Skip to content
PodSubs
ShowsPeopleGuestsJobsNewsEvents
More
BlogPodCred
Menu
ShowsPeopleGuestsJobsNewsEventsBlogPodCredNetworksSign in
Join nowSign in
  • Shows
  • People
  • Jobs
  • News
  • More
    • Guests
    • Events
    • Blog
    • PodCred
    • Networks
    Join nowSign in

Mastering Therapy

Mastering Therapy artwork

S4E5: Stop processing parts without mapping their purpose first (IFS & EMDR)| Dr David Polidi

Mar 12, 202648 minAudio
ShareXLinkedInFacebookWhatsAppEmail

What happens when you blend the structured world of EMDR with the nuanced, parts-based approach of IFS? Dr. Natalie Stott sits down with David Polidi - EMDR therapist and “IFS guru” (his clients’ words, not his) - to get practical about integrating Internal Family Systems and Eye Movement Desensitisation and Reprocessing in complex trauma work. They tackle everything from how to honour protectors (without bulldozing them) to what actually happens in this mysterious “Phase 2.5,” and how to avoid getting tangled in your own parts as a therapist. Plus, the age-old questions: Do you really need bilateral stimulation? And can you use a parts lens without an IFS certificate? No hype, just candour, solid tips, and welcome reassurance for therapists at every stage. TIMESTAMPS • 00:00 Introduction and purpose of blending IFS and EMDR • 02:41 The “Syzygy model” and holding both maps in session • 06:24 EMDR’s Phase 2.5/Discovery Phase - what is it, why is it useful? • 14:43 What to do when protectors hijack reprocessing work • 24:24 When negotiations with parts fail - what next? • 27:13 Why blend models at all? And do you have to pick sides? • 33:15 What happens between sessions? Homework for clients (and therapists) • 36:42 Getting started: books, trainings, and the value of consultation KEY TAKEAWAYS • Always check in with every part - genuine consent trumps protocol when reprocessing trauma memories. • Use “Phase 2.5” (Discovery Phase) with blended protectors - pause, get curious, and only proceed when all parts are on board. • The “fire drill” is a quick, practical tool: name your own therapist parts at the start of sessions and gently ask them to step aside. • Don't bulldoze protectors - forced reprocessing often brings backlash and, at best, patchy results. • EMDR's structure maps well onto IFS’s parts work, but the pace needs to match your client’s system - not your agenda. • It’s OK to use parts language without formal IFS training, as long as you’re respectful, collaborative, and guided by your client’s experience. • Encourage clients to build ongoing relationships with their parts between sessions (quick daily check-ins can genuinely help). RESOURCES S4E5: Stop processing parts without mapping their purpose first (IFS & EMDR)| Dr David Polidi Guest Information: David Polidi is a practising EMDR therapist known for integrating IFS into trauma work. He recently edited a collaborative book on IFS-informed EMDR, gathering voices from trainers, teachers, and therapists innovating at the frontier of blended models. Social media: Website: Resources mentioned: IFS Training Programs | IFS Institute Intro to IFS informed EMDR - EMDR Insight IFS Informed EMDR Training Program - Syzygy Institute David's Book ** Check out Mastering Therapy’s Youtube Channel for all podcast episodes ** For notification on up coming episodes and for occasional summaries of tools discussed on the podcast sign up here: www.masteringtherapy.com To recommend a topic you’d like to hear about, or if you’d like to appear on the podcast please get in touch at www.masteringtherapy.com/guest For private psychology services and therapy visit www.drnataliestott.com ***** Subscribe to the Mastering Therapy Podcast YouTube channel Follow Mastering therapy on instagram Connect with Dr Natalie Stott on LinkedIn SUPERVISOR PLATFORM Supervisor Platform is an online directory designed for therapists, psychologists, counsellors, and other mental health professionals to connect with qualified clinical supervisors. It makes it easy for practitioners to browse, compare, and contact supervisors based on their expertise, approach, and availability, while giving supervisors a professional space to showcase their services. Supervisor Platform (with 3 months free trial code 'WELCOME3') To search for a new supervisor visit HERE For free resources on supervision visit HERE Disclaimer: The Mastering therapy podcast and the information provided by Dr Natalie Stott (Dclinpsych, HPCP reg), is solely intended for informational and educational purposes and should only be used by qualified professionals. Mentioned in this episode: Supervisor platform SUPERVISOR PLATFORM: Visit www.supervisorplatform.com to search supervisors You can list your profile for free for 3 months Guide

Audio and video play straight from the show's own hosting. PodSubs stores and serves no media.

Transcript

From the show. Tap a time to play from there.

Welcome to the Mastering Therapy podcast. This is a show for psychologists, psychotherapists, and counselors who are looking to build on their therapy skills, increase confidence in working with clients and be inspired by alternative models, tools, and ways of working. I'm your host, Dr. Natalie Start. I'm a clinical psychologist and founder of Supervisor Platform, A directory that supports. Clinicians to showcase their supervision and training to other therapists. It also helps you to find a supervisor that fits with your work and your style.

