In order to love ourselves, we first have to know ourselves. But getting to know ourselves isn't always easy. Over time, we can become attached to a particular identity or story about who we are. While that story may be true, it may only be one part of us, leaving other authentic parts hidden beneath the surface. In this episode of Immersion, we explore how our self-concept develops, why we become attached to certain identities, and how we can begin reconnecting with who we are beneath the roles, labels, and stories we've accumulated over time. We'll cover: - The psychology behind how our self-concept forms, including the role of splitting. - Why it's normal for our sense of self to be partially shaped by our relationships and social world. - What the ego actually is (and how it differs from the way the term is often used). - The role of unconditional positive regard in humanistic psychology, and how being truly seen by others shapes our sense of self. - Practical exercises to help you get to know yourself more deeply and expand your sense of who you are. Who are you beneath the story you've been telling yourself? Timestamps: 00:00 How Does Self-Concept Form 04:14 Relational Models and the “Looking-Glass Self” 08:13 Ego Defined 10:22 How Self-Concept Becomes Too Rigid and We Suffer 14:12 Carl Rogers and Living With Congruence vs. Incongruence 15:32 Steps to Get to Know Ourselves Full Relationship to the self series playlist on YouTube: https://www.youtube.com/playlist?list=PLPJBR0a3Yz6vsH5TkuPFtd2b7YgbL11OG And Podcast version of the first episode of the series: https://www.buzzsprout.com/2318937/episodes/19265696 Resources: - Questions to fall in love: https://36questionsinlove.com - Creativity course book: The Artist's Way by Julia Cameron - How to Rebuild Self-Identity After Years of Shame by Tim Fletcher https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=VWktnnPa8Xs - Possible further reading - Ego and justification: https://www.psychologytoday.com/us/blog/theory-of-knowledge/202105/what-is-the-ego Write in to the show here Leave a voice message here Newsletter sign up YouTube - channel Instagram - we will be posting here soon
Audio and video play straight from the show's own hosting. PodSubs stores and serves no media.
Transcript
From the show. Tap a time to play from there.
SPEAKER_00So, how can we love ourselves if we don't truly know ourselves? Often, the version of ourselves that we love is the version that we present to the world, the business person, the well-put together woman, the athlete. And it would be tempting to oversimplify and say that this is completely a facade. I don't think that that is true either. I think that the person that works in business might truly love the strategy that's involved and who they are at work. But the problems arise when we become fixed in our identities and we hide behind them and we lose parts of ourselves.
SPEAKER_00So, how do we find who we truly are at our core, which could be a much more expansive version of ourselves? That's what we're going to dive into today. Welcome to Immersion, 30 Minutes Beneath the Surface. I'm your host, Pamela, and here we explore psychology and philosophy topics to find meaning in the modern world. Let's dive in. We need to start with the narrative because humans live through stories, and we've been telling ourselves stories about ourselves. So let's peek into the life of a woman named Elizabeth.
SPEAKER_00We first meet Elizabeth when she's 12 years old, heating up a meal while her siblings argued at the dinner table. She would come over and gently prompt them to get back to their homework. And Elizabeth didn't even realize that she stepped into the role of a parent a few years ago, around 10 or 11. She came to become the dependable one, the one adults thanked, but also expected a lot from. And once she became the dependable one, it quietly started informing all of her other choices. She ended up dating carefree men in her 20s who really appreciated her dependability and how she might sweep in to clean up their messes from time to time.
SPEAKER_00And they would give her affection back, but not the kind of love that she wanted, where she felt like she had an equal partner. She ended up finding a job working as an administrative assistant where everyone told her, You are so detail oriented, we can always count on you. And even taking personality quizzes, she would always get responses that said that she was conscientious or agreeable. And then she would feel validated in that and say, Yeah, that's me, that's what I bring to the world. Without even questioning that this is a story that she's been telling herself her entire life, that she sees herself through one narrow lens instead of like a kaleidoscope of many possibilities.
