Branding is difficult because you are trying to turn a complex, 3D human or experience into a flat, 2D logo. In this episode we cover the psychology of branding and how to simplify your message without losing your authenticity. In this episode, we cover: 00:00 The Thesis: "3D Humans" vs. "2D Brands" 01:20 Personal story and rebranding the podcast 02:00 How Nike does this well 03:27 Keeping authenticity despite simplification 05:49 Person vs. Persona: Drawing the line 07:21 Sticky" Branding: Amplifying your core essence 08:58 Working with a branding expert for our re-brand 10:44 Defining branding - is it just a logo or much more? - Case study with Apple 12:42 On coming up with names for brands 13:53 The Mystery Gap: What to show vs. what to hide 15:23 Existence Precedes Essence: How Jean-Paul Sartre’s philosophy explains modern personal branding. 17:25 How to identify what makes you unique in a saturated market 21:31 How to apply this as a consumer 22:46 Reviewing all touch points for your brand while considering your ideal customer or consumer 25:30 On our continued rebrand and if you are thinking about rebranding 26:40 Conclusion: Marrying the 2D & 3D Self Resources mentioned in this episode: Cal Newport's article in "The New Yorker" https://www.newyorker.com/culture/cultural-comment/tiktok-and-the-fall-of-the-social-media-giants His podcast Deep Questions here goes into this idea further: https://podcasts.apple.com/us/podcast/deep-questions-with-cal-newport/id1515786216?i=1000732634023 The branding expert we worked with Patrick Pearce: https://www.linkedin.com/in/mtlpatrickpearce/ Marty Neumeier defing branding on The Futur https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=sO4te2QNsHY Colin Gray's episode on the brand becoming the name and not the other way around: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=ja3HfB2f7fY Branding and philosophy / existentialism: https://www.brainzooming.com/blog/brand-marketing-and-existentialism-by-randall-rozin Write in to the show here Leave a voice message here Newsletter sign up YouTube - channel Instagram - we will be posting here soon
Audio and video play straight from the show's own hosting. PodSubs stores and serves no media.
Transcript
From the show. Tap a time to play from there.
SPEAKER_00Coming up later in the episode, I examine this Cal Newport theory from The New Yorker. You may have noticed that so many social media platforms are just becoming twins of each other. Now they all have stories. Now all of them have the same kind of algorithm where it's just trying to push the most wild stuff to the top. For instance, it's a dog flying through the air, uh parasailing. Is that the thing where it's up in the air? And it's like, sure, but if they all are trying to be the most outrageous or eye-catching, they're all sort of the same now, and then they've lost what makes them unique.
SPEAKER_00And I think that we do that with ourselves often, especially if we fall prey to comparison, which basically everyone does, it can be easy to try to mold yourself into something that you're not, and then you lose what makes you special or unique or competitive in the marketplace in the first place. Hello and welcome to Immersion, 30 Minutes Beneath the Surface. This week's topic is the psychology of branding. Specifically, what we're going to get into is how in the modern world we have to represent ourselves or our businesses, creative interests into a 2D flattened concept instead of a 3D lived-in experience, in order to make sense to people at first.
SPEAKER_00And how this reduces authenticity, but it's also necessary. What brought up this topic for me is as you might have noticed, we rebranded the show from the Pam Carrie show to Immersion. And to help us with this process, we actually worked with an expert who kept asking, why you, why this show, when there are so many other alternatives out there. There are 400,000 at least other podcasts out there. So why are you making this show? And it's hard to answer that question at first, especially as we'll get into.
SPEAKER_00I mean, maybe you're going through this and asking, yeah, how can I differentiate myself when there are so many other options? But first, let's dig more into that 2D versus 3D concept. And to illustrate that, let's use a well-known example. Nike is used in a lot of branding talks, and that is because they have such a clear brand. We all know the Nike swoosh. We all know just do it. We all know how the commercials feel. They can feel pretty motivating to get off the couch and go work out. And that just do it slogan, what they're saying, is really appealing because we also all know that feeling of dropping whatever else is on our mind to get something done, whether it's a project or a workout, to just do it.
