Skip to content
PodSubs
ShowsPeopleGuestsJobsNewsEvents
More
BlogPodCred
Menu
ShowsPeopleGuestsJobsNewsEventsBlogPodCredNetworksSign in
Join nowSign in
  • Shows
  • People
  • Jobs
  • News
  • More
    • Guests
    • Events
    • Blog
    • PodCred
    • Networks
    Join nowSign in

Material Matters with Grant Gibson

Material Matters with Grant Gibson artwork

Aaron Betsky on why architects should stop building (and reuse instead).

Dec 3, 202457 minAudio

Aaron Betsky is a US-based writer, educator and critic, who has served as director of the Cincinnati Art Museum and the Netherlands Architecture Institute, as well as a curator of architecture and design at the San Francisco Museum of Modern Art. He has also written over 20 books with subjects ranging from Zaha Hadid, Frank Lloyd Wright, and the Dutch architecture practice MVRDV to the relationship between architecture and same-sex desire. He is about to publish another. Don’t Build, Rebuild: The Case for Imaginative Reuse in Architecture implores the construction industry to refrain from doing what it does most - building - and, instead, find new ways to use the materials and stock we already possess. In this episode, we talk about: the trauma of election day in the US; how we can reuse buildings imaginatively and effectively; working with relics of the industrial age; why the digital world is changing the architect’s role; making spaces more egalitarian; squatting; what architects can learn from artists; urban mining; taking inspiration from music festivals; hanging out in the legendary Studio 54; the importance of loft living; and much, much more. (This episode was recorded on election day in the US.) Support the show

Audio and video play straight from the show's own hosting. PodSubs stores and serves no media.

Transcript

From the show. Tap a time to play from there.

SPEAKER_01Hello and welcome to the latest episode of Material Matters with Grant Gibson. I've done over 120 shows now. However, for listeners who might be new to all this, the idea is I speak to a designer, maker, artist or architect about a material or technique with which they're intrinsically linked and discover how it changed their lives and careers. Today I'm delighted to be talking to Aaron Betzky. Aaron is a US-based writer, educator, and critic who over the years has served as director of the Cincinnati Art Museum and the Netherlands Architecture Institute, as well as a curator of architecture and design at the San Francisco Museum of Modern Art.

SPEAKER_01He's also written over 20 books with subjects ranging from Zaha Hadid, Frank Lloyd Wright, and the Dutch architecture practice MVRDV to the relationship between architecture and same-sex desire. The reason we're chatting today is because he is about to publish another. Don't build, rebuild the case for imaginative reuse in architecture. Implores the construction industry to refrain from doing what it does most. Build. And instead find new ways to use the materials and stock we already possessed.

SPEAKER_01Aaron, thank you very much for doing this. How are you? I'm well, great. Thank you very much for having me. No, it's a pleasure. We are talking on November the 5th, which is bonfire night in the UK. Obviously, presidential elections where you are in the US. I mean it's a kind of cliche question, but how are you feeling? Uh apprehensive.

SPEAKER_00I am quite concerned I might uh have to come real estate shopping in England uh as of uh tomorrow.

SPEAKER_01Okay.

SPEAKER_00It's on the knife's edge here. And uh I think uh in terms of uh my immediate life, on the one hand, I'm uh have all the privileges you can imagine, but uh as a citizen of this country, I'm not sure I'll be able to uh survive uh in this country if uh uh Trump is elected. So um concern is very real.

SPEAKER_01I mean, in the UK, we're being told of the prospect of civil insurrection if the vote doesn't go for Donald Trump. I mean, does it feel that way to you?

SPEAKER_00Of course there is that danger, but I think that that is a lot of bluster. I just don't think that the amount of people who would support that are enough to uh cause um a kind of real danger.

SPEAKER_01Aaron Powell Well, it's an interesting time, and we'll see how things transpire over the next 24 hours, I guess. Back to the podcast, Erin. Where are you right now? We're looking at each other across the screen. There's not too much that's being given away in your background, I have to confess.

SPEAKER_00I live in a house uh that the first part of which was built in 1703 in Mount Erie, which is a neighborhood of Philadelphia, Pennsylvania. And uh the part in which I'm actually sitting is the uh new edition from 1774. Uh so it's a house that we purchased about a year ago, a little over a year ago. And uh we're very happy to be here in Philadelphia, which is a fantastic city with great architecture, uh, great uh art, great music, uh, great food, good healthcare.

SPEAKER_00Uh and we're also very happy that uh we live in what apparently is the most uh racially and economically mixed neighborhood in Philadelphia.

SPEAKER_01Aaron Ross Powell Interesting. And tell me, is this where you write, where you're sat now? Yes. Okay. Yes, it is. And just for the listeners, could you describe where you write? Would I describe it as a den or an office?

SPEAKER_00For a long time I've uh made a uh uh book nest for myself in the various houses where I've lived, and I've lived in a lot of different places, uh, in which the rooms are uh completely covered with books. I have about 6,000 books on art, architecture, and wow, other topics. And a good chunk of them are in this room. And then I always make sure that I have a window that's near me so I can get some light and uh my computer in front of me, and that's really what I need to be able to do my writing.

