How to run a profitable restaurant comes down to your numbers, and most restaurant owners are being let down by the people meant to look after them. For restaurant owners, café owners, and anyone in a hospitality business, the right accounting setup is the difference between building wealth and quietly going backwards every week. Tim Niesler is the director of The FC Accounting Co, the accounting firm built specifically to service hospo owners, and he's seen exactly where the industry gets failed. For years, accountants told hospitality owners not to bother with tax planning because they probably wouldn't be around next year. Tim built something different. An accounting firm that sets owners up for the future, not just the next tax return. In this one, the two Tims go deep on the stuff most owners were never taught. Why your business structure matters more than you think. How putting GST, PAYG and super aside weekly gives you an early warning system. Why, in hospitality, you almost never have a cash flow problem, you have a profit problem. And the Division 7A trap that quietly snowballs into a tax bill you can't pay. If you've ever told yourself "I've just got a cash flow issue," this episode is for you. You'll hear: → What a hospo-specialist accountant does differently from a traditional firm → Why the right business structure protects your personal assets → The weekly habit that flags trouble in your first three weeks, not five months later → Cash flow vs profit, and why hospitality owners confuse the two → How to handle ATO debt without going further backwards Key takeaways: Put your GST, PAYG and super aside weekly from day one. It becomes your red flag. In hospitality you get paid every day, so a cash flow problem is usually a profit problem. Your real break-even includes loan repayments and ATO debt, not just your P&L. Pay yourself a wage and your super. Your business sale is not your retirement plan. Ready to build a restaurant that makes money and runs without you? Book a Profit Finding Session: https://discover.foodiecoaches.com/bac Follow Foodie Coaches: @foodie_coaches @tim.kummerfeld New episodes every Wednesday.
Audio and video play straight from the show's own hosting. PodSubs stores and serves no media.
Transcript
From the show. Tap a time to play from there.
SPEAKER_01We had people who uh accountant told them they didn't need to do tax planning 'cause they're probably not going to be here next year. It's almost like the whole accounting profession just turned its back on hospitality and was like, Well, we don't know if these guys are gonna make it or not. So if someone is losing money all of this time and they've done that all year, and we've said, well, we need to do tax planning whether you're losing money or not, they go book the call, get on the call, and they go, Oh, we lost 130 grand this year.
SPEAKER_02When business is going really, really well, all we can see is the good stuff. We don't plan on what could go wrong, and having that sorted out right from the start, super important. Welcome back to Make Restaurants Profitable, and today we're joined by Tim Nielsler. Tim, who are you? Where are you from? Into that camera.
SPEAKER_01Hi guys, uh Tim here from FC Accounting Co. Uh I'm the director uh and we've been doing this with restaurants and and other business owners since 2014 together.
SPEAKER_022014. So uh for some context, for some context here, we have a whole we started off as an accounting firm, foodie coaches started off as an accounting firm, Timmy and I um in this accounting firm, and then I'm like fuck accounting, it's bored, it's boring. So Timmy held the fort in the accounting firm, and we started growing foodie coaches. We sold our original accounting firm, and then a few years later everyone's like, we just need a good accountant. So Timmy headed up um as the you know the director of the partner of FC Accounting Co.
SPEAKER_02which is was directly built to service the clients of foodie coaches, uh, and now we've grown from there. So Timmy's the accounting partner, you'll hear from the bookkeeping partner later on, Kylie. And today we want to talk to you, we want to come to you. I just want to hear, like, you know, I want to hear Timmy, what do people need to know um from their accounts at the moment? Like, what do you think?
SPEAKER_01Well, I think it it starts with the original story of how we got here, which um you mentioned there that you know people didn't have somewhere to turn, and we had people who their accountant told them they they didn't need to do tax planning because they're probably not gonna be here next year. And it's almost like the accounting, like the whole accounting profession just turned its back on hospitality and was like, well, we don't know if these guys are gonna make it or not. So when they do, we'll help them, and when if they're not making it, then we'll wait until they do. And and then you know, the other thing is that we had all of these people where their accountants have their own agenda everywhere.
SPEAKER_01And I was thinking about some of the things before you know coming in today, and one of those is you know, a lot of accountants they're so scared to lose clients, and so they you know they aren't letting their clients go and get help from coaching, whether that's food coaches or somewhere else, and they're like, oh, we can do that.
SPEAKER_02Yes, we know we hear this, you know. Oh, I spoke to my accountant about joining, and he reckons like we can do it. And it's like, well, if you can do it, why the fuck weren't you doing it before? You know, why have you come to us to make the decision to get to them? Yeah. So all right, so accountants are traditional, and some accountants are. There's accountants that recommend people to food coaches all the time.
SPEAKER_01Yeah.
SPEAKER_02Um, there's like a there's a have and a have not. There are a good account. Don't please don't get me wrong, we're not throwing stones at the whole accounting industry. There's just a subsection of accountants that haven't grown with what business needs to survive in this day and age.
SPEAKER_01Yeah, 100%. And they they just have a lot of fear, you know, that they're gonna lose a client. And I think one of the things that FC Accounting was born out of is that if we had a fear that we're gonna lose a client, it was probably because we haven't done our job effectively. You know, so if people are leaving, then that's a sign to us that you know we need to be better, we need to do the things that we say that we're gonna do. Um and so rather than having this fear and trying to have control around our clients about trying to keep them, you know, having their zero files uh under our name so that we can shut them off or get paid or whatever it is, you know, rather than having that fear, let's just do our job and um and help other people make money.
