This third episode of Season 6 brings together Dr. Yuanlu Niu (University of Arkansas) and Dr. Jos Akkermans (Vrije Universiteit Amsterdam) for a conversation about the 2026 article Navigating careers in non-traditional work: Toward a more context-sensitive and dynamic research agenda, which was published in the Journal of Vocational Behavior, Volume 168. The article can be read here. For full details on the HRD Masterclass series, visit hrdmasterclass.com, and for the bios of the guest scholars visit https://www.allbypodcast.com/navigating. This episode this is brought to you by the Human Resource Development program at the University of Minnesota, within the Department of Organizational Leadership, Policy, and Development. Ready to elevate your career and join a community of world-class HRD leaders and scholars? At the U of M, you will learn to design high-impact learning and development initiatives, forecast talent needs, and drive strategic change. Whether you’re looking for in-person collaboration or complete online flexibility, we offer master’s pathways designed around your goals. Our M.Ed. in Human Resource Development is a hybrid program that offers you learning and experience through interactive communities and a hands-on internship. The Master’s in Learning & Talent Development is a fully online, asynchronous degree that lets you build strategic leadership skills on your own schedule, from anywhere. Discover how a world-class degree from the University of Minnesota can transform your impact and growth. Visit our website to learn more and apply today at https://olpd.umn.edu/human-resource-development.
Audio and video play straight from the show's own hosting. PodSubs stores and serves no media.
Transcript
From the show. Tap a time to play from there.
SPEAKER_00I'm Joshua Collins, Professor of Human Resource Development at the University of Minnesota, and current president of the Academy of HRD. I'm here today with Dr. Aguime Manang Song, Assistant Professor in the School of Leadership and HRD at Louisiana State University. We'll be talking about her article, Living at the Intersections of Race and Gender in Diversified Mentoring: Experiences of Minoritized Women, Leaders in Higher Education. The article was published in 2023, Volume 25, issue 4 of Advances in Developing Human Resources.
SPEAKER_00Agi May was the lead author, along with colleague Dr. Rashi Ghosh. I chose this article for this episode because it tackles a question that I think many of us in HRD care deeply about, and that is how mentoring can both create opportunities and reproduce inequities. Rather than treating mentoring as a one-size-fits-all developmental practice, this study to me shows how intersectionality shapes mentoring experiences and what organizations and mentors can do differently to better support women leaders of color.
SPEAKER_00Augime, thank you for joining me today. And perhaps you could kick us off by telling listeners what the article was about.
SPEAKER_01Well, thank you for having me. In short, the article is about exploring the diversified mentoring experiences of 15 women of color leaders in higher education. They had various leadership roles, those formal leadership. And what we wanted to explore is how their multiple marginalized identities interacted with their mentors' identities, particularly when those identities were dissimilar in terms of demographic.
SPEAKER_01So a lot of the women leader uh participants, their mentors ended up either being uh white males, white women, or not sharing the same or similar backgrounds to themselves. So, how did they actually navigate those interpersonal relationships in order to maximize their mentoring experiences to not only develop as professionals, but solidify a leader identity as well as advance through the structure of academia?
SPEAKER_01Our assumption, Dr. Ghosh and I, was that academia itself, higher education, was gendered and racialized. So that was the assumption we were working off. So, how did these successful women actually end up where they are using mentoring? And if they didn't use mentoring, how come?
SPEAKER_00Thank you, Aguime. And I think you were getting at this as you were introducing the article just now, but can you say a little bit more about what drew you to ask these particular research questions and maybe even why did you want to conduct this research?
SPEAKER_01So this study actually started in my year one of my doctoral program. So that was what, 2017, and it got published in 2023. So you can see that was a six-year process.
SPEAKER_00We all have those.
SPEAKER_01So for me, it started with my first methods course, year one. I wrote this proposal up thinking like this could be a great way to really start researching my dissertation. I came in hot into my doctoral program where I knew what I wanted to study. And specifically, I wanted to study these constructs because they personally resonated with me. So it would give me great insights into the field that I was entering and wanted to enter to be a professor.
