Wes Lambert from the Australian Restaurant and Cafe Association (ARCA) says Australian hospitality could be 100,000 workers short in the next 12 months. The reason is the new visa rules. Open hospitality jobs have already gone from 45,000 to 68,000 in just two months. In this update, hospitality experts explain how the new visa rules for skilled workers, students and working holiday visitors are creating this gap. They also talk about what owners can do about staff and prices. Plus, they cover what happened after the surcharge ban, the trust tax changes and the Michelin Guide launch in Adelaide. ▶ Book a Profit Finding Session: https://foodiecoaches.co/yt-bac 0:00 Hospitality visa changes in Australia: 100,000 worker shortage 0:39 Credit card surcharge ban: menu prices and service charges 4:37 Trust tax changes in Australia: restructure costs and stamp duty 7:09 Why migration is the bigger issue for hospitality 8:30 482 skilled visa processing times for chefs and cooks 9:30 Student visa partner ban explained 11:40 Working holiday visa delays and the new ballot 13:20 Hospitality jobs on SEEK: 68,000 open jobs 14:00 Should you sponsor your staff? 16:54 Michelin Guide South Australia: Adelaide launch and NSW reusable cups ▶ Book a Profit Finding Session: https://foodiecoaches.co/yt-bac DISCLAIMER Update on the NSW reusable cup legislation: This episode was recorded before the NSW Government changed its position. On Wednesday 28 October 2026, the NSW Environment Minister announced that the reusable cup requirements discussed in this episode would be changed in response to small business concerns. The proposed rules to ban single-use cups for dine-in customers and make cafes provide free reusable cups are no longer going ahead. Some changes remain: from 2028, single-use takeaway coffee cups will need to be recyclable, and cafes and fast-food outlets will need to accept customers’ own reusable cups. The rest of the episode reflects the situation at the time of recording. Always check current regulations for your state before making changes to your business. https://www.epa.nsw.gov.au/news/epamedia/261028-statement-of-regulatory-intent-on-reusable-cups
Audio and video play straight from the show's own hosting. PodSubs stores and serves no media.
Transcript
From the show. Tap a time to play from there.
SPEAKER_01You're not supposed to charge a service charge because you have to be able to avoid any drip pricing.
SPEAKER_02I'm with Wes Lambert from ARCA and we're breaking down the surcharge ban, the trust tax changes, and the visa changes that could leave hospitality 100,000 workers short.
SPEAKER_01I challenge anybody who's asking, did you put your prices up on your coffee? If that's the only stupid question that you ask a cafe or restaurant, in accommodation food service, two months ago there were 45,000 open jobs on Seek. And I've been tracking this number almost for eight years. Last month, there were 60,000. This month, just yesterday, there are 68,000 open jobs in accommodation food service. Where do you think that's gonna go?
SPEAKER_02Welcome back to this month's industry update with the man, the myth, the legend. We are in person today, which is nice. Which is nice because we don't, we're not managing tech, so we just get to sit down and go over person. But um, whereas there's been heaps happening since last time we spoke. Obviously, credit card surcharges have come out. Most people have lifted their prices, and everyone's like, oh well, we didn't expect that to happen. And everyone's like, of course it's gonna happen. Some people, few people have absorbed it, few people have absorbed it. Um, a lot of people have raised their prices, and then there's all sorts of other stuff that's happening.
SPEAKER_02So let's go front end to back end.
SPEAKER_01So you talked about the surcharge ridiculousness and pricing. Yeah, now I challenge anybody who's asking, did you put your prices up on your coffee? If that's the only stupid question that you ask a cafe or restaurant, well, they might not have put their regular flat white price up. But you need to ask them follow-on questions. Did you increase the prices on anything on your menu? Yeah. Did you add a Saturday surcharge? Did you add a weekend surcharge?
SPEAKER_01Did you increase your weekend surcharges? Did you increase your public holiday surcharge?