SPEAKER_02Okay, so what is doing our job effectively look like?
SPEAKER_01Yeah, so obviously um setting people up in in structures that they're gonna be able to build wealth on in the future.
SPEAKER_02Making sure people have got the right structure to operate in, both from a legal liability point of view and a tax liability point of view.
SPEAKER_01Yeah, tax liability point of view, um, asset protection point of view. So that you know, if we make all this money and then for some reason, like let's say someone opens a business next door or there's a train station that comes in and all of a sudden our business is not the profitable money-making machine that it that it once was, that our personal assets are protected. So that's probably one of the things that's closest to my heart is making sure that we secure people in that way as much as possible.
SPEAKER_02So yeah, planning for the worst. It's interesting you say that because I think when business is going really, really well, we just all we can see is the good stuff, and we don't plan on what could go wrong, and having that sorted out right from the start, super important. So when when you're seeing clients coming through to the accounting firms, what's some of the problems that you're seeing that they're having or that should have been sorted earlier? So the people who are listening right now can be like, oh that's me, or hey, I've got to sort that out.
SPEAKER_01Yeah, some of the ones that uh we've had really recently is um you know trusts are a have been a big issue for a long, long time. Yes, forever. And it's not only obviously they're gonna be a lot more of a problem now and and moving forward with the the government changes depending on what comes in. However, it's it's been a lot problem long before this. And I would say that all of the problems that come through is less about uh uh the actual problem and more about the understanding the education around it.
SPEAKER_01So from a trust, if we just use the trust example, uh people aren't educated by what having a trust means, what the difference between a distribution and paying yourself a wage is, and then you know they get to the end of the year and that the the client um and they haven't been explained how their tax works and that they're whether they make money or um um they're paying back loans or whatever it is, that profit gets distributed to them whether they're taking the cash or not. And so um there's just and that that's just one area of education.
SPEAKER_01Um another one might be the the amount of GST and P A Y G to put aside each week and and to really how important it is to do that from day one, because we see people not knowing what to put away, and then knowing they haven't put anything away, to putting their head in the sand, and and you know, not then there's nothing put away. So they go on a payment plan and then it just gets worse and worse and worse and worse. And if they it all started because they didn't know exactly what to put away from that at the start, and then just snowboard.
SPEAKER_02Okay, so let's just rewind uh let's just rewind to the trust section. If someone's and trusts were, you know, there was a period of time where we set up all trading entities with the trust and a corporate trustee, and then we're like this is shit. Let's let's use it let's use a corporate trustee with the trust as a shareholder, and now we're looking at some changes coming in. So talk to someone in a trust right now, operating over trust, what should they be doing? What should they be thinking of? That's my first question.
SPEAKER_01Well, I look to be honest, I'd I'd say that right now there's there's nothing to do other than make sure that you've got an accountant that's got a plan if the changes come in.
SPEAKER_02So call up your accountant and just be say, hey, I'll listen to these two Tims and they're like, I need a plan.
SPEAKER_01Yep. Yep. So what are we going to do if um these changes do come in? Yep. Um because otherwise your profits are gonna be taxed at 30%, and we can't get any of those profits distributed through to a company to reduce the tax if we're making good cash.
SPEAKER_02So that's the first thing. What else should they be thinking of? Uh are they paying themselves a wage? How is their tax distributed?
SPEAKER_01Yeah, I I would I think again it it really depends on the situation as far as whether how much money they're making, how many partners are in the business, is it a family, is their children in the business, but buying and ha and how much you're working in the business as well. Uh and the turnover the entity of the amount of wages the entity's paying. Because if you're if you're turning over, you know, six million bucks and your wages are two mil a year and you're paying payroll tax, then the um the the conversation is gonna be a little bit different.
SPEAKER_01But um, I would say for most mum and dad businesses, we want to be paying yourselves a wage, we want to make sure that your wages are split between you know in venue and working on the business so that um we get a really clear idea of where your wages really sit, whether um you're working in the business or not.
SPEAKER_02Um yeah, okay, so it's good stuff. And then talk to me about putting tax aside because we all know that if you put your tax aside every week, and now let's be honest, we got um payday super, so superannuation gets paid, which is how it should have been the whole fucking time. Like get technology's changed and now we can do it, but that would have saved a whole heap of hurt. So payday super sorted is P A Y G weekly, or that's still monthly as well, isn't it?
SPEAKER_01Yeah, well, it's really uh discretion. Now on the payday super, we've had people say to us, uh, this is the best thing that they've ever done, and they wish that you know this had been this way from the start. Like the best thing that happened to my business was was payday super. And if you're opening a business right now with PAYG, you can actually pay that directly to the ATO weekly if you if you've just opened, or if you're already up to date with your PAYG. So you can make it super simple for yourself that you never actually keep the money, it just goes with your wages.
SPEAKER_02Just pay your PAYG weekly with your wages, so you pay your wages, pay your team, pay their tax, pay their super. Ooh, and then as an owner, because you're paying yourself a wage, you're paying your super as well, and you're not telling yourself your false story that your superannuation is going to be when you sell your business for a ridiculous amount of money, which it's never gonna be worth.
