Skip to content
PodSubs
ShowsPeopleGuestsJobsNewsEvents
More
BlogPodCred
Menu
ShowsPeopleGuestsJobsNewsEventsBlogPodCredNetworksSign in
Join nowSign in
  • Shows
  • People
  • Jobs
  • News
  • More
    • Guests
    • Events
    • Blog
    • PodCred
    • Networks
    Join nowSign in

Matters

Matters artwork

A re-introduction to heterodox thinking

Oct 4, 202428 minAudio
ShareXLinkedInFacebookWhatsAppEmail

Bish Sanyal is the Ford International Professor of Urban Development and Planning and Director of the Special Program in Urban and Regional Studies (SPURS)/ Hubert Humphrey program at the Massachusetts Institute of Technology. He served as Head of the Department of Urban Studies and Planning at MIT from 1994 to 2002 and was the chair of the entire MIT faculty from 2007 to 2009. In this video, he discusses the contribution of Professor Alice Amsden to the field of heterodox research. He also mentions the contributions of Professor Judith Tendler and some of the basic tenets of heterodox research that were formed at the International Development Group housed within the Department of Urban Studies and Planning at MIT. This is a public episode. If you would like to discuss this with other subscribers or get access to bonus episodes, visit mattersthepodcastforourtimes.substack.com

Audio and video play straight from the show's own hosting. PodSubs stores and serves no media.

Transcript

From the show. Tap a time to play from there.

SPEAKER_00So Alice Amston was teaching in a temporary spot within the department at MIT when I came as a young assistant professor. But by the time I had become department head in 1994, I was able to get Alice back from the new school where she was before and back to MIT in a tenured full professor position. First thing I want to say is that Alice Amston had a very rough few years before that.

SPEAKER_00The same year that she was denied tenure at Harvard Business School, she was diagnosed with breast cancer, and she had a divorce. And this woman had incredible resiliency. She stuck in there. She fought, she taught temporary courses, like I said, at MIT, etc. But her book, Asia's Next Giant, has just come out in the mid-80s or so.

SPEAKER_00Prior to that, she had also written a very influential piece for a book called Bringing the State Back In by Theda Skocpol and Peter Evans and Dieter Ruschmeyer. And Alice had a piece on, I think, on Korea or on Taiwan, one of those. Anyway, so it was very clear that Alice didn't buy the idea of this Washington consensus that government is the problem and this kind of supply side economics, you know? And so why we are attracted, we are an urban planning program and we do,

SPEAKER_00at that time in 1984 when I came, the department had just started a new specialization called international development and regional planning. And there were a number of us, me, Judith Tendler, Karen Polinsky, Ralph Gockenheimer, Lloyd Rodwin, Lisa Peedy. I mean, it was very, very big names. So when Alice, the reason we chose Alice is Alice's work was very highly respected by heterodox

SPEAKER_00economists at MIT like Michael Peary. I remember Michael Peary telling me that she is so interesting. I said, why is she interesting other than the fact that she likes government and she really supports government intervention? He said, look at the book. The book is based on very minute study of the industrial sector at the very micro level, how firms learn in Korea and how they compete, how they learn, they copy and they compete.

SPEAKER_00So, I knew that she was very grounded and that is something we appreciate in planning, urban planning. Urban planning is not known for big theory, but it is ultimately where things get done. And so you need somebody who has that kind of a very micro level understanding of problems and how things work. And the moment you go down to that level to see how things work, the broad theories don't really make a sense. You have to revise those broad theories.

SPEAKER_00And that's where heterodox comes in. But heterodox is not just some idea from the air that government matters. It is based on actual things on the ground that have worked and that have worked because of government intervention. So Judith was also believed, strongly believed in government intervention. So we created kind of a group of people who all were fighting against at that moment against Washington consensus in various forms. And Diane came also after 19.

SPEAKER_00So she was also, she had taught with Alice in the new school. And so she knew Alice very well. So it was a very important moment. I think we played in the IDG group, International Development Group, There was a clear theme. There was a clear theme that these people believe in government innovation. They are very empirically driven. They are not ideologues, right? And they have worked all over the world. And of course, Alice's work on South Korea stood out. And also she did some work on Taiwan.