SPEAKER_00But more importantly, what are they not saying through this messaging? When a brand is strong, when it has an opinion, by the nature of saying something, they're also not saying something else. The slogan just do it is not saying, hey, it's okay to press snooze if you're really tired. It's not saying, let's analyze what got in the way last time you tried and failed. It's simple and that's part of what works for it, especially in a world that can overcomplicate. Let's contrast that with some other workout or gem brands that emphasize no judgments or judgment-free zone.
SPEAKER_00Now, this is not to say that your Nike shoes are judging you from across the room on the days you don't go for a run. It is just saying that by the very nature of boiling something down to a very simple essence, you have an opinion, you stand for something, and then you can't end up standing for everything. In fact, that's a very common saying. If you stand for everything, you end up standing for nothing. If you try to appeal to everyone, you end up appealing to no one. But this can be difficult in the process of refinement. In this way, branding is actually taking apart and taking away everything that blocks the path of a very clear message.
SPEAKER_00When I was doing the rebranding for the show, part of the reason I struggled so much to get to that core essence, at least for what I want to do, is I wanted to show all parts of myself right away. The nerdy part and the researcher, the coach part that will say some tough love at times, the part that could be playful, silly, or quirky, the part that could be professional and just get the work done when they needed. I wanted to try to be myself, to be authentic, which on any given day could have any of those hats, but that's too complicated to show up front.
SPEAKER_00It doesn't really make sense to people. And what I learned also through going through this process is that you can be authentic when people are actually interacting with the product and in the experience. It is the the brand on the outset, what people see on the front door, the image, that needs to be simple and 2D. But when you watch the video or listen to the podcast, you will get all those sides of me. So this would apply to a business where maybe they realize they really want to have a clean, modern look, which helps attract their ideal customer, but it could be viewed as a bit cold.
SPEAKER_00That doesn't mean that there's a stuck in the persona of being cold. They can be so warm from that first handshake on, but the branding could emphasize the modernity. And so there's this back and forth, this push and pull between authenticity, which taken too far can mean letting it all hang out there, and then this other pull towards curation. And I think we all know what something can feel like when it's over-curated. It reminds me, I guess, personified as uh Michaela or Kiki in Sirens, from the clothes she wears to her posture, her tone of voice, the angling of the head, the word choice, the people she surrounds herself by, her home.
SPEAKER_00And this is where something gets blurry. She has an organization helping these wild birds, but she also has, you know, herself as a person. And I think that in this marketplace, the line gets really blurry because what part of her is just her and what part of her is the figurehead for that organization. And especially these days where a very high percentage of the marketplace is either working for themselves or maybe has some sort of side or creative project, that line gets blurry too.
SPEAKER_00It makes me think of the author who knows that when they show up for interviews, they need to dress a certain way, or their messaging on their social media needs a unified theme. And this can be limiting. And it also makes me wonder this is something that we're not going to get quite as into in this episode because it's a really uh complex question. It could be a different episode, maybe down the line, is is this in a way a commodification of the self or an objectification of the self? Because at what point, if that author becomes their brand, like a person at a certain level, when you think of your favorite author, someone that's maybe made it pretty big, you think of their work.
SPEAKER_00You don't necessarily think or know of them as a human being, which is which is a bit separate. But then the way people, even on a much smaller scale, curate their social media, curate how they present themselves to the world, if almost everyone has some sort of either creative ambition, side project, freelance, you know, like if you work for an organization and you're under a huge figurehead, you might not really ever have to think about this because that huge organization is taking care of all of that for you. Wow, I'm getting off script. Let's get back on script because that could be a topic for a possible future episode.
SPEAKER_00Now we'll get to some advice later on in the episode if you don't know what makes your work special or unique. But here in the dive section, I want to close it out by just expressing this concept more abstractly, more in a philosophical way, of asking what is true, what is amplified. Think of a comedian or a musician. Most comedians, maybe they have a little bit of that persona in their everyday life, but in order to make the stories more interesting, in order to make people want to tune in for 60 minutes, they have probably amplified what is unique about them to be more sticky.
SPEAKER_00And that's essentially what a brand is. Is it saying this is what's unique, this is what's sticky, this is what you can grab onto and understand very quickly in a world where there are thousands of other, who knows how many other comics out there. And this is happening regardless of the product or marketplace. Now, when I talk about customer experience or product, it's again, I'm not just talking about something like a water bottle or a physical product. We could, like we talked about authors, be talking about a book. And it doesn't even mean that the person's buying it.
