Skip to content
PodSubs
ShowsPeopleGuestsJobsNewsEvents
More
BlogPodCred
Menu
ShowsPeopleGuestsJobsNewsEventsBlogPodCredNetworksSign in
Join nowSign in
  • Shows
  • People
  • Jobs
  • News
  • More
    • Guests
    • Events
    • Blog
    • PodCred
    • Networks
    Join nowSign in

Material Matters with Grant Gibson

Material Matters with Grant Gibson artwork

Tomáš Libertíny on beeswax.

Nov 18, 202050 minAudio
ShareXLinkedInFacebookWhatsAppEmail

Tomáš Libertíny is an artist and designer, who was born in Slovakia but currently lives and works in Rotterdam, The Netherlands. He burst into the wider consciousness with his Honeycomb Vase during Milan’s Design Week in 2007. For the extraordinary piece, Libertíny constructed vase-shaped beehive scaffolds and, essentially, let nature take its course, in a process he dubbed ‘slow prototyping’. The beeswax work took one week, and approximately 40,000 bees, to create. It is now in MoMA’s permanent collection in New York. Since then, the designer has worked with a range of other materials, including paper, which he turned on a lathe, ink from Bic biros, and hand-welded layers of stainless steel, as well as refining the Made by Bees series. He has had major solo exhibitions in Amsterdam, Rotterdam and Brussels, while his pieces are in the permanent collections of the Cincinnati Art Museum, Corning Museum of Glass and the Royal Borough of Kensington and Chelsea, to name just a handful. In this episode we discuss: becoming a chat show host over lockdown; his love of literature; the importance of copying; and how exactly art is like a cat (while design is much more like a dog). But mostly we talk about his relationship with bees - why he came to work with them in the first place, and how they are about to collaborate on architectural-scale projects. Find out more about Tomáš here And sign up to my newsletter here Support the show

Audio and video play straight from the show's own hosting. PodSubs stores and serves no media.

Transcript

From the show. Tap a time to play from there.

SPEAKER_03Hello and welcome to a new episode of Material Matters with me, Grant Keep Ton. We're on series eight, and as regular listeners will know, the idea of a final show is that I'll speak to a designer, maker, artist or architect, about a material or technique with which they're intrinsically linked, and discover how it changed their once and for all. The COVID virus is still very much with us, and at the time of recording, England is once again in lockdown. That being the case, we thought it prudent to record this series over the internet. Nevertheless, I'm very happy to say that my guest this week is Thomas Libertini, the artist and designer was born in Slovakia, but currently lives and works in Rotterdam in the Netherlands.

SPEAKER_03He burst into the wider consciousness with his honeycomb vase during Milan's design week in 2007. For the extraordinary piece, Libertini constructed vase-shaped beehive scaffolds and essentially let nature take its course in a process he dubbed slow prototyping. The beeswax work took one week and approximately 40,000 bees to create. It's now in MoM's permanent collection in New York. Since then, the designer has worked with a range of other materials, including paper which he turned on a lathe, ink from bic Byros, and hand-welded layers of stainless steel, as well as refining the Made in Bees series.

SPEAKER_03He's had major solo exhibitions in Amsterdam, Rotterdam, and Brussels, while his pieces are in the permanent collections of the Cincinnati Art Museum, the Corning Museum of Glass, and the Royal Borough of Kensington and Chelsea, to name just a handful. Thomas, thank you so much for doing this. I really appreciate it.

SPEAKER_01Thank you, Grant. Finally we get to uh speak to each other in a proper manner. You've uh written a few articles about my work, so I really appreciate it that we get to extend our communication channels.

SPEAKER_03It's a pleasure to talk to you. It's a complete pleasure to talk to you. Thank you. I'm looking forward. One of the first things we do in this podcast is get the guests to describe their studio space where they work. I don't know. Are you in where you work at the moment or where are you right now?

SPEAKER_01No, um, I am at home right now because I thought it would be more appropriate for our conversation to kind of slow down and not be distracted by the work environment. You know, I'm sitting in my library, which is full of books, and that's uh the place where I like to contemplate. Uh so I thought it would be more fitting to uh speak with you in this context rather than in the studio. In that case, we'll cheat a little bit. Uh can you describe your studio? Well, that will be easy. It's the same studio I've had maybe since 2009, so almost 11 years.

SPEAKER_01It's a large space uh in the center of Rotterdam. It's half underground, half above the ground, so it is sort of a uh a basement, but it has a daylight, and it's a former post office building near the central station in Rotterdam. It's generous with space. I have lots of storage room and uh different spaces for different activities. I have a painting studio, I have the office, I have a photo studio, I have a casting room, welding room, uh sending, you know, uh storage.

SPEAKER_01So I feel quite privileged with the studio that I have uh in the Rotterdam. But I miss daylight. That would have been a little upgrade. Do you have a team? Um I work on and off with people depending on the projects. Of course, internship is a regular occurrence, but in terms of uh staff, a lot of times it's better to work on projects together. So I keep it flexible instead of having a permanent team of five, six people.

SPEAKER_03And how are the Netherlands with the pandemic at the moment? I mean, we're all stuck at home in England. What's the situation where you are?