SPEAKER_00And are you tidy? Not nearly as tidy as my husband. Uh in especially when I'm working on a book project, there will be piles of uh material that appear on the desk, although less than in the past because of more and more of the information I use is digital, obviously, uh and the images are on the screen. But uh there still are a few piles around here that are uh uh uh projects that are in the works or about to be in the works.

SPEAKER_01I mean, you've written, as I said in the intros, I mean like over 20 books over the years. You obviously enjoy the process. There's a lot of time spent by yourself when you write a book. I know from experience.

SPEAKER_00Enjoy is a complicated word. Um it certainly is something that I feel driven to do. Um I have uh passions and beliefs about art architecture and other topics that I uh want to communicate, whether it's through articles and books or lectures or teaching. And when you do a book, you get the chance to do so in the most fulsome and extended manner.

SPEAKER_00And that's really why you do a book. You don't do it to make money, at least I've never really made much money on books, especially compared to uh the amount of time you put on them. Uh, but you do it because it gives you a chance to really make an argument uh over an extended uh narrative, an extended period. And quite frankly, I also, a long time ago, when I was being both a writer and an architect, found that it took me a long time to do drawings and I wrote very quickly.

SPEAKER_00So then you tend to gravitate towards the thing that you do with uh you know where you're heading.

SPEAKER_01Yeah, yeah.

SPEAKER_00Yes. Uh and as my editors would tell you, I probably write too quickly.

SPEAKER_01And are you very disciplined? Do you have a routine when you're writing a book?

SPEAKER_00Um I like to think I'm not very disciplined, but uh outsiders think I am disciplined. Uh when I'm writing a book, I usually uh get up six, seven in the morning. Uh well, until recently, always six o'clock in the morning. Now that I'm retired, I give myself the extra hour and um do my writing mainly in the morning. So I'll just sit in my bathrobe uh and do the writing uh until it's time for lunch.

SPEAKER_00And then depending on the intensity of book, maybe put a few more hours in the afternoon. But I really try to I find myself most articulate, or so I think, uh, in the mornings.

SPEAKER_01So you have this new book out. This is this is why we're talking. You have this new book out entitled Don't Build Rebuild The Case for Imaginative Use in Architecture. Why this book? Why now?

SPEAKER_00There are three reasons why I think we need to stop building, and that's really the message of uh this book. We need to stop making new buildings, and if we do uh make new buildings, we should make them completely out of components, whether they are from the building industry or from anywhere else that are already at hand. We can mainly no longer afford to use up natural resources we cannot replenish, and uh in the act of building, rape and pillage our environment.

SPEAKER_00The second reason I think we should not make new buildings is they also take space away from uh the general use of our increasingly diverse society, and they become the built affirmation of the social, political, and economic status quo. And if we instead can concentrate on breaking open our existing buildings and spaces in such a manner that they help us understand where we've come from, that the history of them is evident in the buildings, the lives that have been led there are evident in the buildings, show us where we are by literally opening them up, and perhaps show us where we could go together as an open society.

SPEAKER_00That to me would be the way forward. And finally, uh new buildings are also quite alien to people by their very nature. Something that is new is alien. Moreover, new buildings are made by architects who are professionals sitting somewhere almost always still male, uh usually still white, and decreeing a space for your life without knowing really who you are, even if you are uh the rich client commissioning them.

SPEAKER_00And when the building is built, it represents the values of the person who commissioned it, not necessarily the user. Now, when you reuse a building in what I call an imaginative manner, you are able to open it up to the textures, the look and feel, the many stories inherent in it, so that it connects uh more directly to people's current lives.

SPEAKER_01Your opening line for this new book is, in my view, right up there with uh Hunter S. Thompson's In Fear and Loathing in Las Vegas, where you say very bluntly, we should not construct new buildings from scratch. And then the rest of the book goes on to explain exactly why. Can we talk about the categories of reuse you illustrate? Maybe you could define them for me.

SPEAKER_00The categories are a little fluid, you know, they uh they gelled to make the book. But I think that the there is a hidden history of temporary buildings throughout architectural history, and because they don't last, uh we tend not to pay them much notice. But uh I talk about the fact that there is a long tradition of making buildings that only last as long as a society's commitment to them, and they have to be continually rebuilt.

SPEAKER_00There's the Isei Shrine, which is a building in Japan that has been rebuilt for 1,500 years uh continually. Uh they actually have two of them. Well, one is being used, the other one is being rebuilt, and then they switch back and forth. And this has been going on for uh well over a thousand years. There also are buildings like the libraries and mosques in Timbuktu, the great center of learning in Africa. But they're also which are made out of mud that has to be continually rebuilt.

SPEAKER_00There are also, of course, fairs and religious festivals that we have created throughout history. And today uh I find that some of the most interesting social spaces are our music festivals, the coachellas and uh all these kinds of places. And I believe that they might provide a different model of urbanism. So that's one category. I believe that a lot of this uh notion of reuse uh really gelled because we came to a point where the industrial revolution, that great explosion of economic and social power that started at the end of the 18th century, finally turned into what we sometimes call the third or the fourth industrial revolution, which is one focused on consumption, first of all, and then now on ethereal and uh miniature ways of making value uh through computer and communication technology.

SPEAKER_00That means we were left with these giant relics from the Industrial Revolution, the factories, the warehouses that in cities began to be reused by artists or to be squatted in by people that created their own communities, and then in their larger versions, in the great steel mills, began in the 1980s and 90s to be turned into what I say are our new cathedrals, our new pyramids, our new palaces, our buildings at a humongous scale with absolutely glorious spaces and very exciting moments where structure uh comes together and the buildings completely overwhelm you.

