Skip to content
PodSubs
ShowsPeopleGuestsJobsNewsEvents
More
BlogPodCred
Menu
ShowsPeopleGuestsJobsNewsEventsBlogPodCredNetworksSign in
Join nowSign in
  • Shows
  • People
  • Jobs
  • News
  • More
    • Guests
    • Events
    • Blog
    • PodCred
    • Networks
    Join nowSign in

Kültürkampf

Kültürkampf artwork

Live chat on Venezuela-Turkey

Jan 7, 202615 minAudio

This is a free preview of a paid episode. To hear more, visit kulturkampftr.substack.com Hi folks, We’re back from break! In the new year, Nick and I thought that we’d try to do more of these live recordings to react to things in the news. The podcast will be reserved for weighty guests and book reviews. Note that live streams are quite a bit less formal than the podcast. The intros are often clunky because we’re waiting for people to trickle…

Audio and video play straight from the show's own hosting. PodSubs stores and serves no media.

Transcript

From the show. Tap a time to play from there.

SPEAKER_00Okay, so let's just get straight into it. For long-time listeners of the podcast, we thought that we'd do this whenever big news happens, right? And we'd preserve the podcast for book talks and more planned stuff. So hopefully, yeah, you'll tune into this as well as the other stuff. Yeah.

SPEAKER_00And yeah. And everybody, you can just, you know, people can write in. Yeah. I can write messages, ask questions. Yeah. And I thought we'd start with that little tidbit of information that was in a New York Times story, I think a couple of days ago, where it starts with Maduro could have ended up in Turkey, right?

SPEAKER_01And he didn't- It does seem like you made the wrong choice.

SPEAKER_00Yeah, it does. It does. Which suggests that obviously they must have talked about this with Erdogan. They must have talked about it with him and said, well, listen, would you like to take in Maduro? Or the other way around. I mean, you think Erdogan suggested it? possible it's possible i mean he does like to get involved in everything doesn't he he loves the idea of being the mediator and i mean i i've had

my theories about this about this sort of uh being washington's guy in in the the the sort of third

SPEAKER_00world or or post-colonial world, non-Western world, whatever have you, right? The global South. I don't like that role.

SPEAKER_01And it was striking because at some point, I guess before the holidays, a lot of op-eds started showing up being like, you know, could Maduro find refuge in Turkey? Could Turkey help broker a way out of this? And it was clear that this was somehow under discussion and people who were enthusiastic about this and were trying to promote a positive agenda for U.S. Turkey had latched onto this as something that could happen. You know, which again, it looks like, all right, they were clearly basing that on some real discussions. But it... It also highlighted for me,

SPEAKER_01I mean, the challenge is there's more to being a successful moderator than just really wanting to be a moderator. There's more than, you know, the challenge is actually pulling these things off, whether it's negotiating Maduro's exit, whether it's solving the war in Ukraine. And that's, yeah, I mean, again, to sort of criticize Turkey for failing, it's really difficult to, you know, since there's no, like, negotiating a successful resolution of this conflict was not going to be an easy thing to do,

SPEAKER_00but. With the other ones as well, like the war in Ukraine, that is not easy to do. Exactly. You know, and various other conflicts, you know, Libya, many, many others. But I found, I mean, one of the things that strikes me about this is that there is now a discussion among the elite, right? Like people who run countries and big corporations like

billionaires and people

SPEAKER_00like that of, you know, regarding Turkey and what it is and what kind of role it fulfills. Yeah. And then there's a discussion that's much more popular on the popular level on the internet. And because I found that being online, a lot of people... found that when they look at the Maduro thing, they do see Erdogan.

SPEAKER_00And quite a lot of that is obviously wishful thinking. People who hate Erdogan are going to say, well, yeah, maybe he gets abducted by the United States as well. Wouldn't that be cool or something like that? When obviously Erdogan is on the other side of this power equation. But still, people keep coming back to it, which suggests to me that there is a part of political reality where this

SPEAKER_00country... people feel like they're on the global south part of the equation, even though the elite of Turkey feel like they're much closer to the global north side of the equation, right? And that is by design in the Erdoğan system, right? Which I think that raises all kinds of questions, like, you know, where's the country headed and

SPEAKER_01But how, I mean, I know you, I feel like you're getting at that you don't think this is sustainable.