SPEAKER_00But what's important to realize is that none of this makes Elizabeth fake. She really is a caring and responsible person. But each event that emphasized this was like water carving the Grand Canyon, tiny events and perceptions and actions that made what was once adaptable feel and become more fixed. No single drop created the Grand Canyon, but over years the landscape itself has become reshaped. I think identity forms in much the same way. So today we are going to begin a three-part series within our relationship to self series, exploring one of the oldest questions that humans have asked.
SPEAKER_00Who am I? In this episode, we'll look at how our identity or self-concept forms. Next episode, we'll ask, how fixed is it really? And finally, we'll put everything together, we'll look at what psychology and philosophy suggest about living with a more flexible sense of self and more sense of possibility. So, first, let's define identity. When people talk about identity, they often think about the parts of themselves that are visibly or socially defined, such as gender, race, culture, nationality, and our roles in life.
SPEAKER_00And those are important parts of identity, but identity also includes the internal story we carry about ourselves, who we believe we are, what we're capable of, what we value. And psychologists often refer to this internal picture as our self-concept. So upon knowing that our dilemma is a rigid self-concept that we want to make more flexible, and that a lot of this was defined by early childhood experiences and other people, we could then come to the conclusion abruptly to not worry what anyone else thinks, find validation on the inside, and just decide yourself who you're going to be.
SPEAKER_00The problem is that it's a bit more complicated than that. A lot of psychology actually points to the fact that we learn about who we are in relationship to other people. We do not exist in a vacuum. Many branches of psychology, from relational psychoanalysis to social psychology to attachment theory, all support this. For example, Elizabeth did not think I am a caring and responsible person all on her own. Adults in her life would say things to her, such as when she set the table before dinner.
SPEAKER_00Wow, you are so helpful. And then she started to develop that view about herself. And the views that you have about yourself were things that were mirrored back to you from others. Those others were not only your parents, they were also teachers, they were peers and friends, they were coaches, they were someone you just met on the sidewalk. We are constantly informed about who we are from the outside. A theory that I find particularly helpful here comes from Charles Horton Cooley. He has this theory called the looking glass self.
SPEAKER_00And it takes things in a slightly different direction. We imagine ourselves through others' eyes, and then we develop feelings about ourselves based on that imagined evaluation. A really small example of the looking glass self could be viewed through the lens of appearance. Think about a day that you felt really good about how you dressed leaving the house. You might then pass someone on the street, think that they see you as a put-together person, think that's a good thing.
SPEAKER_00They view me in a positive way, and then view yourself in a positive way. We've talked about this before, how often we then bring a different energy into the world. So it's often not even how others view us, it's how we feel about how other people might view us. As you can see, it starts to be a lot of mental gymnastics, which is partly why people explore these ideas to begin with, the whole idea of working on your relationship with yourself, because you get to define yourself through your eyes and ask, how do I feel about how I'm presenting, my values, my actions, beliefs, words, all of it, versus only asking how do I look through others' eyes?
SPEAKER_00And the last branch of psychology that supports that our view of ourselves is not created in a vacuum is the idea of attachment theory, which we also talked about last week. John Balby and later other attachment researchers found that early relationships help us develop a model for how we see relationships, but also how we see ourselves in relationships. For instance, if you have an anxious attachment style, if you feel as though you need to work hard to earn love, you might feel yourself being perceived as too much sometimes.
SPEAKER_00And then you have a view of yourself as being too much. Versus someone with secure attachment might have a view of themselves that says, I am lovable, my needs matter, and the needs and feelings of the other person matter. And this doesn't just define how we show up in relationships, it is another part of our self-concept. So, how much validity is there here in these relational models and how they impact our view of ourselves? I think it's important to realize that we are social beings, relationships and our broader culture help us define ourselves, and this is to a large extent okay and helpful.
SPEAKER_00And we need to at least understand that our self-concept is in part shaped through feedback, belonging, comparison, social roles, that these things will inform how we see ourselves, and we need to understand that impact. Where it gets more nuanced, though, is that the self is not only created by others. We're not different around every single person we come into contact with. And finally, adults can choose to update these narratives and define themselves differently. The whole second half of this episode will have action steps on just how to do that.