SPEAKER_00And now in places like the Ruhr Valley in Germany and in Beijing, and in fact, all over the world, you can go crawling through those buildings, and they become places that are uh museums and beer gardens and schools and offices and all kinds of other activities. The third category is the reuse of residential structures. Uh, of course, architects like to experiment on their own house.

SPEAKER_00Uh, it's where they have the most freedom. And so I argued that private homes, in this as in most other movements in architecture, became the um the testing ground, the laboratory for imaginative reuse. And now that is moving out into the design of apartments, social housing, and larger residential structures that's not just for architects, but for everyone.

SPEAKER_00And then, of course, there's the in-between category, uh, which is where most people will confront it first, which is in institutions. Our museums, our theaters, our clubs and cafes, our places where we gather, are our libraries, are the places where we also as a society show what is possible. And again, all throughout the world, I have found beautiful examples of museums and libraries and other such strictures built in old factories, warehouses, shopping malls, uh, residential buildings, office buildings, all kinds of buildings that have been opened up and turned into places of public use.

SPEAKER_00And finally, um, there is a category that uh is the don't make it fake it one, which is to say that in our digital world, uh maybe you don't need to build anything. Uh maybe you just need to uh imagine and project and rethink what already exists uh in a way that is ethereal uh and has even less perhaps of a carbon uh footprint.

SPEAKER_01Trevor Burrus And completely redefines the role of the architect, fundamentally.

SPEAKER_00Yeah. Yeah. And there there are two other uh categories. I also talk about landscape architecture, so actually are seven categories. I talk about landscape architecture and opening up existing and reusing existing uh spaces. And uh I also talk about uh the uh very interesting experiments, mainly in northern Europe, in upcycling all kinds of things from pieces of washing machines and truck tires to plastic bags to uh sewage pipes uh to create uh new buildings out of the remains of old uses.

SPEAKER_00Very good.

SPEAKER_01Let's unpack probably not all of those seven in the time that we have, but but maybe some of those seven. I want to return to your intro for a moment, which in and of itself is very rich and provokes a lot of questions. And you write in the intro that we need to stop ruining our planet, and we also need to open the built spaces of our society to be more egalitarian and just. You add subsequently, and this is still in the intro, the act of reuse should break through the hierarchies of class, sex, and race. You're asking it to do quite a lot. How does it do that, Erin?

SPEAKER_00Well, it actually goes back to some of the work that I did uh that you mentioned in your introduction on queer space, a space of same-sex desire, in which uh queer men and women, but especially men in the West, were able to appropriate the edges of cities, the piers, the parks, the places where the center city faded off into the undetermined area around it, uh, through cruising and later through bars and parties, but also through residential neighborhoods that reappropriated uh spaces that have been used for a single by single users and the single type of people for a whole different group of people and a much more open uh group of people.

SPEAKER_00You can find the same kind of thing happening in squatting and in the way that people are taking parts of cities again throughout the West. Uh, but also, I was just in China, you can find the same thing in the cities like Shenzhen into different kinds of places because in our continual movement of goods and people and ideas, our cities are no longer monoliths and need to accommodate different cultures, different kinds of people.

SPEAKER_00And uh those people make use of existing building stock and bring them alive with their own ways of living, their own social practices, their own colors, their own forms. And architects uh sometimes don't know what to do. One of the stories I tell is that of the Torre David, a very well-known uh building in Caracas, in Venezuela, that was a 40-story skyscraper that sat half finished for years, and then a group of people just squatted it all the way up to the 24th floor and built not just places to live within it, but stores and clinics and gathering places and a gym and all kinds of elements of a real community.

SPEAKER_00And a local architect, Urban Think Tank, went in there saying, We're gonna help you, we're gonna bring it up to code or whatever it is that architects think they're gonna do to make people's lives better. And they got there and they said, hmm, these people don't really need us. What we need is to take what these people are doing and learn from it and let other people learn from it. So they worked with a very good photographer, Iwan Ban, to document this and to tell this story and bring it out into the world where it again has had a huge amount of uh influence.

SPEAKER_01One of the threads runs through the book is that once people have moved in and reused buildings imaginatively, is that leads almost inevitably to gentrification. I mean, the New York's Highline, for example, house prices go up, local people who have been living there are forced out as new money comes in. Is there a way of preventing that, in your view?

SPEAKER_00In our capitalist society, no. Uh that is one of the contradictions of this book. And uh I don't have a solution. My editor kept saying, tell us how we're going to solve this. Don't you hate editors? I used to be one of those. No, she was great. And she was right, but there is no answer. And uh to put it somewhat technically, in our society, when you do anything to the built environment, whether it's making a new building or renovating, you're investing resources, capital, money.

SPEAKER_00And the people who are investing those resources, capital, money, expect to get a return, to get it back plus to get a profit, as we call it. And that means inevitably gentrification. It is only if we as a society decide that we want to invest collectively in the renovation and imaginative reuse of spaces for the good of the people who need it, that we can escape gentrification.

SPEAKER_00And there are a few examples of this, uh, again, mainly in Northern Europe, which have very progressive uh social democratic societies, but they are very few and far between. And even then, people argue about whether they really uh prevent gentrification or not. But it it is the contradiction at the heart of this book for which I have no answer.

