This is a free preview of a paid episode. To hear more, visit kulturkampftr.substack.com Hi folks, Nick and I are back with live recordings! This week we talked about AI in Turkey, which was the topic of my essay on Wednesday (below). Much about the discussion about AI is understandably about the Western world, but I think the social problems this technology creates are more serious in places like Turkey. Give it a listen, tell us what you th…
Audio and video play straight from the show's own hosting. PodSubs stores and serves no media.
Transcript
From the show. Tap a time to play from there.
SPEAKER_01So, I guess two things to discuss today, and they're very different things. The first topic we thought we'd talk about is the way AI, what AI feels like in developing countries, and the one we're familiar with is Turkey, right? And how that might be different from the discussion in Turkey. The United States, obviously, but also Europe a little bit.
SPEAKER_01And then the second topic is Syria, the SDF, what's going on specifically in Northeast Syria and Southeast Turkey, right? The Kurdish question, because there's a lot of movement on that.
SPEAKER_00I like how we've just leaned into the bifurcated nature of this podcast. We do like half topics that everyone's interested in and then half super niche turkey topics that no one else is interested in. I think it's a great approach.
SPEAKER_01Yeah, that's the direction the whole thing is going, isn't it? I like it though.
SPEAKER_00Yeah, start big and then the real hardcore people can stay on for the Kurdish question. Yeah, yeah.
SPEAKER_01But I mean, on the AI question, I mean, I wrote about this this week. I don't want to be like, I don't want to be saying, okay, nobody's talking about this and we're going to talk about it. Because I started the week off thinking, okay, what am I going to write about this week? I didn't know, right? And that can be kind of a tense question. And then I somewhat thought of this topic and I'm like, why aren't more people talking about it? Yeah.
SPEAKER_00But is anyone talking about it at the cultural level? Because we do get these pitches for big pieces about how different countries in the world are adopting AI at the government level. And it's all very bureaucratic. And it's about, you know, are there countries that are leapfrogging because of their different kinds of infrastructure? And they all tend to be boring pieces. But it's a potentially interesting topic, but still less interesting than the one you wrote about, I think.
SPEAKER_01I mean, that's the sort of tight-ass discussion of like, oh, there's this huge industry now of like macro AI discussions, right? Is AI agentic? What does agentic mean? Is there going to be superintelligence? How should these firms be regulated, et cetera? You know, how to think of chips? And all of those questions are, of course, very, very important. Yeah. But they detract from real issues, which is how does it impact people's lives right now?
SPEAKER_01And how does it impact different people's lives in different places differently? In my blog post, I write briefly about how in the sort of Turkish-speaking half of my life, I see a lot more AI slop than I see in the English-speaking part of my life, which is more sort of It's kind of a function, I think, of developmental level at some point.
SPEAKER_01If you go to a developing country, if you go to Istanbul versus, I don't know, Stockholm, Istanbul is going to be a lot more colorful. The buildings aren't going to be synchronized in the way that they are going to be in Stockholm. People don't dress in that uniform way. People are more all over the place. It's kind of intrinsic to the way the world is structured now.
SPEAKER_01So I think we've kind of taken for granted that, yeah, of course the Turkish part of my life would have more AI slop. At the same time, there isn't really a Turkish word for AI slop, right? It's just the water that we swim in now in the Turkish-speaking discussion. But there isn't the nuance yet of defining it, talking about it, etc. that has already started to happen a little bit in the English-speaking world.
SPEAKER_01And that's really important, I think, to defend the human.
SPEAKER_00I mean, it's worth just spelling out too. You mean there's more AI slop in Turkish, not just, you know, because I think when I searched Sire Post, I was like, well, obviously like Turkish, Turks writing in English, there'd be more AI slop because there's a translation issue. But you mean like actually in Turkish, there's more AI slop.
SPEAKER_01Yeah, so at the bottom of the piece, I add some like Turks writing English and how there's more AI involved there, which is, I think, understandable to a great degree. But yeah, to your point, in Turkish, there is a lot more AI. You know, every Friday, if you're in a group chat or something with slightly conservative people, you're going to get like, oh, have a blessed Friday message of some sort. And for the past like 10 years, that was like, you know, a picture of a rose or something.
SPEAKER_01And then it says, it was cursive letters, you know, and stuff like that, you know, have a blessed Friday. Now that's like, you know, the image I use in that piece is like a girl praying and then there's like a pattern of roses and stuff that's coming off. So it's an AI generated moving image of some sort. That's now wishing you a blessed Friday or something.
SPEAKER_01There's all the images that I come across seem to be AI generated. Or a cousin of mine had twins recently. And sent this AI generated message to our broad family group chat where he was like, okay, you know, about When people could come visit, when they shouldn't, etc. And that was kind of weird.