SPEAKER_00But first, we need to go a little bit deeper on some of the theory as to how we got here. It's important now to dive into the idea of ego, which is integral to the idea of self-concept. If you've heard the term ego in culture, you've likely just heard it in the sense of being egotistical, someone having a big ego, just meaning that they're conceited. That's not how it's used in psychology, philosophy, spirituality, which are the fields that we're actually exploring in this series. I want you to think of it here actually how Merriam-Webster defines it very simply.
SPEAKER_00The self, especially as contrasted with another self or the world. You can think of it as yourself as a separate entity. The ego is protective, the ego is functional. You have a body, you are here, and you are trying to survive. And people that have a healthy sense of ego do see themselves as a separate person, their wants, their needs, their desires, and how to exert that in the world. Someone that has too little of that ego strength actually might crumble under pressure, not know what they want.
SPEAKER_00Or if they don't have true ego strength, if they're overcompensating, then there's those things such as excessive bragging or excessive force. We want a healthy and balanced sense of self. And something that's important to understand about the ego is that it has a lot of what's referred to as self-justification or the need to see ourselves as consistent over time. So let's now go back to Elizabeth as an example, the caring and dedicated daughter turned administrative assistant. She might behave, in one instance, a little bit selfishly.
SPEAKER_00And if someone called her out on that and said, you were actually a little bit selfish there, that would sting a disproportionate amount to someone like Elizabeth than it would someone else who maybe is at peace with the fact that they can sometimes be a little bit selfish. I even know someone who is a mother who actually attributes some of what makes her a good mother to the fact that she can sometimes be selfish, but she also defines selfishness as doing things like taking time to exercise and telling her husband, hey, I need you to take care of the kids today.
SPEAKER_00So for her, selfishness is just looking out for herself. But this is where identity gets to be a problem. Because if you have firmly attached to the idea that I have to be XYZ way, it's limiting. It's like playing with one hand tied behind your back, saying, I have to be fill in the blank. Then you've taken away possibility and agency. I'll give you an example from my life, and then we'll go into how we might bridge this with some work by Carl Rogers.
SPEAKER_00I always defined myself as being someone that was very hardworking. And if I'm being honest, I often still do. This meant in college pulling all-nighters constantly, which led to waking up in the library with sleep paralysis, heart racing and unable to move. It was very terrifying. If you've never had it, it's where you feel like you're trapped in your body and trapped asleep, but you can't move because you're just coming out of a dream. But anyway, it was developed through growing up, realizing if I do something like run extra sprints after soccer practice, not only did it give me an edge, which I was rewarded for, even the act of doing so, I got a reward from.
SPEAKER_00Coaches would notice, my parents would notice. And of course, that not only gave me a boost, but it gave me something to hold on to. Our identity in some ways is like a tether of who am I in this vast world. The idea that we could be anyone at any moment is a bit disorienting. And also, we want to, again, have that validation of feeling good about ourselves. The problem is, as I got older, I didn't have the ability to know when to rest or when to take care of myself. This led to things like overconsumption and addiction, because the problem is that if you're never compassionate with yourself, if you only approach things through force, the body and the mind will find ways for a release from the emotions or need for rest that it stuffed down before.
SPEAKER_00So there was a lot of dysfunction in not only this part of my life, but other parts of my life, because I was so rigidly attached to being a certain type of person. And that's really what we're talking about here is there are always consequences when you rigidly attach to one form of identity. And I would love to hear from you in the YouTube comments ways that you've seen this, either in your life, in culture, in stories, or with people that you've seen without saying who they are. We could all learn from each other. But let's now take a couple ideas from psychology to reintegrate ourselves, to give us a path forward.
SPEAKER_00Tim Fletcher has a great video on self-identity and shame that I'm going to link below. And he really clearly articulates what is often referred to as self-splitting, where you see a part of yourself that you hold up as this ideal self. In my case, it was being hardworking. And then you see a part of yourself that you're ashamed of, which often is the opposite of that. Needing breaks, needing that compassion, needing rest, being lazy. I lumped these things together when they shouldn't be.
SPEAKER_00And I disowned that and stuffed it down and said, I am not that person, even though sometimes we are that person, which I'm about to get into in a moment. But what Tim Fletcher, this counselor and speaker, does also really well is describe how we find these areas that were special and we double down on them. This is something I've talked about in past videos, but he also articulates well the ways that we then compare and compete. If you are always rewarded for being the attractive one, what happens when someone else walks in the room who's more attractive?