SPEAKER_01Trevor Burrus, Jr.: So essentially we need a new political or economic system to change issues around the city with gentrification.

SPEAKER_00Aaron Powell Yeah. I always say that um, since I work in the world of architecture, architects have to understand that they have two responsibilities, uh, which of course are intertwined. One is as a professional with a certain amount of knowledge and skill who can provide something to make our society better out of those skills, uh, but that ability is limited. And so your other responsibility is to work as a citizen in parallel with that, uh, to bring The kind of social change that I believe we need.

SPEAKER_01You have always worked in architecture. You've also worked in art, and and the book looks to the art world very often, likes of Fiesta Gates in Chicago, Gordon Matter Clark, Mike Nelson, for inspiration. Architects have a lot to learn from artists, in your view?

SPEAKER_00Absolutely. I think first of all, um the distinctions are increasingly arbitrary. Yeah. I wouldn't disagree with that. But yes, it's it's also true that artists are uh the RD lab for architecture, um certain extent music and other things. But you know, when when change happens and when people figure out how to do things better, they usually figure it out in art or in popular culture like music, maybe sometimes in novels.

SPEAKER_00Architecture lags behind. So architects have to look towards artists. You know, when I went to work for the architect Frank Gehry, I asked him the stupid question that you should never ask an architect, who's your favorite architect? Because, of course, their favorite architect is themselves, right? Like who's your favorite artist if you're an artist? Yourself. But he had a good answer for it. And his answer was Gordon Mullah Clark, who was an artist who was trained as an architect, but then built up a practice in New York at the end of the last century, uh, breaking open buildings and liberating the spaces within them.

SPEAKER_00That was very tied for him to a social practice, to um a kind of punk movement or proto-punk movement, if you will. Um, but it also led to absolutely gorgeous spaces that were uh very influential on the work of not only other artists, but also architects like Frank Geary.

SPEAKER_01Can we focus on Theiesta for a moment? Partly because he's someone I've always wanted to get on the podcast. He's a ceramic artist in the UK. He's had a retrospective at the Whitechapel Gallery a couple of years ago and designed the Serpentine Pavilion too. But he's much more than that, isn't he? And it seems to me that he's the embodiment of imaginative reuse. I think he described himself as a hunter-gatherer. I'm quite keen to know, for listeners who maybe don't know what he's done, but but also why he matters.

SPEAKER_00Yeah, absolutely. No, I think uh you're right. He he is a kind of avatar of what uh I think we could be doing. So Theaster is a very interesting guy. He was uh trained in first in urban planning, then he went and apprenticed himself with a master ceramicist in Japan. And then he came back and got a degree in theology from the University of Chicago. And then he started working as a neighborhood activist in the south side of Chicago.

SPEAKER_00It's a little short. Career was a little more complex than that. But he was able to put a lot of those things together uh in something called the Dorchester Project, where he began using uh abandoned, semi-abandoned buildings and their pieces, but also things like record collections and book collections that were of special importance to the black community in South Chicago, and bring them together, assemble them together, hunt and gather them together into these structures.

SPEAKER_00Those structures had fragments uh which became the artwork that he could sell to finance all of this. But the core really was, uh, were and is are these kind of environments, first at Dorchester, then at the um uh Stony Island Bank Avenue Bank project, but also in projects like this that he did in other locations in the world. And when he comes into these locations, he does uh break them open and reveal hidden histories, which in more recent years he has made more explicit by looking at the traditions of African and African American art and uh riffing on that and bringing that, populating his exhibitions and spaces with uh those figures, again, also drawing, as you noted, on his ceramics uh knowledge and skills.

SPEAKER_00Um the final point, which I find especially beautiful, is um I experienced not too long ago when um he had an exhibition at the New Museum in New York, and I realized, luckily, that uh the next day was the last day of the exhibition, so I ran up uh to see the exhibition, which I had not seen until then, and uh the elevator doors opened on the top or the top exhibition floor of the new museum.

SPEAKER_00There are these huge elevator doors, and there's one large gallery. And there was the aster with this group uh that he calls them various times the Delta Monks, the blues monks, the Mississippi monks. Yes. Uh, and they make and were making this combination of gospel, soul music, little rock and roll, uh zen chants or chants. And it was this combination of very bluesy, very ethereal uh riffing on the traditions that all were coming today there.

SPEAKER_00And it literally sang alive the gallery and the space and made the white container uh around these rescued, upcycled fragments really come alive.

SPEAKER_01I mean, this notion of hidden history and uncovering hidden histories is quite important for you in terms of what imaginative reuse is all about. In other words, you're not talking about preservation here, you're talking about finding new ways to do things with buildings.

SPEAKER_00Absolutely. And the movement to that, I think, really started in the 1970s, uh, both in Europe and the United States, when architects and artists um began taking historic structures and not just putting something new in them, fixing them up and putting something new in them, but examining them, rubbing them, chipping away at them, making openings in them and small additions, finding pieces to elaborate in them.

SPEAKER_00I contrast two buildings that were finished around the same time or done around the same time. One is the renovation of the so-called Castle Vecchio, which is a museum uh in Verona by the Italian architect Carlo Scarpa. When you look at the facade of that building, the front of that building, you can see bits and pieces of its life as a castle, as a garrison for Napoleon, as a museum, all of the lives it's led. And then when you look up at a corner of the roof, you can see that part of the structure is visible, some of the tile is still there, a new covering to make it all waterproof peaks out from underneath it.

