Do you approach therapy as an expert? Do you assume a position of knowing what's going on for someone? This episode welcomes Ged, an experienced family therapist, to discuss the balance of knowing and not knowing in therapy. Hosted by Dr. Natalie Stott, the conversation looks at how to handle uncertainty, the use of questions in systemic practice, and why sometimes “not knowing” can be as important as having the answer. The discussion gives practical examples of embedded questions, playful approaches for working with children, and how to manage stuck sessions. Ged also introduces the concept of “1.5 order therapy” working in the grey area between being the expert and being a collaborator. Simple and practical, this episode offers tools for both family and individual therapists to help clients open up, look at problems differently, and create safety in therapy. Highlights include: 01:35 Embedded questions and reflexive thinking 04:26 Using challenge and managing rupture in therapy 08:30 Handling “I don’t know” responses in therapy 17:52 What is 1.5 order therapy? 30:47 Themes vs. details in therapy sessions Guest Info Ged Smith is a senior family therapist with expertise in systemic practice and collaborative work in therapy. He is known for his practical approach and clear way of explaining the use of collaboration and curiosity in therapy sessions. For more on Ged's work and publications: HERE Guest Information: Connect with Ged ** Check out Mastering Therapy’s Youtube Channel for all podcast episodes ** For notification on up coming episodes and for occasional summaries of tools discussed on the podcast sign up here: www.masteringtherapy.com To recommend a topic you’d like to hear about, or if you’d like to appear on the podcast please get in touch at www.masteringtherapy.com/guest For private psychology services and therapy visit www.drnataliestott.com ***** Subscribe to the Mastering Therapy Podcast YouTube channel Follow Mastering therapy on instagram Connect with Dr Natalie Stott on LinkedIn Disclaimer: The Mastering therapy podcast and the information provided by Dr Natalie Stott (Dclinpsych, HPCP reg), is solely intended for informational and educational purposes and should only be used by qualified professionals.
Audio and video play straight from the show's own hosting. PodSubs stores and serves no media.
Transcript
From the show. Tap a time to play from there.
Welcome to the Mastering Therapy Podcast with me, Dr. Natalie, stock Clinical psychologist. This is a show for psychologists, psychotherapists, and counselors who are looking to build on their therapy skills. Increase confidence in working with clients who be inspired by alternative models. Tools and ways of working. Join my guests and me as we learn from one another and aim to take insights and put them into action.
In this episode I interview Ged Smith, a principal family therapist. Ged has been working for over 30 years and because family therapists work with most people, his experience and expertise is incredibly broad. . What I really wanted to capture on this podcast, which I hope you will agree with me that we have, is How can we sharpen that systemic lens can we bring some of those systemic principles into the room? Something Ged says s part of this interview is once you pass through the doors of systemic perception, there's no going back. It literally changes the way that you think.
Everything is connected. Relationships are everything. It's a really powerful quote and , since doing this interview, I found really helpful to holding in mind. This interview is going to help you think a bit more systemically, give you certain questions, remind you of some of those systemic principles , that you might have learned if you've done any family therapy training. Ged has released a number of papers in his career, and the ones that have stood out to me are one called Cut the Crap, which is all about the language that we use, and another one is called 1. 5 Order Therapy Explained.
What I think is great is GED makes it very applicable, even if you don't have training in family therapy, we talk about practical techniques like internalised other interviewing, how you might challenge clients and how you can use playfulness or circular questions. I've listened back to this interview a couple of times. It's just full of gold. So get your note paper and pen out and thank you Ged for coming on. natalie_2_12-10-2024_141033: Most of the, listeners, psychologists, therapists will be used to working one on one with somebody.
And obviously your bread and butter is working with multiple people. And I always remember. My systemic teacher saying, it's always more interesting when you've got more than one person in the room. squadcaster-d43h_1_12-10-2024_141034: Oh yeah, definitely. and easier as well, which it doesn't seem to be the case, but it is easier with more people It's the questions that do the work. that's a really essential part of any systemic thinking. The questions do the work, finding ways of asking powerful, facilitative questions that make people think differently.
