Amin Taha has been described as ‘London’s most controversial architect’. This is largely due to 15 Clerkenwell Close, a development that is defined by a single material, stone. The building (which houses his collective practice, Groupwork, and where he also happens to live) was shortlisted for this year’s Stirling Prize, the UK’s most prestigious architecture award, despite that fact it was finished in 2017. And it’s fair to say the nomination came as a surprise. This wasn’t simply to do with the timing, nor the building itself - which is a smart, witty, and, it transpires, sustainable piece of work that subtly references the area’s history. But rather because, three years ago, it was issued with a demolition order by Islington Council for non-conformity with the submitted plans. Happily, Taha won his appeal and has taken the thinking behind the building - which uses limestone as a structural frame, rather than as a facade for steel and concrete - to investigate how we might build carbon negative towers in the future. As architecture writer, Tim Abrahams, has pointed out what sets Taha’s practice apart is his ‘fundamental rejection of style as an orientating device in favour of structure’. In other words, this is an architect for whom materials really matter. In this episode we talk about: the controversy around 15 Clerkenwell Close; being shortlisted for the Stirling Prize; learning to build in stone; why it’s a sustainable material; the nation’s planning system; beauty; being born behind the Iron Curtain; growing up in Southend-on-Sea; studying under Isi Metzstein and working for Zaha Hadid; designing 30-storey stone towers; and how the construction industry could become carbon negative. Support the show
Audio and video play straight from the show's own hosting. PodSubs stores and serves no media.
Transcript
From the show. Tap a time to play from there.
SPEAKER_01Hello, and after a short break, welcome back to Material Matters with Grant Gibson. That's me. I've been doing this for three years now, but for listeners who might not have heard it before, the idea behind the show is that I speak to a designer, maker, artist, or architect about a material or technique with which they're intrinsically linked and discover how it changed their lives and careers. Today I find myself at 15 Clarkenwell Close in London to talk to his architect Amin Taha of group work about the material that defines this extraordinary building.
SPEAKER_01Stone. Amin, who also happens to live and work here, has been described as London's most controversial architect. And I think to general surprise the building was shortlisted for this year's Sterling Prize, the UK's most prestigious architecture award. It came as a shock, not because 15 Clark and World Close isn't a smart, witty, genuinely eye-catching, and it transpires, sustainable piece of work, which subtly references the area's history, but rather that it was issued with a demolition order by Islington Council for non-conformity with submitted plans three years ago.
SPEAKER_01Happily for us all, Amin won his appeal and he's taken the thinking behind the building, which uses stone as a structural frame rather than as a facade for steel and concrete, to investigate how we might build towers in the future that could be carbon negative. As the writer and critic Tim Abrahams has pointed out, what sets Amin's work apart is his fundamental rejection of style as an orientating device in favour of structure. In other words, this is an architect for whom materials really matter.
SPEAKER_01Very well, thanks. Thank you very much for doing this. Well, thank you for inviting me. Was that a reasonable intro? Yeah, it's very good. Everything accurate?
SPEAKER_00Yeah, absolutely. The FT did say the most controversial architect in London, which I still, you know, just because we were issued with a demission order doesn't make us controversial.
SPEAKER_01No, it's an inter I mean, I was going to ask you about that because it's it's a slightly curious thing telling somebody they're controversial to their face. When you set out to create this building, I mean obviously it wasn't your intention to get into an argument with Islington Council, but did you realize it would be it would divide audiences?
SPEAKER_00Uh I'm not sure we I think we probably realized it would not necessarily divide um opinion, divide audiences, but it gave us an excitement when we saw the stones being lifted into place. We'd already known and discussed with the case officer um that we wouldn't know exactly which stone would face which direction, what finish would be placed, where on the building, because we'd only get the stones about two weeks before they're um delivered on site. And of course, as they're coming on site, they reveal themselves.
SPEAKER_00The actual finished elevation um reveals itself. And of course, that's for us as architects very exciting. Instead of having drawn something three years, five years previously, and expect it to be exactly as you've drawn, which is often a disappointment because you might have spent a long time literally drawing it by hand, shadowing it, making beautiful images of it, or even by computer renders. And they are never what they are in reality. And the reality should be the pleasing outcome as opposed to a disappointment of the constructed image three or four years beforehand.
SPEAKER_00So for us, yes, it was exciting. We expected other architects or engineers, because obviously a highly engineered bit of structure, to be equally excited. And inevitably, yes, because it's different, some um raised eyebrows, but not necessarily um a certificate asking for it to be demolished.
SPEAKER_01No, I mean, maybe we'll talk a little bit about that later. I mean, I know you've talked about it at some length in the past. I mean, I was intrigued researching it because I hadn't realized that it was actually shortlisted for, I mean, really amazingly, for Building Design's Carbuncle Cup. They described it as ruin porn. And I'm wondering, how does that when somebody does that, how do you feel about that?
SPEAKER_00Uh tricky one, isn't it? Because it's the sort of playground stuff, isn't it? If you put yourself back in a playground, really, it shouldn't really bother you at all, but of course it does um still um um hurt in some ways. Uh, but you you know, you're you're an adult and you can brush it aside. But I think the only reason I took it particularly um seriously at that time is because we had the demolition order, and of course, it just adds fuel to this particular councillor's opinion that it's ugly.
SPEAKER_00They hinted that it was possibly um him uh pushing for that because he'd been on a campaign to demonstrate other people think it's ugly, and he'd been phoning lots of architects and um conservation groups asking for support and they weren't giving it to him. So it became conflated with his campaign, with this particular person's campaign. So I think that it it hurt for that reason because you realise, well, he's politically gaining momentum for his purpose, and that's really what this whole thing was about. You naively think, well, at some point people will look at the paperwork and it's fine, but actually politics can completely overwhelm and drive that purpose as opposed to what you think is just facts, facts on paper, approvals, etc.
SPEAKER_01Maybe we'll get into that in a bit more detail later because we we want to talk people through the building. I mean, in the first instance, it'd be quite nice to know how things are going. I'm having to ask everybody this, obviously, when I we've been doing these for the last couple of years. We've had the COVID crisis, there have been lockdowns. How has it affected the practice? Have you coped?
SPEAKER_00Initially, some clients um put things on hold, they're worried, looking to see uh how things will pan out. So we suspended some projects, and I think within about six months or so, they pretty much all came to life, and a couple of new projects arrived as well. We initially thought how are we going to run the office via Zoom and et cetera, remotely, because we're most of the time always huddling in a group, looking across drawings and details in discussion. And I didn't think, you know, as the senior member, grey haired member, didn't think that online software would do it.
SPEAKER_00And flapping my arms about, I was eventually um pulled towards the screen and told, look, it's so easy. And here's a pen on a touch screen, it can work. And yeah, it was a complete revelation, it works brilliantly. In many ways, it works um well, in some ways it works better than being physically around a table because you can get more people on the screen and everyone can actually annotate a drawing with their opinion, which you can't do physically. However, you still need to meet physically um other design team members, etc.
SPEAKER_00But um generally, yeah. I shouldn't grumble so far so good. Touch lots of wood, we're doing okay.
SPEAKER_01And how are you working now? I mean, have you adopted hybrid methods? Is this how it's worked?
SPEAKER_00Right. Uh, because previously, any meeting with a structure engineer, mechanical electrical engineer, as well as clients, was always physically come round and into our office, or I travel by cab or tube somewhere else. And now, can't we just do this meeting by Zoom or Teams? Because a lot of the meetings are general agendas uh and ticking those off as opposed to anything particularly detailed.
SPEAKER_01And the team, are they coming in regularly? I mean, you have people downstairs, but how are you working that practically?
SPEAKER_00Almost everyone's here all the time. One person whose family was Spanish-based and they were in lockdown there. It's pretty much all all the time in Spain. I think it comes over maybe, I think you just saw it comes in maybe every two weeks for two days. That's uh yeah. Otherwise, yeah, everyone's here.
SPEAKER_01And the Sterling Prize. Should we talk about that? It was the second time, isn't it, you've been nominated. It must come as a nice surprise. Had Reba tipped you off that you'd be shortlisted?
