Contempt is one of the most damaging emotions in human connection - but what exactly is it, and why can it be so difficult to let go of? In this episode of Immersion, we explore the walls that are often built between ourselves and others, sometimes unspoken and sometimes maintained for decades. These walls can form between people in romantic relationships, workplaces, the political arena, group dynamics, and even within our relationship to ourselves. Some psychologists suggest that contempt doesn’t simply go away on its own - it persists unless we begin to break down the walls that keep us separated. So today, we’re asking: What are these walls made of? Finally, we explore how contempt can often be an attempt to get out in front of pain - to protect ourselves before we can be hurt. I hope this episode helps you dive deeper into the ways we can find healing through connection. I’d love to hear what you think. 00:00 The most dangerous emotion in human connection: contempt 00:44 What is contempt? An example 02:40 How different psychologists define contempt: primary vs. secondary emotions 05:13 When is contempt likely to occur? 7:00 Criticism vs. contempt 07:25 It’s not about if we have conflict, but how we have conflict 08:04 Why this emotion is so dangerous: resentment, walls, and disengagement 09:24 What does contempt look like? 10:20 Why doesn’t contempt just go away? 12:13 Group dynamics and contempt 15:29 Contempt directed at the self 16:44 Action steps and hope Resources: - Paul Ekman on contempt: https://www.paulekman.com/universal-emotions/what-is-contempt/ - Vanessa Van Edwards speaking about contempt on The Psychology of Relationships podcast https://podcasts.apple.com/us/podcast/the-psychology-of-relationships/id1852111386?i=1000777054616 - The Gottman Institute on Contempt https://www.gottman.com/blog/the-four-horsemen-contempt/ - Psychology today article quoted for group dynamics part: https://www.psychologytoday.com/us/blog/the-psychology-of-intergroup-conflict-and-reconciliation/202204/a-devil-in-disguise-how - Terry Real quote on contempt directed outwards vs inwards https://www.youtube.com/shorts/vgWJvcxZvxU Write in to the show here Leave a voice message here Newsletter sign up YouTube - channel Instagram - we will be posting here soon
Audio and video play straight from the show's own hosting. PodSubs stores and serves no media.
Transcript
From the show. Tap a time to play from there.
SPEAKER_00In this episode, we are going to discuss what is often regarded as the most dangerous emotion in human connection. Have you ever felt that someone both didn't like something about you and disrespected it at the same time? It is an awful feeling. Today we are going to talk about contempt, which is a very complicated emotion. Many psychologists believe that there's actually several emotions inside of it. So today we'll unpack what is this emotion, why is it so destructive to connection, and what are some things that we can do about it to connect better with others?
SPEAKER_00Welcome to Immersion. I'm your host, Pamela, and here we explore psychology and philosophy to find meaning in the modern world. Let's dive in. So many of you know that I like to often give the central idea upfront. Contempt is not just another emotion. It is when resentment, pain, fear things build up for so long that then it turns into a feeling of superiority and then becomes like a wall between you and this other person or group.
SPEAKER_00Let's look at an example from the website of the Gottman Institute, which is founded by John Gottman, who is a relationship researcher you may have heard of. And we'll be looking at their work during this episode. So on their website, which I'm linking down below, they have an example of one person who is frequently late. And then their partner says to them one day, look, I learned how to tell time when I was five years old. When are you ever gonna learn? This has so much in it. And that's the whole reason we're doing this, is because contempt is different from the other ways people show up in conflict that John Gottman has researched, such as defensiveness, such as criticism, stonewalling, the other parts of what is referred to as the four horsemen, which are the most destructive patterns in relationships.
SPEAKER_00But contempt is widely regarded as the most dangerous. And in his research, he found the number one predictor of divorce when it is not repaired well. So what's happening in this example? The person is not just saying, Oh, it's really frustrating to me that you're always late. That would have not been great because they would have said always, which is another relationship no-no to not have black and white thinking, because this person is likely not late a hundred percent of the time. But this is worse because saying, look, I learned how to tell time when I was five years old.
SPEAKER_00When are you ever gonna learn? What that does is it establishes one person in the relationship as superior, maybe more of the adult who knows more. It implies the other person is flawed and almost incapable of changing. This is where I want to get into how different psychologists define contempt in their own unique ways. Paul Elkman, who is a researcher who has done a lot of work on emotions, found contempt to be one of what he deemed to be seven primary emotions, including anger and enjoyment.
