We spend our whole lives chasing happiness, but we rarely stop to ask: Are we chasing the right things? Or more importantly - do we even have control over how happy we are? Research suggests that while a portion of our happiness is genetic, a significant amount is firmly within our control - if we know which levers to pull. In this episode, we dive into the science of building a happier life. We look at why our brains are notoriously bad at predicting the future (affective forecasting) and how to stop stumbling into happiness and start designing it. In this episode, we cover: The 50% Rule: Is happiness genetic, or is it a choice? The Prediction Trap: Why we are bad at guessing what will make us happy (Affective Forecasting). Hedonic vs. Eudaimonic: The difference between "feeling good" and "deeper meaning" The PERMA+ Model: The scientific "ingredients" list for a good life. Surrogation: A strategy for making better major life decisions. The Toolkit: How to use Positive Psychology to move the needle on your satisfaction (as the first part of an upcoming series) Reference: The "Happiness Pie Chart" discussed in this episode is based on the work of Sonja Lyubomirsky, Ken Sheldon, and David Schkade Other resources mentioned: đź“• Stumbling on Happiness by Daniel Gilbert Character strengths: https://www.viacharacter.org/ Affective forecasting by Timothy Wilson and Daniel Gilbert Does more money make us happier? NOTE upon looking at this closer, I saw they went into some additional nuances not covered in the video - worth a read if you are curious https://penntoday.upenn.edu/news/does-more-money-correlate-greater-happiness-Penn-Princeton-research On the long-running happiness study: https://news.harvard.edu/gazette/story/2017/04/over-nearly-80-years-harvard-study-has-been-showing-how-to-live-a-healthy-and-happy-life/ Some more on Perma: https://ppc.sas.upenn.edu/learn-more/perma-theory-well-being-and-perma-workshops Some more basics on positive psychology: as referenced from Peterson 2008 https://www.psychologytoday.com/us/blog/the-good-life/200805/what-is-positive-psychology-and-what-is-it-not and https://positivepsychology.com/what-is-positive-psychology-definition/ My positive psychology professor from university: https://www.drryanduffy.com/ Timestamps: 00:00 Intro: Stumbling on happiness 02:28 How is happiness actually defined? 04:17 How controllable is happiness? 07:24 Affective Forecasting: Your mind lies to you 09:16 PERMA+: The ingredients of the good life 15:35 "Surrogation": A tool for better decision making 18:21 The field of Positive Psychology & Footnotes Write in to the show here Leave a voice message here Newsletter sign up YouTube - channel Instagram - we will be posting here soon
Audio and video play straight from the show's own hosting. PodSubs stores and serves no media.
Transcript
From the show. Tap a time to play from there.
SPEAKER_00Welcome to Immersion. This week we're going to begin a new series on what I like to call strategic happiness, where we ask the questions, how controllable is happiness? Can it be trained? And if so, what are the levers that move the needle to increase happiness levels? I don't know about you, but I often catch myself feeling happy. I'll maybe be doing something simple like the laundry, and then suddenly I realize I'm actually pretty happy in my life right now. And the same thing happens when I'm feeling down.
SPEAKER_00It will sort of feel like it sneaks up out of the blue. And I thought it was weird to interact with emotions this way until I saw this quote: One cannot divide nor forecast the conditions that will make happiness. One only stumbles upon them by chance, in a lucky hour, at the world's end somewhere, and holds fast to the days as to fortune or fame. Will a Cather. This was in the beginning of a book called Stumbling on Happiness by Dan Gilbert, who is a researcher in this field. And that phrase, stumbling on happiness, both in the quote, in the name of the book, made me realize that I'm not the only one that sort of feels like I trip and fall into happiness.
SPEAKER_00And it is really unintentional that way. Yet it's something that's so universal and core to being human that it made me wonder how we can be a little bit more intentional in our approach to increasing happiness levels? Now, this might seem lofty or ambitious, but there's actually a field that studies well-being in particular. It's called positive psychology. So in this series, we will heavily look to positive psychology research, but we will also look to philosophy, Buddhism, examples from culture and art.
