Skip to content
PodSubs
ShowsPeopleGuestsJobsNewsEvents
More
BlogPodCred
Menu
ShowsPeopleGuestsJobsNewsEventsBlogPodCredNetworksSign in
Join nowSign in
  • Shows
  • People
  • Jobs
  • News
  • More
    • Guests
    • Events
    • Blog
    • PodCred
    • Networks
    Join nowSign in

LytePod

LytePod artwork

A PhD Decodes a Design Frustration - Why the Material You Pick Never Looks Right — It's Lighting

Aug 25, 202646 minAudio
ShareXLinkedInFacebookWhatsAppEmail

What happens when a PhD who studies color science sits down and reveals why the material you picked never looks right once it's installed - and why the answer has nothing to do with the material and everything to do with the light? In this episode of LytePOD, host Sam Koerbel sits down with Tony Esposito, a color science researcher and co-chair of the IES Color Committee, for a rare, unfiltered conversation about what the lighting industry gets wrong about color - and why the metrics we've relied on for decades are failing designers, manufacturers, and the people who live and work in the spaces we create. This isn't a conversation about fixtures or photometrics. It's a deeply technical yet profoundly human look at how light shapes color perception, why CRI isn't enough anymore, and why TM30 might be the most important tool lighting designers aren't using yet. 💡 Key topics explored: • Why lighting impacts color perception - and why the material you select under one light source won't look the same under another • How preference isn't personal opinion like cake flavors - it's scientifically measurable, repeatable, and likely biological • Why CRI only tells you how close a light source is to the reference illuminant - not whether it's good, preferred, or optimized • The difference between fidelity, preference, and vividness - and why TM30 gives designers the vocabulary to communicate all three • How TM30's 99 color samples and four key metrics (RF, RG, red fidelity, red chroma) predict visual outcomes CRI can't • Why the Annex E system simplifies TM30 by letting designers specify design intent (P, V, or F) and priority level (1, 2, or 3) • Why manufacturers don't need new equipment - they already have the spectral data required to calculate TM30 • How interior designers and lighting designers should collaborate earlier to ensure finishes are selected under the right light • Why experiential learning - seeing light sources side by side - is the only way to truly understand what TM30 can do Whether you're a designer frustrated by materials that don't look right on site, a manufacturer wondering if TM30 is worth the effort, or anyone curious about why light matters more than you think - this conversation offers a rare, honest look at the science, the metrics, and the future of color in lighting design. Listen now to discover why great lighting isn't about chasing CRI - it's about understanding color, optimizing for humans, and using the right tools to predict what people will actually prefer. ❤️ Big appreciation for the partners who support this work and trust the vision. They believe in thoughtful conversations, strong community, and letting designers' voices lead. Grateful to build this together. 1️⃣ Nightingale - https://watch.lytei.com/nightingale 2️⃣ Kelvix - https://watch.lytei.com/Kelvix 3️⃣ LEDflex - https://watch.lytei.com/LEDFLEX 4️⃣ Diode LED - https://watch.lytei.com/diode 5️⃣ Targetti USA - https://bit.ly/targettiusa Chapters 00:00:00 Opening: Why the Material You Pick Never Looks Right - It's Lighting 00:01:03 Sponsor Spotlight: Nightingale Lighting 00:02:22 The Velour Couch Problem: When Lighting Changes Everything 00:04:28 Human Preference Isn't Opinion - It's Biology 00:08:28 The Planckian Radiator: What We're Really Measuring Against 00:10:39 CRI Explained: Closer Doesn't Always Mean Better 00:13:58 Why LED Technology Demands More Than CRI 00:15:29 TM30: The Full Vocabulary of Color Rendition 00:22:01 The Four Metrics That Matter: RF, RG, and Red Chroma 00:23:36 Why Red Matters: Skin, Evolution, and Visual Sensitivity 00:24:38 Sponsor Spotlight: Kelvix, Leadflex, and Diode LED 00:29:58 Annex E: Simplifying TM30 for Specification 00:34:34 Sponsor Spotlight: Targetti USA 00:35:15 Busting the Myths: Cost, Complexity, and Change 00:38:49 Seeing Is Believing: The Experiential Learning Path 00:41:00 The Toolkit: How to Start Using TM30 Today 00:44:12 Closing: Integrating Lighting and Interior Design for Better Outcomes

Audio and video play straight from the show's own hosting. PodSubs stores and serves no media.

Transcript

From the show. Tap a time to play from there.

I feel sometimes like the word preference sends a message that what we're quantifying is squishier than it really is. Tony Esposito studies how we measure light and color and why the way we're doing it is failing us as an industry. I sympathize with lighting designers and the profession of lighting design. There's no substitute for experience. We need to think about the balance between simplicity and accuracy. There was a time where CRI was good enough, but LED technology has a spectral diversity that makes it very difficult to evaluate all of the available products.

