Skip to content
PodSubs
ShowsPeopleGuestsJobsNewsEvents
More
BlogPodCred
Menu
ShowsPeopleGuestsJobsNewsEventsBlogPodCredNetworksSign in
Join nowSign in
  • Shows
  • People
  • Jobs
  • News
  • More
    • Guests
    • Events
    • Blog
    • PodCred
    • Networks
    Join nowSign in

Immersion

Immersion artwork

How to Overcome Choice Overload: Is Decision Fatigue Real?

Nov 8, 202625 minAudio
ShareXLinkedInFacebookWhatsAppEmail

Do you ever struggle with choice overload or analysis paralysis? We’re continuing our series on The Paradox of Choice, exploring the practical implications of the ideas in Barry Schwartz’s book for our daily lives. In this episode, we unpack: What are the implications of having a lot of choices or options? What areas of our lives does this impact? From health to finances to where we choose to live, and more. Is decision fatigue a real thing? Practical steps to limit choice, from rules and philosophies to choice diets, and more, to help us, as Barry says, “choose when to choose.” Mentioned in this episode The Paradox of Choice book by Barry Schwartz Photography class study: https://pubmed.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/11999920/ Research on jams and chocolates: https://pubmed.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/11138768/ Retirement study: https://www.researchgate.net/publication/237792043_How_Much_Choice_Is_Too_Much_Contributions_to_401K_Retirement_Plans Maximizer and satisficer episode: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=0t6VMXby5Yo Minimalism video: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=OFmdMWZOjI8 Write in to the show here Leave a voice message here Newsletter sign up YouTube - channel Instagram - we will be posting here soon

Audio and video play straight from the show's own hosting. PodSubs stores and serves no media.

Transcript

From the show. Tap a time to play from there.

SPEAKER_00Have you ever been to a restaurant and there were so many good options that it made it hard to choose any? In this episode, we are going to be discussing choice overload when you are overwhelmed with too many options and you end up in analysis paralysis because this applies to way more than just menus. So we'll be unpacking this broadly, and this is a continuation on the series we've been doing on the paradox of choice by Barry Schwartz and applying the implications from that idea to our daily lives.

SPEAKER_00We will also ask the question: Is decision fatigue a real thing? And we will close with some action stuff that you can use in your own life to reduce this overwhelm and overload from so many choices that are around us. Let's start this out by looking at a study by Sheena Ayangar and Mark Lepper. Some participants chose between 30 chocolates, and other participants chose between six chocolates. The participants who were choosing between only six chocolates were four times as likely to choose a box as payment for participation and were happier with their choice after.

SPEAKER_00And this ties into what we've been finding through this whole series that often when we have an ever-increasing amount of options, it makes us less likely to choose and less happy with our choice. I think at face value, a lot of us can sort of start to tune out these studies. Maybe you've heard of the famous jam study as well that I'll link below, where people are more likely to choose a jam out of only a few options instead of 24. And when I first started studying psychology, I thought, yeah, that's pretty obvious.

SPEAKER_00If we have too many choices, we're not going to choose. But we don't realize how many areas of our life this impacts. For instance, I will also link a study down below on retirement plans that shows that when more options are listed, people are less likely to choose a plan. Of course, things like retirement are important and more important than choosing jams or chocolates. Those are just a little bit easier to study in the lab repeatedly. And I noticed myself even feeling something kind of counterintuitive when it comes to this overwhelm with choices.

SPEAKER_00There was a podcast that I was getting pretty into, and I realized I liked almost every idea that they had in their feed. I was excited to start listening, but I felt a little overwhelmed with options. And that's not a big problem. That's how it almost always feels when you find a creator that you're interested in. Then I realized that all the older episodes past a certain date were for subscribers only. And I actually felt relieved because there was less to choose between, which is counterintuitive. Wouldn't we think that we would not be happy to have less episodes to listen to?

SPEAKER_00But I think that it comes down to two things. One is the common phrase that you often might throw out for this analysis paralysis, the idea where we actually don't act. It's not that we're overwhelmed for a little bit, it slows us down, and then eventually we choose. Often, when it comes to areas that can be important to us, such as that retirement plan study, people will sometimes simply not choose because it's too overwhelming. The other reason that this can be stressful for people is because of the amount of areas of life that this interacts with.

