Skip to content
PodSubs
ShowsPeopleGuestsJobsNewsEvents
More
BlogPodCred
Menu
ShowsPeopleGuestsJobsNewsEventsBlogPodCredNetworksSign in
Join nowSign in
  • Shows
  • People
  • Jobs
  • News
  • More
    • Guests
    • Events
    • Blog
    • PodCred
    • Networks
    Join nowSign in

Material Matters with Grant Gibson

Material Matters with Grant Gibson artwork

John Tuomey on the importance of materials in architecture, designing London's V&A East, and his new book, Middle Quarter.

Sep 9, 20261 hr 7 minAudio
ShareXLinkedInFacebookWhatsAppEmail

Dublin-based architect John Tuomey first appeared on Material Matters in 2024 to talk about his brilliant memoir, First Quarter. Now he’s written the follow-up, unsurprisingly entitled, Middle Quarter. John is the co-founder of O’Donnell + Tuomey. He was the inaugural professor of Architectural Design at University College Dublin and visiting professor at Princeton, Harvard and Yale. Over the years, he has won numerous awards, including the RIBA Royal Gold Medal, and his practice is responsible for buildings such as V&A East, the Lyric Theatre Belfast, and the Glucksman Gallery in Cork. In this episode, he talks about: this year’s opening of V&A East; material as ‘tangible reality’ in architecture; why he wrote his new book (and why it isn’t a biography); being interested in mortality and melancholy; architecture and ‘endurance’; his relationship with his mother (and her friendship with actor Richard Harris); the purpose of poetry and the purpose of architecture; creating buildings with lasting value; being ‘lucky’ and working the way he wants; failure; the importance of music in his life; architecture as an ‘occasional art’; his inner drive; being drawn to the scared; oh... and telling Michael Graves to ‘fuck off’. You can buy the beautiful Middle Quarter here: https://shop.materialmatters.design/products/middle-quarter Support the show

Audio and video play straight from the show's own hosting. PodSubs stores and serves no media.

Transcript

From the show. Tap a time to play from there.

SPEAKER_00Hello and welcome to the latest episode of Material Matters with Grant Gibson in association with our thought leadership partner, Berghaus. And it's also the first you can watch as well as listen, which I have to confess is making me a little nervous. This is a podcast where I talk to a designer, maker, artist, or architect about a material or technique with which they're intrinsically linked and discover how it changed their life and career. Think of it as a bit like Desert Island discs, but with materials instead of music. And today I'm delighted to welcome the excellent John Toomey.

SPEAKER_00I spoke to John several years ago about his brilliant memoir First Quarter. Well, guess what? He's written a follow-up, unsurprisingly, entitled Middle Quarter. John is the co-founder of O'Donnell and Toomey. He was the inaugural professor of architectural design at University College Dublin and visiting professor at Princeton, Harvard, and Yale. Over the years, he's won numerous awards, including the RABA Royal Gold Medal, and his practice is responsible for buildings such as VNA East, the Lyric Theatre Belfast, and the Kluxman Gallery in Cork.

SPEAKER_00John, thanks very much for doing this. How are you? I'm good. Nice to meet you again. How are you? I'm all right. I'm all right. Yeah, yeah. I mean, we're doing this over YouTube for the first time. Okay. So the audience can, if everything goes right, see you.

SPEAKER_01See what we're up to.

SPEAKER_00Yeah. I know it's it's like it's like taking back the curtain of the Wizard of Oz. But uh um but it'd be good to know where are you right now, John?

SPEAKER_01Okay, I'm sitting in my studio. Um a little structure that I built with my partner, Sheila, is at the end of our garden in our house in Rath Mines. So it's uh it's a workplace at one remove from the real studio, you know, from the office, but also crucially at one remove from the house. So it's a it's a shed at the bottom of the garden, but it's uh it's it's important. It's yeah, it's become a great place, actually.

SPEAKER_01I'm delighted we did it.

SPEAKER_00Yeah, and is the studio far from where you are now?

SPEAKER_01No, it's about a five-minute cycle, very nearby. So people can come and I mean, typic you know, in my in my earlier life, I spent a long what you mentioned about me being a professor, I spent a lot of time at the School of Architecture in UCD, which is in the other direction. My office is in that direction. And uh after I left teaching at UCD, the worry was that all that kind of outside the office time would get sucked into being in the office all the time.

SPEAKER_01And I was looking for this kind of in-between space where I could be doing things that weren't exactly the office or or kind of a more a more um yes, uh a kind of a third space. And and actually this place has been fine for writing, for drawing, for kind of parallel projects that that aren't exactly the business of the office, but or maybe at the early stages of conceptual design when you just want to be on your own, you know.

SPEAKER_00Yeah, yeah. So is this where you wrote the book?

SPEAKER_01Yes. Yes, this is where I wrote the book. That's right. At this very desk where you can see me now.

SPEAKER_00Very good. I mean, you are the first guest we've had on for a second time in the show's history. So we've done 152 episodes now. I know. Um, since we last spoke, you've opened uh a couple of buildings in my hometown of London. Um they're right next to each other on the site of the 2012 Olympic Games, Saddler's Wells East and VA East. Now, I saw you there briefly when the latter opened earlier this year. Um, and I'm interested in the the building's form.

SPEAKER_00How did you about how did you go about giving a an outpost of the VA shape?

SPEAKER_01Yeah, you know, that it's kind of I would say it's atypical of what you're normally asked to do, because normally what you're trying to do is make sense out of a pre-established program. You know, if it's a school, you know, it's got six classrooms, two teachers' rooms, you know, whatever. Most buildings have a defined room-by-room kind of schedule. But the VA, they wanted a building that could take any sort of exhibition, that could be open to change, that could be flexible in every way.

SPEAKER_01In other words, we weren't involved in the design of the exhibitions that go into the building. So we had to make a structure that could accommodate many voices, that could protect the unspecified museum ingredients, because the VNA has a such a huge collection, now all stored in the storehouse nearby in the Olympic Park. So actually, the primary consideration for the trustees and maybe for the kind of ethos of the VA was going to be this question of the identity of the building.

