In this first episode of Season 3, guests Dr. Marilyn Y. Byrd (University of Oklahoma), Dr. Chaunda L. Scott (Oakland University), and Dr. Terrence E. Maltbia (Columbia University) discuss the relationship between HRD and Antiracism, including: What is meant by the term Antiracism? What is the connection between Antiracism and the concepts of work and the workplace? What are the systems, policies and practices that tend to perpetuate racism within organizations, and what’s the role of HRD to challenge and amend those? What is the relationship between Antiracism and HRD, and how does research, theory and practice in one influence research, theory and practice in the other? How does Antiracism help HRD to understand and work on current and future challenges in organizations? What measures can HRD professionals use to assess an organization’s current state on addressing racism and progress it’s making? Where should HRD practitioners go for guidance on how to do their Antiracism work? What role does education play in positioning HRD to have a strategic role in working on Antiracism initiatives? and much more. For full details on the HRD Masterclass series, visit hrdmasterclass.com, for the bios of the guest scholars visit allbypodcast.com/antiracism. For more information on the Academy of Human Resource Development, visit ahrd.org - by being a member of AHRD, you can access bonus materials from podcast episodes. This episode is sponsored by The Columbia University Coaching Center of Excellence at Teachers College - find out about them by visiting their website at https://www.tc.columbia.edu/coachingcertification/.
Audio and video play straight from the show's own hosting. PodSubs stores and serves no media.
Transcript
From the show. Tap a time to play from there.
SPEAKER_02I go back to the paradigms of human research development, the foundation, economic theory, systems theory, and psychology. There was no room for conversation about racism.
SPEAKER_01Welcome to Human Resource Development Masterclass, the podcast series from the Academy of Human Resource Development, the organization that leads HRD through research. I'm your host, Darren Short, and here in our third season, we're exploring the relationship between HRD and other topics and disciplines, with the help of leading authors, researchers, and scholars. Today our focus is the relationship between HRD and anti-racism, and my guest scholars are Marilyn Byrd of the University of Oklahoma, Terence Multbier of Teachers College, Columbia University, and Sean DeScott of Oakland University, all of whom join me for conversations recorded during May of 2022.
SPEAKER_01Our episode today is structured into two halves. In the first 30 minutes we look at what we mean by the term anti-racism and take a high-level look at its relationship to HRD. And then in the second 30 minutes we dig deeper into that relationship. You can find out all about the questions explored in the episode, the three guest scholars, and also the episode sponsor by visiting allbypodcast.com forward slash anti-racism.
SPEAKER_01Talking of sponsors, Human Resource Development Masterclass is only made possible thanks to the wonderful support of our sponsors who cover all of the costs associated with the series and so enable us to release them free of charge to listeners like you. I encourage you to show your thanks by checking them out and letting them know just how much their sponsorship support means to you. Today's episode is sponsored by the Columbia University Coaching Centre of Excellence at Teachers College.
SPEAKER_01Their one-year Columbia Coaching Certification Program is a graduate-level credential designed for mid-career professionals committed to evidence-based practice. 3CP takes a multidisciplinary approach that draws on theory and research in adult learning, adult development, psychology, neuroscience, and change leadership. The program is the result of a partnership between the Executive Education Unit of the Columbia Business School and the Department of Organization and Leadership at Teachers College.
SPEAKER_01They invite you to visit their website to learn more at tc.columbia.edu forward slash coaching certification. Right, let's dive into the episode. So welcome to our episode on HRD and anti-racism. Let's start by meeting today's three guest scholars. First of all, I'd like to welcome Marilyn Byrd, who's Associate Professor in the Department of Human Relations at the University of Oklahoma. Marilyn is a recognized social justice scholar and educator and a subject matter expert whose research focuses on theorizing the leadership experiences of Black American women.
SPEAKER_01Welcome Marilyn.
SPEAKER_02Thank you, Darren, for the opportunity.
SPEAKER_01My second guest for the episode is Terence Mulpier, Associate Professor of Practice in the Department of Organization and Leadership at Teachers College, Columbia. Prior to joining Columbia, Terry had 20 years of diverse experience as an external and internal organizational effectiveness consultant, thought leader, and educator. He's won multiple awards for his work on coaching and was also the Academy of Human Resource Development dissertation of the year award winner for his pioneering diversity practitioner research.
SPEAKER_01Welcome, Terrence.
SPEAKER_00Thank you. It's a pleasure to be here and looking forward to the conversation.
SPEAKER_01And my third guest for the episode is Shonda Scott, Professor of Human Resource Development in the Department of Organizational Leadership at Oakland University in Rochester, Michigan. Shonda's scholarly teaching, research, and service activities are focused in the areas of human resource development, workforce diversity policies and practices, social justice education, post-apartheid diversity education, and eradicating racism. Welcome, Shonda.
SPEAKER_03Thank you, Jair. Glad to be here.
SPEAKER_01So I'd like to start off our conversation by exploring the term anti-racism so that listeners are clear on that, ready for when we dig deeper into discussing the relationship between anti-racism and HRD. So perhaps you'd each be willing to share your definition or understanding of that term.
SPEAKER_03Well, I would say uh looking at anti-racism would be a strategy that speaks out against being a racist or a racism. So basically, it's about gathering policies and you know practices that are against racist attacks. Kendi, who is a leading scholar uh at the University of Boston in the area of anti-racism, speaks clearly about that. It's it's a powerful tool to where you can speak up and out freely against it.
SPEAKER_03You're willing to confront it.
