Skip to content
PodSubs
ShowsPeopleGuestsJobsNewsEvents
More
BlogPodCred
Menu
ShowsPeopleGuestsJobsNewsEventsBlogPodCredNetworksSign in
Join nowSign in
  • Shows
  • People
  • Jobs
  • News
  • More
    • Guests
    • Events
    • Blog
    • PodCred
    • Networks
    Join nowSign in

Mastering Therapy

Mastering Therapy artwork

S4E9 Changing emotion with emotion in EFT | Dr Anna Oldershaw

Apr 16, 202644 minAudio
ShareXLinkedInFacebookWhatsAppEmail

S4E9 Changing emotion with emotion in EFT | Dr Anna Oldershaw EPISODE SUMMARY Most therapists are comfortable talking about emotions, but Emotion Focused Therapy (EFT) takes things several steps further. In this episode, Dr. Natalie Stott sits down with Dr Anna Oldershaw, consultant clinical psychologist and EFT trainer, to demystify the nuts, bolts, and chairs of EFT. They explore why “changing emotion with emotion” is central, the art of letting clients discover their own “Rome”, and why the therapy is more than a rebranding of common practice. Whether you’re curious about chairwork, anxious about secondary anger, or wondering how EFT fits in alongside Acceptance and Commitment Therapy (ACT), you’ll leave with something practical for your next session. TIMESTAMPS 00:03 What is Emotion Focused Therapy, and why does it matter? 02:20 How Dr. Anna Oldershaw stumbled upon EFT (and SPEAKS therapy for anorexia) 05:39 Can you integrate EFT with schema therapy or ACT? 07:35 Chairwork: making internal parts less terrifying 09:38 EFT’s view on emotions: adaptive, maladaptive, and what’s really going on when clients say they’re “just angry” 16:54 Working with clients’ own process, not parachuting in with answers 26:31 The nuts and bolts of running a chair task (and what to do if things go off piste) 31:19 What can clients do between sessions to keep the work alive? 45:24 Interested in training in EFT? How to start KEY TAKEAWAYS • Use “chairwork” to facilitate clients’ dialogues with critical or protective parts - let them find their own insights, not yours. • Distinguish between primary adaptive emotions (helpful, situation-relevant), primary maladaptive emotions (old wounds replaying), and secondary emotions (reactions to other feelings). Don’t take clients’ first answers at face value. • When chairwork risks a shouting match between parts, focus on building assertiveness in the “experiencing” chair and softening of the critic - don’t force a negotiation. • Listen for process “markers” as sessions begin to decide which EFT task (chair, focusing, imagery) will actually fit. • To boost client awareness between sessions, ask them to notice and name when certain inner critics or feelings emerge - no need to “fix”, just notice. • Be careful about overlaying your own formulation. Use conjecture gently, reflect back, and let the client’s experience lead. • If a client experiences blocks (i.e., “I can’t go there”), work with the blocking part directly - don’t bulldoze through. GUEST Dr Anna Oldershaw Consultant clinical psychologist, internationally accredited EFT trainer and supervisor, and director of the Emotion Focused Therapy Institute. Specialises in eating disorders and developed the SPEAKS therapy approach for anorexia. RESOURCES FREE EFT training- apply HERE Emotion Speaks Overview of Emotion-Focused Therapy, research, and videos 🔗 Link here Core Skills Training (Level 1) Four-day EFT training focused on core tasks you can use immediately (Next course in May 26) 🔗 Booking link Advanced Empathic Attunement For therapists wanting to refine moment-to-moment emotional work 🔗 Booking link SPEAKS Therapy (Eating Disorders) Integrates Emotion-Focused Therapy and Schema Therapy 🔗 Training link | 🔗 Book link • Les Greenberg’s EFT videos and further resources: Emotion Focused Therapy Institute UK - Video Resource ** Check out Mastering Therapy’s Youtube Channel for all podcast episodes ** For notification on up coming episodes and for occasional summaries of tools discussed on the podcast sign up here: www.masteringtherapy.com To recommend a topic you’d like to hear about, or if you’d like to appear on the podcast please get in touch at www.masteringtherapy.com/guest For private psychology services and therapy visit www.drnataliestott.com ***** Subscribe to the Mastering Therapy Podcast YouTube channel Follow Mastering therapy on instagram Connect with Dr Natalie Stott on LinkedIn SUPERVISOR PLATFORM Supervisor Platform is an online directory designed for therapists, psychologists, counsellors, and other mental health professionals to connect with qualified clinical supervisors. It makes it easy for practitioners to browse, compare, and contact supervisors based on their expertise, approach, and availability, while giving supervisors a professional space to showcase their services. Supervisor Platform (with 3 months free trial code 'WELCOME3') To search for a new supervisor visit HERE For free resources on supervision visit HERE Disclaimer: The Mastering therapy podcast and the information provided by Dr Natalie Stott (Dclinpsych, HPCP reg), is solely intended for informational and educational purposes and should only be used by qualified professionals. Mentioned in this episode: AIRNOTE | AI SCRIBE FOR THERAPISTS AirNote is an affordable AI-powered note-taking app designed specifically for therapists in private practice. It securely transcribes sessions and creates professional clinical notes, without the price tag of many traditional AI scribes. Early user price is at £9.99 p/m, no hidden costs. Available to mac users only DOWNLOAD AIRNOTE (FREE TRIAL available) AIRNOTE

Audio and video play straight from the show's own hosting. PodSubs stores and serves no media.