What we find over and over again is the desire for increased saturation, especially in the reds and oranges. It's so repeatable that it suggests that there's probably something biological here. The good news is that the data that you need to compute CRI is the same data you need to compute TM30. One of the things that people often misunderstand about CRI or color fidelity is Before we jump in, I want to thank five companies that show up for this community.

Nightingale, Kelvix, Ledflex, Diode LED, and Targeti USA. Because this show exists thanks to their belief in designers and the way they work every single day. The people, that's who we design for. And that's especially important in healthcare. I want to share how Nightingale helps with that. Patients in behavioral health settings are often moving through some of the most challenging periods of their lives. In those moments, the environment around them can make a difference. Spaces that feel calm and thoughtfully designed can help create a greater sense of reassurance for people receiving care.

So Nightingale designs lighting that does more than light the space. It helps to study the senses. Every detail is considered. Softly distributed illumination, recessed forms, and gentle curves that integrate without drawing unnecessary attention. Soft enough to feel human, strong enough to meet the demands of care. From ambient lighting to task and nighttime illumination, Nightingale's behavioral health collection helps rooms feel less clinical and more reassuring without compromising safety.

Quiet strength in every detail. Visit NightingaleLighting.com to learn more. In a theoretical world, That probably actually isn't theoretical because you think about the world of architecture and interior design, finishes, products, the velour couch, it gets selected and then it gets put on a project, but it doesn't look the same. Is it possible that lighting is the culprit for that? Yeah, 100%. So lighting, as we know, if we start fundamentally, lighting impacts our perception of color.

So if we're selecting material finishes for a space, the light source that we select those under or we view those under has a huge impact on how we perceive those colors. And that light may or may not match the light that ends up in the final architectural space. So in this sense, it's very important that we understand the performance of the light source so that we can understand how it's impacting the colors that we're currently looking at. And then try to evaluate how those objects will look in the lighting in the final installation of this space.

It's this word performance that you're using, right? What's curious to me is how performance gets measured in from one light to another, right? It said it was this here. Why isn't it that there? This might be 3000 K and 80 CRI. Yet there it's not the same thing. We'll get into that a little bit more and why CRI and color temperature might not be all the information we need, right? But before we go there, I wanna talk about preference too, right?

There's the preference we have as human beings to live under or to experience light in a certain way. 85% of our life is spent indoors under electric light, yet the black body curve, this beautiful sunshine that we live underneath, this full spectrum light is something we love. And we undeniably know it because when we go outside, we have a certain feeling and reaction and emotion. What do we know about preference for humans as it relates to our visual system and the color we see through it?

The research shows us that people tend to prefer increase in saturation, I'll use technical jargon here, relative to the reference source. So CRI or color fidelity measures tell us average performance relative to a reference source. They don't tell us if a light source is going to increase or decrease the saturation of objects, which is what the research tells us can predict a person's preference of objects under an illuminated environment. And so something like CRI, the color rendering index, cannot predict

across a large array of color rendering characteristics, whether or not somebody is going to prefer or find acceptable the way that colors are rendered in certain environments. When you think about who we are as human beings, I might prefer this and you might prefer that. Let's just talk about cars for a second, right? Yeah. You want a fast car, I want a slow car. We both want fast cars, but one's red and one's blue, right? That's almost like a preferential opinion. When it comes to preference in terms of humans' perception of color and what we prefer, is it more definitively and scientifically defined or is it just that personal opinion?

Yeah. I feel sometimes like the word preference sends a message that what we're quantifying is squishier than it really is. color preference is not really the same as do you like one particular type of cake or another type of cake. I like carrot cake. Maybe you like red velvet cake. Yeah. And so it's not really quite like that. When we're talking about preference from a research perspective, we're not talking about what does one person like versus what another person likes.

What we're really trying to quantify is what do most people on average find more preferable under different kinds of lighting conditions? So for example, if we have a research study where we have 20 light sources with different color rendering performance, and we show those to a large number of people and we ask them, which of these light sources do you like the best? Do you find most acceptable in the most conditions? Most people, most of the time, will choose the one that has an increased saturation, and in particular in the reds.

And so we're really capturing average response of many people over a long period of time. We have research results going back several decades showing this. So it's really much more robust, scientific and measurable and repeatable than, say, something like individual preference for cake or pastries. Is it fair to say that that's a biological part of humanity? Yeah. Yeah, it's a great question. So if we go back to sort of the research perspective on this, let's say we do a similar study.