SPEAKER_02And Shonda, adding to what you have explained about anti-racism, I believe that anti-racism speaks to group experiences as well, because now different groups are uh embracing the term from their own cultural or racial experiences. So for me, anti-racism speaks from the Black experience. Um, so naturally I would I would take my own experience as a black person when I'm when I'm conceptualizing anti-racism.
SPEAKER_02So when I think about anti-racism, I think about eradicating racism as it has affected black people. Other groups have had their own experiences of racism. Mine would be the black experience, which would be building policies that speak to the uh black experience.
SPEAKER_00I think to understand anti-racism, even though it's not the opposite of racism per se, I think we have to look at it as individuals and systems. So I think anti-racism also means anti-racist, which is the individual work around eliminating that work, and anti-racism, which gets to the to the system. So I think that's important. And to even understand any of those ideas, I think we have to get to the root of racism or racist, which is race, and to know that that's a categorization system.
SPEAKER_00And so for some it's black, for some it's other. But I think the notion of race may not be transferable around the world. Everyone doesn't look at it the same way. But we can look at all societies and know that color matters. However, you want whatever label you want to give that, we see a hierarchy and different ranges of privilege based on color, even in relatively quote, homogeneous societies. It's about uh the work, whether it's at individuals, race, anti-race is really eliminating those behaviors in themselves, and racism is attacking the very systems that perpetuate and make that those types of behaviors acceptable in organizations, in society, and in the world.
SPEAKER_01So ultimately, I'd like to explore with you the relationship between anti-racism and HRD. But I'm thinking that perhaps a half-step to that is to first consider the relationship between anti-racism and the concepts of workplace diversity and workforce diversity. So, how do you view that relationship, the relationship between anti-racism, workplace diversity, and workforce diversity?
SPEAKER_03I would say, you know, looking at trying to define the terms workplace and workforce first, I think the workforce really encompasses the people. And the workplace is more or less the environment. And so when you're connecting that to anti-racist or anti-racism, we have to start with the environment, looking at the culture of the environment. Many times, you know, organizations today, you know, they're supporting diversity and now more anti-racist work, but they really haven't really engaged in the work before.
SPEAKER_03So therefore, the current policies and practices are still there. Those, you know, racist policies and strategies were there. I mean, technically, you know, organizations within the US were really not structured to be diverse and to include diverse groups of people. But now that we have expanded into that, you know, there's still challenges of racism, you know, people not being treated fairly, people not getting promoted, people not getting hired.
SPEAKER_03And so, you know, it's a problem with the culture. Just because you have a workforce that's diverse, it doesn't make it free of racism. It just means that you have a workforce that's diverse. So I think looking at the two of those, I think it really is a problem with the workplace, with the environment. I think organizations need to look at, you know, when they're opening their doors to more diversity, they need to ask questions what type of diversity are they looking for?
SPEAKER_03Is our company ready to receive the diversity that it's looking for? So, you know, I think those things need to start first because people will come and get hired within the organization, but you just work there. You're not really a major equal partner or equal employee. It's just that you you represent the diversity more than what your skills and abilities lead to.
SPEAKER_00Darren, you mentioned in your your introduction to me that I had done my dissertation work on diversity, which I did looking at diversity practitioners. And back then, which was 2001, we were talking about diversity and workplace diversity. Nowadays, there's a a series of labels: diversity, inclusion, equity, belonging, and they're generally there's some combination of those four words. And so I think really distinguishing, going beyond the workplace and the workforce. So, Shonda, I love that distinction.
SPEAKER_00It kind of builds on if this is all ultimately about behavior, building on Lewin's work around the person and the environment, you captured it really well in making that distinction between the workforce and the workplace person and the environment they find themselves in. You know, so I think we have to be clear about, you know, diversity is really descriptive. It's really looking at categories, um, whether it's inborn kinds of things like race, gender, ethnicity, age, and so on, uh, whether it's experience-based uh experiences that we have, um, education, location, all those kinds of things, or in an organizational context, organizational dimension.
SPEAKER_00So diversity is really a descriptive concept. Inclusion is a behavioral concept, that is what we do with the diversity in that workplace, in that environment. I think equity and belonging are two outcomes. And equity is really, I think, about not treating people, quote, the same, which I think a lot of people confuse equality with equity. Equity is really about do people have the resources and access that they need to do their best work.
SPEAKER_00Equity is really outcome-oriented, and belonging is hard data. You can link hard data to that. And I think belonging is really about climate. What does it feel if you're the other to be in this environment? I think Shonda, you were touching upon that, that the house, the organizational house may not have been built for me.
SPEAKER_02Thank you, both uh Shonda and Terry. And I'm gonna play devil's advocate just a little bit because uh, you know, workforce diversity and and workplace diversity, I think that those are terms that when we think about it from the business world, you know, we think about it's more representation. And actually, uh Terence Sparkman and I have an article that's in um HRDR, and it's looking at the uh dichotomy between uh the social side of diversity and the business side for diversity.
SPEAKER_02And the business side still looks at representation. You know, we we want to have a diverse workforce, we want to have all these representations, but I believe that that there's that there needs to be some common ground between the business side and the social side. We need to integrate both perspectives so that, yes, I know businesses do want to build on their diversity to make their bottom line, but also at the same time, businesses should not forget that people that come into a workforce that are different, they're gonna have some experiences where they may not feel included, they may not feel like they are respected.
