Skip to content
PodSubs
ShowsPeopleGuestsJobsNewsEvents
More
BlogPodCred
Menu
ShowsPeopleGuestsJobsNewsEventsBlogPodCredNetworksSign in
Join nowSign in
  • Shows
  • People
  • Jobs
  • News
  • More
    • Guests
    • Events
    • Blog
    • PodCred
    • Networks
    Join nowSign in

Magic Internet Math

Magic Internet Math artwork

Kayfabe Math is Now Mainstream

Sep 13, 20261 hr 17 minAudio

We’re back because math keeps refusing to stay in the classroom. In this episode, I unpack two very different kinds of “math pop culture.” First, we revisit entropy, seed generation, and wallet security through a Bitcoin lens: dice rolls versus machine randomness, Bitkey’s firmware checks, Bitcoin Core as the most-reviewed software stack in the room, and why truly understanding how keys are made matters more than blindly outsourcing trust. The deeper theme running through that whole section is validation - how much of security is really just getting honest about what you can and cannot verify for yourself. From there, we turn to two recent rage-bait flashpoints: the anti-algebra Tucker Carlson clip and the hype around AI “solving” Navier-Stokes. I argue that abstraction is the toolkit that lets you reason your way out of the matrix, and that dismissing algebra as fake misses the entire point of mathematical thinking. On the AI side, we get into proof formalization, peer review, incentive problems in mathematics, and whether machine-generated breakthroughs actually advance math - or mostly advance our need for better audit trails. We close on a more optimistic note: AI may compress old workflows, but it also increases the value of high-agency humans who can validate, reason, and build beyond the rails. AnchorWatch: https://www.anchorwatch.com/ Presidio Bitcoin: https://www.presidiobitcoin.org/ Block: https://block.xyz/ Bitkey: https://bitkey.world/ Bitkey Wallet GitHub: https://github.com/Bitkey-Wallet/ Bitcoin Core: https://bitcoincore.org/ libsecp256k1 GitHub: https://github.com/bitcoin-core/secp256k1 BitDevs: https://bitdevs.org/ OpenAI Navier-Stokes announcement: https://openai.com/index/navier-stokes-solution/ Clay Mathematics Institute: https://www.claymath.org/ Algebraic Number Theory and Fermat’s Last Theorem: https://www.routledge.com/Algebraic-Number-Theory-and-Fermats-Last-Theorem/Stewart-Tall/p/book/9781032610931 Hell Money podcast: https://play.fountain.fm/show/W8pjfavWchv8diXjikgC Wavlake: https://wavlake.com/ Sir Andrew Wiles: https://www.maths.ox.ac.uk/people/andrew.wiles Open Ordinals: https://ordinals.org/ Casey Rodarmor’s blog: https://rodarmor.com/blog/

Audio and video play straight from the show's own hosting. PodSubs stores and serves no media.

Transcript

From the show. Tap a time to play from there.

UnknownAlright. Magic Internet Math is back. We back, baby. We back. We can never go away, and there's too much going on. Sometimes I do wonder just how busy, certainly how busy you are, how busy I am. Can we keep this going? And then like the universe just keeps taunting us. We're, this is good use of rage bait to get us back Just Yeah. Back on schedule. Yeah. Like, I I just say right before we hit record, we now have math pop culture. Like, the the the universe is calling out to us and trolling us to get us on the mic.

UnknownI think so. I do. I I I try never to ignore the signals from the universe. Right. You know? God, it's been so I mean, it's been three weeks. The only and the only reason it's been three weeks because I had to get back on, like, I had to get back on coordination schedule with my other podcast. You were off cycle elsewhere, so you had to move things around? Yeah. A little bit. And then I I the things we are thinking about right now are like,

definitely benefited from an extra week of of

Unknownthinking it through. There were things to ponder. Yes. Because it's because these things aren't pop culture now, there's more to think about because there's more k fabe. Oh, no. That was the alarm I set originally for me to get up to do the podcast, and I was off by an hour. So Nice. There you go. Like, we're in k we're dealing with k fabe math right now. K fabe math? Okay. I love it. It is k fabe math. I I see exactly what you're saying. You see what I'm well, the first I mean so, you know, look. If you're picking this up and you're it's the year 2031,

you're not gonna remember, like, why we're pre ambling this the way we are. Yeah. But if you are picking this up in real time, I e, you know, today is September 13, Shana Tova. It is, Rosh Hashanah, and I have to say I saw the big I saw the big Bitcoin yarmulkes, and I gotta say in control.

UnknownAnd big dreidels. Dreidels and I haven't seen the dreidels, but I did see the yarmulkes on Well, you're right. I didn't see a physical one. I saw a photo of one, a concept art that they're working on in the lab. I'm not a In the compliance. I also I'm not a fan of generating entropy through dreidels. It's too many too many spins. It's too many spins. They take too long. It's harder to find out if they're not weighted too because it's more of a point. It's very hard to find out. So, like, if you're playing dreidel for, you know, for fake gold chocolate, that's all fine.

UnknownYeah. All well But those are the prop those are the proper stakes of, doing that. Yes. Proper stakes. Do not generate your seed using a dreidel. Yeah. That is the, the Jewish member of Red Team. You heard the token? Giving you his giving Red Sea I'm Red Teaming the Entropy. I'm just appointing We we need to just call you the Red Team Rabbog. Have you ever heard what I I

had this thing where I was when I first, I don't know, was getting into rabbit holes. I Yeah. I decided for myself that the word rabbi was actually an abbreviation for rabbit hole.

UnknownReally? Oh, interesting. Yeah. Entomology. Yeah. Because, like, I like the the Torah is the ultimate rabbit hole. Like, those guys never come out of it. Of course. They're just they're there permanently. Yeah. And, like, the object of life is to basically go through every other rabbit hole before going to that one. Yes. Right? We we talked about Pascal on our first, like Yes. Second episode. Yeah. Yes. We have a speaking of, as a quick quick shout out, there is a member, Red Team and core developer,

Lorinc Yeah. Who I was catching up with in person, and he heard that we had a math podcast and started listening to it. And he's going he's a true believer. He's going in order. Oh my god. Wow. So, like, he I saw him last, last week, and he started asking me questions about our conversation about Pascal's wager and had a lot of opinions about it. And I was like, buddy, that was three, four months ago. It's it's a I you're right. I don't know I don't know why we're wrong, but you're right. Come on the podcast, and you can yell at us. Oh, totally. Yeah. That's what I told him. That's what I told him. I don't mean I'm the only person in my podcasting relationships

Unknownthat does what I'm about to say I do, but I really listen. I don't my forty hours a week is constantly like relistening to my own podcasts. That's bad entropy. Well, you're right. But I'd say it's not it's not an entire closed system, but, you know, it's what I'm interested in. It's is it bad entropy? I don't know. I mean, it may be bad entropy, but it's good it's good. Well, the thing is you have a high entropy. You have high entropy of the podcast that you create.

Right? Yes. Like, have many kinds of themes of podcasts. So that is that is good.

UnknownIt's bad entropy around my confirmation bias, but it's good entropy around general just general, you know? I don't know. I think it's a good place to be in, and maybe it's like you have like, I have to break through that. Once I break through that, I'm really ready. I then I can really trust the entropy I'm getting for myself in the world. You know? It's and it's it's like getting through all these other rabbit holes before you get to the the granddaddy, the one you won't escape, which is maybe we'll debate this later. But but I was all to say is, like, I I remember the Pascal conversation like it was yesterday.

