Skip to content
PodSubs
ShowsPeopleGuestsJobsNewsEvents
More
BlogPodCred
Menu
ShowsPeopleGuestsJobsNewsEventsBlogPodCredNetworksSign in
Join nowSign in
  • Shows
  • People
  • Jobs
  • News
  • More
    • Guests
    • Events
    • Blog
    • PodCred
    • Networks
    Join nowSign in

Immersion

Immersion artwork

Ending Excess Screen Time (Habits that actually work)

May 10, 202626 minAudio
ShareXLinkedInFacebookWhatsAppEmail

We’ve all heard the basic advice: turn off notifications, put your phone in grayscale, or just "try harder." But if you’re like me, those tips didn't stick. After years of experimentation and diving into the psychology of habit formation, I’ve finally found a system that is working for me. In this episode (Part 2 of our series on technology), we are moving past the philosophy and getting into more specific action steps. We’re talking about building friction, managing decision fatigue, and finding the "why" that actually keeps you away from the screen. In this episode, we discuss: The Power of Friction: Lockboxes, website blockers, and "dumb phones." Beating Decision Fatigue: Creating a "Guidelines List" so you don't have to make constant difficult choices. Drilling Down to Your "Why": Finding a compelling reason to change. Why adding fulfilling activities is better than just "stopping" (Shout-out to Cal Newport and his "Deep Life" work!). Analog Switches: Why using tools such as paper planners, watches, and physical notepads helps more than we may have initially thought. Timestamps: 00:00 Intro: The bold claim about ending screen time 01:10 Strategic Friction: Using lockboxes & blockers to break the habit 07:20 Ending Decision Fatigue: How to create your "Guidelines List" 15:39 The Deep Life: Why "just stopping" doesn't work (inspired by Cal Newport) 17:29 The Core Shift: Digging to your compelling "Why" 19:27 Analog Wins: The psychology of paper, pens, and watches 23:46 Join the Conversation: How to leave a voice note (SpeakPipe) 24:33 A Personal Note: Life update & why the schedule changed Resources and Episodes Mentioned: Changing Your Relationship With Technology (Part 1): https://www.buzzsprout.com/2318937/episodes/17789635 Finding Purpose and Meaning: https://www.buzzsprout.com/2318937/episodes/18932472 How to Organize Your Mind: https://www.buzzsprout.com/2318937/episodes/17960805 Cal Newport’s The Deep Life Podcast: https://www.thedeeplife.com/ Gretchen Rubin: Abstainers vs. Moderators: https://gretchenrubin.com/articles/abstainer-vs-moderator/ Write in to the show here Leave a voice message here Newsletter sign up YouTube - channel Instagram - we will be posting here soon

Audio and video play straight from the show's own hosting. PodSubs stores and serves no media.

Transcript

From the show. Tap a time to play from there.

SPEAKER_00Okay, so I normally hate these types of YouTube videos or podcasts where people say, stop too much screen time once and for all, as if they're going to have the solution for such a complicated problem. But I have spent years focused on this in my personal life. And I truly believe I have found a way to end my destructive screen time once and for all. So I would love to share with you what I have found. This is a follow-up to an episode that I did called Change Your Relationship with Technology, but that focused more on why it matters so much to change these more like philosophically, how to approach this, but this is more tangible.

SPEAKER_00And if you have tried stuff like grayscale and putting a rubber band around your phone, so you have to take the rubber band off and ask why you're using it. And if none of that stuff worked, if even screen time limits on your phone haven't worked because you know that password and you can just put it in when you want to get back on Instagram. This episode is for you. Welcome to Immersion, 30 minutes beneath the surface. Here we apply psychology and philosophy to find meaning in the modern world. Let's dive in.

SPEAKER_00So we're going to break this down into four separate components. The first one is creating friction. And you might feel as though you've done this before too. For instance, the one we just talked about, where you put in an app limit through your iPhone and then you go on Instagram, you hit the app limit, and then it kicks you out. But if you're anything like me, that takes about five seconds to just put in the password and get back on the app. So it really wasn't that much of a deterrent. If we're going to be creating friction to make it harder to do the things that you want to be doing less of, then it needs to be actual friction.

