developed by Martin Seeger and John Berry. And it is basically the idea that female virtue and female suffering are emphasized

SPEAKER_02and magnified in our culture, whereas male virtue and male suffering are minimized. And then on top of that substratum, that cultural substratum, feminism built the demonization of masculinity, especially of masculine sexuality. And so we can go back to Susan Griffin and Susan Brownmiller in the early 1970s. Brownmiller famously declared in her book Against Our Will, Men,

SPEAKER_02Women and Rape, that rape is nothing less than a conscious, Program of intimidation by which all men keep all women in a state of fear. And notice the word conscious. So she claimed that rapists act on behalf of all men because all men prefer women to be terrified. And when there are rapists in our culture, it keeps women terrified and that allegedly benefits men. So that was the idea in 1975 and people accepted that nonsense.

SPEAKER_02And then it went on from there. And we had Andrea Dworkin in the early 1980s claiming that not only rape, but all heterosexual sexuality was the pure sterile expression of male contempt for women. And when we finally got to about 1989 with Catherine McKinnon, a colleague of Dworkin's who claimed she was also a Professor of Law, who claimed that the only difference between normal sex and rape was that

SPEAKER_02the normal happened so often it was impossible to get anybody to see anything wrong with it. So that was the climate that developed, stoked by feminist anger in the 1970s and 1980s, and it has now percolated out into the general culture So that we believe that male sexuality in general is objectifying, it's predatory and it's abusive. So therefore we get all sorts of people making pronouncements

SPEAKER_02about how men enjoy rape, don't think there's anything wrong with it, giggle when they find out that their friends rape and so on.

SPEAKER_00Yeah. I really liked in your piece, because I don't read articles like that. They don't pop up in my feed. And so you said that Selma L. Wardady said, the monster that lives in every man. And so that I found very shocking how you highlighted what they're writing about, these sweeping claims about men after,

SPEAKER_00you know, this is clearly just, this hasn't even been resolved yet.

SPEAKER_02No, no. And I'm sure many of these women making these various sweeping anti-male generalizations haven't even really dug into the details. They're not interested in the details. This is just for them. A good opportunity to brush off their statements and to say once again that every man has a monster inside of him, as in that example, that we should all be thinking about extrajudicial justice as one of the other Substack writers claimed. In other words,

SPEAKER_02unless Cornell and the District Attorney act very quickly to punish these particular men, We're going to take justice into our own hands and we're going to start enacting violence against these men and all men that we determine are a danger. And as I claim in my Substack essay, that call to violence has been prepared by feminist theorists and advocates for decades. And again, it's never been called out. We have Sally Miller Gearhart saying that if there's going to be a future,

SPEAKER_02it'll have to be female. And the population of men will have to be reduced to 10% of the human population. She said we should do it non-violently, but obviously the implication is the fewer men who are around, the better off we're going to be. We now see on TikTok. Women celebrating sex-selective abortion, if they find out that they're having a male child, they will abort that child and encourage one another to do that and celebrate women who do so.

SPEAKER_02We see women like Mona El-Tahawi, an Egyptian-American activist who claimed that women should practice preemptive violence. Against men. She doesn't get any pushback for that. I mean, she gets some, but she still does her book tour and is widely applauded. We have legal theorists like Marianne Franks saying that we need a redistribution of violence so that women commit more violence against men in order to make men afraid, allegedly, so that men will stop committing violence against women if they're afraid of women.

SPEAKER_02And that women who commit violence against men should be treated more leniently in the criminal justice system. Of course, they always are. I mean, the climate anti-male hatred is stoked deliberately by these various figures. And, you know, we see, of course, the Senate Minority Leader Chuck Schumer already assuming that Jane Doe is a Is a victim, a survivor, as he called her. We have Hollywood stars calling for these men to be castrated.