Transcript

From the show. Tap a time to play from there.

Welcome to the Mastering Therapy podcast. This is a show for psychologists, psychotherapists, and counsellors who are looking to build on their therapy skills, increase confidence in working with clients and be inspired by alternative models, tools, and ways of working. I'm your host, Dr. Natalie Stott. I'm a clinical psychologist and founder of Supervisor Platform, A directory that supports. Clinicians to showcase their supervision and training to other therapists. It also helps you to find a supervisor that fits with your work and your style.

Join my guests and me as we learn from one another and aim to take insights and put them into action. This is season four. Let's go. Natalie Stott: Welcome everybody to this week of mastering therapy. We are gonna be talking about emotion-focused therapy or EFT as it's otherwise known. I have my wonderful guest of me today, Dr. Anna Oldershaw. Anna is a consultant clinical psychologist. She is an internationally accredited EFT trainer and supervisor. Um, and she's also the director and lead trainer of the emotional, the

Emotion Focus Therapy Institute. So very very well positioned to come and speak with us today. So Anna, thank you so much for your time and for coming on and for sharing all that you're gonna share with us. Anna: Thank you for having me. It's great. I love to come and talk about, and it's really nice to be invited on as a guest Natalie Stott: let's start with the basics then, and think about maybe just how you got so involved in EFT What was it about EFT that that drew you to it, and how has it come to be your primary model of working?

Anna: Yeah, so I came to EFT through the speak therapy work, so I specialize in working with people with eating disorders. And over 20 years ago now, I did a PhD on emotion and social cognition and anorexia. And I was always left feeling that emotions were really important for us to focus on in therapy. And over time they became more integrated into models for eating disorders. But I always felt like maybe there was something missing and there was a different way we could go about working with emotion,

particularly for the people who got really stuck and were more complex. And after I did my clinical training, you know that they're the clients I was seeing in practice. So I applied for some research and. Research money to do, um, some development work, really to develop some kind of emotion-focused intervention for people with anorexia. And I didn't know anything about EFT really at this point. Uh, it was only through putting together that grant application that I came across EFT, because it's just not been that well known in the uk unfortunately.

And part of the development work was to develop an intervention for people with anorexia from the bottom up. So understanding from lived experience, what does recovery look like? How do we facilitate that change? And through that, so myself and Tony Lavender and Helen Startup who put the Speaks model together, we ended up with this kind of model of, of change that people were telling us about. And the more I looked into EFT, the more the EFT was. Such a great fit for this change process that people were telling us. It really sort of seemed to fit with that and also seemed

to fit with schema therapy. So I, I went away and I trained in emotion folks therapy and I trained in schema therapy. And what we ended up with in Speaks is quite an integrative model, um, that integrates EFD schema therapy and some other elements. 'cause we were building it from that bottom up rather than applying top down. You know, we're gonna do EFT for anorexia or whatever it might be. And. When I trained in EFT, I just really loved it and I, I fell in love with that as a model and it really fit for me as a person. And some of the things I loved about it were just the level of detailed

research that's gone into EFT. You know, this model started in the seventies and itself was built from the bottom up, from client experiences, from hours and hours of videotape analysis. And, you know, I can say more about that. They've really researched the change processes. So what goes on in a therapy session that leads to better outcomes, what goes on across therapy that leads to better outcomes. And I was really drawn to that because I felt like sometimes I was missing something in the therapy room as to something that would guide me, that would

help me guide my clients in their process. And EFT really I felt offered me that. And, and it gave me a really nice balance between working with the here and now and the client's process right in front of me, whilst also being able to have skills and tasks and knowledge that I could support the client and guide them within that process. So a really nice balance between following and guiding. Natalie Stott: Yeah. You mentioned schema training that you've done as well. Is EFT something that's standalone or do you find that you are

weaving and integrating it in, you know, alongside other models? Anna: I mean it have. Anxiety, depression that themselves have been researched and have an evidence-based for, and so you can use it on its own, you can also integrate it, and people do, and actually it's almost, I would say the flip where EFP has been integrated into other models. So Antonio Pascal only talks about EFT as being the Trojan horse, which is not great if you're trying to define a distinguished kind of model in and of itself.

When I say more about the emotion change process, that might make more sense that EFT comes into other models. So you can do both. You can integrate EFT tasks into your existing model, and there's research that's been done that's shown that, you know, pre and post. From an individual therapy session, if you're doing an EFT care work task versus say, A CBT intervention, um, maybe, you know, thought challenging or whatever, the pre and post outcome looks the same, the effect size, but

if you continue to integrate that one EFT task into your therapy as you go. Not every week, but here and there, you end up with a better outcome overall than if you just stuck with the other model. So it's a really nice example of how you can integrate it and it can lead you to better outcomes, Natalie Stott: Hmm. Anna: but also it does, you can do it standalone. Natalie Stott: there's even some things that you've mentioned language that I'd love it to come on to, because like. A lot of models. EFT has its own kind of dictionary. And I think that would be helpful just for listeners as we go on.