SPEAKER_00And I think that's been part of the evolution. And you you can even say that there's a developmental nature to this work. And early on, diversity is often, that's why I said the descriptive nature, it is often about representation and counting, but that's not enough. And I think that's why we were only talking about diversity in the late 90s and early 2000s, and then inclusion begin to try to get into uh some of the way people that sort of social dimension that I think you're talking about. Are organizations there and are they great at integrating those two concepts?
SPEAKER_00Maybe not. But I'm not even sure that those two are enough. Because what I'm really after when I start getting at equity is not only counting or feelings, I'm really getting at outcomes. You know, are do we do we actually see equity? Do we are do people have not only can we count them, but do we see people having the access that they need, do resources? Because I think when you really begin to do this work, you got to bring in elements of power. We have to think about the reality of rank, uh, the reality of status, the reality of privilege.
SPEAKER_00And so I think all of those things begin to bring in that you must do more than think about diversity. Diversity is the starting point. Or eliminating racist behavior is about power at the end of the day.
SPEAKER_02I feel like the social justice, Terry, is as you say, the outcomes. I see the outcomes as being a more equitable in terms of social, social justice, which is the idealized state, having the discussions about social injustices, racism. You know, we don't have we don't have those types of conversations a lot in in, you know, in in in organizational meetings and those sorts of things. So so that I I guess is it's what I'm saying is I'm looking at social justice as being the outcome.
SPEAKER_03Well, I do uh agree with um Marilyn. I think in our textbook that we created, workforce diversity, current and emerging trends, and again, we really you know talk about the history of diversity and then go into the different cultures that are working within organizations. And then Marilyn's last chapter focuses on where is this leading to? So if we're having all these issues with disabilities in the workplace, uh race in the workplace, uh gender in the workplace, uh, intergenerational challenges in the workplace, then what is the end result?
SPEAKER_03And so I do agree with Marilyn that you know, we do need to have an outcome. We need to have some measurable outcomes, and uh, we do need to have an end result because it can be very uh challenging mentally.
SPEAKER_02You know, we need to reconceptualize diversity and look at the outcomes. We're trying to get to social justice, equal respect, equal dignity, power versus marginalization. We try to bring that into more of a equal balance. You know, we know people are marginalized because of their diversity of their diverse location. And we know power and privilege are are dominant in organizations, but we say, can we have some kind of equalization of how marginalized?
SPEAKER_02We know people are marginalized, but can we, you know, bring some kind of uh common ground to power and privilege and marginalization? So yeah, we we look at outcomes and we see that as being uh a social justice perspective.
SPEAKER_00I also think the focus on uh social justice or anti-racism or equity, those outcomes without dealing with the other end of the spectrum explicitly uh can also be risky. Meaning, if social justice is the outcome, you have to go directly and hard on after injustice. Uh, if you're gonna talk about anti-racism, I think you have to go hard on and recognize that you wouldn't need anti-racism if there weren't racism.
SPEAKER_00I'm not talking about a dualism. I'm not talking about injustice versus social action. I am saying to get after and achieve any measure of progress towards social justice, you must go after the other end of the continuum. And I think we'll talk about that more when we get into interventions and what will HRD professionals and researchers and practitioners do to help organizations move the needle.
SPEAKER_01So I think that leads us nicely then into exploring the connection between anti-racism and an HRD. So I'm wondering how does the research theory and practice in one influence the research theory and practice in the other when we look at that connection between anti-racism and HRD?
SPEAKER_02I go back to the to the paradigms of human research development, the foundations, economic theory, systems theory, and psychology were the three theoretical foundations. There was no room, no comfort no room for conversations about racism. It was about learning and performance within those three theoretical foundations. Those were it. Whether we have discussions about racism, that was that was the dilemma I had.
SPEAKER_02If I'm building a dissertation or even a study, a research, how do I bring in based on the theories that HRD is supposed to be grounded on? Whether I talk about racism, how do how do these theories support discussions of racism? They do not. I believe that before we can have discussions about anti-racism and uh the human resource development field, we have to have conversations about how the field has looked at racism.
SPEAKER_02And recently there was a um a special issue on developing black males and these special guest editors looked at how uh the field actually represented black people, and I'm using uh Black, uh the Black experience here, or they found very little research that had even looked at racism. So that says a couple of things. Uh either uh people who are researching this phenomenon um have not been targeting our journals, or they have been targeting our journals, and the gatekeepers have kept them out, you know, that that topic out.
SPEAKER_02From my own experience several years ago, uh a group and uh a group of scholars and myself, we submitted uh work to a journal that that talked about we actually used diversity management, was what um what we used as the topic. But of course, we were getting into some uh discussions of racism. It was rejected. Uh we were told that you know these are interesting little stories, but it was given to us in a way that we knew that it was not going to be accepted.
SPEAKER_02So in in terms of how uh you know uh HRD has looked at um racism as a topic in terms of research theory and practice, if that has not been strongly addressed, then how could we have a strong foundation for addressing anti racism? Work. So there's been very limited, um, very limited resources that informs our practice of anti-racism.
SPEAKER_03Well, I too um see that, you know, the the field of HRD, you know, has not really embraced, if you will, you know, really topics of race, nor racism. It really hasn't been a featured topic. And um, as right now, since there, since the George Floyd murder in Minneapolis, you know, there's just been an explosion of, you know, corporations, universities, and the like, you know, talking about racism and anti-racist work, which I really feel in a way startled by because a lot of these people have sat quietly and they not, and they have not even said anything about it when things are happening, you know, broadly on TV.
