S5E1: What if compassion makes a client feel worse? | Professor Paul Gilbert What do you do when a client understands compassion perfectly well, but rejects it, distrusts it or feels worse when you introduce it? Professor Paul Gilbert developed Compassion Focused Therapy for precisely the clients who cannot simply “be kinder” to themselves. In this episode, he explains the three clinical shocks that helped shape CFT. This is for those moments when clients can produce more balanced thoughts but deliver them in a cold or hostile tone. Many people experience kindness as weak, undeserved or almost toxic. For others, receiving care might activate painful memories held within the attachment system. Dr Natalie Stott, Host and clinical psychologist discuss empathic bridging, the importance of social trust and why receiving compassion from others can be particularly difficult. Paul also revisits the familiar three circles model. He explains threat, drive and the system often called “soothing” through their evolutionary functions, including the role of connection in helping us return to a regulated state. The conversation finishes with practical ways to bring compassion into everyday behaviour. These include changing the emotional tone of self-talk, practising one compassionate skill at a time and validating the emotion underneath an immediate reaction. Guest Information: Professor Paul Gilbert is a professor of clinical psychology at the University of Derby. He is the founder of Compassion Focused Therapy and the Compassionate Mind Foundation. His work has shaped clinical understandings of compassion, shame, self-criticism and threat. Website: https://www.compassionatemind.co.uk/ CFT Trainings CFT conference ** Check out Mastering Therapy’s Youtube Channel for all podcast episodes ** For notification on up coming episodes and for occasional summaries of tools discussed on the podcast sign up here: www.masteringtherapy.com To recommend a topic you’d like to hear about, or if you’d like to appear on the podcast please get in touch at www.masteringtherapy.com/podcast ***** Subscribe to the Mastering Therapy Podcast YouTube channel Follow Mastering therapy on instagram Connect with Dr Natalie Stott on LinkedIn SUPERVISOR PLATFORM Supervisor Platform is an online directory designed for therapists, psychologists, counsellors, and other mental health professionals to connect with qualified clinical supervisors. It makes it easy for practitioners to browse, compare, and contact supervisors based on their expertise, approach, and availability, while giving supervisors a professional space to showcase their services. Supervisor Platform (with 3 months free trial code 'WELCOME3') To search for a new supervisor visit HERE For free resources on supervision visit HERE Disclaimer: The Mastering therapy podcast and the information provided by Dr Natalie Stott (Dclinpsych, HPCP reg), is solely intended for informational and educational purposes and should only be used by qualified professionals. Mentioned in this episode: AIRNOTE | AI SCRIBE FOR THERAPISTS AirNote is an affordable AI-powered note-taking app designed specifically for therapists in private practice. It securely transcribes sessions and creates professional clinical notes, without the price tag of many traditional AI scribes. Early user price is at £9.99 p/m, no hidden costs. Available to mac users only DOWNLOAD AIRNOTE (FREE TRIAL available) AIRNOTE
Audio and video play straight from the show's own hosting. PodSubs stores and serves no media.
Transcript
From the show. Tap a time to play from there.
Welcome to the Mastering Therapy podcast. This is a show for psychologists, psychotherapists, and counselors who are looking to build on their therapy skills, increase confidence in working with clients, and be inspired by alternative models, tools, and ways of working. I'm your host, Dr. Natalie Stott. I'm a clinical psychologist and founder of Supervisor Platform, a directory that supports clinicians to showcase their supervision and training to other therapists. Join my guests and me as we learn from one another and aim to take our
insights and put them into action. This is season five. Let's go. Dr Natalie Stott (Host): Welcome everybody to this week of Mastering Therapy. I have with me Professor Paul Gilbert. Many of you will be familiar with him, but in case you are not, he is a professor of clinical psychology at Derby University. He's the founder of Compassion Focused Therapy and of the Compassionate Mind Foundation, and has shaped the way that many of us see compassion in our clinical work, understand shame and threat.
So really thrilled that you are here, Paul. Thank you so much for sharing your time with us and hopefully your wisdom Prof Paul Gilbert: Yes, hopefully. Dr Natalie Stott (Host): Undoubtedly your wisdom. We're gonna jump straight in because something I have seen in my own practice and seen in forums and discussions with clinicians, many of us will be familiar with the concept of clients needing to be more compassionate to themselves. I mean, what human doesn't need more compassion in their life?
But it, it's just not always as simple as that, there might need to be 50 steps before we actually get to the place of somebody recognizing that they're worthy, deserving, or even having the insight of what compassion is. I was wondering what you feel are the main errors that you've seen clinicians make when jumping straight into, "Oh, well, you need to be more compassionate. Look how critical you are to yourself. How would you talk to a friend?" You often see these questions and things being used, but it's just
not quite as simple as that, is it? Prof Paul Gilbert: Yeah No, it's not. So first of all, thank you so much for inviting me, Natalie. It's a delight to be with you to talk to you. So, I think it's quite useful to think about how CFT began because it began with what we call the three shocks, and mostly compassion was developed for people who can't do it, or actually when you start doing it, it creates quite a negative reaction. I was-- my area was depression, and I did my PhD in depression in the '70s, and we did a lot of cognitive therapy, and I think cognitive therapy is great, but I
was often working with quite chronically depressed people and people who have, had trauma and that sort of thing. Dr Natalie Stott (Host): Hmm. Prof Paul Gilbert: so you would do your cognitive interventions, and they'd say, "Yes, I, I can see the logic of what, of why my negative thinking is not really accurate or whatever, but it doesn't really help me." So you know, you have people who say, "I'm inferior, I'm this, I'm that," and you say, "Okay, well, let's have a look and see. Would you talk to a friend like that? What would you say to a friend who had those same ideas that you had," and all that sort of thing. Great. And, and sometimes when you have people stand back and become a
little bit more mindful, like that, that was really helpful. But sometimes people would say, "Yes, I can see that, but it doesn't really help." So one lady who was, had a, quite a nasty depression actually, we had a idea that she shouldn't have been born, wasn't lovable, wasn't wantable, wasn't, wasn't wanted. But she had a very good relationship with her husband, and she had three lovely children, but she was very stuck in this idea about that because was adopted and it was a very difficult adoption and, "You're lucky that we d- adopted you 'cause you weren't wanted," that sort of thing or whatever.