But also, you mentioned chair work and I understand that EFT was one of the original models that used chair work as an integral Anna: Yeah. Natalie Stott: the model. And I think a lot of people are using parts work more and more as a way of conceptualizing parts of the self and life and chair work is a really powerful way of somebody to. process, reflect in the moment things that might otherwise be too abstract

or too scary or whatever it is. But I think chair work can also be quite intimidating for therapists. Our plan is to have a bit of a conversation about that. Um, The question that comes to mind I hear, emotion focused therapy for people that are thinking, well, you know, we all deal with emotions that is our bread and butter as psychotherapists, that we Anna: Yeah. Natalie Stott: clients to notice, to name, to reflect, to become aware of. What are the layers beneath that in emotion focused therapy that we might

just not normally get in training? Anna: In emotion focused therapy, we, we, we of course, are looking at helping people to process emotions and there are lots of different stages to emotion processing, as you rightly say, are integrated into lots of models. So becoming aware of, being able to reflect on being able to regulate, there's, you know, lots of different elements through motion processing that lots of models do. Do. The thing about EFT is the, the more unique aspect is we also have this notion of emotion transformation or changing emotion with emotion.

And that's the change process that we're targeting. And evidence has shown that that leads, leads to better outcomes when, when you facilitate that emotion transformation process. So to understand what I mean by that, it might be helpful to say a little bit about the different types of emotions or how we conceptualize emotion in EFT. Natalie Stott: Yeah, please do. Anna: Yeah, so in EFT, we think about emotion from an evolutionary point of view that we develop to have emotion for good reasons. It helps us to survive and thrive. The first thing we experience in the world from the very beginning, it helps

us to communicate with our caregivers, express our needs, and get our needs met. And so when we think about emotion, we have emotion because it gives us good information about what we need, and it guides us towards helpful action to get those needs met. And in a nutshell that you can like that, if that's what emotion regulation is. You know, we have an emotion tells us about what we need. We meet the need, and then gradually that emotion can recede because it's done its job and we can move on from it. So in e ft we call those primary adaptive emotions.

The problem is that emotions as well as taking this forward as primary adaptive emotions can do, they can also keep us quite stuck in our lives. So sometimes we have emotions that are really about the past. That have developed from past unmet needs, and that we call those primary maladaptive emotions, also core pain. So the primary maladaptive emotions that would hurt the most. And so an example of a primary maladaptive emotion might be shame. For example, you know, I've, in the past I was very heavily criticized.

I didn't have my needs for sort of acceptance, being prized, being loved just as I was. I developed a sense of shame about myself and about who I am. And that shame can be very easily triggered in the present, even when it's not a good fit for a situation at hand. And then the problem becomes, that's telling us something we need, and it's guiding us towards action, but it's not helpful action. So if I'm very sensitive to being criticized and that easily triggers a sense of shame, my action tendency for shame might be to, to hide away.

And, you know, not, not confront it. And you know, I might feel that I just need to protect myself, but actually that's not gonna help me in the present situation when it might just be a simple misunderstanding and problem solving it, being able to, to come at it with more primary adaptive emotion of maybe being a little bit hurt, but, and wanting to discuss that with the person that's gonna help you resolve the situation better. So that's primary maladaptive emotion. And then one of the things that can happen is we end up.

Shame's a hard place to be, right? It's, it's hard to feel shame. So we can end up either covering that emotion up or going into sort of some kind of secondary process that is a reaction to that emotion. So that could be secondary anger. So I feel shame and I end up get getting angry with you. Natalie Stott: Yeah. Anna: Instead. So we would conceptualize that as a secondary emotion. So other models, I know that they might talk about that as kind of a protecting part or whatever. And we do, we can get onto parts in EFT because they're there too.

So that might be a secondary emotion or, you know, for women, I think we're socialized in particular ways. Maybe we feel primary adaptive anger about a situation, but then we very quickly feel guilty for getting angry. And so that would be a secondary emotion. And if we listen to the guilt. We're telling us we need to make amends, so we're actually gonna be sort of reaching out and being kinder to the person. Whereas actually, if we could have listened to the primary adaptive anger that was telling us to set a boundary, that's telling us this wasn't okay. Very different outcome.

You know, making amends with someone who's actually done something to hurt you versus setting that boundary and saying, this isn't okay. So the key point is we need to listen to primary adaptive emotions. They're the things that are gonna guide us forward in our lives. They're the things that would be at the heart of a concept like the healthy adults in schema therapy. Um, or I forget what it's called in, I test that kind of Natalie Stott: Like the Anna: of call self part self-energy. Natalie Stott: Yeah. Anna: think about it as being sort of primary adaptive emotion.

And so in EFT what we wanna do is we wanna help people move past the secondary emotions, which are. And global distress, which is often what people are gonna come into therapy with. They're gonna come in with symptomatic processes, they're gonna come in with these particular ways of coping in their lives, you know, kind of using drugs or alcohol or just trying to avoid emotions generally. And we want to help people to move past those kind of secondary level emotions and distress. Deep into primary maladaptive emotion.

And then we have this changing emotion with emotion process where we want to facilitate primary adaptive emotion in the context of primary maladaptive emotion that leads people to a new kind of self state that might be sort of self-compassion or, and so when Greenberg explains this, he'll talk about how, you know, with shame, if that's your primary maladaptive emotion. That causes you the action tendency is to hide away and withdraw, and with anger. The action tendency is to thrust forward and to assert yourself.

