Skip to content
PodSubs
ShowsPeopleGuestsJobsNewsEvents
More
BlogPodCred
Menu
ShowsPeopleGuestsJobsNewsEventsBlogPodCredNetworksSign in
Join nowSign in
  • Shows
  • People
  • Jobs
  • News
  • More
    • Guests
    • Events
    • Blog
    • PodCred
    • Networks
    Join nowSign in

Mastering Therapy

Mastering Therapy artwork

S5E7 Narcissism in Therapy: Moving past social media labels | Dr Ruth-Ann Harpur

Nov 5, 202645 minAudio
ShareXLinkedInFacebookWhatsAppEmail

S5E7 Narcissism in Therapy: Moving past social media labels | Dr Ruth-Ann Harpur What do you do when a client arrives in therapy convinced that their partner, parent or sibling is a narcissist? In this episode, Dr Natalie Stott speaks with clinical psychologist Dr Ruth Ann Harpur about the sizeable gap between narcissism as a clinical concept and narcissism as social-media shorthand for somebody who has behaved badly. The conversation also tackles the difficult boundary between a painful relationship and abuse. Ruth explains why coercive control, financial restriction and physical violence require direct assessment, careful attention to safety and appropriate specialist support. Narcissism and abuse are not synonyms. Harm should be named clearly without turning a diagnosis into a moral verdict. They also consider critical parents, therapist anger and the point at which consuming yet another video about narcissism stops helping a client build a life beyond the relationship. Content note: This episode discusses emotional and psychological abuse, coercive control, financial abuse and physical violence. Guest Information: Dr Ruth Ann Harpur is a clinical psychologist specialising in relationships and issues of narcissism. Her work includes supporting people with narcissistic traits, people affected by damaging or abusive relationships, and couples seeking to understand difficult relational patterns. She also creates educational content about narcissism, personality and relationships. Website: https://www.ruthannharpur.co.uk/ YouTube: https://www.youtube.com/@drruthannharpur Instagram: https://www.instagram.com/drruthannharpur/ TikTok: https://www.tiktok.com/@drruthannharpur Resources mentioned: - *Disarming the Narcissist* by Wendy T. Behary: https://www.newharbinger.com/9781684037728/disarming-the-narcissist/ - *Rethinking Narcissism* by Dr Craig Malkin: https://www.drcraigmalkin.com/ - Heal NPD videos by Dr Mark Ettensohn: https://www.healnpd.org/videos - The Nameless Narcissist YouTube channel, mentioned in the discussion of self-esteem regulation: ** Check out Mastering Therapy’s Youtube Channel for all podcast episodes ** For notification on up coming episodes and for occasional summaries of tools discussed on the podcast sign up here: www.masteringtherapy.com To recommend a topic you’d like to hear about, or if you’d like to appear on the podcast please get in touch at www.masteringtherapy.com/podcast ***** Subscribe to the Mastering Therapy Podcast YouTube channel Follow Mastering therapy on instagram Connect with Dr Natalie Stott on LinkedIn AIRNOTE AirNote is an affordable AI-powered note-taking app designed specifically for therapists in private practice. It securely transcribes sessions and creates professional clinical notes, without the price tag of many traditional AI scribes. Priced at only £14.99 per month. Available to mac users only DOWNLOAD AIRNOTE (1 month free trial using to code 30FREE) SUPERVISOR PLATFORM Supervisor Platform is an online directory designed for therapists, psychologists, counsellors, and other mental health professionals to connect with qualified clinical supervisors. It makes it easy for practitioners to browse, compare, and contact supervisors based on their expertise, approach, and availability, while giving supervisors a professional space to showcase their services. Supervisor Platform (with 3 months free trial code 'WELCOME3') To search for a new supervisor visit HERE For free resources on supervision visit HERE Disclaimer: The Mastering therapy podcast and the information provided by Dr Natalie Stott (Dclinpsych, HPCP reg), is solely intended for informational and educational purposes and should only be used by qualified professionals. Mentioned in this episode: AIRNOTE | AI SCRIBE FOR THERAPISTS AirNote is an affordable AI-powered note-taking app designed specifically for therapists in private practice. It securely transcribes sessions and creates professional clinical notes, without the price tag of many traditional AI scribes. Early user price is at £9.99 p/m, no hidden costs. Available to mac users only DOWNLOAD AIRNOTE (FREE TRIAL available) AIRNOTE

Audio and video play straight from the show's own hosting. PodSubs stores and serves no media.

Transcript

From the show. Tap a time to play from there.

Welcome to the Mastering Therapy podcast. This is a show for psychologists, psychotherapists, and counsellors who are looking to build on their therapy skills, increase confidence in working with clients and be inspired by alternative models, tools, and ways of working. I'm your host, Dr. Natalie Stott. I'm a clinical psychologist and founder of Supervisor Platform, A directory that supports. Clinicians to showcase their supervision and training to other therapists. It also helps you to find a supervisor that fits with your work and your style.

join my guests and me as we learn from one another and aim to take insights and put them into action. Let's go Natalie: Narcissism seems like it is everywhere at the moment. You only need to open your social media feed full of posts telling you how to spot a narcissist, red flags, how do you leave a narcissist or recover from one,, or work out whether your mom, partner, brother is a narcissist. I've had quite a few requests for me to do an episode on narcissism, so

I am really delighted to welcome Dr. Ruth-Ann Harpur, who is a clinical psychologist, but specializes in the area of narcissism. So thank you so much for coming on to the Mastering Therapy podcast. Ruth Ann: Oh, thank you for having me. It's really nice Natalie: So I think I'd like to begin in asking you how we go about defining narcissism because there's narcissistic traits, there's narcissistic personality disorder, narcissism.