SPEAKER_00These are emotions that he says are universal and they can come up spontaneously. Other psychologists believe that contempt is a secondary emotion. A secondary emotion is less immediate, and it's when we have a combination of emotions or cognitive processes that are layered on. So let's look at an example of that. If someone is jealous, their initial primary emotion is likely anger or fear. This is something that we talked about in our episode called Happiness is not the opposite of sadness, which goes into primary and secondary emotions also.
SPEAKER_00But just to recap that here, if someone maybe sees their partner flirting with someone, they might initially feel some fear about losing them. And then that's the primary emotion is fear. And then in a process that happens so quickly that the way I conceptualize this is that we don't even know it's happening, we quickly layer something else on. So jealousy is what we feel right after the fact. And it can be from insecurities that then protect us from feeling that pain of that primary emotion. And it can have to do with shame and other deeper things we're experiencing.
SPEAKER_00So, why does it matter that some people view contempt as a secondary emotion? Well, because if this is the case, then that can mean that there's a lot more complicated aspects going on. Some psychologists define contempt as a combination of other emotions, such as anger, disgust, and even disengagement. Let's look at that in an example. Imagine that you're scrolling social media and you see a post that you just completely disagree with. And then your knee-jerk reaction is not, I disagree with that.
SPEAKER_00Instead, it's, oh, those people are such idiots. In that moment, you felt maybe some anger. You felt disengagement potentially, almost putting that wallet between you and them, like, I can't with these people. You just feel so frustrated that you almost view there's no hope of connecting reconciliation, getting on the same page. And there might even be a sense of disgust is a certain word that might apply in some aspects for contempt, but we could also think of this as simply disrespect.
SPEAKER_00We really want to see with contempt that there is this hierarchy in play. And the hierarchy does not always actually mean that those in power are looking down on those that are not in power. It can often go the other way. And sometimes that can be from a place of seeking protection or a way for a certain group to feel more superior. For instance, on Paul Elkman's website in his article in contempt, he talked about teenagers feeling contempt or maybe a prisoner feeling contempt for a guard.
SPEAKER_00And this makes total sense. If someone, for instance, a prisoner, feels powerless or has even been wronged by a guard, it would be natural to feel negative feelings towards them. And those negative feelings could take many different forms or have many emotions baked into them. So this now brings up when are the situations when one is most likely to feel contempt. One is in very close interpersonal relationships. You don't likely feel contempt just for a friend often.
SPEAKER_00It's a lot more likely in a romantic relationship, which is why it comes up so much in couples therapy research or in these examples I'm giving. But it could also be in family dynamics. Anyone that you have a lot of close encounters with, contempt can come up because it often has to do with repeated conflict or repeated wrongdoings, or at least the perception of that. And then the other two times it often comes up is power struggles, like we've talked about. And then lastly, when someone has encountered something that they feel is in conflict with their morals, where they might then feel superior, for instance, that social media example we talked about.
SPEAKER_00Because all of these could then create a looking down upon another. If you want to boil it down to one way of looking at it, criticism might look like I don't like that you did that. Contempt often can look like, I don't like that you are this kind of a person. I don't respect this kind of a person that I think that you are from these actions that I've seen. And this is why it's so dangerous. A lot of the research that I've seen on contempt does come from the Gottman Institute.
SPEAKER_00One thing they're most known for is doing a longitudinal study over decades. They had over 3,000 couples come in and they studied them in conflict. What they noticed is that often it wasn't about having conflict or having different opinions on frequency of intimacy or finances. It was actually about how these couples talked about these things. And I think, again, this could apply in any relationship. If you're at work, it's not about if you have conflict, it's about how you work through that conflict.
SPEAKER_00And the reason why contempt is so, so dangerous in any kind of relationship is because over time, so much resentment has built up that you don't just see this person as doing something wrong. You view them as wrong. And the reason why it often can have disengagement is because after repeated conflicts, eventually you kind of just want to give up. So that's where, again, that wall can come up. I've actually read in some of my research that some psychologists say this is the one emotion that doesn't just go away.
SPEAKER_00You could have some sadness or anger, and these things are more fleeting, but contempt is lasting. And I don't think they mean that that emotion is always with you, persistent. I think what they mean is that it's a wall that comes between you and the other person because of these repeated conflicts or repeated hurts. And it doesn't happen right away. It happens once things have gotten really bad. So that's why it doesn't just go away on its own. It's a signal that many other things have gone wrong. I want to do some rapid fire questions, and then I want to relate this to group dynamics, our relationship with ourselves, and then look into some potential practical solutions to work on feeling this emotion a bit less.
