Skip to content
PodSubs
ShowsPeopleGuestsJobsNewsEvents
More
BlogPodCred
Menu
ShowsPeopleGuestsJobsNewsEventsBlogPodCredNetworksSign in
Join nowSign in
  • Shows
  • People
  • Jobs
  • News
  • More
    • Guests
    • Events
    • Blog
    • PodCred
    • Networks
    Join nowSign in

Immersion

Immersion artwork

How Do We Actually Heal From Trauma? A Psychologist on Self-Worth, Recovery & More

Aug 30, 202647 minAudio
ShareXLinkedInFacebookWhatsAppEmail

I sat down with clinical psychologist Anita, who specializes in trauma work to talk about what working through trauma actually looks like, how trauma-focused therapy works, and what healing can look like in practice. Timestamps: 00:00 Meet Anita & What we cover in this episode 01:42 When Are You Ready to Work on Trauma? 03:08 What Is Trauma-Focused Therapy? 04:08 Avoidance: How Do We Avoid Looking at Trauma? 07:18 Trauma, Self-Worth & Bridging the Gap Between Knowing and Feeling 10:57 Cognitive Processing Therapy & Incremental Improvement 12:00 How Different Forms of Therapy Work Together 16:55 Corrective Experiences & Healing in Connection 18:50 How Do We Learn Who Is Safe to Trust? 22:01 How Do We Change Our Patterns? 23:57 How “The Pendulum” Shows Up in Our Patterns 25:40 What Are the Stages of Healing From Trauma? 31:05 What Is Trauma? What Is PTSD? 34:07 Stepping Away From Comparative Suffering: “Your Pain Is Your Pain” 35:39 Integrating Fragmented Memories & Building a Narrative of Our Lives 38:36 Moving Between the Stages: Healing Isn’t Linear 41:10 The Back and Forth Between Therapy & Life 42:00 What to Expect in Therapy If You’ve Never Been 43:04 Why Is Therapy a One-Sided Relationship? Referenced in this episode: Judith Herman, Trauma and Recovery Cognitive Processing Therapy (CPT): https://www.apa.org/ptsd-guideline/treatments/cognitive-processing-therapy Anita's practice is currently full, but if anything changes, I will link more about her work here! Content note: This episode includes non-graphic discussion of trauma, PTSD, and abuse. Write in to the show here Leave a voice message here Newsletter sign up YouTube - channel Instagram - we will be posting here soon

Audio and video play straight from the show's own hosting. PodSubs stores and serves no media.

Transcript

From the show. Tap a time to play from there.

SPEAKER_00In this episode, I'm so grateful that my friend, who is a therapist who specializes in trauma, came onto the show and helped us do a real deep dive on this topic. If you subscribed, which a lot of you all did during the relationship to the self series, you might remember that we talked about wanting to do an episode specifically on how trauma affects self-worth and self-esteem. So we get into that in this episode. We also talk about what's the difference between knowing something, knowing it wasn't your fault, versus actually feeling that at your core, what qualifies as something like PTSD?

SPEAKER_00How do we actually work through trauma? What are the actual steps? Are there steps? How do corrective experiences or being in connection to others, how does that affect the healing process? Or what are different types of therapy? Because there's different ways we can even approach this work. So we discuss all of this and much more. It's a bit of a longer episode, and we did not do video for it. We really just wanted to focus on the conversation her and I, and we filmed in a certain location where video wasn't ideal.

SPEAKER_00But you might choose to just tuck this in your pocket while you're doing some chores or running an errand. Okay, so we'll get started. Welcome to Immersion. I'm your host, Pamela, and here we discuss psychology and philosophy topics to find meaning in the modern world. Let's dive in. And so I'm so excited to welcome my friend Anita to the show. Anita is a PhD psychologist with 14 years of clinical experience. Eight of those years were in a hospital setting specializing in trauma. Welcome to the show, Anita. Thanks for having me, Pam.

SPEAKER_00So the first question I have is something that actually came up yesterday. In a city, sometimes you'll witness things happening. Sometimes there's great cruelty. And it was a reminder to me that trauma can sometimes be things that we experience a long time ago, like 10 years ago, and we can talk about it in this very distanced way. And sometimes trauma is something that we're in the midst of right now. And we're getting into this heavy topic. Can you think of what might help the audience know if they're in a place where they're even ready to work on their trauma?

SPEAKER_01Honestly, I know it sounds very simple, but having an agreement with yourself that you are ready to do it is important because I think that there's so much ambivalence that comes with, I mean, when you think about it, looking at thinking about one of the worst, if not the worst, moments of your life. I think people underestimate one's own willingness to do that and motivation to do that. Because I think there's also a difference I've come to know in this work that there's a difference between wanting something and being ready for it, ready in terms of just giving time to it, both in session and outside of session, and the emotional capacity that you have at that time in your life.

