My Daughter, the Mathematician (Fathers Day Special)
58 minAudio
In this Father’s Day episode of Magic Internet Math, I welcomed my daughter Kayla to the mic for her first appearance on the show. We started with her recent work explaining group theory in just three minutes, then used that as a jumping-off point to talk about why ideas like groups, inverses, isomorphisms, elliptic curves, and point addition matter so much in Bitcoin and cryptography. We also got honest about the difference between intuition and rigor: I’ve spent a lot of time building conceptual bridges for this audience, while Kayla is bringing the mathematician’s instinct to stop, verify the ground beneath her feet, and ask what has actually been proved. From there, we traced the path that led her into math in the first place, from early logic puzzles and Waldorf-school mental math to an unusually rich high-school calculus experience, AP Calc BC, Penn State, linear algebra, analysis, and her current summer research in number theory. Along the way, we talked about why good teachers matter, why “math person” does not mean “numbers person,” how linear algebra suddenly makes everything click, and why Gauss keeps showing up everywhere once you start taking mathematics seriously. Magic Internet Math: https://magicinternetmath.com/ BTC Prague: https://btcprague.com/ Programming Bitcoin by Jimmy Song: https://jimmysong.org/books/programming-bitcoin/ Understanding Cryptography by Christof Paar and Jan Pelzl: https://link.springer.com/book/10.1007/978-3-642-04101-3 Benedict Gross (Harvard profile): https://people.math.harvard.edu/~gross/ Harvard Math E-222 Abstract Algebra archive: https://legacy-www.math.harvard.edu/archive/122_fall_03/index.html Linear Algebra Done Right by Sheldon Axler: https://linear.axler.net/index.html Penn State Department of Mathematics: https://science.psu.edu/math Waldorf Education (AWSNA): https://www.waldorfeducation.org/
Audio and video play straight from the show's own hosting. PodSubs stores and serves no media.
Transcript
From the show. Tap a time to play from there.
UnknownAlright. Welcome back to the Magic Internet Math podcast. We're back. And, I got a new face sitting next to me. This is why don't you introduce yourself? I'm Kayla. I'm his daughter. Yes. And this happens to be Father's Day. This is my Father's Day gift to all of you is you all know that Kayla studies math. At least I've claimed this. It's time you guys are gonna get to verify and see what she has,
what's going on up there. And we're doing this because I think she's gonna be part of the podcast in some way going forward. And I don't know. This is well, this is the first time we're doing this. This is my first time doing this now since coming back from Prague where I basically got to teach abstract algebra over there to at the Bitcoin conference. What do you think about that? Me? No.
UnknownI was like, I was teaching abstract algebra to people in my research program. We were doing the same thing. You want me to say that again? Say more. Say more. More. Yeah. Well, I had to do a practice talk where I talked about, like, a fundamental concept in my research. And my mentor was like, just talk to them about what a group is. And so I had to talk about group theory in three minutes
UnknownThree minutes of group theory. And why it matters. That's not a lot of time to get through it. We did about six episodes on this. On group theory. Yeah. Yeah. I need you need, like, a whole, like, college lecture, fifty minutes of So what did you end up doing? Me? Yeah. No. Sorry. So what did I do? I put, like I had to convince you that the integers was a group in one minute. Okay. So I you know, like, associativity
Unknownand Are the integers a group? Yes. Under addition. Ah, yeah. K. Which was funny because when I made my slide, I put, like, oh, examples of groups, and I put, like, integers under multiplication. And while I was practicing, I was like, I had this, oh, no. Like I noticed. Introduced the concept of zero and net like, every integer has a negative version of itself. Then when you add them together, you get zero. And at that point in the I had to record this presentation. At that point, I'm, like, yelling. Like, this is amazing. Like
UnknownThree minutes? Like, I think integers under addition is the only way to do that in three minutes. And then it's like, why does any of this matter? Why do we need to define a group? And so I felt like I had to talk about isomorphism without even without saying isomorphism. That's how I got introduced to topology. And I would say, like, maybe fifty minutes or less is topology classifies, like, which shapes are the same or are equivalent.
So, like, a circle and a square equivalent because you can, like, pinch out the edges. You don't have to tear a hole in the circle to transform it into a square. And that they were describing to me like a homeomorphism.
UnknownIt's yeah. So this is, like, my eternal question and why I think this stuff is really important is exactly this thing. It's like, how do you do you deal with the fact that two things that don't look like each other can be considered equivalent? And, you know, for in one, if in the context, like the context that we worry about in Bitcoin with cryptography, that's double edged because you may worry that there's some backdoor in an equivalent
isomorphic. In some isomorphic world, maybe it's easy to break the discrete log problem. Whereas in the world we all live in, it's basically impossible. Right? Or maybe you worry about, I mean, I guess that would violate the fact that it's an isomorphism. But I mean, maybe in some isomorphism, somebody can actually see it in a way that enables them That can break it. Yeah. It enables them to attack it. So that would be a fear. Right? So that's something we will kind of want to be aware of and want to understand
isomorphisms. They, know, they're very powerful. They they could be an attack. They could also be a solution where like, you see this come up in the quantum conversation notion of isogenies where you can have an isomorph you can have an elliptic curve that's isomorphic to the current elliptic curve that might have better, stronger properties, more protective properties that make it or at least that make it one more abstraction and one more step one more dip one more step of difficulty to
breaking discrete log. So, like, I it's like it's a solution, and it's also another attack factor. But it's something that you wanna be aware of. So I think in three minutes, if you were able to get this concept of isomorphism without saying the word like that, that's saying those sounds,
Unknownthat's pretty good. Because once you say isomorphism, people who don't like math, they just stop listening. They're like, yeah, this is what math is. Just complicated words. Yeah. ISO blah blah blah, whatever, know. It's not even Greek. I don't even know what is you know. Yeah. Things like isomorphism that's why I like the jargon. I mean, it's important. It's important to us so we know what we're talking about. But, like, it's also important that we spend some time trying to think about how to communicate this to regular people.
