Defenders: Two Front Lines - Fraud From the Case File and the Comments Section
1 hr 11 minAudio
Send us Fan Mail Most people experience fraud as a single event. A suspicious text message, a fake investment opportunity, or a phone call from someone pretending to be their bank. The reality is that modern fraud is an organised global economy, powered by criminal networks that continuously adapt their tactics while relying on the same psychological manipulation to deceive victims at scale. Understanding how that economy evolves requires intelligence from two very different front lines: the investigators working to dismantle criminal networks, and the people encountering new scams every day. In this episode, hosts Gary Ruddell and former INTERPOL Director of Cybercrime Craig Jones are joined by cybersecurity educator, strategist and digital safety advocate Caitlin Sarian, better known to millions as "Cybersecurity Girl" to explore the two front lines of the modern fraud economy. Drawing on perspectives from international cybercrime investigations, threat intelligence operations and a community of millions reporting scams as they happen, together they examine what each side sees that the other doesn't and what it takes to transform intelligence into action against a threat that adapts in real time. By understanding who these actors are and how they operate, you can better anticipate threats and protect yourself in an increasingly hostile digital world. Subscribe to learn more about Group-IB's Top 10 Masked Actors - and stay one step ahead in the fight against cybercrime. FOLLOW GROUP-IB Group-IB Threat Intelligence on X: https://www.x.com/GroupIB_TI Group-IB on X: https://www.x.com/GroupIB Group-IB on LinkedIn: https://www.linkedin.com/company/group-ib Group-IB on Facebook: https://www.facebook.com/groupibHQ/ Group-IB on Instagram: ...
Audio and video play straight from the show's own hosting. PodSubs stores and serves no media.
Transcript
From the show. Tap a time to play from there.
Gary RuddellYour data is valuable and it's under attack, but so is your bank account, your identity, your trust in the message that just landed in your inbox. Fraud isn't fringe anymore, it's organized, it's adaptive, and it's scaling with the same technology the rest of us use every day. Today we're talking with two people who each get an early view of the same threat from opposite directions. One from inside the investigations that take fraud networks down, one from the front row of the public actually living through it.
Gary RuddellToday we're joined by Caitlin Sarjan, a globally recognized cybersecurity educator, influencer, and cybersecurity strategy expert with more than a decade of experience in consulting, data privacy, and digital safety advocacy. You may also know her as the Cybersecurity Girl. Caitlin has made it her mission to make cybersecurity accessible to everyone and ensure we are all staying safe online. Caitlin, thanks so much for joining us today. Tell us a bit about yourself and your career so far.
SPEAKER_02Yeah, thanks for having me. I'm so excited to be here. Um honestly, my career is never linear. I feel like most people in cyber, your career is not linear. Um, but I started out as an aerospace engineer. And after school, I wanted to do consulting um after my master's, and I was asked by EY if I was interested in getting into cyber. And in my head, I was like, oh my gosh, sounds like a lot of coding and I'm really bad at it, but I'm not gonna tell them that. So I told them yes. I got the job, and then I was like, you know what? If I don't like it, like I'm I'm intrigued. If I don't like it, I can always change.
SPEAKER_02And I learned everything on the job that was, I think, 13 years ago. And uh that's what kind of inspired me to start the cybersecurity girl channel. So I did cyber consulting for like nine years before going into in-house at TikTok and then eventually quitting and just continuing to really focus on kind of the cybersecurity girl education piece. I felt like there was no one out there helping people understand how scams and frauds impact their everyday lives and how to protect themselves. I always say cybersecurity starts at home.
SPEAKER_02Um, we are all given technology now before we can even speak, but yet no one has taught us how to use it. And it's not like a tech issue. This is not like a corporate issue anymore. That's how cyber started is like, how do we protect the corporations? It's it's an every everyday issue. So much so that I was driving the other day and I was listening to the radio, and I like one of the stations was like AI and algorithms. I'm like, wait, what station am I listening to? And it's like a normal. I'm like, why are we talking? This is crazy. And it just like continues to show how important protecting ourselves from these scams, from these frauds, and just in cybersecurity in general is so important because like we are literally online 24-7, unfortunately or fortunately, depending on who you are.
SPEAKER_02And I just love to like help people understand the risks, how they can protect themselves and and kind of what's out there in that environment. So I'm so happy to be here to talk about this. It's such an important topic. So thanks for having me.
Gary RuddellThanks for taking the time to join us. What um what draws you towards cybersecurity specifically? What's the attraction?
SPEAKER_02So I get bored really easily, and cybersecurity has kind of kept me in its like, you know, grasp for 13 years now because it's constantly changing. It's the environment is there's new threats every day. I mean, now we have AI, and I my job is never gonna go away at this point. I I can't envision a life without any type of cyber. And so for me personally, I just loved being able to learn and adapt and grow with the new technology. Um, and it just kept me busy. And I just think it's so interesting.
SPEAKER_02And now I absolutely love what I get to do. I get to protect everyday people um all day, every day. So like I think it's so important. Before I was a little, you know, the reason why I started was I was like, I'm so tired of protecting corporations. Like, I'm like, I'm tired of like, you know, shielding them from getting fines for data privacy because I started specializing in data privacy about six years into my career. I'm like, I want to help like everyday people. Like most of these people don't even know what's going on. And so for me, like I wake up every morning so excited. Like I make videos every day. Um, I don't batch them, I just like see what's in the news and I get excited about helping and and teaching people.
SPEAKER_02So I think cybersecurity is the coolest area ever. Like it will, it's always growing, it's always changing. Like now with AI, now with and then we're we're going into a quantum area too, where we're like, okay, what's gonna happen with cyber? How are we gonna stay ahead of quantum? I mean, technology is so insane, and we're we're I'm just here for it. I'm here for the ride, and I'm here to here to protect as many people as possible.
SPEAKER_00So I think your journey there is really interesting. So you talk about sort of 13 years ago. Obviously, I'm the uh the elder on this call, shall we say? Um, but same thing, I got into law enforcement because I wanted to protect my community. I wanted to be able to, you know, keep people safe. That that was the bottom line, and we did that in a very localized sense to start with in law enforcement. And a bit like you, my my pathway through to ending up as a director of cybercrime at Interpol, it wasn't linear, it was you bounce around. And I think over that time with with the sort of um cybercrime, it started off, it was businesses, they were the ones.
SPEAKER_00But I remember a couple of my first jobs where I was getting calls from lawyers who were reporting the crime, and the reason they were reporting the crime to the police was because they had to. Um, and you know, there was a a requirement because of the information commissioner's office in the UK, GDPR, that side of it, and actually they wanted to protect the company, and it was almost secondary, I would say, that the people whose data was breached or whatever. Um, there was one particular toy company, shall we say, that was rather large, and the victims of that took out a class action against them and won their class action.
SPEAKER_00And it's really hard. You know, that company was a victim, absolutely, but I think maybe if you have API 123 as your passwords, then you are leaving yourself open to, and I'm not I'm not blaming the company directly, but there is a certain layer of security we have to put in whether a company or an individual as well. And I think what you're doing is shining a light on it, sharing the experiences, you know, giving people those examples that they can really identify with as well.
SPEAKER_02Yeah. No, I love it. I actually I don't know if you knew this, but I lived in the UK for a couple of years during the GDPR era when I was doing my privacy stint. So if I was there when people were reporting, and then it came back to the US for the CCPA stint, and that was like during COVID, I was like, why am I helping these companies? Like they don't even really care about the people. Like, I feel like these people should know how much data these companies are collecting and like how to protect themselves because like otherwise no one's no one is gonna understand like the gravity of the situation.
SPEAKER_00And I think that's where you know potential things like GDPR were actually what should be paid for, they are important because there is an onus. But if you're holding that data, you you're responsible. You know, it's it's like a bank. You are holding something that's important. Yeah, it may not be cash, but actually it can become a cash asset to the criminals, but also as a victim, you can be really, really impacted by by those data thefts as well, which we've seen on numerous examples of.