SPEAKER_00No, no, no. Well, I've been on that jury for about six years, national and international jury. So you know how the judging proceeds. There's about six, seven hundred entries every year. They go through regional awards, so the local regions, and specifically here, the London region, initially pick buildings. They then get elevated to national for consideration for national award, and the national jury decides whether yes, it deserves a national. And then they um spend three, two, three days um deliberating on those to create a long list of projects.
SPEAKER_00If your project is under consideration, you actually have to leave the jury. Right. So you don't have a clue. And even the drinks have entered the end of all this because it takes months for jurors to go from regional all the way to the sterling short list. Everyone's mum. You know, you haven't got clues. You're looking for clues, you're looking for winks or um uh yeah, something or other body language. But they're very good. Everyone's very good. Yeah, they'd tell you in a sort of um Kevin McLeod grand designs type way, and by the way, in front of camera or something.
SPEAKER_00So that's when you find out.
SPEAKER_01Yeah, yeah.
SPEAKER_00So nice surprise. Very nice surprise, yeah, yeah. Yeah.
SPEAKER_01Well, look, we're here to investigate your relationship with Stone, and we can't really do that without talking about this building, 15 Clarkenwell Close. But actually, you've worked with the material before. You did a staircase, I believe.
SPEAKER_00Correct. We worked on uh Caroline Place, essentially a house of five bedrooms or thereabouts, uh refurbishment north of uh Kensington Gardens. There they wanted um light to come down from roof level all the way down to new basement level as well. And so a new staircase really had to open up, have a light well in it. The easiest way of making that staircase work was through lots of winders, essentially create a an oval, a helix for a staircase. Now, traditionally, a stone staircase is keyed into walls, rested on another step all the way down from top to bottom, and that's all the way into the early 20th century.
SPEAKER_00Everybody knew how to make that, stonemasons knew how to make that. And we'd then forgotten until the some point in the mid-80s when Price and Myers were scratching their heads, wondering how this system worked. Uh so as architects, engineers, we'd forgotten. We kept on using steel and concrete, lots of structure to hold up what in the past would have just been the stone steps on their own. So we asked um some stonemasons to help us with that. And of course, in this country, it turns out that we're only training stonemasons to work in ornamentation, decoration, restoration projects.
SPEAKER_00In France, they still train them to work with superstructure and specifically those sort of staircases as well. I think of the three tenderers uh that volunteer to look at the project, they're all French. Two of them are actually based here, one of them based in Italy, but they're still a French group. It was the Italians who got it because I think they were provided a more interesting stone to look at. But they taught us the system, what's called part um cantilever, part reciprocal loading. And we uh we actually traveled to their workshop to see how the stone's extracted, how it's cut up, and then we realize actually it's not just something based on traditional skills, but you're using today's technology, software.
SPEAKER_00So the software that we uh in our office we use to draw the staircase in three dimensions is then taken by them to their routing tools, their cutting tools, their machinery, if you like, their robotic cutting tools to divide up larger blocks into the staircases. And what we realized actually was that that software allows less wastage of stone. So it occurred to us um there's a point where our new technologies can influence traditional um skills, and obviously they're then teaching us about those traditional skills as well.
SPEAKER_00We then looked into the history of stone, specifically staircases initially, and other structural ideas in stone. So before long steel beams and um uh reinforced concrete slabs, you could cut small stone bricks, if you like, to interlock with one another to span potentially 14, 15 meters without any intermediate columns, and that's called a reciprocal structure.
SPEAKER_01Reciprocal because it's relying on itself.
SPEAKER_00Exactly, that's right, from one end of the brick to the other, to the other, throwing the load, as it were, along its path to the edge columns and walls, uh, which is quite remarkable when you look at it. So some of this was already drawn and conceived in the 1600s, specifically in France again. Some of it was then built within a hundred years of those initial concept drawings and ideas, engineering ideas. They're very good examples still standing in France. There are now architects working with that CAD software to cut the stone with robots and all the rest of it, to then bend those flat planes that were conceived in the 1600s to become double curved.
SPEAKER_00So there could be barrel vaults, they could be double curved, they could have all sorts of yeah. It's suddenly taken on a very contemporary feel as a combining heritage craft with technology and I think.
SPEAKER_01Precisely, yeah, yeah.
SPEAKER_00Yeah, so for us it was it was a revelation, a sort of embarrassing revelation because we realized that we're no different to everybody else. We're we're taught architecture mostly in the drawing sense. We have no real feel for the materials. Materials tend to be colours and textures that we apply in two-dimensional sense to a drawing. We would like the building to be made of brick, we would like to make partly cut in stone, etc., etc. And no idea that these materials actually have potential structural purpose in their own right.
SPEAKER_00And even if we did, we are suspicious that maybe they don't work, and that's why we have to build steel and concrete frames. So it then drew us to seeing whether we could, instead of just using these things as facades or cladding, whether it's brick or stone, whether we could um use those materials for structural purposes. I won't get overly technical at this stage, but maybe it'll come through through the colour.
SPEAKER_01Well, it's it's it's a mixed audience, so uh so we'd need to be aware of that. Because this building wasn't originally going to be in stone, was it? It was going to be finished in bronze, I think I'm right in saying brick. Then it moved to brick before you finally alighted upon stone. So the obvious question is why stone? Yeah, I I read somewhere it's because you were lazy. I'm quite intrigued by that. Maybe we can unpick that as well.
SPEAKER_00Yeah, no, the the lazy thing is when when I'm in lectures with students and explaining why um try and use one material as opposed to um say a stone column that does everything, the superstructure and the external finish, fireproofing and all the rest of it, as opposed to a steel column with all its other materials. What I tell students is why don't you do the lazy thing? It's far easier drawing a stone column and then fixing that to a floor plate than drawing a steel column with its fireproofing, it's waterproofing, it's thermal insulation, it's vapor barriers, it's connections that have to go through all those layers back to the steel, then get sealed again to then connect to a fixing on the back of a piece of stone veneer.
SPEAKER_00Now you've drawn that, you might even just copy it from a bit of information that a subcontractor sends you. However, every time somebody decides to change the proportion of the windows or move a door, and these things happen all the time with clients and design team members asking for amendments, even planners asking for amendments, all that has to be redrawn and it's painful and laborious, and you scratch your head thinking, God, why am I redrawing all this stuff? And then you see this stuff occur on site, and there's a team of two or three guys putting stone veneer on one column over a week as if it's bathroom tiling.
SPEAKER_00And my sort of pithy um request is be lazy, just draw a stone column. It will be plonked down within an hour, and that's the end of it. And you never have to redraw that several times. So that's the lazy thing. Yeah. But why did it change from one material to the other? Yeah. The long answer is um I'll try and I'll try and keep it brief. Um the long answer is uh all of us as architects will plan the typical layout of our blocks of flats and offices on a particular site, and the site has all its typical criteria.
SPEAKER_00This one has got two-party walls at right angles to one another, so that has its own problems in terms of how much light comes into that plan, and therefore where you lay out bedrooms, bathrooms, living rooms, habital spaces. Where does the sun rise, where does it set, how much overheating occurs, and all the rest of it. While you're doing that, you're thinking, well, what's this building going to look like? What's it made of? Because ultimately what it's made of will begin to determine what it looks like, which I've sort of explained earlier is the way we tend to do things as opposed to come up with an image on the outside, then to let somebody else decide how it's held up, what the structure is, what the materials are.
SPEAKER_00So to help us make a decision on a choice of materials, we will do general research, sort of a if you like, a historical social history research. And obviously, this location is deep in it. There was nothing here until the Normans invaded and they built the abbeys. And literally on our site, we would have been within the Augustinian nunnery, but we would have been where the stables are, all the informal buildings, the timber structures. On the other side of Clarkenwell Close, which was the internal road of the enclave, would have been all the limestone structures. So we were being quite literal and saying we won't build in stone, we will build it uh something that alludes to the half timber structures that were on the site.