SPEAKER_03Now that this has become a national, if you will, or an international movement, you know, people are out there toting the band uh about being an anti-racist. And I'm not really sure that they understand, you know, what that is and you know, what that means to people who have actually experienced racism. So, you know, I just, you know, really think that there needs to be more education around that in HRD.
SPEAKER_03I think that would be a great way for them to start. Because right now we have a lot of people that are leading anti-racist work and it's new to them. I mean, we have a lot of people going around saying, I'm doing DEI work. No, to me, you're just saying you're doing DEI work because you have to have a basic understanding of what you're doing. And so people tend to look at diversity and anti-racist work is that anybody can just jump in at any time without having the lack of preparation for that.
SPEAKER_00Shonda, I'll build on your comment since you brought up our experiences. I I think our experiences and even studying diversity in the academy, and you know, I'll I'll sort of name my employer and Alamar as part of this conversation, which may not be uh I may not be popular when people start listening to this podcast. But, you know, in all seriousness, when I actually proposed the idea uh of studying diversity practitioners, interestingly enough, there were a few people in cohorts prior to me who actually reached out to me and said, Oh, um, you're not going to be able to get that done through Teachers College because several proposals have been rejected.
SPEAKER_00Now, see, I I think that's really interesting. And I think, Marilyn, it gets to your point about talking about race and racism triggers the anxious brain. It's very difficult for people to even really have that conversation. And I think the statement that I just made is really interesting. Of all places, Teachers College, which has an espoused view and legacy around social justice and social action. And yet, uh, prior to my finally getting a proposal approved, there have been several proposals on the topic of diversity that went nowhere at the college.
SPEAKER_00So there are, and Marilyn, I think that gets to your comments about are our journals are people being attracted to our journals or are gatekeepers uh keeping it out? And I I think Sean and I both have a lived experience. We were both able to get through it, but I would argue that the work of the people before me actually softened and made the way for it finally being able to get through by the time I got there. So, Marilyn, I just think your comments about the status of race being explicitly addressed in HRD is an important observation that we should hold on to.
SPEAKER_00And it makes that point that you, you know, anti-racism is racism is an ideal if you don't deal with racism. And frankly, I think it's easier to talk about the ideal than the reality.
SPEAKER_03Right. And then just to add briefly, I think with the current state, you know, looking at the academy of you know them embracing the anti-racist committee and the work that we're doing, would not have been um come forward if I hadn't challenged their uh Black Lives Matter statement. Because all, you know, all of a sudden they had a Black Lives Matter statement. Oh, we support this, but then again, when and where?
SPEAKER_03So I challenge the the Academy on that, and you know, got some understanding and some apologies and whatnot to where I really think that now they're really serious in moving in in that direction, and I'm happy to see that.
SPEAKER_02But but to be honest with you, who is gonna take the reign for that uh or take charge? It's people who are having the experience. You know, other people can can can see and hear about what's happened to us, but but I think it's it's people who have actually had the lived experience as we talk about, that are gonna be the ones that are gonna be at the forefront, that are gonna try to make change happen. We're gonna be the agents of change, or we're gonna try to be.
SPEAKER_02I think it sometimes is going to be the responsibility of people like us who are, you know, and in like Shundas in my book, we have a model that we are developing right now. It's in a conceptual development stage. Our next step is to take it to more of a to move it into more of a research phase where we can, you know, collect data on it. And that that idea is going to advance the idea of anti-racism work being uh grounded in education.
SPEAKER_02Uh the other place that we feel like is very strongly needed is education in the classroom. You know, we're we're we are we're educating um uh future practitioners, future leaders. So that is where we need to begin the anti-racism work.
SPEAKER_01So we've talked now then about the relationship between anti-racism and and work and the workplace, and we've started to dig into the connection between anti-racism and HRD. So I wonder if it helps us to put it in the context of the challenges that are happening within organizations and specifically the challenges facing HRD in organizations over the next few years. And and how does anti-racism help HRD in understanding those challenges and then and then working on them?
SPEAKER_00So if I think about HRD challenges that are facing organizations, one of the things I think that's has to be embedded in a more uh broader context to say what are organizational leaders, whether that's corporate, nonprofits, government, you know, what are the kinds of what are the challenges they're facing? Because after all, part of our work is to really help them learn, grow, and perform. So I think from an external perspective, no surprise, uh COVID-19 disruptions, raising uh inflation rates, labor shortages, including uh various dimensions of diversity, you know, supply chain disruptions, changes in consumer behavior.
SPEAKER_00So that you know, leaders today are faced with amplified challenges, uh, many of which were triggered by COVID-19, and a lot of the social action and uh and dissatisfaction that was really triggered by all those events. You know, there's a series of internal factors that leaders are faced with, and these are reported by many sources around attracting and retaining talent in the context of an increasingly diverse workforce, which may not feel included or that they're getting access to treatments and so on, fair treatment, um, we do see because of COVID-19 an acceleration of what was already going on in terms of digital transformation.
SPEAKER_00We are transforming from, we are forced to transform from in-person to virtual now to hybrid to high flex. And so, you know, in terms of the relevance to anti-racism work, several sources have identified racism, i.e. institutional bias, racist protests, violence, race, ethnicity, representation as a top social change issue that employees expect their organizations to address. So I think that leads to some questions.
SPEAKER_00I don't have any answers, but it leads to a lot of questions about if the organizations that we are uh supposedly supporting are dealing with those external and internal challenges that then translate to HRD challenges, right? Um and uh employees are increasingly expecting organizations to deal with these social change issues around race. You know, there's been some interesting research that's emerged outside of HRD that really talks about how different identity groups responded to uh working remotely.