SPEAKER_02We have all sorts of people on TikTok calling for these individual men whose names and faces are available anywhere you want to find them. They don't get their anonymity. Calling for them to be hunted down and murdered. If something does happen to any one of these men, We would all have a collective responsibility. I've not seen a single one of these figures of authority, whether it's the Attorney General of New York or the Governor of New York or any

SPEAKER_02of these people who are talking about survivors and terrible crimes, I've not seen a single one of them step forward and say that the calls to violence against these men are completely unacceptable in a decent society. So I find it quite remarkable how willing so, so many of us are in the name of righteousness and concern for victims to come forward and to countenance these kinds of hideous calls for violence against men that don't even have any criminal charges laid against them yet.

SPEAKER_01Amen.

SPEAKER_00And how quickly they were doxxed. That was shocking to me how she still remains Jane Doe. And I've used that myself simply out of fear if there's a 1% chance. But how quickly all of their names and pictures were revealed, that was astonishing.

SPEAKER_02It really is. It's amazing to me. All of these figures quite happy to speak about violence against them as if that's a righteous thing to do. It's just remarkable. What happened to the presumption of innocence, the importance of due process in criminal legal proceedings, all of that just gets thrown out when there's an opportunity for grandstanding on behalf of female victims.

SPEAKER_00There was something else that you said as well, how even those Even conservatives had a hard time that they sort of felt obliged to talk about the men's behavior. Yes.

SPEAKER_02Yeah, as reprehensible, disgusting, horrible. Yeah, everyone, even those who are saying, hold on, let's not rush to judgment. They still have to judge. We all have to worship at the altar of the female victim. We've all, to some extent, it seems, accepted that female sexuality in any encounter, even if it wasn't criminal, In any encounter, female sexuality is passive, it's benign, it's never hurtful. Male sexuality by its nature, even if not criminal, is somehow wrong.

SPEAKER_02It's dehumanizing, you know, it's about power. It's aggressive. I do not accept that. We don't even know what these young men were thinking or experiencing in that moment. I am not going to assume that what they primarily wanted was to assert power. That they wanted to degrade and dehumanize her and yet that is the fallback assumption. Feminists have been enormously successful in convincing us all

SPEAKER_02that there's something wrong with male sexuality and never anything wrong with female sexuality. It's amazing.

SPEAKER_00I mean I myself said you know I do think that all of their behavior Was immoral. And I hope that my sons will never go into a situation like that. But I make that claim. I think that she should also have been expelled, that we should also say that her behavior was disgusting. And in that context, you can talk about all of their behavior. And I'll make a separate episode on why I'll make that claim that this is all immoral.

SPEAKER_00So I didn't hear all of their statements, these conservatives, if they also condemned her behavior.

SPEAKER_02No, they never do. Of course not. No, no, no. Nobody ever condemns a woman because she might be an innocent victim. So yeah, there is no even-handedness if one wants to take a moral stance on this issue. I mean, this isn't the place to get into it, but we never talk anymore about the provocation that was likely involved in this case and who is more responsible in that kind of a situation.

SPEAKER_02Do women have no Responsibility whatsoever not to tempt men. We used to talk about that sort of thing, but that's been ruled out of order now. We never talk about the fact that young men have an extremely powerful sexual urge. Feminists have taught us that we're all just blank slates and that even sexuality itself is simply an effect of cultural conditioning. So we can't talk about the reality of what young men feel in relation to seeing

SPEAKER_02a naked young woman. All of that is just ruled out of order. The falsity, the dangerous falsity, false notions under which we're all operating doesn't help us to have any kind of honest or useful discussions.

SPEAKER_00Okay, so let's dig deeper, let's go a bit behind. And I think we have to ask the question, how did we get here? Janice got into it a little bit before how we made this fertile soil for this to happen. Tom, can you tell us a bit about what you discovered about women's attitudes and beliefs?

SPEAKER_01Yeah. You know, what Janice was talking about and described so well is that Women are victims. I mean, everything she said, the end product is, we must be victims. Men are terrible. Men do this. Men do that. They're doing all sorts of things. We're victims. And if you take that victim stance, then what happens? You blame someone else for your situation, right? It's what we see over and over and over again. So I ran into these charts.

