Skip to content
PodSubs
ShowsPeopleGuestsJobsNewsEvents
More
BlogPodCred
Menu
ShowsPeopleGuestsJobsNewsEventsBlogPodCredNetworksSign in
Join nowSign in
  • Shows
  • People
  • Jobs
  • News
  • More
    • Guests
    • Events
    • Blog
    • PodCred
    • Networks
    Join nowSign in

Mastering Therapy

Mastering Therapy artwork

S1E1: Working with a strong inner critic | with Dr Chris Irons

Oct 24, 202443 minAudio
ShareXLinkedInFacebookWhatsAppEmail

How do you approach working with clients that have a strong inner critic? This episode features an interview with Dr. Chris Irons, one of the leading psychologists within in the compassion focused therapy world. In this episode they explore managing self-criticism and the inner critic through Compassion-Focused Therapy (CFT). The discussion unveils practical exercises and tools, such as those available on the Balanced Minds website and the self-compassion app. Key insights include identifying self-critical behaviours, understanding their psychological impacts, and strategies like imagery exercises and compassionate writing to foster self-compassion that can be used with clients. 05:05 Identifying and Addressing self-criticism 08:35 Exploring the Functions of self-criticism 18:22 Visualising the self-critic 22:15 Managing distress during therapeutic exercises 27:42 Exercises to address the self-critic 37:21 Compassionate Mind Training 38:48 Resources and tools for Compassion Focused Therapy ***Guest Info*** Connect with Dr Chris Irons on LinkedIn Balanced Minds website Self-Compassion app ** Check out Mastering Therapy’s Youtube Channel for all podcast episodes ** For notification on up coming episodes and for occasional summaries of tools discussed on the podcast sign up here: www.masteringtherapy.com To recommend a topic you’d like to hear about, or if you’d like to appear on the podcast please get in touch at www.masteringtherapy.com/guest For private psychology services and therapy visit www.drnataliestott.com ***** Subscribe to the Mastering Therapy Podcast YouTube channel Follow Mastering therapy on instagram Connect with Dr Natalie Stott on LinkedIn Disclaimer: The Mastering therapy podcast and the information provided by Dr Natalie Stott (Dclinpsych, HPCP reg), is solely intended for informational and educational purposes and should only be used by qualified professionals.

Audio and video play straight from the show's own hosting. PodSubs stores and serves no media.

Transcript

From the show. Tap a time to play from there.

Welcome to the Mastering Therapy Podcast with me, Dr. Natalie Stott, Clinical Psychologist. This is a show for psychologists, psychotherapists, and counselors who are looking to build on their therapy skills, increase confidence in working with clients, and be inspired by alternative models, tools, and ways of working. Join my guests and me as we learn from one another and aim to take insights and put them into action. Vocaster Two USB-6: Welcome to episode one. Vocaster Two USB-5: I thought I'd start as we mean to go on.

And that is with a brilliant mind and a much respected guest. I had the privilege of speaking with Dr. Chris Irons as we discussed the tricky topic of working with a strong inner critic. Working with high levels of self criticism is so common in the work that we do Vocaster Two USB-7: And what better way of managing this than interviewing a very experienced clinician to walk us through it. Vocaster Two USB-5: We discuss compassionate mind training, how to work out the type of self criticism and the function of it. I love that he goes through the actual questions he asks people and then the

options of how you might follow that up. This is a packed episode with lots of resources mentioned and exercises that you can try. So it's going to be one for the show notes. Get your notepad out because you're probably going to want to take notes. Enjoy! natalie_1_07-17-2024_131508: chris, thank you so much for joining me today. You are. one of the directors of Balanced Minds and also you fairly recently, co created a compassion app. Do you want to just say a bit about who you are for listeners that maybe are not so familiar?

chris_1_07-17-2024_131508: Yeah, sure. Thank you so much for having me on this episode. It's been a joy. Yeah, I'm Chris. I'm a clinical psychologist, I guess, an academic, researcher and a trainer in CFT. and I I guess I've been doing this for quite some time. I first met Paul Gilbert, who's the big brain behind CFT in 1999. So, it's been 25 years of my life basically working in this model. I did a PhD, academic PhD with Paul, so I was looking into attachment theory and shame and self criticism to help him to do some of the, early studies, looking

at some of the background processes that we will discuss a lot in CFT. And then, when I did my clinical training, I was lucky enough to have two years on placement with Paul. And so I had him as clinician Paul Gilbert as my clinical supervisor. And that was just amazing seeing this master clinician work. And so I feel very lucky and blessed to have had these different versions of backgrounds in CFT. And then since then Lots of years working and using this approach in inpatient settings in MDT settings, CMHTs, outpatient psychotherapy services, but more latterly, just trying to take this model and spread

it as far and wide as possible. natalie_1_07-17-2024_131508: One of the things I've think I've realized through my years of experience is that regardless of the presentation that somebody comes with and the difficulty that they're coming to therapy with, think the majority of people would say that they find it hard to have that same compassion that they might have to other people, to themselves, and that can be a real block for many people. When they're feeling vulnerable, how do they operate in a compassionate manner to themselves?

