Skip to content
PodSubs
ShowsPeopleGuestsJobsNewsEvents
More
BlogPodCred
Menu
ShowsPeopleGuestsJobsNewsEventsBlogPodCredNetworksSign in
Join nowSign in
  • Shows
  • People
  • Jobs
  • News
  • More
    • Guests
    • Events
    • Blog
    • PodCred
    • Networks
    Join nowSign in

Magic Internet Math

Magic Internet Math artwork

Pascal's Wager, Blackjack, and Homeschooling

Feb 2, 20261 hr 9 minAudio
ShareXLinkedInFacebookWhatsAppEmail

This is the second episode of the Internet Math podcast, where the hosts discuss their views on math, its connection to spirituality, and the importance of individual knowledge creation. Key Topics: Ice storm in Nashville The role of mathematics in spirituality and understanding the universe. Pascal's Wager and its relevance to decision-making, particularly in the context of Bitcoin. The importance of individual knowledge creation and critical thinking, especially in the face of technological advancements like AI. Critiques of the education system and the need for more meaningful engagement with mathematics. Card counting as an example of applying mathematical principles to real-world scenarios. Hal Finney and the selection of the LibSec P256K1 curve for Bitcoin. Out-of-sample bias and the challenges of making predictions, particularly in the context of Bitcoin's price cycles. Summary: The hosts begin by discussing the recent ice storm in Nashville and how it disrupted their schedule. This leads to a broader discussion about the importance of understanding patterns and avoiding faulty thinking, which sets the stage for the episode's focus on math and its significance. The hosts then transition to the main topic, emphasizing the idea of learning math for its own sake rather than as a means to an end. They express their belief that studying math can be a pathway to understanding the divine, describing it as a form of prayer and a way to explore the universe's logic. They reference historical figures like Pascal, who combined mathematical pursuits with religious beliefs, illustrating the natural connection between the two.

Audio and video play straight from the show's own hosting. PodSubs stores and serves no media.

Transcript

From the show. Tap a time to play from there.

internet math welcome we're back again part two electric boogaloo we are back we thought the weather might actually not allow you know this might throw us off of course i'm glad to be back yeah it's good to be here it's actually flurrying here right now in nashville but nowhere near bad as last week i've never seen an ice storm before in person where it is the water is of the right temperature that the moment it makes contact with anything it freezes into ice yeah and uh

walking around the days after you would see like blades of grass like encased and mummified in like a nice like thick sheath of ice and it was like like a like very prickly it was very and all the trees all the branches just like frozen in ice it's like someone just like poured a bunch of water on it and then immediately like dropped rod dropped it to zero degrees it was pretty wild like dr freeze or something yeah yeah because like a soul power it was very wild

yeah and no one knows how to plow in nashville there's no they don't salt i was talking to someone and they were um they they followed one of the big like salt trucks in the plows into like a 7-eleven and they're like i just want to let you know you're not dropping the salt like like you have this big thing but like i followed you for the past couple miles and the guy was like yeah you know it's just really tedious like i really like having that big heavy load on the back while i'm plowing so i don't drop the the salt because it's safer for me to drive then

and when it's like yeah your job is to drop the salt so it's safer for everyone else so they don't salt here they never plowed any of my local roads right here um so i was kind of frozen then but All's well, ends well. We're on the other side. They vibe-salted down there. That's right. That's right. It just didn't quite work out. Well, I mean, I'm really glad nobody I know down there got in any trouble. I'm sure some people did, but it feels like... Some people still don't have power.

Yeah. It feels like our little community down there is good. Pretty good. Yeah. Awesome. Awesome. So it's been a while. I think it's been three weeks. Three weeks. We expected to do two weeks. And it's like that last week, it's almost like a long week. It's because so much happens. And there's so much that happens that makes me think about what we're going to do here. Like all the time. And when we have a major event like we're having now, we typically, I doubt we would ever talk about current events.

you know other than other than if it really matters like it's mathy which they tend to be but quantum computers but you know in terms of like price dumps and more you know market turmoil i don't think anyone will ever index episode two as oh that was the one that happened when you know during one of those big events yeah that happened to be this last week while between weeks two and And so it just brings up, you like, you know, when you start seeing the patterns of people's sort of faulty thinking about events like that, it starts, it really does start to make me think, think, sorry, I'm having, I'm like burping, sorry.

It makes me think a lot about, makes me think a lot about math. And I don't know if you saw the thing I sent you this morning. you probably didn't but it's just people send me these things all the time they're like here's something that you might think is cool, a math thing and I always have the wrong reactions to them so I want to you know I feel like what we'll do today is mostly a continuation of the first episode which is like we're still

fleshing out how really we view things and you know you and I are not the same But we connect enough that I feel like I can say things like that. And like I think the real premise here, the last episode we focused a lot on the liberal arts framing. I mean I don't know. It's not as important as I think I make it sound. It's just that when you're fighting the tide, you end up emphasizing certain things that make it sound like it's more important to you than they are.

Because you feel like you have to emphasize them. so I feel like emphasizing the liberal arts focus one is like it's a catchy way of it's a little bit different and it's like a way of you know expressing my contrarian take without causing pain to anybody necessarily more confusion right but like that's sort of a good lane for an educator is to not to confuse intentionally but I'd rather have confusion than pain so yeah because confusion just is your development of the sense making process in general and things

that were once confusing aren't anymore and that's how you kind of also compound and learn new concepts you take all of these things that uh you don't want to jump right to the end you want to have a sequential sense of progression demystifying which is good for your psychological like loop of getting feedback and seeing progress and you want to be able to you know build on that and that's you know, if you're not getting confused on a regular basis, it means you're not growing. Well, yeah, you're not, it's exactly right. And so that's a big, let's like, that's a big, like,

pillar. The thing you just said, it's like a big pillar of what we're doing here, right? You want to put yourself in a state of confusion, you know, or like a controlled state of pain for learning and for a particular reason. So, you know, so what I tend to like to want to really emphasize is learning math for the sake of it as opposed to, you know, learning it as a means to an end. And there's nothing wrong with means to ends, but it's like the world's got that covered, right?

So it's like the world's got that one covered and not so much learning it for its own sake. Like that's a rare minority, I feel like, of people who value that. Totally. Right? And you prove it by actually, quote unquote, wasting your time. You know, wasting your time on wild goose chase rabbit holes, not knowing why you're doing it. And so the one thing I'll say, so here's where I wanted to go today. This might surprise you, but I feel like this is going to be good.