SPEAKER_00And again, you know, being frank about our naivety, we imagine, well, it's highly likely our building will be a steel frame. But when architects, when we tend to draw our elevations, we sometimes forget the glazing system is not some super transparent material. It actually comes in typical sections, widths and heights. So full height from floor to floor, but the widths tend to be standardized. And that frame, if it's an expressed external frame, or even if it's encapsulated by the glass, behind the glass will be what's called a backbaked element, i.e., you can't see through it.
SPEAKER_00Put that next to one another, you suddenly have roughly a hundred mil or more, a hundred millimeters or more, width of this blackness going up the building. If you elevate your building and you draw those black lines, they're actually quite powerful to the elevation themselves. And there's quite a lot of metal in them. So we worked with the engineer, which is a piece of software that um is self-learning, and you seed the software with the amount of metal involved in the glazing system as well as the superstructure, and you ask it, reduce the amount of metal essentially.
SPEAKER_00That's what you're asking it to do. And how can I um express that unitized system in another way? So, can we get double-glazed units without any metal in them at all? How would that be held up? And the answer is an exoskeleton in the same way as it's half timber structure in metal. But you galvanize it for weathering, waterproofing, so stop it rusting, but you put um intumescent paint for fire purposes, and then you put a hot bronze application. So it's vaporized bronze that's a self-finish on the outside of that. So, really, what you're looking at is what looks like a piece of bronze sculpture, as it were.
SPEAKER_00It looks like alludes to the half timber frame structures that would have been on the site, literally on the site. You place a diagonal here and there to help the load path go down the facade, and before you realize it, the software has actually modulated that facade in plan and section. So it's actually quite a waveform structure to look at. We thought it looked beautiful. Uh, it reduced the amount of steel on a typical um building of this size by about 30%. Planner really liked him, case officer, and he's one of those old school case officers trained from a while back, who is, you know, in his opinion, it's you know, uh uh as with all things, structures change.
SPEAKER_00But in his opinion, uh the planning is still structured via the case officer. The case officer is the conduit, the drop box for all the consultation, so including conservation officers, drainage, whatever it is, refuse. He will consult all those people, pull that information, and he will make a decision. So he's the power, as it were. So I think what he found was that the structure within the planning department, and possibly generally now most planning departments, is beginning to change. The power is shifting towards what we call design and conservation officers. And uh, and sure enough, he had a tussle with the design conservation officer who felt he was too busy to really get into this scheme, and popped his head through the door during our meeting and said, I don't understand why using um bronze.
SPEAKER_00I've read the um conservation area guidelines, use predominant materials that says, in my opinion, the predominant material is stone. And I begged to differ and said, Well, actually, in this area tends to be brick because at some point in the since the 70s, since that conservation era guideline was written, it said brick, and everyone's been doing brick ever since in a sort of pastiche way and constantly you know it's a sort of self-fulfilling prophecy that what used to be a mixed streetscape of brick and stone and bits of timber is now predominantly 70s, 80s brick.
SPEAKER_00Nevertheless, he said, try for stone. So we had two other projects. Our case officer said, forget it, I'm just gonna push for your bronze all the way to committee, we'll get approval for it. But we realized that if that goes to committee, there'll be a battle between the two. Right. And we thought, well, actually, we've got no prejudices against other materials. We can work in any material. Let's just see whether it is possible. So we had two projects running: brick and stone at the same time. Brick as a load-bearing structure is actually it's possible, but uh the problem you have is that you you have to use something like lime mortar, and lime mortar takes a while to go off.
SPEAKER_00So it takes five days, six days to go off, and you can only go up four or five courses before it gets squeezed out. So, really, what you're asking to do is get your bricklayers on site and ask them to leave for a week, then come back. Leave for a week, come back, and that that means your entire um program is double the period it needs to be. Stone, is it possible to build in stone? So that was our question to the design team. And uh sitting around the same table in the previous building, we asked them um is it possible? Quantity surveyor says, Well, the reason that we don't use stone is because it's prohibitively expensive.
SPEAKER_00If you look at the parliamentary officers, the last ones to use post-tension stone, you could have um clad the entire building in top series BMWs, end to end, and it would have been cheaper than what the outcome was. When was the last time you used stone? Well, I never have. Uh so how do you actually know? Well, I just know from that building. Okay. So it's a bit of a circular argument for the quantity surveyor. Same with the structural engineer. When was the last time you used stone? I never have. Well, why don't you use it? Well, one, we're not trying. Trained as structural engineers, and there's problems with progressive collapse. So ever since Ronan Point, if you take out a panel or a column, does the rest of the building fall down?
SPEAKER_02Yeah.
SPEAKER_00Okay, so how do we go? I don't know. I wasn't trained. Okay, so generally the design teams got circular arguments because we haven't been trained. Architects don't know either, obviously. So we went back to those stonemasons and asked them, is it possible? And they just looked at us as if we were fools and said, Of course it's possible. In France, we used to call it austerity construction because building in stone was cheaper after the war.
SPEAKER_01Yes, post-war in Marseille was a particular spot, wasn't it?
SPEAKER_00Exactly. Yeah. So yeah, that was um Fernand Poulon, who at the same time as Corbusio was building Unité up the hill. He was asked to rebuild the waterfront, and of course he built it for a sort of fifth of the price per apartment, the unite.
SPEAKER_02Yeah.
SPEAKER_00But that was their experiment. It was the post-war period, and you know, concrete and steel are emblematic of the new period. Stone is the old world.
SPEAKER_01So stone was a practical solution, but obviously it was also a risk in that case, is what you're saying.
SPEAKER_00Only when our stonemason said it's possible. Right. And they said, just get the engineer to tell you how much stone you need in volume in cubic meters, and we will tell you a price. So the engineer used exactly the same software as the previous scheme. It sized all the columns and beams. We gave that as a volume to the stonemason, and the price came out a quarter of what it would be for a steel frame clad in stone. So we said, okay, fine, it's financially viable then. It's a news to the QS. The QS has learned something as well as the rest of the design team. Now it's up to the engineer. What is the problem with progressive collapse?
SPEAKER_00Can Stone manage it? And his initial proposal was why don't I increase the reinforcement in the edge of the slab or if it's CLT, the sort of ridge beam? But that was again a sort of slightly perverse solution because essentially what you're doing is creating a series of bigger and bigger beams, but you don't need the intermediate columns. So you're getting this weird argument that eventually do you need any of those intermediate columns at all? And then he had an insight and realized ah, if I increase the plan of our columns, you know, the XY dimension in plan, the volume of the stone increases not exponentially, but quite dramatically by what quite a quite a factor.
SPEAKER_00And that is sufficient. So I will only need to increase it by 50 mil or 100 mil, depending on where the column, what load the column has, and that will be sufficient strength because it's all about internal explosions. So if there's an internal explosion, the columns and beams stay where they are.
SPEAKER_01Right.
SPEAKER_00They're already strong enough to take vehicles bashing into them. It's about internal explosions. So that was ultimately the solution. So we found out financially viable, structurally viable. And then the last question left for the architect is um, well, what does it look like? How is it what we call dressed? So is it Gothic revival, neoclassical? Uh what is modern dressing, contemporary dressing? And that's ultimately where we found instead of dressing it, leaving it naked, as it were, undressed, that the quarry found, you know, when we when we visited the quarry and found all the fossils, ammonite shells, uh, quartz pockets, etc.
SPEAKER_00We realized, well, why can't we have those?
SPEAKER_01I was going to ask, because we've talked for quite a lot of time, but it'd be good for the listeners if we could kind of describe the building because it's what six stories, mixed use, there's offices, there's also residences, you've got a garden on the roof. Yeah. Maybe we can try and paint a picture of what the building looks like for our listeners.
SPEAKER_00Okay. It's essentially taking the superstructure that would normally be inside. So most of us live in buildings where there's internal concrete or steel columns, and sometimes we don't see them because they're hidden behind plaster board. It's taking that structure and putting it on the outside. So it's taking the grid, the skeleton, which is just a grid of either steel or concrete, outside. And here we're doing it in stone. So there's a stone grid of columns and beams. If you like Stonehenge, multiple layers of it instead of a single layer, six stories of it.