And if we can activate primary adaptive anger in the context of primary maladaptive shame, you can't thrust forward and hide away at the same time, and so you are creating a new state where people come out with something more like self confidence or self-compassion, Natalie Stott: Yeah. ' Cause I think often when people come, they will self-diagnose, I'm really anxious, or I've got an anger problem, or whatever. It Anna: Yeah. Natalie Stott: And that feels like for them their primary focus,

you know, what are your goals in Anna: Yeah. Natalie Stott: feel less angry, I wanna be less reactive. And Anna: Mm-hmm. Natalie Stott: How soon into the session are you introducing this idea that these are maybe secondary? Um, what's the term? The secondary reactive emotions. How quickly are you peeling back the layers helping them recognize that although this is what they observe, it's maybe. About this, because I think this is Anna: Yeah. Natalie Stott: tricky thing for therapists. We might be able to see that, but the client isn't

Anna: Mm-hmm. Natalie Stott: able to see Anna: Yeah. So the short answer is we don't, we don't tell them, we don't say, this is what your experience is, because that's not the position we take in EFT. So in e ft what we want to do is we want to work with the client's process and help to guide their process. And you know, there's lots of different ways that we can help clients get into their process. So we say all roads lead to Rome. But I also talk about it like, you know, I could get really excited. I could get all my travel brochures out and I could be like, look, this is what Rome looks like and this is, you know, this is what you experience in Rome.

I could tell the clients all about Rome, but unless they've actually been to Rome themselves, it's not the same experience. It's all just conjecture. And what we want is we want to help clients travel to Rome so they can describe Rome to us rather than us giving it to them. So the way a session of EFT would work, how you get clients to that. Of course not right at the beginning. At beginning you need to be establishing a relationship and EFT developed directly out person-centered therapy back in the late sixties, early seventies.

So the person-centered kind of stance is very important. All of those core conditions, empathy, therapist presence, and in EFT we have a very particular way of talking and guiding our clients. And so we once, once we've sort of established the relationship. We're listening out for what in e ft we call markers at the beginning of a session. And this is telling us there's a particular process that's live and active for the client right now that might be worth working with. So we're not going into sessions with the pre-planned, well, it's week two, so then

we're gonna do this, whatever it might be. We're listening out what's the client really bringing? There might be a narrative they're bringing, but what are they really telling us? So we're maybe lifting out for a part of the self. So. That part that really gives you a hard time today that seems really loud today. Does that, does that fit with with what you are experiencing Natalie Stott: Hmm. Anna: or, you know, does that hear that part that just doesn't want you to feel and tell you don't go there? I see that part coming in, what you know, what you think. And so we're noticing a part that seems really live and active or a process

that seems really live and active. And then in EFT, we've got all these tasks that match the markers. For example, if you came into a session with me, Natalie, and you were beating yourself up about something that had happened in the past week, I might say, oh, I hear, you know, and I hear that part that's saying, you know, you're such an idiot. You know, you would, people would expressing it, you know, oh, I'm such an idiot. I shouldn't have done that. I should have. So I'd reflect it back as a part. So, oh, I hear that this part, you're giving you a really hard time. You know, you are an idiot.

You shouldn't have done that. You know, it sounds really loud. How does, does, does that fit with your experience? Maybe, does that feel like something of worth us working with today? And then for, for that, that's a marker for potentially an inner critic. And we have a two chair task for that. And so we'd invite 'em to come and sit in the chair that's giving them the hard time to tell her. So imagine yourself in front of you in a second chair. We only ever work with two chairs. Get the client to position their chairs facing each other. So, so tell her what you've just been telling me.

You know, you're an idiot. You are. And we'd get the client to express it to themselves, and then we get them to move cares. And in the second chair, we call that the experience, Natalie Stott: move chairs. Anna: physically get up and move into the second chair. Ideally, I mean, we have adaptations if, if this isn't possible for various reasons, but this is the ideal where the task runs. So then we'd ask them to come in the second chair and we call that the experiencing chair, because we dunno quite what's gonna pop up in that chair. Whether it's gonna be more of a protecting part, or often people are just in full agreement with a quick, you know, they're right.

What we want to do is to get the clients, what do they feel? How does it feel to hear that, you know, she's just told you you're an idiot and you're, how does it feel to hear that? Often, you know, we can do this with all sorts of processes. It can be a symptomatic process, you know, the eating disorder part, the worrying part, you know, the whatever part that's provoking you. And then we want to explore how that other client feels in relation to that. And often they'll start at quite secondary emotion. So just feels awful. Or I feel bad, or I'm exhausted from hearing it all the time.

Natalie Stott: as the therapist holding you, you wouldn't then label, oh, the, oh, this is a secondary emotion here. You would be Anna: No. Natalie Stott: know, you'd holding, I guess as part of your formulation in your mind, Anna: Mm-hmm. Natalie Stott: this and helping the client. Oh, look, can you see the way that you jumped in there? you Anna: No, no. Natalie Stott: Okay. Anna: We let it run. And in fact, what we are trying to do is hold the client in the dialogue with the part of themselves. Of course there's, there's times when we would bring them back into contact

with us, maybe for emotion regulation, but we're, we're trying to hold them in that dialogue with themselves. So when we're interjecting. What we're interjecting with are process guides, so things like can you move chairs? Um, but also we have all these different ways of empathic responding. And in e fq this is like a whole three day training in and of itself. And there's been so much research for different therapist responses we can give to help guide our clients' process. And so this can be really sort of holding responses if the client is in a deep,

painful emotion, but also responses we can use to try and help deepen and move past. Maybe some of those stuck emotions or those secondary emotions to deepen their emotion process. And so we are using tasks like this chair task to help facilitate clients' emotion processing. And we of course will validate, you know, the secondary emotions that come up. But our main goal is to try and help clients move past them to underlying more, more painful emotions and to help them move towards its emotion transformation process.