SPEAKER_00So let's look at some rapid fire questions. One person might ask, how does this emotion look? And a couple of these parts of the rapid fire questions, I'm going to be pulling answers from an interview Vanessa Van Edwards did on the Psychology of Relationship podcast. I will link that episode down below. She said that contempt looks like a one-sided sneer or smirk. So it can look like this. Sorry to do it to you right now, but if you're watching the video version, you can see it.
SPEAKER_00I don't even know if that looked accurate. I'm going to link Paul Elkman's website below, which has a photo as well, so that if you're listening to the podcast version, you can see it as well. And once you see it, you definitely get it. And Vanessa said that some people could mistake it as half happiness because it's a smile, you know, on one side of your face. But as soon as you see it, it does sort of look like a bully. So you immediately understand, oh, yep, that that seems like contempt. Another thing that she mentioned on the episode helps answer the question: why is this something that persists?
SPEAKER_00Why doesn't it just go away like other emotions do? And she brought up a very simple example where contempt could come up. Imagine two people are meeting and someone brings up something about dogs, and then someone has that little facial expression pop up. And maybe they do have some contempt. And we don't actually know why they're experiencing that. And this gets into an action step right now, which is that you can ask someone, oh, what were you thinking about that? Or I feel like a thought just came up and I'm curious about that.
SPEAKER_00And that helps prevent those walls from being built between you and the other person. Because maybe that person is, I don't want to say judging, but does have a fleeting negative feeling about that interaction. We don't know why. It could be that they're, like I think she said in the interview, afraid of dogs or some other thing there. Let's imagine that this is a third date and the person is thinking, oh, this person probably loves dogs. I don't love dogs. This is going to be a source of conflict. Oh no. And so I actually think contempt is a pretty dramatic feeling to feel in that instance.
SPEAKER_00But I also wonder if there's maybe degrees of contempt, full-on kinds that could have been brewing for decades and then just flashes of maybe a one or two out of ten contempt, which is maybe what was happening there. And the last thing in this more fast-paced section is how else might this look if you're still a little bit stumped on what is contempt? How can I recognize it? It can also look like mockery, sneering, eye rolling, mimicking, sarcasm, name-calling, these things that can feel very toxic, and many of them are.
SPEAKER_00I will put well done sarcasm to the side, which could be a whole separate episode. But all of these things, they take a fight and then they're escalating it in a very specific way. So let's now briefly get into group dynamics. And I want to be careful in this section because this is definitely the section that could kick up the most for people. And I don't want people to think the solutions that I'm proposing at the end necessarily could apply to all of this as a cure all. I actually just think it's really important to understand the depths of the pain that a lot of people are experiencing.
SPEAKER_00So it's actually the opposite. It's just trying to see another lens for the walls that we've often built up between each other. Because often within group dynamics, one group could have been hurt for such a long time that eventually instead of thinking these people have hurt me, they move to these people are beneath me. And we're not justifying looking down on people, but we're understanding where it could have come from. We can have empathy for something without saying, hey, this is a great thing we should all do.
SPEAKER_00But I think it's really important to see. And the way this might unfold is someone might say, People like that hurt me. People like that are all a certain way, people like that are beneath my respect. That might be how it might flow. And I want to read a quote on this before we move to the self-contempt section. This is from a psychology today article that I'll link down below. Harvard professor Arthur Brooks' keynote address at the February 2020 national prayer breakfast, hosted by members of the United States Congress, was titled America's Crisis of Contempt.
SPEAKER_00In it, Brooks noticed people often say that our problem in America today is incivility or intolerance. This is incorrect. Motive attribution asymmetry leads to something far worse, contempt. And it's not just contempt for other people's ideas, but also for other people. In politics today, we treat each other as worthless, which is why our fights are so bitter and cooperation feels nearly impossible. I think I've said this before when we get into political discourse, I keep saying that these things could be a completely separate episode because I think that that's true.