How do you explain it to people in a really simple way, Ruth Ann: Okay. So, first of all, it's a mess. It really is a mess. There is so much noise on social media about narcissism, and it has given people a whole language around narcissism that bears no relationship to the clinical definitions of narcissism and what narcissist- uh, pathological narcissism actually is. So you have these two worlds that are very, very far apart. So, I mean, I will tell you, the clinical definition of narcissism is

actually, it's not an unhealthy thing. It is the desire to feel special and to be special and to be unique, and we all have it, and to a degree, we all need a level of healthy narcissism. Yeah. Healthy narcissism is what allows you to make a podcast, to think there's something special about me that I want to put out in the world, and I want to contribute to the world to other people. That's healthy narcissism, yeah? Um, and we need a degree of it, and some people have quite a lot of it, and they can be quite charismatic and quite exciting, and they can do really

great things with their creativity and that little bit of ego drive. There's nothing wrong with that. Where narcissism becomes pathological is when it's like, "I need to feel special in order to be valued." It becomes a drive. It becomes, "I must put other people down to come up." It's very hierarchically-- uh, it's very hierarchical, and that, and that's when it causes problems. So I would really distinguish healthy narcissism that we all need, and you can have not enough of it.

If you are someone who says, "I don't wanna be special. I never wanna stand out. I only want to promote other people, and I want to stay in the background and n- don't have the confidence to put myself out into the world," that's as much of a problem as having too much of it. And sometimes you can find in relationships, one has too much narcissism, the other has no-nowhere near enough. And if you go right back to the Greek myth, Narcissus' lover was Echo, and Echo had been cursed by Hera, who was Zeus's wife, um, to only be able

to repeat what other people said. And so all she could do when she fell in love with Narcissus was repeat back to him what he said And ultimately, Narcissus kind of, different versions of the myth, Narcissus ignores her. He gazes at his reflection and ultimately drowns in the pool, and she goes off into a cave where all you can hear is her echo, 'cause she never actualizes. She never becomes herself. She never expresses herself So if you wanna go right back into the Greek myth, that's where it comes from Natalie: Yeah, yeah, no, it's, it's helpful.

Is this something that has been defined for a long time, or is it, is it recent? You know, is it in the DSM, ICD? Ruth Ann: Narcissistic personality disorder has been in the DSM and the ICD for many, many years. Natalie: Mm. Ruth Ann: not new. As a diagnosis, it's not new. Um, I would say clinically, I've only really seen it diagnosed in forensic settings. It's not really a diagnosis that is typically made, and I don't think that's inappropriate because actually there are no specific treatments for narcissistic personality disorder.

It's not even like something like emotionally unstable personality disorder where there's trials of, um, DBT or schema therapy or cognitive analytical therapy. We have actual clinical trials that we can say, "Well, this is an indicated treatment for someone with this presentation." We don't have that in, in narcissistic personality disorder. So I mean, my view is probably to lead much more on formulation, to think more of it as this, uh, this particular presentation this person is presenting with.

but in terms of someone coming to me, if they're saying, " I need to be special all the time. I put other people down. I'm driving people around me crazy. My partner wants to leave me because I don't have empathy for them, because I'm critical of them, because I'm constantly, uh, I'm lying or I'm cheating. I'm behaving in ways that make me feel better about myself and give, give me a boost to, to boost my self-esteem, and actually it's harming people around me," then I'll kind of wanna understand that more psychologically,

and I'm probably gonna come at it with more of a understanding of a more personality disorder lens. But in my day-to-day clinical practice, I really don't tend to refer to diagnoses often at all, if at all. Natalie: What immediately came to mind when you were describing that individual is I'm hearing somebody very self-aware, reflective, um, conscious of the impact of themselves on Ruth Ann: Mm-hmm. Natalie: That to me is like the therapy dream. is it possible that that same person could, could fit really within a,

a diagnostic lens of narcissism? Because they might be aware that they're doing those things, the fact that they're caring, is that not contrary Ruth Ann: They may be caring that they're about to lose their relationship Natalie: Oh, I see. So it's in, Ruth Ann: Or their job. It may be very much self-interested. I, I try not to kind of separate it out too much. I guess what I would say, one is I've specialized in narcissism. I have colleagues who work with narcissistic presentations who are world experts in, in that field, so I get those kind of referrals.

I don't know that that's necessarily typical of everyone with narcissistic presentation, because someone who doesn't have that self-awareness probably isn't gonna show up. But there is some research that actually shows a fairly high level of narcissistic traits in the population seeking private therapy, and we can end up in a kind of no true Scotsman. It's like, yeah, I've had people come to me and they're like, "I'm really struggling with narcissistic traits," and they're calling it that. And I'll say, "Well, you know…" "But I've seen other therapists," and they say, "Well, you're, you're self-aware. You can't possibly be a narcissist.

