Send us Fan Mail What does the growth of IB in India tell us about the opportunities - and challenges - of bringing IB philosophy into different educational cultures? In this episode, Jon talks with longtime IB educator Gayatri Mehta about the place of IB within India’s remarkably diverse educational landscape. Their conversation moves from families seeking rigorous, internationally recognized education to the challenges students and teachers face when moving from finding the “right answer” to inquiry, questioning, and making meaning for themselves. Gayatri also reflects candidly on the adjustment teachers make when they stop seeing teaching primarily as explaining and begin creating space for students to think. Ultimately, the conversation moves beyond how IB might grow in India to a more interesting question: What can IB and India learn from each other - and how can education give students the confidence and agency to challenge ideas for themselves? Course resources: Description on the IB Website Subject Brief Email IB Matters: IBMatters@mnibschools.org Instagram (IB_Matters) Twitter @MattersIB IB Matters website MN Association of IB World Schools (MNIB) website Donate to IB Matters Podcast: Education by Design with host Phil Evans IB Matters T-shirts (and other MNIB clothing) To appear on the podcast or if you would like to sponsor the podcast, please contact us at the email above.
Audio and video play straight from the show's own hosting. PodSubs stores and serves no media.
Transcript
From the show. Tap a time to play from there.
Gayatri MehtaSo yeah, in India it is not just opening more schools, it is trying to understand this this pedagogy of IB and this philosophy of IBs. And so I don't want the international curriculum to simply replace Indian curriculums. I want the entire the idea of inquiry. What does inquiry look like in India? What does international mindedness mean for an Indian student? What is global citizenship learner profile? What does it mean? And how are we using our history, our challenges, our experience more in our kind of way of way of teaching?
Gayatri MehtaI would not want my student to be good at simply reproducing information on in an exam. I would want a student who can challenge an idea, say we don't agree with that, and have the confidence to do that and also explain why. And I think that is what the IB is eventually training the child to have enough confidence to do that.
Jon PetersonHi folks, welcome back to IB Matters. And I'm here with Gaitri Mehta from India. And she and I have talked a little bit offline about some of the things and the projects we might be working on. But one of the subjects that I thought was really interesting and she was willing to speak about is just the role or the place of IB in the giant country of India. There are many different systems of education in a country that large, and IB is just one small part of it. But I think for our listeners around the world, maybe just to let you know that our listeners in South Asia actually number about a third to 40% of all of the listeners to IB Matters.
Jon PetersonSo I think it'll be a subject of interest for folks there in that region, but also for the rest of us from the rest of the world. So welcome to the podcast. And why don't you start by introducing yourself a little bit?
Gayatri MehtaThank you. Thank you for having me, John. It's really, it's really nice to be here. So I'm Gaitri, I'm Gaitri Meta. I have been an IB educator for about 10 years now. I teach economics, global politics, as well as T O K in the IB, in the DP specifically. And yeah, I've taught mostly in North India. I've taught in, I'm currently in a school in Chandigarh, which is the capital of Punjab and Haryana. I've taught in Delhi. I've taught in the British school in Delhi as well as in Pathways in Delhi.
Gayatri MehtaRight now I'm in Strawberry Fields High School in Chandigarh. I'm an examiner, uh, I'm a Nyask visitor. So the works. I've done a couple a couple of things. I've been around in IEP for a bit now.
Jon PetersonWhat are you what are you an examiner for? Which subjects?
Gayatri MehtaEconomics, paper one, and T O K, the essays.
Jon PetersonSo Okay. Yeah, so you've got quite a breadth of experience there. And it sounds like if you were in the British school, you're probably familiar with the British system as well.
Gayatri MehtaYeah, absolutely. Although I taught the DP in British school as well.
Jon PetersonOkay.
Gayatri MehtaSo, but yes, of course I am familiar with the British system as well.
Jon PetersonAll right. So where did you first encounter the IB in your in your educational journey?