SPEAKER_00I think there is so much psychology to unpack with some of the division we're having. And I think that these are really important conversations to have. And I think that my whole point in bringing this up here is to see the walls and what they're made of. Knowing that the walls are partially made of contempt and what contempt is and pulling it apart and seeing the anger and seeing the pain and seeing the disengagement that can come from it is really important. And I realize some of these things are about power hierarchies, some of these are just about different groups in general, some about the political divide, but we are just talking about the fact that this can apply in the macro as well as the micro.
SPEAKER_00And then now we'll shrink that even further to the self. This is relevant for a lot of the work we've been doing because we've been working on that relationship to the self series. And you've probably noticed that we've been interspersing other types of topics and episodes. So we are still doing that relationship to the self series. We have some guests coming on in the next month that I'm really excited about. So we will definitely keep going with that series, but it applies here because we can have self-contempt.
SPEAKER_00It looks like disdain or judgment towards yourself, having really maybe rigid standards and feeling terrible about yourself when you don't uphold them. Again, it's going from I did something wrong, that more criticism to I am wrong, which quite frankly is shame. And there's a good quote by the psychologist Terry Real on this who says, contempt is poison. Whether it's contempt that you direct at yourself, that's called shame, depression, or whether it's contempt that you direct at someone else, that's called grandiosity, superiority, retaliation.
SPEAKER_00And I thought this was really interesting because I hadn't thought about the idea of grandiosity in relationships. Usually we think of grandiosity in the sense of someone's over-inflated sense of self-importance, how great they are. But we can have grandiosity even in one-on-one connection. And I think that that distinction between contempt pointed outwards versus contempt pointed inwards is a useful distinction, but both can be destructive.
SPEAKER_00Now I'd like to end this with not only some action steps, but also what I hope is a feeling of hope. Because yes, contempt can be like building walls. Yes, if unaddressed, it's extremely destructive. But there are things that we can do to lessen these emotions in different dynamics. So, first of all, I think that in ourselves, just being aware of contempt can potentially lessen it because we realize the complexity of this emotion and we can see it for what it is.
SPEAKER_00Maybe when we're berating ourselves or we're in an argument with someone else, we can pause and realize oh, I'm actually feeling contempt right now. This goes beyond just a bit of some judgment or some annoyance. And then we can pull it apart and ask, this is the kicker. We want to ask, what is the hurt that I am feeling under this? What is the hurt I'm trying to run from? Because contempt is in a lot of ways, I believe, a defense mechanism.
SPEAKER_00Let's take that argument we talked about earlier with the couple where one person is always late. If that person asked, why does it bother me that they're always late? They might realize that there is so much under it. Maybe they grew up in a house where their parent was always making them late and they were getting in trouble at school and that being late makes them really anxious. Or maybe they just realize that someone being on time to them signifies that they're valued and they feel disrespected and not valued and not important to their partner.
SPEAKER_00When really they could be so important to their partner, but their partner maybe doesn't view it the same way. They just get really engrossed in what they're working on, or they're a little bit time blind. And it's not about them not valuing the person, it's just that they view this situation extremely different. If that person can look under the contempt asking, what is the hurt I'm running from? I don't think psychologists would say that all contempt is running from pain. Someone could be in traffic and have some contempt at a stranger for cutting them off.
SPEAKER_00Granted, I don't know. I think the framework still exists there. There was probably some fear of getting hurt or a collision, and then it could be a defense mechanism of anger as a result of that. I don't know. That could be an interesting thing to chew on. Is it always some pain that we're actually covering up? I don't have a clear answer to that, but it is a hypothesis that I'm willing to run with here and that we can chew on as we go about our lives. Another thing we can apply is curiosity. We mentioned it earlier. If you see contempt in others, asking, oh, what is that that just came up for you?
SPEAKER_00Like we talked about with the dog example. And that curiosity can apply to ourselves. Let's say that you feel like you've just been really behind on your work lately and you're always just getting things in at the last minute. You don't feel like you're living up to your standards. And let's say that actually turns into some self-contempt. I'm always doing this, I'm doing sloppy work. And it can turn into feelings of feeling not enough. And if you look under that, getting curious can look a variety of ways. Not only asking what is pain that I'm running from here, which that is pretty clear.
SPEAKER_00Usually when people attack themselves, it's trying to get ahead of the criticism of others. If I criticize my own work and my own standards, then other people cannot attack me to the same degree that I am. And it won't feel like getting the rug pulled out from under me by them. It's at least by myself, and that feels safer. But what else is going on there? Getting curious about, well, why am I getting it done at the last second? Do I have an incredible amount on my plate right now? Am I incredibly drained for some other reason, maybe some health reasons?