SPEAKER_02So many examples of how companies are impacted after either a data breach or something along those lines. But uh yeah, it just it's wild to me. I mean, we live in a such a crazy world, and uh I just yeah, I feel like there's a lot, and there's tons of people now helping corporations, right? Like uh protect themselves. But again, there's really not a lot of people translating that to everyday people. And it's both sides. Like, I always talk to people in in in the cyber world. Obviously, I'm always still in it. I'm going to all the conferences, and they're like, really?
SPEAKER_02Like, why are you doing that? I'm like, honestly, I'm helping you. Like these everyday people are also your employees. And to me personally, like, and we're seeing this actually, I think the news just broke yesterday or a couple of days ago about how you know certain hacking groups are already into a lot of the US infrastructure right now and US organizations. And to me, like when I first started, I'm like, it's the everyday people that are going to get duped and scammed and frauded in some way, shape, and form. And like we need to protect those people. And like, and it's those everyday people that are also in charge of our critical infrastructure.
SPEAKER_02And they're not watching the stupid cybersecurity trainings, no offense. They're just not watching it. No one wants to watch it. It's terrible. And so, like, how are we able to translate that? So people actually are intrigued and watching and are aware of what's going on, but not like not scaring them, not like you know, there's no like fear-mongering. It's just like, okay, here's what's happening and how you can protect yourself and then like share it. Because honestly, and I'm sure we'll go through this in the uh in the podcast, like people are so ashamed when they get scammed. But I honestly if you ask like your group, I guarantee you there's one person in your group that's probably been scammed or frauded in some some way, shape, or form, but they're so embarrassed to talk about it.
SPEAKER_02And I'm like, no, we need to stop that shame and embarrassment because we need to start talking about it in our groups because otherwise people won't think that it's happening to them. And really, it's like happening to thousands and thousands of people every year. Um, so I'm I'm excited to get to kind of dive into this this podcast.
Gary RuddellYeah, it's it's a lot of people impacted. I think uh in last year's high-tech criminal trends report, uh, there was over 80 criminal infrastructures behind all the romance scams and the sextortion scams across like 14 countries, hundreds of arrests, group IBs, intelligence helped to you know take down all of that. But like that's not somebody messaging you directly to scam you. It's like a whole organized infrastructure built to like exploit people at scale, you know. Caitlin, you see this from an individual victim perspective in your DMs and your inbox, I'm sure.
Gary RuddellTalk us through what that looks like.
SPEAKER_02Yeah, I mean, so there's there's well let's just break down what a scam is versus a fraud, right? Because I feel like people are like are a little confused. I'm always like, okay, which one are we talking about? Basically a a scam is a fraud, but a fraud is also has its own little thing. So scams are all frauds. Fraud is and scams basically like they're trying to extort you for usually for money purposes. Now, a fraud can also be like, and and and the person is like kind of willingly in it, right?
SPEAKER_02A scam, a person is willingly in a fraud, they can do it without your knowledge. So that's kind of the difference. One's like a fraud can be like I'm I'm doing identity theft, and that person has no idea that they're involved in it. But a scam is like uh you reused the credential and I gone into your account and now I'm doing identity theft. So it's it's a little bit different. One's like a person's like actively in it, and the other sometimes like a person can be out of it. Craig, is that kind of how you define it? That's kind of I don't want to make sure.
SPEAKER_00Yeah, I mean, I suppose I I also have to come back to legislation. So it depends on the legislation of a country. And again, this is this language piece that we have. So obviously, this is this is global international and an Interpol, you know, you would go to one country and say, Well, actually, that's not a crime here. And you think, well, it's not why it's not a crime because their legislation hasn't caught up. We're using legislation which has been added to or amended, and it's a bit like a retrofit. Retrofits never really work that well.
SPEAKER_00So, for example, in the UK, you can't steal um data under the Theft Act, which is an old act. So we compute uh we made the Computed Misuse Act, and data comes under that. But when you're having these conversations, and also we just did the United Nations work for new cybercrime convention, so we had a you know hundred and two hundred countries sat in a room at the UN discussing cybercrime, and this was the diplomats. So you're trying to have this very in-depth, let's get um, you know, a new global convention out there through the UN, a new sort of treaty effectively on cybercrime.
SPEAKER_00But we just couldn't agree the language. We you know, if you would say one thing and one and it would mean something else somewhere else as well. So I think that the the bottom line for me is if someone is hurt, if someone loses money, if someone loses data, that's gonna be a crime of some sort. Um, but actually stepping out about how do we prevent it in the first instance. I think that's the key to this. How do we prevent it? How do we make it as hard as possible to criminals, but make it as easy as possible for for you and me as a normal individual that we are protected?
SPEAKER_00And maybe we don't even know that we're protected because someone else is doing it, but hopefully we don't have to pay for it. But actually, there is a cost in this as well.
SPEAKER_02And I I love that question. And I go just quickly, just a fun fact about going back to like how are we defining it and like what does that look like? I I always ask this question do you spell cybersecurity with like one word or two words? Like people, and it's because in the US, for specifically in the US, the US government actually spelled it when they wrong or both ways in the initial document about cybersecurity, you know, 20, I think it was around 20 years ago when they were coming up with this massive document. So it's technically spelled both ways, and it's the second same with like terms, right? Everyone has these different terms, and it's like at the end of the day, it's a scam or a fraud.
SPEAKER_02You're like, you're probably losing money. And like, how do you protect yourself, right? And so for me, I'm always like the US came out with, and I think the UK kind of goes along with this, is like if you do um, you know, a few things, you prevent like 90. I don't remember what the actual percentage is, like 96% of scams and frauds, which is you know, have strong and unique passwords. I I want to say for all your accounts, but that's really not likely for most people. So for your key accounts, your the accounts that are most important, you know, have software updates turned on. Like you want to automatically have updates on.
SPEAKER_02You want to turn on multi-factor authentication wherever possible. And then kind of like, I always say, like, just don't click on links if that's possible. But I mean, what going back, Gary, to what your question was of like what I see, I see every type of scam, right? I will say I think it's really important to talk about. Oh, when you think of scams, you think of like, oh, I don't want my parents to get scammed or my grandparents to get scammed. But in reality, it's these younger people too. We just don't have as much. I'm not gonna we, I'm putting myself in a younger group, but like the younger kids have don't have as much to um like monetary to lose, so they're not really paid that much attention to.
SPEAKER_02Um, but like I get messages like again, thousands of messages a day from kids that have like lost access to their social media accounts. And you might be like, well, it's social media, but here's the thing is like for Snapchat specifically or any account that has like disappearing pictures, I've seen so many younger kids come into my messages being like, I lost access to my Snapchat. Now they're taking the pictures that were like saved only in my Snapchat role that were supposed to disappear, and they're like kind of exort like export like exploiting me with this.
SPEAKER_02Like, how do I get it back? So, yes, it might not be monetary, but there's so many types of scams and frauds. And honestly, I like to point out two things scams and frauds go both ways, right? They can either hack my account and like fraud me and scam me in some way to get into my account, um, and either use it against me, like trying to extort money from me, saying, Hey, I have your photos, I'm gonna release it unless you pay me. Or they can use my account to scam other people, and that's happening too, right? So we see that all the time.
SPEAKER_02And I think it's just so, so important. Well, one, just a little blanket statement, nothing that you do online is ever gonna disappear. So why don't you remind your kids that? Because it's if you don't want your parents, your grandparents, or your teacher to see whatever you're posting, just don't post it or do anything with it. But I think the other thing to think about is that like this scams are rampant and they don't care who you are. They really don't. They just want most of the time, they just want money. They want to figure out how they can extort you and get money from you in some way, shape, or form. And don't ever say, oh, it doesn't matter.
SPEAKER_02I'm a nobody. I always say burglars like to go for a house that's unlocked versus a house that's locked. So you might as well take the simple steps that you can, like we talked about, to kind of harden up your house a little bit, protect yourself.
SPEAKER_00I think Kelly, what what you're saying is really important because I remember one of the first presentations I gave at Interpol um was in Korea back in 2019. So my first main presentation, and I started off with a picture of my mum and her granddaughter, so my brother's son's daughter. And I said, look, here's an example then of how how can these people potentially be victims of cybercrime? My mum's not connected to the internet, so how can she be a victim? I said, but the one I'm already worried about is is the two-year-old, my niece next to her, because her mum and dad are posting stuff already about her online, and just recently in the UK, we've had the warnings about you know making sure you it's closed down because what criminals are now doing is taking images of children, they are turning them into sort of pornographic images, things like that as well, then extorting people and things like that.