You know, like, I talk about these conversations a lot with my daughter. I'm like, oh, you know, we had this conversation. It's math you know, about Pascal. And Yeah. You know, math, religion are those are pretty big topics in my household. So, like, they're you know, it's it's always this stuff is always getting covered.

UnknownIt's I think it's part of rich discourse to have this all part of it. And I think it's better entropy than dreidels. Well, that's true. Which by the way, I should just specify. Dreidels are are a Hanukkah toy. Mhmm. They come up you know, they're I don't know that it's like a globally Jewish toy. Well, just for Hanukkah. Or are saying it's, like, American? I I thought it was like It's kinda like it's like mistletoe. Right? You'd like, mistletoe is not used universally for the most part. Right? It's only used around Christmas time.

Yeah. You can. You can enjoy mistletoe anywhere and anytime you want. Mhmm. But its relevance and significance and use is only around this one time of the year. Yeah. Got it. That makes sense. Yeah. I would say, speaking of waiting Mhmm. I did an informal experiment on the Anchor Watch challenge coin you gave me. Okay. At my meetup. Feels weighted. Oh,

feels weighted. We were spinning it like a dreidel. That so and

Unknownthat's when we figured out that we think that that the Bitcoin side is a little a little heavily weighted based on our You got my hustle. You know how much money I've made doing coin flips on that? Like, that's funny. What's the Anton Chagor from No Country for Old Men call it? We did like 20 spins in about two hours. Yeah. This is when I started imagining how much of a bitch it would be to spin a dreidel. And do the chi square test for randomness. Yeah. Oh, man. But I think flipping it, throwing it up and flipping it.

This is a PSA if you're using the Angouwise Challenge Coin. Yeah. Your Entropy.

UnknownThrow it up and flip it. What it is, it's a great card protector if you're playing poker. Just a big obviously not a chip. Cool and shiny. It's pretty cool. Before we move on, I was talking, I was at the open source Bitcoin summit and at Presidio Bitcoin this week. First off, Presidio Bitcoin is beautiful. I've never been there. I've only had spent before this week, three, four days in San Francisco in total my entire life. The Presidio did not realize this. It's on the northern it's like basically on the South Side of the Golden Gate Bridge.

It is this park on the northern tip of that part of the land mass. It's a federal it's federal land because it used to be the western command center for all of World War two, and it's beautiful and clean. It is the it like and I walked around. Was like, oh, this is what all of San Francisco should be. Just like a complete, like, former military based techno fascist lockdown because it was nice and clean and enjoyable to walk around. And, there I was on a panel with a security engineer, block Jordan, and he he made it, I was talking about we were talking about entropy and randomness. I said, well, who's ever actually run, like, a chi squared test on their,

on their entropy? And he said, well, I haven't personally, but in the BitKey firmware is a Pearson chi square test. And I just pulled it up and there is in the firmware. They actually do full generation, and a histogram to show how the entropy is being created within the BitKey. I I I'm looking at it right now.

UnknownSo it's in the GitHub? It's in their GitHub. It's public. There's a like, the the there's a chi squared test, a unit test that runs within the firmware. It's probably I mean, it really is probably it's it's a minimum, I think, minimum standard if you're gonna You're doing randomness, bud. And LibC like like, LibSecP also has, like like, distribution tests and stuff that it it has in it too, but, like, no one's doing a check on the check except for block it looks like.

UnknownYeah. Again, I think we talked about this last time, but like if you're even going to use a machine's random number generator, that machine should give you a mountain of ways to validate it. It's very like, how are you gonna do it? Buy, like, a thousand of these machines? Buy a thousand Dickies and test the random randomness of all of them? Or, you know, like, how how is an individual supposed to do that validation? And so like this conversation,

much as I hate to validate guys like JW, but the more I have this conversation on like, how do I have to validate the randomness of a wallet generated seed phrase? Right. It's just defaults me to like, just go have Bitcoin core do it.

UnknownYes. I I think that's like the I use Bitcoin Core wallet all the time. Like, I am a big fan, and it is objectively true that the one with the most peer review is Bitcoin Core. It doesn't mean Bitcoin Core is perfect, but the idea of the looking at the code base has the most eyes and to be like, there's multiple layers of where the testing the pieces go in. Because it's interesting, like how the repositories work.

SecP is not part of the Bitcoin org. It's a Bitcoin core org that then loads in the libsecP library. Right? The the the whole conversation around that is just around usability. It's it's user experience, and, I would even go far enough to say that you should have in theory, you should have Bitcoin Core entry as part of it. But even that, I like, from a risk distribution standpoint, you're still putting all your eggs in one basket.

UnknownYeah. I the way I the way I think about it is I I mean, I'm starting to think that a person should just have their brains understand how Bitcoin corn makes keys. So, like, at the very I don't think most people have done that work, John. Yeah. And and and, like, and and if you didn't go to if you didn't go to the basement and, like, go look at all and check it, then you're still trusting, not verifying. Yeah. That's right. Because I just the the you're never gonna kill you're never gonna have case closed that, like, you're really good with

everything you set up

Unknownfor, you know, for your There's always there will always be trailing risks, and your job is to mitigate those trailing risks as much as possible. Yes. And so I while I think the I think the best ADIQ solution is rolling your own dice, I really do. I don't think that using Bitcoin Core is the best ADIQ solution. I think that is a I think that is actually a smarter it's a smarter solution. Yeah. The it is. Like, I think properly air gapping

Bitcoin Core. Right? Like, I wouldn't load I wouldn't use Bitcoin Core on my computer right now and generate keys and have that be what I use to secure my life savings. Right? Like, I also wouldn't be buying reused hardware. Right? And the there's one thing I think Bitcoin Core at least should have the option of, and it should just let you add your own Entropy as an additional input to be XORed in on top of everything else. Right? Like, it just should,

you should just be able to, in addition to everything else, add a little bit more because the way we talked about this on the Entropy episode two podcasts or last podcast, like, to XOR in Entropy at worst retains the same level of Entropy you currently already had. So it is a it is something that does not have downsides if implemented correctly, right, to add additional Entropy. So It doesn't reduce

Unknownentry. Yeah. Right? Yes. I I so look. The the case should never be closed. I don't think you could ever say, oh, I'm really, really good with this. But I do think that if you roll your own dice and you understand at least the log six divided by the log two and you understand why rolling at least a 100 times and maybe, you know Mhmm. If you're if you're worried about your

dice being loaded, roll, you know, roll them a 120 times or Mhmm. You know, whatever makes you feel comfortable there. You at least know in your like, if you're, ten hours away from your seed and you find out that it's totally that every seed that was made the way your seed was made is being compromised. Right? Or at least being stored on devices that your seed is being stored on, you can at least go back and

it's it's like coded into your soul, I feel like. This is how I felt when I was at Lake Satoshi trying to evaluate whether or not Right. I was screwed or not. I was it was like like, the thing that I did to make the seed was encoded into my soul in a certain way. Like, I could in turn that's what and it gets internalizing something means. Right? Yes. I don't think you get that trusting Bitcoin Core, even though you may get the same quality, you may get the very same quality. You don't get that internalization.