SPEAKER_00Like I mentioned earlier, let's go into that now. And as I list these examples, of course, some people might be thinking, wait, not everyone has all these options available to them. And that is true. We want to acknowledge that some choice is better than no choice. We are simply saying that as options increase, there is a diminishing return. And like we keep saying in this series, some options are better than no options, but often a thousand options are not better than a few options.

SPEAKER_00So I'm going to laundry list a bunch of ways we have choices in our life now that we would not have had some time ago in history. From insurance plans and credit cards to aesthetic enhancements, vacations, to how we spend our time after work, who we want to spend our time with, how much do we want to be on technology? What career to pursue? Kids, no kids, one kid or more than one? Take an Uber or bike or drive in your own car or walk or take the subway?

SPEAKER_00What kind of a routine do you want? Do you want to do yoga or spin or Pilates or weightlifting for your exercise? Do you want to buy more sustainable products or organic or regular produce? Should you take time off after college? Or do you want to go to college at all with how expensive it can be in many places? How do you want to decorate your house? Do you go to therapy or do you try to go at it yourself with journaling? Drink caffeine or alcohol or abstain? Where do you want to live? Near your family, near your partner's family, some other city?

SPEAKER_00Stay single, or do you want to get married? Or cohabitate and not get married? Should you switch careers later in life? I could go on and on. And in fact, in his book, The Paradoxal Choice, Barry Schwartz lists a lot of examples. And basically, most of the only critical reviews I saw for the book were sort of getting at this. Why is he listing so many examples? For instance, he's listing data from consumer reports at certain times, or listing basically every type of genes at a gene store. And I think it's easy to sort of laugh at that, especially now.

SPEAKER_00But this book was written in 2004. So Barry was living and researching this at an interesting time because consumer culture was changing a lot. And the internet, of course, changed things even more as more and more people went online. But he said he first started shopping at a time where you would just go and buy jeans. And then one day he realized he went in and there were 30 different types of jeans. And this felt very overwhelming. And so I think that someone reading the book could say, like, why is he listing all these types of genes? But I think he's trying to make a point that before a certain time we didn't have this level of optionality.

SPEAKER_00And I did see in a talk that he recently gave that it's only increasing. Again, he wrote this in 2004 and was talking about how much change he had seen till then. We know anyone who's been living from 2004 on has probably seen options explode even further. It used to be that you maybe had some records and that was the music you would listen to. Whereas now you could, if you have an internet connection, find virtually any song in the world and listen to it. I wouldn't trade a lot of the things we have in our modern lives to go back in time.

SPEAKER_00It's simply to acknowledge the tax that many of us are paying for these benefits. And like we're going to go into, we can get a lot of the benefits without the cognitive strain if we learn to limit our choice in certain areas of life. And before we go into those action steps, let's unpack the question is decision fatigue a real thing? And depending on how much you've been running in psychology circles, you may or may not know about decision fatigue as a physical process.

SPEAKER_00They used to think that our glucose would get depleted as we made more and more decisions. You may have heard about the study where judges would grant more favorable rulings after lunch. So they felt like, oh, people are more likely to make a certain decision after they've had food. So there must be something with blood glucose. And I see how they could get there, but then this later was largely debunked. And it's not that there's as much of a tangible physical nature to it, where it's like a battery is actually being depleted and you cannot make the same level of decision when you've made a bunch in a row.

SPEAKER_00So that's good to know that there's not a hard wall that we hit. But it is still cognitively taxing and demanding to make decision after decision. We have many things competing for our attention. And like we've repeatedly talked about in this series, we often fall prey to heuristics. Now, we might do a whole series at some point on heuristics if that's something you all would be interested in. An example of that is the sunk cost fallacy. So for instance, you buy a ticket to a concert, it was$20, the time comes for the concert, you don't want to go, you're feeling really run down.

SPEAKER_00If we still go to the concert, even though we did not want to and we would not enjoy it as much, we have fallen prey to the sunk cost fallacy, where we made a decision based on a sunk cost, a cost we've already paid, and we don't get anything more out of it by continuing to go to that concert if we wouldn't enjoy it. And that's a fallacy you've probably heard of. But there are so many mental shortcuts we make because decisions are cognitively taxing. So this is all connected. And when we have more choice around us in the modern world, we're going to make these shortcuts more and more.