And of course you, you don't get there the first time you do the chair task with somebody. It takes a few times, but it's all part of the emotion processing that clients start to move between emotions. They start to find language for emotions. And we do kind of a lot of emotion coaching, a lot of focusing. Um, so asking the clients to look inside. We don't say, what are you feeling? And there's a sort of a bit of thing in e ft that we don't ask questions. Of course we sort of do. But we do a lot of conjecture. It's like, what's. Is it, is it like you are, you are frustrated or like kind of, you know, we

might sort of put conjectures out there. I think particularly for people who find it hard to name emotions or we're exploring what's going on inside in their body, we're trying to help them build up the picture of emotion, you know, or what, what image or word comes to mind, you know when, when you're feeling this way. So we're trying to help people really land on their emotions. Different tools and then we're also then trying to help them deepen their emotion process to move its emotion transformation. Natalie Stott: Hmm. So you are really facilitating as opposed to leading.

What does, what does your formulation tend to look like then? Uh, is that something that's shared with the client? Anna: we would. Yeah. Yeah. I mean, in the moment. I might be doing conjecture, you know, like I might say, you know, oh God, I dunno, it sounds, you know, just so lonely to be. And, and then they'll, you know, does that fit? And then they'll say yes or no, or, so we're helping the client to sort of formulate and make sense of it in the way that we guide them. And then of course, at the end of the session, you know, we do a task for maybe

sort of 20 to 30 minutes of a session. And then at the end we're trying to piece it together, you know, what's the client taking away, what have they noticed, what, you know, what really came up? And so we are formulating in terms of parts, you know, this is a critical part. And, and sometimes people might notice something about the critic. You know, it reminds them of, you know, their mother or kind of whatever. And then that, that's kind of. Another piece of work that we know that we need to do, that we can maybe flag with the client. Um, but we're trying to help them to piece it together. And so in terms of formulation, there's a few different ways

you can formulate in EFT. I tend to formulate in terms of parts of self and helping the clients to kind of understand the different parts and maybe the way that they're interacting or kind of the emotions that relate to those parts. In general, the main thing I'm holding in mind is that kind of emotion deepening process holding in mind. Whereas where do I think my client's at and what are the key primary maladaptive emotions that keep coming up? And are we, are we doing anything to kind of resolve those yet or do we need to keep coming back to those You are looking for emerging shifts

in the client, in, in the two chair task where a new emotion can come up. Then you're helping the clients to really reflect on that at the end of sessions. Some clients do need things written down. I think EFT can be quite a verbal therapy and I work a lot with neurodivergent people who do need things written down so we can explore ways in which we can do that and make things more visual. Um, thinking about different parts and different emotions. Natalie Stott: Hmm. could say the chair task, that'd be the whole session that you would spend.

Anna: Would be, yeah. Natalie Stott: Yeah. Is there anything that you feel is particularly important to think about when moving into chair work with somebody, or any words of caution? I, I thought it was really interesting that there are certain things that you would say to guide their process. Specifically. And you know, that is maybe something that if you're not EFT trained, whether that process could really go off the rails or not be so contained if

Anna: Yeah. Natalie Stott: don't have that specific training. But what, what do you do to make sure that it's set. Up well, and that a client Anna: Mm-hmm. Natalie Stott: for that and can receive it. What should people be thinking and holding in mind? Anna: Yeah. Yeah. I mean, one thing I'd say is, you know, not all chair work is the same and lots of models use it in very different ways. So the EFT chair work that's first developed maybe it's helpful to say that kind of. So EFT developed out of, like I said, the person centered, but also focusing and gift out therapy.

So in the sort of early seventies, Les Greenberg trained as the Gestalt therapist and the very first task that was he developed there was another one before that by Laura Rice, but the very first task he developed was this chair work with that kind of critical part. And the way that he developed it was by watching hours and hours of the tapes, looking to see what happens for people who resolve. Their critic and people who didn't. And what were the steps of change? So with all of the tasks in EFT, there were different steps. They're really well mapped out.

I think perhaps, you know, I'm gonna argue compared to chair tasks in other modalities 'cause they've all been researched and built from the bottom up. And so EFT actually started out with just a bunch of different tasks because that's how it developed. And then it became a whole model that was put together. So. In EFT, we have a very clear process that we know from research is linked to outcome. So I think when people are using fair work, it can look like very, very different things that, with different aims maybe that they're trying to achieve

and different ways of going about it. I think probably the most common issue that people get stuck in with chair work is you end up with two parts that are just arguing with each other Natalie Stott: Hmm. Anna: lead people feeling more stuck. So you have the critical part and then you have the other part that either completely agrees with them and sort of feels quite sort of disintegrates in the face of it. Or you have another part that maybe can get angry or maybe feels like it should get angry. 'cause that's what it thinks the therapist wants it to do. And the two parts are just arguing.