SPEAKER_00Because we've chosen one aspect of our identity where we need to be the best. This, of course, can lead to shame, but it comes from a limited view of the self. This is what all of this comes back to. And Carl Rogers, the humanistic psychologist, has a beautiful solution to this. He talks about living with congruence or incongruence. Congruence is when you feel as though your current life and reality is in alignment with your ideal self. Incongruence is when there's this discrepancy between who you feel like you should be ideally and your real self.
SPEAKER_00And this can make us feel anxious, it can make us feel cognitive dissonance. And the reason why this happens is because all of us have an ideal self in mind. But then we have what he refers to as an organism experience where we have feelings, which could be sorrow or fear, or even just simply being tired or hungry. And we can't wear a mask all the time to try to simply be our ideal self all the time.
SPEAKER_00And he believed the solution to this is what is known as unconditional positive regard. This is a beautiful part of humanistic psychology and Rogers practice, where you truly accept yourself and your feelings. And this actually brings about a better version of yourself that you feel better about and who actually functions in the world more effectively too. Now, someone might be asking, what next? Where do I go from here? We need to embark on the process of getting to know ourselves.
SPEAKER_00And this, as Tim Fletcher explains in his video, can take years. Think about getting to know another human being, true intimacy. Could you expect to know them in a few hangouts? Yet people expect to have a lot of progress in therapy after a few sessions where we tried to know ourselves very quickly. If you've been suppressing parts of yourself for decades, that's been very functional for you. And it's going to take time to reintegrate those parts. And also just find yourself because you missed out on all these years of play and experimentation where other people were allowed to do that.
SPEAKER_00That's something Tim also talks about in his video. These are the tools that I would recommend if you are completely stuck with how do I meet myself now? Targeted journaling practices, meditation, therapy, corrective relationships, and play and experimentation. But stay with me because I know that you've heard these before. So I want to explain why they work so well in this context. One tool that you could use, and I recommend it to every single human, whether you identify as an artist or not, is the artist's way.
SPEAKER_00It is a 12-week course on uncovering your creativity, a part of you that you've likely suppressed. But the beautiful part is through this process, you'll be doing three things. First, every morning you'll be writing stream of consciousness journaling. If you've never journaled regularly, and I mean for weeks at a time, you may have never had the breakthroughs that it is often accompanied by.
SPEAKER_00There are many subconscious thoughts that you might be suppressing or not even aware of that you might completely just let out on the page. Kind of like when you talk to a really understanding friend and you learn something through talking through it. So it's about having a regular process of kind of talking to yourself, getting to know yourself. And you might not realize that the rest of your day, you might be replaying conversations about other people, thinking about needing to pick the kids up at a certain time, wondering if that client email was phrased the right way. All of these things where you're kind of concerned about other people, tasks, how you're viewed, versus actually seeking to get to know yourself.
SPEAKER_00And the stream of consciousness journaling is not necessarily aimed at getting to know yourself. There will be some of that in the process. The other parts of the course have to do with taking yourself out on artist dates. So literally doing things that you wouldn't normally do, like going to a book reading, going to a film festival, just going to your library and picking out a book you would never normally pick up off the shelf, going for a walk in a new park.
SPEAKER_00And through this experimentation, you allow yourself to play, to try things. And not only is it nourishing, but you're getting to know new parts of yourself. And finally, there are many prompts and reflections and exercises so that we're not just getting up and going through the motions and repeating the same things all the time. Julia Cameron asks very specific questions, for instance, in the chapter on jealousy, to help us realize where it might be coming from. But there are many tools, journals, resources for prompted self-reflection.
SPEAKER_00This way, if you're not in therapy, maybe you have a guide with you getting you to think about things in a different way. Very targeted questions shape the way that we think and understand ourselves. I'll give you an example of that in relationships. You may have heard of the 36 questions to fall in love. Created by the researcher Arthur Aaron and popularized by the New York Times. And it's basically a list of questions that are so thought-provoking, deep, and intimate that if you do them with someone, it has a very high likelihood of you at least becoming friends or possibly even falling in love with this person.