SPEAKER_00And I say Stonehenge because the columns and beams aren't just clean cut squares, uh rectangles. They've been left as quarry found, which essentially means a master block is taken out of the quarry, then split according to what the engineer sized for a column and beam, and left as rough as that. So when you're looking at it, that grid is actually quite rough and textured to look at.
SPEAKER_01And it's got fossils embedded in it.
SPEAKER_00Yeah, because it's a sedimentary stone, limestone, its fossils are then uh expressed when you split the stone. So just like finding fossils on the beach, you split the stone, and that stone will split across its sedimentary layer in the same way as wood grain splits quite easily. And then within that sedimentary layer is often the uh a revealed fossil of one description or another.
SPEAKER_01I mean, the stone comes when you visited the quarry, discovered that it comes in three finishes. So the the building is has these three different textures, right?
SPEAKER_00So depending on the quarry you go to, you've got you know industrial scale quarries where uh just giant robotic machines are slicing stones out of the out the quarry, and it's the robot cutting tools will will have everything prepared almost perfectly. There are more artisanal quarries where the stones are obviously a bit cheaper because it's two guys are supposed to have vast amounts of infrastructure doing it. And when it's those sort of quarries, you'll find that they have very simple tools: diamond um wire, encrusted wire, industrial diamond encrusted wire, that cuts the stone like a cheese wire for 20 meters long, and then they use drills to split the stone, and then as well as then um going into the sedimentary layer and sometimes opening it up either with a what they call inflated metal balloon or chiseling into it, it just falls open.
SPEAKER_00So there are those three in those types of quarries, there are those three types of finishes, minimal finishes. And if you're looking to avoid wastage of stone, that's what you live with. The sort of skill of the quarry master to extract the stone and leave those finishes.
SPEAKER_01And can we talk about the roof? Because that's quite fascinating. You have trees up there, bees, bats, all sorts of things.
SPEAKER_00Yeah, yeah. Every building in the UK now, all of us are aware, every time we've got heavy rain, sometimes the sewers overflow and you've got flooding. Every building now, new building, the idea is you have to try and keep any rain water that hits the roof on site. Don't send it into the sewage system. So everybody has to build, especially if you're in an urban setting, if you're somewhere in a new house, in a rural area, suburban area, and you've got land, you can create a pond to keep that water in. But if you're an urban setting, you essentially build a sub-basement somewhere.
SPEAKER_00And the sub-basement's effectively like a pool that nobody uses that you collect the annual rainfall. You then have to have a pump that takes that water through pipes all the way through the building to either water the roof or maybe flush your toilet. So it's grey water usage. It's more infrastructure. And then perversely, because those sub-basements tend to be below um invert levels of old Victorian um sewers, any water going in from the ground into it has to have a sump that's not allowed to mix with the grey water, and then a pump in that sump. So you've got double pumps, double sumps, infrastructure, all costing, not just financial cost, but carbon as well, constant energy being burnt with these pumps, and then replacement of them and maintenance of them.
SPEAKER_00So if you keep all the water on the roof, that's called a blue roof. But what do you do with it all? Do you create this same infrastructure and pump that throughout the building? Or again, this is the key thing about keeping your design team around the table. At some point, they, you know, the landscape architects looking a bit bored, thinking, well, I've done my bit of the agenda. Why am I here talking about sump pumps and we're talking about the blue roof? And you know, his brain lights up where ours wouldn't. And he said, Well, you know, you do realize that trees will suck up that rainfall, grasses won't. Yeah. So, as well as having to deal with water attenuation, planning policy also asks us to create, if it's not a pitch roof and a flat roof, biodiverse roofs.
SPEAKER_00And normally biodiverse roofs are just uh uh wild grasses that don't have to be maintained or sedum roofs, occasionally a piece of timber. The idea is to attract invertebrate insects up there, so it's not just a monoculture. But those grasses will never suck up drink or the annual rainfall. So the landscape architect uh, you know, has a light bulb moment and says, Look, if you put a one giant oak tree up there, it'll completely absorb your annual rainfall. But the structure engineer is also around the table and says, Well, I don't want to deal with a giant oak tree, I'd I have to thicken the slab. How about we have smaller trees?
SPEAKER_00And the landscape architect says, Well, of course. We can have four trees instead of one tree. And if you locate them towards the, the engineer says, if you locate them towards the end of the skeleton, the exoskeleton edge of the slab, uh, we don't need to thicken the slab. So what we have up there is a blue and green roof combined. It's the first time we've done it, and obviously the two different departments and the uh the council don't normally speak to one another. You overlap them as a Venn diagram, and they finally say, Yeah, of course, that's that's possible, let's give it an experiment. And um, yeah, it's it's a revelation to us all that um it's it's flourished so wildly and amazingly.
SPEAKER_01You work with engineer Steve Webb, structural engineer Webb Yates and the stonemason Pierre Bidou on the project. I mean, how easy was it to find the people with the right skills?
SPEAKER_00Well, we've been in practice, ooh, uh I don't try and remember, quite a while. So it takes a while to to work with different teams until you find somebody who um Steve would put it, you sit in the pub with and uh and have a few drinks and argue and um uh uh and you know uh inspire one another. And that's Pierre, the stonemason, Steve, at least one other engineer as well. Can't be all Steve.
SPEAKER_00Um yeah, so it's it's it's about relationship building where uh what I always express to all of them is uh none of us could have reached that result. It's a combination, it's only by uh uh constant feedback between one another we all find something that's I don't want to call it unique, but a bit a better result than we would have found on our own, which is goes back to this idea that architects are you know trained to draw, uh uh draw an elevation, draw a plan, and now hand it over to structural engineers and others just to fill in the structure and other details similarly, and then stonemason gets hired to just put on the cladding or something, as opposed to sitting around the table having that discussion, somebody saying, Well, can you why don't you just do it in in a block of stone as opposed to the and the engineering?
SPEAKER_01But it's more than sitting around the table, isn't it? I mean, you're you're visiting the quarry itself, you're learning from the material, and the material is defining what you do in many regards.
SPEAKER_00Take the table away. We're on our feet, walking in quarries or sitting in pubs, whatever it is, it's about communication, even via Zoom. It's it's about constant questioning one another, challenging one another, with humor, uh not um bullying one another. Yeah, and that's how that's how these inter-relationships um produce good results.
SPEAKER_01Yeah. So I mean, from what you've said, the benefits of building something like this in stone is that it's it's quicker, it's cheaper, uses fewer trades, but there must be, well, there is, because you've talked about it, an environmental benefit as well. Can we talk about what that might be?
SPEAKER_00Yeah, so we imagined we might be reducing the carbon forum because we're, you know, we're architects, we're not trained um sustainability engineers. We imagined just sort of intuitively, well, uh stone has got a less of a carbon footprint than than a steel column and beam, which has to be extracted just like stone out of a quarry as an ore, but with all the other elements then fired up with coking coal and all the rest of it. So it must be a saving of about 15-20%. That's what we imagined. At the end of the project, the um sustainability engineer finished his assessment of the as built and said, what I found was that you've saved 92% of your embodied carbon compared to a steel frame clad in stone.
SPEAKER_00Uh, and I asked him, Well, how on earth have we done that? Just think about it, I mean. I won't tell you, just think about it and call me back when you've uh when you've realized. So put the phone down and ask the rest of the office, what do you guys think? And um, nobody had an answer. We all went home. Um, I'm sure all of us were you know standing in the shower, still wondering what it was. And then about halfway through the next day, somebody piped up, ah, uh, it was laid down four four hundred million years ago, wasn't it? Uh it's already made for you.
SPEAKER_00It's a pre-made, pre-processed product. The only energy being burned is the cutting machinery, the transportation and erection on site. Phoned him back up, and he said, Yes, exactly. It's just the energy in those three processes, the cutting and the transportation erection on site. And he said, Had you managed to get a British quarry to give you the stone, you would have saved another 5%. But at the time, British quarries couldn't give us uh the strength certificates, we would have had to um extract pieces of stone from every part of the quarry and then send it for testing to find out which part of the quarry we could take the stone out.
