Skip to content
PodSubs
ShowsPeopleGuestsJobsNewsEvents
More
BlogPodCred
Menu
ShowsPeopleGuestsJobsNewsEventsBlogPodCredNetworksSign in
Join nowSign in
  • Shows
  • People
  • Jobs
  • News
  • More
    • Guests
    • Events
    • Blog
    • PodCred
    • Networks
    Join nowSign in

Human Resource Development Masterclass

Human Resource Development Masterclass artwork

HRD & Artificial Intelligence

Oct 10, 20231 hr 3 minAudio

In this ninth episode of Season 4, guests Dr. Alexandre Ardichvili (University of Minnesota, USA), Dr. Maria José Sousa (University Institute of Lisbon, Portugal), and Dr. Uta Wilkens (Ruhr University Bochum, Germany) discuss the relationship between HRD and Artificial Intelligence, including: What is meant by the term Artificial Intelligence? Why is Artificial Intelligence in the news? How is Artificial Intelligence impacting organizations, and how could that impact change in the coming years? What does all of this mean for individual employees and different profiles within the workforce? What are the implications for HRD practice - the work it does, where it works, how it works, who is involved, etc? What are the implications for HRD education and how people are prepared for careers in HRD? What are the implications for HRD research and, specifically, what research is needed into HRD & Artificial Intelligence? and much more. For full details on the HRD Masterclass series, visit hrdmasterclass.com, and for the bios of the guest scholars visit allbypodcast.com/generations. For more information on the Academy of Human Resource Development, visit ahrd.org - by being a member of AHRD, you can access bonus materials from podcast episodes. This episode is sponsored by the Human Resource Development program at the University of Minnesota's Department of Organizational Leadership, Policy, and Development.

Audio and video play straight from the show's own hosting. PodSubs stores and serves no media.

Transcript

From the show. Tap a time to play from there.

SPEAKER_03For training and development specialists, they not only need to understand how their clients are using AI, but they also need to understand how to make sure that AI actually supports their work rather than completely substitutes.

SPEAKER_00Welcome to Human Resource Development Masterclass, the podcast series from the Academy of Human Resource Development, the organization that leads HRD through research. I'm your host, Darren Short, and here in our fourth season, we're exploring the relationship between HRD and trends in society and organizations, with the help of leading authors, researchers and scholars. Today our focus is the relationship between HRD and artificial intelligence.

SPEAKER_00And my guest scholars are Dr. Alexandra Ardishvili of the University of Minnesota in the United States, Dr. Maria Jose Sousa of the University Institute of Lisbon in Portugal, and Dr. Uta Wilkins of Ruhr University Bochum in Germany. All of whom join me for a conversation recorded in April of 2023. Our episode today is structured into two parts. In the first, we look at AI and its impact on organizations and the workforce.

SPEAKER_00Then in the second, we explore the implications for HRD practice, research, and education. You can find out all about the questions explored in the episode, the three guest scholars, and also the episode sponsor by visiting allbypodcast.com forward slash artificial. Talking of sponsorship, Human Resource Development Masterclass is only made possible thanks to the wonderful support of our sponsors, who cover all of the costs associated with the series, and so enable us to release them free of charge to listeners like you.

SPEAKER_00I encourage you to show your thanks by checking them out and letting them know just how much their sponsorship means to you. Today's episode is brought to you thanks to the sponsorship support of the Human Resource Development Programme at the University of Minnesota Twin Cities within the Department of Organizational Leadership, Policy and Development. Want to join a community of world-class HRD scholars? At the University of Minnesota, HRD practitioners are prepared to design training and development programs, identify systems and business process needs, forecast necessary staffing changes, and improve employee engagement and performance.

SPEAKER_00The University of Minnesota offers PhD, MA and MED degrees in HRD, as well as a new fully online master's degree in learning and talent development that prepares you to lead training and development in organizations, assess where various development strategies are needed, and implement and evaluate solutions for organizational change. Access courses from anywhere on your schedule and earn a world-class master's degree. For more information on their HRD program options, please visit z.umn.edu slash hrd.

SPEAKER_00That's z.umn.edu slash hrd. Right, let's dive into the episode. Welcome to our episode on artificial intelligence and the implications for HRD. And let's start by meeting today's three guest scholars. And first, I'd like to welcome Dr. Alexander R. Dishvili, Professor of HRD and Helovic Adow Chair in Leadership and Adult Career Development at the University of Minnesota in the United States.

SPEAKER_00Sasha is the recipient of the Academy of Human Resource Development Outstanding HRD Scholar Award and of numerous awards for research excellence. He's published four books and more than 100 articles and book chapters on international HRD, leadership, entrepreneurship, business ethics, sustainability, and the impact of artificial intelligence on learning and development. Welcome, Sasha.

