Skip to content
PodSubs
ShowsPeopleGuestsJobsNewsEvents
More
BlogPodCred
Menu
ShowsPeopleGuestsJobsNewsEventsBlogPodCredNetworksSign in
Join nowSign in
  • Shows
  • People
  • Jobs
  • News
  • More
    • Guests
    • Events
    • Blog
    • PodCred
    • Networks
    Join nowSign in

Magic Internet Math

Magic Internet Math artwork

Quantum Computers Don't Exist w/ Brandon Black

Jul 19, 20261 hr 24 minAudio
ShareXLinkedInFacebookWhatsAppEmail

In this episode, Rob and I sit down with Brandon Black (aka Rearden Code) for a deep dive into the quantum-computing debate around Bitcoin. We unpack why Brandon thinks the more useful framing is not “post-quantum” but “post-secp256k1,” and why Bitcoiners should care less about sci-fi narratives and more about understanding the actual cryptographic assumptions that protect coins today. Along the way, we revisit the now-legendary conference panel on quantum risk, talk through exposed pubkeys, xpub leakage, multisig, Taproot, Lightning force closes, and the difference between a theoretical break and an economically viable attack. We also spend a lot of time sizing risk correctly. Brandon helps us separate slow, visible cryptographic degradation from the far less likely “everything breaks tomorrow” scenario, and we explore how incentives change depending on whether the attacker wants profit, strategic advantage, or chaos. The conversation eventually zooms all the way out to math, physics, and engineering: Shor’s algorithm may exist on paper, but building a machine that can actually matter for Bitcoin is still a very different question. If you want a rigorous, grounded conversation about quantum threats, elliptic curves, MuSig2, FROST, and how to think clearly instead of panicking, this is a great one. The legendary panel: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=wbJkODcrz7Q Magic Internet Math: https://magicinternetmath.com/ Brandon Black speaker profile: https://sv23.adoptingbitcoin.org/speakers/brandonblack/ James O'Beirne: https://jameso.be/ BIP 360: https://github.com/bitcoin/bips/blob/master/bip-0360.mediawiki BIP 327 (MuSig2): https://github.com/bitcoin/bips/blob/master/bip-0327.mediawiki BIP 340 (Schnorr Signatures for secp256k1): https://github.com/bitcoin/bips/blob/master/bip-0340.mediawiki BIP 341 (Taproot): https://github.com/bitcoin/bips/blob/master/bip-0341.mediawiki BIP 32 (Hierarchical Deterministic Wallets): https://github.com/bitcoin/bips/blob/master/bip-0032.mediawiki BIP 39 (Mnemonic code for generating deterministic keys): https://github.com/bitcoin/bips/blob/master/bip-0039.mediawiki FROST Protocol (RFC 9591): https://www.rfc-editor.org/rfc/rfc9591.html

Audio and video play straight from the show's own hosting. PodSubs stores and serves no media.

Transcript

From the show. Tap a time to play from there.

UnknownAll right. Welcome back to the Magic Internet Math podcast. I am Brian, the host. Rob, the host. We have such an awkward introduction. Which one's the host? We gotta make sure the clankers know who we are because we just don't I think by nomenclature, I'm the cohost. By nomenclature Casey and Aaron situation? Yeah. Like, I'm I think I'm definitely the cohost. Brian, this is I am more just a mathematical shaman guiding you on your journey.

UnknownJust to be clear. Yes. Thank you. Yeah. We got a guest today. I'm pretty excited about it. We have Brandon Reardon. That's me. Is that okay? Yeah. Well, you know, Brandon Black, Reardon. Reardon Code. I have all these names. Now I figured this out of my own, by the way. I figured out. I connected. Yeah. I was pretty proud of myself. I'll be honest. I was pretty dang proud of myself when I figured that out. But it's really great to have you.

We kind of just know you. We know you from Bitcoin technical life, I guess. And, you know, we are in a group chat. And I remember I was, you know, we were talking before the show, I remember listening to the episode of TFTC where with Brandon Black, and I was driving home driving home from Nashville. I was in Nashville for grassroots. If you guys remember,

there's a there's an episode on where Rob and I did a live magic internet math episode in Nashville. So then very next day, I'm driving home and I got that like, oh, TFTC is a new episode and it's about quantum like that's kind of up my alley. And with Brandon Black, and I don't know, like, I feel like I heard you for about forty minutes and I had to pull over and I started texting Rob. I'm like, is that weird? It sounds like what

he would sound like. And Rob's like, yep. Oh, man, did I feel good? I felt like I felt like a genius. Anyway, Reardon, man, you are kind of a genius. And so you're somebody I do look up to. I'm still doing the introduction here. We met in Vegas in person. And that was terrific. We got to spend a little bit of time. You said something very funny to me. I know you don't remember it. And maybe you'll remember it when I tell you now.

But I forgot what I was, you know, we're at the beefsteak. And I was having a good time making fun of something. Can't remember what. And at some point, you looked up and you said, fundamentals. You're as pithy in person as you are online. I think you meant that as a compliment. I didn't know what the word pithy meant. I had go look it up. But it was that I felt good when you said that to me.

UnknownSounds like the old say. Yeah. I just I don't know. For some reason, knew you were, like, a real one when you said that to me. Like, oh, you actually know me online. You don't just block me. That's nice. I I there's only a few people I block. So I consider so I in Vegas, you were on a panel. I still call it the legendary panel. And it was the one it was the quantum panel in the main stage

Unknownwhere My first time on the main stage. Yeah. That was like quite an experience. So first of all, you should know I was with all of your boys. I was with the whole crew. Just happened to be with your crew while that like, and they were all rooting for you. They're like, yeah, yeah. I'll link it to the show notes, people should watch the panel, I actually think it's really good. But it was like one of the most contentious

panels I feel like you'll ever see. And, you know, all of us all of us have experience speaking at these conferences. They're usually very nice and polite. They They take very very rarely seriously that one. Sometimes they get spicy because you have some people who are skilled at doing that without bringing like, without going to fight level. But on this panel, this was a brawl. Legit, this was a legit brawl.

And like, I give all credit to James O'Bearn. So you had you James O'Bearn, Hunter Beast, Alex Thornton was the moderator. And Alex Pruden of And Alex Pruden was the villain, basically. And like, basically, every time James, the funny thing if you watch this is that every time James basically gave a body blow, which he was doing just constantly, just body blow after body blow, like you were sitting next to him and it's like you could we could see you

trying not to like react.

UnknownI was trying to be like somewhat civilized and failing. Totally. Totally failing. So yeah, I mean, Rob, I don't know if that was your take. What does it Well, I was on the news desk doing commentary with Aaron Redwing for that panel. So, like, the entire I mean, like, the, like, the entire time I was trying to, like, listen to it and get ready for the notes and the play by play commentary, and there were so many things happening so quickly, like points getting flown around back and forth to try and give a cohesive, like, ninety second summary when the camera panned back to us.

I did pick up on what you were describing, though, for sure.

UnknownWell, like, I there's things I wanted to say on that panel, and and it it was with four people all with, like, strong points to make, it was it was obviously gonna be a limited time for any one of us to speak. And and so I was would hear James, and then and then he said something that I had been planning to say. Like, that's why I couldn't not react anymore. We because he's like, oh, there it is. That's the worst. Oh, that's the absolute worst is when the guy next to you takes your talking point. Makes my point. Yeah. No. It was it was good, though. It was good. He he he crushed it. And he and, of course, you know, he's he's

sharp witted. And so he put it in ways that were pretty cutting. And so definitely made for entertaining radio.

UnknownWell, I don't know anyone who could really pull off what he pulled off on that panel. And people should just People listening should watch it. It was very contentious. There was a very specific idea being debunked. And I think like what I would like to do just to get constructive around quantum. The thing that you said on that podcast that resonated with me the most that still sticks with me to this day. And I think I used this when I was moderating the panel in Prague that I thought was gonna be on quantum, but I still used it. I've your essence

on this, which is this attitude that like quantum computers don't exist. And whether or not you think they do or they will or you think they won't, it's probably a more constructive view just to think that a classical computer is going to break elliptic curve cryptography. And the actions would be the same. The actions are we better learn the hell out of this cryptography

and better be ready. It could happen tomorrow. And that resonated with me so much that like, I think I stopped caring if you're a good person or not or anything like that. It was like that idea so hit me very, very hard.