Usually questions that they haven't asked themselves before. I always find that the best response to a question is, when people go, Oh, that's interesting. I haven't thought about that one. let me think. And then they reflect on it. And that's great when that happens. it's very obvious questions. I rudely call those obvious questions doctor questions Because doctors ask us, what's your date of birth? where's the pain or how long have you had it? We know the answers to they're not helpful for us They're helpful for the doctor
Because their looking to diagnose and medicate and understand or whatever, which has its place, but that's not therapy. questions are Are very different from that. Our questions , illicitreflexivness, which h makes me t hink in a different way. natalie_2_12-10-2024_141033: Can I ask you about embedded questions? Because I I know this is a, a specific tool within systemic thinking, you're inferring meaning through your question indirectly. squadcaster-d43h_1_12-10-2024_141034: yeah. natalie_2_12-10-2024_141033: Could you give us some examples of embedded questions? squadcaster-d43h_1_12-10-2024_141034: Yeah.
parents come, complaining about their child's behavior, very common, now in my head, I'm thinking, well, whatever's going on, there will be an explanation for this, we have to try and work out what that is. Another belief of mine is that , behavior or naughtiness, as it's often called, is a communication of distress. So that could be a question. you could own your own thinking. I often think of, uh, children's behavior as a communication of distress. what do you think about that?
Or I might go further and say, If you thought of Billy's, behavior as a protest, what might he be protesting against? Now, hopefully that will make people reflect and think, Oh, hang on. what's this mean? Let's think about that. Some people might say nothing. Cause he's got everything he could possibly want. And I'm thinking, well, no, he hasn't. He hasn't got your, he doesn't feel secure or safe or loved or something in his life will be going on. But people don't quite get that sometimes.
natalie_2_12-10-2024_141033: Reflecting on how I sometimes with people, I'm using embedded questions unintentionally. And I think that probably comes from a position of us. I don't know, maybe not always being aware of. our stance as therapists or not, being conscious of our own bias. I just wondered whether you use them always intentionally, or is it okay that embedded questions come out, subconsciously? squadcaster-d43h_1_12-10-2024_141034: Well, you would hope intentionally the mental processes that go on in therapy are I think more complicated
than any of us can possibly understand and it will sometimes surprise us. so in family therapy, often we work with a team and some sometimes later when debriefing after a session, somebody might say, what made you ask that question or follow that line of inquiry or whatever. And we don't always know. It can surprise us. So I wouldn't pretend to say everything I do, every question I ask is all very conscious and thought out and understood because sometimes it isn't, it's very much
kind of on the hoof in a way, in a good way, in an authentic, relational way, you have to be spontaneous and open to what happens. A common mistake with trainees or beginners is. To be thinking of the next question while the person's answering your question. It's like, Oh, what am I going to ask next? I must think of a good systemic question, then you don't hear what's being answered to your previous question. So spontaneity, openness, trusting the process is a big part of it.
but yeah, I think my own embedded questions have intent and consciousness about them most of the time, but not always. . natalie_2_12-10-2024_141033: If somebody gives you a response and in your mind, you're thinking, yeah, this isn't it. I'm interested how you go about using challenge and using your role as therapist in that situation. Do you? always challenge. Have you got more comfortable with it as you have got older? Because I guess what challenge does it risks a rupture.
And, that can be really difficult and can be quite scary for therapists. And I know for my own journey, definitely earlier on, definitely risking less because I wanted to get it right and I didn't want to upset anybody. What's been your story? squadcaster-d43h_1_12-10-2024_141034: I Agree absolutely with you, challenge is never easy, and we have to do it very carefully and with a judicious use of language, which takes a long time to, to perfect that art and I would call it an art, but we have to do it carefully and each time is
different depending on the therapeutic relationship that we have with people. for instance, if I'm thinking this kid's really not happy. the parents think he is, and I'm thinking, well, it's a good job that he's misbehaving and kicking off because if he wasn't, you'd think he was okay. But he's showing you that he's not okay by his behavior, which is really difficult for you. I understand. However, what I understand in that communication is my life is not okay. Can you please attend to my needs, my emotional needs?