SPEAKER_01So might as well start learning about what women of color's experiences are, given the structure of academia. So given the fact that I know that women are underrepresented in leadership positions, they're underrepresented in the professorship in terms of tenure track, all of these things, I am entering in that space. So might as well learn. And particularly for me, mentoring has always resonated.
SPEAKER_01So does that look differently, having multiple marginalized identities? Because growing up in California, a very diverse state, not problematic. I'm not in California, I'm not in the same place. So I it would be foolish of me to assume that my mentoring experiences were gonna be the same and they were gonna be particularly successful in in terms of having a good interpersonal relationship with a colleague, but also it's gonna get me to where I need to be.
SPEAKER_01Right. So that's really the sort of um starting point. And then uh luckily enough for me, my second uh methods course was with Dr. Rashi Ghosh, who was also my PhD advisor and my research supervisor. So I had all of my fellowship hours with her. Uh, and she was very intrigued by uh the setup. It was a mixed method study setup uh in terms of having actually the a quant focused first rather than a purely qualitative angle.
SPEAKER_01And I up to that point, I've never really done um from start to finish a qualitative study on my own. So it was this project is very much indicative of me developing as a researcher, um, getting mentored by my second author, who is also uh my research supervisor and advisor. And of course, me being synergistic, I was like, you know, I can use all of these things to actually develop my dissertation, which was my original thought.
SPEAKER_00Yeah. So you mentioned that this was this happened to be your first foray into, you know, really conducting research and certainly conducting qualitative research. Let's think process for a second, and then we'll get to your findings in a minute. What did you learn from the process? What did you take from this one of your first experiences as a researcher that you now carry forward with you in your role as a faculty member?
SPEAKER_01Right. I I think the biggest thing was how to actually apply a theoretical framework to the structure and development of your research study and not just to the analysis. Because I learned that too, but I the most important thing was okay, we're doing intersectionality. What is that even? Because you can read about it and you're like, okay, so race and gender and all your marginalized identities become additive. So actually exploring these viewpoints uh was very much something I carry to this day.
SPEAKER_01Intersectionality is probably one of the uh theoretical frameworks I reach for the most because now I'm comfortable with what that actually looks like when I'm designing the study. How can I think about this in an intersectional viewpoint? And intersectionality is very much you do your best at the starting point to think about all of the different experiences someone could have when they have multiple marginalized identities.
SPEAKER_01So for women of color and their mentoring experiences, even though, as you know, my mentoring experience have been largely positive, I couldn't come into this space assuming that was the case, assuming that they had access to even mentors who had one similar identity to them. So being a woman or being a person of color or having an immigrant background, whatever the case may be. So that really taught me this study, really taught me that process of how am I actually applying the framework that we love to write about?
SPEAKER_01And we love to say, oh, it we use this as our analytical lens. How does that actually look like? And it really challenged me, particularly with the feminological process of what could someone's lived experiences be. And how is that different from mine? Do I accept their reality? And that was one of the biggest things because I had participants who had similar background to myself, and I had to really catch myself when I was thinking, well, I wouldn't have a handle that situation, how you handled it.
SPEAKER_01And when they got emotional, I got emotional. So it was qualitative research. It's far messier than quantitative research in that regard.
SPEAKER_00Something that you were just discussing makes me want to kind of jump to your findings really quick. And when I think about your findings, you know, one of the one of the findings really emphasizes both I think the challenges and the opportunities inherent in when cultural differences are present in mentoring relationships. And in fact, one of your participants talked about, I'm going to use a quote, I've had that feeling many times where in my mind I'm not going to bother because there is too much to explain, right?
SPEAKER_00So, like this idea that sometimes we might be in relationship or community with people where actually having that shared identity means there's a whole bunch of work we don't have to do because we can say certain things, certain words that might have a cultural significance or meaning, um, certain references that might have a certain cultural significance or meaning, and that person automatically gets it without further explanation, and we can stay focused on maybe the work we're actually doing rather than educating about our culture or answering questions that aren't relevant to the problem in front of us.