SPEAKER_00Yeah, I mean, one of the lessons of the whole Venezuela thing is that, well, in Venezuela, right? Hugo Chavez took power, what, in 98 or something, right? Early 2000s, he was really big. And he was wildly popular all the time as he just ran the country to the ground. really awful. The amount of state failure in Venezuela is really staggering, right? And anybody who I think who's taken the trouble to Google this

SPEAKER_00will not compare it to Turkey. These are very different countries. Well, and Venezuela was always presented as the nightmare scenario for Turkey. Like when things started going wrong with the economy and the moments after the

SPEAKER_01coup when things really seemed, kind of looked like they could go in an ugly direction, it was always the worst case scenario people always pointed to was like, You know, not that it would, I mean, people always have, as we discussed in the last podcast, a lot of different comparisons and scenarios, but Venezuela was always like, shit could get really bad. And I remember at some point the Turkish government even reached out to Maduro for like economic advice or something. And I remember people really freaking out at the time and they kind of stopped talking about that because it was,

SPEAKER_00I mean, especially because of inflation, right? Um, like the countries showed up next to each other on a lot of sort of indicators of inflation and stuff like that. But yeah, I think, I mean, obviously there's like, Venezuela is so mismanaged that there was, Famine problems, people fleeing by the millions. Right, just catastrophic numbers. Yeah, yeah. You know,

SPEAKER_00you could talk about brain drain in Turkey and stuff like that, but it's not the same thing, right? It's very different. But the thing is, you know, on the other hand, maybe... Turkey's a really great place for rich people now, but for poorer people, I don't know. I mean, there are malnutrition problems that are pretty well documented in Turkey now, and they're growing, right?

SPEAKER_00There are problems for the many, certainly not the few, but for the many, there are many, many problems that they're growing. And there's no reason to think, I think, that post-Erdogan at some point, those problems will get better. Um,

SPEAKER_01Well, and that's the other weird thing with the whole dynamic you're talking about, that it's on one hand, you know, I mean, people do want to show solidarity with the global South. People do want to show that they're, you know, Turkey standing alongside Venezuela or Iran, as the case may be. But no one wants to live like people in Venezuela or Iran. No one wants to deal with the catastrophic economic consequences that result, you know, fairly or unfairly from taking that kind of oppositional stance towards the West.

SPEAKER_00Yeah.

SPEAKER_01So we'll see. I mean, yeah. Oh, I don't know. I was going to, like, at some level, you know, give Erdogan credit for being pretty good at managing the sort of getting the emotional satisfaction, getting the publicity of being in solidarity with, you know, the forces of the global south while still You know, like you said, actually not saying on good terms. I mean, you also hear these conspiracy theories that, oh, like behind the scenes, everything's always been fine between Erdogan and the U.S. and this is all public performance.

SPEAKER_01You know, not saying that at all, but just really being good at calibrating the degree of resistance, the forms of resistance. Not to say it's just to get maximum public benefit while still not always as effectively as they want, but still minimizing the amount of real backlash. You know, which isn't to say it doesn't happen. I mean, there's a reason the economy is struggling the way it is. There's a reason Turkey's not getting back in the F-35 program. There's a reason,

SPEAKER_01you know, all this stuff is, these tensions are real and they have consequences. But it's, you know, for what's a difficult balancing act, you know, they're doing it well.

SPEAKER_00Yeah, what was it? Tom Barak recently, a few weeks ago, said that, well, Turkish... That Turkish rhetoric on Israel was just rhetoric, that it wasn't anything real.

SPEAKER_01And whether that's true or not, if you can get the U.S. ambassador to say that, that's like half the battle.

SPEAKER_00Yeah, exactly. I thought that was impressive. That they've been able to get to a point where they can have him say that, right? Even though I think... It would be very difficult to say. It's obvious that the Erdogan palace has a line to Israel, and that they are talking. It's not like they are talking, that they're inherently unreasonable. People think of these things in terms of,

are people ideological or are they pragmatic?

SPEAKER_00Right? And that's just a false binary. Everybody's ideological and pragmatic, right? If you weren't pragmatic, then you'd get nothing done. And if you weren't ideological, then you'd have nothing to sort of combine people into. You wouldn't have any drive, right? Yeah. Yeah, so it's a false dichotomy, I think.

SPEAKER_01Well, and to bring this back to Venezuela, it seems like part of what the Trump administration hasn't necessarily thought through, you know, that they decided they'd get rid of Maduro and then they'd find, you know, they'd work with Rodrigo's government as the kind of new, you know, bring them to power instead of having a democratic transition, which is probably less catastrophic, but not necessarily effective. I mean, I think they seem to think like, okay, now we've got Maduro gone and we have someone pragmatic in charge.