SPEAKER_01How would it read? How would people know it was a museum? How would they see beside these other more um typical institutional buildings? How would they see that the museum was had its own character? So that was kind of interesting. Um actually, I think if you're able to see on the screen, you can see on the top shelf behind you there, um, almost my first model ever of the of the folding form for the VA. And I wanted to get this idea across that that the contents of the museum were protected, but that the form of the museum was expressive.

SPEAKER_01So the thought of it wearing it, it wearing a jacket, you know, it wearing a protective garment, um, seemed like a nice analogy. And and I don't know, I was looking at paintings by Vermeer in the Irish National Gallery where where the you're thinking about the space between the sleeve and the body, you know, um the in-between space, if you like. I was looking at exhibition we saw at the VA that had Balenciaga um costumes that where Balenciaga was sort of hanging his garments from the shoulder drop to the floor, which reminded me of um clerical robes that, you know, from my early days as an older boy, as a schoolboy.

SPEAKER_01So I guess I thought, yeah, we'll just put it, we'll just put a jacket on it, you know, and then we'll fold it like tailoring. And I mean the the big driver from the VNA's point of view, common topic was to be sure to what they call lower the barriers to entry, that is, to invite as many people to walk in that door, people who may not even know what the contents of the museum were, but to make it open. So thinking of it like a tent, you know, thinking of it like with big openings at the bottom and then into the protection of the tent, I think that it sort of began to make sense.

SPEAKER_01Um enough sense for us to develop it as a design. But you've been there, so you've you can tell me what you think.

SPEAKER_00Well, I have, but I might tell you later. But this is a because this is a podcast about materials. So I'm bound to ask the question. Oh no, you must. It's in a sandy-coloured, you decided you specify the sandy-coloured kind of concrete. And I guess you're probably most associated with your work in brick and and in the book actually, which we'll come on to shortly, you talk about London being a city of bricks. So why concrete? Exactly.

SPEAKER_01Uh exactly, to be not brick, if you know what I mean. And I mean when I say that once the concept was established and once the thought metaphor, you know, was communicated through simple cardboard models, and then there's a question of how to make it. And I don't know about you, but maybe people of my generation have a strong foreboding about the idea of precast concrete because you tend to think about very repetitive forms and very expressed joints and leaky joints, and you know, it has a bad association in the minds of someone who grew up in the 70s, 80s.

SPEAKER_01But I thought if we if if we went to the workshop and spoke to the people in the pre-cast concrete, maybe we could do something because maybe that could maybe that could suit the idea of the form. So the first question, you know, was can we make a building out of 480 pieces, none of which are exactly the same as each other, all of which must connect precisely with each other to millimeter tolerance. And I want to draw lines over them to make those connections, to, if you like, disguise the idea of it being in any way a panel system.

SPEAKER_01And what I found in the workshop was the same craftsmanship I'm used to finding on the site, if you like, but just indoors. So we had carpenters, we had steel fixers, we had all the people that I would associate from my childhood working on building sites, they all work in this big factory, and there's that minimizes waste, that minimizes um they're very conscious about carbon and recycling their materials and even recycling the steel and the water.

SPEAKER_01And um it was a I must say, that part of the project, the part you're asking about, about the material, that became really, really compulsively interesting to me. And um we did something I didn't that I didn't know could be done. That we we built something, I would say, that is extremely carefully put together, as if it is a monolith, you know, as if it's made out of stone.

SPEAKER_01Um but uh and where the structure and the skin are sort of codependent on each other. So the form is the structure, if you like. And then I was looking at, yes, the non-brick buildings, like the Bodleian Library or I don't know, the Tower of the House of Parliament, you know, things with lines on them and things with made in sandstone and things things that were monument rather than fabric, if you like.

SPEAKER_01And um we did a lot of studies because the colour is comes out of sand and gravel. And yeah, I I actually, for uh apart altogether from the question of form and identity, the construction question, the material question, is is really for me that was a journey of discovery and and very worthwhile, I think.

SPEAKER_00Yeah, I mean it's interesting because in the book, which we again we will come on to shortly, middle quarter, uh you write uh a very short sentence at one point stating quite simply that materials matter. And I guess from your perspective, why?

SPEAKER_01Well, because I feel somehow that the further I mean, if you allow me to say the craft of architecture, the further the craft of architecture moves away from commitment to material, the less convincing it is. You know, an architect is an intellectual. An architect thinks about their practice as an art practice. But if the architect loses the belief in the primacy of the thing itself, then what do you build what gets built deteriorates?

SPEAKER_01Buildings last far longer than my lifetime or any architect's lifetime. So you must make something that carries the thoughts that are in your head, embodies them in the form, but then carries it through in the actual stuff of the building itself. I'm I'm determined that um material, you know, the physical depth, solidity, uh tangible reality matters hugely in architecture.

SPEAKER_01And um I would I wouldn't want to do a building that didn't have that feeling of substance about it. Um so that means that when you use a material, you have to use it true to itself and and um not try and do not do the wrong thing with it, you know, not not try and do the not try and do the opposite. Um materials matter, okay. That'll do. Isn't that the title of this podcast? Well, it might be.

SPEAKER_00It might be. Uh I mean the other interesting thing about VNA East is uh, as you've pointed out, it's it's uh the second new building on the site from the VNA, the other being Storehouse by Dillas, Gavidio and Renfro. I mean, inevitably, architecture critics have compared and contrasted. I mean, the last piece I read uh of Jeremy Melvin's Before He Very Sadly Died recently did precisely that. Um is that a curious sensation? I mean, it's a situation that doesn't come up in architecture too often. The situation being people comparing one one VA building to another that's round the corner.

SPEAKER_00I can't imagine that situation could emerge from the colour. Not just a VA, but but you know, a building that you've done.

SPEAKER_01The storehouse, which I think is wonderful, is all about taking the volume of space that's made possible by a big shed and stacking it. It's a gigantic shelving system. I mean, and its reference points are the management of storehouses like Amazon storehouses or data centers, or you know, it's a it's a huge machine, but based on the model of a of a shelving system with gantry access.