SPEAKER_00That was the origin. And so when I become department head and I found out that Lance Taylor, who was also somewhat of a heterodox, who left MIT, Lance was at MIT. Lance left MIT to go to a new school. So the moment Lance left that job, and Lance had a half-time appointment in our department, half-time in economics. And since I was department head, I immediately proposed that we should think of Alice. So I called Alice and said, would you like to move? And she said, yes.

SPEAKER_00So that was the origin. So she joined in, I think, 1996. something like that. And since she came in, she had a very strong presence. As you know, she had a very strong presence. She taught courses on industrial policy, on rapid industrialization, how nations catch up, which was a big part of her work. But she focused mostly on the macro. The only thing Alice didn't do, Alice was not

SPEAKER_00going to talk about the macro impact on cities. She didn't reach the cities very much directly, though her work had implications for cities, but her scale was macro. But macro not in the macro economics classical sense, but macro being discussed with very detailed micro level study of industrial sector. I think she contributed a lot to our department. She brought us a lot of attention in terms of the whole complexion of the program changed.

SPEAKER_00Sometimes there will be an argument between Judith who do more rural and for projects. Alice was not into projects. Alice was into broad policy, government policy, industrial policy. I thought, yes, it was different for both of them, but they were complimentary. And I think that the students who could use both of them, you probably one of them, that got benefited from both. Yeah.

SPEAKER_01So thank you so much, Bish, for that. What do you think is the relevance of her work today? And in fact, not just her, but the entire IDG group that had focused on this kind of looking at good governance.

SPEAKER_00Yes, yes. I think that her work is still very important. And the word good governance was invented by the Washington Consensus Group. You notice that it's good governance, it's not good government. They wanted good governments by reducing government. You know, that was their agenda. So we are always skeptical about this term called good governance. And in a way, both Judith and Alice,

SPEAKER_00and we also still, some of us also played a role in that, tried to show that without calling it good governance, that some parts in the developing world, locally, regionally, nationally, government is actually doing some very positive things. We don't call it good governance to fit into that old mold, but we do want to understand that holding constant for the constraints that government faces and the bureaucracy, etc. Why is it that some of these public sector organizations perform reasonably well?

SPEAKER_00And Judith's work on Northeast Brazil was directly a part of that when she looked at that. So we were trying to understand what leads government to perform. And I think Alice's early work on disciplining of capital, which Diane actually, I think, borrowed that term from Alice because Alice had looked at how the Korean state worked with these big firms in trying to increase export.

SPEAKER_00What were the mechanisms? So the idea was that, yes, I'll give you subsidy as a government, but in return, you have to show me that you have indeed performed by expanding export. So this kind of arrangement between the state and market was definitely Alice's contribution to look at it in a new way. The state was not just regulating in the old sense, right? And the same thing comes up again in Judith's work on regulations in the Northeast

SPEAKER_00saying that, you know, regulation worked, that these people were labor regulators who are working in Northeast. And they found that the regulators that went to these farms where there was concern about violation of labor practices, They listen to the regulators if the regulators also help them in other ways to gain access to the market, right? So regulations, how to enforce regulation, how to change the relationship of antagonism between business and market,

SPEAKER_00business and state, I think it was a very important insight. What does it take for government to get markets to perform the way we want them to perform? And by just dictating, it won't happen.

SPEAKER_01And I think that IDG played a very critical role in shaping that narrative because that narrative has now changed. How do you see the evolution of IDG's work?

SPEAKER_00I did this work after Alice died, left, and then soon after Judith died, Karen Polinsky retired. Ralph Gackenheimer retired, Lloyd Rodwin died. And somehow what happened, and this is, I don't know how much of this you want to say in the public forum, but what happened was that because of Alice, Judith, and a few of the IDG group who are very strong scholars and very strong women,

SPEAKER_00they had somehow, the rest of the department were often felt like they were that these people thought that they were the real scholars and others were not and it's true compared to design which is you know urban design is a little bit fluffy right so so when they left it was very hard for me to convince the department that somebody in that domain should be replaced they were I didn't know if they were but first of all many of them had not read the work But second of all, they were reacting to the individual strong personalities of these people.

