Skip to content
PodSubs
ShowsPeopleGuestsJobsNewsEvents
More
BlogPodCred
Menu
ShowsPeopleGuestsJobsNewsEventsBlogPodCredNetworksSign in
Join nowSign in
  • Shows
  • People
  • Jobs
  • News
  • More
    • Guests
    • Events
    • Blog
    • PodCred
    • Networks
    Join nowSign in

Human Resource Development Masterclass

Human Resource Development Masterclass artwork

HRD, Inflation & Unemployment

Sep 19, 20231 hr 4 minAudio

In this sixth episode of Season 4, guests Dr. Fotios Mitsakis (Nottingham Business School, Nottingham Trent University), Dr. Mandolen Mull (Rockford University and MullMentum Consulting, LLC.), and Dr. Parisa Mahboubi (C.D. Howe Institute) discuss the relationship between HRD, inflation and unemployment, including: What is meant by the terms Inflation and Unemployment? Why is there so much interest in the topics of Inflation and Unemployment? How do Inflation & Unemployment impact organizations from an economic point of view? How are employees and the workforce as a whole impacted by Inflation & Unemployment? What are the implications for HRD practice - the work it does, where it works, how it works, who is involved, etc? What are the implications for education and how people are prepared for careers in HRD? What are the implications for research and, specifically, what research is needed into HRD & the topics of Inflation & Unemployment? and much more. For full details on the HRD Masterclass series, visit hrdmasterclass.com, and for the bios of the guest scholars visit allbypodcast.com/inflation. For more information on the Academy of Human Resource Development, visit ahrd.org - by being a member of AHRD, you can access bonus materials from podcast episodes. This episode is sponsored by the Board of the Academy of Human Resource Development, which encourages you to register for their 31st International Research Conference in the Americas in Arlington, VA, February 21-24, 2024. For full details, visit https://www.ahrd.org/.

Audio and video play straight from the show's own hosting. PodSubs stores and serves no media.

Transcript

From the show. Tap a time to play from there.

SPEAKER_02Budgets are tightening. As everyone is feeling the strains coming from high inflation or high unemployment, there is a direct, I would say, impact on organization on HR.

SPEAKER_00Welcome to Human Resource Development Masterclass, the podcast series from the Academy of Human Resource Development, the organization that leads HRD through research. I'm your host, Darren Short, and here in our fourth season, we're exploring the relationship between HRD and trends in society and organizations, with the help of leading authors, researchers and scholars. Today our focus is the relationship between HRD, inflation, and unemployment.

SPEAKER_00And my guest scholars are Dr. Foti Osmetsakis of Nottingham Business School, Nottingham Trent University, Dr. Mandolin Mull of Rockford University and Momentum Consulting, LLC, and Dr. Parisa Marbubi of the C. D. Howe Institute, all of whom join me for a conversation recorded in April of 2023. Our episode today is structured into two sections. In the first, we look at inflation and unemployment and how they impact organizations and the workforce.

SPEAKER_00Then in the second, we explore the implications for HRD practice, research, and education. You can find out all about the questions explored in the episode, the three guest scholars, and also the episode sponsors by visiting allbypodcast.com forward slash inflation. Talking of sponsorship, Human Resource Development Masterclass is only made possible thanks to the wonderful support of our sponsors, who cover all of the costs associated with the series and so enable us to release them free of charge to listeners like you.

SPEAKER_00I encourage you to show your thanks by checking them out and letting them know just how much their sponsorship means to you. Today's episode is sponsored by the Board of the Academy of Human Resource Development, which encourages you to attend the 31st Annual Research Conference in the Americas, being held in Arlington, Virginia from February 21st to 24th, 2024. It's the ideal opportunity to meet leading scholars, practitioners and rising stars, including many of the guests in this podcast series, as they report their cutting-edge research.

SPEAKER_00The event is perfect for learning and networking. And AHRD is an inclusive organization that invites all of those who are interested in the field, no matter where they are on their scholarly journey. Mark your calendar for 2024 in Arlington. We look forward to seeing you there. For further details, visit the AHRD homepage at ahrd.org. Right, let's dive into the episode.

SPEAKER_00Welcome to our episode on inflation, unemployment, and HRD. Let's start by meeting today's three guests. And first I'd like to welcome Dr. Fotios Mitsaikis, senior lecturer in human resource management and organizational behavior at Nottingham Business School, Nottingham Trent University in the United Kingdom. Prior to joining Nottingham Business School, Photios completed his PhD in human resource management at the University of Strathclyde. Fotios undertakes research in areas including human resource development, strategic HRD, and training and development, and has published several articles exploring strategic HRD in times of business and economic uncertainty.

SPEAKER_00Welcome, Fotios.

SPEAKER_02It's nice to be here, Darren, and discuss with colleagues such a topical topic and share our insights.

SPEAKER_00Thank you so much for joining us. So my second guest for the episode is Dr. Mandolin Mull, Chair of the Puri School of Business and an Assistant Professor of Leadership at Rockford University and founder of Momentum Consulting LLC, a bespoke leadership and organizational development firm. With a PhD in organizational development and change and an MBA in international business, her expertise lies in change management, operations, and leader development. Mandolin has accrued over a decade of corporate leadership experience and consults with organizations across the globe, providing analysis and interventions targeted to improve organizational performance outcomes.

SPEAKER_00Welcome, Mandelin.