SPEAKER_00Then it is followed by some prolonged eye contact afterwards. So it's a bit intense. And it can also help you fall in love deeper with someone that you're already in a relationship with. Truly knowing someone and being known is such an intimate act, and it does lead to love. And the opposite of that, not being known, not being understood, being projected upon, we know how negatively that feels. In a way, it can feel like the opposite of love, not being seen. Because so much of this, again, when we talk about that validation, how we're seen from the outside the looking glasses, we care so greatly often how we're seen through the eyes of others.
SPEAKER_00And a lot of what this series is about is learning to see ourselves through our own eyes, to appreciate what we see, to magnify what's important to us and to move in the directions that we want to go and how to unearth that if we're not sure. By the way, if you're curious for you and someone you're seeing, I will link to the 36 questions down below. I bring that up to say through targeted journaling prompts, you can get to know yourself better through questions that would never even occur to you that can help build that self-intimacy.
SPEAKER_00Next up, let's talk about a more unstructured practice. So, how does meditation help us get to know ourselves better? When visiting Japan, I spent a little bit of time studying meditation at a Buddhist temple. One thing that I found beautiful about Zen Buddhism in particular is that they didn't really recommend a curriculum in a traditional sense. And the practice is deceptively simple. You sit often with your attention on your breath and keep returning to the present moment.
SPEAKER_00And what's surprising is how much that simplicity can teach you. Anyone who's practiced meditation for a length of time knows that eventually the same thoughts and emotions will keep resurfacing and you'll recognize them and learn from them. You notice, I've been irritable lately because this This one person in my life has been treating me a way that's bothering me. And if I don't address it directly, it's going to come out kind of passive aggressively. I can feel that bubbling up. Or I've been escaping into hours of TV every evening because I'm dissatisfied with work.
SPEAKER_00And you start to realize that that distraction isn't going to solve the root problem because instead of continually running from it, you're sitting with yourself. Meditation creates the conditions where it's harder to hide from yourself. And sometimes that self-knowledge goes beyond habits or anxieties. And there's moments where that constant narration quiets down a bit. And instead of feeling separate from everything, you start to feel deeply connected to nature, other people, or simply reality as it is.
SPEAKER_00Next, let's talk about why therapy is the gold standard for getting to know ourselves. I want to introduce the idea of blind spots. Part of the reason why therapy is so essential and why working with someone who their literal job is to help you get to know yourself and what you're hiding from yourself in ways you maybe split yourself, like we talked about, hiding the part we're ashamed of, amplifying the part that we are proud of, is this was a survival technique for you. You might have been in a situation, whether you were bullied in school, whether it was your home life, where it was of the utmost importance to suppress this part of yourself.
SPEAKER_00So because it was a survival strategy, you will often not know you're doing it. Or maybe even if you do, you won't know the extent you're doing it, other ways it's coming out, or how to break out of it. Because maybe your brain still mostly sees the benefits, not the ways it's also detrimental to you. I remember my first session with my therapist, who I've now worked with off and on for many years. She was challenging me on some of these views of what I felt like I needed to achieve. And again, that work ethic part.
SPEAKER_00And she said, Is it okay for someone else to take breaks? And I said, Yeah, of course. Of course it's okay for other people to take breaks. It's just not okay for me to take breaks. You know, at the time I felt guilty for even maybe 20 minutes of TV at the end of the day. And she said, Anytime that you think you're the exception to something, it's a flag to pay attention to. And her being so direct, calling that out, first of all, was really helpful for other things in life where I felt like I was the exception to something because that's not a great thing to do.
SPEAKER_00I'm a little embarrassed even sharing that, but I want to be transparent here of how this process can look. Because it took a long time together trying to uncover why did I feel like I had to be this specific way? It wasn't just like, okay, we know that it's dysfunctional, that I can't take a break. Great, just start taking breaks. It doesn't work that way. It's pulling apart a really tangled ball of yarn week by week with a person that knows how to untangle that ball of yarn. Now, here's actually a better analogy for it.