UnknownYeah. Mean, I think I think it's so important because people keep saying post quantum cryptography. And really all they're saying is post SecP256K1 cryptography. Right? We we depend not even on elliptic curve cryptography in general. We depend on one specific elliptic curve for the security of all of our Bitcoin. And if that elliptic curve were to have some kind of a break, whether it's quantum or classical, we don't currently have a fallback. And so the action of doing all this research And so this is the good side of quantum, is that

it's caused funding to go into doing research into other kinds of cryptography that we could use. And the reason I think it's important to not say post elliptic curve as a general is that one of the new kinds of cryptography is also elliptic curve based, but based on a different curve and based on different assumptions within elliptic curves. And so is that a place we should go with Bitcoin cryptography? Maybe. But, yeah, the post quantum is just such a silly thing to say because it doesn't matter what breaks it. It matters that it broke and that we need to have something to deal with that. And

treating it like quantum is the only threat could lead us in the wrong direction because then we're looking for a very specific solution. And we could end up in this case, let's say we did a different kind of cryptography but using the same elliptic curve. That would be foolish in my opinion because that would protect us from quantum, but it wouldn't protect us from a break in the structure of that curve. We don't wanna be so specific in our new crypto that we're only protecting against quantum. And so I think it is valuable to look at post SECP two sixty k one crypto in particular.

UnknownIt reminded me of like BPA and plastic. You know? Like, do you remember when oh, well, we've identified the only thing dangerous. Bad thing. And now we've taken it out, so all good. Yeah. And now we're all full of plastic in our balls. Just not BPA though. Oh, okay. You know, that it's like, I don't know. Was there a name for that fallacy or it's just like a bias? It's just like identification bias.

UnknownYeah. I don't I don't know the name for it, but it is yeah. Certainly, there's a phenomenon that people go through of the threat that I can see right now is the only threat. And it's like, no. You need to broaden your perspective on threats. Otherwise and then, frankly, as part of why, like I'll chill for a moment why why I I've been doing what I've been doing, which is kind of helping people with security stuff. Because one of the fundamental things in doing security research and auditing and stuff is seeing the stuff that other people didn't see, opening your perspective to other ways people could attack a system.

And that's, I think, fundamental to the quantum conversation and a lot of other things in Bitcoin as well, is people hone in on one threat, and then and then that's that's their horse blinders. That's all they see.

UnknownIs there, like, a division of labor, though, of, like, maybe certain people, individuals are only capable of seeing one threat, but we need to get more of them in a room together? Well, I think it's somewhat natural for any person to kind of obsess with the thing they're obsessed with right then. And that's kind of the point of but it's not productive, I would say, even if you are that person. You're the you're the quantum threat person or you're the,

you know, what whatever the the the centralized custody person, whatever. Hone in on one threat. But I think it's important that you don't try to act like yours is the only possible priority even to other people. And that's, I think, where everyone tends to get into that mode of my threat, the thing I'm obsessed with is what everyone else should also be obsessed And that doesn't really help anything. So I think that's maybe what I try to bring in these conversations is helping people open their perspective to other threats.

UnknownSo curious question. Do you think this is a natural way we think or is it related to the fact that to get capital to solve a problem, it has to be, you you have to convince somebody that yours is the most important problem. I think both of those are true. So especially, you know, people that lean towards this like obsessive mindset that gets you into Bitcoin in the first place are naturally gonna be prone to thinking in that way, kind of focusing on a singular thing. And then also people who are running companies need to make their threats seem the most important so that they can raise money for this company. So both of those things happen and they kind of feed each other. And I think we've seen that many times in Bitcoin is where those those two tendencies, the fundraising side of it and the natural obsession side feed into each other and kind of amplify a signal. Yeah, mean, and I'm not knocking that. I'm just trying to explain it, right? It's like,

Unknownit's natural. The reality of competing for capital is if you don't have the most important problem, you shouldn't get it. Right? Absolutely. But then a lot of people just obsess over their one thing for the love of the game. It's also just the nature of when you specialize and focus on a specific thing, you become more, you have this, like, feedback loop where you are the expert in said thing. So you get into more conversations. You get more perspectives since you're at the tip of the spear, so to speak.

And with that, you become the domain expert. And then your credibility of being able to speak at conferences or to be engaged in in opportunities is defined in the fact that you have this narrow subdomain specialty ultimately. So it's almost like the industry also kind of rewards you for concentrating on something special.

UnknownSo it's the strength of your brand or your ability to get capital, all those things. I mean, these aren't shallow things. These are these things matter. These are reasons these are reasons why people care about stuff like this. Right? Yeah. And I think that that happened with some of the authors of of BIP three sixty, for example, where where because they were working on that, they got invited to do lots of stuff and and that contributed to their focus on that as as the thing to focus on.

UnknownIt's like, could we just implement that and then not have yeah. Just remove the cache. It's like once you implement it, we can So there's can send them on their merry way. Right? I mean, I was I I am, I would say, generally supportive of BIP three sixty. But as it's as it's matured, actually, there have been more people pushing back on it. And I think there some of that pushback is is right, actually. For

example, I I as a as a BIP three sixty supporter, I I I would have said, you know, I I like the efficiency of having both a keyed path where you use Taproot because you know you have a you have a cooperative path, whatever it is, that can use a single key via music or frost, and so you use Taproot. But if you if you don't, if you always need a script, like lightning channel closes, always need a script because they always close through a script, once you've done a force close at least. Since their force closes always need a script, then you use BIP three sixty,

pay the Merkle root, because you don't have a key at the root, and it saves you a few bytes to not have that key in the case where you don't need it. But actually, there's now a proposed change to get rid of that byte savings because it would create an incentive to switch and then defeat the privacy benefits of Taproot. And so there's more and more conversation happening that maybe we shouldn't do something like the $3.60 and we should instead, and I think, should nobody's been writing about this a bit recently. We should instead have a

fallback plan until that everyone claims their coins if we have to disable Taproot key spends. And I think we're quite close to having via these various methods, whether they're commit reveal or post change reveal, there's various ways we can recover coins even in a break of SecP26A1. And so maybe then BIT360 isn't the way to go. So just to be clear Got it. Yeah. Got it. Just implementing it is not, I think, an obvious move. We should address the concerns that it brings up,

but whether it's through Bit $3.60 in particular or not, I don't know right now. Yeah. Got it.

UnknownI was say maybe we could take it as just a step back and maybe distinguish like what the solution space is addressing for the most part. There's a mathematical solution or there's a mathematical problem where you know, you've low hanging fruit in Bitcoin of people whose pub keys are exposed, right? Those would be the first lot. People who are afraid of quantum would say that's the first those are the first addresses that'll be attacked. Is that right? That Yeah. And and in particular, it would be it would be large

UnknownUTXOs with exposed public keys because there's a reasonable I don't know if it's a speculation or a guess that the first quantum computer is gonna be very expensive to operate. Right? It might take $500,000 of electricity to break one secret key if there is if if it happens, that first quantum computer. And so you're not gonna attack Brian's $50 UTXO because just waste your quantum computer. And so it's it's large UTXOs

with exposed pub keys. And I think that's one of the things that is often missed that I also try to bring up frequently in these competitions about quantum is any kind of preemptive disabling is like is gonna just steal people's money for nothing because most people's points aren't vulnerable to those early quantum computers even if they happen.

UnknownThis is also just in general when this problem is talked, it's almost treated as a binary flip of sec p is now broken without understanding the economics or the duration thereof? Let's say, like and maybe, Brandon, like, if we live in a world where this exists, you could flesh this out more. Is it something that once the binary is flipped, you spend a bunch of money and it takes a fraction of a second and it's all short range attacks? Or could you be in a world where this stuff hypothetically turns on and it still takes weeks

to be able to crack a key? Yeah. So it depends on the tech.

UnknownIf if a superconducting quantum computer is is the one that actually works, then once that turns on, it'll be pretty quickly a short range attack. But if it's a neutral atom, which is what I think is the most promising technology to maybe get there someday right now, that may never get a SecP key in less than two weeks. And so we just don't know yet even what the solution space is because we don't know what tech is gonna move forward. And so yeah. So so certainly, if it's if it's a neutral atom type computer that that solves it, you may never wanna disable

secp keys for small values. They'll just give advice like, Hey, don't use this for large UTXOs. And we have other crypto for large UTXOs, and it kind of makes sense that other crypto is much more expensive to spend, but it protects you because you have a large UTXO. And then if you don't need that, you forever use the old stuff, and it's fine.