SPEAKER_03Thank you so much, Darren. It really is phenomenal to be on this podcast and having this really timely and important discussion. Thank you.

SPEAKER_00And my third guest for the episode is Dr. Parisa Marbubi, senior policy analyst and leader of the CD Howe Institute's Human Capital Policy Council. Parisa's research interest focuses on social policy with a concentration on demographic, skills, education, and labor market concerns. In addition to authoring research studies, Parisa regularly writes a column for the Globe and Mails Business section. Prior to joining the C.D. Howe Institute in 2016, Parisa worked at the Statistics Canada Research Data Center and as an instructor and research assistant at the University of Guelph while completing her PhD studies.

SPEAKER_00So welcome, Parisa.

SPEAKER_01Thank you, Darren. Doreen, it's great to be here, and I'm happy to be part of the discussion on important topics, employment and inflation. Hot topics today's.

SPEAKER_00They really are. And over the next hour or so, we're going to be talking about inflation and unemployment. And then from that, implications for organizations and individuals, and then implications for HRD. And I was thinking that before we dive into the details of those, I think a good place to start would be exploring why there's so much interest in the topics of inflation and unemployment. And then to hear from each of you about how you've worked on those issues as part of your research, writing, and practice.

SPEAKER_00So, Focios, I wondered if you'd be willing to get the ball rolling for us on that.

SPEAKER_02Yes, uh, thanks, Darren, again. Uh I think that with all the crisis events you know we have encountered the last 10 years or more, inflation and unemployment are the two of the most important microeconomic indicators to assess the health and the stability of national economies. So, from a general point of view, and I would say for all of us being global citizens, we need to know at least the basics of how inflation and unemployment, and if you like HRD as well, could interrelate with each other.

SPEAKER_02Uh, to put it simple, since inflation affects all aspects of the economy from consumer spending, uh, taxation, unemployment, unemployment rates, uh, interest rates, business investments, including HR slash HRD, if you like budget allocations, inevitably it affects everyone's life to a different extent or to some extent. Now, from a research point of view, uh, relevant research, I feel, and to my best knowledge, is that is nonsense on the interrelation between of those topics, or it is superficially discussed through other topics.

SPEAKER_02So, since inflation, unemployment, and HRD are interdependent notions somehow, I feel that this discussion could offer space or great opportunities for interdisciplinary research collaborations to initiate.

SPEAKER_00Mandelin, how does that relate to your exposure to the topics of inflation and unemployment, and how is that fed into your research, writing, and practice?

SPEAKER_03Yeah, I agree with everything that Petites is saying here. Um, you know, we one of the things that I think most people get very conditioned to in our organizations is this mentality of we've been here before, we've weathered STEMs before, we've weathered the 2008 global crisis or the global pandemic. Um, and that mindset can really stymie growth and development. Um, so that's been something that um I've had to work on on the consulting and practitioner side of assisting people to, especially uh executive leaders, understanding that they have not been here before.

SPEAKER_03Uh, you know, we're looking at these numbers of inflation and unemployment. Uh, Parisa knows this is probably far better than I do. Um, but you know, these numbers I think we haven't seen in over, you know, 70 years, um, if if I'm correct on my research. And adding to that, we're seeing about 10 million people, at least here in the States, um, that have started new businesses. So it's in that's impacting uh unemployment as well. We're seeing impacts uh with uh more people taking disability because of the global pandemic, etc.

SPEAKER_03So when we think about these things, there's a lot of variables that are coming together. And unfortunately, we're seeing some organizations continue to act in reactionary ways, um, in hysterical ways. I've uh a good example of that is mass layoffs. So that's a lot of where I've been working on this subject, and uh something that I hope we're making some progress in. We've got a bit to go.

SPEAKER_00The more we talk about it, I know we're early into the conversation, but the more we talk about it, the more the more topical and interesting this definitely becomes. Parisa, given where you sit within a policy research perspective, how does inflation and unemployment look like from your own research, writing, and and practice?

SPEAKER_01Similar to what Fatih Tedan mentioned in regards to uh unemployment and inflation, because we can assess the health of the economy. And uh in my case, specifically in terms of the labor market, uh, it is really important to look at these indicators and identify the challenges that employers, workers, uh, individuals, any any individuals in a society might uh be affected and uh face challenges uh through these uh economic changes and identifying the strategy to help individuals mitigate uh those uh negative impacts and also to adopt new strategies to be able to navigate through those extreme times, you know.

SPEAKER_01Sometimes uh you know, in normal times, unemployment and inflation, uh, they are not uh they don't affect our lives uh significantly. But in extreme cases when we are facing uh very low unemployment, or uh in case of low unemployment for uh work um for employ uh for organizations, but in terms of, for example, high unemployment for individuals looking for employment, and also in terms of inflation, inflation affects everyone, every single individual, those uh you know, uh consumers, workers, uh, organizations, and also it has implications for policymakers to provide the uh policy solution and um recommendations for for individuals and employers to be able to navigate through uh during these uh difficult times or uh strange situations, also for policymakers to be able to provide the sound policy to be able to support businesses and individuals during this time, in terms of, for example, um inflation and unemployment sometimes affect uh lives in a way that we need a specific type of labor mobility policies or labor market policies to be able to support individuals.

SPEAKER_00It's interesting listening to um how the three of you have approached the description of inflation and unemployment. And like it one of the things that comes through maybe is that depending on where you are in the world right now, the chances are you're experiencing something that's somewhat abnormal. Um, and that um certainly in in many of the locations where listeners are likely to be, the chances are right now that unemployment numbers are probably quite low, and inflation numbers uh uh historically, anyway, quite high.