SPEAKER_00It needs to make it difficult for you to do those things. So we're talking about lock boxes. We're talking about actual blockers for certain websites. Now, it is important to remember that no matter what you're doing, for the most part, with very few exceptions, you can undo these things. Unless you've paid someone to literally stand over you and slap your computer shut if you're not doing what you want to do. Most of these things you can undo. Or I think I've heard of some people that know how to code using these different websites and then changing the code so that they can't put in a password when they want to get around it.

SPEAKER_00But for the most part, we want to create the amount of friction that at least makes it harder for you so that you really have to stop and ask, wait, do I want to be doing this? Or it just makes it so annoying that you don't feel like it anymore. Because half the time that we do something, like check our text or email in the middle of the day, we don't really get that much from it. I mean, how often do you check your text or email and you get something so amazing that the little dopamine spike was just totally worth it? Probably like 1% of the time or less, compared to the 99% of the time where you just interrupted your flow, you feel a little bit worse about yourself because you're not keeping any kind of structure that helps your life feel streamlined for what matters to you.

SPEAKER_00The ones that have been helping me the most is getting actual blockers for certain websites on my computer. There are different apps like Jomo. There are some that actually have more control over your computer, like self-control. I remember using that in college. I don't really want to give an app that much control over my computer at this phase, but that is something that you can look into. And yes, again, similar to the screen time limits earlier, you can put in a code, but I think that there's also a certain novelty aspect when you install a new limit or a new app, there is a fresh start effect of, oh wow, I have this thing and I can choose to honor it compared to, at least for me, part of the reason I would always put in the combination in my iPhone so much for screen time limits there is because I was so used to doing it that I almost wasn't even noticing myself do it anymore.

SPEAKER_00So when you get a different app, there's a chance that it could help you start fresh. But also I think that there's one extra layer they have on the certain website. You know, do you really want to be here right now? And you have to actually like open the app and change the settings versus again just typing in four quick numbers in your phone. So I do find it a little bit different. Another thing I am doing is I got a flip phone. So excited about it. And it is going to be my personal phone, and then I'm going to keep my iPhone for work purposes and necessary apps.

SPEAKER_00There are so many great other videos out there that helped inspire me to do this. A lot of people will permanently just go to a quote dumb phone. But I think that it can be really difficult when there's a lot of apps these days that make it feel pretty necessary to have a smartphone. Of course, there's ways around it, but it was going to be such a pain for me personally that I decided that if my smartphone is so unappealing that I don't feel like using it very much, using it for a necessary app like Brivo Pass to get into a place that I have access to, like it's a key.

SPEAKER_00That's not an addictive app. If Instagram is not on it, if Reddit is not on it, YouTube is not on it, if I don't personally, I don't even have email or safari on it. There are ways to take Safari off or at least hide it. So I can't even just go down different rabbit holes on my phone. My phone is boring. I don't get news alerts. I get no notifications. It is simply right now a tool for what it was intended for. I do allow podcasts, audiobooks, music because these are things that I usually multitask with.

SPEAKER_00So for instance, if I'm procrastinating and doing laundry, I actually find it a net gain to put on a podcast and do the laundry with that on. Which brings me to another point, which is we need to evaluate how we're using tech. And for each aspect, ask, is this making my life better or worse? I think sometimes we can get in a frame of mind where you try to reduce all tech. But if a certain aspect is making your life better, there's no problem with it. But I'm getting ahead of myself here a little bit. So let me finish up the friction aspect.

SPEAKER_00I have a lockbox with a literal lock in my apartment where I will put my phone at certain times. Actually, for the holidays this past year, I had asked for that for Christmas, which was a um unplug box. I believe it was from Etsy or something. It's beautiful, it's wooden, and then it has a lock on it. But there are other types. If you want even a little bit more friction, I believe there's some that lock for a set amount of time and won't open until that time is over. And of course, there are tools like the brick or other types of software and hardware that you can use.