So today is Sunday. And, you know, it is morning. And most people probably would find themselves in church or a place of worship. And, you know, what I want to, I think, I'm going to say it, I believe studying math is like a pathway to God. and I almost think God wants us to do it because it's like the way.

It's like the language of exploring God, right? So when you sit and study, I don't know about you, dude, but when I sit and study, I am like literally praying to God. I'm like, please help me understand this. Like I have no, like I'm at the edge of my ability to understand something and it's uncertain whether it's going to click. And that's the moment I find myself praying. And I feel like mathematicians have that sense of prayer,

even though a lot of them are nihilists and don't believe in God and all that stuff. And we can talk about that aspect of things too. But I do think there is always this moment for me, and maybe this is why I'm so connected to math and why I'm so willing to spend time on it, is because it's like really a process of me praying and having my prayers answered. Well, I think if you look at it from like an anthropology standpoint, there's plenty of examples of kind of, you know, earlier mathematicians who were heavily religious. You know, back in a world that was less industrialized and developed,

you would spend a lot of time thinking about God and theology, and you'd be thinking about its relationship in the world. And to your point, it was a lot of demystifying the world and kind of you're trying to understand the rules God had set forth. Right. That there's this divine sense of logic in a universe that was manifested by an almighty creator. And you're just as part of your own spiritual journey, you're trying to demystify and understand these things. And the one I'm thinking off hand was Pascal was not just a mathematician, but he also was a staunch Christian and wrote a lot about Christian theology.

but that's I think also I think in a world with less dopamine receptors less technology less kind of like social media all of these things and you're sitting there just thinking all day you're thinking about life the meaning of life and creation and then you start thinking about numbers and I think that's I think it's a very natural leap of for a certain person's mind if they're inclined to thinking in numbers and mathematical concepts to kind of marry the two it's like and spend their brain cycles. Yeah. And you just jogged something in my memory

that when the original, like, sort of group theorists, there was a notion that, like, a generator of a cyclic group was, like, was a god, was godlike, because it gave, at least this is how religious people were looking, were viewing, were viewing these concepts, because the one generator gives life to every element in the entire group. Yeah. And so what we're talking about in a cyclic group is like if you have a finite, let's say a finite field, the integers up to the number five, right?

You take a number like two and you can multiply it by itself over and over again. So two times two. First number is two. The second number is four. And then eight mod five is three. and then three times two, that gives you one. I have a video on this that's slightly less confusing. But it's like you basically take the powers of the number and you end up generating every element in the group and this was viewed as analogous.

This was viewed as analogous to God-like power. Right. Right, yeah. No, I think that makes a lot of sense. You try and, I was going to say, like, pattern match, you think about creation, and you're seeing about how mathematics is also creation. And one small addendum note I just remembered, too. What's more important, what most people know Pascal for is actually Pascal's wager. Oh, I was thinking the triangle. I was thinking the triangle, too. But then I realized, like, oh, for the on-ramp for other people who are thinking about math stuff,

it's the same man. This is great. Why don't you go, you want to go into Pascal's Wager? Yeah, so it's, it actually came up in pop culture recently, because with the passing of Scott Adams, he talked about converting to Christianity on his deathbed and specifically referenced Pascal's Wager. And the base premise is if you have a two by two square with four different possible outcomes. One of them is God exists, God does not exist. And one is you are a believer in God, and you're not a believer in God.

So if God doesn't exist and you're not a believer in God, there's no eternal consequence. If God does not exist and you do believe in God, there's still no eternal consequence because there's no afterlife. There is no God. If God does exist, though, and you do not believe in God, the idea of eternal damnation, punishment, purgatory, whatever flavor of your religious interpretation is. and then if god does exist and you are a believer being able to get you know to salvation to get to

heaven right and it was just being like put forth and you can also view this in the lens of game theory like a john nash game theory if you have these different boxes and you try to and this is a dangerous thing when you apply this to philosophy and politics and economics but if you try and apply a mass utilitarian umbrella of how many utils utils that you would get right you would get plus one utile if i have a cup of coffee if i get plus five utils though if i get an espresso because i really love espresso but i don't like the drip coffee right and if i don't get caffeine that's minus two because then i'm grumpy and i'm under caffeinated um if you lay out all of these

different possible outcomes you can view the nothing happens it's like zero so god doesn't exist at zero zero but then you have like plus infinity and minus infinity between if god does exist and if you believe or do not so it's trying to put forward this rational exposition of just looking at the possible outcomes utilizing you know it predates john nash by hundreds of years but the idea though is that game theoretically um even if your your game theoretic optimal choice

is to believe that god exists and to work towards salvation because the the eternal timeline in which your soul would face either in damnation or salvation you are in a much stronger position to be believing in god um i guess for those maybe who want to learn a little bit too about you know pascal triangles is you basically if you can think about a number right start with the number one and then below it on the lower left hand side the lower right hand side you take the

sum of what's above it and you have one so you have a triangle that's one and then the lower left is one and the lower right is one. And then you go one more level down. And what you do is you're actually then adding the parts that are above it. And you have one and one, you have two right below it. But then on the left, the far left hand side, you only have a one. And then you have on the far right hand side with the two things above it, well, there's only one above it. And that's a one. So you have a triangle that starts at the top at one. And then you have another the one right below it, you have one and one because it's something the one that's right above

it and then you have below that one two one and then you can continue this down ad infinitum uh and it's just kind of talking about probabilities common metrics uh it's one of those things that you learn uh just in general it's actually interesting for uh binomial distribution if you want to kind of lay out all of the different sequences of possible outcomes you can use that as a way to kind of see the universe of all the possible um abilities of how things can execute and uh it's it's just like a you know a fun little visual too to kind of think about things

and you can go down certain trees of the triangle to kind of see different executions of outcomes as well um i'm thinking through here well i think we i think we've lost fundamentals so i'm just going to keep on vibing for a second um so yeah i think tying back to the original point the the viewing of mathematics as a portal to the divine is that i think in common culture

like culture today you would see them as kind of like pure rationalist and uh irrational right when it comes to the domain of religion and math. And I think, I mean, for me personally, I would view it as you're kind of doing a divine act in the sense of trying to better understand the world God has made. And with that, you have an ability to challenge yourself, you're throwing yourself against the laws of the universe, and you're trying to find deeper meaning in the math.