SPEAKER_00While France still does that, every quarry will give you strength certificate for the stone from every part of the quarry, so you can choose the appropriate stone.
SPEAKER_01It just sounds a dark question, but why are the French continue to build in stone where we we've seemingly forgotten?
SPEAKER_00Yeah. The short answer is all their historical towns, they each one had to have a group of masons looking after the historical towns, so they effectively created a market, a constant, continuous market after the war for restoration and rebuilding of those historical historic towns. So there is a job creation and a market. Well, one making sure those stonemasons are still trained that way, and two, uh quarries are still extracting the stone for that purpose.
SPEAKER_01From a layman's point of view, while stone is less emitting than steel and concrete, I mean it's still extractive. If all our buildings and all our cities were built from stone, we'd surely need vast quarries that would have the environmental lobby up in arms, wouldn't it?
SPEAKER_00Absolutely. Very good question. Now think about making a piece of metal requires a quarry to dig out the iron ore. There's less iron ore than the the imagine the earth's crust is principally stone. So we're sitting on molten magma, and when it cools on the crust, that is the stone. So really all we're doing is acting like termites, extracting a bit of stone here, building it up there. You don't need a lot of stone to build a bit put a building up. And if you look at Edinburgh Old Town, Edinburgh New Town, the the Victorian Edinburgh, most of it was built from a quarry that is now a shopping center, a retail center, uh within the the great the greater town.
SPEAKER_00So the quarries don't have to be big at all. While the quarries for steel and cement are vast. Uh uh and the energy required is vast. And they they are finite. So the iron ore and cement and all the rest of it. We uh certainly sand for the cement we're um we're struggling with. The quarries for stone to build, put our structures up will be uh a fraction of what's required for the other.
SPEAKER_01I mean, there's a lobby that would suggest we'd just be better off, and I know you've worked in cross-laminated timber, but building in in timber wouldn't be.
SPEAKER_00Yeah. There's always a danger with these um uh debates that they become false dichotomies. So people say either or, we're never going to stop using steel, we're never gonna stop using um concrete cement. It's just uh about having an intelligent decision process about what material suits what structure. So if we're going to build a fantastic tunnel from here to uh Ireland, uh it's highly likely to be in concrete. Sorry, I'm laughing. Yeah, sure, sure. Same same with a bridge across the Irish Sea.
SPEAKER_00It's going to be lots of concrete and steel. Could probably do a bit in stone, but it's more likely to be that. So some bits of infrastructure will always require more concrete and steel than stone or timber. Uh so coming back to timber, it again, it won't be uh either timber or stone. There could probably be a mixture. The problem with timber is that you need lots of sustainable forestry, which is not a problem in one sense. There's a um uh a professor Tom Crowther at ETH Zurich, who's finished a piece of research not long ago, which says uh which suggests that there's enough unutilized land, so non-arrable land, cleared land that's in private ownership as well as public ownership, enough of it to forest.
SPEAKER_00So if we clicked our fingers and all of us went out and planted trees in there, he said within a hundred years would be at pre-industrial age levels of atmospheric carbon. Now, only a fraction of that forest would need to be um set aside for construction industry. And the thing about obviously most of us know is that wood trees are carbon sequestrating. Um, and it's a figure that that you still can't can't get your head around thinking that well, one ton of timber holds 1.6 tons of carbon.
SPEAKER_00You think, well, how on earth is that? How does that work? Yeah, but it's it's so essentially the wood is carbon negative. So if you minimize the amount of processing of that wood, i.e. you've cut the tree down, you've cut it into planks or or beams, great, it's it's still carbon negative. If you turn it into cross-laminated timber or nail laminated timber, and these are this is hardwood nails into soft wood planks, and it's the moisture equalization of between those that that that keeps them together, that's still carbon negative. So you you you know, the thought experiment is that very quickly you can make all buildings out of timber, cross-laminated timber, and all the rest of it, and that building is carbon negative, which basically means that the construction industry goes from being a carbon emitter to carbon sequestration industry.
SPEAKER_00So instead of inventing machines that have to suck the air uh into them and draw out the carbon, and then we store the carbon and send it underground or whatever it is, you just plant woodland for construction, and that becomes a carbon-negative sequestration industry and accelerates Professor Crowther's idea of within 100 years we'll be um pre-industrial levels of um atmospheric carbon. However, you know, not everything can be built of uh wood either. So there's bound to be a mixture of stone and wood as ideals of low carbon construction.
SPEAKER_00Um, and we undertook a bit of research for the building center exhibition where we suggested, well, can you build the New Stone Age? This was exactly. So we titled it the New Stone Age, um, you know, to grab everybody's attention. Come along and find out whether we'll be living in flintstone houses or whatever. We went to Canary Wharf and asked them, look, give us your ideal tower, commercial tower, because we just want to do um a bit of research that demonstrates is it the same price? Is it the same carbon footprint or not uh to build in stone?
SPEAKER_00So we initially started off. They gave us a brief, they said our ideal tower is about 30 stories. It's got a footprint of uh X by Y, so many lifts, and all the rest of it. That's ideal for a single tenant, multilets and all the rest, etc. etc. So we then directly compared a steel frame, a concrete frame, a stone frame, and also stone floor slabs. So eliminate as much concrete as you can, steel and concrete as you can. Um the stone, purely stone project ended up um cheaper than a steel or concrete frame version, but it was all it still had a positive embodied carbon footprint.
SPEAKER_00It was a fraction, I think like a tenth of the of the um the steel frame and about um 40%, 40-30% of the concrete frame. So very good. Uh but it occurred to us, well, can we do another version where it's an excess skeleton of stone for fire purposes to meet fire regulations because it performs very well in fire, but the internal floor slabs are cross-laminated timber. Other elements internally are all timber. So you increase the amount of timber. And before you know it, what you find is this again working with Web Yates and eight associate sustainability engineers.
SPEAKER_00We found that you end up with a carbon negative building. So more carbon negative than the uh the equivalent building, concrete frame building is positive. You compare those, you add those together, and you still have a carbon negative result. So you could hypothetically build two at the same time, and you still you are still carbon negative, which tells you it's more efficient to probably demolish some buildings and rebuild them continually in timber and stone, and you end up with a carbon sequestrating um product and industry, as it were.
SPEAKER_01Interesting. Coming back to this building again, that 30-story tower you're talking about was based on ones. Exactly, isn't it?
SPEAKER_00Extrapolating the research we did on this.
SPEAKER_01Yeah. I just want to come back to the Islington Council that seems very determined to demolish it, and there are stories of documents being lost, of information being redacted. I don't really want to get into that because it's been quite well rehearsed, that thing. But I think you told D Zine when you won your appeal that it didn't feel at that time like much of a victory. Pyrrhic victory. That's how you described it. I mean, do you still feel that way, I wonder?
SPEAKER_00Uh well, I mean, it literally means um, you know, you've almost rivened yourself financially, because that's what the Pyrrhic Wars did, and then they eventually left um Rome and said if we beat Rome again, we'll be ruined. And that's what it felt like at the time. You wish you hadn't spent that money. I wish us still today that we didn't have to spend that money. I again, I don't want to, you know, uh you you you you've pulled the string, I'm just gonna carry on after. But at the end of it, our barrister said, give me some money, now we will sue the council for tens of millions. And you're you're tempted to do it just to get your the money that you spent back.
SPEAKER_00Um, because you don't get all of it back at all. But uh, you know, lots of advice from others was like you're gonna spend the next two years, you've just spent two and a half years stressed and writing legal letters, you're gonna spend another two and a half years doing this, then you won't just want to carry on being an architect. So that was the decision.
SPEAKER_01You gave a talk for the AJ when you're in the middle of it.
SPEAKER_00You were obviously visibly yeah quite distressed. Yeah, yeah. Yeah. It's difficult, isn't it? Because uh People forget it's actually a piece of paper that says it will be demolished. Whether you demolish it or we demolish it, it will be demolished, i.e., you're going to be homeless, your practice will be homeless, financially ruined, etc. Uh, and you have two and a half years to consider that before the actual appeal hearing. During that time, it concentrates the mind. You know, uh, how on earth did this happen? You blame yourself. It must be your fault. It must uh, we as architects must have done something wrong with the paperwork.