SPEAKER_01Yep. Okay. And if if we just loop back to the trust situation, that's why we'd always rather see people um in the payroll. Yes. Is because to us and and FCA is that we're setting you up for the for the future, not just for the right now. And if you're just taking a trust distribution, 99 times out of 100, you're not paying yourself super.
SPEAKER_02Yep. Um, so yeah. Yep. And you hear the story, and this is like this is bringing back to accounting firm days, you hear the story, oh no, I'll start paying, I'll start paying my super when things get better. And then next minute, next minute, it's two years later, and we haven't paid any super for the owners who are missing out again, you know. So, okay, cool, so pay super pay. And then what about let's talk about GST and you know, P A Y G, which like the company, the tax on the company profits, which then cause other problems.
SPEAKER_01Yeah, well, you you well, if we talk about the the GST, the GST first, obviously, if we're just starting out um and getting an amount that we can pay weekly right from the start, um obviously helps. And what I find with owners is if you're on top of it and you're putting these things away, and if things aren't going well, there is an immediate red flag as soon as you open within the first week, two weeks, three weeks. You know, usually you have a big um amount of turnover and everyone wants to come in and try you out because you're new and and all the things, and then after those three weeks it starts to drop off.
SPEAKER_01And if you're putting your uh GST, P A Y G and you're paying your super weekly right from the start, and there's no money there, even if you're not on top of your numbers, you've got an immediate red flag, well, we got no money. Yeah. And uh, if that's not enough for the owner to um go and do something about it, whether it's you know, working, looking at the menu, or whatever it is that they're doing um with with you guys inside of foodies um or the information that's out there on the internet, um, it should be, you know, and and some businesses owners don't get that red flag until they do their bass.
SPEAKER_02Yeah. Which is like usually three months, four months, five months later. So you're already five months behind.
SPEAKER_01Yeah, and if you've done a massive fit out, well that first bass might be a refund. So then which hides it even more. Yeah, so then it could be eight months before we we get that realization. So putting it away weekly really brings that to the forefront. Um, and what we see is that we need people to have that realisation of where they're truly at to be able to take action and and make a change. And I think that if we had that realisation so much earlier in the industry as a whole, we'd be able to improve our businesses so much faster and see so many less businesses in our industry going broke.
SPEAKER_02Yeah, well, you know, people go broke because all sorts of reasons, you know, numbers is probably the biggest one that we've seen, or lack of understanding around how the structures work. So, um, okay, what what about if someone's uh holding ATO debt, and obviously we'll have um you know we'll have a conversation about restaurant revive on a separate conversation, but someone who's already carrying some ATO debt, payday supers come in, they're like, you know, we've seen some news articles, people blaming their shutdown because of payday super.
SPEAKER_02Oh, you know, shutting down's all payday soup. It's not the reason why shutting down is because your fucking business model was broken in the first place, and payday super was just the pressure that you needed to get you across the line. Like, you probably it was the same as COVID. There was a lot more people gonna go broke before COVID even started, and COVID just rescued the industry. Yeah, rescued, yeah. Yes, so let's just go back and rewind. Um, people who are already in that financial spot with ATO debt, and you know that you were talking about put it away weekly, and like fuck man, I'm flat out, I'm flat out keeping up with ATO payments plus put it away weekly.
SPEAKER_02How do we do it? What's your advice around that?
SPEAKER_01Well, you really need to understand what's what's current that you're putting away and what's old that you're paying off. You need to know what your options are with that debt to uh be able to adjust your cash flow. So right now you you have an ATO debt, you're probably paying it off over three years if you're lucky, it might be over a year if you've done the payment plan yourself, and so that cash flow's um tightened right up because of your repayment schedule. And so you need to know what the options are with that older debt. So it might be to get a longer payment plan, it might be to get a loan, it might be that you know we have other options to reduce that debt that I'm sure you'll talk about with the restaurant revive guys.
SPEAKER_01And so if your accountant isn't across all the options, um you want to uh look at someone who has an idea of what those options are so that you can make an educated decision.
SPEAKER_02Yeah, you're better you're better off extending your ATO debt over the longest possible period with the shortest amount of payments to stay on top of your current debt, so stay on top of your current liabilities. There's no point in leveraging out to catch up and then you can't keep up with your current team's POYG or you know you can't keep up with your current GST standards because your cash flow is still going backwards.
SPEAKER_01Yeah, yeah. The problem is that um a lot of people think that the ATO payment arrangement is it just every new debt keeps adding on. But the thing is if you're paying$300 a week and the debt's$50,000 and the next uh bill that's coming up is is$20, every time a new bill gets added, it's uh you're going backwards, you're you're adding more and more to the debt, and so there's a misunderstanding around that the next one just gets added on.
SPEAKER_01Um because every new one is supposed to be paid on time.