SPEAKER_00And they didn't think they were good for the department in terms of collegiality. But it's unfortunate because actually Alice was a very gregarious human being and Judith was too. But they stuck to their ground. They were not willing to say, yes, yes, yes. They were not of that kind. They had their own point of view and they said that point of view very strongly. So the department then started saying, international is not the only group. IDG is not the only group that does international.

SPEAKER_00Everybody is now doing international, which means, because the market opened up with the Washington Consensus, many American scholars started going abroad and doing this one week study and two week study and coming back and prescribing like in the old colonial mode, you know? And so they thought that they are doing international also. So the department actually approached us and said, we are also international. So the department started doing a vector diagram of the faculty where they're working.

SPEAKER_00And many faculty said they're doing international. But if you ask us how international is that work, we laugh. It's not rigorous at all. It's not rigorous. I mean, the amount of rigor that Alice and Judith, the detailed knowledge they had at the ground level, these countries, they spoke the language. I mean, they have years of experience. They were not the types who fly in for a week and write a report. So that struggle is still there. And so also second thing, industrial policy.

SPEAKER_00I remember when Alice was trying to replace, I found a very interesting fellow who had worked with Richard Lester, who was at the Industrial Relations Group at MIT, Industrial Performance Center. And this man was studying China and production in China and how Chinese production on the ground was changing. I thought he was brilliant. I wanted to hire him. In the meeting, again, the people said, well, but why is he coming here?

SPEAKER_00Why isn't he going to economics? So it struck me that these people like Alex Judith, who came from development economics, and had made a real, real contribution and then also made the classical planners vulnerable conceptually. So they thought, why is the department not focusing on cities and city planning and things like that, right? And so that's been a loss. And I think IDG as an area, it's still looking for a team,

SPEAKER_00a team of that nature with this idea of heterodox economics. In the meantime, in the United States, there had been big upheaval. There has been, you know, Black Lives Matter and also this problem with inequality, increasing inequality, etc. So now the department decided three main areas of work. One is inequality, one is inclusion, and one is racial justice or something, social justice. neither Alice nor Judith nor any of us will disagree that those are important goals

SPEAKER_00but there is something kind of every everybody is into that now why would we stand out I mean you go to any place they're talking about the same thing right so I feel like that that we need that we are searching still and we hired a very interesting important woman who young faculty from Harvard who studies conflicts, cities that have faced severe conflict and how the city manages conflict, spatially,

SPEAKER_00culturally, socially, et cetera. Now, that's getting a lot of attention. Because many cities around the world have faced conflict. And we really don't have a theory of how to deal with it. And conflict resolution, et cetera, that kind of standard things that came out of the American experience is not really valid in those contexts, right? So that's one. The second of all, the one other thing that has struck me is development economics was originally based on the idea that these countries,

SPEAKER_00developing countries, needs are different, their constraints are different. And that general theory, neoclassical economic theory doesn't hold. That's why you created development economics, the difference. Now, from late 70s, early 80s, this attack on development economics that came from neoclassical economics, you know, from this rent-seeking bureaucrats, etc. And all of a sudden, micro is focused on micro of individual behavior.

SPEAKER_00And that somehow, if you have the right incentives, right sanctions, individuals would behave in a certain way. As if the constraints are similar. They are not similar. So this idea that how different are these countries, or how similar are these, remains a big issue. It remains a big issue.

SPEAKER_01Thank you for that, Bish. Do you see a scope for the resurgence of the types of research that was undertaken by the original IDG group within urban planning?

SPEAKER_00It will be, I hope so. I hope so. Though the division of labor is quite pronounced and we could break that division of labor in the 1980s because we were leading, MIT was leading in the field at that moment. And so we could set the trend. Now, if we look at American planning schools, There are very few schools, except for schools that have hired Alice's students,

SPEAKER_00most of them are focusing on the urban, the city. And at the same time, development economics within economics department has been trashed, except the Nobel Prize that Abhijit and Esther got brought that back, development economics, in sense of this evaluation of projects. But they don't have much to say. They're not the types who will think about a broad frame, right? And they have been criticized for that, that they are too focused on this micro level project level,

SPEAKER_00right? So cities, now the cities, they should, if somebody could look at cities, how cities grow, why some cities are able to attract private funding, others are not, right? This is very important to do micro level work. But since the cities don't have much power compared to the national government, nobody takes the cities that seriously as a key player.