SPEAKER_00And interestingly enough, uh in one study, um, other group that actually felt more comfortable working remotely than in person were black males compared to any other identity group. And so it begins to raise the question: what is it about working remotely and via technology that may feel more inclusive or less exclusive than in-person environments? So I think you know, the pandemic and you know, a lot of the social unrest that happened during those times are at least triggering conversations uh that I was not hearing in the 20 years that I was in corporate America.
SPEAKER_01We'll be back in a moment with more from Shawna, Marilyn, and Terence as we dig deeper into the relationship between HRD and anti-racism. First though, here's an important reminder that this episode is brought to you thanks to the wonderful sponsorship support of the Columbia University Coaching Centre of Excellence. In addition to their flagship coaching program, the Columbia University Coaching Center of Excellence conducts applied coaching research, including a current project focused on the role of race in executive coaching.
SPEAKER_01The centre also enjoys a global learning community of nearly 800 credential coaches from over 50 countries around the world and offers custom talent development solutions to organizations such as Equitable Advisors, JP Morgan Chase, and S ⁇ P Global, to name a few. Right, let's return to our discussion for the second half of the episode. Welcome back to our episode on HRD and anti-racism, where I'm joined by Marilyn Byrd of the University of Oklahoma, by Terence Moltbier of Teachers College Columbia, by Sean DeScott of Oakland University.
SPEAKER_01Okay, to kick off this next section of the episode, I'd like to return back to something that you were talking about a little earlier, which was about how little HRD research has been done on racism and anti-racism? In light of this, it's got me wondering where HRD practitioners should go for guidance on how to do their anti-racism work within organizations.
SPEAKER_02To answer your question, I'm going to pose a counter question. Are HRD practitioners doing anti-racism work? So the community of HRD in general has not addressed racism. Under the banner of HRD, is are people even talking about racism? Probably it's going to be within the training and development leg of HRD.
SPEAKER_02So that's the trainers. But are the trainers actually talking about racism? I don't know. I cannot speak for the, you know, I cannot speak for all industries, all professions, whatever. But who's training the trainers to speak about racism? Some may believe that racism and therefore anti-racism is being addressed under the umbrella of diversity, but it is not, because diversity has become a generic term, and usually it is used in terms of representation.
SPEAKER_02So in organizations, it's usually those people who have been victimized or harmed that are leading anti-racism work. And I really do not believe that there is a cookie-cutter approach to doing this work. So when you say, you know, where do HRD practitioners, where does anybody go for guidance on how to do, you know, to do to do their work within anti-racism work within organizations. This is a highly contextualized discussion.
SPEAKER_02What usually stimulates action and guidance on racism are events. So how one organization handles anti-racism may not look the same in another. And I truly firmly believe that this work requires committed action. You know, anti-racism work is usually reactive rather than proactive. Unfortunately, that's just the way it is. And it's a well-worn statement that action begins at the top.
SPEAKER_02The language of racism, not diversity, the language of racism needs to be present. Racism needs to be called out in organizations' missions, visions, and all those concerns if an organization is truly committed to being anti-racist. So there's a lot of you know variables that that's um that we have to address in order to say who do we go to to guide us on anti-racism work?
SPEAKER_03Well, I agree with uh what Marilyn was saying because I do believe uh one major issue is that now that anti-racism has been put on the table, put forth as something that needs to be addressed, and racism needs to be addressed, that you know, people want to automatically connect it with diversity and inclusion work. And so I think there definitely is a separation, and I think that separation, you know, really needs to be, you know, broadened in our teaching, in our in our research, so you know, people can really understand the difference.
SPEAKER_03You know, you know, people look at what's similar many times and they want to link it together, but you know, it just doesn't fit. So I think that really needs to be explicitly explained. Uh, because I think people see it, see an automatic connection with, oh, well, if it's about diversity, let's just talk about racism in the DEI committee. And I don't think that's the case.
SPEAKER_00One of the things that when I did study diversity practitioners, if we look at diversity practitioners, the demographics are pretty clear. The field is dominated by white women, followed by women of color, and those women of color tend to be black women more than other uh categories of women of color. Big drop, uh men of color, usually black men, and then a huge drop to white men. Um so I think it's, and one of the things that the diversity practitioner said to me, particularly those who were black, is there was the formal agenda, the formal diversity agenda, but every single one of them had an informal agenda working with the CEO and others around race.
SPEAKER_00You know, and so I I think that's also, at least my experience in organizations, is there's the formal organization, what we say we do, and then there's the informal organization, which is what really gets done. So I think even when we're talking about diversity and who's doing that work, and I happen to know a lot of diversity practitioners, and I know a lot of black diversity practitioners. And while they do quote the company's work around broad and inclusive, many of them, because of their personal experience, really do place an emphasis on race and racism, and frankly, anti-racism and some of the more recent actions gave them a platform for going public with some of that work.
SPEAKER_00So I don't think it's an either-or. I actually think it's a one-and. And I think while there may not be a lot of racism work going on in organizations, more of it is going on, no matter how dilute, in the diversity circles than HRD. So I think we have to be clear about that reality as well.
SPEAKER_01It sounds like there's a tremendous potential for HRD in anti-racism, but I'm also reflecting back on what was said a few moments ago, the question of who's training the trainers to talk about racism. And it takes me, I think, to reflect a bit about what role education has, and in particular what role education can play in positioning HRD to have a more strategic role in working on anti-racism initiatives.
SPEAKER_01So, so what do you think about that role of education?