SPEAKER_00And so I'm wondering what this means for organizations, as in what are the implications for organizations from that economic point of view? But but Matt Mandalay, you mentioned you mentioned layoffs, and I'm sure there's far more than that. As in, what's your thinking around implications for organizations?

SPEAKER_03You know, what we see in these types of situations is obviously high inflation starts to put enormous risk on organizations to raise their prices because they're having to recoup their costs of their resources. Um, and low unemployment also puts an enormous pressure on organizations to ways to raise their wages. Um, and so what we are seeing is really there's this tension state, these kind of you know, twin conflicts occurring.

SPEAKER_03Um, you know, there's a researcher out of Stanford, he's been looking at mass layoffs for quite some time, and uh his name is Jeffrey Pfeiffer. And you know, what we have seen, and we've seen this over hundreds of studies, I just kind of chose chose him to look at when I was doing some research for this, um, because we we've seen from hundreds of stories that organizations that act in reactionary ways and do these mass layoffs typically feel far worse, uh, especially within about a year um to three years, if they had not done the layoffs.

SPEAKER_03Um what we see is about a 20% loss of productivity in those organizations that conduct those. Uh, we see the remaining employees who are staying are now shouldering more workload. They have a loss of morale. Um, and so we see within about six months, about 8% of those individuals are going to be leaving within that first year after mass layoffs. Uh, about 50% start to um leave that organization. So it really is detrimental.

SPEAKER_03It's outside of the organization's best interest, and yet we continue to see that be a leverage mechanism in situations where there's high inflation and there's low unemployment because organizations are trying to recoup those costs to protect their shareholders. Um I think that's a wonderful opportunity for us, and we'll get into that later as HRD practitioners and scholars, where we get to start saying that doesn't have to be your only magic lever, right? There can be other levers you can use here.

SPEAKER_03But from an economic perspective, you can you can really appreciate this uh contextual pressure that organizations are under to try not to raise costs of consumer goods of their products um to retain their customers, but at the same time be able to retain and and um grow these wages uh that are being demanded by the workforce. And that's not to mention uh other things that we're seeing in terms of, as I say, demographic changes and particularly with um, you know, this really big rise in gig work or a gig economy as well.

SPEAKER_03So lots of variables are contributing to this. So there's a there's a massive economic pressure on organizations right now, and it really does call for organizational leaders to be a lot more innovative and expansive in their leverages here rather than the hysterical uh metrics or measures they may have used in the past.

SPEAKER_01I totally agree with uh Amanda in in regards to impact, especially in terms of uh you mentioned that, for example, uh mass layoffs is going to affect those workers who are staying in the job. This can be really true because uh over time, employees, when they see employers, they are willing to let them go when they are facing uh challenges. So it's uh it reduces the uh royalty. When the company is in a difficult time, if they know, for example, an employer is willing to invest in them, you know, in terms of providing training, you know, responding to their needs, they may remain loyal and uh staying uh with the company when it's the when they are facing difficult times.

SPEAKER_01And uh the opposite is true when uh employer uh employers are willing to let employers uh uh leave their work easily when they are facing the problem. And we saw that during the COVID pandemic. Many employers in the beginning in the beginning started doing mass layoffs, and uh uh and after that, when the market, you know, and the market recovered so quickly, no one could expect that. And uh when the market uh recovered, they had difficulties to bring back those individuals.

SPEAKER_01They said, no, you you have fired us, you didn't uh you put us in a difficult situation, and they decided to move to, you know, there are the other reasons, but this could be also something that we need to move to different industries, we meet we need to go to different employee uh employers. So that affects individuals' decision in terms of staying with the existing or past employers or not. But also one more thing that I like to add in terms of impact on an organization when it comes to inflation and unemployment, is it's really important to understand what causes inflation.

SPEAKER_01Inflation uh could be um could be a result of high demand. So, in the beginning, uh actually, organizations are in a good position because there is a demand for their products, and they they have incentive to expand and hire more individuals. Um the labor market didn't become tight. Uh, in that situation, we are seeing low unemployment and high inflation. As unemployment uh decreases, it's become more difficult for uh businesses to expand and hire individuals and even um do retention.

SPEAKER_01So retention also becomes a problem for them when we are facing low unemployment. And uh in terms of spending and demand, when when price goes up significantly, it also affects demand. So eventually demand decreases, and now businesses are in a difficult situation, so uh they can't keep their uh employee employees, they can hire uh new individuals and they are seeing decreasing demand for their goods and products. So that's why when a recession may start.

SPEAKER_02For me, I think we need to look on the relationship between those uh terms, if you like, or uh you know, phenomenon. So, as we all know, inflation and unemployment they have an inverse uh relationship, but at the same time, we could notice a direct relationship as well, and here comes the phenomenon of stagflation. So, respectively, I feel that the impact on the organizations follow more or less the same approach, either a direct or indirect impact.

SPEAKER_02I think the most direct uh impact uh on organization is that budgets are tightening, you know, either if we're talking about HRD uh the budgets or any other budget within uh you know the organization. Uh as everyone, you know, and I refer to people, as all people, employees, are feeling the strains you know coming from high inflation or high unemployment, then uh there is a direct, I would say, you know, impact on organization on HR, on organization on HR, because they need to shift their focus on health and well-being for their workers as well.