SPEAKER_00Let's dive in on this series. And in the first episode, we're going to be doing a broad overview so that we understand the lay of the land. First, we will define happiness. Then we will answer right away that first question we posed. How controllable is it? Then we'll look at those levers. What controls happiness? What does positive psychology say about action steps we can actually try to change these happiness levels? And then lastly, I'll give you one very practical tip or shift at the end because some of it will be theoretical, but I want you to feel like you have something you can hold on to at the end of this episode.
SPEAKER_00Finally, we'll talk about some of the other upcoming parts of this series coming up. First, how is happiness defined? Positive psychology researcher Sonia Lubomareski defines happiness as the experience of joy, contentment, or positive well-being combined with a sense that one's life is good, meaningful, and worthwhile. This already hits on a big distinction here. And this is both talked about in philosophy and psychology. The idea of eudaimonic happiness, which is more about meaning and virtues, and you could think of it more as long-term happiness, versus hedonic happiness, which is more about short-term pleasure, simply feeling good.
SPEAKER_00Now, these are not always clearly cut and dry with something being only one or the other. For instance, I've seen gratitude listed as a positive feeling state, but also as a character strength, which could be defined as a virtue of sorts. However, I think it's pretty clear, for instance, some things feel great in the short term, but they don't necessarily lead to long-term fulfillment, like eating ice cream and watching your favorite comedian. Nothing wrong with that, but it's going to feel a bit different than maybe sitting down and having a great chat with your grandmother over tea on a Sunday and then helping her with some chores around the house.
SPEAKER_00It might not be as exciting, but it will be more meaningful. So we can get into later in the series a little bit more on what philosophy has to say. This was talked about by Aristotle and a lot of other people, this distinction, this branching off. But I think it's important to understand that happiness is not purely about trying to feel good and not bad. It's more about human flourishing more broadly, especially as it pertains to positive psychology and that field.
SPEAKER_00The next question someone would likely have is how controllable is happiness? Is this even a question we should be asking to begin with? Or is it purely the result of our genetics or our life circumstances? So for a long time, psychology 101 would have this pie chart that I'll put up on the screen. And it showed genetics as being 50% of what determines how happy you are, circumstances, your money, house, job, where you live, your life circumstances as 10%, and the actions you take as 40% of that pie of what determines how happy you are.
SPEAKER_00And this was really great, particularly for bolstering people's belief in the fact that they do have some control over how happy they are. However, those numbers are not so cut and dry anymore. Different research will come out saying that happiness could be 35% genetics all the way up to 80% genetics. I've seen different numbers. However, that 50% is in the middle and a number that I think we can safely go with. However, that 10% for life circumstances, that has a big asterisk with it.
SPEAKER_00That only applies if someone is safe and their needs are met. If someone is struggling to pay their rent or if they're recovering from pretty severe trauma, then life circumstances, that 10% of the pie, will be bigger. But if someone has food in their fridge, good internet connection and an iPhone, if things are pretty stable, they have a little money left over at the end of the month, they just feel safe and secure in their life in general, then it is closer to 10%. Getting a slightly bigger house or a slightly higher paying job is not going to move the needle much in terms of happiness, despite what many people think.
SPEAKER_00Now, this is another area where research has gone back and forth. And I'm tempted to talk about how this has changed throughout history, but I will save a little bit of that for the footnote section to keep us moving. Now we have the area that is controllable. And like we talked about, we're not going to split hairs about if that is indeed 40% like they used to think, or if it's 15% or 20%. If we use an analogy of a car, imagine our genetics being the engine and life circumstances as the weather and the road we happen to be on.
SPEAKER_00Like if it's paved well, then we could think of our actions we take as the steering wheel and our ability to move that wheel in the direction that we want. So even if it's only 20% or even if it's up to 40%, it doesn't really matter. What matters is what we do with that amount. The way that this was expressed by my positive psychology professor at the university is think about the difference between a 3 out of 10 happiness level compared to a 7 out of 10 happiness level.
SPEAKER_00Sure, you don't control 100%. You're not going from a zero or a one to a 10, but there is a really big difference between three and seven. And so what we do really matters, and we can focus now on that. So the next question people would likely be asking is okay, I'm on board to control the aspects I can control. So what are they? Right before we get to that, important to note that humans are notoriously bad at predicting what will make us happy.
