Skip to content
PodSubs
ShowsPeopleGuestsJobsNewsEvents
More
BlogPodCred
Menu
ShowsPeopleGuestsJobsNewsEventsBlogPodCredNetworksSign in
Join nowSign in
  • Shows
  • People
  • Jobs
  • News
  • More
    • Guests
    • Events
    • Blog
    • PodCred
    • Networks
    Join nowSign in

Magic Internet Math

Magic Internet Math artwork

Risk of Ruin: Bankroll Math for Bitcoiners

Jun 7, 20261 hr 22 minAudio

Rob and Brian shake off the dust after a busy stretch of conferences and a milestone YouTube debut with guest Alan, then map the road from elliptic curves to an upcoming mini‑series on hash functions. We talk Prague plans (a keynote on “the mathematical layer of sovereignty” and a quantum‑security panel with Trezor), growing Miniscript adoption (Liana, Trezor), and why the Magic Internet Math platform now extends into local community with a new math‑forward BitDevs in Philadelphia. Along the way we reflect on conferences as cultural glue and classrooms for Bitcoiners. The back half is a detour into poker as a living analogy for Bitcoin: bankroll management, game selection, Kelly criterion, and conviction under volatility. We kick around time‑preference versus risk‑preference, the perils of leverage, and treasury/custody tradeoffs - from digital credit notes and proof‑of‑reserves to insurance‑backed multisig. Expect practical takes on River’s yield accounts, ETF custody signals (Bitwise/Coinbase), and why resilient operations matter more than narratives - plus a few fun asides from WSOP lore to Rounders and the Potoshi pattern. 'AnchorWatch': https://www.anchorwatch.com 'Miniscript (reference implementation by sipa)': https://github.com/sipa/miniscript 'Liana wallet (WizardSardine)': https://wizardsardine.com/liana/ 'WizardSardine': https://wizardsardine.com 'Pay to Script Hash (P2SH) - Bitcoin Wiki': https://en.bitcoin.it/wiki/Pay_to_script_hash 'Pay to Witness PubKey Hash (P2WPKH) - Bitcoin Wiki': https://en.bitcoin.it/wiki/Pay_to_witness_public_key_hash 'NYC BitDevs': https://bitdevs.org/nyc 'BTC Prague': https://www.btcprague.com 'Zeus Wallet': https://zeusln.com 'River': https://river.com 'River Transparency / Proof‑of‑Reserves': https://river.com/transparency/ 'Kelly Criterion - Wikipedia': https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Kelly_criterion 'Factorial (52! for deck permutations) - Wikipedia': https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Factorial 'World Series of Poker (WSOP)': https://www.wsop.com 'Binion’s Gambling Hall (WSOP origins)': https://www.binions.com 'Rounders (1998) - IMDb': https://www.imdb.com/title/tt0128442/ 'Arkham Intelligence': https://arkhamintelligence.com 'Holt’s Cigar Company (Philadelphia)': https://www.holts.com

Audio and video play straight from the show's own hosting. PodSubs stores and serves no media.

Transcript

From the show. Tap a time to play from there.

UnknownAlright. Welcome back. Welcome back to another episode of Magic Internet Math. We're doing it. Rob Hamilton and Brian Hirschfield. Remember, I got I got I gotta give my name. Otherwise, bad things happen bad things happen in the AI. Your own clanker rebels against you and gives you a new name. Brady. They gave me the name Brady. Actually still in the show notes, and I left it in there to remind myself of the anger that it causes in me.

UnknownOh, man. Excellent. So it's been a minute. It has. There's been a couple we did the last episode with Alan, which I think was very well received on YouTube. It was our first lie it was our first guest. It was our first YouTube recording. Yeah. There's a lot of things going on there. Alan insisted we put it out on YouTube because he went out of his way to wear an AcroWatch hat. That's right. That's right. He's like, I wore the hat. I can't I what's the point? I have to say I have to say a couple things. For one, you know, I we I I think I messaged you guys right after the episode ended, and I basically said,

this was the finest to me, like, the finest representation of what, like, our vision of this podcast would be when I when I talked to you when you were on the road driving up, and we said, what should this podcast be like? And I think the I'm so I'm really taken aback by how that episode turned out because it was such the, like, kind of the personification of what we want of what certainly, I I think we wanted this to be. It was like a perfect visualization. I hope to hope to have many more of those.

UnknownYeah. You're on mute. I agree. I was on mute. Yeah. I was changing some a b stuff. Yeah. I agree. They're fun little checkpoints too. So you and I are not caught in our own little echo chamber of going back and forth to bring other people in different perspectives. I think Alan helped set kind of the trajectory for the next major block of stuff we'll do. We're we were already talking about it, but I think we're committed now. We're gonna after we finish up elliptic curves, we're gonna go into hash functions. Yeah. I hope we don't hate doing hash functions, and we're just stuck in a we're stuck in a farrington trap. Well, I think hash functions

Unknownjust by the nature of how they work are gonna be less complicated than, elliptic curve cryptography. Right? And I think hash functions are the other thing besides elliptic curves that really glue the Bitcoin system together. But they're the nature of those are very, general because hash functions are not secret. Right? Hash functions are explicitly a public function. So there's less, like, mission critical math associated with them because you wanna make sure you do the electric curve math right so you can hold on to your money and no one else can take it from Whereas hash functions are things that you publicly put out for everyone to review and verify.

So I think the nature of the problem is way more scoped in. It's way more tractable of a thing to wrap our arms around in a couple episodes.

UnknownI don't think it's gonna be eight episodes of hash functions. No. I don't think so. And so even if we don't like it very much We'll just eat our vegetables and keep on going. Exactly. Because it's not like I don't know that it has the richness. Like, there's I feel like we can we'll we'll do the hash functions thing. We'll do something else, and then maybe we go back and do another five episodes on elliptic curves because there's just still so much Yeah. Still so much more to get out of that. With the hash functions too, like, hash functions were a thing that I was using on the Internet in the late nineties, early two thousands where you would have like, a a company would be like, here's our dot EXE file, and here's the hash function. Like, here's the m d five hash. It used to be m d five hash. Right? So, like, it's something that's been around for,

I would say for the normie sphere way longer. Your computers are using hash functions all the time even if you don't realize it. If you use if you're doing programming, you're absolutely using hash functions. That's how dependency management works with, like, package tagging and all these things. So, like, a hash function, think, is just gonna be easier, more straightforward for sure. And you've been on a you you've been fully on the PodConf tour because I we were both in Vegas. We hung out a couple times briefly here and there. And then

you had your fish concert.

UnknownYou had all of the That's fish concerts. There. And then you got home for a couple days, and you're like, yeah. Fishconf. And then you had you're like, I gotta do I gotta do another conference. I I I don't have an I need more. Whereas more commendable than me. You're you're more aggressively hitting the podcast circuit than me. Well, I'm hungry. I don't have you know, I need to I need to get this off the ground. And the amazing thing that happened after we released the Allen episode is that the YouTube basically ballooned to 3,500 subscribers.

UnknownNice. Allen's like the eye candy. Pretty incredible. Allen's the eye candy that brought all the viewers in. No no one cared about the math until we put on we brought the squirrel on. For sure. You know, I used to have this joke. I'm not a candy guy. Okay. But, like, but if there was, like, eye mac and cheese around, that might be a problem. Mac and cheese? Yeah. I can't resist mac and cheese. I I would eat mac and cheese off of a highway if it Got it. Got it. Mac and cheese is your comfort. Like, you're just gonna go to that no matter what. Yeah. Yeah. I could resist candy. I can't. I I you know? Yeah.

UnknownYeah. So yeah. So, like so things are moving. Conferences. I'm going to Prague in a week, and I'm getting I'm gonna get to deliver a keynote twice. So once at the Freedom Tech Conference, that's like the side Assad Conference the day before Prague starts. And then once at the main conference, and it's the keynote's gonna be called the mathematical layer of sovereignty. Okay. So Matthijs basically just allowed me to

run with just run with this idea. Right. You know? Like, part of why I will travel to the other side of the world is because some of you know, these conference organizers have given me a lot of rope, and I'm very grateful, very, very grateful to them for that. And I wanna, you know, give them the

UnknownLooks like we lost Brad if the AI were to call him that, but we lost Brian for a moment here. So in real time, I'm just gonna improv Jazz jump in here to make his life easier on editing the podcast. I guess in general, just to try and keep it somewhat thematically aligned with what he was talking about. If you're have never been to conferences, I think it's a great way to get yourself better integrated into the cultural side of Bitcoin. Being able to meet people in real life,

being able to probably get your spot on a speaker stage, putting a little bit of work. If you're interested in doing work in the industry or building something, I think it's something that's incredibly valuable. And in general, I can speak to this for my time in Bitcoin and going to conferences. It is like a second family you get to bounce around and go see pretty regularly. I would attribute a lot of my initial integration into Bitcoin by doing things like clubhouse and conferences.