SPEAKER_03I think that education is very important. Um, I mean, linking it when we talk about diversity training, that's really how it kind of got started, is in the training area. But even before that, you know, a lot of practitioners uh who have college degrees and academics who do, you know, they had very little preparation or understanding about these concepts in their training. So again, now I see an evolution of you know, people being promoted to chief diversity officer from HR or from other supporting areas, but don't necessarily have the background in that area.
SPEAKER_03So to me, I think education is very critical at this point. I know that in the textbook that Marilyn and I have out uh workforce diversity current and emerging trends, you know, the first chapter that I wrote was the historical perspective for studying workforce diversity. I think that's the starting point to really know how this evolved. Uh, we try to teach our students, like, you know, how it started, where we are now, and you know, where is this going?
SPEAKER_03So I think a lot of practitioners and academics alike, you know, have not had that preparation. Uh, myself and my new graduate diversity certificate program, you know, we are creating more uh courses, you know, that are really looking at some of the lived experiences that you know people are going through. One course that we just developed is spiritual allergy and racism. So, you know, we're really getting into the hardcore areas of this and you know, providing more conversation, which I do believe leads to learning, but it has to be by a person who is really grounded in the work and understands it from a historical perspective.
SPEAKER_02Claritha Hughes's diversity intelligence model speaks to, I mean, it has a lot of assumptions, but one of the basic assumptions that I like to use is that leaders themselves need to be uh educated in diversity perspectives. A lot of times leaders themselves kind of put themselves in an isolated bubble, like they don't need to be informed or educated. And a quick example, when I was um an administrator for a state agency, I was in charge of training, making sure uh folks, you know, went to training and that sort of thing.
SPEAKER_02And when we first uh started diversity type of initiatives or training, my boss told me to make sure that you know certain administrators went to training. Then I said, okay, I can do that. I said, and and and when are you going? He said, Well, well, I don't need to go. So that mindset, I think, still Is very prevalent among leaders that they don't necessarily need to go and be educated. That's a problem that that we'll need to, I don't know if we'll ever get over that that uh that barrier.
SPEAKER_02But leaders, since we always say it comes from the top, you know, the commitment to this work comes from the top. Well, if the leaders are resisting being educated, well, you know, that's you know, we we've got to navigate around that, but that's uh a continuing problem.
SPEAKER_00Marilyn, you mentioned the importance of leaders, especially senior leaders. And if if senior leaders are chief architects of culture, one of the things I've learned just in my organizational development capacity, et cetera, role, is leaders don't warm up to the idea of training, uh, because many of them have had a lot of that. And education at that level is really a series of focused conversations, whether it's individual, looking at their own autobiographical experiences with race, that's a form of education.
SPEAKER_00And so I think if we really want to begin to speak to the senior executives, even the language of training I found as a practitioner didn't work. They don't see themselves as trainees, and so training and trainees actually in their mind go together. Whether we agree with it or not doesn't matter. They're really the core group. And so I think really thinking about what does anti-racism education look like for senior executives, um, I think is something that we as HRD researchers, practitioners, and so on can really give some thought to if we really want to be a strategic partner.
SPEAKER_00Because if in fact the aim is to build a race equity culture in organizations, then senior leaders who are the chief architects have to be on the forefront of that transformational process.
SPEAKER_02Training to me is a skill type of activity. And I'm just gonna mention right quickly the critical pedagogy model that Shonda and I created back in 2010. And as we market it and refine it more, it actually speaks to social justice education. Uh, I think we say from the classroom to the boardroom. So we have designed, I mean, we have conceptualized a model of social justice education that is, I feel like is ideal for senior leaders.
SPEAKER_02It emphasizes education from the very beginning, social action. And then it comes up to, you know, all of these things equal social justice education. But yes, education for leaders is what we actually are building, and we are using, we have built in the language of racism. So it's already there.
SPEAKER_00There is a knowledge and skill aspect to anti-racism, like what we need to know and what we need to be able to do. But I think the harder work is really mindset work, which is where I do think education comes into play. We have to engage the whole person head, heart, and hand, and think about our training and educational strategies to align with that holistic emphasis.
SPEAKER_01As I listen to the role of education here, I'm assuming that the goal of education would be to lead to action, and that part of that action within organizations would be to address the systems, policies, and practices that are perpetuating racism within those organizations. If that's the case, what what are those systems, policies, and practices perpetuating racism that we would want addressed by HRD professionals?
SPEAKER_03Uh well, I would say one of the main ones would be, you know, the hiring. It really seems to be a roadblock for, you know, a lot of people of color, uh, African-American people, you know, trying to get into different jobs and career fields. And then, you know, going through some of the interview processes. You know, you know, people will interview, they meet all the qualifications, they're a great candidate, but still yet they're not the right fit. So basically, what does that mean?
SPEAKER_03So again, there's just a lot of unspoken things that are are happening as it pertains to hiring. And even with DEI policies and practices that are out there, you know, they'll have statements, but still, I mean, is it just a statement on paper? How is it being acted out in real time? So I think, you know, just saying it and not doing it doesn't mean it's okay. And then looking at the demographics, I mean, you know, we're, you know, we still have, you know, people of color that are highly qualified, college degrees, and so forth.
SPEAKER_03You know, they're still not highly represented in organizations, universities. You know, the door is open for other people to come in, but they're not there.
SPEAKER_00It's really the whole life cycle from once people get hired, what's your orientation and onboarding process? The more informal that is, the less likely people of color will get the type of onboarding and orientation they need to understand how things are done here, which everything is not in a public policy. Uh, again, there's a formal system and the informal system. There's training and development, again, formal and informal, technical and sort of human interaction related.