SPEAKER_00But the idea is asking what are the ways that I'm using technology that I don't want to be? And then how can I create friction? This is a behavior change 101 principle of just making things harder that you don't want to be doing. And then, of course, for habits we want to add, we can make them easier. But that would be for things like adding exercise. But right now we are focusing on screen time. So we'll keep going. Another thing that I am doing, guidelines. We want to reduce decision fatigue.

SPEAKER_00You've probably heard of decision fatigue in the context of having certain clothes like a work wardrobe. So you don't have to think so much about what am I going to wear today. With tech, if you are constantly saying, I want to reduce screen time, when should I use my phone? Oh no, I just used my phone too long. Oopsie, that is not going to fly. We want to have guidelines so that you don't even have to question when and in what capacities you are using your phone and laptop. And I do want to touch on the laptop because often we talk about screen time and I feel like scrolling and phones gets so much press, but I personally waste more time on my laptop because my phone is already pretty unappealing.

SPEAKER_00But I am prone to curiosity, rabbit holes, Reddit dives. That is my struggle. It's really important to do an inventory and ask what is your specific struggle? And then troubleshoot specific to that. What I'm sharing here is what works for me. But if you personally have issues with the news or Netflix or gaming, you need to find what is the root cause of that and what can you do to make that change?

SPEAKER_00So for instance, if someone is gaming more than they want to, is it because it's more of like a neurobiology addiction and they need to seek some help for that? Is it because they don't have enough exciting things going on in their life? So it feels like the only fulfilling challenge or community that they have access to. Is it because they're not really sure what they want to be doing in life? So they feel like they're lacking purpose and then succeeding at the game gives them that. That's kind of tied to the last one. But no matter what your problem area is, and again, problem is subjective.

SPEAKER_00We're asking, is this making your life better or worse? To use it to the extent that you are. And then we're making changes. So we make these rules around that. For instance, one thing that's kind of, I don't know if I would say this is embarrassing, but it seems silly to me. The thing that I would really struggle with most is texting because I haven't had social media on my phone, I think since like 2016. I just download it to post and then maybe see what a couple friends have posted.

SPEAKER_00If I happen to be on there, I use it more for work and then I just delete it. Of course, I'll respond to DMs or something when I'm on, but generally I do most of that once a week from a desktop. It's just not my main thing I struggle with. But because I am a strength coach for my work, I often am coordinating with clients. And if I'm about to leave the house and I don't know if someone's canceled and I shouldn't be leaving the house, I will often check my text. Or I go to check my text and three clients have texted me: one about food, one about changing their appointment time for next week.

SPEAKER_00I could go on here. But the point is that due to my work, I started checking text a lot. But then that created a situation where I would often respond to friends or family faster. And while I wasn't on Instagram or WhatsApp or checking email all the time, I was texting regularly. And if I looked at my screen time, it was kind of shocking how much of the day I spent texting. And so I think this shows that no matter how many holes you plug in your plan, there can always be more in unexpected areas.

SPEAKER_00Almost everyone assumes that it's just social media scrolling that people are doing, but there are so many ways we can get lost in our devices. And so to bring this back to creating guidelines, something that I am playing with is having windows where I check my text 8, 12, 4, 8. And also before I leave the house, just because it's functional for my job. Although I might have to work with telling clients to call me instead of texting to cancel. And then that would even eliminate that.

SPEAKER_00So again, back to that troubleshooting and finding what works for our unique situation, our job, our family situation, et cetera. For instance, I know people that are parents who will set the school or certain places to be able to bypass do not disturb, but they know they'll get the calls that they need. Or even if it's just any call can get through, but no texts get through during do not disturb, there's a lot of different options for these settings. And it can take some time and trial and error to find the systems or guidelines that work for us.

SPEAKER_00For instance, if you don't want to be getting news alerts regularly, do you batch this and twice a week you look at a couple newsletters you're subscribed to? For email, do you have a certain time a day that you check it? Or for your work, do you have to be on email more often? And what's the amount of time that is needed, just so you're not checking randomly all day and never getting into deep work? And of course, I do want to give a shout out and a thank you to Cal Newport and all of his work, which is always an inspiration for this.