Not too hard, but, like, gotta think hard about it. I got eighteen minutes in, in Prague on the GART stage, and, it turned out to be enough to get across, like, the basic things, like, basically, what we talked about in six episodes here, which is how an elliptic curve is a group. Right? It's a finite field, and it's also a group that has these properties. And if you understand these, you know, the properties of closure and under inverses,
talked about this a lot, you could actually understand how your, you can validate your private key if you have a public key that you know is on the curve.
UnknownI think that's the most important part is the inverse. Inverse. Yeah. Some groups where it's like, you don't know like, if you have a result, you know that two things are multiplied to get that result, but you don't know what things are multiplied. You just know that you can get back there. Yes. That that's the key. That's why Harry Adney's weapon against the Minotaur, the only one to defeat the Minotaur in the cave was the thread. Right? Because Ariadne, all of the other
all of the other people who went in to fight the Minotaur couldn't find their way out of the cave. Right? So that's the the inverse is very powerful. If you can't find your way back and actually, you know, so other things in cryptography, like a hash function that that doesn't have an inverse semi group doesn't have an inverse. It's also very powerful. So we use those as well. And so, like, this field is loaded. So, like, as much as we may hate applied math, right,
With regards to cryptography, I don't find myself not hating it very much. I find I find it very engaging. I find it a very engaging motivator to like, it's actually enlightening in a certain way that, you know, you could go your whole life saying, I don't care if this matters to anybody, but one day it matters to people, and it's act that's that's actually kind of exciting. Right?
UnknownBecause people wanna know, like, oh, what applications does I know. Group theory have. That's actually a cool application. Yeah. I could spend three more minutes just talking about why it's an application. Why don't you? I can't just say, like But do it in the moment. Because we were just saying, like, if you multiply, like, 20 things together, it's really hard to find out how many times it was multiplied, but a computer can multiply, like, 20 like, if you wanted to say, like, six to the twentieth power,
a computer can do that in seconds. But if they give you, like, a huge number, they can't figure out what number to the power is that. Like, two to the two fifty six? Yeah. Yeah. And
Unknownyeah. Go on. No. That that's it. But, like, you know you know that it exists. Right. That's right. That's private key. That's you know it exists only if you well, the thing we've never done for what it's worth and to be totally fair, the thing that we've never done here is actually prove or validate that an elliptic curve is a finite field, or that the points on the elliptic curve is a group. That's probably work in our future. Right? That's more that's like the kind of thing I'm waiting for you to be
more far further along in your work to do something like that. Right? Because that's right now, we're waving our hands at this knowledge. Right? Because I was honestly Because that's what we know. I'm trusting a math book right now that the elliptic curve or points that that are elliptic curve creates a group and their points on a finite field in a finite field. So, like, right now, we're trusting that. So to be fair, right, that that this is where, like, now that Kayla's here,
you guys might not know it by looking at her, but she's coming in and bringing rigor. Am I? Yeah. You are. You're bringing rigor that I I'm not a rigor. I'm not really I guess that's what I'm trained in. I Well, that's why. Yeah. I'm not a rigor guy. I'm a guy that, like, just wants to read more books and find out how it connects to things, but I'm not I'm moving in a forward direction much faster than you are where you're like, no. How do I how do I know this rock I'm standing on is solid before I jump on to the next one? And that's what that's really what mathematicians do.
That's why I don't call myself a mathematician, but I call Kayla a mathematician. Right? So, like, we need we need that. We don't need everybody to be that. We just need enough of those people to make sure that our assertions are solid. Right? Just to make sure that we can verify what everything we're saying. So we are still assuming, like, I haven't done a proof for anybody here. I haven't yeah. And I haven't seen one. I haven't really sought one out yet
around this idea that the elliptic curve does form a group or is does possess the properties of a group or that it's isomorphic to a finite field modulo to the two fifty six minus two to the thirty second minus nine seventy seven. That modulo that big prime. My modulo big p. We haven't done that proof. We haven't proved it. We have been assuming it. Right? So even if you know this is like we say, like, man, even if you know the math, you still have to you still have to do a lot to prove it to yourself. But
I think this is more about the journey of saying, where are my gaps? Right? That's the that's where, like, your power comes from, I think, as a human being. It's where are the gaps?
UnknownThat's it. What background am I missing? Like, I feel like for elliptic curves, it's background and maybe some algebraic geometry. Which you're studying. Yeah. Because the first time I learned that the elliptic curve was an abelian group was in a crash course about Fermat's last theorem. And they basically just told us, this is an abelian group. Well, they didn't even say. They just said that it was a group. Right. And that
then I asked. I was like, isn't it an abelian group? Good question. I read I read my old abstract algebra teacher's paper. I'm pretty sure he was studying elliptic curves and endomorphisms and stuff that I don't understand, but I was interested in his work. And so that's when I first learned that elliptic curves form an abelian group, but I had no idea how.