And I just think the internalization is important to sleeping at night. It's like that's maybe it's important to getting to the next stage of validating. Like, don't move ahead in the video game of validating unless you internalize these things. Right. I think that's fair. Yeah. That's the you know? So all that that's aside stuff, but Mhmm. You know, I think it's good. So why not do both? I guess that's that's really where I so where I end up is why not do both? And then like

if a comp when you find out that a company like Block is doing all the putting all this energy, we'll just say, into the version of this that you're probably you may not even do. Right? Well, it's probably useful to go to the GitHub and take a look. Like, it's probably useful. One. It's nice. Yeah. Nice. Ask the question of Rob. Like, why would you ever spend? What like, what's the point of a I think it's really valuable to say what's the point of a chi square test? And I don't know that we were gonna do that here, but, like, you know, what's the point of rolling a die a thousand times? What's the point of all that? And it's all again, it's like we don't have anybody at the Bitcoin store to go to

to ask if we're good. Right? Like to say, hey, are we good against you know, in the insurance game, right? There's this concept of like named risks. And then there's this concept of all risk, all of which And must be in the case of protecting your seed, you're in the game of all risks, whether or not they even exist today or not. Right? There's risks you're gonna find yourself existing in five years, then you're not gonna find out until it happened.

Right? And so that's the bar. The bar here is the bear, not, you know, the, you know, the saying, you don't have to outrun the bear. You just have to outrun the other guy. Yep. The bar here is the bear. Right. Right? Really. When you said when you determine your seed, the bar is the bear. And whether or not that happens in a year or five years is based on the other guy. Okay.

UnknownSo like we Well, this is I think part of this too is good. Just goes to the fact that like, it's the same thing like security. And I've been using this metaphor that like all of the red team in the security stuff is not like Norton antivirus scan where you like hit the button and it says you're clean. You're like, oh, I guess I'm done. Like, I'll check back in a month. Like risk and security in the same spectrum of like, you can never there's a there's a bad asymmetry in cybersecurity where with AI, the attackers are able to move faster because

attacks are verifiably executable. Whereas defense, you can't, like, have a verification function that my code has no bugs. And so you just have this, like, to your point, like, you'll you can find out shit's fucked, but you're never gonna be able to, like, provably say, like, oh, no. I'm good. Right? You'll just have asymptotically lower and lower and lower amounts of risk.

UnknownBut in a case of entropy, I think you probably can. I think in a case of entropy, you can, what you were what you were able to do is I would say with a physical form, physically that I did a random physical thing and that encodes to a some set of entropy. To go to, like, the Bitcoin Core example, like, if I were doing Bitcoin Core, like, as my my my policy strategy, I would have more than one cold computer. This is kinda what I'm getting at. Like, I would I would walk into a Best Buy with cash, and I would buy a random computer. And then I would buy

like, I would use my Mac for one of them. Like, would turn it offline and, like, reboot it and, like, like, offline entirely. And then I would do another one that would, like and I would do multiple computers because the the way the Entropy works for Bitcoin Core is it pulls it in from, like, four different sources and one of them being, like, the operating system entropy. Bitcoin generates its own entropy. Like, there's actually a really great tweet, which I I reference. And if you know Raw Avocado Yep. Hell yeah. Yeah. Alex Walls. He get him on the show. Oh, he would love he would just do that for, like, hours.

Right. He would he would he would just be going off for hours, but he has a really nice, like, page where he just talks about the like, he wrote it down on a piece of paper and, like, and color coded. I'm pulling it up now. Core Entropy. He does a really good I Did we talk about this last episode? I think we did. Yeah. I'll just call it right here. So he called There's the proc random that gets stuff from the script. And then there's

four sections. One of them or is it five? One, two, three, four, four. There's four colors that he has here. So one of them are like system processes, low level entropy processor instructions from the CPU. One low level, like, entropy from the operating system, dynamic events and static events from your computer session. Right? And like this, I've been looking to this. This came all in version 13 of Bitcoin 0.13 2016, which was when we've entirely regutted the the structure of the wallet to do what are called bit 32 hierarchical deterministic quality with an x prim and x pub. Before then it was a JBOD wallet, which is just a bunch of keys.

And it had different ways of doing it before then. But like, if you have Bitcoin from version 13, I think you're in a very good risk minimized spot for sure.

UnknownYeah. And so I guess what we're saying is, at least what I'm saying is that if there's probably a trustworthy version of a random number generator, it's probably Bitcoin Core because of the evidence, the eyes, the evidence and the resilience it's shown. Except I would just say that stops short of, I think a bar that is needed for this type of validation, is internalizing

it. And I don't know. So like I just don't, it's not that you don't trust because it's not trustworthy because it is trustworthy. And sometimes we will, There are times when we have to default into something that is trustworthy probably. But this for your entropy, it's not necessary because you can do it yourself. That's my point. And so when you don't when you can do it yourself, but with rolling dice, which I still say that's the ADIQ solution.

UnknownI agree. Literally, any anybody can roll dice and convert you know, then you just convert that into your seed. Okay. That's the key. That's the thing you have to learn how to do. Okay. People there but, you know, if you're gonna trust something, trust we'll say there's program that have been validated. Mhmm. And come to come to the bit devs I'm starting. We're gonna talk about this. And we're Oh, yeah. So if you can understand okay. Duh. Anyone can roll their own dice. Right? Now can you do the one small step is of converting that into your key? Then you're good. And then it's internalized. You don't have to trust Bitcoin Core, which I think anyone really ever wants to have to do.

UnknownYou shouldn't have to trust one thing. You can. Okay, if you it's like a 20 IQ solution, I guess. But, like, it's more of like it's the way I think of the Bitcoin core solution is you have to be you have do a lot more work to validate it. You have to do your chi square tests. You have to do all of you you know, you now have to do all these tests to make sure it's truly random. Whereas if you just roll your own dice, you know, and so You know, actually sick. A really cool open source

Unknownsoftware that should be built is basically a wrapper on top of Bitcoin Core. So it doesn't modify any Bitcoin Core, but you run on top of it and you can start running chi squareds on the entropy poles that Bitcoin Core does. Yeah. It'd be pretty Like, that would be sick. Like, that would be sick. You you you could you could go to the bath store and explicitly prove to yourself that, like, the box that you're about to generate keys on has random distribution. Discussion. So Yeah. Yeah. There's there's two things going on in pop culture, and I think they're both k fabe. Okay. But and and they're both rage bait. Like, they both rage baited me into waking up this morning and wanting to, you know, really been been thinking about this for a couple of weeks.

Yeah. Alright. So let's hit the first one, which is this if we were like a professional podcast, we would we would subject you to this clip. That's right. In its entirety, but it's the the Tucker Carlson and some fucking dick nose.

UnknownI don't even know who it is. I don't know who they are, but it's like it's like they were they exist strictly to rage bait me and us. And this conversation this is the conversation that Tucker Carlson was having with some guy about why are there letters in algebra? And basically his answer, his actual answer is because it's just to fuck with you. It's totally not needed. I don't know a single person who even uses algebra. I don't know. I created

he went on to say that in college he was able to, because he was able to drink with his advisor, he was able to bypass get having to take any math classes. Oh, he said he took something called finite math, which I think is interesting.

UnknownSure. So okay. Good. So he was able to take like discrete math essentially and only deal with whole numbers. And I don't know what he you know, he was an art student. So I guess that makes sense as to why Yeah. They let him take those classes and all that. And we know that college math system is all fucked anyway, but, like, this this so Tucker sat there and said, oh, yeah. Everything he basically is like, yeah. I have no pushback for anything

you're saying here. I mean, the you know, this is a guy that didn't let Sam Altman get away with even trying to, like, slough off a whistleblower that was murdered. Mhmm. And Tucker Carlson, I'll say, you know, he clearly has the ability to push back when he wants to. Sure. He did not do that here.