Join my guests and me as we learn from one another and aim to take insights and put them into action. This is season four. Let's go. Natalie Stott: welcome everybody to yet another episode of Mastering Therapy. For those of you that joined last season, you will probably have heard the episode I did on IFS and an introduction to IF. And how we might use it in sessions. Well, this is kind of a part two. But this week my guest is David Polidi He is an EMDR therapist.

IFS guru. And David, a couple of months ago, just released a book about blending these two approaches. And I know there is lots of, um, question, that people have because there's not much out there about. How to really blend the two. So thank you for coming today and for sharing your wisdom. I am a little bit intimidated, uh, my parts are a bit intimidated, but also delighted to have you. So thank you for coming on. David Polidi: I just wanna, you know, I'm flattered. I don't find myself to be a guru of IFS this is how I'm referred

to by a lot of my clients. Natalie Stott: Yeah. David Polidi: I'm a social worker and somebody who wants to be a healer, wants to be a helper. And even the book, you know, my book, I don't even really call it my book. It's IFS informed EMDR. Creative collaborative approaches. it highlights 22 of us that are trainers teachers consultants, and therapists, and it's really, I think, the beauty of the project. Is that it's not any one person saying, this is

And form eMDR is. It's more like a reflection of this is how 22 souls have interpreted and used and found meaning in the models and in Natalie Stott: mm David Polidi: of the models. Natalie Stott: Yeah, and so I think you've done really well to capture that and also the, you know, the people that you have been influenced by and sharing a bit of your journey. So you know, we may be able to get touch on that today. There are some people that will be listening to this that are primarily

EMDR, that have maybe recently done some IFS training and are at the beginning stages of thinking how do I weave this in? And there'll be other people that maybe are more kind of heavily IFS. Dominant with a bit of the, you know, EMDR thrown in occasionally. I wondered for you whether you are always blending like just, is that your default or Have you kind of created this new model that isn't one or the other? It is just this new kind of I-F-S-E-M-D-R model.

David Polidi: Yeah, no, I love that question. And I would say I'm definitely like all of us, I'm continually growing, continuing developing. As of right now my journey has really been a lot with learning the Sgy model, which is Bruce Hersey and a lot of the people in the book not Natalie Stott: Hmm. David Polidi: but all of the SY trainers are featured in the book and the Csy model, I would say, again, it's Bruce Hersey. I would say that, you know, that model really sees us working with clients

with always using IFS informed DMDR. We're always using IFS, we're always using EMDR, with Natalie Stott: Hmm. David Polidi: I find that, from day one, we're implementing strategies we're not necessarily going right for reprocessing trauma memories, but if we have a sense of the eight phases, we always know what phase am I in, what phase am I in, and what phase am I heading to?

So that's a map that we're always holding when we're with a client. And at the same time, I would say with IFS. We're always holding the sense that there's a multiplicity within all of us. And so whatever we're doing with the EMDR at that moment, we're always asking ourself what parts are in the room, what parts are here with us? What parts are we working with? What parts are we doing EMDR with and what IFSI think IFS levels up just ego

state because it really keeps us aware of, in addition to what parts are in the room, we're always asking ourselves how much self energy is in the room. and I don't know if Zandra spoke about self-energy. I would imagine they did. Natalie Stott: Yeah. David Polidi: a, a big focus of IFS is how much self-energy does my client have and how much self-energy do I have, and trying to find a way to connect to more and more self-energy. 'cause that self-energy is really kind of the animation of the IP.

System. Natalie Stott: Hmm. David Polidi: So we're always seeing like, how much access do we have to that? Natalie Stott: Yeah. One of the things we'll come onto a bit later is you know, when you're doing reprocessing and it feels like protectors are kind of. Preventing or getting in the way of that or protecting. And that can, that can actually be really difficult for therapists. 'cause I think that interrupts that self energy and it's really important to then think about, you know, what systems are going on for us as therapists.

So maybe we could talk about that. That I'm sure that will come up. Just thinking about those phases. So just as a disclaimer for those listening, I'm EMDR trained. I'm not IFS trained, I've always felt like EMDR because it is so structured, even the words that you say, the order that you say it feels very, very important to adhere to the model. In that way, IFS seems a lot more gentle and thinking about. Phase two in particular of EMDR, so the resourcing, the stabilization

that we might do with clients. In your book, you talk about phase 2.5, and I think this is. Part of Bruce's model. And I think this will be an important context for maybe thinking then about working with parts and protectors during reprocessing, but do you mind just explaining to our listeners about that phase 2.5 and how it differs from maybe what you might normally do as part of the standard EMDR protocol? David Polidi: Yeah. Well, I'm happy that, that's a great question.

I think that IFS will kind of add a lot of value or does add a lot of value to EMDR in that, and Anabel McGoldrick speaks a lot about this as do others that, if you're going into a house and you really want to help a child who's struggling, you meet the parents. At the front door, you're not just gonna barge right in and be like. Let me go to the kid, let me fix the child.