And so it was very stuck, right? So but anyway, we could do this, said, "Well, let's stand back from that and say, 'Okay, but today, look, you, you have a husband who loves you and these three children, and you can bring that to mind. How, how is that?'" She says, "Yes, I know that, but I can't really feel it." So I said to her, "Well, how do you hear it in your mind? When you kind of play that in your mind, you're looking at the evidence for the fact that your husband is caring for you." She said, "Well, what do you mean?" I said, "Well, speak it out as you actually hear it. Can I?" said, said, "Really?" I said, "Yes." So this is what happened.
She said, "Come on, you're doing cognitive therapy, aren't ya? You got a husband who loves you. You got three lovely children." So the emotional tone was very hostile. And so I began to explore that with other clients, and I found that even when they were trying to come up with ideas of reappraisal, re-evaluation, reframing, they could come up with the ideas, but the emotional textures of their thinking was often either cold or indifferent or sometimes contemptuous or hostile.
so I started to invite them to change specifically the emotional tone of what they were thinking, not just the content, but the emotional tone. So the first shot was the real hostility Which I hadn't recognized. Now, another lady about the same time actually, that when people are depressed and they lay in bed ruminating, you have to help them get out of bed, do some yoga exercises or whatever, and so they, they do movement, and that can be quite useful. And we'd been doing that for many years. so this was a lady many, many years ago, to get her out of bed
so she wasn't ruminating, she put a little card on the side of her bed. Okay, when you wake up, don't lay ruminating. Get out of bed, do some stretches, bit of yoga. Great. Came back next week. How did you get on? Yeah, she said that, that was all right. I tried to do that. So what happened then? You woke up, you saw your note. Yeah, she said, I saw my note, and I said to myself, "Come on, get out of bed you lazy bastard. Do some…" "Well, hang on a minute. Where did that come from?" She said, "Well, that's what I have to do. I have to force myself. I have to make myself." this idea I have to make myself, to force myself, to convince myself, blah, blah, blah, all of that stuff is very common in depressed people because that's
part of what the criticism is about. okay, so we got to this point, and then you've got all this. So let's try and do some, develop some warmth. Imagine you were talking to a friend. It's what would your textures, what would your vo- voice tone be like if you brought in a, a kind, warm to- tone to the cognitive things? And she said, "No, I'm not doing that." I said, "Well, okay. Well…" "No," she goes, "I can't see that that's… I, I… What are you talking about?"
Dr Natalie Stott (Host): Yeah Prof Paul Gilbert: got her on tape saying, "That's just… I mean, okay, it'll be nice, but it's not gonna help me any." "So stronger," she says, "Stronger. You've gotta help me believe all these things." So there was a lot of resistance. She didn't wanna do it, and she really didn't like this idea of being kind to myself. Are you serious? mean, all that stuff. And a lot of people really, particularly highly hostile people to themselves, you mentioned kindness, it's like toxic. It's like a poison, right? Dr Natalie Stott (Host): Mm. Prof Paul Gilbert: You serious? You w- if you knew the real me, you would not think I deserve
kindness, all that stuff. So that was the second shot. And the third shot was that when we did start to do it, and the way in which you do that is you have to be the compassionate other to begin with, you have to bridge into their experience, because quite a lot of individuals with these very complicated depressions and things, they have unprocessed trauma in all kinds of ways, often neglect or emotional disengagement. When you do that, then you're going to run into all of the traumas carried in the care system.
Now, the key here is that all motivational systems carry their own trauma. So if you are somebody who likes going on holidays, you're very motivated for exploration, you're an explorative type, and off you go doing your holidays, have wonderful times, and then one year you get badly beaten up or have a terrible illness or something, you have to be flown home, something terrible. what will happen the next time your thoughts of a holiday are triggered is you won't remember all the good times. You'll im- your body will immediately go into the experience of the trauma.
It's like if you have a, cheesecake and it makes you very sick, you're very ill, the next time you smell a cheesecake, your body will immediately react. So, know, when there are traumas in motivational systems like care systems or whatever, you start triggering that and the body will then react. So they're not gonna respond to, "Oh, this is great," and, "Be kind to myself." They're not gonna respond to that. What happens is you trigger the trauma. And so what would happen is that they… clients would start saying, "No, I, no, I don't, don't like this.
I… This, this compassion stuff. No, I don't like it. It makes me feel b- I feel terrible, actually. The more I try and do it, the worse I feel." And so you… Part of it, you have to explain this to them, and then you have to explain that therefore part of the issue is how we detox your attachment system, detoxify it, help you with the trauma memories in there. Now you're in a little bit of a catch-22 because you obviously want to have a compassionate position when you're going into the trauma. But on the other hand, it's difficult for them to develop a compassionate position till they've done some work on the trauma.
So it's a bit of a tricky one, but one of the ways you do it is by you acting as the compassionate other, and one of the ways you do that is with empathic bridging. Now, empathic bridging in the early stages of compassionate focused therapy is extremely important. And what that means is that when people tell you things that are tricky or distressing to you, you help them pay attention to the emotion behind them. Now, Freud talked about what he called de-affected memory. What he meant by that is memory without emotion, that people tell you these
stories of abuse, but there's no emotion. kind of detached themselves from the emotion. So what you do is you, you connect it. So this lady would say about, excuse me, times that she was hit by her mother and sent to her bedroom, left there all alone at night. And I'd say, "That must have been terribly frightening. That must have been really distressing to you and very upsetting." She said, "Yes, I suppose it was, but you know, that's how it was. You just had to get on with it." And another time she said about, having a a birthday party when she
was young, and the day of the party, mom said, "I've got a headache. I'm not gonna do it. Send all the kids home." I said, "Oh my God, that must have been so disappointing to you." "I suppose it was, but that kind of thing happened all the time. You just had to get on with it." So all the time, right? Dr Natalie Stott (Host): And would you see this as protective? Would you be using the language of, I guess what I'm thinking in from an IFS perspective, protectors here? There is a block to allowing that part of herself to feel it, like it's serving a function, right? Prof Paul Gilbert: Yes. We have a very different model to IFS, as but so it's not a deliberate block.