SPEAKER_00So, what did you find? Particularly, I want to think about culture and cultural differences. What was the importance of that element of uh this work in the people that you interviewed? And what would you take from that if you needed to give some advice to leaders in the higher education space, like what they can learn from this related to culture and providing better mentorship to women leaders of color in higher education?
SPEAKER_01That's a great question. So I think there's two parts to this. So, in terms of the research process, as we were discussing, being women of color, Dr. Ghosh and myself, our participants automatically related to us. They felt a sense of safety, I would say, where they could be very honest about whether or not mentoring actually was positive or their struggles with finding professional development opportunities. There was a lot of moments where there was a, you know, you get it.
SPEAKER_01It was basically signaling to us as women of color, we should understand their viewpoint. So it actually helped getting rich data and getting very honest reactions to their lived experiences of mentoring when it's mentoring across differences. In terms of what we found, there's diversity within diversity. Women of color is not a monolith, particularly when it comes to culture. So we had participants who had immigrant backgrounds and participants who were American.
SPEAKER_01They were born in America, been here for generations, and they approached particularly the topic of mutuality. So let me learn you something about my culture differently. It was very burdensome to uh the participants who were of African American descent. Because what do you mean that I have to tell you about American culture? Right? I only have 60 minutes.
SPEAKER_01I shouldn't be spending 30 minutes on how you said something is inappropriate. And oftentimes uh their their mentors were white male. They were uh several decades older than them. How come I have to teach you this? So it was very burdensome to them. And that is sort of summing up why professional development for black Americans is so problematic.
SPEAKER_01It's because they very much came from a place of they're not gonna know about my cultural X, Y, and Z, my food, my celebrations. So I don't mind teaching them. So they were very much more open to that mutual learning. I'm gonna get career development and then I'm gonna teach my mentor how to at least handle someone who has my identities, my cultural background.
SPEAKER_01And in terms of leadership and what they can learn from that aspect, is that it's gonna be burdensome. Being culturally competent is something that leadership needs to emphasize in order to sort of maximize the mentoring relationship, particularly in higher education, where all faculty there's the expectation that they mentor. It's part of our service.
SPEAKER_01We get basically graded on it. And whether or not we get tenure relies on whether or not we actually have good mentoring relationships with our students, what our students vouch for us.
SPEAKER_00Yeah, absolutely. Well, and it it makes me think too about how developments around cultural competency competencies are needed. And we want to make sure that as people develop their competencies about cultures that are not their own, that they are digesting information that is accurate, that they are digesting information that is respectful. So uh let's flip this for just a second and talk about the mentors or the leaders who maybe don't identify among the characteristics of leaders that you've identified for this study, right?
SPEAKER_00So let's think about a white male leader, mentor who genuinely wants to be a part of uplifting all leaders in spaces that they occupy, and maybe they don't have a lot of exposure to different cultures or different cultural competencies, and they want to get it right, but they also don't want to ask all of the questions and put that labor on somebody who holds a different identity from themselves. Do you have any advice for that kind of person about where they might go, the kinds of things that they might do or read or access to develop their skills around cultural competency?
SPEAKER_01Right, that's a good question. So, of course, in terms of doing research, reading the books of critical race theory, reading the books of intersectionality, and also feminist theory is a good starting point. Viewing your potential mentoring relationships as not having to be identical to the route you took is one of the biggest things, where you have to look at development as where are they and where do they want to be, and allowing them to be agentic and proactive within their own development.
SPEAKER_01Learning how mentoring can really manifest the different types of approaches, feminist mentoring approach, there's um relational mentoring. So maybe there's the mutuality aspect where it does not have to be my mentees teaching me about their culture. That's one of the biggest things, is I'm not trying to, as a white male mentor, make this woman of color a white male mentor eventually. Uh, that's one of the biggest things.
SPEAKER_01And I think for just a personal, interpersonal, you have colleagues. And a lot of us, we're not your mentees. It wouldn't be burdensome for us. We actually welcome those questions. I'd rather you ask me how to handle an Asian woman immigrant mentee than ask her. So you can rely on your developmental network, which was one of the biggest findings. You should have multiple mentors feeding you still, even if you're in a leadership position, to help you understand those perspectives, but also help you ask certain questions in uh a thoughtful and respectful way.