You, you just have a very negative view of yourself." And they're like, "Uh, no, I really don't." And actually, yes, they do have a negative view of themselves, but all of that kind of ego and grandiosity and self-aggrandizement is compensatory. It's this is my defense against my low self-esteem. Natalie: Yeah Ruth Ann: I've certainly had multiple people I've worked with over the years who have said, "I've seen other therapists, and they argue with me. They just tell me I can't possibly be a narcissist."

And it's like they can't accept that label. Someone's taking that label on themselves. I've never said to someone, "I think you're a narcissist." Um, but someone taking that label and saying, "No, you can't have it. No, you can't put…" Like it is so stigmatized, it's almost like the therapist wants to protect the patient from it. And I'm like, "Well, that's an interesting Natalie: Yeah, that is Ruth Ann: thing to do." Natalie: yeah, I'm imagining that people are often hold by their loved ones or people close to them, which is potentially why they might then

seek out therapy support because Ruth Ann: Oh, yes. Natalie: uh, having difficulty because this person is saying that they are a narcissist and they're displaying these traits, and maybe they're left feeling confused, and they come to a therapist to seek some kind of confirmation or not for that Ruth Ann: If someone comes to me like that, I will say, "I'm not judge, jury, and executioner. Natalie: Yeah Ruth Ann: in fact, I have no interest in calling one of you a narcissist and declaring one of you the baddie and one of you the goodie, because

that's not gonna get us anywhere." So I'm much more interested in the dynamic Natalie: Yeah, and that's the beauty of working with couples. I wonder whether you had any advice for people where the session's very much being dominated by relational dynamics and patterns, and maybe even that individual's talking about the other person who's a narcissist and their behaviors are affecting me. Ruth Ann: Okay. I do several things when that happens. One is I try to look beyond the label, and I ask what, what's actually happening?

Describe the behaviors for me. Let me understand what is it that this person is doing. What-- how are you responding to it? How are other people in the system responding to it? I really wanna get the behaviors rather than the diagnosis. I actually wanna get away from the kind of narcissistic language, because then you just end up with a kind of whole jargon of narcissist love bombing, discarding, all of that stuff. And I'm like, "No, I need to know what specifically is going on. What are you calling gaslighting?

What does that actually look like? Give me examples." And then I wanna understand the dynamics. I wanna sta- understand how is the person I'm seeing responding. Are they going into a very, um, defensive, angry, fighting mode? Are they going into a comply, be quiet, don't argue mode? What-- and what's the cost to them of doing that? So I-- that's-- I'm gonna focus much more on the dynamics, even when the other person isn't in the room. The other thing I do, and I know not all individual therapists would, like, do

this, I will say, "Well, can I meet them?" Would you like to bring them to a session? Natalie: Oh, I see Ruth Ann: Let me understand, let me meet them and see… 'Cause that's a revelation. You, you- to meet the person that you've heard so much about is often a very different experience, for better or worse. Natalie: Yeah. Ruth Ann: Yeah, and that's, and Natalie: obviously Ruth Ann: I would just say that's not always appropriate. If there's abuse going on, I wouldn't suggest that. The same with couples. If there's a really abusive dynamic, I won't do couples therapy, 'cause

it's just not, it's not safe Natalie: Yeah. I mean, that's a tricky one, isn't it? Because, uh, the emotional and psychological abuse it's not easily visible. Ruth Ann: I would certainly be looking at the persistence of it, and I'd also be looking at the I think sometimes there's, there's a degree just like your own feeling in the room. Is there-- is the power dynamic completely one-sided here? Is there any robustness from the, the non-narcissistic

person in the relationship? I kinda think you know. You, you, you-- there is a degree to which you have to go and feel. But if it's, if there's like coercive control, if the person's finances are being controlled, if they're not able to leave the house, if they don't have freedoms to do their own thing, if they really cannot make… That, that, that would be a hard line for me. Natalie: Yeah. Ruth Ann: if I have a sense of coercive control, financial abuse, physical violence. But the sort of where does kind of just really horrible emotional dynamics

between two people cross the line into th- this is so emotionally abusive, this cannot be for couples therapy. Uh, I think that can sometimes be a bit more of a gray area. And sometimes in that instance, if the couple can't work in the room with me, I'll see them individually Natalie: Just on a practical note, with those questions around coercive control, back in the day I used to work on the helpline at Women's Aid, um, long before I was a clinical psychologist, and, uh we were very much

instructed to be quite direct in how we would ask about things because unless you are direct with your question, you won't always get a direct answer. And I guess part of the dynamics in being in an abusive relationship is that you don't recognize it, or part of you doesn't recognize it. Ruth Ann: Ja Natalie: So do you find you end up doing a fair amount of, education with people, and do you ask directly? Ruth Ann: In individual work, yes.

Uh, uh, I mean, in a couple's work, I am looking for… If, if I get hints of coercive control, I won't do couples work. That, that really would be the hard line. The kind of-- the things I w- I would be willing to work with in couples are infidelity, cheating, deception, um, with, with a history where it's been exposed, um, th- lack of empathy, criticism, um, putting someone down. I, I can work with that to an extent if the person's willing to work on it.