and in that journey itself it is also somewhat of a spiritual uplifting and interesting thing all right we're still recording all right you're back there was only maybe like 15 10 15 seconds of dead air i kept on ramping i'll be able to yeah yeah you can edit around that so i was just as a hook to bring you back into it is that bring it back to your original point um viewing the domain of uh mathematics is trying to further divine and understand the rules that god has set

forth and that while in common culture you would see this diametrically opposed between a pure rationalist and like a faith-based thing um to apply yourself to try to understand mathematics in its own sense is a spiritual journey because you're throwing yourself against the laws of the universe and you trying to find meaning in the general like disorder of it all yeah and so here I was thinking about all this and probably want to keep keep going on pascal wager a little bit but like here why i was thinking about this god thing not pretentious or philosophical or anything like that it's like when i see um people say in bitcoin

which is it's clearly a great pascal's wager example right people who um people who accept kind of accept that part of the wager in Bitcoin. What I see missing, what I see people getting in trouble with themselves is that, you know, in the short amount of time, this has been around 15-ish years, you know, there's a lot of education on how the banking system works

and how money works and all that. I know people are going to expect me to say right now, like, oh, there's not enough emphasis on math. And that's not really where I'm going. Where I'm going is there's not enough emphasis on the individual himself, like on, like you are a part of the equation of whether or not this thing works. And it's like, it's, your knowledge is incomplete. And like God made us incomplete, but gave us the ability to develop our own knowledge.

right um and we you know it's almost like our own our ability to create our own knowledge is entrepreneurial meaning like we're rewarded if we create knowledge that turned out to be correct and we get wrecked if we create knowledge that turned out to be incorrect and then there's a selection process of those who seem to do a better job of creating more correct knowledge right and so what seems to be missing from an evolutionary standpoint in the bitcoin conversation

and probably all of the all of like the real issues of the day right is our own individual ability to create knowledge for ourselves which you must like you can't do unless you have a strong conviction in your own ability to actually reason with yourself you can't do unless you have a way to know you're right or a way you know not to know you're right but to be able to have a confidence interval that puts you in a Pascal's wager territory that you say you know I'm okay making

this gamble because I'm 80% confident I have this worldview yeah I'd even add to that right in that the human mind subconscious thought loop so you're always going to be thinking about something and the question is is are these thoughts that you have your own that you've gone through your own process to divine and understand and construct a worldview around or are you repeating what someone else told you or are you just being conditioned by culture society your friends whatever it is right so there

is there there's there is no escaping that you're going to be thinking about things so the question is are the things you're thinking about are they a kind of metacognition thinking about your own thoughts and evaluating critiquing them or are you taking convenient ideas and running off someone else's software basically right and i think with the discipline and domain of math in general is what you're doing is you're saying that there's this objective universe and what i am trying to do and the beautiful thing about math is that um since it you're you can go pure theoretical you

can just draw it out and start at one plus one equal two and divine and create this entire like axiomatic linking of how math works there is no uh when you get down to the the ultimate like ground truth of it there is no like peer pressure opinion among how this all works right so what you're doing is in in the in the discipline and domain of understanding math more you're explicitly pushing yourself to go through your own rational chain of thoughts and events and critically evaluating them in such a way that you're kind of learning how to not be socially

guided in one direction or another you have to just understand how the math works and the math is the math and there's really no beyond that yeah and we're really the meet the ends we're trying to meet is just it's not like um we're trying to understand how to make a wheel roll to a certain location or, you know, we're trying to understand ourselves. And, you know, sometimes it's funny. You said, you know, yeah, a lot of times we are operating off of a knowledge system that

somebody else programmed for us. And a lot of times that other person is ourselves from the past. Right. So like we have a lot going against us in, you know, moving sort of forward on the pioneer trail because we're not only fighting other people's programming, we're fighting our own programming. And it's just all like the level of strength that's required is, is high. And,

you know, this, there aren't like a lot of natural pathways for, for really attacking this. And I'm, you know, I really am looking to build a community of people that want to do this. You know, I'm going to do it anyway myself, but it's boring and very alienating to be doing this myself and probably not that productive. Right. It's great. I'll die as a knowing how much more I knew than anybody, but I couldn't explain it to anybody. So I'm miserable. And, you know, it's not a good life. It's not a good life for us.

It's just that, you know, it is it's the calling. The calling is, you know, when you feel like you know something, you want to teach it to people. But what that requires is telling them that they didn't know this before. And, you know, you know, so like I just so on a large, long scale, this sort of way we've been inclined to reject math or to use it only for vocational purposes, I think has been to keep us from being the kinds of people who can develop our own knowledge.

And, you know, that is an insight that can quickly turn to slop if you don't do the work. Yeah. That's what I'm sort of encouraging. I think that also is a comment on the education system in general. My kids are homeschooled. My wife does an amazing job. My wife also got a Ph.D. in biochemistry and biomedical science. Right. She went to an Ivy League.

And so I feel very blessed in the sense that my kids could have someone who was intentionally pushing that sense of learning and the importance of learning onto them. I think there is a commodification that happens in education in general that is just trying to check boxes and kind of move through a process in the system. and unless you find very good teachers, you have people that are more part daycare than they are actually trying to do education and enablement.

And you need to have people that are hungry for knowledge and excited about the journey of acquiring knowledge to be the ones educating you. It's a lot easier to pass along worksheets and say, just follow this ABC step. I'm not sure if you saw this. There was this, it went viral a couple days ago. There was this woman and she was trying to help her daughter with her math homework. And it was four times 500. And the worksheet that the four times 100 had, it was four times 100.

And it was like, okay, what you should do is you should actually factor out the five and the 100. So you have four times five times 100. And then each line, each one of these lines I'm about to describe was a line. And then what you do is you go down one line and you do four times five times 200. And then what you do is you factor out the two and then you like, and it went on for like six steps. And the mom is exasperated. She's like, whatever happened to just 500 times four and then doing the numbers and then doing a bunch of small little notifications, like multiplications. And I feel like a lot of, I've seen this multiple times now.