SPEAKER_03Thank you, Darren. Hello, everyone. It's great to be here.

SPEAKER_00So my second guest for the episode is Dr. Maria Jose Sousa, Pro Rector for the Development of Distance Learning and Professor and Researcher at Ishte at the University Institute of Lisbon in Portugal. Maria has co-authored more than 100 scientific articles and book chapters and is a guest editor for more than five special editions. She was president of the ISO Technical Committee 260 on Human Resources Management and represented Portugal at the International Organization for Standardization.

SPEAKER_00Maria was the lead editor for the book Future Health Scenarios, AI and Digital Technologies in Global Healthcare Systems. So welcome Maria.

SPEAKER_01Thank you. It's great to be here.

SPEAKER_00And my third guest for the episode is Dr. Uta Wilkins, full professor in work, human resources and leadership at the Institute of Work Science, Ruhr University Bochum in Germany. Uta gained her PhD in management and economics from Chemnitz University of Technology. Her core research interest is related to the interplay of individual and organizational capabilities while adapting to change dynamics, especially to technological innovation.

SPEAKER_00Since 2021, she's speaker of the Competence Center Humane, the human-centered AI network and transfer hub of the Ruhr Valley. And she was recently appointed to the ACTEC Expert Group on Learning Systems, a network of leading researchers in the field of artificial intelligence. So welcome, Uta.

SPEAKER_02Thank you for having me here and welcome to the audience.

SPEAKER_00So over the next hour or so, we'll be talking about artificial intelligence and the implications for organizations and individuals, and then to the implications for human resource development. But before diving into those details, I'd like to start off our conversation by exploring what's meant by the term artificial intelligence and how the three of you have worked on the topic through your research, writing, and practice. So, Sasha, I wondered if you'd be willing to get the ball rolling by talking about what AI means to you and how you've worked on it.

SPEAKER_03Well, in a nutshell, artificial intelligence is a computer program that performs tasks that typically require human intelligence. And I'd like to distinguish between two important terms. One would be artificial general intelligence or AGI and artificial narrow intelligence or ANI. General intelligence, AGI, is basically still an aspirational concept, and many experts believe that it's decades, if not hundreds of years in the future if we ever can achieve that.

SPEAKER_03At the same time, ANI is something that is already here. Artificial general intelligence would be something that actually can perform any task and jump from one uh performance uh domain to another. Whereas the ANI is actually focused on a very specific domain, very specific task, and cannot uh switch to other tasks so easily. And there are already dozens, uh hundreds, I would say, applications of ANI in our lives.

SPEAKER_03When we look at uh Netflix recommendations engines and what to watch next, when we look at uh customer service chatbots that actually respond to our queries when we access any company's website, these are all examples of uh narrow uh AI or ANI. Uh even uh if we take the current application that is in the news so much, uh Chat GPT, it has such an impressive uh range of uh tasks that it can perform, but at the same time it is still the same narrow technology based on a specific uh statistical algorithm and with a very specific uh task in mind.

SPEAKER_03So uh we need to make this distinction. Why am I saying this? Because uh there is too much worry about uh AI taking over the world or uh replacing human beings completely, and that actually would be a GI, general intelligence. Whereas we already are in a situation when ANI is actually present in our lives even when we are not seeing this or not realizing this.

SPEAKER_03And a lot of that is changing the way we work, the way we learn, the way we develop as human beings. And so that's what my interest is in to understand how these ANI narrow AI applications change the way the workforce develops, performs its tasks, and continues to be human beings.

SPEAKER_01Artificial intelligence is applied to a wide range of areas such as robotics, natural language processing, computer vision, machine learning, and expert systems. So um when we think about our lives, when we get up in the morning, uh the first thing most of us do is to look at our smartphone.

SPEAKER_01So at that moment we are already using artificial intelligence. So my relation to um this field uh is mostly uh research-oriented, and uh I have conducted several studies regarding the application of artificial intelligence to uh economic sectors, uh specifically uh to health uh sector, also.

SPEAKER_01And my approach to uh artificial intelligence was in the Ministry of Economy when I performed a study with several companies and how they used AI to develop products and services, and how the approach they have with the customers using virtual assistants and the chat box, as Sasha also mentioned.

SPEAKER_01I am also using it in my current job as projector for the development of distance education because we are creating several educational programs based on virtual uh reality and also augmented reality. And we are going also um to metaverse. So there is a lot of activities on this moment that we are working on.

SPEAKER_00It's funny that you mentioned picking up the phone and and the role of AI in that because um I did exactly that thing this morning and uh opened up my Instagram and completely regretted the fact that yesterday when I was in Instagram, I'd seen a pair of socks advertised and I clicked on that to find out more information. And now when I open my Instagram, every third thing that I see is an advertisement for a different pair of socks from a different organization. So I think Instagram has got the impression that I really am deep into different colored socks.