The, the person, the perpetrator, the f- the offender as it were, is willing to, to acknowledge that at least to some extent, I will. Where you have a really pattern of coercive control, I just don't think that's appropriate in couples therapy. And I think, yeah, it is, there is a need to be more directive and certainly be signposting people to groups like Women's Aid and also potentially the police because it b- it, it can become criminal. And it's, it is where this kind of work you've actually, you, you do need to

really be thinking about the person's safety and not just the not just physical safety in the sense of is there physical violence, but that kind of pattern of coercive control is so dangerous. It's, it's not something for a couples therapy. And I personally won't even work with the offender in that instance because it, that's beyond my skill level. That needs to go to someone who's got experience working with offenders Natalie: Hmm. You know what's interesting me about just even my line of questioning is I've kind of jumped to abuse and the, dynamics of abuse.

maybe this is showing that to some degree I equate narcissism with abusive behavior. Ruth Ann: Yeah Natalie: with that? Or is that too strong a link? Ruth Ann: Okay, so it is, it's a very interesting thing 'cause there's the term narcissistic abuse, and I think it's kind of interesting because I'm not sure we take any other mental health disorder and call it abuse. If you said something with-- someone with depression could be very neglectful of their partner because of their depression. They could be very withdrawn.

They could be very withholding. They could be absent. They could be distant. Would we call that depressive abuse? Someone with OCD, for example, could become very controlling of their partner Natalie: Hmm. Ruth Ann: as part of their rituals. Would we call that OCD abuse? Natalie: Yeah. Ruth Ann: What? Natalie: a very good Ruth Ann: So Natalie: but yet, and I wonder if this is the influence of narcissistic abuse, five signs overall TikTok or whatever. - It has become a little bit of a word hasn't it?

Ruth Ann: It's become a word that is, it covers a multitude of sense. Because it covers those extreme examples we're talking about where I'm just like, "I'm not gonna touch. This needs to go to police, law enforcement, domestic violence, uh, groups. This is not for me as a therapist in private practice to work with. It's not safe," to the relationship where you have two people really sniping at each other And everything in between. So we, we use it in such broad ways. And so I guess for me, the first thing to do is to define who you're working

with, what the issues are, and, and to kind of escape that diagnostic language into when my-- when this person in the relationship feels put down, they respond with insults, they respond with criticism, they respond with excuses. This person… It's, it's difficult to do without kind of thinking of specific examples. Natalie: Yeah Ruth Ann: So you, you wanna understand the dynamics that you're working with rather than labeling it as narcissistic abuse.

And But at the same time call abuse abuse Natalie: Yeah. and it makes it so much harder that maybe to some degree when people are coming to therapy, they're really seeking for that validation and might be coming being like, "My partner I think is a narcissist. you help me understand? Is this true?" I mean, d- do you get that much in having to Ruth Ann: Yes. Natalie: Yeah. Like, uh Ruth Ann: And then I would say, "Tell me what makes you think

your partner is a narcissist? Tell me what is going on in the relationship. What's your experience? How are they treating you? What's the overall experience of the relationship? Are there exceptions to that? Are there… What, what is it about this person that you might like?" So it's, it's kind of asking the questions and, and actually trying to make it less psychology-y and more human. Like, talk to me in everyday language. Natalie: Yeah Ruth Ann: You know, and I've said to people, 'cause they've said, "Ah, and then there was a discard, and there was a, a love bombing stage, and then there was

this, and then there's the gaslighting. You'll know what I mean 'cause all of this happened." And I'm like, "You have talked to me, but I have absolutely no idea what has happened in your relationship. Natalie: Yeah Ruth Ann: I have no idea what your experiences have been. I have no idea how it's impacted you. I, I… You know, it's just words. Help me understand." Natalie: The word we haven't spoken about yet is trauma, would it be right to assume that people that would come under that kind of a diagnosis

of narcissistic personality disorder have some kind of trauma history, attachment ruptures in earlier life? Do you tend to see that pattern? Ruth Ann: I mean, I would say assume nothing, but ask. And yes, I mean, I've yet to meet someone who doesn't have history. Natalie: Yeah Ruth Ann: So-- But, and, and but the histories can really vary between experiences of abuse, experiences of being put down, a lot of bullying in

schools, a lot of being, like, the kid who's bullied, who's excluded, the kid who was different in some way, um, the kid who gets devalued, and then it becomes my way to cope with this is to make myself really special, is to-- I feel so disempowered by other people. The way I cope, I become the powerful one. I become the one who's always in control. So you have all kinds of coping modes of self-aggrandizement is probably the, the one that's most associated with narcissism, but you get huge amounts of over-controller modes.

I work from a schema therapy lens, so you get that I have to control everything. I will be-- you know, I will make sure things get done 'cause I don't trust anyone else to do it. Um, you get huge amount of hyper-independence. I can't rely on anyone else, so I rely on myself, and I'm the best. So you, you get all of those coping modes. Um, you also get the kind of fantasy of this will be my perfect person. This will be my ideal lover Natalie: Does that Ruth Ann: So Natalie: come from a, I must make this happen because I guess a

desperate fear around being left or being alone or being that bullied child once again that's rejected Ruth Ann: left, being put down, being discarded. I often think, um, there's a-- It's actually quite a well-known YouTub- I don't think he's doing YouTube as much now, but he was the nameless narcissist on YouTube. Um, and he described, um, narcissism as self-esteem regulation. He's like, "Everything I do is to make-- it's to regulate my self-esteem.