SPEAKER_01So I think I think that's actually honestly probably the most important part of readiness for trauma work.

SPEAKER_00Some people might not have much of a background in what trauma work is. And all therapists, I'm sure, deal with trauma in some capacity. So, how would you say a trauma therapist or someone that specializes in that is unique?

SPEAKER_01So, okay, this is interesting because I think that what makes trauma-focused treatment different is there is an explicitness to what you're doing in therapy. There very much has to be like an agreement between client and therapist that this is something that we're working on. You know, in general therapy, especially like psychodynamic general psychotherapy, I think that there's a lot of options of where we can start.

SPEAKER_01You literally will hear a therapist say, where should we begin today? And it's by design, because the idea is that the person is the expert of their own experience. And I think that that's important. But in trauma therapy, the reason why explicitness is so important is because avoidance. Avoidance is a hallmark feature of what maintains and preserves trauma symptoms and in more extreme cases, PTSD. And so when avoidance is there, it will inevitably and very understandably get enacted in the therapeutic space.

SPEAKER_01This is also why I was saying motivation is really important too. So trauma-focused treatment is different because so much of the work, at least how I like to practice, is we're processing thoughts and feelings related to somebody's trauma history. But then we're also talking about when we're not talking about it and what that might be about and being curious, not judgmental.

SPEAKER_00And I think some listeners might be curious what avoidance might look like, because a lot of people probably assume avoidance could be just not going to therapy, but you're saying people can avoid it in therapy. What's a hypothetical example of how avoidance might look?

SPEAKER_01So there are so, so many ways that people can avoid. And I often joke with my clients that the smarter you are, the more creative you a person gets, like their subconscious gets at avoidance. And it's nothing to feel shame about, it's nothing to feel badly about because it's it's in a mechanism of protection. It that's what avoidance can be, right? But in in this case, it can be an obstacle to doing the work.

SPEAKER_01So there are so many ways. I mean, I discover new ways that people can be avoidant, you know, when I'm working with different clients. Common ones is changing the subject. We're talking about something in session, and then suddenly we're talking about something else, and they they shifted. I'll sometimes say, you know, I noticed we just changed the subject. What do you what do you make of that? Or what do you what do you notice we were talking about right before we went in this direction? And sometimes when we point out the avoidance, it actually can teach us something about what's maybe coming up for someone that they didn't even realize was hard to sit with.

SPEAKER_01So that's one way of avoiding other ways of avoidance. People can focus on cognition. So, you know, really thinking about things, but not really focusing on affect. Uh, and and what I mean by affect is like emotion, right? And so sitting with their feelings about something, they can over-intellectualize and be really, I mean, and you can imagine very, very smart people do that. People can white knuckle their way through things so they can tell you the really, really difficult thing, but they're like powering through, holding off any sort of emotion, or in some cases they can numb out, right?

SPEAKER_01Disassociate, where they just cut themselves entirely off from any emotion. Those are different kinds of avoidance.

SPEAKER_00I also have seen myself do these things in therapy. I would often come in with a list of things to talk about. And if it got uncomfortable, I would jump to the next thing in the list, and my therapist would do exactly what you're saying. So that's really helpful. I would love to regroup to the idea of relationship to self, since this is part of that series. Something you were recently talking about is people cutting themselves off from feeling. And so I've kind of a compound question here you can take in different directions.

SPEAKER_00How does trauma affect our relationship with ourselves, how we view ourselves, our self-worth? And then also within that, I think a lot of the listeners are the intellectualizing type that you're talking about. And so we can know that something wasn't our fault, but we don't necessarily feel that. So maybe there's still this feeling of being not deserving, not worthy, even if you know it came from trauma. Okay.

SPEAKER_01So the first part of the question is a very big one. So I'm gonna stay with that for a second. I think in terms of one's relationship to self-worth and the impact that trauma can have, I think that's highly dependent on several important factors. The time in which across the lifespan a traumatic event happened, its frequency, right? Are we talking about an isolated event that happened, you know, within the last few years within adulthood? Or are we talking about an isolated event that happened when somebody was a child?

SPEAKER_01How old a child, right? There's a difference between a toddler and a 12-year-old. Is it chronic? So all of these things play a role in shaping the impact it can have on somebody's self-concept and their self-worth and self-esteem. And if you really think about it, it makes sense because when we are children, we're building our foundation. And the younger you are, the more sort of basic foundation we're building. And so when we get disrupted at that point, you can think about how that impact can have just a cascading effect if it's happening at, you know, age three or four.

SPEAKER_01So I think another piece of this is there's so many different types of traumas that can happen, right? Trauma in terms of abuse, whatever it may be, physical, verbal, sexual, it's mistreatment, the ways in which somebody verbally abuses you, you may internalize as true, especially if you're a child and like that is being said to you. But there's also traumatic events that happen that are natural disasters, or traumatic events that happen during wartime if you're a service member, or things that are sort of beyond our control, and that just happen.