Gayatri MehtaSo I did not study B in school myself. I was in the Central Board of Secondary Education. I was in a convent school myself, Convent of Jesus and Mary. But I encountered the IB in fact much after my master's. I did my master's in political science in Ireland after a master's in economics in India. So I did a double master's in that sense. And when I came back, there was a school called Pathways, which was looking for an economics teacher. I applied, I got in. Pathways did all the training, all the category training, all the in-house PD happened there.
Gayatri MehtaAnd that's where I really appreciated the IB to be uh to be honest. I loved it. I loved it. And then I just decided to stick around, and here I am, 10 years later.
Jon PetersonYeah, I think we've had quite a few people from Pathways on the podcast. Is there just one pathway school, one one physical place, or is it a group?
Gayatri MehtaIt's a group. It's a group. So there are three pathways schools, and they're fairly big. There's a there's a residential school as well. I was in Noida, so in three different parts of the of Delhi and NCR. But now, of course, I've moved on from pathways and I'm in Chandigarh and Strawberry Fields High School. So yeah.
Jon PetersonOkay, okay, great. So let me let's back up. I heard you say Ireland and part of your education.
Gayatri MehtaSo why don't you why don't you talk a little bit about your own education, how you got into uh being an educator so I did my master's in economics from India from a national from Jamia Milliar Islamia in India. I was in Delhi University for my economics honors, like my undergraduate course before that. Ireland just happened. I had a friend who wanted who was in the UK at the time, and I applied to a bunch of places in the UK and Europe. I got into the Republic of Ireland, I got into the University of Limerick for a master's in IR, international relations, and it gave me a scholarship as well.
Gayatri MehtaIt seemed like a great opportunity. At the time, I was very interested in the work of the UN. I had worked in a couple of volunteered for a couple of UN projects and then and the National Human Rights Commission. So yeah, so then Ireland happened, and then I when I came back, it was that kind of lull that happens after college, after university. What now it felt like of course the UN would be waiting for me, but it wasn't. And yeah.
Jon PetersonYeah, it's a big world. Yeah, yeah, it's a big world.
Gayatri MehtaYeah, I know. I thought I'll teach like a stop gap arrangement, but then I really loved it. So yeah. So then that that's how I ended up in teaching.
Jon PetersonOh, that's great. I appreciate that kind of little context. And I think I've actually interviewed some young people that are in IB or just finishing IB, and I think it's nice for them to know too that that the journey is not necessarily a a thread that you just follow along. It's gonna go jump around and do other things and yeah, be prepared for whatever comes your way. So, one of the things we're taking on kind of an ambitious project in this conversation, which is to think about IB in India, which is you have your own perspective, but you also have you've moved around enough to probably know more about it.
Gayatri MehtaI think the the biggest or the first thing to understand about India is that there isn't one Indian education system. It's incredibly diverse, and education somewhat reflects that diversity. We have government schools, private schools, different state boards. We have the Central Board of Secondary Education, ICSC, and then we have international curriculum like the A levels and IB. And of and even within all of these, there's a lot of, I would say, urban-rural divide. So the educational experience, in a way, of a student in a private school in Mumbai or Delhi or Bangalore or Chandigar for that matter is completely different from that of a student in kind of a rural government school.
Gayatri MehtaBut I think it is a mistake which we often speak about in a workshop, and go in our workshops and PD and schools as well. That you cannot describe Indian education simply as traditional versus progressive. There are some very, very innovative government schools and Indian state boards, and educators are doing, of course, extraordinary work across. Just as there can be very traditional private schools with very high fees, and and yeah, and I think what also could be a significant point here if you think about if you take a bird's eye view of education in India, is that India, of course, academic achievement is very important for most students.
Gayatri MehtaSo when you when you have a system like the IB, which says that we want students to question, and you have a T O K and an extended essay, and a lot of times it is a risk as well because it is a challenging curriculum. So it's exciting to see how parents take that in a lot of or students take that in a lot of places because they want academic achievement.