SPEAKER_00Or if we don't as much, but we're thinking through them a lot, that's cognitively demanding. So what's the way around this? The way around this is to limit our choice when we can in ways that are advantageous to us. We're going to go into several steps you could apply. And the first one is, as Barry says, choosing when to choose. So for instance, you might have something like a guideline, such as he goes into, I only have two drinks at a time. Or you might have heard of leaders such as Steve Jobs or Obama having a work uniform because they'd rather save that mental bandwidth for things they find more important than what they're going to wear that day.

SPEAKER_00Another example from someone I was discussing the script with on an airplane, he mentioned that he gets the same things when he goes to the grocery store every time. He's not wondering what I should get? Should I get this or try this? He knows his staples and he goes in and buys them. And in the book, Barry actually divides this into multiple frameworks: rules, presumptions, standards, and routines. So having the same thing for breakfast every morning would be a routine. But the idea that you stop yourself after only two drinks at an outing, that would be an example of a rule.

SPEAKER_00So he breaks this down into more specific criteria. But the idea is that these are predetermined choices because we've taken the time to think about what do I really want? And then when the moment of decision comes, we're not having to make constant decisions, like do I want to wear my seatbelt or not? And it does help eliminate this choice overload. So while that last step was about having decisions pre-made, the next step is about limiting the options we see to begin with.

SPEAKER_00I call this the blinders approach. Like I mentioned, I was speaking about this podcast script with someone on an airplane. And he had a really interesting and powerful point. He said that he grew up pretty poor, but he was in a small town, so he didn't know his family was poor relative to a lot of the country. It wasn't until he was watching MTV Cribs that he realized what else was out there. Now, of course, this was probably two ends of the extreme.

SPEAKER_00Most of the world was not living like MTV Cribs, but he does bring up a really good point that social comparison is a big part of this. If no one else around you was doing a certain thing, you might not think that that's even a decision or choice that you need to even make. I'll give you another example relative to houses. A friend of mine was redesigning some of their house. And while they were making some interior design decisions, such as, you know, what color to paint it, things like that.

SPEAKER_00She considered going to an open house in her neighborhood to just kind of get design inspirations. But then she realized she would probably feel agitated and annoyed about things she could not or would not be doing, things she wasn't going to spend the money on. And so she puts herself on what is called a choice diet. She just chooses to not expose herself to options that she's not going to pursue. And I think that's really interesting. It makes me think of our maximizer and satisfacer episode from a few episodes ago, how maximizers are trying to make the best choice.

SPEAKER_00So they expose themselves to more and more options. And this can again make all of this overwhelming. So a way you might implement a choice diet might be when you're making a certain specific choice. And you might say to yourself, I am allowed to look at three potential hard drives when I'm getting a new external hard drive to back up my files. That's it. Maybe I can read one article looking up reviews and that's it. I'm capping it. That's the information cap I'm giving myself. Some people might choose to stay off social media or limit the amount of ads they see, such as getting up and doing a couple exercises if there was an ad break on TV instead of watching those ads, just trying to limit our exposure to how many options we're exposed to.

SPEAKER_00The next step you might take to reduce this overwhelm with how many options there are is adopting a certain guiding philosophy for your life. Maybe you have certain values that you hold dearly and then you use as guiding principles for your life. For instance, minimalism. A lot of people adopt that not only because they like the aesthetic, but also because they might feel that it brings mental clarity and peace to their life. And I have a really old video back before I started the podcast, but it is on my YouTube channel where I talk about the fact that minimalism is not just about belongings.

SPEAKER_00Something I feel pretty passionate about. I'm gonna link that episode down below because you can choose to adopt minimalism in many areas of your life, because really it's about only saying yes to the things that greatly matter to you and then moving away from the things that do not feel aligned. And there's other philosophies that have these underlying principles, but could be applied in slightly different ways. For instance, in the book, Barry Schwartz mentioned the voluntary simplicity movement, which, in doing some brief research on it for this episode, has a bit more to do with ecological awareness, self-sufficiency.

SPEAKER_00Someone could have the same motivations for adopting minimalism as this, but the philosophies do differ slightly. These are areas that you could look into because when you have this mindset, it actually changes how you approach life. Even when I'm at something like a conference, well, actually, I was recently at a podcasting conference and I did get a little bit of swag. I did get a tote bag that I liked. I didn't have anything in the podcasting space because that was my first one. But generally, I'm going to not get any swag because one of the ways I identify is as a minimalist.