SPEAKER_00There's everything else like job evaluation, promotion, compensation, uh, conditions of employment, i.e., contracts, performance management, and secession planning. Ultimately, senior executives approve any system, because that links to culture, any system that's in organizations. People, someone in HR or diversity or someone might create the policy or the practice, and yet there are systems that drive behavior in organizations, and many of that now is is embedded in what people call sort of the talent management or talent development uh cycle.
SPEAKER_00And so some of the diagnostic work we can do is really what are those systems. I would argue that if we really want to make sustainable change, I would actually go to the top, the system I would attack, and I know this to be true working with organizations that have made progress toward the distribu what their senior executives look like based on race and gender. You go after two systems. You go after what does the what does it look like at the top, and what's the system that drives what it looks like at the top.
SPEAKER_00And that system is secession planning. And so really going after that system and looking at the incumbent profile of executives historically, and you'll see all the patterns you need and the in-group and out-group dynamics. So I agree, Shonda. I want to know about recruiting, but I also want to know what are differences between the way people are being onboarded, training and development experiences they get, and some of those development experiences is why I say training and development, because some of the more significant experiences that relate to advancement, when I look at my own autobiographical experience, what got me promoted, training was necessary, everyone had to have it.
SPEAKER_00But what got me promoted were developmental experiences, working with certain managers, having exposure to different areas of the organization. And so I think we have to go after the systems that drive behavior in the organization. And are we doing that in a comprehensive way? We do that up front, that's diagnostic work, and then on the back end is measurement and evaluation.
SPEAKER_02I'll just add one because both of you have summed that up very well. In terms of the function, system functions like hiring, promotions, also the reward systems is an area where racism can be very uh subtle. Are people of color or blacks? Are we being um compensated or fairly? Uh so that's another um in terms of systems that I didn't hear it was implied, but I wanted to particularly point that one out reward systems.
SPEAKER_01So a topic that's come up a couple of times, um, and I and I'm thinking it's now is a good time to to dig into it in a little more depth, is that of of assessment and and measurement. And and so if if to kind of follow the thread through from the conversation, you know, education is leading to action to address what's perpetuating racism in organizations. And so I'm wondering what what measures uh could be in place to help organizations assess their current state and and also to track progress that that they might be making.
SPEAKER_00The kinds of assessment work and diagnostic work I do on the front end, which is where I think assessment work comes in. And I I distinguish that from evaluation and measurement that's more on ongoing and on the back end. You know, so if I'm dealing at the individual level, you know, I could look at various assessments to gain insight into where people are. There's various race identity measures, there's implicit associate tests, you know, there's a variety of things. When I look at how racism is showing up at the interpersonal level, you know, again, in addition to training and education, there are assessments that deal with that, like the intercultural development inventory, cultural general, cultural competence.
SPEAKER_00Um, but once you move to the institutional and structural level, you're dealing less with individuals other than senior executives, and more with the outcomes of those behaviors, like discrimination treatment, like unfair policies and practice, like inequities, and then the structural things are again all the policies. And so I think of sort of two core factors. Can we create measurement systems that are both efficient and effective? And what are we measuring?
SPEAKER_00And oftentimes we're measuring processes, hiring processes, onboarding processes, selection processes, etc. And what are the outcomes of those processes, you know, and so we're looking at equity mixtures, or again, more specifically, we can look at equity around race and black. And, you know, based on demographic data, you know, what do you know, we can look at parity focus, um, which is numbers, we can look at climate focus, uh, we can look at utilization, how we're using our talent, and we can look at impact.
SPEAKER_00You know, a number of people sort of gristle at measurement. And again, especially in for-profit organizations, um, no metrics, no movement. Every organization that I've ever worked in measure what they think is important, and they they pay attention, and you know that because they measure what they think is important. So if there are no metrics around race mixtures and so on, what they're telling you, whether explicitly or not, is we don't think that's important.
SPEAKER_00Because everything an organization believes is important, no metrics, no movements. And so I think you can look at trend data around race in organizations at various levels of the system. Um, you can look at job readiness, um, and you know, while it's being worked to erode, we still do have legal remedies, and it's not just about legal, yet I don't think we can ignore the legal remedies because the fact of the matter is post-civil rights movement and with the with the advent of EEOC and affirmative action, we saw more people of color in general and more black people enter colleges and universities and corporations that we have seen historically.
SPEAKER_03Well, I would just like to add, I know that you know, several of the companies that I work with, and you know, just in my own institution have been involved in doing cultural audits to kind of test the culture. And, you know, it's just been a lot of information put forward that, you know, sometimes hasn't been as positive as they would have liked. But when the results come out, everything is positive. So I mean, you know, many times a a lot of organizations, not all, are sometimes, you know, checking the box, saying that that they're addressing the issues, you know, using uh an instrument or having an outside company come in and do it.
SPEAKER_03But then when the results are put forth, then everything seems like it's okay, and then we don't hear any more about it, and the issues still persist. To me, those are just some of the games, if you will, that are kind of being played to say, well, well, we measured this and everything is fine, but it really isn't.
SPEAKER_00And and to your point, Shonda, when you do cultural audits, you know, one is what questions are they asking, right? Um so you get what you the results are partially what you're asking. But also importantly, how do we know how to what degree have those results been sanitized? So it gets back to power, right? So they may have collected the data, and and I have a sense of this from the inside of organizations, they may have collected data, but oftentimes if you're an external consultant doing cultural audits, which I've done, you get a lot of pressure from the organization wanting to either quote sanitize it or just sort of like, well, let's sequence the messaging and start with the positive, right?