'Cause my self-esteem can go super high, it can go super low. It can go everywhere. So I'm either the best or I'm the worst." So you have that, those two extremes, and so I look to my relationships to make me feel good about myself. I want someone who's gonna tell me I'm good about myself. I want someone who's gonna look good. I want someone who's gonna present a good image to the world, that look at us, we're like a great couple. L-look what I've-- look who I am. I wanna feel special at all times, because if I don't, I feel terrible. So it's like y-you have those big, big swings.

Um, and so yeah, there's obviously there's a history behind where that has come from and why, and often that has stemmed from experiences of abuse within a family. Sometimes it also stems a bit from being in a family where the demands are very, very high, and you're only acceptable in this family if you're a very high achiever So super high levels of perfectionism and demandingness Natalie: Yeah. Um, i- in a sec, Ruth, I'd like to, like, broaden the discussion to instead of just couples thinking about, like, other family members.

But Ruth Ann: Mm-hmm. Natalie: Just touching on what you said about schema therapy, obviously people listening will come at it from all different Ruth Ann: Mm-hmm. Natalie: All different models. Have you always used schema therapy? Ruth Ann: I like schema therapy as a model. It's the one I use, but I tend to see models as, you know, pick your model. Natalie: Yeah Ruth Ann: don't think-- We certainly don't have evidence to say this model's better than this model. I have some colleagues who work, um, completely psychodynamically who d- sort of train more in transference focus therapy, and

they're amazing at what they do. Um, but I guess, well, actually when we talk to them, we use different language, but we describe the same thing. I, I do think it is the blind man and the elephant scenarios, like our, our models may use different words at times, but we are describing very much similar phenomenon, sometimes coming at it from different, slightly different perspectives. In terms of CFT, I use loads of CFT as part of schema therapy because it's often a really good way to connect with a vulnerable child mode, and it's a very good way to strengthen the healthy adult mode.

How can you look at this with compassion, not letting yourself off the hook, appreciating everything that's going on? And also for those defensive narcissistic modes, if you go at them with, "You shouldn't be here. You're a very, very bad narcissist, and this is a bad way to behave," you're just replicating those very critical, demanding, harsh voices that have generated those narcissistic modes. So it's like, "No, I actually wanna understand why you're here." You know? I'll do that part, like chair work. Like, "Okay, let's talk to your self-aggrandizer.

Let's talk to the part of you that wants to be on show." And, and I'll have a bit of fun with that. I'm like like, "You're a big shot. And I totally get it. Tell me how great you are." And I'll en- uh, I'll en- and they're, they're fun. It's fun to do that work 'cause they can really go for it, and I'll be, "Okay. That's great." But like underneath this, like underneath this, "I've gotta show off," what are you protecting him from? What's your fear? What are you worried about? What, what's your biggest fear? What, what, what are you most worried about? You know, and that's often a really interesting way to kind of just get beneath it. What is underneath this mode?

And then to confront that mode. Like, "Yeah, you know what? You protect him. You keep him safe. You've sto- you, you've saved him from hell quite often. But hey, you're also, right now, you're stopping him being able to connect with his wife and his children. And that's pretty painful 'cause this part of him would actually like to do that." Natalie: Yeah. Ruth Ann: So, Natalie: it's Ruth Ann: there's work to get there, and you have to have rapport with people before you can go there. And I think they actually need to know you're not condemning. And I think this is one of the issues with this whole kind of YouTube

internet sensation around narcissism, is we've made it a shameful, shameful thing to be narcissistic. Whereas I think actually healthy narcissism is a functional thing and we all need it, and not enough of it is not good for us because it gives us low self-esteem. People with very low levels of narcissism are more prone to anxiety and depression. The, the-- it's not-- too much of it is also a problem. So that's why I kind of, I, I think that compassionate approach is really, really essential because if we come at this thinking narcissist equals bad,

it's just introducing a moral judgment into therapy that doesn't belong there Natalie: And I have to be Ruth Ann: And to be, and I, and I also feel the need to just jump in and go, "That is not me defending abusive behavior. Abusive behavior is not narcissism, it's abusive behavior. Natalie: Yeah. Ruth Ann: And by the way, I'll call the police." Natalie: Yeah. Honestly I, I don't think we can get away from being a product of algorithms and Therapy content on social media or, like, your odd kind of shorts here and there as

therapists, I think we have to recognize we're influenced by that, um, spoken mainly up to this point around couples. Um, family and family members that display narcissistic behavior, particularly parent to child, think is a Ruth Ann: Mm-hmm. Natalie: other host of complexity that I just wonder whether, you could speak to a little bit. And in particular when we as therapists might be picking up

traits of narcissism from what they're saying about their parent Ruth Ann: Yeah. I. Um, the thing is, anyone coming to me has probably seen my social media, so the word narcissism is not gonna be new. They're usually using it before I am. So someone describes the behavior and I'll, I'll say, "You know, look, this is hurtful behavior. This is behavior that's damaging." I may introduce in the spirit of, well, let's understand and let's have empathy for your parent, and just to be really clear, empathy is let's understand what might be going on for them, that your parent may be…

Think of an example of, like, the super critical parent. The super critical parent, and you can do nothing right. And it's like, okay, let's understand how, how is that impacting you? You feel never good enough. You feel really terrible about yourself. You work really hard, um, and it's never, ever quite enough. And so let's focus on you and building you up, and you developing that sense of I'm okay within yourself, that compassion for yourself, a sense of healthy pride in yourself and your achievements. Let's not defend yourself. Let's get away from the understanding what you're doing.