SPEAKER_00In some senses, yes, uh, there are there are subsections of planning law that allow you to submit what's called a section 96, uh section 27 or something. I can't remember exactly. I shouldn't know, but I shouldn't mind.
SPEAKER_01But your listeners can write in tennis.
SPEAKER_00I've handed it all over to planning consultants from now on that say every time you make a slight change in the scheme, even if the case officer allows it, if you use one of these certificates, it's indisputable. No one will ever be able to dispute it. Uh, and all your drawings are then legally bound to that certificate. And what had happened was that somebody uh at the enforcement office decided to literally take all the drawings, all the references to Stone out to say there was no Stone approval at all.
SPEAKER_00Uh strictly speaking, legally he wasn't allowed, but it was in his opinion, it was arguable. And it turned out he hadn't actually asked for legal opinion, he'd just done it on himself as you know a senior enforcement officer. He he thought he was correct in doing so. So you ask yourself, is it ethically correct ethically correct that somebody can do that? Um, you know, you as I said, two and a half years to concentrate the mind, that when somebody presses a button because he's been told by a counsellor to do that, uh, what are the consequences? Does he realize that he's actually potentially making the people who live in the block homeless, including myself, our business financially ruined, etc., etc.?
SPEAKER_00Or is he just doing it because he's been asked to? And it's just a piece of paper. I've ticked the box. Uh, the consequences further down the line I've got no sense of. And you realize that's the sort of thing that's going on. It's not somebody being personal, they don't know you, they don't know your circumstances. There's just several stages up the line, they're wholly emotionally removed and have no ethical connection with what they're doing. They've just, you know, press the button, as it were. So you have to set that aside and put it in a box and not think about it to be able to carry on. Uh, and then obviously at the appeal, um, when the enforcement officer is being cross-examined, he then confesses yes, because he's under oath.
SPEAKER_00I've removed all the drawings because I was told that no stone should be in existence. Did you seek legal advice? No, I didn't. If they're all poured back in uh as as they should legally should be, is there an enforcement notice um viable? No, it wouldn't be. Okay, end of story, that's it. And that's uh uh and that's you know stuff you learn uh uh not only about ethics, but also people are in a position of power, not only to be able to press buttons for for those sort of actions, but actually their decision-making process.
SPEAKER_00So why did they decide that? Well, it turns out that councillor was under the miss uh because it the scheme had got approval via delegated powers and didn't have to go to committee. This councillor sits on the planning committee, he had made the mistake thinking he ought to have seen it and approved it. And then he just he he he just started a campaign which he couldn't press a reverse button on and it was all about aesthetics to him. I don't like the look of it. And you think, well, how is somebody in that position who's unqualified? Well, one, is it ethically correct that you should be making decisions about someone's private property?
SPEAKER_00It's not a public building, it's not public money, it's not publicly shared, uh, to decide whether they are ugly or not. And then you decide whether they should be there or not. And then, I mean, setting aside that he did it without, if you like, in quotation marks illegally, why are we putting people who aren't qualified to make those ethical as well as aesthetic decisions? So you you it concentrates the mind. It's it's sort of interesting, interesting in many purposes as well as stressful.
SPEAKER_00Yeah, I can imagine. That you realize, aha, there are some revelations coming on here about how the entire planning system works, how we've because we we've walked into it, we've we've handed power to people who aren't qualified to make these decisions, and you sort of feel sorry for them because they they are sitting. You see them in committees scratching their heads looking for guidance. Is this building ugly? And you think, well, why are you deciding whether it's ugly or not? It should just be strict planning policy. Does it meet the planning policy? Has it got the correct employment use, enough affordable housing, etc.?
SPEAKER_00Not whether you like it or not.
SPEAKER_01There's a whole debate about beauty here, which I think is a podcast for another day. But I'm I'm very keen to talk about your background because it's fascinating. Your parents came from Iraq and Sudan and met studying medicine in East Germany, which is where you were born. So how did they end up behind the Iron Curtain?
SPEAKER_00Both of them are born in um post-colonial Iraq and Sudan. And what tended to happen in those countries is Britain lowered the flag and a new flag went up, and Britain had put in a friendly head of state, as it were, uh government. Very quickly, those um governments tended to be on the whole, they tend to be a revolution of some description or another. And you in the post-war period, you were either nationalist or communist, and sometimes that literally then divided up into um eastern bloc or or western bloc, as it were.
SPEAKER_00And Iraq had its communist revolution, as did Sudan. Uh, their immediate counter-revolutions and counter-counter-revolutions. And in that period, when there were about both of them about 15, 16, uh, communist periods, the the Eastern Bloc countries, just like the British Council, would come over to counter countries and say, why don't you study in the UK? Uh, and part of that purpose is yes, you know, it's good, good cross-fertilization of cultures and knowledge, but essentially what you're doing is creating a cultural link, uh sort of cultural capital links to those countries.
SPEAKER_00And those Eastern Bloc countries are doing exactly the same. We will give you scholarships to come and study in Berlin, whatever you like. And they they came over and studied, um, I think my mother actually started chemistry first and swapped over to medicine, and then met my father after having swapped over that year. They then studied medicine, they had us while they were studying, at least two of us, and then a third after they graduated and were working. They didn't have to stay, of course, but what happened was that there were counter-revolutions in their countries. And my mother's brother was actually a nationalist.
SPEAKER_00So he he basically called her and said there's no point in coming over. The entire nationalist party is going out, finding all the communists and shooting them, so you better not come back. That's a good reason not to go home. So she was certainly a maroon, same, same with my father, and they never couldn't they couldn't go back. Uh and she's never been back since.
SPEAKER_01Oh, really?
SPEAKER_00Yeah, yeah. Because obviously, you know, post-um Saddam, Iraq um hasn't been easy either. So they they then had to find where else to go. Uh they had relatives over here. This is 70s, and England was looking for UK was looking for more doctors, fill-in places, so they they had relatives who were working in hospitals. So we landed at South End on Sea.
SPEAKER_01Oh wow.
SPEAKER_00Yeah, South End General Hospital, uh, hospital accommodation, doctors accommodation. So you're kind of an Essex boy. Absolutely. I was uh would have been about seven years old, I guess. Uh and um, you know, South End on Sea. I know it, which is a misnomer. It's on the estuary, it's not in the sea at all. When the tide goes out, there's no sand, it's just mud flats. But you quickly get used to it, don't you?
SPEAKER_01You know, did you s did you swim in this in the estuary? Um I went because I am an Essex boy. I didn't go to South End so much. I bought some electric guitars from South End. Clacton. Clacton Pier used to be a family day out. Frinton, if we're feeling particularly posh, would be uh posher. But I have swam in that coastline. Do you remember East Germany? Do you have any memories of it?
SPEAKER_00Yeah, of course. I mean, you know, seven years old, you'd remember it. I mean, but uh you know, when people uh ask for memories, they imagine it's it's you know what they some dystopian um images because that's what everybody driving a Trabant or something. If you're an adult brought up over here and then dropped in over there, probably is, but as a child, it's just your environment, isn't it? And there's nothing particularly terrible going on for children. But I think it's an it was a new state, wasn't it? New post-war state, uh, and it's making its mistakes and errors.
SPEAKER_00And some of them are structural, they can't help it, they're never going to change it unless they want the country to fall apart. But even as a as a uh six, seven-year-old, you're aware of them. There are very, very odd decisions where you which you think must have been uh contrived by the education department to make the country fall apart. Such as um, well, they'd give you books on um being a good communist child, and uh all the East German um possibly the same for the rest of the Eastern Bloc, all the all the children would join the equivalent of scouts, and Germany it's called the FDO, which uh I'm not sure what the acronym stands for, which is equivalent of scouts, everybody gets a neckerchief.
