Skip to content
PodSubs
ShowsPeopleGuestsJobsNewsEvents
More
BlogPodCred
Menu
ShowsPeopleGuestsJobsNewsEventsBlogPodCredNetworksSign in
Join nowSign in
  • Shows
  • People
  • Jobs
  • News
  • More
    • Guests
    • Events
    • Blog
    • PodCred
    • Networks
    Join nowSign in

Mastering Therapy

Mastering Therapy artwork

Bonus: What to do when... you are asked a personal question by a client

Jun 4, 202623 minAudio
ShareXLinkedInFacebookWhatsAppEmail

Do you wonder how much of yourself to share with clients in therapy? Self-disclosure in therapy can feel like a tightrope walk,one foot in humanity, one in professionalism, and absolutely no brick walls in sight. In this sharp, practical episode, Dr Natalie Stott explores the everyday moments when clients ask about your personal life, and how your answer (or non-answer) shapes the relationship. Get clear on the difference between purposeful self-disclosure and those accidental reveals, like a stray photo on LinkedIn or being spotted with your dog at the park. We talk genuine connection, boundaries, and those inevitable “Are you married?” curveballs. This episode is essential listening for anyone navigating the unscripted art of being real in the consulting room. TIMESTAMPS 01:17 Common client questions therapists get (and what throws us) 05:07 The four types of self-disclosure - yes, even the accidental ones 08:10 Why small disclosures can strengthen trust and reduce shame 11:01 Red flags: When disclosure meets your own needs, not your client’s 15:11 Online presence: your digital self is always in the room 18:06 Practical ways to respond to personal questions (without making it weird) Guest Information: Social media: https://instagram.com/masteringtherapy Website: www.masteringtherapy.com ** Check out Mastering Therapy’s Youtube Channel for all podcast episodes ** For notification on up coming episodes and for occasional summaries of tools discussed on the podcast sign up here: www.masteringtherapy.com To recommend a topic you’d like to hear about, or if you’d like to appear on the podcast please get in touch at www.masteringtherapy.com/guest For private psychology services and therapy visit www.drnataliestott.com ***** Subscribe to the Mastering Therapy Podcast YouTube channel Follow Mastering therapy on instagram Connect with Dr Natalie Stott on LinkedIn SUPERVISOR PLATFORM Supervisor Platform is an online directory designed for therapists, psychologists, counsellors, and other mental health professionals to connect with qualified clinical supervisors. It makes it easy for practitioners to browse, compare, and contact supervisors based on their expertise, approach, and availability, while giving supervisors a professional space to showcase their services. Supervisor Platform (with 3 months free trial code 'WELCOME3') To search for a new supervisor visit HERE For free resources on supervision visit HERE Disclaimer: The Mastering therapy podcast and the information provided by Dr Natalie Stott (Dclinpsych, HPCP reg), is solely intended for informational and educational purposes and should only be used by qualified professionals. Mentioned in this episode: AIRNOTE | AI SCRIBE FOR THERAPISTS AirNote is an affordable AI-powered note-taking app designed specifically for therapists in private practice. It securely transcribes sessions and creates professional clinical notes, without the price tag of many traditional AI scribes. Early user price is at £9.99 p/m, no hidden costs. Available to mac users only DOWNLOAD AIRNOTE (FREE TRIAL available) AIRNOTE

Audio and video play straight from the show's own hosting. PodSubs stores and serves no media.

Transcript

From the show. Tap a time to play from there.

This is the Mastering Therapy Podcast Bonus episodes. These are shorter episodes focused on those practical in the room moments that happen in our therapy sessions. The bits that many of us were never taught on training, but we navigate every day in our jobs. Alongside these episodes, I'm running some workshops exploring these topics in more depth, so be sure to check out the show notes. Let's go. I've been wanting to do this episode for such a long time. This is about self-disclosure in therapy.

Self-disclosure is something that I have been a lot more thoughtful about the more experience that I've got, If I could boil what I'm gonna say down to one thing, it would be that clients do not want a brick wall. They don't want a robot. But we also must never find ourselves in a situation where clients are taking care of us. They're in therapy for them, and it is our role to support them as best we can The more therapy that you do the greater amount of situations you find yourself

in, where you're faced with questions from clients, how much you share, maybe things that the clients say resonating with you. And so we're gonna cover all of those things in today's episode. These are some of the things that I have had clients ask me, are you married? Do you have kids? Where are you going on holiday? Or did you see the episode of the traitors? Do you have a dog? What would you do if you were me, have you ever had that situation happen to you? have you ever had therapy?