SPEAKER_02Yeah. Can we talk about can we talk about um like can we talk about the difference between profit and cash flow? Because I think there's a lot of people out there who don't understand it, because you still hear people going, oh, I've just got cash flow issues. And you and I both know that in hospitality you don't have a cash flow issue, you've got a profit problem. And if you're sitting there going, oh, I've got a cash flow issue, that's what people tell themselves to make them feel better about their situation, is actually terrible. Now, I will say there's one stipulation there is that if you're in like a catering business or something where you're on 30 or 90-day invoice terms, maybe working for a big mine side or a big government contract, maybe you could have some cash flow pressure.
SPEAKER_02But outside of that one situation, if you've got a cash flow problem, you've normally got a profit problem. Can you speak to that?
SPEAKER_01Yeah, so typically a cash flow problem in accounting is when you're a builder uh or you know you you produce a product and you're not gonna get paid for a certain amount of time. Um, you know, where where we live, we used to do a lot of mining clients, and the mines went and changed their payment terms from 30 days from end to month to 60 days from end a month, and all of a sudden that's a cash flow issue because you've got to pay your staff in the meantime, you've got to pay your staff for the work that they've done, you've got to pay for the materials that they've done, you've got to pay for the fuel, all the other things, and then you don't get paid for another 30 or 60 days on top.
SPEAKER_02Yep. That's the cash flow problem, right? 100%. What happens in hospitality?
SPEAKER_01We get paid every day. So you know, uh you maybe you change uh merchant providers from Tyro, where you used to get it dropped in and you had a Tyro bank account, and then you change to like a square, and maybe you get it a couple of days later. So for a couple of weeks until you catch up, you've got a cash flow issue. But outside of that, you get paid the same day every week, unless you know you're doing a lot of catering contracts, like you mentioned. So when we talk about the difference between a cash flow problem and a profit problem, um, you could be profitable, but the only time where you'd have a cash flow problem is that your liabilities, your repayments, exceed what that profit is.
SPEAKER_01So let's say you turn over 20 grand a week, you your wages are maybe nine, your food bill that's six and a half, seven, and then your overheads, um, and you're only making 500 bucks a week, but your payments to the ATO are 600, all of a sudden every single week you're going backwards 100 bucks.
SPEAKER_02Yeah. Yeah, on top of if you've got silver chef commitments, on top of, you know, if you've got a car loan in there, on top of the fact that if you're not paying yourself and you're taking cash out of the business, as well. So all of those things add on, and that's where people find themselves in trouble, right?
SPEAKER_01Yeah, so one of like um one of the things that we or when when I was more inside of the foodie business that we did is we built a break-even point that wasn't a break-even uh in the PL, it's a break-even including all of the balance sheet items. So it was revolutionary for a lot of members that have never really understood what their actual break-even open the doors, pay all of my repayments.
SPEAKER_02Break-even on a cash flow perspective.
SPEAKER_01Yeah.
SPEAKER_02Yeah, yeah, and I this is where I think the market's been failed. I think the market's been let down by their own providers in that there hasn't been enough education around, you know, you might have a break-even point, that's great. Your break-even point might be, you know,$25,000 a week. But then if you've got$1,000 a week in HR, you've got$1,000 a week in Silver Chef, you've got, you know,$500 a week in car repayments because everyone needs a new car. You've got all those things on top. All of a sudden, your break-even point's not that, your break-even point's a hell of a lot higher because you're going to make that money on the bottom end.
SPEAKER_02Yeah. Okay. Um, all right, so that's that's that's the difference between cash flow uh and profit. What are some of the other things that you think people need to understand when it comes to what they're doing with their accounting?
SPEAKER_01Yeah, well, I've got two actually just in the last week that I've had some conversations about. We had uh a potential new client come on board and they had all of these uh what we call in accounting or tax world division 7a loans. And what it is is when the director or one of the shareholders or someone has taken money out of the business without being paid a wage, without um, and this is in a company scenario. So um without being paid a wage or without a dividend being declared, or um it gets class as a loan.
SPEAKER_02Effectively, effectively, if you're in a company structure or you're in a trust structure, if you take cash out of the bank account and spend it, or you take um food, like say a lot of people live out of there, there's some rules around that. There is and we'll talk about that in a second. We can talk about that. You take food out and you take that out and you just go and spend it, and you don't pay and you don't class it as a wage or you don't pay a dividend on it, it goes to a loan account, and that loan account is called Division 7A, correct?
SPEAKER_02Exactly right. All right, can you talk to the problems with Division 7A? Well the problems is that we've got to pay it back because it's a loan.
SPEAKER_01Or we've got to pay tax on it and declare it. In in and and if you've taken you know 100, 200 grand out for the deposit on a house or something like that, uh it becomes an even bigger issue because if you want to repay that back in one year and declare a dividend in in one year, and you're already paying yourself a wage of ninety, a hundred, two hundred grand, like it goes. Very, very expensive, very, very fast.
SPEAKER_02And it gets expensive because it puts people up into the next tax bracket?
SPEAKER_01Yep. Okay. Yeah, so if it was 200 grand that you took out and you're already paying yourself 150, you're gonna pay.
SPEAKER_02Your taxable income comes up to 350,000? Yeah, and the extra tax that you're paying on it will be, you know, 48 cents on the dollar?
SPEAKER_01Yeah.
SPEAKER_02On that 200 grand. So then if you think about it, 48 cents on the dollar plus is it 48 cents? 47, yeah. Plus Medicare?
SPEAKER_01No, no, that's included Medicare, yeah.