UnknownSo now since I know that, Brendan, you're you're into poker, you're knowledgeable of poker. Correct? I I have played some poker. I'm not super knowledgeable or anything though. You sounded kinda knowledgeable when we were arguing about it. Definitely Oh, well, so so my my background here is I've never played that much poker. My dad played a whole bunch of poker and he was Okay. He was head of this this I I don't know what what to call it, but he was a table player. So he would he would go to tournaments. That's what what are we not conferences. We do conferences. He did tournaments. You

Unknownknow, they're very similar. This culture personality, like, dominating everything. Right? Very similar. Tournaments loved him because he he was a predictable player. So they put him in the early tables, and so they he wouldn't fuck up the really great players. He would play predictable poker, and and he'd get to, you know, the semifinals or whatever. He'd get to maybe cashing in some of the tournaments. But they love to have people like him there because they don't mess up the good players. Got it. That's know about poker is from his experiences and stuff more. The poker analogy I would like to make for Quantum is something called monsters under the bed syndrome.

You see it, if you read online, if you're online a lot and you're reading like hand histories, they'll just say I got MUBS, I got MUBS and folded a because I assumed my opponent, had no you know, I just got monsters under the bed syndrome. It's a very common term in poker.

UnknownAnd I mean, this is where you're like, you lose a huge hand because you have you have pocket kings, someone else had pocket aces or whatever. And you lose this this huge hand because because your hand was strong and it was gonna give bet stupid. But you had, like, a full house, and you let a big bet make you fold because you just assumed that the guy had a straight flow. You just, like, get the Oh, it's at the opposite. Okay. Okay. Yeah. Like, you could not shake the fact that you were beat even though and it's like I think the Bitcoin space could use that terminology very much so right now, not just for quantum, but for a lot of things.

UnknownIn the, properly sizing risk, the ability to appropriately size risk. Sorry. That was a question. Like, the skill to be able to the skill to be able to pick up. That should be kind of Well, yeah. That's really the quest that but when when you say that, it's sort of like, there's a specific skill, let's say when all the cards are out on the table and you're getting value bet, and you have to ask yourself, what's the probability that he has it versus the probability that he doesn't. He said a value bet is suggesting by what's a value bet is like a small bet

meant to get paid off. It's like the winning hand usually will put out a small bet. So even if you're bluffing, you're gonna pretend you're gonna still throw a value bet out. You're not gonna try to get too much because you're gonna that's how you assert that you have the winning hand. You know, on the river, you might throw like 20% of the pot or something like that, some small bet to get paid off. And you have to sit there and assess, okay, what's the likelihood that he has what he says he has? And that's, is it more than 20% or is it less?

Then you look at your implied odds with the pots paying off. That's Rob, is that that's what you mean I assume? You're on mute my friend.

UnknownYes. That's exactly what I was getting at. Right? Being able to actually go through risk patterns and understanding calculated payoffs. You know? Every every argument has a proposed underlying wager beneath it. And when we talk about stuff like quantum, it's a question of, well, what are the percent likelihoods of this exceeding versus the total amount to be lost? And I think everyone would agree in general to throw it into, a general insurance term of this is a very low frequency, high catastrophic

at the high level understanding. But then the question is is, okay, abstractly that may be hypothetically possible, but then you start getting into the mechanics of, okay, Even if this does exist, it is low frequency, high catastrophic outcome for maybe an individual address. This is not a nuclear bomb that just takes out the entire Eastern Seaboard. This is more like a tornado that throughout the entire United States, if you had a low frequency, high high catastrophic event, it's not gonna take out the entire US in one

slew. It's gonna hit, like, one street in a town somewhere. Right? So even the concentration there to even understand hypothe and this is why, it's almost like a Mott and Bailey situation where it's like, this is catastrophic. It's gonna destroy everything. You're like, well, wait a second. It's not even practical at scale. Like, what is the time to unlock this stuff? Like, what is the economic overhead? It's well, no. No. No. No. No. No. Like but the fact that's possible is, like, a thing we should be concerned about. So we need to make all of these drastic changes because an individual address may be under extreme threat attack. Right? Like, you you start you start moving around the argument, and I think you have to view the problem in its full

context that, okay, let's I'm gonna take you at your word. 1000%, the binary switch is gonna flip from this is not possible to is possible. Okay. What is the time and the overhead for that? And, okay, let's say it's a multisig instead of just a single signature key. Cool. Now you have to do three keys out of five instead of just being one key. So if it takes two weeks, you're not talking six weeks, and you're telling me in that time I won't be able to move funds. Oh, you also have to know it's a multisig, and you have to know there's no passphrase. You have to know Well, the that doesn't matter. The passphrase doesn't matter because it's a public key that's sitting on the blockchain.

Because it because if if the if you reuse the address I'm not gonna ask. The one that gets talked about a lot is the Binance address. So Binance cold storage is like a three zero five multisig, and they reuse the address. And because they reuse the address, the public key is sitting on the stack so anyone can look at it. So you don't need a passphrase. Like, when you do the quantum computer unrivaling, you're not rederiving the bit 32 seed, which goes to Lalu and now Shinobi talking about ways you could actually do a zero knowledge proof to recover. And this is an important detail. When you use BIP 39, what you're actually doing is you take these words,

you smush them together, and then you hash it. I think it's 512 times. And because you hash it a bunch of times, you now disassociate yeah. I think I think it's 512.

UnknownIt's shot it's shot 5122000 times. Right. And since you are doing a hash function, as we've briefly discussed previously on this podcast, you're now outside the domain of the, traditional quantum computer breaking sec p in the way that would be a problem. So it may break an individual key, but it won't be able to actually reverse derive your seed phrase. And that's the important part Yeah. With doing a zero knowledge proof. Yeah. And that also applies to every hardened derivation within your wallet. So if you if you make a a

an x pub and then or an XPRIV, I should say, and then you derive hardened for several layers, and then you'd unhardened below there. Even if a quantum computer were to get your XPUB and get one of the keys I don't know if you guys know this property. Well, Rob probably does. But if someone gets an XPUB and then an unhardened derivation below that, they get a secret key, they can immediately compute all the secret keys within that unhardened path. So if you have one XPUB and one secret key,

can arrive all other secret keys within that path, just with simple simple computation.

UnknownYeah. It's a it's a thing that's often not discussed with BIP 32 is that if you have the XPUB and you have a private key belonging to that XPUB, you can walk across the entire chain of all of the private keys that exist up to that level, but you stop once you hit a hardened derivation path level. Because the hardened derivation path is partially rederived from using your c your private key your your seed phrase, like your actual ultimate, like, seed level and it's hashed. So there's no algebraic relationship anymore. It's a hash relationship.

And so hard hardened derivations are an important part of any kind of discussion of quantum and everything because one of the things that's also under discussed is people are like, oh, my I've never used addresses, so I'm totally safe. Well, have you ever used a web service where you gave them your XPUB for any reason? Because you have to assume that that XPUB is out there in the world now. And so if now, it doesn't matter if you've reused an address, it matters that you ever spent from any address under that XPUB and you gave that XPUB to a service. Because we have to assume that if a quantum break happens, that not only

are old encrypted traffic on the Internet decryptable, because there's probably archives of a lot of traffic that was out there when you sent that XPUB to that server. But if that company is compromised because they don't have a quantum hard crypto system on their backups, backups. Their backups get compromised. They get your exome. Like, all your XPOPs that you've ever sent to a web service are are out there. So so I'm hesitant to make much of a distinction between addresses whose public keys are are known and not because the the best assumption is that most public keys are known. Like Rob said, the Binance addresses, the Coinbase addresses are, in general, the Uri's addresses as well. So it it's simply the the default assumption is that public keys are public. That's why they're fucking called public. Just to be This is this is an important detail too for take it. But now it's like, yeah. Okay. Someone's gonna come and take it. And just realistically,

Unknownyou necessarily have to treat ex pubs and public keys with a different level of security than private keys. You just necessarily have to. Right? No one is running, an elaborate system of security with hardware security HSMs and, trusted execution environments and air gaps to drive to give you an address. Like, that's just not happening. Right? So because the public keys are relatively free in the sense of, like, yeah, give me another one. Give me another one. Give me another one because you wanna get more deposit addresses. And so the security models of those

XPUBs and public keys necessarily for a functioning service have to be at a different level of security, which means it's much more likely that those are just out and available in the world. Yeah. Like most most people are even told for good reason when when you get like a multisig vault with with, know, whatever Casa or Swan or Anchor Watch or anybody who does multisig,

Unknownyou're told to like store your descriptors redundantly. Right? We we treat those which have all the public keys in them as information that should be redundant. And, yeah, you should be a little bit careful with it because it's a privacy leak. It can reveal your balance if you let it out, but it's not a secret key. And so you might put that in a Google Drive or you might put that in a OneDrive or an Apple Cloud, whatever, might put it somewhere that you would never put a secret key in those places. And so the only reasonable assumption is that public keys are public. And so we've gone off on this tangent, to loop that back to this question of measuring the risk.