Now I might actually say that to somebody, but I wouldn't say this is the truth. Listen to me. I might say, a lot of people might think that your child is communicating his distress. He's unhappy about something, and the unhappiness might be this. what would you say to that? Or if I say, for instance, that earlier question, if you thought of your child's behavior as what might he be protesting against? And they say, nothing. few more follow up questions still get, well, nothing, because, his life's
really good and he's got everything. I might then share my thoughts and say, well, well, I've got a few ideas. Would you like to hear them? And people always like to hear them. So I might say, well, told me earlier or last time about the time you two split up and you went to live in another house for a few months and you, or, you were hospitalized when you were ill. And he had to go into care for six months, he hasn't seen his dad for a year, or he doesn't get on with his stepdad, or whatever it is that's going on.
now these are the things that might make, probably would make most children unhappy or distressed, and they've all happened in your son's life. That's the kind of thing I mean. What do you think of that? And then people often say, Oh yeah, didn't think about that. Maybe. we might think are obvious, but lot of people, for them, it's not so obvious. How children's safety, security levels of happiness natalie_2_12-10-2024_141033: Yeah. squadcaster-d43h_1_12-10-2024_141034: by these ruptures in their care or security.
, And, they don't say, excuse me, I'm feeling a little insecure. Am I like, can you please, attend to my emotional needs? Like I said earlier, kids don't do that. They kick off and create and make adults lives difficult because they want to be understood. natalie_2_12-10-2024_141033: Yeah. The thing I'm often squadcaster-d43h_1_12-10-2024_141034: way of doing it. natalie_2_12-10-2024_141033: Yeah it's a really helpful example. I'm often conscious of how cognitive talking therapy is, obviously, we're very much talking about thoughts and getting people to perspective take,
and for some people that is quite hard. When you were consistently getting, I don't knows, I don't knows, and I think sometimes that can be a response to someone feeling threatened, the questioning can put someone in that state. So they shut down. So it can be a protective strategy from a systemic point of view. How do you handle the I don't knows when when it starts to feel like this is actually getting in the way here. I'm just curious how you go about doing that, because I think that's relevant for all therapists, regardless of what modality you use.
squadcaster-d43h_1_12-10-2024_141034: Yeah, absolutely. Well, first of all, the great advantage in family therapy is that you can ask other people, about what might be going on. So you can ask siblings and make it quite playful. ask a sister, what do you think your brother feels about being here? Oh, he doesn't want to be here. Why do you think he doesn't want to be here? Oh, because he thinks he's going to get told off and he hates this kind of thing and like that. And that playfully with siblings. and then the referred child or patient himself can then respond and that's
easier than asking the child himself, what do you think about being here or why do you smash your room up? that's a, that's a question I would never ask. the word why the question why is ver seldom asked in family therapy. It's a kind of causal word. Why? Yeah. In terms of human behavior and relationships. It's almost impossible to do justice to why we do what we do. You know, you asked anybody, why do you do the job you do? Why did you choose the partner you're with? You can never do justice.
To aspect of natalie_2_12-10-2024_141033: quite accusatory, isn't it? It can feel a bit shaming. It's the one thing that's really influenced me is the staying away from why and naturally we're always thinking, why are they doing that? But you really have to reframe how you say it because I think you get a lot more out of people and helping them to explore that. squadcaster-d43h_1_12-10-2024_141034: I say to people is, I'm going to come back by the way to your, I don't know question, but natalie_2_12-10-2024_141033: So, squadcaster-d43h_1_12-10-2024_141034: just getting up to it. One of the things I say to people, that nobody's angry for nothing.
Or I'd share it as a belief. Do one of my beliefs is that. Nobody is angry for nothing. What do you think about that? might ask that to the parents. Nobody's angry for nothing. So, something must be going on to make him feel so angry. I wonder what that might be. Because it can't be nothing. So that's quite an expert statement. I'm not telling you what it is, because I don't know, but I am telling you, Nobody's angry for nothing, is my belief. Do you want to with that, or do you disagree with that?
So that, that's an example, same with people when people cry and then say, Oh, it's nothing cool. I'll talk about something else. I don't quite let that go as gently as I can. I will stress that this must be really important, even though it's uncomfortable and you don't like it. I'm thinking as a therapist, this is significant and something I think we should return to because it natalie_2_12-10-2024_141033: yeah. squadcaster-d43h_1_12-10-2024_141034: if it makes you cry, tears are significant. But when people say, I don't know, as I say, the circular questions technique is good to avoid that earlier by asking other people, but for children if someone
says to me, I don't know a lot, I might say a younger kid, should we have a deal? You're only allowed to say, I don't know three times today. Okay. So use them wisely because you only got three. And kids like that game, and they actually play it. natalie_2_12-10-2024_141033: Yeah. squadcaster-d43h_1_12-10-2024_141034: But another one is, is ridiculous, really. What do you think about this? Oh, I don't know. I know you don't know, but what would you think? And they answer it often. Or, OK, I know you don't know, but what's your best guess?