And we show a bunch of light sources and we ask people to rate them on a scale of likeness to dislike or dull to vivid, things like this. And then we, after the experiment, ask people, what were the objects that most influenced your perception? They almost always pick the red or orange or yellow objects. And then we find that those objects really influence how they're making decisions about a space. And then again, when we find over and over again is the... desire for increased saturation, especially in the reds and oranges, for example.

For me, this suggests it's so repeatable that it suggests that there's probably something biological here. There's some hypotheses around this, but we're still sort of exploring why that might be We know it's there. We're not exactly sure why it's there. Yeah. But as it relates to that, we can definitively say that when we light an environment, creating a preference towards that might be a good thing. And there's a way that we put light into a space today.

And that way is typically selecting it and specifying it. around a reference. You had a cool word. You said black body, but what's the, what's the technical term you use for it? A planking radiator. Thank you so much. I love that term. Yeah. What is that planking radiator? What is that curve? And why is that important to this conversation? we sort of focus a little bit on color fidelity, on CRI, and understanding that measures of color rendition are relative.

So we're always computing the performance of a light source relative to something else. In this case, it's relative to that standardized reference illuminant. So for something like CRI, it's going to be up to 5,000 Kelvin Planckian radiation, broadband radiation that has energy in all wavelengths of light. Our sun is a Planckian radiator. Above 5000 Kelvin, it's going to be a mathematical phase of daylight. So we're always going to be comparing our light source to standard aluminum at the same CCT, it'll be Planckian or daylight.

Daylight is just Planckian radiation filtered through our atmosphere. So it all it all kind of sort of goes back to Planckian radiation. Okay, wait a second. It's planking radiation filtered through atmosphere, which is daylight. Is daylight. So we have a reference source, which is truly a reference, not necessarily something we utilize every day, i.e. daylight. Daylight is a form of planking radiation. Basically, filtered Planckian radiation. Okay. And we'll get into a little bit, I think, as we talk about more expanded color rendering metrics.

But as we'll see, the reference illuminant should be thought of as just a reference, a place to put your stick in the sand and to measure from. It doesn't set it as the ideal illuminant. Really, there are ways we might want to deviate from the reference illuminant that people like or enjoy and find acceptable. That's where preference comes in. Often people prefer an increase in saturation, which takes us a little bit away from the reference illuminant. And that's what's important here. Just chasing the number of 100 in the legacy metric of CRI doesn't necessarily mean perfect.

It just means we achieve meeting that reference. Yeah. Yeah, that's right. So I think one of the things that people often misunderstand about CRI or color fidelity is there's this sort of built-in assumption that higher is better. In reality, higher is just closer. You're just closer to the reference. Sometimes that is good and sometimes that's not good. If I want to increase preference, I have to move away from the reference illuminant. And so that would be a way in which... Higher fidelity is not better. It's actually detrimental possibly to the perception of preference.

So really we need to think about the reference illuminant as just a place to put the stake in the sand and measure distance from, but it's not necessarily the best place to go, so to speak. So we're flirting with this thing CRI, right? Yeah. What is it? Yes, a good question. CRI, I think, is often misunderstood. I do a lot of lecturing around and I ask a lot of people questions and I'll do a quiz on what is CRI. And I often get a lot of answers that relate to accuracy and accuracy.

percentage of accurately rendered colors. But really simply and directly, CRI is a measure on average of how close our light source renders colors to that reference source. If you're closer, you have a higher CRI. If you're further, you have a lower CRI. And sometimes you can be further, but increase saturation or further and decrease saturation. So really, CRI is just a measure of, on average, how close are we to the reference.

You're mentioning saturation, right? Yeah. But then we're talking about preference. Yeah. there's other things in the space of color that we now know about, or did we always know about them? That's a great question. So CRI was published in early 1900s, or 1954, I think was the first time it was published off the top of my head. And some of the original authors of the document that defines CRI went on to almost immediately publish metrics related to preference.

One of them is called Dean B. Judd and published the Flattery Index. So very early on, researchers knew that CRI was only one possible metric, one possible quantification of color. It's just that... We as an industry haven't necessarily adopted new metrics to predict or communicate those other aspects of color rendition. But scientists have known from almost day one. CRI was developed around a sample set. It was a limited sample set around another reference source.

that has since been updated through a set of documentation called TM 30, which has 99 samples. And those 99 samples are colors that come from 10,000 objects. So there's real reason behind this, as opposed to what may have been previously established with either eight or nine, depending on how you look at it. Am I right? Eight. It was eight, right? It was eight. Okay. Okay. Why did TM30 all of a sudden appear in our world of technical lighting?