UnknownSo right now, it's a fact that we're trusting. Yeah. But I remember thinking it's really cool. Like, really? Is it under addition or under multiplication? Under what what they call point addition. Okay. K. So point So interesting. Yeah. Point addition. Sorry. I was looking to see if I had my cryptography book here. I don't. But in that first cryptography book that I got by Par and Palzel, point edition is, like, super elementary that they brought in very early. Like, this is basically how elliptic curves work, point edition. You can see point edition in Jimmy Song's programming Bitcoin book, like in the first chapter.
It's a very elementary operation. It's not but it's an abstract operation. It's not the kind of addition that we think of when we say one plus one equals two.
UnknownIt's It's like a b plus c d. It's more vector addition. Yeah. Something like more like a vector addition where the object the output of the object is not an a number. A point on the elliptic curve represents something with more information than just a number. Right? Just like a vector. It has to, like, solve the elliptic curve, basically. Sorry. Like, the point has to solve the elliptic curve. So you can add the two points, but you have to show that the result
actually works, and it's not, like, an incorrect equation.
UnknownYes. So that's and that's how you validate it. So the other interesting thing, I guess, on this is when I was in Prague, I met a professor. I think he's a professor. I I I don't know. I was introduced to a guy. His name is Jan Kopek, and he wrote a book. Ugh. So stupid. I should have it here so I can show it. He wrote a book. Basically, it he wrote a book called Bitcoin Mathematics, but it's all in Czech. Like, 100% of this book is written in Czech. This guy speaks a number of languages, just not English,
mostly out of not caring about ever communicating with English people, English speaking people. But when I was introduced to him and I saw his book, we basically just geeked out for thirty minutes over modular arithmetic. Like, he's obsessed. And I you know, like, this, you could tell. You know? You could tell when two guys who don't speak each other's language can talk for half hour about this thing. We're just obsessed with it. But so the thing that oh, man. I'm gonna have to figure out a way to support this with some
images here. But, basically, the cover of the book is a it's like a doughnut with a tangent like a plane tangent to it. So picture a doughnut and a plane tangent. And somehow that's he represented an elliptic curve. He represented all the points in the elliptic curve essentially as that object, which I think is really powerful and how that's sort of tearing open a new rabbit hole that I feel like like, I'm either gonna go, like, super into Galois theory, or I'm gonna try to understand why the hell he put this picture on the cover of his book.
Right? So, yeah, very, very interesting, but also cool experience. And, like, it's kind of thing, like, in Prague when I was doing the I did this keynote on called the mathematical layer of Bitcoin sovereignty. And it's like everything I talk about in the podcast. But like, all of a sudden, man, I really did get associated by like being this math guy. So like, somebody's like, oh, I gotta introduce you to this guy who wrote this math book. Like that never happened to me before. That was no one was nobody was trying to introduce me to people like that. Right? And there was never gonna be a mutual respect immediately upon meeting somebody like that.
Right? I would have had I would have had to have approached him like a fanboy or something like that and just, you know, especially a guy that doesn't speak my language. But, like so this was there was an immediate respect and immediate all all these things, it's you know, sometimes I wonder why did I fly to the other side of the world to do a talk about group theory, you know? But it's starting to like, for people who listen to this podcast, people who are interested in this, it's starting it's it's starting to grow. The identity is starting to form,
and it's a good thing. So what I thought we would do with Kayla here for the audience now that you now that you got a taste of what, you know, how you know, what she is here. You wanna talk about, like, I think we should talk about your education and how you got here. That would be interesting. Right? I don't know that we wanna talk today about endomorphisms and isomorphisms
and algebraic geometry just today. Right? Let's talk about your education.
UnknownMaybe Like, lifelong education. Start as early as you want to how how did you become this? It's a good question. But into the mic. Yeah. Of course. This is our first podcast, so I have to and I have to just keep dadding her into making sure you guys making sure you guys hear her. So that you can hear me. Yeah. I don't know where to start because I remember in second grade, I pretended to like math
because I wanted to be annoying.
UnknownTo who? To the world. Oh, nice. And but I ended up really enjoying it. I don't remember what we did. What does that mean, by the way? I wanted to be annoying to the world, so I pretended to like math. Because everyone, like, you know, everyone hates school when they're a kid, and everyone hates math because they think it's difficult. Yeah. Mhmm. I hated doing math homework as a kid. I think that was my first
taste of math and, like, learning geometry and
Unknowncool stuff like that. So by pretending to like it, you kinda forgot you were pretending to like it and you started to like it? Yeah. Really? That's you tricked yourself into I did trick myself. It was so weird. That's amazing. Parents out there, boy, I don't know how you use that information, but it's pretty all this time, I thought it was my parenting that did this, and apparently, she just trolled herself into liking math. Yeah. I remember I had a math tutor. I don't remember what age I was, but I just wanted to know what it was like to have a tutor.
And I remember doing these logic puzzles. And I think that was the most fun math I did as a kid. I don't remember any of this. It was like, you know, like, when you go to the airport and they have those, like, crossword puzzles and stuff. They have, like, those logic puzzles where it's like, you have to find out which person ordered which thing from the restaurant Yes. Based on three prompts.
UnknownWe got five people. There are five different occupations. They order different five different things, and you had to, like yeah. I love those. I love those logic. I'm pretty sure I got those for you at the airport. But I'm trying to remember when you had a tutor. I don't recall. Don't recall. Very long. I don't even remember her name. But she would come in for thirty minutes, and we would just do logic puzzles. What? It was just math and wisdom math. How was I not? I feel like we did one of those patches, and I was, like, struggling really hard.
