Inside the Course: MYP Individuals and Societies -- Understanding People, Understanding the World
24 minAudio
Send us Fan Mail What does it mean to understand the world through the people, societies, and events that shape it? In this episode of IB Matters, we launch our exploration of the Middle Years Programme (MYP) subject groups through our Inside the Course series. Our guest, experienced IB educator and department head Vikas Pahwa, takes us inside MYP Individuals and Societies, a subject group that brings together history, geography, economics, politics, and other social sciences to help students understand the connections between people and the world around them. Vikas explains how the MYP moves beyond memorizing facts to develop inquiry, research, communication, and critical thinking skills. We explore the four assessment criteria, how expectations progress from MYP Year 1 through Year 5, and why formative feedback is essential to student growth. Through classroom examples, including an interdisciplinary investigation of the Aral Sea environmental disaster, Vikas illustrates how students connect historical events, geographic conditions, economic decisions, and human consequences. We also discuss how Individuals and Societies prepares students for the Diploma Programme while encouraging curiosity, empathy, and the confidence to question assumptions. Whether you're an MYP teacher, coordinator, student, parent, or simply interested in an inquiry-based approach to education, this conversation offers a practical look at what makes Individuals and Societies such an important part of the IB continuum. Inside the Course features IB teachers explaining the courses and subject groups they know best. Produced by IB Matters. Email IB Matters: IBMatters@mnibschools.org Instagram (IB_Matters) Twitter @MattersIB IB Matters website MN Association of IB World Schools (MNIB) website Donate to IB Matters Podcast: Education by Design with host Phil Evans IB Matters T-shirts (and other MNIB clothing) To appear on the podcast or if you would like to sponsor the podcast, please contact us at the email above.
Audio and video play straight from the show's own hosting. PodSubs stores and serves no media.
Transcript
From the show. Tap a time to play from there.
Vikas PahwaIf you really want to understand the world, you first need to understand the people. That's what individual societies and MYP is about. And I think one of the best aspects of MYP individual societies is that it helps students not just know what they're doing, but also buy and make a sense of what they're doing, to ask questions, make a sense of the world, critical thinking, practical skills, and the best part. It's a gateway of scaffolding to the DP.
Jon PetersonHi folks, welcome back to IB Matters and Inside the Course. In this episode, we are describing the MYP Individuals and Societies subject group. And our teacher guide is Vikas Paula. And then, Vikas, you've been here for other podcasts, but thanks for coming in and being our guide for the MYP subject group, individuals and societies. Why don't you introduce yourself to the folks and then we'll get right into it?
Vikas PahwaYeah. Hi folks. Thanks, Jon, for inviting me one more time. So it's wonderful to be back. And for everybody who's listening, yes, along with the DP I was doing in my current school, which I've been thankfully been there for almost 10 years now. And I went to MYP as well, both as the head of department for the INS as well as teaching integrated humanities, integrates and societies.
Jon PetersonFor those of you that are not familiar with the structure of the IB, the middle years program, which is five years long, has eight subject groups. And this subject group, individual societies, is most closely aligned in the US to history and economics and those kinds of things. But what we're here to find out a little bit about how the IB structures that group of courses. And we have a great guide for that with Vicas. Vicas, why don't you kind of introduce us to the subject group?
Vikas PahwaYeah. I think if you really want to understand the world, you first need to understand the people. That's what individual societies and MYP is about. And the best part is that it's not just discrete with individual subjects, but it all it is also integrated individual and societies, right? So it has subjects, aspects of history, geography, politics, and you could bring in the beauty part is you could bring in aspects of economics and business management, and that's what makes it integrated. And I think one of the best aspects of MYP individual societies is that it helps students not just know what they're doing, but also why and make a sense of what they're doing, to ask questions, make a sense of the world.
Vikas PahwaCritical thinking, practical skills, and the best part, it's a gateway of scaffolding to the DP.
Jon PetersonYeah, and we'll talk a little bit about how it connects back to the PYP also. But yeah, I think that's a great way to put it. I'm glad you said it that way because we often in here in the US, we think of seventh grade social studies as one thing, eighth grade social studies is another. In the IB, it integrates and you deal with all these things in a connected way. It also goes back to the philosophy of IB of know your own culture first and then explore others. And I think this is a great platform to do that.