SPEAKER_02Uh it's also uh there is also a direct uh you know uh impact on how we recruit people, how recruit employees at current or higher salary levels, as Madeline suggested, that wages should go up because everything goes up. And uh last but not least, I would say since most people want uh to work remotely, that again has either a direct or indirect impact on HR and all other organizational practices as to how to organize work.

SPEAKER_00I wonder if that leads us then in kind of segues us nicely into looking at the implications for individual employees and if you add that up. guess into the workforce as a whole and and and parisa you were you were referencing this in your answer to to the last question so how how do you see the implications for individuals and and if you put the put them together essentially for the workforce in regards to impact on workers so it's really if we are only focusing on inflation it really depends on the movement of wages if wages increase at the same rate as the inflation and prices uh increase um increases in the prices they are not affected financially and they are able to manage through inflation but we know for example uh because of the tight budget uh employers may not be that much responsive we know for example wages grow slower than inflation basically uh they are seeing uh their real income uh decreases during these times and also in terms of uh job security it's going to affect individuals uh and their motivation productivity for those who have a job when we have low unemployment we may see some mismatches in the labor market so we we may be able to see some individuals that they don't have the requirement to be able to find an employment in normal times they are able to find a job that doesn't require the the same level of uh you know they have lower level of skills and education they are able to find employment so it is it is helpful for those individuals without job when the labor market is uh tight and we are seeing low unemployment but in times of high unemployment rate it's opposite so individuals even with a high level of education they are competing with each other it's more difficult to find employment and also uh they they don't have that much barning uh bargaining power so uh they are they are not able to negotiate wages to increase their wages uh during the when unemployment is high we we what we usually see individuals we see we see high enrollment in postsecondary education and that's the reason because they are not able to find employment so they are going to invest in themselves to be able to uh sell themselves to employers and so unemployment and inflation not only can create uncertainty for uh businesses it can also create uh uncertainty for individuals and it also affects the way that uh even the skills requirement in the labor market can be affected by inflation and unemployment we are saying so the automation for example and technological advancement are going to affect the type of skills so in in when we are seeing uh low unemployment uh employers may switch to automation in that case it affects the type of skills employers are looking for and therefore uh workers need uh to be aware of that they need to invest in the skills that are in demand interesting there one of the things that you were just talking about is the psychological impact on employees by contrast what it's like to look at LinkedIn now versus LinkedIn say three years ago my LinkedIn now is full of people who are saying hey I've just been laid off or I'm open to work and and it and it feels as if many of my contacts are uh either have either lost their jobs or alternatively are fearful that they could be in the next round of layoffs which presumably has a knock-on effect to like how they're feeling at work and how they're as you say Parisa their their productivity at work as in you know when a certain percentage of your brain cells are focused on will I have a job tomorrow there's less of your brain there's fewer of your brain cells available to focus in on on actually getting the work done.

SPEAKER_00So I mean I'm interested in like I get mandolin photos how how do you react to the thought about the psychological implications?

SPEAKER_03I think it's huge, right? So you know I studied under uh Jerry Gilly I'm you know one of uh our strategic HRD uh gyrus and you know he would always say that growth does not occur in an environment of fear. And so we can talk about mass layoffs but we can also talk about the exorbitant rates of burnout that we are seeing particularly in healthcare fields education right we're seeing mass exodus and it goes back to what Teresa was saying when individuals said you know look I don't have loyalty to you organization because you laid me off during this massive pandemic and now you want me to come back so consequently workers started looking for multiple streams of income we're seeing so much of that we're seeing solopreneurs, entrepreneurs, we're seeing a lot more freelance workers we're seeing people hold a couple of different jobs or even knitting their jobs together.

SPEAKER_03Having something like LinkedIn networking opportunities or even what we're seeing with you know phenomenal platforms on social media in other avenues people are able to start earning an income entirely differently than the traditional organizational structure than what we've seen. So that whole idea of that you know quiet quitting which I really hate that Tim but the idea that you know you can't expect people to have loyalty to you if you didn't have it to them.

SPEAKER_03And so I think the psychological factors of layoffs of burnout of the pressure of how do I pay my bills when my wages aren't keeping up to purse's point there with that inflation or something you know that's not coming at the same same rate my cost of goods have gone up but my wages haven't etc etc is also starting to see a trend in a lot of agency with the workforce to say I can craft my own career rather than rely on an organization or an institution to craft it for me.

SPEAKER_03And that's why I think we're seeing a lot more um in the training and development um more solopreneurs in that kind of realm um you know I'm speaking as a very biased consultant here so I will I will preface that I am aware of that but I really do see that people are starting to try to figure out different ways because the traditional workforce especially in the states I will say particularly in the states and Foto spoke about remote work we're seeing such high demand for that the states kind of went with that and then really dialed it back.

SPEAKER_03I just think we're going to keep seeing something different because I think the workforce is now demanding that Darren I think you're exactly right about that psychological impact and the workforce is driving that demand to change the organizational structure far more than even the economy at this point.

SPEAKER_02So for me I think either if we go ahead with the inverse relationship between inflation and unemployment or a direct you know relationship between the two to go back to the scenarios that Parisha has described earlier there are only strangles for individuals to cope with and it's not up only to them to you know to to go ahead and find solutions how as to you know increase their income uh how to spend less or to you know to to afford living the same and have the same living standards as before.