So often people in that position will get very, very defensive. "Yes, but I did this, and I did this, and I did this, and I've done all the…" I know. Don't defend. You don't need to defend yourself. Um, but then when someone's got to that point where they're feeling a bit better in themselves, there may be a bit of space to say, "Well, let's understand that perhaps the highly critical parent is coming from a place of fear. They fear that you won't be good enough. They fear that you won't measure up, and they see it as their role to improve you and to make you better." That's the that's the intention, that the effect may be very, very different.

The effect may be to put you down and make you feel absolutely dreadful about yourself, but the goal may be different. And I have had quite a few people who've got to the point where they're able to say, and it's quite comical when it happens, they're able to say, "You know what, Mom? You're always looking out as to how to make me better. You're always looking out as to how I can improve myself, and I just want you to know, I think you did a great job 'cause I think I turned out pretty good." Natalie: Mm. Ruth Ann: So Natalie: that, Ruth Ann: guess what? You can relax.

Natalie: there Ruth Ann: You can relax. And it doesn't always work because the reaction can be a little spicy. But I think to get to that point where you don't have to be so activated by it, it's like, "Okay, mom's in the critical mode." Natalie: If you think about a 30-year-old that's come to therapy, and they're describing their relationship with their mother or father, and you're thinking, "Gosh, they have had 30 years of this," that they have been made to feel like they always need to improve, that they're never good enough.

It's quite a perspective shift to have to get to the place where you can care for yourself, back yourself, recognize, Ruth Ann: Mm-hmm. Natalie: okay, some of these beliefs have come from this critical perspective that I have inherited from my parent." it's just hard. I think brings things up therapists in seeing that dynamic when the client can't see it , Would you be primarily then beginning with up their self-esteem, their

understanding of their upbringing, as opposed to immediately jumping to the parents or parent or sibling, yeah, as, Ruth Ann: Yeah Natalie: aggressor? Because they haven't named it, but maybe you as a therapist are thinking, "Oh, okay, you've never been apologized to as a child. Oh, okay, you were shut away when you cried. You were…" You're seeing all of this, but the focus of the work is still the client. It's not that relationship, Ruth Ann: Yeah. So 100%, you've gotta focus on where the person is at because, you know, what I just described is someone being able to handle a very critical person with a

bit of humor and grace, and to be calm. You can't do that unless you've got a really strong, healthy adult mode. You just can't. So, you know, in schema therapy terms, and anyone working from a different model can translate it into their own model 'cause I, I just think we're just using different words. This person is either in their vulnerable child mode, where they're just devastated by all of this criticism and feeling dreadfully vulnerable, or they're in one of the more coping modes, whether that's I'm just gonna detach and withdraw,

I'm gonna get defensive, I'm gonna work really hard and try to prove myself. Um, all of those kind of coping strategies, you cannot do that-- you cannot re- you, you really, if you wanna have a better relationship or a relationship where you stay sane with someone like that, you're not gonna be able to do that from a vulnerable child mode. You're not gonna be able to do that from a protector mode in IFS terms. You're not gonna be able to do that from a withdrawn, detached protector mode in schema therapy. You're not gonna-- You, you can't.

So you've gotta kinda get through those modes and really help the person to meet their own needs or get their needs met from other places, and to build that much more sturdy, robust sense of themselves. And I'll even do imagery work with people. I've done this with people who are actually going through divorces with really, really horrible, horrible ex-partners, and it's like they're dreading going to court. And I'm like, "Okay. Well, guess what? We're gonna do a little imagery exercise where we imagine little you, the vulnerable you, and we're gonna send them off to a babysitter for

the day who's gonna look after them. And your defensive modes, we're gonna make sure they maybe stay in the car park. And when you're in the court, you're gonna stay in your healthy adult mode." Natalie: Mm. Ruth Ann: and we visualize doing it, like staying grounded, letting the lawyer take over Natalie: Yeah. Even like talking about this, I'm noticing in me it does bring up It feels quite heavy, and it feels, um … I think we get protective of our clients, and

you tend to side … Well, maybe you don't, 'cause you're, you're used to working in couples, and so probably are good at staying in that neutral ground. But when you've only got one side of the story, you, you can get quite invested. I wonder if you had advice for therapists in terms of noticing, what's coming up for them, how have you found when you've been in situations where there are big feelings that come up for you, you do with those? Ruth Ann: Yeah, this is, you see, this is where I think it gets … I'll

probably be controversial. I don't see the issue. If someone treats someone appallingly and really, really badly, it's completely right to have a reaction to that Natalie: Mm-hmm. Ruth Ann: Right? Natalie: Yeah. Ruth Ann: often, I, I mean, I can think of numerous people I've worked with where they've described behaviors and I'm furious. And Natalie: Ja Ruth Ann: I'll just say it. I'm just really fucked off. I'm really fucked off at the way that you've been treated. This is appalling. This is dreadful behavior. I c- uh, it's completely unacceptable. I am so, so sorry that that is what you've been through.