And so many clients, it's one rule for everybody else and another rule for them. And. One of the things that I have seen lots of people ask about and I've definitely come up against in my own practice is when somebody's internal voice is really, really negative. So when they have what we would call a strong inner critic. When Making any kind of progress in being able to like yourself, be warm to yourself, feels really impossible.

I would be really keen to get your insight on when you have worked with people that are very strong in self criticism, when their inner critic shows up and doesn't budge and doesn't move out of the way, where would you begin with somebody? And would you name that with them? And then where would you go from there? chris_1_07-17-2024_131508: It's a great question. I guess the first thing just to sort of validate your personal experience is that, you know, the whole starting point in a way of CFT was with Paul Gilbert recognizing that some of his clients, those who are very high in shame and self

criticism were struggling to benefit from therapy in the way that other clients were able to benefit from therapy. So the whole CFT model in a way started with shame and self criticism. And there was a recent meta analysis by Lo et al. I think it was published maybe two or three years ago. We can send a link in the notes for the show. And they found that across multiple studies and multiple therapies, those clients starting therapy with higher levels of self criticism did less well in therapy than those clients starting off with lower levels.

So this is backed up very clearly by research, that there's something about self criticism that blocks the ability of therapy to be as effective as it would be for people who don't struggle so much for self criticism. So I think your point is a really important one. There's a lot of ideas and a lot of work in CFT focusing on exactly this bit, which is at first becoming aware of the potential power of self criticism and how do we begin to raise that and help the people that we're working with. And so, I don't know if it's helpful but maybe we.

Could have a think about this in almost like stepping stones. I don't mean that I would necessarily do it in a sort of linear based way of therapy, but in my mind, there are a variety of steps and the first one, of course, is identifying it. You know, if you don't. know that this is happening as a clinician or as the person seeking therapy, then of course, it's very unlikely that you're going to do something about it. So first is an identification that there is a self critical process going on. And so I guess for me, it's always holding in mind that self

criticism is significantly higher in all the major mental health diagnoses than people who aren't. Currently given a diagnosis of mental health problems. So in a way I expect there at times to be a self criticism running under the hood. One of the things I'm looking for is to check in with people, you know, if somebody is describing a difficulty they've had at work, if somebody is describing a struggle they've had with their partner or with their child or whatever it might well be, trying to look out for and asking explicitly when

this thing happened, whatever it was. A, how did you feel? But how do you respond to yourself in these moments? In that sense, as you were saying, what's your self relationship? And one of the pieces of work that Paul Gilbert and I did many years ago was to recognize that actually there can be different types of self criticism. So the first bit is kind of about helping people to identify when they are being self critical so we can help them to begin to notice the types of things they say to themselves and recognize that those can be quite different. I had a a client who once was sort of quite mild of themselves,

you know, it's not you, you silly idiots, , you silly sausage. It was critical, but it was said with a lightness. And then of course, when you begin to hear the inner dialogue and it's you fucking piece of shit, you stupid. Stupid idiot. So you're beginning to try to pick up both the words, the content, but also the emphasis that that comes with. natalie_1_07-17-2024_131508: And with that client, did they realize that until they had begun the work with you, did they realize that it was as aggressive as it was?

chris_1_07-17-2024_131508: No, I think for many of us, and I will say us here because clinicians also struggle very much with self criticism too, it's a little bit like we don't notice what it's like to be breathing. We don't think about or really consider Speaking the language that we speak that's our mother tongue. We just speak, you know, for many people self criticism is so ingrained It is automatic and they just don't notice it. In fact, i've had many many people say to me I'm, not self critical and then when you slow the process down and you actually get people saying out loud what

they're saying to themselves And you ask them What would you feel like if you said this to the person you love the most and they have that strong reaction? Oh, you know i'd never do that. That's awful. You know, why not? It'd be so horrible it would be so critical , and they kind of catch themselves that it is in that moment that I would not be saying these things to my child, to my partner, to my colleague that I care for, but actually it's kind of running underneath the hood here without me even noticing. So bringing awareness is important. first step and then helping people to recognize that there are different types.