Vikas PahwaYeah, I think that's it's very important to also be mindful of this that individual societies actually help students to go deeper. As you said, it's a five-year thing. So from year one, that is grade six, to year five, that's grade ten, the students have a journey of not they go beyond what happened to explore deeper. Why it happened, who was affected, whose perspective, what evidence, and how what do we learn from it? All this this trajectory of learning through inquiry, research, critical thinking, communication, reflection, all this is what makes them understand the world, the complexity of the world that is around them.
Vikas PahwaAnd also encourages us to not only connect, but question as well.
Jon PetersonBoy, that's really good. It's funny because I've been interviewing folks about the DP courses, and I the history course uses the same language you just did. That is this investigation, the critical thinking, the perspectives, those are all things that are continuing on in the DP. How is this course structured? How does it set up? I think there's they use the term criteria.
Vikas PahwaYeah, it's see when you they use four criteria, and it's also called in the IB language, it's also called objectives. So it's like criteria or objective. A, B, C D A is knowledge and understanding, B is investigating, C communicating, and D is thinking critically. And each of these objectives or criteria have their strands within them which demonstrate the levels of understanding. For example, objective A would have objective A1 and A2.
Vikas PahwaSo when you say objective A1, uh let's say to put it very simply, it would be like trying to understand the command terms. And it goes across year one, three, five. So for example, year one, A1 is use vocabulary in context, A1 in year three is use a range of terminology in context, and A1 in year five is use a wide range of terminology in context.
Jon PetersonOkay.
Vikas PahwaSo that's how the progression goes.
Jon PetersonSure, there's a development of skills as they go through year one through five. Yeah. Exactly. And I think just because I used to be an MYP coordinator, I know a little bit about this, but the that knowing and understanding objective A is in a traditional school, that is often all the further it gets. And what just knowing things. And with the IB, those additional objectives are really important. Let's jump into what are those other objectives, B, C, and D about.
Vikas PahwaLike, for example, if you say objective B, that's investigating. So Objective B, explain the choice of a research question, formulate a research question and justify its relevance. So you explain the choice first, you give them some, you identify, and then explain why. Then next trajectory, you formulate and explain the relevance. And finally, you formulate and justify. So it's a progression which you are doing. Similarly, if you look at communication objective C, so you communicate information and ideas with clarity.
Vikas PahwaFrom there, you start, move on to communicate information and ideas in a way that is appropriate for the people or the audience. So you are putting in your own thought here. It's not just about what's given. And finally, you communicate information and ideas effectively using an appropriate style for the audience which is there and the purpose. So there you bring in your own critical thinking when you say an appropriate style. So you identify what's required and then you put it. That thinking part comes into picture.
Jon PetersonYeah, consider the audience.
Vikas PahwaYeah. Exactly. And finally, objective D, thinking critically. The idea of that understanding, fundamental understanding of the difference between those three important command terms. Identify, analyze, discuss. From year one, identify to year three, analyze concepts, models, sources, and all to discuss the concepts. So there's a big shift which happens. And the best part is it's such a range of skills, techniques, and concepts that the students with they do themselves.
Vikas PahwaSo that is what makes them even sharper as they go. That project progression is very sharp because you give them that tools, but then they have to play with the tools themselves.
Jon PetersonYeah, and when it comes to the assessment of that, and we'll talk about that in a minute, but it listeners, I'm sure, can hear the sophistication of this curriculum pedagogy that allows a student to really grow and build. And I think one of the criticisms of MYP sometimes is it feels light, but when you realize that you're going way beyond knowing and understanding, and you've just described the scaffolding of year one, year three, year five, it takes a lot to reach the highest level in year five.
Vikas PahwaAsk me about it, Jon. I think it's the fact that it feels light because you have some suggested textbook, but then you don't want to have a fixed thing you look into. It's teacher-driven, but it's actually okay, we decide, we design our resources and we design the curriculum. But I think in actuality, in the classrooms, the students who are driving it. And that is why it's because it is not stuck to the framework or in the rigid structure. It doesn't feel people feel it's right, but I think it goes way deep.
Vikas PahwaAnd you're right, the way it develops, and if you see the progression from year one to year five, by the time they reach doing the e-assessment, it's just skills that you've actually gone into. So that's and that's not easy. It's it might not be there in books and fundamentally on paper or curriculum, but it is there in everyday practice. And I think that's what the essence of the IB is as well.