Think we'd all agree that these are normal questions. As a therapist, you are making a decision in a moment. You don't have minutes to think about this. You have seconds, and sometimes it can throw you off guard and the decision is, do you answer it? Do you explore the meaning behind the question? I'll come onto that in a minute. Do I hold a boundary? Do I reflect the question back to them? Do I share something really small? Do I tell a half truth? We have to make these decisions very quickly.

But I really do believe that self-disclosure used in the right way can be a massive bridge to helping build the therapeutic relationship. And I think it's very often spoken about as a way of keeping clients out and not oversharing and protecting the therapeutic relationship and not enough people talk about the ways in which it can be really beneficial. In therapy, clients are being asked to disclose things that are incredibly vulnerable to them, to somebody that is virtually a stranger. And obviously when you've worked with somebody for a while, you

build up more of that rapport. But in a way, it kind of gets weirder for the client because the deeper that they go with you. The more they feel the gap between this person that knows them, that seemingly knows them very well, and the fact that they don't know anything about that person at all. And it is strange. When I think back to my own therapy experiences, with one therapist. I was trying to work out how many children she had. 'cause I can see certain number of shoes by the door. And it's natural to wonder,.

I always try and remember that we are asking things of our clients that are incredibly vulnerable. We're asking them to take risks relationally to trust us, to disclose things maybe they've never said to anyone before, and I guess I do feel like that requires something of us relationally. I don't know that you can be a therapist without. Using the relationship. At least not in the models that I have been trained in, I personally have found self-disclosure quite uncomfortable. This is something I definitely had to learn and continue to learn,

when a client throws me a really personal question, historically that has unsettled me and I've been a bit like a rabbit in headlights thinking, oh, I dunno what to say here and then I have said weird stuff that I think has ended up creating a disconnect in the relationship. And I'm gonna talk a little bit about what I would do differently. But that discomfort is useful because it slows me down and it really makes me think about what I'm about to share and why I'm going to share it. And I've got a lot better at not being such a flipping robot when

a client asks me a question. Let's just, do the classic teaching thing. What is Self-disclosure? Therapist self-disclosure is any information that the client learns about you, whether it is verbal or non-verbal, intentional or not. So that's the important thing to say, that some of these things that when we're talking about disclosure, are not. Intentionally disclosed by you. So that might be about, you know, decoration in your home or your office

photos, whether you are pregnant or not. Wedding rings, jewellery, tears, body language, how you position yourself in the room. All of these things are giving off information to the client. It isn't just about what we say. When I thought about that, it really freed me because I began thinking, disclosure's already happening. Are you thinking about it? There are essentially four types of self-disclosure. It might be helpful for me to break down. So, first is the deliberate self-disclosure. the self-revealing parts, This is where you intentionally

say something about yourself. facts about your own life, your interests, your preferences, where you are going on holiday. I might use it deliberately to try and connect with someone. I recently had a client that was a football fan. I'm also a football fan, and I support Arsenal, and I could tell they were really ambivalent at the start of sessions, and so I was informal. I, I disclosed that I was an Arsenal fan and when I shared that I was an Arsenal fan, I could see it like brightened something up in them.

Disclosing that I was an Arsenal fan led to a really lovely level of connection and maybe got us there quicker than if I hadn't have revealed that. And then there's these self involving, which is your immediate reaction to the client, like noticing their body language or noticing how something sat with you, what you feel in the room. I think the more that I have done ACT training, the better a therapist I've become in being able to be self involving and use my reaction in the room.