They're getting into a debate and you're not gonna end up with any kind of negotiation. And what, what we want to do, I think generally in chair work that comes from GUST out, but also particularly we're trying to facilitate an efd is where you have this idea of the top dog and the underdog know that was the original kind of GU terminology. You have the top dog saying this example, a critic, and then the person who's on the receiving end experiencing self is the underdog. What you want to try to do is increase some kind of assertiveness in there.

So getting to some prime reductive emotion and expression and some softening in the critic if you can. So it's a bit more of a level playing field before you then try to negotiate between the two parts. And so that's where the emotional deeping process and the emotion transformation process is really important, to kind of build up the assertion on that side. And then also maybe get some softening in the on the other side when they see the impact that it's having. Natalie Stott: Yeah, it is reminding me of the kind of concept around

witnessing in IFS where you're getting parts to bear witness to one another and that's done through that. Sitting, sitting with each of the parts and alongside them, interviewing them or just having dialogue there. Anna: Yeah, I think it would be a very different. Process probably in EFP, we don't interview parts. What we're always trying to do is create a dialogue, an internal dialogue within the person that we're, we're facilitating the process of as therapist.

Natalie Stott: Yeah. And is there anything that in EFT clients would need to do outside of sessions? Are there specific things in EFT that you might encourage clients to do outside of the therapy space to keep the work alive for want of a better phrase? Anna: Yeah. Yeah. I mean, there's a few things. I mean, one of the things that we're always doing in EFT. We're, we're curious about people's emotions. We're always asking people to look inside. Is that fit? Is that so we're giving people the message the whole time that

your emotions are important. They mean something to you. And encouraging people to start to symbolize emotions, to use their emotions in more productive ways. And so this is the general kind of. That we're not explicitly teaching, but we're, we're modeling and the client is taking in over the course of therapy that we want them to go away and continue to do afterwards. You know, we want them to go and. Be able to use their emotions in productive ways in their life after therapy. It's one of the kind of underlying goals. So one of the things that we would hope people would do between sessions is to

become more aware of their emotions, to check in a little bit more, to think about their emotions, that just little bit more we also, another type of awareness homework might be to notice parts, because sometimes if I've done that chair work with the critic, I might say, let's see if you can notice when the critic pops up. This week, you know, you might not feel you can do anything different in relation to it, and that's fine. But just see if you can notice it. Because what we're trying to do, first goal, you know, if a chair task like that is to differentiate from the critic and hear it's, you know, so in the

critic chair it's always you, you are you this, and then in experience chair, it's always I, so that's just one of the small, kind of nuanced ways that we're using language to differentiate between parts and experience. And so it's the client can start to become aware of, oh, this is the message I'm giving myself, rather than this is the truth about me. That's quite a significant shift, even if they can't do anything different in relation to it yet. And I often say, you know, we can't change something unless we become aware of it. So I think one of the key things that we're trying to do is to increase

awareness and understanding and then the client can gradually use that differently in their lives. Natalie Stott: And it sounds like the chair work task is really helping. That awareness come to life in the session? If somebody is, experiencing a lot of anger and anger, is that primary emotion that's showing up, is the goal really to then help them, not just change that emotion, but to act differently? Towards it, you know, I'm wondering how you would, um, 'cause a lot of clients

might say, I just, I wanna be less angry. Anna: Yeah. Yeah. Natalie Stott: yeah. Are you also focusing on behaviors that come with the emotion that's problematic for the client? Anna: So the, the anger wouldn't be primary, but it might be the, the presenting problem that the client's bringing. No, that's okay. But it's confusing with the language, Natalie Stott: is. Anna: would conceptualize it as being secondary. And the thing is, when secondary anger's coming like that, it looks so different from primary adaptive anger, which is more like assertive anger, harmony,

setting your boundaries, you know, primary adaptive emotion is much more naturally well regulated, et cetera. If someone's presenting with anger, it's gonna be like quite dysregulated, more rage, like probably, um, and, you know, is gonna be more problematic in their lives because it's gonna be pushing them to kind of lash out or behave in dysregulated ways. So. What the, the different ways that we can work in ET. You know, we don't just use care work, we use all sorts of different tasks. So it might be they're coming and they're saying, I'm just so angry, or I

lash out and I don't know why I do it. And so they've got this kind of, they're puzzled about their reaction, about their anger. So we have a task for that as well, which is more of an imagery and focusing task to understand a little bit more where it's come from. We can also put sort of symptomatic processes in the chair, you know, be the angry part, you know, what does it, what does that part say? 'Cause there's a part of you that's angry and then a part of you that's, I hear that part that doesn't want to be angry. It's kind of almost sort of on the receiving end of that anger or the

problems that that anger causes. And then we also have another chair task, which is an empty chair task where we can put another person in the chair. And so if somebody is feeling, you know, regretful over some of their actions, maybe around what, what happened when they were angry, then we can, we can work with that by putting another person in the chair. And that can also reveal more about the origins of the anger. Um, we can, we can also put parts that sort of block emotion or that, drive people to kind of unhelpful processes.