SPEAKER_00And below where the architect has clawed away that, fixed up, but also revealed the roof, there is a shelter for one of the most important statues in Verona of one of their great military leaders who's propped up beneath uh that in that new veranda. And that attitude continues in the building where paintings are held forward uh but you can on new struts, but you can also see their back and you can understand uh their exhibition history.

SPEAKER_00At the same time, an artist in San Francisco named David Ireland bought a house on 500 Cap Street and started renovating it for his home and studio, as artists do, but instead of just cleaning it up, he started peeling away the wallpaper and the coverings, but leaving parts of it and became fascinated in the history of the house, found old documents, turned those into artworks, where he bumped into the wall when he was moving a safe uh downstairs.

SPEAKER_00He turned that into an artwork in itself. A bunch of brooms that were there became an artwork together. He covered some of the walls with beeswax so that their history really shone. And it's that kind of loving, almost fetishistic preservation and revealing of the past that I think has generated much of this imaginative reuse in the last few decades.

SPEAKER_01That does seem like an important project for all this. I mean, one of the things you suggest when confronted with an old building is that architects should do absolutely nothing. That's going entirely against their educational grain, isn't it? And the reason they became architects in the first place.

SPEAKER_00Well, it's not I don't say that they shouldn't they should do absolutely nothing when confronted with an old building. I would say they should uh ask yourself the question, uh, do they need to do something when they receive a commission? If so, what? Um and it's not necessarily a new uh question. Um the architect Rem Kohlhas uh in the Netherlands, at least for a while, claimed that when people came to see them with what they thought was a commission for new building, they would ask them, do you really need a new building?

SPEAKER_00Do you need a new image? Do you need to reorganize what you already have? Do you need to get the divorce? Do you need to reorganize your company? Uh what is it that you really need to do? What are you after with what you think is a new building? And quite often you'll discover that the answer uh is not necessarily making a new building. It might be reusing an existing building, but it also could be doing nothing whatsoever uh but doing something in a completely different sphere.

SPEAKER_01Has your attitude to the profession of architecture changed over the years? I mean, as we mentioned in the intro, early in your career, for example, you wrote a book on Zaha, you worked in Geary's office, and these people were form makers, or at least Geary became one. Does form still interest you?

SPEAKER_00Yes, I and I'm a sucker for good architecture. Uh I travel around the world looking for good architecture, I write about it continually. So in that sense, I'm not uh doctrinaire, shall we say. Uh, but I think that the imperative, given what is going on with our climate, what is going on uh in uh the social life of our planet, and uh given the problems that architecture has made for itself, is to stop making new buildings.

SPEAKER_00Now, obviously, when people make new buildings, despite that, I prefer that they be good buildings, uh, and I keep looking for them elsewhere. It's just that I have indeed come to the conclusion uh over the last 10 years or so that that really is not the way forward.

SPEAKER_01Well, there are difficulties with the practicalities of reuse. As you point out, engineers don't like using pre-use steel because they don't know what stresses it's been under in the past. What are the issues around circularity in architecture?

SPEAKER_00The biggest issue in general is still that it's cheaper to build new than to renovate in most cases. And that's again because as a society and as an economic system, uh we value certain uh ways of doing and making things in everything from the way that we have organized our production and distribution and extractive industries uh to the way in which our tax code works. Now, that has been changing over the years, uh, first through the emergence of historic preservation tax credits and those kinds of mechanisms.

SPEAKER_00And more recently, um, again in Europe, uh the since 1998, there has been a mandate to improve the circularity and to reduce energy use in buildings, uh, not only in their uh operation, but also in their production. And uh in some countries, uh people are supposed to now, the the guidelines, so they're not yet laws, uh, are that people are supposed to make buildings out of 50% reused upcycled materials.

SPEAKER_00They also are supposed to design buildings so that they can be easily taken apart and reused, which can be very simple things like uh not using glues or soldering, but using screws uh to put things together. Um and those guidelines are turning into laws. So I do think uh that we are moving to a situation where the economic and legal system will make it more advantageous uh to reuse existing buildings and components.

SPEAKER_00Uh, but we're not there yet. And whether we will be able to do so in time before uh we destroy the possibility of human beings living on this planet, I don't know.

SPEAKER_01Yeah. I mean, are there some countries that are taking it more seriously than others? I mean, obviously, with the book you travel around the world, but a number of your examples come from the Netherlands, and I guess there's a reason for that state subsidy.

SPEAKER_00Yes. And uh I would say that uh Germany, Belgium, the Netherlands, Denmark, Sweden are the places where uh the laws and the tactics are most advanced. You know, the Germans have this lovely world that they developed a number of years ago, which I won't even try, uh, which is that one of the consideration in judging whether a building can be built or not is uh the value the value of the building as a remains.

SPEAKER_00Right. So how much of it can be reused uh once its use has run out.

SPEAKER_01Yeah, yeah. And value is often about perception, isn't it? Yeah. We were involved in a talk, a Nigroni Talk at our event that we have recently, and we had some artists who did our entrance space, and their thing is reusing materials from buildings that have been knocked down called Studio Tip, and they became very interested in these glass blocks that were gonna be dumped. And it transpires that when the architects discovered of the building, discovered that they were interested in these glass blocks, they became interested in the glass blocks, and all of a sudden the value of these glass blocks that were gonna be just dumped spiraled.