UnknownI don't And think he was ill equipped to even have the conversation. He didn't wanna look silly. I think, you know, I think this is one of those things where you ever get gaslit so hard that you're like, you're like paralyzed in the moment. You actually don't even know what to do. It's so fun. For me, I just enjoyed listening. I'm like, keep go off king. Like, I wanna hear more of this craziness. Like, this is great. Like, like, when someone goes off in a schizo land, I just become like, I'm locked in. Let's do it. Yeah. Math is fake. Let's let's talk about it. As a podcaster, I've never had this situation where I've like somebody saying something so like

fucked up that I just sat sit and enjoy it. That's never happened. Although, I hope to be on that level one day where I'm just So I can't even relate. I don't even know if I can relate to Duggar Carlson and to say, oh, he was wrong or anything. I think that this thing was so I feel like he just sat there so gaslit and didn't know what even to make of it to respond. Mhmm. Other than to say, I live in a fake world, so I don't know any of what I can't even begin to opine on what you're saying. Right.

But back to since this is verbal. Right? So back to the point of this idea of, math. Why are there letters? And by the way, I hate the fact that he used the word letters. So, like, my autistic brain is like, no. They're symbols. Symbols. They're not letters. Letters are no different You're not pronouncing them. You're not pronouncing them. Yeah. They're not yeah. They're symbols. So just for the record, right? Why do we use symbols in algebra?

Okay. So there's different letters for different symbols. So, okay, we have what is known as X, Y, and Z, right? You'll see X, Y, and Z. Those are called indeterminate. This is all Descartes. Descartes determined this construct and this is the way. Fake by the way.

UnknownFake. Yeah, Descartes fake. Descartes. He's letters. It's all fake. Is definitely. So XYZ would be the letters to determine what you call indeterminants. I mean they could be anything, right? This is the essence of algebra, right? Essence of algebra is that they could be they could be anything

and but then we have these other letters, a b c, that you might see. Mhmm. If you wonder, okay. Well, what's the difference between a b c and x y z? Why are they used differently? And a b c are meant to be what's called scalars or constants. Mhmm. So, like, we're not we're still not gonna define what number it is. We're just gonna tell you that it's not gonna change. It's not meant to vary. Mhmm. Okay? It's predetermined, not meant to vary. So when we see a line like ax

plus b y equals c, that is Mhmm. That is the equation that determines a line. Or, hey. How about an elliptic curve? Y squared equals ax cubed plus b x squared plus c x plus d. Okay. Right? The a b c's and d's are constants. And so with Bitcoin's elliptic curve, right, is y squared equals

x cubed plus seven. Mhmm. So a equals one, never changes. Yep. And b equals zero, c equals zero, and d equals seven. Mhmm. This is the top level, not the wire stress level, which already was already, you know, made constants out of some of those

or zeroed out some of those constants. Yeah. This this is just so the a, b, c's, d's are predetermined. K? Yes. But the x cubed, that's we're saying that's where the two Oh,

Unknownno. They're they're coming after him. He found the truth. He found the truth about math being fake, and now they're coming after him. Do what you gotta do. Do what you gotta do. Hey. Alright. We're back. Part two. This is the most technically challenging probably episode we'll have had to do. And you know what? It's fine because the world does not want us discussing

these two topics. So whatever. This Tucker interview, I don't know. I hope we captured it from the last from the last call. Yeah.

UnknownMaybe let me jump off because you were going like, my thoughts on this is that Yes. The there is a nugget there. And the nugget is most people throughout life don't handle any level of abstraction in their thinking so they never have to think about symbols and they offload all symbol mathematical higher order thinking into technology Because like for sure when you're you know like engineers that are designing cars are thinking about physics and thermodynamics

which require multiple points of abstractions in multidimensional space, and they're using these equations. But, like, you personally driving the car are not thinking about that. Right? I think it's also fair to say that, like, the median American going through their life isn't thinking about multiple levels of abstractions when it thinks like, when you think about the complexities of the financial system. Right? Or in, like like I said, driving to work. Right? And so it's like pop it's like mathematical populism, the idea that, like, this is all fake and gay, but they're all gonna use technology that's used by people. And, like, all these people are using AI now, and you wanna see how many fucking symbols are in linear algebra?

You know you know what I'm telling me? Like, you're gonna tell me that, like, like, the this stuff is Use a calculator.

UnknownI mean, can't yeah. Again, I don't wanna overblow this. I wanna just use this as a way to maybe get our thoughts out here. But you know, the there's an important there's one there's an important thing in what you said, which is when you say people don't think in terms of abstraction. Right? What that means is if you're if you're stuck in the matrix, you're not getting If you can't abstract your the only because the only way out of the matrix is to abstract your way Totally.

And, you know, it's like even if you're a a Bitcoin user and you really got yourself to understand the elliptic curve x cubed plus set y squared equals x cubed plus seven, you're fine if that never changes. But if that ever is going to change, what is what good is the work you did in understanding the curve? What good is it if it's going to change and you have you can't see it

at any level of abstraction other than what it is. When we start having a conversation of say using a different curve, right? And people start making claims about what's equivalent and what's not. What good is that work that you did gonna be if it was not at an abstract level outside of this curve? It wasn't something more general than this thing?

It's like, know, maybe you have a program, maybe you coded something when you were a kid to say this, I've coded something to work for me. I'm three feet tall. And this is gonna do everything I need to do for myself in my life. Then all of a sudden you grow six inches and the thing you coded doesn't work anymore. You know, like, this is all kind of unnecessary, right? But it's just like you don't want to get caught up in and say I don't need to know.

Don't need to generalize things because I'm happy where I am. I'm happy with the system I live in. To your point about like, you have to abstract to get out the matrix.

UnknownAs the world changes around you, if you shut off the entire world of mathematical thinking, then you are necessarily locked in rails and unable to reason new models to be able to change your perspective based on the situation. You're just shutting off an entire line of just like you're not you're basically turning off the toolkit. Like, you're you're you're throwing out the toolkit, and you're like, I'm just gonna, like, remodel my house with my bare hands. And what's wrong with that? You're allowed to. What's up? I mean You're allowed to, but I guess the thing that I think was so galling about this discussion was that it was sort of, like, presented as some type of intellectual achievement.

Yep.

UnknownRight? It's like this is like the you know, this was presented as some type of vanguard of thinking that, hey, man. Have you ever noticed that we don't need any of that shit? You know? Right. You really think about it? I think about it deeply. Right. And it's, you know, I don't know. I think there's a lot of people maybe that confuse this for

good thinking, radical thinking. And they're gonna get this is a way to one shot people off of basically off of the escalator. Totally. Matrix. Right?

UnknownTotally. Maybe that's why I'm so upset about it. It's not about the math thing. It's just it's just about like, god, you know, bad thinking. Bad thinking calls me really badly. Oh, man. Yeah. I mean, that was I I it's funny because the time between we saw that and this podcast has been a couple of days, but I also feel like it's like, it it was just K fame to get engagement on the podcast. It's like that tweet that that that 97 clip went around everywhere.

It's just not serious though. You get on a plane, you get on you you drive a car, you use a computer, you like, you're using all of these, like, things. And just because someone packages it up to you in a really clean abstract way doesn't mean that doesn't exist.