SPEAKER_00They can see the ball of yarn. You're doing it with your eyes closed. And they don't have the same pain that you're bringing in because sometimes it's too painful to just set down our defenses right away without the help of a loving, supportive person that sees not only who we are, but we can be on the other side of that. Two more things that will help you get to know yourself deeper. One is play and experimentation. We touched on that a bit through the artist's way, but Tim Fletcher did bring up in his video that I keep referencing here that children get the chance to play and experiment when they're growing up to figure out what they like.
SPEAKER_00If you were raised in an environment where you again had that splitting, you had to be a certain way, then you never got the chance to do that. And you never got the chance to learn what you like and who you are. So he brings up in the episode that someone could be 50 years old and not know who they really are. So it's okay if you're starting then, but the point is to start then. And it might take, again, working through, he has a program that he's referencing in it, but it could be something you do with a therapist. You get to know yourself for a while, then you realize, oh, I really light up when I think about how different colors work together in a room and how that makes someone feel.
SPEAKER_00I really love helping friends rearrange their living room. I really like looking through magazines on design. And suddenly you realize that you really appreciate design. We don't know if that will turn into your future career or just something you do occasionally with friends to help them out. But what we do know is that you found something that you liked through paying attention to yourself, A, even just noticing. B, experimentation and play. C awareness, seeing how you feel as you do that over time.
SPEAKER_00This is how we get to know ourselves. It is not linear. It might take exploring many things. Another way we can get to know ourselves is through corrective experiences in relationships with other people. This is something we talked a bit about last week, but just to summarize it here, every time we form a relationship with someone that sees us authentically, validates our emotions, helps bring out the best in us and us in them, we get to know ourselves better. This is called effective mirroring.
SPEAKER_00And if you were only seen for what you could do for the other person, or you were only seen in lights that the other person could accept or tolerate, they maybe couldn't tolerate your sadness or your vulnerability, then you never really had an accurate mirror. And when we form healthier relationships, maybe through a 12-step recovery group, whether through a new friend later, or even a romantic relationship, this does help to get to know ourselves because again, like we talked about, some of getting to know ourselves is reflected from the outside.
SPEAKER_00The problem is, and what makes this difficult, is that often we will seek out people unconsciously that reflect back to us the version of ourselves that we think we are, this identity that we've latched onto. Someone like Elizabeth ending up with those carefree men that need a caretaker, she will continually get that reflected back to her that she is only valued for being responsible, detail-oriented. And this is what we often do.
SPEAKER_00We can talk more about this another time if you're curious about how this plays out. But over time, if we can learn to present ourselves authentically from the start, then we'll be more likely to attract people that want us for who we are versus this identity or self-concept that we've latched onto. Often it does take getting to know ourselves and learning to be authentic first. And sometimes it's a little bit easier in places like friendships, therapy, or group work first.
SPEAKER_00So, where have we ended at the end of this first episode? We've ended where Elizabeth has currently paused. She hasn't changed her job. She hasn't necessarily ended her relationships, but she's more curious about who she is. She pauses and she notices when she's repeating these same patterns, she notices what's reflected back in the world around her. She notices how a lot of this started when she was very young. And for the first time, she's asking a different question.
SPEAKER_00She's not asking, who am I? She's asking, who has the world told me that I've needed to be? And if you don't have to be that person anymore, who could you be? Speak with you next week. I release episodes Sunday morning. They're available on YouTube, and many podcast players all are linked down below in the description. See you then.
There was a time when large cultural moments brought us together. Everyone was watching the same movies and shows, reading the same books, and participating in the same cultural conversations. But with so much more...
Do you ever struggle with choice overload or analysis paralysis? We’re continuing our series on The Paradox of Choice, exploring the practical implications of the ideas in Barry Schwartz’s book for our daily lives. In...
This is Part 2 of our discussion on the Paradox of Choice and dating apps. In this episode, I’m joined by a friend to discuss his experiences navigating dating apps in a place like New York City, where the paradox of...
If you’ve been on the apps for some time, you know that while there are more options than ever to find love presented in front of us, in many ways, it can feel harder. This is counterintuitive - so in this episode, we...
Would you rather feel happy with your decision or make a slightly better “objective” choice? It’s an interesting question, and in this episode, we unpack it through the lens of maximizing vs. satisficing. What does it...