You're gonna wait to be invited in by the parents Natalie Stott: Mm David Polidi: Okay, let me go. and so I think with phase two in general, we're getting a lay of the land of what parts are present, what parts are here, and do we have permission? To meet with some of the trauma, some of the ones that are holding what if FS would call burdens what EMDR would call trauma memories. But do we have permission for That, that's huge. Asking for that permission. And I think that we always wanna honor that

This, you know, this work and so. What happens at times is with the IFS model, people become blended with their parts. They have the parts kind of controlling them, taking over, and they're not even aware of that. So Natalie Stott: Hmm. David Polidi: get a sense of is that going on? And some of our protectors, you know, I've heard that protectors are as big and hold the same amount of energy as the hurt. That the exiles hold. So if we are

Natalie Stott: Yeah. David Polidi: if we're holding a lot of hurt, then the protectors are gonna have a lot of energy. They're gonna say, I don't want to unblend, I can't, that's gonna be unsafe. So we, Natalie Stott: Hmm. David Polidi: And what phase 2.5 is, which another name for it is The discovery phase. really trying to focus on a that's blended with the client. And when we don't feel any self energy or any access to the a IP, you know, system,

is a way to use bilateral stimulation and to say, we just wanna get to know this protector a little bit better, Natalie Stott: Hmm. David Polidi: would it be okay for us to do a little bit of bilateral? What this model, the Sci U model does also, which is really cool, is it uses some of knife's work and pops skis work, which a level of urge to use and, and a level of urge to avoid something. And what it says is it uses it with the protector focusing on

the level of urge to protect. Natalie Stott: Hmm. David Polidi: to protect us, we wanna find, and this is going back to Dick Schwartz book, no Bad Parts. All of our parts have a purpose, have a reason, and have a positive intention. That positive intention, if we're able to identify that positive intention, we could actually ask, okay, you have this intention, whatever it is. How strong is that from one to 10? You know, let's give it a number that becomes our suds.

then we say, you know, try to explore that. And we do the bilateral and we see, you know, where that's going to take the person. And ultimately, I believe what Bruce has found is that we're connecting with the self energy within that protector part. Natalie Stott: Hmm. David Polidi: we allow that self-energy of that protector part with the bilateral to grow and grow and grow, eventually we're gonna quote unquote flip the part. And when we flip the part, now all of a sudden we're revealing, this is the exile.

That that part is protecting, that we could eventually move Natalie Stott: Hmm. David Polidi: But it's not about having an agenda of healing, it's really about having an agenda of building a relationship Natalie Stott: Hmm. David Polidi: having the Natalie Stott: Hmm. David Polidi: with them, build a relationship, gain trust so that at some point they're just gonna say, Ooh, could you help me? And at that point, okay, let's figure out how we could help you. and then we're moving into more of a phase three, phase

four of EMDR, but what my book. about is how so much of the work with complex trauma and with a lot of the people that I meet with and that I think, you know, unless you have a single traumatic episode that you're going to therapy specifically to heal, in which case EMDR works very smoothly. we're talking about complex trauma. We're really sitting. In phase two, quite a bit, Natalie Stott: Yeah. David Polidi: if you like. we're expanding that world because there's a lot of healing that takes

place within phase two, and I found that like when we get to phase three, phase four and all the rest, the work actually goes fairly quickly. But getting Natalie Stott: Because you've prepped so much, you know, you've done so much work. That it's as much about that almost as it is The reprocessing. David Polidi: Or even more so. Natalie Stott: Hmm. David Polidi: EMDR with all of its wonderful addition to the field, and I, I would never, you know, say that EMDR isn't a really important model for me.

it's been amazing. I feel that. It doesn't really give specific steps and specific ways. It has a couple of suggestions, but I think IFS has a lot more specificity and language that could help clients process and move through the phase two of the MDR. Natalie Stott: I think this will be really encouraging if people maybe are EMDR trained and have found themselves getting stuck because it's very typical

for us to think, oh, this is me doing this wrong, and if they were with another therapist, this would be really easy. But I think you're right to make that distinction. With the complexity because I have found that sometimes even mentioning this concept. The protective part is just there and you could get somebody just shutting down immediately because they just can't even tolerate the idea of revisiting something. And so I loved that metaphor that you used about, meeting the parents at the house.

And like you, you have to be invited in. And sometimes I think our medical models and time limited. Interventions just force a bit of a knocking down the door and that doesn't ever feel good. David Polidi: This Natalie Stott: it doesn't ever feel good. David Polidi: I agree with you completely and this is where I could bring in motivational interviewing and we could go as much or as deep or not at all as you Natalie Stott: No share. David Polidi: Mo. Natalie Stott: think it'll be interesting for people to hear.

David Polidi: Well, yeah. I have a lot of thoughts about the medical model and you know, USA where I'm at you know, how much pressure there is on therapists to do it quickly, and I think MI would say that. If we wanna go, and IFS says this too all the time. If you wanna go fast, you gotta slow it down. And you know, mi sees it as physics perhaps, where if you're pushing too far too hard one way, the natural response of the other

person, it's gonna be pushed back. And so Natalie Stott: Hmm. David Polidi: we have this medical model, it's like, let's do it as quickly as we can. Let's run in, let's do what we can. And you're just building up defenses. By doing that as opposed to having no pressure whatsoever and just instead having this really beautiful relationship of trust. And then when that's built, say, where do you wanna go? And trusting that the person that you're sitting with knows the quickest, most efficient way to get what they're needing, already inside

of them helping them trust that. Natalie Stott: But I would love us to have a bit of a discussion on how you might weave IFS. Into that. If when you are processing, you come up against. A protector and how you stay in, you know, noticing your own self energy and not getting flustered or discouraged by that or how you know that that's happening, and then how you attend to that.