UnknownYeah, totally successful kfabe, we'll just say. That's right. You know, I think us calling, you know, just calling attention to it. So I'm not even sure if we're even gonna air any of this because some the first twenty minutes, I don't know. It's we're gonna figure it out. We'll figure it out. By the time I my clanker who puts this episode together, everyone will have forgotten about all this. But regardless, let's talk about the other one. I think that that's

that's the one I really wanted to hit because this is now it's wild. It's wild that dinner party conversation is now like basically, mathematics is now part of dinner party conversation. Did you know that artificial intelligence is now, you know, solved a major unsolvable, previously unsolvable problem? And this thing goes deep, like the k fave here. This was like

really successful because it enraged mathematic. It can raise the entire mathematics community. Navier Stokes. You know, Navier Stokes. No. Do you? No. You know, but, everyone's talking about it. Yeah. Oh, we solved Navier Stokes. This is, you know, the crowning achievement in AI. The entire math community is completely just distraught distraught over this, But it's really because, you know, I'll just say fairly and unfairly. Fairly, there have been a lot of people that have done work on this that AI would not have been able to do what it did had it not been, you know, had it not been for the sole the shoulders Right. It stood atop of. K? Right. And they're upset that now they don't know who to give the prize money to,

and they don't know who's gonna do who's gonna do any work in math anymore if AI is just gonna suck up the prize money. So this is why I have a particular interest in discussing this because I think it's become an incentive issue now. And the state of mathematics is now maybe moving towards or maybe accelerating the incentive game theory here. Okay? Which I think is maybe a good thing. Right? But but this other thing I wanted to talk about, which is

I don't get I don't like I don't like where the conversation the dinner party conversation and the the Overton window is on on this. Meaning, I struggle to see why it's actually relevant that AI solves a math problem. And that I think I'm skipping a lot of steps in what I you know, I think I'm skipping steps in my explanation.

I just if I go right to the if I go to the end, I'm asking myself, so the fuck what? So what? What changes? What impact does this actually have on the world? And if I if it does have an impact on the world, it's really bad. It's bad, which is no more work gets done on this. That's the impact. If like if there's any impact, it's like, okay, I guess nobody's curious to solve this anymore. So let me

pause before I go because I have another rant loaded on this. Let me pause for you.

UnknownYeah, so it's interesting because I think to your point which is true that the AI to be able to move through this was definitely done with the contribution of man, right? With all of AI technology is basically synthesizing the collective works, The computer in of itself doesn't have the ability to do this. It takes all of our unstructured data of our words and papers and all these things and assembles it together. And the method in which they're starting to basically solve these is the equivalent to like a full brute force. Like this is a loose analogy,

but when if quantum computers become real, you basically mass brute force bending the rules of how you would think about constructing these problems and attack it. Right? So they're having these agent swarms which are like 10,000 agents that are just kind of dispersed, and they're looking at all these things at once, which would be the equivalent of, like, hiring even if it's 10,000 agents, let's just say, like, 50 of these is one mathematician that would be, like, spending their day. But they're since they're computers, they don't sleep. They're just cycling. Right? So you're taking the equivalent of, like,

dozens, if not hundreds of mathematical PhD equivalents that are just attacking this one problem and systematically with perfect information hand off talking to each other and getting this done. And they get to an answer. Right? And it's done via brute force. They're not PhD students.

UnknownSorry. They're not PhD. They're more like Okay. Right? But that's like the What grad students? Like what do wanna say? Like grad students? They're more like, we'll just say very we'll call them really strong graduate students. But they haven't done the one thing that would differentiate them, which is do something new. Got it. But do you think that they're now starting to do new things? Does this not count as doing new things? No. No. No. I don't.

UnknownAnd why is that? Don't think you don't think a grad student if they if they prove Navier Stokes would not become get a PhD out of it? I think they would. But what I'm saying is they would have people they would have had to have done something that let's just put it this way. If a computer could do it using linear using a linear combination of what it's already loaded up with, it wasn't new. That's my because that's the point. So, like, there there's a lot of this there's I think there's years of low hanging fruit where

computers are gonna accelerate what human beings could have done. So

UnknownI didn't mean to interrupt you with that. I just but that was like the real point there. Right? Got it. Got it. Well, I would say the other interesting thing related to all of this is this like world of formalization of proofs. And it actually goes back folded nicely from the earlier part of the conversation talking about you don't have mathematical certainty of defense. This is a new emerging thing in cybersecurity and computer science with can you formally verify computer programs? And if you could formally verify the execution of code, are you able to in a way get a higher bound of certainty of the security of the software that you're running?

And I actually was asked I asked this. I on Tuesday this week, I recorded HellMoney podcast with Casey and Aaron. And I mentioned this, and I'll give you everyone a little preview. Casey was like, fuck no. Because the problem is is you'll statically verify this function or this system, but you're never gonna be able to get to the entire universe of all of the interoperability and complexity. So you're gonna, like, have this perfect perfect function, but, the processor it's running on is gonna allow for arbitrary, like, remote code execution, which then fucks your entire thing. Right? Basically, like, the daemons will exist in whatever part of the system you don't formally verify. And because of that,

like, it's nice. It's maybe better than not having it, but it you can't view it as a panacea and like a complete security solution.

UnknownYeah. So the and that it's kinda like it's all weaving around the same thing, which is there's a math math is for us. Math is not for the clankers. And so let me go back and tell you one of the things I I just like. I spent the last two and a half months with a textbook called Algebraic Number Theory and Fermat's Last Theorem.

And the reason I was using this textbook was because of the discovery I had with Kayla. And I think we you and we were three of us were talking. And, know, we went through this whole 12, however many episodes we did on Elliptic curves, and saying, you know, we need to in order to validate your private key, we know we know that all the points in the elliptic curve or group. Right? Yeah. And under this operation called point addition.

And we went through this whole thing to show how you could validate your private key if you know the public key and it's actually the only way really is to know this. It's the only way to validate it is to know this algebraic properties. And then we got to the I got to this point and had this light bulb moment like, shit, somebody has to prove that those points on the elliptic curve are a group. Like, how do we do that? And, you know, there's no again, there's no Bitcoin store.

And there's no algebra store either to tell you how to do these things either. Right? So you just have to go. And I found this textbook that chapter 13 was elliptic curves. And but it was like a real build. It was an abstract algebra build into elliptic curves. So I like had some pretty decent confidence that if I can get through this book, and I can get into and I can get to this section, it might show me something, right? It might give me some direction as to how to where this proof is going to live.

And it turns so like it turns out that, like what does Fermat's last theorem have to do with any of this? Fermat's Last Theorem was, you know, three fifty year old problem. It was well known because of how long it took to prove. Right? And, you know, legendarily, from Matt wrote in those margins, like, Oh, he's like, I didn't I didn't have enough room for the proof, but anyone can do it. So just enough time to I don't have time. Blah blah blah. Here it is. Right? And then he dies, and

no one can do this proof. Right? The thing so the question really is what happened in those three hundred and fifty years? Right? What happened in those three fifty years was we got we invented new fields of math to solve to try to prove this thing. We invented algebraic number theory. We figured out something called modular forms, we got this thing called the

Taniyama Shimura conjecture, actually more known as Taniyama Shimura Weil conjecture in the context of Fermat's last theorem, which then connects this idea that if an elliptic curve is a modular form, this is part of how you know that it's a group. But also, this is how you get to Fermat's Last Theorem. And it's a three it was a three hundred and fifty year process that did have prize money associated with it that did have incentives. But, you know, people worked and worked and worked and worked on this and ended up with fray elliptic curves and eventually

got to what Andrew Weilz was able to prove. And, you know, you just have to go back in time three hundred and fifty years ago and ask the question, well, what if a clanker just just did it? Do we not? Do we not spend the next three fifty years developing these fields? Do we not do that? Are we no longer curious? You know, that's the first question, right?