SPEAKER_00Uh you you go camping, you do all the things that scouts do, different type of salute, but it's a blue neckerchief. And in the same books, you you read about being visited by the Russian equivalent and uh sharing camps, and you're looking forward to the camps, but mysteriously they're all wearing a red neckerchiefs. And we you're already told if you're very good and do all your duties and are a good communist child, one day you will graduate to a red neckerchief. So you imagine in the books they're saying, well, all the Russian ones already graduated to that, and then you meet them, and it turns out they just get them automatically.
SPEAKER_00Yeah, for a child, that's already unfair, isn't it? It doesn't take much. You think, well, in hindsight, you know, as you get older, you think, why why who on earth thought that a child a child would ever accept that? So in immediately all of us as kids were well, why are they getting the red one? Yeah. What do we have to do? Why do they get it automatically? So that's resistance that the teacher who was telling us the showing us the book hadn't expected. It's odd, isn't it?
SPEAKER_01When you well washed up, landed in South End. Yeah. You were presumably a German-speaking. Of course, yeah, yeah. Well, I was that I mean, you're an age where you're just difficult.
SPEAKER_00I'd actually spent um I think my mother had three kids while um studying, and my gran would come over and help with the childcare. And I think she offered, why don't I take Amin, the eldest, to to Baghdad for a while to give you some time. So I actually ended up in Baghdad for for about two years. Oh wow. Forgot German, learnt Arabic, and then came back to Germany, forgot my Arabic, learnt German, and then immediately went to England. And you can imagine Germany's continental climate, Berlin and um and nice and dry and proper snow, and you arrive in the winter in um in in in South Endwall Sea and it's damp and raining and there's no snow.
SPEAKER_00Yeah, it was a bit of a shock initially. But then again, yeah, you have to learn English, uh, but it doesn't take long as a child, you know, you absorb this stuff pretty quickly. Yeah, you've got no choice.
SPEAKER_01But you come from a diverse and let's face it, post-communist background. I mean, did that lead to any issues?
SPEAKER_00Not really, no, no, I mean not. You mean in in as a child in the 70s, 70s south and on 70?
SPEAKER_01Yeah, 70, 80s interesting time.
SPEAKER_00Somebody would say, Oh, I hear you come from communist um Berlin. No, not at all. It's more, you know, uh, I don't know if you you you're an Essex boy, then you'll remember you're probably about the same vintage as I am. If you go to the school, how many non-white kids are there? It's that sort of thing. Very few. Yeah, exactly. So now, of course, the schools are uh much more diverse, but back then you'd find yourself as the any non-white kid, and it's uh initially exotic to some kids, but you know, we all seek out difference for teasing and all the rest of it, you know, it could be your your hair.
SPEAKER_00Of course, my hair? I don't know why I looked at your hair. I'm imag imagining it was ginger.
SPEAKER_01Very sensitive about my hair at the moment.
SPEAKER_00Yeah, so you yeah, it's that sort of those are the differences, uh, as opposed to um um you know thinking that you're a communist child or something. Yeah, and were you always gonna be an architect? No, no, I was uh, you know, my parents are doctors. Uh uh, they they I'm the eldest, they expect me to set the example for the other three kids and become a doctor. Uh, but as the eldest, you're doing all the childcare as they're in um, you know, doing their ward rounds and uh working on call and all the rest of it. Um, and you realize this is a terrible job.
SPEAKER_00And never here. Why would why would anybody work this hard and never never be with the kids? Uh so I opted for architecture, didn't tell them until I got my place. And then I my mother still says she has a letter that I wrote to her saying I'm going off to study architecture. It broke her heart on me.
SPEAKER_01Oh, really? Interesting.
SPEAKER_00It broke my heart.
SPEAKER_01I think my parents were because both my parents are doctors, as has come up in this podcast in the past um cousins and aunts and uncles and great-grandparents when they were alive. And they were quite relieved when I said I didn't want to be a doctor.
SPEAKER_00Yeah, yeah. It's a difficult one, isn't it? Because they um they they had a they they felt it, there's a moral purpose to it. So if you fantasize about being a lawyer, they would argue with you why it's bad to be a lawyer, uh, any other profession. So you just stop talking to them about it. Um but all the other kids ended up in medicine. Because they asked me, you know, what's it like being uh in a school of architecture, going to be an architect? And of course, the first thing they tell you in a school of architecture, uh, as all other architects tell you, is you're applying for it.
SPEAKER_00It's a life of penury, you know, the you're you're the whim of recessions, and you'll all end up poor. Please don't do it, go ahead and do accountancy or something. So you transfer that to your siblings, and uh and you know, the National Health Services' job for life, fantastic, um, fantastic uh pension, all the rest of it. So they they just stuck to that.
SPEAKER_01I mean you you studied under Izzy Metstein at uh at Edinburgh, um, who I I guess is best known for a series of extraordinary contemporary churches in and around Glasgow with Gillespie, Kidd and Coir. Yeah, I mean he also hailed from Berlin.
SPEAKER_00That's left for the same age. Yeah, exactly. Yeah, yeah.
SPEAKER_01Um what was his influence on your career?
SPEAKER_00Uh uh very, very bluntly, he made it clear that you have to be in control. You're the captain of your own, not just the architecture, but your own life. So it wasn't really just teaching you about the aesthetics or form or or how to uh coordinate, plan, section the hard stuff, the graph that every architect has to do, but it's more life lessons as well. So I think because his background's roughly you know, sort of similar, uh, what um what um um 18th century German and Swedish um um um anthropologists, pseudo-scientists would call Semitic.
SPEAKER_00We're both of the Semitic race under that demon definition, similar sort of family background. I used to giggle with him about the sort of stuff he used to say. Other people might be offended or couldn't take it, but it's the way that families talk to one another. So uh his guidance, which sometimes is a bit sort of needling, chimed with the way our family talks.
SPEAKER_01Well, it's interesting because in his OB in The Guardian, Gavin Stamp said he was both revered and feared for his incisive and often devastating criticism of student work. Yeah. So did you revere or fear?
SPEAKER_00Uh well, I think I revered him because he was the way he was, uh, as you say, sometimes feared. I mean, essentially all he was doing was saying that you didn't do enough work. So some people would pin up and would expect to have a have a light touch um criticism because other tutors would do that. But he would look at it and say, Well, look, um, you clearly only started drawing two weeks ago, and I set this project eight weeks ago. Don't try and kid me, you didn't. Uh, because you, you know, I know you guys can resolve this, but you because you've left it so late, you can't.
SPEAKER_00It's evident. And you'd nod your head and say, Yes, you're quite right. Other people would collapse under the criticism. Um, and he wouldn't phrase it like that. I mean, he'd there'd be guttural bits of swearing and um and uh mostly analogies. And at some point, uh, the student body, the student cohort, I think one or two of us had really hard times with her, uh, got together, wrote him a letter saying, you know, this is unfair, you need to change your teaching style. So he held a meeting.
SPEAKER_00Um, and uh at that meeting, the the leader of this uh revolution, as it were, um uh started it off saying, Look, Izzy, you like your analogies, but uh going into a crit with you is like going into a car crash. We're um always experiencing these car crashes, and of course, not everybody experienced the car crashes, but uh clearly some people found them very difficult. We're in fear then of uh of going into these crits. And he he he he turned around and said, Well, you know, if you're having so many car crashes, perhaps you should have your license taken away.
SPEAKER_00Of course, I giggled and started laughing because I thought, well, it's it's true, you know. If you're if you're that terrible at it, perhaps you shouldn't be doing it. Um, but yeah, it sort of disarmed the uh the revolution, you know. He he he stayed on and um well he did eventually leave, but I think he didn't really want to. And because he realized, look, uh he enjoys it if the students enjoy it. And most students up to that that stage, I think it's a generational shift, you know, what they call the snowflake generation. I think we were already the initial snowflakes general uh who couldn't take it.
SPEAKER_00Uh and he realized, look, I like students that I get on with. And if if at least half the student cohort are struggling and I can't get on with them, perhaps this time I did go. Interesting.
SPEAKER_01Can I ask all this background? Does that feed into the way that you've set up your own practice? I mean, everyone who stays at group work for 18 months automatically becomes an equal partner, I think I'm writing saying.