SPEAKER_02Did you add a group surcharge? I've seen some uh I've seen some service charges getting added from a few people. I thought that was really interesting. Now you have to pay a percentage for service, and I was like, oh, that's cool. I wonder how like long it's going to be until that loophole's trying to be clear.
SPEAKER_01Look, so you're not supposed to charge a service charge because you have to be able to avoid any drip pricing. So you know, we we certainly advise strongly against that. Basically, just put that fee into your prices um because that's what you're supposed to do if it's if it's not avoidable on a particular day. Um, but then the whole ATO debacle and the government knowing since July that the ATO was gonna ban the credit card to pay for tax debt. It's ridiculous.
SPEAKER_01And then the small business minister who I like coming out and saying, I didn't know anything about it. Come on, that's BS. Come on, you know, shame, shame. Tell the truth.
SPEAKER_02I I was like the I honestly I shouldn't be surprised, but I am I I was dumbfounded when the ATO was like, yeah, no, we're gonna create can credit card surcharges.
SPEAKER_01It's like what what are you so so it's growing wider? So there are many, many organizations that are now considering banning credit cards. So the deft rent paying system is banned cards. We're hearing that councils and state governments and lots and lots of um authorities that previously accepted cards are considering stopping. Yep. So it isn't gonna go away, governments. This whole you know, stepping into private business and mucking around with something that wasn't broken so that you could say that you lowered the cost of a cup of coffee eight cents.
SPEAKER_01Yeah. Well, you didn't. Now coffee is 510, 520, 550. Good on you, government. Will a change of government fix it? Well, technically, yes, but you know, we're a year and a half away from the next election. And look, a change of government wouldn't just be a clear-cut two-party system. No. Then if there was a change of government federally and even maybe on a state level, you're talking about the other side, the conservative side, that will be made up of four or five different parties or different groups of people.
SPEAKER_02Because the way I'm looking at right now, like you got a lot of a lot of owners rolling around in trusts, like trust is shareholders, so we've got this trust issue we've got to deal with, surcharge rubbish that's come out, like which is just it's just noise. It's just more noise in the market. Like everyone puts their prices up in different ways. We just keep moving, it's more noise. This COP thing.
SPEAKER_01So let's talk about the trusts, right? Well, you you mentioned it. Let's go there. So the trust legislation is currently being reviewed. And the government says they are going to pass it before the end of 2026. They have the numbers to pass it. So this will make small businesses, small restaurants and cafes almost all that I know are in trust setups. So I'm not sure. Well, the trust is a shareholder, yeah. Yeah. Or the trust is the head office, and then you've got you know some businesses with five or ten PTY limiteds, which is what the government is using as an example.
SPEAKER_01Oh, you know, there's only blah, you know, hundreds of thousands of trusts in the country. But you're like, yes, because they own a bunch of PTY limiteds. And so all the money flows up to the trust and then back out to the trust beneficiaries. Yeah. Well, if this passes, it means that come 1 July 27, 1 July 28, sometime in the future, the legislation's going to come to roost, meaning people will have to spend money to find out if they need to restructure.
SPEAKER_01Yeah. And then they'll have to pay money to restructure. And in many jurisdictions, that will involve stamp duty, no matter what anybody says.
SPEAKER_02Stamp duty and stamp duty and potentially like CGT as well, like rollover depending on the year.
SPEAKER_01In some instances, yes. And the legislation that's already passed around the uh capital gains tax means that every asset must be revalued on 1 July 27th or later. So imagine the valuers are going to have millions and millions of businesses that they have to revalue. It's more and more money, more and more money. I mean, you know, and they're trying to stop inflation. And they're trying to stop inflation. And now all this money is going to have to go out the door just to comply with the red tape that the current governments, state and federal, are putting forward.
SPEAKER_02And it comes out of disposable income for some people. And the disposable income comes out of hospitality. Correct.
SPEAKER_01Because that's where we spend the money first, getting our coffee. Yeah, it doesn't.