SPEAKER_00So this is where organizations the the states should step in as well and put forward probably some strategies uh to to be honest with you I feel that no matter what strategies will be put in place uh these struggles will continue uh I'm not sure if this is the outcome of the capitalistic you know approach we are all following okay but definitely definitely as I've said I think uh the financial struggles that we all face and I could even give you examples you have mentioned you know the the junior doctors here in UK uh I mean they they work like crazy and they get nothing uh we academics uh recently uh we had some you know uh strike actions uh and if I recall well we managed to get like a 3.5 increase and a one off bonus which could get us up to let's say five to six percent when inflation currently is around 11 or 12 percent so what can I say then I was struggling and I'm still struggling or you know I'm not struggling that much but still it's not easy for me for my family and for other families as well probably to say to you have a decent life sometimes okay and when it comes to the psychological just wanted to make a quick comment on the psychological impact and maybe the psychological contract you may have you know with your employer again I would put it simple it's under a constant questioning you know it's not like 10 years ago that you could go and work for a company for the rest of your life and you knew that everything will go well despite of what will happen despite the crisis events that we may encounter the world is changing people are changing struggles are changing uh and I feel and usually I'm an optimistic person but I feel that I cannot be that much optimistic you know regarding this relationship between inflation employment or unemployment HRD or organizational practices in general it's interesting I um reflecting back to like what I was talking about earlier and like contacts that I've got who've lost their positions it's been interesting to have conversations with them and one of the themes that I've found in in talking through their reactions to being let go has been um a reaction of I I now I now see work differently I now see my employer differently and up to this point I've had this I've seen my employer as my family and and I've used terms like I bleed orange because orange is the corporate color you know and that all of a sudden I've realized that I never was a member of a family um and that and they let go of me so easily and and I think that's interesting because I think it does break the psychological contract of how those people will view future employers.

SPEAKER_00So so I wonder if this is a good time to pivot and start talking a bit about the implications for HRD because I think in the first half of the episode we've um had a really interesting conversation I think about what we mean by the terms inflation and employment what we're experiencing right now in terms of inflation and employment um what that means for the organizations and how that's feeding through to individuals. So I'm wondering therefore if we start focusing in on HRD what this means for HRD practice initially so the the work that HRD does in organizations maybe where it works how it works like who's involved in that work um photios what what are your thoughts about the implications for HRD practice yeah just to to to set up some basic uh you know expectations around HRD I mean we all know that HRD is about if we focus on the D part of the term is about development that could refer to individual career development organizational development and many other things okay including training and development and so on.

SPEAKER_02So as I have mentioned at the very beginning I think there are direct and indirect impacts you know coming from inflation and unemployment that relationship and as I have mentioned before I think the most direct one is that budgets are tightening. So the HRD budget is tightening and eventually we end up as HRD professionals to offer less training and developmental opportunities and career development opportunities to our employees.

SPEAKER_02So both the HRD departments and the employees can feel the pinch if I say on their finances especially the HRD departments to secure employees development. You know they have because in most cases as I have mentioned earlier their wages might remain flat or may not meet the inflation rate with an increase.

SPEAKER_02So apparently we need to offer some support I would say to employees you know uh and provide some advice not in terms of training but in terms of you know a simple support like giving advice how they could manage those struggles that I have mentioned earlier. Even add some training opportunities around health and well-being because most of those people are developing you know health and well-being uh related uh issues because of those struggles and uh another I would say probably indirect you know uh impact of inflation uh of the relationship between inflation and unemployment is that it's harder to recruit new employees especially if we keep the current salary levels respectively for HRD uh if we recruit less and we don't have a budget to offer training to our existing ones then we might lose them we might not get their full potential in terms of their performance and so on.

SPEAKER_00And last but not least the comment again I made uh earlier about uh you know having more employees requesting to work remotely that eventually has an impact on HRD and the way we offer we deliver we design deliver and deliver you know our training initiatives so in the past most of the training initiatives were offered in-house and face to face while these days uh you could see a sharp rise of uh you know online training uh online performance evaluations everything is conducted online and we need to ensure at the same time the same standards that we could meet when we offer all these options face to face but again to my understanding we are still working towards that mandolin you you're you're doing consulting work with organizations who presumably uh struggling to walk this line at this point between wanting to offer development opportunities to retain people at the same time as probably being really tight on budgets for for HRD so what what so what are you seeing in terms of your consulting and how are you advising organizations around walking that line so that's this is so much fun i'm this is a phenomenal question on this one I'm you know I think FOTIS and I agree so much I think I might be a little bit more optimistic on where we have some some agency here um I what I would say is absolutely I think traditionally organizations would look at HRD their HRD or whatever they wanted to call it the people department all of these you know training and development um they would look at those areas and say those aren't the moneymakers let's not invest in those budgets but because we know recruitment is really not an option for many organizations these days they just simply cannot find the labor.

SPEAKER_03So they've got to retain and they've got to create versatility within their organizations. They've got to create developmental programs that may be cross-functional throughout the organization and really invest in that longevity of the employee. So we're starting to see I think you know we saw in December of this last year so December of 2022 Deloitte came out and I I feel kind of threw down the gauntlet for many of us of a 1.4 billion dollar investment in training and development.

SPEAKER_03And I think we're gonna see more organizations saying we have to develop our people now where does that make a difference for us that our practitioners in the consultancy arena we cannot be a standardized one size fits all type consultant. We have to go into true uh customized you know very customer centered person individual centered type training and development we're really having a lot of agility and versatility of how we're developing people forward which I think is so much our realm.