SPEAKER_00And then we and of course we know what happens, the organization gets distracted and we never get to the negative.
SPEAKER_02Yeah, you're right, Terry. That could be silent. So, what you know, so what exactly are the measurements telling us? Because if a person's lived experience, I mean, am I gonna feel really comfortable talking about my experiences of racism within my organization? Probably not, because I don't know what kind of repercussions that's gonna bring on to me.
SPEAKER_03So right, but even more than that, you know, like if there's few people of color, and by the time they get to the demographic information, and if you say you're African American, you work in HR, and there's only one African American working HR, then you know, are you are you really feeling comfortable to answer that question or not, because you're self-identified without even saying who you are.
SPEAKER_01So I I'm wondering if a good way of wrapping us up is with a a call to action and and and specifically, I'd I'd love to hear your advice on on how HID professionals can gain relevancy and and become a key player in this work.
SPEAKER_02I believe that the field of HRD will continue to hold true to its origins that are dominated by a positivistic paradigm, which is not created space for lived experiences. And that is where we need to, the the discussions of racism reside. However, the the the good thing is that a paradigm shift to critical HRD has opened up space for discussions of power and for power imbalance.
SPEAKER_02So critical HRD scholars have challenged and responded to the inadequies of the of the field of HRD, which again is still rooted in its dominated uh paradigms. So critical HRD scholars have responded and have addressed this lack of emphasis on social systems in just a uh just a very broad um statement. Critical HRD scholarship then has advocated for um reform of the workplace and and for development of practices that are aligned around justice and equity and respectful treatment and dignity of all people.
SPEAKER_02However, though, the language of racism and actions for dismantling racism may be lost even within critical HRD, within the general conversations, because to gain relevancy for anti-racism work, racism itself has to be called out. And the the words and the language have to be strongly inserted into the work that's being done. Now, the HRD literature, what we call the HRD literature, is a significant source for the field of HRD to gain relevancy, even the work of critical HRD scholars, because uh calling for papers that speak explicitly to anti-racism could be initiated by journal editors.
SPEAKER_02That's one place that we might gain relevancy, and and and you know, it's being published about this work. And just to sum up, in my in my article, does HRD have a moral duty to respond to to issues of social injustice? I issue a call to our dedicated HRD community for having more open and candid conversations about social injustice and explicitly racism.
SPEAKER_02So I appeal to agency. I I appeal to agency. Will this create social action? Will this be you know be enough just to call out uh racism and and and ask that we um is being published in the journals? Maybe, maybe not. But my commitment as a critical justice scholar is to continue to call it out and to call it what it is.
SPEAKER_01Well, and unfortunately, we have run out of time for today's conversation, but that feels like a wonderful place to wrap it up and to give people plenty to reflect on and hopefully to turn that reflection into critical action. So I've really enjoyed our time together. So thank you all so much indeed for being a part of this episode on exploring HRD and anti-racism.
SPEAKER_02Thank you. Thank you, Darren.
SPEAKER_01Sounds good.
SPEAKER_00Thank you, Darren. Thank you, Marilyn and Shonda.
SPEAKER_02Thank you. Thanks, both of you as well. Bye.
SPEAKER_01Thank you so much for joining me for this episode. It was wonderful spending time with Marilyn Byrd, Terence Moltbeer, and Sean DeScott. If you enjoyed this episode, check out all of our others. There were 22 episodes in the first two seasons, and we're releasing a further eleven here in the third. Between them, they provide access to conversations with over 75 leading HRD scholars from around the world. New episodes release weekly.
SPEAKER_01To learn more about the series, check out HRDmasterclass.com. And to learn about the Academy of Human Resource Development, check out ahrd.org. By becoming a member, you can access extra bonus materials. Also, don't forget to look into our sponsors, the Columbia University Coaching Centre of Excellence at Teachers College, by visiting their website at tc.columbia.edu forward slash coaching certification.
SPEAKER_01I'm looking forward to being with you in our next episode when we're exploring the relationship between HRD and HRM with the help of Valerie Anderson of the University of Portsmouth in the United Kingdom, Ronan Carberry of Cork University Business School in Ireland, and Jacek Moranski of the Warsaw School of Economics in Poland. Until then, this is Darren Short signing off from the Human Resource Development Masterclass.com.
This fourth episode of Season 6 brings together Dr. Sanghamitra Chaudhuri (Temple University) and Dr. Kyung Nam Kim (Texas A&M University) for a conversation about the 2026 article Gendered Pathways to Work-Family...
This third episode of Season 6 brings together Dr. Yuanlu Niu (University of Arkansas) and Dr. Jos Akkermans (Vrije Universiteit Amsterdam) for a conversation about the 2026 article Navigating careers in non-traditional...
This second episode of Season 6 brings together Dr. Matthew Hurtienne (University of Texas at Tyler) and Dr. Heesun Kim (Francis Marion University) for a conversation about the 2024 article Silence in the workplace:...
This first episode of Season 6 brings together Dr. Joshua Collins (University of Minnesota) and Dr. Ague Mae Manongsong (Louisiana State University) for a conversation about the 2023 article “Manongsong, A. M., & Ghosh,...
Welcome to the trailer for Season 6 of Human Resource Development Masterclass - the podcast series from the Academy of Human Resource Development, the organization that leads HRD through research. The sixth season...