UnknownOkay. And this is when you were in second grade? Maybe, like, third grade. Second and third grade, we we hired a tutor for you to do logic puzzles with. Just because I think I was just like, hey, mom, dad, I want a tutor. So I'll just say, from my vantage point, we were getting very we were starting to get kind of intense in second and third grade. And it wasn't until fourth grade that I started to figure out that I didn't like I really didn't want you in public school anymore.
UnknownYeah. They didn't like me because I would be, like, taking off my shoes and putting them back on. Oh, yeah. I went to a parent teacher conference, and I went to I remember going in first grade to a parent teacher conference, and the teacher was complaining about how you took your shoes off. And I was sitting there. I had taken my shoes off under under the table. And I was like, I remember it's just like, this is this is all this is bullshit. Like, they just don't they're they're gonna I don't know. They're gonna take something away from you that makes you you. I didn't I it was starting I was starting to not like it in first grade. In second grade, I was it was getting more intense. Third grade was, like, the final the last straw, I thought.
UnknownBecause they didn't put me in the advanced math program. All I needed was a teacher recommendation. Which I didn't care that much about. Didn't Me neither. I was like, I don't care. Like, the people in my math class are funny. Like, I don't wanna change classes. I didn't but I didn't like the reasons. And I didn't like how little I had to say about it. And I I just didn't like, like, really any of it. And then what happened in fourth grade was you actually had a good teacher. So we almost got tricked in fourth grade. But by that time, I'd already done all my research on the Waldorf School. And by fifth grade, were gone. We had pulled you out and you were gone. And that was that.
UnknownAnd then Then my math teacher was my class teacher who actually graduated from college with a math degree. So she was teaching us she was basically teaching us, like, theorems without us knowing what it is. She taught us modular arithmetic with that like, as mental math tricks. I remember bringing he one time, he taught me this trick, which is so cool, and you can actually prove it by induction.
But any number ending in five squared By he, you mean me? Yeah. My dad. Yeah. Yeah. Any number that ends in five, when you square it, it ends with 25. And then you take the first, like, the digits before that, and you multiply it by the consecutive number after it. So, like, 35, you take the three, and it's three times four. And so you have 12, and then you just add you just add 25 to the end, and it's 1225. And it works for every number ending at 5. And I remember coming to her with that,
and she would make us do mental math problems like that every day.
UnknownYeah. That's cool. And that's, like, easy to prove algebraically, but it's still just a cool thing to, you know it's just it's just one of those cool little things. She would make us do It's like spinning a basketball. Mental math, she would be like, okay. So today is Tuesday. What day will it be in fifty seven days? Mhmm. And we would just have to know that, like, what number 56 was by seven. Like, dividing by seven, what's the remainder with that?
So we can say, oh, actually, what day will it be in one day? And so, like, fifty six days, it'll be Wednesday. She made us do problems like that, which is pretty much modular arithmetic by seven.
UnknownEquivalence classes, residue classes. I mean, you know, I'm I'm you're seeing Vermont's little theorem at play in here. Right? It's all I saw so much of that at the Waldorf School that nobody else saw. Like, I saw it through knitting, especially particularly crochet. I saw it through you guys had to knit a Mobius. Yeah. Right? And, you know, I'm trying to explain to the parents at parents meeting, like, you guys understand. You got you're teaching advanced math right now without actually knowing it.
And every most people just wanted me to shut up. And you know what I think is it's interesting. You had all this, and it was very rich. Yet I don't think anybody other than you is studying anything even remotely related to math. From my class. Yeah. From your class who had this particular class teacher who was a math major who actually
Unknownwas teaching you these things in a, you know, in an interesting way. In a way that they're I think that they're supposed to be taught. Mhmm. And it's funny because everyone in my class was like, why is she our math teacher? Why are we learning math this way? I know. Because so if you guys don't know in the Waldorf School, what's called the class teacher, like, start in first grade, and you go to eighth grade with that teacher. So by the time you're in fourth or fifth grade, she's like your mom. So it's just a it's just a a different relationship
that you would have with a typical than you would have with a typical teacher. So I could see why the kids are getting, like, uppity about, like, oh, why is she a math teacher? You know?
UnknownThen I got to high school, and it was, like, regular high school curriculum math. Like, you gotta learn algebra one and two. Mhmm. And then you gotta take geometry and precalculus and then calculus. Yep. And they put me in algebra two Mhmm. With I was in ninth grade, and I was in class with a bunch of tenth graders. And that was the hardest. You were in algebra two because it was an obsession of
your mother. I was not till those disassociated from that, but it was not I wouldn't call it an obsession. But like that, it was like you had to get to calculus in high school. That was, like, the way she thought. And, again, I'm not saying that she's only she's the only one who thought that. I'm just saying that that that her she had an obsession, and it was a driving force. And so if you just back in to what would've what conventionally needs to happen if you're gonna get to calculus in your senior year. You'd have to take
precalculus in your junior year, geometry in your sophomore year, which means you'd have to go to algebra two in your freshman year, high school. You couldn't start with algebra one. Now that's that was the back end thinking, and that's why you were in algebra two. It turns out your path was so messed up and weird that that whole thing went out the window. Right? What do you mean? Well, you did algebra two and you did geometry, but then because you were in a class of six kids and only you were the only one the only one that was gonna take pre calc. You were the only one that was gonna take pre calc. So the teacher said, we're I'm not we're actually not doing this class. You're gonna have to take it at a college over the summer. Well, I got to choose actually
Unknownbecause Tanya was offering for me to take Tanya was offering me to take calculus as an eleventh grader instead of twelfth grader. This is another teacher at the school, a math teacher Mhmm. At in the high school who was exception who like, so you She's great. You had an exceptional calculus teacher. So okay. So, basically, what happened though was So she made me choose, and I really had to think about
you know, I've made it so far ahead in math. Like, do I wanna, like, continue studying this beyond high school? I wanna find out what is beyond calculus. Because for me, I always thought that calculus was just the end. Right. And, you know, finding out that there was more than that, I was curious. So then I was like, okay. Let's let's try and go as far ahead as I possibly can. So I was I was the only eleventh grader
taking calculus in a class of twelfth graders in eleventh grade.