SPEAKER_00And so Alice's work was at the national level. She looked at the national level. She looked at national government. So I think that which organizational category you are focusing on at what scale tells you a lot about what's happening with the profession.

SPEAKER_01Fantastic. I'm going to switch tracks a little bit and ask you, what is joyful for you about urban planning right now?

SPEAKER_00What is joyful for urban planning is, well, let me just say a little bit about work that I'm doing now. So I was looking at a book that has been working for five years called Hidden Success. And it's basically looking at the city level, why some cities in India have been able to perform better than others in particular sector. And Indian government from 2000 with June Ram, et cetera, gave money to cities.

SPEAKER_00But the results are varied. They vary. So I did a competition with a lot of application from India of cities that have done well. For example, Indore in India has done incredibly well in sanitation. So I am very interested to know, how did it happen in Indore? What was the reason? And in that, the classical explanations are the following. The classical explanation, if you ask somebody from business school,

SPEAKER_00they'll say, oh, it was a great leader who was running it, or you had political will. And we are not interested in that because there are two bland explanations. we are interested in what happened organizationally in that moment in that historical moment and why this organization was able to perform well so in other words what we are looking for is pressure for good performance within organization that's the currently the work that i'm doing on looking at what what creates pressure for good performance within organizations that's one thing that so i'm

SPEAKER_00looking at the at the more the positive way The other thing that makes me interested, I want to be joyful, but definitely how cities are trying to deal with climate change. I think there is a clear kind of a mandate now, more of a growing consensus that cities have to do something. Right about this, so the need for cities that's where people are based that's where economic economic activities are based it's becoming more and drawing more and more attention.

SPEAKER_00So there was a time when we thought if national economy blooms, eventually that benefit will trickle down to the city. Nobody believes in that. They think the city is where it has to start, right? So the work that I think Diane and others are working on the sovereignty of the city, like what kind of power should cities have to confront or to address the kind of challenges they're facing? Do they need more power? What kind of power?

SPEAKER_00What kind of legislative power? What kind of financial power? I think it's on the board. It's for a conversation.

SPEAKER_01Thank you, and we're looking forward to reading your book, Bish. How can we bring the state back in?

SPEAKER_00The state is back already. And that's the part of it to show that when, which what Alice's early work was, when everybody was giving credit to Korea for withdrawal of the state, she showed that state was very heavily involved, right? So the state has always been involved. The question is, though, we don't want to become like a cheerleader for the state. So just saying state involvement is important is not enough.

SPEAKER_00You have to tell me how, in which way, and considering the constraints of bureaucracy, considering that people don't want to pay a huge amount of tax, et cetera, how is the state going to be effective? I also worry that... If you look at what has happened in the US and many other parts of the developed countries since 2000, I would say since Trump came to power, the attack on government, both politically and otherwise,

SPEAKER_00has been very severe. So all these authoritarian things in countries that are emerging are emerging saying the state in its old form is not able to address issues. We need a more authoritarian government, right? So the question is that, well, when Alice looked at Korea, Korea was also authoritarian. And that's been a criticism of Alice that she never addressed that question of politics, right?

SPEAKER_00though it was a military government at that time. And so many people would say, do you need authoritarian government to be successful? Alice always brushed aside that question.

SPEAKER_01And I think that on that note, that is a fascinating point to end this discussion on and very relevant, actually, that point to what we're facing today, as you said, with government and authoritarianism. I think that's fascinating, Bish, to bring it all together in that way. And we're very much looking forward to reading your book.

SPEAKER_00Thank you. It should be out by the end of the spring semester. I have my sabbatical in the spring, so I'm trying to put it together. But really, I'm looking, I've been sitting on it because I need to find a really nuanced explanation that cuts across various cases, you know. And so that's been the challenge, but it's worth it. And again, it's in the same tradition that I got from Judith and Annalise by having them as colleagues.

SPEAKER_01And I do hope that you will come back to Policy Chatters and give us your thoughts on other pressing issues in urban planning.

SPEAKER_00Well, I want to thank you. And I'm very proud of you. We are very proud of you and your work. And now that you told me what you have been working on, I look forward to interacting with you. And I give you an open invitation to come to MIT to speak sometime. And I'll be very happy to organize a meeting where you can talk to the students and faculty.