So we found that there can be a type of self criticism, which is more about inadequacies and failures and setbacks, which was significantly associated with psychological distress. So we did that. We published studies on this. We developed a questionnaire to measure exactly this. Again, I can leave a link to it in the show notes, but then there's also a type of self criticism, which comes with a real sense of hostility and hatred. And as you can probably imagine, that's highly associated with psychological distress, really highly, very, very common type of self criticism.

natalie_1_07-17-2024_131508: Okay. So awareness as the first step to bringing that out into the open having, that be something that you address. If you're, in an assessment with someone and they're bringing this problem at work and you ask the question, how do you respond to yourself? And then you ask the follow up question. And how would you respond to someone else like that? And they've got this light bulb moment of. Oh gosh. Yeah. I'd never speak to somebody like that. Would at that point you be exploring, okay, which type of self criticism is this, would you go into that level of detail with the client or

is that something that just in your formulation you're holding in mind? chris_1_07-17-2024_131508: I guess it depends. It depends on the person, but potentially yes. And potentially one of the things that we might do. It's helping the person to begin to monitor this. So, for example, they could start to use a diary in which over the next week they start to track and become more familiar with the frequency, the presence and the content of their self critic so that they're actually tuning into this now after many years of being dissociated from it, beginning to recognize just how often it's turning up and what the consequences are.

on them. So we could do it in a diary like way. We could also get people to begin to get more familiar with the pattern of self criticism, because self criticism isn't just the words you say to yourself. So when we're self critical, so if I'm self critical of my body, it guides attention to my body. I'm not, like, focused on, I don't know, something completely irrelevant. I'm focused on my body, maybe the part of my body that I dislike. Self criticism, of course, will shape up the content of my thoughts, so they will be negative in focus and, you know,, labeling or judging, I'm

fat, I'm ugly, whatever it might be. Self criticism is likely to shape behaviorally, what I do or don't do. So, for example, if it's a summer holiday and I'm self critical about my body, maybe I'm more likely to keep my t shirt on than taking my t shirt off when I'm on the beach. And of course, self criticism can also come with a type of an emotional tone. And of course, there's research going on. I've been on about this for a very long time, going back to Les Greenberg and so on, that self criticism isn't just a cognitive process, it's also an emotional one, which I'll come back to later, because that's another

stepping stone of what we would do. But first bit is just getting people to recognize the pattern, and in beginning to recognize that, then we can explore with people one of two things. Sometimes it's useful for people to begin to explore where this came from, to be able to look back in time and to think about how old is this part where did this part learn to do this critical process? Was there someone or something that shaped the way that this part is operating so we

can do a little bit of backwards tracking? But for sure, one of the exercises that we get people to do is a type of functional analysis in which we ask people to bring their self critic to mind, maybe a time Recently, where they were being self critical, and then we asked them to imagine that magically somehow that in this session that somehow I could take away their self critic so that they could never, ever criticize themselves again. And as they're imagining this, I get them to try to imagine living their life without a self critic.

To then see if I can guide them what type of concerns or fears begin to emerge inside of you about living your life without the self critic. And so what we find, and again, we've done research studies on this, we've published a questionnaire that focuses on the functions of self criticism, is that people start to reveal some very common themes. So people get that without the self critic, they'll make mistakes that they'll become lazy. They won't progress in life. They'll become like Donald Trump, this narcissistic he could just be

out there doing everything themselves that they would hurt other people. And so there's these types of fears that begin to emerge mentally. And underneath those, if we hold the phrase. Follow the fear, , what is it about those things? Because I'm sure most of us know people who are quite narcissistic, who seem absolutely fine with that. I know a bunch of people who seem relatively lazy in life and not achieving stuff that they seem fine with it. So partly it's thinking then about what's underneath all of this. And mostly what you get to, of course, is that the fear and depending on these

things are existential ones, rejection, loneliness, essentially, I will be stuck in this kind of position, disconnect. And a failure, and that's normally what you begin to get to. So the I guess, of doing this functional analysis is to help people to begin to recognize that is there something that their self critic is trying to do for them? almost in a protective way. And of course, what this exercise helps people to recognize that, yeah, maybe

there is a functional reason here. There is something that this critical part is trying to prevent me from doing or experiencing. And that of course can be quite a powerful revelation, but also one which can begin to open up some empathy, I guess, for aspects of what the critic is doing. natalie_1_07-17-2024_131508: I think that can also be really powerful for the clinician as well. I'm just thinking about a client of mine who I don't think I've met someone with a stronger and a critic and we started on that path of.

Really getting her to tune into you know, what the inner critic was saying and when it showed up and then really trying to understand what the function of it was. And we just were coming up against this block of lots of, Oh, I don't know. And we tried drawing out, which I think sometimes helps, , take it out of the chat and get it on paper and I noticed, and this is the thing I took to supervision, almost feeling frustrated myself, and probably was feeling what she was feeling, this frustration at the inner critic. But it was when we realized,, Wow.