SPEAKER_01And people can have a lot of thoughts and feelings about what they did or did not do in a moment like that. And that then can affect their self-worth because of the what-ifs of what if I had just done X, Y, and Z. And so I think those are different ways, right? That you can it can affect what you think about yourself. The second question you asked around intellectually knowing something that, you know, this is not my fault, or I didn't, I didn't do anything to deserve this.

SPEAKER_01But then that there's that feeling. I think that there's no quick fix with that. I think part of sitting with these things repeatedly and looking at them and talking them through is what helps somebody emotionally metabolize and acclimate to what they know intellectually. There's a lot of different types of therapy that address this. So, like in cognitive processing therapy, we will literally say, This is the maladaptive thought.

SPEAKER_01It's called stuck point. This is the stuck point you have, this belief that you have about yourself or the world. And then we're going to offer you an alternative, more balanced belief that honors what you've been through, but also acknowledges that it's not so black and white. But then we then ask you, what percent do you believe this? And then we'll also ask, what are the feelings you have with the stuck point? And then what are the feelings you have now with the alternative? And at what percent? And I say that to my clients, I'll say, you shouldn't feel like you need to be at 100% belief around this alternative thought.

SPEAKER_01You shouldn't feel like you need to be completely calm and not at all anxious or sad or angry. If we see a slight reduction in that, then we're we're making progress. That can be true across theoretical orientations, no matter how you work. I think that that's true also with psychodynamic or more relational ways of working.

SPEAKER_00That's so interesting. And it leads us into another question that I wanted to chat about, which is different forms of therapy. So when I say psychodynamic, I usually think of talk therapy, really deep work, looking into the past. And of course, feel free to fact-check me on that. But I had been curious if there's ever a point where looking to the past becomes no longer helpful. And if we need to incorporate tools, CBT, DBT, somatic body work.

SPEAKER_00And it sounds like even in that example you just gave, that you're using several modalities together. And maybe that's what most therapists are doing. So I'd love to hear how you think about different modalities in trauma work.

SPEAKER_01So I am definitely somebody who I have a strong foundation in a social justice psychodynamic orientation. That's my foundation. But I would say that I practice more integratively across different theoretical orientations. Trauma work in general, I think it demands a certain amount of creativity of putting together an approach, a treatment plan, if you want to call it, with somebody that's always able to evolve.

SPEAKER_01So absolutely, I think tools managing distress, distress tolerance skills can be so important. Mindfulness, I use that a lot. And sometimes structure can be so containing. So for folks who have big feelings and have thoughts that move around a lot, have what we call intrusive memories. So literally parts of a trauma can like come into their mind without them wanting to think about it. Having structure and them knowing what to expect each week if they have homework or certain tasks, that can be really helpful.

SPEAKER_00I'd love to zoom in on what some of this looks like. So when you talk about tools or having homework, I would picture that being more cognitive behavioral therapy type things or DBT dialectical behavioral therapy. And when you say it gives people structure, talk therapy and psychodynamic is kind of the, I assume, intense therapy that people picture, the stereotypical someone's laying on a couch, even if they're not actually laying there, they're getting into their relationship with their parents. And then cognitive behavioral therapy might be oh, fill out this worksheet with some ways we can reframe some thoughts that come up for you.

SPEAKER_00And so these are totally different ways of doing therapy. But for someone that's never even been to therapy, they might not even know that there's different approaches. So I'd love to hear you just speak about maybe switching between modalities with a little more of a granular focus of maybe one or two examples.

SPEAKER_01So I think that for me, I often will probably start from a place of building the foundation with psychodynamic. And it is a lot of what you've talked about in terms of going into one's history, kind of looking at childhood and you know, those formative years and how they shape how and why somebody functions the way that they do now. The other piece of psychodynamic, which is probably why I lean on it so much in the beginning, is it's not just about the past. Psychodynamic also and relational therapy also helps us look at the therapeutic relationship itself.

SPEAKER_01And that is going to be really important for folks who have trauma within the context of relationships like abuse of all kinds, because what that is is a violation of trust, uh, whatever the abuse is and safety. And then what we're trying to do in the therapeutic space is create trust and safety. And so a lot of the work is also looking in the here and now and looking at our relationship together, talking about what patients might need from me, what's coming up for them when they hear me say certain things.

SPEAKER_01And so I think that's also another important piece and why I like to start there, because if you're going to entrust in me the worst moments, if not worst moments of your life, and you are gonna do the very difficult, strenuous work of looking at the thoughts and feelings related to those moments, then you need to trust me, or at least I think trust is ongoing, but we need to have a foundation of trust and safety that we are attending to always.