SPEAKER_03So that's where I get excited and get optimistic about this because I think that's our competitive advantage. I think our competitive advantage is being able to create and customize those career pathways with individuals really invest in that development to say we want you here in this organization long term. We're not gonna sit here and talk about the quiet quitting anymore. We're not gonna talk you know we know there are we we we're gonna lean into the fact that there are these psychological factors that have occurred to Fodiosa's point we're gonna talk about the health and wellbeing of our employees we're gonna reconfigure the things that really matter I talk to a lot of um Sherm individuals you know we work with a lot of those individuals and my question to all of them all the time is when was the last time you asked your employees how your benefit package actually serves your employees most everybody in the state offers like a 5% employee matching for the 401k and I said you know what if your employees would really like pet insurance?

SPEAKER_03I have dogs I'd be really excited about that. But um we're offering benefits packages for a workforce that is no longer in our workforce. We really have got ourselves into this complacency track. And so again I think this is a prime opportunity for HRD to really get in and do our best work. So I have a lot of optimism about that because I think we're badly needed. And when I go into companies I found my you know my brand of that more customized work which is highly informed by our HRD.

SPEAKER_01You know when I go up against the traditional management consultants we won't name the big names but I get the opportunity to distinguish myself with a very big competitive advantage because of HRD because of that true personalized perspective of really investing in the individual the team and organizational level um and so I I really think we're undermining um or we're we're not giving ourselves enough credit there to um say that there is badly a need the sad thing is a lot of organizations don't always know that we exist and they default to the consultants who have come in previously gave them a standardized package it didn't resonate with their employees the employees were already overworked and burned out you know we're all just spinning our wheels we've got to do it differently today this is completely a different workforce than what we've ever seen we've got to change the strategies and I think HRD practitioners are really really primed for that opportunity I totally agree in terms of uh the needs for investment in the skills and it's it's it should be something that uh you know in the past you don't you didn't need to invest in your skills and education after finishing schools.

SPEAKER_01So labor market uh could use your skills that you learn at School, and you could, you know, uh gain some experience and also to be able to finish your job. But the labor market is changing significantly, as an as an as I mentioned, it's going to affect the type of skills we need, and it changes so quickly. So individuals need to invest in their skills. At the same time, employers also, again, unemployment is uh low, so hiring is so difficult, and employers need to invest in their own workforce, they have to uh invest in their employees to be able to meet their skills needs and also to make sure that employers are productive and happy, you know, in terms of even in providing uh skills development uh um opportunities for employers, make them happy if they are not able to improve significantly their uh compensation package.

SPEAKER_01But one thing that I like to mention, for example, when inflation is high, we are seeing tightening budget. So tightening budget means the uh investment and the um human resource development might be affected in terms of providing training. At the same time, if you are seeing low unemployment rate, it means that retention has become difficult, hiring has become difficult, individuals are able to find better jobs.

SPEAKER_01So those individuals, for example, last year we we've seen some employers, they didn't require the specific education certification to hire individuals. They just ask for a label. It doesn't matter what is your education, we just need you, we are going to train you and make you able to do the job. When employers are going to do that, it means that they have to provide a budget, they have to invest uh invest uh in um skills development and to be able to make sure that employers are able to do the job and to be productive, and then they they want that.

SPEAKER_01So, what to do when we have we are facing uh tight budget, but we are facing uh employers that need uh uh some human capital investment and they need to improve their skills. We have to think about, you know, we have to think about uh innovative ways, creative ways, as uh uh Mandal mentioned that so thinking about informal and formal uh skills development and uh human resource development. So there are two ways employers can think about that.

SPEAKER_01Sometimes they have to invest and they have to pay for tuition, you know, courses, programs. Sometimes they have they are able to do it internally using an experienced workers to be able to work with new hires and train them. And also there is a role for government. When the labor market is not able uh in the labor market, there are challenges uh faced by uh employers, and even sometimes when we are facing high employment uh unemployment, uh challenges faced by uh uh workers and individuals looking for jobs.

SPEAKER_01There is a role for government. So this is really important that government supports businesses to be able to continue because at the end, we want a healthy economy, we want uh businesses to grow and to be able to produce um goods and services and provide services. So at the end, we need sometimes, especially, for example, during these difficult times, uh, if uh there is a pressure on uh all individuals, so government can play important roles to through a labor market policy, you know, education and skills development policy, supporting uh workers to be able to invest in their workforce.

SPEAKER_01So uh it's really important to make sure that all parties work together, they understand the challenges, and they are helping each other to address the issue.

SPEAKER_00One of the things I find particularly interesting in listening to the answers you each gave to that question is it makes me feel as if it places HRD practitioners maybe in a place they haven't quite been before. I think it feels like there's potential for them to uh add value, um, and there's potential for them to leverage policies, and there's potential for them to influence decisions being taken within organizations, but they're not quite the sort of role that HRD practitioners potentially were having until recently.

SPEAKER_00Um and so where that leaves me, I guess, is wondering what we can be doing to prepare people to have that role as an HRD practitioner in an organization. Because my guess is most of the education that happens for HID practitioners probably isn't directed towards the sort of conversations that we've been having for the last 45 minutes. So, so so Mandelin, given like your position in terms of being in a business school, when you take a look at education, what what do you see as being the implications for how we do prepare people?