SPEAKER_01It has this beautiful poetic aspect to it that the dimensions of those gangways were are pr pretty well, I would say, precisely um tied into the dimension of the Smithson's Robin Hood Gardens. So you feel when you're in it, you're in streets in the air or decks in the air. You know, I I find I think it's a generous and capacious and kind of mystifying um storehouse. But our building is the exact opposite of that because our our building is for display.

SPEAKER_01Our building is an exhibition building. And the the VA's plan, I mean, what in the VA's language, our building is the stage and the storehouse is you know backstage. And there's no reason they should look alike. There's a great advantage that you can put something in a truck in the storehouse, bus, you know, drive it around in the secure dock of the museum and put it on display, and you know, and people can see the selected, if you like, the curated objects as well as the uncurated or stacked objects.

SPEAKER_01Um I I don't they they should not be similar. They are not similar, and they're not similar in kind.

SPEAKER_00Well, I guess it's a question about journalism or criticism as much as anything. Uh-huh. You know, where you're where you're expecting a compare to be compared and contrasted. And does that bother you?

SPEAKER_01Well, because me and Liz Diller are both working for the VA. No, we we I mean we spoke about it, we met and talked about the difference between our two approaches. Um I think in our terms, in in the the both working architects' points of view, it's a compatible proposition. Critics will make what they make of it. Um one criticism that I I was surprised by, and I'm not sure if it's the one you mentioned.

SPEAKER_01But um one person said what an ugly colour it was. And I thought, well, it's this it's the colour of all the sandstone monuments in the English public realm. So that's quite a sweeping um dismissal. Does that bother you? Do you read all the the reviews? Of course you read reviews because it's so it's not like you don't in the old days you if you didn't subscribe to a magazine, you didn't see it.

SPEAKER_01Now it's impossible not to see everything. That's that's uh that's coughed up. Um and I think you have to be careful because if you react negatively to negative reviews, then you you turn yourself into some sort of protected species because and you sh and you should not get high in your own supply. Um I I I'm happy that if the building stands it's if the building stands in the way I want it to stand, and if it's thriving in its use, then I think opinions can come and go.

SPEAKER_01If somebody tells you you're looking lovely tonight, you you better you better know that there's more going on on their side. You know, it's not all directed at you.

SPEAKER_00I mean you say in the book uh that buildings speak to other buildings. Yes, they do. So I'm interested, what are VA East and Saddler's Wells East saying to one another?

SPEAKER_01I actually I I think they're they're the product of the same way of thinking. If you walk around them carefully, you will see that a lot of the folding brickwork geometry in Saddler's Wells East is the same geometry as you see. What you see inside Saddler's Wells East is the same set out geometry, the kind of crumpled wall that or faceted form that you see on the outside of the VA. Saddler's Wells East is another, if you don't mind me just talking about it for a moment, it's a very interesting question because maybe an architect's first thought, if they were asked to do a dance theater, dance studios, would be to think about movement, fluidity, dynamics.

SPEAKER_01You know, because they've got dance in their head. But what's interesting when you sit down with dancers and choreographers, they are definite that they want coordinates. Dance happens on a rectangular or even a square stage. The stage is set out with chalk marks on the ground, and the dancers know exactly where they're landing. And when they do a triple turn, they watch the corner, come back to the corner. You know, they take their bearings from the geometry of the room.

SPEAKER_01So it was we did a lot of work with the choreographers and dancers out of Saddler's Wells and went to visit studios and um people in Europe, in Belgium and in the Netherlands, France. And what we learned was that dance studios are rectilinear. And if they're not rectilinear, the choreographers partition them into rectilinear form. You know, we went to that beautiful building that Herzog Demaron did, the Laban Studios.

SPEAKER_01Yeah, which are curved, it's a curved building. But inside the studios that they they are partitioned now into rectangles, and um because they the dancers want to be able to clock, you know, time and measure their actions. So that was interesting. So you're you're you're not going to make a free form fluid form for dancing activity. What dance needs is rhythm and rigor and measure. So Saders Wells is all about the harmonious arrangement of established parts.

SPEAKER_01It's like an arrangement of pre-sized elements. It's closer, in a sense, to a school, you know, where the rooms are defined, and the architect's job is to is to assemble or yeah, is to combine these things into a meaningful artifact. So you couldn't find two buildings more opposite to each other, two questions more opposite to each other than Sadler's Wells, Dance and VA Museum. But what they had in common um was this desire to open their doors, open their foyers, and invite in participatory audience.

SPEAKER_01So actually that sense of foyer is public space, delayed threshold, invitation um it's a common theme to both buildings. And it's is something that we try and practice in our work every day, this feeling of threshold or shared shared in between. So, you know, they might look different, but their ethos is not different. Does that is that is that explain itself or does that make sense?

SPEAKER_00No, it yes, it it it goes it goes some way. It goes some way. I mean, we're really here to talk about your new book, Middle Quarter. Um as I said, a memoir, follow-up to first quarter, um, which it's safe to say, John, I I loved. Um I mean, when we spoke last, you weren't sure if you're gonna write a second instalment. If memory serves, you asked me if you should write a detective novel. Um but was this book always really gonna happen?

SPEAKER_01No, no, no, no, no, no. Um this book wasn't always gonna happen because I thought I thought what I was trying to do was trawl up, you know, how my childhood made me before I began thinking like the way I think now. But what happened to me after publishing it and um after it became you know an object was a feeling of um missing the process. I miss the evening activity of sitting down by myself trying to trying to put trying to make sense out of the things I could recall.

SPEAKER_01So I mean this book is not a is not an autobiography, it's not a research book telling you day by day, week by week, it what this book is like trying to find themes or strands that I could somehow or other make into stories that that would um even if they're even if they're slightly at one remove. I I was thinking of them as factified fables, you know.

SPEAKER_01It's not that I mean all of it is true, but it but but for me it was more important that the that the lessons I learned or that the the situations I was faced with would would sort of be compressed into visualizable um elements in themselves, you know. It's a kind of memory box. And I yeah, so I I think I I think I just liked the writing of it, you know, and wanted to do it again.

SPEAKER_00I mean there is the cliche of the uh the difficult second album. I mean, was that true in this case? Was it trickier a second time round?