Jon PetersonYeah, and I'm gonna continue to say things that are for me, I'm just advocating for MYP because one of the things that I've used a metaphor many times, but I think for a lot of folks, when they're looking for more rigor, they just are the metaphor of a soundboard, all they're doing is turning the volume up. And what IB does is it adjusts and makes a really rich texture of sound, shall you say, or in this case of educational ability, the texture of what we're learning, the depth of it, the wide range of skill sets that then lead to a really uh well-informed citizen, what the IB MYP is about.
Vikas PahwaI think, Jon, not just absolutely, just not just the texture and the mixture, but also, especially in case of individual societies, the integration. I think that's where it's so easy to forget that social sciences and humanities is individual and societies, but it is so easy to blur that line between history, geography, economics, and all. But I think bringing it out together, and if time allows, I'll give an example of one of the things we tasked, we did which showed this integration. That is the beauty of it. Where I think the educator also has to up their skills to be able to get that integration done.
Jon PetersonYeah, yeah, absolutely. Let's jump into the assessment side of things, and then hopefully we'll have time for that example you talked about.
Vikas PahwaYeah, again, as is fundamental to the learning trajectory of IB. Formative assessment, surely, and the unpacking actually, we talk to it like uh the one of the most interesting aspects is the previous knowledge assessment. So the word assessment is not assessment or a test, but it's like to see a kind of a self-review for the students to understand where they are with respect to a certain theme or unit which we are doing. And it also gives the educator the starting point from where to us. So the one of the most important aspects of a PKA or the previous knowledge assessment is exploring the command terms, analysis of visual sources like infographics, pictures, video clips through case studies.
Vikas PahwaSo exploring command terms like explain, analyze, discuss, all these, identify, all that. And after analysis for visual sources, very important, students to be able to know. If you're suppose you're looking, watching an eight-minute video clip, and you have a task given to you to identify certain pieces of information which are related to a general inquiry question given. So that skill of being able to analyze the source based on what is focused and required is a very important skill.
Vikas PahwaThen from learning to formulate a research question and to justify why the question is worth investigating is the next level which you have in terms of assessments. In all is a formative learning to write analytical responses and making claims as well. So our formative assessments would be designed in a way that they try to test these. Now, test here means not mark so great, but comment-based. So when you have comments and annotations, it keeps the students also a bit relaxed in terms of not having the pressure of a map and also helps them to think and be focused on thinking rather than focused on getting it always right, because that's not the idea.
Vikas PahwaWe make it clear, it's not about being perfect, it's not about being right or wrong, it's about thinking and seeing where you are and how we can discuss.
Jon PetersonYeah. And you think about the fact that right now knowledge is pretty cheap, and with AI becoming a bigger part of education, if we just ask students to tell us stuff, they can find it without any uh thinking. But if they if we can see their thinking through comments and other ways, that's more the purpose of education. At least it's becoming that. The purpose of education is changing. It probably always was more about thinking and understanding and what your how your mind processes things. But we often rely too much on just regurgitating information.
Vikas PahwaAbsolutely, and I'm quite happy to see this. They say that many of the students actually would come and ask me if I to that can you if I'm not given any comment, suppose for an answer, please give us some comments. We look forward to the comments. So it's important that a formative assessment, if it is a comment-based, it helps them to know what was that went well and what was it that even better if so that could lead them to a summative assessment, which will have marks, right?
Jon PetersonYeah, yeah, yeah. Yeah, and I don't know how important it is for us to go through the specifics of the numbering and how they how they determine a uh a score in the MYP. We could just do a real quick version of that just because people like how do you get a grade in this if it's about these four criteria? It's very briefly, very quickly.
Vikas PahwaIt's like adding the final achievement levels of all the four assessed criteria, A, B, C, D, to get a total out of 32, which is then mapped into a final one to seven scale using the grade boundaries. That's about it. Yeah, but yeah, and within each criteria, you have up till eight, zero to eight, and then you total it out of 32 because it's four, no, so four eights are 32, right? And then a final mapping of from one to seven. That's it.
Jon PetersonYeah, yeah. So you just kind of grade boundaries for those of you that are new to the MYP or IB in general. It's once you see the scores of students and you're looking at what maybe a 28 might be a seven, depending on out of 32. And also just to reiterate error to clarify too, with the MYP and IB in general, we're more interested in where the student ends up, not where they were in September or the beginning of the school year.