SPEAKER_00Dan Gilbert and Timothy Wilson are two researchers that have been working on this and were the people that coined the term effective forecasting, which is basically the idea of predicting how happy we will be in the future based on certain decisions right now. And turns out humans are not that good at this. And there's research dedicated to this, there's books dedicated to this. It's a really interesting field. One example of this that was in Dan Gilbert's book that I mentioned was a study where they asked students how happy they would be if they won a big football game that was coming up.
SPEAKER_00And those participants imagined rushing the field, maybe some music playing, everyone celebrating how good it would feel after that victory. But then, in actuality, they didn't think about what would happen right after, for example. Both the winning and losing team had to go home and finish their homework before the next day. So we often don't look at the many factors that determine our happiness levels. We often zoom in on very specific outcomes that we think will make or break our happiness, and we don't realize all of these other factors.
SPEAKER_00Another thing that makes us miscalculate how happy we'll be in the future or not is not knowing the ways that we often make ourselves feel better, such as through what's called a psychological immune system or an emotional immune system, which is what our whole next episode is going to be about. But the idea to take away here is that what we think will make us happy is not always what will make us happy. So let's now examine some of the levers that are most often cited as things that determine our happiness through positive psychology.
SPEAKER_00The framework that is most often cited is called PERMA, or more recently, PERMA Plus. It's an acronym to help remember the main tools in positive psychology that we can implement. And this was developed by who is often referred to as, I believe, the father of positive psychology, Martin Seligman. P being positive emotion. So this would be experiencing emotions that feel good to us, such as gratitude, love. It's not simply pleasure of, oh, this food tastes good, but joy, contentment, just positive feeling states is one aspect.
SPEAKER_00Then another aspect is engagement. So this would be flow state, being fully absorbed and immersed in activities. This could be through work. It also could be through an interest or something like art or playing a sport. R is for relationships. And I'm going to read a quote from the Harvard Gazette talking about actually a very long-term study that was conducted at Harvard. Close relationships, more than money or fame, are what keep people happy throughout their lives, the study revealed.
SPEAKER_00Those ties protect people from life's discontents, help to delay mental and physical decline, and are better predictors of long and happy lives than social class, IQ, or even genes. They followed people for 80 years, and it's very rare to find studies that will follow people for that duration of time. Coming in in the edit, and this study is actually still going on, and it is in its 87th year. Pretty amazing. Okay, back to the episode. And yes, it's one of the many areas within psychology that point to relationships being far and away the main predictor of happiness levels.
SPEAKER_00This is something that I used to really underestimate, but we will surely get into that more later in the series. M is for meaning or serving something greater than yourself, whether that is through spirituality or other contributions, being a part of an organization you really believe in. And a lot of it has to do with purpose and values. An A is for achievement, striving for certain goals, aiming to attain them. More modern views of perma also include additional areas, such as resilience and grit, something we'll also talk about in this series.
SPEAKER_00Body vitality, health. For instance, it's really hard to feel good in your mind and life if you don't feel good in your body. They are intimately linked, as we know now, and other areas. For instance, character strengths. Often in positive psychology, we do really try to emphasize what people are good at. For example, if someone has humor as a really high strength, maybe it's how they bond with people, it's part of what helps them cope when things are difficult, it's part of what just brightens their day.
SPEAKER_00How can we allow that person to apply that at work? How can we bring out what people are already good at? And so if you're curious about what your character strengths are, they're a little bit different than the kind of strengths you might think about typically. If they are the areas of positive psychology we've been talking about, such as gratitude, but also zest or appreciation of beauty or curiosity. They're really beautiful aspects of what it means to be human. I will link down below the character strengths assessment by the Via Institute.
SPEAKER_00And I recommend taking that if you'd like. I'll link it down below. So that perma plus model, which we'll dive deeper into as we go throughout our series, talking more in depth about relationships, flow state, each of those areas. I think it's a fantastic model to remember things. But if you were curious about the field of positive psychology in general, it does study more than just those areas. For instance, institutions, such as family systems, schools, workplaces, governments, what can they do to help people improve their happiness levels?