SPEAKER_00But I'll talk a little bit later in the episode about an area he specifically inspired later on. I recommend for the guidelines to have as few as possible. If you have 10 different ones, it's too much to keep up with. So for instance, I'll read you mine right now. Having certain times that I check it that works for my personal life and work, having a system for when I check email and news. So those are in designated blocks. After 6 p.m., there are no rules because I think it's a little bit tough to say, oh, I'm never gonna do anything fun, like go on a Reddit rabbit hole or watch some Netflix.

SPEAKER_00It's just too restrictive. But during the workday, I don't want to be doing those things. And it doesn't mean that I have to be productive all day, but a break might be something like having lunch with a friend or getting a workout in or things that I find more fulfilling. Because I personally feel like as soon as I sort of start to lose the day to something, like I can be really distracted and lose hours to the internet sometimes. And so I find it easier to have very clear guidelines.

SPEAKER_00Gretchen Rubin has a great article on this that I will link down below about moderators and abstainers. A lot of times people think that everyone should just be able to practice moderation. You know, oh, just enjoy a little bit of that thing that you're trying to reduce, because otherwise, if you're too strict with yourself, you're going to binge later. But I love her work on this that says that that's not the case for everyone. For some people, really clear guidelines is what works for them. And I think for things like technology, it already is a slippery slope because we can't completely abstain because it's so integrated in our lives.

SPEAKER_00So having these clear guidelines is at least what helps me personally. But I also have a bit more of this personality type, like when it came to alcohol or caffeine or other changes in my life, being a little bit more cut and dry was way more helpful for me than just try to do it a bit less. But everyone's different. So you could check that out if you are curious where you fall on that dichotomy between abstaining and moderating. And one rule I didn't talk about here is whenever you slip up from your guidelines list, instead of guilt, just get back on track because we're forming a new habit.

SPEAKER_00It's hard, it takes a long time. It's not true that it takes three weeks to form a habit or whatever simplified thing you've heard. It's really nuanced. So every time you slip up, when you come to, I almost think of it as come to or snapping out of the fog where we notice, oh, I'm not doing what I said I was going to do. Just immediately pivot back then when you notice. No guilt necessary. And like we talked about, a lot of this will need to be figured out as you go. For instance, what about looking up something really quick that you need to for what you're working on?

SPEAKER_00Where does that go? Do you write it in a notebook and then look it up later, or do you look it up really quick and get back to work? So I think that a lot of times, again, we need to find what works for us. And just every time you have a new policy that you think is working or you want to try, add it to your guidelines list. And then this will get updated over time. Okay, so another aspect, and this is where I do want to give Cal Newport a thank you, is the idea of creating a meaningful life and adding purposeful leisure and caring about, you know, what he basically calls the deep life.

SPEAKER_00Because it's really, really hard to just reduce screen time for the sake of reducing screen time or because you know it's important. We need to be moving towards something that matters to us and we need to be filling our life with these things. If you imagine someone who's 25, maybe they live in a moderately big city and they go to a corporate job and then come home every day, it's going to be really hard to not just spend the next four to five hours before bed on YouTube, on Netflix, and scrolling social media.

SPEAKER_00Because what else are they going to do? I mean, they could meditate, they could read a physical book, but I think they're going to be a lot less likely to turn to these things if they are meeting up with friends or in a sports league or pursuing some type of art in their free time or getting into cooking. Not everything has to be out. Maybe they just want to find a new recipe once a week and do that on Sunday evenings. But creating a really fulfilling life. This also is connected to the idea of do you find it easier to move towards things or move away from things?

SPEAKER_00And if you're someone that finds it easier to move towards things, this will help. But it's also about the idea of a lot of us are lonely, a lot of us are seeking fulfillment. And when we don't have that in our lives, we go for the quick, easy fix. And that is only natural. We're trying to meet a need. So how can we meet it in a more effective way? Is something we want to be keeping top of mind and pursuing. And this is really connected to the idea of why are we making this change in the first place? I won't reiterate all of this because that was the main thesis of the last episode that I did link in the description.