SPEAKER_01Well, this is an interesting thing uh with the Dutch landscape politically, economically, socially. It's always been quite a liberal country and they don't like being told what to do. So I I've noticed it early on, probably sometime in March this year, when the first, let's say, uh limitations came across uh different spheres of life in the cities and in the country, traveling included. I traveled a lot to Brussels and it was a stark contrast between how the people in Belgium and people in Holland handled the pandemic.

SPEAKER_01It looked like nothing was happening in Holland and there was a crisis in Brussels. Uh so just hoping on the train I could see a big difference. The Dutch are handling it quite blasé, I would say. Unless there is a stiff regulation from above, they tend to act like it doesn't exist in some sense.

SPEAKER_03Right.

SPEAKER_01But I have to say it depends on socio, economical, ethnical differences. So different groups, different, you know, wealth, different ethnic background uh has a different reaction to following the regulations or let's say looking at them with more seriousness than less seriousness, which is interesting to observe. Yeah, yeah. Is everything open? Right now we are in the same situation as you are, so the museums are closed. I think it was about two weeks ago that all these tough measures uh came back again.

SPEAKER_01So it's a little bit like uh the first wave, but not that strong. Right. We kind of got used to it, so things are limited and businesses have adjusted. So, for example, restaurants are closed, but they are now doing regularly takeaways. Even the restaurants that have never done it before on a sort of luxury level uh restaurants, they also adapted. So it's not only the fast food uh industry, but also high-end restaurants, which is interesting to see, and lots of different businesses have adopted as well. So and how's it affected you, Tomas?

SPEAKER_01Well, uh you're asking from like the beginning or right now, the second wave? Well, we could do both. Well, the first wave was a blessing, not in a wrong way, like I am pro lockdown. We finished a major project just before the lockdown, and I was ready to work on other projects over the coming months in a sort of you know quiet way. So it came like a gift that a lot of things around me slowed down, and there was no fast-paced rhythm to you know make you feel anxiety that you're missing out.

SPEAKER_01But it affected me in a way that lots of projects were uh scheduled to you know materialize this summer. For example, we were invited to do the Venice Architecture Biennale, and we were really busy with the proposal and uh realization of it, you know, then it got postponed until September, then it got cancelled and pushed to next year. So in that sense, we feel it, and um, some exhibitions were canceled, but I didn't have anything that totally disrupted my workflow in that sense.

SPEAKER_01So uh we finished a major project and a lot of projects were scheduled to be realized either 2021 or we just have more time to make them.

SPEAKER_03Yeah, yeah. So I noticed you spent some time hosting your own chat show, really, the bus chairs conversations. Right, you have a competition. Yeah, I do, I do, I don't like it.

SPEAKER_01How did those start? Well, it started because uh it's been quite some time, but uh I've uh designed, uh sculpted this marble chair in Italy, and uh we had it here and the pandemic hit, and I thought it would have been really nice if we could use this chair, which I thought it would be nice to be placed in nature, to invite people to sit on this chair and speak about the pandemic being seated in the chair in the context of nature, because you know I like nature, I think it's important, and this thing with us having limited access to socializing and going anywhere, nature was the only escape that we had at that time.

SPEAKER_01So people were a lot in the park or just seeking places to you know socialize in a way that it's still permitted, and nature and parks was the place, which was interesting to see to observe that people still feel this way once the whole rush of the city and rhythm of uh fast-paced work, sleep is over. This is really uh something we've been missing. And I wanted to talk to people about this uh effect uh that the pandemic made us slow down and uh yeah, we invited them to sit in nature.

SPEAKER_01So the the concept was to speak with 12 important Dutch arts and culture people. It was interesting, this whole wide range of people.

SPEAKER_03Yeah, I mean they last about half an hour. You had quite a big crew by the look of it. Did you enjoy being a host?

SPEAKER_01I was a little bit nervous to start with. I've realized that it did me really well. I really enjoyed talking to other people. I didn't know I was a good listener, but I found out I'm a good listener. I was afraid that with some people I wouldn't have enough experience and knowledge to have an equal conversation. And um, you'll see that everybody is sort of naked in front of the camera. Like there's nobody who's not aware, it's not afraid.

SPEAKER_01We're all human. So it was interesting to see that we're all the same in some sense, uh, in front of the camera. And now being on the other side asking questions, I've noticed that everybody has a little bit of unrest just before the shooting, which was really cute uh to see that you know, people with 20, 30 years of experience of public talk and selling to clients still have a little bit of that self-awareness in front of the camera, being afraid to say something wrong. So that was interesting, but um I really enjoyed it.

SPEAKER_01I must say uh it was an eye-opener for me. Maybe I should do it more often. I was gonna say, will that be more? Well, first we still have to put online the last two conversations, right? And after that, uh we'll see what happens, and we have another lockdown. But I thought maybe to speak to another group of people, let's say a younger generation, because in some sense I interviewed or conversed with that's a more experienced demographic uh within arts and culture. So it would be nice to speak to the younger generation, uh, how they felt about this.

SPEAKER_03I noticed that you gave your guests a present at the end of each show. I did, yeah. It's important to point out that you don't get that here, I'm afraid. Speaking with you is a gift. Very good, very good. The purpose of this podcast is to talk about materials. You've developed this global reputation over the past decade or more for producing these well, really exquisite objects created by bees and made from beeswax. The first piece was shown in Milan in 2007, as we said. Can we talk a bit about the process, Tomas? How are these pieces made? Sure.