Jon PetersonSo yeah, I yeah, it's always dangerous or risky, I should say, in to paint a culture in a single brush or whatever. But I think in general, there is this impression in India that parents are very on top of their child's education and have high high expectations. And I've spoken to a lot of students in India and it I've gotten the impression that they definitely have parents that are in behind the scenes making sure that they are doing the most challenging thing they can. But as you did you allude, if I'm hearing between the lines of what you were saying, is that because IB has this kind of multiple perspectives and things, that might be a challenge for Indian parents to accept that.
Gayatri MehtaI think more than multiple perspectives, it's the idea of instance and students here too being very focused on what they're gonna do after school. So one thing about the IB is the kind of international mobility it gives, it gives the students that they do want, they do want the a lot of students do want to go abroad, they do apply to the best of the universities around the world, especially kids in a lot of these private schools. So yeah, and Indian parents are also very future-oriented, so they understand that a curriculum like the IB where it might be challenging, it might focus on multiple perspectives, but it is also making them future, it's making them ready to go to different countries around the world.
Gayatri MehtaAnd of course, the IB does in inherently, I think the curriculum itself does make them confident communicate, make students confident communicators. So yeah, so yeah, I think that the danger of this is saying that we will that we want to send our student uh our child to the IB because the child should go somewhere abroad or the guy or the child should apply in different countries. So that that is one of the criteria to make them more ready and more mobile in different countries around the world.
Gayatri MehtaSo yeah.
Jon PetersonTo your knowledge, what to what degree has IB been taken up in rural areas?
Gayatri MehtaI don't know. I think not as popular as it is in urban India. Uh definitely not as popular. But having said that, there are a lot of people who come to bigger cities who are originally from rural areas, and they do come to bigger cities in order to be a part of the IB because students are often incredibly academically driven in in India. So yeah, so I suppose maybe I feel you would find fewer rural IB schools, but you would have people traveling if they can afford it, and if of course, because IB schools are usually not always, but usually a little more expensive than the the other schools, the government schools and things.
Jon PetersonSo are there are there some states in India which are where there's a higher concentration of IB schools and some states where you wouldn't find one?
Gayatri MehtaAbsolutely. I think IB has been concentrated largely in India's larger metropolitan areas, and like I said, in and in schools who are serving families who are more internationally oriented or who want to send their children abroad. So Bombay, Delhi, Chandigar now, maybe Kerala, some parts in the south, Bangalore, Calcutta, all of these bigger metropolitan cities definitely have more schools.
Jon PetersonYeah.
Gayatri MehtaSo yeah.
Jon PetersonI thought I'd ask because it is I know it's uh IB is feeling like they need to, they have a big goal of in about 10 years having essentially double to triple the number of students in IB, and the way to do that is to go into areas where they don't already exist. And so that's one of the things they're hoping to do. Yeah. Yeah. And even here in the United States, we are definitely more likely to be found in urban areas like where I'm located. It's not a big urban area, but uh most of the IB schools in our state are located within about 50 miles of each other, and there's only a handful of them outside that area in our state.
Jon PetersonSo let's talk a little bit more about let's talk a little bit about the the continuum. The school you're in, what age groups do you have in IB?
Gayatri MehtaSo we have PYP, and then we have we have the national curriculum, they have a choice between the national curriculum and IGCSC, and then they have the DP. So they have uh so they have a choice, and they can also choose between the national curriculum and the DP in higher school. So yeah, it's a couple of things, but by doing so, it caters to like a variety of students in a way. And a lot of schools do that, they have a choice between curriculums.
Jon PetersonAnd I've heard that before from other people that I've interviewed there, that it sounds like in the middle sometimes they don't necessarily have MYP, they use the national curriculum or the IGCSE. Do you have do you know why that would be, or why do you think they do that?