SPEAKER_02Yeah, yeah, yeah. Coffee, breakfast, lunch, dinner. We track a lot of numbers in this group, but the one that matters most is a revenue. It's impact. Every operator we work with is proof that this industry doesn't have to run on burnout. So if you want to build a better business without sacrificing everything else, book a discovery call through the link in the show notes below.
SPEAKER_01Now, Tim, there is a much bigger issue in all of those things.
SPEAKER_02Let's talk about it. Migration. Yep.
SPEAKER_01I've already had people in my inbox on it. So for your members, for the wider audience who don't fully understand. Look, we do have a housing affordability problem. Now we don't necessarily have a housing shortage. Now you go to San Diego, San Francisco, and you see the tiny houses and the tents and the caravans on the side of the roads. That have that have fully employed people and families living in them. That is a housing shortage.
SPEAKER_01A housing avoidability crisis means that we don't have enough affordable housing for people to buy their own house or to live close to their job. We do not have hordes and hordes and hordes of people on the side of the road who are fully employed. So that's problem one. Now, we all agree that we have a housing avoidability crisis. That is being corrected. Property prices are coming down quite substantially. The issue is that all three major parties, current government, coalition, and one nation, all have even more successively restrictive migration policies, which means that the current government's migration policy is actually the least worst of the worst.
SPEAKER_01So it ain't gonna get better. Migration's not gonna get better in the short term, no matter who's in government. The issue is that the current government has decided that skilled employees, skilled workers in accommodation food service, chefs, cooks, restaurant managers, trade waiters, someliers, they are now last priority. And when I say last, I mean like dead last. Like those applications overseas aren't being processed for 16 to 24 months.
SPEAKER_01Now, if I have a shortage now, if I have an open job now, do you think I can wait 14 or 16 to 24 months to fill that job from overseas? No. Onshore, it's nine months to a year for your application to be processed, but at least you're here. So that's skilled. Now, that means that that we're gonna continue to have a shortage and then there'll be a lack of people applying. That's not gonna change the processing times because processing times for those visas are last. And there is nothing that speeds them up. They are 482s that have to go through home affairs, even if they're through the state processes, they're still last on the list.
SPEAKER_01Then international students. Now, international students' numbers were already plummeting because of the visa approvals, but now partners are banned on student visas, which means you cannot bring family or partners along with your student visa. You know what?
SPEAKER_02At all. I heard this. I had a cab driver on the way to the hotel on Monday, and you come over here and he was okay, but he couldn't get his partner here and his kids all because of because of the change, because of the change in visa. That's right. And they had all these plans and they changed the visa and like, no good.
SPEAKER_01That's right, no good. So if you hadn't applied already, no good. Which means, now I understand there was a loophole that if you actually put in a legitimate partner visa, it would take years to get your partner here. But if you got an international student visa approved, you could bring your partner and kids over almost instantly. I understand they closed a loophole, but those partners, and in many cases, the dependent um work-age children can no longer work in accommodation food service. Huge drop. So if they're not here, they can't work with the other. Oh, yeah, yeah, yeah. And that's where they all go too.
SPEAKER_01So also, there's no further stay. You're here on a tourist visa. I came on a tourist visa when I came the first time. And you're still here. And I'm still here. Permanent resident and citizen. I was gonna say permanent resident. Yeah, you're still here on tourists. Uh-huh. Um, no further stay. Yep. Gotta go. Yeah, right. You come here on working holiday. Can't convert that to any other visa type. Really? If you're an international student, you cannot visa hop. If you finish your cert one, cert two, cert three, cert four, diploma, bachelor's degree, master's degree.
SPEAKER_02Yep.
SPEAKER_01You have to go forward. So you can't come here as an accounting student and get a bachelor's in accounting and then want to stay and say, I'm gonna get a cert three in hospitality or commercial cookery. Can't do that anymore. You gotta go. So that's a big problem because lots of people came, decided to go do something else because there were too many accountants or too many something.