This is a protector. This voice is protecting you because you were so terrified to let me in. So what I was seeing were all these walls and barriers and questioning her motivation. Is she wanting to do the work? Is this the right time? But actually the inner critic, which was frustrating for her, frustrating for me, was just this protector part. And so since we've labeled it as that, my goodness, the compassion that I have. And so now when it shows up, we just really gently acknowledge it, that this

protector part is looking after you here because that's what it's had to do. You know, your whole life. It's just helped put language to something that before was happening unconsciously and between us. It's really helpful for you to have highlighted that. And also when people are thinking, Oh, which route do I go down? Do we go down? Where has this voice come from? Or do we start with what are the functions of it? And I think that will be dependent on the kind of service you're in. If you're in the NHS and you've got six sessions with somebody,

you're probably not realistically going to have the time to go right back to where has this come from? Where did you learn this way of relating to yourself? So maybe starting with the functions is going to be more helpful for them in the shorter term. And maybe you would acknowledge that, look, if we had longer, this is the kind of work that do with you. But for now, this is going to be most useful. chris_1_07-17-2024_131508: Exactly. And everything you're saying really resonates with me. So it's finding a way basically to help people and like with many, aspects

of our threat systems, which serve some sort of protective function. If you get people to imagine, or you get them to imagine that being taken away from them, it's like you're looking underneath the hood of the threat system, you're able to get into the fears. And the point there is you can say, explore with people, , how would you feel if this therapy then was about me trying to reduce or get rid of your self critic? And of course, most of us shake our heads. No, because we've just had this revelation that there it is, that without it,

I'm going to feel lazy, I'll make more mistakes, I'll hurt people, I'll be narcissistic, all these types of things. So one of the things we say in CFT is that, look, if you want to keep hold of your self critic for the time being, keep hold of it. Because for me going up against the self critic, somebody else's self critic, which is rooted and powerful and strong and been around for decades. And there's a me that gets 50 minute sessions once a week for however many weeks. Who's gonna win? Well, it ain't gonna be me. So the bit that we're saying, first of all, is that we validate and reassure people. As long as you need to keep hold of this, this is fine.

Now, in my mind, what I'm thinking is, of course, hold this as long as you want to, until there can be another part of self that can begin to take over some of this in a way which isn't going to be harmful for you. Because it's really important from the CFT model that while self criticism does often have a function, it's trying to protect us from something. The way it goes about doing it is very, very, very painful and causes problems. I mean, the correlation between self criticism, depending on the type, and psychological distress is a 0.

4, 0. 5, 0. 6, sometimes 0. 7. I mean, this is a major predictor of psychological distress. So we also then need to flip the side of the coin to say, whilst on one hand, This part is trying to protect you from another concern. The way that it does it often causes huge distress and to help people to do that, we then have an exercise in which we ask people to to put an image to their self critic so that if they could imagine that they could see their self critic in front of them, what would this look like? Now. We specify here for it not to be a real person.

So we ask them to be able to create something new. The reason for that is partly the work that we come on to later on. But often, of course, what will happen is that people will start putting an image like my mum or my dad or my abuser. Now the problem there is how much of this is a self critic versus an internalized other, like a real abusive person. And so we want to be able to identify and separate out in CFT If you basically internalized your abuser, it's a real person who said these real things to you, and now that's living in your head in a way masquerading

as a self critic, but actually it is an external critical harmful other. What we're trying to do is create space for people to be able to create something which can be a little bit separate from this. And so often what you'll find is that people can create all sorts of types of images. Some of them will be archetypal, Witches, snakes, goblins but it can be all sorts of things. We ask for people to imagine whether the image is static or moving, whether it's making any gestures, if it has a face, what's its facial expression like, if

it has a voice, what's its voice like. And then crucially, as people are developing this image, we also then ask them to imagine that the image is directing criticism at them, what sort of words is it saying to you, so to get people to say that out loud through the imagery exercise. But then crucially to ask them, what emotion or emotions is this image of your critic directing towards you? the important thing there is, is that you'll get a wide mixture. So sometimes it will be anger, rage.

hostility, disgust, contempt, disappointment, shame, anxiety. and the interesting thing is that they are massively different emotions. They are not the Same emotion. So knowing that as a clinician becomes crucial because when we work with the self critic, we need to know in a way, what sort of, what's it punching with? What's its weapons? What type of emotion? Because a critic that's directing, let's say contempt at you is quite different from a critic that's directing disappointment or anxiety to you. So this is a really crucial bit for us to know and to help our clients to know.