SPEAKER_01Thank you for the nice compliments you gave to this project. Uh I appreciate it. The project started sometime between 2005 and 2006 when I was interested predominantly in consumer culture and I studied conceptual design in consequence. Um, not that I necessarily wanted to become an industrial designer, but I was interested in everyday objects and the whole myth and traditions surrounding the rituals.

SPEAKER_01And of course, there was lots of Ronarad and Philip Stark and all that to be looked at and uh enjoyed and criticized. I already noticed there was a lot of this macho culture going on in industrial design where the materials that were used were very masculine. I don't know how to describe it properly, but I felt to look at history of making objects from a different perspective, and I wanted to choose an antagonistic material which was totally counterintuitive to let's say industrial production.

SPEAKER_01And B Swix came across as an interesting choice because it was so vulnerable. Like it's the total opposite of functionality.

SPEAKER_03When you say vulnerable, what do you mean by vulnerable?

SPEAKER_01What I mean it's uh sensitive to pressure, sensitive to heat, sensitive to light. In that kind of a sense, it's vulnerable. Um, I don't know if that necessarily means vulnerable. I mean, everything is subject to external forces in some way. It felt marmable, uh, so it's easy to destroy, it's easy to affect. And of course, if you have wax objects, the most iconic is a candle. Once you use it, it disappears. It's not something that you can reuse again.

SPEAKER_01So, in that sense, vulnerable. Very good.

SPEAKER_03Sorry, I disturbed your flow because we're just in the middle of the process.

SPEAKER_01Oh, sure, no, I can I know where. Well, so I left it at choosing beeswax as a material of choice, and I started doing a lot of research around it. Of course, we all know it comes from the bees, and but that is probably as much as I knew at that time. So I started talking to beekeepers a lot about the process of how beeswax is created, and then in consequence, learning a little bit about the bees. So the first objects that came from there were revolving around the idea of a vase or a vessel or an amphora, because I thought it was very fitting the whole circle of life from flowers through the beehive back to the flowers.

SPEAKER_01So it had a bit of that circular, not yin yang, but the kind of complete journey. The bees collect the pollen from flowers, use it as energy to produce beeswags, create the amphora or the vase, and then the flowers on their last journey as cut flowers are put in that vase. It made it very, you know, complete. Uh so that's why the vase is not any other object such as a chair or a lamp or you name it. It wouldn't have a proper meaning in that context. I started experimenting with different methods of having bees create something that I could recognize.

SPEAKER_01And um beekeepers also didn't know much about the outcome because I proposed something that was not yet, or nobody ever made anything like that before, so we didn't have any reference. We had a lot of trial and errors, objects collapsing in the beehive, or bees overbuilding everything. Eventually, when a vase came out, I didn't know what to think. Because when you study industrial design and you study engineering or architecture, you grow up with the idea that what is your plan is also your desired outcome.

SPEAKER_01So you're very specific about your wishes for the end result. And uh with that mentality, I approach also the work with the bees, but the outcome was never the same as a sketch or the proposal itself. So once the result was revealed, I wasn't sure whether to be happy or disappointed. Which taught me an interesting lesson about certain uh humility and modesty towards nature that, you know, um it's about accepting what is in front of you rather than um being a little dictator, uh, like a lot of designers are, you know, with their approach to it has to be like this and radius like that and millimeters, and suddenly there is a process that is intrinsically hard to control.

SPEAKER_01So you have to get used to uh being less of an engineer and more of the conductor within the limitations of the players who are in your orchestra. So you design the music according to the capabilities of the individual players. So I thought it was an interesting shift from me being very specific uh to being more open to what could be the outcome.

SPEAKER_03You've compared it to growing a bonsai tree in the past, I think.

SPEAKER_01I did, yeah, yeah. You regularly have to open a beehive and have a look at how it's going on. So I designed the skeletons and they don't always follow these templates uh that I give them. So I have to stir them sometimes by cutting off the overgrown pieces and then they clean it up and they continue building somewhere else. So you steer the growth of the honeycomb chambers or these cells, and that's what I meant by you know growing a bone site that you cut and then they move somewhere else, and then you cut that and they move somewhere else.

SPEAKER_01So it is a back and forth process, it's not a push-of-a-button uh automation unit.

SPEAKER_03And did you have to work hard to get the beekeepers themselves on side, Tomas?

SPEAKER_01In the beginning, and I have to say, still, it's very rewarding uh for the beekeepers, because for most of them they've never seen anything like this before. So they are very happy to participate and help me with making of these sculptures and uh projects. Sometimes they're very proud of their bees, like this, they call them art bees, like they're little artists. Uh because the skill is in them, they just haven't explored it, but they have used it for other means, you know, harvesting honey and uh growing the colony in a very kind of uh modernistic way.

SPEAKER_01Because beehives are designed uh sort of as a modern architecture. It all started sometime in the mid-19th century.

SPEAKER_03You talk about it being a critique of industrial production and looking to well, I guess almost feminize the process of the use of materials. Was it just coincidence that when you started making these that bees started disappearing? You had colony collapse disorder. It was a coincidence. Right. So it wasn't part of your thinking.

SPEAKER_01No, I I think I just sensed it. It's my strength but also weakness. Uh, I'm quite sensitive. And I felt this was you know, like when I saw these polished chairs of Ronarad, I love them, but uh the you know, this kind of whole visual vocabulary of the 80s and 90s, everything is slick and shiny and hard, and and then you miss that kind of softness. I felt this was an interesting way to make a critique, but not necessarily as a social justice warrior, but more in combination with making something beautiful.