SPEAKER_00But the main thing I talk about there is that it's absolutely wild that many of us will waste years and years collectively of our lives to internet rabbit holes, to social media feeds that we don't even value. I find it mind-boggling. And I know that other people do too. Tons of people talk about this, think about this, write about this. But if we just get on ourselves, I don't think it solves the root problems. So instead, asking, what kind of a life do I want to move towards?

SPEAKER_00And why does this matter? Like your deepest, deepest why. Whether it's wanting to be present for your kids, whether it's wanting to make a difference in the world, whether it's an art form that you want to pursue mastering the craft for, there are just so many compelling reasons. And it's important to find the ones that cut to your core. You will know you found it when it deeply moves you. And you know you need to make the change for that reason. Now that is not enough. I think we need the friction. I think we need the scheduled activities away from it.

SPEAKER_00I think we need hard guidelines. Okay, we're almost done. We have one more section after this, but before that, I want to speak a little bit more about your why, your compelling reason, your purpose, your reason that getting off of your screen matters. If you feel like you don't know how to think about the idea of purpose and meaning, and it just feels a bit too abstract, lofty, detached from your life. I do have an episode on finding and creating meaning.

SPEAKER_00And I will link that down below. I realize I'm plugging a lot of other episodes. I really try to only do that when it's relevant, but I think that a lot of people struggle with the idea of purpose. So potentially check that out. So the last step is go analog where you can. I think I used to underestimate this because I thought, why does it matter if I use a paper planner or a notebook that I carry around? Why can't I just drop my notes in the Google Doc? Why can't I just use the calendar in my phone because it's so much easier?

SPEAKER_00And of course we can. There are so many apps that make our lives easier and better. And we should keep using, of course, if we decide that they make our life net better. But the problem is that once we go into that digital land for one reason or another, it's so hard to catch ourselves from falling down this like metaphorical cliff and just, oh, I tapped the screen to check the time, but then I saw a notification. So then I started responding to my text. And then after that, I ended up getting a notification for this other thing that I ended up wanting to respond to.

SPEAKER_00And so even if you have good willpower, maybe you've already turned off notifications, but you go in to check the weather and then you can't help yourself. You're like me, you get really curious and you want to check your texts. So if we just go into that digital land less often, it really reduces temptation and the pull. So for instance, I'm going to try using a paper planner. That one's new just because the nature of my work, I have so many appointments a week. I get really worried about dropping the ball, but a friend of mine is inspiring me.

SPEAKER_00I'll let you all know how that change goes. But for instance, I do try to wear a physical watch often and that limits pickups, having a notepad on you to jot down ideas, but then also having a sort time at the end of the day so that those notes actually end up in the right place. Maybe that right place is somewhere on your computer, in a Google Doc or in your calendar or in a reminders app. There's nothing wrong with using it. It's just a matter of how often are you picking up your phone and for what purpose.

SPEAKER_00And so if you do not have the step of putting it where it needs to go later, of course you're not going to stick to the notepad method. And I have an episode called How to Organize Your Mind. If you are curious about where to put information and then what to do with it later, you can find that in the description below. I'll put that there too. The analog step can actually be pretty fun and pretty fulfilling. I think that a lot of people enjoy this, whether it is getting a watch, whether it is getting a separate alarm clock, whether it is using a planner.

SPEAKER_00I think a lot of people. Are craving this. I've noticed Gen Z and some younger people really enjoying pen and paper writing and at least the people I know, but I think that it can be kind of a fun step. It doesn't have to be a limiting thing. Like, you know, can you find a cute notepad? Can you start using your library and getting physical books and then returning them so that you're not reading them on your phone? Again, there's nothing wrong with it, but it's just going to be getting us off our devices more and more.

SPEAKER_00I think I saw a video where someone even got a separate camera to use instead of their phone's camera, which is really neat. So if you guys are interested, I can do a part three follow-up down the line to let you know how some of these changes are going once I've done them for a while, because some of them are new. And that would be, I guess, a part three on changing our relationship with technology. If you want to after this, you can go back to part one. But I think even if you just listened to this one and implemented the changes, you would see some results because it's really about the ideas.