It's not set up as a protector. It's just, it's a, it's a biological you just can't, Dr Natalie Stott (Host): Mm-hmm. Prof Paul Gilbert: know, it's a condition. It, it's like saying that, when you vomit after having a bad cheese, smell of cheesecake, it somehow it's Well, sort of, but it's basically an automatic reaction as well. Anyway, so the point is so you keep doing this. So, a- and gradually what you see is the, that you, you're watching the non-verbal communication start to change. And then one time she was talking to me about time when she'd hurt, and she
went to her room, and she was crying, and she looked out at the stars, and she could see them twinkling, and she imagined her biological mother out there amongst the stars, and the- it would form a chariot, and this chariot was gonna come through the window and take her. And so you empathically bridge. Now you have to use your emotion. And so we said to her at the time when she was thinking about that, "So I can just feel in you that yearning, 'Please, Mommy, please, Mommy, come and find me. Please, Mommy, please, Mommy.'" So that, that, your empathic connecting in the way that you're
connecting opens the system. And of course at that point she just then began sobbing, and that carried on for quite a while. And that was the beginning then of her being able to process this immense grief that was in the system that she was absolutely terrified of. And also if she ever touched it, she became so overwhelmed by it, she closed it down. Now, so the key point then to come finish your story, finish the story, is always remember that CFT was developed for people who can't do it.
the whole point of it. If you can do it, you can go and do compassion to yourself. It's in the birth. Oh, yes, I feel so much better. That's great. Go off and do that. But you don't need CFT as such. CFT is for the people who can't do it, and when you try and do it, they get frightened of it, they get distressed by it, they get overwhelmed by it. so, and the, the fact that they can't do it means that those brain systems don't work for them. They can't activate them. So anyway, that's the, that's the long story. Dr Natalie Stott (Host): Mm. Yeah. And y- y- what you're describing, and I, I think you've talked about in some of your
writing around the head and the heart lag. What I think's interesting with these clients is that if you were to have a conversation about compassion or you were thinking about somebody else, they often would have the words, Prof Paul Gilbert: Yeah Dr Natalie Stott (Host): have the feeling towards another, but it's like when it comes to themselves, they're a separate other. Prof Paul Gilbert: Yeah Dr Natalie Stott (Host): isn't that same rule for themselves as they might feel towards other people. And so I think clinically when we're working with people, we have to be careful that we don't just buy the language because people are really
good at saying the right thing. But when-- I really liked what you were saying about the, like, y- you do have to get to the emotion because people logically know, "Oh, well, I guess that was bad." Prof Paul Gilbert: Yeah, yeah. Dr Natalie Stott (Host): and you need a strong therapeutic relationship to be able to contain that, right? Prof Paul Gilbert: that's right. mean, the point is, as you know from attachment theory, in which children deal with threat is to go to mommy or daddy, and they-- So that is a resolution through connection. Dr Natalie Stott (Host): Mm-hmm. Prof Paul Gilbert: how children do it right from the word go. But if you can't resolve threat through connection, if you can't resolve threat
by receiving care coming to you from the other, that system simply doesn't work. And so the child is left to try to self-regulate, but without the natural regulator that they were born to need Dr Natalie Stott (Host): Hmm. When you were talking about when you said to her, "Oh, I need you to… Like, let's, let's offer some warmth or kindness," and she was like, "No, I don't, like, I don't want that." Are you talking there about a block? And do you think that's something that before you do any kind of compassion
work with somebody, you're assessing what their beliefs are around compassion? You know, do they believe it's weak and pathetic? Do they see it as being too needy or self-pitying? Is that kind of a core part before you start any kind of empathetic bridging or intervention? Prof Paul Gilbert: It's a great question because again, it depends on how you start off your therapy. Now, all therapies usually have some explanation about what the therapy's about at the beginning. So if you're a psychodynamic therapist, you say, "Okay, what we're gonna be
doing is you're gonna free associate, and I will make, pass comment on it. Just lay here on the couch," or whatever. you're a CBT therapist, we're gonna monitor your thoughts and help you see the connection. So that's important. So what we do in CFT is we say, "Well, you've come into a compassion-focused therapy. What do you think about that? know, what's your ideas about compassion?" Okay. And so they say, "Well, it's about being kind to yourself," whatever, whatever. It's very nice. "Do you think that's gonna help you?" "Well, to be honest, I don't know really. I'm not sure."
Okay. So then we say, "Well, actually, you have intuitive wisdom that's very different to what you've just said to me." "Really?" "Yes. You know what compassion is. You just don't realize it." "Really?" "Yes. Let me do what is called a guided discovery, which in CBT is very important." "Okay. Is that okay?" "Yeah." "Okay. So I want you to bring to mind a friend. You got a friend? You think a great friend? Okay. What is it you like about them?" So you prime, this is called priming, so you're priming. So you're priming the memory of the friend, so they get the feeling,
stimulate the feeling, and then you say to them, "Okay, now supposing your friend phones you up one day and they're very distressed because they have to go to hospital for a, a, a, an assessment. It's not a major thing, but it's important they go. But they're hospital-phobic, maybe 'cause of things that happened when they were a child. Well, they can't g- they're panicking. They're having panic attacks. H- how would you be with them?" Oh, I'd understand that. Yes, I could see that, and I would be c- would you be concerned for them? Yeah. Would you be sensitive to their…
Oh, absolutely. Well, of course you would. Anybody would be, wouldn't they? See somebody struggling like that. Oh, that's interesting. What would you do? Would you-- don't know. Maybe I'd go and see them. Okay. Anything else? Well, perhaps I'd offer to go with them. Oh, I see. So why would you go with them? Well, because if you're that, like that and you have somebody that supports you and cares about you. Oh, I see. So that you'd give them the courage to go. Is that right? So when you have support and care, you get courage to face things that are tricky? Yes, of course you do. I see. Okay. You've understood compassion, haven't you?
Compassion is developing the courage and wisdom to face things that are painful. That's what it is, right? Kindness and all that. Those are ways you can be compassionate. They're good ways. But actually, it's how we develop the compassi- courage and wisdom to be able to face the things that are so painful for you. That's what we're gonna be doing. That's what it is. Okay. And you've already discovered that when you're caring and you have that caring orientation, that gives you courage and wisdom, okay? That's what we're after, how we use compassion to help
us with courage and wisdom. So basically have a discussion around that because it's such a key issue, and the number of times I've individuals and they haven't really helped the client understand what they're doing and why they're doing it. But if you use examples like that then they can see, yeah, for friends, know, if, if you're very frightened that somebody comes with you, helps you. Why? Because you're biologically designed to be helped by care and compassion. Your brain is set up for it
Dr Natalie Stott (Host): Mm-hmm. I think this is also where, and I have definitely made this error, where you move too quickly into, "Oh, okay, this would really help my client, and so I'm gonna try and really help them see this." Almost they haven't got the insight, but as the therapist you do, so you're trying to bring in compassionate imagery or soothing rhythm breathing, but it's kind of backfiring. I think that's, it, it's quite interesting that you-- the, the client has to get there themselves.