SPEAKER_02So it's 47?
SPEAKER_01Yeah.
SPEAKER_02Yeah. So then you get taxed 47 dollars 47 cents on that$200,000. So then you get a tax bill for another$96,000. Am I on the money? Ye yes. Short answer, yes. And then you've got to pay it. Then you've got to pay it. So then usually then you've got to take more money out of the company. Yeah, it just becomes this this becomes so then you're gonna take more money out of the company to pay for that 90 grand tax bill, correct?
SPEAKER_01Yeah. Or what we do most times in accounting is we'll we'll pay it back over seven years and the uh pay it out slowly with dividends over that time, pay some interest on it, pay tax on the interest, and uh it's this whole thing.
SPEAKER_03Yeah.
SPEAKER_01Now, again, if we go back to the education piece, if this person had been educated early before they did it, or they'd asked the question before they went and took the money out, or they had the right accountant, now this money that was taken out was for a property, you know, um, and the property was in uh a trust. Uh and it's commercial.
SPEAKER_02You know, if if you could have just set it up in a company and done into entity company loans and you wouldn't have had a division 7A.
SPEAKER_01And then we wouldn't have had a Divis 7A loan. Yeah. So, you know, asking uh first of all, understanding the money that you're taking out, what's the purpose of it? Yeah. Um, asking the question, what's the best way that I can do this before we go and do it? Yeah, uh, could have saved this person a whole heap of uh heartache.
SPEAKER_02Sounds like it. Sounds like it. So that probably comes back to how much people talk to their accountants. I feel like there's and this comes from my my our time originally way back when, and like let's be clear, like I'm the worst person asked for accounting advice um right now. It's just you've got to be doing it all the time, you've got to be keeping up to it, you've got to be up to date, you've got to be living and breathing it, I believe. So I think there's a stigma about people afraid to ring their accountants because they're gonna get a bill, or that when they do get their bill from their accountants, um then they're like, oh you know, this bill's ridiculous, what have they done?
SPEAKER_02And can we just speak to her around billing and costs of accounting? Because I I think more people in the industry need to talk about it. I think more people in the industry need to be like, well, you know what, your accountant bill is expensive because like there's a lot of fucking work in it, man. There's a lot of work in it. So can we talk about um the value in paying for accounting and and why people should be really putting that in their budget?
SPEAKER_01Yeah, so one of the things that we wanted to do with our clients was uh A, that they weren't gonna be ever afraid to um to have that conversation. So all of our clients get 15-minute calls where they can just book in with their senior accountant and just go, hey, just want to run this by you, what do you think, or whatever they need. Um, can you just help me with this? And as many 15-minute calls as they want throughout the year, um, they can book in. And you know what? Usually they go for half an hour and you know that's that's totally fine. But if we have to step away from that and you know, go and do some stuff and have a longer conversation, maybe there's an out of scope on top, but right.
SPEAKER_01Um, you know, it's very rare that we that we do that unless it's this very significant. So that that's probably the first part. The second part is if we loop back to the conversation that I had about the the story that we had about the accountant, the client who came to us and their accountant said, Don't you do tax planning, you're not gonna be here next year. We didn't want anyone to not get tax planning because even if you're losing money, it could be the best time to change your structure or adjust something rather than waiting until uh you know you're making a hundred, two hundred, five hundred grand a year, and then all of a sudden changing things gets very expensive.
SPEAKER_00Yeah.
SPEAKER_01So we wanted to make sure that uh those things are in place back then. And the other thing with tax planning for us, it's not just about paying less tax, it's about if you're losing money and no one's looked at your structure in a while, and you've got two directors there, we might have uh more of a liability risk than we need to. So if if it's the only time that a client wants to talk to us throughout the year, it's our number one opportunity to go, hey, we should be looking at this structure.
SPEAKER_01Hey, you got some debt here that maybe there's some options with. Um, do you like uh do you need any equipment in the next 12 months? Like rather than them going out to some loan shark, maybe we have someone better that they can talk to, are people's wills up to date? So it's really about all the conversations that we see that clients should have had when we weren't in accounting and making sure that all those conversations do get had.
SPEAKER_02Can you just rewind there for a second? You just mentioned if you've got two directors on and you're losing money, and that's something that we should be thinking about. What exactly do you mean by that?
SPEAKER_01Yeah, so as far as directors go, you have director duties and responsibilities. Um, and that's to not be trading a company while it's insolvent.
SPEAKER_02What does insolvent mean?
SPEAKER_01So uh the definition of well, if we just go it in its most simplest form, you can't pay your bills if and when they fall due.
SPEAKER_02So that means if you're operating at a loss for a significant period of time and you don't have a plan in place to get it into a profit, effectively you're operating insolvent. Correct. I want that to sink in because the amount of people who are operating at a loss for far too long and then leave it far too long before they make a decision, you need to understand that you're operating insolvent. Is that correct?
SPEAKER_01Yes. Uh short answer, yes. Long answer, you could be uh uh trading insolvent for a long time, you could be losing money for a long, long, long, long, long time and not be insolvent, assuming that the shareholders keep tipping in money and keep funding the loss-making activities. Yes.