SPEAKER_00Add friction, create guidelines for yourself so that it's clear. Think about why you're using it. Think about what makes your life better or worse. Add things to make your life fulfilling outside of it and go analog where you can. These things are more theoretical, but I know you can apply them to your life in the way that works for you. And it is so difficult because technology is integrated into so many aspects of our lives. If any of this sounds like I'm extremely disciplined, I actually think that I do all of these things because it feels like the opposite.

SPEAKER_00I really struggle with them. So I feel like I have to almost try twice as hard as some other people. But no matter where we're starting from, we can always change. I truly believe that. And that's why I do this. And I'd love to hear from you. You can either comment on YouTube or if you want to connect a little more directly and share your thoughts as a voicemail. We have a Speakpipe account. I will link it in the description. And if you're watching, I'm actually going to show you the screen here that shows how it works. You just go to that website and there is a link or button in the middle of the page that you can click.

SPEAKER_00And then it gives you an option to record a little message just straight from your computer. And then you can listen back, make sure you feel good with it, and then submit. And it goes right to my email inbox. If it seems like a good fit to play on a future episode, we will work it in there. But either way, I'd love to hear from you. I know there's a lot of curious people out there that are looking to grow as well. And I'm just looking forward to hearing from you too. The last housekeeping thing. I said last week that this week was going to be on emotions and how happiness is not the opposite of sadness.

SPEAKER_00It's something a little bit more nuanced than that. But full disclosure, I'm actually going through a breakup with someone that I've been with for a very, very long time. They're very special to me still. They're a great person. There were just compatibility issues, and it was a little hard to do an episode on emotions when I was so in my own emotions. I might do that episode down the line, but also after a 10-part series on positive psychology, I don't know.

SPEAKER_00I was ready to talk about other things. And through this life transition change, I've been thinking about things I was neglecting during that time. Nothing to do with that partner. They were extremely supportive. I just think often when we're in a relationship, sometimes we don't pick our head up and ask, like, what are the areas of my life I want to change? And of course, people can at any point, but at natural transitions, I think we do it a bit more, which led me to some changes, such as this technology one. So I'll also let you know how the flip phone goes separating work and personal, and speak with you soon.

SPEAKER_00Thanks for being here.

Open the transcript file

Hosts and Guests

Nobody is credited on this episode yet.

Credit the people on this episode

Be the first to rate this episode

More episodes

All episodes
  1. Do We Still Have a Shared Culture? What We're Losing (and Gaining) in an Era of Endless Media

    Nov 16, 202630 minAudio

    There was a time when large cultural moments brought us together. Everyone was watching the same movies and shows, reading the same books, and participating in the same cultural conversations. But with so much more...

    Credit the people on this episode

  2. How to Overcome Choice Overload: Is Decision Fatigue Real?

    Nov 8, 202625 minAudio

    Do you ever struggle with choice overload or analysis paralysis? We’re continuing our series on The Paradox of Choice, exploring the practical implications of the ideas in Barry Schwartz’s book for our daily lives. In...

    Credit the people on this episode

  3. The Paradox of Choice in Online Dating: An NYC Perspective (Interview – Part 2)

    Nov 1, 202629 minAudio

    This is Part 2 of our discussion on the Paradox of Choice and dating apps. In this episode, I’m joined by a friend to discuss his experiences navigating dating apps in a place like New York City, where the paradox of...

    Credit the people on this episode

  4. What dating apps are doing to love: Why more options can make finding love harder

    Oct 25, 202623 minAudio

    If you’ve been on the apps for some time, you know that while there are more options than ever to find love presented in front of us, in many ways, it can feel harder. This is counterintuitive - so in this episode, we...

    Credit the people on this episode

  5. Why trying to make the “best” choice can make you less happy

    Oct 18, 202628 minAudio

    Would you rather feel happy with your decision or make a slightly better “objective” choice? It’s an interesting question, and in this episode, we unpack it through the lens of maximizing vs. satisficing. What does it...

    Credit the people on this episode