And then a follow up question is, so in the face of this criticism from the image of your self critic, how does that leave you feeling, receiving this? And again, the interesting thing here is that the emotions and feelings can be very different. So again, some people might start with fearful, anxious, panicky, sad, distressed, disappointed, ashamed, but sometimes what you'll also hear are things like angry. or rageful. And so my response, the part of me that's receiving the self criticism can have very

different emotional responses to this. And again, we're going to need to know this because we would deal with those responses in very different ways. Just like in the therapy room, if a client turned up and they're full of anger and rage, the way that you might work with that face to face with that person is quite different. And if they turned up with Or fear, for example. We don't just respond to all emotions in the same way, and that's going to be the case that when we bring compassion to these two separate parts, the critical part of self and the criticized part of self, we're going to want to know what's held inside of this.

natalie_1_07-17-2024_131508: And when you're doing an exercise like that, I mean, we're really talking about when guess you've got that therapeutic relationship with somebody and you've got that trust. chris_1_07-17-2024_131508: Exactly. natalie_1_07-17-2024_131508: This depth of work can activate someone. So when they're thinking about the inner critic and they're in it, in some ways, they are almost reliving it in the moment. And I wondered, have you ever had an experience of when someone's become really distressed in that kind of an exercise and you've had to do a grounding exercise or pull them out of that?

How would you manage that if someone was really struggling because they were getting upset? chris_1_07-17-2024_131508: I have had that a few times. I mean, you're, you're correct that I would not do this session one. I wouldn't do this session three. This would be down the line where I already know the person. they've also got to know me as well. And because we're doing the exercise, I'm tracking them and I'm asking them how they're getting on as they're doing it. So I wouldn't just leave somebody open just to the whole of it. I'm checking in. How is this? Okay. Now. Of course, it might be that we need to support people with some grounding stuff that goes back a little bit to some of the compassionate mind

training that we would have already been doing with people to build the capacity to regulate threat system. But I think one of the crucial things that emerges from this, even if people get upset, it's quite a powerful thing, Because this lives inside our heads, we don't realize the deleterious effect that it's having on us. We put it on the outside and we start experiencing what it's like as an external other directing this to us. And people can be bowled away with just how hostile, just how pernicious, just how potent and powerful this critic is and how awful we feel in the face of this.

So even if people do get distressed, often it's actually a therapeutic gain, if that makes sense, because it is in this bit. I've had clients say, fuck, I never realized how awful this was. It was only when I did this exercise. And one of the bits that we try to round that exercise off with is we ask a couple of questions, you know, does this image of your self critic want to see you do well in life? And then the second question, does this image of your self critic take joy from your happiness?

The interesting thing is with the first question, now and again you'll get people say, yeah I think it does want to see me do well in life, but most people shake their head. When you start asking about does it take joy in your happiness, 99. 9 percent of people I've ever done this with have shaken their head because joy is not an emotion of the self critic. The self critic belongs in the threat system. The threat system has emotions like anger, disgust, anxiety, shame, and so on. It does not have access to pleasurable emotions of things like joy, and it's not bothered about happiness.

It's bothered about you not effing up. It's bothered about not making mistakes. It's bothered about you not being rejected. So it's not really so bothered about you flourishing and your well being. And so in that moment, you can begin to help people to see that whilst with the functional analysis exercise, we saw that on one level, this part is trying to protect you. On this other hand, in this exercise, we suddenly uncovered that the way it does it, the emotional tone of it, and the way it leaves you feeling is horrendous, is awful.

Off the back of that, sometimes where we can go to is a very short backwards and forwards exercise, eyes open, which is, about best teacher. So we try to then say to people, look, If your child, for example, was struggling with maths at school, they're having a really hard time, they were falling behind, they really hated maths. Would you want the image of your self critic to be the teacher of your child? Immediately people shake their head. natalie_1_07-17-2024_131508: mm, chris_1_07-17-2024_131508: Intuitively, I would not want this type of thing on the outside, speaking to somebody who I love and care for and who's struggling.

And then, of course, the follow up bit is, well, how come it's okay that it resides unimpeached inside of here?. And of course Quite challenging for people. And then we can follow that up with what sort of teacher would you like for your child who's struggling with maths? And we can be a little bit playful with it and say, you know, would you want a teacher that says maths is boring? You don't need it. You've got natalie_1_07-17-2024_131508: yeah, yes, chris_1_07-17-2024_131508: so let's go play football. And of course, people shake their head because they know that it's important for kids who are struggling with maths to be able to learn.

So they'll say, I need the teacher to be persistent. I need them to be supportive. I need them to be kind. I need them to be understanding. And of course, what do those qualities sound like? Well, they sound like what we describe as compassion. And so what we're leading people onto here is a recognition that actually, when it comes to compassion and self compassion, this isn't about ignoring problems. It's not about allowing for mistakes. You know, all those fears that we had about letting go of self criticism. A compassionate teacher is also bothered about those things in a kid.