I really like how Russ Harris talks about. Therapy being like working as a team. And so you use what you are feeling as a therapist in that moment. Like I noticed when you said that I felt really heavy. That's a form of self-disclosure and you're using it therapeutically to maybe mirror to the client what they're feeling or an alternative emotion that they may have not recognised. The unavoidable parts of self-disclosure. This is where the client learns something because it's obvious. So this might be your age or your gender, or if you are wearing, if you have

an accent, you are pregnant, , you've got a visible disability, your office decoration, the clothes that you're wearing, the jewellery that you have on what they see on LinkedIn or on social media, what they find when they ask AI about you or they Google you. The accidental forms of disclosure. You know, something gets revealed that you didn't plan, like you bump into a client and you've got your kids with you, or you post something online and a client finds it that maybe you hadn't intended your client finds something about you

online that you wrote three years ago. It also could be things in a session like a spontaneous facial expression or a comment that you make, um, or a visible emotional reaction. And finally is client initiated. This is where the client goes looking, and I had a situation when I was early on in my training that I tell you about, when a client is Googling you, looking you up on LinkedIn or Facebook or Instagram, maybe asking you direct personal questions

or reading things into what they find online or what they listen to online. I think we need to get out the head space of, do I self disclose and recognise we are already doing it, but what kind of disclosure are we talking about when we talk about self-disclosure closure? Most of us will recognise when self disclosure is useful, but ultimately, if it serves the client and where they're at, and it's going to be clinically useful. It is incredibly normalising and validating. Often when clients ask questions, they're not trying to catch

us out or it's not a test. Normally they're just curious like you or I would be. And I think really small disclosures reduce shame. And make clients feel less isolated and less like they're the only one that's ever experienced that. I think it can really build trust and rapport. Often clients don't always know where they stand, and this is a really interesting one. You might have had this, when clients say, are you, are you fed up of me?

Are you bored of me? And ultimately you have to make the call. Okay. They're seeking reassurance here. What does it do if I feed that? I actually don't overthink that anymore. I'll normally just answer No, I didn't find that frustrating when you said that. No, I didn't feel like you were a burden when you said that. There's always a place to go and explore meaning and go into depth, but I think instinctively I respond in a way that's going to be most helpful to build that rapport in that moment. Self-disclosure can be really useful in modelling and I use a lot of that and ACT,

you know, naming your internal experience, modelling, diffusion, um, emotional openness, values-based responding. Often when I'm doing psycho ed about values, I'll bring in something personal for me, around. How I wasn't particularly feeling like it, but I chose to act in accordance to my values. I might reveal to people that I hate queue jumping and I feel like it's an injustice and it gets me angry. those examples can really help clients connect to what you are

asking of them and illustrate the work in a better and deeper way. Obviously we can use disclosure to develop that relational depth we have with a client. We have to be really careful. It doesn't become about us and maybe you've had conversations where clients have said, oh yeah, this previous therapist, they, they always told me about their health problems and what was going on with their family. I don't believe that that's ethical practise, but a brief response now and again, can really strengthen the therapeutic alliance

Okay. Let's talk about red flags. Often this comes up in supervision and any self-disclosure I will often take to supervision even if I think I've worked it through myself, because my supervisor might ask me questions that I wouldn't have thought to ask myself. Um, a big red flag is, whose need is this serving? Is this serving your need? Like you could argue that sometimes disclosing something to deepen that therapeutic alliance, if done in the wrong way, could be to meet a

need that in that moment I'm feeling disconnected from the client and so I'm going to use something to try and bring them in closer relationally. That then becomes about me as the therapist and not about a client that's a red flag. , Maybe you might disclose because you feel awkward or you're falling into kind of people pleasing patterns. You are seeking to try and reassure the client, , or to try and prove that you understand, you know, I've been through this. I absolutely get it. Or maybe if you're anxious, you're really anxious and you don't know what to do.

That can mean that you run the risk of oversharing sometimes, a good rule of thumb is if the client ends up listening to you, managing you, comparing themselves to you, or feeling that they have to respond, well, you're probably, uh, in dangerous territory and definitely take that to supervision. Timing of disclosure is also important to think about sometimes, if you are early on in therapy with somebody, you're not gonna have the information that you might need to know whether a certain disclosure's gonna be helpful or whether something is

needed in order to explore, or whether it's one of those questions that does require you to explore more meaning. Personally, and there's no right or wrong with this, I tend to use disclosure when I've been working with somebody for a while, rather than using it immediately, unless it's something that I feel is going to help the relationship, like my Arsenal example, and like all interventions that we do in therapy, you are taking a relational risk there and sometimes it won't work out.