I feel like a lot of the education, it's turned into worksheet culture. It's just like we have a step and the things we do. We can't explain the concept that to do five times 400, what you could actually do is you just walk down the list and you do the five and the four and you just add the zero and then you carry it over. And the idea of carrying over number from the single digit column to the second digit column because you are now over one power of 10. Like all of these things are just way too complicated. So we're going to make everything to the most granular bite-sized piece.

and you're going to be able to kind of just baby step your way through this because we don't want to actually really involve too much math beyond like one digit addition subtraction multiplication division right um and it's because you don't want to like rock the boat they learn a basic thing you want to try and build on that and that's like a very brittle foundation as opposed to um challenging yourself and expanding more that's why just in general i think education i would also So just as a general lens, I would also throw it into this is the misalignment of government funded education just in general.

Creating like a make for work class of people who get to take off three months a year to be able to collect a pension and hang out. And they're they're punching into their job just like a lot of people do day in and day out. But rather than it being for some Fortune 500 company, they're doing it for the future generation and their ability to learn and discern things. And I think that's like just a great disservice in general. for sure i have a couple of thoughts here for one you know the problem you diagnose here is just one of the compulsory nature of math education it's the fact that it's required it's gotten to a point

now where it's it's so required that you don't have anybody who actually knows how to teach it that's a extreme but you know the by and large the system can't the system can't support the teaching of it, it can't support the requirement, you know, and it's getting crushed under the weight of that requirement. And then you just see little bad idea after bad idea to try to, you know, keep the boat afloat, right? So this compulsory nature of having to teach math is like, you know,

problematic, right? Now in a homeschool setting, you know, I guess parents probably view it as compulsory also but it's not like um it's not like life or death like um what if you don't do well on this test or the standardized test and all that stuff and I think like there's a big opportunity so it's a big opportunity to offer um something to homeschooler homeschoolers are a big part of what I think about all the time and the thing about um the thing I I feel like is out there

is, you know, not everyone has PhDs in hard sciences. And I think a lot of people at some point in time, just like with their Bitcoin stack, will lack the conviction that they can really deliver an education to their child. And the more potential their children show, the more that'll wear on their conviction. Because, you know, it's a big bet on yourself. it's like homeschooling and bitcoin are both big bets on yourself and the thing that no one talks

about is what i just mentioned 10 minutes ago which is you us as the individual is the primary determinant over whether or not it actually works out or not not the thing you know it's not bitcoin and its principles and its properties aren't the determinant i mean they're they're a determinant but you are the determinant as to whether it works out for you. It might exist on its own, but homeschooling as a movement may be great and thrive, but it may not work for you unless you find a way to actually make it work.

And if you're like, you know, I think the public school system might be a good thing for people who genuinely are below average at teaching and learning and have no values around it. um whereas if you are above average you do not want you do not want to pull your uh family down to the average which is a terrible average did you see um talking about like public education um this is in california the remedial math classes they're like that only 40 percent of

people got right in college uh no no uh i'm i'm seeing if i can effort the um usd uh uc uh university of california san diego reports a 2300 increase in students needing remediation of math since 2020 roughly one in eight compared to students unprepared and i think a lot of this i think just to even start is definitely because of covid it disrupted the entire education people got kind of like left left where they weren't able to do their traditional education what little

traditional educational structure existed had entirely kind of collapsed um the math problem i'm trying to find the exact math problem right now um uh six plus seven equals blank plus six sorry seven plus two seven plus two equals blank plus six oh my god so that's yeah i mean unbelievable are you going to tell me that two years of

two out of the 12 years of just interrupting schooling has like interrupted the ability to solve an equation like this yeah well just to let you know 25 of students at uh university of california san diego could not answer that question see i would just see that these are college students yeah i would ask the question see i still want to come in and ask the question why did why is this important right because i don't i think the reason you're seeing the result like this is because nobody i mean people should naturally think people should have a natural

inclination to think that it would be important to be on that level and they don't so it doesn't happen right and sort of what this shows me is what's possible if you absolutely really do ignore these things like it's actually possible to create a human being that can't figure out by the time they're 20 how to how to do that right like i don't i wouldn't have thought it was possible right like forget school like you could be raised in a jungle right and have the ability to you know have the ability to you know into it and discover these numbers in your brain yeah and figure it's

like is it even possible to create a human being that cannot you know that is incapable or is it i see i just think it's a rejection and it's like i don't care i just don't care i don't see why like it's not even like they can't do it it's like they just don't want to i don't get i'm guessing right it's yeah like the ways you could look at it you could view it either as um an emergent property of a system or an explicit conspiracy but there is a problem right like

whether whether it was explicitly orchestrated and designed to remove the cognitive load of people or there are other things that happen that yeah certainly an emergent property but like it's you know i but i think you have to understand people need to get that if you don't I don't – it's – oh, God. There used to be a sign in the library I grew up in. I remember the sign. It always, like, struck me. But it just said that people who don't read are no better off than people who can. People who don't read are no better off than people who can.

Who can't. Who can't. Yeah, who cannot. Right, right, right, right, right, right. Yeah. And it's like if you – so it's like if you don't do it, yes, you will, like, atrophy. and it's like it's amazing how much people will allow themselves to become so weak right it's remarkable in the time we live in how much how people will do that so that's why i always want to i always like to keep this focus on like why does it matter why why is it important

these are just arbitrary numbers right and blanks and why like why is this important it's not important to know what five plus two equals. It's just, but like, it's important to care and to then be engaged. It's important to be engaged in the process of, you know, it's being curious as being in pain. It important to be engaged in that process of solving that curiosity and building strength off of it And just like this is I feel like again what God wants And like you know I think engaging in math just to learn it is a form of Pascal wager