SPEAKER_01And I think that's why I like to start there.

SPEAKER_00It's something that I hadn't even thought about. As someone that went to therapy and just kind of jumped in, I probably didn't have the trust there. And then that's why you throw up some of those avoidance techniques in the beginning. You might think you're ready and you're not. And so then, yeah, I've heard about corrective experiences. We talk about them on the podcast, but what a lot of people I think don't realize is that these corrective experiences we have in relationships where we learn to trust relationships in general, often the first one people have is with their therapist.

SPEAKER_00And I wanted to talk here about how that looks in healing from trauma. So the way I conceptualize it is you start to realize that people are safe. Often that first person is your therapist. And is the reason that's important is because often the trauma was from people. So then healing from trauma needs to be in connection with people. Is that how it works?

SPEAKER_01I think it can work that way. I think that I'm also, I think a lot of trauma happens in the context of relationships, but not all. But it never hurts to try and do engage in recovery and healing in the context of a relationship, right? Because I think that even if it's not a relational rupture, that's part of one's trauma history, there is something really powerful about being in it with somebody that you trust that's bearing witness to the experiences that you had that maybe have been unspeakable up until that point.

SPEAKER_01And so I think that there's power in that too, even if it's not relational trauma. If you've witnessed something horrific, a car accident, if you've been to war and you've done or seen things, you know, I think there's something really powerful about looking at these things in connection with someone versus the other piece where, you know, doing some of the corrective repair work in relationship with your therapist, another person.

SPEAKER_00So going off of these corrective experiences, a lot of people have sought out the same relationship patterns a lot of their life. They keep getting into the same kinds of relationships, they kick up the same types of trauma, and then they stop trusting themselves to even seek out friends, partners, relational experiences because they just think, you know what, my picker's off. So, how do you help people maybe as they're working in their relationship to trauma? How do you help people see who is someone that they can trust in connection?

SPEAKER_00This is so much of the work.

SPEAKER_01So I think that in an odd way, I don't think it's so much about identifying those people you trust. I think the work needs to focus on helping you to really understand yourself as a like a discerning person who has certain skills. What trauma does is it really just messes with what you do and don't know. And I I often call it the pendulum.

SPEAKER_01So you swing one way to overcompensate for what you do know about yourself and the mistakes you've made. And then in that process, you can be a little guarded and too protected. And then you also know that that happens if you're further further enough along in your in your recovery, right? And in your healing. So then you say, I know I do this. I know I do this, and I'm being too guarded. And then so then you swing the other way, right? And then you start to ignore certain alarms, right?

SPEAKER_01Certain alerts, certain intuition that's saying, you know what, this might not be so safe. This actually, this is like a beige flag. Maybe it's a red flag, but I know how I am, and I know that I can be too protected or too guarded, and I overreact. And so I think I need to just stop. So that's the the pendulum swinging in that direction. And so because you swing back and forth, it's a self-fulfilling prophecy because then you overlook the things that would help you break yourself from that cycle, and then you find yourself right back into that relation, relational pattern.

SPEAKER_01And so it's really challenging.

SPEAKER_00I have seen myself do this time and time again with navigating dating. There's so much that I thought I had worked through in therapy. And then certain things like going through the dating process will make you realize, oh, I still need to work on that. And I see myself doing this exact same thing. I'll have these really rigid standards because I'm trying to protect. I'll see myself do it. And then I'll say, no, no, it's normal that he did that thing. And so, even just last night, there was something that I realized like, no, that's objectively weird.

SPEAKER_00If that happened to a friend and they ran it by a group, everyone would say, No, no, that's not normal. You should leave that situation. But again, I'm trying to give people the benefit of the doubt. So, wow, this brings up something I'd wanted to ask you, which is about the stages of recovery. So we can talk about that more globally in a sense. But I'm curious on this specific example of this pendulum going back and forth, does it start to settle in the middle where you see, okay, these are the ways I'm self-protecting, these are the ways I'm letting too much go.

SPEAKER_00This is the truth that's in the middle.

SPEAKER_01Yes, I think that there is a settling of the pendulum, but I I think it is something you have to be constantly attending to. Because I still see it as success if you see yourself wandering into your pattern and then you say, Hang on, this is what I'm I'm doing what I do. Let me take a step back, retrace my steps here and try this again. I think that's a win. You know, I think people think that they're supposed to just stop doing that.

SPEAKER_01And I just don't think that that's realistic because the reality is, and I think this doesn't get talked about enough. There's a reason for why you are the way that you are and that you developed the way that you are. Because at some point in a person's life who is traumatized, that protected them. That was resilience, that was adaptive in childhood, right? If something happened and they they adapted to that, that's just resilience. But context change. We grow up, we shift from being single to married to some people having children, right?