SPEAKER_01I ran into the, it was a survey by What was it, the Survey Center on American Life? And they were talking about young Democratic women most likely to blame men for their problems, right? I thought, well, that's interesting. So I looked at it. They only had one chart up there, though. And that chart, you see it now, it showed the Democratic women,

SPEAKER_01Had answered a question much differently from the Republican women. The question was, men's behavior or actions contribute a great deal to the challenges women face in American society. In other words, do you blame men for women's problems? And you can see this chart here, the Democrats, 66% of the young Democrats Said, yes, a great deal. It's men's fault. And the Republicans are lower. And then the next age up, it's 54% and on and on.

SPEAKER_01But it keeps the Republicans low and it keeps the Democrats higher. And I think that this particular group has a Republican bent and they wanted to show that the Democrats are probably worse than the Republicans and so be it. But it made me wonder, you know, if they did this survey, there must be more to it than just this one chart. But I couldn't find it anyplace. But they did have the data. They had the data for all the questions. And so I downloaded the data,

SPEAKER_01fed it into AI, and started asking AI questions about, okay, well, what else did they say? Oh boy. And so when you find what else they said, so the first question was, the answer was a great deal of women's challenges are caused by men. The next question was a fair amount of men's challenges or women's challenges are men's fault, right? So when you put those two together, you get a very, very different picture.

SPEAKER_01Now to me, a fair amount means like what, between 25 and 50%, right? And a great deal means above 50%, you would think. So it's still a considerable amount. But look at this chart. Look at the dark blue shows the Democrat who said a great deal. And the light blue shows the Democrats who said a fair amount. And of course, with the Republicans, the dark red shows the great deal. And the light red shows a fair amount. And look at what you see.

SPEAKER_01What you see is that above 90%, Above 90% of all Democrats of all ages, they think at least a fair amount of their problems, of women's problems, are men's fault. 90%, come on. But here's the kicker. Look at the Republicans. The Republicans, when you add a fair amount, they answered the question a fair amount instead of a great deal. About 70% of Republican women think the same thing. A fair amount of women's challenges are caused by men.

SPEAKER_01So what does this tell us? This tells us, uh-oh, Houston, we have a problem here. Most women have been influenced, I think, by decades of feminist ideas that Janice so described about how men are the problem, men are terrible, men do this, men do that, and they see themselves as victims and they see themselves as needing to blame men for their problems. Now that's a sad and sorry state, but even more sorry is What happens to people who believe that someone else is

SPEAKER_01to blame for their problems? Which is what we can say most women today think men are to blame for at least a fair amount of their problems. And so I came up with five things. Actually, with the help of AI, I came up with five things. One is the loss of examination. When you blame someone else, you're not thinking about what your side is. You're not thinking, how did I contribute to this? You're thinking, who did this to me? And that makes it easier to repeat the same mistakes over and over and over again.

SPEAKER_01Number two, more defensiveness. When you blame someone else, you get more defensive. Feedback can feel like an unfair accusation rather than useful information. Number three, difficulty repairing relationships. Apologizing, acknowledging someone else's pain, changing behavior becomes harder if the person sees responsibility as entirely belonging to other party, right? So you're not thinking about your part of things. And of course, what's happening here? You know, this is the gold that the alchemists talked about changing lead into gold.

SPEAKER_01But really, when we see our own problems, when we see we're responsible for something, that's when we change the lead into gold. So really what we're seeing here is the reverse. We're seeing women turning gold into lead. The gold is looking at yourself and saying, oops, I did that. I won't do that again. Or oops, my problem. I'm so sorry that I did that. We don't see that anymore. You certainly don't see it in relationships as you did before.

SPEAKER_01But number four, a diminished sense of agency. If others are always the cause of your difficulties, you may also come to believe that improvements depend entirely upon them. Your focus becomes changing them rather than changing yourself. So if your agency is diminished because you think someone else is the fault, you're going to focus on changing them. What do we see with feminism? It's all about changing men. Everything. And zero about changing women.

