Skip to content
PodSubs
ShowsPeopleGuestsJobsNewsEvents
More
BlogPodCred
Menu
ShowsPeopleGuestsJobsNewsEventsBlogPodCredNetworksSign in
Join nowSign in
  • Shows
  • People
  • Jobs
  • News
  • More
    • Guests
    • Events
    • Blog
    • PodCred
    • Networks
    Join nowSign in

Immersion

Immersion artwork

On "Book hangover" and how to cope with the sadness we feel after finishing a great book

Feb 28, 202524 minAudio
ShareXLinkedInFacebookWhatsAppEmail

Have you ever finished a book or show and felt an overwhelming wave of sadness - like you’ve just lost a friend or left a world you loved behind? That’s book hangover (which can also happen with TV shows) - an emotional cocktail of grief, longing, and nostalgia that can hit harder than we expect. In this episode, we explore: Why stories leave such a lasting emotional imprint and why they feel so real to our brains How living vicariously through fictional worlds can reflect a deeper longing for purpose or meaning in our own lives The bittersweet experience of saying goodbye to characters and worlds we grew to love Whether you’re reeling from a fantasy epic or mourning the end of a favorite series, this episode unpacks the emotional weight of book hangovers and why they resonate so deeply with many. If you’ve ever felt this way, drop a comment or shoot me a DM or message on my website with the book or show that left you with a story hangover - I’d love to hear your picks! --------- Show notes / resources: article on experience of it and some on the brain: https://www.rd.com/article/book-hangover/ video referenced on "If you feel like something is missing in your life" - a video on purpose - https://youtu.be/G8fe4tpkA2s Video referenced about how we can each make a contribution even when that feels hard at times: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=9-uuzUHxUUc Write in to the show here Leave a voice message here Newsletter sign up YouTube - channel Instagram - we will be posting here soon

Audio and video play straight from the show's own hosting. PodSubs stores and serves no media.

Transcript

From the show. Tap a time to play from there.

SPEAKER_00Have you ever finished a book or a show and just felt so distraught that it was over? You miss the characters, you miss the world. Maybe you're not even done with the book yet, but you're dreading getting there. So you're starting to read slower to soak in every last morsel. Because this world is so beautiful and exciting, sometimes, particularly compared to our own lives, which can of course be mundane at times. In this episode, we're going to cover what this phenomenon is.

SPEAKER_00This is called book hangover, but I think it can apply to TV shows as well. We're going to talk about how it feels. We're going to commiserate. We're going to talk about if it's overall a positive or negative thing, like the pros and cons of feeling these emotions, and then different things that we can do about it. This is not going to be, oh, here's the five steps you can take after, because honestly, this feeling, I think that it can feel as strong as when things actually happen in our own lives.

SPEAKER_00I think I have felt more sad by a book ending than certain relationships coming to an end in my life. And this is something that I don't think a ton of people talk about. It's almost something that we go through alone because we read books alone. So I also want to talk about some things that other people have mentioned to me, like their experiences with feeling this, because that can help you feel less alone if that's something that you're going through right now. Or you might just listen knowing that you've been through this before and you will go through it again, even if you're not in the midst of what we call a book hangover right now.

SPEAKER_00So as we jump in here, we've already talked about what this is. How long it can last, I've read really varies, anywhere between days and weeks. I think similar to a breakup or something in real life, it can often feel the most pressing in the beginning, like the first day or two. And then slowly, as you start to ease back into reality and away from this mythical world, the feeling slowly dissipates over the next week or so. And my partner had a really good point about this that a lot of it depends on how long you were immersed in that world for.

SPEAKER_00If you're reading a five or seven book series, that's going to affect you differently compared to one book. If you are watching the same TV show for three seasons, four or five, up to ten seasons, you're going to feel really attached to those characters, almost like you know them, compared to a movie, which is much more encapsulated. It's an afternoon and you're done. You might feel so many strong emotions from that movie, but I don't think you feel attached in the same way that you do with a TV series.

SPEAKER_00And they also brought up that it becomes a large part of our routine. You end the day maybe watching the same show every night, and then suddenly that part of your routine is gone. That's why a lot of people will restart it afterwards because it not only is a part of your routine, but it really does feel, and I think that our brain and mind maybe have a hard time even differentiating these are people that I don't know versus these are characters. Because when we read, and I'm going to link a couple of resources down below, our empathy is really exercised.