SPEAKER_00Uh Uta, how does all of this compare to how you've viewed AI and the work that you've done on it?

SPEAKER_02I agree with uh Sasha's uh definition, and you just gave an example for us that is based on unsupervised uh learning, I guess. Yeah, how it works uh for customers. So I think uh it is very important to make a distinction between uh current cutting-edge technology research and technology development. There is somehow a vision that AI becomes more and more similar to how the human brain works, but what we experience in our daily life, in our workplaces, in our business environment, that is rather based on technology that is from the second wave of AI, so it's more or less 20 years old from the tech development, but this is now integrated in use fields, and this is then based on uh either supervised or unsupervised learning, sometimes even reinforcement learning.

SPEAKER_02And the core issue here is uh that the technology detects patterns with data from imaging, from voice recording, or also from time series analysis, so data from time series analysis, and then it supports us uh in uh fields of quality control, of diagnosis, in predictions, in analytics for uh specific fields of decision support, but sometimes even in fields of uh creativity, so we can distinguish different functions or roles of the technology, it might serve as a tool, as a pure tool for the individuals.

SPEAKER_02Sometimes it's a medium to interact and enhance interaction between others, and in other fields, it is also considered and discussed as a counterpart in work settings.

SPEAKER_00So as the three of you have talked about AI, I think one of the things that comes through to me, I think, has been like the amount of attention that there has been on the topic, particularly over the last couple of years. In fact, it's it's it's somewhat challenging these days to open a new site and not see some sort of news or commentary on the topic of AI. So I wonder if it's worth digging into that a little before we start looking at implications for organizations and individuals.

SPEAKER_02We have to take into consideration that media tends to draw a little bit biased picture of uh how AI works in our environment and in our workplaces. It is often more dystopia than utopia, and especially driven by uh um uh the idea that uh technology could take over all uh our jobs so that there is a high substitution of labor, which is not valid from economic uh figures.

SPEAKER_02However, this is a picture of a very strong technology taking role in our all our spheres uh of life. So it is hard, and this is our job to do, also from uh research, uh, to um explain that it is more a virtual uh tool that allows to detect patterns, to uh take very specific tasks, uh but uh isolated pieces of tasks and not all over uh all our jobs that is uh helpful in some fields, that it bears some risk we should not uh ignore, but uh so uh to have a um more realistic uh information about uh the effects of AI.

SPEAKER_02But um, however, we could also experience during the last month that uh there is a very high-speed implementation in some fields. So ChatGPT is an example that it comes to our lives, uh nearly everybody's lives in a very short time cycle, and uh so we have to reflect on that. And news gives information, but uh researchers have to give validation and uh should probably uh involve in that debate in order to inform uh uh the society.

SPEAKER_03Well, actually, I think Ruta provided this uh absolutely wonderful explanation. Uh, a lot of hype in the news and emphasis on things which uh are worrying or uh things that people worry about, whereas not enough uh scientific evidence and not enough uh discussion of what's positive, what's negative, what works, what doesn't work. And our role as uh scholars in HRD in my case would be to make sure that we actually uh put this information out and uh provide a more balanced picture.

SPEAKER_00I wonder if that takes us then into start talking about like a more realistic view of the impact on organizations because it it I I was really um captured by the comment you made, Uta, about it's often viewed as more dystopia than utopia. Um and I think it's easy for people who uh focused in on the news cycle um to get a distorted view of what this means for organizations.

SPEAKER_00So to try and remove some of that distortion. Well, when you take a look at AI, how do you see it impacting organizations? And how do you think that impact could change in the coming years?

SPEAKER_02I think the technology bears very high potential for uh the physical development of organizations, but uh it also bears some risks or challenges uh where we should also take into consideration. And uh, we are all together uh in a situation where we have to bring together three uh uh perspectives and fields. So it is a technology development on the one hand side, but also the overall organizational development and the individual uh uh development.

SPEAKER_02Uh, and only if it goes together and we have uh a vision how to balance it and uh how to make uh it useful for workplaces, we can uh develop sufficient and um sustainable solutions, I would say. So for the corporate level, just to specify it uh further on, I would say uh the AI uh enhances uh productivity. There is a potential, and this is then based on automation. So it is also productivity with an automation scale behind.

SPEAKER_02But we can also use it for higher quality. This is, for instance, quality control of materials, but also of production flows. Then there is a potential for accuracy in solutions. This is especially important for the field of medical diagnosis, but also for personal selection and probably personal development we are talking about. And AI can serve as a counterpart in creativity. And so there is a generation of new solutions also for business model development, and so we use statistics and machine learning approaches for different directions.