I think you talk about the, they have to have the insight. You have to have that awareness first of either the head-heart lag or the awareness that, oh yeah, there is a f- I can easily be compassionate to others. And so in an exercise like that, of course they can think the perfect words that they'd say to the friend going in for those tests, but for them to recognize there's a disparity then between that and how they relate to themselves, because I think you'd then change how you work, right? You'd be working on the block there of, I guess, helping them recognize
that for whatever reason they don't feel like they're worthy or maybe some of their beliefs are, "I'm undeserving of compassion," whereas everybody else is deserving Prof Paul Gilbert: Yes, that's right. And you're always working around it. For example, if you have people who say, "I'm not deserving, I'm not worthy," as we all in CFT, we always got the big three, anger, anxiety, and, and grieving, sadness. Those are the big three. They-- Sometimes people can do one or two of them, but not all three. So some people are very into the grieving, they're not very good with the anger.
So some individuals who've got this worthy issue, actually they're in a rage, and they're absolutely terrified of it because raging makes them unlovable. Now, if you've spent your whole life trying to be lovable, trying to do the right things for people who like you, the one thing you do not wanna have to b- face up to is your shadow. You don't want it, right? But the problem with it is, is that your anger system is also the system that will defend you, that will stand up and say, "No, no, no, this is not-- I'm worth more than this. You're not gonna treat me like that." It's the assertive aspect of the self as well as the self-promoting aspect.
Self-promoting is, "I think this is good. I'd like to do this. I'd like to do that." So, when you lose your capacity for being able to maintain your boundaries and deal with rage, life becomes a bit tricky and you're constantly trying to be appeased and pleased, and appeased and pleased. the rage in that is, is huge. And so you-- the point that you're making is very important because it's compassionate. This point is not about soothing, it's about engaging with rage. It's finding the courage and the wisdom to be able to recognize, "Yes,
there is a part of me very injured and very enraged about happened to me, and that should not have happened." So the, the key is you say that if you start, particularly with these clients, if you start just throwing techniques at them, let's do some compassion imagery or soothing rhythm breathing. Soothing rhythm breathing in particular for the rage inhibitors is pretty useless actually. They don't need blah, blah, blah, blah. They, they, they can use it if they're prepared to engage, when they're prepared to engage.
It's like, the diver on the high diving board, then you ground yourself in order to dive. Or the firefighter, you breathe in order to go to the fire. You don't just Dr Natalie Stott (Host): do Prof Paul Gilbert: it just for the sake of it. Dr Natalie Stott (Host): Hmm. Prof Paul Gilbert: so it's learning to do your breathing exercises in order to steady yourself, in order then to face what you need to face. So, certainly with a lot of clients and with depression and self-criticism, hostile, h-harsh self-criticism, they're sitting on a lot of unprocessed rage, and helping them work, helping find the courage to work
through that is very, very important Dr Natalie Stott (Host): Hmm. Something that I think is I mean, when a client makes that transition from, uh, the way that lady spoke to about herself to you to then suddenly recognizing like, "Oh wow, this, you know, being sent to my room like this was awful." That grief part, i- maybe this is just me drawing on like personal experience of working with people, it's a bit of a supervision question, but the, the, the grief can feel quite overwhelming.
So how, how do we work with that when that starts to happen? Prof Paul Gilbert: Well, and you're not pushing people into them, you kind of guided them. And CBT skills, Socratic questioning, guided discovery, these are very, very important skills. You go very slowly, so you can say to people, "Okay, so let's have a look at this. So what happens when you try to be compassionate to yourself? see what arises, can you just stick with what arises? And supposing you found…" I've, I've got a, a video on the members area actually talking to
a client who does exactly this. Supposing that you would have feelings of anger about that, how would you feel about that? And this lady goes, "Oh, no, no, no." And she could see it. She goes back at the … "No, no, no, no. I w- no, I don't-- Anger's not a good emotion. I don't…" And so, so you could say, "Okay, well, so what is it that you would be worried about then?" So you can look at the beliefs about if I began to experience this, what would happen? It could be grief. If you began to experience this and you allowed yourself to tolerate, 'cause, like ACT really, it's all emotional tolerance in a way non-avo-
non-avoidance, what would happen? And of course, in all forms of emotional avoidance, it's because it's too intense or it carries a meaning that this emotion means you're a bad person or something. So the m- the intensity of the emotion and the meaning people put on it, those are the two things that usually are the pa- k- kind of the issue. So you, you kind of look at that and invite them to start to explore that. Supposing you could tolerate this, how would that be for you and so forth. And gradually you lead them to the recognition that actually at some point I'm gonna have to learn how to deal with this side of me.
But the whole point of compassion is to do it in a way that's not overwhelming. Challenging, yes, but not overwhelming. Okay. It's like everything, learning to swim, right? We don't just chuck you overboard in the storm. it's a good idea to start off with the paddling pool. But- Dr Natalie Stott (Host): Mm-hmm. Prof Paul Gilbert: We are moving up the scale of tolerance and ability to work with things. So all these com- all these cognitive behaviour skills are very, very useful because this guided discovery, people begin to see things.
So supposing you say to somebody, "Look, know, you, you haven't felt anger towards what happened to you as a child, but imagine that you a child your sort of age. Can you bring to mind like, young girl or something, full of joy and play, just wants to be loved, and then this happens? How would you feel about them?" And they say, "Oh, X and Y. I'd be very angry," or whatever. And you say, "Okay. Now, what is it in you do you think that blocks that for you? What are you frightened about? If you allowed yourself to feel the exactly the same wisdom, the
same courage that you have for seeing that little girl or whatever yourself, what is it that blocks you? What is it?" And so you begin to help them begin to explore that as a slow process of guided discovery, okay? let's imagine that. So imagine now that in this room you would say, "Actually, yes, Paul. I do feel it." And I, I often ac- ac- activate it out in a friendly way, because if you do a friendly way of doing it, you're sending the nonverbal communication that this is safe with your facial expression, but you're giving the message, right?