SPEAKER_02Well, that's what happens when you're that age, too. Yeah, when you're in uni, yeah.
SPEAKER_01That's right. And so now there's they can't stay. And the worst is working holiday makers. Yep. So you used to be you could get your working holiday maker visa approved in as little as an hour and three days. 72 hours was the standard. Now it's up to three months. Now imagine if you're a working holidaymaker age and you're overseas and you're trying to decide between Australia and other countries, and the Australian website goes, we will process the application within 90 days, you're like, screw that.
SPEAKER_01The spring and summer will be over. I I don't have time to do that. I I thought it would only be, you know, instant or up to three days. So they're not going to come straight into our spring and summer season. And at the same time, they've said that in the very near future that they're going to put forward table legislation and get it passed that says that there will be a lottery system for year two and year three working holidaymaker visas. And the year two will go from 60,000 to 45,000 available visas.
SPEAKER_01And the year one to year three will go from 60,000 to just 5,000 working holidaymaker visas. And in order to qualify, even to be in the ballot for the third year, you have to have done six months in the regions, which means if there's no chance that you, if the chance is so low, 60,000 to 5,000, you're not going to do it. Which basically means that it's signaling that we don't want working holidaymakers to stay here. And so people won't make plans to stay here.
SPEAKER_01And in many cases, they just won't come because they know that in other countries that they can get either an uninterrupted two or three years, or that it's not a ballot system. So in accommodation food service, two months ago, there were 45,000 open jobs on Seek. And I've been tracking this number almost for eight years. Last month, there were 60,000. This month, just yesterday, there are 68,000 open jobs in accommodation food service. Where do you think that's gonna go? Because for the past 20 years, the industry has grown by 30,000 jobs every year.
SPEAKER_01New jobs.
SPEAKER_02Yeah, yeah, yeah.
SPEAKER_01So 600 odd thousand to almost a million in 20 years. Well, in the next 12 months, we're gonna have 30,000 more and 30,000 more. And they've cut off our lifeline of international students, working holiday makers, and skilled migrants. Um, we're gonna have a hundred thousand person whole in the next 12 months. So, everyone, if you have employees that you're considering sponsoring, sponsor them. Sponsor them, spend the money because there is a very good chance that they will have to leave.
SPEAKER_01That's interesting. We're hearing stories of certain uh individuals that are being given a very short amount of time to get out of Australia.
SPEAKER_02Yeah, yeah. It's it's very interesting because obviously, yeah, our members who have been with us for a prolonged period of time have like line-ups of people to work from. They got because you know, everyone wants to work for the people with the culture and the brand and the stuff, right? But the people who are only just starting, they're like, man, it's so hard to find stuff. It's only gonna get worse. So if you're out there saying it's gonna get hard to find staff, it's already harder to find staff. You're gonna have to do something else because the staff, the the team are gonna have a choice now.
SPEAKER_02They're gonna be choices. They're gonna and it's not just all gonna come down to money, it's also gonna come down to culture, environment, job type, how they're treated.
SPEAKER_01So what will happen initially is wages will begin to go up quite quickly in accommodation food service, which means prices, menu prices will go up. Because you businesses can't absorb the supply and demand problem with you either find the chef you need or the manager you need or you close. That's right. Yeah. Um and tech will rise. So a coffee machine can't make any more coffees than that machine can make in an hour, right? You're you if you have 30 seats in your cafe and your customers come for an hour at a time, you're gonna have 30 people per hour.
SPEAKER_01It's not like you can there's bottlenecks.
SPEAKER_02We're gonna start moving to automated machines and well, yeah.
SPEAKER_01I maybe we're not there yet. Not robotic, but where we will be is any businesses that uptake um programs like yours, but also uh hospotech that speeds up the processes of payment, that speeds up the processes of ordering. Um anything that can shave any amount of idle time off of the experience of the consumer. You know, when you think about someone coming in and ordering, standing in line, waiting to order QR codes in line to order ahead.