SPEAKER_00So again, the criminals are using it in a different way, and you know, you can do it in an innocent way, you know, because you're sharing with friends, and like you said, about Snapchat as well. But the criminals will look to exploit that in whatever way they can, unfortunately. And like you're saying, once it's out there, it is out there effectively.
SPEAKER_02And I think it's so I I've been telling it, at least people in the US too, like you posting your kids, like everyone's like, oh, it doesn't matter. Like, obviously, we have there's like three main reasons, right? The main reason to me is like identity theft, because in the US, like you don't, you're not gonna recognize identity theft, or like you're not gonna see anything if like if they pretend to be your kid, if they start taking out loans in your kids' names, you're not even gonna know until you start, you know, 18 years later, which is way too late. Um, so I'm always like, okay, there's identity theft, there's like AI scams, and then there's also just again going back old school, like the physical risks, right?
SPEAKER_02Like, so for example, if you have a public profile and you tag your grandma or you say, like, grandma Susie, right? Grandma Susie and my and my daughter, then a scammer then knows your grandma's name, right? And it makes it that much more believable to start messaging your your daughter or your son and saying, hey, like I'm friends with grandma Susie, like whatever. Like, then it seems more real. And so all the stuff that you kind of put on out online just creates, I we always call it a digital footprint, but it creates such a large digital footprint about you.
SPEAKER_02And now with AI being so easily accessible, I don't think people realize that it takes like 30 seconds to just scrape the internet with pretty much every public-facing thing that you have and really create a unique profile to start targeting you. And that's more like the physical aspect. But then there's obviously again the AI aspect, which is this disgusting and so disturbing, especially with identity theft, you're really shooting them in the foot because like it once they like start building credit, like you can't, it's impossible to get your credit back if you if you have identity theft as a as a child.
SPEAKER_02So you really just like you need to protect yourself, but you also need to protect your kid. And I always just say, like, okay, I always ask because people like, well, why can't I share it? And like, why would you share it? Why, why, like, why do you feel the need to share it? And usually that question kind of stops people in their tracks, right? They're like, Well, actually, I don't know. I just wanted to like share it. I'm like, okay, well, create an account and only add, like, you know, 20 family members and make it private. That then you can share it. Then all the people that you know will still see it, right? But if you have a public account, you're sharing it with the world.
SPEAKER_02And then even if you like, okay, you went from a public account to a private account. I always preface this. I'm like, you still don't know who randomly added, like, you know, accepted you or added you. So you still have potentially a bunch of strangers that are that are following you.
Gary RuddellCraig, is there a type of fraud that you're more likely to see than Caitlin? Like Caitlin's seeing the sort of front lines of like random people from 15 to 50 to beyond. What do you see at Interpol? How does that, you know, what's the difference there?
SPEAKER_00I suspect Caitlin would get there first in terms of because people know who she is, they're gonna contact her. So actually, the trends that we see are probably gonna be after Caitlin. Um, you know, when we went through the whole COVID thing, they jumped on COVID, when we went through the sort of romance scam things, when we're going through the sort of AI and crypto piece at the moment, um, sex torsion, things like that. I suspect Caitlin will see those first because inherently people do not always report these scams or frauds to law enforcement, and this can be for a number of different reasons.
SPEAKER_00I think we've already highlighted the the embarrassment factor. Um, sometimes they're reports law enforcement because there's a regulatory need to, so their lawyers advise the companies to report it, but as individuals, it's not always reported, I would say. I don't know, is that your being your experience, I guess, as well, uh Caitlin, in in around that?
SPEAKER_02Yeah, I feel like because they am like a trusted person online, they want to like ask me. So I they do tell me a lot of stuff. But when I talk to them, a lot of people just don't know how or where to report it. Like they don't know who to go to. I don't know if it's necessarily because they're ashamed. I think there's so many people that want to report, but like they just don't know where, and they also don't see the point because they're like, I'm not gonna get my money back, probably, or it's like not enough to get it back. And then I know some people that have actually even reported it and they're like, they didn't even help at all. Like they just told me, like, oh, we shouldn't have done that, and you know, like moved on, which is even worse.
SPEAKER_02It just depends. And then and I think from every government standpoint, too. And in the US, every state has and even every county has completely different rules and regulations around like what reporting looks like, what who and what can help. Like, I think it just I wish there was a way that like you know, one place where you could report any scam, or like maybe there's like a I don't know, it create is there a way? I have no idea.
SPEAKER_00Yeah, yeah. I mean, you look it I see free um in the US, they take reports on but also they take international reports. Now they may not investigate them, but what that where that helps is is you start getting the trends, you start seeing the patterns effective. I was in Boston back in April, and the Attorney General's office in Massachusetts, they're doing a huge amount around investigation and protecting the victims from frauds and scams, especially elders and the younger generation.
SPEAKER_00But it's done on such a local ad hoc level. And as we know, you know, US is huge. You've got the federal side, you've got the state side, you've got the county side. And, you know, where the crimes are totally borderless. For us in the law enforcement, it's a nightmare because we are totally surrounded by borders and legislation. And when we try and cross things over and what data we can share, and that's where organisations such as Interpol are really, really important. We'll probably talk about that a little bit later. But I think it can be difficult because people say, Well, I don't really know how to report.
SPEAKER_00And in the UK, we had a we've got a fantastic way. It used to be called action fraud. I think it's called report fraud now. So you've been a victim of online crime, you're going to have to go online to report your crime. Well, probably the last thing you want to do is get online to report that. But that's that's the way it works. You can't go to wait, sorry, you can go into a police station if they're open in the UK and make a report, but it's just then tapped straight up onto a centralized system and goes off into the City of London police, one of 43 police forces in the UK, although they have the national league for it.
SPEAKER_00You know, we struggle as law enforcement to understand what's going on in the in our different uh departments, etc., and expecting the members of the public to get that. So again, that's why we come back to the prevention police is so important because it doesn't matter who you are, where you are, you know, the vulnerabilities and systems and networks are going to be very, very similar. The scams are going to be very similar. They will make them and localize them to a region or an area or make them very local to a person if you know they are a big target and they've been working on for a while.
SPEAKER_00But yeah, it it for me, the prevention piece is absolutely key.
SPEAKER_02Yeah. Craig, I have a question for you because I love talking to people about this and they're like, how do I prevent it? Obviously, we talked about like certain measures that you could take, right? But like, what are some like signs of scams or frauds that you see all the time? I'll I'll start with a couple, but there's so many. For me, I'm like, if they ever ask for like gift cards or crypto payment, uh, it's a red flag. If they tell you not to tell anyone or don't like don't contact anyone, it's a red flag. And if there's any sort of like urgency, like you have to do this now, you can't hang up the phone, it's a red flag.
SPEAKER_02But what other red flags like you tell your family about about like to protect themselves with the scam?
SPEAKER_00I mean, you know, for for me, it's it's I keep getting texts at the moment on my normal phone number. Obviously, my number's in the system somewhere, and I keep getting that the gambling companies or whoever called it, oh, you you have this credit, you've won this big prize, we've been trying to contact you. Uh, one of my sons is very similar, he does like betting on the football, so he gets things. And he said, Dad, I got just don't click on it. Are you expecting it? No, you know, just don't just don't click on anything like that. Um, then we go through the cycles of the yearly um tax returns.
SPEAKER_00So normally something comes up at that time, and we still have the sort of uh African princes and the the money on on that side, but I think one of the things we've seen quite a lot in the UK, but also uh yeah globally as well, is uh the celebrities' endorsement um of fake you know the the the AI ones. I think Martin Lewis is a really good example of UK. We we've got a financial guru who is all over the place and he gives great advice.
SPEAKER_00But one of the things he's now had to start tagging is he does not endorse anything. So he's as part of his advice now if you see me endorsing something, it's a scam. But people still see it, they think it's a good deal, there's a quick get rich quick scheme or something like that, and and they jump up.