SPEAKER_00You could get that book from a library, but in a way, you're investing your time still into that person's work. So we mean it a little bit more abstractly here. All right, now we are moving on to our explore section where we go broad, far, and wide into research and other people's opinions, mostly experts in this case, to examine this topic more through their insights and not my own at this point. So, first I want to give credit to someone I really appreciate, Patrick Pierce, who helped my producer Miranda and I with this rebrand.
SPEAKER_00I didn't take 100% of his advice at every turn, but he really helped me understand that you have to keep digging deeper. It took a couple months of analysis, and that's something that I never would have had the patience for had I done this on my own. I probably would have thought, yeah, yeah, I understand what I'm doing and what where I want to go, and let's just move on. But again, with so many alternatives out there, it's really different than doing this 15 years ago, and especially with how fast people move. Someone might end up on a website for a couple seconds and if it doesn't grab them, move on.
SPEAKER_00So we do need to take that time to do market analysis, what else is out there and how can you provide something of value? How can you attract the right people? And some really interesting stuff we learned from him pertained to naming. So let's look at abstract names versus more literal names. So I brought up Apple as an example and I said, Oh, you know, Apple is a good example of an abstract name. And he said, Yeah, Apple is an interesting case because they wanted a name that was very approachable. You know, everyone, I'm I'm not uh quoting him at this point, but you know, everyone eats apples, they know Apple, it's a very simple word, and they want people to understand that their product is very approachable, easy to use, intuitive.
SPEAKER_00And so that name portrays that very quickly. And that never would have occurred to me. I just thought it was kind of catchy, unique, cute, but there's all this subconscious messaging that also goes through in branding. And that's not always, I think sometimes people think subconscious, or it could be easy to think like sublimal or trying to take advantage of you. But again, they're also just trying to convey a message very quickly. And in the case of Apple, I think it was very effective and it's just smart branding. At this point in the video, let's go ahead and define branding. I know we're pretty far into be doing that, but it's relevant to where we're headed next.
SPEAKER_00So this is pulled from an interview. I will link that down below with Marty Newmar, and he's a branding expert. And he said that it is not a logo, it is not even a style guide that includes typography and all of these other aspects, and it is not even in the mind of the business owner. It is in the mind of the consumer. Here is a quote: a brand is a customer's gut feeling about a product, service, or company. He said that that customer is creating it with the raw materials that they're given.
SPEAKER_00So let's take an example. This is now my own thoughts, not his. Let's take Apple. Let's go a little bit further with that brand. When I think of Apple, I don't just think of the phone alone. I think of the packaging. I think of the text message feature that they're so well known for. I think of what the store is like when I walk in and how it looks and how I'm treated by customer service there. I think about the different features of the rolling out. I think about current and past leadership.
SPEAKER_00I think about the fact that they're a Fortune 10 company and just how huge of a company they are. All of these factors and more are in my mind in sort of a web or constellation of connected facts, giving me a picture of what that brand is to me in my mind. But Apple is something different in your mind. I just listed, who knows, maybe about seven different attributes that first come into my mind. But for you, not only could you have different attributes than your mind, but even though they're uniform and well put together, your Apple store near you might be different.
SPEAKER_00I mean, I even just know the one in Brooklyn is pretty different than one I've been to in Manhattan. So everyone will have a slightly different version of a brand in their mind. The idea of a brand living in the mind of the customer also pertains a little bit more to naming in the sense that a name doesn't even necessarily have to mean anything at first, but we give it meaning through how we interact with it and what we know of it. So think of Spotify. I don't think that that's a word. From the little bit I researched before this, I think it was a little bit of a funny moment where two people maybe were yelling out different things like spot and identify, and then they blended them and the name really worked.
SPEAKER_00But now when you think of Spotify, you think of the player, you maybe think of financial aspects regarding them, you think about the volume of music there. Maybe that's your preferred podcast player, maybe it's not, maybe like another one, but you think of the colors. At no point, especially years down the line, now that they're such a big player in the industry, you're not thinking like Spotify, that's a weird name. It just is what it is to you. The name becomes the brand versus the brand having to become the name. So naming is very interesting that way.