I think they're just incredibly viable to go to. And it looks like Brian is coming back in I the saved you, Brian, from doing any editing because I immediately just dovetailed off and talked for, like, a minute while you were gone. Such a pro, dude. So now you're back. I was just talking about how conferences are great. Jumping back to you.

UnknownYou I really I don't know where I cut. Did I get to talk about, like, what I was talking about in Prague? Yeah. The mathematical layer of sovereignty. Yeah. The two conferences. Yeah. These guys just gave me the rope to talk to to do this. I'm incredibly, incredibly grateful, and I wanna go over there and crush and make it great. And so then so I'm doing this keynote, and then the other thing I'm doing is I'm moderating a panel on Quantum with the CTO of Trezor and

another gentleman who is of that and I can't remember the the company he works for. But

Unknownso I've been, like, doing a lot of prepping. Very fun. Yeah. A lot of prepping for that. Pavel's great. I'm happy to well, Trezor has a open PR right now for miniscripts, so I no longer Nice. Have a when miniscript vendetta against them. Looks like they're imminently doing the work. So excited to see They gotta be like so Bitvault. They gotta be like Bitvault. BitVault? Yeah. I know the are they are they doing the panel with you? Or No. No. But they are, like they're all in with mini script. I love it. Like, it's the funniest thing because, like, three years ago when I started talking about this,

I've kind of gone full circle because I wouldn't shut up about it for months and months and months. And it kind of went on deaf ears, but I think a couple people picked it up and realized the potential of this stuff. When I was doing this, it was only me and the wizard sardine, the Liana guys, and that was it. Yeah. And I'm I'm excited. People get this weird conception that, like, it's a unique swim lane that I want to do and that like, if people are like mini scripts my thing, which is 1000% not the case because the network effect of as more ecosystems integrate mini script, the interoperability goes up. Right? It's a network effect. So I want more people building and doing all these things. So I think it's awesome that Vault guys are doing. I think it's I think it's gonna be the future of Bitcoin custody for sure. Like, Bitcoin multisig was kind of standardized in 2016.

It came out well, pay to script hash multisig came out in 2014. Bitcoin's always been able to do, it has always been able to do multisig with paid to multisig addresses. But pay to script hash in 2014, and then 2016, it got really big, and it got really big. Huge shout out to Unchained for their two of three vault structure and being able to do the lending against it. It just that that's ten years ago. So we should be upgrading and doing things that we don't need requirements or forks or changes or anything. So huge shout out there to the BitVault

Unknowncrew and everyone else that's building on top of this stuff. Yeah. Do you know that Magic Internet Math is on its way to being also a publishing company? I did not know that. So we you do know we produce textbooks because I'm I'm familiar. I'm a consumer of them. We you know, this prototype of the textbooks was the Ellipticurve guide that has been in the show notes for the last eight episodes, right, that we based. And that, you know, that got me

really thinking that, well, there's a lot of potential books that we can create. And Right. Know, thanks to the the wonders of AI, you can generate a lot of books and then mostly bad. Math slop. Math slop. Not a lot of math slop, but the way you convert the way you transmute math slop into math signal is by doing the work and editing it. And so I just summarized my Vegas panel, by the way, transmuting a AI slop into AI signal. It really just takes Oh, that's great. Spending the time. So the book that I have spent the last month editing

that I'm a I'm on the last, like, the last page of the last section. It's it's called every bite tells a story. I'm pretty sure I've told it here, but, like, every bite tells a story. Think think of, like, mastering Bitcoin and Nifty's Base 58 were to be raised in a society of strong fathers that, you know, could really have an an exhaustive reference guide. And so right now, it is it's like, the way I'm probably gonna release it. So it's physical copies

and Internet, HTML. And the HTML is super powerful because what you can do is now you can take the the stack, the Bitcoin script. I mean, pretty much pretty much any opcode that you wanna see what it does. Like, what does op check multisig do? And with the HTML version, there's the interactive tools to push, you know, to push the stack one at a time, and you use actual transactions from the mempool to do it, which is pretty awesome. And it tells the story of so,

you know, p to p k starts with block one seventy, which is the, you know, the transaction Satoshi sent to Hal. And then, you know, p to pay to witness PubKey Hash has another story in there where so it's very exhaustive very freaking cool. But there's a sequel to this book, and that's why I brought it up. There's going to be a sequel to this book. I already made it. I just haven't edited it yet. But the sequel is it's around mini script.

So chapter two of the book starts to say, here's where what we had was a little too limited. Here's where script ends and mini script begins. And it's very, very cool.

UnknownYeah. I on that The Bitfault guys were losing their minds when I was showing it to them. That's awesome. So the as a as a very, very brief comment, mini script at the end the day is just a subset of script. The problem is is that if you walk it's like you walked into like a a well, like like a machine shop and there's 10,000 ways you can cut off your fingers if you just use raw script. There are there are script wizards in the world. They do exist.

And they are able to navigate and finesse that. But when you're talking about long term storage, you wanna have general guardrails to make sure that you're not gonna cut your fingers off. The other metaphor I use is it's like bowling with bumpers. Right? And the beautiful thing about miniscript is, I mean, technically, technically you could say a single sig is miniscript, but like it doesn't really mean or do anything that's meaningful. And also just a two zero three multisig or an event It's like saying that's like saying technically,

Unknownordinary least squares is like machine learning. Right. Exactly. Right. It's like the the basic level of it. You're not really leveraging any of the properties of ManyScript because op check multisig and op check sig, like the single sig and multisig operations are really straightforward. They're really, really straightforward. There's no extra considerations that need to be made as long as you follow the very narrow strict template that everyone knows that every single Bitcoin wallet since, like, 2014 has encoded in it. But the moment you wanna do anything else, you wanna do different tap leaves, you wanna do different

you want you wanna do time locks. You wanna do all of these things. There are considerations that need to be made, and that's where the manuscript stuff comes in. So I'm looking forward to seeing that. It's very cool.

UnknownBut, like so the ethos of magic Internet math, particularly with regard to having conviction in your own reasoning and your own ability to huddle your stack indefinitely, is, you know, you have a you have a math pillar that's obviously very important, and then you have a protocol pillar that's very important. And so I I'm going to facilitate my plan is to facilitate both. And now that's where the bit devs I'm starting kind of comes in because the the the that BitDev is is going to reflect

this ethos, which is there's a protocol pillar and a math pillar Right. Of understanding and having conviction in Bitcoin. And I'm really excited. So I'm starting a BitDevs in Philly. I don't know if I'd even talked about it yet on this show. I talked about it on all my other podcasts, but, like, not this one. It's been three weeks, so maybe you haven't yet. Yeah. Yeah. Because that idea didn't come to me. That idea came in Vegas. Right. That was like, you could say probably you'll sum up I can sum up the result of going to Vegas was coming back with the

the divine sense that this is what I that this is what I had to do. Okay. Right? I I just came back with the sense that that's I must I must start this bit devs. Part of it is it's much like I need a classroom. I need a real classroom with students to teach to. Right? Leaders have followers. Teachers have students, and it's time to build something that reflects like, I don't have you know, I could say I'm building a Math Academy, but if I don't have anyone

I don't have students, I'm not really building anything. So, anyway so I realized I need to build something. I need to build my classroom. And I went down, shout out the 21 media who good friends of ours. Yes. And so Jeremy basically arranged this space. It's a workspace. It's like it really is like a I I say this in the most endearing way. It's like a poor man's version of what New York BitDevs is. It's it's

in other words, it's a works it's it's a shared workspace. It's great.

UnknownYeah. But it's like, you know, it's a Philly version of it. You know? But here's the secret is that every single BetDevs is a poor man New York City BetDevs. Yeah. We Everyone is. I've got we we've got Square Pizza coming. By the way, also shout out Zeus and Evan Gluez. Pizza. Oh, yeah. We got we two blocks away, we got Square Pizza that's gonna come in we're gonna come and have pizza just like New York. But Very nice. It's going to be different because it's gonna have the math focus. Yeah. Square Pizza is a very Pennsylvania thing.

Is it? Have family yes. Because I'm from like, I'm I'm not from that area, but my my wife's from, like, more rural PA, and they're really big on their Square Pizza. And I used to mess with her. This is we're now talking twenty years ago. I would I would describe it. Have you ever been to, like, a you'll see it at, a BJ's or a Costco, like, Elio's Pizza, like the Elio's is what I was raised on. Right. And I would I would mess with her and describe her, like, favorite family pizzeria growing up as they're just basically reheated Elio's pizza.