SPEAKER_02Another red flag, by the way. Anything that you could get rich quick is a red flag.
SPEAKER_00Yeah. Or you've invested so much when you have to pay something to get the money out, those sort of things.
SPEAKER_02Yeah, the investment scams I've seen a lot of too. It's yeah, there's so many.
Gary RuddellThe one the Brad Pitt one, the lady in France, the French interior designer who got hit with the Brad Pitt scam. I mean, if Brad had called me, I might have been tempted to indulge that, but uh yeah, that was all AI, wasn't it? I think it was his someone pretended to be Brad Pitt's mother and said that he couldn't get access to his money because of his divorce with Angelina. So we're contacting you. Can you send him some money? And I think they sent like a million dollars over like a year and a half or something.
SPEAKER_02Yeah, I I will say I feel like we a lot of people want to talk about AI AI scams and a lot of that stuff. Like, but at the end of the day, it's the generic basic scams that get everyone like the AI scams are always fun to talk about, and like that's great, but at the end of the day, it those aren't, I mean, those are a lot more complex, complicated scams, and they're not happening as often right now. I know in the future they will be happening a lot more often, but we don't have the technology right now, or at least a lot of the scammers don't have the technology to do that at this point in time.
SPEAKER_02But I'm like, don't scams come in every shape and size, right? Like, don't think that it needs to be like sophisticated. Like one of the biggest scams in the US and works so well was the toll scam, where they were people are getting text messages about missing a toll. And it almost like I almost fell for it because I I got it. It scams happen at like the perfect time when you're about to click on it, right? Like it's like the the people that fall for it, it's like the right time, right place. They hijack your brain and it kind of just like works. But I don't even drive here.
SPEAKER_02I live in Florida, I don't have a car here. I always said I'll buy one when I need it, and I just haven't needed it. But when I went back home to LA, I drove for the first time in like a year. I like drove my old car at my parents' house and I got the toll text like before any of it happened. Like it was like right at the beginning before anyone even started talking to me about, oh, did you get a weird toll scam? And I texted my mom being like, Mom, I thought we had like a toll pass in our car. Like, I just got a text message as I'm like, I don't think I drove on any tolls. Like, I didn't click on it because my rule of thumb is I will literally never click on a link.
SPEAKER_02I I don't care if it's a trusted friend on LinkedIn that's like, oh my gosh, check out what I will not. I'll be like, I you know, I don't click on links. Like, like take a picture of it and send me the picture, or I don't know, tell me tell me the actual manual link to go to or and I'll go, I'll find it myself. Um, but I didn't click on it, but I like almost I was like, that's so weird. Like I don't think I drove on a toll, but like it that's how scams work. It's just like the right place, the right time, and you're not thinking clearly. And I think also the other thing to like debunk is scams like literally like know how to hijack your brain.
SPEAKER_02Like it's not a personal thing. It's like it doesn't mean that you're not smart, it doesn't mean whatever. It's just you're at the right place at the right time, not fully paying attention, or just like you know, you got caught up in the whole scam, right? The whole scam is about like urgency and to hijack your brain and to make you not think and to make you react. It's an urgent thing. So yeah, I don't even remember what you're talking about, but the whole point is like scams just know how to do it. So don't ever feel ashamed or embarrassed about potentially getting scammed because, like, oh, I know what we're talking about.
SPEAKER_02We were talking about like what types of scams get you, and again, it's uh it could be the everyday, the easiest scams ever. Like that whole scam was based on your phone number, right? So, like I have a I grew up in LA, I have an LA phone number, and I just happened to be LA in LA when I was driving, and of course, it was like your LA toll, whatever. And it was like very specific to the different states, and it was based on phone numbers, so it just seemed you know more more targeted. But yeah, it's uh it doesn't matter what type of scam it is, it it's just time, place, and how they how kind of how they get you.
SPEAKER_00So I had one while interpol, I had someone contact me and say, Um, Craig, I've just received um a fine from you. I said, What do you mean you received a fine from me? And they got a very well-crafted email, very officially looking, with Craig Drain's director of cybercrime at Interpol, uh, has issued this summons or a fine or something. You have to pay this ASAP.
SPEAKER_02So again, you know, I suppose Craig, how rude of you to not even tell your friend that you issues.
SPEAKER_00Terrible, but like I issues too here.
Gary RuddellThat can work as a good scam. You you could send out thousands of those, and then when the police turn up, they'd be like, Well, obviously, you wouldn't have sent it. Someone's trying to hijack your identity. Yes, officer, that's right. But actually, it is you.
SPEAKER_00Not me. Not me. I know I'm retired now from that side of it, but uh no, it's not one you have, so definitely.
Gary RuddellYeah, and in like offensive security land, when you know people talk about you know hackers getting into websites and things like that. I try and tell people like, if you're gonna put a website online, assume that the minute it goes live, it's instantly under attack by automated things. It's not people, no, no one's looking out for your new little bakery or you know, website that you've made. No one's paying attention to you. It's just it's bots, it's like automated. And I guess scams and things, it's kind of like maybe bird strikes.
Gary RuddellYou know, birds are always flying in the air, scams are always going on, but your plane happened to be in the same place at the same time as these birds, and it hit the engine, and that's when you had a problem. Um, is there anything you saw in your inbox, Caitlin, like, and you could see a pattern building before it hit the mainstream media? Could you see something coming? Does that ever happen to you?
SPEAKER_02Yeah, but I'm very like, I don't want to ever sound alarms to people without like knowing that a lot of people are getting it. So the toll thing I got a lot of, and uh, that was like maybe a month and a half after I got that toll. I was, I I just ignored it. I didn't think it was gonna be like such a widespread scam. Um, that was like a massive one. Uh, in the US, they were um, there was like a letter kind of scheme, which was very, very specific. But basically in the US, there's a lot of data brokers. Our data is pretty much everywhere.
SPEAKER_02You know, we our our country likes a lot of money and they sell a lot of data for a lot of money and it just goes around in circles. It's really fun to live here sometimes. But um, they were taking the data off of these public data broker sites and sending letters in the mail of a picture of the house that people were living in and saying, like, hey, we're in your house, you know, we're we've been watching you, but don't worry, we'll be really nice, we'll be kind, we'll we'll leave if you just pay us in crypto. And it's so real because again, if you if you still live there, a lot of times, if if which is usually pretty accurate, because you know, if you buy a house too, you're it's public record.
SPEAKER_02So a lot of people like still live there. That was their house, and they just got the picture off on Google Maps, Google image. So it looked like these people really like knew where these people are. Uh, the scammers knew where the people were, and it got so many people. So I got a lot of messages about that. Actually, my cousin got it first, and she was like, Have you gotten this? I'm like, no, but that's crazy. But also, like that picture's from Google Maps, so it's not that they haven't shown you any images like inside your house, right? They're showing you a picture outside, which anyone can get. But like again, if I got that and I wasn't in cyber, I would be freaking out.
SPEAKER_02Um, and I had like, you know, at least 20 people message me about that. Um yeah, there's just so many, like the QR code scams I get a lot of too. But the issue is that those are kind of very specific in different areas. But I've heard so many about QR codes. I also heard a lot about like, you know, Amazon scams of like getting random packages in the mail, either from Amazon or otherwise, and there would be a Q QR code in the box, and they'd scan the QR code and then they'd like enter, I think, their Amazon details or something, and then they kind of get scammed that way.
SPEAKER_02It was just like a random tchotchke or whatever, like a book or something. So there's a lot of uh interesting ones that I see. I wish I could see all of them, but again, I get like I get thousands. I I need I'm trying to come up with an fun fact. I'm trying to come up with an AI bot that will scrape all the stuff and kind of come up with like a trend report of like what people are saying saying in the messages because I want to be able to like see them a little bit better right now. I mean, I don't social media is technically my job kind of part of it, but I don't I use it for a job, right? I don't like go on and like read everyone's messages, it's just it would be impossible.