SPEAKER_03So, you know, it's very interesting to me because I I had a corporate career, I non-linear corporate career before I came into academia, and then I went into academic administration, um, and then consultancy. And so I've I've always kind of felt like a really big hybrid, but um I am the daughter of a master stonemason, I'm an entrepreneur, and so I train iron workers, union iron workers, and here in the States, one of the things I wanted to bring up is you know, in addition to this gig economy, we're also seeing a rise in unionization here in the States as well.

SPEAKER_03What we're really seeing is this kind of demand from people that the American dream didn't quite look the way that they thought it was going to look for their parents. So we're seeing more um younger uh generations wanting to craft a different pathway for themselves. Traditional education is not really what there is, it's not resonating the way that it used to. One of the things that we've kind of done in education is really standardized education to such a degree, um, at least here in the states, that um, you know, we're at some challenges there.

SPEAKER_03Not to mention again the high rates of mass exodus of academicians in um at least in the states, but I think we're seeing that globally too. So, how does that start to impact? Again, just like we have to think about it in organizations, higher education has to really be thinking about it. Because you know, we have a demographic shift coming up where we know that you know, in the 2008 global recession, people were not having as many children. We're about to see that big impact come in of about 15% decline in traditional first-time freshmen in 2025.

SPEAKER_03So, when we see that, one of the worst things that's sad to me is that I don't hear organizations talking about that, which is super going to impact them when you think about not only those individuals who hire uh those organizations who hire those individuals, but also the ones who um are marketing to that group. So traditional education is going to have to change. Uh, I think we're gonna see a lot more generalist type approaches. And we've always had in HRD this blended realm of are we kind of HR management?

SPEAKER_03No, we don't know a lot about employment law, do we? Are we a little bit Io psychology? No, no, no, not quite there. We're we've been this very fluid um area. And you know, our our home coming out of um ASTD, I think we're gonna start to see more of that. Unions have done a phenomenal job, at least here in the States, of having different training structures than traditional educational platforms for their for their workers.

SPEAKER_03And so seeing union members as they go through their apprenticeships and into uh their advanced career stages, I think we're going to keep seeing that um trend rise, rise, rise. And I think higher education and HRD scholars are going to have to be thinking about where do we meet them, where they're at there. If an if we have a small labor market coming in that are those traditional 18-year-olds, they don't want to pay for a college.

SPEAKER_03So, you know, they want to go into the career labor force because exactly as Therese is saying, organizations are now kind of enticing them with you know, get training on the job kind of start, then organize uh higher education needs to start recognizing that and accepting those training credentials. We, you know, higher education, we're not the only individuals who get to educate folks. So we have to think about how we're we again to Teresa's point, where is that integration? Where are we meeting that?

SPEAKER_03So, as HRD individuals, how do we prepare somebody? It's not a linear pathway, it's just simply not. Um, you know, we we've talked about the three-legged stool in in HRD, we talked about all of these other kinds of things of what we are, and you know, I think many of us would agree that in HRD, we've always had a little bit of an identity crisis of what we are. So I think in this realm, that's actually an asset for us. We don't really fit into a box, and I think that's what we want HRD to be in the new world of work.

SPEAKER_03We don't want to fit in a box because that new world of work does not fit in a box. So we really have to think about how we're having versatility. I think that's going to be the most valuable asset, and a really robust perspective. So having conversations like this, where you've got individuals with really diverse backgrounds, really great different perspectives, being able to attack this with a really robust lens is what I think is going to be the biggest asset to HRD in the future.

SPEAKER_02I'm totally echoing, you know, what Mandalin just suggested. And I will put now my optimistic hat uh to take that role you took that earlier, okay. But I think that both uh the Academy and the University Forum of Human Resource Development bodies are working towards all the points that you have made earlier, and this is something you know uh promising. Uh, if I need to discuss this question for UK, probably I would say that definitely there are some uh governmental initiatives offered uh focusing on upskilling you know existing workforce and future workforce uh you know skills.

SPEAKER_02And some of them, though, I would say that are out of date, some others are constantly updated. So definitely a change is needed in all of them. Now, when it comes to uh educational institutions, universities, colleges, you know, and any other educational bodies, of course, uh we need to see them as equal partners in preparing you know students and future HRD or HR uh practitioners uh to have the right skills and knowledge uh to perform their job, to put it simple.

SPEAKER_02Now, in UK, for instance, uh the provision of the HRD programs varies according to the mode of delivery and the provider as well. Uh, to give you an example, for instance, we have the uh a professional body, uh CIPD, Chartered Institute of Personal Development, which is one of the main HRD educational uh providers, offering a wide range uh you know of programs and short workshops and you know uh skills development uh seminars and so on, and they do offer a certificate or a diploma.

SPEAKER_02Uh and equally there are universities, educational institutions that offer similar programs, uh, but I feel that especially in relation to HRD, and um colleagues could correct me after listening to that uh podcast, but there are less than five, I think, in total, five in total UK universities that they do offer a dedicated, if you like, HRD master degree, for instance, or even an undergrad.

SPEAKER_02So, how can we talk about you know uplifting you know HRD awareness to put it in that way, when we don't offer you know programs to support this, alongside with all these points that Madeleine, of course, uh has made.

SPEAKER_00There is a topic that I'd love to close with, which is I'd be uh really interested in your perspective on what you see as the implications for research. Because I think one of the things that's come through for me in listening to the conversation is there's a lot of unknowns in this space. Um that this really doesn't appear to have been uh the center of attention for much research, particularly in HRD over the last few decades.