You know, I'll often put the eating disorder part in the chair and hear from that part. So in EFT what we do notice is often people come in with these kind of symptomatic processes, or maybe a critic that sounds a bit more like a coach, you know, and it's, it's just, it just really feels like the client really feels it's helping them. Even though it's maybe being coercive or it's pushing them towards something unhelpful. And so again, in e fg we've done a lot of research around this about how to move people from that kind of more coach critic or symptomatic process to access

the core critic, which is underneath. And again in how we guide their process in the chairs. So we might start off with one of these more surface level kind of sort of parts of self or presentations. Through the guiding process, we help them move past that to the core critic, which is then link the primary maladaptive emotion, the core pain, you know, that sort of vulnerable little cell for however you want to conceptualize it. Um, I know the models talk about it in different ways. So we wanted to move past those processes to access the, the primary

maladaptive emotion, resolve that. So it's not coming up so much. It's not triggering all of these other processes and symptoms. And also to access primary adaptive emotions so the person can feel more grounded in their sense of self. 'cause that's the other thing that we know is that our emotions connect us to our sense of self. You know this a guy called IL Step who does a lot of research in this area, sort of. It's a neuroscientist and he talks about it, our emotions that like our embodied self is the material me, you know? And so it's a way we really connect with our sense of self.

So by really grounding in and connecting with primary adaptive emotion, moving past all these processes, moving past the stuck primary maladaptive emotion, connect with primary adaptive emotion, we really get in touch with a core sense of self that can go out and be different in the world. It's guided by adaptive emotions giving helpful information. About what, what I need and how to live my life. Um, and I feel more confident, more self-compassionate and more able to be guided by that as well as the fact I can now hear it clearly.

Is really clear and well evidenced in EFT where we're helping people connect with primary adaptive emotion and that that core sense of self and that material, me know, that embodied sense of self that can give us helpful information about what we need and helpful action and how to move forward in our lives in helpful ways so we're not reliant on those other processes. Natalie Stott: This is probably a really a big question, but Anna: Mm-hmm. Natalie Stott: thinking about, you know, the, the, the kind of stories that people

bring to therapy around what emotion was allowed in the house growing up, Anna: Yeah. Natalie Stott: wasn't able Anna: Yeah. Natalie Stott: I appreciate when I've been asking this, I've been thinking about when emotion is obvious and it's, you know, permitted and people are thinking, you know, for example, oh, I get angry or I'm anxious. We also will meet lots of clients where some emotion has not been welcomed or allowed, like anger or maybe even sadness. Um, and I wonder what you, how you help somebody to build, because

emotions are not bad, right? They're information, they're a manifestation of need, and so. When people have really strong narratives about particular emotions that they don't allow, and a part of the process is them needing to maybe feel that anger Anna: Yeah. Natalie Stott: feel sad how do you navigate that with somebody? Is that an experiential exercise? Anna: Yeah. Yeah. So again, this is the core part of eft.

So we think about this as the parts of me that interrupt emotion. So you know, we would think about behaviors like sort of alcohol or maybe symptomatic processes as being things that are interrupting your emotion. Processing. Natalie Stott: Like blocks. Anna: Blocks. Yeah. Because they're, yeah, they're taking you into these other processes or they're just numbing you maybe completely or you know, that they're just, we have these beliefs about emotions. Don't feel, don't go there. Be awful. You won't be able to cope. Or you know, like you say, some emotions are okay, some emotions are not okay.

So again, yeah. So we would work with that in, in sort of self interruption. So we would notice that when that comes up, that can also pop up in the middle of a task, you know, the chair task with the critic. Someone might get so far with it and then this part comes in that stops them from feeling. Um, and so we want to work with those processes that are coming up live in the session. So we might, then we'd notice it with the client and see whether they can set it aside. If they can't, then we've got a chair task we would move into with that. So let's says.

And we work with that in a slightly different. Natalie Stott: Yeah. Okay. And does, do you come from the ethos of, I guess a lot of the time in act? I would say to people, you know, you cannot control your emotions. You can't control your thoughts. Your thoughts come, your emotions will come, but we can learn to change our relationship to them. Does EFT operate in that same kind of way that you, you know, you can't just not.

Have that emotion towards that particular thing or that situation, is it learning that actually you can control your emotion to something? Anna: Yeah, it's not about control in EFD either. It's about coming to emotion with empathy and wanting to understand it. Natalie Stott: Mm. Anna: about wanting to make sense of that emotion, you know, the, the sort of the secondary emotions that are kind of feel big and very dysregulated versus the primary maladaptive.

Emotions that, that are very painful versus the primary adaptive emotion. Our goal is to help people to be able to live in primary adaptive emotion, and to be experiencing emotion that is relevant to the situation at hand. It's giving them good information. Now, that can still be painful and difficult but it's giving them useful information about what they need. Secondary emotions, primary maladaptive emotions are not necessarily giving useful information. So someone who, you know, does have a lot of anger that's maybe secondary,

then maybe we do need to help them to sort of downregulate that a little bit. Um, because we, it's not useful. It's, it's not giving useful information. So it's about the, the type of emotion that someone's feeling in terms of the emotion response type and any emotion could be any of the emotion response types, but it's working out what's this emotion about? And, and is it helpful And, and trying to help people move past the unhelpful emotions. Like I say, resolve the unprocessed stuck emotions and live their