I am so, so sorry. And actually it's the-- that acknowledgement is really, really important. That doesn't require me to buy into a narrative that the other person is a villain. Uh, and I guess where it gets more tricky is where, you know, 'cause you're describing a situation parent-child, where actually the power dynamic is one way. When a child is a child. It may change in adult children, but the, there is a… You know, if someone's experienced being abused, I don't think we need to shy

away from having a reaction to that. I think it's completely appropriate to have a reaction to that Natalie: Yeah. I mean, I would agree. I guess it's, it's that thing of… Like, I think it was really helpful what you said about starting with um, connecting with the vulnerable child and, and giving them compassion for themselves and understanding, rather than straight away going into name this dynamic that maybe you've Ruth Ann: Ja Natalie: curiosity about. And I th- I am thinking that a reaction could lead you to jump

there before you've, before you've Ruth Ann: Yeah. Natalie: the work. Ruth Ann: I suppose it's, it it's kind of having the emotional reaction to those appalling behaviors. I mean, the thing is, is like even if behavior isn't abuse, someone having an affair, for example, it's not abusive, it's not illegal. I'm not gonna call the police. I'm not gonna file a safeguarding concern. Um, but I can acknowledge that the impact of that has been absolutely devastating on the person. And then I can also remain curious about what drove the behavior in the

first place, and being curious and understanding the dynamic and what drove the behavior in no way conflicts with acknowledging the appalling impact of it. And, and I actually think we need both, and I, I just don't think you can-- Yeah, having empathy for a behavior is not the same as condoning it or excusing it Natalie: Yeah. Uh, in terms of, uh, like resources for clients, I wondered whether are there certain go-to books or resources that you would give to clients if they are

to understand more about narcissism? I'm a big believer in yes, you've got the stuff that happens in the therapy room, but also people are living their lives. Like are there things that they can be doing to understand more? Ruth Ann: There are. But what I would also say is I wanna understand, is this person down the narcissist rabbit hole, right? Because Natalie: good point Ruth Ann: I'm like, "Stop reading about narcissism." So I have people, uh, and, and again, it's, it's multiple people, so I'm

not talking about any individual. I have multiple people where I know they're getting better in therapy by the number of Dr. Ramani videos they watch in a week. I literally ask them, "How much Dr. Ramani…" She's a absolute giant in the kind of narcissistic abuse space. "How many Dr. Ramani videos have you watched?" And it's like when they say, "None, because I'm, I'm doing more interesting things," and I'm like, "Yes, you're cured." Yeah. So some people, I want them away from all of that stuff. I'm like, "No, I want you to focus on your own life. Build your own life, build relationships, pursue your own hobbies, get excited

about your career," because this narcissist rabbit hole is just ruminating over a horrible, horrible relationship or a horrible ex-partner, a- and it's not good for you. It-- actually, I want you to expand your life and get interested in other things. Other times there are really helpful resources. One is Wendy Behary's book, Disarming the Narcissist. Love it. It's wr- Wendy's also my clinical supervisor, so a lot of where, where I come from is similar to where she comes from. So she's really using schema therapy to help people understand not only the narcissistic person, but also their reaction and how they can

respond perhaps in a different way that protects themselves. Um, other books I really like are Craig Malkin. Uh, he wrote a book called Rethinking Narcissism, and that's a really, really nice book. It actually looks at what narcissism actually is Natalie: like, clients and clinicians? Ruth Ann: Both. Natalie: Great Ruth Ann: Both. And the other person I love is Mark Etenshon. He has written a book. I haven't read his book, um, but he has a very good YouTube channel, and he's very good at describing pathological narcissism as it really

is in a clinical way, and he's got a lot of compassion, um, for people with more narcissistic presentations. Um, so those would be the ones I, I would recommend. But I would also say don't… Get out of the rabbit hole. Natalie: Yeah Ruth Ann: And, and I think also for therapists, we need to not go down that rabbit hole with people because it just keeps people stuck and ruminating and round and round in circles it's a double-edged sword because I think one of the things that you kind of see with the kind of whole narcissistic abuse

industry, and it is an industry now. I mean, people are selling programs around narcissistic abuse, and these programs basically mean we slap in a, a diagnostic label on someone we've never met, and we're saying, "Well, this is a narcissist and they've abused someone." And selling programs and selling… People who have no business providing therapy 'cause they have no qualifications, selling coaching programs to train people to become narcissistic abuse coaches and work with really vulnerable people. I mean, it is icky. It is a horrible thing. So there, there's a whole industry around this that is, I

don't think is particularly good for the people we work with. Um, but it's so popular because it goes straight for that pain point where someone has been questioning themselves and they're full of self-doubt, and this becomes a, "Here is my label to understand this, that acknowledges that I was a victim, and that I was deeply hurt, and it wasn't my fault." And so I don't want to invalidate that because that's really valid, and for

a lot of people it's really, really, really important to, to see it as abuse to begin with, and to, to really acknowledge the impact it had on them, and to acknowledge they were not at fault. That the… What happened was real. I just don't want people stuck there. And I also don't want that to be, here's a vulnerable person who can then be sold all manner of things to that keeps them really, really stuck Natalie: Yeah. The flip side of that question being for therapists that are listening that think,

"Oh, do you know, this is a complete kind of area of inexperience for me, and I would like to understand it a bit more", and I'm so glad that you have introduced the vulnerability of the narcissist. Because I think we always need to be applying that lens to any kind of presentation. What has led to this point? That's a, that's a key part of what we do, right? But where could they go? I mean, do you provide… And I mean, for those people that don't know, you have a YouTube channel.