SPEAKER_01I mean, my gosh. And then the last one, growing mistrust and resentment. Expecting mistreatment can encourage defensive or uncooperative behavior, which may provoke responses that reinforce the original expectation. In other words, if you think something bad's going to happen, it increases the chances that it is going to happen. So when you put all these five things together, you kind of get a good idea of what's going on in today's world. With women in so many ways seeming to not take responsibility for their side

SPEAKER_01of things, to blame men for that, and therefore their maturity actually is being blocked. At least that's my way of looking at it. What do you all think?

SPEAKER_00Yeah, I think that is the core of feminism. That is what will define someone as a feminist, not whether or not they say, oh yes, I belong to that ideology. That's why I'm saying that there's I see this in all of the relationships that I've seen in so many patients that I've seen. They come in and they want to change the husband. It's all about the husband, you know, the mental load he's giving me this. So when you say that directly translate to to that, that the resentment that they already bring into the relationships,

SPEAKER_00it starts deteriorating before they've even started. Janice, what did you want to say?

SPEAKER_02Yeah, just the same thing really. I mean, the reduced empathy for the sex that is seen to be causing the problems is so marked and we do see that if men are the problem, then we don't care that men have problems. We only care about the problems that they cause.

SPEAKER_00Correct.

SPEAKER_02And I just think we see that all across our culture. And of course, it does do something to the moral psychology of women. I think it really profoundly damages women's ability to be morally accountable for their own harms that they cause. And yeah, it's extremely damaging. Yes. Yeah.

SPEAKER_00But it also prevents them from feeling gratitude. That's what I think is the most damaging because they go into relationship with the feeling that men already have taken so much. So they don't owe them anything. So why should I say thank you when you have already taken from me? And that is so, gratitude is so important in relationship. It's a strong predictor for whether or not it will succeed. And so it's that and that it's directly preventing maturity because they will not take responsibility when there's always someone else to blame.

SPEAKER_01Right, right. This is the five-year-old. The five-year-old rarely takes responsibility unless you really work with them. You know, it's just a natural thing and they don't grow up. They start growing up when they start realizing, uh oh, my fault.

SPEAKER_00Yeah. And you also had, back to what happened in the Cornell 7, where this Jane Doe, she didn't feel victimized at first. And then it seems that after talking to her friends, after seeing how it turned out, that, oh, this did actually damage her reputation and all of that, and she was disinvited to a party, then she started feeling more and more victimized. And Tom, you had an interesting...

SPEAKER_00Yes, it's transforming moral regret into criminal acts.

SPEAKER_01That's kind of the way I see this. I'm not saying that's what she did exactly, but just that process of moral regret. Oh, I shouldn't have done that. And then somehow ideology shifts that idea into this is a criminal act. Someone has hurt you. He's the real problem. Wake up. You've been raped. Oh, my goodness. I remember asking my mother one time. Years ago, years ago, and I was first in studying psychology,

SPEAKER_01and I asked her, I said, Mom, do you think women have any responsibility if they're raped? She looked at me, she said, of course they do. Now, if she'd said that in today's world, she would have been pilloried. She would have been thrown out the window. But I think she was right. Women do have some responsibility, and we have moral blinders to being able to see that. Is that what you're looking for, Hannah? Hannah?

SPEAKER_00Yes, I was looking for where you're talking about, you know, deliberate fabrication and reinterpretation, you know, remembering thing in a different way, the effect of memories and then bringing in therapeutic language.

SPEAKER_01Yes.

SPEAKER_00And yes, that there's a but I also I do think that there's a more, you know, she saw that it didn't have It didn't end up the way she thought it would end up. And so that she sort of, I think that she utilized the tools at her disposal, which was then, oh, I could, you know, if I say that I'm traumatized then, and then she could mobilize the legal system.