SPEAKER_00We don't take things literally once we start to understand what the brand is. We have this image in our mind that is more pressing. This last point I learned from an episode with Colin Gray, and I will link his info down below as well. Another thing I learned through doing research for this is that part of the simplicity means you don't have to show everything up front, and people get more and more the more they interact with it. So you're sort of leaving a trail for people to understand what you're doing, and you maybe do that in order of importance.
SPEAKER_00Because again, if you try to throw out too much at once, it would be like an image having 12 different things to focus on, and it's just too much for the eye to take in. It's kind of the same thing with any aspect of branding. I'll give you an example. There's a podcast I listened to with two women who talk about important issues, but they happen to be comedians. I listen to it, I enjoy the issues, but often at the end of the day, normally I wouldn't tune into a podcast about those issues because they're kind of heavy, but they're so funny.
SPEAKER_00They're friends that just make me feel like I have a bit of company at the end of the day doing dishes. And so nowhere in their branding do they say, hey, by the way, we're funny. I mean, first of all, it's just like never a good idea to like say something like that in branding, of course. But also, they just didn't need to. You get it right away. As soon as you start listening to an episode, you get that they're funny. So it is interesting to notice, okay, what do you highlight and what do you let people experience along the way? Because you can't show everything up front in that door front.
SPEAKER_00And here I use door front as a metaphor for your typography, your logo, whatever people would get when they show up at that metaphorical doorway. And so this gets to finally getting to some philosophy. We knew we were headed there because whenever there is something with no clear answer, you know who has some answers? Philosophers. So we'll examine this through existentialism. For instance, as I was researching, I came across an article on brain zooming by Randall Rosin, and and I'm going to quote something here.
SPEAKER_00Philosopher Jean-Paul Sard premise that existence precedes essence, hits the mark, and that we are as we exist, not as we or others would label us. As for brand creation and brand marketing, brands exist first before their true essence can be realized. In other words, it is the choices organizations make and the daily actions they take to bring to life their brand promise that makes for an authentic experience. So what I take this to mean is that we can do all of this work for creating a brand, but ultimately it's our actions that shape what the brand really is.
SPEAKER_00Someone could have on their website a value pertaining to integrity, but in certain choices they make, they could demolish that. And then no amount of saying it on a website will change how they're viewed in the customer's mind unless they make radical changes in how they behave day after day. And this can be a little bit freeing that yes, there's a lot of work to be done up front, but it's also our actions day after day that help shape the brand. I this is how I interpret it, by the way.
SPEAKER_00I actually don't know if that's how this person meant this. But I think that that can be a little bit freeing, even if it takes a little bit of work to periodically check in and ask, you know, am I on track with how I want to be conducting myself and my business and portraying it to the world also? So now we're going to move to the shift section where we have reflections and action steps. And I think we were hitting on one there with maybe periodic check-ins with ourselves or our team. But let's get into some others.
SPEAKER_00I think most importantly, as we're getting at here, branding is cutting to the core. It is asking with alternatives, why you? And so I think a really good example of this that I think a lot of people can relate to if they're online was illustrated by Cal Newport. And I'll link his episode down below on this. He was asking the question in an age of AI slop, where you can watch Michael Jackson dancing on Everest. I think that was an example he did, but I don't know. He had some really great examples.
SPEAKER_00Why would you watch someone just dancing in their kitchen, you know, something on TikTok? Like, how can any social media platform compete in this world where anything is possible to be created through video? It doesn't even have to have really existed. And he argued that if these social media platforms went back to their roots of what made them special or unique in the first place, then they would be able to compete. For instance, and a lot of this is in my own words, but I will link his description of this down below.
SPEAKER_00I think it's a great episode. And we're going to apply it to you and your business or understanding of businesses in a moment. But Facebook, for instance, could compete not by trying to do the same thing and having the most outrageous videos to try to capture your attention, but instead going back to, hey, this is a place where you are connected to tons of people you know. And it can even guess people that you know, you know, like, hey, do you know this friend? Because there is this interconnected web that is not replicated many other places, if any other place is quite like that.