UnknownYeah. So you ended up in calculus in eleventh grade because that summer you did pre calculus. I was concerned about that plan. I didn't I just didn't know if you would. I think the summertime is a little bit of a compressed time frame for something like precalculus. I was worried that maybe things like trigonometric identities. Like, there's certain things that if you don't internalize them for a long time, you get to calculus and you need them. You need to internalize them and you need to
and I was just concerned that that would be a problem. Still a setback because
UnknownI still have beef with the sine and cosine when I'm taking real analysis, and they love analyzing sine and cosine. Yes. Well, you know, as much as you'll think maybe you love abstract algebra now because you don't have to deal with those things, those they're coming. I I assure you those are coming. When you want to get to cyclotomic fields, cyclotomic groups. Right now, that's what I'm trying to get to. That's my hardest learning curve.
UnknownYeah. So you're never going to get away from sine and cosine are fundamental. Now you don't learn them fundamentally in high school. You learn them as rules. You learn them as actually derivatives of the Cartesian system. Right? You say, here's the Cartesian system, your x y plane. Right? Your cosine is like the x value on that plane. Right? Cosine of an angle is the rep your representative x x value. And the cos the sine of that angle is the representative Y value. So you're taught
trigonometry strictly in Cartesian space, right? And then you get to calculus and long a long way down that road, you get introduced to polar coordinates. And then you're like, why the effing hell did they not just show me this the first time? It's even harder how I felt. Yeah. Like, it's even harder to switch to polar coordinates when your whole grounding isn't Cartesian coordinates. And by the way, so for the audience, polar coordinates means that you're no longer on the x y plane. You're on what's called the r theta plane. Meaning, r is the radius of, say, r is the radius of a circle, and theta is the angle. So you can do anything you can represent as an x and y. You can also represent
by a radius and its angle that it's being rotated on. And that's a really powerful way to think of plotting a point. It also happens to be really relevant when it comes to thinking rotations of, you know, rotations of a of an object.
UnknownAnd And then you can convert from standard x y plane to polar coordinates. And that's really cool. That's where, like, topology starts coming in. Like, there's a diffeomorphism between polar coordinates that you could say that you can say that basically a circle is a square in polar coordinates? What's a diffeomorphism? Okay. I'm try I don't remember the exact definition.
Like, roughly. What is the diff what is the diff we know amorphism means. It's like it's like an I would would you say yeah. It's like an isomorphism, except that the map is continuously differentiable and has an inverse that is continuously differentiable.
UnknownSo it it's it's a stronger maybe version of an isomorphism where it preserves It's like a homeomorphism. It preserves derivatives. Yeah. Interesting. So then you're that's basically how you're able to, like, calculate, like, double, triple integrals and, like, spherical coordinates, and you can go back and forth between them. Right. And so notice what she just said, by the way, going back and forth between them. And that's what we talk about with isomorphisms and why we study abstract algebra
is that you can it's always being able to go back and forth. It's always being able to get back know an inverse exists. You can get back to your identity. And that that's really why why we do this. There's no sometimes it's just the knowledge that you can get back even though you can't show it mathematically. So it's this facility. You you wanna say these two systems are equivalent, and then you can just operate back and forth between the systems depending on what type of math you're trying to do.
So, yeah, that's powerful. So you had a very strange high school experience. You're in this wall so we we glossed over this fact that you're in this Waldorf school, which is like an like an art school, really. It's not, you know, it's not known for producing mathematicians in any way. Right? You know, we have a school not so far from here that's a very well known STEM school. Right?
UnknownAnd down you know, the one in Downingtown. It's like my god. That's right. Is that the place that we visited? No. I had was never was never gonna send you there ever. No. But we visited there for a day. Was that Downingtown STEM school? I didn't Like STEM academy? I was With the helicopter. Oh, yeah. No. No. Well, they might have sponsored that event. That was at the helicopter museum in Westchester. Oh. They might have sponsored that event. So there's a big prestigious STEM school in our neighborhood where we live.
And I thought the Waldorf School was the obvious way to go. And you wanna talk about why maybe why are you nodding your head in agreement and not rebelling against that fact? Because I don't I don't really like science or technology or engineering.
UnknownI just like the math part and doing all the patterns. And I think that's how I learned it. You just like m school? Yeah. We just like m school. Yeah. Should've come you should've talked to Alan when we had Alan on the show. He he was revolting against numbers. Really? Yeah. He doesn't even like the m. He just likes. He just he likes the sta. No. No. He was revolt he'd hate I mean, he just Just all of it. He he, you know, he was so in favor of, like, the abstraction. Right? That he he Oh, me too. Yes. Even, like, if I see a number, I'm gonna, like, get furious.
UnknownLike, people will be like, oh, you're like a numbers person. And I'll and I'll just be thinking like, you don't really know me. You don't understand what I like. You know what, like, frustrates me too? Yeah. Mean, so people assume that they box you into being a numbers person. Right? I have people like I make these arguments. A lot of the arguments I make on on the podcast are like, I have friends who are linguists, and they they they turn out to be linguistic arguments. And they say, but you wouldn't understand this because you're a numbers guy. So but only, like, this is our domain.