SPEAKER_00But the point is that having that philosophy as a guiding principle helps dictate future decisions and makes them a lot easier because it's a mindset that you're applying to many areas of life. For instance, someone might also apply it with how they eat. They don't choose to just eat whatever's around, they're only going to eat certain types of food, maybe mostly unprocessed. And I think that these movements are gaining traction in our society because we're craving that simplicity. What was fascinating in talking to people for this episode is almost everyone could immediately understand what I meant by the paradox of choice.

SPEAKER_00And what's funny is a couple people immediately said, Oh, yeah, I think about that when I eat out and there's a menu with too many options. That's actually why I let in with that example when we first started. But even people that had not heard of the paradox of choice as a saying, as a book, they just immediately understood what it meant because we're overloaded with so many options these days. But I don't think that so many people were craving things like minimalism maybe 15 years ago or 20 years ago when this book came out.

SPEAKER_00I still remember the idea of people wanting more and more. So it will be interesting to see as time progresses if these movements that are counter to that, counter-consumerism, counter more and more and more, if that's going to be picking up steam. And not only from a financial perspective, but for the mental benefits that they bring as well. Okay, so this last tip is a bit of a tricky one. It's the idea of reversible and irreversible decisions. And I'll give you the main principle and then we'll go into some exceptions.

SPEAKER_00Generally, I would think that it is less cognitively taxing, and as we'll go into, in many ways, we're happier with our decisions when a decision is irreversible and it is simply made. This study is by Daniel Gilbert and Jane Ebert in 2002. And in this study, students were in one group where they received a photo at the end of their photography class and that was it.

SPEAKER_00Or another group where their decision could be changed later. The group ended up liking their photo better when they could not change their mind. And I think some of this has to do with the endowment effect, which you might have heard of, where we value something more when it is ours. You might have heard this, for example, when people put items out at a garage sale or something and they overprice it, they think that it's more valuable. And a lot of the reasoning for that is not just wanting more money for it, but that they literally value the item more because it's theirs.

SPEAKER_00So I think that's part of it. But I think the other part of it is how taxing it is when a decision is not fully made, when you leave the door open to change your mind later. We're going to go into a few ways how this changes your thinking. Because if you think something is still up in the air, should I stay in this city? Should I stay in this relationship? Should I stay at this college? Should I stay at this job? Should I stay in this apartment?

SPEAKER_00Should I stay friends with this person? There are so many things in our life we could constantly think of as decisions that are not made up. The door is open to change our mind. And that's fine. We should absolutely leave that on the table. We're free to behave how we want in the world. But when we constantly leave the door open, should I change my mind? Should I change my mind? Am I on the right path? It actually keeps us from inhabiting the path that we're on now, at least for a period of time until we know in our gut it's time to change course.

SPEAKER_00So as we're going to discuss, it's not about tuning out our emotions. It's just realizing that one other way that we can limit choice is to, for a period of time, be all in on something. And we're going to discuss the implications of that. Because when we think about how can I make this work? What can I do to show up to make this good? We show up completely differently compared to the idea of do I even want to be here? And this only applies to certain people, myself being one of them, people that feel as though no decisions are really made because you can change your mind at any time.

SPEAKER_00Great example in the book that Barry gives for this is that he noticed that students that felt that they were at the right college made a lot more of the experience than students who felt that they weren't at the right college. It does make sense, right? Like if you feel like, oh, this is the right place for me, I'm gonna make the most of it, you're gonna see opportunities. Maybe you sign up to participate in student government or research or you join a volunteering organization, and then it becomes this self-fulfilling prophecy. You make it the right place for you because you believed it was the right place for you.

SPEAKER_00The reason why this gets complicated is because I think it can encourage people to stay in situations that are not right for them. So we're not talking about tuning out our emotions or never having check-ins with ourselves or intuition about if we want to change paths. It's simply realizing that if we live in this very flexible state where almost all of the doors to possible lives are cracked open to us, I think it's also about realizing how taxing that can be and how much, like this study said, they liked the photo less the group that felt it was a reversible decision.

SPEAKER_00So, how might it be making us like our own life less if we believe that everything is impermanent? And so a lot of this ties to almost any area of life. If you think you're not going to be in a city very long, you're probably not going to invest in building friendships or community there. And then that makes you less likely to stay there. This applies to so many things. And a lot of it comes down to selective attention. There's so much stimuli around us at any point that we are constantly just choosing consciously and unconsciously what to focus on.