SPEAKER_00And how can we as citizens impact them as well? I don't think that this covers the entire field of positive psychology, but as one person just quickly going through a list of what are the main areas that I should be thinking about, I think that it's a fantastic framework. And the only other main bucket that I think is left out of that is what I would call cognitive approaches. We could think of this as how we look at things in our life. And you've likely heard of CBT or cognitive behavioral therapy.
SPEAKER_00And what that does is gets us to question certain beliefs that are maybe inaccurate, gets us to change how we're thinking so that we can be happier because our thoughts do impact our emotions. So an example of a reframe or a tool from cognitive behavioral therapy would be questioning our beliefs, such as black and white thinking. For instance, you may have heard in relationships, it's not good to say always or never, but it's also not even really healthy to think that way, even in our own head, but instead to see some nuance.
SPEAKER_00Our partner is late and we think they're always late. And then maybe we even start lumping in more things that we're annoyed at them about. But we have the power to question our thoughts, reframe how we're thinking, and it can even be through simple small questions, thinking about when in the last month has my partner not been late, or what are a couple of my favorite attributes about them. And this can sound A, difficult to do when we're annoyed or upset or spiraling.
SPEAKER_00B, it can, I think, get often lumped in with not allowing space for our feelings. It's very different though, and there's a reason why CBT has become such a popular and effective tool, is because the power of our mind is so immense, and we want to learn how to harness it and channel it in the direction we want to go versus falling prey to this monkey mind mental chatter that can often veer more towards the negative than would actually benefit us, our relationships, our work.
SPEAKER_00So that is something we'll also go into is how do we change our thought processes to also be more happy. And so, as promised, I will give you a very practical takeaway that you could even apply as soon as today. And it's going off of the idea that we talked about earlier that humans are not great at predicting what will make us happy in the future. But there is a great tool that also is in Dan Gilbert's book and it's talked about in other areas of psychology, and it is using what's called a surrogate.
SPEAKER_00And that is where we ask other people how they feel in certain situations. Because while we might not be able to say, I would be happy living in that city, or I would not be happy living in that city, we might be wrong about our guess. Often the way we will feel is more often similar to how other people are feeling in that same situation. And it's really tempting to think, well, maybe they like it, but I wouldn't, or vice versa. But if you ask a few people, if you get a decent sample size, you start to get an aggregate or an average.
SPEAKER_00A way that I'm applying this is if you uh listen to the last series, which was on the decision to be a parent or not in the modern world, or the episode before that on decisions we can't take back, such as having a kid, you will know that's something that I've been struggling with. So something I've been doing lately is talking to parents or child-free individuals about their life. What is their day-to-day like? What are some of the aspects that surprised them about going down this path and trying to really understand what it's like, what they're happy with, what they're not happy with, because it's really hard to just visualize, oh, this would make me feel good.
SPEAKER_00This is what a day-to-day would be like without actually living that experience. And I actually had a phone call yesterday with someone that was on the fence for years and decided to be a mother and about what that was like. And I found some of the realizations really surprising. And next week I'm going to talk to someone that is on the other side who was on the fence for a long time and decided not to have kids. I don't say that to get back into that topic. We already talked enough about it for now. It's about the idea of if there's something that you're trying to decide on, can you talk to three people about what it is like?
SPEAKER_00Because, for instance, if you talk to one, it could be skewed. An example I saw about that is if you ask someone if they like a restaurant and they love spicy food, they say they loved it. And if you don't like spicy food, opinion would be skewed compared to how you'd feel. But if you ask a few people, it's kind of like getting Yelp reviews for a certain life path. So I wonder if that's something you could apply with a decision that you've been weighing to more accurately forecast your potential happiness down that path.
SPEAKER_00Finally, I'd like to get into the field of positive psychology a little bit more broadly in our footnotes section, where I add a little bit more clarity for people that are curious about this field. I think a lot of people know a lot of psych 101 stuff. They maybe know about the difference between neuroscience and cognitive, but I don't think that many people have heard about the field of positive psychology. When I talk to people, they haven't really heard much about the field. And it is slightly newer compared to other branches of psychology.