life in primary adaptive emotion. And understanding that from this evolutionary point of view, that it's, it's use, hopefully useful information. If it's definitely primary adaptive, it will be. And yes, it's painful, but it's giving, it's giving you some information about what you need right now. And people also get people to replace that. They feel that they, to listen what they. Natalie Stott: Hmm, Hmm. What's the, yeah. It does, it does. Thank you. So if someone wants to train in emotion-focused therapy, how

do they go about doing that? Um, is it something that you go on, you know, is it something that then is accredited? Anna: Yeah, Natalie Stott: do you, in case anyone's listening and they, it feels like it might fit the client group that they work with, Anna: yeah. Yeah. Yeah, so I mean, EFT has got, uh, reasonably good evidence based across client groups. Um, and so if you're wanting to focus more on emotions and therapy and understand how to work productively with emotions then I think EFT can be generally a good fit.

I think I was saying earlier, um, that actually there's been some research that showed that. Change process in EFT is actually facilitated by lot of therapies, but it's just in EFT We are more directly and deliberately trying to facilitate that change process. And that change process is also shown to link to outcome. So this whole changing emotion with motion change. So the way that people would train is that we do like a level one training, which is a core skills training which follows the International Society promotion focused therapy curriculum. I always do that in person because it's a very intense training

people bring themselves because it's a process oriented therapy. It's not a therapy where we're trying to learn the nuts and bolts, and that's enough, you know, people bring themselves as clients. So they can experience the change process and know what it feels like, and then they're more ready and able to bring that to their clients. But also so the therapist can learn how to guide an active process that's unfolding in front of them in the room. So when they do the, that, that's a four day training. Sometimes people just come and do that. We cover the core tasks, like the chair task with the critic I was talking about.

And sometimes people feel like that's enough. They're gonna go, go away and start to integrate that in their existing practice. Other people love it. Quite a lot of people love it and they want to do more training. So then we've got an advanced skilled training. We also do trainings, like I said, that three day training just on how, how we can respond and talk with our clients. And there's empathic responses that guide clients process that you could do standalone anyway. You don't have to have done. The EFP training for that, that can be useful. If you are, if you are working with emotion in another model and want have useful ways to guide your client in their process.

Um, and then there's sort of supervision and so people get accredited. We're an accredited EFT institute in England and then we're accredited by the International Society. So it's like most therapy models, but then you do supervise practice and so on. Um, and then you get accredited by the international society. Natalie Stott: And on your website, and I hope it's okay to point people to that you have some really great resources at the bottom, which are short, two, three minute videos by, is it Les Greenberg on?

And Anna: Yeah, Natalie Stott: is a great starting point because they're short, snappy, but like full of gold. So that's another place that people Anna: yeah, yeah, Natalie Stott: thank you Anna: yeah. Thanks, Natalie. Natalie Stott: with us. It's. Given a real flavor of what EFT is and how it also differs and goes a bit deeper than some of the other models that we've spoken about on this podcast. Thank you for your time. Anna: So. Natalie Stott: Thank. Thank you for listening to this episode of Mastering Therapy.

All of the resources mentioned are available in the show notes. If you are interested in getting more information on what's been covered this season, you can sign up to our mailing list or visit the website, mastering therapy.com. If you know someone that would be great to interview on this podcast, you can submit a recommendation and I'd love to hear from you the Mastering Therapy podcast and the information provided by me and my guests. Is solely intended for qualified professionals for information and educational purposes. I look forward to joining me next time.

Open the transcript file

Hosts and Guests

Nobody is credited on this episode yet.

Credit the people on this episode

Be the first to rate this episode

More episodes

All episodes
  1. S5E9: A practical take on SEO and AI Search for Therapists

    Nov 19, 202625 minAudio

    S5E9: A practical take on SEO and AI Search for Therapists Can prospective clients actually find your therapy website? In this practical solo episode, Dr Natalie Stott explains how SEO and AI search affect...

    Credit the people on this episode

  2. S5E8: Working with Stuckness in Therapy | Dr Robyn Walser

    Nov 12, 202639 minAudio

    S5E8: Working with Stuckness in Therapy | Dr Robyn Walser EPISODE SUMMARY What do you do when therapy feels stuck and you notice yourself working harder than your client? Dr Natalie Stott is joined by clinical...

    Credit the people on this episode

  3. S5E7 Narcissism in Therapy: Moving past social media labels | Dr Ruth-Ann Harpur

    Nov 5, 202645 minAudio

    S5E7 Narcissism in Therapy: Moving past social media labels | Dr Ruth-Ann Harpur What do you do when a client arrives in therapy convinced that their partner, parent or sibling is a narcissist? In this episode, Dr...

    Credit the people on this episode

  4. S5E6: How to Find Your Therapy Niche with Josephine Hughes

    Oct 22, 202646 minAudio

    S5E6: How to Find Your Therapy Niche with Josephine Hughes Do therapists really need a niche, or is this simply another piece of marketing advice that makes private practice feel more complicated than it already is? In...

    Credit the people on this episode

  5. S5E5: Practical AI for Therapists: Green, Amber and Red Uses

    Oct 15, 202632 minAudio

    S5E5: Practical AI for Therapists: Green, Amber and Red Uses How can therapists make practical use of AI without handing over sensitive information, clinical judgement or half the contents of their inbox? In this solo...

    Credit the people on this episode