Do you wanna just talk about where people can find you on social Ruth Ann: Yeah, you can find me on YouTube, Dr. Ruth Ann Harper. I'm also on Instagram and TikTok, but YouTube's my main place. It's where I make my main content. Um, if people have cases and they want a one-off case consultation, I'm completely up for that. That can be fun, actually, can be really nice. Um so people are welcome to get in touch for that. Um- I guess what I would say is don't be razzle-dazzled

by the social media content. Most of it is so-- it's TikTok language. It's not, it's not our training. You're not lacking in training, right? If you can have empathy, if you can understand someone's history, if you can understand trauma, if you can understand relational dynamics, you're good. And in fact, you're possibly in a better position than someone who's just going to call everything, um, narcissism Natalie: Mm-hmm. Ruth Ann: So I think my biggest thing when I've worked with therapists is like, like chill out. You know, I've had therapists come to me saying, "I think I

need to refer this person to you." they, they go-- they, I've had people call and they're like, "I wanna refer someone to you. I've been working with them, but they're definitely a narcissist." And I'm like, "Okay, well tell me more what you mean." And I would say nine times out of 10 at the end of that consultation, I talk myself out of a referral. I'm like, "You don't need me. You're good. You're good. You know, you're fine. you, you've worked with this person, you have rapport with this person. You've identified some narcissistic traits. You're good." Understand where it's coming from. Don't freak out.

You don't have to… You know, just that because-- and particularly I think when, uh, people who come to us are using a lot of language that sounds psychology-ey and we're unfamiliar with it, it, it's not psychology, it's TikTok. Yeah? It's psychologies. Everyone speaks pure psychologies. And I'm like, "I have no idea what you mean." and people go, "Oh, you're not trained." I'm like, "No, I really am, but you're not speaking, you're not actually talking about psychology concepts, you're just drawing on social media language," and that it, it's enticing and it can make people sound a lot more knowledgeable

than they really, really are. So I always say get underneath that language and understand what are the, what's the phenomenon they're referring to. Ask for examples. Give me an example. Someone says gaslight. I'm like, "Give me an example. Give me an example." let me get the specifics Natalie: Yeah, that is really helpful. Um, and a good reminder that I think sometimes we are too quick to jump to, "Oh, I don't really know much about this area, therefore I can't do it. I'm gonna pass it on." And obviously it's good to know when something's beyond

your boundaries and your Ruth Ann: No Natalie: but also that's a really helpful framework that you gave Ruth Ann: Let me tell you, Natalie: take Ruth Ann: at all of those coaches out there with confidence. They have nothing like the knowledge and the experience and the awareness that you have. And I'm just like, uh, uh, I wish therapists 'cause we have lots of really experienced, good, empathic, fantastic therapists, and I think approaching it with curiosity and empathy, y- y- you're 90% of the way

there You know, you really, really are. And I think we probably underestimate our ability to manage and cope with these kind of things Natalie: We do have a website we can signpost people to Ruth Ann: I do. It's drruthannharper.co.uk Natalie: Great. So all of your resources plus those particular individuals that you mentioned and the channels will be linked in the show notes. . Thank you so much for coming on Ruth Ann: You're welcome. No, thank you for having me Thank you for listening to this episode of Mastering Therapy.

All of the resources mentioned are available in the show notes. If you are interested in getting more information on what's been covered this season, you can sign up to our mailing list or visit the website, mastering therapy.com. If you know someone that would be great to interview on this podcast, you can submit a recommendation and I'd love to hear from you the Mastering Therapy podcast and the information provided by me and my guests. Is solely intended for qualified professionals for information and educational purposes. I look forward to joining me next time..

Open the transcript file

Hosts and Guests

Nobody is credited on this episode yet.

Credit the people on this episode

Be the first to rate this episode

More episodes

All episodes
  1. S5E9: A practical take on SEO and AI Search for Therapists

    Nov 19, 202625 minAudio

    S5E9: A practical take on SEO and AI Search for Therapists Can prospective clients actually find your therapy website? In this practical solo episode, Dr Natalie Stott explains how SEO and AI search affect...

    Credit the people on this episode

  2. S5E8: Working with Stuckness in Therapy | Dr Robyn Walser

    Nov 12, 202639 minAudio

    S5E8: Working with Stuckness in Therapy | Dr Robyn Walser EPISODE SUMMARY What do you do when therapy feels stuck and you notice yourself working harder than your client? Dr Natalie Stott is joined by clinical...

    Credit the people on this episode

  3. S5E6: How to Find Your Therapy Niche with Josephine Hughes

    Oct 22, 202646 minAudio

    S5E6: How to Find Your Therapy Niche with Josephine Hughes Do therapists really need a niche, or is this simply another piece of marketing advice that makes private practice feel more complicated than it already is? In...

    Credit the people on this episode

  4. S5E5: Practical AI for Therapists: Green, Amber and Red Uses

    Oct 15, 202632 minAudio

    S5E5: Practical AI for Therapists: Green, Amber and Red Uses How can therapists make practical use of AI without handing over sensitive information, clinical judgement or half the contents of their inbox? In this solo...

    Credit the people on this episode

  5. S5E4: How Therapists can start and grow a business | Dr Jo Carlile from PEAR

    Oct 8, 202638 minAudio

    S5E4: How Therapists can start and grow a business | Dr Jo Carlile from PEAR What happens when a therapist has a business idea but no idea how to build it? In this episode, Dr Natalie Stott speaks with clinical...

    Credit the people on this episode