So we should assume that if a quantum computer happens, all UTXOs that are within the value range for that quantum computer to to to attack are subject to that quantum computer. And then It's like they don't care if it's P2PK, they just don't care. It doesn't That's a red herring at this point. That's unlikely to be the difference. It's really about the size of the UTXOs and whether this The current quantum computer can economically attack those UTXOs. Okay. So we should also be mindful.

Rob was talking about the risk sizing, likelihood versus sizing. And there's There's several of those embedded in quantum, Right? Because there's a low severity risk that is more likely, and that is we see a gradual progression of quantum computing capability, it gets gradually less expensive, maybe hits some floor, maybe doesn't hit a floor, but either way, it's a gradual process. And so in that case, the most vulnerable wallets are these large UTXOs with already known public keys. The next most vulnerable are large UTXOs with partially hidden public keys.

And those folks are kind of active companies managing wallets, and they can easily migrate to new crypto. So we'll see the thing coming from a mile away. We'll give them some new crypto. It's going to be expensive and crappy, but it'll be fine for them because they're large UTXOs and they can handle those costs. So that's kind of the the low severity, more likely scenario. And then there's this much less likely high severity scenario where tomorrow, a quantum computer or a classical break of SecB comes up that immediately

lets anybody quickly reverse any secret key into a public key. Now this is very unlikely, but if it happens, it is catastrophic. And what happens, I think, with the quantum conversation is that they put these two things together. There's this moderately likely thing, which is a slow break of SECP over time with quantum that is not very severe. We can solve this progressively. We have lots of time to work on it, whatever. And then there's this extremely unlikely thing that is the sudden total break. Mhmm. And that would be somewhat catastrophic. It would really make a mess of our shit.

But it's so unlikely. It's barely even worth talking about the likelihood of that. And and they put them together and say it's it's somewhat likely and it's extremely severe, but those don't come together.

UnknownI have a third category potential. So I have a question. Do you think we've covered monsters under the bed now, but do we have main character syndrome? Where does Bitcoin rank? It seems intuitive to us that it would be a target because there's a lot of money there. However, I would ask, is there lower hanging fruit out there for a very expensive quantum computer that has to meet a certain bar for even for them to know it's a tackle be successful,

right?

UnknownI think it depends who gets it. If you're a VC and you're funding a company to break quantum, definitely one of your payoff directions is is is attacking something like Bitcoin and other cryptocurrency type system. Because of the in various ways. Right? Can because of the the what it would mean, the lore, what it would mean. It would it's like beating the the fucking chess master. It's like beating the computer. You know? It's like Yeah. And you might you might say, oh, part of our revenue plan

Unknownis to, let's say, capture Satoshi's coins. We believe they're unowned. We believe we can therefore make a reasonable claim to this being recovering lost property and that we can keep it. So our part of our revenue plan is to recover Satoshi's coins and make them spendable by us. And that'd be maybe a reasonable thing for VC to invest in. On the other hand, if a government funded actor is the one who breaks it, they're not gonna go after that. They're gonna go after decrypting old communications between their enemy states and stuff like that.

There and so it's got a very different attack there. Yeah. It really depends on the actor. Do we have main character syndrome? Is RSA, like, with everyone's

Unknownpasswords and access to all that? Is that, like, just maybe something they they might want to Yeah. Yeah. Certainly, like all old PGP is all gonna be vulnerable too. And there's a lot of stuff, like pretty heavy stuff encrypted with PGP out there. So so, yeah, they're like also that again, depending on the actor. Like I said, I would say that Bitcoin is in the target list. I don't think we're over super overdoing it there. I think some people say, oh, it's gonna be all the other stuff. Problem is everyone knows that Bitcoin is slower to change than a lot of those other things.

So it's basically, if your threat actor is interested in old encrypted stuff or, sorry. Yeah. If if if your threat actor is interested in old encrypted stuff, then they're not gonna go after Bitcoin. But the but the people who are not at risk of quantum the most are like the banks. Everyone's like, oh, banks are gonna be more vulnerable. No, they're not. Because banks can just turn their website off. Totally. The day quantum hits.

UnknownRight. And that's why all the other coins same way. Like they can just rewrite their data. They just undo it. That is one good point. I heard Alex Pruden make this on a podcast somewhere. And that was one of the one things I ever agreed with him saying was like Bitcoin will be a target for that reason. Yeah. Cause we're slow. Now, I don't know. Do you know if anyone's funding projects to do this right now? I don't. Just seems very theoretical that yes, we understand why

that would happen. That doesn't mean it's out there happening. But we just know that we would do that if we got Yeah, sure, that makes sense to us.

UnknownI don't know for sure. I know actually even partially from talking to Alex, but also other folks in the quantum side. Some of the funding is certainly in other things like using quantum to improve sensors and stuff like that. So there's like industrial scale quantum stuff that is happening, that is that is getting funding. I don't know for sure if there's funding going out there specifically to break Bitcoin. It feels like it, but it I that's only a feeling. I don't know. We kinda wish there were. It's really good thought there were some VCs that part of their,

Unknownlike some VCs invested in companies because part of the return on investment was being able to derive Bitcoins and extract it from the network. I have no facts. I only have a feeling on that. Yeah. Like, we want it so bad because we wanna be relevant. I mean, that to your, like, your main character syndrome, like Bitcoin main character syndrome as it relates to quantum? Like, why is that the focus of it all? Yeah. I wonder. Like, it's so Oh, because it's money. Such an easy target. Such an easy target for this. Because because here's the thing. One, it's money. Two,

most of the time when people talk about getting Bitcoin from Quantum, it's Satoshi's coin specifically. No one no major company is going to employ quantum computers to attack Binance, I'm assuming. If North Korea got a quantum computer, sure. But, like, the the bleeding edge of all this research happening, they're gonna just try and take Satoshi's coins, which also presupposes that there needs to be the the the ceiling has to be at least whatever worth 50 Bitcoin are worth at a time.

And they may pull what's more likely to happen in a world where this does develop is they will spend 100 x the amount of money to crack the Genesis block key as a show of force. Yeah. Not to actually be profitable, but once you can do because you have to understand, like, if if they're all trying to hack a particular public key, it is the Genesis block public key. Because, like, you're not doing it to make the 50 Bitcoin. Well, it's just a as an interesting point, in the Bitcoin consensus code, this is a funny quirk. The Genesis block is unspendable.

So they're not gonna do it to actually make money, but they're gonna do it to be able to show that they cracked Bitcoin because it's the original key in the blockchain. Mean, that's more than a funny quirk. It's like literally the linchpin. Right? It's just like it it has to be that way. Right. No.

UnknownIt doesn't. They they he could have put the Genesis block UTXO in the. It just didn't didn't matter. It is poetically, like, good. Like, ah, yes. I created this. And from this Genesis block, I cannot ever get that money. I can't print myself my own money. Because that's actually what he's saying is that since the only block that was ever just made without anyone else ever being able to participate in the network is the Genesis blocks. Right? And then after that, he had to do work by mining the CPU. So there's, like, a philosophical

beauty I see. In making that unspendable. But if you also remember, it was six days between the first time he created the Genesis block and he actually started mining. He waited for it was from January 3 to January 9. So he gave an opportunity for the rest of the world to start mining So like, it's much more of a philosophical think boy piece on that. It's not technically a reason why he had to do it that way. What I guess what I wanna ask is we're just flesh out. There's two types of attackers. Right? There's the kind of attacker that wants value.