SPEAKER_02I would also say that AI can perform tasks where companies suffer a shortage of labor or a skill shortage, so there might be also a field of compensation and manufacturing, but uh also in some services. And when we have to talk about the risk, there is always the risk of using biased data, so that there is a low trustworthiness of AI, then there is an ethical issue, that there is a hidden discrimination, even though it is not intended.

SPEAKER_02There is a risk if the development process of the technology was biased. Other risk is the implementation itself, how it is organized. If it is just a top-down implementation by a management, then we often have to cope with resistance to change. Individuals do not have a vision how their workplace, their job design, the individual proficiency will further develop.

SPEAKER_02So we have to take that into consideration. And it could also be a risk that AI is not user-centered, so that we neglect the customer perspective and the customer interests, and then there is a low technology acceptance. This might have to do with missing explainability, but also with a missing understanding of the customer's workflows when uh we In the field of uh business to business.

SPEAKER_02So it is very, very important uh that we bring together technology development, organizational, and individual development.

SPEAKER_03I'd like to elaborate on one of the important points that Uta made. She talked about new business models, and I think that would be hugely important to dwell on. It used to be that uh AI was uh available or they could afford it only if it's a large company and uh with lots of money and so they couldn't uh otherwise use AI. But with Chat GPT, we see that now it's available to anyone, to individuals, and small businesses uh certainly can use it.

SPEAKER_03So there is a lot of talk now about new business models accessible to small businesses, so they could actually develop new models utilizing AI technologies, and they could create new, uh completely revolutionary, I would say, creative ways of serving their customers, provision of on-demand services, let's say, or predictive maintenance, or subscription-based models, and so on. So this could uh revolutionize uh the work uh of small businesses and of course large businesses at the same time, and uh also will change the way people work in these organizations.

SPEAKER_03So that's I would think is important to keep in mind and do research on.

SPEAKER_00Maria, you've you've been focusing, I certainly you have a couple of books uh related to the implications of AI for the service sector and also for healthcare. I think when you take a look at organizations, uh are you seeing the the trends, the topics that Uta and Sasha are talking through?

SPEAKER_01Uh yes. We have a new set of uh technologies like Chat GPT that can help to potentiate the small and medium companies with not so much financial structure that they needed before all of those uh technologies uh emerge in our market. For instance, for uh websites, we used some softwares to create websites and it was uh costly.

SPEAKER_01And at this moment we have one software, we have more than one, but this is really amazing, it's durable, and durable just creates a website in one nanosecond. So this kind of technologies based on AI, they of course help a lot the small business and the startups. And here in Portugal we have a lot of tech startups because of Web Summit.

SPEAKER_01It's a huge conference that we have every year in the city of Lisbon, based on new technologies, uh emergent technologies. 60,000 people is coming in one week. And the entrepreneurs, the tech entrepreneurs they are coming to Portugal to create their business year because the government is creating a lot of facilities and giving some benefits, uh fiscal benefits, for instance.

SPEAKER_01So I think we are growing and the the labor market also are in changing. People need to think about to change their skills also in the universities and also training centers and the companies itself, they need to think about new models of training and also new pedagogies for learning so we can have a workforce that is able to deal with all of these uh huge changes.

SPEAKER_01We have, for instance, a lot of new softwares, and of course, machine learning and deep learning that we are using for creating of applications that are transforming the labor market and are automating manual processes and are helping to analyze large sets of uh data for better decision making.

SPEAKER_01So it's a very disruptive period of our lives as citizens and also their society and the labor market.

SPEAKER_00I like what Maria says there about um like how shifts in organizations and as um as Sasha spoke about, changes in business models, how all of that starts impacting the individual employee and start impacting the workforce. So the the amalgamation of individual employees. So, Uta, when you take a look at that, uh how do you see artificial intelligence impacting individual employees and maybe different profiles of them within the workforce?

SPEAKER_02Yeah. You just mentioned it in your question, it uh depends remarkably uh on the job profile and the work uh context, which uh uh how it impacts the individual. So there are different ways how the individual employee and the artificial intelligence, so the non-human agent, interact. And I think I could illustrate that with uh a few examples. When we consider a physician and medicine, then AI is especially in use for radiologists.

SPEAKER_02So they detect diseases, for instance, metastasis. And then the AI takes a very specific function, it's more an isolated function in the overall job profile of a physician, and it has for the person rather an augmentation uh potential because the proficiency increases, the technology provides somehow a safety net for a better decision, and um, so uh we have a better solution uh in uh in the diagnosis for the organization but also for the individual development.

SPEAKER_02It's somehow a win-win uh situation in this case. But there are other job profiles and they are very nearby. So I mentioned radiographers or also speech therapists, and in these fields, uh the AI tool takes broader parts of the overall task of these employees. So uh, and then uh the individuals start to consider about, and they are a little bit afraid about the individual uh job profile and how it will further develop.