SPEAKER_01And um, you know, when you're in the venue and you're waiting for a server to come and take your order, QR codes on the table to order ahead. Yeah, yeah. Like all of those kind of things that can speed up the process so that the consumer doesn't notice it's actually better customer service, but that you can turn the tables faster and that you can actually get more people through. So that's a good thing about having you know the wedge of uh lower workforce, but all of those things come at a cost. And you know, the government just hasn't factored in that cost increase.
SPEAKER_02Yeah, yeah, yeah, yeah. So, all right. Do you have any good news?
SPEAKER_01Sunny outside. Um, it's raining in Queensland where you are. Um, look, it's um sunny. It's sunny. Yes. I mean, tourism's down still 6% year over year. You know what? I've got some good news. What's the good news? I was at the Michelin launch in MLAs.
SPEAKER_02Yes, that's right. You're gonna talk about this. I saw the photo. Yeah.
SPEAKER_01How was it? Oh, you want to see the photo? No, my friend. I've saw the photo. I saw the photo. Um, yeah, so I was lucky enough to be invited by Michelin to come to the Michelin Guide launch in South Australia, and I can tell you that the 77 businesses that uh are in the guide were well deserved. And what I can also tell you is that's gonna put a huge amount of pressure on the other states and territories to bring Michelin to their state. Really? Yeah, of course. Yeah, technically, in the restaurant card game, two stars is a hand that certainly beats a hand of three hats.
SPEAKER_01Yeah. Sorry to say that, but global recognition, where you are compared against all of the other starred, two-starred, three-starred venues around the world, that two-starred business is the number one restaurant in Australia. And I know people will disagree, and that's fine, but that's just how the rankings are in a local system versus a global system.
SPEAKER_02Talk to me. What are the other states going to need to do to get Michelin in there?
SPEAKER_01Well, you know, the tourism ministers and the tourism bodies in a couple of states, New South Wales and Victoria, um, need to get off their bums and and look at the economic benefit that Michelin and South Australia is bringing. Okay. Um, you know, it's I told the Peter Malinowskis, the premier, um, right after the presentation that I'd back of the envelope that in a 12-month period, it will be nearly a billion dollars in economic activity just to South Australia.
SPEAKER_01And yeah, absolutely, because it's if you come as an international food tourist to bucket list the two-starred restaurants and the one-starred restaurants in South Australia, yes, you're gonna eat at those restaurants, but you're gonna have breakfast somewhere else, you're gonna have lunch somewhere else, you're gonna have a plane, trains, automobiles, hotels, retail, yeah, all the other things that you do, other experiences. And even if you were conservative and you said it was only$200 million, very conservative, that's what I expect just the revenue in those businesses increase will be.
SPEAKER_01But if you said 200, that's 20 million extra in GST, which I promise is more than it costs to bring Michelin to South Australia.
SPEAKER_02Yeah. Yeah, very true. Very true. Did you did you explain the numbers like that to him?
SPEAKER_01Well, you know, Peter doesn't need an explanation, he understands. But the other um ministers and tourism bodies, you know, they need uh boot up the bum.
SPEAKER_02Because it's like like do you reckon they understand the economics in the keep cut system? Ha. They don't have anything to do with that.
SPEAKER_01I I think I think ultimately um it isn't a financial decision. I think it's more an a established industry player decision. So there are lots of award systems, state and federal, um, that have been around for a long time that are the incumbents. And it's hard to change, it's hard to turn to something new. But Michelin is a global award system that brings international tourists.
SPEAKER_01It doesn't change local award systems. Um, you know, the James Beard Award in the US and many other state and local awards for hospitality businesses did not go down when Michelin came to the US and to other jurisdictions. It doesn't negatively affect any of that.
SPEAKER_02No, I don't think I yeah, I think there is only an op sort, to be honest. Um all right, Wes. Well, mate, so let's just think about what this means for hospital. Number one, um, if you haven't if you just absorbed your F plus surcharges and you haven't put up your pricing, well, you need to think about that. You need to get onto that now because you just it's just costing you money. Um, number two, the whole keep cup thing. I think we just sit on, we'll just put that keep cup thing on the fence a couple of years away from it, let everyone carry on.