UnknownIf you start shortcutting the journey, I see your point, right? That like, do we stop developing new ways to try and solve these problems that develop into their own fruitful fields of exploration. Maybe my counterpoint on that would be we just bump up against the edges of the system sooner and we figure out new ways to expand and think about thoughts and ideas and probably AIs can be helpful, contributory to understanding new possible fields of math and this would be like the acceleration argument that like what took three fifty years,

you know, we're going be able to do quicker now and then like when we bump up against the edges, we're going be able to start figuring those new things where you're like your AI PhD mathematicians are going be like supercharged to be able to find those new fields of exploration and get them mapped out. It's not that like we're figuring out all of human knowledge, we're expanding out to the gap of what is available within our current understanding And then once that's and we're at this like just like in cybersecurity, we're at this inflection this moment because we have decades in cybersecurity and millennia in math where we're hitting up against like,

okay, what were things that humans could have figured out and we did not know? And you start bumping around those edges and then when that's all figured out, you start the PhDs now instead of trying to figure out the gaps in the human knowledge, like in the sense of we had the answer, just didn't know how to think about it properly being like, okay, what are the new fields of math we need to start thinking about?

UnknownWell, yeah, but how do you know how do you know that? So here's the first question is first of all, who can a human being validate these proofs? Isn't that the idea with the formalization that it basically, like, takes you take little baby brick by brick and you build it up? Like, there's, like, 10,000 sub proofs that are part of the neighbor strokes proof. Right? Isn't that supposed to be part of it that like you take these discrete pieces and you build them up to a complete understanding?

UnknownYeah. But what do we know? Like I guess the question is how do what do we know of that validation? Well, I guess this is the, this is maybe to your point too, the problem with using mathematical proofs, and like groundbreaking like discoveries as like research, it hasn't gone through peer review yet. And, you know, you also have to ask what's the this is like, I really love this conversation because this goes back to what's the point of mathematics to begin with. Mean, and I'm not saying I know what the point is, but like, in my mind,

you know, if you really just go back and ask what the hell is even mathematics, right? It's not adding, it's not calculation, it's not arithmetic, it's not computation. In fact, at some level to me, mathematics is nothing more than a general thought exercise that works towards formalization. It's a thought exercise. You know, it's just a the reason why we use number systems is because those are like

sort of good game board pieces to help make the arguments. It's the same reason you use cards in poker. It's just they help make form the argument. Poker is no more they like a game of poker is no more than a thought exercise. Sure. And, you know, somebody says I'm better than you. And, you know, they're going to act and imply that they are but everyone knows at the end, everyone's going to find out if we get there. Right? But it's still it's just a game. It's a game to say I have an argument.

And you either believe it and you or you don't. And we're gonna, you know, we're gonna bet our assets against. We're gonna use the fact that we're betting our assets against the fact that I have an argument to make. You can make a you're welcome to make a counterargument. And that's that's the game. And the mathematics at the high level is nothing more than thought exercises that become formalized, you know, through the little pieces. Like, the amino acids are the number systems. Do you think aesthetically

Unknownthere's, like like, there's something, like, aesthetically displeasing about these formal like, these mathematical formalized proofs as like machine code versus like papers? No. I actually in in some ways, it's preferable. Right? In some ways, I think it's if you're gonna make these formal if you're gonna do these formalizations, right, I think this is this may be a great breakthrough in the formalization. Right. I was thinking, like, the formalizations too actually make it more approachable

for people to be able to follow along in the proofs and distribute the knowledge. Because, like, when this eventually gets published and I wanna ask, like, how does this work? It'll have the total sum rather than it being like predictive text guessing how to like answer my question. It's just going to load the proof and look at the code and then translate that into words which is a much cleaner way to make sure things don't get lost in translation than scanning the papers and trying to predictively token guess the next word.

UnknownYeah, if anything, what this is doing is it's exposing the need in AI. What it's doing is it's advancing AI more than it's advancing math. Because what AI doesn't have is a great audit function to audit every action that it does. And that's what's needed. That's what you know, so in other words, maybe, know, if anything, this idea of we're going to go through a thought exercise called can AI actually prove anything?

Well, what would be needed in order to demonstrate that? Well, we would need a really, you know, we used to have this problem. I'll say I used to have this problem in quant space, when you had Monte Carlo simulations that were using, say, ephemeral seeds, and you know, you really wanted to basically validate your calculation, your 20,000 scenarios, but you really couldn't do it because you're,

you know, you were generate like, back back before disk space was, you know, before Moore's law allowed for it, you would just you know, you wouldn't store all the simulations in memory. Right? You would destroy them. And then you would have your results. And you would say, well, my math says the average, know, the math of it's called the Feynman Cag theorem says that the average of all these simulations is equals

the expected value. And okay, good, right? But then it's like, at some point, right? The banks got wrecked. Because they couldn't validate that they actually couldn't validate that their simulations even converged to that expectation.

UnknownRight. So what needed to be done was to go back, you know, was to go back underneath that hood and say, hey, before you destroy that, we, you know, no, we need to store all that. Right. Right. Right. And then we need to hire a team literally that's just gonna look at the thread that The logs. Goes through all that. It goes through all those, and we call that audit trail. I mean, this is the audit trail is just like, you know, if you're a boss of the function that does all that, your your fucking head spins all the You

know, you're dealing with, you know, I remember when the 65,000 row limit in Excel was finally exceeded. You know, because you couldn't even then bring these things into

Unknownwhat that's from, right? Bytes 65, five thirty four. That's FF, is it? It's two to the 16. Yeah. Isn't that FF? And x? I think x. Well, two to the 16 minus one. Yeah. That's fine. Yeah. Right. So, like, again, this is all to say that what the human race may be grappling with and what this is all contributing to is this ability

to validate. And you know, we were not very good before AI at validating and then AI has come and put even a whole nother level, whole levels of abstraction on you know, like untraceable abstraction into the I'm guessing most people don't even know that it's deterministic.

UnknownIt just quick correction. Two to the 16 minus one is FFFF. It's four F's. FFFF. You. That, you know, we're in the bath pod. We gotta get that right. I would rather just keep rage baiting people like Alan into, like, coming on a show. Coming on and just being incorrect. Yeah. Just leave these errors. I've I've learned the wisdom of just leaving these errors out there. Right. Totally. Right. But, like, so maybe what were the inflection point for humanity now is that,

a like, AI is exposing the fact that we were not very good AI and Bitcoin are exposing the fact that we were not very good at validating things before the fact before all this. We didn't care, and we didn't know, and it's necessary as fuck to do it. And, know, and I think that's to me, that's the only value here being brought to bear. Maybe the field of mathematics is limited by our ability to validate also. Maybe we're

not ready. We're just not ready to spend the next three fifty years off finding new math to solve naive or stokes. Right? We're just not ready to do that.

UnknownI almost feel in the same spirit of that, though, if we're able to build the tools that are able to solve it and use the technology, maybe we haven't arrived to the point where it's time to solve it. Perhaps. Doctor. Right. And like, this is the complicated part of it. They've announced that they've solved it but it hasn't been peer reviewed yet. The peer review is going to take a year like months, year like I don't know like It could take a day where they realized something was wrong. Right. Right. That's what I mean. And like this is such a complicated thing. It takes time to validate these things.