So, loads of different directions we can go in, but I guess a discussion on what we do when those protectors get in the way, and how you attend to them in that moment. David Polidi: I'm like, Ooh, let's have a demonstration. 'cause I know that's something we wanna do. And that might, it might come up just in that, because I'd have to think of a specific example or if you had a specific example. I definitely welcome that. Natalie Stott: Yeah. So for example I was processing, this was a client that I worked with, uh, a few years ago. We were processing a particularly difficult childhood memory that

had taken loads and loads of resourcing to get to that point. And they were really. Terrified of going there, but were up for it and felt like it was important and really wanted to process that. However. You know, it didn't take long no matter how much grounding work that we'd done that they would just kind of dissociate in the session. And then it was really hard work as a therapist, because then the rest of the

session was really trying to ground them, stabilize them, and, you know, reassure and not finish the session like that, That happened quite a few times. And I wonder in that, you know, at that point I didn't have any IFS language for that. But when I look back, I think, gosh, that was a protector just doing a fantastic job. They were doing what they had done for their whole life and they were doing it really well. And I wish, like past me could have spoken to it, but.

You know, this is the beauty of growing, isn't it? Are there certain things that you, ways that you go about pausing and sitting with that protector, speaking to it, working with it, how do you do that? David Polidi: Yeah. so I'd back up, because you've said a lot of beautiful things. I would back up and as the therapist, notice what parts are coming up inside of me. Natalie Stott: Hmm. David Polidi: like, am I feeling that feeling of self-energy being present

or other parts, like an anxious part or a pushing part or worry part? I need to stay to the protocol and just gently ask them, you know, Joanne Tumbly has a chapter on the fire drill, which is an IFS technique. Natalie Stott: I was hoping you would bring this up. Do you mind just saying what that is? Because I think that's a really helpful tool that therapists can use, or even in supervision as well to. Work with their own parts. David Polidi: Of course, and I'll say, you know. I find the biggest value of the IFS Institute level one training and

probably level two, level three as well, is really having you sit there with other people using the model, practicing and really recognizing the parts that are coming up inside of you. I laughed to my wife that, you know, I go through a training and it's like, great. It's like I just had intensive therapy for two days straight and you get exhausted. but so I think that there's a lot of value to understanding what's inside of you so that you could be in the right frame of mind. And the fire drill is basically just trying to.

I'm gonna say something embarrassing here. I don't know why it's called the fire drill, but, I read Joanne's chapter and it's amazing. and basically what it is, is saying, you know, what parts do you recognize inside of you? And as a therapist, if you are doing IFS work, you're probably familiar with some of your parts and you're just gently asking them, could you step aside? So that I could be in self-energy in this therapy session. Could you step aside? I see you, I'm naming you.

I'm taking a moment. Just acknowledge you and I'll come back to you after therapy when I have my own time, when I'm meditating, when I'm relaxing. But for right now, could I just see you, recognize you're in the room? But really this is a, a big thing that we say in IFS. You wanna speak. Apart, not from apart. So if there is a part coming up you know, saying, you know, if you need to say something, tell me and I'll translate it or it'll come through my heart, but I don't wanna be blended because that's a great way to have

the therapy get off track and not Natalie Stott: Hmm. David Polidi: And I guess, you know, kind of thinking about it, I think of like an elementary school. Yeah, when you have a fire drill, you have all the kids line up and they go class by class, and then you, you separate all the class and make sure all the kids are there so that you're not missing anybody. Nobody's stuck in the building. it would be similar with a fire drill. You're taking all your parts gently asking them to leave the building and then just lining them up so you know everybody's there.

You're seeing it, you're counting for everybody, and then you're not allowing them to take over in that session. Natalie Stott: Hmm. David Polidi: So Natalie Stott: Great. David Polidi: kind of moving forward, that's the fire drill as I understand it Natalie Stott: Yeah. Thank you. I think that would be helpful. David Polidi: yeah, sure. Of course. So moving forward with your example I would first ask, you know, after doing a fire drill, I would just ask like. What parts are present and could you make sure that we have all

the parts permission before going towards our work with the MDR? Because clients a lot of times, will wanna do the work and, and that could be one part that, that just like, I gotta Natalie Stott: Hmm. David Polidi: I gotta get this. But we really wanna make sure, do all your parts agree. Does every part of you give us that permission? Because if any one part doesn't, we wanna pause and we wanna understand more. What is it afraid of? You know, what is the wisdom that it has for us before we

continue to do the healing work? and so, you know, what I'm hearing from you is there was this. Part that used dissociation as a tool, as a protecting tool. And that Natalie Stott: Hmm. David Polidi: was not fully on board. And so that part would come up. And so we would wanna note that, notice that pattern, and talk to that dissociating part. And get to know that dissociating part. And that's really hard, right? When, when you hear a client say, well, if you say what's coming up inside, or what part is here?