SPEAKER_00So going back to what sets them apart would actually make them competitive. You may have noticed that so many social media platforms are just becoming twins of each other. Now they all have stories. Now all of them have the same kind of algorithm where it's just trying to push the most wild stuff to the top. For instance, the dog flying through the air, uh parasailing. Is that the thing where it's up in the air? And it's like, sure, but if they all are trying to be the most outrageous or eye-catching, they're all sort of the same now, and then they've lost what makes them unique.
SPEAKER_00And I think that we do that with ourselves often, especially if we fall prey to comparison, which basically everyone does, it can be easy to try to mold yourself into something that you're not, and then you lose what makes you special or unique or competitive in the marketplace in the first place. And if you have a hard time knowing, okay, what does make this unique, this product, what I have to offer, what I've made, you can talk to other people. And I recommend talking to a couple different groups.
SPEAKER_00You could talk to people that really, really know your product. And again, product doesn't just mean a tangible product here. You can talk to people that really, really know you if a lot of it has to do with a personal brand. For instance, in preparation for this rebrand, I worked with my writer's group who has watched every episode and gives feedback. I ask them, what makes what I do unique? Because it's really hard to tell, especially. We all can often be our own worst critics. So it was really affirming to know, oh, these are things that I should amplify or play up, or these are things that I could work on to try to improve that aren't going as well.
SPEAKER_00And it can be really illuminating. Like, for instance, some feedback I got from a couple people was that it's distracting when I change my background or I'm in another room or another angle. And I thought, well, why does that matter? It's about the ideas. And then I realized, like, no, that's literally branding 101, is it's not just about the product, it's about the packaging for that product in every single aspect. So that was really informative. And so talking to other people can help. And you can also talk to, I mean, not everyone needs to hire a branding expert, but you know, if you know when you're anyone in your life who works in marketing or advertising, branding, who has that kind of unique eye, picking their brain.
SPEAKER_00Um, of course, if you have the budget for it, working with someone who does that can be really helpful too. Because I think talking to someone that understands packaging and then someone that understands the product together can help you come up with packaging for your product. As I mentioned, this also applies to consumers of products. Everything that you've heard here, you might be applying to different businesses you know or see in your own life. And if this is a layer to reality that you've almost been blind to, I know that was me. This does not come naturally to me.
SPEAKER_00It can be really interesting to walk next time you're in a strip mall and just notice what the different businesses are named, notice the colors they use, notice when you land on a website. Maybe where they're trying to guide your eyeline. You don't need to think about this all the time, but it could be interesting to bring it a little bit more to your conscious experience. You might notice, oh, that does look like a donut. I didn't notice because the design was a bit more abstract. Or again, if you're like me and it's just something you were not paying attention to, you might notice some sort of obvious connections that you missed.
SPEAKER_00For example, Home Depot. Until I was renaming my show and actually analyzing names, I did not think about, oh, it's Home Depot, a depot for home goods. I just hadn't thought about it in that way of taking the words apart. Just to me, it was Home Depot. And that's where you go. If you need to get a lighting fixture, then they have pretty good plants as well. One example, also from a business owner's standpoint, could be to go through every single touch point pretending that you are a consumer. For instance, maybe someone is a dietitian and they might land on their social media page and realize that the outfit that they're wearing or the photo portrays a slightly different tone than they want to portray.
SPEAKER_00Maybe it's just a little bit too casual, even though it is friendly. But then doing this for every single layer of their visual and virtual experience. And another layer to this is creating or considering your ideal customer, or this is often called in the business world, one's avatar. Now, a really common mistake in the beginning with this is to cast this net way too wide to think, oh, anyone could benefit from what I'm making. And I know I made this mistake at first too, in the sense that not that I thought everyone would like my show, but I thought that it could apply to most people because it's about psychology and everyone has a brain, everyone has a mind, but not everyone likes to analyze said brain and said mind.
SPEAKER_00So it does not apply to everyone. In fact, I think it actually applies to a pretty small percent of the population. There's a reason that people don't talk about this stuff at dinner parties, but when you do meet someone that has similar interests, you really light up because hey, we can go down that rabbit hole together and they are along for the ride. After years of not understanding this, I started to get way more specific. What does my ideal listener to this show listen to? What do they read? What do they do in their free time after work?