SPEAKER_02And often they do not have a organizational support that gives them an idea what will be their own profession and what will be the support function of the technology, or if even the technology could take over most uh interesting parts uh of their job. And then there is uh a higher resistance uh on the individual side, but also uh a missing uh perspective, and even though it is not intended that these uh tasks are substituted by technology, it is more that the individual has not uh the overall idea of uh the physic development.

SPEAKER_02And I think this is a managerial task, it is has also to do with human resource uh development to bring that together and to take it as a task of overall organizational development. We should also consider some fields where uh the substitution of labor is definitely appreciated when we are talking about work context, for instance, in chemistry, nuclear power, or also in the circular economy, where employees have to do with very dangerous materials or substances, and then AI can make a considerable contribution for reducing risks and protecting health for the individuals.

SPEAKER_02If I should bring that into an overall picture, do we have a substitution of labor when we use AI or when we use technology? And this is not a new debate. We always had this debate if technology uh substitutes labor, and this is the same uh with AI, and we have to consider two effects in parallel. The one effect is the substitution effect uh of uh due to automation, and we have that in standardized fields of production and also of services.

SPEAKER_02There are differences between countries. Uh, when we follow OECD data, we have a high substitution potential currently in Germany, Austria, UK, and Spain, but we have a substitution potential, for instance, in the United States that is lower than the average of other countries. So it depends on the overall industry structure of these countries. But then we have to take into consideration the second effect that is the innovation or compensation effect.

SPEAKER_02When we use automation, we enhance productivity in a specific use field, which also might increase the demands in these fields. And a further part is that we have new demands in other use fields. And we always had this innovation effect for other use fields, where there is then a development for new business, new services. This is what Sasha and Maria just mentioned when they talk about the uh startup activities, the new wenches and business with new business models.

SPEAKER_02This is what we have in parallel. So in the overall balance, uh, it is according to what we know from former developments, is that is always positive. Yeah. So uh we have a physical development of our economies, but for a single workplace, it might be the case that it is substituted.

SPEAKER_03I would like to talk about the impact on individuals' ability to grow and develop. That's again my HRD head. I am worried about the impact on long-term expertise development in situations when knowledge workers are using uh the AI tools to substitute parts of their jobs, just some of the tasks. And the assumption is that these knowledge workers will be fine because they are not really giving all their tasks to AI.

SPEAKER_03AI supports them, enhances their productivity, and so they are fine. But how does expertise develop? Expertise develops over many years, some say 10 years, of deliberate practice, uh deliberate engagement in specific, uh progressively more complex problem solving, and learning from this problem solving, reflecting on it, and creating specific understanding of how their domain of expertise works, and so that's how people progress on the ladder of expertise.

SPEAKER_03Now, if we give uh more and more uh tasks to AI, do we have an opportunity to actually practice those skills which help us to grow? Do we have an opportunity to reflect on what we learn from these progressively more complex tasks? Do we have an opportunity to actually understand the larger picture of our job? So these are all issues which we need to consider.

SPEAKER_03And unfortunately, there is quite a lot of research already accumulated from the fields of accounting, finance, and medicine, where we see that there is a tendency for de-skilling and loss of expertise. So in 10 years from now, will the people who will be using AI are expert enough to take advantage of the positive affordances that this technology gives them?

SPEAKER_03Because they may not be as expert or as developed themselves. So this worries me, and that's what I would like to study more and urge my colleagues in HRD to reflect on more.

SPEAKER_01From the literature and the research, we have uh two different perspectives. We have a very negative perspective regarding artificial intelligence because it raised the question of uh job elimination, job destruction, and uh we have the other perspective about more rich uh jobs, more creative, more innovative, more jobs that uh can motivate the employees.

SPEAKER_01So we need to uh to deal with these two uh perspectives and analyze it, and uh we can see that some um jobs of course uh will need to transform because some of the tasks of uh that are integrated in those jobs are being automated, and uh, of course, the employees need to think how to develop new new skills and to create new opportunities, and also the employers need to think about uh how to train the workforce and give them uh new skills to perform better jobs, better activities.

SPEAKER_01But one thing we can be sure is that machines they don't have the possibility to use emotional intelligence as human people have that possibility. Of course, there are several jobs that will never can be destroyed, and human beings will be always needed to perform some kind of activities.

SPEAKER_01We just need to think how to transform ourselves and to accommodate the potentialities of artificial intelligence in our lives and also in our jobs. It is a dilemma, of course, uh but uh I think as human beings and being so creative as we always been, and we can look at history, and technology was always seen as a threat, and uh uh along the time we could deal with that, and we we reinvented ourselves, and uh different jobs were created along the time to face the changes and the challenges of the technology.