SPEAKER_00Absolutely. Thank you for that. Another question that I had for you, it relates to both the methodological approach, um, but also tends to be an outcome of the methodological approach that you selected. So phenomenology, often it's talked about representing the essence of an experience. And as a result, something that comes up very often in analysis is that we kind of only end up presenting the information that is relevant to all or most participants, right?
SPEAKER_00But something that might be expressed by just one or two or a few participants doesn't necessarily make it into our findings because we're trying to present the essence of a shared experience. So uh just out of curiosity, was there anything that ended up on the cutting room floor, as it were? It's not in the article, but you found it, you thought it was interesting, something you found interesting in the process or as a part of your findings that just didn't quite make it into the article, but is worth talking about or exploring?
SPEAKER_01Um I'm sure there was, but I can't think of one right now. And I think it's more because intersectionality provided us that sort of leeway to even though one person said it, we can still include it, right? Because it's not just similarities across the board or you know, frequency. Five participants said it. Um if it's important enough, it should be included. But I'm sure there was.
SPEAKER_00That's a great answer. And I want all like doctoral students, novice researches out there who are thinking about phenomenology to hear that, right? To hear that there are different ways, number one, of thinking about approaching this methodology, but also that the frameworks that you choose can either limit or expand the scope of what you're able to present as your findings. And in your case, having intersectionality as one of your lenses actually gave you a broader way to present how we even think about what would be commonalities in terms of what your participants shared.
SPEAKER_00So I actually think that in and of itself does answer the question, just maybe not in the way that we thought it might when I asked it.
SPEAKER_01Thank you. I I think it's very important to when you use something like critical race or use feminist or queer theory, it gives you that room because if you have 15 participants and only three of them are black or only four of them have immigrant backgrounds, yeah, that's the minority. But it's immensely important to amplify their voices because what they're experiencing could be an exemplar for the larger community.
SPEAKER_01Um, and I think critical frameworks allow that. And whether you're doing IPA or narrative inquiry or whatever qualitative approach you're taking, that framework does really become important in terms of the process. And we had multiple processes. So it wasn't just, okay, who said what, and didn't enough of them say it to be majority. So if we saw that most of the Americans were saying the same thing, then well, that's a finding.
SPEAKER_01So that aspect in terms of American versus immigrant background was something we didn't get to emphasize a lot of, but it's there. And that's something that I'm taking away and looking for. Now in my other research, is there a difference in terms of being an expatriate and being someone who was born in this country? And that's something that really expanded my use of intersectionality as a framework.
SPEAKER_01Because now I'm looking beyond race and gender. I'm looking at national context because that does feed into how we view mentoring experiences, leadership development, because we did notice that a lot of people really came who have the immigrant background came from, I think it's large power distant cultures. So they We're very comfortable with traditional mentoring. So things like that become very important when you use these frameworks.
SPEAKER_01And for me, it's it was a learning moment.
SPEAKER_00Yeah, absolutely. Augie May, I'm gonna ask you to put on your speculative hat for just a minute to the extent that you're comfortable, right? So I think you mentioned that this data was collected in 2017 or there around. The study was published in 2023. So obviously, lots has changed since January of 2025. No specific reason, you know, just, you know, things changing.
SPEAKER_00I count no fewer than four words in your title that are now banned by federal agencies, by some of our institutions. How has the context or your understanding of this work changed? What do higher education leaders and mentors need to know in this moment, right? As a result of your work, but also thinking about your work and how it might translate in the current context, what are some of the things that you think people should keep in mind?
SPEAKER_01I think it just highlights the importance of these topics that we cannot say. So, in terms of practice, I don't think anything has really changed. We still have to be very responsive to these differences. Because even just as a selfishness, if we're not developing our doctoral students because we're ignorant to what has happened outside of our office, we're not going to develop them successfully.
SPEAKER_01They're just going to drop out. And we have to even be even more mindful now of the stressors that our students may be facing because their differences are being targeted. Speaking candidly, some of my students are international students and they don't want to leave the United States to go to UFHRD. So even if they have a great idea, they would have to bring me on because I can leave the United States. So I would be presenting on their work that I may not have really contributed to other than guiding them through the process.