I don't know. Or you must have a guess. Anything. I'm not asking you to be right or for a big theory. just a guess. natalie_2_12-10-2024_141033: Yeah. squadcaster-d43h_1_12-10-2024_141034: like that. Family therapy is so much fun, actually. natalie_2_12-10-2024_141033: Yeah. squadcaster-d43h_1_12-10-2024_141034: not all of natalie_2_12-10-2024_141033: Yeah. squadcaster-d43h_1_12-10-2024_141034: but can be so much fun. And kids come expecting to be told off. suddenly they're engaged in playful, creative conversations, which Yeah. Yeah. Parents having to be slightly more accountable for themselves
and their responses more than the kids are, kids love. And it's a very equalizing thing where. Usually, I think children leave feeling, empowered and understood and think, Hey, that was all right. I'll come back there. He didn't tell me off once and the parents leave thinking. more to our child's behavior, or children's behavior, than we thought. This is natalie_2_12-10-2024_141033: Yeah. squadcaster-d43h_1_12-10-2024_141034: He's not just naughty or bad, this is something else which we need to understand.
and I think that's a really helpful thing to leave people with, natalie_2_12-10-2024_141033: Yeah. squadcaster-d43h_1_12-10-2024_141034: and they're more likely to come back and engage in the therapy if the children and the adults are thinking those respective things. natalie_2_12-10-2024_141033: Yeah. Have you got any way workarounds for when people obviously feel stuck or they're feeling threatened and they're shutting down? squadcaster-d43h_1_12-10-2024_141034: If it was adults, I'd be more interested on a, in a different way. I'd be thinking, well, you said it in a way that they might feel threatened. So if I name the feeling that can be liberating.
So, , I'm trying to make sense of you not knowing a lot. Or because when people say, I don't know a lot, it's often because they might feel threatened or they might feel something difficult. I wonder what that might be with you. Yeah, exploring the not knowing, often when people say, I don't know, it's not because they don't know natalie_2_12-10-2024_141033: No. squadcaster-d43h_1_12-10-2024_141034: Yeah. Yeah. Yeah. or something like that. what do you think, feeling that you don't know or not wanting to share, uh, ideas with me might be about, is there anything I can do to
help make this any easier for you? So it would be a different kind of, questioning with an adult, obviously, less playful, usually. natalie_2_12-10-2024_141033: Yeah, I remember being taught around being curious as to what it might be like for them not knowing because then you're getting off the content , getting more into their experience of what it brings up for them when they're in that not knowing position. squadcaster-d43h_1_12-10-2024_141034: But sometimes in terms of challenge, which you asked earlier, I often find a good way for me to challenge
is to frame it as a dilemma. I know you say you don't know, and I want to respect that and move on. But a little bit of me, the therapist, pushy bit of me wants to say something else and I'm worried you might get offended by this. I hope you're not because I don't mean it as an offense, but what I feel like saying is. I think you do know, but you're afraid to say what do you think when I say that does that offend you or is that a To say? instance, that's one example. natalie_2_12-10-2024_141033: Yeah, nice. That is a great example. I think the more that we can use play and humour, even for adults, it is disarming.
It's our job to create that therapeutic safe space that feels secure. squadcaster-d43h_1_12-10-2024_141034: yeah, exactly. And if we're real and authentic and a bit humble, but What I haven't said is that I always say to people, I'm really happy to be challenged. If there's anything I say or do that you don't like or don't understand or wonder why the hell is he asking or doing that, please ask me because I'm really happy to be questioned or natalie_2_12-10-2024_141033: Yeah, squadcaster-d43h_1_12-10-2024_141034: So natalie_2_12-10-2024_141033: I think that is so Yeah, that's so important
because I'm thinking about this from the perspective of, creating psychological safety, is really important to create that and people are not going to speak up if they feel like you're this kind of God and remembering the power that we hold as therapists. If that isn't explicitly stated, that power goes on. unspoken, that could be a real barrier for somebody feeling like they can approach you or can say like, yeah, I don't really agree with it. I love it when clients say, no, that's not really quite right.