UnknownI could live with that, by the way. I see, I don't need all this new I don't need all this new pizza. I like it, but I don't need it. Like, I would have been fine with Elio's with the pepperoni chunks on them. Right. No. But just coming from New York and and having, like, a dozen good pizzerias within, like, a thirty minute drive of your house, like, you get opinions on pizza. And it was never bad, but, like, it was it's a very unique vibe. Philly's similar. Like, I don't know. For some re like, I always need to know and have a strong opinion on every pizza place. You know? Gotta have the authoritative opinion.

That's right. That's right. But pizza's part of BitDevs because of New York. So, like, we are I'm emulating I'm gonna emulate the their what works over there. But we're gonna have so we're gonna have a quarterly bit devs, but a monthly math devs. Very nice. That makes sense. And so Evan Evan agreed to do the quarterly bit devs, I guess at least until I can figure out how to do them on my own.

UnknownNice. Good stuff. And so, like, shout out Evan, Zeus, Jeremy, the twenty one media. They're make we're all making this happen. And oh, and it's a block away from Holt. So, like, we can go smoke cigars before Sick. After. Very You know? You need a torch lighter? You're you're you're you know? Did you go to come to the meetup and you forgot your cutter? I remember that. Just go to Holt's and Get hooked pick one up. Dude, it's, like, pretty great. It's like that it's all kinda like I don't know. I see this whole thing coming together. I could see it being a great time. I remember when you came to do the BitDevs in Philly. I wanna take you to Holt's, like, so bad. And for some like, logistically, we couldn't figure out how to do it without dragging everyone from the meetup.

UnknownYeah. That's the the Philly bit the John is Yeah. I didn't realize you guys do a once a quarter, once a year bit devs. It's not a It's once a year. And, like, it's maybe once a year and, you know yeah. That was a conversation when it first started where there was this idea that Philly was just too stupid. Well, it's also that you have New York City BitDevs that's close enough. Like, you could just do the It is. Train ride in, and, like, you can get your BitDevs hook up. You're not quite in an isolated island.

UnknownYeah. I gotta start going to those now much more much more regularly. Well, the the real hack would be you should go to New York City Bitdevs, and then the week after, do Philly Bitdevs and have, like, a like, basically crash course notes on how to set up. Is the hack, dude. That that that that that's the hack. Yeah. Especially if I wanna bring anyone of them any of them over. You know? Right. Right. Get them to come. It's right, by the way, also, the location of the BitDevs is so good. It's at the most central subway stop in Philly. Love it. Yeah. So, like, well, if you're training down from New York, it's a little it's a tiny little Uber ride. If Very nice. Unless unless you wanna get on the subway, which most people don't. Right. But it's kinda like going into Penn Station and taking the

Unknownjust just hopping on one stop to Times Square. That's that's essentially what this is like. Yeah. And there's, like, multiple lines that will take you to 42nd Street from Penn Station, the one two three the four five six. Like, you have plenty of options. Like, you just gotta get up jump up eight, ten blocks. And you could just decide to walk it. You could. Right. Anyway, so that's that. And so the Magic Internet Math, like, platform is really starting to get some legs. I'm really excited about it. And, you know, so now the question is, what do you wanna talk about here today?

There's many many thing. You know? It's so it's was, like, surreal hanging out with you in in Vegas. You know, I got to hang out with you in Nashville. Got to hang out in Vegas. You know, it's, like, surreal to, like, turn that on and then turn it off. Totally. Totally. And I almost forget, like, you know, we were in Vegas just just talking about literally anything and everything. And we were almost like doing the math podcast just to each other. Right. In in person. Absolutely.

Now it's like, okay. What do we what do we really it's it's a embarrassment of riches that there's so many things to hit. But, like, you know, what do you think? Like, if we're gonna pick an episode right now, which is like a transition episode between the elliptic curve stuff and the hash function stuff that we'll cover when next time.

UnknownRight? Next time on Magic Internet Math. And I yeah. Next time. And so, like, there's, like, a there's, like, a a little index of things. Like, I still really wanna you and I have never really done the talked about poker in-depth. Not on the show. Not even really, maybe even in person. Yeah. I don't think we've done a lot. Yeah. You know why I so you wanna know why I really like poker as a subject for Bitcoin in general?

Why poker uniquely poker is unique. It's it's a unique, like, example. Yeah. It's because there is a obviously, there's gambling. Right? So, like, it's Mhmm. You know, it's important. Anytime there's gambling, right, you are you're bringing to bear the game theory. Yeah. Right? Without gambling you know, how many times have you played poker with your buddies and had this conversation where, like, poker

has to be for money? We can never play for The game the game doesn't work. Right. The game doesn't work if it's not for money. You can't play for Cheetos. It doesn't it doesn't work. It's not a score. It has to bring to bear the game theory. Only a gulp limit, enough a certain amount of money that is a little uncomfortable to lose Right. Brings to bear the game theory that poker poker is nothing more than a conversation. Right? Right. But around who's who can basically present the highest conviction story.

Right. But yet there is always a final settlement at the end that, you know, you it's you know, law, you know, legal cases are kinda like this, right, where it's like there's a lot of bluffing and a lot of poker being played assuming maybe we don't have to show down at the end. But there is always a showdown at the end that nobody really wants to risk. And so that you know, when you think about the game theory of being a Bitcoiner. Right? Mhmm. There's a

there's decisions. Like, there's decisions at every level, and that's why I like poker. Poker, it's not just betting on an outcome like a of a baseball game, and you sit and watch the game. Right? That's one level of it. But there's there's there's betting at every instance, every single instance of the game. Every time a card is dealt, there's a betting round. Every time Yes. A card is shown, there's a betting round. And that's more what it's like to be a Bitcoin hodler where you have to make these decisions and evaluate the opportunity cost and collect information about what's going on from every single

decision point that's being made.

UnknownRight? Yes. And the beautiful thing is an iterative game, you get it back around to the other side, and you start with a clean slate again, but you do have artifacts of knowledge from the previous iterations that even though the entire set of cards is different, you have learned new information to be able to try and evolve the game. And that's why it's a rich, deep, iterative game. Yeah. And particularly, like, you get information about your opponents. Yes. That, you know, you might have information you can get in between rounds because the cards are always different.

UnknownThat's right. I mean, you can get you you can get information about yourself. That too. That maybe you didn't realize. Like, I don't know what like, you might you might normally be a very comfortable turn better, and then you might find yourself sitting at a table with people where you just don't have that nerve, and you don't know why. But you do have to you do you you have to reset your probability space when you realize this. And the difference, like, the

further you get within the game of a single hand, the further out on the brink of the unknown you are. And that's why in theory, like, before like, pre flop, you're just having your two cards and folding, like, closes out many, like, nasty patterns of being exploited. And every incremental round of betting, pre flop, the flop, the turn, the river, you're further out in this zone of uncertainty. And the small percentage differences between a casual player and a good player and in a professional player,

you start getting really wide distributions because the really good players will be able to further with better ability navigate the later betting streets. And the nature of poker when you're putting money in a pot and the bets are usually based off what is the size of the pot, the bigger bets and the like, that's where the more meaningful, like, value and skill comes in is on those later streets for bigger stakes as well. And we're being specific now, like, to a a no limit or a pot limit game.

UnknownRight? Yeah. Where, like, in the beginning stages of the game, a good player tends to want to control the size of the pot so that they're not commit you know, they're not necessarily committed, but then it they're better at the end of the game of getting all your money. Getting all your money if they know they're They're they're putting in as little money as possible when they are uncertain, and they're putting in a lot of money when they are certain. And that is so that's that's the key right here. So it's it's like the key here is you get to you you not only get to, but you must express your conviction

in your, basically, your ability to play the game at every Right. Essentially, at every moment. And that's why it's very that's why I like I like that. I would love to see a bigger poker culture in Bitcoin. Right? Because that that this is the game. Right? We are, in one sense, you know, this debate of, like, is it a store of value or is it a medium of exchange? Right? There's like that debate.

And I hate that debate because it's I like, is it both or is it neither? Or is it, you know, it can be both. It has to actually is both. I mean, it's both. And you don't have one without the other. And, well, does it have to be a store value first? See, in poker, it's both. Right. Okay. So your conviction in in your skill and your ability to stay solvent, right, that's your store of value. But the medium of exchange is what allows you to express that on every turn of every

every turn every betting opportunity of the game, which is nearly continuous. Right? Like, you get two cards and then you bet. And then you see a flop and then you bet. You see a turn and you bet. And it's like the nature of the nature and the nuances of, like, okay, position and hand strength. And these are the kind of things that you it's like you have to simultaneously assess yourself and your opponents and then go express your conviction.