SPEAKER_01In terms of leadership, I think it's more of just we're going to keep our heads down until the adults re-enter the room. So it's how much do I shift and change to accommodate what's happening outside of my department, outside of my control? And how much do I just keep going forward? And I think that's the the biggest part of it. Um when leadership is trying to help us navigate this, when we are trying to help uh our students navigate this.
SPEAKER_01Because who's drawn to me? It's people who want to use critical frameworks, it's people who want to investigate and highlight voices that have been marginalized. That's what people want to work with me about. So it's tough all around, but I think just research how it's set up actually helps us. This research project took six years to complete. It went through a ton of stuff and it ended up getting published.
SPEAKER_01And so it is very much a good reminder that staying true to your authentic um academic identity is probably the most important.
SPEAKER_00Yeah, absolutely. I really like a question that you asked in what you were sharing just now, which was, what can I do authentically to me? And I just think that when we live outside of our authenticity, it is apparent, right? And so when you're thinking about the questions that are important to you, the places that you want to make an impact, the only way to move forward, regardless of what is going on around you, is to do that authentically.
SPEAKER_00Um and people interpret that in a lot of different ways. I think it's very powerful to hear from you that even in this moment, for you, authenticity means I'm gonna continue doing what matters to me, right? That is my authentic move in this space. Other people in this moment might find themselves making authentic moves in different directions. And I think that um embracing people's um ability to survive the moment as well.
SPEAKER_00Um, obviously, your study was situated in higher education, but as I was reading, I could not help but to think this feels applicable in a lot of different kinds of organizational settings. So, what are your thoughts on that? Do you think there are things that we can learn from the experiences of minoritized women leaders in higher ed that we can apply elsewhere? What are some of the nuances of that from your perspective?
SPEAKER_01It's definitely applicable to any organization where there's an underrepresentation of women, particularly women of color, in amongst their leadership ranks. The assumption that we came into the study with is that higher education was an exemplar of what the issues are in other disciplines and other organizations and other fields. It's that gendered and racialized space that structures informal and formal power and how you achieve that.
SPEAKER_01So a lot of the insights could be applied to various different um fields. And even more so because a lot of the participants came from different fields and they ended up in higher education through either sort of hapostance or they selected, like, I want to teach, I want to research. So they ended up in higher education because that's the only place they could do it. So a lot of them were working lawyers, a lot of them were nurses and doctors uh before they uh joined a university.
SPEAKER_01So they're pulling from their experiences when we were researching them, when they were sharing their stories with us. Uh they were pulling from their experiences in different disciplines, not just their experiences in higher education.
SPEAKER_00Augie May, thank you for your time today and the opportunity to talk to you about this amazing research. I also want to thank you in my current capacity as president of the Academy of HRD for all the work that you're doing, specifically that I think is doing much to advance curiosity around inclusion and mentorship in the field, specifically with an eye toward our graduate students, which is extremely appreciated and valuable. And so thank you very much for your time.
This fourth episode of Season 6 brings together Dr. Sanghamitra Chaudhuri (Temple University) and Dr. Kyung Nam Kim (Texas A&M University) for a conversation about the 2026 article Gendered Pathways to Work-Family...
This second episode of Season 6 brings together Dr. Matthew Hurtienne (University of Texas at Tyler) and Dr. Heesun Kim (Francis Marion University) for a conversation about the 2024 article Silence in the workplace:...
This first episode of Season 6 brings together Dr. Joshua Collins (University of Minnesota) and Dr. Ague Mae Manongsong (Louisiana State University) for a conversation about the 2023 article “Manongsong, A. M., & Ghosh,...
Welcome to the trailer for Season 6 of Human Resource Development Masterclass - the podcast series from the Academy of Human Resource Development, the organization that leads HRD through research. The sixth season...
This final episode of Season 5 brings together the current president of AHRD, Dr. Seung Won Yoon of Texas A&M University, the current president-elect of AHRD, Dr. Joshua Collins of the University of Minnesota, and the...