A compassionate path towards you is also bothered about you making mistakes, becoming narcissistic. about being rejected. It cares about those things just as the self critic does. It's just the way it's going to go about dealing with those is vastly different. And so it gives a little bit of a segue then, to then move on to think about how we can specifically bring compassion to the self critic and then to aspects of self when we're struggling. natalie_1_07-17-2024_131508: That's a really lovely exercise. That's an alternative to the, what would you say to a friend, which is

I think, one we're all familiar with, but often I've had the response. Oh, well, I'd tell them, Oh, don't be silly. Oh, we've got a bantering relationship. And so people will often say that they would say the same thing, but you wouldn't get that response when you get them to think about a child or their child. chris_1_07-17-2024_131508: Yeah, exactly. I mean, it's, it's not that there's anything wrong with that questioning. It's just that actually sometimes What we recognize is that people have to learn how to cultivate a compassionate part.

CFT, when we think about developing compassion, whether it's for others or receiving it from others or crucially self compassion, for us, it's like a, it's like a muscle. We have to build The skills, we have to build the capacity, the strength of this, we can't just assume that it's there because for many people, they don't have this, they might have it a bit to others, but even then you can't guarantee that it's got all the components that we might want it to be and certainly to self, it's like saying to somebody who's never heard Japanese before. Oh, well, you know, just just speak Japanese.

I don't know this thing. This is literally like a foreign language to me. I don't even know where to start here. We have to build capacity first, and then we can start putting it to work in a variety of different ways. And this is where the compassionate mind training becomes crucial, that we would suggest that you build, just as you would go down to the gym and there's multiple machines that help to build your biceps, your thighs, your stomach muscles, whatever it might well be. The point here is that we can build the compassionate part of you. We can focus on the physiology of this, which is grounding

and helps to regulate threats. We can build the psychology of this. And the components that become crucial, because the bits that we're going to need are strength and tolerance. So if we're going to engage our self critic, we're going to need to be able to be in the presence of it without getting washed away. We're going to need to have wisdom and understanding about why it's doing what it's doing. We need to be able to see behind it and see the fears that it's trying to cover for. And then thirdly, we need to have a caring commitment to it. But also to why it's doing its role, why it's been picking up and trying to

cover for some of these other fears. And by using that and building up that part, once I'm confident that I've got that part running and working, then I've got some choices for doing some more work with directly engaging with and addressing the self critic. Which of course could be in, I could write a compassionate letter to the self critic. And I could write a compassionate letter to the criticized part of self, the part that receives all of this. I could do some chair work in the way that would typically be done, I guess,

in having the chair for the critical part of self, and then the criticized part of self, and we could have some dialogue going backwards and forwards. But in a CFT way, the tweak that we would make to that is that we would then have a third chair. And what we get people to do is occupy that third chair as their compassionate self. So we have got them already practicing accessing this part of self that is wise, strong and caring. And we would maybe a very brief warming up exercise so that people can feel into this. And then we get them directing compassion either to the critical part of self and having a dialogue there, or of course the criticized

part and doing some dialoguing there. But another way that we do it in the CFT is using imagery. And so this time round, we will get people again to generate an image of their self critic, put it on the outside. But this time around, first of all, what they've done is to imagine themselves stepping into their compassionate self. So occupying a part of self, which they've practiced, which is strong and grounded, which is wise and understanding. It has some understanding about the self critic, why it's there, what its function is, but also has a caring, committed motivation.

And so taking that part into the imagery. We then ask people to see the image of the self critic in front of them, to focus first of all on just being able to be in its presence and tolerating it. So a bit like a tree with deep roots that remains standing through a storm, this idea that your compassionate self can tolerate the hostility, the emotions, the awful words the self critic is chucking towards you. And then once we can stabilize that bit, people feel okay, we might then go to wisdom. So looking out from your compassionate self on this image of your self critic,

what do you understand about why it's there, what it's trying to do? Almost, if you could look behind the self critic, what is it trying to protect you from? And of course, back to the functional analysis one, which is all about fears of making mistakes, rejection and so on. So there's a wisdom here, a little bit like you know, we use the analogy of the Wizard of Oz that when the characters first meet the wizard, this big booming, scary voice, But if you remember from the film, when the curtain gets pulled back, it's this little old scared man. And the point is, is that once you get behind the big booming voice,

the scary voice, often there is something far more vulnerable, far more scared, far more concern behind it. So there's a wisdom to see that. And then the final is that you direct a caring commitment of your compassionate self. You begin to verbalize or direct your compassion at the thing that sits behind the self critic at its vulnerability, at your fears of rejection, at your fears of failure. And what we find is that once you start directing compassion at that thing, the critic starts to lose its' power. And often what people describe as literally the image of the

critic will reduce in size, in power, in its hostility. Or actually all transform into the vulnerability. So I had a client recently who said they had this big, almost like devil, like self critic as an image. But as we started to direct compassion behind the self critic to this vulnerabilities that she had experienced for many years. The image of the critic morphed into a five year old version of her, and it was of course the five year old version who had been experiencing the abuse, had been experiencing the awfulness of life, and so there was this real