SPEAKER_00To sort of salvage her reputation because it is better and especially in our society to be a victim than you even get the social cache of victimhood from our victimhood culture than to be someone who who started a gangbang. So it's better to be the victim of a gang rape than being the initiator of a gangbang. And I don't think that she understood from her text messages that, you know, that seems to align She did think that she would be some sort of a hero

SPEAKER_00from having started this gangbang, that that would reflect positively on her reputation, seemed from her text messages to be somewhat surprised at people's reactions to that. And then I think it's easy to go from that to utilizing the legal system to re-categorize yourself Rather than the effect of misremembering and reinterpretation. Although that can sort of happen. I think in this case, it's the,

SPEAKER_00you know, the use of bad psychology and how quickly everyone around her also used that bad psychology too. Yeah.

SPEAKER_01Yes. Gynocentrism. If I could jump in for just one moment.

SPEAKER_03If people are interested in finding like a research paper that looks at or has identified regret after sex as being a common theme amongst people that make these sorts of allegations. There's a paper published in a journal called Women and Criminal Justice in 2014. And it identified, it went through 55 different case files and they identified different themes

SPEAKER_03of why women were making allegations. And one of the five themes was regret after sexual activity and usually the people were intoxicated with drugs or alcohol. So that was one of the key themes. And then other key themes included things like Just trying to avoid trouble or providing some sort of alibi for themselves. Mental illness was another theme. Attention seeking was another theme and so was revenge and anger.

SPEAKER_03So we have research that shows some of these reasons why these allegations and they seem to match up in this particular case.

SPEAKER_00Okay, did you have anything else, Tom, that you wanted to add here?

SPEAKER_01No, I think that's good.

SPEAKER_00Because then I would like to continue with you, Jim, and perhaps you can take us through more of actual reality when it comes to false accusations. What are we looking at here?

SPEAKER_03Yeah, so this research area is kind of an interesting one and I've only recently been introduced to it and just kind of taken some data that's already been published in academic papers and then just presented it on Substack. There's a lot of kind of debate in this area. What is the percentage of rape allegations that are false? And you just get people saying all sorts of different numbers. And originally, there was a paper that gave this wide range.

SPEAKER_03So it summarized all the existing research we had, and it ranged from anywhere between like 3% to like 90%, which is completely unhelpful, right? So the major problem was that everyone was defining these things differently across studies. And so people needed to get to a point of coming to a consistent definition of What a false rape allegation would be.

SPEAKER_03So the number that gets thrown around now is a conservative number, and it's 5%. So 5% of all rape allegations are false. Where does that number come from? It comes from two major sources. One is a meta-analysis published in the archives of sexual behavior in 2016. And it overviewed seven studies that use the same consistent definition. And so what this definition entails, it's a very high standard of definition.

SPEAKER_03And that's why it's a conservative estimate. So to be considered false, it has to be knowingly untrue and malicious. So rather than accidental in its nature, and I will give an example of that in just a moment. And it has to be confirmed to be false through a police investigation. It has to be knowingly untrue, malicious, and confirmed to be false through a police investigation.

SPEAKER_03It can't be an accidental false allegation. And I think an example of this that I came up with would be a case where, let's say a woman is kind of kidnapped off the street. Quickly, someone puts a blindfold around her and she never sees the person and the guy rapes her. While he's raping her, he's talking. After the whole thing is over, so she had the blindfold on the whole time, she says, I know who it was.

SPEAKER_03I recognize that voice. So she's convinced that she actually knows who it is. She's like, no, that's the guy I work with or something like that, right? So she is not doing it Maliciously, she actually thinks that she knows who it is, but it turns out it wasn't Bill Smith who she thought it was because Bill Smith was out of town that day. And so she was wrong, but that doesn't get tallied as a false rape allegation according to this definition. So this is where it's a conservative estimate.

SPEAKER_03And then the data I've published came from a paper that was published a year later after the meta-analysis in 2017 in the Journal of Forensic Psychology. And the reason why it's a solid paper is it used FBI data from 2006 to 2010. And it not only quantified the number of false rape allegations, but also false allegations across a variety of different crimes like theft and so on. And it came to the same number, 5%.