SPEAKER_01That is, I would love that, Bish. That would just be wonderful. I would love to come back to MIT. I would love to talk about this. And I would love to get your thoughts, you know, about how to evolve the heterodox series and how to make it relevant or how to make it pertinent. And would love to continue engaging with you on this.

SPEAKER_00That's for sure. Let me know. I can pull together. You know, I still had the mid-career program, the mid-career urban practitioner. It's sort of like a Fulbright for practitioners. It's funded by the U.S. State Department, the Hubert Humphrey program. So I have like 15 or 16 fellows who come for a year. And I have been looking for teams for my seminars over the week. So if you tell me when you're going to come, et cetera, I might be able to pull together a group of people like Michael Peory and others

SPEAKER_00and have a half a day to sort of think about what should be the research agenda with the new heterodoxy.

SPEAKER_01I would love that. I mean, that would just, that would be joyful for me.

SPEAKER_00So that would be joyful. It'll be more fun. And you know, Harvard also has some of the faculty who are working on that. So let me know.

SPEAKER_01Okay. Okay, great. So I will keep you posted. And if you can think of anybody else, I have been in contact with Michael about the series. And if you can think of anybody else I should be speaking to, please let me know.

SPEAKER_00Okay. I will. I will. I'm sure there'll be other people whose names will come up. The group of people who wrote in the Bringing the State Back In.

SPEAKER_01Yes.

SPEAKER_00The first book. I know that Peter Evans is kind of old, getting old, but he has some students in the area.

SPEAKER_01I think he may have passed away, Bish.

SPEAKER_00Peter, did he die already?

SPEAKER_01Very recently. Yes.

SPEAKER_00Very recently. He was very sick. I know he was very sick. Yeah.

SPEAKER_01I think very recently. So I think he did pass away. But I have emailed Lance. Oh, was it Lance Taylor? I'm sorry. I may be mistaken. It was Lance. It was Lance. And Peter, I did email he at Berkeley, but I never heard back.

SPEAKER_00But maybe Robert Wade.

SPEAKER_01Yes, I reached out to him. Also, I haven't heard back. So we just got school. Oh, I haven't reached out to her. She's a good, she's a good, she would be a good person to reach out to. I will definitely, I will definitely go to her.

SPEAKER_00Yeah, yeah, yeah, yeah. Yeah. Keep us informed and we'll do something together. Okay.

SPEAKER_01Sounds fantastic, Bish. You have a good rest of your day and it was lovely to catch up.

SPEAKER_00Same here.

SPEAKER_01Okay. Bye-bye.

Open the transcript file

Hosts and Guests

Nobody is credited on this episode yet.

Credit the people on this episode

Be the first to rate this episode

More episodes

All episodes
  1. Industrial Policy --Again

    Nov 12, 202632 minAudio

    Leela Lebowski interviews Professor Ben Selwyn at the University of Sussex about his book co-authored with Christin Bernhold, Capitalist Value Chains, which was recently awarded the 2026 International Political Economy...

    Credit the people on this episode

  2. Cockroaches: Employment and Education

    Jul 28, 202636 minAudio

    Our guest today is Professor Santosh Mehrotra, who has recently co-authored a book with Jajati Parida on employment in India: India Out of Work: Rethinking India’s Growth Story. This podcast is part of a new series...

    Credit the people on this episode

  3. Tarrif's, Tarrif's, Tarrif's -- Episode 5

    Jan 1, 202652 minAudio

    Dr. Ajay Chhibber is a Distinguished Visiting Scholar, Institute for International Economic Policy (IIEP), George Washington University, Washington D.C., and a Distinguished Fellow, Isaac Center for Public Policy,...

    Credit the people on this episode

  4. GVCs, GVCs, GVCs -- 1st Episode

    Nov 3, 202530 minAudio

    Professor Benjamin Selwyn is Professor of International Relations and International Development at the University of Sussex, UK. He researches and writes about global value chains, poverty and inequality, and global...

    Credit the people on this episode

  5. A Long History of Mental Illness

    Jul 23, 202553 minAudio

    Andrew T. Scull (born 1947) is a British-born sociologist who researches the social history of medicine and the history of psychiatry. He is a distinguished professor of sociology and science studies at the University...

    Credit the people on this episode