That for me I feel like we're tracking together because they feel comfortable enough to say, yeah, you didn't quite hit the nail on the head there. And that feels like progress. squadcaster-d43h_1_12-10-2024_141034: I've almost got to the point and I felt like it's happened a couple of times where people complain to me, not officially, but complain and say, I'm not happy with what happened last time. And I'm like, Oh, okay, this is good. Let's talk about this. I'm glad you're raising this. If you're not happy, I want to hear about it. This is okay. Rather than feel crushed and defensive about it. natalie_2_12-10-2024_141033: Yeah.
Yeah. squadcaster-d43h_1_12-10-2024_141034: But I'll never forget the time a woman said to me after about five sessions in the family after whatever I'd said, I don't remember, but she said, you're just some fella really, aren't you? You're just some fella. natalie_2_12-10-2024_141033: Yeah. squadcaster-d43h_1_12-10-2024_141034: you, you're just an ordinary person. Because up until then, she As you said, she had this notion of, infallibility on a pedestal natalie_2_12-10-2024_141033: Yeah. squadcaster-d43h_1_12-10-2024_141034: Whoa, you're just some fella, which I natalie_2_12-10-2024_141033: Yeah. squadcaster-d43h_1_12-10-2024_141034: a good natalie_2_12-10-2024_141033: It would be useful to frame some of our discussion in how people can think through some of these ideas.
When they're working with just one person, another thing I remember is that you should never ask somebody, how are you feeling? You ask, what does so and so think about how you're feeling or something to that effect? squadcaster-d43h_1_12-10-2024_141034: Yeah. So that's an example of a circular question as we natalie_2_12-10-2024_141033: yes. squadcaster-d43h_1_12-10-2024_141034: I mean, it's not banned. It's not like you must never, but it's, but it's less likely that we would do that. natalie_2_12-10-2024_141033: Yeah, I think it's helpful to have those things in the back of your mind though, , to think through different ways of asking something because, one route can lead to a very closed option and another route
gives you a lot more information and part of, I guess, a lot of the time what we're trying to do in therapy is broaden out somebody's understanding of something or, gathering greater pieces of, information. Do you mind just saying a little bit about, what you mean by 1. 5, order practice or how you got there? squadcaster-d43h_1_12-10-2024_141034: Yeah. Well, the paper you're referring to is the, was the one in the family process, American journal, of, December, 2023, uh, 1. 5 order therapy.
What's, what 1. 5 means is it's the, the space or the gap between first and second order, practices of therapy. Should I explain what that means? natalie_2_12-10-2024_141033: That would be helpful. Because some people won't be familiar with, family therapy. So yeah, just give a brief overview squadcaster-d43h_1_12-10-2024_141034: Yeah. Well, family therapy can be and often is very philosophical and full of scientific language, sometimes jargon, which most of us struggle to understand at times. So, I say that because, first and second order cybernetics is the
full name, is quite complicated. And sometimes some people might say unnecessarily complicated and they can mean different things to different people. So, 10 family therapists might give you three or four different answers to the question about what orders mean. First and second order. natalie_2_12-10-2024_141033: in true family therapy style. Hey, squadcaster-d43h_1_12-10-2024_141034: yeah, there you go. But my take on it, my, my use of it is to do with. origins of family therapy were first order, which meant that the originators of these models, systemic models, were powerful, charismatic, guru
type figures who knew an awful lot. And they wrote a lot about how they met with deeply entrenched families and their problems and magically cured them in one go or very quickly by doing these fantastic first order systemic therapy from a position of knowing, absolutely knowing what's wrong and what needs to be done. So they were the origins of family therapy. That was back in the 50s and 60s, even through to the 80s. The kind of, you might call it the post modern turn, late 80s, 90s,
feminist turn, gave us a new order, second order, was more of a not knowing, collaborative approach. suddenly people realized, hang on, is this actually the best type of therapy to do? Do we really know as much as we say we know? How about tolerating uncertainty? How about not knowing things and in fact collaborating with families and exploring meaning with them? Not from a of experts or knowing but from a not knowing position and a lot of papers
and Writings of that time are actually called the not knowing approach You Which doesn't mean we don't know anything. It means we don't presume to know your particular issue in advance of meeting with you. Nor do we know what you should do. We wouldn't even think like that, particularly now. Okay. So you get the idea. it's, in a word, it's a move from knowing to not knowing from being a guru type expert to a collaborative therapist who explores meaning