SPEAKER_02Yep. What happens if they're not, which is the majority of fucking hospitality, let's be honest. Good frame. Good frame for the corporate people out there, there you go, corporate people, you ticked your box. But if you're not tipping in cash yourself, yes, that's right. You're operating insolvent. Now tell me what is what happens if you're operating insolvent for a long period of time and you eventually get wound up.
SPEAKER_01What does that look like? Yeah, so if you eventually get wound up, um insolvent, it really depends a on the level of debt that you accumulated. Okay. So if you accumulated a million dollars in ATO debt and the ATO is pretty cranky at the liquidator when you eventually get wound up, then that liquidator's potentially gonna pursue you for um insolvent trading. Yep. Because you've been trading all of this time. The longer that that goes, the longer that they can prove that that goes, the more liabilities that you've taken on during that insolvent period.
SPEAKER_01The angrier they get. The angrier they get. Um, and so if you have personal assets in your name, um then the more that you have, the more likely that they'll pursue the claim, and then um yeah, you potentially lose everything.
SPEAKER_02Yes. And if you don't have everything and you're not going bankrupt, like obviously there's a bit of a that's gonna put you on hold for a bit as well. Correct. Okay, cool. Uh all right, and if someone is operating insolvent and they're like just had that, what like what's your suggestion?
SPEAKER_01Uh again, it's it's understanding what your options are. Yep. Um, and it might be that there are things that you can do to regain your solvency.
SPEAKER_02Yeah, like maybe book a call with foody coaches and let us help you fix your profit problem. 100%. Yep, cool. Um, alright, so cash flow, structure, tax, um, insolvency. What else do we need? What else do we need to cover? Tax planning. Uh, let's go back to people who might not be in the great financial position and why they still should be like pre-thinking ahead. So you were just saying before that you still do tax pl you do tax planning with all clients, even if they're not making money or where they're at.
SPEAKER_02What's the what's the thinking behind that?
SPEAKER_01Well, it's to make sure that you understand your options. Um, that if we are losing money, we're mitigating that insolvent trading uh risk. Yes. Uh it's to those options that I just mentioned to become solvent again, um, that you that you know what those uh like regaining solvency options are. Yep. Uh and really sometimes it's just a wake-up call.
SPEAKER_01If someone is losing money all of this time and they've done that all year, and we've said, well, we need to do tax planning whether you're losing money or not, they go book the call, they get on the call, and they go, Oh, we lost 130 grand this year. And it could be the first time that they've looked at their PL and someone, because they haven't wanted to look at it, they've had this fear around their numbers. Yeah, and so it's just another touch point for us to be able to go, hey, this is where you're at, were you aware of it? Is this what you expected?
SPEAKER_01Yeah, um, what are you doing about it? Because not every not all of our clients are um have the beauty of of being foodie clients.
SPEAKER_02Yeah, yeah. Um so, okay. If someone else is what other things should people be knowing about what they need to be doing working with their accountant right now?
SPEAKER_01Yeah, I think that you can't have too much understanding or information. Uh you know, we had another client that's just coming on board and they mean it's back to structures, but their accountant put them in this partnership structure of a company and a trust. Um In a partnership. In a partnership.
SPEAKER_02Really?
SPEAKER_01Yeah. We haven't seen one in years.
SPEAKER_02I don't think that's why we're we're all smiling here as ex-accountants. Well, that's a bit weird. Yeah, it is, it's super weird. That was a I reckon that was a Friday afternoon decision after a long lunch for sure. A hundred percent. That's what's happened there.
SPEAKER_01Uh so, anyways, we're at the point now of okay, we've got to unwind this. Yep. And then the the same accountants given, not just shit on accountants, but um they've got a car in the business and we've got fringe benefits tax issues that we're doing. Yep. And the fringe benefits tax, the way that it's it's been done, is created a bigger and bigger every year, Div 7A loan. Yes. Um, and so just again explaining to the client what it is, what's really happening, what the numbers are, and um because the at the end of the day, the reason that I'm having the conversation with the client is that I don't really want to allege the FPT return.
SPEAKER_01Um, because it's to me, there's other ways to do things. Yeah.
SPEAKER_02Um and so do you not think that people need to be more aware of fringe benefits tax when they're making these decisions of buying cars and entities and doing this, especially with AI now, with how smart they're getting, like they just know. Wild smart.
SPEAKER_01Yeah. Wild smart. So what the client's gonna do now is um their next car, which they were just about to purchase anyway. So I'm so glad that we had the conversation now and we brought it up. So they're gonna go and buy that in their personal name, we're gonna do a logbook, yeah, pay themselves a bit more of a wage, yeah, and then we'll claim the car in their personal name and not need to worry about all of this rigmarole. So just knowing what your options are and and what these things really mean, rather than just following the accountant or what everyone else does, I think that uh we see other people in business tradies and whatnot, and they have youths and it all gets depreciated through their company, and we're at barbecues and people are telling stories, and we think, oh, we should go and do that.
SPEAKER_02Yeah, you know. That's the worst, that's the worst piece of advice to get is from a barbecue or from a pub.
SPEAKER_01Yeah, 100%.