SPEAKER_02Um, and what's the next step for you? Will you go and like knock on some doors and be like you guys are making some bad decisions here?
SPEAKER_01Is that we already did that. And so yeah, ultimately um we lobbied through the media, which is one way to lobby. Um, and you know that that has changed the narrative. And hopefully the New South Wales government doesn't go ahead with a restrictive cup system. We love sustainability, but uh just like the single-use plastics, you had a decade, you work with suppliers, you worked with businesses, and we don't you know we don't really feel the single-use plastics. It's balsa wood, it's paper, it's paper cups and straws, and we don't mind it.
SPEAKER_01No one really cares. But to demand and force and mandate it that that never works with small businesses.
SPEAKER_02No, no, no.
SPEAKER_01Um and we'll keep pushing on the trusts. We're headed down to Canberra again in November to fight the trust tax changes, and we are going to mount a large-scale campaign on migration.
SPEAKER_02Oh, yeah, and then migration. So the migration thing, that's happening now, right?
SPEAKER_01Look, part of it is and but the signaling. So if I told you that in the very near future that there were gonna be major changes to something around migration, you're probably not gonna come here. Yeah. You're probably not gonna, you're gonna go somewhere where you're gonna feel safe about it.
SPEAKER_02Yep. Welcome with open arms. Yep, yep, yep. All right. Well, thank you. I appreciate your time. Um, team, I just want to finish off on saying that you've got two options. You can focus on the negatives or you can focus on the positives. There are positives out there, and if you focus on them, you will find more positives because that's what you'll look for. And if you're struggling with staff right now, you need to understand it's not gonna get better and say it's hard to get staff, isn't gonna fix it, and you need to do something about it. Um, so if that's you, I'm gonna put a link to my my book a call with one of my team, and we'll show you the systems what you need to put in place to do it because it's not gonna get fixed overnight.
SPEAKER_02And if you're not a member of ARCA yet, you need to be. I'm gonna put a link to Wes's membership down there. It's like cheapest chips, it's like 50 bucks.
SPEAKER_01$52 a year for uh just a voting membership. It's arca.org.eu.
SPEAKER_02Yeah, and the more Wes is doing, the more active it's becoming, and there's all sorts of stuff popping up on my calendar all the time. Conversations. Um, so make sure you jump on, support him. If you're struggling with staff, jump in. We've got solutions for you. Won't change overnight, but it will happen. So until next month, Wes, we'll see you then. Thanks, Dave. I didn't come from hospitality, I came from accounting, watching skilled operators struggle with the business side of a business that they were great at running. And that's the gap Foodie Coaches was built to close.
SPEAKER_02So if that sounds like what you're missing, head to the show notes and book a discovery call.
Thinking about a second concept, or watching customer numbers drop even though your costs are in order? ▶ Book a discovery call: https://foodiecoaches.co/yt-bac In this solo episode, Tim answers two questions sent in by...
Running a cafe or cake shop and still working 16-hour days with no profit to show for it? ▶ Book a discovery call: https://foodiecoaches.co/yt-bac In this episode, Tim sits down with Carmen Connell, who owns Dash Cakes...
Julien Moussi has opened 40+ venues and has scaled Only Hospitality Group to $71M+. His success came from strategic decisions like selling the cafes that stopped paying for his time, learning that more venues is not the...
How to scale a restaurant business: Johnny Di Francesco, 2014 World Pizza Champion and owner of 400 Gradi and The Gradi Group, shares what he learned going from one Melbourne restaurant to seven restaurants in...
How to scale a restaurant business: Mo Saad, co-founder of Fricken Chicken, explains how he went from one food truck to four locations across two states. ▶ Book a Profit Finding Session: https://foodiecoaches.co/yt-bac...