Vikas PahwaExactly. And also it's the journey they've gone through that has made them reach where they are now. So, yes, obviously, it's that journey always. And of course, by the time it's year five, whether you've reached that level of skills which you should have, that's what it is.
Jon PetersonYeah, it's harder to get a it's harder to get an eight as a tenth grader than it is that what the expectation for an for uh uh eight on a criteria or an objective would be different for a sixth grader versus a tenth grader by far. Absolutely, absolutely. Yeah, yeah. Okay. Good.
Vikas PahwaSo do you want to go through that example you were talking about? Yeah. So I think, and I I have being a head of the department, I think I have a very have an excellent colleagues in the team who have actually made this possible. Mr. Randolph and Ms. Yavi were two excellent individuals. I have educators I have in my team. And it's I'll give an example of a formative we had done. And uh it's when we do it, we first start off by decoding the concept and unit details, then we go on to conceptual grounding, and then we go on to the actual case study which we are looking at.
Vikas PahwaSo, for example, we were looking at a case study of the topic natural resources. Okay. So we had uh the anatomy of a disaster. So where we are looking at two case studies, one of the global case study and one was uh case study from India, right? So the global case study was the RLC. So how, and we brought in geography, history, economics together into it, but as to the students looked at a video clip we had as to how the RLC during the Cold War era, due to the policies which were there of the of Stalin's during Stalin's time, they actually tended to resulted into trying out of the entire RLC and how it actually led to a disaster which was awaiting to happen, and how it actually it was such a disaster for everything.
Vikas PahwaSo, for example, in the formative assessment, we divided into four parts because two criteria each we divided, and it was like the first formative we had. The question one was criteria A, state one example of an omnipresent natural resource mentioned in the source. Question two, criteria A1, outline the main difference between renewable and non-renewable resources. Question three, criteria D1. The source states that humans must be careful on how quickly they use renewable energy.
Vikas PahwaExplain the specific issue that arises within the utilization of renewable resources. Question four, criteria D4. The source mentions that we often forget other living beings on the planet that also need natural resources to survive. So discuss why human societies tend to forget that and that how it should be shared. So this is one kind of formative assessment we have. And this is all comment-based. They do it, we discuss it in class, they can do it in the notebooks, and we can discuss it further and come to a conclusion as to what went well and what could have been better in their responses.
Jon PetersonYeah, good. Thanks. That's a great example. Yeah, and as you were talking about going, we there's been some other more recent examples. These things are always happening, and in the context of your local experience.
Vikas PahwaIn fact, I think the what very unfortunately happened in Nepal is a classic example of as we go forward, we will talk about climate and then how it can lead, change can lead to disasters. It becomes through whether it could be year one or year two and other things. So it becomes a very relevant. That's what the beauty is of M5. It is giving you everyday examples. And Jon, as a practice in our school, we do before we start the curriculum, we do something called the SGO. We have an entire mapping we done do from year one to five.
Vikas PahwaSo where we do the planning from year one to six and see one to five and see how topics can be linked as we go from one year to the other. Right. So that also helps in creating that progression for the students.
Jon PetersonWell, that's a great point. Thanks for mentioning that. Because for listeners who are new to the MYP, one of the structures that MYP has is this continuum planning. It's definitely built into the PYP also. And so when you do continuum planning, if you're thinking of if you're a non-IB school or non-MYP school, you're leaving it mostly to the teachers to just do the collaboration if you give them the time. But in MYP schools, it's expected that the continuum is planned out so that the sixth grade teachers and the tenth grade teachers are on the same plan, basically.
Vikas PahwaAnd I think the two educators I mentioned, Mr. Randolph from Shiarvi, Ms. Ave, they are all three of us and are the department. Actually, they've done an amazing job to be able to get this clarity to everybody that how things work and the kind of examples and seasoned perspectives they bring in makes the program very interesting and very fruitful for all of us to do it together as a department.
Jon PetersonYeah, and there's other ways to connect. We're not even talking about those other subject areas, but when you mentioned the recent disaster in Nepal with the landslide, you could see where maths would be involved, you can see where science would be involved, the sciences, even the arts. You can imagine that people are coming up with ways to express themselves about the tragedy that happened there.