SPEAKER_01It's fascinating. One of the things you talk about in the the book, the return of phrase I rather like is the need for urban mining. What does urban mining entail?

SPEAKER_00I I didn't make up that phrase, uh, by the way. I'm not actually sure who did, but it's been used in a number of articles and books. But uh I I'm a hunter and gatherer of phrases and uh things like that as well. Um But uh urban mining is the notion that you quite simply mine your resources uh not from uh some coal pit or iron ore pit, uh, but rather from the existing buildings, the dumpsters, the alleyways, uh whatever is already out there.

SPEAKER_00And uh a Dutch architect called Jan Jungert has developed a software for that that uh allows you to uh do what he calls uh urban harvesting, which is something similar, uh, and it's called the harvest map. And uh it really helps you identify and organize uh what kind of materials might be available all around you uh and what can be used. But it it could be all kinds of things. Uh another example that I yeah, I think is in the book.

SPEAKER_00I'm trying to remember where they made it off the editing table, uh, is a building again in the Netherlands where it's a lab building. Uh they reuse part of the seal structure of an old lab building that was being torn down. They also reused part of its uh brick cores uh for the new building. As they were going to the site, they saw that work crews were uh uh uh um axing, what do you call it, tearing down uh trees, felling trees by the side of the road because they had gotten diseased and old.

SPEAKER_00And so they were able to reuse those. Uh they found 18 toilets in a uh lawyer's office that was being renovated. They reused those. Uh they found uh rest remnants of carpet that all had slight imperfections in them and organized the imperfection to make a pattern in the new buildings. So they just found these things all over the place.

SPEAKER_01I know this is new, as you point out.

SPEAKER_00The Romans were at it a long time ago. They called it spolia. Yeah. Uh like our word for spools, spoils. And uh they would go to old temples or whatever was around and use that to make new buildings. And a lot of Rome is made up of those spoils.

SPEAKER_01Yeah, yeah, yeah. Having said that, I mean obviously you talk about the Romans, but much of the book, as you've already mentioned, is focused on kind of post-industrial buildings. Early on, you described the loft as the single most successful and ubiquitous bit of architecture in Western nations. I think that's a statement that might raise a few eyebrows, but why are lofts kind of the ideal canvas for imaginative reuse?

SPEAKER_00Well, uh, for architects, uh the loft is the three-dimensional reality of their default way of working, which is to make a grid. And the grid in three dimensions becomes a cube, uh a structure. And that's how architects work, whether they like it or not. Uh but in reality, the loft, or what we think of today our loft, was developed starting at the end of the 18th century in mainly in both England and France, as flexible workshape workspaces filled with light that would accommodate uh new and ever larger industrial processes.

SPEAKER_00Over time, its form became and its construction became perfected and rationalized like no other form of building, other than perhaps uh home building uh in the United States out of wood and in Europe out of concrete. But it really is an incredibly flexible unit. And it was able to accommodate all kinds of work and uh storage, warehouses, but also selling.

SPEAKER_00Most uh department stores are based on a similar principle. And then in the 1960s, as the Industrial Revolution began waning, artists began taking them over and turning them into places to both work and live because they were so flexible and filled with light and had so few limitations on them. Then uh their patrons began to notice that, and began the lawyers began moving in. Uh and pretty soon offices and other uses began moving in.

SPEAKER_00And by now, uh loft spaces have turned into everything from housing and offices and museums and gyms and anything you can possibly imagine. Um, what's interesting to me is that they are the urban equivalent of what you see in uh a large belt across the world from South and Central America all the way through the Mediterranean, all the way into Asia, which is uh people who are able to afford a simple concrete structure that they have a professional come in and build, and then they themselves, over time, fill it in with whatever material is available uh as their homes or their businesses.

SPEAKER_00And so throughout these countries, you see these half-built structures that over time uh again telling the story of the people there begin to fill in and be lived in.

SPEAKER_01Loft living also became a style, didn't it? I remember Charlie Sheen's character in Wall Street creating a loft with uh or loft style with brickwork that was stapled to the wall, raw, fake raw brickwork. And I wonder, are there things in this book that could tip over into becoming a style?

SPEAKER_00Oh, absolutely. And I, you know, again, that like uh judgefication, there's no way out of that. Uh I realized that a long time ago when I did my first book, which was called Violate Perfection, and which I thought was all about how architecture was going. To change in a revolutionary way. And instead it became something that students and practitioners kept at their desk to crib ideas from. And that's the way architecture books work. I hope, in fact, that some of these ideas are picked up and copied.

SPEAKER_00I think that would be great. But as I point out in the book, a lot of this, the success of imaginative reuse, is due to not only loft living, but I point out to magazines like World of Interiors in England, which was hugely successful in the 80s and 90s, which specialize in these kind of dilapidated, distressed, aristocratic environments that people were inhabiting in a somewhat tenuous but also elegant manner.

SPEAKER_00And that again became the inspiration for a lot of this work.