SPEAKER_01That was kind of bureaucratic and weird, I thought. Or the same cousin. He did another thing, which I thought was actually kind of cool. Whenever somebody has a birthday in our broad family group chat, there'll be people... Wish them a happy birthday or something. So he had AI composed poems to these people. An uncle of mine, he's a businessman.
SPEAKER_01He installed heating equipment and stuff into buildings. So it was like an epic poem of how he kept people warm and stuff like that.
SPEAKER_00And that's like, that's sensitive because composing shitty poems is kind of one of my like skills that I'm most proud of. If you're having a birthday, I'm going to write you a stupid poem that I composed and that's going to be a pure expression of my...
SPEAKER_01I mean, I thought that one was kind of funny. At the same time, some people thought it was real. So they thought, oh, you know, my cousin had gone above and beyond. And then another uncle had his birthday and another poem. Um, So people thought that my cousin was sitting there at his desk, you know, really making an effort. Well, it just wasn't. But also just in everyday life, if you walk around a city like Istanbul,
SPEAKER_01you're about to see a lot of AI-generated images in a way that I don't see around here in London all that much.
SPEAKER_00Wait, did we talk about this during, I think for Ramadan, people had those... I think you had one at one point, the weird sort of cozy Ottoman background, like Zoom backgrounds. Oh. And those were the most fascinating to me because they were like, I mean, it was undeniably Ottoman. Like the whole aesthetic was that sort of, you know, Ottoman nostalgia. But somehow they also made it look like a cozy Christmas background.
SPEAKER_00There was this like weird AI syncretism going on where like, I don't know, two different cultures version of cozy religious, you know, kind of got conflated somehow.
SPEAKER_01While I was researching this piece, I went through a lot of news reports of how different news agencies in Turkey, for example, use AI. And in those reports, they use a lot of AI-generated images. And all these AI-generated images of the Turkish media being like, you know, hyper-modern in this one sense, but also there was one where it was like there's a tent in the desert
SPEAKER_01and there's robots in it, right? So the AI clearly thought that Turkey was this hyper-Oriental 19th century Arabia type of place that was also super technological. It was just Very, very strange. Yeah, I mean, that's going on. And beyond the aesthetic level as well, there is the same stuff that's happening everywhere else with universities.
SPEAKER_01People just AI generate all of their homework now.
SPEAKER_00For people who haven't read the blog post, though, give a quick version of the thesis here, because I do think that's...
SPEAKER_01So I made a two-fold argument. So I argued that AI damages society and culture, right? I think that's a given. Right. But I think it damages developing countries, society and culture more than it does developed countries. And there's two reasons for it. The first is cultural, right? Developing countries often have a catch-up mentality, right?
SPEAKER_01And because in recent history they've had to adapt technology coming from behind, so like Think of railroads, for example, or computers. The developed world, the United States and Europe especially, had adopted these technologies and then you had to sort of catch up, right? But it's no longer the case with stuff like AI because everybody kind of jumps
SPEAKER_01into it together, right? But there's still this developmental mentality and that means that you're Less likely to be suspicious of new technologies like AI, and more likely to just jump into it, assume that it's going to be the next big thing, and you're just in this sort of hustle to adapt as fast as possible. That's one. And two, there's a more structural argument, which is that with something like AI,
SPEAKER_01you really need strong institutions to To resist the negative effects, right? You need to have a strong education system. You need to have strong universities. You need to have a strong media, right? In order to absorb that new technology well, I think. And, of course, globally, I think, especially traditionally, We're in the neoliberal era, right?
SPEAKER_0140 years into it. Obviously, all our institutions are suffering, right? But in a place like Turkey, institutions are in a far worse place than they are in a place like the United States, right? So society, there's nothing really standing between this new technology and society. So the harm is just going to be exponentially worse, I think. It's definitely going to be worse, I think.
SPEAKER_00The first part of it's so depressing because it's like, you know, all this stuff by, whether it's historians writing about Ottoman history or people, the sort of fantasy version of what kind of AKP alternative modernity was supposed to be. You know, there's this whole idea of like, oh, look, these non-Western societies will, you know, adopt aspects of Western technological modernity in their own way, in keeping with their own values in a way that, you know, some of the really idealistic stuff where it was like, Especially going back a century,
SPEAKER_00you know, marrying the technological progress of the West to the eternal values and sophistication of the East and creating a new synthesis that was going to be somehow a superior form of modernity, which, yeah, at your point, is a nice idea, but the other option is just that it ends up with the worst of both worlds.