SPEAKER_01Um, some people also getting married, not everybody gets married, but context changes and it matters. And so I think you have to honor where you've been to understand why the pendulum does what it does. Because I think there's so much shame that can get kicked up when you find yourself in your pendulum swing. I often say to people, if you're coming to me and you are 38 years old, you've been functioning this way for 38 years, you're gonna have to cut yourself some slack. There may be some backsliding, and I think it needs constant attention and attending to.

SPEAKER_00That makes a lot of sense. And I want to make sure that since we're talking theoretically, that people feel grounded in how this might actually look. So with this pendulum, might one side be someone being so self-protective that maybe they kind of snap at anyone that they think wronged them, and that's the self-protective side, is this maybe they have a short fuse. And then on the other side, it might be letting things go almost borderline people pleasing.

SPEAKER_00And are those potentially the two ends of the extreme, or how else might this look if people hear pendulum? I think that's a good one, right?

SPEAKER_01Where it's I think you used this before, like rigid. I like things a certain way because it keeps me safe if I know what to expect. The other pendulum swing is like, this is what I do. I get really rigid and then I'm not reasonable because I have high expectations and people can't meet them. I need to relax, I need to soften. And then the softening gets to a point where maybe you're overlooking somebody who who's not meeting basic expectations. So that's an example. Another example is saying no to everything because it helps you feel in control and safe.

SPEAKER_01Like, I don't want to do this, I don't want to do that, I don't want to go out, I don't want to go here really being very limited in what you're willing to do, and then you know, swinging in the other other direction. I always say no. I'm always turning this person down, I'm or I'm always never willing to go out. And so I should give a little bit more, I should do what someone's asking me to do because I always say no and I'm always like this. And then do you wander into saying yes to things you don't want to do?

SPEAKER_00Now, zooming out and looking at the road to healing trauma more broadly. We talked about how this might look in relationships, but what are the stages of healing from trauma in general? Or is that even how you conceptualize it?

SPEAKER_01I find the trauma and recovery model that Judith Herman has come up with, it's her three stages of trauma recovery, to be really helpful because it's it's a nice framework, but it doesn't lock you in to something that is linear because I don't think recovery from trauma can be linear. It just can't. And I think it does a disservice to people who are trying to heal, to frame it that way.

SPEAKER_01But the way Herman talks about this is there are these three stages, and it's actually a lot of what we've been talking about. So the first stage is safety and stabilization. It's what I was talking about earlier about like building that foundation of safety and trust within the therapeutic relationship. I think Herman does a really lovely job also of considering folks' sociocultural context. Safety and stabilization can be literally making sure somebody has housing, making sure somebody has their basic needs met.

SPEAKER_01Trauma work in some ways, trauma-focused treatment, it's a luxury. If you don't have your basic needs, if you're unhoused and you don't have access to food, or you are dealing with severe unattended disabilities, that is probably not the time to be doing trauma work because it's intense. That is the time to be getting your basic needs met and building literal physical safety. So I think that also is included in that safety and stabilization, in addition to building the safety within the therapeutic space.

SPEAKER_01And so then after that has been established, but keeping in mind you're always trying to maintain safety. That always has to happen. And it's not a given. Ruptures happen in the therapeutic relationship too. Therapists, we're human beings. We make mistakes, we are, we fail. And so you have to be able to attend to that if and when that happens, because that's how somebody trusts you and stays safe with you. The second stage is what she calls remembrance and mourning.

SPEAKER_01This is what a lot of people think is the trauma therapy, which is this is where we make meaning of the traumatic experience or experiences. This is where we integrate traumatic memories into one's broader life story. So oftentimes trauma gets stored in fragments, uh in pieces. And in a way, there's something really adaptive to that. Cause would you want to share a giant disturbing thing or save it?

SPEAKER_01Or would you want to save pieces of it? Because it's that's more tolerable. And also it's likely not something, right? The avoidance, it's not something you've looked at a lot because why would you want to look at the worst moment of your life or moments of your life? It's not very well examined. And so all of these things, this isn't this is the time where we slowly and carefully help a person take a look at what pieces are there, the fragments, and then help put them together in a way that helps one have meaning.

SPEAKER_01And then putting that together into the larger narrative of a person's life, integration. Our hope and goal is that trauma is not all of who you are, it's a part of who you are. And then along with this is also just acknowledging the grief that comes along with trauma experiences. What were the things that were lost because of this experience? For some people, it's literal childhoods. For others, it's relationships. This stage, what's very important here is pacing. You cannot rush this.

SPEAKER_01We have to meet people where they're at. We, as I said, we may go back into stage one to establish safety, re-establish it, expand it, and then come back to stage two. I think actually I probably dance between these two a lot in my work. And then the final stage is what Herman calls reconnection and integration. So this is where there's work in re-engaging with one's life, relationships, their identity, widening their world, and really sitting with perhaps a renewed sense of agency and personal meaning, and then like exploring these different parts of their life that maybe have not had their ability to be like in full expanse, right?