SPEAKER_03So it found that about 5,000 individuals per year in the U.S. are accused falsely of rape for sure. So 5,000 a year. And one of the reasons why I wanted to put that data out there is because I know, for example, like some men's advocates would say the 5% number is too low. It's much higher than that. Okay, maybe. But even these absolute numbers, the 5,000 people, those are big numbers.

SPEAKER_03Those are other people's lives who are destroyed. Tom? Did the second study use the same criteria? I believe it might have been, it might have had a little bit more flexibility in its, no, sorry. I think the meta-analysis had a little bit more flexibility in its definition, but more or less, I think the two papers use roughly the very same, like high standard of a definition.

SPEAKER_01Yep.

SPEAKER_02Yes, it is. And that is a good point. I think, you know, 5% is... A substantial number. I'm positive it is an extremely conservative estimate. And of course, as we all know, police departments do not tend to investigate false rape allegations with great zeal. They're not interested in investigating and how would it ever be proved?

SPEAKER_02That it was a false rape allegation only in cases where the man physically could not have been present at the rape or cases where there is DNA evidence or cases where the woman confesses that it was a false allegation. Other than that, maybe there's some I'm not even thinking of, but there aren't very many other cases. It's a difficult thing. It's difficult to prove a negative in that case. And so we have all sorts of cases that are simply not. They're never followed up. There's not enough evidence to proceed with charge or,

SPEAKER_02you know, there's various other, or they do proceed with a charge and the person is found not guilty because there wasn't enough evidence or, you know, whatever it happens to be. And those do not get counted. And few women do confess that their allegation was false. And there are all sorts of famous cases where it's pretty clear that the allegation was false and yet those women were never, they're not named as false accusers. I'm thinking of the famous case in Canada of Jian Ghomeshi in which

SPEAKER_02the three accusers were all shown to have lied to police and on the witness stand about various issues. They were shown to have conspired together to get their stories straight. All three claimed they had never had any contact with the alleged rapist after the incidents, yet text messages and emails showed that they were in contact with him. They were willing to meet with him again. They wished to reignite the relationship.

SPEAKER_02They sent him pictures, one in a bikini, one of a woman filleting a beer bottle, all sorts of sexually suggestive messages, which they either had forgotten that he had Or thought he wouldn't have had because, as in many cases, these were allegations made many years after the alleged incidents. Those women were never pursued with any criminal charges. They weren't charged with mischief or obstruction of justice or anything. And they're still often referred to as survivors.

SPEAKER_02They still proclaim their innocence. There's many, many feminists who believe a great injustice was done and that Gian Gomeschi was found Not guilty. So there are many cases like that where it's pretty clear that what was described was not what actually happened. And yet those aren't classed as false allegations. So yes, it's a very difficult case to prove.

SPEAKER_01Oh boy. And things will not change until we start really punishing proven false accusers.

SPEAKER_02Well, exactly. I mean, I absolutely don't understand. Well, I do understand. I really think that that would be one route to changing the culture that is so quick to allege bleem would be to charge and to prosecute false allegations.

SPEAKER_03I would like to just take a minute to show the listeners how just awful this area is and just how much activism is In my post where I posted the graph, I included a quote from the state of Victoria here in Australia. The police, so the state police, they have a fact sheet about challenging misconceptions about sexual offending. And I just want to read you this quote to give a sense.

SPEAKER_03So it says, quote, the rate of false allegations of sexual offenses is very low. A range of studies show approximately 5% of rape allegations are proven false. This myth about false allegations is harmful for society and harmful for victims of sexual offenses. It contributes to under-reporting, and victims wrongly fear they will be met with disbelief and blame if they report."

SPEAKER_03So what they are doing there is they are minimizing Even the five, there's no reason for them to minimize the importance of the 5% number, but they're doing it anyways. That's how active, and this is the state police of Detroit. That's one out of 20.

SPEAKER_02Yeah.

SPEAKER_01And that's very conservative.