SPEAKER_01It was good to put a deadline on it, I mean a deadline an endline on it. I thought I thought I thought I would end at the point where that discussion we've just been having, where you know we won this big competition in London in 2015, the one we've just been discussing, the East Bank. And I thought I'd stop it before that, so is that there's some distance between, like 10-year distance between what you're reading now and and now, if you like. So it's it's it's reflection.

SPEAKER_01Um so that was the only limit I put. I thought, well, it it'll be the follow-up to first quarter. I'm not gonna write four quarters. Um uh there are place names in the landscape, you know, in in Ireland, in on the Iron Islands and in parts of the countryside where you get East Quarter, Middle Quarter, Far Quarter. So I thought that's it, that's the answer, you know. That um that's the answer. Middle quarter. And then I and then my publisher told me I had to write a follow-up book.

SPEAKER_01Well, you know, we want we want another book.

SPEAKER_00So um So your publisher was seeing the the pound signs.

SPEAKER_01Well, I I I don't think he's making any money out of it. He he wanted a follow-up book, yeah. And that was good. So uh so it's book two. Yeah.

SPEAKER_00Yeah, there you go. I mean, there are a few themes, both professional and personal, that come out of the book, and I'm I'm sure we'll talk about them later. But the subject that crops up again and again is is death. I mean, of your parents, of friends, of work colleagues, your opening line reads dead, deceased, cease to be, gone. And the final line is uh is a joke about your own burial site. I mean, it does it does beg the question, are you feeling your own mortality, John?

SPEAKER_01I am. I I I am interested. Um I I mean, you know, I I am interested in what survives of us. Um if I hadn't been an architect, I might have been an archaeologist. I I I'm interested in the idea even of being buried in the ground. I mean that joke that you're talking about, it does kind of does kind of i in interest me. I'm not afraid of death or it doesn't worry me, you know. Um I I I yeah, I it's a natural process, I think.

SPEAKER_01So what happens when you're trying to recall the things that mattered in those years that you're writing about is that the you start missing the presences that were vital presences in your life. You know, I write about my parents, but I also write about friends that um should should be here now, you know, should be with me now, but are dead because they died young. Um and I wanted to kind of you know, yeah, honor them, I think, or tell myself about them, you know, just just set it down.

SPEAKER_01Um there is a lot about there is true, there's a good bit about death. But melancholy isn't a bad str state of mind, I don't think. Um you know, they're dead, but they're not gone. I mean, yes, they're gone, but they're not gone because because you because um there's this great thing that there's this great thing that Auden says in his um testament to WB Yates when he died in 1939, that he says, you know, he died in the dead of winter.

SPEAKER_01He died in the dead of winter. But he he says that um on the day that he died, he became his admirers. In other words, that somehow or other all the people who knew him or all the relationships he had became who he was after he was gone. So I you know, it's like half-life or or distributed life or something. I think that is an interesting way to deal with the dead is to think about their presence, you know, in their absence and and where their presences are made evident.

SPEAKER_01I mean I I I must say I think any architect is probably got to be interested in things beyond a lifespan. Well, interesting legacy. Yeah. No legacy. Endurance. No, no, I don't know. I don't I don't know about legacy because you're interested. I mean, if you treat the buildings you meet on the street as being alive, I mean that is to say that you can relate to them, you can read them, you can. Buildings speak to buildings, you know. I mean that that the ideas in the buildings are still vibrant inside in the buildings.

SPEAKER_01Um, I'm not talking about personal legacy, I'm talking about the lasting presences of structures, infrastructure, urban structure, landscape structure, and architecture. These things outsp outspan, I mean they must outspan any human life. So it is interesting to think about time passing, people passing, but but things going on.

SPEAKER_00This is just to remind you that our big fair, Material Matters London, is opening very soon. It runs from the 15th to the 17th of September at Unlock Shoreditch and is part of Shoreditch Design Week. There's lots to look out for. Berghouse, our official thought leadership partner, will be leading our Cafe Conversations Talk Series, for instance, and you'll be glad to hear that the Groni Talks will also return. Elsewhere, there are installations from the British Council, Matrix Design, the Wood Awards, and the Only Natural Awards. Front and biotech company Biomason have joined forces to unveil the Mimic Tile, a floor and wall tile that grows with the help of bacteria, and they will be joined by companies such as Ultrafabrics, Architectures, Bench Space, Lockskin, Blast Studio, and Mali, working materials such as hemp, coffee cup waste, and bacteria.

SPEAKER_00I could go on, frankly, it's a very long list full of extraordinary people doing fascinating things. Material Matters London is free to attend for trade, but it's vital that you register, and you can do that at our website, which is materialmatters.design. That's materialmatters. I don't mind confessing that the opening chapter made me a little teary. Um I mean just before she died, your mother told you that love is the only thing that matters.

SPEAKER_00But then you go on to say it was always war with my mother. What did you mean by that?

SPEAKER_01Um I mean, my mother's it's the first book, first quarter, I think, dealt a lot with my father. And uh I mean I didn't know he was gonna pop be in it so much, but he was in it a lot, and indeed he's in this one too. But but my mother was such a strong influence on me when I was a child because my mother gave me the feeling when I was young that I had something to do, you know, like you are here for a reason and you have to do it.

SPEAKER_01So from early childhood, I was you know, bred to believe, led to believe, that I had that I was on a mission or I had a purpose. And so that push that I got from my mother is formative. But then strangely, when I started to practice the independence that she had encouraged me to take up, which say happens in your teenage years, um it caused a lot of conflict because she wasn't happy with the choices that I was making.

SPEAKER_01And and then that sparked argumentation because you know I was trying to say this is what happens if you encourage independence, is you you get it, you know. Um and and I think something happened, some kind of breakdown in trust, maybe. Or I don't know, trust. Certainly the innocence of the of our early relationship was a little bit maybe on my part there was a sort of veil of caution um introduced.

SPEAKER_01But actually, she is such a positive force and only looks to the up that um that uh she was a dynamic and um she was only interested in what the positives where the positives could be found and how to go for them. And um I'm absolutely sure that that has you know entered into my own character, but they were kind of clashes, you know, there just were.