Right? And you what I like about poker is if you are, you know, if you're wrong about yourself, you're gonna find out very fast, you're and not gonna play. You won't be you won't even be able to play anymore. Right. Right? Whereas, you know, somebody with, like, good skill but bad bankroll management may may find themselves

Unknownto they'll be able to keep playing but not as a sovereign. Yeah. I I would say that actually the two most important skills in poker are bankroll management and game selection. Those are which is funny because it's not like you're bluffing or, like, your x y z social. Like, everything is downstream. It's a very insurance man gets an insurance man's assessment, by the way. So good on you there. Yeah. Well, the the this is also, like, in a time of my life, learning how to count cards, like the Kelly criterion. Right? It's like understanding that size management. Like, there there's a fun little map. We we could do a whole, like, one off, like, gambling detour episode on just, like We're here. That's it. That's this episode. That's this. We're doing it right now. Would pull up the proper Kelly criteria, and I would pull a couple other things up. But, like,

the when you get into poker, don't realize it at first, but the game selection and your bankroll management are explicitly the two most important things. To your point about being a sovereign, you blow out your bankroll. It doesn't matter how good of a player you are. If you don't have any money, then, like, you can't play at the big tables.

UnknownSomebody could back you, but you're now not sovereign. You're, like, now Right. Beholden to to your backers. Right. And then you're you're you're playing a backer thing. And then poker's rife with stories of someone being backed and then someone, basically backing out of paying out their stake. And so Yep. You know, the or you have people who sell more than a 100% of their action because they're just assuming they're gonna lose, and then they just, like, collect, like, yield. So if you sell a 105% of your action, it's okay as long as you lose.

UnknownFractional so they used to, like, fractional reserve players? Yeah. Like, it's yeah. It's pretty bad. Like like, that's poker's just very rife with all these stories of people who, don't honor their bets or they're, like, they're a good player, but they get stuck in a hole. And then they owe a bunch of people money because they're stuck, and then they just go to random, like, events and games and tournaments, and they get other people to back them. And then someone sees them there being like, hey. That that guy owes me a bunch of money. What is he doing here? Or it's a friend of a friend. Poker's a very also, like, tight knit, like, camaraderie people element thing because it's you you have to have high trust if you're operating with these people outside of the table because people are handing around money all the time

for their games. Super high trust. And they're handing around, like, hundreds thousands money on a whim, like like, a reputational system. Like, they'll just be like, oh, here's $10 so you can play the main event kind of thing. Well And it's so funny. Right? You

Unknownthink about, like, the Bitcoin PLEB slop ecosystem. Right? And they tell you, like, you know, you can't even get take a thousand dollars out of the bank because they don't have it. Right? You met so when you think about, like, these poker players trying to settle up, and they're always just like, don't worry about it. You're good. We got you. Don't worry. Blah blah blah. Right? And it it's because a lot of that comes down to the fact that gamblers, like, the one code they do have is that you pay your debts, otherwise, you get your action cut off. And that's Right. So they they're they're actually quite reliable to pay their debts for the most part. Yeah. Because the last A

Unknownthousand percent reputational game. I one very brief change because you just mentioned it. I've been every time I use the banking system, I get radicalized more in justifying my career pursuit and my interest in Bitcoin. My I had a local bank that I set up an account. They would only let me move $500 a day ACH. And I was like, what are you talking about? Like, you took you took a larger deposit without asking questions. Now you're not letting me move the money out. And, well, I guess we can, like, give you a check. I was like, thanks. I'll take a check. And then I took a check, and I had to, like, run around, like, carrying checks. And, like, it was, one of these moments when I was like, I'm just going to,

not use the banking system. I hate this I hate this place. Get me out of here. Yeah.

UnknownNot not a fan. But so the interesting thing with game selection. Right? The best way I think I could explain it is if you are the second best poker player in the world and all you do is choose the game with the best player in the world, you're you're you're gonna go broke playing poker. Right. And it's a rough thing. Right? Because you can go to a game where, let's say, you're the second best player in the world, but eight people sit at a table. So there's six people that you're better than. And then your whole strategy in game is like, how do I make sure I avoid as many hands as possible with this good player? But the thing is if he's a better player than you, he is intentionally going to try and isolate you to take money from you.

Yes. So, like, you can do your best, but then, like, if you you have to then, like, get beat up on the chin by the better player and just try and get the most out of the other players. Like, this is where the iterative like, the game is always different, always changes. That's one of those things too that, like, the arrangement of a deck of cards, there's more. I think it's actually larger than two to the two fifty six. 52 factorial. Wow. Yeah. Like, the ordering of the cards, I think. I'm gonna actually look that up right now. Size of two, fifty two factorial.

UnknownIt's like the dollar milkshake theory. Is it not? Right? The guy that the best player in the world is always gonna be looking at the second best player in the world to sort of aggregate all the other bad players. Okay. So it's actually two to the two twenty six. So it's just under the size of the universe of the elliptic curves that we play with in Bitcoin. It's act wow. This is you wanna you wanna hear some fun math stuff? 52 factorial is exactly two to the two is 26. It's exactly.

UnknownThat's incredible. That's incredible. Yeah. I mean, you probably could do could do is you could factor out every 52 times 51 times 50. You could probably factor those all out into base two units is probably how you're able to get there. Or and if you have, like, three and, like, nine, like, odd numbers, you just put them together. Like, there's probably a way you can combine all if you took 52 factorial out, you could make all of them base 52 a bit base two. And then for all the odd numbers, you can probably combine all the odd numbers into base two numbers. That's how you got there.

UnknownInteresting. Yeah. I mean, theoretically, we could create a cryptographic system off of a deck of cards. Know people who will do, like, two like, they'll you could, in theory, roll your secret with a deck of cards in theory if you wanted to. In theory. There's 200 there's two to the two twenty six, and that's a lot. I mean, it might not be It's pretty big. You might not want the base. Yeah. You wouldn't want base. This goes back to the debate of a 12 word or 24 word seed phrase where 12 words is 128

bits, and that's technically sufficient enough to have good entropy. Yeah. That's one of those things you could. Maybe I would advise it, but you could.

UnknownSo back to, like, you get this table, right, with the best player and the second best player in the world and then a bunch of people that both the first and second best player know are inferior. Right? And does is this like this is like, the dollar milkshake theory playing out in a certain way. Right? It's there's a gets liquidity, and it all kinda trends in one direction? Like, the second best player is gonna aggregate a is gonna do a lot of the work for the best player. Yeah. Well, this also goes into, you know, what like, how money flows at a poker table independent of skill.

It flows to the left because that's the order of turn action and being able to act second has more information and explicit monetary value. So you could even have a meta third skill, which is if you're picking a game and you're picking like your bankroll management, where you sit at the table in position to the strength of the other players, the best place you could be is to the left of, like, the weakest player in theory. Right? There's obviously more common metrics to figure out, but the fact that you get to act second more often against the worst player, it gives you more opportunity to extract more. But then

is it really worth it if the best player is to your left? Right? And so if anything That's a great point. You wanna have the best player to your right so that you're always with the with with most of the time, you would be acting after that.

UnknownIt's a gigantic, gigantic advantage. And, like, if you're let's just say you're you're like a professional poker player. Right? You're not one of the best in the world, but you're good enough. You you're profitable. You're pretty elite. You have elite skills, and you drive to your local casino. And you know that you're gonna be better than most of the people at the table. Right? But if you have somebody sitting to your left who is a lunatic and you can't understand them and all they do is raise you every time you bet,

you may have a really like, you are no longer gonna view yourself as a highly competent poker player at that moment. This is why there's, like, local optimas.

UnknownRight? Like, I'm the best in this context. You're not able to accentuate your strength as much if you have a lunatic to your left. Now that also comes with the flip side of the coin where you're gonna be able to probably catch them off guard and out of bounds more often to be able to correct that behavior. But it would ruin lucky enough to get your mojo. Yeah. If you get the cards that allow you to do that, but, like, you could say that, like, it kind of ruins your mojo a bit where if you were able to earn 10 big blinds an hour, which is a massive edge. If you have a lunatic to your edge and you can't get into as many pots because you're kind of being, like, bullied all the time, maybe you're only gonna make five units an hour. Yeah. So it's all this is the infinite fractal of,

the game theory and the

Unknownand the strategy of of poker laid forth. Because you're not gonna and, you know, you're you're not gonna make your stand against this person unless you have a premium hand. Right. Really. Right? You're just gonna wait to and but in a live game, it it may never come. Well, then the opportunity comes too is if that really strong play like that player that's really aggressive, he make it someone's gonna eventually call his bluff. And then what you want, you want you you wanna be the guy who does that. Because then if he busts out, then then you lost opportunity value of getting his chips. Someone else got his chips.