Sure. There's a lot to unpack. I'll start by saying that CRI was pretty good for quite a while. It did a decent job of separating... out the differences between legacy light sources that didn't have a lot of spectral diversity. You think back to the old fluorescent tubes that I have some students now who are probably never never specify a fluorescent tube moving forward, but there was a time where CRI was good enough.

But LED technology has a spectral diversity that makes it very difficult to evaluate all of the available products. just with your eyes. And so we need to rely a little bit more on measures and predictive performance of color rendering perhaps than we used to have to. And TM30 hasn't, in some sense, it did come out of nowhere in the sense we didn't have TM30 and then we did. But TM30 really built on multiple decades of scientific research in color that, you

In some ways, it's more of a synthesis of all of the work that has been done over the decades rather than inventing entirely something entirely new. And so I think in that sense, it's very defensible. It's built on many decades of research and the modern research on it shows that it works. It works really well. And so... I want more people to use it. So listen up.

Listen up. Let's go. Let's go. Yeah. We wouldn't develop anything for the sake of it not being used, right? There's this clear intent behind, as you're suggesting, moving to the next stage, the next opportunity. I want to talk about what drove it. I want to talk about why it's maybe more useful today than it has been in the past.

But before we open up the TM30 chapter, I have to close the book on one thing with CRI. When a project doesn't go right, when a project doesn't feel the way it feels, is CRI the thing that's screwing us over? Yeah. We could think of it with an analogy. I love analogies. Yeah, me too. I think in analogies.

I'm a painter and I only have access to two colors. And I can make pretty good paintings using those two colors. But say a paint manufacturer comes along and says, hey, you've only been using two, but now I have 10, 15, 20 more. Of course, you could make good paintings before. A good painter can make quite a lot with just those two colors. But having access to the full palette of colors opens up the world of possibilities for what you can achieve.

CRI is kind of like painting a picture just with two colors. We can do a good job. Sometimes. but there's a whole lot more we could be doing if we use a more sophisticated system for communicating color rendition. It's like a black and white photo versus a color photo. Exactly. Right? That's right. You could take a black and white photo and I think there's a lot of advantages to that, right? Yeah. Without the information of color, it creates its own visual curiosity, but the reality is providing the information of the color the camera sees

gives you more context. It gives you more opportunity to perhaps perceive something in a different way. And one might argue a better way, but I'll leave that debate for another year. Yeah, sure. Right? LED technology has been around for 20 years. You mentioned this thing called the spectral power distribution or the distribution of the spectral distribution. I know you like to think in analogies. What's the analogy for what a spectral distribution is? Yeah. So sort of in scientific terms, the spectral power distribution tells us roughly how much power is in each wavelength of light.

Wavelength? is roughly correlated with sort of saturated color appearance. We can think of color rendering really from the spectra power distributions perspective as a recipe. So we talked a little bit about cake earlier. You can make a cake with two different sets of ingredients. Maybe we make our carrot cake with two different kinds of flowers and on the outside they look the same, but the recipe under the hood is different, which will eventually lead to a different taste.

We can think about color rendering in the same way, where two light sources might look the same. They might have the same CCT of, say, 3500 Kelvin. They may have a DUV of zero, meaning they're directly on the Planckian radiator. But their recipe is different. They have a different spectral power distribution under the hood, which eventually leads them to having a different impact on the color perception or the color rendition of objects in a space. So we really have to understand the downstream effects of color rendition, which come from the light source of spectral power distribution.

And that downstream effect is literally what we see, right? That's right. Back to the example at the beginning of our velour couch where we just had the fabric sample. You could even have multiple light sources in that selection room or that demo room. But just because those characteristics match there doesn't mean they end up, relatively speaking, matching on the project. Yeah, that's exactly right. And if we take it even further, even if we were able to say...

match the same light source in our office, maybe where we're evaluating the samples or the finishes, even if we could match the final lighting in the application as in our office, it doesn't necessarily mean we've optimized the performance or the color rendition of the light sources for the objects. It just might mean they're same so that they may be predictable. in some way, but that doesn't mean they're great. Yeah. Just means- It just means they're the same. Just means it's the same. So TM30 does a couple of things, right?

It gives us a different way to evaluate color, but then it also gives us a different way to quantify color so that we can do things like gear towards what humans might actually want in that preference metric, as opposed to just meeting a fidelity metric. Yeah. I think of it a lot like sort of back to the painter analogy, but we could use the same idea and language. Having this discussion would be quite a bit harder if we only had 10% of our vocabulary.

Sort of the increased vocabulary allows us to exchange ideas much more efficiently. Yeah. In the same way, like CRI, a measure of color fidelity might only be 10% of the total language that we would like to have access to. Whereas TM30, which is a color rendition system from the IES, gives us a much more sophisticated vocabulary for communicating ideas. And in this case, communicating ideas that can optimize lighting for the built environment. And optimizing lighting for the built environment has a big equal sign next to it.