SPEAKER_00Then there really isn't much uh there really are haven't been many research articles that have explored the implications between of inflation, unemployment, and HRD. Um so given your role uh from a policy perspective and a research perspective, what would you what would your recommendations be on how we close that gap over the next few years?

SPEAKER_01When it comes to research, why it is important to do the research because uh unemployment and inflation can have uh can shape uh human resource development and they can have create challenges and also opportunities for employers, individuals, and also sometimes uh they may uh you know, to be able to deal and navigate uh it requires some policy responses from even governments. So to be able to understand uh the causes, even the causes of employment, unemployment, uh, and inflation, uh, it's really important in terms of the response you are going to uh have.

SPEAKER_01So, what drives inflation, what drives unemployment, is going to affect the strategy employers are going to use. So it's really important to conduct the research to identify all the contributing factors and also in terms of the impacts on organization and individuals and the strategies. Sometimes you have to come up with new strategies. Sometimes traditional strategies are not going to work. So to be able to address the issues and to be able to support individuals and organization, we do we do need research.

SPEAKER_01And it really depends, you know, and also at the same time, the labor market is changing, economy is changing. We have globalization, we have uh technological advancements. These factors are going to affect the way that uh uh workers and employers are interacting with each other, and also in terms of skills development, that's a key part. You know, we are hearing that the skills are becoming more and more important in the labor market, and it's not only sometimes technical skills, we are hearing about um softest skills.

SPEAKER_01So, how to be able to manage that? I'm hearing employers are saying sometimes we do have young individuals with technical skills, but they lack soft skills, they are not able even to write a formal email, a business email. How to how to address that? How to provide training for those individuals, the new hires, young individuals finding their first job to be able to support them.

SPEAKER_00That sounds like a tremendous call to action, actually. And so my hope is that folks listening to the episode uh hear that and um and uh pause and reflect a little as to what that means for their own research agenda going forward. And and hopefully there's some folks listening who are contemplating what their dissertation topic could be. Um and it sounds like there's uh there was at least 10 to 15 possible dissertation topics, I think, in that answer.

SPEAKER_00So if we can just get a bit more attention on this within the research community, I think it would be great to see some of that feeding through into conferences and journal articles over the next over the next few years. Well, unfortunately, we've run out of time for today's conversation. I I feel like we could probably carry on for a lot longer, which which may suggest we need a follow-up episode at some point. But I wanted to say a massive thank you to Fotios, Mandalin, and Parisa for such an interesting discussion and for giving us all so much to think about and then to act upon.

SPEAKER_00So thank you all so much indeed.

SPEAKER_01Thank you, everyone.

SPEAKER_02Thanks, Darren, thanks, Madeline, thanks, Parisa. It was nice talking to you.

SPEAKER_03Thank you.

SPEAKER_00Thank you so much for joining me for this episode. It was wonderful spending time with Fotios Mitsakis, Mandalin Mull and Parisa Marbubi. If you enjoyed this episode, check out all of our others. There were 33 episodes in the first three seasons, and we're releasing a further 11 here in the fourth. Between them, they provide access to conversations with over 100 leading scholars from around the world. New episodes release weekly. To learn more about the series, check out HRDmasterclass.com.

SPEAKER_00And to learn about the Academy of Human Resource Development, check out ahrd.org. I'm looking forward to being with you in our next episode when we're exploring the relationship between HRD and remote working. With the help of Dr. David McGuire of Edinburgh Napier University, Dr. Jessica Lee of the University of Illinois, and Lal Ferrar of GitLab. Until then, this is Darren Short signing off from the HRD Masterclass.com.

Open the transcript file

Hosts and Guests

Nobody is credited on this episode yet.

Credit the people on this episode

Be the first to rate this episode

More episodes

All episodes
  1. Gendered pathways to work-family balance

    Nov 17, 202634 minAudio

    This fourth episode of Season 6 brings together Dr. Sanghamitra Chaudhuri (Temple University) and Dr. Kyung Nam Kim (Texas A&M University) for a conversation about the 2026 article Gendered Pathways to Work-Family...

    Credit the people on this episode

  2. Navigating careers in non-traditional work

    Nov 10, 202636 minAudio

    This third episode of Season 6 brings together Dr. Yuanlu Niu (University of Arkansas) and Dr. Jos Akkermans (Vrije Universiteit Amsterdam) for a conversation about the 2026 article Navigating careers in non-traditional...

    Credit the people on this episode

  3. Silence in the workplace: What do we know from research?

    Nov 2, 202634 minAudio

    This second episode of Season 6 brings together Dr. Matthew Hurtienne (University of Texas at Tyler) and Dr. Heesun Kim (Francis Marion University) for a conversation about the 2024 article Silence in the workplace:...

    Credit the people on this episode

  4. Diversified mentoring: Living at the intersections of race and gender

    Oct 27, 202634 minAudio

    This first episode of Season 6 brings together Dr. Joshua Collins (University of Minnesota) and Dr. Ague Mae Manongsong (Louisiana State University) for a conversation about the 2023 article “Manongsong, A. M., & Ghosh,...

    Credit the people on this episode

  5. Season 6 Trailer

    Oct 12, 20262 minAudio

    Welcome to the trailer for Season 6 of Human Resource Development Masterclass - the podcast series from the Academy of Human Resource Development, the organization that leads HRD through research. The sixth season...

    Credit the people on this episode