And they're like, nothing, there's, there's nothing right now mean a lot of things. And one of the things it could mean is maybe that nothing is a part. or the dissociation is a part. So, you know, that could lead into a whole nother discussion. But part of that is or an element of that is do we get to know this dissociation part? How do we help the client relate to it? To listen to it, and how do we help have a relationship between the client's self energy and that dissociating part?

And at that point, maybe the dissociation part. Could feel a little bit more comfortable to relax and allow the process to take place. Natalie Stott: Hmm. And would you be doing that? I mean, it's hard to know how long these things take, right? Because a protector that is really not on board may not just suddenly be like, oh, do you know what? Thanks for hearing me. It's fine. Continue. I think that were to be great, but I think it then comes back to us being

able to not be flustered by that. Because often I think. Maybe it's just me, but put pressure on myself that, David Polidi: not just Natalie Stott: that I, this must go well. Oh gosh, if we don't do this, then the client's gonna feel like, oh, we didn't actually process this session because my part's got in the way and I'm a failure. And then you're managing another part. So it's complex, isn't it? David Polidi: So. Natalie Stott: But the thing I love about FS is that there is, like you

say, you go like it's slower and even if you really want to rush. Parts are not gonna let you just because that's your agenda and that's when you come up against dissociation or you know, whatever it looks like for somebody. Even them pushing to just keep going could, you know, be that threat part of them that's activated that is just not allowing them to really feel it just, yeah. David Polidi: for that because then I think what if FS says is there could be

backlash, you know, if you piss off one of these parts and you just bulldoze right over them, maybe you get somewhere. But then throughout the week it's like something really bad happens. The anxiety spikes, they, they get really upset. You know, Dick talks about how he had somebody and he was negotiating with a part that was like, wanted to cut. they were gonna cut the girl, I believe it was her wrists. And he is like, you can't do that. and he bulldozed the part without meaning to, and the next week she showed up

with the gas on her face part's like, Natalie Stott: Oh. David Polidi: told you I wouldn't cut on her wrists. That's what we agreed. Natalie Stott: Yeah. David Polidi: I think there could be this huge backlash if we're not respecting these parts. Natalie Stott: Have you ever found it, David, where you've. Not had success with negotiating with a part, and therefore have you then pivoted if you are, say, in the middle of processing and protector shows up and you

sit alongside it, you get them to name it. You try and talk to it, but it is just not having it. How do you deal with that? David Polidi: my jokey answer is I go to a consultation and I say, help me, help me. But I think that, in that moment. Yeah, of course. I've had that and I've learned that, you know, and hopefully I do this more and more, that it's not about negotiating with the parks. It's not about trying to change them. It's not about really wanting anything.

It's just sitting with them in that self energy saying, here for you right now. I'm here for you. My heart is open for you, and trying to help the client do that. With their self energy and just that Natalie Stott: Hmm. David Polidi: alone is major. So we're really trying to help a client in more and more of their own self energy into the space. And if Natalie Stott: Mm David Polidi: in negotiating with a part, we're in the wrong place.

Natalie Stott: And also if you start getting frustrated annoyed, sad. I think these are all signs, aren't they? Of us, bringing our own systems into the mix and needing to step outside of that because if we are in that space, then we're not gonna be able to serve our clients in the way that they need. David Polidi: Completely. Natalie Stott: Can I ask you a bit of a controversial one, David? David Polidi: Yes, Natalie Stott: of where my mind is going with that is how, and I talked

a little bit with Sandra about this, this idea that the client has everything already inside of them. They have that. You know, and it is about connecting with that self that's always been there. I guess it's similar a little bit in the idea that with EMDR, you're facilitating what the brain is designed to do and you are just kind of a, you know, overseeing that you're not causing it or adding it. It's kind of already there. You're just helping that process because of, I guess, how IFS positions itself.

Is there a need for EMDR at all? Why not just use IFS? Why use the bilateral stimulation at all if we could? Or like, is there some, have you found there'd be greater benefit when you have blended the two within particular situations or with particular clients? Or sometimes do you think we won't, we'll just literally use IFS here. David Polidi: Part is coming up, has sarcasm, which is saying to myself,

Natalie, is that controversial? where is the controversy in that? I'm laughing because you're bringing up a very important thing and you're bringing up something that I wonder if there is some disagreement in the field about that. And I think there might be a bunch of IFS quote unquote purists that feel that that's a very legitimate question that they would say You only need IFS. and it is a complete model and you don't need anything else.

I think personally not wanting to step on any toes, but also wanting to be honest and transparent and truthful. It's just not how I think. You know, I really feel that models. Are not the end all and be all. And I think that I could say I love IFS. It's been life changing to me. I love EMDR. It's been life changing to me. They're models. And I guarantee you 10 years from now, there's gonna be tons of changes in them if they're gonna still be relevant because we're constantly growing, we're constantly

learning, and I would never want a model to stifle me and being able to relate to my client and what they're telling me right there, right then in the moment. And that's where I go back to my training as a social worker. You know, if I'm with a client, I'm in a relationship right there, which is. The most important thing when we're healing somebody or helping them heal and in that relationship, if my model tells me to go one way, but I'm feeling that the right way clinically is to go another way, trust my gut.