Right. And that's for the humans that occupy and use that space. Yeah. Back to that biology point, but also continuing on, right? We have studied and there is some data that suggests there's preference around it. Not exactly sure why, but following that right here in the front of our brains, right? TM30 is a set of data. That data gets quantified and presented in a certain way. What is it? If TM30 is the full vocabulary, it's like learning a new language, right?

And it has a lot of measures of color rendition in it. I think I've counted more than 149, something like that. It's very sophisticated. But of those available metrics, there's... about four that the science, the research shows us are important to focus on. We see RF, which is TM30's average fidelity metric, which is conceptually similar to CRI, but more scientifically accurate. We have RFH1, which is red fidelity, which is conceptually similar to R9, but much more scientifically accurate.

So we could see already we have 50, we have language for 50% of the metrics, right? Conceptually similar to things we're already familiar with. Then we go to RG, gamut area, which describes average increase or decrease in saturation, where people on average prefer an increase in saturation, and they do not like on average a decrease in saturation. And then the final is where I, The part of TM30 that I really love is the chroma shift metrics. They tell us exactly what's happening to certain colors.

So we have chroma shift for red tells us, is red being increased in saturation or decreased in saturation? And it tells us exactly what our visual experience is going to feel like. I think it's important as we talk about all these, right? Again, it's always back to reference. Yes, there is this preference that has been studied. But what's cool is you can intentionally maybe shift away from preference or, you know, dominate into preference. You keep mentioning red, so I have to ask, what's going on with red?

Yeah, I sort of mentioned it earlier. It's like when we do these experiments over a long period of time, researchers just keep finding that people respond really strongly to changes in red saturation. And when you ask them, what are the colors and what are the objects that are influencing the way that you evaluate objects and spaces? We find a lot of focus on on red. And there there are some. guesses for why that might be. The guess that I kind of quite like is this idea from an evolutionary standpoint that skin is red and we might have developed some sensitivity or maybe we are paying closer attention to red because a lot of skin can be used to predict things like diseases and sickness and things like that.

So the skin changes color based on oxygenation. So I quite... I'm quite fond of the idea that we're sensitive to red because the evaluation of skin is very important to us. So I quite like that idea. Evaluating who you work with is also important, but we've done some of that work for you. Here are some manufacturers who support design. Kelvix doesn't just move fast, they move with purpose, helping the design world turn ambitious ideas into seamless, buildable realities.

The Kelvix team works at the pace of your project, delivering tailored solutions backed by people who know how quality, timing, and precision elevate the final outcome. In every spec and every collaboration, Kelvix proves lighting is more than illuminating. Lighting protects design intent, sharpens the details that matter, and brings spaces to life with clarity and ease. See what's coming from breakthrough products to standout projects at Kelvix.com or on their social channels.

Another partner of ours who we trust and you can too is Leadflex. Because at Leadflex, linear light is designed to do more than illuminate. It's engineered how to shape how spaces are experienced. Rooted in British manufacturing, Leadflex works alongside lighting designers, interior designers, and architects worldwide. Supporting projects where detail, precision, and execution matter. They're not just a manufacturer. They're a technical partner, providing bespoke solutions, rapid prototyping, commissioning, and long-term support from early concept through final handover.

If light is integral to your architecture, choose a partner who stays with the project. Learn more at ledflexgroup.com. One more company that we know and trust is Diode LED. Lighting performance isn't an add-on. It's the foundation of every successful linear lighting project. Designers need solutions that carry ideas smoothly from specification through installation, and Diode LED is built to support that reality. With industry-leading inventory, reliable delivery, and responsive support, Diode LED keeps pace with real project timelines, not theoretical ones.

Real solutions for real projects, no matter the scale. Learn more about what's happening in Reno, Nevada at diodeLED.com. So obviously, TM30 can zero in on the chroma hue of red, but it could do it for any color. That's right. And you could create that data for any color based on a spectral distribution. That's right. This is almost a mouthful, right? But it's exciting. The trouble becomes, we're so used to just one metric, CRI.

As an industry, how should we go about recognizing while this is, quote, a lot more, there is an opportunity in a way to simplify it so that it can be presented and specified? I'm optimistic in the sense that I believe it's inevitable that we will move towards more sophistication and color rendering specification. I think once people see what TM30 has to offer and the kinds of visual outcomes that we can predict, like preference or vividness,

with this new system, I think it's inevitable that we will move towards a place of more sophistication. How long it takes us to get there, I'm not really sure. But the way to start is for lighting specifiers, lighting designers, lighting engineers to do a little bit of self-education, shoot me an email and ask some questions, and start requesting the data. That way you can start to develop a sense for how my light is rendering colors and what are the performance metrics that are...

associated with the kind of light that I'm already comfortable with. So lighting designers and specifiers already have some light fixtures that they're used to using and they find acceptable or they like. You could request those light sources from your rep or dealer and evaluate them and then try to create some internal feedback towards what my experience is with the light and what the performance metrics are. Mm-hmm. And then at the same time, I think I'd like to see some manufacturers using TM30 as a way of differentiating product, of a way of developing new markets, showing people that light can do more than just match a reference source.