SPEAKER_01So intimacy, sexuality, work, anything, parent relationship, child relationships, being in community with other people, goals, all of that. It's sort of the opening of what's possible. And I often say trauma work is an attempt for us to help you live the life that you want to live. And so this is the part where we start to kind of think about what how you want to do that.

SPEAKER_00Okay, so we'll take it in order. The first part of the framework that you talked about brought up that this is a luxury and that is such a good thing to bring up. Often we think about how difficult it is to dive into our trauma, but there's so many people that are actively living in trauma of having their needs not met. And that also brings up the question of what is a trauma? Because I would think someone living without their basic needs met, you know, they might not be going through abuse, they might not be in a war zone, but there's the trauma of waking up and not knowing if they're going to have food for themselves, for their family.

SPEAKER_00So, how do you define what trauma even is? I know this is a little late in the episode to get to that, but I think we can take it for granted and assume we know what that means.

SPEAKER_01This is tricky, right? Because I think a lot of people, if you notice, I haven't been saying PTSD a lot. And there's a reason for that, because PTSD is a very specific diagnosis that has a certain collection of symptoms that one needs in order to really define how acute a traumatic event or events has impacted their life and how impaired they are. That's really what PTSD signifies. But I am a firm believer that trauma and somebody who's had trauma, I think that is pretty common.

SPEAKER_01And like sadly, more often than not is part of like the human experience. And so if we're talking about PTSD and actual as like the DSM defines it, the first criteria you need in order to diagnose PTSD, it's an index trauma, criteria A. And it very clearly defines what that is. A criteria A trauma is when a person has been exposed to death, threatened death, actual or threatened serious injury, or actual or threatened sexual violence in one of the following ways.

SPEAKER_01You either by direct exposure, so it's happening to you, or you are witnessing it firsthand happening to another person. You're learning about this trauma happening to a close relative or to a close loved one. They've also added, which is interesting, also indirect exposure through, you know, hearing about like aversive details of trauma. So really vicarious trauma. Somebody maybe in my profession who is repeatedly hearing about other people's very disturbing experiences, as I've described before.

SPEAKER_01So that is how if we want to get into the nitty-gritty of like actually diagnosing PTSD, that is the first thing that's needed. I think it's important because PTSD has become this very used word. I understand why people use it, because they right, it's a it's a language to help us each understand the intensity in which somebody is struggling. And so I understand that, but I think it's also important to know when we're talking about PTSD, we are talking about like a very specific form of impairment.

SPEAKER_01But I also just because somebody doesn't have PTSD, it doesn't mean they're they're not suffering. And I think that's also important.

SPEAKER_00A word block that you probably see quite a bit is people actually diminishing their own trauma because it's not as bad as someone else's. And I know there's this thing about not doing comparative suffering, but I know when I first started in therapy, I just couldn't almost do any work because I would see something like a genocide and just think, I don't have any right to talk about anything that I've gone through. And I would love to hear you talk about that because I know therapists say not to do that.

SPEAKER_01I'm smiling, not because of this horrible thing you just said. I'm smiling because what I would say to that is I would wonder with you about is this a form of avoidance? Right? You're a smart person. It's a really like thoughtful way to distance yourself from your own pain by focusing on everybody else's far more worse pain, as you understand it. And so that's depending on the ego strength that someone has, if I've been working with them a long time, I might just say, hey, listen, be curious about that.

SPEAKER_01This is a very common thing that comes up for people when doing trauma work. What I try to do is just ground them in the pain that they're in. Your pain is your pain, and that's important. And if you are not living the life that you want to live, then there's work for us to do, and that's important.

SPEAKER_00I don't think I've ever heard such a clear answer on that. And so much of this is about going into our pain instead of trying to find ways around it. So thank you for that. And going through these stages, stage two, you mentioned fragments and how we store what I assume would be memories. And without going into any of the specifics, there's a certain event I experienced when I was 18. And I do only remember it's almost like snapshots.

SPEAKER_00It's like almost like I'm watching an old camcorder movie of it. There's probably two five-second chunks that will play in my mind, and that's all that was stored. Is that kind of what you mean by that?

SPEAKER_01That's exactly what I mean by that. Absolutely. That's like a that's a beautiful example of that. And even the way you described it being like a movie, that's I the amount of people who say that to me. It's such a very, very common sort of way of understanding how it's been stored within you. Yeah, I think it can be so frustrating to have something so upsetting stored in that way. But I think what we don't realize is that it's again, it was adaptive.