SPEAKER_01So I believe we can do it because uh we are more skilled, we are more prepared, and uh we will think about our future and uh how can we deal with all of these um uh changes and transformations. Um we are talking a lot about uh the digital transformation of uh organizations and the digital transformation of uh education and digital transformation of society.

SPEAKER_01So we have been thinking about this for several years, uh, but I think we did not find any kind of solution at this moment, and uh, there are still uh those two perspectives that we need to think how to make them more uh close and uh think how to uh to raise a new era with a look to artificial intelligence as uh benefic and not as distraction.

SPEAKER_01And uh I think for the future and regarding HRD, uh we will have uh several new jobs focused on data analysis, and we already have in the labor market jobs regarding the analysis of metrics and the prediction and the analysis of trends and so on, and of course, regarding HRD, we will um be more focused on that also, because it helps to uh take better decisions, and I believe HR data scientists will be a job for the future of uh HRD.

SPEAKER_01And of course, we have already the people analytics experts, and in the future, uh I think uh the focus will be there because uh it will lead to better decision making for the human resources development fields.

SPEAKER_00I wonder if that's a good segue then into exploring what this means for HRD and in particular HRD practice. I think Sasha, you going back to what you were talking about, you you were discussing the implications for the development of expertise, the implications for how individuals grow and develop, um, and some of the challenges that we could face over the next few years around that. So when you translate that into looking at what this means for HRD practitioners, um, what what do you see as the implications for HRD practice?

SPEAKER_00So what work is done by HRD, where it works, how it works, like who who is doing that work? How do you see that changing?

SPEAKER_03Before I address your question directly, I'd like to mention something else. Uh recently there was a report by the World Economic Forum, which shows jobs that are in danger from AI and those which are safer. And it was interesting to see two specifically HRD jobs listed in those lists. In uh the list of top 20 uh jobs that they considered safe was uh organization development professional.

SPEAKER_03And then on the other side of the equation, uh jobs that uh might be at danger. Again, in top uh 20, there was uh another HRD job, uh training and development specialist. That was really interesting to see, and I understand why they are saying that. Recently a doctoral student at my department, his name is Chris Bolden, he uh conducted a study uh trying to see examples of AI implementation in HRD fields, in specific tasks of HRD.

SPEAKER_03And he used the famous five-stage AD model basically needs assessment, uh, design, development, implementation, evaluation. And uh he was able to find examples for each of these five uh stages where AI is already used to substitute for training and development specialists sometimes, or augment their uh jobs and performance. So, what does it all mean for HRD professionals?

SPEAKER_03So, of course, uh in both cases, in the lucky ones, the organization development specialists, they need to understand how AI works, uh, how AI works for in their client organizations. What are The applications because the job of uh organization development specialists will be to develop new change initiatives to make sure that the implementation of AI actually positively affects organizational structures, culture, processes.

SPEAKER_03And for training and development specialists, that's probably even more complicated for them because they not only need to understand how their clients, customers are using AI and what are the AI tools that they will be using, but they also need to understand how to use AI in their own work and how to make sure that AI actually supports their in their workers and completely substitutes their performance.

SPEAKER_03But moving on to the question you asked earlier, of course, there are lots of things we as HRD professionals need to understand. I talked earlier about expertise development, that's one. But uh we also have uh other areas which we need to think about. For example, accidental and incidental uh insituated learning. As you know, this is one of the uh largest areas of uh HRD research and uh practical implications.

SPEAKER_03How does AI affect that? Opportunities for incidental learning from your peers may be eliminated if we outsource a lot of tasks to AI, but at the same time the opportunities may be created also. Communities of practice. How do we work in the communities of practice when members of that community are not only humans but actually uh artificial intelligent agents?

SPEAKER_03So all these things will need to be considered to make sure that uh HRD professionals uh remain on top of their game. And at the same time, I would say understanding the AI technologies, understanding how how they work, what they can do and what they cannot do, uh would be one of the first tasks we need to attend to.

SPEAKER_02Um no, I think he made this very uh strong and important point that we have to distinguish between the organizational development, so the overall moderation of corporate developments, and then the highly specified tasks, which are probably more uh effected. And uh what we are doing in our research lab is that we develop new training uh tools based on serious games approaches, and this is also for shop follow training and for managerial training and how to cope with AI and how to use AI in decision making.

SPEAKER_02So, not just in HRD, but then to support the development all over the organization. This is where employees can, for instance, experience that it works to invest in a very clear data structure and to invest in the trustworthiness of AI in order to benefit from it in later processes of work or how they can experience that there might be an augmentation potential within the technology that even the individual professional can then make better decisions in cases where uh technology is not available and so on.

SPEAKER_02So we can uh uh bring forward the overall organization, not to just face what is going on in the HR or HID department, but how to support work uh and learning uh development uh all over the company.