UnknownThis is all so, I mean, this is all very much analogous to the macrospace we deal with, right, in Bitcoin. This it really is. Like, who gets the money? Who's out there? Right. You know, we're not predators. Right? But we are sort of predators of monetary energy in a certain way. Right? Because we believe we're playing a game where we believe we have a premium hand. Right. And we are

Unknownwe're certain of this. We're certain that all it takes is time. Well, is Right. Also bankroll management being the most important skill. If you went, you have full faith and conviction Bitcoin's gonna work, but you go all in, but not just all in, you go on leverage at a 119 k, the all time high. It doesn't matter how right you are in the long run if leverage and margin and, like You don't have a lot. Circumstances wipe you out. Okay. Let me ask you this then. Okay? Forget magic Internet math right now because we're now in a we're just this is Brian and Rob shooting the shit now. Yeah.

I don't know if I've ever asked you about so everybody loves to talk about this thing called time preference. Right? Sure. Which is like, okay. The marshmallow test. Can I think long term can I think long term about something? Can I can I prioritize can I prioritize long term concerns over short term concerns? Right? And I've always I've always had this view of, like, anybody can have a low time preference for, like, a minute.

It's having it longer than that. Sure. You know, like like, the second the second something happens and your circumstances change, that low time preference goes out the window. Right? And I've toyed around with this concept of risk preference.

UnknownOkay. Which is risk preference is the is what gives you it's the kite it's the type of life you lead that gives you the ability to maintain a to maintain a low time preference for a time. Right? So, like, a cocaine addled you know, like, Stu Unger would have had a very high risk preference even though he probably had very low time preference, ironically. Right? Like, so, you know, like, a guy that just need like, an action junkie

who understands the game. Right? Right. Low time preference is like you really are you is your skill in the game, but your risk preference is what allows you to stay off tilt to actually think your best and to maintain your grounding in those in in in your skill and in your talent to maintain that. Because low time preference is nothing more than a way to say that's the way to win at this game. Like, if you're in a Bitcoin game, low time preference is the way to win it. That's the strategy to win at that game. It's not a Right.

It's not a a moral or human being human property. It's not a panacea for all circumstances to always be low time preference. It's an optimal strategy for the game that that either you have the ability to maintain and execute for the duration of the time you're in the game or you or for whatever reason, life is not set up such that you can do that. Right. And so I was trying I've been trying for, like, four years to come up with this thing called risk preference,

which is like, if you look at a two by two graph, time preference and risk preference, that there'd be a quadrant that's like, oh, dude. That is the ideal person that would benefit from Bitcoin. Right? It would be somebody that in a in a certain quadrant,

Unknownright, where they have And that would be low time preference, high risk preference? I haven't I haven't sorted out what the best psychological by the way, I hate the fact that low I hate that it's low time preference. That is the good one. Right. Well, let's think about it. It's Like, for time preference intersecting with Bitcoin, there's probably a lot of people that are just inherently long term thinkers. Right? They they are not endorphin chasing. They are strategic. They make sacrifices. And There's been a selection for those people. There's a selection. And but you need a certain level of risk preference to say, I'm gonna put a significant part of my wealth into Bitcoin because it's un it's untested. Right? Like and this is where some would, I would say, advocating through education enablement

to set the right framing up to be able to jump in and be like, oh, you perceive this as high risk, but it's actually not high risk. And you have to kind of, like, zig when the rest of the market zags and say, no. No. No. This is actually there's unpriced upside here. And while someone someone who likes to do long term saving and not be endorphin chasing, not a gambler by any means, you have to take that leap. And some people would describe it as a leap of faith, others as a conviction one of having faith in a in a thesis. Right? So you have to kinda be contrarian to the rest of the market,

and that is inherently more risky than just than just holding treasury bills. Right? I think that's a as a very brief tangent, why digital credit as this meme has taken off where people just wanna get fixed income instruments because they just wanna know that's actually a perfect in this grid, that's a perfect way to put this in here is like, you know what? I just want the fixed income instrument. I don't wanna own the raw equity of the asset that will appreciate over time. I just I have cash flow needs. I have my own risk, my treasury management portfolio as a person or a company where I wanna be able to just tap into that. It's you're right. It's it optimizes

Unknownfor, people with, like, sort of a low time preference, but not quite the risk preference to be able to deal with Bitcoin. It's way higher risk preference to deal with the fixed income instruments than it is just to Right. Put on Bitcoin. So the way I was thinking I think about it is like, okay. Living below your means is one of these qualities. Right? Not being being, not having unsecured debt, living below your means Sure. Being really

being really good at something that you know, sure having having marketable skill that you know, being a good having a strong wine business. Right, or something like that. Something that gives you structure and foundation.

UnknownOne sec. I'll be right back. Yeah. You said strong wine business, so I got my peony my Peony Lane wine hat right here. Got a strong wine business. You get a hat? There you go. I'm gonna freak you out. Oh, man. It was right after you were here too. So next time you're here, next time of your club. Oh, no. Oh, no. Ben's blown up on his spot. No. I I ordered, like, a big case of wine. I ordered, like, 12 bottles.

Yeah. I do Basically, every two years Shoot that record. That.

UnknownOkay. We're actually doing a then. Oh, I'm gonna talk to Ben. I you for sure. Oh, no. Ben was on our Ben was on the podcast. Ben no. No. It's all good. Ben was on the podcast couple months ago and Yeah. Just we, you know, just clicked. Just clicked right away. Yeah. So I think about it's a great example because he's a guy that otherwise you know, he's not a banker. Doesn't come from trading or TradFi or anything like that. But he's in a strong position because

he has a low time preference, but also has a

Unknownskill. He has a skill. He has a business. Absolutely. Right. So, like, I feel like he's gonna be around longer than you know, he's and it's like as a poker player. Right? And you wanna as a poker player, he's sitting around the table trying to figure out who's gonna be around in ten years. Right. Right? This is the kind of stuff that we do. Right? We sit around the table figuring out who's gonna be there. And, you know, like, I like, the digital credit stuff is just for a different kind of person.

Right? I say it's for second class citizens. And, you know, maybe that's the the loop in for magic Internet math is just that we're trying to build people into not being second class citizens. Mhmm. Right? But, like, the fact is the world is loaded with second class citizens who can't who either can't get it together enough to buy Bitcoin or Yeah. Figure out how to hold it because they're they're circuit you know, their wives like to go to Target too much. You know? They can't just fit sort it. They can't figure it out. Like, that's a good solution.

Like, you can't they they can't buy Target gift cards with strike STRC dividends.

UnknownWell, this is right. Well, this is an interesting thing too. Right? I think, like, this goes back to risk management too and bankroll management where, like, I don't hold any SADA STRC. I don't. I think the way I would view it is that you would put it in for short term cash needs. And for, like like, if you wanted to have basically, like, maybe your three to six month, like, cash that like, you wanna have that, like, your emergency fund, you could put half of that into one of these things to just get a little bit from it or something. May maybe not your emergency fund should be actually closer to just pure cash or just treasury, like, something very liquid and very stable. But if you wanted to have a a second tranche of, like,

six to twelve months, and you could put this in there because if it goes down a little bit, whatever, it's fine. All this to say is you don't put anything into it that you're not willing to lose, which you obviously do for any investment, but I just have more faith and conviction in just the protocol of Bitcoin than I do these derivative instruments. And For sure. I I try not to get too wrapped around the axle around telling people how they should put their money. I think everyone's an adult, and everyone's allowed to make their own decision. I'm not big on telling people where they should put their money, but I know that's been a hot button issue of the prominence of these tools versus Bitcoin itself.

And I view it as this is just this is hyper Bitcoinization, baby. Like, people are gonna come in. They're gonna do things with it. It's gonna integrate in the financial system. There inevitably will be blow ups as there have been in with Mt. Gox and FTX. I am not saying these tools are of that kind, but people saying, like, oh, this is gonna end badly. It's like, yeah. Maybe. Totally. Don't think so. Not now. I just think It's possible. I just think it's, like, it it Sure. I think it's more probabilistic that these tools have an unwind than Bitcoin were to go to zero. That's my point. Right? So on a risk calculation basis, they're just different. So I was gonna say, like, yeah. Rob Hamilton should not be in,

UnknownSTRC, but I probably can make a strong case for why AnchorWatch might be in and out They're a little bit in there? In and out of these things just for short term liability, just the way you know, I I I could could make a strong case for an institution to use it as a money market. I would like, I could make you could make a case for three months of cash or something. I don't wanna put a year of runway into that because if that gets haircut 40%, then I just lost, you know, I just lost three months of operational business flow. That that's me personally. Right? But And that's right. And that's where risk this is but this is so, like, we're playing is a risk selection. Yeah. We're having risk preference conversation here. Right? And so it's like

like, I think that we can so funny. Now this is now we're doing a Bitcoin for institutions podcast. Yeah. But, like, the reality is if you have a short term liability, right, you an insurance company, you you're gonna know that you have some payouts in the next three months. Right? It may not you know, there's a, I think, a strong case to be made for, you you know, basically utilizing a yield vehicle of the ilk of STRC

to, you know, to manage pay known payments that are in that time frame.