It can change how we perceive different environments and it can be used to optimize vividness for certain kinds of applications or preference and other kinds of applications. Yeah. Like to see more of more sophistication in the way that we deal with color. When that sense and that notion comes forward, people start to do this one year, two year, five years down the road. We've got to document it. What does it look like to try and document TM30 data on a spec sheet or in a fixture schedule or just in a conversation where...

the request can be made and afforded the opportunity to live. The good news is that the data that you need to compute CRI is the same data you need to compute TM30. So if you have access to the spectral power distribution or the manufacturer has computed CRI, in theory, you already have the information you need to compute TM30 metrics. You don't need any more fancy measurement equipment. It's just using the same data we already have access to. If you have the TM30 information and you want to communicate that in a spec sheet, you could do that in a various number of ways.

You can use the metrics directly. So that would be RF, RG, red chroma, red fidelity. The other way to do it is with something called Annex E. So Annex just means appendix. E is A, B, C, D, E. That's the fifth letter of the alphabet and the fifth Annex or appendix of TM30. And in there is a specification table that is meant to reduce the difficulty or complexity that is necessary towards specifying TM30.

So it starts with something called design intent. What is my goal? What do I want to achieve? Lighting designers often start there when they're doing a lighting design anyway. What do I want the space to feel like? Where do I want people to focus? How do I want people to navigate? How do I use light to emphasize different places? So designers are already equipped with thinking about how do I use light to influence how a space feels? We could do the same thing with color by specifying a design intent, like preference, vividness, or fidelity, P, V, or F, and then setting a...

level of difficulty or ease, let's say priority level one, two or three. How important is color rendering in my project? Sometimes color rendering is the most important. Sometimes it isn't. Sometimes we need to consider how complicated lighting design is. We're always trying to balance different things in lighting design, product availability, cost, lead times, budget constraints. availability of Lumen packages and beam spreads. So there are always competing factors and we need to decide how important color rendering is in our project.

So the NXE system gives us the ability to set our design intent, which is what we want to achieve, and how important color is or how strong we're willing to fight for it. And so it's meant to be a flexible system that gives designers the ability to simply specify what they want to achieve and how important it is. That comes in the form of design intent, P, V or F and priority level one, two or three. So a specification might look like P1. if I want a highly preferred light source that I'm sure will meet, will cause the environment to be rendered in a way that people find pleasant or, or pleasing.

And so that it could be as simple as that a P1 lighting specification. And if it was a P1, would CRI be gone? Because P1 creates a set of assumptions then? The NXE system is entirely based on the TM30 system. So in this case, CRI equivalent in the TM30 system is RF, Fidelity, Average Measure of Fidelity. So the NXE system considers... the four metrics I mentioned earlier, RF, RG, red chroma, red saturation.

And it uses those in different combinations to predict these design outcomes with different level of stringency. Alternatively, you could just specify like an RF of 98, similar to a CRI of 98, where the only fundamental difference would be you're benchmarking on 99 samples as opposed to eight samples. Asterisk, asterisk, asterisk. I don't want to, you know, draw conclusions, but... Sure. Well, those of us who are working in this field and we're trying to build metrics to quantify, we need to think about the balance between simplicity and accuracy.

CRI is quote-unquote simple in the sense that it's only one number. If adding a number increases prediction ability, it's also perceived to be a little bit more complex. Two numbers is necessarily more complicated than one. But if we want to have a more... efficient or precise prediction, we need more information. We don't want so many metrics that it's impossible to use.

But if we want a better system, we need more measures. We just do. And so the TM30 and the Annex E system and the IES Color Committee have spent quite a lot of time thinking about how do we have a system that is accurate enough to predict what we want, but also simple to use. And that's what the NXE system is meant to do. It's meant to be a highly precise system that is accurate, but easy to use. So that's where the PVF sort of framework comes from. I want to take a moment to recognize a team that understands what every designer already knows.

Light isn't a fixture, it's the soul of a space. For almost a century, Targetti has shaped how people experience architecture, using precision optics, performance, and that unmistakable sense of Italian design to elevate every moment a space offers. Because light isn't just seen, it's felt. It drives emotion, guides the eye, and transforms intention into atmosphere. For Targetti, light isn't simply the medium. It's the identity, the craft, the legacy, and the commitment behind every solution they create.