SPEAKER_02But I really wish there was a better way for me to to see see some of the scams before. But like again, when I have the ability to kind of go through messages in certain times of the day, I've I've seen a whole lot. And then also like let's let's bring up that you know tech crimes trend report again because I know that I I think I read in the the the report that there was like 4,055 ransomware attacks in 2025 in the US um alone, which is crazy. So I I see a lot of ransomware attacks with small business owners that message me um asking, like, what do I do?
SPEAKER_02Like they uh, you know, they got in and now they're holding basically holding my business for ransom and I can't get back in. Um but I again attacks come in all shapes and sizes. And the whole point is like, you know, do kind of the technical bits, the password, the software updates, the multi-factor authentication, and then be just aware of like the triggers and the warnings and like don't act urgently. Like I always say, even with sales too, I'm like, if anyone's trying to convince me to buy something and I'm not ready, it's a huge red flag.
SPEAKER_02Like anyone, I'm and I tell people like if I'm even with like technology, right? Like, I'm obviously I run a business. I'm like, if anyone's trying to push me into buying whatever piece of technology they want me to buy, I'm like, you are immediately going in a bin as a red flag because let me think about it and get back to you. Don't don't try to push me into this. So I always try to tell my friends like any urgency, just take a step back. There is a company called Take Nine, it's a nonprofit, and it's basically like take nine seconds to kind of get remove yourself from the situation. It's such an amazing, like I love, I talk about it all the time.
SPEAKER_02But remove yourself from the situation. And sometimes I always say it's actually easier sometimes if you get a buddy, right? So my mom is my my buddy, and my mom, anytime she gets a message, she just doesn't click on anything, she just knows to screenshot it and send it to me. Because that gives you obviously more than nine seconds and it gives you a second perspective, right? So you're not in it by yourself, you're not like rushing around, like, oh my gosh, I have to get this done. So I always say, like, get a buddy and just like be like, hey, anytime I get some weird message, I'm just gonna send it to you and you do the same with me.
SPEAKER_02And then we can kind of keep each other, you know, grounded a little bit so we don't get caught up in the in the urgency.
Gary RuddellCraig, from an investigative standpoint, how much or how useful would it be to get your hands on Caitlin's reporting? Would that be useful in producing formal intelligence?
SPEAKER_00Yeah, you're a mind reader. I think you know, this is where a lot of the sort of threat intelligence is going now. So it's that predictiveness of it. So seeing those early signs, those early signals, but then also attributing that to you, you spoke then about small businesses having ransomware attacks. So, okay, what does that look like? And what you can start doing that is cross-referencing other data sets as well, and this is where AI does add value. So we're looking at big data sets.
SPEAKER_00How do we crunch those numbers? How do we extract from that myriad of data actual intelligence? And this is how then we can go after the criminals. Group IB are greater doing this. This is why group IB and other companies work directly with Interpol because they can pull and leverage on that data, they can then turn that into actual intelligence because the only people that can put their hand on a criminal's shoulder is the law enforcement, but they can only do that when they've got the right data and information, and also it's shared in a timely manner as well.
SPEAKER_00So you look at some of the operations that Interpol have been doing, you know, going back to when I was there, but also now, we we we have teams across the globe coordinating activities, looking at the infrastructure, so going after the infrastructure of criminals, taking down the infrastructure. But one of my main mantras has always been follow the money. And we're losing ourselves in this AI bit a little bit, but at some point they need that money, and whether they leave it in crypto, whether they cash it out, that's where they're really vulnerable.
SPEAKER_00Because if you take that away from them, that then hurts them effectively. So being able to identify those money mule networks, being able to find those bank accounts, those wallets, and then go after them, seize them. Um, Interpol's doing another thing at the moment called silver notices, so that's when we see suspicious activity and transactions. So again, trying to get quicker, trying to get ahead of the criminals so you can intercept that money as it's bounced around accounts and things like that is really, really important.
SPEAKER_00And you know, we're not look look we're not working in that localized environment now, are we? You know, we are working cross-border, so being able to communicate through systems and networks with Interpol, Europol, Afropol, and others is absolutely critical.
Gary RuddellThat was going to be my next question. What regional differences are there? In fact, did do you see any differences across regions, Caitlin? Like, is there things that happen like just in Thailand that don't happen anywhere else, or is everything everywhere at this stage?
SPEAKER_02I think it's everywhere. Again, scams come in all shapes and sizes, scammers come in all shapes and sizes. I think something that we didn't hit on today, too, is like a lot of scammers are like it actually like human traffickers, right? Like some of these scammers don't have any other option but to like be forced in a room and do these call centers and like they don't they're not even allowed to leave until they get someone, right? Like I see I don't want to empathize or sympathize with any of the scammers, right? Like, I don't want people like, oh, poor scammers. But at the same time, I think it's it's a business.
SPEAKER_02And like some of these, like a lot of these people get like human traffic, like they are told, hey, you have a job in Dubai, we're gonna pay you this much. They go to Dubai and they get trapped and they literally get like stuck into the scamming world and they don't have a way out. So, like, people are like, Why would anyone want to be a scammer? Most of these people don't have options, right? Like, they have to provide for their family, they have to like continue on. Like, this is what they have to do, and it's it's awful. Like, it's a whole cycle of just everyone's getting scammed all the time, right?
SPEAKER_02Those the scammers got scammed into doing the scamming, and now they're also scamming other people. And I think it's I think it's just it's I wish that there was a way to stop it, honestly. Um, but I uh going back to your main question of like, is it different? I I really don't think so. Obviously, like there's not gonna be toll scams in Thailand, but the foundation of scams and frauds are pretty much always the same, right? It's like, and most of the time it's for money. Uh obviously, there's a lot of different types of reasons why people hack, right?
SPEAKER_02But for scams and frauds, it's usually monetary. Um, and they will do whatever it takes to get that money, whether they're gonna pretend to be Brad Pitt, whether they're going to, or like any type of romance scam, um, which are really easy nowadays because there's so much public information about random strangers online that you could just pull their information out. Um, whether it's you know identity theft or um, you know, you're reusing your passwords, and so it makes it it makes it a little bit of an easier target. I mean, it's all about hijacking your brain, it's all about urgency, it's about like just getting you at the right time at the right place and and then fully kind of extorting individuals from there.
SPEAKER_02So I don't know, I don't see that much of a difference, but Craig probably has a little bit of a different I don't know if you have a different perspective because you see it at Interpol, but yeah, I I think you know we we've seen this whole digital transformation across industry, and the criminals have done the same thing.
SPEAKER_00So we're looking at these modern cybercrime syndicates effectively. They they operate as a decentralized technology firm, but they have specialist division of labor that could be in the same country, same compound, it can be in different countries, different continents. So you've got like a leadership and financing team, and they there they run it and set it all up effectively, so they arrange the infrastructure, investments, um, you know, bring up the servers, all that sort of thing, and also look at jurisdiction hopping as well, potentially.
SPEAKER_00Then you've got tech and logistics. So they like any ICT team, they're looking to build that and maintain that infrastructure and that fraudulent trading platform, making it look real to someone. Then you've got those sort of frontline operators, and these I think these are ones that have been trafficked effectively. So low-level workers within that ecosystem, um, they run the boiler operation, they manage hundreds of fake social media accounts, personas, translation, and then we've got the money mule side of that as well. So you have these money mules that are set up, you've got financial managers, where's the best place to cash this out?
SPEAKER_00How do we bring all that money together? How do we get it back into the financial system? How do we get that cash out of the country? So, you know, it's a really big, complicated network. And if you go back in the day, you used to maybe have a village in Eastern Europe, a couple of people in that village would start making money. They would then bring their neighbors in, and the neighbors would start doing it. It was a localized operation, but now the operation doesn't need to be localized anymore. You know, it's really decentralized, really spread out around the world, but also sometimes bringing everybody into one place.
SPEAKER_00And we've seen the scam centres operating out of Southeast Asia, where the jurisdiction is a little bit harder to get into. Um, but interesting, just recently we've seen a lot of sort of Chinese organized crime groups operate in these areas, and actually, China has now started focusing on these groups. And the reason they've started focusing on these groups, in my humble opinion, is because individuals. Have been impacted in China. So their adoption of digital technology and AI now they've really embraced it, but they're now finding that their citizens are being scammed and they are having money taken off them.