SPEAKER_02Yes. I mean, the feminists were successful. They got at the police force. Every police force in the Western world. And the judges. Yeah, and of course, yes. And, you know, again, yeah, it is startling that we allowed that to happen in every country in the Western world. And yeah, I would hope that there might also be a statement saying that making

SPEAKER_02a false allegation is a very serious crime. And we strongly urge that every accuser Examine carefully the situation that she or he wishes to report to make sure that it actually is a sexual assault because this is not a charge to be taken lightly. But of course, we would never say that because that might prevent someone from coming forward. I've seen feminists admit that encouraging more women to report is a public good.

SPEAKER_02And obviously, the police forces have accepted that accusers should be encouraged to come forward and should be assured that they will not in any way be blamed for making that report. And of course, they shouldn't be blamed for making a report if what they're reporting is 100% truthful and accurate, but often it is not. And in those cases, they should be blamed. And yet, that has been ruled out of order in the moral universe that feminists have created for us.

SPEAKER_01Yes, indeed. We should just throw something at

SPEAKER_00the wall. Yeah, just see what sticks.

SPEAKER_01Women's pain is something we need to worry about. Men's pain is not so important.

SPEAKER_02Yeah. Are there anything else?

SPEAKER_01Almost everyone has it. Almost everybody has that reflex. And most people don't even know it.

SPEAKER_00Yeah. Are there other changes that we could make, you guys think? What should universities do, for example?

SPEAKER_02Well, I'm of the opinion that universities should not be in the business of adjudicating so-called sexual harassment and sexual assault at all. I know that's a minority opinion, but I don't know how they ever got into the business in the first place. Really, the people who are tasked with this very serious responsibility are not trained for it. They don't have the training to assess evidence or to cross-examine witnesses or to gather evidence or any of that.

SPEAKER_02Often the procedures that are in place are patently inadequate. The same person who does the investigation is often the person who makes the final determination. Sometimes these people are ideologues. They're drawn from the fields of sociology or women's studies. They come with all the biases intact. And if a crime has been committed, then the police should investigate. We've already talked about the problems with the police, too, but at least... That's the province of the police is to do that work and university people,

SPEAKER_02academics are not qualified to do it. So I don't think they should be doing it, ruining men's lives. Everybody says, oh, well, it's not a criminal investigation. Well, if you're kicked out of your college because you're alleged to have engaged in some sort of sexual misconduct, it's a pretty serious investigation. Result and it is going to radically derail your life in a negative way. And so the fact that these investigations are conducted by people ill-equipped to do

SPEAKER_02so, they're judged on a preponderance of the evidence basis, which means a very low bar for making the decision. And yeah, I think it's a terrible mistake. However, if universities are going to continue to do so, which clearly they will continue to do so, They should at least make a statement saying that we take these allegations seriously. We will perform a full and impartial investigation and we will treat both accuser and accused.

SPEAKER_02They should not use the word survivor. We will treat both accuser and accused with fairness and we will do all that is necessary and possible to maintain their dignity and privacy. And they should do that. And the accused should be able to maintain their privacy. That should be at least as important as maintaining that of the accuser.

SPEAKER_00They also have the university's best interest at heart. They worry about the university's reputation. And it seems like especially then, you know, this case from Maryland and also the Cornell case, they risk more if they find For the accused rather than for the accuser. If they would play it safe, they would just fine for the accused. For the accuser. I mean, exactly. But it seemed like they actually didn't do such a bad job of the investigation,

SPEAKER_00the university, I mean, in this Cornell 7 case, and then still...

SPEAKER_02The men were punished quite severely. And she wasn't. And 1,100 pages of investigation does suggest that it was taken very seriously. And yet none of that counts. Once the media and the activists get hold of this subject, it's blown up into some massive failure. By the system of this poor woman.

SPEAKER_00All of those pages can be just thrown out because she claims trauma and then none of it matters anymore. It's all just nulled out because she was traumatized.