Experience it for yourself. Visit TargettiUSA.com. I'm going to give you a couple of myths and let you confirm them or bust them. Okay. One from the manufacturer's side, one from the specifier's side. The first is from the manufacturer's side. I don't want to push TM30 forward as a manufacturer because it's too much work and costs too much money. There will always be effort associated with change. So I won't sit here and say it costs nothing, no work or no effort to...

provide additional information. It will take the additional person power that it would take to take all of the existing products you have and run them through the new calculation engines. So of course, it will take some work. It won't be 100% free. Like we mentioned before, it's the same base data used to calculate CRI as TM30. So in theory, it should be not significantly more complicated. You don't need to spend $20,000 on a new measurement device.

You just need to run the SPD through some calculator tools. The IES publishes an online spectral calculator for TM30 that is free for everybody use. And for anyone who buys and downloads the TM30 standard, it will include a TM30 Excel calculator. So all of the data that you already have can be simply fed through these calculation engines. So for somebody, a manufacturer who wants to have this data, they don't even need to program it themselves necessarily because we've already built calculation tools for them.

The myth of the designer is... I don't possibly want to go redo my specifications. I have to wait for a new project to start using this. I mentioned before that lighting design is hard. There are a lot of things to consider. I sympathize with lighting designers and the profession of lighting design. At the same time, I'm trying to show lighting designers that there might be more options available to them than they previously knew or understood.

If I show them that it's possible to have light that increases vividness that you might want in some kind of applications or increase preference in a way that might be great for some of the projects you're already working on, then hopefully, eventually, they will see the value in doing the additional work of really fighting the uphill battle of change. Change is hard. But I think it's worth it. And I think... Once we get to a point where there's more products available that can do more things, the lighting designer will find it eventually easier than it is now.

But to go from where we are now to where we wanna be requires first understanding where we wanna be the ability to communicate what color can really do, and then really putting in the legwork to try to shift the industry in that direction. You mentioned being worth it, right? And that's part of the myth on both sides of it. Why is it worth it? One of the things that really strikes me about this thing, this whole situation is I do a lot of lecturing.

I teach a lot of people these concepts. I've talked with hundreds of lighting people about TM30 and color rendition. And there are lots of lighting designers who take it seriously. They try to learn it. They learn the concepts. They learn how to communicate about it. But it's still complicated, potentially. But it's still complicated. And it's almost always I have this like universal experience where if I show somebody how preference and vividness and fidelity can... be changed and optimized with different kinds of light, they go, I get it now.

I get why TM30 matters. Like, I get it now. And so there's this element that seeing is believing, however cliche it is for a lighting person to say that. But it is true. And this is why I really encourage lighting designers to get the data, look at light fixtures, try to create that internal feedback loop. Because once you see what the system can allow us to do, Very few people ever say are uninterested after they see what it can do. Is it fair to say that if we were more focused on TM30 data and the metrics behind it, the CRI number, if we actually went backwards for a second, could drop instead of increase, yet we would be happier with the outcome?

Hmm. I think this probably plays to the idea of we don't know what we don't know. In the sense that if I'm running a demonstration and I show people the high preference light source, a light source that's optimized using TM30 and research to... render colors in a way that people like, scientifically demonstrated criteria for this. Let them sit under it for a little while. They get used to it. In the way that our visual system adapts, we acclimate.

Then you go back to the really high CRI, high fidelity light source, and there's always this like, oh, we're back here feeling. And so there's always this feeling that like, again, once you show people what they can have, They're, they're very, they're very interested. And so I think we, like I said earlier, CRI was good for what it was for as long as it was good for, but I think it's time to move on and increase the sophistication of our specification.

What's the toolkit someone needs to take these steps? You mentioned starting to understand what's around you. How do they do that? There's no substitute for experience with light and. I think this, we mentioned earlier, there's sort of an apprehension to change or perceived increase in difficulty. But how did we learn lighting design? We started doing projects. We played with lights. We moved light sources around to look at distribution and how lighting different surfaces impacts how we feel in a space.

And so lighting designers are very familiar with lighting experiential learning. And that's what we need with color too. The best way to learn it is to experience it, is to evaluate products side by side and connect that sense of feeling with the data. And then over time, there will be a sense in which the data is just an outgrowth of our thinking. It just becomes second nature for evaluating lighting design. So I think it's, there's no substitute for experiential learning.

Where can people experience it? Give me a call. Invite me out to your place. Yeah. I mean, you obviously have a demo. I feel like this is a, it's a call to manufacturing too, to consider figuring out how to demonstrate this in their environments. People visit manufacturers all the time. There's lots of reps. There's this concept of showrooms, if they still exist out there, but it's an industry opportunity.