SPEAKER_01I don't like making statements just for the sake of it. I like that to be part of making something beautiful as a sculptor or a painter or a photographer, an object to cherish. So it was a critique uh and I was surprised that around the same time Al Gore came with the inconvenient truth. I think it was just when I did these vases, and then the whole spirit of you know broad public being aware of global warming, a necessity to kind of reorient the economies towards more sustainable production, but also lifestyles.

SPEAKER_01So demanding consumers to demand different ways of production or different products in that sense, being more responsible came along, so it became part of that vocabulary and it got adopted by, let's say, more the design crowd as a vehicle for this uh conversation.

SPEAKER_03And you presumably you didn't mind that.

SPEAKER_01No, because I agree with it uh totally. It just didn't start as that. It started much more artistically with reading Dostoyevsky and Brothers Karamazov, and I got struck by the idea that he used a main character as a non-hero character. So he starts the book by introducing to the reader that the idea that in this book you will not find a traditional hero. This hero is weak, uh, he is not very interesting, very mediocre, but you will discover that through the book that he is the most consistent and most solid character in the book who survives it all.

SPEAKER_01And I thought, what a brilliant way of trying to choose my hero as a beeswax is for me in my story, that something that seems extremely soft and vulnerable and tragic becomes something very long-lasting because, and I say beeswax is one of the most durable natural materials in the world. It will last easily 2000 years without deterioration. And we use beeswax for sealing furniture, so it uh it's protected. We use it in food industry, in uh cosmetics, and yeah, bees produce it by themselves, so it is also sustainable in some sense.

SPEAKER_01So I chose a hero like Dostoevsky that seems weak, but in the long run is extremely strong.

SPEAKER_03One of the things I'm interested in, and listening to you talk just there, is you use the word beauty with abandon. And it seems to me that designers and and architects in particular are quite wary of the word beauty, but it doesn't you're happy to use it. How do you define beauty, I wonder?

SPEAKER_01It's a very good question. Uh, I'm glad you asked it. I don't think beauty is uh definable in a general sense where you say uh there's an absolute. I am not afraid of beauty. I like beautiful things. I think when I started studying, I wanted to become an artist, but at the time the art was more into wanting to be ugly on purpose. So I started to be interested maybe much more in design of objects because they didn't mind it.

SPEAKER_01But I read this really interesting uh book about ten years ago by Arthur Danto, he's the American philosopher and art critic, and he wrote a book about beauty, and he said that the whole idea of the divorce between art and beauty started around the time of Duchamp, where he rejected beauty, and he rejected it because he associated beauty with bourgeoisie or something has to do with money. And uh I think it was more of a statement.

SPEAKER_01It was not that art shouldn't be beautiful, it was a particular statement, and unfortunately the art world adopted this notion that art should not be beautiful. I think it's disappearing slowly, so that's really nice to see. But the idea is that art doesn't have to be beautiful, but it doesn't have to avoid it. If it can be, why not? Uh so I think there's a whole premise. It doesn't have to be, but if it can, you shouldn't avoid it. So that's sort of my my vision.

SPEAKER_01Or, my opinion about art and beauty. So you're not avoiding it, in other words? No, I mean we all seek it. I mean, it would be so counterintuitive to try to avoid it. It's like causing yourself. Like we all like things that please us. And obviously, beauty pleases us in some sense. And too much of it is, of course, not good. So it is all about dosage. I mean, we all like chocolate, it feels good, uh, but eating it all the time is also not healthy. And um, the same goes for uh good wine, sex, you name it.

SPEAKER_01There are things that have their time and amounts, and um you deal with it in that way, I think.

SPEAKER_03Okay. I mean, when you created that first piece back in 2006-2007, did you think you'd still be working with the process 13 years later? No way. How do you refine that process over the years?

SPEAKER_01That's a good question, Grant. Actually, when I made the first pieces, I thought I was done.

SPEAKER_03Right.

SPEAKER_01And uh here we are, uh let's say 14 years later, and I'm still excited about making new new works. So to answer your question, I didn't plan on it. The second question was Well, how you refined the process over that time? Oh, right. So I started working with uh more complicated, well, let's say I challenged the way I work with bees in terms of size, complexity, and color and conditions. First, vases were quite small, then I um diverted from vases and started to make much more sculptural objects.

SPEAKER_01I'm still busy with that idea, basically trying to make it more complex, maybe bigger in size, and uh refer and play with the meaning it creates after it's made and installed in a gallery or in a museum or in a different context, um, or adjust a picture. Uh sometimes that's enough to communicate the idea. I would love to see it one day in an architectural scale. So we're busy with having bees design in a small scale an architectural form, and then we would scale it up, you know, scan it, scale it up, and fabricate in different materials.

SPEAKER_01So using bees as sort of a quantum computer to calculate uh architectural tensions on a small scale, and then uh we use that as a foundation to build it in a different scale from different material. A little bit like architects use complex softwares to design their buildings. I have this biological quantum computer called Beehive to design a uh a building or a facade or a gate uh or what have you.

SPEAKER_03I'm very intrigued by that. So, how do you go about doing that? Presumably you set some framework up for the bees to follow.