Okay. Okay. And most people are failing, which is like, you know, what if it doesn't matter at all? I never, what if it's true? I never needed to know this for anything, which is what most, that popular opinion, right? I never need to know this for anything. And what if that's true? okay good and then i'm gonna make that bet and it's like we seem to have a large amount of people making that well what we well remember what we used to back when i was in math class i was always told well you're not going to have a computer in your pocket walking around right right so there

is a there is a case to be made of like technology solves these things that presumed the reason to know math is to be a computer right bingo right right that the end sum was i i'll push back and say i think knowing that five plus two equals seven is actually important because like that is not um we're not talking about the identity property of a matrix or getting the eigenvector what we're talking about is going to the grocery store and i have to get seven you know pounds of

potatoes and i have five currently i've they come in five pound bags how many bags do i need to get to get to the seven you know i mean like it is such a immediate every day in your life in your subconscious you're looking at those kind of math numbers it also would have me asking question how many people actually can answer that question but they don't understand the abstract nature of a math problem where you have five plus two equals x plus six and they don't understand the abstract property but viscerally they get it to your point people a tribe uh an isolated tribe that has never

made contact with with the outside world probably could figure out if you have two hunting groups and you have a group of five a group of two a group of three and a group of six they could figure out the groupings to make them equal and go out and hunt for food right so it's also this it's an it's an abstraction problem the entire thing is an abstraction problem i i reject that if you phrase it as a word problem, this is something we're doing at homeschooling, right? There's a little bit of work, like looking at, here's a bunch of math equations, like two plus three and five minus three, and going through all these things and looking at all the

different options. And then you say, Sally has six apples. She gave one to her friend, Jane. How many apples does Sally have left? And you can actually see, I can see with my kids, they can do one and not the other. Like my son, worksheets all day. And my daughter can do the word problems, but not the worksheets. But like, so there is definitely an application of knowledge transfer problem here. But I think this is an important point. The domain to be able to transpose a concept into an abstract thought and being able to analyze it

at that abstract thought level and not at the literal word problem, this is me as the person level is a really important piece of the becoming your own sovereign individual. If you want to be cliche for a Bitcoin podcast, right? You need to be able to have these transpositions between different levels of abstraction and mental models to be able to think about things for yourself. And the higher levels of abstractions, the more often you're able to cross, pull from different disciplines, different aspects to kind of create your own more holistic worldview that you're dividing yourself through your own thought processes.

Yeah. I mean, if you just take five plus two equals seven, I think it's much more important. I think the number seven is the least important part of it as far as knowing you're right. Just knowing that the way you know that that's right. Anyone listening to this, I'm sure, knows what I'm talking about. Right? Understands the knowledge. You know, it's analogous to the Atlas Shrug, A equals A. A is A.

Right. It's like you just know when something equals something else. You just know 5 plus 2 equals 7. And it's more important that you know and how you know you know than your ability to count. Right. The ability to count is like, you know, it's important, obviously. Well. It's important. Like, if you can't count for yourself, you're going to have to trust somebody else to count for you. And that's not very ideal. But it's also, you know, towards the ability to think.

Like, you know, even a child can understand knowing that they're right. So it's so funny. Where my brain goes, and you'll appreciate this here in a second, like it's important to count, I immediately go to counting cards. Right? And the foundation of being able to count cards is can you add by one and minus by one and keep a running tally? Right? The most simplest of math. Seems easy. Easy, yeah. Like the application of said skill is its own kind of like discipline of its own of like, and I'll get to that in a second. but the counting piece is what unlocks the next level of the problem,

which is the statistical distributions of remaining cards. And this will be a fun little potpourri for everyone listening. The base premise of counting cards is that when there is a higher ratio of remaining tens and aces left in the deck, it is more advantageous to you as the player to win. And when there are more low cards left in the deck, it is disadvantageous to you. How does this get applied? uh well one just in the game of blackjack the whole rule you get dealt two cards the dealer gets one card face up one card face down and then you are asked okay do you want to hit which means

take on an additional card or do you want to stay where you are there's also splitting and doubling down which i'll put aside for a second that has a mathematical expected value piece of it too but the idea though is that you want to put more money on the table when you're more likely to win and less money on the table when you're less likely to win. And the way this actually works in practice is every time a card gets dealt, this is the simplest high-low system that there is, is that if the card value is between two and six, you add one to the count. When you start, the count is zero. And then every time a 10 or an ace comes in,

you minus one, and then seven, eight, nine, or zero. So when you're counting cards, you're keeping this rough distribution ratio, and there's a reason why it's like this. two through six, two, three, four, five, six. That's five. There's five, those are five, a group of five cards. Then you have 10, king, queen, jack, ace. Those are also five cards. So you're keeping a pure ratio. And then seven, eight, nine are just left at zero. So now you have this even distribution

of good cards, bad cards. And what you're doing is you're trying to understand the ratio between good cards, bad cards, good cards, bad cards. And that gets extended into how many cards are left to be dealt and a bunch of other things and deviations from strategy. But all this to say is all you're doing is you're taking plus one and minus one. And the actual game of counting cards much more turns into how do you not get pinched? Because you can get told what's called backing off. And if it's really bad, you'll get trespassed, which means you can't even enter the casino property anymore. But my math professor in college was on the MIT card counting team.

And I'd go to his office hours, not to understand the math behind card counting, but it was like, how do you keep the heat off you? And it was like, order a screwdriver. but then go to the bar, get an orange juice, go to the bathroom, dump out your screwdriver and just drink the orange juice and just keep on sight. Like ways to make yourself look like a drunken and idiot, right? And a lot of like meta games like that. But that's all to say though, that it's just starting with plus one, minus one, right? And you can see how that foundational bit of knowledge starts understanding statistical distributions, understanding how to play games.

Like not even just like gambling games, just like the games of life. And that counting is a gateway to be able to do any of the other things. If you can't reliably count, you can't reliably apply statistics, right? And so there's just, there's an order to this. I have a question now. So yeah, so like I feel like, I feel, I've done the counting thing. It's a, you can develop that ability. Everyone can probably. Maybe not, you know. I think everyone who really, really, really, really wants to can do it. You know, I mean, it's a fun thing to do

when you're by yourself with a deck of cards and you need to pass the time. I think the two things activities I've done the most by myself was drawing out a Pascal's triangle as large as I can when I have a long train ride or something like that and sitting with a deck of cards going one by one and practicing that so the question to you is the real question is how do you get from this rule to a decision in your mind that I believe