ways forward with families. That's what first and second order is in the way I use it. And the 1. 5 is the shift between those positions and the taking up of a position in between them. So for a lot of my career, I was very much in the second order camp of not knowing, collaboratively exploring with people, and that was great. But as I got older and more experienced, I. Started to think, hang on a minute, I do actually know things. natalie_2_12-10-2024_141033: Hmm. squadcaster-d43h_1_12-10-2024_141034: Have some knowledges of mental health
issues and how humans work and behave in systems, in families, in relationships. And I began to get more and more persuaded by myself and by my aging or experience or confidence to find ways to say those things, which was kind of breaking the rules a bit. It was like, whoa, I know I'm not supposed to do this, but I am going to offer some thoughts, not, deliver truths to people, but tentatively offer a possibility or
a thought or an idea or a hypothesis back towards the old first order ways yeah, so for people who know family therapists, after years of working like Tom Anderson or Michael White or under their influence, started to slip back behave a bit more like Mnuchin or Haley. So apologies to those who, for whom those names mean nothing, but family therapist will know what that means. So
Back towards the old originators of family therapy who are very much knowing. So that's what 1. 5 means. It means slipping between knowing and not knowing, sometimes going back towards earlier practices. Embracing my expertise, my knowledge. But as I say, not delivered as a dogmatic truth, but more as, a sharing of experiences ideas or knowledges that I've had or have and seeing what families and couples make of them or individuals sometimes.
natalie_2_12-10-2024_141033: Something that struck me from reading your paper was around how you use, that knowing and not knowing position and then how that is manifest in the language that you use with people. And am I right in thinking that position can work the same, that you can be directive, but also be curious. It doesn't necessarily just have to work within a, say, a family therapy context. squadcaster-d43h_1_12-10-2024_141034: Yeah. You can use systemic practices and ideas with any number of people including
one, systemic work with individuals is actually much written about. But I supposee I would say in a sense, this is a philosophical point, probably. Once you pass through the doors of systemic perception, there's no going back. It literally changes the way you think. everything is connected. relationships are everything. Relationships and context is everything. So once you think in that way after many years of doing courses and working in
that way it becomes who you are really. So when I work with individuals I'm still thinking. I can't not think systemically anymore. so with individuals, couples, families, groups, organizations, teams, whoever, I can't but think systemically, same when I watch the news or the TV or anything, the world is systemically in my head now. natalie_2_12-10-2024_141033: I'm wondering how these ideas influence when you're working with someone on an individual basis. So if we think about, when you've got multiple people in the room, it
would be easy to, for example, ask the mother, Oh, what do you think it is that your child is hearing or thinking about when they hear you saying that, so how would you do that if there isn't that child in the room? Would you ask that same question, just getting them to hypothetically think, if they were here, what might they say if they were listening to you speak like that? squadcaster-d43h_1_12-10-2024_141034: yeah, exactly. Here, what do you think she would say? Even if dead or emigrated or whatever. bringing absent people into the room in the minds of people, is one very
clear and obvious way of doing that. Missing person X was here, what do you think they might say? Other possibilities about bringing those, ideas, questions, thoughts into the room. natalie_2_12-10-2024_141033: Okay, so if I'm working with somebody and they are talking through, relational dynamics, obviously I've got one side of the story and I might be curious as to the other side of the story, but how do we help somebody else give us a bit more of the fuller picture or help us support
them in, I don't know whether that's them making a decision about something or them changing or adapting their behavior, as a result of that particular challenge that they're bringing. So for example, I have a client who is, thinking about, separating from her husband and this has been a four year process and they're in couples therapy, they're together, going through that, but she's decided there's not too much fight in her anymore, but what she keeps saying , she keeps using this phrase. I'm not sure whether I'm owning my stuff.
He says that I'm this and this, and I'm now questioning myself. I'm not really trusting what is coming up for me. And, I wonder in that circumstance when I've only got the client in front of me, what questions I can ask or how I can go about helping her to think through what actually is going on here. She's, receiving this narrative, I'm not owning my stuff, and doesn't have the confidence to say, Yeah, I am owning my stuff. And this is an attack or to say, Yeah, actually, I think there's some truth here.