UnknownAnd there's a kind of attacker that wants to send the Bitcoin network that wants the Bitcoin network control. These are two clear archetypes. They probably both exist. We will assume they both exist. I think it's safe to assume that they both we don't know if they're both well funded and actively trying to do these things. But we can we assume they are right? Probably correctly assume they are. So is the value, right? Have different incentives,

right? And there's a different ROI threshold that probably for both of them. Right? So the guy looking for value isn't attacking isn't going to attack Satoshi's coins, he's gonna try to prevent anyone from doing that. And he's going to try to another good point Alex made on a podcast somewhere that I'm going to attribute this to him is like, they're going to go after some three bit

Unknownexchange that no one's gonna know that no one's even gonna know they hit them, right? Or some UTXO that's not a Satoshi UTXO, but it's very old and has more than 50 coins in it. So there's a bunch of those out there, right? That have a few 100 coins that someone turned on a miner for few weeks in the early days, mined some Bitcoin and then never moved on, probably because they deleted the wallet at that. I think I may have And done that so there are outputs out there that are larger than 50 and are probably dead, and they're going to go after those because they'll be able to get those without totally taking the value. You'll be able to liquidate them. Right? And that's less where you're gonna get value. But right. The attackers

Unknownwant to go after Satoshi's going strictly because of the impact that's gonna have. Right. To take the network. Yeah. Like the price will tank and maybe they again, maybe it's a one two punch, you know, they first they first they scalp the coins for themselves and then they then they tank the value and spend the public and buy more coins or whatever. Yeah. Yeah. Who knows? But like that. But I think it's good to see the world as those two type those two archetypes and maybe what they're likely to do. And we don't wanna collapse them into one thing. You'd also do this attack, and then you would go short Bitcoin and double dip on the price volatility.

UnknownNice. Nice. If you're gonna If you're gonna do sell. Yeah. Yeah. Yes. Sorry. I was just calling my calling my Yeah. But I think for the main character centric point, was that about Bitcoin always make like, us and Bitcoin culture, I mean, that's always the main character? We still think like so we have this probability space that we have we're assessing what the likelihoods are, right? But then there's if you zoom out of that probably it's like so it's like Venn diagram, but when you zoom out, there's a world around

that Venn diagram too with other entities. So like, whatever probability we think, whatever probabilities we sort of get comfortable with ourselves, they're probably haircuts by the likelihood that Bitcoin is not the main target, which is not one, not zero, something between zero and one of right. There's just some likelihood that Bitcoin isn't even the main target of these first waves of quantum computers is very likely that we'll find out quantum computer exists without Bitcoin being affected at all. I mean,

Unknowngoes to a thing that's often described about with the game theory if you had a cryptographically relevant quantum computer is you would the the best example we have of this is the cracking of enigma during World War two. Right, and where the the allied powers actually figured out the German decryption scheme, was able to decrypt it. They let planes get shot out of the sky, ships get sank, people die, civilians and military troops die. Because to it was more important to continue the illusion they did not know what was happening because there were higher strategic things at play.

And so I actually think the biggest utility for a quantum computer is not Bitcoin. It is decrypting secrets. Right? You could hack a server For many the encrypted files, and you just sit on them and wait until a cryptographically relevant quantum computer comes to allow you to decrypt the said files. Yep. That is 1000% the most important tippy top thing. China doing to The US and US doing to China and everyone doing it to each other. That is the actual most important thing with a quantum computer.

But those are not directly monetizable. Especially

Unknowncan I just add on to that? Especially if you are like, you know what? I can I can I can wax Bitcoin whenever I want, by the way, with this thing, but it's not the most important thing? Right. Well, that that's right. And and the moment you whack Bitcoin and you make this a public show that you've cracked Bitcoin, everyone's going to assume now that all encrypted secrets that have ever been lifted are now revealed. So it's it's a very big deal. Like, Bitcoin could easily 10 x in value, and the and the US government could have a way to break all of Bitcoin, and they still wouldn't do it. Like, that would make sense in a game theory playing out of the structures of the system. Like, that's an entirely plausible thing that people don't talk about. They assume the moment you get to a cryptographically relevant quantum computer, you're gonna pop Bitcoin. And it's like That's my point. You know, like, US

UnknownRight. That's the haircut that I was talking about. Right? So it's like, maybe it's zero. It's You know, it's like You've, like it could you just made a case that it could never happen potentially. It could never happen. So just to be clear, the The US gross domestic product, and you can have caveats on how it's measuring all that, but this is just one year of economic activity is $33,000,000,000,000. So, like, Bitcoin is, like, It's two worth 2% of that. And that's every year. Right? So ten years of economic activity, the value of the Bitcoin is now a basis point in basis points. Or if you're talking about a decade. So, like, why

why would you give up that edge? Because The US would be able and, you know, from a military strength and coordination. What if, like, janitor breaks in breaks into the room where the quantum computer is? Goodwill hunting. I did that just to see Brandon's face.

UnknownSo so the do you even even put kind of a finer point on it? If you have a a cryptographically relevant quantum computer, let's say you're a let's say you're a shady actor. Right? So people are like, oh, what about what about if some some bad actor, whether it's North Korea or whoever else? Maybe they're gonna go after Bitcoin. Rob Rob said it earlier even. Well, but, you know, the also they could do, if they could get some Internet traffic that might reveal business plans, They could they could make more money trading the market with the information they get from a quantum computer than they could from buy from from stealing Bitcoin.

So so there I mean, it it is really this kind of mixed thing where, yes, Bitcoin could be a target. I said that earlier and I stand by that, but it's not the only target and it really depends on who the actor is. Who gets it makes a huge difference.

UnknownBingo. And also how fast it is. Is there any chance that there has been one that's existed for a long time and we just don't know? And think it's With this wild goose chase. It wouldn't surprise me at all. This is what quantum proponents point to that, like, basically, when the nuclear bomb development happened, like, paper started not being published anymore, and all of the professional industry leading people kind of disappeared from Indi because they were just working at Los Alamos. Like, they were just working for the US government,

on a on a field somewhere to try and, like, advance this stuff. You could make that case that's already happened with Quantum, and and maybe it has. And that would and if that's true, we're living in the thesis we're just talking about right now where, like, they would they have cracked it, and they do not care about Bitcoin because Bitcoin is still such and this could be a point about main character syndrome. We think Bitcoin is literally everything as a 1 and a half trillion dollar asset. It's like, buddy, that's percent that's that's 2% of The US GDP per year. And at the level of nation states, you're talking about wealth and you're talking about centuries time horizons.

UnknownIt's it's irrelevant for them today. Also think it's the top priority of all governments in the world to eliminate it. We think it's the we just Yep. Bitcoin strategic reserve though, man. Come on. It's gonna It's change weird though that it's it may end up just being such a poison pill that it never gets touched. Because it's a public disclosure. Because it's a public ledger. So yeah, I just think it's good to zoom out and think about this rationally.

UnknownAnd one of the things I had objected to from Alex's framing was this is such a non mathematical appeal to people. But he would say, if there's only 1% chance, we have to take this very, very seriously. And like, after everything we just said, you have to like the likelihood is so much less than 1%. But like that talking point is very powerful still. Yeah. And that's part of why I've used it various times, this background of of of a unicorn farting next to a quantum computer.

Because the reality is that it's very easy to claim that there's a threat that has a low probability but a high severity and that we have to do something about it. And and so it cannot be the case that people running trillion dollar assets, not that huge in certain ways, but quite huge other ways, take action based on every tiny probability risk that has high severity that could be presented. Because I could probably come up with 20 of those in the next half hour and write write about them using a clinker. And, of course, Bitcoin is not gonna respond to those. So quantum these quantum folks, they have to have

evidence that it actually is coming. And and more papers published does not necessarily equate to evidence that it's coming.

UnknownNo. It doesn't. It explicitly doesn't. Just one thing to close out there, the concept of parallel construction in, like, law enforcement. Like, you actually would it would actually be much more straightforward if you use a quantum computer to break inside of an exchange and lay out a plausible set of facts and then within exploit their business processes to hack them and not use the quantum computer to move the funds. You just entirely pwn their entire architecture using a quantum computer. And then you steal the funds, and you can bread crumb out a parallel construction of this was just sloppy security and bugs and breaking that happened, and you take the funds. So you used a quantum computer to move the funds, but you did not literally crack the keys and move them without consent.

Like, that's just infinitely

UnknownThis is a five d man in the middle of But this literally happened in World War two. Yeah. That's exactly It's like the secret. Yes. That's exactly right. 11. You know, like, it's like what they that was Ocean's 11 where they just recreated a whole set. Right. Right. Yeah. Look like they were doing the thing. Yeah. Yeah. No. Bingo. But that that's and if you're talking about people, like, this is something I think in Bitcoin, we don't give enough credibility to the amount of intelligence someone who is trying to attack the network in one way or another would actually do. They just think that, like, they go to a level one analysis and, like, this is what they're gonna do. They don't think that maybe

my enemies or people people who are trying to attack the Bitcoin network are more sophisticated than I would like them to think. And since I'm well, I'm a brilliant Bitcoiner. So I am a multilevel thinker, but those opponents You are. They are they are trivial, and they are not serious people. So they're gonna just do the first level analysis and the level of the threat attack.