SPEAKER_01Yeah, yeah. So in the beginning we had uh very rudimentary methods where I would design this kind of positive-negative spaces, some bit like mold making, and uh that didn't always work because bees like to work within a very small confined spaces, but then it's hard to take it out. Then uh I introduced uh let's say copper skeletons, uh wooden skeletons, and um right now we are 3D printing complex skeletons. It's it proved to be the best method.

SPEAKER_01So we I designed most of the sculptures on computer and then we 3D print it, yeah, and then we used it as a foundation.

SPEAKER_03So something like the agreement, which was a 1.6 meter tall sculpture outside the Natural History Museum in London, that would have been 3D printed originally, and then the bees worked on it.

SPEAKER_01That was an exception to the rule. It was a very complex method of creating a hollow, double-curved surface form. It was sort of like a pipe bending and an opening uh that looks like a flower, and I wanted it to be completely hollow, so we had to create um a skin for the bees to build on, but we also had to create a load-bearing skin, offset it next to it. We did it with etching metal, so we were using uh stainless steel, very thin stainless steel sheets, and we etched those, so using this photographic method where you project a film on a surface and then the acid eats away the lines.

SPEAKER_01So it was very, very precise a way of getting metal strips, but they were bent in 3D, they were under tension, and we had to use a software for designing boats, which you use to to calculate how the wood bends when you make the body of a boat. So there was interesting kind of cross-different sources, different methods. So I tried to make these skeletons different way all the time, but right now we're busy with 3D printing. But I tried everything that's possible from metals, etching, uh you know acrylic, depending on form and what it needs.

SPEAKER_01I also made the Unbearable Lightness, which was this Jesus-like figure uh floating in the space with red skin, uh red beeswags skin, and that was the inside was completely 3D printed, glass-like foundation. Can we talk about your background?

SPEAKER_03You were born in Slovakia, your father was an architect, your mother a historian. Yes. How has that shaped your career? I wonder. There's obviously a huge literary background in your household, I'm guessing.

SPEAKER_01Um, I grew up with books, that's correct. My birthday presents were always books. Depends on who gave me the books, or sometimes it was geography. Uh my father always gave me, this is interesting, my father always gave me books about nature and art. I only look at it back now, like, oh yeah, there was always nature, geography, uh these kind of things. Yeah, and uh mom would give me more uh literary kind of you know fiction uh books to read. But everywhere I went, whether it was my grandparents from my mother or my father, they both had huge libraries.

SPEAKER_01So yeah, that affected me. So in that sense, I grew up in an intellectual family. There was art in the house, obviously. Were you constantly making things? I was actually constantly uh disassembling things. Uh that was one of the tragedy of my parents in my childhood that uh when something arrived at home new, I would probably take it apart and not be able to put it back together. I was always not making, as really interesting uh when I look at it, I was always taking things apart.

SPEAKER_03You were encouraged to do that, or did they get irritated when they go home to discover everything?

SPEAKER_01No, no, no, no. They get irritated, of course. Uh but uh I would be endlessly curious. So I was more seeking probably knowledge and understanding rather than trying to be expressive. You know, if you look at it from the point of view of create, you create to express yourself, and I put things apart to be able to understand how things work. And I still think, yeah, and I still think I carry that kind of uh sense of like I'm interested in the making of things more than probably the end result, or I'm interested in both, that's why we're still talking material matters.

SPEAKER_03It's interesting because I mean you talk about this knowledge of how things are made and why they're made. And you started by studying engineering and design in Slovakia, then you went to the University of Washington where you focused on painting and sculpture. Yeah. And I'm wondering how that shift came about.

SPEAKER_01I think I felt in my uh twenties that engineering wasn't enough in terms of being complete. Uh so I knew that I was driven towards art one way or another. I just probably wasn't willing to accept at that time that I'm more an artist than, let's say, uh industrial designer or an architect because of let's say more inputs and the complexity of my thinking. When I studied in Slovakia, probably I I sucked out everything I can.

SPEAKER_01I I need more, I'm curious more about what's in America, what's in stock there, and I wanted to taste that educational process and be exposed to American art, American museums, yeah, the culture. And I think art, education there served me, uh served me well because it was so broad, uh, I could involve different things in the studies rather than just engineering.

SPEAKER_03From there you went on to the Academy of Fine Arts and Design in Bratislava. Right. Before going on to the Design Academy Eindhoven, where you received your MFA. I mean, that's a lot of time in education. Did you stay so long because you thought your work wasn't ready?

SPEAKER_01Um, it seems long, but I just did a lot within a short period of time. Um, so I think I studied within six years uh or seven years of five places. So it seems like I studied a long time, but I graduated when I was 26, 27, something like that. I think I couldn't stay at one place for more than two years. I felt I've squeezed out uh a lot, and there was nothing more to squeeze out after two years. So I think that's why this kind of hopping from different place.

SPEAKER_03Yeah. What did your student work look like? Maybe when you left Bratislava for Eindhoven, what kind of things were you doing?

SPEAKER_01That's interesting. I had a lot of actually uh works that were referring to nature. Um, that's interesting. Um I had lots of student projects that dealt with nature, mathematics, and I had a huge uh painting portfolio, so I did a lot of painting, drawing. That was sort of my student work, experiments in uh nature and mathematics. I think the mathematics has something to do with father's uh discipline, so architecture. Um so it's kind of logic uh behind nature.