UnknownIt means mean even that after you're a Yeah. After a while. I mean, after a while I could look it up like what was the time between when he, you know, when he submitted it to the time where it got peer reviewed? Talking about Fermat's Less Theorem. Yeah. It's it's gonna take this may take longer. And the question is, know, this is the same thing we deal with in Bitcoin and what we talk about on the podcast, which is the gap between the people doing this, and us is so much bigger. Even though we like we're all on Twitter engaging in this conversation.

We're all in the public sphere engaging in this. Dude, mean, I can't believe how many people have asked me about this in the last couple of weeks. It's big news. Yeah. We're all engaging as though understand it. But the gap between the people doing the peer review and us is absurdly. It's absurdly great. Right? Yeah. Absolutely. Some level, that's just why I feel like it's annoying that it's being even it's even a dinner conversation

topic.

UnknownYou finally made it and you're not getting what you want? Well, wouldn't do it. Matt's dinner table conversation now. It's like the monkey's paw but at the worst context. We finally made it. Yes. And it's ex yeah. Exactly. You know what? I mean, yeah, this is the Mark Twain thing. Right? Like, I never I I wanna be in, like, every club except for the ones that would have me. Yeah. Was that Mark Twain or I've been a professional podcaster, and I've sneezed three times in the past thirty seconds without letting you guys all at home, but we're casual here. So you guys know that's why keep abruptly pausing my mic with half thoughts. Yeah.

UnknownThose Trinidad scorpion peppers while you're doing podcasts. That's right. But, yeah, at this any club that would wanna have me is a club I don't wanna be part of. Yeah. That's I thought that was Mark Twain. Yeah. Anyhow, I mean and it's not to say, hey. Let's not discuss it. But I just think it's just wild. It's it's just wild that it's the same thing kind of in the sec p two fifty six space where it's like, we can't have the same conversations about that library that we can have about Bitcoin Core because this the distance between them and us is so big. Well,

UnknownI will say I would love to start having people start thinking about formal mathematical proving of sec p and also SHA two fifty six. Yes. So was Like like, those are that's really like the two load bearing things in Bitcoin are SecP and SHA two, and I wouldn't hate if some people started nerds getting nerds sniped into doing formal proofs for those two. You don't have to formally prove the p two p networking layer of Bitcoin. I don't care about that at the same level of, like, critical nature. But understanding that we that SHA two is secure within our understanding and SecP would be critical.

Like people should get paid grants to do that for a year.

UnknownYeah. I told my daughter, I was like, you know, this stuff is good. She know, everyone's bombarded, you know, because she's a senior in college and a math major, and everyone's bombarding her now. Like, oh, no. AI is gonna you know, there's no more need for mathematicians anymore. And I'm sitting here laughing. You know, when I was a senior in college, studying to be an actuary, everybody was saying, well, there's computers for that now. So like, what do they

do they need them for? And I will say I here's the other thing I wanted to talk about a little bit is that I actually think that this makes human beings more valuable. I think AI is actually making human beings more valuable, and I'm not starting to see it clearly. Not all of them, but like, know, I think the top 10% of them that can keep that have ability to stay above stick and tread water and wield it,

I think are going to be insanely valuable. I think that the bottom 50% of humanity is gonna have their lives improved by it. And then I think that that midwit 40% is fucked. I maybe believe with that. Yeah. I think I'd

Unknownthere's I'm I'm fundamentally an optimist. I actually I think I'll have to think on this conversation more. I'm I'm not sure we maybe have maybe a good follow-up conversation with a spirited disagreement about this stuff because I think one fundamentally as an optimist, I view these tools as further accelerating the most productive people to doing more things. Right? And

that is not strictly an intelligence thing. It is also people who are motivated and self determined. I think the red team stuff is a good just snapshot example of being motivated and wanting to challenge yourself and, like, do hard things. You're able to quickly catch up. There have been untold number of conversations I've had in the past six weeks where I'll talk to someone who I'd consider a gray beard in Bitcoin or someone who is way smarter than me that that never two years ago would have thought I'd be getting them on the technical details of something. And

they will I'll have a thesis. They'll say, well, no because x y and z. And I'll say, me put it in my clinker real quick and they'll laugh at me being like, but you don't understand this? I'm like, no. And then my clinker comes back with like a very pointed like counterpoint like, oh, actually, you know what? You may be right. Right? And that's just me is like, I'm a I'm a dumb insurance salesman. You know what I mean? And Aaron Redwing describes it as the the tarot card, the fool. That and the fool, everyone laughs at the fool, but the fool steps off the cliff and falls and is fine because he he is unburdened.

Right? So you just I'm willingly waving my hand saying I'm ignorant, which, like, there's no ego death or, like, there's no shame. I'm I'm I'm I'm I'm yeah. Right. Yeah. And yeah. Exactly. Kama prescient Kama, one of my favorite modern philosophers. And it's interesting. And so, like, in the math space, seeing that, like, a bunch of people can just walk in and just do things that all of the wizards weren't able to do previously, I think is a positive story. Think there's

and I think There's more hands to pick up a hammer. There's more hands to pick up a hammer. That's a good point way of phrasing it and there's going to be social and psychological changes for people who were used to a previous order who are not yet adjusted to the new set facts of things. And additionally, there's a part of it's happening. So living in the world where this is now happening and I cannot stop it and understanding how to reconcile that because resistance is futile. Like like, you're Yeah. Like, the the the store the the the toothpaste is not going back in the tube. You're not undoing this knowledge of, like and this ability to do this stuff. So

the those who adapt sooner are gonna be better off rather than resisting it along the way.

UnknownSo interesting too because Kayla's also a math minor I'm sorry, a music minor. And everyone in music's having the same conversation. Yeah. Like like, oh, the barrier to entry now is so low to be Everyone's having this conversation. There's not me being honest. Maybe like, oh, my son's gonna be a plumber. It's like, okay. And then in in seven years when, like, the optimist robots from Elon can just be loaded in with, like, the plumber, like, brain map. Like, it's all everything's getting conversation. Like, your employability

versus your value is a different there's this is a different conversation. And then, like, when I say value, I'm probably talking much higher level of like, what is the value of a human being? And I think math and music are two areas that do demonstrate that clearly without necessarily regard to who's going to pay them to do what they do. Because that we have a what like that's what I was saying before is there's an incentive issue that's now also going to have to get worked out to line up the value with actually getting paid for that value.

A lot of what you said can be done right now is being done on a volunteer basis. Right? A lot of what people can do with red team and a lot of what people can do to get and that and the thing is, you know, okay, there's this conversation that if you are you're poor, you can't help. Right? We had this conversation last week, like you have to have your own oxygen. So if you're like fucking poor, and just trying to make your own living, you're not gonna you're not gonna open up a clanker and try to figure out,

you know, what technical details of Bitcoin do I not understand? You're just not gonna do that. Right? So like, that's the first. That's why say it's an agency thing, not just an intelligence thing. You can have low IQ, high agents, like people that wanna like better do things. So it's you have to be in a position to do it. And for, you know, I you know, poor can mean a lot of things. But if you're time poor, we'll just say, which means you could, you know, like, I'm guessing the c the CEO of the company I last company I worked for doesn't isn't doing this either.