SPEAKER_01I mean everybody has that with their parents. Um where you even feel that they're foreign to you, or you're foreign to them, or something. Um luckily she lived a long life and um and we got to know each other, you know. She was a hundred, nearly a hundred when she died. And I never lost touch with her, and um we did a lot of things together, which I'm very glad to say. Um I'm very glad that we did, we spent a lot of time together.

SPEAKER_01Um she was she just was a formidable woman. She was, you know, you you she was no push over.

SPEAKER_00I mean, there's a there's a very poignant moment where you're in Paris after her funeral, and you always send her a postcard when you're on your travels, and you wonder if you can still keep the conversation going. And yeah. And then that's interesting because you say your relationship with your father improved in the years after he died.

SPEAKER_01I I I think it I think it did. It kind of settled into I mean I I even think in a way, conversationally, you know, you now the talk the talk is internal, but but I I remember a lot of what he said, and I he's kind of with me a lot in but I mean he you know inside my head. Um this is part of this idea that that that the that the memories of the person are are are still somehow you know in in the ether and and that they're still for you to deal with, you know.

SPEAKER_01Um if you don't mind, I I I I remember that when I was in university learning about architecture, and I think we were being taught a sort of first principles, problem-solving find the you know, the function finds its form kind of argument. And then when I left college and went to visit the buildings of Palladio, um, which I did with Sheila, and we spent a long time, you know, tramping around the backyards of Palladian villas and the Veneto, which are really farmhouses, you know, fancy farmhouses.

SPEAKER_01Um you realize, my goodness, the I I I can read this as if it was as if I can read the ruin as if it's a building site. You know, I can see the possibility in the thing that seems to be vanishing, I can see it as if it is emerging. And then I realized, well, we're all living in the same time. It doesn't matter actually if it's 600 years old or if it is now. Um it's possible for the thing to be, let's call it the continuous present.

SPEAKER_01So I sort of feel that about my um my dead friends and relatives, that that um that just because they're past doesn't mean they're lost. They're they're they're uh their presence is still is now kind of, or at least you know, part of it, has been um taken inwards into all the people they knew, including me. And um I find that I find that kind of interesting, that idea of distribution or concentration. Um is this making any sense to you?

SPEAKER_01Yeah. This is this is I mean it's it's help it's it's it's helped me um reconcile myself with you know things I might have said or things we should have said or things we could have said. I I I feel we can, you know, you can kind of continue to exercise it in your in your own way. I mean in a way that is also the function of poetry, I think, that poetry does that. It puts shape on on sentiment in a way, or shape on perception. And I mean there's a very close link between the purpose of poetry and the purpose of architecture, as far as I'm concerned.

SPEAKER_01Um so yeah, the yeah, it's just trying to make a sense out of the memory. Yeah.

SPEAKER_00No, it's fascinating, John. I mean there are some lovely sides in this, though. Your mum grew up with Richard Harris. I mean, that's pretty cool, right?

SPEAKER_01Yeah, that's very cool. It's very cool. He was our next door neighbor in this fancy this fancy street in Limerick. Um, you know, they lived in big houses next door to each other. And of course, when we were young, and my my mother would be telling us about Dickie Harris, you know, when he was on television or in the cinema, and we kind of didn't really credit it, you know. We thought, ah, yeah, yeah, yeah. Um my mother is, you know, when we were young, she had a role to play. She had five children and she was quite proper.

SPEAKER_01Um, anyway, we were walking along the street in on holidays in Kilkey, which is where Limerick goes on its holidays, on the promenade. And I heard this voice calling, you know, like, GLADUS, you know, down the promenade. And my mother whirled around, and and this he's a broad-shouldered athletic kind of a guy. And he was home from some film set, and he came bounding down the promenade and picked my mother up, and they went dancing off down the beach. And I just thought, what's that?

SPEAKER_01And um she was she was super excited to see him again. And um it was kind of great because I suddenly you know saw my mother as a teenager. Um and and and met and I met Richard Harris. And uh yeah, it was it was fun. It was fun, and it turns out to be actually real, you know, as well as just uh this booming voice.

SPEAKER_00There are lots of other stories in the book of friends and families, but also architecture and architects. Uh, and in 1987, you got a phone call from Michael Graves asking if you'd be interested in taking a teaching position at Princeton, and you put the phone down on him. I did. I mean, why else did you do that? Well, it's worse than that.

SPEAKER_01I said, How would you fuck off and put the phone down? I thought it was a joke, you know. I was cooking dinner. Um, I mean, we Sheila and I had just had a young son, and you know, I was at home and I was, I think, you know, cooking dinner and the phone rang. You know, the old days of the phone in the kitchen. I picked it up and said, you know, would you come and teach with me in Princeton? And I thought, ah, it's one of my friends. In fact, you know, I had a good friend in America that's also mentioned in the book.

SPEAKER_01And I thought, ah, yeah. And so and I was busy, you know, and I said, Oh, just fuck off, you know, hung up. And um, the phone rang again, like it just rang again. I picked it up, and um Michael Gray said, I'm I'm sorry about that break, uh, breaking connection. There must have been something wrong with the line. I was asking you, would you come and teach in Princeton? And uh he was my and you know, he never mentioned the um it again. You know, he never said that.

SPEAKER_00He just he just glided over it. I mean in the in the late 80s, he must have been in his kind of imperial phase, I imagine. What was he like?

SPEAKER_01I I think I got to know him a little bit because I was there for the semester. Um and his work was at a stage where he had got, you know, he had got he had been moved out of this kind of ultra-crafted work for, you know, extremely refined post-Corbusian American houses, villas, really. Um he'd been moved from that into a much more commercial world, and he was doing big hotels for Disney, and he was doing, you know, he's doing um and he had lots and lots of people in his office and lots and lots of work.

SPEAKER_01But you know, Michael Graves, when I was when I first heard of him when I was a student and when I saw his work first, he had such an incredibly um refined way of drawing and way of shaping purist kind of post-Carbusian space, which I'm you know, was very interested in. Um so he had he he he had all that, but he had kind of he had kind of um he had been led in other directions by commercial pressures, I think.

SPEAKER_01I think of him as a postmodernist. Would I would I be like to him, you know, something and he's you know, one night we were at a dinner and he said, uh I'm uh I'm just a boy from Indiana who can't say no, you know. But but uh when on my first times teaching with him, you know, he was very generous about allowing me to participate in writing the program, steering the students, directing the students, and keeping an ethos in the studio. And it was my first you know, step outside my province, if you like.