So I'd say to them, "Supposing there was a part of you that actually one day just thought, 'Well, just fuck you. Fuck you.'" And you smile, right? How would that be? The point about it is, is helping them hear you say to them what they're frightened to hear, Dr Natalie Stott (Host): Hmm. Prof Paul Gilbert: Okay? So I remember a client saying to me, "Oh, when you spoke like that, it used to really worry me. But then I thought to myself, 'I actually probably do have those thoughts, but I don't wanna have them.'" And then you say, "Well, yeah, but they're natural, aren't they?
They're the ways we feel." So the ways in which you create sufficient safety and safeness in order to experience frightening emotions is part of what m- a lot of therapies, CBT, ACT, all of them are basically about how do we help people tolerate emotions they're frightened of and are blocked off from. All, all compassion-focused therapy does is, oh, this is one way you can do it by creating a compassionate mind state, 'cause that mind state has oxytocin, blah, blah, blah.
All of those stuff will help tolerance. But in other ways, CFT uses a lot of pretty standard, evidence-based therapies of engagement, imagery, exposure, all that stuff. Dr Natalie Stott (Host): Mm. On I guess we're mainly talking-- Well, we've talked a little bit about how people relate to others and that being easier. One of the things that you're-- Well, you're known for a lot of things, but the flows of compassion I did wanna touch on because I think clients can
often connect with that as a concept, and it can be quite a helpful way of moving them from, "Oh, yeah, I haven't really thought about this," to, "Oh, wow, there is a difference in how I connect myself to how I connect with others." And the most common way that I have seen it played out is that somebody finds it a lot easier to give compassion to others, but not only do they have maybe a lot of self-criticism and a lack of compassion towards themselves, but they also really struggle to receive it from other people.
And the way I tend to describe it to a client is that there's something quite v- like, there's a vulnerability there that recognizing that you might need something from somebody else activates a threat state, and so they-- it's easier to shu-shut it down. I mean, it's quite a difficult question, but why is that? And is it easier to then start with allowing them to have other people deliver compassion to themselves? Than starting with self-to-self relating? Prof Paul Gilbert: Well, it's a great question.
Depends. Sometimes, sometimes not, actually. So of the key themes with that really is social trust. Now you could say, "Oh, well, it's difficult." And I would say to a client, "Well, you don't trust them, do you really?" "What do you mean you don't trust them?" "Well, you don't trust them because y- you're worried that if they got closer to you or they got to find out about you, then they'd stop being kind to you. Or you could-- if you trusted them and you relied on them and they let you down, where are you gonna be then, right?" you direct them to the issue that part of not allowing compassion is,
is because I don't deserve it or whatever, but it's also distrust. I don't, I don't believe people will care about me if they kn- know about me, if they know what goes on in my mind, if they know about things that I've done or thought, 'cause cl- some of these clients do have quite dark thoughts. So talking about the issue of distrust is quite important. All right? What, what would it mean to actually trust somebody if they say they wanna be helpful to you? What would you immediately think?
"Oh, I don't wanna be a burden." Okay. So would you worry that they'd see you as a burden? "Well, yes." Okay. So it's all about helping them recognize that process of, of distrust and, and so on. And also, as we've talked earlier about, it, it stimulates the yearning then when you begin to realize, "Actually, no, I do want people to care about me, and I've been yearning for that for a long time." So there's all these different elements in it as they begin to experience being open to the compassion for others. But our research, and you're right about this, Natalie, our research
shows that the fears of compassion from others is more predictive of depression and anxiety than self-compassion. And self-compassion's a big thing obviously, but actually the ability to be open and receive compassion because we're a social being. Our brains are designed for social relating, so our ability to feel socially embedded is more important to us than self-compassion. Dr Natalie Stott (Host): Hmm. Prof Paul Gilbert: But it's just, yeah Dr Natalie Stott (Host): I always d-- I, I do always feel a little bit encouraged
because I, I also work a lot with ACT, and I think often when some-someone is able to be so compassionate, and ironically it's often the people that aim-- are most self-critical that you find in caring professions, like they're a doctor or a nurse or they, they give their lives for other people, and they're so compassionate to other people, yet to themselves they're not. I'm not always put off by that because I guess I see it as there's something in them. They, they have a value for compassion.
It just hasn't quite translated towards themselves, and that, I mean, is great information in and of itself, isn't it? To then think about where you might begin to, to work with somebody to help them recognize that because it is so transformational when somebody moves from that place of not caring, being completely numb, to recognizing and nurturing within themselves a different voice. One of the things I like to do with clients is obviously you're doing a lot of practice in sessions, but because you see someone for such a
short amount of time, what they do in their life, what they're observing and doing, I think really does count. Are there-- and obviously it depends on the client, but are there certain practices or things that you have found to be really helpful when you're working with clients to maybe develop a more compassionate view of themselves that you might encourage them to do outside of sessions? Yeah Prof Paul Gilbert: Yeah. So the key thing is where we started this, voice tone Which is one thing,
develop a friendly voice in your head. That's one thing. And if you notice, I've got a client at the moment who's really struggled with this, but he just today emailed me, said, "I think I've got it. It really helped me the other day." Dr Natalie Stott (Host): Oh, great Prof Paul Gilbert: He gets frustrated with things and then says it's because he's stupid and he's made silly mistakes. So when you notice this, right, just take a breath, ground, and create a friendly face and just focus on, okay, well, this is distressing, it's upsetting, and practice the emotional tone. Change your emotional tone. Switch, switch your brain state.
Switch your brain state. You practicing switching. Don't worry too much about getting the right cognitive views. Just refocus and try as best you can to be a little bit more friendly, a little bit more playful. So changing the tone of what you're thinking is, is, is extremely important. thing with compassion is guided practice. Again, a good CBT thing. So we would say to clients, "Okay, think about f- three or four things that you think would help you with compassion," things that you, you know.
They say, "Well, maybe I could be more empathic," or, "I could be more patient," or, "I could be more assertive." And you say, "Okay, so what we're gonna do is we're gonna practice one skill for this week. Only one, right? Okay, so this week is Okay? So we're gonna practice." So then we do standard, pretty standard assertiveness training. know, we don't do the fierce compassion of that. We do s- pretty standard assertiveness training, but with the focus on compassion and with the focus on respectfulness for the other, with the ability to
empathize with the other if you're in conflict with them, to mentalize, but at the same time hold your position. So we, we-- and then we say, "Off, off you go. Practice for the week and see what happens," right? And so they practice that one. Or they could be, I want to practice being less easily frustrated. Okay. The first thing is mindfulness. We're gonna being mindful when you notice the body starting to react. We're getting frustrated, that, that shit feeling, the oh, shit, that arises within you. Noticing that take a breath and s- and pull out.