I'm like, no. We should actually be talking you. We're the exact same. We should be we should be putting our heads together. I'm not a numbers guy. I hate numbers. I don't hate them. But like
UnknownWell, I You know? I was like, oh, I hate numbers until I started learning number theory. Yeah. Number theory is the solution to hating numbers. And, like, it's nice to Everything can't be completely abstract. You can't learn a lot if everything is so abstract, right? You need to have some way of representing things in your brain. I think a number is a very powerful
representation, very powerful abstraction of a polynomial. Right? A base 10 polynomial. So the number 2,003
UnknownI was just reading about that in the number theory book that you gave me. It still what? Blew my mind. Yeah. Because everything we try to do in abstract algebra with polynomials is very tedious and painful. But if you can first have a sense of how it works with actual numbers, it's a little bit more palatable. Right? So you're at the Waldorf School. It's a bit of an art school, but you somehow have these gems of math teachers.
And so what did that make a difference? Do you think if you went to a different Waldorf School that didn't have these teachers, it wouldn't have you'd be studying like, what would you be doing? We'd we'd be working at Dunkin' Donuts. Math was boring. I don't know. You'd be back at know what I mean? Would you be just, like, kinda working at Dunkin' Donuts at this point in time? Oh, my math teacher,
Unknownwhen I was taking calculus, the highest basically, the highest level math at my school is intro to calculus, where they teach you derivatives, like, derivative of every function you could think of Mhmm. And some integration. But by the end, all the seniors They choose stopped school. Like, in Waldorf, the seniors end school in, like, April, and then they do, like, their senior play and class trips.
And so it was just me and my teacher. And she was like, guess what? You're taking the AP exam next year, and we're gonna learn calc BC. And I was like, what is that? And she's like, it's calculus two. And I was like, what do you mean there's a calculus two?
UnknownYeah. What the hell? She immediately started going into, a like, AP calculus, a b content because she basically, everybody she's taught AP calculus to has gotten a five. And she's like, you're gonna get a five. I, like, feel so much pressure to keep her streak. Yeah. And we start learning, like, u substitution. And I'm like, oh my god. This stuff is so difficult. But it ended up just being her and me doing math.
UnknownYeah. You worked so after you did calculus, the last class in your junior year, you needed now something to do your senior year. And so she basically said, you're doing calc two your senior year. Now I took calculus two as a summer class in college. And that's where I realized that you don't wanna take certain classes as summer classes. When I was worried about your pre calculus, I was drawing on my I basically didn't learn anything. It was too fast, way too fast and way too compressed.
I did that because I got a d in calculus my freshman my first semester. I was you guys know I didn't go to high school pretty much until, like, I got caught. I skipped school for years, and I got caught. I had to go back my senior year, and then I did get into college. I tested into the honors program mostly because I was good at calculus. So I tested into the honors program, and they put me in honors calculus, and I got a d. It kicked my ass. I mean, the guy that taught it was the head of the math department and was just, like, total love of the game actually and was really into challenging kids, and I was not up for it.
And I got I got a d in it. And so I had to retake it in the spring. And then in order to cat, you know, stay caught up with my schedule, I had to take calc two that summer. And I got like a c minus or something in it, and I barely learned anything. When I took calc three, it was like one of the most suffering I've ever ever had to do. So when I thought of you taking the summer class, I got concerned. But but now you're gonna now you're not only gonna get calc two,
not not not even for a college semester. You're gonna get a whole year. Of calc one and two. Calc one, a whole year of calc like the intro to calculus stuff I had the year before. So this is when I am starting to think you are really getting a powerful foundation. Like, this is, like, honestly, like, I started seeing this. Like, I hadn't this was not in my calculation that you were gonna get to do any of this. I thought you were we I thought we were just gonna overcome the fact that you were in an art school and that we would do it ourselves.
And it turned out you got you had incredible support and you got incredible opportunity. And you did get a five on your I did. AP test, and you didn't and basically, so you got to go to college and just take calc three I I had a teacher that just loved math so much
Unknownthat I'm it rubbed off on me. And I think that made me wanna study math in college because our classes would just be us either it's either her, like, really refining my skills because I had a lot of difficulties. Like, I still have this difficulty where I have, like, the plus and minus sign mixed up. Yes. You're we used to say you're allergic to negative numbers. Yeah. Like, some algebraic techniques that I think I really
started mastering in calc BC because that's basically all that it is. Yeah. Or it was just us being so excited about a problem and trying to figure out how to solve it or what mistake we made.
UnknownShe was so great. I mean, I remember taking you to her house on Saturdays for out and leaving you there for hours. Yeah. We would take practice exams every weekend. Yeah. Incredible. I mean, what a what a just an unexpected fortunate step along the path, but this is how this is how you got to where you are. So when you arrived at Penn State, you were you had already had calc one and two in the rearview mirror. Like, just by contrast, when I got to college, I was so I
was so not there that I had to retake. I failed calculus basically the first time. One which is calculus one is really easy, by the way. Like, I'm guessing like most people
UnknownIt's the one that people like. Most people can do it drunk. I actually not and be fine. It's like when people say they like math, it's because they only took calculus one. But it can be difficult if the professor wants it to be. It can be really difficult and really rewarding, any math. It's kinda like any if you lift weights with a personal trainer, like, you have a trainer a trainer can show you at very low weights how a low weight could be very heavy.