moment in which, because in a way for us, the compassionate self represents a secure attachment figure, It's safe haven and secure base functions. It can allow the threat system just to settle down. And once it starts settling down, then, of course, we're more likely to be able to reveal some of those more vulnerable, fearful memories or parts of self. And of course, that's ultimately where we want to be able to do the work. So the self critic is important, but really it's often other parts underneath or behind it that we really want to get to. natalie_1_07-17-2024_131508: For many people listening or watching, they may

be familiar ish with CFT, but maybe haven't done the compassionate mind training or be familiar with some of the things that you're talking about. So for people in that camp doing these imagery, exercise and things. Do you think there's anything that you would be saying to people where they might need to do some work prior to that? Like, is this something that any kind of good counselor or therapist could do? Or do you feel it really does need that grounding in, talking someone

through emotion regulation systems initially, having some of that compassionate mind training, or is it that people can just use as a tool? What would you say to that? chris_1_07-17-2024_131508: I mean, it's interesting, you know, I could take somebody, as long as they're maybe lower in psychological distress, I could take somebody through some of these exercises, and they probably would find them very powerful and quite helpful. But my sense would be the further you get up that dimension of psychological

distress, The more as a therapist when I'm doing this work that you're going to need to know some of the bigger parts of the CFT model because I had lots of experiences where somebody's gone on CFT training. They've heard about an exercise like meeting your self critic with your compassionate self. And then they go and try it with their clients without first having done those different steps with understanding the self critic without crucially having done compassionate mind training and building the part of self to be able to engage. And then, of course, what happens, their clients hate it because basically

they get overwhelmed and they get knocked out of a compassionate orientation into a critical one. And there are some approaches in which you're told that you can shout at your critic and you can get angry at your critic, you can even attack it. whereas for us, the problem with that is, is that the critic's already in the threat system. And if you start attacking it, that's threat system. So it's threat system to threat system. It's amygdala to amygdala. It's like fighting fire with more fire. And if you understand physiology, you understand the evolution of mammals in which we regulate distress through the attachment system, what

we first need to do is cultivate that aspect, that part of our clients that is then able to do the work. And so we're really keen on helping people to understand that process and then using some of the exercises rather than just using an exercise out of context, which, of course, can be very tricky. natalie_1_07-17-2024_131508: In terms of where people can get more information on CFT if they're not familiar or to really understand key components of how an exercise like confronting your Critic would go,

is Balanced Minds the best place? Where would you say is a good place for them to start? chris_1_07-17-2024_131508: Yeah, so on our website, we've got a host of resources linked to Compassionate Mind Training, but also guides to some of these steps that I've just outlined running people through sort of handouts in which they can begin to do this. So I think the Balanced Minds website those are all free, people can access them. And one of the things I guess I've been doing apart from Balanced Minds, which was set up basically to try to bring compassion focused interventions out there into the world outside of the NHS to as many people as possible.

I've also just been trying to find ways of bringing the model in a sort of self helpy kind of way, whether it's writing books doing the app yeah, just a whole bunch of different things of trying to spread the words as much as possible. natalie_1_07-17-2024_131508: Thinking about the resources that people can use outside of sessions. Do you want to just say something about the aim of the app we have so little time in the therapy room with people and what they do outside really does count. I think the app is an amazing way of someone having something in their pocket that they can access at any time.

what's the vision behind that and have the results been? chris_1_07-17-2024_131508: Well, one of the aspects of compassion focused therapy, a significant part of it is called compassionate mind training. So compassionate mind training are the body and mind trainings that anybody can do, which have been shown to. Stimulate aspects of your physiology, like a vagus nerve, attention training, various types of mindfulness work, body posture work, body movement work, breathing rhythm work, using memories, imagery, acting techniques.

There's a whole bunch of things that we will use under the banner of Compassionate Mind Training. But I guess the intriguing thing about Compassionate Mind Training is that it can also be done separately to therapy. They could use the app. And basically, we're taking them through key bits of the CFT model. Now, it's not therapy because, I'm not there with them. I'm not providing a therapeutic relationship that they get to learn. Some psychoeducations and wisdoms about the nature of how hard it is to be human, the three system model, how we've evolved this amazing, but tricky brain. So we give them some insights about themselves.