Take a breath and pull out. Just this practice, that one skill, noticing when that, oh, shit feeling arises in your mind and switching. So compassion, otherwise it gets too, a bit too all over the place, so you're bringing your skills into focusing on particular themes and letting them practice and then come back to you. Now, in CBT, there's a very nice assertiveness one, which anxious clients are not so keen on. You ask them to go into a shop, for a demonstration of a washing
machine or whatever it is, take up the time of the assistant and then say, "Thank you very much. I'll give it some thought," and walk out. S- Anxious people do not like doing that. But you're very friendly, and you say, "Thank you. That's been great. You've been very helpful to me. Thank you very much." And then walk out. So there is all kinds of things that you can help people engage in behavioral practice. It could be things like, s- making a request. Are there any requests that you would like? know, if somebody says, "What would you like to eat for dinner?"
And you say, "I don't mind, you choose, darling." Okay, so over this week, if anybody asks you anything, you're gonna make a decision. right. Oh, yeah, but suppose they don't like what I've chosen. Okay, we're gonna work with that. But this week, whenever you're asked, what would you like to do? What would you… You're going to make a decision. You're gonna make a decision. Okay? it, it may be in your physical relationship, learning to make s- the first move, not wait. So there can be many, many areas where y- you teach them assertiveness training of actually making the positive choice, blah, blah, blah.
Always being respectful of other people, of course. So the key thing is that, but you do it with this, I'm going to develop my compassionate wisdom and courage now, and you do it in a friendly way, and I'm going to make this request. See? So you create this emotional texture all the time if you can, order to engage with the thing that you're struggling with Dr Natalie Stott (Host): I love those examples because sometimes I think we f- clinicians can feel a little bit hesitant in leading the client, and obviously some modalities, with CBT, you'd maybe spend the session
setting up a behavioral experiment. But Prof Paul Gilbert: Yeah, Dr Natalie Stott (Host): I think it's important for people to have the permission that, if you give that to the client, like, "Okay, so what could you try this week?" That they can draw blanks because that can feel quite overwhelming. So I think those are some really practical ways, and hopefully will give people permission to think, "Oh yeah, we can make it something like, going to a shop." It doesn't have to always be, going away and practicing your compassionate other script or soothing rhythm breathing. It, it can be the, the practical shop example.
Something I found with a client, just in case it's helpful anyone listening, with a client who really struggled with the tone we started with writing because writing they were able to generate really amazing, compassionate sentences, and it was only after quite a few weeks of them doing that in their own time that it began to then change the tone. So it was almost like the writing un- unlocked something and, uh, so just in case somebody else is struggling with that, sometimes changing the method by
which compassion is heard, in the mind, maybe how it's read can help sometimes. Prof Paul Gilbert: Yeah. I think that's-- And one of the-- 'cause you, the key thing is like when you're doing your compassion, making them, helping them feel it in the body, 'cause if they don't feel it in the body, we often say it's like sexual fantasies. You can have fantastic fantasies, but if nothing's happening in your body, it's not, they're not really any use, are they? And you're only using fantasy because your brain can change your blood flow. Your brain can release hormones.
That's why you use fantasy, 'cause it's a powerful physiological stimulator. But so with compassion imagery. this is, very important about learning how to use these kind of images to, to stimulate the body. And Dr Natalie Stott (Host): Mm-hmm. Prof Paul Gilbert: So that's one thing. And the other thing is getting people, having people practice relating to themselves. So one of the things I do a lot is create a compassionate self. Now imagine a part of yourself that's struggling, maybe the anxious self. Okay? Now then, the first thing that we always do as a compassionate
self is called validation. Okay? So I'm gonna ask you now just to say to that self, "I can understand what you're feeling and why you're feeling," and name yourself. So if I was doing it to myself, I'd say, "Paul, I can understand why you're really anxious and that's so difficult for you because these are things you've experienced a lot, you know, and you've really struggled with." So I'd validate it, and I'd have them practice it, and then say to them, "Let's hear you say it. Now when you say that from the compassionate mind to that part of you, what are you feeling?"
So you're getting them to actually develop this dialogue and practicing the dialogue and the therapy so they can practice being in the compassionate mind and then dialoguing, so they get the hang of that. And I often give them an example that, you know, I was younger, in my 40s, and I give them an example that the compassionate mind can often help you understand emotions that perhaps you're denying. I was in my 40s, I used to love playing cricket, and that was great, and I-- 'cause I was at boarding school, so being part of the boys' teams was always important for me.
But as I got older, I wasn't getting, I wasn't getting any better , I was getting worse. And of course, younger people were coming into the team. It was quite a good team. And I knew that probably within the next year or two, I'm not, wasn't gonna be chosen anymore. And I was struggling with that. And then one day, we had this quite important match, and I dropped a very easy catch. was so angry at myself. I was really angry and I was really fury, fuming. And I got home and I thought, "Well, I'm just, Let me do a compassionate self." So I s- said, "Paul, I can see why you're distressed because you dropped the catch.
That's very upsetting for you." And then the compassionate self said, "The real relationsh- the real problem, isn't it, is that you can't come to terms with getting old and you're grieving for what you're about to lose. You're grieving." And I was very qui- I felt quite tearful at that point and I thought, "Yeah, that's actually true." Dr Natalie Stott (Host): Hmm. Prof Paul Gilbert: this raging and everything because underneath these days are finished. I won't be able to play like that anymore. I won't be in a team like that anymore. not gonna be wanted anymore 'cause I'm not good enough
But that is the reality, right? So now compassion says, "Yes, that's reality. We have to face that, and that's part of growing up and getting old." so compassion allowed me then just to settle it down and say, "Actually, the real pain is the reality of growing old and losing your abilities to perform at the way that you were." So compassion, when you teach people how to have a compassionate mind that validates the mind, they begin to sense things going on, not just the anxiety, but things behind the anxiety.