Right? Based on certain techniques and certain form that he'll ask you to do, perfect form, a low weight might actually seem very heavy. And you can a good math professor can make Calc one challenging, difficult. But what I was saying was I wasn't ready for that. And I went through my entire freshman year, and I still hadn't had
Unknowncalc two done yet. Right? You came freshman year. It was all already Already starting calc three. Yeah. I didn't even know there was a calc three. Yeah. So I was like sitting there. I'm sitting here wondering, okay, what what point do you get kicked in the teeth? Right? Because calc three kicked me in the teeth pretty good. I took calc three and linear algebra at the same semester. And, you know, I tried. Like, I really you know, people think I wasn't trying
just because I was getting bad grades. No, I was in like Temple's library. I was in the worst neighborhood in the country. And I was in their library at three, four in the morning just trying praying to God, really, to understand what I'm doing. Now we you know, when I was doing it, we didn't have YouTube, didn't even have didn't have the Internet, didn't know, it was just me, the book, and God. And
it was what it was. So I'm just saying from my experience, I was wondering if you were ever gonna get kicked in the teeth by any of this and hasn't really happened yet. So the more that didn't happen, the more I started thinking, you know what? You might actually might actually be a mathematician one of these days.
UnknownYeah. I guess. I didn't really I mean, there is one class that really challenged me, and that was classical analysis one, which is basically you're learning topology and equicontinuity and really different and How's that? You learn about, like, normed vector spaces. And Okay. I guess it's it's all rooted in topology. Like, oh, what are the open and closed sets? And then let's
expand our knowledge out to metric spaces. And I had I took linear algebra, and I got an a, but I didn't learn anything. He basically curved. I got a what a I got an 80 out of one twenty on the final This is which is a 60. Wait. But you took you took a class called matrices.
UnknownIt's called yeah. It wasn't linear algebra. Right. So for the audience, like, you know, matrices is more of like They teach you how to solve the matrix and how to multiply matrices and how to compute the inverse and the determinant. Yes. And I was just like, I don't like, what does any of this mean? All I'm doing is solving the matrix. Why do I have to know what all this stuff means? And I got to classical analysis one, and we were getting, like, basic linear algebra problems, like, oh, let's let's find an orthonormal basis for two by two matrices.
And I'm coming to the professor, like, how do I I'm, like, coming to him with basic linear algebra problems, and he's like, didn't you take matrices? Isn't that, like, a required class for your major? And he actually told me, next semester, you have to take linear algebra or else you're not gonna understand analysis too. I was like, ugh, I hated I hated matrices.
UnknownThought it was dumb. Yes. Because matrices is STEM. Right? Linear algebra is pure math. So it's on this, like, what's the difference? Right? It's computation versus I guess conceptual understanding. Yeah, I mean, the depth and the richness in linear algebra, I. E. Vector spaces, column spaces, row spaces. This is abstract algebra in a in a very compressed area.
UnknownI remember asking my professor too in office hours. I went to all of his office hours because I was just so confused about everything. And I remember being like, what is an inner product? Like, what is it? Just tell me what it is. Because he just kept saying, oh, it just, like it really, like, measures something about the vectors. And I'm like, what? What is it measuring? And then I got to linear algebra. And I don't know. Like, doing we we did linear algebra over the summer. Yep. We just not like, no course. We were just watching YouTube videos. Yep.
And I think by the time I had internalized all of that, I was able to understand all the concepts that in freshman year when I took matrices, I was like, why do we have a basis? Why do we need to find bases? What is linearly independent? What is a subspace?
UnknownAnd it's like, I don't know. We found a way to understand all of that. We did. And not only that, but the book I worked with you on turned out to be the book that was used for your linear algebra classes. How great is that? I mean, that's the kind of stuff I start to think, man, we are onto something here. This feels right. Right? It was linear algebra done right, by the way. That was the that was the book. But, yeah, we were watching videos every day that summer.
UnknownAnd not just linear algebra done right. Right. It was, like, also the more computational algorithms, like the triangularization. But it was that course was more computational, which I think I needed because I didn't know how to multiply matrices. I know. I couldn't believe I I actually couldn't believe it either. I was like, how did you get through matrices? At least Penn State had a decency not to call that linear algebra. They had the decency to call it what it is, which is matrix operations.
UnknownRight? It was called matrices. Matrices. Because then you took linear algebra, which was more of More conceptual that It's more vector space. It's like, okay, this is a course about vector spaces. And I had told you. And I was like, when they explain it in the concept of vector spaces, I'm like, oh my god. All of this makes sense now. Remember what I told you? You had to hear it for yourself to believe it. But like I told you, I heard heard this in
doctor Benedict Gross's abstract algebra class where he said, the one thing he tells his students is you could never learn enough linear algebra. And I'd never heard anybody say that, but this is like a guy that I had on a very high a very high esteem in my mind. And he said, you could never ever ever learn too much linear algebra. And the book he chose to do that class that I that I was watching was the most linear algebra based abstract algebra book.
And so he was sort of true to his word, and he really had this belief. And it turned out we looked into this guy. This guy was one of the most leading probably the most leading mathematicians of the twentieth century who was running this course. It happened to be this course at Harvard, and we'll look at it in the show notes, but like, everyone should go watch this. It's incredible. It's very accessible, accessible abstract algebra class. And if nothing else, I hear a throwaway comment that he that's not even about abstract algebra. It's a throwaway
comment of advice to say, you cannot learn enough linear algebra. And he didn't say you can't learn enough matrix operations or eigenvalues or eigenvectors. He said linear algebra. And it's the more you study abstract algebra, the more you realize why he said something like that. Right?