SPEAKER_01Yeah, and also because technology is now so fast, It just, we have no time to absorb it, to weigh it. Our governments aren't really working in our interest anymore in a real sense. Yeah, so whatever. Also, the AK Party, I think, has really exposed, we couldn't have done this anyway without the AK Party, but they've really exposed the idea of this alternative modernity
SPEAKER_01for just being hollow. Entirely. I mean, uh-huh.
SPEAKER_00But also to the extent there's any pushback against AI slot in the West, and it was depressing reading your piece and being like, oh man, this is like, the American version is the positive alternative, we're really fucked. But, you know, it's not that the government, God knows, is doing anything or, you know, even any of these big institutions. It's like sort of these smaller institutions or small kind of professional self-respect, professional pride, which, you know, it's interesting because you've seen in certain areas,
SPEAKER_00that's like the one place where, you know, be it against Trump's authoritarianism, you've actually seen like And in part, it seems like it's because... And even when Trump was attacking law firms,
SPEAKER_00it wasn't necessarily that the people standing up to him, such as they were, were doing so because they had strong political or moral convictions. They had this sort of sense of like, we're proud of what we do. We have this craft, like our craft means doing X, Y, and Z. And like, we're upset about perverting that. And it seems like with AI, that's kind of, you know, that the publications that are pushing back against AI, the ones that have a really sort of holding contributors, you know, at least for us at Foreign Policy, you know, to a strict line about AI use.
SPEAKER_00It's not like out of any kind of deeper political sense or social mission. It's just like journalism is what we do. Good writing is what we do. We have the sense of like, And so, yeah, it leaves less resistance at that individual or in that sort of micro level.
SPEAKER_01I think that's a really interesting connection, yeah. This idea that, I mean, there was an old idea that, okay, if you're middle class, if you're bourgeois, right, you can, I mean, when people talk about resistance to fascism, for example, if you're middle class, if you're bourgeois, you don't really have to resist all that hard. I mean, you might because you have certain ideas that go against this, right? You have ideas of decency, et cetera, and you resist.
SPEAKER_01But more broadly, the working classes will kind of have to resist. That kind of idea exists. Whereas with this, yeah, the resistance to this kind of conflates those two things. It's about basic decency, but also you kind of have to put up a fight. Otherwise, you can very clearly see that It's leading into a place where you're going
SPEAKER_01to be redundant or that your entire industry, the things you value, right? Not just individual publications, but the act of reading and writing itself and thinking is going to disappear. And you have to kind of put up a fight some way,
SPEAKER_00shape or form.
SPEAKER_01Of course, I mean, yeah, in the United States, There is limited resistance in some sense, right? But on the other sense, there is quite a bit as well. If you compare it to a place like Turkey. Because you still have major publications like the New York Times, the New Yorker, across the pond you have the Financial Times. All these places where these are mainstream, powerful institutions that
SPEAKER_01They are putting up a fight. Whereas in Turkey, it absolutely does not exist anymore. There is a left-wing kind of publishing world that writes everything itself, I think. And those people don't even have to put up a sign saying, we write everything ourselves. Of course they do. Birikim isn't going to use AI to put their stuff out there.
SPEAKER_01I'd be very surprised if there was much AI involved. Sometimes the text is impenetrable, sometimes it's not great, but it's always going to be there because you have those leftist guys thinking, okay, I need to make sense of the situation and write way too long essays on various topics. I mean, that's the raison d'être of that place. But yeah, we'll see.
SPEAKER_00Can I ask, can you tell, is AI writing better or worse in Turkish? Is there, like, relative to English?
SPEAKER_01So, it's worse. I believe it's demonstrably worse. Okay, so... A few things. So AI processing is worse in Turkish. It's very, very clear because AI systems, the big AI systems, I believe maybe all AI systems, are trained on languages other than Turkish and most of them, the vast majority of them are trained in English.
SPEAKER_01And Turkish is not an easy language for them to understand because Turkish is
This is a free preview of a paid episode. To hear more, visit kulturkampftr.substack.com Hi folks, Alexander McKeever and I held a live discussion on Friday. You can listen and watch above. For those who don’t know,...
This is a free preview of a paid episode. To hear more, visit kulturkampftr.substack.com Hi folks, We’re back with another episode of the podcast! This is a big one. Some of you will remember that I wrote a review of...
This is a free preview of a paid episode. To hear more, visit kulturkampftr.substack.com Hi folks, Nick and I did a live chat yesterday. As the title suggests, we talked about the politics of the World Cup, as well as...
This is a public episode. If you'd like to discuss this with other subscribers or get access to bonus episodes, visit kulturkampftr.substack.com/subscribe
This is a free preview of a paid episode. To hear more, visit kulturkampftr.substack.com Hi folks, It’s been a hell of a week. I’m working on a couple of essays exploring the Turkish angle of this Israeli-American war...