UnknownYeah. I think that's reasonable. And you have and if you have the balance sheet, if, like, you're an insurance company, you have the balance sheet where if this were to get impaired or you're underwater on your obligations versus the cash you're holding because, hypothetically, one of these notes instead of being near par is at, like, 80¢ on the dollar or 60¢ on the dollar, whatever it is. Like, you have additional funds to charge that up. Right? And that's why on a risk adjusted basis with treasury management, which is just bankroll management. This is actually a really funny, like Yeah. Full circle conversation on poker and and businesses.

Your your treasury management, your bankroll management, like, you can get away with it, and that's fine. Right? Like, it's the the thing is what? At at, like, 11%, you need to have it stay at par for ten years to get your principal back. Like, in theory, like, that's what you're looking for. Yes. Now these tools have been around for about a year. So, like, we'll see. Also, like, there's a world just as a as a huge shout out, actually, I'm not sure most people know this. If you use River and you keep cash at River,

they'll give you 3.3 percent Bitcoin accounted daily, paid out monthly. So you can just park your cap. Like, I I think there's a a stronger case from a and the stronger case being for my risk appetite. Right? I'm not saying that this is the you have to allocate your money. But if you wanna put, you know, if you're a business and you have cash throwing it's FDIC insured. So you can I'm not gonna say risk free entirely. Right? Because there's always risk, but at rate greatly de minimis reduced risk, you could put up to the FDIC limit in River and

get a monthly payout stream in Bitcoin. And if you do the math, just we're gonna sit right here for a second. The FDIC limit is $250,000. You can divide that the three point three three point three three percent divided by 12. You can get $700 a month in Bitcoin just in your bank account. And I'm not saying it's, like, perfect, but if you are holding cash somewhere and you're getting 0% interest in a checking account, the marginal effort just to move it over to River, be an FDIC insured account, and get paid out in Bitcoin,

like, that's a that's instantly I there actually is not a strong case as to why you would keep your money at a 0% checking account at this point for up to the FDIC limit. You should just have it in a River. There there is no there is no better reason why to justify that for sure.

UnknownCompletely agree. Future sponsor river. That's great. But, yeah, I mean, completely agree there. And the biggest risk is that just keeping it in your in cash. The biggest risk is keeping it in cash earning three and a half percent and not Bitcoin there. But, again, if you're already sort of like now, again, you're talking like a first class citizen, somebody with options. Right? Somebody with the ability to hold their money at River also has the ability to buy Bitcoin. And these are not the people these are definitely not the people that

are that should be looking at second class type of vehicles. Right? Right. So like and and Anchor Watch is far from a second class citizen. I just say there's definitely a case for, you know, you're an intelligent investor at this point now too. Right? Yeah.

UnknownI guess. Yeah. But I think a lot of people don't maximise cash sitting in a bank account somewhere. Right. So I just read that like and I think also the three the 3.3%. Here's the fun thing. If interest rates rise, if they do, the yield that they're going to pay out is also going to have to rise in the bank accounts because the banks can be making more money because the lending rates are gonna be higher. It it also changes the math of, like, it's not 0% or 11%. I think the actual hurdle rate interest right now is what you can get in a bank account. In River if you wanted to. You could also just tick the button and get US dollars instead of Bitcoin, but

the delta is actually that 7%. It's not zeroed cents on the dollar. It's not it's not 0% or 11%. It's actually 3.3% to, that. And if you go above the FDIC limit, we are basically underwriting one. You you are technically under underwriting the execution risk of river and the security of all that. Like, that's totally there. But it act they use they use a bank. So you're just making sure that bank stays solvent. Right? And so, like, if the the and this is there's many levels and and depths and things you can go into around that for bankroll management and risk. But Well, they're all yeah. And what but what

Unknownwhat you're pointing to is there are multiple assets called that you might call a risk free asset or a risk minimized asset. That's in bankroll management, you have to peg you have to find your peg. Right. Now we're in a just a time in the world where we've just obliterated the world's notion of what a risk free asset is because it had been the treasury. It had been the US treasury for all this time, and that's now not it's now not the case. Right. Right? No one thinks it's the case.

Right? No. And it's up for grabs, really. And so, you know, I don't think MicroStrategy is making a case in any way, but they but they're the people that are buying this seem to be trying to make that case, and I would disagree.

UnknownRight. I've made the case personally that that I think BlackRock thinks, like, Bitcoin is that now. Is Bitcoin is the replacement for bonds at least as a, you know, risk minimized asset in a modern portfolio theory context. Agreed. Yeah. But yeah. So it's like it as a bank role manager, you have to you have to make that decision for yourself within your own sense of risk.

Right?

UnknownYeah. It's all it's all comes back to risk. And I think I think a a requisite requirement to be class one sovereign citizen, whatever the hierarchy tier you wanna do, you have to be aware of this stuff. This is actually a toolkit of knowledge for if you want to be in your control of your own destiny. You have to have risk management. And as part of risk management, bankroll management or treasury management, whether you're a home or a business, those things are necessarily required to be able to do that for sure. This is, like, foundational substrate stuff that is needed to get to that tier. Yeah. Oh, here's a fun fact.

UnknownI know I know you know this, but it's a fun fact that a lot of people probably maybe don't know or don't remember. If you didn't watch every episode of the World Series of Poker from 2002 to 2006, if you didn't watch every episode, you may not know this, But that the main event winner up until, I think, up until 2000 up until o two pre moneymaker, I'm pretty sure every main event winner was offered to be paid out in silver. Interesting. And that the guy Joe the Binion.

Binion was always in so Binion's his the it was the dad that started the World Series of Poker, but his son took it over. And, apparently, they had a bunch of silver buried in the desert.

UnknownDid you know this? I did not know this at all. Yeah. It's wild that they he's got a bunch of bunch of silver like Azimandia's, breaking bad. You know? Like, he's got coordinates where GPS coordinates where he's got all the silver buried in in the in the Nevada Deserts. Yeah. And they were paying out all of the World Series winners in silver. Very cool. I was never aware of that. Worth looking into. It's just yet another little thread that

makes it relevant in, you know, peep it's it's it's a reason why, like, again, I would say, you know, Stu Unger would have wished to be paid probably in cocaine, but and not not in silver. And, you know but, like, the reality is we you could be a degenerate and still have, like, a low time preference and have a strong ability to execute risk. You have strong, strong ability.

UnknownRight? It's also like you have a certain strength in being able to play this game because you know how to walk up to the line of risk, but sometimes that bleeds over to going down the other side. And if you step too far on that other side of poor risk management, you get totally blown out, and it's all for not. Yeah. A lot of the ways that Bitcoiners get exploited for their stacks is because they they're they're put in situate they're put in, like, rhetorical situations where they they they don't wanna take any risk. Like, the the price risk of Bitcoin is enough for them, and then they can't, like, another

they can't take another ounce of risk other than that. Right. And that's like where, like, the the quantum thing that makes it really obvious. You know, well, what kind of a stupid person would be in Bitcoin and expose themselves to a quantum computer? Right? What kind of a person would be in Bitcoin and expose themselves to CSAM? Right? And it's like all of these little things, they're at the margins. But

because I think a lot of people in Bitcoin are at the absolute edge of their ability to handle even the risk of the price. Oh, interesting.

UnknownThat they're willing to underwrite price risk, but any incremental risk changes their equation of being able to be exposed like, have Bitcoin on their balance sheet. Because they're not because they're not they don't really know how to do the work to get comfortable with the price rick risk. It was all done through culture in the last ten years, and that's starting to fall apart. Because, I mean, quantum like, all of these risks are price risk. The price goes down because a quantum computer comes out. Like like, that that is all price risk. So, like, did they really underwrite the price risk, or did they

get a bunch of secondhand knowledge prepackaged them with a nice easy to digest narrative? And they were okay with that risk because they say, well, historically, it's gone down and it goes back up, but, like, not really clicking into the deeper economic implications of it all. Yeah.

UnknownWell, I think it's very reasonable for somebody to say to themselves, I can eliminate, you know, I can eliminate the risk of, like, ownership, and I can eliminate, like, the risk of theft and all the counterparty issues. And all I have to do is accept this price risk, except that I don't and that's really reasonable, but then the first that that person largely doesn't have the physical and emotional makeup to actually really do it and doesn't

become know how that person. Right. Right? So we've used the culture has developed to try to do to try to make be a substitute for actual for actual skill, actual ability to handle the swings. Like, tell you, poker players can handle the swings. Yeah. The volatility. But the price for them is degeneracy. Right?