SPEAKER_01It's sort of similar to what we talk about around out-of-body experience. People have come to hear folks say that all the time, like it's an out-of-body experience. But the thing is, is that it's real. And if you've not experienced it, it can be really odd. But the amount of times that I've heard people say that I was going through this horrible thing and it was like I floated up to the corner of the bedroom and it's like I was watching myself go through it, or it's like I'm watching what happened to me or what I did, like in a movie, or a video game.

SPEAKER_01That's another one. And so I think the thing about that is it actually makes a lot of sense because why would you want to be in your body when like the worst thing is happening to it? And so it's survival, it's the body and the mind's way of protecting itself. As you can imagine, though, that can get really frustrating as you then move away from it and you're trying to make sense of things and make meaning of your life and move on from it.

SPEAKER_01And these shards are living within you. And like that's that can be painful. But I think again, like you hear me say this a lot. It's honoring where you've been and understanding that there's a reason for why it is the way it is, and that acknowledging it's not working for me anymore, right? It's an obsolete operating system, and I need an update. And so that's how we then work with those pieces to help somebody make sense of what happened, not why it happened. Making meaning of something really horrible.

SPEAKER_01There's not often a why. There's not often a why for why something so horrific happened. Often nothing justifies these horrible, horrible things.

SPEAKER_00That last part in particular, I think can really help people because people that intellectualize things will keep going into the why, because you think if you can understand it, you can be safe or make sense of it. That does feed into one of my last two questions, which is so we have these fragments, and a lot of that has to do with the past. And you talked about integration and a narrative for your life going forward. And that part three, what I kept visualizing was we dove into the past and now we're moving into the present and the future, and that community you brought up and parts of your life you've been neglecting.

SPEAKER_00And we just did a small series on identity, and a lot of it was looking at who we've been told we were, maybe by family members, teachers, and then coming up with a new identity for ourselves. And it's really beautiful to hear you talk about that because it loops back to what we were talking about with psychodynamic work or talk therapy. Everyone thinks it's all about the past, but your point is we're looking at the past to assemble these fragments into a something that makes sense to us, and then coming up with you brought up a narrative so that we can move to the future.

SPEAKER_00And if there's anything you want to say on that, maybe either correcting how I'm conceptualizing or building on it, I think that would be really helpful.

SPEAKER_01I think you said that really well. The only piece which we've been kind of saying as that's thread through all of this is nothing is linear. So you're doing the work of integrating parts that I won't say lost, but parts that have been maybe cast aside or have not been attended to in your life that you want to return to. You can be doing that and still then need to go back to stage two and do some work around meaning making in order to continue to move through these other parts of your life that you maybe for very understandable reasons have neglected or overlooked or avoided.

SPEAKER_01I think there's a very natural back and forth between those stages. And then let's not forget stage one. We are always, again, attending to safety because things can happen within the context of the therapeutic relationship that might mimic or parallel what's happening in other relationships. And that's an opportunity not only to build safety within the therapeutic relationship, but then also practice the thing that a person is struggling with in stage two, and then how they want it to be in that relationship in the future in stage three.

SPEAKER_01You can see how one can like bounce between all three constantly.

SPEAKER_00Okay. So if I understand that correctly, maybe you struggle with setting boundaries. You do that with your therapist in the therapeutic setting, and then you're able to take that out into your life as you build relationships. So you're going back and forth between these stages.

SPEAKER_01Yes. And then let's say you do a really good job in one relationship, but then you falter in another, and then you're like, oh shoot. And then so you have to go back to stage two and just understand what's going on, you know, and why is that? And then let's say your therapist says something you don't like, and then you're like, well, I don't that didn't make me feel very good. Then you're back in stage one. And then you have to build the safety because they told you something that was really hard to hear, you know. And so like you can see how it can kind of move all over the place.

SPEAKER_00For anyone that hasn't done therapy, someone who's been thinking about it, maybe they're nervous or just curious. Do you have any thoughts for those folks?

SPEAKER_01First of all, it's awkward. The natural setting of coming in, talking to somebody you don't know, it's awkward. And building that back and forth and that ease, it takes time. And we're gonna work through it and we're gonna build that sort of ease and back and forth. And just naming that, I think, is super important. And know that like the therapist notice that too. There's not an expectation that it just be easy. Sometimes it is, but oftentimes it takes work and time. And I think another thing is fit is important.

SPEAKER_01Recognizing is this is this therapist a good fit for me? And how you can establish that is you ask questions. It's really important for you to be able to ask your therapist questions. I often will, I'll do my best to leave time for that in the first session for somebody to ask me questions about how I like to work. And so this is not every therapist will feel this way, but I think this is important. You know, I think in the therapeutic relationship, folks may or may not know this, especially if you're new to therapy, it's what we call a one-sided relationship.