Vikas PahwaYeah. See, it's the the setting, the theater is geography. You have the mountains and the glacier which came in. And it's, I think, and maths comes in because you could bring in the angle at which things happened and the trajectory. But the effect it had on economically to the entire country, what how impact it what impact it had, how countries, especially immediate neighboring countries, came into help Nepal. So the global international relations comes into picture. How this might impact probably Nepal's trading aspects of business management comes into picture as well.
Vikas PahwaSo I think integrated individual societies and MYP gives you limitless possibilities to connect, to engage, and actually bring out this fact, which we many a times, I'm sorry, that's a personal opinion, which many times we forget in the DP that these are it's not history, job of economics or something else. It's humanities and social science. It's goals together. It's not cut off. We must bring it together as such. Yeah.
Jon PetersonYeah, yeah. And that's that's kind of the philosophical basis or underpinning for all of IP is that it's pedagogically adjusted as the students age. And quite honestly, when you get to the DP, we're almost forced to become a little more discreet and subject-oriented because of the expectations for university and others. But the IB still, even in those cases, it definitely has the connections to other subjects. And TOK is a great tool for that for the DP. But thanks for explaining the MYP. I one of the questions I had for you is what you love about teaching it, but I wonder, listeners are probably listeners have probably already figured that out.
Vikas PahwaYour enthusiasm is infectious. I could again put it very quickly that integrated ILS makes truly an intradisciplinary class become a reality and provide students with a futuristic lens to understand the true relevance of the continuum between MYP and DP and brings out the relevance of what everyday life and in knowledge is all about for the students. They learn to understand the world and begin to understand their place within it. So that's no important.
Vikas PahwaGreat.
Jon PetersonAny final thoughts? I just want to make sure you have time in case you have any other things you'd like to mention.
Vikas PahwaI think I just say that for everybody that at its heart, MYP's individual societies is about it's it, I think it's a very good opportunity for everybody who teaches MYP and from the DP as well to do and experience both of them as a bridge to each other. Because I think for me personally, it is not just it is not only giving the students too a tool to understand their world, but it also helps us to become more curious and empathetic and also have the courage to ask or question assumptions.
Vikas PahwaAs you said, TOK is a great mirror to that. But I think humanities, social sciences, individual societies, and TOK go together, and that's a great mirror to uh the entire IB way of teaching and learning. That's great.
Jon PetersonThanks, Savikas. I appreciate your being on here, and hopefully we'll have you on. We you teach other things, so we might have you back for another inside the course as well.
Vikas PahwaThank you so much, Jon. I equally look forward to coming back as soon as possible. That'd be wonderful, as always. Thank you so much.
Jon PetersonThanks. Thanks for listening to IB Matters. With more than 145 episodes covering topics across the IB continuum, there's much more to explore. Visit the IB Matters website linked in the podcast notes to promote episodes by program and topic. If you find these conversations useful, please follow or subscribe to IB Matters in your podcast app so you don't miss any future episodes. And consider sharing this episode with an IB colleague who might find it useful. That's one of the best ways to help us reach more educators around the world.
Jon PetersonYou'll also find a link in the podcast notes to text me with comments, suggestions, or ideas for future episodes, including letting me know if you'd like to join me for a conversation. Now in our seventh year, IB Matters has been heard in more than 180 countries. Thanks for being part of this global IB community.
Send us Fan Mail What does the growth of IB in India tell us about the opportunities - and challenges - of bringing IB philosophy into different educational cultures? In this episode, Jon talks with longtime IB educator...
Send us Fan Mail In this second conversation about the new MYP themes, Adrian Von Wrede-Jervis takes us beyond the framework itself to a bigger question: How do we help students make meaning for themselves? Adrian...
Send us Fan Mail What is the IB Diploma Programme really like from a student perspective? How are IB DP students navigating CAS, the Extended Essay, TOK - and now AI in education? Twin sisters Avantika and Anantika...
Send us Fan Mail Four years ago, IB Matters first spoke with Jiana Shah when she was a 14-year-old MYP student. We caught up with her again as she entered the Diploma Programme. Now, Jiana returns for a third...
Send us Fan Mail We are re-connecting with Adrian Von Wrede-Jervis to get his thoughts on the changes occurring in the MYP. Specifically, Adrian and I begin a conversation about the MYP themes and how we might think of...