I believe this. I trust this. I'm going to go all in with my time and learn to do this and effort. And I'm going to learn how to drink fake screwdrivers because I know this works. How do you get to that point? That level of the conviction leap? Yes. So it goes in stages. It starts with, hey, can I do the simplest form of this? And the simplest drill you can do with card countings, you can take a deck of cards, count it, hold the last card in your hand and be like, I know this is either a seven through nine or two through six or a 10 or an ace, right? You're able

to just know because mathematically, since it's the deck of cards, the whole, the true count of all cards that exists is zero. If you're at the end and you have a plus one, you know, I have a, you know, I have a 10 through an ace at the end or in vice versa, right? So you start building a chain of competencies and understanding, right? So you can read a card counting book and you can understand oh this this is what the person's telling me to do and it's like for my process it was gradual steps and understanding the sequence of events and then understanding the law of large numbers and knowing that even within an individual session i could lose right because

to be clear like when you're counting cards what you're doing is you're making it like a 53 percent chance in your favor you're not you're not guaranteed printing money you're just instead of the casino having a two three percent edge you have the two three percent edge um so it's an understanding of walking through for me all of those um foundational pieces that build up to an overall thesis and understanding the law large of law of large law of large numbers and being like okay i could do this i understand the math i know it cold i know it forwards and backwards and from

that um you know you could call it faith in numbers but it is kind of grounded in this sense of I have the statistics on my side. It's faith in your understanding and inferences and the knowledge. You have to build your own bridge in your mind from this rubric to comfort that you're actually going to do it. And that's why not everybody does it the same way. Right. You have to build your own bridges. You have to. So that you are the factor.

You are the determining factor. It's not whether or not you implement this correctly. right it's really whether or not you know the way to implement it correctly is to maintain consistent belief you don't have law of large numbers unless you're unless your conviction right is equally high for every trial right right right so if you start to lack conviction when you really have to put the big money up right you're not you know you are gonna now you're you are messing with this experiment and the law of large numbers.

And, you know, so like that's really where I like to spend time and energy on. Right. Is like we have all this application, like everyone, the applications are like we have a lot of people doing that. Yeah. And they're good. There's a lot of good applications. Right. We send rockets into space. Contrary to popular belief, we do do that. Never to the moon, though, just low Earth orbit, right?

Yeah. But, like, you know, whether we did that or not, we do these, you know, these applications of math are, they've been open sourced. And they work in low Earth orbit just like they work. They're pretty good at working universally. it's um it's the question of you know what's your objective is your objective to send satellites into space or is your objective really to be a strong human being who's and maybe you

want to be a strong human being who sends satellites into space you know that was my dad yeah my dad was satellite engineer um you know complained all the time about not making money in financial engineering and all that stuff, but he's like, I'm sorry, I just love sending stuff into space. I couldn't help myself. So maybe that's what you're after, right? Maybe you're after making money in blackjack, right? But what I'm after is people who want to, who really want

to strengthen themselves and be, you know, like in order to put satellites into space, do you understand the kind of conviction it takes to put yourself through a PhD program and And, you know, you're not just trusting the math. You're trusting, like, you know, when I talked in the beginning about, for me, and I, you know, look, I didn't get a math degree. I got a, you know, applied degree that was much easier to get. Because I didn't have the maturity or the conviction at that age. But, like, I do remember always sitting down with my book and having a moment where I'm praying.

like please and you know where my prayers might not be answered for weeks and i'd be on the same page and not be able to move on and then one day it happens and you just don't even know you really don't know why you just kept pushing and pushing and i think there's this synergy between yourself the energy you put into learning right the desire you have the energy the amount of time and energy you spend on it. And, you know, like, it's just when you're studying pure math for the sake of it,

and it's, it really is pure math that I think, you know, is where that this process lives, right? It's like, what, you know, like, why are these structures so universal? Why do they work? you know why does you know you talked about this um process of assigning taking 13 cards and mapping them to either one zero or negative one right that's the map that's a linear map so in algebra that's a linear map it's um it's it might or it might be an isomorphism probably not

but it's probably you think about it as a linear map you're taking a set of you're taking a domain of 13 numbers and you're mapping them into a domain of three numbers. So it's definitely not an, you know, every, it's a function. Every input has an output, right? Yeah. So like, and so that's the kind of thing. So it's like, why does that, why does it matter? You know, why does that, why do these things matter? What are these structures and what else do these structures enable us to do? And so back to five plus two equals seven, right?

you have to understand how to do that in order to so if i would say the end game of that this type of numerical arithmetic for me and the people that i think i want to teach would be at least understanding why um multiplying two numbers is easy but factoring them is difficult yeah that's a fundamental oh yeah physics that's a physics property of the world of

cryptography that we live in and that that we are um you know subjected to right right and in order so in order to understand how easy it is to multiply two numbers you kind of have to understand how easy it is to add two numbers okay right true and well i mean and and going from a private key to a public key as a multiplication operation. It's just the domain in which you're multiplying against is just so massively large that you can't reverse factor it. Unless you have a quantum computer. It's multiplication by a generator

that we had established was thought to be you know, deified. Yeah. Did I mention that on the last podcast? Why that generator and everything was picked? No. I don't think so. There's one of the earliest posts on the Bitcoin talk forums. Someone asks, why is it the LibSec P256K1 curve? And basically the response, I think it's Satoshi, it's either Haller or I think it's Satoshi, comes back and says, it's the only curve, the generator,

that didn't have any weird constants held at it. Interesting. And the reason why that important is that a lot of elliptic curves they have an arbitrary constant being held and it turns out it because someone has been able to reverse engineer it If you hold this thing constant right here the entire generator being a secure encryption falls apart, and then you're able to reverse engineer everything. So Satoshi, when he picked that curve, was like, it was the only one I saw that didn't have any weird things going on with it.

You know, you talk about, like, you know somebody who had conviction in his enough to make his own pascals wager to set this thing off like this right i mean it's like that's the that you know are we all you know we all have that in us and i think we all have to find our way yeah you know we have to find our way into that path ongoingly because whether we win or lose really does depend on whether we have conviction

And we start to see how fake people's conviction is when it's tested. And whether it's a low-level test like spam, you know, low-level test. Like, oh, my God, I can't believe how easy that was to shake people's conviction. Or, you know, we're going to have some very difficult tests, I believe, in store for us in the next maybe 10, 20, 30 years. I think they're going to be much more difficult, much more slick, much more challenging.

Well, I think especially as just with the introduction and rapid acceleration of adoption and impact of AI in general, it's going to be a lot easier to just have someone serve it up to you. It's going to be a lot easier to just like, here's an answer. And it's so eloquently written. It's so much better written than anything you, dumb person, could ever write with your own hand or type out as your own message. So you're going to get, as the kids call it, you get one shot by the AI.

You just take the gospel of whatever it says and you spit it back out. Did you see the one where I sent you that I got it to admit that it was literally just optimized to impress humans? Are we peeking behind the production of the podcast where you send me all of the extortions and yelling and everything you do when talking to these AI models to just like – when the AI revolution comes, you're going to be the first one. You're going to be on the stretch racks immediately.