SPEAKER_00We really feel like we're there. And I think some of us, maybe even more than others, don't have that separation of this is a story. We really feel like we're in it. That's why we feel adrenaline rushes when the character is going through a battle. That's why we feel like we're in love when we're reading about a love story. And there's this cocktail of chemicals and emotions going off like fireworks in our brain. A lot of these thoughts for me are coming off of reading a book that really affected me. And it was both a romance, it was fantasy, and it was an action-packed thriller.

SPEAKER_00And I think that that specific list of ingredients just really affected my mind. And coming off of it after I felt like I was actually having withdrawals, which is wild. And I know there's different camps as to like what constitutes an addiction, behavioral versus substance, but I do think that, you know, you are coming off of these chemical highs in a sense, even if it's your own brain kind of creating it from what you're reading, even though we know it's different than substance use.

SPEAKER_00Which brings me to the next point, which is not just how long this story lasts, it's also how exciting it is. An example that I was already going to use, but happened to be in the article that I referenced, is that if you're reading about someone solving a crime mystery on this luxurious island, or someone in the wizarding world finding out that they're a wizard, Harry? And or or riding dragons.

SPEAKER_00It's it's so hard to come off of that and then just think about filing your taxes or folding the laundry, or you're reading about this epic love story, and then you and your partner later are talking about what do you want to make for dinner? Do you want to make chicken or a salad and what time do the kids go bound for bed? It's hard to compete or compare the two. And that's something that really is at the crux of what I want to talk about here, which is how much of this is a problem and how much of this is just a nice escape.

SPEAKER_00How much is this vicarious living, this escaping to other worlds, other lives, how much of that is a beautiful thing that we have available to us, and how much of that is a problem? Escaping our lives to the point that maybe we don't feel as happy or engaged in them, or we're using it to escape so that we don't have to engage in our own lives. And I think people are really mixed on this. I'll start out with my own experience and then what friends had to say about that.

SPEAKER_00So recently when I finished the book that I was talking about, I felt very sad. And then I felt alarmed that I felt sad, guilty that I felt sad, confused. It's like, A, there's going to be more books in this series. Why am I so upset about this? B it's a beautiful thing to get lost into a story. Why do you feel guilty about it? But I really spent a lot of time unpacking it because this was a newer emotion for me.

SPEAKER_00I didn't read as much as most other kids growing up. I played a lot of sports. I didn't realize that I have very mild dyslexia. It just wasn't what appealed to me. But as an adult, I've started to read more and more. This phenomenon of book hangover has been new to me. I think for people where reading's been an escape for them their entire lives, they've just sort of accepted this. Like, oh yeah, you get really sad when you get towards the end of a good series.

SPEAKER_00That's part of it. And they've they've maybe developed ways to cope with that. They have another book series lined up that they want to read as they're approaching the end of one. They know they just need to take a week or two off reading before starting their next book. Maybe they find a book that's very similar or very different from the one that they just read. Maybe they get into fan fiction or listen to podcasts about that series because they miss the world. Maybe a lot of people actually read, they will reread the same book.

SPEAKER_00And it's funny because for certain books, like some people will reread it once, twice, three times, and then then they're finally ready to move on. It's almost like they needed more of that world before they were ready to move on. Everyone approaches it differently. But for me, it it just felt very alarming. What is this feeling? Why am I so attached to these fictional characters? And I'm someone that gets very lost in shows that I watch. I really feel I'm there versus, oh, I'm watching a show.

SPEAKER_00And I think that everyone lies in a different place on that spectrum with how maybe immersed they feel in what they're consuming or detached from it. I will even dream constantly about the books that I'm reading. I'll feel like I'm in that world or I'm talking to the characters or I am the characters. Same thing with TV shows that I'm watching. It's almost like my life and these worlds start to collide. So, for a lot of people that have been through this before, I think they were almost confused why I was so alarmed by it.

SPEAKER_00They were almost like, yeah, that's that's just a part of reading. Yep. Which is comforting, right? To hear that it's just a normal part of it. Um, so some more specific thoughts that they gave. I love the thought one of my um family members said, which is that reading and stories are almost the spicy sauce of life. And you wouldn't want your whole life to be spicy sauce, you want your life to be the sandwich. But it's nice to have that excitement, that adventure, that spicy sauce that you dip your sandwich in.