I'm gonna trust what you know, and I think in IFS language that's really sitting in self. Natalie Stott: Mm. David Polidi: It's sitting in this knowledge of like, there's some knowing that we both share, and in this moment we're gonna trust that. And whatever's in the model, whatever's in, you know, it's a great guide. But I was talking to Kendall Hart. Last week and we were talking about how you know her as, as a trainer, as a consultant, you know, I'm like, you know, if, if I'm sitting with

somebody and we're doing EMDR, but clinically, like the book tells me that the protocol says, go here, go. Right. But I'm feeling like the best thing to do is go left. I'm gonna go. And she said, well, you know, as long as you could explain why you're doing that, as long as you could put words to this is my rationale, and this is my thought of how to get back on track to the model her. She said, we're good, we're good. And, and so I, I feel that way too. I feel that, you know. It's, they're maps. They're maps, and we don't wanna be stifled by maps.

we wanna take a map and get to know a landscape. But if I'm looking at a map of some place that has, you know, I'm thinking of when I went to Africa and there's soil degradation and, and I'm like, the map isn't matching up to what I'm seeing. I change the map or do I say like, oh no, let's force some more soil on this because it has to match the map that I made. And you know, when it comes to IFS, I think Francine Shapiro, has found something that has been magical to people, you know, and we have, you know,

all these different books, you know, and trainers and ways of understanding some of the magic of EMDR and some of the ways that this really helps people. Hit some really deep things inside of them. Why are we gonna throw that out? Because we have another model that also works. Wouldn't it be better to just say, you know, what could we take from the EMDR world connect it with the IFS world? and if IFS if somebody for whatever reason isn't connecting with the language,

isn't connecting with the imagery. still gonna have an IFS lens. I'm not gonna stop seeing them as multiple because that's just how my mind now is conditioned to see reality, but I'm not gonna throw parts language in their face. I'll use some Natalie Stott: Hmm. David Polidi: MDR R language, you know, and I'll, Natalie Stott: Hmm. David Polidi: talk about it as like, now I'm talking to your exile part. What could you do some insight work and talk to your exile part? I'll say, oh, let's do some EMDR if you want to. And let's see, like what memories are we talking about and how could we work

Natalie Stott: Mm-hmm. There, there are so many thoughts that I have on this, David, and one of them is a discussion on the evidence base. And I again, love that metaphor of, going right or left. You know, if you see to go left, you're gonna go left. Just go right. Someone's told you to. And I do think this is, again, it comes back to the medical model and what we define as what the evidence base is. But there's something about IFS that I think invites a necessity to be flexible.

But my experience, I guess, of EMDR is that it's very much not. So I think there is something kind of magical. In being able to blend these two approaches that, you know, EMDR has some, I mean, I think so many of us have stories of, you know, where you are. You know, maybe in a session you're thinking, oh my goodness, like, is this, is this gonna shift? And then. It is quite miraculous and somebody's, you know, then saying, oh, I feel like completely different. My life's changed.

And maybe I didn't have the faith that that would happen even in the middle of it. So the protocol works and it's, it's wonderful. But I think I can also think of many times where I've come across situations where now my language would be, I'm coming up against the protector here and. The worst thing to do would be just to keep going and be, be that bulldozer and not listen to what that protector is saying or what your gut is saying,

which is maybe to stop and maybe in MDR terms, you might pause, you do some stabilization or resourcing, and that might be the rest of the session. But Just a question that's come up for me. You know, at the end of a processing session, you'd talk about how processing can continue after the session. You know, make a note of anything that comes up, dreams, thoughts. When you're blending the two, are you inviting clients to note down how their parts respond after the session? do you use that as a material when they then come back for their next session

and you say, has anything come up? How's the last week been? Are you interested in how the parts are responding to the therapy? David Polidi: Absolutely, and I think IFS goes even further where, you know, I caution my clients, like if we're doing sensitive work, if we're doing trauma healing processing, it's nice to have a witness. It's nice to have somebody else in the room. It's nice to have somebody objective that has the self energy to be there and to sit.

However, you're finding parts you know, be it protectors, ex house, whoever, and you're relating to them, you know, IFS has this beautiful way of saying could you make an arrangement to maybe meet with your part, you know, throughout the week? Could you check in? Could you see how that part is doing? Could you just sit with a little bit of love for that part and see if the part wants to Natalie Stott: Hmm. David Polidi: And so it's encouraging. The client to even schedule a time or to make some kind of agreement of

they will check in with their parts throughout the week to really have that ongoing relationship between themselves and their parts ideally. When clients are feeling activated upset or going through a hard time, I find it extremely beneficial when clients are able to witness, what part is coming up in those moments, can you take a pause and just sit with the part that's coming up? even if it's just putting your hand your heart and saying, I see you right now. I see you, I name you. Natalie Stott: Hmm.