Gayatri MehtaI think I think uh see that different schools have different different reasons behind it, but I think the e-assessment is one of them that uh parents don't take very well to the e-assessment at the end of the day, it's like changing mindsets. It's it is it is making convincing parents that this curriculum is rigorous enough, yeah. And I think also the IB jargon can become a little difficult to explain sometimes to students of MYP, and like in DP, of course, a lot of them take their own decisions and they want to go to the international curriculum, the university, they want to get into university and all of that, and they want they feel that the DP prepares them better for university.
Gayatri MehtaBut in MYP, I feel that there are still a little bit more traditional mindsets where they get caught up in the jargon of IP, they do not understand why does the whole idea of concepts and conceptual understanding and learning like why is that better than more traditional system than what is the child gonna write in the exam? And I feel like in a lot of places the e-assessment is also not, but that's of course just my perspective. I feel that it's not taken as well as a traditional pen and paper exam. Sure. And and the national curriculum is considered more rigorous for that age group as compared to the MYP.
Gayatri MehtaThat is just the perception, of course. It's not necessarily the truth. Yeah.
Jon PetersonSometimes the MYP takes a more there isn't a quick answer to what is MYP. The MYP is this kind of multifaceted thing that I believe in the MYP. I think it's really an important part of the IB. I often have described it as the DNA of the IB program K-12. But in fact, it does mean there's more inter more understanding required. Parents have a harder time understanding it. So now you so you have PYP and the DP, and then you have others in the middle. Do you do you find that are you teaching only in the I'm only teaching the DP.
Jon PetersonAll right. So do you what talk a little bit about how students come in prepared and then their what that feels like for a student as they go through the the two to four years that you see them.
Gayatri MehtaSo the problem, or rather, the difficulty for me as a teacher would be that students have come in with this mindset of being rewarded giving the correct answer. That there is one correct answer, and if they give that, that's great. And and it's a very of course, you have evaluative and an analytical questions even in tenth grade and all of the curriculums. But the assessment criteria in the IB of say evaluation, so even if I speak about economics, even in that, what evaluation truly means, and also that is something they find very difficult to grasp or even to write, like on in global politics, to evaluate a real-world example in global politics, or TOK, of course, is a completely new area for most students.
Gayatri MehtaApart from just these three, the pedagogy of IB of being more inquiry-led, that is also some somewhat difficult to grasp for a lot of students. But then inquiry-based teaching, I suppose, can be difficult in any curriculum. It's like trying to maintain the kind of depth of the class while still taking a little bit of a back step. So, yeah, that and knowing as a teacher when to intervene and when not to. So I would say that that students who come from different curriculums need a little bit more scaffolding initially.
Gayatri MehtaBut yeah, I think it just takes a little bit of skill on the part of the teacher also to understand how to drive this class forward as it would even if they came from MYP, I'm sure. But yeah.
Jon PetersonYeah. No, and I think that is you hit the nail on the head there that the I think that's one of the reasons why some folks would want to have MYP because there is that exploratory time where students understand they there are multiple ways to answer a question and a number of ways to look at things through inquiry. When I was a DP teacher, I taught in a school that did not have a feeder, but didn't have an IB feeder. So I can I totally empathize with that. Let's talk a little bit about that. You just described one of the challenges. Do you find are there other challenges being an IB school in your community that you find is there a competition for students?
Jon PetersonAre you needing to explain IB and quote unquote sell it to families so that they choose you to come to your school or choose students choose to take on the IB once they're there?
Gayatri MehtaYeah, I think the transition, of course, from like I said, the transition is one of the major challenges that you especially when you are offering the board that they're used to or the curriculum that they're used to in high school as well. The transition is challenging, the explaining how teachers, uh the pedagogy of IB is challenging to explain to uh parents and students for that matter. So that's where the implementation of IB or how it's implemented, where all of this is not like this impossible mountain that they have to climb.