UnknownDid I ever give my NBA analogy on this? Where like, they're gonna grow 12 foot people because they're gonna make some no, there's a big financial incentive to grow 12 foot people because they can go and look at Victor Wimmin Yanma right now. Going to ruin the game. So like, that's obviously going to happen. And they clearly want to do that. So we probably should start changing the rules now. Right, we should make there be a height limit or move the basket now or whatever. Yeah, probably move the basket now is probably how we should. I

it just sort of illustrates, I don't mean to be that absurd and dismissive. I don't like that I'm that way that that's somehow how I always have to communicate. But like, I don't mean to be that absurdist about it. But it does illustrate why it's stupid to start making changes when the probability is so far, no matter how catastrophic it is, when the probability is so far objectively below 1%. I don't think anyone can make a case that the probability is even close.

UnknownYeah, mean, that's where, you had a, in the pre show, we talked a little bit about this question of the mathematicians versus the physicists. I think it was a good time to segue into it because I would rather say and the physicists than versus. I don't know that we're a fancy Yeah. Term, but The mathematicians and the physicists working on quantum. And so one of the things that I think is really fascinating to watch, and actually also the engineers, so we need to add them in there as well, is that it is definitely the case, I would say with with almost certainty

that if a low enough error, fast enough quantum computer with long enough coherence times could be built, that using Shor's algorithm, you can break Bitcoin secret keys into their public keys. Right? That's almost certainly true. So that's where we can say people say, well, the math is done. And that's, I think, a reasonably true thing to say. So if you're looking at quantum computing purely from the mathematical side, you can say, yes. It is done. It will work. And then you go to the physics side. And on the physics side, it's the view is a little bit different. The physics side says, well, we don't have proof because that's not really how physics works

that a quantum computer could be built. We have theories under which it is highly likely a quantum computer of cryptographic relevance could be built. Right? But there are other possible theories that also explain all of our observable facts under which a quantum computer of cryptographic relevance cannot be built, and we don't know what's true yet. And so that's where physics is. Now the most popular theories say a quantum computer that's relevant is possible.

But most popular and true most true are not the same. Right? Obviously, going back, to the very early days of kind of physics of this type, you know, the the heliocentric the sorry. The geocentric view of the of the solar system was wrong, but it was the most popular theory, and it explained the presently observable fact at the time.

UnknownIt's coming back, by the way. Fuck. So so so we we have to say we don't know which physics is correct yet because we yet haven't had the engineering, and we'll get to that next, to build a quantum computer of a size that would tell us which physics is more correct. Or if there's a whole other theory, like neither of the existing theories or none of the existing theories actually match the facts at some point, and we have to revise our theories. That's always the progress of science. And so when you go to the physics

position, it's like, well, what we think is most likely makes it possible to build this quantum computer of of relevance, but we don't know yet. And then if you go to the engineering, well, we are still in the process of building the quantum computer that is advanced enough to even tell us which physics is correct. Right. And so far, we haven't even been able to get a quantum computer to the coherence time and the size where it can tell us which physics is right. And so depending on where you query the quantum computing research, you get totally different answers as to whether it's likely or unlikely that it's possible. Mathematically,

totally, we are there. Physics, we think the best theory would support it. Engineering, we haven't even been able to test the theory yet.

UnknownMathematically though, you've only done Shor's algorithm though. Would argue there's more probably if you looked into what is stopping the physics from working, may be Well, yeah, we kind of go back and forth physics to math. Yes. That are, So like the physicists will say, well, we ran into this problem in building Well, the engineers will say, we built the thing and it broke in this way. The physicists will say, here's the physics behind why that broke. Mathematicians, is there a way we could use

this evidence to create error correction that will overcome these challenges? And kind of go back and forth, engineering, physics, math, back and forth. And so that's where the new Google paper was basically a mostly pure math paper that said, Oh, if we can get the physics and the engineering to work in this way, we can dramatically reduce the number of physical qubits we need to build to achieve a certain level of computation to run Chor's algorithm. But there's several layers of ifs in that. And now we go back down to the physics and the engineering and we say, okay, physicists figure out what physical properties we exploit to build that kind of qubit, can run this math, and then the engineers go and try and physically build that. And so far in quantum computing, every time we do that loop, the engineers go and say, oh fuck, we built it the way you said based on the physics, and we hit some roadblock where

the errors are higher, the noise is greater, the heat is too high, whatever the thing is, the engineers say, actually, everything you said that worked in theory, when we tried to put it into practice, we ran into a hard roadblock, run it back up the tree, get some new math, get some new physics, and try it again.

UnknownYeah. And I got triggered when you said the pure math guys because they're working for Google, right? And it's almost it's like a little nefarious. This is why I get so concerned about like my child who's a pure math major ending up working for the enemy like that, you know, and we're having their skills build, like, you build somebody to be able to do that. And then they end up in a hay, they end up working towards,

it's a little nefarious, don't you? Like I just think it's a little bit nefarious because I feel like at Google, they understand how the public views this. They understand the low bar for causing a ruckus. So like they have a bunch of egg, they have a bunch of people that are, they, you know, maybe they studied pure math, but then they end up they're like high paid think tankers. And, you know, they have them do a paper. And then the next thing you know, BlackRock is leaning on miners to change the Bitcoin protocol. Like what you know what I mean? Like that, but like that chain of events is,

you know, it's not entirely accidental. And it's not, it's definitely not driven by pure curiosity and concern.

UnknownYeah. I suspect that the the people who made the decision to redact that circuit layout for the the Google paper, at least some of those people did that intentionally to cause a ruckus. Now, I don't know exactly who to what but it would be surprising to me, frankly, if there wasn't intentionality on creating a ruckus with that redaction. They're like, this is good enough that we can get away with redacting it in this way. Let's use that to our advantage. Right? And and, of course, like, you can't just redact every little result because that would look foolish, but they're like, this one's good enough. We can redact it and make it look even worse. Right? Like, I I I they had to Totally.

UnknownTotally. Yeah. Because just like, BC's researcher labs, like, if you're purely academic are also trying to get attention and funding. Like, it's not just companies. Anyone who's in a university or doing any leading research in anything is is trying to play a game in What was the redaction? Sorry. It was the circuit. The exact circuit to run this simple not simplified. This this lower More efficient. Version of Shor's algorithm. Yeah. And wasn't that, like, a week after, like, everyone just used AI to, like, partially reconstruct it? They're, like, 85%. Like like, people just started just racing to it because they revealed enough information that experts with large language models could basically closely approximate the exact layout of that circuit. I see. They leaked it temporarily and then redacted it too.

No. They I think they were from the start, it was redacted. From the start, it was redacted.

UnknownOh, to give the illusion that it was like But it was legitimately an improvement in performance. It wasn't it wasn't an illusion, but it was to get attention. Like, it reminded they redacted me because they didn't wanna create risk. And it was like, but the the devices that could run this algorithm are are decades away. What what do you mean? What risk are you reducing? Like, it just didn't make any sense. The risk of not getting funding. Yeah. There used to be this old there used to be a radio show that would play, Obama speeches, but they would bleep out certain words that made it sound like he was cursing his head off.

It's hilarious. And so like that so I'm wondering that is that what is that what this is a little bit? It just trying to create

Unknownto that degree because they believe that's something something real. It wasn't like they made it up, but they did certainly use it to get more attention. I I think it's almost certain. Oh, man. Yeah, it's it would be like having a 12 guy, but it's just like having a funeral for that in a coffin. You know, we just we're gonna put a 15 foot coffin in the ground, say, Oh, that was part of our experiment to ruin the NBA. That's right. I'm

committed to this analogy.

UnknownNo, mean, it does actually somewhat work. There's a thing that could happen maybe in the next thousand years. And so we're gonna start changing the rules now. Yeah. And the other thing with quantum that I think is so fascinating is that we all imagine that the engineering progress is gonna be straight line. And we think that, of course, because in many domains that ends up being true. I'm,

of course, obsessed with Elon Musk. I'm a little bit of a sycophant, so I'll use some of his companies. Like, when Elon started Tesla, the reason he well, anyway, whatever. The reason that he got involved in Tesla was because someone convinced him that all of the necessary physics was solved. Because he he he had he had actually turned down getting involved in other battery electric company car companies before, and it was it was I think it was JB Struble convinced him that the battery tech was actually solved, and so it was time to do it. And so it had already been fully reduced to a engineering and production problem before he got involved. And so people like to to kind of imagine that that's where we are with Quantum, that it is fully reduced to an engineering and production problem.