I find it hard to know how to support her with that, because I only have her side, and she's undecided. So it's really difficult for me to help her through the trees. Yeah. squadcaster-d43h_1_12-10-2024_141034: So when you give that example, I think, I might ask her about the history of her relationship with self confidence, for instance., where did that come from? her doubts now in her version of herself being accurate, does that, resonate
with any earlier period in her life? how did her mother or father contribute to that way of thinking, for instance? But it's still a kind of fairly individualized focus because the way I heard it, it was she talking about herself and how she thinks. So other than questions about the influence of other people in her life, parents, family partner, how they influenced her thinking, but that's still quite individually focused because she hasn't come as far as I've just heard now from you to talk about her relationship, particularly she's talking
about whether or not she should leave if she was talking a bit more relationally or in other ways, a very useful technique way of thinking that I like to use, you might be aware of already is called the internalized other interviewing. Are you familiar with that? natalie_2_12-10-2024_141033: Yeah, where you might then use a chair to represent that internalized other, or where you're to them. Yeah, squadcaster-d43h_1_12-10-2024_141034: Yeah, so I might say, so Mary, if that was her name, can I talk to the internalize your partner whose name
is John, through you explain that. And then I've talked to her as John, the John that she internalizes. So John, I've been meeting with your partner, Mary, for a few sessions now, she's quite undecided about what to do. How much about this? Has she talked with you to get me? So Mary has now become John, , and she'd say, Oh, well, Mary spoke to me last week and told me she, she thinks she might leave. Okay. So carry on talking to John,
And what, john in her head natalie_2_12-10-2024_141033: and in your mind, Ged, what are you trying to do for the client by doing that? What are you trying to bring out? squadcaster-d43h_1_12-10-2024_141034: Well. Ideally that conversation internalized other would take place with the couple actually in the room. the real John would be listening to this. natalie_2_12-10-2024_141033: Yeah. squadcaster-d43h_1_12-10-2024_141034: And part of the idea of it would be, at the end of it to say, were there any things Mary that you said as John, which surprised you? Because sometimes people say things in role, which they actually surprised
themselves about, can you believe? But we do. But also to ask John, how well did it seem that Mary knows you? Did she get most things right? Did she get significant things wrong? How did that go? the real life John might say, Wow, she knows me so well, or that was terrible. I just don't think any of those things. You don't know me at all. You got it all wrong. of those positions is really important. Mary knows you that well? What did you think when she said as you, that, you care more about your
mother than you do about her or whatever it is that came out in that session. So ideally it would happen with both people presence or more than two people presence if it was part of a family, but it can be done with individuals, Still because people don't do that, they think about things, but they don't do it in such a way, which is quite intense and powerful. And then think, Oh my God, yeah, I realized what he thinks now. And only through doing that exercise today, achieve new realizations, even
though it's only in their own mind. . natalie_2_12-10-2024_141033: Yeah, absolutely. The one thing I wanted to touch on before we finish is in your article or in your paper, you talk about exploring themes with people and I think you say, detail is the enemy. How do you word it? D, detail is the, I wrote it down. Yeah. squadcaster-d43h_1_12-10-2024_141034: really. natalie_2_12-10-2024_141033: Yeah. Detail is the enemy of. squadcaster-d43h_1_12-10-2024_141034: an endeavor. natalie_2_12-10-2024_141033: Yes, detail is the enemy of therapy and how so much of the time people can get really bogged down in the detail and that eats
up, people are only in sessions for 50 minutes an hour and you can spend 10 minutes explaining something that is largely irrelevant and what you need to do is cut to what are the themes, what is it that leaves you feeling? So squadcaster-d43h_1_12-10-2024_141034: Yeah. natalie_2_12-10-2024_141033: do you go about doing that with someone? So I think that's a really practical thing that lots of us encounter and knowing. When just to let somebody go and when to say can I just stop you there? That's hard and that you need confidence to do that. squadcaster-d43h_1_12-10-2024_141034: Yeah. Oh, it's such a big question.