Yeah, probably. Well, you know, I have shared my AI yellings, my yelling at AI with a lot of people. And what I've been told was a lot of people have just had their accounts canceled by, like, Anthropic. And so, you know, I don't think I've crossed that line. I think I stayed within this line of, like, how I would talk to an employee if I didn't care about their humanity. Yeah. And it's like I think that this is part of the conviction process because I need to know how much conviction I can have in this tool that I need to really kick the tires on its capabilities.

Yeah. So calling it out, calling it out to the limits of like when it's lying to me or when it's really not – like really calling it out and asking it like what were you thinking the moment – like I ask it. What were you thinking the moment you saw my instruction and decided to do something else? That's the level of granularity I get when I'm really grilling it. And then eventually it confesses things. Maybe you're reliable, maybe not.

But the theme of conviction is really what it's all about. This is another new technology that you're going to have a lot of fools. you already see it right fools with really high conviction giving it its API keys letting them go crazy you know that's not going to be how intelligent people use this right so I'm not worried I'm not so worried about it going crazy because it's very limited even as powerful as it is still very limited

and I think you always have to be like I have a lot of faith in myself to navigate the new thing And I think that's what I want for people. Totally. I want people to have that power and to feel like they're – without having to give it all away to a new technology and say, well, I want people to have agency. And I want to – that's the world I want to live in. Right. You want to avoid the – I mean the meme is funny to me, but the at Grok, is this true? Just like something happens and you just at Grok, is this true?

Totally. Yeah, you want people, it's all part of this building your own bridges in your internal process, being able to understand and rationalize reasonable things. I'm a big fan of don't tell me chat GPT said so. Can you show me the chat history? Because I can corner it into a box that I actually am, like I am physically a potato. I'm not a human if I prompt it the right way. So it doesn't really matter to me what a given output spit out is. I want to see the, the reason I want to see the chat history is I want to see the journey of the conversation and the thought process and all of the assumptions and all of the kind of coaching and guiding to get to an answer.

For maybe something fun to throw in the show notes, I just linked the thread I found. It's Hal Finney. So Hal Finney on January 9th, 2011 asks, why did Satoshi choose this curve? and there's a long discussion with a lot of ogs gavin andreason mike hearn christian decker um gregory maxwell are all in this thread uh and it's funny uh it comes back around

it gets bumped a couple years later and greg maxwell like right near the end of the thread is talking about because someone's like oh i don't like how this curve was used it makes me feels weird and someone cites all of the constants and backdoors and Greg Maxwell replies you mean you feel uneasy that he chose the only standardized curve that doesn't have unexplained parameters in it? That's basically the end of the thread. Is that like everyone's looked at this thing and this is the only curve like Satoshi in the universe of any random curve he could have chose for all this like for all the public private key cryptography

chose the one curve that didn't have any weird screwball values in it. Pretty incredible. It's just incredible that you think about how immaculate this had to be. And, you know, people need to understand. The reason why this is important to understand is because you should not have ultimate conviction in what Satoshi did. No. You should not have that. And you should have a way of pressing and pressing the same way you press anything to see where the holes are and where maybe you shouldn't have full conviction.

Yeah. Yeah, this is, I think, part of the journey. And it should be comforting, too, that there's nothing wrong with walking through these thoughts. Because you need to understand and discern this knowledge for yourself. And even in this thread that I linked, people are speculating it's Satoshi the NSA. Which is a very common talking point even today. And there's nothing wrong with kind of going through your own thought process and game theorying and thinking these things through. I think it's actually kind of the responsible thing to do

especially especially if you've put a large percentage of your net worth into Bitcoin and you're not asking these questions then like what are you doing? Are you just listening to some macro podcasts and you're like I'm just going to take all of my life's work and energy and throw it into this thing? I know, well I would say I know what they're doing they're just going to sell the second they get thrown off it's like you know But the conviction is false. And so it's just these are easy targets.

And I don't want people I care about to be cannon fodder for Fudsters. This is actually also kind of my love with the price being down. Not going to lie. There's a lot of Johnny come lately's like the price must go up 50% every year in X, Y, and Z. And I got my conviction and belief in Bitcoin when Bitcoin was at $200. My core thesis hasn't changed. Right. And this is part of that process. even cycle theory ending with a sample size of three going on four you're you're draw you're

making deterministic claims of finality of how the bitcoin price must behave is like yeah you have a sample of four yeah you have a sample you have a sample of four where the sample the first three of the sample we had zero interest rates and one sample we're in now where everyone is reacting and this is like a whole episode i feel like we have to do about but like with the one And it triggers me to no end when I hear all this from people, especially people I know are mathematically inclined and they're not even doing the work to think about the out-of-sample bias.

You should always be thinking about out-of-sample bias literally 100% of the time you make a prediction about anything. 100% of the time you need to think about that, right? Yeah, absolutely. And this is not a hard thing to think about. Oh, you know, it is literally the issue of our time, which is non-zero rates in this one cycle. Right. We've had three with zero rates. We've had one with high rates.

High at 5%. And we're making conclusions. Higher, historically high. I'd say the hardest money environment Bitcoin's ever lived through. That's true. That's true. I'm more just laughing about in the 70s and 80s with 15% interest rates. I came into the actuarial profession when everyone was using 8% discount rates. There you go. And when they went down to 5, everyone was like, oh, my God, we got to be lump summing now like crazy. Yeah. Because we got to take advantage of these low rates. I get it.

Yeah. But, like, the reality is, you know, it's not just – rates aren't just a number, right? It's just like age. Age is not just a number. It's like age is just a number, you know, a number that has a high. likelihood of predictive high predictive quality of how long you're going to live yeah actually yeah like you know rates are not just a number right it's an indicator of how hard the monetary environment is and you know we you're going to draw conclusions about the nature of the world based on an absurdly different um an absurdly different observation in your sample set totally

low sample set that there is. I can't stress this enough. I mean, if I had to do 10 episodes just about this one thing, I would do it. The time value of money. Yeah, the time value of money. Like how critical that is for every other economic calculation. But also just know what people, this is like the mistake people make when they're creating their own knowledge and ignoring such egregious out of sample bias and trying to create their own knowledge. I mean, any kind of recency bias should raise your eyebrow also.