SPEAKER_02Trauma theory has been one of feminism's most genius inventions over the last I don't know how many years. Certainly it was widely used in In the Harvey Weinstein trials, all of the evidence that these women were willing participants in the sexual relationships that they engaged in with him simply becomes proof then that they were traumatized. So whatever the alleged survivor does, if it confirms what a victim would tend to do in a case like that,

SPEAKER_02then that proves that she was sexually assaulted. It contradicts what we expect a victim to do, then that also proves she was sexually assaulted because it's evidence of her trauma. So it's a perfect vicious circle in which the woman is always traumatized and the man is always guilty.

SPEAKER_01Amen. Yes means yes or no, and no means no.

SPEAKER_00Yeah. Jim, what do you think we can change?

SPEAKER_03I'm going to go with Janice. And also the interesting thing about the U.S. is, you know, a lot of or most U.S. universities, I mean, particularly the major ones, they have police departments on campus. They have university police. So I don't quite understand why they wouldn't be the first people you would report to or talk to. But I'm no expert, so I don't know.

SPEAKER_02You know, the other

SPEAKER_01thing I think universities can do to start teaching what universities are supposed to teach and get rid of ideology. Any of the crap like women's studies and all those kind of ideological studies, put it someplace else, not in the university,

SPEAKER_02you know? Absolutely. Yeah.

SPEAKER_01Because that's fouling the water.

SPEAKER_02It certainly is. Yes. Yeah.

SPEAKER_00That would go a long way. So, yeah, I think we went through a great deal. And, and, yeah, any, any last comments? Last, last words?

SPEAKER_01Were we going to talk about trauma stuff?

SPEAKER_00I think we did. I mean, I did a whole episode on the traumas. I didn't want to dive any deeper into it. But I think we'll wrap it up for today. And it's late for Jim. So I think we'll cut it there. And thank you so much for joining me today. And we'll do another one soon. I enjoy speaking with all of you. Thank you for your insights.

SPEAKER_02Thank you, Hannah. Always a pleasure. Indeed it is.

SPEAKER_00And thank you for watching and listening. Please like and subscribe on your way out and visit all of their Substacks. Tom's Substack, Jim and Janice's Substack will be linked in the description. Easy to find. It's really worth a read. Please go and support their work by subscribing. And if you're listening on audio, then leave a rating and a review. Thank you so much. And I'll see you next time. Have a nice day.

SPEAKER_02Men are good, as are you.

Open the transcript file

Hosts and Guests

Nobody is credited on this episode yet.

Credit the people on this episode

Be the first to rate this episode

More episodes

All episodes
  1. Healing Men. Changing the System.

    Nov 16, 202659 minAudio

    What happens when a man seeks help for pain that has a political cause? Therapy may help him recover, but what changes the institutions that injured him? And how do we help men recognize injustice without leaving them...

    Credit the people on this episode

  2. Men’s Issues: Past, Present, and Future — with Warren Farrell & David Maywald

    Nov 2, 20261 hr 8 minAudio

    Men’s Issues: Past, Present, and Future - with Warren Farrell & David Maywald I was grateful to sit down with two men I greatly admire: Warren Farrell, whose fifty years of work have helped shape the modern conversation...

    Credit the people on this episode

  3. False Allegations

    Sep 3, 20261 hr 9 minAudio

    We are getting a head start on International Falsely Accused day on Sept 9th!How many false allegations of sexual abuse are there? We are often told they are extremely rare - perhaps only one to three percent. But those...

    Credit the people on this episode

  4. The Women's Health Narrative Meets the DATA

    Jul 15, 202635 minAudio

    What if one of the most common claims in health policy simply isn’t true? We’ve all heard the refrain: women are underfunded, under-researched, and left behind by the medical establishment. It’s repeated so often that...

    Credit the people on this episode

  5. False Accusations

    Jun 11, 202610 minAudio

    This video explores the enormous challenges men face when they are falsely accused. It also examines our culture’s tendency to overlook or dismiss men’s emotional pain, particularly in situations involving false...

    Credit the people on this episode