And that's where we grow and learn. I wanna talk about naming what's in the room. We've spoke about this in terms of self involvement, and this is a question about the kind of therapist that you want to be. , I feel it's very appropriate for therapists to show when they're moved by something, But it's important that that's contained so the client doesn't feel like they have to manage you. There have been situations in client in sessions where what a client has shared has been so incredibly moving that I have shared a tear and I don't hide that fact.

And I will name it I'm noticing. I feel incredibly sad when you say that. I feel really sad when you talk about the little girl that didn't know how to get her needs met, especially when somebody is emotionally shut down. That is an intervention in and of itself. So we are using self-disclosure not only to model, but as an intervention, and I have seen that be really effective. There's a real difference between a therapist being moved and the therapist making it about them, or being the emotional centre of the room and that

is what isn't appropriate, right? Being able to relate is something that's really important to me and the kind of therapist that I want to be shared. Humanity is important. Validating is important. And this isn't about being a friend to our clients, it's about being true to yourself and being authentic ultimately. Some disclosures are not even made in contact. They're made before you've even met with somebody by AI or chat bt by an algorithm. It might even be by a profile photo or a post that you, or a post that you made

ages ago that you'd forgotten about. If you have a presence online, LinkedIn, Instagram, most people do. And if you are unsure of what your online presence is, Google your name and your profession, or imagine that you're a client, what will a client Google? What can you tell me about Dr. Natalie Stott for example. See what comes up, I would say for almost certain clients are Googling you before they meet you. So it's good to be prepared with what the internet is disclosing to people about us. This doesn't need to be a point of tension I might just ask somebody,

what did you think about what you saw? Was there anything that made you feel, was there anything that made you feel unsure or. Whatever it is, I'll just have that conversation with them. Little story. When I was training, I had a client that had looked me up on Facebook and my profile picture was me and my husband, and they came into the session and I felt completely blindsided because they asked me, are you married? And then I was really weird and responded very oddly with, oh, what was the, what would this mean about me if I was to answer yes.

Which I wouldn't answer like that now. I would be far more human about it, but they then followed it up with, well, I've seen your profile photo and it looks like you're married. I wish I had felt a bit more confident in myself in having thought through is the modern world AI tech that we're living in, and we can't avoid it. I've come up with this decision tree. We've already spoken about how you are making these decisions in the moment, and so it's really worth thinking about this when you've got a bit more space, and I hope this podcast episode will allow you to do that.

So a few things to think about. Number one, why now? What is it that I'm trying to communicate by disclosing this? Two. Who is this for? Is this for me and my own insecurities or my own fears, or is this to benefit the client? Three, is this actually relevant? Is this going to move therapy in the direction that it needs to go? Four. Can the client hold it? Will it deepen the work or destabilise things? Five. If I say it, can I contain it? Can I keep it brief?

For an example, something really simple like talking about where you're going on holiday. If a client has asked about that, if that then becomes a five minute piece of work, that time is being taken away from the client Sometimes small talk is used as a bit of a distraction and , is a more comfortable place for a client to sit. So it's just worth bearing in mind. I also hear that small talk can be a really important part of grounding somebody. I just think we need to be careful which way we're going.

The other option with self-disclosure rather than just responding robotically with, what would it mean if I answered yes when I've answered people with slightly more intrusive questions about my family, or my beliefs? I might then just, if I'm wondering if it's unsettled someone or it's caused any kind of tension, I will just simply ask about it. What was it like hearing that? Did that help? What made you want to know that, or what did you imagine before I answered?

The therapy relationship is just as important to explore as the contents of what is brought into therapy because so much of what goes on is a mirror. My supervisor is really great at reminding me of that We've spoken about how disclosure is a really important and meaningful intervention, but it's also the meaning that the client makes of what you have said that is just as important to consider. I'm just gonna try and make this a bit practical. There's loads of different ways of how you respond to direct questions.

I definitely have gone on a process with this because initially I'd always say something like, I can hear that this is really important for you to know. What would knowing that mean to you? Or how would knowing that influence how you see me? I might ask something like that. Or I might ask something like, I wonder what your, are hoping my answer might tell you now. Particularly for me personally, that's just not how I roll, and I don't speak like that I am much more inclined to answer the question directly and then

afterwards ask about the meaning or what the client thought about how I answered and unpack it from there, rather than making it weird or risk shaming the client for asking that in the first place. But that's just my preference. We're all different. We use different models. There's not a right answer. If you have disclosed something and you feel like the client is running with it. An example for me, recently I was abroad and a client then wanted to know, where are you going and which part are you staying in?