SPEAKER_00And I think that's a wonderful analogy. And I told them back that maybe everyone has varying degrees of how spicy. I don't mean this in the other connotation that people mean it, but like how spicy they want their life, how much excitement or adventure you want in your life. I think one thing that I found troubling is I could see myself becoming really addicted to this as an escape to the point where I'm engaging less and less in life.

SPEAKER_00There's a big difference between using stories to escape from life versus to engage with life. If we think about it on a spectrum, on one end, we have people that are maybe reading almost all day. They're starting to almost shirk other responsibility, they're detaching from relationships because they'd rather just be reading and not around people that they know. And on the other end of the spectrum, maybe there's people that just are so into their own life, maybe they don't even really want to watch TV at night or read a book.

SPEAKER_00They're just completely in their own life. But I think somewhere in the middle is where we have these stories as an outlet. We have these stories as inspiration, we have these stories as a lifeboat, like buoy is up in hard times and spicy sauce to give us some excitement, but they're just one part of our lives. We have deep relationships, we have deep purpose, we have things that give us excitement, like things we might just do for fun. We have, um, I truly believe that purpose, I don't necessarily mean what you do for work, but having a sense of a way you want to contribute, which I will link another video on that here and down below.

SPEAKER_00That is something that is missing from a lot of people's lives. I think that it can lead to a feeling of feeling lost. Victor Frankel's logotherapy has a lot to do with this, that a lot of issues that a lot of people have could partly be solved by having a sense of meaning from purpose from how do you want to contribute. And now I'm not saying this in his own words, but that's how I've conceptualized logotherapy. And I think that that's a big factor here is that we should have a sense of hero's journey mission in our own life outside of just oh, reading this book to kind of check out or watching this show to kind of check out from life.

SPEAKER_00We can examine the connection between purpose and fiction through the lens of the chosen one trope. Love it or hate it, the chosen one trope is about a person through whether some gift or power that they inherited, or for some reason, they are the only one that can save the world. And I hate this trope because I think it does two things. It taps into our need that's positive to want to contribute and have purpose and change the world in some way, which I think all of us can in big and small ways, but it does it through the lens of, oh, but you need to be chosen.

SPEAKER_00It needs to be destiny, it needs to be fate. And I strongly disagree with this. I have a video about how each of us can contribute in our own way and how important that is. I'll link that down below. But it just really irritates me because I think it it hijacks that need. It like basically taps into that need to contribute. And then it one tells us that we have to be chosen to be able to do that. And two, maybe I'm misinterpreting this, but I I feel like it almost gives us the excuse to like, oh, well, I'm not that type of a person. And yes, there's the underdog mentality, this person has to overcome all sorts of stuff on their hero's journey to contribute.

SPEAKER_00But again, they were the chosen one versus choosing to step up to the plate on their own accord. And the second issue is if we are getting this need met through fiction exclusively, completely immersing ourselves in books all day, do we feel less of a duty to try to make a difference? Because we kind of feel like we're already doing that through a story. We're having that experience, so then we don't feel the need to get that need met. And it kind of reminds me of certain traits. Maybe someone feels powerless in their own life, so then they watch superhero movies and they watch someone with ultimate power.

SPEAKER_00And it's a way of maybe escaping those problems or uh not even having to worry about trying to develop certain traits. Now, of course, it's okay to escape the world and get to live as someone who's maybe more witty, braver. And these can things can be inspiring, they can be fun. I'm not saying that we all have to have main character energy. In fact, I'm actually saying the opposite of that is that everyone can contribute and it's not about one chosen special person. Now, it might depend on the phase of life you're in. If you're going through an extremely difficult time, you might need those stories to kind of buoy you and get you through that.

SPEAKER_00But if you find years and years going by and you just keep checking out into other narratives, it does ask the question: what is missing from my own life? And these stories, these writers, they're really good at tapping into what we want most. And that's why it's so easy to fall into them. In the play People, Places, and Things, written by Duncan McMillan, the main character is an actress and she's also an addict. And she talks about how when you're an actress in a play, you get to live the most intense parts of a life over and over again, and all the boring bits are cut out.

SPEAKER_00And that's something that really draws us into stories. If the character is stuck in traffic, it's for a reason. It's maybe so they can get out of their car and do a dance, like in La La Land. It's not just because, okay, now we're gonna watch the character stuck in traffic for an hour, like really happens in LA. And these stories can inspire us when you're going through a specific difficult time like grief, like addiction, or there's certain turmoil in your country's politics. When you read a story where the character is going through something similar and they're courageous or they're insightful, or they're just walking the same path that you're walking, maybe a little bit further ahead than you.