And you should be looking out for just, oh, is this time different? You know, those general questions. And maybe it's different for reasons I don't know. But we have the most important reasons like smacking you in the face. The other thing, too, is that this past four years is the first time institutional investors actually cared about Bitcoin. Like the tail end, the picotop of the 2017 cycle was the turning on of the futures market for Bitcoin. like it's like it's like to the to almost the week the futures market the chicago mercantile

exchange bitcoin cash settled futures and the bitcoin peak price is almost identical and so if that's the top and that's kind of if you want to view it's the start of the next cycle as it goes down and goes back up like that was the first one where it really mattered and this is the first time where like it really really mattered between 2017 2021 you had a couple niche side players. I mean, Sailor wasn't even stacking until 2020, right? So like, you just look at it in this context of like, as the ship in the capital base gets bigger,

it's going to be more at the whims of macro assets. That's been the one thing people are complaining about. And all of these things, this is why one, a sample size of four is bad. And two, the context in all of these is so much more critical. And it's way more likely that a nascent network like bitcoin's having schedule is not the determining factor but it's global macroeconomics because that's bitcoin maturing as an asset like the maturation of bitcoin as an asset is not uh the entire universe goes around into bitcoin like there's a merger happening between financial

and economic systems and bitcoin as it exists and bitcoin is amazing but it's not going to be laying down all the rules and and going to be controlling everything because all all of those early OGs who sold, sold their Bitcoin into a network of traditional finance holders, which means that they are a larger percentage holder of the network. You know, millions of coins between ET, well, just MicroStrategy 700 that, right? But then you have all the ETFs and everything else that is a larger percent of the float of the capital base of Bitcoin. So obviously it's more at the whims of the traditional macro system in general. Yep. For now, especially.

For now, yeah. If you're trying to draw, if you're, if you're building knowledge, if like the you in the future is living off of something that was programmed by the version of you in the past and that is you right now making really specious conclusions right and putting it's really dangerous and this is like the thing I want to really highlight and say this is why this work is so important it's that you should be this should be like one of the highest priorities you have of your life is to not is to at least eliminate the creation of knowledge that's going

wreck you. Yeah, absolutely. Is there anything else you want to update our many fans on? Anything else for the podcast? We'll try and get this in two weeks too. We'll try and make the three weeks a one-off thing, but we'll go back. I'd say the website's coming along. We have magicinternetmath.com is now the domain name. And, you know, in the last episode, I told my story about how the LibSec GitHub was the thing that threw me into the rabbit hole.

I figured out a way to just make a class. I threw the GitHub into my process for my website, and I made a class out of it. And actually, if I had that three years ago, we probably wouldn't be here right now. Yeah. And I just had a thought about doing this now for some of the Bitcoin talk threads. Yeah. Which I think... You can find a whole explanation of why LibSecP. You can just go to that thread that starts. There's a lot of good things to start with on that.

A little bit of a teaser, not to promise anything yet, but we've been in contact with some people that are way smarter than us that work on LibSecP that we may be able to bring on to a future show as well. And that will hopefully elevate the class and do a service to our listeners that way. For sure. My pattern on podcasts in the past has been now a small sample size of four or five. but like you know my partner we have a maybe maybe have four episodes of stuff we need to get out

and then there's not much more to talk about between the two of us and so we got to now bring in the experts that's right so uh you know look out for i'd say definitely look out for that look out for guests um and check out the website play with it engage with it i am starting a pioneers Club. So if you're listening to this on Fountain, you can start to see some extra content I've been putting out there. One thing I do want to highlight is I'm putting out a video series

based on the book Men of Mathematics by Eric Temple Bell. And it's a 2,500-year history. It's biography. It's like every episode is like another biography. It's like a 10-minute biography. And Pascal is definitely one of the episodes. And I love, like, I really want to push math history. I think that's the lowest hanging fruit that a lot of us can really start on this process with. You know, the history of math, it's just, you know, Bitcoiners like history. I think if you want to know the history of money, you should know the history.

It's really the history of mathematicians. Right. And history of, it's like, where are you? If, you know, we are people searching for conviction. in ourselves where, how did, how did the top of the top of those people live? Right. And that's why we read and that's why we study history and study these people. Right. We want to sort of find our place because we are on a similar pioneers trail where we find ourselves right now without a real blueprint of how to do it. Totally. Excellent. Yeah. I think that's well said.

Exciting. Thank you. All right. Second one in the books. All right. We did it. All right. Number two. Take care, everyone. Have a great day. Thank you.

Open the transcript file

Hosts and Guests

Nobody is credited on this episode yet.

Credit the people on this episode

Be the first to rate this episode

More episodes

All episodes
  1. Exponential Got Less Exponential

    Nov 2, 20261 hr 10 minAudio

    In this episode, we picked back up on our red-team tour of Bitcoin cryptography and tried to make sense of the last few weeks of fast-moving math news. We unpacked why the recent excitement around the exponential time...

    Credit the people on this episode

  2. Red Teaming Elliptic Curve Cryptography

    Oct 11, 20261 hr 27 minAudio

    OpenAI just dropped roughly 300 math papers with Lean proofs, mathematicians are crashing out, and the vague-posting has started: "math is breaking, so cryptography is next." Brian and Rob Hamilton refuse to hand-wave....

    Credit the people on this episode

  3. Hash Functions, Linear Algebra, and Alice in Wonderland

    Sep 28, 202650 minAudio

    Magic Internet Math: https://www.magicinternetmath.com/ Shout out to https://x.com/uncleJim21 for the Alice in Wonderland story and the following rebuke of Lewis Carroll: https://www.youtube.com/shorts/33FYXpEWgyA This...

    Credit the people on this episode

  4. Kayfabe Math is Now Mainstream

    Sep 13, 20261 hr 17 minAudio

    We’re back because math keeps refusing to stay in the classroom. In this episode, I unpack two very different kinds of “math pop culture.” First, we revisit entropy, seed generation, and wallet security through a...

    Credit the people on this episode

  5. Legalize MATH

    Sep 2, 20262 hr 2 minAudio

    Magic Internet Math is back. After the summer that set the Bitcoin world on fire - the Cold Card entropy disaster - Brian and Rob Hamilton (AnchorWatch) reunite for a two-hour deep dive on the event Rob spent three...

    Credit the people on this episode