And oh, have you visited this and have you done this museum? And I just reminded. I'm really happy to share that, and so as interesting as hearing about my holiday is this is a space for you. And, I'm not sure how helpful it would be to use our time discussing my holiday. And I said it in a, with a smile on my face and the client kind of smile and said, yeah, yeah. Like, okay, let's carry on. And if there's something that accidentally comes up or comes out, uh, I think it's really important just to address it head on and not

pretend like that hasn't happened. So, for example when I was pregnant, I didn't just not say anything to my clients because that was obvious and it felt to me that even though it was obvious, it was important to name I didn't make it a big thing. I just brought it in very casually. There's lots of different thoughts here. Self-disclosure is a tool that you can use. It's an intervention. It's also something that's going to happen regardless of whether you've got an online presence or not, because we've spoken about the non-verbal and verbal forms of self-disclosure.

I don't think it's helpful to get into camps of, oh, you are a really unboundaried therapist and I'm a really boundaried therapist. It's all about being thoughtful, clinically sound in why you're choosing the method that you're choosing. and most importantly is taking it to supervision. There have been quite a few moments where I'll add it in supervision and I'll say, oh, I shared this with a client and I think it was helpful. I'm not sure why they asked this, and we'll have that discussion. And my supervisor has asked me some of those hard questions of.

Who was that for? Was that for you? Was that for them? . And I'm growing as a result of those conversations. I don't believe clients want us to be these blank slates. I don't think they need our history and our life story either. What they need is a therapist that can think about the relationship carefully authentically and enough to know when sharing will be helpful and when sharing too much could get in the way. I think we can get very rigid about this as therapists, and ultimately

there isn't one right answer. But I hope that this episode can help you think a bit more effectively about how you approach self-disclosure. Thank you for listening to this episode of Mastering Therapy. All of the resources mentioned are available in the show notes. If you are interested in getting more information on what's been covered this season, you can sign up to our mailing list or visit the website, mastering therapy.com. If you know someone that would be great to interview on this podcast, you can submit a recommendation and I'd love to hear from you the Mastering Therapy podcast and the

information provided by me and my guests. Is solely intended for qualified professionals for information and educational purposes. I look forward to joining me next time.

Open the transcript file

Hosts and Guests

Nobody is credited on this episode yet.

Credit the people on this episode

Be the first to rate this episode

More episodes

All episodes
  1. S5E9: A practical take on SEO and AI Search for Therapists

    Nov 19, 202625 minAudio

    S5E9: A practical take on SEO and AI Search for Therapists Can prospective clients actually find your therapy website? In this practical solo episode, Dr Natalie Stott explains how SEO and AI search affect...

    Credit the people on this episode

  2. S5E8: Working with Stuckness in Therapy | Dr Robyn Walser

    Nov 12, 202639 minAudio

    S5E8: Working with Stuckness in Therapy | Dr Robyn Walser EPISODE SUMMARY What do you do when therapy feels stuck and you notice yourself working harder than your client? Dr Natalie Stott is joined by clinical...

    Credit the people on this episode

  3. S5E7 Narcissism in Therapy: Moving past social media labels | Dr Ruth-Ann Harpur

    Nov 5, 202645 minAudio

    S5E7 Narcissism in Therapy: Moving past social media labels | Dr Ruth-Ann Harpur What do you do when a client arrives in therapy convinced that their partner, parent or sibling is a narcissist? In this episode, Dr...

    Credit the people on this episode

  4. S5E6: How to Find Your Therapy Niche with Josephine Hughes

    Oct 22, 202646 minAudio

    S5E6: How to Find Your Therapy Niche with Josephine Hughes Do therapists really need a niche, or is this simply another piece of marketing advice that makes private practice feel more complicated than it already is? In...

    Credit the people on this episode

  5. S5E5: Practical AI for Therapists: Green, Amber and Red Uses

    Oct 15, 202632 minAudio

    S5E5: Practical AI for Therapists: Green, Amber and Red Uses How can therapists make practical use of AI without handing over sensitive information, clinical judgement or half the contents of their inbox? In this solo...

    Credit the people on this episode