SPEAKER_00So they are starting to do something about it. It's like any priority, isn't it? It's we used to have I used to have um high harm, uh high volume, uh, high interest cybercrimes. The high interest one is normally the government one. Once you get a politician involved um in it, suddenly it starts raising up the agenda in the government um a little bit more, and then you get the resourcing put onto it as well.
Gary RuddellCaitlin, AI, the two magic letters that are the bane of my life these days. How is AI changing all of this?
SPEAKER_02Oh man, I mean, in every way possible, it's changing. So let's look at it from the scammer side on how you can get information first, right? AI is making it so much easier to scrape all the open source intelligence, open source data. So anything from Google, public websites, if you're ever in the news, if you're ever social media, um, I just did a video about wedding registries. If you've ever had a wedding registry that's public, obviously it's most of the time it's public because you need people to sign in. Although I did have a friend recently have a password for her wedding registry, so you can do that.
SPEAKER_02But it scrapes all this information and it makes you such an easier target because obviously if you get it an email that's specific to you, right? Like, oh, your wedding registry, like I'm your your friend, whatever is I'm I'm like a mutual, I'm a mutual friend with you, and we both play pickleball and we both have dogs. It's it's so specific, it doesn't feel like a skim, it feels like a friend. So from like a from a data perspective, it makes it so much easier to find information and target individuals.
SPEAKER_02Also from a data perspective, it makes it a lot easier to group certain people and and target rather than individuals, target groups of people, right? And then on top of that, if you look at let's look at like the ways people scam, right? We have phishing, which is which is like the fake text messages, scam text messages, right? I and I'm gonna say all these terms and know that I hate them and I'm just translating them because I don't ever use these terms. I think they're terrible. I think as a cyber professional, we should get rid of all weird tech terms. So there's phishing, which is text messages. There's or no, sorry, phishing is emails.
SPEAKER_02There's smishing, which is text messages, there's quishing, which is QR scams. So like there's all these things in general, they're scams, right? But AI makes it a lot easier to send, you know, detailed emails that are pretty and they're not like the Nigerian prints with a bunch of issues on it, and they don't have like pixelated images anymore because we have AI that can generate images. So it makes the actual scamming part too. Not only like does it make it easy to find and group information and people together, but it makes compiling the actual scam a lot easier because they can have AI write it for them.
SPEAKER_02They can have AI generate a realistic photo, they can have AI generate a realistic video, like we talked about earlier about how there's you know all these celebrity endorsements that are popping up that aren't celebrities. So not only is it making it easier to get all this information, group people, et cetera, target target people, target groups, it's making the actual scam seem a lot more believable. And I always say we can't fight AI without AI. So, okay, how are we using AI for good then, right? Like, how are we using AI to start figuring out the scam tactic tactics a little uh a little bit earlier so we can prevent it better?
SPEAKER_02How are we using AI to kind of comprehend these big groups of data? How are we using like so we just need to start figuring out how can we use AI to combat AI, but I mean, it's drastically changed the threat landscape and honestly the scam and fraud landscape completely, like in the last two years. And I know I always have viral videos of like, how can you tell if it's if it's a deep fake? And I mean, the video that I showed was like if you show three fingers, it kind of like ruins it. But like there are still some deep fakes that can pass that test, right?
SPEAKER_02So we see all different levels of AI being used, and it just makes it that much more believable for people, so makes it that much more um urgent for people to start sharing stories and testimonials of what happened to them or if they got breached or whatever. And I'm like, I'm always I'm on the scam side of social media, so I I like search for like scam calls and messages, and I like message people on the platforms, be like, thank you for sharing, because like more people need to see this. But yeah, AI has completely changed the cybersecurity, and I actually feel like it's brought cybersecurity more public than ever because it's just impacting so many people's lives.
SPEAKER_00Yeah, so just uh just follow up, Kevin. I think the way the scams are working now, what the criminals are doing, there was one reported in Singapore the police investigated um just back in May, I think it was reported. The victim lost uh 3.8 million US dollars. Uh a call was put together, like a Zoom call, and they take in videos um from different places. So, Prime Minister Lawrence Wong back in 2022, he was on a video conference during COVID. So they'd taken that video, they spliced it in with another, and the whole point of that call was saying we need to coordinate action around the straight-up or moves.
SPEAKER_00So, again, something's very current at this moment. So they set up a fake webinar, um, they fabricated this whole story, they had people sat together where they'd spliced it together, and that's you know, they were using the sort of fake and the AI side on that. Uh, and at the end of it, you know, this person transferred money over. And I think back in well, 2025, group IB reporting about 35 million US dollars in sort of AI fake related scams and things like that as well.
SPEAKER_00So these are not small amounts, and I think you know, again, when you're in a normal business environment and you're a you know uh CEO of a large company or someone like that, you're gonna have these calls. This is your day-to-day life, isn't it? It's your bread and butter. If you think you're talking to a politician, um, you know, it we're almost going back to prove it, we've got to physically meet the person, haven't we? You know, that's what we going back to right. I'm physically gonna sit down with you in a room because we're having this call at the moment.
SPEAKER_00We we could all be we could all be fake, we could be AI, you just don't know, do you? We're not obviously uh yeah, yeah, hang on. Yep, yep, yeah, it doesn't mean um but yeah, how how how do you know? So that's just again just a small example there, and yeah, probably a lot of planning and preparation went into that by the criminals, and they they got a big payday from it. Um, but you know, Singaporean police force are on it, and I'm sure they'll be making some progress on that because I know the amount of work goes on in Singapore by the police, um, their sort of anti-scam center they have as well.
SPEAKER_00They have one of the first anti-scam centres um in the world. A lot of a lot of police forces have gone to Singapore to see how that operates. But again, that came around because of a need during COVID where a lot of the elderly were getting scammed. But you know, they they did something and are doing something about it, which is which is great to see.
SPEAKER_02Yeah, and I think just to your point too, obviously uh I know that I think it was a couple years ago, maybe last year, it was saying that cybercrime is actually like the third largest economy in the world outside of what I think the US and China. And obviously, frauds and scams kind of fall into cybercrime. There's a lot of other things that fall into that, but it just shows how much money is being made with all types of cybercrime. And just know that like cybercrime now, I think it's gonna get all exacerbated with AI. So, like going back to like AI and cyber and how scams and frauds have completely changed, I think this landscape is gonna get even crazier as we go on.
SPEAKER_02And so, Craig, to your point of like how do you protect yourself? Like, we kind of like walked through some of the key things, but the other thing I always tell people is like if you because that happens a lot, like you'd be surprised. Um, you know, like a lot of public figures, like CEOs and executives are in, you know, in the limelight. And so it's easy to get images and videos of them talking, and that happens a decent amount. Like, I see I've seen this in multiple companies where they have like you know fake CEOs say, Hey, I uh I need you to wire money. Like we just changed, changed vendors and they need it now, and like they're not really thinking red flag, urgent, do it now.
SPEAKER_02But um, I always say like reach out to that person on a completely separate form of communication. Like, if you have their text, if you have a Slack, if you have a WhatsApp, if you have a separate email for them, like I would confirm like three times just confirming with them. Um, and then the other thing is like again, if they're ever telling you, don't tell anyone or like do this fast, it's it's a big red flag. But I mean that that is happening again, way more than we think, and no one's really talking about it. Like, there's also like internal procedures that you need, obviously, that you should have in your company to prevent something like that.
SPEAKER_02So it goes through multiple people, minus just one person being like the the lever arm of what where the money's going. But yeah, there's a lot that can be hopefully helped prevent it, but you know, we live in a crazy world.
SPEAKER_00I think it's a similar thing, you know. If you are talking to someone, it's someone you know, ask them a question that only they would know the answer, something only the two of you would know. And I've heard some people do that and they've caught the person out fairly, fairly quickly on that. Or, like you say, right, I'm not gonna do that just now, I'm gonna go off and do something else, and then contact them a different way or something like that. That's really, really important. And I think also in a company sense, I think sometimes when you have a junior member of staff being told to do something by a senior, it's quite difficult.