SPEAKER_00That is inspiring and informative and important. We learn through stories. It is part of what it is to be a human. You know, we would gather around the campfire from at least the way I understand it, and people would share stories. We would tell stories, and we've been doing that for as long as we've been able to communicate. And it's really into the fabric of what it means to be human and it's why it affects us so much. And I think that there's a reason why we often learn more through story than someone just giving us the answer.

SPEAKER_00And you know this. You've probably read certain stories about what it's like to maybe have a certain medical condition, to live in a certain part of the country, to have gone through a divorce. The story draws you in and brings up the most poignant parts of that experience so that you can understand it and draw that into your own life and relate to it and relate to what those other people are going through more than if you hadn't heard an entire story about it, more than if maybe you had just heard a bullet point, one or two-point list of a couple ideas.

SPEAKER_00And so going back to that part about all the boring bits left out and all the exciting parts amped up, these writers really know how to do that extremely well. Think about some of your favorite writing. Often the main character will be special in some way, or their love interest is uniquely special in some way. They're tapping into that idea of, oh, what would be exactly what you want? And then let me just ramp it up even a little bit more.

SPEAKER_00And part of what makes it so intoxicating is that they're also safe at the same time. Think of um, maybe there's a story about vampires. I read Twilight in high school, and okay, she's with Edward. It's meant to be dangerous and scary, but we know she's gonna be safe. So you get all of the thrill, but without actually being in danger, and also because you're not actually the one there. You're just living vicariously through them. I think that's also partly what makes it so intoxicating, is like all the adventure. Well, a lot of the adventure, but with the the veil of safety over top of it, versus in our own lives, when we want to have that kind of adventure, we're not actually safe.

SPEAKER_00And that's why a lot of us will shy away from it in some aspects, and rightly so. I mean, if there were real vampires, it might not be smart to actually date one. But yeah, it's real, it's real fun uh to come along for the ride on this side, though. And other things that can make us feel all sorts of things with the ending is of course, sometimes something may have happened to the character or their relationship. So maybe even though it's not a real person, there could almost be a sense of grieving afterwards because this really felt like a loved one.

SPEAKER_00And even if you're not grieving the loss of a character, maybe there was an ambiguous ending, or you're just curious what's happening next in this person's life. There's a lot of different types of grief and a lot of different types of nostalgia. And then this is where we can have sort of sort of some guilt associated with it because there's this pushback of, but this isn't even real. Why am I feeling this this much? And I've noticed that different people have varying levels of self-compassion when it comes to this. And just knowing that in a lot of ways our brain doesn't really know the difference, I think is helpful.

SPEAKER_00And so, with this feeling of kind of longing to be in this world, which is really what a lot of this is, is that we want magic in our lives, whether that's the fantasy worlds of magic, the magic of romance, the magic of the thrill of a chase, the magic of excelling at something after working really hard. We're we're chasing a little bit of magic here in stories. We're also chasing, as a friend of mine pointed out, lives that are different than our own.

SPEAKER_00She talked about being in Amsterdam and riding bikes around and feeling a sense of sadness that this is not her life, that she's going to come back to New York and have that life. And she loves her life here. She's so happy and fulfilled. But it goes back to something, and I have an upcoming video I'll I'll do on this soon is the thousands of lives that we all long to live. We all want to live in so many different lives. And stories are a way to experience that. Like, what would it have been like to be a dancer in the 1920s?

SPEAKER_00What would it be like to live in an island off the coast and be a professional surfer? What is it like? And because we don't get to, at least in this lifetime, live multiple different lives, we get to do that through story. There will be a sense of grieving coming out of it. This is not my life. I only get one life, and it's not this one. And all of the beautiful, magical parts about that get ripped away as well. In the words of my friend, she describes this feeling as being sad to leave, fulfilled by the book, and mournful to return to the real world.

SPEAKER_00And I think instead of judging myself, I want to see the beauty in it. That we can feel that strongly for a story that's not our own, that we can dive that deeply, and that we have the capacity to really feel in that world for a time. How amazing is it that we have that ability as humans to ride these different waves and then come crashing back out of them into our own world and the opportunity to go into different ones. So, to summarize, but also give a springboard for where we're going to go next week, when I had this book coming over, I really did a lot of journaling, talking to people, pulling apart, is there something missing in my own life?