UnknownI remember also learning that about how cool eigenvectors were. I don't even think I got to that in my matrices class because my teacher was so terrible that he ended up having to curve our grades. That's how I ended up getting an a. I don't think I would have even passed if it was a university park class. But actually understanding what makes eigenvectors so special. Have you connected them to characteristic functions? Yes. Yeah. I mean Because we had we had a whole chapter in linear algebra done right just about polynomials.
So that's more getting into, like, abstract algebra and factorization of polynomials.
UnknownYeah. Yeah. So anything you wanna this has been good. We've had we're like almost an hour. Your first podcast. Wow. That's great. You'll always remember your first podcast on Father's Day. We're just talking about math. Yeah, you all you talked into the mic almost the entire time, which is good. Anything we want to close with any parting thoughts? Oh, I don't know. You gotta you gotta help me with this.
Give me some aiding questions.
UnknownWhat are you well, I guess, why don't you tell everybody what you're working on this summer? Okay. So I'm working with a faculty mentor on understanding I'm pretty sure understanding her research topic, which is on quadratic forms. In number theory, like, number theorists want to find out what are all like, how can we classify all integers represented by a homogeneous quadratic
polynomial equation? So, like, a x squared plus b x y plus c y squared, like, in two variables. And they're using algebraic techniques because Gauss so long ago proved that all functions of that form of binary quadratic form actually forms a group under multiplication, which means two integers represented by these functions.
If you multiply them together, you get another integer represented by those functions. Good god. So we so we have, like, a closer way to figure out how to rep like, how these integers are represented. We want, like, an explicit formula, I think, at the end of the day.
UnknownIt can't be overstated what Gauss has done for the He didn't even know what a group was. The human race. He had, like, two pages full of formulas of how to describe this multiplication of binary quadratic forms and that they're equivalent up to linear transform like, linear isomorphism. And his successor, I forget how to pronounce it, like, Dersley. Yeah. Formalized all of that in terms of
group theory and, I guess, number fields.
UnknownWow. That's that's incredible. I mean, can't I don't even think we can imagine a world that Gauss didn't exist. If like Gauss didn't exist, we can't know what what world we're even living in right now. It's so remarkable. This guy has his name on everything. The first time I heard about Gauss was at Waldorf School. My teacher made my classmates do a skit, like, he's, like, adding all the numbers up to 100 together.
UnknownGo. Gauss famously so you're talking about where the teacher the math teacher asked for the sum of one to a 100. Right? To, like, punish the kids. Yeah. To punish the kids, and Gauss got it in, like, two seconds. He intuited it. Now we all know it would you would take a 100 plus a 100 a 100 time times a 101 divided by two. Right? So what is that? 5,500? So the sum of the sum of numbers one plus two plus three all the way up to a 100.
Gauss knew it. He's 5,500. And so like the supposedly the way it went, right? Kayla was that the professor was like incredulous and he didn't even really know the answer. Yeah. Right? So you had to do a skit you had to do a skit simulating that
Unknownmoment history. Teacher was I thought that she was, like, in a That was Carmen? Yeah. She, like, got a bunch of students, and she was like, you guys are in trouble. You guys are staying over recess. And, like, over recess, she made them, like, do this whole skit about Gauss. And she's like, this is called Friedrich Gauss. And So she punished him by reenacting the punishment. Yeah. And she that's how she taught us that trick of how to add a bunch of numbers together. That was probably, like, a mental math question that
UnknownWell, similar to the square it's similar to the squaring because you're taking consecutive number. You're using multiplic the multiplication of consecutive numbers. Right? Yeah. So there's that. That's really cool. But he has done everything. He's contributed to so many areas of mathematics. You don't even know. You still don't you still haven't even scratched. Well, you scratched the surface, but you still haven't, like you still haven't seen the iceberg yet. Yeah. You should
Unknownyou should find I have to find out. I don't remember what the book is called. I think it's like, like Oh, Disquisition. Yeah. Yeah. It's like Gauss's book on congruence classes, and he actually talks about binary quadratic forms in that book. And it's one of the most, like, revered mathematical texts. Well, guess what? That book is summarized on magicinternetmath.com. And if you go to the website under seminal works, it's under the section seminal works. So I have Euclid's elements there summarized.
I have Gauss's, thequisite dispositions. I'm pretty sure I have Lagrange's seminal work there. Yeah. So go check that out. You should go check that out. And I think that's where we're gonna wrap it. Good job.
UnknownGood job. Me? Yeah. Oh, thanks. Alright. Very good.
In this episode, we picked back up on our red-team tour of Bitcoin cryptography and tried to make sense of the last few weeks of fast-moving math news. We unpacked why the recent excitement around the exponential time...
OpenAI just dropped roughly 300 math papers with Lean proofs, mathematicians are crashing out, and the vague-posting has started: "math is breaking, so cryptography is next." Brian and Rob Hamilton refuse to hand-wave....
Magic Internet Math: https://www.magicinternetmath.com/ Shout out to https://x.com/uncleJim21 for the Alice in Wonderland story and the following rebuke of Lewis Carroll: https://www.youtube.com/shorts/33FYXpEWgyA This...
We’re back because math keeps refusing to stay in the classroom. In this episode, I unpack two very different kinds of “math pop culture.” First, we revisit entropy, seed generation, and wallet security through a...
Magic Internet Math is back. After the summer that set the Bitcoin world on fire - the Cold Card entropy disaster - Brian and Rob Hamilton (AnchorWatch) reunite for a two-hour deep dive on the event Rob spent three...