The rest of it, in theory, takes care of itself. You mentioned, you know, better product market, Federer, competitive edge. I can't imagine people not wanting to be interested in that. Right. Besides this podcast, besides giving you a call, what else exists today to give people the resource for this? So another way to engage is engage with the IES. download or purchase the standards. If you're already a member of the IES, you already have access to TM30 and NXE and all of the calculators that we've discussed already.

You can reach out to me and the other co-chair of the color committee. We can find a way to get you engaged with the color committee if you're really deeply interested in this. Yeah, and be engaged in the community. Talk with other lighting designers and other specifiers and manufacturers and explore this together as an industry and recognize that this is something that we're all doing together rather than something that's being forced upon us that we have to use. To take it back to where we started in my Velourcax, if I was selecting a material,

under a light source, how important would it be for me to have what data on it to make sure that I could verify that was going to be there in the field? Is it the four that you mentioned? Yeah, exactly. So I think it's really important to for one, for the interior designer or whoever is picking the finishes to work with the lighting designer to really understand how, what is the performance of the lighting that will end up in the space eventually?

And then trying your best to select your finishes under that light source rather than whatever just happens to be in your office. So taking a little bit more care with how we consider the finishes in the interior environment. Like to see a lot more integration between the interior designer and the lighting professionals on projects. And you have me thinking here on the spot, it's like, there's also potentially an opportunity for when an interior designer selecting finishes to actually like have a dynamic lighting system

so that they could potentially say, well, I want this to look more red. And instead of having to select a different, maybe more expensive finish, you just have a light that can increase that preference without changing that actual material. Yeah. Very real opportunity. Absolutely. So that would be a great way for an interior design professional, for example, to tune in the lighting that might eventually end up on a project. Imagine, for example... you have a really good light source in your office and you choose the finishes based on that light source, but it goes into a space that maybe happens to desaturate reds.

You spend all this time thinking about the red finishes or the gold finishes, and then put it into a space that's going to desaturate reds in a way that people don't like. It's feels like wasted effort to me. So we want to make sure that the final product, the final installation represents, is represented well by the light under which we're making decisions in that case. I mean, it's, it's an encouragement to realize that not just the lighting designers should be doing lighting mock-ups.

Absolutely. Tony, thanks so much. You know, there's a, there's a real opportunity here and the work that you do with the color committee and the work that you do as a professor speaks to the importance of it. So keep it up. Well, thanks Sam. Thanks for having me. I'm really grateful to be here.

Open the transcript file

Hosts and Guests

Nobody is credited on this episode yet.

Credit the people on this episode

Be the first to rate this episode

More episodes

All episodes
  1. Is a Label Real? 2 Lighting Leaders on Compliance, What It $$$, What They'll Never Tell a specifier

    Nov 17, 202659 minAudio

    Anyone can put a compliance icon on a website. Signing your name to it is when it gets real. Host Sam Koerbel sits down with Donna Sumner (Sr. Director, Strategic Operations, Acuity) and Tom Howe (VP Sales, Kelvix) for...

    Credit the people on this episode

  2. The Group Writing the Rules for Lighting + Keeping Them Alive | CEO + Associate Executive Director

    Nov 10, 20261 hr 17 minAudio

    For six straight years, the Illuminating Engineering Society couldn't finish a year in the black. Last year, it finally did. This is what it cost. Colleen Harper (CEO, IES) and Brienne Willcock (Associate Executive...

    Credit the people on this episode

  3. If You Spec Lighting, These 4 Numbers Don't Tell The Whole Truth.

    Nov 3, 20261 hr 6 minAudio

    What happens when two lighting engineers with 30+ years of designing products and reading spec sheets reveal why the four numbers everyone relies on (CRI, CCT, IP ratings, and lumen maintenance) don’t tell the whole...

    Credit the people on this episode

  4. Beauty as Medicine? A Hospital Designer Talks Neuroaesthetics, Design & Healing | Brooke Horan, HDR

    Oct 27, 202630 minAudio

    What happens when a hospital designer reveals why beauty isn’t a luxury - it’s medicine - and why neuroaesthetics proves art, light, and design are critical to healing? In this episode of LytePOD, host Sam Koerbel sits...

    Credit the people on this episode

  5. Why Some Rooms Just Feel Good — A Top Interior Designer on Lighting’s Secret Power | Sarah Kuchar

    Oct 13, 202638 minAudio

    What happens when a top interior designer who's spent a decade crafting unforgettable spaces reveals why lighting isn't just another layer in the design - it's the secret weapon that makes or breaks whether a room feels...

    Credit the people on this episode