Gayatri MehtaI think that that is where the challenge of IB really that's like the core of the challenge, right?
Jon PetersonYeah, yeah. And as you were talking, I was thinking, I think she's talking about the students, but I was writing down to myself, what about the teachers like yourself? You did not grow up as an IB student, and your teachers in the building that are your colleagues, I would guess that the vast majority did not start out as IB students themselves. Are there challenges in helping your colleagues, the professionals, take on or take up these same pedagogies you talked about? And you're an IB educator yourself, so you are part of this.
Gayatri MehtaYeah, so I feel like it's very difficult to be standing in front of a group of students and not explaining some, not making it teacher-led. And a lot of teachers, I feel me included sometimes. I feel that if I'm not talking at them, I'm not really teaching. If they're not so that was a very difficult mindset for my for me to change as well. If they're not drawing the diagrams of this extremely complicated diagram of welfare loss and indirect taxes, how are they even understanding it?
Gayatri MehtaAnd that takes a little bit of understanding that how to make a class student-led rather than a teacher-led. And I think for me personally, I think it the idea was that I didn't have to disappear from the class and let them do whatever they feel like, and I think it is it is asking in it is the pedagogy is telling you to ask the student why do you think like that? Or can you explain your thinking or your understanding of this topic? It's taking one step back but still being there for the student.
Gayatri MehtaI don't know if I'm explaining this well enough, but but yeah, I feel like the problem is just that that's standing in front of them and saying that I'm gonna explain everything, I'm gonna write it on the board, copy it down, figure it out. That's the problem.
Jon PetersonYeah, I had a teacher that did that. He put stuff on the board, we walked in, copied the board, and he didn't talk to us. He just said, You get here's what I want you to know, and then on Friday to see if we did know it. And so that's so different for an IB educator that they have to act differently, and it is it's part of the training, and it's one of the the difficulties, like you said. So I'm glad you you put that into words because I think that is for a lot of educators, and the majority have not had an experience as an IB student. Come into an IB program for myself. I taught 28 years before IB came into my school, and so I had this idea of how to teach, and IB gave me some new tools and new ways to think about it, what I teach.
Jon PetersonBut what I loved about it is philosophically it matched what I wanted to do. It just gave me some tools to do it. I knew I I always picture myself as being on the same side of the table with the student as opposed to the other side of the table. In other words, let me sit next to you and let's figure this out together. And I think that is a metaphor for I think how IB wants people to teach, wants teachers to teach, and help the student find it themselves. And you're a guide, you're helping them, you're building the sandbox, if you will, so that they can explore, and then they hopefully will go out beyond the sandbox and learn new things.
Jon PetersonBut no, it's a really I like the way you express that. I think that's really gonna be helpful for people to imagine that. So we talked about a few things, and like I said at the top, this is your perspective. And and one person in a country of 1.3 billion doesn't know everything about education in a country, no offense. But but I think do you have any final thoughts? What do you what's your kind of big picture thinking about IB? Where does this go? What is your own future going to be? Where is your school? Where do your students go with IB? Where do you think this will be in 10 years, five, ten years in India?
Gayatri MehtaSo I think it's of course I would want the IB to be more accessible in India, and that doesn't necessarily mean opening more IB schools. It means understanding and trying to implement the philosophy of IB uh well enough. What I mean by that is also that I don't want I would not want my student to be good at simply reproducing information on in an exam. I would want a student who can challenge an idea, say we don't agree with that, and have the confidence to do that and also.
Gayatri MehtaAlso explain why. And I think that is what the IB is eventually training the child to have conf enough confidence to do that. So yeah, in India, of course, sorry, I digressed from the question. The that of course it is not just opening more schools, it is trying to understand this pedagogy of IB and this philosophy of IDs. And so I don't want the international curriculum to simply replace Indian curriculums. I want the entire the idea of inquiry.