SPEAKER_00But you almost should reward them for challenging that because you know well it yeah, yeah, but the the company and certain companies in certain regions, if the boss tells you to something do something, you do it. I I've had it previously where I've I've told someone to do something, they've gone off and done it, it's not been working, they've come back. We've had a follow-up meeting two weeks later, but it wasn't working. I said, Well, why don't you come back to me? Well, because you told me to do it. And it's like, no, no, that's the but again, you do have that in some companies that if you you've given instruction, you know, you go off and do it.
SPEAKER_02Exactly. Also, a family safe for too. I mean, like safe work with the company, company safe for family safe for it. So that just basically means like if someone does call with AI, and I actually just watched a video about this online yesterday, and I'm gonna do like a kind of a separate one just to explain what happened. But some girl got a call, what it seemed like from her mom, right? They spoofed the number her mom's number, and it sounded like her mom was crying, and then someone came on the phone and was just like, Don't worry, don't worry, don't call anyone. She's really worried, but like I have her, and I won't give her, like, I'm I'm not gonna release her until you know you pay.
SPEAKER_02And she had texted her dad, even though they told her not to do anything, being like, Are you with mom? Like, is she okay? And her dad was like, mom's asleep, you know. But like, she's like, it was so realistic. And if you had a family safe word, she could have been like, Okay, let me talk to my mom. I need my family safe word, then I know it's you know true. Um, so her mom could have been like, I don't know what a family safe word is, like Spongebob or something. I don't know. Um, but like if you have a family safe word, it kind of confirms that it is you're talking to the person that they you're they say they are um too. And you can do the same thing in like uh in companies too.
SPEAKER_02You can have like a company like specific team safe word too.
SPEAKER_00So I mean the the I mean this comes back education. So I went to a fairly senior meeting in the UK, not long after I'd left Interpol. We were talking about cyber and how do we get it out into the workforce, how do we get more people out there? And it came back to well, like you say, okay, you you you became interested in cyber at a certain time, but we don't have that in the curriculums in our schools, we don't have that at this moment in time, yeah. And try to change something in that curriculum.
SPEAKER_00And at this meeting, which is a fairly senior government meeting, I asked, I said, Well, we don't have a department of education here. I'm a little bit surprised because actually we're talking about you know, we want more people in cybersecurity. How do we how do we get it into that curriculum? But because there's so much in there already, to change just one piece in the UK school curriculum is really, really challenging. I don't always like in the US.
SPEAKER_02Oh, I was gonna say, imagine you have five times worse because we have country or like count country, like federal, state, and county. So you can get it into like you could say, like, hey, I want a federal program, but that's only for certain public schools and certain public schools or county schools. It's actually because my original passion when I started this was like, I want to like really protect the kids. And it was just, I mean, I I could probably go into it now. It's not like a full priority, I still still priority, but you know, it's on the list. But it's I've been told so many times it's like nearly impossible to you just have to go school district to school district in counties, and then on top of that, it just becomes outdated so fast.
SPEAKER_02I mean, obviously the the the advice isn't really that that outdated again. Like at the end of the day, it's kind of the same like 10-ish tips, right? Like you just kind of keep like honing in on those tips. But even from like a okay, so there's like a protect the kids type of aspect, right, of cyber, but there's also like, okay, how are we uh inspiring the next generation of kids to want to a career in cyber, right? And I am not gonna like, you know, I'm throwing a little bit of shade on the the school systems right now, but like all of the cybersecurity degrees that I've seen are terrible.
SPEAKER_02They're all like 10 years behind. They don't really teach you anything. I mean, you learn how to code, but like what like I will say, I don't know if you guys want to take this out or not. The Israeli army is extremely, extremely good at training their cybersecurity professionals. And honest, honestly, like 50% of cybersecurity companies are based in Israel. They're really, really smart. I don't know what we need to do to change overall in the in US and in general, right? Like, how are we making sure that we are training the next generation to be intrigued, excited, curious, and like good, right?
SPEAKER_02Like we want white hat hackers, we don't want black hat hackers, and they're already getting you know kind of groomed with gaming right now online, but um there is a good company, I don't know, and it's kind of based out of the UK, but it's international. It's called the Hacking Games. Um, and I'm part of like Fergus. I know Fergus. Yeah, Fergus is the greatest.
SPEAKER_00We had the Prevent program we started at UK back in about 2014, something like that, and it was specifically trying to target the sort of 12 to 14-year-olds, um and get them on a different pathway effectively. But 18 months ago, I was at one of the prevent conferences at Europol, and there was someone from the e-games UK there, and he was speaking about the age groups now, and he was saying it's not 12 and 13 now, it's five, six, and seven.
SPEAKER_00He said, Here's here's an experiment for you. He said, When you're flying back to your country wherever, just look around at the families and the people and look at how many children are on devices, how many kids have got these in their hands, or these laptop, you know, little iPads in their hands. So I went back and I really started seeing, you know, it was whole families were on their devices, and these were like kids in prams are on the devices. And I think you said very early in the in the in this podcast about kids not being explained about what they've got and things like that.
SPEAKER_00And I know my youngest son used to do a lot of gaming, he didn't care about what he did basically. As long as he could cheat his way, win the game. It's like being in a school playground, isn't it? You know, you want to be the quickest kid, you want to get over that line first. Well, this is happening in the online space, and then the criminal groups are recognizing it's where the grooming now goes on, as you just alluded to there. Where they are coming into those spaces, they're grooming the kids. They they're the ones that are recognising the talent and starting to recruit that talent uh at an early age and nurture it, which is a very one, but then that's how organized crime works anywhere in the real space.
SPEAKER_00When you look at you know, organised crime, you you don't just just suddenly become a top criminal, you go through that process, don't you? You go through that apprenticeship, you go through those different stages, those divisions. Um, some don't carry on down that criminal line because they're caught and they're locked up. But you know, unfortunately, you are less likely to feel a policeman's hand on your shoulder and arresting you for a cybercrime or a fraud than you are for stealing a motor vehicle or having a fight in the street or something like that.
SPEAKER_02Yeah, I said that we give kids technology before they even speak, and we've never taught them how to use it or how to protect themselves or what it even means, like on the other end. Like what does that mean when you're chatting with someone like around the world? Where does your where does that information go besides to them, right? Like what and how does that impact you in the future in the in like by tomorrow? Like we don't even talk about any of that. We just are like, here's a fun game, here's an iPad, sit and stare at it. And then I will say a lot of times too, people blame, you know. I just had like a video about this.
SPEAKER_02I'm like, who, who's responsible for protecting our kids, right? Is it the parents? Is it is it policies like government policies, or is it the technology platforms? And obviously it's a little bit of both. But we have, you know, parents on one side being like, you know, it's your response, it's your game, it's whatever. I'm like, but you also can't just stick your kid in front of an iPad and like not expect, you know what I mean? You have to have, you have to have balance, right? There has to be a policy, a governmental policy around protecting kids. We've seen that in Australia recently. I think kids can't have social media before what, 16, 13, 16.
SPEAKER_02Then you you have to see, you know, there's certain technology companies that are implementing a little bit better, you know, kids, kids' privacy and and and security and standards and allowing them to, you know, shut off, you know, chats and you know, only talk to friends or whatever that is. So that's like the technology piece. But then we still, as parents, obviously I'm not a parent yet, but like as a parent, you need to be able to communicate with your kids and explain what's going on and explain like sometimes the harsh truth and and try to have that open line of communication with your kids and try to kind of monitor what your kids are doing in like a you know, a safe environment.
SPEAKER_02So it's I think it's a little bit of everything, but again, kids don't know any better. They're thinking it's a game, they just want to win, they want to figure out how to win. Cheat codes are always so fun. My brother and I used to do cheat codes all the time, not gonna lie. Um, and you know, you just want to win the game. You're not thinking I mean, you're a kid, you're not thinking of the bad things or the negative things, you're thinking of winning. And so, yeah, being able to kind of capture that at a young age and get pique their interest, but also get them excited about, you know, potentially a career. Like I never thought, I mean, cybersecurity to me when I was growing up was not a career at all.