SPEAKER_00Maria, as I as I listen to Sasha and Uta there, it it it makes me think about what I typically see in HRD education and the extent to which HRD education is preparing um HRD professionals to take on this sort of work. Um it sounds uh somewhat different from the traditional way that we have prepared HRD practitioners.

SPEAKER_00So when you think about the implications for HRD education, how do you see us needing to change the way that we educate on HRD and prepare people for careers in HRD?

SPEAKER_01I think there is a lot of implications in HRD education because all of the changes that we are facing on this digital world where we continue to live. People during the last three years needed to learn very fast and a lot of skills to use a lot of platforms and all the digital tools to perform their jobs.

SPEAKER_01And also, uh, when we are talking about educational system, also the students and the professors needed to learn a lot of new uh technology, educational technologies and to learn new uh pedagogical models as using uh games, as Jutta referred, and uh also um using virtual reality and augmented uh reality to learn new skills and to develop the activities, the professional activities uh in different ways, using, of course, these technologies as a mean because they are transversal to all the professions and in a very dense way, and we were not used to these contexts, so there were a lot of changes, and people needed to adapt very fast.

SPEAKER_01So, uh, today what we are envisioning for uh HRT educational programs, uh, we need to uh to focus on giving the employees tools to know how to analyze the data and uh what kind of applications they have to perform better. For instance, there are a lot of softwares, some are free, some are paid, of course, uh but uh it they can help to better do the employee engagement surveys to do the pre-hire assessment through IE, for instance, using video analysis, and um the the professionals need how to use these kinds of tools and how to analyze the data so they can perform and they can make better uh decisions.

SPEAKER_01Um, regarding uh the programs that we are defining for distance education here at Ishkte, we are including in almost all the courses some optional curricular units that are focused on these new technologies. For instance, we just created a new postgraduation for public administration, and uh we included uh the different topics regarding IE and uh data analytics and of course cybersecurity topics because this is also very important um regarding the uh this digital world where we are living in the companies, and we had several big issues regarding cybersecurity.

SPEAKER_01So we are trying to prepare our students to be more aware of all of these topics and um uh to uh to be more skilled regarding artificial intelligence.

SPEAKER_00Sasha, when you take a look at your own programs at University of Minnesota and looking more broadly, maybe around the uh United States, are you seeing similar sort of changes to those that Maria is talking through? And uh and are you picturing other changes in addition to those?

SPEAKER_03Yes, I definitely see changes, but at the same time I say uh that's not enough in quite a lot of universities, including my own. We don't have a full range of uh these important topics which Maria outlined, and uh I think uh it is uh time for us to urgently rethink curricular content and add new uh coursework. Let's say at my department we do have a wonderful course on uh big data, for example, but there is no separate course on AI implementation.

SPEAKER_03And I would add to the list that Maria discussed a couple of things. One is would be economic, ethical, and moral implications of the implementation of AI technologies. As HRD professionals, we need to understand this and we need to be able to later communicate it to our customer. The second is uh what is the impact on learning development, expertise development as I discussed earlier, and in general on human development and flourishing.

SPEAKER_03So that could be another either a course or part of a course, which should be part of our regular curriculum.

SPEAKER_00Uta, for your own programs and those that you see around Germany, are you seeing similar sorts of challenges and changes ahead on education?

SPEAKER_02Yes, definitely. Uh I agree that AI literacy is a very crucial point for all disciplines, uh, meanwhile. Uh and it is often in uh tech disciplines where there is a high uh focus on, but uh it is uh of similar relevance also in humanities, uh social science, economics, and so on. And we are elaborating on that, but I think uh there is also a little bit to do in order to prepare our graduates uh uh for the physic uh developments in our society.

SPEAKER_00Well, I'm conscious that we're coming close to the end of our time together, and there's one question that I definitely wanted to make sure that we touched on before we wrapped up. So we've talked about the implications for HRD practice and HRD education, and I I think um the final piece really for me is the implications for HRD research, because one of the things that's become clear as we've talked through this is that um certainly there's a fair amount known, but there's also a fair amount that is not currently known in this.

SPEAKER_00Um there's probably also a bit of a delta between what's happening in practice and what we know in research. And I would imagine with practice moving as fast as it is, it can be challenging for research to keep up. And so, Maria, when you take a look at research, what what do you see as the implications for HRD? And what advice might you have for researchers or for possibly PhD students who are trying to select a dissertation topic?

SPEAKER_00What advice would you have around research in the coming years?

SPEAKER_01There is a lot of implications regarding HRD research. Of course, artificial intelligence can help to create new models of thinking, of learning, how to research. And of course, there are a lot of softwares that we can use at this moment to do our research. For instance, regarding systematic literature reviews that is also a hot topic at this moment for researchers.