Gayatri MehtaWhat does inquiry look like in India? What does international mindedness mean for an Indian student? What is global citizenship? All of these words, learner profile, what does it mean? And how are we using our history, our challenges, our experience more in our kind of way of way of teaching? So yeah, I feel like that is what I would want the IB to be, but I don't know. Yeah.
Jon PetersonYeah.
Gayatri MehtaI think it has some exciting opportunities. Yeah.
Jon PetersonYeah, yeah. And that's that the IB has enough humility to know that they don't have a lock on all these pedagogies. It is a funnel for best practice, as I've said many times. And in fact, what you're describing is that maybe some of this philosophy will leak out into the rest of education in India, and that would be a good thing. And as it influences people as they go from for example, if were you to leave an IB school, you would not forget all the things you knew about teaching if it was not an IB school. You'd still carry a lot of that with you. And so I think that is ultimately one of the whole points of IB is as it says in the mission of create a better, more peaceful world, doesn't mean you necessarily have to be an IB student to do that.
Jon PetersonWe'll be talking about other things in the future. But do you have any other final thoughts?
Gayatri MehtaYeah, I think the more interesting question in this regard would not be what IB can bring to India, but maybe what IB and India can learn from each other. One of my students said this, in fact, in a TOK class where I was talking, we have that unit on knowledge and the knower. And the student was talking about what it means to be a knower. And so I said that what does it mean to be a knower in the DP? And he said that it's not just what I can learn, of course, I am the student and I am learning things from the IB, but it's also about what I bring to the IB.
Gayatri MehtaWhat and I thought that was quite interesting for a 17-year-old to kind of come up with. He said, Because the way I think of I respond to your type of teaching, the way I am responding to these ideas of international mindedness and global citizenship that you keep telling us. The way I am that's also bringing that's also data for the IB. So I was like, oh yeah, that's true enough.
Jon PetersonWe've used the word agency a lot in education these days, but there's a student who's got it. They're like, What aren't you interested in what I bring to you? That's cool. Yeah. Good. Thank you, Kaitri, for being here and sharing these perspectives, as we said, on on IB in India. And I think you and I are probably going to have a conversation about a project that we're working on with the describing some of the IB courses. So we'll be in touch again for that. So thank you very much.
Gayatri MehtaThank you so much.
Jon PetersonThanks for listening to IB Matters. With more than 145 episodes covering topics across the IB continuum, there's much more to explore. Visit the IB Matters website linked in the podcast notes to browse episodes by program and topic. If you find these conversations useful, please follow or subscribe to IB Matters in your podcast app so you don't miss any future episodes. And consider sharing this episode with an IB colleague who might find it useful. That's one of the best ways to help us reach more educators around the world. You'll also find a link in the podcast notes to text me with comments, suggestions, or ideas for future episodes, including letting me know if you'd like to join me for a conversation.
Jon PetersonNow in our seventh year, Ivy Matters has been heard in more than 180 countries. Thanks for being part of this global Ivy community.
Send us Fan Mail What does it mean to understand the world through the people, societies, and events that shape it? In this episode of IB Matters, we launch our exploration of the Middle Years Programme (MYP) subject...
Send us Fan Mail In this second conversation about the new MYP themes, Adrian Von Wrede-Jervis takes us beyond the framework itself to a bigger question: How do we help students make meaning for themselves? Adrian...
Send us Fan Mail What is the IB Diploma Programme really like from a student perspective? How are IB DP students navigating CAS, the Extended Essay, TOK - and now AI in education? Twin sisters Avantika and Anantika...
Send us Fan Mail Four years ago, IB Matters first spoke with Jiana Shah when she was a 14-year-old MYP student. We caught up with her again as she entered the Diploma Programme. Now, Jiana returns for a third...
Send us Fan Mail We are re-connecting with Adrian Von Wrede-Jervis to get his thoughts on the changes occurring in the MYP. Specifically, Adrian and I begin a conversation about the MYP themes and how we might think of...