SPEAKER_02Yeah, yeah. And can I just say if you've got an accounting question, don't just go find some random person you know. Oh yeah, he's smart. I'm just gonna ask this guy. Because I'm gonna be honest, there's people who still reach out to me now. Like we sold out in what 2019, 2020. Well now, 2020. Six years later, people still message me going, hey man, I'm doing this with my super fund. What do you think? And I'm like, I think you should go and pay someone for advice. Motherfucker, don't call me. Timmy's laughing right now because he knows I'm the worst person to get advice from.
SPEAKER_02But um, in accounting, because you have to this laws change every year. So going, you need to have a good relationship, and that one phone call that you're trying to save a hundred bucks on, or you know, that one phone call that you're not making to your advisor could potentially cost you thousands or hundreds of thousands of dollars later on. 100%. Yep. There's a couple things I want to touch on. Um the first one is this whole anti-money laundering thing coming in.
SPEAKER_02Um, how is that how is that going to affect accounting and how is that going to affect Hospital? Because not a lot of people know about it. Like real estate agents, it's a pain in the ass for them. I judging by some of the meetings that I've sat in on in the accounting firm, it seems like a lot more work for you guys. Can we just educate the market on what's going to have to happen and the questions that accountants are going to be asking you?
SPEAKER_01Yeah, so uh a number of years ago the that we had this whole banking reform. Yes. And you go to set up a company bank account, and if your shares are held on trust, it just made everything an absolute nightmare.
SPEAKER_02We needed trusteds and you've got to go in and have meetings and send stuff and have phone calls and all sorts, right?
SPEAKER_01Yep. Uh and that whole identification process that the banks have to do. It now, anytime that you buy or sell a property um or a business, uh, or you have a registered office um or a whole range of things, uh your accountant, real estate agent um or solicitor, solicitors are quite caught up in it as well, uh, need to do this identification between yourself, the entities, and then make sure that people are not doing things for the wrong reasons.
SPEAKER_03Okay.
SPEAKER_01Um, in a nutshell. So anti-money laundering, obviously that we're not um getting money from uh terrorism or drug activities. Yes. And funneling that through our business.
SPEAKER_02Um the old Like someone coming and buying your business bit with a bag full of cash.
SPEAKER_01Yeah, we've we've seen that happen actually.
SPEAKER_02Yes. Recently.
unknownYeah.
SPEAKER_02In the last couple of years, yeah. Yeah. So um what are what are clients need to understand? What are owners need to understand about what's on change?
SPEAKER_01Really just uh, you know, if we're taking on board new clients or you're doing a new service with your accountant, there may be some additional identification that you need to do. Yep. Um it's going on everywhere anyway. If you're buying a property or you're um buying or selling a business or setting up a new company, it's it's gonna happen. You're gonna see this in your everyday life and just a little bit more if you're a business owner.
SPEAKER_03Okay.
SPEAKER_01Um, you know, we've had clients in the past where they don't want to get a director ID and um and won't won't be able to be a director, so their poor business partner has to go and be the director. But and and maybe back then that was okay and you could get away with that, but now the way that Australia's moving with the digital age, that's not going to be possible. That person would have to go and live in another country to build, uh have assets and own property and those kinds of things.
SPEAKER_02Okay, so in other words, yeah, if you're like out there and you don't want this, you just need to be aware it's coming, and you're probably already aware of it for other reasons, anyways. Um laundering. My next thing that I had for you is can we touch on um partnerships and estate planning and you know getting your wills sorted out? Because I feel like in Hospo we're all about the now. Like we almost live week to week. Um, we're focused on what's going on now.
SPEAKER_02So many people aren't focused on what's happening if something bad happens.
SPEAKER_01Yeah, and it's again, it's why we do tax planning with every client is that we get to really step back and go, what is the bigger picture? Obviously, right now you're making a hundred grand. Like, what is the what is the bigger picture? Not just looking at the right now that you've just mentioned. Because if we're always just in the now, we're never gonna think, well, what if we make a million dollars a year? Yeah. Or what if we lose 500 grand in a year? And making sure that we're set up for both instances.
SPEAKER_01And sometimes just the stepping back out of your current situation and going, what if either way, is what you need to do to change or motivate yourself to change your situation that you're in right now. Um, and it's one of the reasons that we really love our tax planning. So uh obviously we've got the um what if either way. Um the estate planning, it's one of the conversations that we have there. Okay. Um obviously we don't do the estate planning, we um have uh you know recommendations of people that we should go and see.
SPEAKER_01But if you're if you have a business and it's profitable and and we have some goodwill there, like it's actually worth something, then we want to make sure that you know if both mum and dad were gonna die, like how does how does the business continue?
unknownYeah.
SPEAKER_01We want to have some contingencies in inside of that.
SPEAKER_02So because and you can't just assume that someone's just gonna come and take it over and do the right thing, because we've seen and we know that when you know people die as sad as what it is, sometimes things don't work out the way they're meant to. Uh, and we've seen families have arguments over all sorts of things. So if you've got even if you've got a profitable business right now and you don't have your estate planning up to date, use this as your cue to go and get it sorted.
SPEAKER_01100%. Um, and if you have a solicitor that's gonna put in a uh testamentary discretionary trust, probably um get a second opinion.
SPEAKER_02Yeah, okay. And if you're sitting there going, well, the business wouldn't operate because it needs me to be here, I'm gonna make I'm gonna suggest you book called us because if the business needs you to operate, you've got a full you've just got a job, right?