UnknownLike, you can go to sleep at night having lost half $1,000,000 and not think about, like, what you would have done with them. I think poker players, it's it could come off as degenerate, but I think they just have full faith and conviction in their own ability to be a positive expected value winning player. And they are understanding that to be a winning player, you have to have losing sessions. Like, you necessarily have to. The best poker player in the world will lose hands. Naturally. Yes. Will go through bad streaks because they are riding this volatility wave. And it's rather than faith

external, like, protocol like Bitcoin, they have faith in their own internal ability to navigate that volatility and to ultimately come out as a winning player in the long run. But it's also one of those lies that poker players will tell themselves that I'm a winning player in the long run, and they just kind of sigh up themselves into that. And then the market just beats them up until they lose. And they know that, like, wait. I need a reality check. And the better players are able to be like, you know what? I need to step down a tier in the games. I need to go figure it out and work my way back up.

UnknownYeah. So I think there's a cultural way in poker that they get good with the swings, which is that they all tell each other they don't care about, you know, losing a $100,000 or $200,000 in a night. They you know, this is, again, at the top levels, but nonetheless, everyone has their own version of that. With Bitcoiners, there's you know, there needs to be a bit a better skill build for dealing with the swings

because it is a self I think it's a very self evident choice to say, I don't want my money to be stolen or debased. And the price of that is I have to be okay with the swings. And you can make like, I can see a lot of people jumping off that bridge right away, but then realizing that they're not cut out to deal with those swings. And that that's real so to me, that that's the work. The the work I wanna be doing, the work I wanna be doing with this, you know, is building people's ability to genuinely

to genuinely be okay. And I get you know, this is I think the first solution to this is don't spend your Bitcoin, and I get that. Right? And that's like Mhmm. That's that's very rational. Right?

UnknownYes. I think this goes back to bankroll management, though, where, like, just to make the math easy, like, the conviction play is often said that, like, if you don't sell your Bitcoin, it means that you're not in Bitcoin enough. Right? But, like, the fact that you have other assets and you have dollars laying around means that you're not fully con have high enough conviction in Bitcoin. And from a pure economically rational You're playing for Cheetos. You're playing for Cheetos still. Yeah. Right. At the same time, if you took a person and their options were allocate 10% into Bitcoin or allocate a 100% into Bitcoin,

but if they're a 100% allocated to Bitcoin and the price starts moving against them, they're going to sell out and have zero Bitcoin. It's better they just have the 10% and don't touch it. Right. From like, sure, they're not 100% all in. Like, they're they're not on zero. Right? And I think there's an internal conversation with among Bitcoiners who all are aligned and get the big vision. They say, well, obviously, the number is 100%. It can't be any other number. But from the incremental and I have a buddy of mine who I don't say that. Term. I don't I don't think that. No. No. It's a no. No. It's not you. It's it's a common thing in discourse. My my buddy had this term he came up with called slow pilling.

And what you actually wanna be doing is not, like, getting right to one of the fire hose and going a 100% in immediately because if they're it's almost like a quick flame that burns out quickly. You're better off seeding the ground and being like, you're gonna hold this 10% allocation for ten years, and then you can revisit it, is actually on the margin better because, one, it reduces volatility of the price if everyone's doing that because they're just locked in holding versus if they're constantly at, you know, the emotional tax too. Right? There's also a question of, like, what does it cost you psychologically and emotionally to be seeing your entire net worth in Bitcoin volatility

wiping around? And that is not something most people have. Most people do not have the stomach of fortitude, and that's not a moral judgment or a bad thing, to be clear. It's just Not at all. Right. Like, they're just not equipped for that. And that's why it's better just to have an allocation, and that allocation, you just set and forget, and you go live the rest of your life as a productive member of society, and you just don't sell that. Like, that's a different trade between someone who's hyper all in on Bitcoin who wants to, who realizes that since Bitcoin is the rational economic play, they're gonna be a 100% allocated. But then if you don't have that full level of conviction, you're just gonna wash yourself out in the volatility and sell.

UnknownSo the interesting answer is the one I'll tell you. This is the one I would like to publish a book on thinking through, but I'd say the interesting answer is there is an allocation that allows you to minimize your time preference. It's not a 100% and it's not zero. Right? But there's some allocation that is the best that you can do to in terms of maintaining a low time preference. And maybe it's 30%. Okay. Let's just say. Right? Whereas anything beyond that, you're gonna you're gonna start to

lose your patience with the swings. Right? So, like, there's a certain amount that you're built to that you're built for that can minimize your time preference. Maybe it's for your typical normie, maybe it's 2%. Right? And then you learn to live below your means and you work your way up to 5%, 10%. But it's the thing where if you do any more, your time preference will raise again, and you're gonna start to make tilted not the best decisions, right? So like, whatever that is, and then you I like slow pilling because it's basically like, then you spend the rest of your life

trying to raise that allocation because the other thing is the longer this is something I recently discovered. Right? I'm sure you know this. But the longer you're in I think I heard Adam Back say this, that the longer you're in Bitcoin, the close that you just naturally get to a 100%. It's just like you get there very fast. You you you get there two ways. One, you get there because of your faith and understanding increases, so you go to a 100%. But, also, Bitcoin just sits there and does its thing, and all of a sudden, your 10% becomes 20%, 30%. Because you're spending your Fiat, and you're holding your Bitcoin. And event Yeah. Over time eventually, you get pretty to close to a 100%. So you you have to outrun that's a difficulty adjustment on your time preference. Right. And you have to so you have to, like, kinda do the work even if you're 10% or whatever it is. You gotta do the work to outrun the fact that your allocation's gonna grow naturally

probably beyond your ability to hold it. And, you know, and this is, again, this is the big poker game of Bitcoin. And you see this in poker where people can't you know, people don't go into poker already being able to handle the swings. They learn to handle the swings by doing it and realizing they didn't die. Right. But it's like, get watch the opening scene of rounders and understand what a gut punch it is when you blow your bankroll. Right?

UnknownYeah. This just goes back to risk of ruin. Yes. Risk of ruin. I I I think I've mentioned to you. Think I've even mentioned on this podcast. I have the domainriskofruin.com because You did. Longtime gambler, was very familiar with the concept of blowing out your bankroll. And I I started intersecting and thinking about it with risk of ruin as it came related to Bitcoin custody and realizing that all of these ETFs strategy, all these treasury companies, the actual risk of ruin is is is the custodian. You could be 1000%

right on all of these pieces, and the idea with any watch multi Also, right, also with you at holding your own keys. Bingo. Risk of yes. You have a risk of ruin. And so the premise with Anchor Watch was if we could underwrite this with high quality insurance, like Lloyd's of London insurance, And we upgraded the custody infrastructure to greatly mitigate the cost of a risk ruin. And even if a risk of ruin event were to happen, that there would be an insurance policy underwriting it, that you can actually pass off that risk. And now, like,

it's funny because I think about this with, like, the digital credit instruments. I think about this with, many things. I'm gonna round up and just say it's 1% interest. It's less than 1%, but just call it 1% interest. Would you be willing to do STRC that paid 10% instead of 11% that that Bitcoin was actually insured?

UnknownAre you kidding me? Right. So, like so, like, you understand quickly, oh, like, it's this funniest thing where, like, at a moment's notice, people will happily pay half a point to execute a buyer or sell in Bitcoin. But they're like, oh, can I insure this asset for the year? And then, like, people get maybe a little more price squeamish that, like, if you're wrapping these, like, digital credit instruments and all this stuff, if you could, like, think about that. The the risk is actually, I would say, higher than 1% because well, the risk may be on paper

Here here's the thing. The risk of a massive, like, Coinbase custody blowout is absolutely way higher than 1%. I think it's way higher. I think I think it's less than 1% on a year to year basis. Right? Because it's not in perpetuity. Yes. Right? It's a one year insurance policy. So it's less than one percent. But would that not materially increase the strength of the credit instrument by way more than 1% on the demand allocation that would inflow into the instrument if it was insured so that if the custodian gets hacked, you're not even on the hook.

Like, I think that's, like, the really meaningful thing.