SPEAKER_00And then that changes our views. So when they say the grass is always greener, yes, it's a bit of a cliche, but it's about the idea of what we're focusing on. And then, you know, the other part about saying grass is greener where you water it, where by pouring into our current life, we can make it closer to our dream life. And it isn't always about these 180s or big changes. It can be sometimes about making the most of our current situation. And for people that do pay attention to their feelings and intuitions and realize, you know, something isn't right.

SPEAKER_00By pouring into our life as it is now, sometimes that can help be the bridge to the life we want. If you're in a job that you aren't happy in, I don't mean ignore your intuition and stay in it and just water that grass. But it also doesn't necessarily mean try and change your life in a day. What can you do to show up in your current job, maybe to make it a little closer to your dream job, like taking on responsibilities that are a little closer to the kind of role you might be wanting to apply to next. So it's again about that selective attention.

SPEAKER_00But I'll close with just sharing one more way I'm applying this idea of reducing choice overload, overwhelm in my life. And it has to do with time and my to-do list. Because I work for myself in a couple areas, and this means there's a lack of structure or external accountability of someone else saying this is what you need to get done this day. And this applies to you too if you have any artistic ventures or entrepreneurial ventures. I think often you just think, okay, well, I'll get up and I'll work on that project.

SPEAKER_00I know what I'm supposed to do. But I've started to do this thing that of course everyone talks about in the productivity space. Sometimes I just haven't always had best practices of applying it, is breaking down projects into tiny, almost laughable steps, baby steps. And I actually almost treat myself like I'm babying myself in like this kind way. We are going to make this so simple that if someone else saw your to-do list practically, they could do it today, versus, oh yeah, yeah, uh, I know what to do. And I've always had a to-do list for different days.

SPEAKER_00I'm just trying to make it much, much more clear. Again, not filling it super, super full, not making it overwhelming that way. But often if you have something that's a creative project, if you have something that's entrepreneurial, it can lead to choice overwhelm because there's so many projects or tasks that you could move forward on any given day. And so having a Sunday like meeting with myself where I plan my week out has reduced some decision fatigue because I knew, okay, since I have to finish the outline by Saturday to be able to shoot something on Sunday, something like that.

SPEAKER_00And every single project is attached to tiny action steps that are slotted onto a specific day. So I'm not constantly making decisions. So I'd love to hear in the comments on YouTube or in a voicemail on our SpeakPipe account, which is linked in the description. How are you planning to apply this theory to your life? Reducing choice overload and combating analysis paralysis. Thank you for being with us on this journey. We'll see you next week as we continue on this journey of all the options available to us decision making series, but we're going to take it in a slightly different direction.

SPEAKER_00Looking forward to speaking to you then next Sunday. Hope you have a great week.

Open the transcript file

Hosts and Guests

Nobody is credited on this episode yet.

Credit the people on this episode

Be the first to rate this episode

More episodes

All episodes
  1. Do We Still Have a Shared Culture? What We're Losing (and Gaining) in an Era of Endless Media

    Nov 16, 202630 minAudio

    There was a time when large cultural moments brought us together. Everyone was watching the same movies and shows, reading the same books, and participating in the same cultural conversations. But with so much more...

    Credit the people on this episode

  2. The Paradox of Choice in Online Dating: An NYC Perspective (Interview – Part 2)

    Nov 1, 202629 minAudio

    This is Part 2 of our discussion on the Paradox of Choice and dating apps. In this episode, I’m joined by a friend to discuss his experiences navigating dating apps in a place like New York City, where the paradox of...

    Credit the people on this episode

  3. What dating apps are doing to love: Why more options can make finding love harder

    Oct 25, 202623 minAudio

    If you’ve been on the apps for some time, you know that while there are more options than ever to find love presented in front of us, in many ways, it can feel harder. This is counterintuitive - so in this episode, we...

    Credit the people on this episode

  4. Why trying to make the “best” choice can make you less happy

    Oct 18, 202628 minAudio

    Would you rather feel happy with your decision or make a slightly better “objective” choice? It’s an interesting question, and in this episode, we unpack it through the lens of maximizing vs. satisficing. What does it...

    Credit the people on this episode

  5. Does More Analyzing Lead to Better Decisions? | Decision Series Ep. 1

    Oct 4, 202619 minAudio

    Do you struggle making decisions? The vast amount of optionality in our modern world has improved our lives in many ways, but it has also left many of us feeling frozen - trapped under the weight of our decisions and...

    Credit the people on this episode