SPEAKER_01We have, for instance, Ryan, it's a software that is based on artificial intelligence, and of course, we have R that help us with neural networks analysis and statistical computations and numerical analysis and the use of Bayesian inference. So we have a lot of tools that we can use. The big issue is uh what can we research and um if the companies are willing that we introduce our PhD students and master's students in their environment to study all of the artificial intelligence technologies that they are using, and uh the implications they have in their workforce and the competencies that the employees are acquiring with those technologies and the new models that they are implementing, the new organizational models and the new jobs that are emerging.

SPEAKER_01So there are a lot of topics that we can study. We are dealing with some issues about the openness of the companies regarding uh the research. I don't know if this occurs in all the countries, but uh as this is also a new topic for companies, they are not so open to research. So if you look at the production, the scientific production, you will see a lot of systematic literature review regarding artificial intelligence.

SPEAKER_01Uh, you can look at uh not only the scientific production but also the patents analysis. Um, but then uh when you focus on the field, the case studies are mainly on the multinationals, and um the medium and the startups are having some difficulties in open themselves, and also the public administration, they have a lot of uh uh um projects, um and it is a really difficult uh process of communication with them and uh to include our students and do some kind of research with them.

SPEAKER_00Well, it makes me feel as if um there's uh so much to talk about on the research topic. Um I almost feel as if we need a second episode to keep the conversation going. And the speed with which um the AI issue is moving might suggest it's worth us getting back together again in a year's time or two years' time to explore this further. But unfortunately, for today's conversation, I'm afraid to say we've run out of time. But I wanted to say a big thank you to Maria, to Sasha, and to Uta for such an interesting discussion, and I think for giving us all so much to think about and then hopefully to then act upon.

SPEAKER_00So thank you all so much indeed for your time today.

SPEAKER_03Thank you so much, Darren. I really enjoyed this conversation.

SPEAKER_02Thank you. Thank you. See you. Bye bye.

SPEAKER_00Thank you so much for joining me for this episode. It was wonderful spending time with Alexandra Ardishvili, Maria Jose Sousa, and Uta Wilkins. If you enjoyed this episode, check out all of our others. There were 33 episodes in the first three seasons, and we're releasing a further eleven here in the fourth. Between them, they provide access to conversations with over 100 leading scholars from around the world. New episodes release weekly. To learn more about the series, check out HRDmasterclass.com.

SPEAKER_00And to learn about the Academy of Human Resource Development, check out ahrd.org. Also, don't forget to look into our sponsor, the Human Resource Development Program at the University of Minnesota's Department of Organizational Leadership, Policy and Development. For more information on their world-class HRD programs, please visit z.umn.edu slash HRD. I'm looking forward to being with you in our next episode, when we're exploring the relationship between HRD and the climate crisis, with the help of Dr.

SPEAKER_00Maria Che and Dr. Ellen Scully Russ, both of the George Washington University in the United States, and Dr. Eugene Stafford-Smith of the University of Surrey in the United Kingdom. Until then, it is Darren Short signing off from the HRD Masterclass.com.

Open the transcript file

Hosts and Guests

Nobody is credited on this episode yet.

Credit the people on this episode

Be the first to rate this episode

More episodes

All episodes
  1. Gendered pathways to work-family balance

    Nov 17, 202634 minAudio

    This fourth episode of Season 6 brings together Dr. Sanghamitra Chaudhuri (Temple University) and Dr. Kyung Nam Kim (Texas A&M University) for a conversation about the 2026 article Gendered Pathways to Work-Family...

    Credit the people on this episode

  2. Navigating careers in non-traditional work

    Nov 10, 202636 minAudio

    This third episode of Season 6 brings together Dr. Yuanlu Niu (University of Arkansas) and Dr. Jos Akkermans (Vrije Universiteit Amsterdam) for a conversation about the 2026 article Navigating careers in non-traditional...

    Credit the people on this episode

  3. Silence in the workplace: What do we know from research?

    Nov 2, 202634 minAudio

    This second episode of Season 6 brings together Dr. Matthew Hurtienne (University of Texas at Tyler) and Dr. Heesun Kim (Francis Marion University) for a conversation about the 2024 article Silence in the workplace:...

    Credit the people on this episode

  4. Diversified mentoring: Living at the intersections of race and gender

    Oct 27, 202634 minAudio

    This first episode of Season 6 brings together Dr. Joshua Collins (University of Minnesota) and Dr. Ague Mae Manongsong (Louisiana State University) for a conversation about the 2023 article “Manongsong, A. M., & Ghosh,...

    Credit the people on this episode

  5. Season 6 Trailer

    Oct 12, 20262 minAudio

    Welcome to the trailer for Season 6 of Human Resource Development Masterclass - the podcast series from the Academy of Human Resource Development, the organization that leads HRD through research. The sixth season...

    Credit the people on this episode