SPEAKER_01I mean, I'd been teaching in England a bit, but I'd never crossed the water to America. And uh one of his he's at a very famous house called the Hanselman Residence. And one of the children of that client, a young woman, um, Julie Hanselman, was studying in the studio. So she was, you know, the child of one of his clients, and she had joined his studio in Princeton, and I was her tutor. And we were talking about her work, and I was trying to kind of put a bit of rigor in her work and clean out some of the, let's say, the fat out of her work.

SPEAKER_01And I was saying this to her, and he was at the opposite desk, um teaching somebody else, you know, in the studio, at a desk review. And Julie looked up and she said in a loud, cheeky voice, she said, but John, everything you're telling me is is the opposite of what Michael is doing. And I mean, it's um what would Michael? And Michael's sitting right there, you know. And she said, It's you're just teaching me the opposite of what Michael would have done, like the house he did for my parents.

SPEAKER_01And she looked, and Michael just looked over the top of the desk, you know, looked over the top of his glasses and said, Now, Julie, listen to John. So he was very funny and very generous, and actually very inclusive of a range of ideas, even though uh his office had gone in the Direction that you have described. So it was a different experience teaching with him than I mean I wouldn't have been, if you like, working with him.

SPEAKER_01And I think I was a bit dismayed on that day I did the tour of his office, and I met this amazing woman who's painting banana leaves up the side of a model, you know, for a Disney hotel, like seven stories high, and she's painting banana leaves. And I just I must have, because I'm no poker player, I must have revealed my you know um dismay. And he he put his arm around me. We were going to lunch, and he put his arm around me as we left the office and he said, It's all right, John, you don't have to like this shit. So he I I liked him.

SPEAKER_01And um he interestingly enough, he kept in touch with us after that. And uh occasionally we met at events, or indeed he came to visit. Um I think he came to visit when we finished the Irish Film Center in the early 90s, and then he wrote to me a couple of times after that, you know, um, including once telling me to be careful what I wished for. Um so yeah, people aren't only one way, you know.

SPEAKER_01And uh he he had a lot, he had a lot to offer. He's a very good critic, a very good teacher.

SPEAKER_00I mean, there are lots of phrases in the book. I mean, you're a beautiful writer, John. There's lots of phrases in the book I enjoy. One of my favorites is a simple sentence where you write, and I'm gonna quote, you don't make architecture from good intentions. What does that mean?

SPEAKER_01Well, maybe that connects back to what you were asking me earlier about material. Um I was talking recently to a friend from Italy and we were discussing the problem that emerged in Italian architecture in the in recent times, when the architect had, if you like, stepped too much into the position of the intellectual and gave up engagement with geometry and construction.

SPEAKER_01Um so talking about architecture won't make architecture. Um wishing it to be nice won't won't make it good. There's a base there's there are baselines like x-ray lines around geometry and proportion. And then there are real physical facts around construction and material. And I think if you lose track of them and only think about um only think about your good intentions, then you won't make architecture, you won't make a build you won't make a building that contains any lasting value.

SPEAKER_01Um I'm certain of that. I feel certain that buildings themselves have their own authentic or their own physical presence. And an architect has to respect that. That's what I mean when I say artisan, maybe artisan craftsman, you know. Um it's not it's not a notional activity.

SPEAKER_00You have a chapter entitled Luck and Timing. Do you think you've been lucky?

SPEAKER_01Depends on the day that's in it. I I do feel frustrated that some things, some lucky things that might have gone well vanished, vanished in the ether. Um, so I feel, you know, unlucky. Um, but I know that I'm lucky because the principal aspect of my luck is that I've been able all my life to do what I want to do. I I I don't think I've ever done anything I didn't want to do.

SPEAKER_01So that must that must be luck. You know that that I'm working at I'm working in in the way that I want to work, and I'm working on the sort of stuff I want to work on. So yes, I wish that I wish that some things that went wrong had gone right, or some things that fell off the table had stayed on the table.

SPEAKER_00Um but I know that you know I've been able every day to to feel that I'm that there's a purpose to what I'm doing. Yeah, that's really interesting, John, because there are disappointments from the book. Competition's lost, projects not going quite as intended. I mean, you mentioned a school project in the Utrecht uh, for example. There was a project in Hungary uh missing out on awards, and you talk about the Irish economy uh crashing at one point and not building in Dublin for uh a decade, and you mentioned being broke before you uh won the RIBA raw gold medal.

SPEAKER_00I mean, this is an architect's life, I guess. I mean, how how do you how do you deal with the setbacks?

SPEAKER_01Actually, I thought it was also important to say that because you know architects architects probably know how to live a good life, and and maybe people think that architects, you know, lead a glamorous life or something. But I mean my my experience and the experience of many people I know is is is sailing much closer to the wind than that. Um so I I thought it was important to talk about failure. I mean to reveal failure or to be honest about it and and to show moments when you think it's all washed up or that the boat has sailed.

SPEAKER_01Um so it's a bit yeah, it's cyclical, you know, like a theater. You go, you know, you you put all your work into something, it goes dark, you start again, you put all your work in, it goes dark. But that's a cycle, but there's also this kind of dips and rises, you know, in and somehow or other you have to manage to manage that melancholy doesn't turn into depression. Um I we I we describe it as a constant struggle. It is a constant struggle, I think.

SPEAKER_01Yeah. I think you know, there's an odd thing that say you say you do something like, you know, that everyone thinks is fine, but you've kind of extinguished the very you've extinguished the source of the work that was there by doing the thing. You know, if you build a theater in Belfast, then that theater is built. They're not going to want another one, you know. And oddly enough, um there's no repeat work because we're doing all these one-off buildings. It's not like a restaurant. If you cook a good meal, somebody comes back the next night because they want to have another nice meal, you know.

SPEAKER_01The director of the museum isn't going to want another museum in the morning. Um so there is this high-risk aspect that it requires all of your concentration to make the work as intensely real as you can. And then you have to find a way of finding another one to do or something different to do. So it is a precarious, it is a precarious existence.