So you teach them that, and that you can do that in five minutes. Come into your compassionate self. Now imagine this part of you, your grief part or your upset or your angry part, and validate that. "I can see why you're so angry because…" or, "I can see why you're so distressed because…" And that act of learning to validate themselves in a compassionate voice is very powerful, actually. Dr Natalie Stott (Host): Hmm. Hmm. How much of a role do you feel clinicians-- We spoke about it at the beginning with the empathetic bridging. Do you think there's a risk of overdoing that as a therapist offering
too much encouragement, praise, or is there kind of no limit to that? Prof Paul Gilbert: Well, I think like everything really, you're using your clinical skills. I mean, anything applies just across the board. Some people need it more intensely than others, and so on and so on. Some people can go faster than others. So you're always using your clinical skills, to make judgments about that and checking out with your clients. I mean, one of the great things about CBT is the collaborative
checking out all the time. How is that for you? Does that make sense to you? Would you like to change it? Do you wanna have another go? All of that Dr Natalie Stott (Host): Yeah. Prof Paul Gilbert: stuff. So you're building your journey together as opposed to trying to get them there or get them there. You're, you're building a collaborative journey, and that's actually quite a skill 'cause you often want them to be miles ahead of where they are. But this collaborative process, I think, is such an important element of therapy. Dr Natalie Stott (Host): Hmm. Paul, it's gonna be a crime if I don't talk about three circles
model with you, given I have you on and we haven't got there yet. I think it's probably the, the one thing that even if you're not CFT trained, you probably have come across this diagram, and for those of you that don't know what that is you're gonna have to look it up. But essentially, it's documented as three circles. You've got your threat, drive, and soothing system. Now, when, when I was taught this and began looking into it, I, I often thought about this system as, like, the three circles being like, well,
you need, we need to have balance. You know, you can't just have threat and drive. You need soothing as well. But my take on it now a bit, a few years on, is that it isn't about balance. It's about ensuring that you have all of those systems, and you are able to be in threat, but you can mitigate threat with soothing. Not that we should all be balanced all of the time, and I guess I just-- I think because it's such a model that connects with people, you know. You mention to most clients this idea of being in threat mode and
being in drive and sooth, people get it quite quickly, in my experience. But I do think there's a little bit of a risk that we kind of use it as a tool that, you know, people can connect with. We kind of then feel like, it's made sense to somebody, but we might be missing that actually what somebody might be showing us is that they permanently live in, like, this threat and drive state, and what is completely lacking from their life is an ability to actually come out of drive using the soothing
system, that when they fail, they go straight back into that threat state. So in your experience, what do you, what do you think the errors are of, that you have seen clinicians make when using the three circles, and how sh- how we should use it properly? Prof Paul Gilbert: Yes, I think that's a great question. I mean, so the first thing is that, and sometimes this is not always explained terribly well is we have the, the what we call the, the two, three, and five. So I'm trying to do this better now. We did it in Human Nature and Suffering, but nobody reads that
because it's too complicated in '99. So the two, all living things are designed for survival and reproduction. Basically, that's the thing, right? a result of doing that, you have three tasks. One is all living things need to be able to detect threats to their existence and do something about it. There's no point in detecting the threat and not being able to do anything about it. Even the bacteria in your gut can move away from toxic areas. They have a movement. So there's some species that move and some species that don't. Plants obviously don't move, but they have other ways of protecting
themselves, like curling their leaves if there's not enough water. Some of them have evolved sap, which is poisonous to insects and that sort of thing. Okay, that's the first thing. All living things need an ability to detect threat and respond to it. Now, on the, on the whole, threats come to you. You don't go looking for them. You don't go out, "Oh, I think I'll go out and see if I can find a lion to play with." I don't think that's what happens. The second major to life task is you have to obtain things.
You have to go out and obtain food and find mates and build shelters and find a, a burrow to live in or something or build a house, whatever. So that's a going out. That's a… And tho-those are r-rooted in positive emotions to do, to, to be rewarded for the behaviors that you do. Your threat system is primarily to keep you safe, so those are unpleasant emotions, so you have to take action, right? there's a third one, which interestingly enough, we often talked about it as rest and digest, and that's when the other two, so you're not under threat, you
don't need to be activated, and you're not out struggling to find food and all that, so you don't need to be activated. So it allows the system to settle and bring you back into homeostasis. Now, in homeostasis, body settles into a pattern which allows it to recover and repair. Now, the vagus nerve is quite important for that, but many other systems are as well, because all living things need to find states of homeostasis where they can operate functionally and where the repair systems work. Now, it is linked to rest and digest because you're not having to achieve
anything and you're not under any threat. But what's very interesting and very important is that with the evolution of attachment, you didn't need to do that for yourself You didn't resolve threat, your mum did. You didn't need to go out and get resources, they were brought to you. So whenever you were under need, they would arrive, and that means that the caring system became a, a means of bringing you back into homeostasis.
It brings you back into homeostasis. So if you're distressed and somebody gives you a hug and you feel supported, that will automatically calm your threat system. So you don't have to wait for your threat system to calm down or your drive system, you actually can be supported in homeostasis. Now, interestingly enough, when you're supported in homeostasis through relationships, caring relationships, you don't just rest and relax, you actually become activated. You get an endorphin oxytocin hit.
Dr Natalie Stott (Host): Hmm. Prof Paul Gilbert: you also have a sense of joyfulness, positive aff- it's a different type of positive affect. So if you read Compassionate Mind, it, it says that types of positive affect. One is achieving, doing the dopamine, winning the lottery, getting excited. The other one comes from that sense of connectedness. people would call it love. You can call it that in close relationships if you want to, but it's that sense of just, "Ah, this is wonderful. I just feel," so it's not purely just resting and digesting.
That, that can be an element of it. And so this element of the third system, the-- what we call the soothing system, and I kind of regret it a little bit calling it that because there is… Oh, it's about, just about Dr Natalie Stott (Host): What would you call it instead? Attachment system? Prof Paul Gilbert: I think we would call it social connectedness system, yeah. We do actually, if you look at the original diagrams, we say kindness and connectedness, non-wanting, that sort of thing. But yes. But so it is a grounding, it is a settling, just like when the mum does that to the baby and the baby gradually calms down. So it is a very, very important system.