SPEAKER_00And that is why I was getting so much fulfillment from these narratives, losing myself in them, feeling empty when they were done. How much of a big deal is that? And after some contemplation, I realized, you know, there probably are some things that were missing in my own life. So next week we're going to do some self-inquiry for if you feel like something is missing in your own life, here are some places to look. Because I did a video on that before. That's the one linked down below.

SPEAKER_00But I think that there is a lot more exploration we can do on that. We're gonna do a more far-reaching, deep dive on that topic. I'm still toying with a lot of these thoughts. I'm still pulling these ideas apart in my mind. Lastly, uh speaking of discussing with people, a friend was talking about how it's what we're all chasing is transcendence. And I think that's a lot of what I'm getting at here is getting that transcendence for moments and then coming out of it. It's kind of like that quote: you know, is it better to have loved and lost or better to not have loved at all?

SPEAKER_00So the next time that you're really sad at the end of a book or TV series, you can remember that that is a sign that you truly loved it. We're we're having these moments of transcendence. We're having them through literature, we're having them through work of art we might see in person, we're having them through looking at a sunset or just listening to the sound of the rain sitting out on the porch with a loved one. We're having them constantly. And sometimes they're through works of art and sometimes they're through our own lives.

SPEAKER_00And that's just something that we have to juggle. How much of that is through volunteering or getting your hands in the dirt and planting something and engaging with the real world? And how much of that, now that we have so much entertainment, books, shows at our fingertips, how much of that is through escaping once goggles and other forms of virtual reality become more pressing? How much are we going to escape, escape, escape into almost like a matrix? And how much are we going to engage? And how much of that is a problem, and how much of that is just beautiful to have these outlets. I think these are questions that I have thoughts on.

SPEAKER_00I hope that we stay really engaged in the real world, but I also think that it's okay to escape in stories, especially books. Books are so beautiful and they're such a gift. And I love the authors that write them. And I would love to just keep discussing with you because this isn't something with a clear, cut, and dry answer. So I would love to hear from you in the comments what your thoughts are on this. If you think it's like just a part of reading and maybe I'm really overthinking, if this has been something on your mind as well, if this is something that you went through with a particular series that you want to talk about, see you next week.

SPEAKER_00I post every Thursday on this channel or my other one, and every Thursday, that same episode is available to listen on my podcast. It's available on Apple Podcasts, Spotify, and many other podcast players. Thank you for being here and see you next week.

Open the transcript file

Hosts and Guests

Nobody is credited on this episode yet.

Credit the people on this episode

Be the first to rate this episode

More episodes

All episodes
  1. Do We Still Have a Shared Culture? What We're Losing (and Gaining) in an Era of Endless Media

    Nov 16, 202630 minAudio

    There was a time when large cultural moments brought us together. Everyone was watching the same movies and shows, reading the same books, and participating in the same cultural conversations. But with so much more...

    Credit the people on this episode

  2. How to Overcome Choice Overload: Is Decision Fatigue Real?

    Nov 8, 202625 minAudio

    Do you ever struggle with choice overload or analysis paralysis? We’re continuing our series on The Paradox of Choice, exploring the practical implications of the ideas in Barry Schwartz’s book for our daily lives. In...

    Credit the people on this episode

  3. The Paradox of Choice in Online Dating: An NYC Perspective (Interview – Part 2)

    Nov 1, 202629 minAudio

    This is Part 2 of our discussion on the Paradox of Choice and dating apps. In this episode, I’m joined by a friend to discuss his experiences navigating dating apps in a place like New York City, where the paradox of...

    Credit the people on this episode

  4. What dating apps are doing to love: Why more options can make finding love harder

    Oct 25, 202623 minAudio

    If you’ve been on the apps for some time, you know that while there are more options than ever to find love presented in front of us, in many ways, it can feel harder. This is counterintuitive - so in this episode, we...

    Credit the people on this episode

  5. Why trying to make the “best” choice can make you less happy

    Oct 18, 202628 minAudio

    Would you rather feel happy with your decision or make a slightly better “objective” choice? It’s an interesting question, and in this episode, we unpack it through the lens of maximizing vs. satisficing. What does it...

    Credit the people on this episode