David Polidi: That could sometimes even just be enough. to be able Natalie Stott: Hmm. David Polidi: Have that ongoing relationship. So I think IFS is really kind of sharing with people, you know, this is more than just therapy. This is a lifestyle, this is a lifestyle of recognizing there's parts. That are like your family inside of yourself, and you wanna build this ongoing, trusting relationship with them. Whereas I think EMDR doesn't do that as explicitly and, and doesn't, you know,

it's more like you go into therapy, you have e mdr r, you're healed, you're done. I like the kind of practice that IFS invites Our clients to have. Natalie Stott: Hearing the way that you talk about it, David, I think is energizing and helpful for people. And it's always a good reminder of when our stuff might be interrupting the work. For people that are beginning this journey of. IFS and EMDR and combining them.

Where would you say if they haven't done any formal training? Obviously your book is a great resource for people, but I imagine that getting some kind of formal training is necessary to really feel confident in, you know, if your IFS trained an MDR trained to be able to bring them both together, where could people go or where could they get more information? David Polidi: I love that. Think that, you know, I found it very helpful to have a consultant.

You know, consultation is great. Maybe the first thing is, is picking up some books. I have tons of books. I think that is exciting. I think also, you know. Either it's my book or, or something else. My book has a lot of people that offer trainings, and so just contacting some of the training places, I think JI is a wonderful place. I think Annabelle McGoldrick has some amazing trainings. There's many trainings. You know, I don't wanna miss anybody. So there, many trainers that I think.

Teach about IFS and EMDR. I think also, you know, there's some really cool trainings on just the IFS even. the gold standard would be to go through the institute, which is expensive and it does take a while to get in. But I think if somebody is really saying, this is something I need in my life, the institute. is amazing. You know, the community of IFS practitioners inside the IFS Institute and going to the conferences and seeing, the people that you align

with and whatever topics that you're interested in, getting more information Like, has somebody connected these topics with IFS? Probably yes. And if not, maybe you're the one to do that, you know? Natalie Stott: mm. David Polidi: to get to grow, listen to podcasts like yours, like mine. I think that was really helpful to me to listen to some of the podcasts that are out there. Hearing the author speak, hearing some of the big names and IFS speaking was, was very helpful.

Natalie Stott: And we'll put these as links into the show notes, your podcast and your book. David Polidi: Sure, We could even list out the authors so people could see what they're training Natalie Stott: Mm. David Polidi: them directly. There's some amazing trainings that they offer. Natalie Stott: A final question that I had, iFS obviously has gained a lot of traction over the last few years, and no matter what modality people find themselves majoring in, I think the concept of parts is really powerful because we can all relate.

Now, I spoke in depth with Zandra about how important training is that it's experiential because it's not just about learning. Okay, what are exiles, what are managers, what's blended, you know, all these IFS terms. You have to live it to be able to do the work, and so. I guess this will be interesting for people if they're like me, EMDR trained, but not if FS trained, but as a word of caution, would it be right? For people that are inspired by parts work, and they're using

it in EMDR, they're coming up against maybe dissociation. Would it be okay? Do you think for them to then start interviewing parts and sitting with parts if they haven't really gone through the IFS model and training and experienced it for themselves, do you think? Do you think there's harm in that, I guess is what I'm asking? David Polidi: So I might be totally wrong on this. I don't wanna speak for anybody else. You know, or SAGI, I would ask my consultant and be like,

what the, such a good question. My own self. So, take this answer with a grain of salt. This is just me. my understanding is no, there's no harm in that. and I'll tell you why I was doing it before I had any official training in my EMDR class. brought in Frazier's dissociated table, and it was in an ART and EMDR class that was like an adjunct. They brought in Frazier's associated table, and the next day I went in armed with the associated table and was having clients talk about their

parts and inviting their parts into the table and sitting around the table and just having dialogues with the parts. In your knowledge as a therapist, what you feel comfortable with? You know, there's a lot of formal steps that you'll learn in the classes. There's a lot of unburdening and stuff, but I think the general concept, the importance of it is we're, and to go back to what you and Xander were talking about. It's a model that is not supposed to be in your head solely.

It's really in your heart. It's in the energy, it's in what you're bringing to that space that goes beyond cognition. and I think EMDR does that too, maybe a little again, more implicitly, but I think EMDR does do it. I think that what Dick would say is that if we have an appreciation for parts and we're talking about parts, we really wanna do is be mindful of being respectful and honoring their voice.

Natalie Stott: Hmm. David Polidi: move into this space of, you know, I, I would never want to tell you this is your part, or, or this is the part that I, you have, I, I might suggest it. I might say, you know, this is what I think. How do you feel? What do you feel is coming up? What do you feel is inside? Does this feel right to you? Does this resonate with you? People sometimes are gonna talk into parts language. Naturally, a part of me wants to go here. Part of me doesn't, part of me, you know? And, and, okay, let's notice that.