SPEAKER_01Yeah. Funnily enough, I had a question all about World of Interiors ready to go, but you've beaten me to it, which is absolutely fine. Back in 2007, Erin, I wrote a piece for the RABA journal about how Glastonbury was a temporary city. So I was really intrigued to read your chapter in the book about modern nomadism. You propose that it could be a future model for how we live. You write that it can be light on the land and continually recycled. It can also be a place that celebrates the vital and continual work of making a community.

SPEAKER_01We're going through waves of migration caused by global destabilization and climate crisis. Traveling communities have always existed. But this model you lay out, this is for a very particular part of the community, isn't it?

SPEAKER_00Yes. But I think that places like Glassbury or Coacheller, which is the place I visited, really, or last visited, really are, again, experimental RD labs for something we could do in other places. And they are that because we spend so much money on them. I don't know how many millions are spent staging every uh every Glastonbury every year, uh, but certainly the tickets uh prices indicate that it's a lot. Well, you've got to be quite wealthy nowadays.

SPEAKER_00It is a self-selecting community, that one. Yeah. I was quite astonished at the price at uh Cochella as well. And because there's so much money, there's a huge amount of inventiveness in everything from the larger civic structures or amount to the larger civic structures, the stages, uh, to the various uh temporary components, stores, toilets, uh clinics, everything that a community needs. And at a completely different level, uh, the people who go there can often afford these incredibly innovative tents that I wrote about starting 20 years ago when the whole uh camping industry was revolutionized by North Face and Commos and companies like that.

SPEAKER_00And all of that together means that there's an incredibly beautiful, efficient, and portable architecture that comes together in those kind of venues. They also uh support the communities that more and more are what our communities look like, which is they are uh places where people of shared interests, beliefs, tastes, desires, whatever it might be, come together in a fluid manner, sometimes online and sometimes like this in real life, uh, for however long they want to.

SPEAKER_00And that kind of uh global nomadism, I think, will demand uh a different kind of urbanism, one that I believe could revitalize uh and change our notion of what it means to be urban and stop us from investing so much in cities that we have to then invest a huge amount in renovating almost as soon as they're done. Having just been to Shenzhen, I can I I saw that at first hand. Uh the problem, of course, is that this is, again, for rich people. Uh the question is, can we find a way, and that would be one of my challenge to architects, can we find a way to learn from these kind of highly charged and highly uh monetized venues for the real problem of our nomadic world, which are the millions of people, tens of millions of people that are displaced and will be increasingly displaced by climate uneval, by social unrest, and by all of the injustices inherent in our global capitalist system.

SPEAKER_01Aaron Powell When you were talking just then about fluid moving cities, kind of archogram jumps immediately to mind. Absolutely.

SPEAKER_00They were quite important to you, I think. Yes, absolutely. And you know, they were they were very visionary architects, these architects from England who, in a comic book style in the 1960s, imagined walking cities and suitaloons that were both suits and bubbles and all kinds of wonderful uh technofantastic inventions. Um, they built on the work of people like uh Buckminster Fuller, the guy who invented the Judistic Dome. And uh there actually is a direct connection.

SPEAKER_00It turns out that the innovations in tents I spoke about were the result of a lecture that Buckminster Fuller gave in Berkeley, at the University in Berkeley, California, in the 1960s. And uh a bunch of students uh who were also campers were very enthused by that lecture and say, oh, we can take those principles and use them to redesign our tent. And three of them together founded what became Moss Tent and Northface and another company and really changed the whole industry.

SPEAKER_00Very good.

SPEAKER_01I mean, while we were on the subject of music, I have to ask you about this, Erin. You have been to the legendary Studio 54. I love the fact you were looking at the architecture while everybody else was having the time of their lives. Oh, I was having the time of my life as well. Oh, you're having a time of your life. Oh, good. I'm glad to hear it. Tell me all about it.

SPEAKER_00Well, what really was impressive about Studio 54 to me, and a lot of this, I'm sure, is post facto uh rationalization. But I do have the distinct memory of going to this place where the architecture was this old theater that was somewhat dilapidated, and that was part of its charm, the sense that you were in this somewhat ruinous environment that still had an aura of the uh great television shows. The Ed Sullivan show was uh filmed there, and the movies that were shown there, the theaters that took place there, this sense of a kind of elegant grandeur that now you were reliving as you moved in there.

SPEAKER_00So it already uh made you feel as if that past was coming alive with your entering into the space, and then it was infused with technology, and there was very little building. There was scaffolding and there was lighting and there was music. But the brilliance of the crew at Studio 54 was that beyond all the stuff about celebrities and uh the other reasons it became so successful, is that they were able to manipulate these very ethereal means sound, music, light, to uh create spaces that would bring you together, take you apart, manipulate you in all kinds of incredibly sensual uh and convincing ways.

SPEAKER_00And that to me was really at the core of what made it so exciting.

SPEAKER_01I'm very aware that we're running out of time, but before you go, there's a couple of things I'd quite like to ask, which is a lot of what you discuss in the book concerns city centers or former industrial zones. But I guess our suburbs are changing too. You wrote a PN in D Zine about the death of a shopping mall in the US. Are we going to find a way to reuse these buildings too?

SPEAKER_00We have to. And I do show a few examples of that, but you're absolutely right. Um, in a way, the downtown and its renovation is already happening and will continue to happen. And I hope it will happen quicker uh and in better ways. But the real challenge, the real issue is out there, is out where more and more people live, where the waste of resources is even greater. Uh, that is exactly where we have to figure out how to reuse our houses, our shopping malls, and our warehouses in such a way as to open them up, to make them available to a much more varied group of users.