SPEAKER_01What Olaf Ureliasan made his Oeuvre with obsession with geometries and uh things like so. I was uh already then uh busy with those things, nature and uh mathematics. Now it's not even a surprise that I'm busy with bees. Uh yeah. You make me realize things, Grant.

SPEAKER_03Well, there you go. That's that's why we're here. That's your gift. It is. I'm glad I've got one. Were the bees happening in Eindhoven or after you left?

SPEAKER_01It started in Eindhoven. Yeah, it started in Eindhoven. One of my first projects there was I was doing a big research on Coca-Cola. Right. And I did this big project about Coca-Cola doing lots of research and some design artworks. And I think it stemmed from there where it was a critique on, let's say, the product, the iconic image of it, and then this artificial sugar overload of the whole drink. And I think that sugar thing led me to the bees somehow critique of consumer culture because it's it's such a such a thing, like even Ai Wei Wei has this Coca-Cola on a Chinese vase.

SPEAKER_01You can't not go criticizing consumer culture and uh let's say capitalism by not using Coca-Cola in one way, like once somewhere. I think it started there with uh Coca-Cola. And I recently used it again after 14 years in my last show now in Amsterdam. So back to Coca-Cola.

SPEAKER_03Back to Coca-Cola, all roads lead to Coca-Cola. Um I want to change tack slightly because there's been a very lively debate about copying in design in the UK this year. Sure. That was created by the designer Simon Brewster, who started a high-profile campaign against a manufacturer that hadn't paid her for her designs before putting something extremely similar out on the market. I mean, it's a problem you've had your own brush with. Back in 2013, there was an advert for duers, which had a sculpture of a bottle of whiskey made by bees.

SPEAKER_03Yeah. How did you feel when you saw that?

SPEAKER_01I was outraged. And the reason was not because there was a context. The the advertising agency behind it, the Canadian Advertising Agency, contacted me. They wanted to do this with me. And they, I think a few hours before the conference phone call, they pulled out. They said, Well, uh, small internal changes will contact you when we are ready. And then nothing happened. And then I think it was a half a year later, or like three-quarters of a year, they came out with this project.

SPEAKER_01It was an advertising uh project where they commissioned somebody from California to do this. But it was so similar in many ways to what I did that in the very instance I was uh pissed. Uh but then I calmed down. I mean, uh, it is what it is. It was an interesting subject because just around the same time uh somebody else uh approached me that wanted to make a copy of my uh work as a study for school project.

SPEAKER_01Right. And I thought that's interesting. Uh I got involved, and uh the student she made a replica of my honeycomb vase that's in MoMA, trying to replicate the process. So I gave her hints and she tried to make it similar without having all the information, sort of like reverse engineering it. Yeah, yeah. And then she displayed it in a gallery and a show, and I thought it was very nice. Then I wrote uh I think you're referring to the essay I wrote uh on the zine.

SPEAKER_03Yeah, yeah. Subsequently. Well, you you kind of pointed out that in your view there was a place for copying in design education. Absolutely. Yeah, yeah, yeah.

SPEAKER_01I think it's absolutely necessary, and I think uh it there is a lack of it, uh, on the contrary. I think it should be much more encouraged. Copying is a way of learning. We just somehow became so obsessed with the whole issue of copyrights and being original and unique and uh you know new that we somehow don't realize that part of growing is to grow on shoulders of others. There is another issue, of course, exploiting it financially, but that's a different subject.

SPEAKER_01I think in education, I would totally encourage you know, if you study furniture design, make a replica of IMS furniture, just reverse engineer it, uh make it make it yourself uh to understand how these things are made instead of taking it for granted, like just looking at the sketches, having a hands-on experience on could I make it myself? Because at the time, if you look at the books of um the IMS uh couple, you see how much of their initial processes were all studio-based.

SPEAKER_01It was not all factories, production company. A lot of them were initiated in the studio with their own means of making models. So I think that's interesting to learn by copying others. But it all, of course, I wrote in the essay in defense of copying, but with a tongue-in-cheek reference to, you know, exploiting intellectual property.

SPEAKER_03Yeah, yeah. I mean, the other interesting thing about that piece, and we've talked about your love of reading, is that you write with quite a dash. I mean, you quote everybody from Bruce Lee to Picasso in the same piece. That's all right. So writing is presumably very important to you.

SPEAKER_01I do write, but I don't write enough, I think, because there is no incentive for me to write. I mean, I don't get uh regular plays in any um newspaper or magazine. So it sometimes is about opportunities and it costs time and energy. I feel like I'm a little bit of a perfectionist. So to write a piece, and I'm sure you know, it's not just sitting one afternoon, probably also take uh quite some time. You write the first draft, second draft, you go over it, you erase. It can take you a couple weeks to write something meaningful that you're happy with.

SPEAKER_03I just blacked it out, Thomas, for money.

SPEAKER_00No, I don't believe it. You're a pro, you don't do it like that. No, let's sell the idea that grand works uh let's do that for months.

SPEAKER_03Yeah, pay me more money for it. That's what I want. Exactly. There's another quote of yours that I like, which wasn't from the design piece, it's from somewhere else, where you said, I don't think one should expect anything from contemporary art. Let's think of it like a cat. So I'm interested to know how art is like a cat.