I mean, you literally could spend a whole day just talking about this. And there are some examples of it in that paper and other papers. But the premise of it for me is that I think people come to therapy thinking, want to know everything, won't you? So I better tell you everything. And I'm thinking, no, we absolutely don't need to know everything. And getting that balance between allowing them to tell a bit of the story enough so that they feel heard and understood. But not follow the idea that, well, I've got to tell you everything. Otherwise you won't be able to help me.
it's playing it by ear to some extent, but eventually there comes a point when, okay, I've got the idea. I've got enough. And sometimes I share my belief that about detail being unnecessary, sometimes too much detail, and points out as you suggested, it's about a theme. So it happens a lot in couples work. People say, let me tell you what he did last week. Let me tell you how bad things really are at home with her or him or whoever, when you've heard two or three of them, that's usually enough.
So I might say, can I just stop you there? Or can I tell you something in all the years I've been doing this, I find that stories about how bad the other person is or very detailed accounts of situations are usually not that helpful. In fact, they're hardly ever helpful. A mantra I have is the thing is not the thing, and they say, what do you mean? I say, well, the thing you want to tell me, which is an account of what happened last week, not actually the thing, by which I mean the real issue in your
natalie_2_12-10-2024_141033: Yeah, squadcaster-d43h_1_12-10-2024_141034: You know, the thing, your thing will be what he did last week. But the thing I want is, what's the meaning of that for your relationship? Yeah, it's all about meaning, not facts. So we don't want facts much. We want meaning. What's the meaning of this event or episode that happened last week? It means don't feel loved or she reminds me of my mother, or I feel stifled in this relationship or whatever it is get into that quicker because we
don't need 20 stories to get to that. seven sessions, natalie_2_12-10-2024_141033: yeah, squadcaster-d43h_1_12-10-2024_141034: very hard to explain by just talking about it because it just sounds, it sounds like it's rushed and almost impatient and almost, disrespectfully lack of listening, but it at all without observing it. It might not make much sense, in real life, it works well. And natalie_2_12-10-2024_141033: Yeah squadcaster-d43h_1_12-10-2024_141034: appreciate it. people are okay about being stopped, about being interrupted. If they feel they're in safe hands, people are like, okay, this is all right.
I'm natalie_2_12-10-2024_141033: Yeah, okay. Well Ged. We are at time we've kind of talked through some of the concepts in that article and I will put a link to the show notes if anyone's interested. But this conversation has done what I hoped it would, which is to just bring to the front some of these systemic ideas that regardless of whether we're seeing families or we're seeing people individually, we can, remind ourselves of some of this and bring this in because We just often get stuck in our ways and I love how systemic ideas just, , they zoom you right out. So you've got like a wide angle lens view on a situation.
And you can never have too much of that. squadcaster-d43h_1_12-10-2024_141034: that's a really good, phrase, which is one of the essences of systemic thinking, which is don't zoom in, but zoom out. A lot of mental health approaches zoom in on the problem or the referral. In the systemic theories, we zoom out and look at the big picture of the context because it will make sense in a context. We don't Yeah. in the head of the individual, but in the world or the life or the culture or the society of that person , sorry, you've just reminded me to zoom natalie_2_12-10-2024_141033: No, that's great. squadcaster-d43h_1_12-10-2024_141034: yeah. natalie_2_12-10-2024_141033: But thanks so much for your time.
squadcaster-d43h_1_12-10-2024_141034: Pleasure, thank you. Thanks for your questions.
S5E9: A practical take on SEO and AI Search for Therapists Can prospective clients actually find your therapy website? In this practical solo episode, Dr Natalie Stott explains how SEO and AI search affect...
S5E8: Working with Stuckness in Therapy | Dr Robyn Walser EPISODE SUMMARY What do you do when therapy feels stuck and you notice yourself working harder than your client? Dr Natalie Stott is joined by clinical...
S5E7 Narcissism in Therapy: Moving past social media labels | Dr Ruth-Ann Harpur What do you do when a client arrives in therapy convinced that their partner, parent or sibling is a narcissist? In this episode, Dr...
S5E6: How to Find Your Therapy Niche with Josephine Hughes Do therapists really need a niche, or is this simply another piece of marketing advice that makes private practice feel more complicated than it already is? In...
S5E5: Practical AI for Therapists: Green, Amber and Red Uses How can therapists make practical use of AI without handing over sensitive information, clinical judgement or half the contents of their inbox? In this solo...