SPEAKER_01But the lucky part, as I say, is is the feeling that you you're only doing things because they interest you or because you're committed to doing them.

SPEAKER_00I mean, presumably there's an easier route you could have taken through the profession of architecture had you chosen to.

SPEAKER_01Do you think do you think you choose? Um I think you are who, you know, you're going the way you're going. And um I I there there's a lot, I know there's a lot of willfulness in in the formation of every individual. But I don't know. Do you choose? I think you feel this is what has to be done. You know, I think I think I have to I gotta do this. This I have to do this.

SPEAKER_01And and that that's you know, that's that that's maybe that's what I'm talking about about my mother. That there's just a feeling of drive, you know, that that um I can't remember ever saying I choose this over this. I just I just remember feeling a sense of compulsion, you know.

SPEAKER_00You've talked about the importance of poetry, but the importance of music in your life is another thread that runs through the book. I mean, obviously Goethe wrote famously described architecture as frozen music. I mean, is there a relationship in your mind between the two? Does music influence your work? I mean, poetry obviously does.

SPEAKER_01Poetry does, you know, if you like, in a practical sense, because I think what you have to be able to do to do the kind of work that I'm doing is you have to be able to take thoughts, put them into form the thoughts, into a story or into some sort of narrative, which is sufficient to account for itself, you know, to explain yourself to planners, to clients, to other architects, to builders, to, you know, in a way, people have to get it in order to do it, in order for it to be done.

SPEAKER_01So the thought about taking abstract ideas and transforming them into language. Um I I I I think that that's a close parallel with, if you like, practice. Music is so different because music is on another and extremely abstract plane. And I find music absolutely, you know, elevatingly um diverting.

SPEAKER_01So I don't look for anything useful, if you like, out of listening to music except the the beauty of being transported into the into the act of listening. And of course, it's not physical, you know, it's in the air. So, and it doesn't last a minute. You know, I have musician friends who say to me, you know, concert's over, but your buildings are still there. Um, but no, I think music is a very high form of human activity. But it's not but it's but for me, it's a diversion, you know.

SPEAKER_01It's but it's a constant diversion. I listen to a lot of music. Do you play anything yourself? I mean poorly. I mean, uh poorly. I play, you know, it's like you know, I played the guitar when I was young, when I was a kid, and I kept that up a little bit, and then I tried to go back to it by learning classical guitar. But but I mean at my level, it's you wouldn't want to hear it, Grant. It's it's it's it's just following the dots, you know.

SPEAKER_01Um but uh but it's relaxing, maybe, or maybe it's taxing, I don't know. Um it's a discipline. But it it no, I'm I'm not able, I'm not able to transfer anything that I would ever do with my guitar to what I'm hearing when I'm out at a concert. But I I love, I love, I'm thrilled by being close to the you know perform musical performance. It's a great, it's great, I think. Great for the soul.

SPEAKER_00Talking about the arts, towards the back end of the book, you describe architecture as, and I'm gonna quote, an occasional art, as I as opposed, I guess, to the mother of the arts. What do you mean by an occasional art?

SPEAKER_01No, architecture is no longer the mother of the arts. You know, I mean, I mean I guess that I guess this this is at a time when anything that happened in the arts was happening within the architecture. I mean, take a Gothic cathedral, you know, which is a mother of the arts building, because all the sculpture is applied, all the painting is integrated, all the you know, it's it the arts don't happen without the architecture. But now it's not like that.

SPEAKER_01So what happens, I think, when I say occasional, I mean that an architect doesn't have anything to do until their demand is made of them to do something. Architecture is uh architecture responds to conditions, whatever they are. Um whereas music poetry maybe is generated from within and needs no other impetus other than the internal drive of the composer.

SPEAKER_01So an architect would be lonely an architect left to his own devices, you know, would be a lonely figure. But um but but poets, writers, musicians, painters, what you know, they they they're doing it because of what's inside them. Um you know it's coming out from within them. Which I I mean I know that's true about our practice of architecture, but our practice of architecture relies on the invitation to or the occasion, you know, the opportunity to do something.

SPEAKER_01Um so it's a little bit more tied to the ground, you know, than these um than these elevated activities. Um Hegel in his analysis of the arts thought that architecture was at the bottom of the pile, if there is a pile, and it went architecture, sculpture, painting, music, poetry at the top, he thought.

SPEAKER_01And that's because he thought all artistic practice aspires to the condition of poetry. Um far from architecture being the mother of the arts. And I mean, I mean it's a pompous analogy, but there's some truth in that. I there's some truth in in you know in poet, you know, poetical thinking or the aspiration to um poetical resonance that that that that probably at every level, you know, through those steps from architecture through sculpture to paint, that probably is what artistic people are aspiring to.

SPEAKER_00You describe yourself um as being driven from the inside and self-propelled. This is a question that seems to pop up quite a lot on this podcast. I mean, having written the two books, have you worked out what created that drive, where it comes from? Is it all down to your your mother, as you were saying earlier?

SPEAKER_01Isn't that interesting I mean isn't it interesting about I mean that old question about nurture and nature? Because I mean I have two children and I know that I treated them the same. I think I treated them the same. But I also know that more or less when they arrived, like when they were born, you know, I I don't see that much difference between them now in their 30s to what they were like when they were infants, you know.

SPEAKER_01I can't like I think that you know they're you're you're born as a person. Um now there's lots that can happen to you along the way. And I was given a lot of encouragement when I was young. You know, I mean, I was you know, I was clever at school and I I was kind of talkative, and I was probably taking on you know conceptual things when I was young. But I was given a lot of encouragement to keep at whatever I felt was the thing I ought to be doing, you know, to go out and do it, get on with it, and all that.

SPEAKER_01And I of course I'm sure that's instilled in me, a kind of self-belief or something. But I I I I can't tell you who, you know. This comes back to luck and timing. I mean, I have been lucky because I met some of my heroes, and I at crucial moments, you know, I got I got the restoring or or uh consoling, you know, um reinforcement of knowing that that there were that things that I imagined could be made could actually happen, you know, and and gave me the maybe gave me the spur to keep at it, but or maybe I don't know, maybe I would have kept at it anyway.