But I think we get into trouble if we try to force things. You know, if we're trying to force parts language on somebody that doesn't want to go there, then, then don't do it. And, and I think IFS training would say the same thing. You know, you don't wanna force that if it's not connecting with our clients. You, you Natalie Stott: Hmm. David Polidi: it if it feels disrespectful or if it feels like we're calling out or shaming in any way, or even having like some judgment to what we're doing. But if we're doing it in an honest, open way, where we are our intention

is just to really help the client understand their inner systems better, and we're doing it respectfully. Why not a parts language? You know, I mean, I think we already could use that without any IFS. Natalie Stott: Mm. David Polidi: states, ego states Natalie Stott: Yeah. David Polidi: So, you know, it, it, Freud talked about it. he just named his parts it ego and super. So it, we use it. It's just how do we wanna language it? And IFS, you know, the more we dig into it, the more it gives us this very unique

and, and I think cool language for it. Natalie Stott: Yeah. David, thank you for that response because I. You know, that question is very much a, well, I introduced it as like my perfectionist part, and I think a lot of us have that when you are maybe a bit more apprehensive or less experienced in a model, there's this real drive to get it right and do it right and follow the protocol, which I think. You know, some models set that up, you know, like EMDR is quite like,

this is right, and if you're not doing this then you've done it wrong. But IFS is not like that. And that's what I think So amazing about it. So anyone listening that you've dipped your toe into the parts work. You know, don't, don't feel like you're doing something wrong, I think is a really this does come with experience, doesn't it? The more experience you get and the more clients that you see and the trainings that you expose yourself to, you will have a greater confidence, I think, in being able to do that from reading a book or being on the receiving end of therapy.

So, yeah. Thank you. I think that will be a, a welcomed answer. David Polidi: I would even say this, and I don't know how this hits you, and I'm not a trainer in EMDR. I would even say even in EMDR. I hope that there's more and more focus on the relational aspects of it, that it really is about being able to be open to what you're offering the client and how it's hitting them and how they're It. And so

Natalie Stott: yeah. David Polidi: I really dig into this sense that I think Rotem Briar brings in that, you know, it's an art and a science. So, yeah, we wanna be as faithful as we can to the model because there's a lot of wisdom in it. But we also have to understand that we bring our own interpretations, our own sense of what's right and wrong, our own sense of like how to heal with us into that room. And if we're too focused on doing it exactly the way that it's spelled

out, we're missing I think the underlying energy of that model. Natalie Stott: Hmm. David Polidi: And so I, I go into it saying to myself like, I'm gonna mess it up. I'm not gonna do it perfectly. I'm not gonna, and, and, you know, I had my consultant when I was going through certifying, getting certified in the MDR r that'd be like, You need to follow the rules. And I'm like, but I'm a rule breaker. I don't wanna follow the rules. And I'm not saying don't follow the rules, and I'm not saying. Don't, you know, respect the EMDR, but I'm also saying go gentle.

Go easy with yourself. That it's not about following the rules of EMDR. Natalie Stott: Hmm. David Polidi: using them and seeing how it hits the person you're working with and responding to that person in that moment. Natalie Stott: What a lovely note to end on. David, thank you so much. You've been so generous with your time and your wisdom and I'm sure those listing will be as grateful as I am. So yeah, thank you so much. David Polidi: It's my pleasure. it's been really fun sitting here with you, so thank you.

Natalie Stott: Thank you. Thank you for listening to this episode of Mastering Therapy. All of the resources mentioned are available in the show notes. If you are interested in getting more information on what's been covered this season, you can sign up to our mailing list or visit the website, mastering therapy.com. If you know someone that would be great to interview on this podcast, you can submit a recommendation and I'd love to hear from you the Mastering Therapy podcast and the information provided by me and my guests.

Is solely intended for qualified professionals for information and educational purposes. I look forward to joining me next time.

Open the transcript file

Hosts and Guests

Nobody is credited on this episode yet.

Credit the people on this episode

Be the first to rate this episode

More episodes

All episodes
  1. S5E9: A practical take on SEO and AI Search for Therapists

    Nov 19, 202625 minAudio

    S5E9: A practical take on SEO and AI Search for Therapists Can prospective clients actually find your therapy website? In this practical solo episode, Dr Natalie Stott explains how SEO and AI search affect...

    Credit the people on this episode

  2. S5E8: Working with Stuckness in Therapy | Dr Robyn Walser

    Nov 12, 202639 minAudio

    S5E8: Working with Stuckness in Therapy | Dr Robyn Walser EPISODE SUMMARY What do you do when therapy feels stuck and you notice yourself working harder than your client? Dr Natalie Stott is joined by clinical...

    Credit the people on this episode

  3. S5E7 Narcissism in Therapy: Moving past social media labels | Dr Ruth-Ann Harpur

    Nov 5, 202645 minAudio

    S5E7 Narcissism in Therapy: Moving past social media labels | Dr Ruth-Ann Harpur What do you do when a client arrives in therapy convinced that their partner, parent or sibling is a narcissist? In this episode, Dr...

    Credit the people on this episode

  4. S5E6: How to Find Your Therapy Niche with Josephine Hughes

    Oct 22, 202646 minAudio

    S5E6: How to Find Your Therapy Niche with Josephine Hughes Do therapists really need a niche, or is this simply another piece of marketing advice that makes private practice feel more complicated than it already is? In...

    Credit the people on this episode

  5. S5E5: Practical AI for Therapists: Green, Amber and Red Uses

    Oct 15, 202632 minAudio

    S5E5: Practical AI for Therapists: Green, Amber and Red Uses How can therapists make practical use of AI without handing over sensitive information, clinical judgement or half the contents of their inbox? In this solo...

    Credit the people on this episode