SPEAKER_00Yeah. Uh that plus working in other offices. So I spent my time going in at least two, three other largish offices. When I say large ish for architects, that tends to be 20 plus, sometimes 50, 50 plus.
SPEAKER_01Because you worked at Rick Mather and Lif Schultz-Davis, Sandy Lands, Wilkinson Air, Zaha. Exactly. Well done. Thanks. That's your CV.
SPEAKER_00Well, yeah, well listed. Uh, one other one, Andrus Persons, who was entirely on his own. I missed. Missed Andres Persons, who lived a couple of doors down from me when I was uh when I first came to London. What you realize is that it's the name on the on the brass plaque outside the outside the building, as it were, and it's their name forever. And uh it's actually the hard work of everybody who's there that's that's building. I know that they were the founders, they're the guiders, uh, and they still often do guide and teach, uh, but really it's the hard work of everybody else that lifts and elevates that practice and maintains it and propels it.
SPEAKER_00Lots of hard work, lots of innovation and um ideas that come from people that join, as opposed to all of it from the one master, as it were. So I was determined if I was to start up a new practice, leave independently, work independently, then um at some point, as people join, we have exactly that understanding. And it's a mutual respect where yes, I might be old and uh more senior and more experienced, I can give that knowledge, but it's a debate. So as you say, it's the same way that Izzy might have debated with you.
SPEAKER_00You could you could throw those ideas about and he would quickly tell you whether that's um it's gonna have legs or not, uh, from experience, as it were. But then if there are new ideas, he'd be open to them and say, okay, I think that could work if you did the following from his experience. So it's that sort of relationship. So part of it, yes, about open debate, being open to criticism and not collapsing under criticism, and part of it that you reward people for their actual endeavors as opposed to it's just your name on the brass plaque and all the wealth is yours, etc.
SPEAKER_00And that's probably, you know, somebody's argued that's probably because you spent your formative years in East Germany.
SPEAKER_01Well, yeah, I mean, uh yeah, that's that's that's the the path, the narrative path I was uh I was treading. What was it like working at Zaha's?
SPEAKER_00Do I say the exact opposite of that? She the office was her family, and I think people misunderstand when they think of her as a prima donna who was super aggressive and angry and uh to be feared like Izzy. It's the same thing. It's um she's Iraqi, uh, the same sort of family dynamics, as it were. Uh, and because the office is her extended family for her, she treated her like a family. So it'd be very open, what people would today call verbal abuse.
SPEAKER_00Uh, you know, you might accuse your parents of verbal abuse, but it was those that sort of relationship. And sometimes it'd be just just you know, I'll give you an example. She'd be on a lecture tour and she hadn't been in the office for a month, and everyone's meant to hang up their coats and um bags uh in the hanging area because there isn't much room in that office, it was a tiny space around chairs, you'd trip up and it'd look like a mess. And of course, while she was gone, the place turned into effing pig star, in her opinion.
SPEAKER_00And she couldn't hold back and scream and shout at everybody, open the windows and throw everybody's coats and bags out as a lesson that you should never do this again. Uh yeah, so it was like that. And as long as you understood, you know, she would fire you on the spot because she just hated something that you did that day, your haircut or something, and literally something like that. Uh, you didn't leave. But if you were new and you didn't understand that, or or you're or you didn't have that sort of parental upbringing saying more about my parental upbringing.
SPEAKER_00If you didn't if you didn't have that sort of background, understand that sort of background, um, you would go. And then the next day she'd ask you, Where's such and such? Well, you just fired them, didn't you? You fired them yesterday, get them on the phone, and then she'd be barking at them on the phone. If you don't get here in the next 20 minutes, you're Fired. But yeah, so it was like that. Yeah. Fun, fun, very lots. I mean, it doesn't sound like fun, but you were given actually lots of freedom. It sounds like it sounds terrifying. No dear. Yeah.
SPEAKER_00No, well, on a more positive note, uh, there was lots of freedom. People don't think there was lots of freedom, but actually, a project would come in and maybe four or five teams would set themselves up of two or three people, and all of us would have a go at that project, have complete freedom, design freedom with it. And slowly but surely, between us all, including Zaha, if she was there, we'd reduce those options and say, well, that one works for this reason, but this one doesn't have any merits at all, and then come up with a result that had the best of all of them, or that particular thing, this single idea was sort of reign supreme, as it were.
SPEAKER_00So there was a lot of freedom and fun in terms of design um opportunity.
SPEAKER_01I've taken up loads of your time. I mean, so I'm coming to the end of this, but I just really quickly want to return to the raison d'etre behind this interview, which is uh stone and the materials. You've described yourself in Architecture Today as finding yourself as, and I quote, an inadvertent campaigner for lower and negative embodied carbon construction. Is that really how you feel? Inadvertent?
SPEAKER_00One of my last projects while studying was on sustainability. There is sort of at least 10 key lessons for every architect to work with when they're designing to make a sustainable future in construction and um maintaining burning energy in buildings, etc. I tried at that time to sort of push that agenda, but you're a graduate, you go into an office, the office has a way of doing things, the industry has a way of doing things, you know, you're you're you're just shouting in the wind, it's pointless. Uh so you just work with industry, within the industry.
SPEAKER_00And what you realize is the the education system is not structured to give architects, designers, including engineers, the full understanding of materials. And that's really key to architecture. So when I say inadvertent campaigner for sustainability, really what I'm saying is that architects need to have full knowledge of all materials and make intelligent decisions about their material choices. And that's not just it has a sustainability title, it has a poetic title that it should give us joy and delight, the architecture.
SPEAKER_00But in the same way, it has to stand up and not fall on our heads. It has to stop from bursting into flames. It should also be have low or negative embodied carbon sustainable.
SPEAKER_01Very good. Final question. Plans for the future. What can we expect from you? What are you working on currently?
SPEAKER_00I'm super keen on trying to get a larger, well, the 30-story plus tower to demonstrate that it is carbon negative. So a standard office building or larger um residential building. At the moment, on our um drawing boards, as it were, large houses, an office building, um not so large, a small theatre mixed bag, I guess, of of things.
SPEAKER_01Very good. Very good. Well, look, thank you so much for your time. I really, really appreciate it. It was great.
SPEAKER_00You're welcome. Pleasure.
SPEAKER_01And to discover more about Amin and Group Work, go to groupwork.uk.com. As ever, there are images from the interviews as well as little films and other things on my Instagram page, Grant on Design, and you can find all the podcasts that I've done, sign up to my newsletter and lots of other stuff at grant ondesign.com. Finally, and this is really important, if you've enjoyed listening and want to see this podcast flourish, then please rate and review on Apple Podcasts or wherever you listen to this from. And it would make me incredibly happy if you went to my Patreon page and made a pledge at patreon.com forward slash material matters.
SPEAKER_01For as little as two pounds fifty a month, you can receive exclusive posts, blogs, and thoughts from yours truly, as well as getting access to each episode before it's published to the wider world. Material Matters is a completely independent concern, and any help you can offer would be hugely appreciated. Ultimately, you'll be helping to take the message the importance of materials, skill, craft, and design to a whole new audience. Thanks very much for listening.
Bethany Williams describes herself as ‘an artist, humanitarian and sustainable fashion designer’. Since graduating from the London College of Fashion in 2016, she has collaborated with organisations that help people...
Corin Mellor is the creative director of David Mellor Design - a brand that is synonymous with his father, David, but also the design and manufacture of beautiful cutlery, primarily made of stainless steel. According to...
Nicola Turner is a UK-based artist who is best known for her use of horsehair and wool in her extraordinary, and often quite dark, sculptures. She originally trained as a theatre designer - working for the likes of the...
Dublin-based architect John Tuomey first appeared on Material Matters in 2024 to talk about his brilliant memoir, First Quarter. Now he’s written the follow-up, unsurprisingly entitled, Middle Quarter. John is the...
What if the materials a building needs are already sitting in a skip down the road? Joel de Mowbray, founding director of Yes Make, joins Grant Gibson to explain how a regenerative design and build practice rescues...