SPEAKER_00And I started to do this a lot more once I actually had people that I knew tuned in every week, and a couple of them were people that I know, like even out of my friends, not everyone listens. Some people do and some people don't. So the people that actually tune in, that like the show authentically, not just because they're trying to be friendly or supportive for me uh to be nice. What do they have in common? And then I was able to actually paint a very clear image when writing up our branding brief. And then here's the key is this helps your branding decisions later.
SPEAKER_00My YouTube thumbnails have I'm gonna have to redo them or at least change them going forward because they were terrible. They were that typical, not the furthest end of this spectrum, but that typical, you know, click on me vibe. And the kind of thoughtful viewers, listeners, people that I want in this community, often they're not the type of people that will click on that stuff because they are again more into this nuanced psychological, philosophical take. Of course, they're not going to click on that stuff or be attracted to it.
SPEAKER_00But it can be really hard in that marketplace. Again, it's tempting to try to kind of either compete with everyone or do what everyone's doing or think short-sighted versus more long-term as well. And as you'll see, if you're watching this in real time versus tuning in a year from now, you'll see the brand evolve a little bit in real time. We don't have our new music done or our artwork, but the work that we've done digging deep into the kind of show that we want to become that will help guide these decisions. And I won't tell you the kind of feelings that we hope to evoke.
SPEAKER_00I hope that you get to decide for yourself because as Marty talked about, the brand lives in each and every person that comes into contact with a product, experience, service, anything like that. And I think that's kind of beautiful. And in that way, a brand is closer to a living organism than something that's static or set. So there was a little bit of a peek behind the curtain with this one. Often these episodes might pertain to a certain more evergreen topic. Sometimes they might be something going on in the current news cycle, sometimes they might be something that I'm just really curious about at the time.
SPEAKER_00If you're in the process of branding or rebranding, I think it's important to remember that rebrands are possible. They can be painful and time-consuming, but you are never pigeonholed. And after some deliberation, sometimes it's time to just do it. So, how do we marry this 2D and 3D concept? Trying to be all things to all people is exhausting, and it's also exhausting for the one experiencing that product. It's nice knowing that a certain author writes a certain type of book and knowing what you're going to get. But it's also important that we allow that author to branch out, even if we don't love their future books.
SPEAKER_00It's nice knowing that if you have a cultivated wardrobe in a certain business setting that you know what you're going to put on that day, but it's also limiting if you don't ever allow yourself to wear something different. So it's a balance between simplifying when it matters, but not oversimplifying to the point that we're over-condensing or flattening, breathing humanity into a brand over time, even if the logo and slogan are experienced fast. Being yourself, but also being understandable. And there's not one clear answer for all situations. It's a balance we have to strike. If you lean too far on one side, there's going to be trade-offs.
SPEAKER_00Either you're going to sacrifice authenticity with a clear brand, or you may have more authenticity, but lack a bit of clarity. So it depends on what you need more of in that moment. The artists I look up to are the ones that are constantly reinventing themselves, pushing the limits of their work and not just churning out more and more of what's worked before. And maybe to feel less jolting, there's a way to take people with you, to leave a trail of breadcrumbs and show the becoming and not only the result. Thank you for being here for this show. Whether you are new, whether you're coming in where the show was already immersion, or whether you have come along the way since it was the Pam Carrie show.
SPEAKER_00I am really excited for where we're going. And if you found this topic interesting, share it with a friend and have a conversation with them this week. And I will speak with you next week where we take another 30 minute dive on a new topic.
There was a time when large cultural moments brought us together. Everyone was watching the same movies and shows, reading the same books, and participating in the same cultural conversations. But with so much more...
Do you ever struggle with choice overload or analysis paralysis? We’re continuing our series on The Paradox of Choice, exploring the practical implications of the ideas in Barry Schwartz’s book for our daily lives. In...
This is Part 2 of our discussion on the Paradox of Choice and dating apps. In this episode, I’m joined by a friend to discuss his experiences navigating dating apps in a place like New York City, where the paradox of...
If you’ve been on the apps for some time, you know that while there are more options than ever to find love presented in front of us, in many ways, it can feel harder. This is counterintuitive - so in this episode, we...
Would you rather feel happy with your decision or make a slightly better “objective” choice? It’s an interesting question, and in this episode, we unpack it through the lens of maximizing vs. satisficing. What does it...