SPEAKER_01I don't know. You can't there are other alternative vision versions of yourself? I don't know.

SPEAKER_00Multiverses we we could get into here, John, but but but the uh but the interview would go on for some time, I suspect. But uh I've got one well, arguably two more questions to ask. I mean, one of which is is not a small one, I guess, but because much of your first memoir focused on religion and losing your faith, and therefore your relationship with your parents changed. In the final chapters of this book, you talk about uh feeling a draw towards religion.

SPEAKER_01Yeah.

SPEAKER_00I mean, I'm guessing you still think there isn't a god or is this changing?

SPEAKER_01No, it's I I don't really feel the need for a god or or any kind of deity. The thing I'm lonely for, I think, is the um is the shape that religion provides on human life. You know, it's the religion I miss, not the theology not the not the deity. Um I I think it's an interesting thing that community, communion, um larger than self, you know, um structure.

SPEAKER_01That uh the consolation of that, you feel it at a funeral, you feel it at, you know, you feel it at a ceremony. Um the the the drag of the incense, you know, um the sense of the sacred, maybe I should say. That's what I really think. I I kind of I I can't see much to aspire to if there's no sense of the sacred. So isn't that a an odd position for um an atheistic um you know it's something to be reconciled, I think, this this this question of what is it that we need?

SPEAKER_01What where do we find the transcendence that we that we need that that we need as humans without the dominance of an over of an overlording you know um deity. Um that that's the kind of that's that's the kind of problem that I'm talking about at the end of the book, I think. Um I'm certainly not the only person who thinks like that.

SPEAKER_00I'm sure there's lots and lots of people who are thinking like that. You're definitely not. I mean we we're coming to the end of our time, John. There are a number of things I could have spent quite a lot more time talking about. Um but I am interested in what comes next for you in terms of your writing. Should we expect the detective novel? Well, yeah, yeah.

SPEAKER_01This book is still quite new, and you know, it has only just been launched, if you like. I mean, you're uh among the first to review it. Um so it's too early to say. But I know that what I have enjoyed, I I I think I'm drawn to that idea of um, you know, I I said to you last time that I thought architecture was about shaping space. But I'm enjoying the thing about shaping sentences and and trying to find more uh trying to find more economical ways of expressing thought through writing.

SPEAKER_01Um so what I I yeah, I will I think I will be writing, but I I don't yet know whether that's episode three or whether it is that detective story that you mentioned at the beginning.

SPEAKER_00I'm interested. Do you have uh narratives, potential stories in your head the whole time?

SPEAKER_01Yeah, I think so.

SPEAKER_00I think so.

SPEAKER_01Yeah, I think so.

SPEAKER_00See, I'm not beaten up by a novel. I'm quite relieved by that in many senses. I I'm you know I do write for a living sometimes, less now than I used to, but I I'm never needing to write a novel.

SPEAKER_01I might, yeah. I sometimes think I might I might want to write a poetical novel, if you know what I mean. Um I like I like the language. I like I like I like the str stretching bits of the language and making it look like you're not, you know. I like I like I like it being simple, but you know, it takes a lot to make it simple.

SPEAKER_00John, I've taken up loads of your time. Uh really enjoyed that. Again, thank you for coming back. And yeah, I hope the book sells in truckloads. I'm not supposed to say that to an author, apparently, but uh no, I really enjoyed the book. Thank you very much.

SPEAKER_01Well no, thank you, Grant. A pleasure to speak with you. Thank you. Thank you.

SPEAKER_00To find out more about John and O'Donnell and Toomy, go to odonald-to me.ie. You can also go to our bookshop on our website to buy a copy of Middle Quarter, and you can find that at materialmatters.design. That's materialmatters.design. While you're there, you can hear other podcasts that I've done. Sign up to our newsletter and find out all about Material Matters London, which runs from the 15th to the 17th of September at Unlock Shoreditch. One more thing. It would make me incredibly happy if you went to my Patreon page and made a pledge at patreon.com forward slash material matters.

SPEAKER_00For as little as£3.50 a month, you can receive invites to various Material Matters events, as well as getting access to each episode before it's published to the wider world. Material Matters is a completely independent concern, and any help you can offer would be hugely appreciated. Ultimately, you'll be helping to take the message of the importance of materials, skill, craft, and design to a whole new audience. Thanks very much for listening.

Open the transcript file

Hosts and Guests

Nobody is credited on this episode yet.

Credit the people on this episode

Be the first to rate this episode

More episodes

All episodes
  1. Bethany Williams on turning discarded clothes into high fashion.

    Nov 10, 202645 minAudio

    Bethany Williams describes herself as ‘an artist, humanitarian and sustainable fashion designer’. Since graduating from the London College of Fashion in 2016, she has collaborated with organisations that help people...

    Credit the people on this episode

  2. Corin Mellor on stainless steel, Sheffield, and designing beautiful cutlery.

    Oct 14, 202655 minAudio

    Corin Mellor is the creative director of David Mellor Design - a brand that is synonymous with his father, David, but also the design and manufacture of beautiful cutlery, primarily made of stainless steel. According to...

    Credit the people on this episode

  3. Artist Nicola Turner on horsehair, sheep's wool and her solo show at the Yorkshire Sculpture Park.

    Sep 15, 202658 minAudio

    Nicola Turner is a UK-based artist who is best known for her use of horsehair and wool in her extraordinary, and often quite dark, sculptures. She originally trained as a theatre designer - working for the likes of the...

    Credit the people on this episode

  4. Reusing Construction Waste with Joel de Mowbray of Yes Make

    Sep 1, 20261 hr 11 minAudio

    What if the materials a building needs are already sitting in a skip down the road? Joel de Mowbray, founding director of Yes Make, joins Grant Gibson to explain how a regenerative design and build practice rescues...

    Credit the people on this episode

  5. Bonus episode: Hyosung TNC's Simon Whitmarsh-Knight on creating elastane from sugar cane.

    Aug 13, 202646 minAudio

    Welcome to another summer bonus episode of Material Matters with Grant Gibson, this time in association with Hyosung TNC. In this special episode, Grant talks to the South Korean company’s marketing and sustainability...

    Credit the people on this episode