You know, they're spending all their time making decks. That's all they do. Like, you know, if you if you spend literally twenty four hours a day making decks, you're not using AI to do any of this. You're not you're not helping. And so that's all. So there's this little pocket of people in Bitcoin that seem that seem to be able to spend time on things without needing to get paid right away. Okay. There's a small pocket of those types of people. And maybe there's the children right now, the children of

well off people that can do that as well. Whether or not they're motivated to or not is a different question, but they can. They're not time poor. And probably caught you know, so like it's a fine needle to thread here in terms of like, trying to unpack what makes human beings valuable. What's going on with AI right now that's challenging that value equation,

where people are saying, well, you know, human beings won't be valuable, friend. You know, there's a certain camp of people that's like, no, this is all going to be done by robots and human beings have no value. And I refuse to believe that. I do too. And so what I'm saying is I the more this happens, and the more I see it, like I've been we've been doing AI music for years, right? I feel like we've been on the we've been on the forefront of AI music in a lot of ways. I've had a couple number one tracks on Wavelake. Thank you very But

what I'm saying is, I've always been see I've always seen that like, the value of humans is always increasing, the more it looks like it's decreasing. Right? And it's like, you know, I see I go to fish shows and I go to, you know, I see how people react to live music and the kind of thing that can be that computers just can't do. You know, there's people I have friends that go to these EDM festivals, and they're fun and all that. But then they, like, those guys are starting now first to come around and to like want to see bands like fish and they want like it's

why is that after like thirty-forty years of obscurity are people who like to you know, people who go to concerts and have fun and spend a lot of their savings doing it all of a sudden finding their way to a live act, to a real live act, something that can't be actually just can't be done electronically. And so there's something that you know, I don't know that this is all high minded, I guess. Think boy shit. But like, I'm just saying that the value of humans is very to me is very present. It's in I see it in music.

And I see it in math. And I'm like, having a convincing argument with my daughter that she's on the right track, that being a senior in college as a math major is a great thing to be right now. Because the math community is going to need capable human beings so much. And, you know, my point about when I was an actual when I was being, you know, actuarial science major, and everyone said that that's going to be replaced by computers. You know, in 1996, when I graduated college,

actuaries basically did life insurance and basic property casualty insurance. And that was it. And they I don't know how many people were employed in the space. Oh, they did pensions, right? And guess what pensions are gone. Life insurance is very, it runs by itself. And most property casualty insurance runs by itself. But now you, you know, I didn't know that the career would let me run, you know, multi

$100,000,000,000 hedging programs, because they'd be selling the stupidest and most complicated financial products known to man. Spreadsheets and computers allowed for that. And so what I'm saying is what we know, what math does in this field is a tiny speck of what it'll be in twenty years. And AI is going to cause that. Right? And you can be a very valuable human being by chasing

Unknownthat wave. I think having high agency which I think is actually from a sense of economic forces and evolutionary biology. I think while intelligence obviously is critically important like how many highly intelligent people do you know that have low agency and they aren't doing anything, Right. I want the people that are really mixed. Most. Right. You actually have a curse where you get to a certain level of intelligence, your productivity drops off. And I think it's beautiful the idea that people who are have high agency or self determined or unwilling to go just do things

are the ones who are rewarded. And I think AI removing the IQ gap barrier that would prevent you previously from doing things is now diminishing is a Like good I say that as a one zero five IQ person. Right? Like, just smart enough to know that I'm dumb.

UnknownYeah. We were we're gonna go challenge the E and Y audits on your IQ. That's right. That's right. Figure that. I was making a joke about red team just starting to go through SEC filings. You just start red teaming the whole stock market. You just start going through it. You know who'd be great for this heated debate? We're gonna have a appointed heated worldview debate on this, you know who'd be either great or absolutely terrible? Good one.

UnknownOh, we have a good conversation with him. We should just bring him on some point for sure regardless. He just has such strong views on AI. I know. I know. I've been meaning to catch up with him about all the stuff I've been doing. Yeah. Like, I I think, you know, I I've I like I've wanted to have him on the math podcast, But I like just I don't know waiting for the right. Think now we should find a good time to do that. We should we should load him up. That would be a fun one. We should do that. Yeah. What is our next actual like big? Are we doing hash function still? Is that our next big like

Unknownthing we're gonna hopper. I'm still make you know, I I will admit I have I have pointed my efforts elsewhere mathematically, mostly career oriented in a career oriented fashion. But I have a full study guide on hash functions. Just haven't I haven't been through it. Okay. Okay. So like I have a I have it. Yeah. I have probably I have dozens of study guides on subjects we could go through.

Yep. But I haven't been through like a full review.

UnknownYeah. And, you know, I do I do also have limited time, believe it or not, despite the fact that I'm not getting paid a cent for any of to be here right now. I'm not being paid to be here right now. Big big math and big big math doesn't cut the checks like big Bitcoin. No. No. The big math you know, when big math starts making the Omnicos, man, maybe I'll start to Soon. Okay. So that's that. That was good. If anything, if nothing else, the last forty five minutes, we can just release without the Yeah.

The Without our technical totally. Totally. We can just jump into it. If it's gonna like, honestly, if it's gonna take me, like, a day of like, I'll spend a full day trying to pull it together, but I don't know. Are we formally tying off the podcast? Are we doing post production talk on the pods? Well, I'm thinking where are we now? Are we good? I'm trying to think that I get it all. We're like an hour and

Unknowntwenty minutes recorded between the two. And so worst case scenario, this forty five minutes we can just jump into it. Hit, you know, we hit the good stuff. And then if you wanna combine them, go for it. I'm gonna do my best to combine them. Well, think you're I think you're gonna want to because the first twenty minutes was a lot of the algebraic representation of stuff. And so you're gonna have you you need you need to get that out of your system. You need to get that up into the world. I think this is good though. Think we're ready to tie it off. Awesome. What do you think? Sick. I think we're great.

Alright. Magic Internet math in the books. Until next time.

Open the transcript file

Hosts and Guests

Nobody is credited on this episode yet.

Credit the people on this episode

Be the first to rate this episode

More episodes

All episodes
  1. Exponential Got Less Exponential

    Nov 2, 20261 hr 10 minAudio

    In this episode, we picked back up on our red-team tour of Bitcoin cryptography and tried to make sense of the last few weeks of fast-moving math news. We unpacked why the recent excitement around the exponential time...

    Credit the people on this episode

  2. Red Teaming Elliptic Curve Cryptography

    Oct 11, 20261 hr 27 minAudio

    OpenAI just dropped roughly 300 math papers with Lean proofs, mathematicians are crashing out, and the vague-posting has started: "math is breaking, so cryptography is next." Brian and Rob Hamilton refuse to hand-wave....

    Credit the people on this episode

  3. Hash Functions, Linear Algebra, and Alice in Wonderland

    Sep 28, 202650 minAudio

    Magic Internet Math: https://www.magicinternetmath.com/ Shout out to https://x.com/uncleJim21 for the Alice in Wonderland story and the following rebuke of Lewis Carroll: https://www.youtube.com/shorts/33FYXpEWgyA This...

    Credit the people on this episode

  4. Legalize MATH

    Sep 2, 20262 hr 2 minAudio

    Magic Internet Math is back. After the summer that set the Bitcoin world on fire - the Cold Card entropy disaster - Brian and Rob Hamilton (AnchorWatch) reunite for a two-hour deep dive on the event Rob spent three...

    Credit the people on this episode

  5. Quantum Computers Don't Exist w/ Brandon Black

    Jul 19, 20261 hr 24 minAudio

    In this episode, Rob and I sit down with Brandon Black (aka Rearden Code) for a deep dive into the quantum-computing debate around Bitcoin. We unpack why Brandon thinks the more useful framing is not “post-quantum” but...

    Credit the people on this episode