SPEAKER_00And there are a few uh interesting examples of that, but too far and few uh between. And I think that's really where the next challenge is.

SPEAKER_01What would you like your readers to take away from this book, Aaron?

SPEAKER_00That we shouldn't build.

SPEAKER_01Goes back to the opening sentence. Yeah.

SPEAKER_00Uh that uh there is no real need for new buildings, or at least there very rarely is a need for new buildings. And if there is a need for new buildings, we could should create them out of what is already available to us. I think that also for those people who are not architects, uh it is a plea to open yourself up to the beauty that's already all around you, to not be fascinated just by the new and the novel. If it's true that most hip-hop music is made out of samples, and if it's true that most clothing is already always a quotation of clothing that's already existed and increasingly is also made out of reused components, why can't we accept that in buildings?

SPEAKER_00Why can't we see the beauty in what's already there, uh what is filled with stories and meanings that are just waiting for us to discover? So it's a plea to look around, to discover the beauty of what we've already built, and to find ways to reuse it, to rethink it, to reimagine it.

SPEAKER_01The beauty that's all around you. That's a very lovely sentiment. Our time is fundamentally up. Final question: what can we expect from you next?

SPEAKER_00Uh my next book is actually about uh a group of architects who is doing a lot of this kind of work. They are called Assemble, and it's a collaborative based in London who do temporary structures, they do structures out of reused materials, uh, they work with communities, and they are also, as I said, a cooperative rather than the usual hierarchical uh form of uh architecture office.

SPEAKER_00Because one of the things I don't really talk about in the book, but that I get asked about when I lecture or talk about it, is that this also implies a different way that the architecture profession uh could be structured. And assemble, I think, really uh is a great example of an alternative. And I see more and more of my students working in that manner. And that book will be published uh by Thames and Hudson uh next year. Uh I'm then hoping to do a monograph on an architect who was truly imaginative and imagined other places called Lebby's Woods.

SPEAKER_00Uh and then I'm hoping to do a book on Los Angeles architecture at the end of the last century, uh, which I will do together with the critics, uh Todd Gannon and Joe Day. So there are a few books in the works.

SPEAKER_01You've got a bit on. You've got a bit on. Well, I look forward to all that. Congratulations on the latest book. I uh I thoroughly enjoyed it. And um thank you very much for your time. Very much enjoyed the conversation. Thank you. Don't build, rebuild, the case for imaginative reuse in architecture, published by Beacon Press, is out now. As ever, to find other podcasts that I've done and to sign up to our newsletter, go to materialmatters.design. And there are images related to the interviews on our Instagram page, which is also materialmatters.design.

SPEAKER_01Incidentally, you can now also find the show on YouTube Music as well as Apple Podcasts, Spotify, Amazon Music, and a host of other places. There's absolutely no excuse not to listen. And it would make me incredibly happy if you went to my Patreon page and made a pledge at patreon.com forward slash material matters. For as little as£2.50 a month, you can receive an invite to various Material Matters events, as well as getting access to each episode before it's published to the wider world. Material Matters is a completely independent concern, and any help you can offer would be hugely appreciated.

SPEAKER_01Ultimately, you'll be helping to take the message of the importance of materials, skill, craft, and design to a whole new audience. Thanks very much for listening.

Open the transcript file

Hosts and Guests

Nobody is credited on this episode yet.

Credit the people on this episode

Be the first to rate this episode

More episodes

All episodes
  1. Bethany Williams on turning discarded clothes into high fashion.

    Nov 10, 202645 minAudio

    Bethany Williams describes herself as ‘an artist, humanitarian and sustainable fashion designer’. Since graduating from the London College of Fashion in 2016, she has collaborated with organisations that help people...

    Credit the people on this episode

  2. Corin Mellor on stainless steel, Sheffield, and designing beautiful cutlery.

    Oct 14, 202655 minAudio

    Corin Mellor is the creative director of David Mellor Design - a brand that is synonymous with his father, David, but also the design and manufacture of beautiful cutlery, primarily made of stainless steel. According to...

    Credit the people on this episode

  3. Artist Nicola Turner on horsehair, sheep's wool and her solo show at the Yorkshire Sculpture Park.

    Sep 15, 202658 minAudio

    Nicola Turner is a UK-based artist who is best known for her use of horsehair and wool in her extraordinary, and often quite dark, sculptures. She originally trained as a theatre designer - working for the likes of the...

    Credit the people on this episode

  4. John Tuomey on the importance of materials in architecture, designing London's V&A East, and his new book, Middle Quarter.

    Sep 9, 20261 hr 7 minAudio

    Dublin-based architect John Tuomey first appeared on Material Matters in 2024 to talk about his brilliant memoir, First Quarter. Now he’s written the follow-up, unsurprisingly entitled, Middle Quarter. John is the...

    Credit the people on this episode

  5. Reusing Construction Waste with Joel de Mowbray of Yes Make

    Sep 1, 20261 hr 11 minAudio

    What if the materials a building needs are already sitting in a skip down the road? Joel de Mowbray, founding director of Yes Make, joins Grant Gibson to explain how a regenerative design and build practice rescues...

    Credit the people on this episode