SPEAKER_00And what's so neat about it is for so long, psychology studied what we were doing wrong or how people could go from really struggling to doing okay. Whereas, as this quote says from Peterson 2008, positive psychology is the scientific study of what makes life worth living. This field is not just about pop psychology of what probably makes us happy. It is an area like other psychology branches where people are doing real research, which is exciting.
SPEAKER_00And finally, the field does not only look at what are the action steps we can take. It's also evaluating, for instance, what happens throughout one's lifetime? How does happiness change throughout lifespan? And it researches a lot of different areas, kind of like we talked about before. How much is controlled by circumstances? And to close that loop that I opened earlier, it's often debated: does increased income increase happiness levels? I will link an article down below on that that I think synthesizes a lot of contrasting opinions on this.
SPEAKER_00For a while, probably like 10 years ago, there was some research saying up to$60,000 or after$60,000, happiness does not increase with increased income. A, that didn't really differentiate, at least from what I heard. I didn't read the research, I would just hear this cited a lot. Didn't factor in family size, it didn't factor in where you live in the country. Then of course, with inflation, I think it got bumped up to$80,000 at a certain point to take some of this into account. The article I'm going to link below, I think describes after 110,000 happiness doesn't change.
SPEAKER_00All of this is um based in America, by the way, it would depend on where people are at. At lower income levels, of course, additional money is going to make someone happier because they're able to sleep easier at night, pay their bills, not worry about going to the hospital if they need to. And the more money you make, the less difference it makes. And even past a certain point, once someone is pretty wealthy, it doesn't make them happier at all. There is a ceiling. And especially what the article talks about is if someone is unhappy and wealthy, more money is not going to make them happier.
SPEAKER_00It's essentially the idea. And I don't think that this is surprising to anyone. One of my exes used to always think that psychology was too obvious to study because almost all of these points, one would think, yeah, that kind of would assume that. But I told him that he was missing what was interesting. What's interesting is the application, it's what we do next. That's why I'm really excited to dig into this series where we talk about how to make a lot of this applicable in our lives, the more specifics for these different areas for PermaPlus and beyond.
SPEAKER_00The producer of Immersion, Miranda and I, we would love to hear from you. If there's certain areas that you have questions on or want to dig deeper into, you can comment on YouTube or you can write into the show at a link I will drop down below on the my website, or you can call into the show. You might even be featured in a voicemail section if you want. It's really easy to just press record, record a little voicemail, and then it sends it to our inbox.
SPEAKER_00So we would love to hear from you about if there's anything that would be helpful in this series. And also on that note, I noticed in my podcast statistics that listeners seem to be really spread out, which is awesome. I believe that there is a listener in Finland, Singapore, Lithuania, Australia, a couple in the UK. I also would love to hear if there is a certain way of looking at this subject matter of how people maybe view happiness in your culture.
SPEAKER_00I think that it's also particularly pretty Western to think that we need to only be happy all the time versus leaning into some negative emotions. I would love to just hear different perspectives on this because later in the series we'll also cover is happiness even the right aim in general? That'll probably be our last one in this series. And I also just am curious to hear people's perspectives from anywhere because it's great to connect with people who care about the same things.
SPEAKER_00So thank you for being here. So happy that you're here and see you next week.
There was a time when large cultural moments brought us together. Everyone was watching the same movies and shows, reading the same books, and participating in the same cultural conversations. But with so much more...
Do you ever struggle with choice overload or analysis paralysis? We’re continuing our series on The Paradox of Choice, exploring the practical implications of the ideas in Barry Schwartz’s book for our daily lives. In...
This is Part 2 of our discussion on the Paradox of Choice and dating apps. In this episode, I’m joined by a friend to discuss his experiences navigating dating apps in a place like New York City, where the paradox of...
If you’ve been on the apps for some time, you know that while there are more options than ever to find love presented in front of us, in many ways, it can feel harder. This is counterintuitive - so in this episode, we...
Would you rather feel happy with your decision or make a slightly better “objective” choice? It’s an interesting question, and in this episode, we unpack it through the lens of maximizing vs. satisficing. What does it...