SPEAKER_02Like that I wasn't in an option. It was like lawyer, doctor, you know, the standard stuff. So I think it's really interesting that we can start nurturing that at a young age because to be honest, the only way that we're gonna stay ahead of scammers is to nurture kids' curiosity from the beginning because you have to you have to have, you know, an interesting way of solving problems in order to solve this problem.
SPEAKER_00But I but I think one of the things we have at the moment um is like you said, there's lots of courses out there, but you're coming out of a qualification, but the jobs are not necessarily there now. Or the company is saying, no, yeah, of course we want you, but you need experience. So it's like, well, how do we have experience? Because we went to college. And a good example is this uh where it's sort of backfire, but um, I've got a forensic uh seized crime background as well, and we had uh CSI uh America came over to the US, so all of a sudden there was a massive interest in doing forensics in the UK, and a lot of universities just created these courses, so you had thousands of kids going to these courses, but there are only about a thousand jobs in the UK season crime officers overall.
SPEAKER_00Now, obviously, the cybersecurity world, there's a lot more jobs, but you layer on that as well AI at the moment, and what AI is now able to do about space, and that's not just in the cybersecurity world, that's in a lot of the jobs now where that learning job, if you like, um, where you you you do that basic work, which gives you some experience, that's not necessarily there now. So it's a real chicken and egg scenario we're in at the moment in terms of getting getting people in, and also maybe the expectation nowadays you're coming into a job, you know, you hang on, I don't need to do this, I'm gonna go straight straight on to here.
SPEAKER_00I I sound like a really old person now. Um, but you've got to work your way through through those levels as well and have those different experiences.
SPEAKER_02I totally agree. I used to have a career club, uh, cyber career club, because okay, so one of the there's three reasons reasons why I started my channel. One to get more people interested in a career in cyber, because at that point NIST had just come out with like some stat that was like in 2025, there'll be a 650,000 job openings in cyber. And I'm like, okay, we need to start like reteaching what cybersecurity is to people because they just think it's like hacking and coding, and we need every type of individual in this pro in in cybersecurity. So one of the main reasons was to get more people and more women interested.
SPEAKER_02I mean, both. It was like, I want more women in STEM, but I also want people to start coming into a career in cyber. And I had a career club where I was doing a lot of mentoring, and I just couldn't do it anymore because I was so tired of getting people excited about coming into a career in cyber, and then there'd be zero jobs for them. And I'm like, you guys are all incredible individuals. You all have like 15, you know, certifications at this point. At this point, it's just down to networking, right? Like you have to just go and network and meet people. That's not like, but I just felt like I didn't want to have like a mentor.
SPEAKER_02I mean, obviously, I can mentor you a lot, but it's like, I want you guys to get jobs, I want you to succeed. And it was just so hard for me to like see all these people that are so smart not find jobs because. No one is hiring entry level. And I would go to the C suites and I'd be like, okay, like I'd go to like a C cell and I'd say, Hey, you know what, what part of your career did you learn the most? And every single person, hands down, including myself, was like, Yeah, your first three to five years. It's when you're getting your hands dirty. You have to learn, you have to adapt, you have to be curious, you have to like you learn it pretty much everything on the job.
SPEAKER_02School is never gonna teach you. And honestly, every company that you work for in tech in cyber is completely different. It's completely just some tech landscape, different software, tech, like just everything. So I'm like, you can't expect people to not have that the first three to five years and then expect success for any tech company in the future because no one is having that entry-level stuff. So we're working on it. I was trying to work with um NIS Nice over here in the US and like figure that out. I mean, it's just a mess right now to be in cyber for entry level, honestly for everyone, because AI people are losing their jobs left and right.
SPEAKER_02It's crazy.
Gary RuddellUh before we wrap up, then if you could uh leave people with some of the best prevention advice that you have, that'd be great.
SPEAKER_02I think having strong, unique passwords for your key accounts is so important. Having software updates like automatic updates, really important. Turn on multi-factor authentication, which means not only are you signing with your password, but you're signing in with a uh a code you can send to your phone or your email or um an authenticator app. All very important. I always say, too, with scams and frauds, like I if you can have the the stance of just don't click on any links and every time someone sends it to you, just be like, what is this? Like, I'm not gonna click on a link.
SPEAKER_02That's what I do. Uh it's a little annoying sometimes, but I trust trust me, it makes it a lot better. The other thing I do, which I I haven't talked about at all on this podcast, is I don't answer phone numbers. I don't know. I just don't. Blanket statement. I'm like, if I don't know, if the person needs to get a hold of me, they can leave a message, they can contact me another way, they can text me, they can email me, they can Slack me, WhatsApp me, whatever it is, but I will not answer a phone call I don't know because I know that like again, scams and frauds know how to hijack your brain.
SPEAKER_02And I just don't want to put myself in a vulnerable, vulnerable position to like feel rushed needed to like react. So I just don't put myself there. I don't answer phone calls, I don't know. And I also don't have a personalized voicemail voicemail because I think it's I think it's outdated. I just have this the default voicemail that's like, you know, they're not able to answer, blah, blah, blah. Because it doesn't confirm that that if it's a scammer, it doesn't confirm it's my number. And on top of that, they can't get any part of my voice, although my voice is out there. But I just so those are kind of my little my little tips that I kind of and I and I try to delete and remove my data from websites whenever possible in the US.
SPEAKER_02I know it's not as big of a deal in in other countries, but those are those are my quick tips. Craig, I don't know if you have any any other options.
SPEAKER_00I think one of the key ones for me is just put it's protecting your accounts. You know, you protect your home, don't you? You have a lock on the door, you have a burglar alarm, you keep your windows locked, you lock up at night, you know, you might have a doorbell, video doorbell, or something like that. So you should do the same with your accounts. Um, you know, using a password manager can be an advantage as well. I mean, passwords is it's a difficult one because you know, we end up having trying to remember so many. So, how do you do that? So, pass keys are quite good now, whereas the person, the biometrics, and the device as well.
SPEAKER_00So, a lot of companies are moving towards that. But again, you know, just taking an ordinary person, you know, we we work in this industry and well we have to cover a lot of stuff to try and stay current and stay up to date. So, how on earth can we expect you know a normal person in the street to do this? So, again, the technology side of this is really, really important, and it should almost be uh frictionless that security side. We it should be in the background where we still have you know data breaches, we still have credentials being leaked.
SPEAKER_00Uh so there's a technical side, but then there's a scam side as well. And I think, Callie, all your points exactly to that point. If you're reading something, just imagine someone's on your doorstep talking you through this. You you'd slam the door in the face, wouldn't you? But once we're online, we we maybe sometimes have a different persona where we think, hey, look, we're in our house, we're safe, it's calm, it's cool, we're we're all we're all right with this. No one's gonna harm us here. Um, and yeah, maybe they won't cause you physical harm, but they might cause you quite a lot of financial harm um in the future because of you've clicked on a link or you've scanned a QR code or something like that.
Gary RuddellPerfect. Well, thank you very much, Caitlin and Craig, uh, for joining us today. It's been lovely to speak to you and we'll definitely keep an eye on your channels and speak again soon, hopefully.
Gary RuddellYour data is valuable and it's under attack. But for every threat actor working in the shadows, there's someone who's made it their life's work to understand them and stop them. Who are these people protecting our most valuable data from falling into the wrong hands? Who are the defenders?
Send us Fan Mail What separates a market leader from everyone else in the criminal underworld? Tycoon 2FA is a phishing-as-a-service platform that helps criminals bypass multi-factor authentication and steal...
Send us Fan Mail The public often sees cybercrime through the lens of attacks, arrests and headlines. Far less visible are the online communities that sit behind them. For many people, cybercrime isn’t just about the...
Send us Fan Mail ShinyHunters has left an alleged trail stretching from university campuses, and major healthcare providers, to government agencies. It even turned on its peers, extorting and publicly humiliating Cl0P...
Send us Fan Mail Successful espionage usually relies on patience. Nation-state actors quietly infiltrate targets, maintain access for years, and gather intelligence without attracting attention. But one threat actor has...
Send us Fan Mail For years, stronger authentication was seen as the answer to online fraud. As passwords became easier to steal, organisations turned to stronger forms of verification, from facial recognition and voice...