And it does seem like at some level Rodriguez is willing to work with the United

SPEAKER_01States, but not, I suspect, anywhere near to the degree that Trump people imagine. And it does seem like they've kind of thought well, like, okay, now that we've got, now that we've showed our power, we'll, you know, they'll be reasonable, they'll be cooperative, we can get what we want. And it's not, there's, as you were saying, there's a lot of space in between. Yeah, I mean, my impression, and, you know, you probably have thoughts on this.

SPEAKER_00I mean, the options were, like, maintain some of the people in power or have, what's her name, Machado? uh come in and the new york times reported recently that they weren't on good terms with machado that that they couldn't make it work but even then it's it's probably useful to have this sort of outside opposition figure and not to have her come in that that supports the you know rodriguez sort of uh uh

SPEAKER_00side of the equation, right? And it's saying, well, we could have had this person that we're much closer to come in and take over the country, but we're not doing that. Probably useful to them.

SPEAKER_01You mean in putting more pressure on the Maduro regime now to say, okay, on one hand, we sort of put you in power by moving Maduro, but on the other hand, if you piss us off, we have other people that we can try to

SPEAKER_00Yeah, yeah. While also allowing them to have some kind of authority in the country.

SPEAKER_01I mean, that's what's sad. As much as, I mean, the level of cynicism revealed by just doing this switch at the top and then using military pressure to try to get them to do what we want, as cynical as that is, I mean, the sad fact is it's still, in as many ways as it could go wrong, still probably better than if they'd really tried to somehow decapitate or bring down the entire regime and actually implement regime change with no boots on there. I mean, that could have been sort of violently catastrophic instead of just

SPEAKER_01then again, this could still be, so.

SPEAKER_00That could still, yeah, be really awful.

SPEAKER_01But what, I mean, is the, like, it's the whole opposition response to Erdogan having such a passive response to this. I mean, it was fascinating to see you know, him essentially being called out for having failed to follow through on his, you know, numerous claims of solidarity with Maduro. And it also, it made me wonder too, you know, is, do people in a situation like this, do people actually want to see some real display of solidarity?

SPEAKER_01Or, you know, do people, even if in their hearts, you know, I mean, in their hearts, they'd love to see Erdogan show solidarity with Maduro. They recognize that there's probably not much he can do. And they, you know, maybe Erdogan supporters are in a way being fair to Erdogan and saying, you know, yeah, we kind of know that he's posturing. We know that he's saying the right things. We know that he's also too pragmatic. We don't want him to destroy our economy even further by picking a fight over this with America. But we're glad to know that,

you know, emotionally he stands with Maduro, which we do too.

SPEAKER_01I mean, I don't know how... Yeah. Well, I mean, my...

Open the transcript file

Hosts and Guests

Nobody is credited on this episode yet.

Credit the people on this episode

Be the first to rate this episode

More episodes

All episodes
  1. Live recording with Selim & Nick: AI in Turkey and the developing world

    Sep 18, 202621 minAudio

    This is a free preview of a paid episode. To hear more, visit kulturkampftr.substack.com Hi folks, Nick and I are back with live recordings! This week we talked about AI in Turkey, which was the topic of my essay on...

    Credit the people on this episode

  2. From Syria: has the SDF dissolved? Plus the latest in Turkey's talks with the PKK

    Sep 14, 202620 minAudio

    This is a free preview of a paid episode. To hear more, visit kulturkampftr.substack.com Hi folks, Alexander McKeever and I held a live discussion on Friday. You can listen and watch above. For those who don’t know,...

    Credit the people on this episode

  3. Can You Explain Istanbul?

    Jul 30, 202629 minAudio

    This is a free preview of a paid episode. To hear more, visit kulturkampftr.substack.com Hi folks, We’re back with another episode of the podcast! This is a big one. Some of you will remember that I wrote a review of...

    Credit the people on this episode

  4. Football nationalism; emigration from Turkey

    Jun 20, 20269 minAudio

    This is a free preview of a paid episode. To hear more, visit kulturkampftr.substack.com Hi folks, Nick and I did a live chat yesterday. As the title suggests, we talked about the politics of the World Cup, as well as...

    Credit the people on this episode

  5. Hungary's lessons for Turkey; latest in Iran War; listener questions

    Apr 17, 202638 minAudio

    This is a public episode. If you'd like to discuss this with other subscribers or get access to bonus episodes, visit kulturkampftr.substack.com/subscribe

    Credit the people on this episode