SPEAKER_01Art is like a cat because when you walk into a gallery or a museum, we come there with sort of these preconceptions that art should please us or art should anger us, or that somehow art, museum, gallery owes us something. And we come there a little bit with the same sensation, like we come to a movie theater where we've seen the trailer and we have these expectations that this is gonna be a really entertaining movie, and this is gonna be really a great comedy, lots of laughs, and we're gonna leave this uh place and then we're gonna get a drink, all good mood.

SPEAKER_01Art works in mysterious ways, and I compared it to a cat because I'm a dog lover and um I love cats as well, and we have cats in Slovakia, so I I kind of like I grew up with cats as well. But cat is such a creature that it doesn't work on a command, uh, it's there when you let it come to you and it will gift you its presence, but you can't be overwhelmingly dwelling on expectations from a pet like that.

SPEAKER_01Every time you get pleasure from a cat, it's almost like in unexpected times when you come home and you're sad, and the cat feels it and it comes to you and it comforts you. And it's not always something you can rely on, but somehow it reveals its true nature. It's very independent from it's not like a tool that you just grab when you need it or a medicine. I think it's similar with art. Artists don't work like this, they somehow reflect the current situation that we live in.

SPEAKER_01And you come to a museum or to a gallery, or you look and you call things online, and you just have to look at it as a testimony of the time we live in, but it is not your pet that's supposed to please you. Just kind of have to wait for it to grant you its presence and it reveals it reveal itself. And sometimes works of art are, you know, ahead of time and uh they are not uh easily consumable, they will be more consumable in two decades when there is enough visual and other type of vocabulary present that you can properly consume it.

SPEAKER_01And there are many examples of artworks like that. So yeah, I compared it to a cat more than to a dog. I think design is more like a dog.

SPEAKER_03Well, I was gonna ask you that, because you are doing that much more to command, right? We tend to be, if you're an industrial designer at least, you're working to commission or a brief.

SPEAKER_01Absolutely, yeah, yeah, yeah. Yeah, but you also use tools to cater to somebody's needs. You are much more in service to society, which I think there's equally important, but design is much more about being maybe a doctor than a musician. I think we all need doctors, but we don't necessarily need musicians to survive. But uh you can uh you can argue about that. I think if you ask somebody else, they say, I can't live without music, or you can't live without art. Well, but you know, you can't live with cancer, you can't survive certain diseases either.

SPEAKER_01So there's this pyramid, you know, shelter, clothes, food, and uh I don't know what the pyramid is called. I think we have to Google it.

SPEAKER_03Well, you've opened a can of worms there, which I'm not sure I'm gonna go any further into. But um, what we've discovered in this hour, we've had talking together, is that you're a man of many parts. And aside from the Maze by Bees series, you're also a photographer, and there are pieces where you've used other materials, your paper vases that are turned on a lathe, spring to mind. I was particularly interested in the work that uses ink from Bic Byros. How did that come about?

SPEAKER_01Yeah, I think it's also a really early work, uh, or I it started really early, um, maybe two years uh after the bees. I was really interested in the big ink pen, which by the way is in the Museum of Modern Arts permanent collection as an industrial design object, and I find it extremely interesting for the reasons why it's there and uh its design. But I was interested in uh in the ink itself, and somehow my painterly history kicked in, and um it's becoming sort of this complementary thing to the work with bees, which is almost predominantly yellow, and I have the blue, and I'm waiting for my red period.

SPEAKER_03You've done red though, your vase is a red sometimes.

SPEAKER_01Yeah, it's it is, it um it is. Uh I um so let me first finish the blue and then I can mark some bees wax. Uh pieces are red. I think there is something beautiful about the depth and the sort of the melancholy of the blue color. It's a really interesting color, it has a beautiful history, reasons why it was used already in antiquity, what sources it was made from, from which natural materials it was made from. And in general, history of colors is interesting to see which colors were valuable, most valuable at what times and what periods they are reflected in fashion.

SPEAKER_01I found blue like one of those mysterious colors, and uh because probably I tend to be interested in things that are somehow unknown, mysterious, and spiritual. I I think the blue is a very good medium to draw the audience into that same mood of contemplation. So I like the blue ink because of its chemical composition when applied on different materials. I made many mixed experiments with different surfaces, and I found out if you use certain types of woods, the big ink acts iridescent, like a butterfly wing.

SPEAKER_01So we looked at the microscopic images of the butterfly wing, and I found Out that there are these membranes that uh trickle down like Christmas tree, which shortens the wavelengths of the light hitting the these these chambers. Because of shortening them, these wavelengths have different scale between the purples and the blues. Because if you look at the spectrum, I don't know which wavelength is the blues, what how many nanometers, but this is the effect. So channeling it down.

SPEAKER_01Certain types of woods we found out when they when you cut it in the right angle, they are tiny tubes. And when you apply ink, and the ink is on the inside of these minuscule tubes, when the light gets trapped inside and if you look at from different angles, it creates the same effect. So we did I almost designed the the way to make these what I call blue scapes using certain types of wood and layering the big ink on the wood to achieve this butterfly uh wing effect.

SPEAKER_01And now I'm continuously busy still with sort of painting with the big ink because it's made uh from this mixture of pigments and chemicals that uh act really well on dry surfaces such as wood. It's designed to be used on paper, therefore, uh wood is like a grandmother of paper.

SPEAKER_03It's fascinating because I thought you'd tell me about you know the disposability of the big pens and we'd have a discussion about sustainability, but that's not behind the scenes.