UnknownYeah. I think that also there's a lot of scenarios where the there's a loss of keys at the custodian. We never find out. Maybe. Where we don't find out you'll find out. Very long time. Right. You don't find out for a very long time. Yeah. Because they like, Coinbase can Ponzi like, they have so much Ponzi buffer. They can Ponzi everyone's shitcoins. No one will care. So they have omnibus wallets. The big institutional clients do have gated, like, here is your address on chain. So But this goes back to our our work and saying, is anybody verified

Unknownthat their Bitcoin is real? Right. Right? You have to go to the Bitcoin store. Go to the Bitcoin store and say, show me the public key. And Right? I wanted to speak to the manager. That's right. You know? You can't speak to the manager at Coinbase, but the you know, it's like a double edged sword because they can Ponzi off the shitcoin balances. They can they they have a they have a long runway. They have their own layer two and everything. Long runway. And that as a quick shout out as a con like, a counter example here would be River with their proof of reserves. And people used to owe it like, here's the thing. Proof of reserves, people say, like, you can't you can't and now block, but you can't prove the liabilities. And I understand from the accounting principle what they're getting at. It's also just a very simple grug brain thing of can you at least show me that you have the the asset side of the balance sheet? So to say that you can't get perfect,

you know, big four accounting firm level attestation proof of it, the beauty of Bitcoin is you don't need a you don't need a team of CPAs to show you that the asset exists. So just from a strict grug brain perspective, just showing the proof of reserves, do the omnibus wallet with the the tree of liabilities as it relates to customers' claims on said Bitcoin. And it's not literally perfect, but I do think it's somewhat of a punt when people push around the poofer. Like, you should just you should literally just have the proof of reserve attestation. Like, there really isn't a reason not to. So one of the panels I moderated in Ireland was,

Unknownwe had a bunch of Bitcoin treasury companies, and I asked about I basically decided to ask about custody because it's my pet issue. Right? And I knew it's controversial, and so there was a fight. It was really cool. I was the first panel I was ever on where it was everyone was fighting. It was pretty cool. Love it. Love it. But the the first guy, I won't say who it was. I mean, you can go watch it, but, like, he was basically he basically is like proof of reserves and meaningless. And the point the real the point is that it's not that meaningful unless you refuse

to provide it. And then it that's when it becomes meaningful. Bingo. Bingo. Right. Bingo.

UnknownThat that that is 10000% exactly it in that, oh, yeah. It's not that big of a deal, but the fact you won't show it is a big deal. Like Yeah. And and so, you know, and to be clear to the listeners, all proof of reserves is is like a solvency. It's a solvency test that you are kinda trusting unless you, at some level, you kinda have to trust it. But at least what you're seeing is some indication that the exchange is willing to provide it and to be held accountable for it, which is it's more of if they don't do it, then that's when, yeah, you gotta

that's when things get hairy. You're on mute.

UnknownThat was weird. I didn't mute. There you go. It may have been a shortcut key or something. Here's the thing. Proof of reserves is not a panacea. It doesn't perfectly prove anything. Asset side, though, is trivial to do. And the inability here's the thing. Coinbase can do it. You know why? They did it for Bitwise, the Bitwise ETF, which means that Coinbase has the infrastructure to do this, which means if you hold coins at Coinbase, you are explicitly choosing to not use that feature. And anyone who's holding a reasonable amount of Bitcoin with the amount of money they're making on custodying the Bitcoin for you, You can call up your account manager, get the product team, and do it for you for sure. It is an explicit choice

Unknownon you. Wait. What what did they do for Bitwise? They did proof of reserves. Just for them? Yeah. Is this because Bitwise was, Virtu signaled their address when they first started the ETF, and then they got made fun of because I would say Bitwise, like, I I've met the team over at Bitwise. Think they're they are just thinking about this responsibly, and they have constant dialogues with people in the community on the best ways of managing these products. I agree. And I know those guys too. Yeah. Like and they just wanna do the right thing. Right? And they have enough Bitcoin to throw some weight around at a Coinbase to have them show that it works. And

the thing is is that it's so trivial. It doesn't really expose any security issue. And ultimately, like, while it doesn't solve everything, it is very little effort and cost if your business is holding Bitcoin to do that work. And there really isn't like, the the whole, like, it's an operational security concern. It's kinda bullcrap because all of the chain analysis companies triangulate

if Sailor buys 20,000 Bitcoin and then a 20,000 Bitcoin UTXO moves on chain. They like, it's public ledger, guys. Like, we're like, this like, I think I think Arkham, like, the chain analysis, like, Intel like, on chain intelligence company, whatever, has, like, 97% of, like, the strategy Bitcoin, like, identified. So, like, it's already there. It's already there, guys. Like What's the name for the Satoshi pool? What is it? What's the name of it? Potoshi?

UnknownOh, Poto yeah. Yeah. It's like they already pattern. Yeah. You could see the in the in the that's actually a fun little tangent maybe for another day because I know we've been running for a bit here. But, there was a pattern in the nonce that was being generated by one miner since the start of the network, and you could reasonably infer that it was a quirk in how Satoshi's mining out, like, stuff worked. And that basically provided a fingerprint to link the coins that were specifically linked to Satoshi. It's pretty wild. Yeah. Yeah. Absolutely. Stay safe out there. Yeah. For sure.

Alright. I guess we can call it here. We can call it here. Yeah. Well,

Unknownthis has been a good little just, like, shaking off the dust a little bit, making sure we're just putting the time in, getting the podcast done. We could probably I think next time we're actually gonna be able to clean up the elliptic curve study guide. Like, I think we're basically I think so. I think I think you and I also for our own enjoyment of this, we have we have eaten a big plate of vegetables and we're just kinda getting to the end of like I'm actually looking at chapter eight of study guide right now. It just lays out the six parameters, which we have already done in detail at each step. This is it's like a summary chapter. And then step nine is key generation,

which, like, what what I'm getting at We're getting to the applied math. We're getting we're getting into the applied math. One, it's applied math. One, it's applied math. And two, we have we have covered everything related to elliptic curves in the core study guide and the core principles at this point. And now it's just applied math between the signatures, the application of the curve, snore, where if you want to, we're gonna just discuss business live on air. If you wanna go into the next one, let's just talk hash functions, a little bit of a pallet cleanser, and then we can that's your call. We could figure it out later. But like, we've done all of the work and we've explained like how signatures work already.

We've explained all these things. We haven't done music yet, but music can probably just do its own thing with, like, a Taproot section. Like, if you want to like, let's just jump into hash functions next time. And then I think you and I will have more refined vigor to tackle a brand new thing rather than what we've been doing now for three months. Yes. But we need to do this ourselves. We need to an entertain for it. Yeah. We need to do this one to, like, a little bit of a decompression. Just wanted get back in the routine of it all. We just had Alan on as our first guest. Now we're doing our own kind of like first

non study guide math episode, non guest episode, and then we can kind of jump in and be excited. Because if you and I aren't having fun doing this thing, it's not gonna persist. So it's more important for longevity that we're that we take little detours like this to have fun and enjoy the conversation.

UnknownI just wanted to feature your white and blue anchor watch hat. Yes. Yes. And, you know, it's all worth it. Yes. Alright, man. All worth it, man. Good stuff. We will will meet again soon. Sounds good.

Open the transcript file

Hosts and Guests

Nobody is credited on this episode yet.

Credit the people on this episode

Be the first to rate this episode

More episodes

All episodes
  1. Exponential Got Less Exponential

    Nov 2, 20261 hr 10 minAudio

    In this episode, we picked back up on our red-team tour of Bitcoin cryptography and tried to make sense of the last few weeks of fast-moving math news. We unpacked why the recent excitement around the exponential time...

    Credit the people on this episode

  2. Red Teaming Elliptic Curve Cryptography

    Oct 11, 20261 hr 27 minAudio

    OpenAI just dropped roughly 300 math papers with Lean proofs, mathematicians are crashing out, and the vague-posting has started: "math is breaking, so cryptography is next." Brian and Rob Hamilton refuse to hand-wave....

    Credit the people on this episode

  3. Hash Functions, Linear Algebra, and Alice in Wonderland

    Sep 28, 202650 minAudio

    Magic Internet Math: https://www.magicinternetmath.com/ Shout out to https://x.com/uncleJim21 for the Alice in Wonderland story and the following rebuke of Lewis Carroll: https://www.youtube.com/shorts/33FYXpEWgyA This...

    Credit the people on this episode

  4. Kayfabe Math is Now Mainstream

    Sep 13, 20261 hr 17 minAudio

    We’re back because math keeps refusing to stay in the classroom. In this episode, I unpack two very different kinds of “math pop culture.” First, we revisit entropy, seed generation, and wallet security through a...

    Credit the people on this episode

  5. Legalize MATH

    Sep 2, 20262 hr 2 minAudio

    Magic Internet Math is back. After the summer that set the Bitcoin world on fire - the Cold Card entropy disaster - Brian and Rob Hamilton (AnchorWatch) reunite for a two-hour deep dive on the event Rob spent three...

    Credit the people on this episode