SPEAKER_01Yep, yeah, no matter what the profit is, you know, and if you have children, you both die tomorrow, um, you know, there there's there's nothing there. There's no um there's no instructions. No.
SPEAKER_02No one's gonna know what to do. And your team won't, because they'll have no one to call. So um, alright, let's change let's change pace because I don't want to end on a fucking Debbie Downer. Um AI and accounting, obviously, you know, AI is doing a lot. AI's doing so much, you know, people are building dashboards and you know, we're sh we're doing so many cool stuff. Certainly inside of FC, you know, dashboards and then education onto those dashboards, and you know, people are building all like marketing things that go on post stuff, like all sorts of cool stuff.
SPEAKER_02Where do you see AI going in accounting?
SPEAKER_01Uh well from a taxation point of view, it's you know it's very hard to slowly keep up and do the actual auditing and the getting the work papers that we need to do your financials to um complete your tax each year. Like there's a there's a lot in it. Um and our wages go up every year the same as same as everyone else's. So we you know, we need AI to do just even tiny little bits here and there to try and be able to keep that cost effective.
SPEAKER_01Uh but at the end of the day, it's it's not where it needs to be uh from a tax and and financial statement point of view.
SPEAKER_02Yeah, because there's arguments like you guys are gonna be replaced, right?
SPEAKER_01So people are like, AI's gonna go. Um so from a tax accountant point of view, Black, it it's gonna happen at some point. You reckon? I'd I'd say so. I don't this definitely not definitely not right now, but uh as why wouldn't it? Yeah. Um but from a bookkeeping point of view, you know, there are starting to be tools that can do better things. Yeah. Um and the reading of invoices and and the automatic entry of you know rules, this goes here, that goes there, and those kinds of things.
SPEAKER_02Is it still gonna need a human to oversee it and drive it, do you think?
SPEAKER_01I think so. And and someone to know what's right and what's wrong. Yeah, that's right. Yeah. Interpret the law, um, you know, some of the arguments that I've had with AI as far as the law and how it is and whatnot, and then you go, yeah, but this. And they're like, oh yeah, you're right. No, yeah. Oh, thanks.
SPEAKER_02Why don't you say that first place?
SPEAKER_01Oh well, no, I just forgot. Yeah. So, you know, there's all sorts of things going around. Um, you know, we get emails quite a lot, and I have a lot of solicitor friends that that get emails um of people you know bringing up complete court cases against companies for um things that they've done and they're just re-representing themselves using AI. Yeah, yeah, yeah, yeah, yeah. Really? Uh so there's yeah, complete it's just complete fabricator to um you know throw this company under a bus.
SPEAKER_01And the cause so solicitors aren't allowed to use AI at all in their case material. And there's cases about AI and there's um the courses that the AI references are not so the courses, the um cases that the AI references aren't real, they're not actually making a case. So the business has to then go and pull it apart, pay someone legitimately to go and represent them.
SPEAKER_01So, you know, from a user point of view and um uninformed, I guess, yeah, um, using AI to go and do these things is just for the economy and waste of time.
SPEAKER_02Okay, okay. This is interesting. So let's be honest, if you're in there throwing it away AI and still getting accounting your voice, that's great. But make sure you're still talking to something. Legit? Okay. Um let's wrap this up. Is there any formal words if someone's out there um right now and you know something's tweaked on them? We'll put a link to your calendar below. They can they can log in and have a chat with you. Yeah, of course.
SPEAKER_01Um and is there any sort of formal words for for everyone at it? Yeah, honestly, I just think that you cannot have too much of an understanding. And if there's things that your account is saying and you glaze over in a in a meeting, um whether it's going back and looking at the transcript, hopefully you've got one, or sending them an email going, hey, can you just confirm what that is so that you can get it in writing, uh, you can go and put that in and research what the words of exit actually mean.
SPEAKER_01Um getting a second in for someone to explain things in a way that that you can understand. And the thing is, most accountants aren't doing uh a value at all. They just haven't been asked the right questions, or they're not able to explain things in a way that makes sense to you. And so finding someone that you find uh can explain things in a way that makes sense to you is probably the most important thing about using your account.
SPEAKER_02Um if you if you realize where you like and not like the money results on the other one,
Thinking about a second concept, or watching customer numbers drop even though your costs are in order? ▶ Book a discovery call: https://foodiecoaches.co/yt-bac In this solo episode, Tim answers two questions sent in by...
Running a cafe or cake shop and still working 16-hour days with no profit to show for it? ▶ Book a discovery call: https://foodiecoaches.co/yt-bac In this episode, Tim sits down with Carmen Connell, who owns Dash Cakes...
Julien Moussi has opened 40+ venues and has scaled Only Hospitality Group to $71M+. His success came from strategic decisions like selling the cafes that stopped paying for his time, learning that more venues is not the...
Wes Lambert from the Australian Restaurant and Cafe Association (ARCA) says Australian hospitality could be 100,000 workers short in the next 12 months. The reason is the new visa rules. Open hospitality jobs have...
How to scale a restaurant business: Johnny Di Francesco, 2014 World Pizza Champion and owner of 400 Gradi and The Gradi Group, shares what he learned going from one Melbourne restaurant to seven restaurants in...