But that's obviously not the case. And we see this over and over again because we go back to fundamental physics over and over again to figure out new ways to try and get the quantum thing rolling. And so every time, there's a new advancement in it, like, oh, it's just engineering. It's just engineering. It's just engineering. It's not just engineering. And you can tell that because we see I think every few years for the last three decades, we've seen a totally new approach to building a quantum computer with different underlying physical materials, different physics rules, different qubits.

Is it an atom? Is it a photon? Is it an electron? What's the qubit? And so it's obviously still in the fundamental research phase, not the engineering phase. And one of the ways you'll know it's in the engineering phase is that you'll see someone like a Steve Jobs and Elon Musk, what's this guy? Brett Scholl of Boom. There's these people out there who have a nose for, I can build a company on this. And those people, the really big hitters who know when it's time to build a company, are not investing in quantum. It's VCs,

and it's these kind of smaller time CEOs who are hoping to be the next Elon Musk, Steve Jobs, etcetera. It's not the kind of the known decision makers who know how to smell when it's just an engineering problem.

UnknownYeah. VC can make their return on narrative. Doesn't have to deliver. It's very interesting. I guess it's like if I'm still committed to this analogy to the 12 foot people are the shores algorithm and teaching them how to walk. Like, we've never had one walk. So like, they all without breaking their feet. Like, there's no like, we haven't figured out how they how that works yet. Right? Yeah. Yeah. There's still fundamental problems in our 12 people.

UnknownYeah. It's like their bone structure just doesn't. I mean, I don't I mean, if you know the NBA at all, like, even anyone significantly over seven feet has all they've all like, none of them have ever delivered on their potential because they've all had foot problems. Well, I mean, once you I mean, the the the biological systems of how our joints and our bodies and our skeletal structures evolve assumed a certain range of heights. And to just because you technically could get the larger than that does not mean that the rest of the system was designed with those in mind and things, you know, entropy takes you down.

Yeah.

UnknownAnd we see this what's funny in other species too. Right? Like, large dog breeds have have major physical problems too. Their architecture supports a certain fairly wide range of sizes, but not up to the size of a of a a mastiff or a Great Dane. They really have a lot of physical problems. Rob, unfortunately, does knows this firsthand. I have a large dog. And by large dog, I mean, like, a 80 pound golden retriever yellow lab mix. And both both of both of his legs have been replaced in the past eighteen months.

He tore his ACLs on both legs, and so he's now in fully in recovery. He's fine, but the it's a very common thing with that breed. Yeah. But these

Unknownyeah. But it boy, we think think we we kinda went off. This is I'm gonna I'm gonna take the Allen. Yeah. If we're talking about my dog, we're really in the, the the bottom of the barrel. I love your dog, man. He's great. But he's not gonna play in the NBA. There is a valid point here in I think it's hard to even address people who think that it's just an engineering problem. It's such an absurdity,

I guess, right? Because we're so far, again, we're so far away from that even being a serious statement.

UnknownWell, problem of course is that the companies working on each of these different technologies publish PRs, which are picked up by the media and which say exactly that, right? Google posts the Majorana paper and they're like, This is now just an engineering problem. We have made reproducible qubits and we're going to just build chips. And then a few weeks later, they're like, Well, actually, we didn't really solve that and we only made one qubit. But they said that really quietly. The loud part is we've solved it, we're going to start building the production facilities next week is basically what the PR says.

Yeah. And And so we can forgive people for thinking that because it's literally what the media tells them. And we know that most people, what they believe comes from the media. That's why I said to you, we started the whole thing with, I said to go read the papers. That's why I said to read the papers. Because the media, you cannot become informed about this topic or any other by reading the media. You have to go to more direct source material that applies to medicine, that applies to quantum physics, that applies to whatever you want to learn about. You have to read the source material.

UnknownYou're right about that. So when I met Brandon and I was like, can you help me get up on this issue? And he's like, yeah, but you got to read the papers. And I'm like, okay, great. I can read any paper. I don't care. It's fine. Good. Send them over. And he sent one over. And I'm like, after five minutes, I'm like, no, I'm not reading this paper. I couldn't. It was a bit The gap was so wide that I couldn't even see that I could attack the rabbit hole.

So

UnknownYeah. No. That's totally understandable. I think it it I basically got tricked into going down the quantum rabbit hole and reading enough of the papers that I could start to put together the tree, if you will, you know, the the whole tree trunk analogy. You know? Yeah. When you start out and you're just reading a leaf, it's very, very hard to understand anything. And then you have to build a tree trunk and then you can start reading the leaf papers and and make sense of it. So sorry about that. When I found myself unable to grok the SecP256 curve,

I said to myself, this is within my aptitude in my lifetime, I will learn it. When I read, when I spread the paper you said to me, I was like, no, this is not. That was that sort of like how I assess these things.

UnknownYeah, I mean, again, it makes total sense. I got tricked into it. I I I didn't want to be the guy who goes on podcasts talking about quantum, but I could tell people were wrong on the Internet. I think Rob mentioned this earlier. But You it's an important thing. If people are wrong on the Internet, it has to stop, And I alone have the ability to fix it. It's basically I can fix I I can fix her. Like, that's what this whole thing is is I can fix it. I know you're being sarcastic, but I don't I I'm like, yeah. I know. You have to fix it. That's why it's good. That's why it's a good line. Exactly.

UnknownNo. And frankly, I think I've I've hopefully, I've actually helped in this area by being someone who got who got sniped into going down the quantum rabbit hole and reading a lot of the papers and then being able to kind of explain the gaps in where we are versus where the PRs say we are. Again, I can't like rule out that quantum computers could happen. It's just that it's not obvious and it's not tomorrow with extremely high probability. Right. I think if I'm being honest, I think the reason you saying

a classical computer is gonna beat beat cryptography anyway, we should just I think the reason why that resonated with me so much is probably a cope because I had the aptitude to understand that.

UnknownYou could reason about the classical break potential more than Now I'm wondering did I screw myself up there? But that's like, that was a very that hit me very strong. And I think it's because it just validated for me that I'm okay. Maybe I should question that. Oh humans. Yeah. This we could like I have five other podcasts that I look at my own biases and do this laboriously trying to do here.

But that's like that really is like you put me face to face with potential. I don't know something I might have made a boo boo here. There Maybe is a I have to learn the physics. I hope that's not the case.

UnknownWell, the physics are just applied math. Well, not in these papers, dude. Not in the papers that Well, it applied math layers deep. There's a lot of jargon, which frankly, I think another bit of evidence. In my experience of the world, the higher the jargon content in a domain, the further it is from being kind of reduced to correctness. Now that's not an absolute,

but it is commonly the case. And so I think with quantum, we're still in the very high jargon phase because there's so much uncertainty. And once we have more certainty around the theoretical basis and around the engineering, it'll actually start to get simplified. And why is that? Well, because in order to get enough people working on something to bring it to full production, you have to simplify and bring the language into readily accessible terminology that people can work with. So I think that's another piece of evidence in a certain sense that we're far from it is that we're still in these very high theoretical jargon

areas. We haven't come up with the simple terminology that applies to the thing that's gonna actually work. That's what happens in those environments is Dun Kruger

Unknownis a big factor and you end up with LARPs who have chauffeur knowledge who know the jargon. It's kind of wild, right? And then they pass it because somebody like me is like, yeah, you must be right. I can't read those papers. They got people just learn the jargon because they can, that's their access. And you end up with people who not only just learn the jargon, but they actually learn the the relationships

between the jargon words between the the between the concepts represented by the jargon words only. They don't learn the the full stack, like, depth of it. And so there are people writing papers right now about quantum that are absolutely correct within all the relationships between the jargon words, but have no relationship to physical reality. And they don't know it yet because they think all those jargon words in the quantum space have a physical analog that they're working with. But what they're really doing is manipulating symbols that are disconnected from reality and hoping they someday become connected to reality later,

but they don't know that.

UnknownIt's wild. And it's I mean, one of the reasons Rob and I do this podcast is so that we can get people used to the jargon going on in math. And if you do that thing here, you're gonna just learn math. Like you're not you know what I mean? You're not going to get wrecked by some misunderstanding. You're just gonna get used to math. But we do it here so that people just get used to the terms, closure, identity, all these things we talk about in groups and things like that. So the I was gonna say, man, I really hope that the solution involves elliptic curves because we spent like six episodes on it.