They can begin to learn about themselves and hopefully have de shaming. And then a whole host of different types of practices that. The points I've just outlined there to you that people can practice and start to use. And then Compassionate Mind Training can also include ways in which we can begin to apply this to ourselves and to difficulties, whether that's to our self critic, whether it's to different parts of self, our angry part, our sad part, our anxious part. And also, of course, in a variety of other different sort of techniques in a way to cultivate compassion. So coming back around to your question, the app and some of the resources

that we have on the Balanced Minds website are set up basically to give people aspects of what they could do in therapy, but outside of therapy. We've got lots of studies now showing that when people do relatively short periods of practice of compassionate mind training, that this brings around significant reductions in shame, in self criticism, in emotion regulation difficulties. Actually, we had a study that was published a couple of years ago, a four week compassionate mind training study that shows significant reductions in anxious attachment, and also avoidant attachment.

So really interesting that we could hit the attachment system through relatively small amounts of compassion based training. And these practices have also been shown in these studies to lead to reductions in things like depression symptoms, anxious symptoms, and increases in well being. Now of course they're not panaceas, there are no panaceas, but the fascinating bit is that these can be used by anybody and it seems to show that it can lead on the whole to significant benefits. Or as a clinician, I might ask my clients to download a copy of the self compassion

app and maybe use that alongside therapy then in which we are discussing, let's say something to do with self criticism. And here's one of the sessions, which is specifically focused in the app on self criticism, which will also help to guide home practice. So I guess it can be used as a alongside therapy tool. Or potentially an outsider therapy tool just to help people to alleviate some of their distress. natalie_1_07-17-2024_131508: Yeah. Yeah. It's so great. I've used it with a few clients and I think people really like having something that they can follow

and that can lead them through because there's, there's practical exercises on there, but there's also the education side. So, if people are not familiar with it, I would highly recommend, I think it's a great resource and something that's much needed. chris_1_07-17-2024_131508: In most of the CFT books, the self help books, there'll be specific chapters on working with shame and self criticism. And so those often give a very detailed guide. in a sort of step by step kind of way. And then if not, they can always email me as well and I can guide them to other things that might be useful. natalie_1_07-17-2024_131508: Well, Chris, thank you so much.

There's loads there that, I'm thinking about clients even in this conversation and it's just inspiring to hear of, some of your success stories as well of when people have made significant progress with this, because I think as a clinician inner critic work Sometimes can feel a bit like a mountain. It's not just a six session piece of work, and maybe it's also important to know that. in terms of our own expectations, but when you are afforded the ability to be able to do the work, it is life changing for people.

Thank you so much for coming on, for sharing I definitely feel inspired. chris_1_07-17-2024_131508: Thank you so much for inviting me. Thank you for listening to this episode of Mastering Therapy. All of the resources mentioned are available in the show notes. If you're interested in getting more information on what's been covered this season, you can sign up to our mailing list or visit the website masteringtherapy. com. If you've listened to this and you've thought of someone you think would be great to interview on the podcast, submit a recommendation on the website. I'd love to hear from you.

Mastering Therapy Podcasts and the information provided by me and my guests is solely intended for qualified professionals for information and educational purposes. I look forward to you joining me next time.

Open the transcript file

Hosts and Guests

Nobody is credited on this episode yet.

Credit the people on this episode

Be the first to rate this episode

More episodes

All episodes
  1. S5E9: A practical take on SEO and AI Search for Therapists

    Nov 19, 202625 minAudio

    S5E9: A practical take on SEO and AI Search for Therapists Can prospective clients actually find your therapy website? In this practical solo episode, Dr Natalie Stott explains how SEO and AI search affect...

    Credit the people on this episode

  2. S5E8: Working with Stuckness in Therapy | Dr Robyn Walser

    Nov 12, 202639 minAudio

    S5E8: Working with Stuckness in Therapy | Dr Robyn Walser EPISODE SUMMARY What do you do when therapy feels stuck and you notice yourself working harder than your client? Dr Natalie Stott is joined by clinical...

    Credit the people on this episode

  3. S5E7 Narcissism in Therapy: Moving past social media labels | Dr Ruth-Ann Harpur

    Nov 5, 202645 minAudio

    S5E7 Narcissism in Therapy: Moving past social media labels | Dr Ruth-Ann Harpur What do you do when a client arrives in therapy convinced that their partner, parent or sibling is a narcissist? In this episode, Dr...

    Credit the people on this episode

  4. S5E6: How to Find Your Therapy Niche with Josephine Hughes

    Oct 22, 202646 minAudio

    S5E6: How to Find Your Therapy Niche with Josephine Hughes Do therapists really need a niche, or is this simply another piece of marketing advice that makes private practice feel more complicated than it already is? In...

    Credit the people on this episode

  5. S5E5: Practical AI for Therapists: Green, Amber and Red Uses

    Oct 15, 202632 minAudio

    S5E5: Practical AI for Therapists: Green, Amber and Red Uses How can therapists make practical use of AI without handing over sensitive information, clinical judgement or half the contents of their inbox? In this solo...

    Credit the people on this episode