SPEAKER_01Absolutely, no, no, no. It tends to look like it, yeah. But uh I was more interested in the melancholy of the blue than let's say the disposability of the pen, like you named it. But I think it's a huge problem as well, and uh I absolutely agree with it. But I'm not the type of artist that would um like uh my good friend uh Hayward, what's his name? The British designer that makes uh chandeliers out of collecting uh Stuart Hagar. Stewart, yeah, yeah, yeah. Uh I don't know why I said Hayward. He makes absolutely stunning pieces and they directly communicate this idea.

SPEAKER_01So I think the work is done there in this territory. Yeah, yeah. So there's nothing to be more done there. So Stuart got it. Uh I think the the message is clear and he managed to also create something beautiful with it. Kudos.

SPEAKER_03Well, I'm very keen to get him on here as well, actually. Yeah, you should. Yeah, yeah, I should. I've taken up loads of your time, Thomas. Final question the inevitable. What are your plans for the future?

SPEAKER_01Near or far? Oh, both. Both. I would really like to uh continue with the portrait series of made by bees. We just finished uh a few sculptures that one is based on Nefertiti. So I created the replica made by bees of the bust of Nefertiti, and uh I created another one which is similar to the bust of Michelangelo of Brutus, the assassin of uh Julius Caesar and the famous story, and also you, my son.

SPEAKER_01So this kind of you know, killing a tyranny and Michelangelo did it because at that time Brutus was considered as a good person, he killed a tyrant, but you know, sometimes Brutus is also looked as a traitor, and uh Julius Caesar is a great general, so there's this duality of history. But in essence, I like the Made by Beast project to be extended more into architectural scale, as I mentioned early in the interview. I think it would be interesting to use Animal Kingdom in this kind of metaphorical way as a quantum computer to try to see if we can get different types of information than we get from using, let's say, real uh computers with their own methods of calculation and approximation.

SPEAKER_01And they still look kind of dry. Uh, if you look at architecture these days that tries to mimic nature, it's always somehow still very artificial mimesis. Uh it's not real, you know. That's why I admire the Sagrada Familia in Barcelona by Gaudi because somehow you look at it, uh these interiors, and they're so irregular and regular in the same time that you think this is not made by the computer. You know, like there is nothing that's correct.

SPEAKER_01And if you compare it, for example, with Frank Gehry, you feel completely the opposite. I feel Gary is very computer-like design on a computer, and Gaudi, I feel like it's made on site. That's my feeling from Gaudi's like uh work that it's made naturally, like they just started from the foundation and started building it up as like growing it. Um, so my hopes for the future is to make architectural scale artworks with the help of the bees.

SPEAKER_03Very good, very good. Well, we very much look forward to that, Thomas. Thank you so much for your time. I really appreciate it. Thank you, Grant.

SPEAKER_01I appreciate it. Looking forward to hearing it and also the other interviews. Thank you so much.

SPEAKER_03To discover more about Thomas's work, go to Thomaslibertini.com. There are images from the interviews as well as little films and other things on my Instagram page, Grant on Design, and I have a new website. You can find all the podcasts that I've done, sign up to my newsletter and lots of other stuff at grantondesign.com. If you've enjoyed listening and want to see this podcast flourish, then please rate and review on Apple Podcasts or wherever you listen to this from. And if you feel so inclined, you can go to my Patreon page and make a pledge at patreon.com forward slash material matters.

SPEAKER_03You'll be helping to take the message to the importance of materials, skill, craft, and design to a whole new audience. Thanks so much for listening, and please stay safe and well.

Open the transcript file

Hosts and Guests

Nobody is credited on this episode yet.

Credit the people on this episode

Be the first to rate this episode

More episodes

All episodes
  1. Bethany Williams on turning discarded clothes into high fashion.

    Nov 10, 202645 minAudio

    Bethany Williams describes herself as ‘an artist, humanitarian and sustainable fashion designer’. Since graduating from the London College of Fashion in 2016, she has collaborated with organisations that help people...

    Credit the people on this episode

  2. Corin Mellor on stainless steel, Sheffield, and designing beautiful cutlery.

    Oct 14, 202655 minAudio

    Corin Mellor is the creative director of David Mellor Design - a brand that is synonymous with his father, David, but also the design and manufacture of beautiful cutlery, primarily made of stainless steel. According to...

    Credit the people on this episode

  3. Artist Nicola Turner on horsehair, sheep's wool and her solo show at the Yorkshire Sculpture Park.

    Sep 15, 202658 minAudio

    Nicola Turner is a UK-based artist who is best known for her use of horsehair and wool in her extraordinary, and often quite dark, sculptures. She originally trained as a theatre designer - working for the likes of the...

    Credit the people on this episode

  4. John Tuomey on the importance of materials in architecture, designing London's V&A East, and his new book, Middle Quarter.

    Sep 9, 20261 hr 7 minAudio

    Dublin-based architect John Tuomey first appeared on Material Matters in 2024 to talk about his brilliant memoir, First Quarter. Now he’s written the follow-up, unsurprisingly entitled, Middle Quarter. John is the...

    Credit the people on this episode

  5. Reusing Construction Waste with Joel de Mowbray of Yes Make

    Sep 1, 20261 hr 11 minAudio

    What if the materials a building needs are already sitting in a skip down the road? Joel de Mowbray, founding director of Yes Make, joins Grant Gibson to explain how a regenerative design and build practice rescues...

    Credit the people on this episode