UnknownThat'd be cool. Have you done an episode on isogeny based crypto yet? Not yet. Not yet. But But let's hit that for a second if you don't mind. Because what we have talked about are isomorphisms. Okay. Really in the power, like the power of an isomorphism for me the whole when I started studying abstract algebra to learn cryptography, I had a light bulb moment that

an isomorphism. So what's an isomorphism? It's basically two things that have the same exact, like algebraic structure. They preserve the same mathematical operation maps between them without loss. Perfect map, like backwards and forwards without loss, right? And what I saw was like, Oh my God, we might be convinced that we might be told that there's a solution to that's an isomorphism. But like who has the ability to do the proofs

and validate these things? And then I was like, Oh, I guess we're just gonna have to trust Andrew Polstra or Jonas, Nick or whoever it is that tells us and they're probably I mean, certainly they're trustworthy. But is that really how we want to be here? But it was really came down to the power of an isomorphism where you have two things that don't look like each other at all. But have they're essentially equal for the mathematical purposes of what you're trying to do. And one of them can be operated on very easily and one can't.

Me that so that's my understanding of an isogeny. It's not an isomorphism, it's called an automorphism, right? Which is essentially similar idea, but onto itself. But you have an elliptic curve that's something morphic either isomorphic or automorphic to the Bitcoin elliptic curve. Is that correct?

UnknownIt's not that it's to the Bitcoin curve. So in a strategy based crypto, we would start from a totally different curve. And actually, you'd end up having several curves involved. And what you're doing with isogenies is you're writing the relationship between points on one curve and the other curve and discovering that relationship. That relationship is your secret key. So it's an extra layer of abstraction, basically. Instead of being told it's x

cube plus seven. We're actually just saying there's a it's the image now it's not the actual curve itself. Now we're going to speak in terms of like the image of that curve with a secret abstraction between a and b.

UnknownYeah. And there would be one curve that's like the base curve because there are certain curves have the property that it's easy to create isogenies based on from them to another curve. Easy to create, but difficult to reverse. Is that what you mean? Difficult to discover that relationship. So just because you know a bunch of points on both curves, you can't tell what the fundamental relationship is that's that's being used to map points between the two. Yeah. I that's about as far as I can go on it so far. I need to reread Conduition stuff on it and and load it up again. But but the the long and short is that when you're doing isogeny is you're no longer

It's no longer about whether one curve has certain properties with the generator point and stuff. Instead, it's about the relationships between curves.

UnknownRight. That makes sense. So what makes sense is that this may not be the greatest analogy in world, but it's the one that's coming to my mind now. It's sort of, it's Endomorphism, that's the word we were looking for before. Endomorphism, which is image based. That's really now it's image based. So the analogy coming to my mind is basically a pay to pub key versus a pay to pub key hash. You're taking one extra, you're making it one degree harder.

UnknownYeah, and it getting bigger because instead of having a point, you now have I forget exactly what the keys are. There's several points that define an isogeny that become your key. And so you end up with a multipoint key, I forget exactly all of that. The details are blurry at this point. I have to read it again. But yes, it is somewhat similar where you're still using elliptic curve, but instead of the relationship, instead of the secret key being something that can be derived by going from a point through the generator back to

its scalar. Instead, it's being able to take the multiple points that define which endomorphism you're exploiting and discover that relationship. And if you have that relationship, then you can generate more points and that lets you therefore make signatures. But if you don't know the relationship, just because you know points doesn't give you that relationship and you can't make signatures.

UnknownYeah. I'm seeing an analogy with Schnoor too here, just in terms of we're attracting another layer and how it's so interesting. We talked we talked about before where Schnorr, the in ECDSA, the signature is not part of the closure. It's just the points on elliptic curve, but in Schnorr, signature itself is a variable that's part signature plus another signature is also is is also a signature. So it's it's also I I see it right there. There there's the they are algebraically

related, but both the the points the the public keys, the secret keys, the signatures are all algebraically related within Schnorr. Whereas in ECDSA, you break the algebraic relationship between the signature and the two points, the public and private key. Yeah. Yeah. We literally talked about this on our last episode. This isn't this is not I'm comfortable that our audience is good with this. Cool.

UnknownThere are dozens of us. Yeah, I mean, and I love that it went here finally, right? Because this is so Rob and I made a study guide and we spent six ish episodes strictly on how to validate a private key from a public key in the current elliptic curve cryptography, like how you know that you can do that because you know the properties, you know the algebraic properties, you understand that elliptic curve is

a group, the points in the elliptic curve under the operation of addition or a group and you can go backward and you know a group has an inverse and an identity and you can, if you know the public key, you know, it's possible to back into the private key, you may not be able to do it with your classical computers or all of them. But you know that it resolves. Slight side note, we have distinguished that somebody we have not proven. Rob and I have not done a proof to say that the elliptic curve is a

group. So and that's actually not easy to do, and I've assigned my daughter with that problem.

UnknownYeah. That that's actually the part where my knowledge of of elliptic curve cryptography, your current ECDL based elliptic curve cryptography, I don't understand the math of how when someone says, oh, it's it's what is it? It y equals b x plus seven or something or a x plus seven? Y y squared equals x cubed plus seven. There we go. How do you prove that that curve has

the same group properties as what you as the field within which you're operating. So you define the group within a finite field of possible x and y values for the points. And then how do you know that each point is uniquely represented and can be reached through the through the the the cycle of addition so that there's a a one to one mapping, therefore, between the possible secret keys and the possible points.

I don't understand that. I know it I know that they do that before they accept one of these curves and and and and decide on the the secret keys and everything, but I I don't understand it. That is a priority of the Magic Internet Math Academy is to publish that paper.

UnknownWe we took that for granted this entire time. But when you get to that point, I wanna read it and learn it because that's the part where my knowledge breaks down. I know there are cryptographers out there who, like, study the curves Mhmm. And and develop kind of demonstrations essentially that Yes. The curves are correctly mapped, but it's it's beyond me. Yes. So that's I I we had been calling that a bit of a red herring, but that's now now that we've gotten now that we've gotten there I mean, we've done 10 episodes just on libsec p.

UnknownLib not the the curve itself and libsec p is implementation of said curve. That's great. Next level, I'm not sure if you have anything else left, Brian. Don't It's always you know, so I think it's always good when a guest gives us homework. That's right. That's right. We have to get through the rest of our Allen homework next. We're gonna have to do hash functions. We're getting there. Allen's coming back. We've talked about it. It's happening. Excellent. This was great. Was great.

Brandon, thank you so very Thank you. Good talking to you guys. Yeah. Awesome. Thanks guys. See you for fun. Catch you later.

Open the transcript file

Hosts and Guests

Nobody is credited on this episode yet.

Credit the people on this episode

Be the first to rate this episode

More episodes

All episodes
  1. Exponential Got Less Exponential

    Nov 2, 20261 hr 10 minAudio

    In this episode, we picked back up on our red-team tour of Bitcoin cryptography and tried to make sense of the last few weeks of fast-moving math news. We unpacked why the recent excitement around the exponential time...

    Credit the people on this episode

  2. Red Teaming Elliptic Curve Cryptography

    Oct 11, 20261 hr 27 minAudio

    OpenAI just dropped roughly 300 math papers with Lean proofs, mathematicians are crashing out, and the vague-posting has started: "math is breaking, so cryptography is next." Brian and Rob Hamilton refuse to hand-wave....

    Credit the people on this episode

  3. Hash Functions, Linear Algebra, and Alice in Wonderland

    Sep 28, 202650 minAudio

    Magic Internet Math: https://www.magicinternetmath.com/ Shout out to https://x.com/uncleJim21 for the Alice in Wonderland story and the following rebuke of Lewis Carroll: https://www.youtube.com/shorts/33FYXpEWgyA This...

    Credit the people on this episode

  4. Kayfabe Math is Now Mainstream

    Sep 13, 20261 hr 17 minAudio

    We’re back because math keeps refusing to stay in the classroom. In this episode, I unpack two very different kinds of “math pop culture.” First, we revisit entropy, seed generation, and wallet security through a...

    Credit the people on this episode

  5. Legalize MATH

    Sep 2, 20262 hr 2 minAudio

    Magic Internet Math is back. After the summer that set the Bitcoin world on fire - the Cold Card entropy disaster - Brian and Rob Hamilton (AnchorWatch) reunite for a two-hour deep dive on the event Rob spent three...

    Credit the people on this episode