And when we do that for ourselves, when we say, "Look, Paul, struggling a bit," blah, blah, blah, it has that calming Have quality to it. So the three systems, right, the three emotion systems are, grounded on the three tasks of life. You have to defend yourself, you have to acquire resources, and you have to bring your sp- your body back into Otherwise, if you don't do that, you're constantly Dr Natalie Stott (Host): Yeah. Prof Paul Gilbert: threat all the time, or you're constantly in drive all the time, it's a struggle. Now, the point that you made is also a very good one, which is
Dr Natalie Stott (Host): Thank you. Prof Paul Gilbert: they make many very good, excellent points. The other point is that in Western society, a lot of our drive system is threat-based. Dr Natalie Stott (Host): Hmm. Prof Paul Gilbert: It's threat-based drive 'cause we have to have a job, we've gotta earn money, we've gotta do this, we've gotta achieve that, we've gotta do this. So a lot of the positive emotions sort of not watered down, but are contaminated a little bit by a lot of threat of what happens if you don't achieve and you don't do, that's a problem.
That's, that's becomes a kind of serious problem. So that's why a lot of people with mental health problems are always worried about failing. They're worried about being failures, about… And, and so on and so on because it's all threat-based drive. And the problem with threat-based drive is that you-- difficult to savor things just for the joy of doing them. Threat-based drive people have problems in play, just doing things for the pure enjoyment of doing them. No, you don't need to do anything, just enjoy the enjoyment. Many depressed people find that very difficult 'cause they're so used
to having to achieve and do, and Dr Natalie Stott (Host): Hmm. Prof Paul Gilbert: can feel good because of their achievements and so on and so on. always want to do more and achieve more and do more and achieve more just to take joy from life. Now, in the Buddhism, of course, that's really quite important that this ability just to be grounded in the moment and, and savor the moment. people with mental health problems really struggle with that Dr Natalie Stott (Host): Mm. With because the soothing system is so attachment-based, Prof Paul Gilbert: Yeah Dr Natalie Stott (Host): somebody, if somebody grew up in an environment
where they didn't have that, so they didn't have the, the mom to give them a cuddle, would it be fair to say then there's not that kind of blueprint internally for them of homeostasis? So Prof Paul Gilbert: Yeah. Dr Natalie Stott (Host): they haven't really ever spent much time there, so they get to adulthood, and they've got, maybe all those kind of positive feelings of achieving and acquiring are met in that drive state, that then when you then ask them about the things that they do for joy or pleasure that are associated with achievement, they don't have that.
But it's, it's not because they don't need it, it's just maybe they've never learnt it. And this often comes out if you get people to draw the, the circles, you know. It's not uncommon for people to draw their soothing circles kind of really, really tiny. But it does make it more complex with somebody that has never had that growing up because they don't really have a grid for it. And is that then where the connectedness towards themselves, so having the compassion for themselves, you might begin because that's the, that's
the consistent part of them in their life in all of those scenarios. So if they can learn to, support themselves in distress and be that, the part that regulates the difficult emotion, then you're like boosting the, the, the soothing system grows Prof Paul Gilbert: Yes, exactly right. I Dr Natalie Stott (Host): But it's hard Prof Paul Gilbert: I think that's exactly right. And the point is, psychoeducation is very, very important in CFT, so we do psychoeducation on tricky brain. You've got a, a brain that evolved for you, not by you, and it's got all
kinds of potentials in it that you never chose, and if they get triggered, you don't want them particularly. So these are very, very important elements to, to, to kinda help, help people with really, and guiding them through that process about how they begin to tolerate some of those emotions that you're talking about Dr Natalie Stott (Host): Hmm. Paul that we've covered so much, and anyone listening that's tried to do some multitasking will have to go back and re-listen, do this 'cause there is a lot in here.
Clinicians that haven't really come across CFT or have been maybe doing some off-the-shelf stuff but are a bit more inspired to understand a bit more about it, where is a good place for people to go? Prof Paul Gilbert: come to the website 'cause we-- you can see all of our trainings. We do bespoke trainings. We can send trainers out into your place of work. We do one-day, two-day, and three-day trainings. We do evening talks and that sort of thing. Come and find out about it. There's quite a lot of stuff on the, on the, on the website for you. And remember that you're already trained in saga therapy, then
we call it compassion-focused therapy, not compassion therapy. It's a way of how you can use and stimulate compassion motivational systems and all the physiology your therapy, right? So we're not trying to, as you say Natalie, you lose a lot of ACT and EMDR, and all that sort of stuff. Absolutely right. These, these techniques are extremely useful. They've been developed over many years. People worked out how to do this, that, and the other. So that, that's not us. We didn't, But what we suggest is that the-- what you're wanting to create is
a compassionate brain state, 'cause when you do that, you're stimulating things like oxytocin, like the endorphins and, and dopamine systems, which will then allow those interventions to really bite. Whereas if you're trying to do them just as logic or whatever they're-- I won't say they won't be effective, but they won't be so as effective Dr Natalie Stott (Host): Hmm. Wonderful Prof Paul Gilbert: to the website and come and join us in our trainings. And we have a diploma if you wanna come and do the diploma for nine months, and that's g- with supervised practice and so forth
Dr Natalie Stott (Host): Wonderful. Paul, thank you so much for your time. Prof Paul Gilbert: thank you Dr Natalie Stott (Host): it's been really helpful. Prof Paul Gilbert: Natalie. It's been a delight Dr Natalie Stott (Host): Thank you Thank you for listening to this episode of Mastering Therapy. All of the resources mentioned are available in the show notes. If you are interested in getting more information on what's been covered this season, you can sign up to our mailing list or visit the website, mastering therapy.com. If you know someone that would be great to interview on this podcast, you can submit
a recommendation and I'd love to hear from you the Mastering Therapy podcast and the information provided by me and my guests. Is solely intended for qualified professionals for information and educational purposes. I look forward to joining me next time..
S5E9: A practical take on SEO and AI Search for Therapists Can prospective clients actually find your therapy website? In this practical solo episode, Dr Natalie Stott explains how SEO and AI search affect...
S5E8: Working with Stuckness in Therapy | Dr Robyn Walser EPISODE SUMMARY What do you do when therapy feels stuck and you notice yourself working harder than your client? Dr Natalie Stott is joined by clinical...
S5E7 Narcissism in Therapy: Moving past social media labels | Dr Ruth-Ann Harpur What do you do when a client arrives in therapy convinced that their partner, parent or sibling is a narcissist? In this episode, Dr...
S5E6: How to Find Your Therapy Niche with Josephine Hughes Do therapists really need a niche, or is this simply another piece of marketing advice that makes private practice feel more complicated than it already is? In...
S5E5: Practical AI for Therapists: Green, Amber and Red Uses How can therapists make practical use of AI without handing over sensitive information, clinical judgement or half the contents of their inbox? In this solo...