SPEAKER_00And getting curious about whose standards am I trying to live up to, mine or some that were thrusted upon me. And while I said I think it gets a little bit more complex when we're talking about group dynamics, with close interpersonal relationships or with ourselves, curiosity is such a gift. It is saying, I don't necessarily agree with what you're saying or love what you're doing, but I love you enough to try to understand you better. I want to understand you. I want to see where you're coming from. And it's a, in a sense, laying down our metaphorical weapons and looking for a connection, extending a hand.
SPEAKER_00And it's a form of vulnerability. I think it's hard to open up your mind and in a sense, opening up your heart that way to say, let me try to understand you, especially in an argument that's happened repeatedly, or with things that you've felt towards yourself for long periods of time. And so to get to our last strategy, we began with the Gottman Institute. We will end with their reflections as well. And they did list in their article on contempt that there are two solutions.
SPEAKER_00One is more short-term, discussing how something made you feel. That partner saying, I feel hurt when you're late because. And as you probably know, we want to stick to I feeling statements versus you statements. But the long-term solution to contempt is what they call building a culture of fondness and admiration. Culture is a very interesting word there. If you think about a job that you've had that had a culture where people really bought in, it probably felt so different than the kind of place where people sort of made fun of their boss or company policies or complained about things, again, kind of rolling their eyes about stuff going on there.
SPEAKER_00The culture can become, I don't want to say addictive, but it can become a cycle. It can be hard to break out of once there's a culture in place of this is how we collectively feel about the place that we go to or about our relationship. And so, what does a culture of fondness and admiration look like in a relationship? And I do think that this can apply to other types of relationships and friendships too. Gratitude, feeling gratitude, but also expressing it, thanking people, showing them that you notice what they're doing, how they're pouring into that relationship, small acts of kindness, sharing what you admire about them and why.
SPEAKER_00I'm proud of you for doing blank, and here's why. Just elaborating versus small tiny lines that you might throw out easily, digging a little bit deeper. And they also mention remembering the good times in the relationship and how couples that have a positive oral history where they describe the relationship in a positive way have better outcomes. But that can be hard to do when you're really unhappy in the relationship, which is why so much of this is about a negative downward spiral or an upward positive cycle. That is it for this episode.
SPEAKER_00I realize that this one could be viewed as a bit of a downer, but I actually think that there is hope here because this is something that's happening, whether we talk about it or not. So by looking at it and examining it and finding routes to experience it less, we can experience more positive connections and relationships. So I don't find it a downer, even if it maybe seemed like one at points. I think that some negative emotions can be very interesting. And what we like to do at immersion is go beneath the surface into it deeply, a certain topic, and then move on and do something else the following week.
SPEAKER_00So next week, we should be getting back to the relationship to self series. Although, if you've been around here long enough, you know there's no guarantees. It's a bit where the curiosity leads. But we do also have those interviews coming up. So we'll definitely get back to that series at some point. And thank you so much for being here. I appreciate you spending the time learning together. And last announcement, if you are new here, this is a podcast that's available on many podcast players such as Apple, Spotify, and many others. I'll link that down below, as well as a video option on YouTube.
SPEAKER_00If you're able to leave us a rating, just tapp those five stars wherever you're listening, or even if you're watching on YouTube. Most of our listens are on YouTube. If you want to help the show out, you can go to a podcast player and tap a rating or review, and it would really help us out. And so that's it for this week. And speak to you next week. We release episodes on Sunday. So talk to you then.
There was a time when large cultural moments brought us together. Everyone was watching the same movies and shows, reading the same books, and participating in the same cultural conversations. But with so much more...
Do you ever struggle with choice overload or analysis paralysis? We’re continuing our series on The Paradox of Choice, exploring the practical implications of the ideas in Barry Schwartz’s book for our daily lives. In...
This is Part 2 of our discussion on the Paradox of Choice and dating apps. In this episode, I’m joined by a friend to discuss his experiences navigating dating apps in a place like New York City, where the paradox of...
If you’ve been on the apps for some time, you know that while there are more options than ever to find love presented in front of us, in many ways, it can feel harder. This is counterintuitive - so in this episode, we...
Would you rather feel happy with your decision or make a slightly better “objective” choice? It’s an interesting question, and in this episode, we unpack it through the lens of maximizing vs. satisficing. What does it...