SPEAKER_01So it's the space where the therapist really doesn't share a whole lot of who they are with their client. And it's by design, because the idea here is that, especially in trauma work, this is an opportunity for you to look at these things in your life without the burdens of a relationship that has baggage. I'm not your daughter, I'm not your wife, I'm not your mother, I'm not your sister. And so because of that, none of the baggage that comes with those relationships, inevitably, is in the room with us.

SPEAKER_01And so that's why you don't end up knowing a lot about my background, because it frees you up to not worry about what I might think and feel from the perspective of being your wife, being your daughter, being your sister, et cetera, or being your friend, right? I'm not your friend, but that's by design because I want you to feel safe enough to say whatever it is you think and feel and not worry about managing me in that. And we do that in relationships that are two-sided. So that is something I think people really should know going in.

SPEAKER_01And it can be weird. You're telling somebody all this stuff about you, and you know really very little about them. That's a very challenging way to build trust. And so I think that's one piece of it. And the other piece of it though is, and this is where I think other therapists may disagree with me, but I think in doing trauma work, this has been really important, particularly like in the ways that I like to work more psychodynamically and relationally. I always say to my clients, if you ever wonder what I'm thinking, you can ask me.

SPEAKER_01You you may not know what the name of my dog is, you may not know where I was born and raised, but if you're wondering in the here and now, as you and I are sitting together and you want to know what I'm thinking or feeling, ask me. And I think that that's important for you to know.

SPEAKER_00I think that's how we build trust. And I think something that I'm learning through this interview, I'm sure the audience is noticing as well, is that there's many different styles. There's styles in terms of how much someone might share. My therapist, I think it's so funny. Whenever I ask her how she's doing, she talks about the weather. And I know that it's to not get into her personal stuff, but in my head, she's obsessed with the weather, but I know it's a technique. You're talking about also using different modalities and how you switch to different ones. And it sounds like people just have to see who they're comfortable with.

SPEAKER_01I think having said ask what I'm thinking and feeling, I want to be clear though, that it's not my opinion, right? It's how I'm experiencing an interaction in the here and now. Because I think that opinions are something different. And that's also along with burdening a client with expectations. That's why we don't give you our opinion often. But if you're wondering what I'm thinking and feeling, how I'm experiencing you in a moment, that's what I mean when I say ask me.

SPEAKER_00That's really helpful, I think, for people to hear too, because one complaint people often have about therapy when they when people first start is that the therapist often won't give their opinion or advice. And it's not coaching, it's therapy, it's something different. All of this was so clarifying, and I know it will be really helpful to the audience. I really appreciate you coming on. Thank you so much. Thank you so much for having me, Pam. For more information on Anita, I might link something down below. I know currently her practice is full, but if that changes or if there's anything that she wants me to include below about getting in touch, I'll include that.

SPEAKER_00But of course, feel free to comment on YouTube to join the conversation there. And next week we will have another therapist as a guest discussing somatic therapy or the idea of how mind and body are connected. And I'm really excited for that episode as well. And if you're not subscribed, but you find this information helpful, go ahead and hit subscribe on Apple, YouTube, Spotify, wherever you're listening. Thanks for being with us and speak to you next Sunday. Talk to you then.

Open the transcript file

Hosts and Guests

Nobody is credited on this episode yet.

Credit the people on this episode

Be the first to rate this episode

More episodes

All episodes
  1. Do We Still Have a Shared Culture? What We're Losing (and Gaining) in an Era of Endless Media

    Nov 16, 202630 minAudio

    There was a time when large cultural moments brought us together. Everyone was watching the same movies and shows, reading the same books, and participating in the same cultural conversations. But with so much more...

    Credit the people on this episode

  2. How to Overcome Choice Overload: Is Decision Fatigue Real?

    Nov 8, 202625 minAudio

    Do you ever struggle with choice overload or analysis paralysis? We’re continuing our series on The Paradox of Choice, exploring the practical implications of the ideas in Barry Schwartz’s book for our daily lives. In...

    Credit the people on this episode

  3. The Paradox of Choice in Online Dating: An NYC Perspective (Interview – Part 2)

    Nov 1, 202629 minAudio

    This is Part 2 of our discussion on the Paradox of Choice and dating apps. In this episode, I’m joined by a friend to discuss his experiences navigating dating apps in a place like New York City, where the paradox of...

    Credit the people on this episode

  4. What dating apps are doing to love: Why more options can make finding love harder

    Oct 25, 202623 minAudio

    If you’ve been on the apps for some time, you know that while there are more options than ever to find love presented in front of us, in many ways, it can feel harder. This is counterintuitive - so in this episode, we...

    Credit the people on this episode

  5. Why trying to make the “best” choice can make you less happy

    Oct 18, 202628 minAudio

    Would you rather feel happy with your decision or make a slightly better “objective” choice? It’s an interesting question, and in this episode, we unpack it through the lens of maximizing vs. satisficing. What does it...

    Credit the people on this episode